National Products, Inc. v. Arkon Resources, Inc.

Filing 160

AMENDED JOINT PRETRIAL ORDER by Hon. James P. Donohue. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A- Trial Exhibits)(TF)

EXHIBIT A
TRIAL EXHIBITS
I.

Admissibility Stipulated:

Plaintiff’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

1

NPI-ARK00068113 NPI-ARK00068115;
Ex. D to Babcock Initial
Report

U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,254,086

12/4/2012

2

NPI-ARK00067649 NPI-ARK00067704

U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,254,086 application

5/23/2012

13

NPI-ARK00004775 NPI-ARK00004798

Round-A-Mount Mounting Systems Catalog

14

NPI-ARK00005661 NPI-ARK00005674

R-A-M® 2000 Mounting Systems Catalog

15

NPI-ARK00067977 NPI-ARK00068112

RAM Mount Catalog - Mounts, Components, Vehicle
Bases, Cradles, Holders, Adapters and Accessories

17

NPI-ARK00068993 NPI-ARK00069077

RAM® Mount GPS Catalog

20

NPI-ARK00068938 NPI-ARK00068938

NPI Pocket Brochure

22

NPI-ARK00069436 NPI-ARK00069438

RAM Mount Catalog webpage from rammount.com,
obtained from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

8/15/2013

23

NPI-ARK00069439 NPI-ARK00069447

RAM Mount Catalog webpage from rammount.com,
obtained from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

7/8/2014

24

NPI-ARK00069448

RAM Mount Catalog webpage from rammount.com,
obtained from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/6/2015

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure (original design)

2004

26

1994
4/2001
2012

2004

27

NPI-ARK00069869 NPI-ARK00069871

NPI Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK01

9/22/2006

28

NPI-ARK00068934 NPI-ARK00068935

NPI Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK01

9/22/2006

1

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Document
Date

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK01

29
31

Document Description

9/22/2006

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

NPI-ARK00068941 NPI-ARK00068942

2007

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK07

32

NPI Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK07

2007

46

NPI-ARK00068487 NPI-ARK00068487

NPI Invoice with picture of hourglass shaped arm

7/1/1995

54

NPI-ARK00069324

"Just RAM It!®" print advertisement, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/27/2013

55

NPI-ARK00069325

"RAM® Gadget Mounting" print advertisement,
obtained from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/27/2013

56

NPI-ARK00069326

RAM® Kayak Mounts print advertisement, obtained
from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/27/2013

57

NPI-ARK00069327

"RAM® Your ATV" print advertisement, obtained
from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/27/2013

63

NPI-ARK00069414 NPI-ARK00069416

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-201U-A, obtained
from the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

1/3/2010

64

NPI-ARK00069455 NPI-ARK00069457

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-101U, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/25/2010

65

NPI-ARK00069458 NPI-ARK00069460

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-101U, obtained from
the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/29/2010

66

NPI-ARK00069412 NPI-ARK00069413

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-201U-A (obtained
from the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine)

2/27/2011

70

NPI-ARK00069343 NPI-ARK00069344

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-101AU, obtained from
the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/27/2013

74

NPI-ARK00069362 NPI-ARK00069363

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-101AU, obtained from
the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

8/13/2013

67

NPI-ARK00069328 NPI-ARK00069330

NPI Webpage: RAM Printer Mount for the Brother
Rugged Jet™ 4, obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

1/15/2013

68

NPI-ARK00069331 NPI-ARK00069334

NPI Webpage: Sony Action Cam Mounts, obtained
from the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

1/15/2013

2

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

92

NPI-ARK00000353 NPI-ARK00000356

NPI Webpage: Motorcycle Mounts

2/23/2016

94

NPI-ARK00000430 NPI-ARK00000432

NPI webpage: Fleet Mounts

2/23/2016

199

ARK004364 ARK004371

Amended Proposed Consent Judgment - Nat'l Prods.,
Inc. v. Gamber-Johnson LLC(Case No. CV04-2524)
(ECF No. 178)

9/26/2006

200

ARK004372 ARK004379;
Ex. D to Obermiller
Initial Expert Report

Amended Consent Judgment - Nat'l Prods., Inc. v.
Gamber-Johnson LLC (Case No. CV04-2524) (ECF
No. 179)

10/02/200
6

239

ARK001817 ARK001819

P. Brassard email to J.Y and Teng re: important new
opportunity

8/10/2013

288

ARK003897 ARK003928

Arkon 2013 Product Catalog

2013

289

AR000007 AR000038

Arkon 2014 Product Catalog

2014

290

AR000039 AR000070

Arkon 2015 Product Catalog

2015

293

ARK001441 ARK001443

Pages from Arkon Catalog entitled "Camera Mounts"

299

ARK003877

Arkon marketing document entitled "Arkon® The
Mobile Mounting Specialists™ - Innovation Commitment - Excellence for Tablets - Smartphones Cameras"

301

ARK004333 ARK004338

The Arkon Insider, vol. 2, issue 1

302

ARK004339 ARK004345

The Arkon Insider, vol. 2, issue 2

311

AR000088 - AR000089

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0802T

2/1/2016

312

AR000092 - AR000093

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM080AMPS

2/1/2016

313

AR000100 - AR000101

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM2XAMPS

2/1/2016

3

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

314

AR000102 - AR000103

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM2XAMPS-SH

2/1/2016

315

AR000126 - AR000127

Arkon webpage: Part No. SP-RMS

2/1/2016

317

NPI-ARK00068400 NPI-ARK00068401

Arkon webpage: Part No. SP-RMS

7/18/2016

318

AR000074 - AR000075

Arkon webpage: Part No. GPRM086

2/1/2016

319

AR000076 - AR000077

Arkon webpage: Part No. IPARM086

2/1/2016

320

AR000078 - AR000079

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-1

2/1/2016

322

NPI-ARK00068396 NPI-ARK00068397

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-1

7/18/2016

323

AR000080 - AR000081

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-2

2/1/2016

326

AR000082 - AR000083

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0791420

2/1/2016

327

AR000084 - AR000085

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0792TWD

2/1/2016

328

AR000086 - AR000087

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0801420

2/1/2016

329

AR000090 - AR000091

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0804P

2/1/2016

330

AR000094 - AR000095

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0861420

2/1/2016

332

AR000106 - AR000107

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM60802T

2/1/2016

335

AR000112 - AR000113

Arkon webpage: Part No. RMAMPS2T

2/1/2016

336

AR000114 - AR000115

Arkon webpage: Part No. RMEQUIP

2/1/2016

337

AR000116 - AR000117

Arkon webpage: Part No. RMS2XAMPS

2/1/2016

338

AR000118 - AR000119

Arkon webpage: Part No. RMSAMPS1420

2/1/2016

339

AR000120 - AR000121

Arkon webpage: Part No. RMSAMPS2T

2/1/2016

341

AR000122 - AR000123

Arkon webpage: Part No. RV180

2/1/2016

342

AR000124 - AR000125

Arkon webpage: Part No. RVAMPS

2/1/2016

344

AR000128 - AR000129

Arkon webpage: Part No. TABRM079

2/1/2016

345

AR000130 - AR000131

Arkon webpage: Part No. TABRM086

2/1/2016

4

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

346

AR000132 - AR000133

Arkon webpage: Part No. TABRMAMPS

2/1/2016

347

NPI-ARK00068394 NPI-ARK00068395

Arkon webpage: Part No. TABRMAMPS

7/18/2016

348

ARK007696

Arkon webpage: Part No. TABRMAMPS

361

AR000071 - AR000071

Webpage from Amazon.com: Arkon Part No.
TABRMAMPS

390

ARK004318 ARK004318

Picture of Arkon Mount (Robust series - 1st Design)

394

AR000650 - AR000650

Arkon Resources, Inc. T-2282, Ownership

1/29/2016

421

AR000743 - AR000751

Arkon Purchase Order No. 6441 and related documents

1/2/2015

440
442

2/3/2016

Physical example of Arkon Part No. RM080AMPS
Brassard Dep. Ex. 32

Physical example of Arkon Part No. RMS2XAMPS

450

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0804P, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/28/2016

452

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-1, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

8/1/2016

Arkon webpage: Part No. RM0862T

2/1/2016

U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,254,086 (Original
Certificate)

12/4/2012

455

AR000096 - AR000097

475
478

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 42

GPSLockBox Classic Series

7/28/1917

480

AR000092 - AR000093

ARKON 80mm Windshield Suction Mount with 4-Hole
AMPS Head

02/01/201
6

482

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 46

Arkon 2014 Product Catalog

12/15/201
3

485

AR000100 - AR000101

Arkon Heavy-Duty Car or Wall Drill-Base Mount for
Camera, GPS, Satellite Radio, and Video Camera

02/01/201
6

486

AR000102 - AR000103

Arkon Heavy-Duty Drill-Base Mount with Security
Hardware and AMPS Head

02/01/201
6

5

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Document Description

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document
Date

487

NPI-ARK00001245 NPI-ARK00001246

Arkon Robust Series Small Mount Shaft

05/26/201
6

497

ARK007880 ARK007881

Spreadsheet entitled “RAM 1 Trade Dress - List of Item
Numbers”

4/18/2017

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

515

Carnevali Dep. Exh. 118

Trademark File History for
U.S. Trademark Registration No. 4,254,086

7/12/2016

519

Carnevali Dep. Exh. 122

Photos of RAM Mount RAP- B-201U

520

Carnevali Dep. Exh. 124

Photos of Arkon Product RM0802517

521

Hersey Dep. Exh. 127

Photos of Ram Mount Composite Short Double Socket
Arm for 1" Ball Bases

539

AR00007- AR00038

Pages from 2014 Catalog

2014

540

AR00039- AR00070

Pages from 2015 Catalog

2015

541

AR000124 – AR000125

Arkon Webpage for RoadVise Wall or Car Mount for
Phones

2/1/2016

546

ARK001817ARK001822

Email from Paul Brassard toJ.Y. and Teng

8/11/2013

547

ARK003897ARK003928

Arkon Catalog 2013

8/11/2013

561

Carnevali Dep. Exh. 123

Physical product, Ram Mount double socket arm for 1"
ball, RAP-B-201U

562

Carnevali Dep. Exh. 125

Physical product, Arkon Heavy Duty Windshield
Suction Mount, model no. RM0802517

Defendant’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex.
No.

568

Marked

Physical product, Arkon Robust Mount Series, HeavyDuty C-Clamp Mount with 1/4"-20 Mounting Bolt,
model no. RM0861420

6

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

569

Physical product, Arkon Robust Mount Series, HeavyDuty C-Clamp Tablet Mount for Tripods, Tables, Carts,
and Desks, model no. TABRM086

571

Document
Date

Physical product, Arkon Robust Mount Series, HeavyDuty C-Clamp Mount for Apple iPad Air, model no.
IPARM086

580

ARK007799

RAM Mount webpage from rammount.com, obtained
from the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

6/27/2014

582

ARK007802 ARK007809

RAM Mount webpages from
rammount.com, obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

1/13/2010

583

ARK007810 ARK007831

RAM Mount webpages fromrammount.com, obtained
from the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

1/13/2010

584

ARK007832 ARK007844

RAM Mount webpages from
rammount.com, obtained from
the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

1/13/2010

7

II.

Authenticity Stipulated, Admissibility Disputed:

Plaintiff’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

12/8/1998

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

12/8/1998

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

4/17/2006

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

3

AR000185 AR000204

4

NPI-ARK00002028 NPI-ARK00002050

U.S. Patent No. 5,845,885 (Ribbon Copy)

5

ARK003237 ARK003245

Supplemental amendment in response to
non-final office action from the '885
reissue file history (U.S. RE42,060)

6

ARK003228 ARK003229

Office Communication from the '885
reissue file history (U.S. RE42,060)

5/9/2006

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

16

NPI-ARK00067861 NPI-ARK00067976

RAM® Mounts Vehicle Mounting
Solutions Catalog

May 2015

FRE 402,
403

30

NPI-ARK00069872

Native Corel Drawing File:
rmrbook06.cdr

9/22/2006

FRE 403,
602, 901

33

NPI-ARK00068939 NPI-ARK00068940

NPI Pocket Brochure, RMR-BOOK07REVB

Jun-07

FRE602, 901

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure,
RMR-BOOK07-REVB

Jun-07

FRE 602,
901

34

U.S. Patent No. 5,845,885

35

NPI-ARK00068936 NPI-ARK00068937

NPI Pocket Brochure, REV-0613

June 2013

FRE 602,
901

36

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 62

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure,
REV-0613

June 2013

FRE 602,
901

37

Ex. 1 to Ware Decl.
(ECF No. 77-1)

NPI Pocket Brochure, REV-0415

Apr. 2015

FRE 403,
602, 901

8

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

38

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

Native PDF File of NPI Pocket Brochure,
REV-0415

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Apr. 2015

FRE 403,
602, 901

Apr.2016

FRE 403,
602, 901

1994

FRE 602,
901

39

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 61

Physical Example of Pocket Brochure,
REV-0416

45

NPI-ARK00068422 NPI-ARK00068422

ASA Trade Show Brochure entitled
"Don't just mount it, Round-a-Mount it!"

47

NPI-ARK00068449 NPI-ARK00068464

Inaugural issue of Team Round-AMount® News™

Fall 1995

FRE 602,
901

78

NPI-ARK00069391 NPI-ARK00069391

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-101AU,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

8/15/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

79

NPI-ARK00069398 NPI-ARK00069400

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-103238U, obtained from the Internet
Archive’s Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

80

NPI-ARK00069401 NPI-ARK00069403

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-103U,
obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine)

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

81

NPI-ARK00069404 NPI-ARK00069406

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-103UA, obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

82

NPI-ARK00069407 NPI-ARK00069408

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-201SU, obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

83

NPI-ARK00069409 NPI-ARK00069411

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-201U,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

84

NPI-ARK00069424 NPI-ARK00069427

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAP-B-201U,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

85

NPI-ARK00069428 NPI-ARK00069430

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAP-B-201U-A,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

9

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

86

NPI-ARK00069417 NPI-ARK00069419

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-B-201U-C,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

3/21/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

87

NPI-ARK00069431 NPI-ARK00069433

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAP-B-400201U, obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

3/29/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

88

NPI-ARK00069392 NPI-ARK00069394

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-201U-B,
obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

3/30/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

89

NPI-ARK00069395 NPI-ARK00069397

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-A-201UB, obtained from the Internet Archive’s
Wayback Machine

3/30/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

90

NPI-ARK00069420 NPI-ARK00069423

NPI Webpage: Part No. RAM-D-201UC, obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

3/30/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

91

Ex. 2 to Ware Decl.
(ECF No. 77-2)

NPI webpage: Patents and Trademarks,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

9/9/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

93

NPI-ARK00000758 NPI-ARK00000759

NPI webpage: Patents and Trademarks

2/23/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

96

NPI-ARK00000932 NPI-ARK00000933

NPI webpage: Part No. RAM-109V-2

2/28/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

97

NPI-ARK00000928 NPI-ARK00000929

NPI webpage: Part No. RAM-109H-2

2/28/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

98

NPI-ARK00001228 NPI-ARK00001230

NPI webpage: Part No. RAM-B-101U

5/26/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

99

NPI-ARK00001231 NPI-ARK00001234

NPI webpage: Part No. RAM-111U

5/26/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

108

NPI-ARK00069546

RAM Video: Camera Mount - Car Wash
Test RAM Suction Cup Mount

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

109

NPI-ARK00069547

RAM Video: High Speed Test - RAM
Dual Articulating Suction Cup Mounting
System and Tab-Tite Tablet Holder

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

10

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

110

NPI-ARK00069552

RAM Video: Smartphone Holder - RAM
X-Grip Shake & Vibration Test

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

111

NPI-ARK00069680

RAM Video: RAM Composite Standard
Length Double Socket Arm for 1.5 Ball

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

112

NPI-ARK00069681

RAM Video: RAM Mounts - Double Ball
& Socket Mounting System

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

124

NPI-ARK00069464 NPI-ARK00069468

Webpage from AkvaSport.com (Part No.
RAM-111U), obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

9/2/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

126

NPI-ARK00069452 NPI-ARK00069454

Webpage from Amazon.com: Ram Mount
9mm Angled Motorcycle Base with
Double Socket Arm, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

1/1/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

128

NPI-ARK00001225 NPI-ARK00001227

Webpage from basspro.com for RAM
Mounts Ball & Socket Mount for
Humminbird Fishfinder/Matrix/Piranha
Max Units - Hourglass Mounting Plate

5/26/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

130

NPI-ARK00069470 NPI-ARK00069472

Webpage from big-mouthysalty.myshopify.com (Part No. RAM-B180U), obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

131

NPI-ARK00069473 NPI-ARK00069474

Webpage from buybits.com (Part No.
RAM-B-176-AP7), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

135

NPI-ARK00001114 NPI-ARK00001117

Webpage from cbocmarine.com (Part No.
RAM-B-179U)

5/16/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

136

NPI-ARK00069476 NPI-ARK00069480

Webpage from cbocmarine.com (Part No.
RAM-B-179U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

137

NPI-ARK00001180 NPI-ARK00001183

Webpage from chaparral-racing.com:
Offset Brake/Clutch Reservoir Cover
Mount

5/16/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

11

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

6/15/2013

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

141

NPI-ARK00069481 NPI-ARK00069482

Webpage from chapparal-racing.com:
Ram Mounts Double-Socket Arm and
Diamond Plate with Handlebar Clamp
Mount, obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

147

NPI-ARK00069491 NPI-ARK00069492

Webpage from ebay.com (Part No. RAMB-179-AP9U), obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

148

NPI-ARK00069495 NPI-ARK00069496

Webpage from gps4us.com (Part No.
RAM-B-181-U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

150

NPI-ARK00001184 NPI-ARK00001185

Webpage from greentophuntfish.com
(Part No. RAM-11U)

5/16/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

151

NPI-ARK00069497 NPI-ARK00069499

Webpage from greentophuntfish.com
(Part No. RAM-11U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

156

NPI-ARK00069503 NPI-ARK00069506

Webpage from marine.com (Part No.
RAM-B-179U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

158

NPI-ARK00069507 NPI-ARK00069509

Webpage from monteringsbutiken.se
(Part No. RAM101), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

160

NPI-ARK00069542 NPI-ARK00069545

Webpage from monteringsbutiken.se
(Part No. RAM-101), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

162

NPI-ARK00069510 NPI-ARK00069513

Webpage from motosport.com (Ram
Mounts Twist and Tilt Motorcycle Mirror
Base With Double Socket Arm and
Diamond Adaptor), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

3/22/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

164

NPI-ARK00069514 NPI-ARK00069516

Webpage from PriceZen.net for Part No.
RAM-B-107U, obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

9/2/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

12

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

166

NPI-ARK00069517 NPI-ARK00069521

Webpage from revzilla.com (Part No.
RAM-B-180), obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

8/22/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

167

NPI-ARK00001186 NPI-ARK00001187

Webpage from satpro.tv for RAM Mount
Twist Tilt Motorcycle Mirror Base

5/16/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

169

NPI-ARK00069522 NPI-ARK00069524

Webpage from sportsmanoutfitters.com
(Part No. RAM-B-180U), obtained from
the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

171

NPI-ARK00069525 NPI-ARK00069527

Webpage from thefishinhole.com (Part
No. RAM-D-111U-C), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

9/2/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

172

NPI-ARK00069528 NPI-ARK00069530

Webpage from thegadgetguys.co.nz (Part
No. RAM-B-101U), obtained from the
Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

175

NPI-ARK00069531 NPI-ARK00069533

Webpage from tigergps.com (Part No.
RAM-B-180U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

3/7/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

177

NPI-ARK00069534 NPI-ARK00069536

Webpage from tigergps.com (Part No.
RAM-B-181U), obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

3/7/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

183

NPI-ARK00069874

Picture of RAM hourglass product
obtained from FlyingMag.com

Oct. 2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

185

NPI-ARK00069537 NPI-ARK00069539

Walleyecentral.com GPS Mount Forum
Archive, obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

187

NPI-ARK00001127 NPI-ARK00001129

Mccmag.com article entitled, "NPI Settles
Patent Infringement Case with GamberJohnson (10/4)"

5/16/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

189

NPI-ARK00001143 NPI-ARK00001144

Atvsource.com article entitled, "GamberJohnson Admits that VersaTrue Products
Infringe NPI Patent; Court Orders
Gamber-Johnson to Discontinue Sales"

10/4/2006

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

13

Trial
Ex.
No.

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

ECF No. 1

Complaint and Exhibits A-E (ECF No. 1)

9/30/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

ECF No. 75-1

[Proposed] First Amended Complaint
(Ex. A to NPI's Mot. For Leave to Amd.
Complaint) (ECF No. 75-1)

12/23/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
802, 901

ECF No. 47

Defendant Arkon Resources, Inc.'s
Revised Motion for Summary Judgment
of Invalidity and Non-Infringement (ECF
No. 47) (Sealed)

11/4/2016

FRE 402,
403

ECF No. 64

Defendant Arkon Resources, Inc.'s
Revised Motion for Summary Judgment
of Invalidity and Non-Infringement (ECF
No. 64) (Redacted)

11/4/2016

FRE 402,
403

First Amended Complaint - Nat'l Prods.,
Inc. v. Gamber-Johnson LLC (Case No.
CV04-2524) (ECF No. 21)

4/7/2005

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

Plaintiff’s Prehearing Statement, Nat'l
Prods., Inc. v. Gamber-Johnson LLC
(Case No. CV04-2524) (ECF No. 43-2)

1/3/2006

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

201

National Products Inc.'s Re-Notice of
Deposition of Arkon Resources, Inc.
Pursuant to FRCP 30(b)(6)

9/2/2016

FRE 402,
403

202

Objections and Responses of Defendant
Arkon Resources, Inc. to Plaintiff
National Products, Inc.’s First Set of
Interrogatories

2/25/2016

FRE 402,
403

203

Objections and Responses of Defendant
Arkon Resources, Inc. to Plaintiff
National Products, Inc.’s First Set of
Interrogatories (Nos. 1-9) (Replacement
pages to Responses served on 2/25/2016)

5/6/2016

FRE 402,
403

204

Objections and Responses of Defendant
Arkon Resources, Inc. to Plaintiff
National Products, Inc.’s Second Set of
Interrogatories (Nos. 10-13)

7/11/2016

FRE 402,
403

191

192

194

195

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

196

198

ECF No. 43-2

14

Trial
Ex.
No.

Document
Date

Objection(s)

205

Objections and Responses of Defendant
Arkon Resources, Inc. to Plaintiff
National Products, Inc.’s Third Set of
Interrogatories (Nos. 14-16)

9/12/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, Subject
to MIL

206

Supplemental Objections and Responses
of Defendant Arkon Resources, Inc. to
Plaintiff National Products, Inc.'s Second
Set of Requests for Production and
Inspection of Documents and Things
(Nos. 39-61)

11/21/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

236

Hull Dep. Ex. 2

LinkedIn Profile of Steve Hull

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403

237

Roth Dep. Ex. 17

LinkedIn Profile of Aaron Roth

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403

238

Brassard Dep. Ex. 29

LinkedIn Profile of Paul Brassard

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403

240

AR000640

[e-mail] email to P. Brassard,
Teng, and J.Y.

8/11/2013

FRE 402,
403

241

ARK001655

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: More on
RAM pricing

2/6/2014

FRE 602,
901

242

ARK001663 ARK001664

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: New
Heavy Duty Pedestal Pricing

2/6/2014

FRE 602,
901

243

ARK001668 ARK001670

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: New
Heavy Duty Pedestal Pricing

2/7/2014

FRE 602,
901

244

ARK001384

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: New
RMxx mounts - Restrictions? (native
email)

4/2/2014

FRE 602,
802, 901

245

ARK001384

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: New
RMxx mounts - Restrictions?

4/2/2014

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 403,
602, 802, 901

246

ARK001856

B. Arana email to P. Brassard re: RM
mount - Ball to ball option for extension

4/2/2014

FRE 602,
901

15

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

247

ARK001449

A. Roth email to P. Brassard and S.
Huynh et al. re: 25mm Ball to 1/4" -20
Adapter

5/30/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

248

ARK001509

P. Brassard email to D. Want (Teng) et al.
re: Another part needed

7/18/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

249

ARK001512

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: Arkon
RAM-type pedestals

7/24/2014

FRE 403,
602, 901

7/24/2014

FRE 403,
602, 901
Plaintiff
Add’tl
Objections:
802

8/12/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

8/12/2014

FRE 602,
901
Plaintiff
Add’tl
Objections:
802

250

ARK001513

A. Roth email to P. Brassard re: Arkon
RAM-type pedestals

251

ARK001368 ARK001368

Teng email to A. Roth et al. re: RMxxx
Series Pricing (native file)

252

ARK001368-1 ARK001368-3

Teng email to A. Roth et al. re: RMxxx
Series Pricing

253

ARK001707

P. Brassard email to C. Lin et al. re: RAM
Suction base with sticky pad

9/15/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901
Plaintiff
Add’tl
Objections:
802

254

ARK001621 ARK001622

A. Roth email to K. Hartlove, P. Brassard,
and B. Arana re: iPhone 6 Google Search
Terms

10/28/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

12/30/2014

FRE 602,
901
Plaintiff
Add’tl
Objections:
403, 802

255

ARK001671

P. Brassard email to D. Want (Teng) and
C. Lin re: new items

16

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

256

ARK001887 ARK001889

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: Using the
Most Important Keywords When
Marketing our Products

4/16/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

257

ARK001852 ARK001855

A. Roth email to P. Brassard re: Using the
Most Important Keywords When
Marketing our Products "ARKON"

4/16/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

258

ARK001902 ARK001906

A. Roth email to P. Brassard re: Using the
Most Important Keywords When
Marketing our Products

4/17/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

259

ARK001484 ARK001488

A. Roth email to P. Brassard re:
Additional Info - Competitor Analysis on
Amazon

4/17/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

260

ARK001489 ARK001493

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re:
Additional Info - Competitor Analysis on
Amazon

4/18/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

261

AR000005 AR000006

A. Roth email to B. Arama et al. re:
Arkon's new website is now live -Arkon.com

8/5/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

264

ARK001457 ARK001458

Teng email to P. Brassard et al. re: 3D
files for RAM-type pedestal

10/20/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

265

ARK001453 ARK001455

K. Tseng email to P. Brassard re: 2D files
for RAM-type pedestal

10/20/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

ARK001456

P. Brassard email to D. Want (Teng) et al.
re: 3D files for RAM-type pedestal

10/20/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

267

ARK001709

Teng email to [e-mail] et al. re:
Ram type pedestal 3D file

10/20/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

268

ARK001710

P. Brassard email to D. Want (Teng) et al.
re: Ram type pedestal 3D file

10/20/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,

266

17

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)
408; Subject
to MIL

269

ARK001774 ARK001782

P. Brassard email to A. Cohen re: Ram
type pedestal 3D file

270

ARK001792 ARK001793

P. Brassard email to Teng et al. re: Ram
type pedestal V2

271

ARK001807 ARK001809

Teng email to P. Brassard re: Ram type
pedestal V2

10/29/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

11/13/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

11/17/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

12/5/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

12/5/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

ARK001653 ARK001654

P. Brassard email to Teng et al. re:
modify RAM-type pedestal body

ARK001867

P. Brassard email to L. Conejo re:
samples needed for Monday

274

ARK001878

P. Brassard email to M. Truong re:
Tooling P.O. for Amount

12/7/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

275

AR000003 AR000004

K. Hartlove email to A. Roth re: New
Live Broadcasting Gear from Arkon

12/10/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

276

ARK001677 ARK001678

P. Brassard email to D. Want (Teng) re:
new RAM-type design samples for CES

12/25/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

277

ARK001703 ARK001704

B. Arana email to P. Brassard re: RAM
partners

4/7/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

272

273

18

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

278

ARK001546 ARK001547

P. Brassard email to B. Arana re: Does
charger city buy all of this item from
Arkon?

4/21/2016

FRE 402,
403

279

ARK001341-1 ARK001341-2

A. Roth email to CJ Gandra re: Ram
Mounts RAM-HOL-PD3U: Equivalent?

5/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

280

ARK001341

A. Roth email to CJ Gandra re: Ram
Mounts RAM-HOL-PD3U: Equivalent?
(native email)

5/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

283

ARK001538 ARK001539

P. Brassard email to D. Want and J.Y.
Wang et al. re: brass insert for Robust
pedestal

6/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

284

ARK001631 ARK001633

P. Brassard email to C. Chang and K.
Tseng re: knobs

6/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Subject
to MIL

285

ARK001585 ARK001585

P. Brassard email to A. Roth re: Friends
entering retail packaged consumer market

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

286

ARK001386 ARK001386

Arkon Customer Service Dept. email to
[e-mail] re:
Adjustable Mount (native file)

7/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

287

Roth Dep. Ex. 27

Arkon Customer Service Dept. email to
[e-mail] re:
Adjustable Mount - printed from native
file, ARK001386

7/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

304

ARK007535,
ARK007538-539,

Arkon facebook photos

11/10/2016

FRE 403,
407, 408

305

ARK007566,
ARK007571,
ARK007573,
ARK007582,
ARK007612

Arkon instagram photos

Nov. 2016

FRE 403,
407, 408

306

ARK007628,
ARK007634,
ARK007648,

Arkon twitter photos

11/10/2016

FRE 403,
407, 408

19

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403

ARK007669,
ARK007674
309

Hull Dep. Ex. 3

Arkon webpage entitled "About Us"

316

ARK007675

Arkon webpage: Part No. SP-RMS

FRE 403,
602, 901

321

ARK007450

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-1

FRE 403,
602, 901

324

ARK007453

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-2

FRE 403,
602, 901

325

NPI-ARK00068398 NPI-ARK00068399

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-2

7/18/2016

Plaintiff
Objections:
403

340

AR000073

Arkon webpage: Part No. RV180

2/3/2016

Plaintiff
Objections:
403

343

AR000072

Arkon webpage: Part No. RVAMPS

2/3/2016

Plaintiff
Objections:
403

356

ARK007449

Webpage from Amazon.com: Arkon Part
No. LBUP7-1

357

NPI-ARK00001207 NPI-ARK00001210

Webpage from Amazon.com: Arkon Part
No. LBUP7-1

358

ARK007452

Webpage from Amazon.com: for Arkon
GPS Lockbox Tablet (LBUP7-2)

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

359

ARK007706

Webpage from Amazon.com: Arkon Part
No. TWBMAG

FRE 403,
602, 901

378

ARK001909 ARK001909

A Mount Inc. Drawing of Model: DSMR01_clamp V2

20

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901
5/26/2016

10/19/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

379

ARK001908 ARK001908

A Mount Inc. Drawing of Model: DSMR01_clamp V2

10/19/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

380

ARK001683

A Mount Inc. Drawing of Model: DSMR01_clamp V2

10/19/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

381

ARK001541 ARK001541

Drawings entitled "Design 1" and
"Design 2"

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

382

ARK001557 ARK001557

Drawing of Design 2 pedestal mount (rear
view)

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

383

ARK001556 ARK001556

Drawing of Design 2 pedestal mount
(front view w/handle)

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

385

ARK001481

Picture of Arkon Mount and Clamp

FRE 403,
602, 901

386

ARK001857

Picture of Arkon Mount and Clamp

FRE 403,
602, 901

387

ARK001858

Picture of Arkon Mount and Clamp

FRE 403,
602, 901

388

ARK001861 ARK001862

Images of Arkon RMxxx Heavy-Duty
Pedestal Mounts and Product Nos. (1st
Design)

FRE 403,
602, 901

389

ARK001863 ARK001864

Images of Arkon RMxxx Heavy-Duty
Pedestal Mounts and Product Nos. and
Amounts in U.S. Dollars (1st Design)

FRE 403,
602, 901

392

AR000001 AR000002

Arkon sales data by item number and first
sale dates (All Sales) & (WA State)

393

AR000641 AR000649

Arkon Resources, Inc. - Unique Customer
List

395

AR000651 AR000657

Arkon inventory data by item number
from Jan. 2012 to Dec. 2015

Jan. 2012 Dec. 2015

FRE 402,
403

396

AR000180 AR000182

Arkon Resources Organization Chart

1/29/2016

FRE 402,
403

397

AR000153 AR000154

Arkon sales data by item number and first
sale dates

1/26/2016

FRE 402,
403

21

1/26/2016

FRE 402,
403
FRE 402,
403

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

398

ARK001054 ARK001054

Arkon customer data (native spreadsheet)

6/30/2016

FRE 402,
403

399

ARK001054-1 ARK001054-51

Printout entitled "Customer Data" from
native worksheet, ARK001054

6/30/2016

FRE 402,
403

400

ARK001054-52 ARK001054-151

Printout entitled "Customer Data RO"
printed from native worksheet,
ARK001054

6/30/2016

FRE 402,
403

401

ARK001055

Arkon inventory data (native spreadsheet)

6/30/2016

FRE 106,
403, 602, 901

402

ARK001055-1 ARK001055-5

Printout from native worksheet,
ARK001055, entitled "IN on Hand"

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; subject
to MIL

403

ARK001055-6 ARK001055-10

Printout from native worksheet,
ARK001055, entitled "IN on Hand RO"

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,
subject to
MIL

404

ARK001056

Arkon sales data by month and item
number (native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,1

405

ARK001057

Arkon sales data by quarter and item
number (native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

406

ARK001058

Arkon sales data by year and item number
(native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

ARK001059

Arkon sales data by month and item
number (native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

407

1

Plaintiff further objects to Tr. Ex. Nos. 404-409, 411 and 413 to the extent that these spreadsheets are not
modified such that the estimated costs and overhead percentages, along with the estimated margins resulting
from calculations using those percentages, remain disclosed.
22

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

408

ARK001060

Arkon sales data by quarter and item
number (native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

409

ARK001061 ARK001061

Arkon sales data by year and item number
(native spreadsheet)

6/29/2016

402, 403,
602, 802,
901,

410

ARK001061-1 ARK001061-78

Printout entitled "Raw Data by Year"
printed from native worksheet,
ARK00161

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408;

411

ARK001061-79 ARK001061-149

Printout entitled "Sales by Year by Item
Number" printed from native worksheet,
ARK001061

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

412

ARK001061-150 ARK001061-220

Printout entitled "Sales by Year by Item
Number RO" printed from native
worksheet, ARK001061

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

413

ARK001061-221 ARK001061-291

Printout entitled "Sales by Year by Item
Number NO" printed from native
worksheet, ARK001061

6/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901,

416

ARK001514 ARK001520

ARKON Style Guide, V3

8/20/2014

FRE 402,
403

419

AR000669 AR000680

Arkon Purchase Order No. 5963 and
related documents

1/20/2014

Plaintiff
objections:
FRE 402,
403

420

AR000723 AR000734

Arkon Purchase Order No. 6275 and
related documents

9/17/2014

Plaintiff
objections:
FRE 402,
403

423

ARK004594 ARK007390

Arkon Purchase Orders, Invoices, and
Shipping Documentation

3/14/2014

FRE 402,
403

424

ARK004758 ARK004758

Arkon Invoice No. 202366

10/16/2014

FRE 402,
403

439

Brassard Dep. Ex. 39

Physical example of Arkon Part No.
RM0791420

23

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

Physical example of NPI Part No. RAM
202/111B/201

443

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

444

NPI-ARK00069682

Physical example of NPI Part No. RAMB-138U

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

445

NPI-ARK00069683

Physical example of NPI Part No. RAMB-166-202AU

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

Physical product sample of GamberJohnson Versatrue mount pictured in Ex.
221

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

446

6/24/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
901, not
produced in
discovery

451

Arkon webpage: "Arkon Robust Mount
Series," obtained from the Internet
Archive's Wayback Machine

1/29/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, not
produced in
discovery

453

Arkon webpage: Part No. LBUP7-2,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

8/1/2016

Plaintiff
Objections:
403

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not
produced in
discovery

7/13/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not
produced in
discovery

5/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not

449

Arkon webpage: www.Arkon.com,
obtained from the Internet Archive's
Wayback Machine

457

Arkon Mounts Facebook Page "Look who
stopped by Arkon HQ Today…."

458

Arkon Mounts Facebook Page "With
Carla Renata and Aaron Roth"

459

Arkon Mounts Facebook Page "With
Vada Ashley"

24

Trial
Ex.
No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)
produced in
discovery

460

Arkon Mounts Facebook Page

5/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not
produced in
discovery

5/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not
produced in
discovery

461

Arkon Mounts Facebook Page "With
Vada Ashley"

462

Arkon Webpage: "US Resellers - Online
Retail Partners," obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback Machine

11/19/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; not
produced in
discovery

466

NPI Pocket Brochure, REV-0415

Apr. 2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

467

Physical Example of NPI Pocket
brochure, REV-0415

Apr. 2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

468

NPI Pocket Brochure, REV-0416

Apr. 2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

469

Native PDF File of NPI Pocket Brochure,
REV-0613

Jun. 2013

FRE601, 901

470

Native PDF File of NPI Pocket Brochure,
REV-0915

Sept. 2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

471

Native PDF File of NPI Pocket Brochure,
REV-0915

Jan. 2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

1/19/2001

FRE 602,
901

4/17/2006

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

473

NPI-ARK00000791

Drawing: RAM Double Socket ARM for
1.5" Diameter Balls

474

ARK002322 ARK002349

Supplemental amendment in response to
non-final office action from the
prosecution file history for the 09/733,691
patent application (U.S. RE43,806)

25

Trial
Ex.
No.

476

477

479

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 40

Document Description

GPSLockBox Flex System

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 41

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 43

Objection(s)

7/26/1917

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408 , 602,
901
FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
901

GPSLockBox Flex System

ARKON Resources Invoice Number
201716 to Innovative Intelligent Products
for Lock Box Pedestal Mount Bundle

Document
Date

9/25/2014

FRE 402,
403

11/20/2002

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

11/16/2004

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

493

File History of U.S. Patent RE42,060
(Application No. 10/300,951)

494

File History of U.S. Patent RE42,581
(Application No. 10/991,325)

495

File History of U.S. Patent RE43,806
(Application No. 09/733,691

12/07/2000

Plaintiff
Objections:
FRE 402,
403

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
1.5 Inch Ball Mount with 6.25" X 2"
Rectangle Base, Standard Length Double
Socket – RAM 111

2/24/2016

402, 403

496

NPI-ARK00000781
–
NPI-ARK00000784;
Color Version of
Hersey Dep. Exh.
144

26

Defendant’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex.
No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

500

AR000185 ‐
AR000204

U.S. Patent No. 5,845,885

12/8/1998

FRE 402,
403

501

ARK004555 ‐
ARK004557

U.S. Patent No. 1,455,441

5/15/1923

FRE 402,
403

502

ARK004558 ‐
ARK004560

U.S. Patent No. 2,650,788

9/1/1953

FRE 402,
403

503

ARK004561 ‐
ARK004564

U.S. Patent No. 2,710,609

6/14/1955

FRE 402,
403

504

ARK004565 ‐
ARK004569

U.S. Patent No. 7,178,421

2/20/2007

FRE 402,
403

505

ARK004380 ‐
ARK004408

Webpage from Amazon.com: for GPS
Mount

8/21/2016

FRE 402,
403

509

ARK003230 ‐
ARK003281

File History of U.S. Patent Application
No. 10/300,951

4/25/2006

FRE 106,
402, 403

510

Carnevali Dep. Exh.
113

U.S. Reissued Patent No. RE42,060

1/25/2011

FRE 402,
403

511

Carnevali Dep. Exh.
114

U.S. Reissued Patent No. RE43,806

11/20/2012

FRE 402,
403

512

ARK002322 ‐
ARK002415

File History of U.S. Patent Application
No. 09/733,691

4/17/2006

FRE 106,
402, 403

513

Carnevali Dep. Exh.
116

U.S. Reissued Patent No. RE42,581

8/2/2011

FRE 402,
403

514

ARK004346 ‐
ARK004379

Consent Judgment, Order on the Parties’
Proposed Consent Judgment, Amended
[Proposed] Consent Judgment, Amended
Consent Judgment in Civil Case No.
CV04-02524P

9/8/2006

FRE 402,
403

516

NPI-ARK00011292 NPI-ARK00011293

Email from Jeff Carnevali re Ram
Mounting Systems @ IWCE 05

4/11/2005

FRE 106,
402, 403,
602, 802

Marked

27

Trial
Ex.
No.

Document
Date

Objection(s)

Webpage from Amazon.com entitled
“Arkon Universal Marine Electronic
Fishfinder Mount”

1/8/2016

FRE 402,
403, 404

ARK004248 ‐
ARK004253; Hersey
Dep. Exh. 128

Webpage from rammount.com re RAMB- 201U-A

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

523

Hersey Dep. Exh.
129

NPI’S Responses to Arkon’s
First Set of Requests for Admission, depo
exhibit 129

9/1/2016

FRE 402,
403

524

ARK004117 ‐
ARK004122;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
130

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Double Socket Arm for 1" Balls - RAMB-201U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

525

ARK004191 ‐
ARK004196;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
131

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Long Double Socket Arm for 1" Balls RAM-B-201U-C

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

526

ARK003974 ‐
ARK003979;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
132

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
1" Ball Standard Length Double Socket
Arm with 2.5" Round Base that Contains
the AMPs Hole Pattern Unpackaged RAM-B-103U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

527

ARK003957 ‐
ARK003962;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
133

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
1" Ball Short Length Double Socket Arm
with 2.5" Round Base that Contains the
AMPs Hole Pattern- RAM-B-103U- A

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

528

ARK004288 ‐
ARK004293;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
134

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Standard Length Double Socket Arm for
2.25" Balls Unpackaged - RAM-D-201U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

529

ARK004155 ‐
ARK004159;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
135

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Double Socket Arm with Pin- Lock TM
Security Knob and Key Knob for 1" Balls
Unpackaged- RAM-B-201- SU

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

517

ARK003891 ‐
ARK003896

522

Marked

28

Trial
Ex.
No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

530

ARK004216 ‐
ARK004221;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
136

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Long Length Double Socket Arm for
2.25" Balls - RAM-D- 201U-E

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

531

ARK003986 ‐
ARK003991;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
137

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
1" Ball Standard Length Double Socket
Arm with Diamond Base Unpackaged RAM-B- 103-238U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403

532

ARK004052 ‐
ARK004057;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
138

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Composite Double Socket Swivel Arm
for 1.5" Balls Unpackaged - RAP-200-2U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

533

ARK004107 ‐
ARK004111;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
139

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Double Socket Arm for 0.56" Balls
Unpackaged – RAM-A- 201U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

534

ARK004232 ‐
ARK004237;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
140

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Composite Double Socket Swivel Arm
for 1.5" Balls Unpackaged – RAP-20012U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

535

ARK004186 ‐
ARK004190;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
141

Webpage from
rammount.com re RAM Light Series
Composite Double Socket Arm for 1"
Balls Unpackaged – RAP-201-1U

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

536

ARK004205 ‐
ARK004209;
Hersey Dep. Exh.
142

Webpage from rammount.com re RAM
Long Length Double Socket Arm for
0.56" Balls – RAM-A- 201U-B

8/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

550

ARK003933ARK003940

Arkon OEM Solutions Guide

8/11/2013

FRE 402,
403, 602

552

ARK004414ARK004428

Amazon webpages for Tablet Mount

8/21/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

553

ARK004429ARK004436

Amazon webpages for Mount Arm with
ball joint

8/21/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

554

ARK004437ARK004439

dailysteals.com webpages

8/26/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

Marked

29

Trial
Ex.
No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

555

ARK004508ARK004547

Rammount.com webpages

8/21/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

556

ARK004570ARK004589

Walmart.com webpages

8/21/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

558

ARK007590

Printout from Arkon Instagram

11/10/2016

FRE 402,
403

564

ARK003801ARK003876

NPI Design Patent Application
29/370,076

4/18/2012

FRE 402,
403, 602

Marked

567

Physical product, Arkon TW Broadcaster,
Tablet and Phone Tripod Mount, model
no. TWBRVTAB

FRE 402,
403, 602

570

Physical product, Arkon TW Broadcaster
Combo, Tripod Phone & Midsize Tablet
Mount for Live Mobile Broadcasting,
model no. TWBRVSM6

FRE 402,
403, 602

573

Physical product, Arkon TW Broadcaster,
Single Smartphone Monopod or Tripod
Mount for Live Mobile Broadcasting,
model no. TWBRV01

FRE 402,
403, 602

574

Physical product, Arkon Sound Feeder,
CD Mount with Built-In Wireless Audio
Adapter, model no. SF340

FRE 402,
403, 602
FRE 402,
403, 602

575

ARK007757

Printout from Arkon, Sound Feeder, CD
Mount with Built- In Wireless Audio
Adapter, model no. SF340

576

ARK007758 –
ARK007759

NPI webpage, RAM Mount Catalogs

577

ARK007760 ARK007791

578
579

8/6/2013

FRE 402,
403, 602

NPI Marine catalog

2013

FRE 402,
403, 602

ARK007792 ARK007797

Arkon Brochure

2000

FRE 402,
403, 602, 802

ARK007798

Instructions for MP070-7PS- 2, 7"
Windshield Suction Mounting Pedestal

2014

FRE 402,
403, 602, 802

30

Trial
Ex.
No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

581

ARK007800 ARK007801

RAM Mount webpage from
rammount.com, obtained from
the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine

1/28/2010

FRE 402,
403, 602

585

ARK007845

RAM Mount webpage from
rammount.com.

8/7/2013

FRE 402,
403, 602

586

ARK007846

RAM Mount webpage from
rammount.com.

3/30/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602

588

ARK000615ARK000639

RAM Mount webapges from
rammount.com

2/17/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602

592

Carnevali Dep Exh.
101

Defendant Arkon Resources, Inc.
Deposition Notice of National Products,
Inc. Pursuant to FRCP 30(b)(6)

8/22/2016

FRE 402,
403

National Products Inc.’s Responses to
Defendant Arkon Resources, Inc.’s First
Set of Interrogatories

3/8/2016

FRE 402,
403

593

Marked

31

III.

Authenticity and Admissibility Disputed

Plaintiff’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex. No.

Document
Date

Objection(s)

NPI-ARK00068930 NPI-ARK00068933

Photos of NPI hourglass shaped
mounts - PMA 71st Annual
Convention and Tradeshow,
February 9-12, 1995

2/9/1995

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

8

NPI-ARK00068447

Picture of RAM Booth at PMA 95
Annual Convention & Trade
Show, Las Vegas, Nevada Feb. 912, 1995

2/9/1995

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

9

NPI-ARK00001810-1
- NPI-ARK000018103

Printout of native spreadsheet:
2016 Tradeshow List.xlsx

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

10

NPI-ARK00001810

2016 Tradeshow List.xlsx (native
spreadsheet)

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

11

NPI-ARK00068952-1
NPI-ARK0006895220

Printout of native spreadsheet:
Tradeshow List 98‐Present
External.xlsx

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

12

NPI-ARK00068952

Tradeshow List 98‐Present
External.xlsx (native spreadsheet)

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

40

NPI-ARK00068393

Printout of Native spreadsheet:
Pocket Brochure Shipments.xlsx

Mar. 2016

FRE 403,
602, 901

41

NPI-ARK00068393

Pocket Brochure Shipments.xlsx
(native spreadsheet)

Mar. 2016

FRE 403,
602, 901

42

NPI-ARK00069677 NPI-ARK00069679

Examples of NPI Pocket
Brochures

43

NPI-ARK00068420

Round-A-Mount® advertisement

1993

FRE 602,
901

44

NPI-ARK00068420

WaterSki Magazine - Ski-N-Stow

July 1993

FRE 403,
602, 802, 901

7

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

32

FRE 403,
602, 901

Trial
Ex. No.

69

71

72

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

NPI-ARK00069875

Document Description

Jurassic World promotional poster

Document
Date

Objection(s)

01/12/2015

FRE 402,
FRE 403,
Not produced
in discovery,
602, 901

NPI-ARK00069876 NPI-ARK00069878

Photographs of RAM Mounts
installed in military vehicles

FRE 402,
FRE 403,
Not produced
in discovery,
602, 901

NPI-ARK00069879

Photograph of a RAM Mount in
use during a Pete Carroll press
conference

FRE 402,
FRE 403,
Not produced
in discovery,
602, 901

113

NPI product review, available at
www.youtube.com/watch?v=mbqbroqIzs

12/26/2013

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

115

NPI product review, available at
www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXeY
WZtiuoc

12/3/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

116

NPI-ARK00068471 NPI-ARK00068473

Cabela’s® 1996 Tackle Shop and
Master Spring catalogs

1996

FRE 403,
602, 802, 901

117

NPI-ARK00068469 NPI-ARK00068470

Pages from Cabela’s® 1996
Marine and Summer Sale catalogs

1996

FRE 403,
602, 802, 901

157

159

NPI-ARK00069880

NPI-ARK00069881

Photograph of a RAM mount in
use at a Chick-fil-A restaraunt

FRE 402,
403 (Not
produced
during
discovery),
602, 901

Photograph of a RAM mount in
use at an ESPN NHRA race track

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

33

Trial
Ex. No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)
FRE 402,
403, Not
produced
during
discovery,
602, 901

179

NPI-ARK00069882 NPI-ARK00069883

Photographs of a RAM Mount
installed on a baby stroller with
skis attached

181

NPI-ARK00001192 NPI-ARK00001196

Various images of NPI and Arkon
mounts, and Amazon.com
webpage of Arkon Part Nos.
LBUP7-1 & LBUP7-2

FRE 402,
403, BEST
EVIDENCE,
602, 901

182

NPI-ARK00001196 NPI-ARK00001199

Various images of NPI and Arkon
double socket arms

FRE 403,
BEST
EVIDENCE,
602, 901

188

NPI-ARK00069884 NPI-ARK00069890

Photographs of various RAM
Mounts displayed at trade shows

FRE 106,
402, 403,
602, 901

207

NPI-ARK00069669 NPI-ARK00069676

Declaration of Timothy Peterson
and Ex. A

9/8/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
802, 901

208

NPI-ARK00069571 NPI-ARK00069579

Declaration of Rob Dorsey and
Ex. A

9/10/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
802, 901

209

NPI-ARK00069580 NPI-ARK00069668

Declaration of Joshua Knichel and
Exs. A-C

9/12/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
802, 901

Initial Expert Report of J.
Babcock, with Appxs. 1-2

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;

214

215

Ex. A to Babcock
Initial Expert Report

Curriculum Vitae of J. Babcock

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;

216

Ex. B to Babcock
Initial Expert Report

Arkon Products Reviewed

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;

34

Trial
Ex. No.
217

221

222

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

Ex. C to Babcock
Initial Expert Report

Materials Considered

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
702, 703,
901; Subject
to MIL

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
702, 703,
901; Subject
to MIL

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901, Subject
to MIL

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;
Subject to
MIL

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802; Subject
to MIL

Ex. C to Obermiller
Initial Expert Report

Ex. E to Obermiller
Initial Expert Report

225

Pictures of Versatrue mount

Photos, drawings, and images of
NPI and Arkon Mounts

Expert Report of Drew E. Voth

226

Sched. 1 to Voth
Expert Report

Arkon's Sales of Accused Products
- Summary

227

Sched. 2 to Voth
Expert Report

Arkon's Dollar Sales of Accused
Products - Detail

228

Sched. 3 to Voth
Expert Report

Arkon's Sales Quantities of
Accused Products - Detail

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;
Subject to
MIL

229

Ex. 1 to Voth Expert
Report

Curriculum Vitae, including
Testimony, Speeches and
Publications of Drew E. Voth

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

230

Ex. 2 to Voth Expert
Report

Documents Considered

7/20/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

35

Trial
Ex. No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

ECF No. 54

Declaration of James B. Babcock
in Support of NPI's Response in
Opposition to Arkon Resources,
Inc.'s Motion for Summary
Judgment of Invalidity and NonInfringement (ECF No. 54)

10/31/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901; Subject
to MIL

232

233

NPI-ARK00067352 NPI-ARK00067367

Expert Report of Steven Moore
and Appx. A-B - Nat'l Prods., Inc.
v. Gamber-Johnson LLC

4/5/2006

FRE 402,
403, 601,
802, 901

234

NPI-ARK00067419 NPI-ARK00067436

Supplemental Expert Report of
Steven Moore - Nat'l Prods., Inc.
v. Gamber-Johnson LLC

4/24/2006

FRE 402,
403, 601,
802, 901

D. McDuff & D. Fairweather,
"Measuring Marketing: Using
Content Analysis to Evaluate
Relative Value in Valuation and
Reasonable Royalty Analysis" les
Nouvelles, June 2016

June 2016

FRE 402,
403, 601,
802, 901

Marked

235

262

ARK001346 ARK001346

CJ Gandra email to J. Tworkowski
re: RAM Mount - Quote Needed
(native email)

8/18/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

263

ARK001346-1 ARK001346-2

CJ Gandra email to J. Tworkowski
re: RAM Mount - Quote Needed

8/18/2015

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

281

ARK001361-1 ARK001361-5

CJ Gandra email to P. Horner
(viavisolutions.com) re: Ram
Mounts RAM-HOL-PD3U

5/19/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

ARK001361

CJ Gandra email to P. Horner
(viavisolutions.com) re: Ram
Mounts RAM-HOL-PD3U (native
email)

5/19/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

282

291

NPI-ARK00069891

Photograph of an Arkon mount
with the original design

36

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408; Not
produced
during
discovery

Trial
Ex. No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

292

Physical product sample of Bosch
Mount pictured in NPIARK00069892

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602,
901; Not
produced
during
discovery

294

Physical product sample of RVS1420 Double Swivel Monitor
Mount from Rear View Safety
pictured in NPI-ARK00069893

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

295

Physical product sample of
Kamerar Mighty Metal Arm Kit
pictured in NPI-ARK00069894

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

296

Physical product sample of
Versatrue mount pictured in NPIARK00069895 - NPIARK00069896

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

298

ARK007501

Arkon product insert for Slim-Grip
Ultra Drill Base Mount (Part No.
RM6AMPS2T)

1/25/2016

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408

300

ARK001881 ARK001882

Document entitled "Top 25
AMZN Searches Related to the
Word "Mount" - MARCH 2015

Mar. 2015

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

303

ARK003929 ARK003932

The Arkon Insider, vol. 2, issue 3

307

NPI-ARK00069553 NPI-ARK00069553

2014 CES Show - Arkon Booth
Photo 1

Plaintiff
Objections:
403, 602,
901, BEST
EVIDENCE

37

2014

FRE 106,
403, 602, 901

Trial
Ex. No.
308

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

NPI-ARK00069554 NPI-ARK00069554

2014 CES Show - Arkon Booth
Photo 2

Objection(s)

2014

FRE 106,
403, 602, 901
FRE 402,
403, 602, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

Physical product sample of RAM
mount pictured in NPIARK00070333

334

351

Document
Date

NPI-ARK00070241 NPI-ARK00070320

Ram Mounts, Vehicle catalog

8/1/2017

4/20/2017

352

NPI-ARK00070321 NPI-ARK00070331

Amazon.com web page, Arkon
Universal Marine Electronic
Fishfinder Mount

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery);
FRE 402,
403 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Physical product sample of
chrome RAM mount pictured in
NPI-ARK00070332

355

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

362

NPI-ARK00069850 NPI-ARK00069859

Facebook pages from
www.facebook.com/lovemyattachi
t/photos

363

NPI-ARK00069692

Screenshot from AttachIt website

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

Screenshot of AttachIt video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

364

NPI-ARK00069848

38

9/19/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

Trial
Ex. No.
365

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

NPI-ARK00069849

Screenshot of AttachIt video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901

Objection(s)

366

NPI-ARK00069691

AttachIt Video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

367

NPI-ARK00069693

AttachIt Video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

369

NPI-ARK00069695

AttachIt Video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

370

NPI-ARK00069696

AttachIt Video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

AttachIt Video

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

371

NPI-ARK00069697

372

Webpage obtained from
www.attachit.com

12/15/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

374

Webpages obtained from
www.attachit.com/product/vehicle
package

12/12/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

391

AR000177 AR000179

Pictures of Arkon double-socket
arms

418

ARK004591

Arkon income statement

422

AR000658 AR000874

Arkon Purchase Orders, Invoices,
and Shipping Documentation

39

FRE 402,
403, 407, 408

8/25/2016

3/5/2014

402, 403,
602, 802,
901, subject
to MIL
Plaintiff
Objections:
403, 602,
802, 901

Trial
Ex. No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

425

ARK001437 ARK001439

Amount Inc. Invoice No. AI030610S1 for plastic samples

6/10/2014

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901;

426

ARK001447 ARK001448

Amount Inc. Invoice No. AI041023S1 for plastic sample
"RAM New Shape Clamp"

10/23/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602, 901

427

ARK001502

Amount Inc. Invoice No. AI041026S1 for plastic samples
"RAM New Shape Clamp V2"

10/26/2015

FRE 402,
403, 407,
408, 602, 901

428

NPI-ARK00001251

Chart entitled "Parts with
Hourglass Shaped Arms - Sales for
Calendar Years 2005 to 2015)
(Printed from native spreadsheet,
NPI-ARK00001251)

5/18/2016

FRE 403,
602, 901

429

NPI-ARK00001811

NPI Advertising Expenses:
Pocket Brochure and Catalogs

3/3/2016

FRE 403,
602, 901

430

NPI-ARK00001262

2016 Price List:
RAMPRICE01012016ALLCUST
OM.xls (native spreadsheet)

1/1/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

437

NPI-ARK00001251

HOURGLASS PART SLS 2005
TO 2016.xlsx (native spreadsheet)

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

438

NPI-ARK00001251

Hourglass Parts Sold 2005 - 2016,
pivot table derived from native
spreadsheet, NPI-ARK00001251

2016

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

Marked

Physical example of Arkon Part
No. RMSAMPS1420

441

447

448

NPI-ARK00069861

FRE 602,
901

Physical example of NPI Part No.
RAP-B-138U

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901, not
produced
during
discovery

Webpage from amazon.com (Part
No. RMS2XAMPS) and product
purchase invoices

40

6/3/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901

Trial
Ex. No.

Document
Date

Objection(s)

454

Arkon webpage: Part No.
LBUP7-2

3/24/2017

FRE 403,
602, 901, not
produced in
discovery

456

Arkon webpage: Part No.
RM0861420, obtained from the
Internet Archive's Wayback
Machine

4/28/2016

FRE 403, not
produced in
discovery

3/29/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602,
801, 902
(Not
Produced In
Discovery)

9/23/2016

FRE 402,
403, 602,
801, 902
(Not
Produced In
Discovery)

463

464

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Webpage from Amazon.com:
"Shop AccessoryBasics by
Charger City"

Invoice from Amazon.com for
Accessory Basics 4-inch tall
mount

465

Physical Example: Accessory
Basics 4-inch tall mount

FRE 402,
403, 602,
801, 902
(Not
Produced In
Discovery)

472

Webpage from Amazon.com:
"AccessoriesBasics 4-inch tall
glass composite dual socket
arm…"

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901;
Not produced
in discovery

481

Physical product sample of a
Kingjoy mount

41

3/29/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802, 901
(Not
produced
during
discovery)

Trial
Ex. No.

483

484

488

489

490

491

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 47

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 50

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 56

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 57

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 58

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 59

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)

Physical product sample of a
Scotty Ball Mount

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Physical product sample of a
Garmin GPS Mount

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Felix Baumgartner's supersonic
freefall from 128k' - Mission
Highlights.mp4 (physical CD)

FRE 106,
402, 403,
602, 802,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Samsung Galaxy- Commitment to
Quality.mp4 (physical CD)

FRE 402,
403, 602,
802,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Photograph from
www.redbullstratos.com

04/18/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

04/18/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Photograph from
www.universetoday.com

42

Trial
Ex. No.

Marked

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

Document
Date

Objection(s)
FRE 402,
403, 602,
901 (Not
produced
during
discovery)

Todrzak Dep. Ex. 60

Physical product sample of NPI
composite mount, RAP-B-139-U

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

506

Carnevali Dep. Exh.
108

Photos of Arkon Product

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

507

ARK003934

Arkon Catalog Page with Part No.
CM043

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

542

AR000161 –
AR000167

Arkon Insider

5/27/2015

FRE 602,
802, 901

543

AR000168 –
AR000171

Arkon Insider

10/6/2015

FRE 602,
802, 901

544

AR000657

Inventory on Hand

545

AR000907 –
AR0001053

Sales finance Data (6/17/16
Production) (Partially redacted)

6/17/2016

FRE 106,
402, 403,
802, 901

548

ARK007743 –
ARK007756

Terry White’s Tech Blog

10/30/2015

FRE 402,
602, 802, 901

557

ARK004590ARK004593

Arkon cost documents (Partially
Redacted)

8/25/2016

FRE 106,
402, 403, 901

560

Carnevali Dep. Exh.
109

Physical product Arkon mounting
pedestal (Corresponds to Exhibit
506)

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

563

Hersey Dep. Exh. 126

Physical product, Ram Mount
Composite Short Arm for 1inch
Ball Bases

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

492

Defendant’s Exhibits
Trial
Ex. No.

Marked

43

Document
Date

Objection(s)

FRE 106,
602, 802, 901

Trial
Ex. No.

Bates Range or
Other Identifier

Document Description

565

ARK007719 –
ARK007741

Old Shaft Sales Summary
Attorneys’ Eyes Only

566

ARK007742

Old Shaft Sales Summary (Native
Format) Attorneys’ Eyes Only

587

Exh. 45 to Todzrak
Deposition

Nexlink Communications
Webpage

7/26/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602, 901

589

ARK005690ARK006728

Arkon invoices from October 2,
2015 through April 15, 2016

10/2/201504/15/2016

FRE 106,
602, 802, 901

590

ARK007745ARK007749

Pages from http://terrywhite.com/

08/17/2015

FRE 402,
602, 802, 901

10/17/2017

FRE 402,
403, 602,
901, not
produced
during
discovery

591

Marked

ARK000785ARK007910

Pages from
http://www.bluestoreinc.com

Document
Date

Objection(s)
FRE 106,
602, 901
FRE 106,
602, 802, 901

Native spreadsheet:
RM1AccusedCost-Final -ATTORNEYS EYES ONLY

FRE 403,
602, 802,
901, 1006,
LCR
16(i)(5), not
produced
during
discovery

Native spreadsheet:
SalesSummary_RM1-Final -ATTORNEYS EYES ONLY

FRE 403,
602, 802,
901, 1006,
LCR
16(i)(5), not
produced
during
discovery

594

595

596

Purchase orders underlying the
summary of costs

2

*2

NPI objects to this exhibit because Arkon has never provided these documents to NPI. Arkon first disclosed
an identification of these documents at 11:49 am prior to filing this Amended Pretrial Order, noting that it “will
make the documents available for inspection later today [December 1, 2017].” NPI reserves its right to make
additional objections upon receipt and review of the documents.
44

45