Doe et al v. Donald Trump, President of The United States et al

Filing 1

COMPLAINT --Class Action Complaint for Declaratory and Injunctive Relief-- against defendant(s) Donald Trump, President of The United States, John Kelly, Secretary of Homeland Security, Kevin McAleenan, Acting Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Michele James, Field Director of the Seattle Field Office of U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Rex Tillerson, Secretary of State, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Department of State (Receipt # 0981-4758977) Attorney Lynn Lincoln Sarko added to party Jane Doe(pty:pla), Attorney Lynn Lincoln Sarko added to party John Doe(pty:pla), Attorney Lynn Lincoln Sarko added to party Episcopal Diocese of Olympia(pty:pla), filed by Episcopal Diocese of Olympia, John Doe, Jane Doe. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A - Executive Order entitled, "Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States", # 2 Exhibit Exhibit B - Joint Declaration of Madeline K. Albright, Avril D. Haines, Michael V. Hayden, John F. Kerry, John E. McLaughlin, Lisa O. Monaco, Michael J. Morrell, Janet A. Napolitano, Leon E. Panetta, Susan E. Rice, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit C - Provisional Revocation Letter, # 4 Exhibit Exhibit D - Guidance issued to all employees of the USCIS by the Acting Director of DHS, # 5 Civil Cover Sheet, # 6 Summons, # 7 Summons, # 8 Summons, # 9 Summons, # 10 Summons, # 11 Summons, # 12 Summons, # 13 Summons)(Sarko, Lynn)

EXHIBIT A

9;88!

Rtgukfgpvkcn!Fqewogpvu

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt!
Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31!
Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128!

Vkvng! 4˜!

Gzgewvkxg! Qtfgt! 2487;! qh! Lcpwct{! 38-! 3128!

Vjg! Rtgukfgpv!

Rtqvgevkpi! vjg! Pcvkqp! Htqo! Hqtgkip! Vgttqtkuv! Gpvt{! Kpvq! vjg!
Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu!
D{! vjg! cwvjqtkv{! xguvgf! kp! og! cu! Rtgukfgpv! d{! vjg! Eqpuvkvwvkqp! cpf! ncyu!
qh! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! qh! Cogtkec-! kpenwfkpi! vjg! Kookitcvkqp! cpf! Pcvkqpcnkv{!
Cev! )KPC*-! 9! W/U/E/! 2212! gv! ugs/-! cpf! ugevkqp! 412! qh! vkvng! 4-! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu!
Eqfg-! cpf! vq! rtqvgev! vjg! Cogtkecp! rgqrng! htqo! vgttqtkuv! cvvcemu! d{! hqtgkip!
pcvkqpcnu! cfokvvgf! vq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! kv! ku! jgtgd{! qtfgtgf! cu! hqnnqyu<!
Ugevkqp!2/!Rwtrqug/!Vjg!xkuc.kuuwcpeg!rtqeguu!rnc{u!c!etwekcn!tqng!kp!fgvgevkpi!
kpfkxkfwcnu! ykvj! vgttqtkuv! vkgu! cpf! uvqrrkpi! vjgo! htqo! gpvgtkpi! vjg! Wpkvgf!
Uvcvgu/! Rgtjcru! kp! pq! kpuvcpeg! ycu! vjcv! oqtg! crrctgpv! vjcp! vjg! vgttqtkuv!
cvvcemu! qh! Ugrvgodgt! 22-! 3112-! yjgp! Uvcvg! Fgrctvogpv! rqnke{! rtgxgpvgf!
eqpuwnct! qhhkegtu! htqo! rtqrgtn{! uetwvkpk|kpi! vjg! xkuc! crrnkecvkqpu! qh! ugxgtcn!
qh! vjg! 2;! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! yjq! ygpv! qp! vq! owtfgt! pgctn{! 4-111! Cogtkecpu/!
Cpf! yjkng! vjg! xkuc.kuuwcpeg! rtqeguu! ycu! tgxkgygf! cpf! cogpfgf! chvgt! vjg!
Ugrvgodgt! 22! cvvcemu! vq! dgvvgt! fgvgev! yqwnf.dg! vgttqtkuvu! htqo! tgegkxkpi!
xkucu-! vjgug! ogcuwtgu! fkf! pqv! uvqr! cvvcemu! d{! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! yjq! ygtg!
cfokvvgf!vq!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu/!
Pwogtqwu! hqtgkip.dqtp! kpfkxkfwcnu! jcxg! dggp! eqpxkevgf! qt! kornkecvgf! kp!
vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf! etkogu! ukpeg! Ugrvgodgt! 22-! 3112-! kpenwfkpi! hqtgkip! pcvkqp.
cnu!yjq!gpvgtgf!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu!chvgt!tgegkxkpi!xkukvqt-!uvwfgpv-!qt!gornq{.
ogpv! xkucu-! qt! yjq! gpvgtgf! vjtqwij! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! tghwigg! tgugvvngogpv!
rtqitco/! Fgvgtkqtcvkpi! eqpfkvkqpu! kp! egtvckp! eqwpvtkgu! fwg! vq! yct-! uvtkhg-!
fkucuvgt-! cpf! ekxkn! wptguv! kpetgcug! vjg! nkmgnkjqqf! vjcv! vgttqtkuvu! yknn! wug!
cp{! ogcpu! rquukdng! vq! gpvgt! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu/! Vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! owuv!
dg! xkikncpv! fwtkpi! vjg! xkuc.kuuwcpeg! rtqeguu! vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! vjqug! crrtqxgf!
hqt! cfokuukqp! fq! pqv! kpvgpf! vq! jcto! Cogtkecpu! cpf! vjcv! vjg{! jcxg! pq!
vkgu!vq!vgttqtkuo/!
Kp! qtfgt! vq! rtqvgev! Cogtkecpu-! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! owuv! gpuwtg! vjcv! vjqug!
cfokvvgf! vq! vjku! eqwpvt{! fq! pqv! dgct! jquvkng! cvvkvwfgu! vqyctf! kv! cpf! kvu!
hqwpfkpi! rtkpekrngu/! Vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! ecppqv-! cpf! ujqwnf! pqv-! cfokv! vjqug!
yjq! fq! pqv! uwrrqtv! vjg! Eqpuvkvwvkqp-! qt! vjqug! yjq! yqwnf! rnceg! xkqngpv!
kfgqnqikgu! qxgt! Cogtkecp! ncy/! Kp! cffkvkqp-! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! ujqwnf! pqv!
cfokv! vjqug! yjq! gpicig! kp! cevu! qh! dkiqvt{! qt! jcvtgf! )kpenwfkpi! ’’jqpqt““!
mknnkpiu-! qvjgt! hqtou! qh! xkqngpeg! cickpuv! yqogp-! qt! vjg! rgtugewvkqp! qh! vjqug!
yjq!rtcevkeg!tgnkikqpu!fkhhgtgpv!htqo!vjgkt!qyp*!qt!vjqug!yjq!yqwnf!qrrtguu!
Cogtkecpu!qh!cp{!tceg-!igpfgt-!qt!ugzwcn!qtkgpvcvkqp/!

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

Uge/! 3/! Rqnke{/! Kv! ku! vjg! rqnke{! qh! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! vq! rtqvgev! kvu! ekvk|gpu!
htqo! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! yjq! kpvgpf! vq! eqookv! vgttqtkuv! cvvcemu! kp! vjg! Wpkvgf!
Uvcvgu=! cpf! vq! rtgxgpv! vjg! cfokuukqp! qh! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! yjq! kpvgpf! vq!
gzrnqkv!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu!kookitcvkqp!ncyu!hqt!ocngxqngpv!rwtrqugu/!
Uge/! 4/! Uwurgpukqp! qh! Kuuwcpeg! qh! Xkucu! cpf! Qvjgt! Kookitcvkqp! Dgpghkvu!
vq! Pcvkqpcnu! qh! Eqwpvtkgu! qh! Rctvkewnct! Eqpegtp/! )c*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqog.
ncpf! Ugewtkv{-! kp! eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! cpf! vjg! Fktgevqt!
qh! Pcvkqpcn! Kpvgnnkigpeg-! ujcnn! koogfkcvgn{! eqpfwev! c! tgxkgy! vq! fgvgtokpg!
vjg! kphqtocvkqp! pggfgf! htqo! cp{! eqwpvt{! vq! cflwfkecvg! cp{! xkuc-! cfokuukqp-!
qt! qvjgt! dgpghkv! wpfgt! vjg! KPC! )cflwfkecvkqpu*! kp! qtfgt! vq! fgvgtokpg! vjcv!
vjg! kpfkxkfwcn! uggmkpi! vjg! dgpghkv! ku! yjq! vjg! kpfkxkfwcn! enckou! vq! dg! cpf!
ku!pqv!c!ugewtkv{!qt!rwdnke.uchgv{!vjtgcv/!
)d*!Vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Jqogncpf!Ugewtkv{-!kp!eqpuwnvcvkqp!ykvj!vjg!Ugetgvct{!
qh!Uvcvg!cpf!vjg!Fktgevqt!qh!Pcvkqpcn!Kpvgnnkigpeg-!ujcnn!uwdokv!vq!vjg!Rtgukfgpv!
XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11114

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

9;89!

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt 0 Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31 0 Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128 0 Rtgukfgpvkcn! Fqewogpvu!
c! tgrqtv! qp! vjg! tguwnvu! qh! vjg! tgxkgy! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )c*! qh! vjku!
ugevkqp-! kpenwfkpi! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{“u! fgvgtokpcvkqp! qh!
vjg! kphqtocvkqp! pggfgf! hqt! cflwfkecvkqpu! cpf! c! nkuv! qh! eqwpvtkgu! vjcv! fq!
pqv! rtqxkfg! cfgswcvg! kphqtocvkqp-! ykvjkp! 41! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt/!
Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn! rtqxkfg! c! eqr{! qh! vjg! tgrqtv!
vq!vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Uvcvg!cpf!vjg!Fktgevqt!qh!Pcvkqpcn!Kpvgnnkigpeg/!
)e*!Vq!vgorqtctkn{!tgfweg!kpxguvkicvkxg!dwtfgpu!qp!tgngxcpv!cigpekgu!fwtkpi!
vjg! tgxkgy! rgtkqf! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )c*! qh! vjku! ugevkqp-! vq! gpuwtg!
vjg! rtqrgt! tgxkgy! cpf! oczkowo! wvknk|cvkqp! qh! cxckncdng! tguqwtegu! hqt! vjg!
uetggpkpi! qh! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu-! cpf! vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! cfgswcvg! uvcpfctfu! ctg!
guvcdnkujgf!vq!rtgxgpv!kphknvtcvkqp!d{!hqtgkip!vgttqtkuvu!qt!etkokpcnu-!rwtuwcpv!
vq! ugevkqp! 323)h*! qh! vjg! KPC-! 9! W/U/E/! 2293)h*-! K! jgtgd{! rtqencko! vjcv! vjg!
kookitcpv! cpf! pqpkookitcpv! gpvt{! kpvq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! qh! cnkgpu! htqo!
eqwpvtkgu! tghgttgf! vq! kp! ugevkqp! 328)c*)23*! qh! vjg! KPC-! 9! W/U/E/! 2298)c*)23*-!
yqwnf! dg! fgvtkogpvcn! vq! vjg! kpvgtguvu! qh! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! cpf! K! jgtgd{!
uwurgpf! gpvt{! kpvq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! cu! kookitcpvu! cpf! pqpkookitcpvu-!
qh! uwej! rgtuqpu! hqt! ;1! fc{u! htqo! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt! )gzenwfkpi! vjqug!
hqtgkip!pcvkqpcnu!vtcxgnkpi!qp!fkrnqocvke!xkucu-!Pqtvj!Cvncpvke!Vtgcv{!Qticpk.
|cvkqp! xkucu-! E—3! xkucu! hqt! vtcxgn! vq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Pcvkqpu-! cpf! I—2-! I—3-!
I—4-!cpf!I—5!xkucu*/!
)f*! Koogfkcvgn{! wrqp! tgegkrv! qh! vjg! tgrqtv! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )d*!
qh! vjku! ugevkqp! tgictfkpi! vjg! kphqtocvkqp! pggfgf! hqt! cflwfkecvkqpu-! vjg! Uge.
tgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn! tgswguv! cnn! hqtgkip! iqxgtpogpvu! vjcv! fq! pqv! uwrrn{!
uwej!kphqtocvkqp!vq!uvctv!rtqxkfkpi!uwej!kphqtocvkqp!tgictfkpi!vjgkt!pcvkqpcnu!
ykvjkp!71!fc{u!qh!pqvkhkecvkqp/!
)g*! Chvgt! vjg! 71.fc{! rgtkqf! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )f*! qh! vjku! ugevkqp!
gzrktgu-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{-! kp! eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Uge.
tgvct{!qh!Uvcvg-!ujcnn!uwdokv!vq!vjg!Rtgukfgpv!c!nkuv!qh!eqwpvtkgu!tgeqoogpfgf!
hqt! kpenwukqp! qp! c! Rtgukfgpvkcn! rtqencocvkqp! vjcv! yqwnf! rtqjkdkv! vjg! gpvt{!
qh!hqtgkip!pcvkqpcnu!)gzenwfkpi!vjqug!hqtgkip!pcvkqpcnu!vtcxgnkpi!qp!fkrnqocvke!
xkucu-! Pqtvj! Cvncpvke! Vtgcv{! Qticpk|cvkqp! xkucu-! E—3! xkucu! hqt! vtcxgn! vq! vjg!
Wpkvgf! Pcvkqpu-! cpf! I—2-! I—3-! I—4-! cpf! I—5! xkucu*! htqo! eqwpvtkgu! vjcv!
fq! pqv! rtqxkfg! vjg! kphqtocvkqp! tgswguvgf! rwtuwcpv! vq! uwdugevkqp! )f*! qh!
vjku!ugevkqp!wpvkn!eqornkcpeg!qeewtu/!
)h*! Cv! cp{! rqkpv! chvgt! uwdokvvkpi! vjg! nkuv! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )g*! qh!
vjku! ugevkqp-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! qt! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{!
oc{! uwdokv! vq! vjg! Rtgukfgpv! vjg! pcogu! qh! cp{! cffkvkqpcn! eqwpvtkgu! tge.
qoogpfgf!hqt!ukoknct!vtgcvogpv/!

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

)i*!Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi!c!uwurgpukqp!rwtuwcpv!vq!uwdugevkqp!)e*!qh!vjku!ugevkqp!
qt! rwtuwcpv! vq! c! Rtgukfgpvkcn! rtqencocvkqp! fguetkdgf! kp! uwdugevkqp! )g*! qh!
vjku! ugevkqp-! vjg! Ugetgvctkgu! qh! Uvcvg! cpf! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! oc{-! qp! c!
ecug.d{.ecug! dcuku-! cpf! yjgp! kp! vjg! pcvkqpcn! kpvgtguv-! kuuwg! xkucu! qt! qvjgt!
kookitcvkqp! dgpghkvu! vq! pcvkqpcnu! qh! eqwpvtkgu! hqt! yjkej! xkucu! cpf! dgpghkvu!
ctg!qvjgtykug!dnqemgf/!
)j*! Vjg! Ugetgvctkgu! qh! Uvcvg! cpf! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn! uwdokv! vq! vjg!
Rtgukfgpv! c! lqkpv! tgrqtv! qp! vjg! rtqitguu! kp! korngogpvkpi! vjku! qtfgt! ykvjkp!
41! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! c! ugeqpf! tgrqtv! ykvjkp! 71! fc{u! qh! vjg!
fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! c! vjktf! tgrqtv! ykvjkp! ;1! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-!
cpf!c!hqwtvj!tgrqtv!ykvjkp!231!fc{u!qh!vjg!fcvg!qh!vjku!qtfgt/!
Uge/! 5/! Korngogpvkpi! Wpkhqto! Uetggpkpi! Uvcpfctfu! hqt! Cnn! Kookitcvkqp! Rtq.
itcou/! )c*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{-! vjg!
Fktgevqt! qh! Pcvkqpcn! Kpvgnnkigpeg-! cpf! vjg! Fktgevqt! qh! vjg! Hgfgtcn! Dwtgcw!
qh! Kpxguvkicvkqp! ujcnn! korngogpv! c! rtqitco-! cu! rctv! qh! vjg! cflwfkecvkqp!
rtqeguu! hqt! kookitcvkqp! dgpghkvu-! vq! kfgpvkh{! kpfkxkfwcnu! uggmkpi! vq! gpvgt!
vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! qp! c! htcwfwngpv! dcuku! ykvj! vjg! kpvgpv! vq! ecwug! jcto-!
qt! yjq! ctg! cv! tkum! qh! ecwukpi! jcto! uwdugswgpv! vq! vjgkt! cfokuukqp/! Vjku!
rtqitco! yknn! kpenwfg! vjg! fgxgnqrogpv! qh! c! wpkhqto! uetggpkpi! uvcpfctf!
cpf! rtqegfwtg-! uwej! cu! kp.rgtuqp! kpvgtxkgyu=! c! fcvcdcug! qh! kfgpvkv{! fqew.
ogpvu! rtqhhgtgf! d{! crrnkecpvu! vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! fwrnkecvg! fqewogpvu! ctg! pqv!
XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11115

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt 0 Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31 0 Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128 0 Rtgukfgpvkcn! Fqewogpvu!

9;8;!

wugf! d{! ownvkrng! crrnkecpvu=! cogpfgf! crrnkecvkqp! hqtou! vjcv! kpenwfg! swgu.
vkqpu!ckogf!cv!kfgpvkh{kpi!htcwfwngpv!cpuygtu!cpf!ocnkekqwu!kpvgpv=!c!ogejc.
pkuo! vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! vjg! crrnkecpv! ku! yjq! vjg! crrnkecpv! enckou! vq! dg=! c!
rtqeguu! vq! gxcnwcvg! vjg! crrnkecpv“u! nkmgnkjqqf! qh! dgeqokpi! c! rqukvkxgn{! eqp.
vtkdwvkpi!ogodgt!qh!uqekgv{!cpf!vjg!crrnkecpv“u!cdknkv{!vq!ocmg!eqpvtkdwvkqpu!
vq! vjg! pcvkqpcn! kpvgtguv=! cpf! c! ogejcpkuo! vq! cuuguu! yjgvjgt! qt! pqv! vjg!
crrnkecpv! jcu! vjg! kpvgpv! vq! eqookv! etkokpcn! qt! vgttqtkuv! cevu! chvgt! gpvgtkpi!
vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu/!
)d*!Vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Jqogncpf!Ugewtkv{-!kp!eqplwpevkqp!ykvj!vjg!Ugetgvct{!
qh!Uvcvg-!vjg!Fktgevqt!qh!Pcvkqpcn!Kpvgnnkigpeg-!cpf!vjg!Fktgevqt!qh!vjg!Hgfgtcn!
Dwtgcw! qh! Kpxguvkicvkqp-! ujcnn! uwdokv! vq! vjg! Rtgukfgpv! cp! kpkvkcn! tgrqtv! qp!
vjg! rtqitguu! qh! vjku! fktgevkxg! ykvjkp! 71! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-!
c! ugeqpf! tgrqtv! ykvjkp! 211! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! cpf! c! vjktf!
tgrqtv!ykvjkp!311!fc{u!qh!vjg!fcvg!qh!vjku!qtfgt/!
Uge/! 6/! Tgcnkipogpv! qh! vjg! W/U/! Tghwigg! Cfokuukqpu! Rtqitco! hqt! Hkuecn!
[gct!3128/!)c*!Vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Uvcvg!ujcnn!uwurgpf! vjg!W/U/!Tghwigg!Cfoku.
ukqpu!Rtqitco!)WUTCR*!hqt!231!fc{u/!Fwtkpi!vjg!231.fc{!rgtkqf-!vjg!Ugetgvct{!
qh! Uvcvg-! kp! eqplwpevkqp! ykvj! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! cpf! kp!
eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Fktgevqt! qh! Pcvkqpcn! Kpvgnnkigpeg-! ujcnn! tgxkgy! vjg!
WUTCR! crrnkecvkqp! cpf! cflwfkecvkqp! rtqeguu! vq! fgvgtokpg! yjcv! cffkvkqpcn!
rtqegfwtgu!ujqwnf!dg!vcmgp!vq!gpuwtg!vjcv!vjqug!crrtqxgf!hqt!tghwigg!cfoku.
ukqp! fq! pqv! rqug! c! vjtgcv! vq! vjg! ugewtkv{! cpf! ygnhctg! qh! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-!
cpf! ujcnn! korngogpv! uwej! cffkvkqpcn! rtqegfwtgu/! Tghwigg! crrnkecpvu! yjq!
ctg! cntgcf{! kp! vjg! WUTCR! rtqeguu! oc{! dg! cfokvvgf! wrqp! vjg! kpkvkcvkqp!
cpf! eqorngvkqp! qh! vjgug! tgxkugf! rtqegfwtgu/! Wrqp! vjg! fcvg! vjcv! ku! 231!
fc{u! chvgt! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn! tguwog! WUTCR!
cfokuukqpu! qpn{! hqt! pcvkqpcnu! qh! eqwpvtkgu! hqt! yjkej! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg-!
vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Jqogncpf!Ugewtkv{-!cpf!vjg!Fktgevqt!qh!Pcvkqpcn!Kpvgnnkigpeg!
jcxg! lqkpvn{! fgvgtokpgf! vjcv! uwej! cffkvkqpcn! rtqegfwtgu! ctg! cfgswcvg! vq!
gpuwtg!vjg!ugewtkv{!cpf!ygnhctg!qh!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu/!
)d*! Wrqp! vjg! tguworvkqp! qh! WUTCR! cfokuukqpu-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg-!
kp! eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{-! ku! hwtvjgt! fktgevgf!
vq!ocmg!ejcpigu-!vq!vjg! gzvgpv!rgtokvvgf!d{!ncy-! vq!rtkqtkvk|g! tghwigg! enckou!
ocfg! d{! kpfkxkfwcnu! qp! vjg! dcuku! qh! tgnkikqwu.dcugf! rgtugewvkqp-! rtqxkfgf!
vjcv! vjg! tgnkikqp! qh! vjg! kpfkxkfwcn! ku! c! okpqtkv{! tgnkikqp! kp! vjg! kpfkxkfwcn“u!
eqwpvt{! qh! pcvkqpcnkv{/! Yjgtg! pgeguuct{! cpf! crrtqrtkcvg-! vjg! Ugetgvctkgu!
qh!Uvcvg!cpf!Jqogncpf!Ugewtkv{!ujcnn!tgeqoogpf!ngikuncvkqp!vq!vjg!Rtgukfgpv!
vjcv!yqwnf!cuukuv!ykvj!uwej!rtkqtkvk|cvkqp/!
)e*!Rwtuwcpv!vq!ugevkqp!323)h*!qh!vjg!KPC-!9!W/U/E/!2293)h*-!K!jgtgd{!rtqencko!
vjcv! vjg! gpvt{!qh!pcvkqpcnu! qh!U{tkc! cu!tghwiggu! ku!fgvtkogpvcn!vq! vjg! kpvgtguvu!
qh! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! cpf! vjwu! uwurgpf! cp{! uwej! gpvt{! wpvkn! uwej! vkog!
cu! K! jcxg! fgvgtokpgf! vjcv! uwhhkekgpv! ejcpigu! jcxg! dggp! ocfg! vq! vjg! WUTCR!
vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! cfokuukqp! qh! U{tkcp! tghwiggu! ku! eqpukuvgpv! ykvj! vjg! pcvkqpcn!
kpvgtguv/!

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

)f*! Rwtuwcpv! vq! ugevkqp! 323)h*! qh! vjg! KPC-! 9! W/U/E/! 2293)h*-! K! jgtgd{!
rtqencko! vjcv! vjg! gpvt{! qh! oqtg! vjcp! 61-111! tghwiggu! kp! hkuecn! {gct! 3128!
yqwnf!dg!fgvtkogpvcn!vq!vjg!kpvgtguvu!qh!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu-!cpf!vjwu!uwurgpf!
cp{! uwej! gpvt{! wpvkn! uwej! vkog! cu! K! fgvgtokpg! vjcv! cffkvkqpcn! cfokuukqpu!
yqwnf!dg!kp!vjg!pcvkqpcn!kpvgtguv/!
)g*! Pqvykvjuvcpfkpi! vjg! vgorqtct{! uwurgpukqp! korqugf! rwtuwcpv! vq! uwd.
ugevkqp! )c*! qh! vjku! ugevkqp-! vjg! Ugetgvctkgu! qh! Uvcvg! cpf! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{!
oc{! lqkpvn{! fgvgtokpg! vq! cfokv! kpfkxkfwcnu! vq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! cu! tghwiggu!
qp!c!ecug.d{.ecug!dcuku-!kp!vjgkt!fkuetgvkqp-!dwv!qpn{!uq!nqpi!cu!vjg{!fgvgtokpg!
vjcv!vjg!cfokuukqp!qh!uwej!kpfkxkfwcnu!cu!tghwiggu!ku!kp!vjg!pcvkqpcn!kpvgtguv˜!
kpenwfkpi!yjgp!vjg!rgtuqp!ku!c!tgnkikqwu!okpqtkv{!kp!jku!eqwpvt{!qh!pcvkqpcnkv{!
hcekpi! tgnkikqwu! rgtugewvkqp-! yjgp! cfokvvkpi! vjg! rgtuqp! yqwnf! gpcdng! vjg!
Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu!vq!eqphqto!kvu!eqpfwev!vq!c!rtggzkuvkpi!kpvgtpcvkqpcn!citggogpv-!
qt! yjgp! vjg! rgtuqp! ku! cntgcf{! kp! vtcpukv! cpf! fgp{kpi! cfokuukqp! yqwnf!
ecwug! wpfwg! jctfujkr˜cpf! kv! yqwnf! pqv! rqug! c! tkum! vq! vjg! ugewtkv{! qt!
ygnhctg!qh!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu/!
XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11116

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

9;91!

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt 0 Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31 0 Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128 0 Rtgukfgpvkcn! Fqewogpvu!
)h*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn! uwdokv! vq! vjg! Rtgukfgpv! cp! kpkvkcn! tgrqtv!
qp! vjg! rtqitguu! qh! vjg! fktgevkxg! kp! uwdugevkqp! )d*! qh! vjku! ugevkqp! tgictfkpi!
rtkqtkvk|cvkqp! qh! enckou! ocfg! d{! kpfkxkfwcnu! qp! vjg! dcuku! qh! tgnkikqwu.dcugf!
rgtugewvkqp! ykvjkp! 211! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt! cpf! ujcnn! uwdokv!
c!ugeqpf!tgrqtv!ykvjkp!311!fc{u!qh!vjg!fcvg!qh!vjku!qtfgt/!

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

)i*! Kv! ku! vjg! rqnke{! qh! vjg! gzgewvkxg! dtcpej! vjcv-! vq! vjg! gzvgpv! rgtokvvgf!
d{! ncy! cpf! cu! rtcevkecdng-! Uvcvg! cpf! nqecn! lwtkufkevkqpu! dg! itcpvgf! c! tqng!
kp! vjg! rtqeguu! qh! fgvgtokpkpi! vjg! rncegogpv! qt! ugvvngogpv! kp! vjgkt! lwtkufke.
vkqpu! qh! cnkgpu! gnkikdng! vq! dg! cfokvvgf! vq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! cu! tghwiggu/!
Vq! vjcv! gpf-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn! gzcokpg! gzkuvkpi!
ncy! vq! fgvgtokpg! vjg! gzvgpv! vq! yjkej-! eqpukuvgpv! ykvj! crrnkecdng! ncy-! Uvcvg!
cpf! nqecn! lwtkufkevkqpu! oc{! jcxg! itgcvgt! kpxqnxgogpv! kp! vjg! rtqeguu! qh!
fgvgtokpkpi! vjg! rncegogpv! qt! tgugvvngogpv! qh! tghwiggu! kp! vjgkt! lwtkufkevkqpu-!
cpf!ujcnn!fgxkug!c!rtqrqucn!vq!ncyhwnn{!rtqoqvg!uwej!kpxqnxgogpv/!
Uge/!7/!Tguekuukqp!qh!Gzgtekug!qh!Cwvjqtkv{!Tgncvkpi!vq!vjg!Vgttqtkuo!Itqwpfu!
qh! Kpcfokuukdknkv{/! Vjg! Ugetgvctkgu! qh! Uvcvg! cpf! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn-!
kp! eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Cvvqtpg{! Igpgtcn-! eqpukfgt! tguekpfkpi! vjg! gzgtekugu!
qh!cwvjqtkv{!kp!ugevkqp!323!qh!vjg!KPC-!9!W/U/E/!2293-!tgncvkpi!vq!vjg!vgttqtkuo!
itqwpfu!qh!kpcfokuukdknkv{-!cu!ygnn!cu!cp{!tgncvgf!korngogpvkpi!ogoqtcpfc/!
Uge/! 8/! Gzrgfkvgf! Eqorngvkqp! qh! vjg! Dkqogvtke! Gpvt{.Gzkv! Vtcemkpi! U{uvgo/!
)c*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn! gzrgfkvg! vjg! eqorngvkqp! cpf!
korngogpvcvkqp! qh! c! dkqogvtke! gpvt{.gzkv! vtcemkpi! u{uvgo! hqt! cnn! vtcxgngtu!
vq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! cu! tgeqoogpfgf! d{! vjg! Pcvkqpcn! Eqookuukqp! qp! Vgt.
tqtkuv!Cvvcemu!Wrqp!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvcvgu/!
)d*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! ujcnn! uwdokv! vq! vjg! Rtgukfgpv!
rgtkqfke! tgrqtvu! qp! vjg! rtqitguu! qh! vjg! fktgevkxg! eqpvckpgf! kp! uwdugevkqp!
)c*! qh! vjku! ugevkqp/! Vjg! kpkvkcn! tgrqtv! ujcnn! dg! uwdokvvgf! ykvjkp! 211! fc{u!
qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! c! ugeqpf! tgrqtv! ujcnn! dg! uwdokvvgf! ykvjkp! 311!
fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt-! cpf! c! vjktf! tgrqtv! ujcnn! dg! uwdokvvgf! ykvjkp!
476! fc{u! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt/! Hwtvjgt-! vjg! Ugetgvct{! ujcnn! uwdokv!
c! tgrqtv! gxgt{! 291! fc{u! vjgtgchvgt! wpvkn! vjg! u{uvgo! ku! hwnn{! fgrnq{gf! cpf!
qrgtcvkqpcn/!
Uge/! 9/! Xkuc! Kpvgtxkgy! Ugewtkv{/! )c*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn! koogfkcvgn{!
uwurgpf! vjg! Xkuc! Kpvgtxkgy! Yckxgt! Rtqitco! cpf! gpuwtg! eqornkcpeg! ykvj!
ugevkqp! 333! qh! vjg! KPC-! 9! W/U/E/! 2313-! yjkej! tgswktgu! vjcv! cnn! kpfkxkfwcnu!
uggmkpi! c! pqpkookitcpv! xkuc! wpfgtiq! cp! kp.rgtuqp! kpvgtxkgy-! uwdlgev! vq!
urgekhke!uvcvwvqt{!gzegrvkqpu/!
)d*! Vq! vjg! gzvgpv! rgtokvvgf! d{! ncy! cpf! uwdlgev! vq! vjg! cxckncdknkv{! qh!
crrtqrtkcvkqpu-!vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Uvcvg!ujcnn!koogfkcvgn{!gzrcpf!vjg!Eqpuwnct!
Hgnnqyu! Rtqitco-! kpenwfkpi! d{! uwduvcpvkcnn{! kpetgcukpi! vjg! pwodgt! qh! Hgn.
nqyu-! ngpivjgpkpi! qt! ocmkpi! rgtocpgpv! vjg! rgtkqf! qh! ugtxkeg-! cpf! ocmkpi!
ncpiwcig! vtckpkpi! cv! vjg! Hqtgkip! Ugtxkeg! Kpuvkvwvg! cxckncdng! vq! Hgnnqyu! hqt!
cuukipogpv! vq! rquvu! qwvukfg! qh! vjgkt! ctgc! qh! eqtg! nkpiwkuvke! cdknkv{-! vq! gpuwtg!
vjcv!pqp.kookitcpv!xkuc.kpvgtxkgy!yckv!vkogu!ctg!pqv!wpfwn{!chhgevgf/!
Uge/! ;/! Xkuc! Xcnkfkv{! Tgekrtqekv{/! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn! tgxkgy! cnn!
pqpkookitcpv! xkuc! tgekrtqekv{! citggogpvu! vq! gpuwtg! vjcv! vjg{! ctg-! ykvj! tg.
urgev! vq! gcej! xkuc! encuukhkecvkqp-! vtwn{! tgekrtqecn! kpuqhct! cu! rtcevkecdng! ykvj!
tgurgev! vq! xcnkfkv{! rgtkqf! cpf! hggu-! cu! tgswktgf! d{! ugevkqpu! 332)e*! cpf! 392!
qh! vjg! KPC-! 9! W/U/E/! 2312)e*! cpf! 2462-! cpf! qvjgt! vtgcvogpv/! Kh! c! eqwpvt{!
fqgu! pqv! vtgcv! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! pcvkqpcnu! uggmkpi! pqpkookitcpv! xkucu! kp! c!
tgekrtqecn!ocppgt-!vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Uvcvg!ujcnn!cflwuv!vjg!xkuc!xcnkfkv{!rgtkqf-!
hgg! uejgfwng-! qt! qvjgt! vtgcvogpv! vq! ocvej! vjg! vtgcvogpv! qh! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu!
pcvkqpcnu!d{!vjg!hqtgkip!eqwpvt{-!vq!vjg!gzvgpv!rtcevkecdng/!
Uge/! 21/! Vtcpurctgpe{! cpf! Fcvc! Eqnngevkqp/! )c*! Vq! dg! oqtg! vtcpurctgpv!
ykvj! vjg! Cogtkecp! rgqrng-! cpf! vq! oqtg! ghhgevkxgn{! korngogpv! rqnkekgu! cpf!
rtcevkegu!vjcv!ugtxg!vjg!pcvkqpcn!kpvgtguv-!vjg!Ugetgvct{!qh!Jqogncpf!Ugewtkv{-!
kp! eqpuwnvcvkqp! ykvj! vjg! Cvvqtpg{! Igpgtcn-! ujcnn-! eqpukuvgpv! ykvj! crrnkecdng!
ncy! cpf! pcvkqpcn! ugewtkv{-! eqnngev! cpf! ocmg! rwdnken{! cxckncdng! ykvjkp! 291!
fc{u-!cpf!gxgt{!291!fc{u!vjgtgchvgt<!
XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11117

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt 0 Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31 0 Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128 0 Rtgukfgpvkcn! Fqewogpvu!

9;92!

)k*! kphqtocvkqp! tgictfkpi! vjg! pwodgt! qh! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! kp! vjg! Wpkvgf!
Uvcvgu! yjq! jcxg! dggp! ejctigf! ykvj! vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf! qhhgpugu! yjkng! kp!
vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu=! eqpxkevgf! qh! vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf! qhhgpugu! yjkng! kp! vjg!
Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu=! qt! tgoqxgf! htqo! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! dcugf! qp! vgttqtkuo.!
tgncvgf!cevkxkv{-!chhknkcvkqp-!qt!ocvgtkcn!uwrrqtv!vq!c!vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf!qticpk.
|cvkqp-! qt! cp{! qvjgt! pcvkqpcn! ugewtkv{! tgcuqpu! ukpeg! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt!
qt!vjg!ncuv!tgrqtvkpi!rgtkqf-!yjkejgxgt!ku!ncvgt=!
)kk*! kphqtocvkqp! tgictfkpi! vjg! pwodgt! qh! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu! kp! vjg! Wpkvgf!
Uvcvgu! yjq! jcxg! dggp! tcfkecnk|gf! chvgt! gpvt{! kpvq! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu! cpf!
gpicigf! kp! vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf! cevu-! qt! yjq! jcxg! rtqxkfgf! ocvgtkcn! uwrrqtv!
vq! vgttqtkuo.tgncvgf! qticpk|cvkqpu! kp! eqwpvtkgu! vjcv! rqug! c! vjtgcv! vq! vjg!
Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! ukpeg! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt! qt! vjg! ncuv! tgrqtvkpi! rgtkqf-!
yjkejgxgt!ku!ncvgt=!cpf!
)kkk*! kphqtocvkqp! tgictfkpi! vjg! pwodgt! cpf! v{rgu! qh! cevu! qh! igpfgt.dcugf!
xkqngpeg! cickpuv! yqogp-! kpenwfkpi! jqpqt! mknnkpiu-! kp! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu!
d{! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu-! ukpeg! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku! qtfgt! qt! vjg! ncuv! tgrqtvkpi!
rgtkqf-!yjkejgxgt!ku!ncvgt=!cpf!
)kx*! cp{! qvjgt! kphqtocvkqp! tgngxcpv! vq! rwdnke! uchgv{! cpf! ugewtkv{! cu! fgvgt.
okpgf! d{! vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Jqogncpf! Ugewtkv{! cpf! vjg! Cvvqtpg{! Igpgtcn-!
kpenwfkpi! kphqtocvkqp! qp! vjg! kookitcvkqp! uvcvwu! qh! hqtgkip! pcvkqpcnu!
ejctigf!ykvj!oclqt!qhhgpugu/!
)d*! Vjg! Ugetgvct{! qh! Uvcvg! ujcnn-! ykvjkp! qpg! {gct! qh! vjg! fcvg! qh! vjku!
qtfgt-! rtqxkfg! c! tgrqtv! qp! vjg! guvkocvgf! nqpi.vgto! equvu! qh! vjg! WUTCR!
cv!vjg!Hgfgtcn-!Uvcvg-!cpf!nqecn!ngxgnu/!
Uge/! 22/! Igpgtcn! Rtqxkukqpu/! )c*! Pqvjkpi! kp! vjku! qtfgt! ujcnn! dg! eqpuvtwgf!
vq!korckt!qt!qvjgtykug!chhgev<!
)k*! vjg! cwvjqtkv{! itcpvgf! d{! ncy! vq! cp! gzgewvkxg! fgrctvogpv! qt! cigpe{-!
qt!vjg!jgcf!vjgtgqh=!qt!

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

)kk*! vjg! hwpevkqpu! qh! vjg! Fktgevqt! qh! vjg! Qhhkeg! qh! Ocpcigogpv! cpf! Dwfigv!
tgncvkpi!vq!dwfigvct{-!cfokpkuvtcvkxg-!qt!ngikuncvkxg!rtqrqucnu/!
)d*! Vjku! qtfgt! ujcnn! dg! korngogpvgf! eqpukuvgpv! ykvj! crrnkecdng! ncy! cpf!
uwdlgev!vq!vjg!cxckncdknkv{!qh!crrtqrtkcvkqpu/!

XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11118

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

9;93!

Hgfgtcn! Tgikuvgt 0 Xqn/! 93-! Pq/! 31 0 Ygfpgufc{-! Hgdtwct{! 2-! 3128 0 Rtgukfgpvkcn! Fqewogpvu!
)e*!Vjku!qtfgt!ku!pqv!kpvgpfgf!vq-!cpf!fqgu!pqv-!etgcvg!cp{!tkijv!qt!dgpghkv-!
uwduvcpvkxg! qt! rtqegfwtcn-! gphqtegcdng! cv! ncy! qt! kp! gswkv{! d{! cp{! rctv{!
cickpuv! vjg! Wpkvgf! Uvcvgu-! kvu! fgrctvogpvu-! cigpekgu-! qt! gpvkvkgu-! kvu! qhhkegtu-!
gornq{ggu-!qt!cigpvu-!qt!cp{!qvjgt!rgtuqp/!

VJG! YJKVG! JQWUG-!
Lcpwct{! 38-! 3128/!
]HT! Fqe/! 3128—13392!
Hkngf! 2—42—28=! 22<26! co_!

XgtFcvg!Ugr>22@3125!

27<54!Lcp!42-!3128

Lmv!352112

RQ!11111

Hto!11119

Hov!5816

Uhov!58;1

G<^HT^HO^12HGG1/UIO

12HGG1

Vtwor/GRU>0IRJ@

utcfqxkej!qp!FUM4IOS193RTQF!ykvj!RTGU!FQEU

Dknnkpi! eqfg! 43;6—H8—R!