The Authors Guild v. Google, Inc.

Filing 44

JOINT APPENDIX, volume 4 of 6, (pp. 901-1200), on behalf of Appellant Jim Bouton, Joseph Goulden, Betty Miles and The Authors Guild, FILED. Service date 04/07/2014 by CM/ECF.[1196263] [13-4829]

Download PDF

A-1051 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 10 of 32 From inside the book 'P i ' 88 "geo =lc';'9 ~.yo ;r th ", book """" "'.... , oho,p and hr ..... ", .. Ide! . "" o! g"l" - H<', 8'" ...... , ..... . . A ,~ . . . '~in ; _ _ " ." ~ .n h;_ , .... . . . . '" ,bo., ~ ..... ,. Pog,106 tho ~ k.o!"<'. ~ .... li!tIo !Col Iho\IId. II .... w.ry . .. oJ !hoy PYt o""O'l<d !C.poui~ili.,.. 10 ~ . . . . . . . . . . . . . Il). lei ..... vV""~ ",, - ~ ~ IItlp d .b mIQn!~ "J .. ok" ;Aa and .m>.>!lI ...... L&1k: pNbkOlll bcfol': Ih<:J Pag,HO ~ U"J ....... , ..... w'!;:w .. .. , ~"''' uo ...... 1 d",,·, tIWo~ it·, f<l' '" """'F"'" "'" riY" away ~ I"l" iiI:< t<:H",. Woool, F ..... ' and W;u,..... Th.~· .. 'Of pila......d I Ib iD ~ [ """:11 be oJ:owt<I 10 lie onI)I lliJ Of eWR In:1liocrt for I "._1,;0 HIOC '~ 0' .... "<cu. Arkr 1Ilf. tLc o..Ua- Jll'J'I ba• • ~aII "I'" I~. _ ......... A-1052 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 11 of 32 From inside the book 81 P"9" m. tching osk. d i, iei , boo. m.: IOilb llill one) .... >I~I irl I'boenl. alMl I ...,.,1 join tIIcm "'_til :hey .".,. l1UCD<.. Tb<} ~'1'1" T..... a", ~ '" I <Oilc<lllolo 100', Ill< n .... a&d ookod i!" .... ad.d to _ .... .. . ...... , riJht '''''Y ""d "" soHi 1M>, "" p!anlCd 10 u!c "'" ... ute! """ 11m I rnlfbt 1.1 .... - I.iI N f.,,- ~"".... 1\"1 I... "" . Le,-. ... e-'. Pay, 234 ( ..kod him .......1 .. ""'"'" b1 tha~ " ...... ~ ., _ _ _ ';' ~M ,• • _ , ••• ~ • • " n~ _ .. ... ,_. .. [ doII't Dew ... hJ <'- ryooe I. uy.:d." Il "bendcr ..id IoICT. "[ e tlIru l ~1 it .... . ··v..... to "~g.. ~ q............ bOI JI....lcd I~ ' Manlllll <aid. ··So 1Oe"r< o.U lIJ ppoood y"" .~""Id h. ....... <~ ~. Gen<. n.:. ""'...,..... ho.vc S"' ... A-1053 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 12 of 32 From inside the book b ~ lclut [ S .ad gaiJty ..all -, • P""CA !rmo<%n n ..... .. 110.1 h,ppo...J .."""d .... Y..,kM, _ . WMn l ollnoy ""_ ..,.. ... nlfCO' ud 100;', allUd of ex 1>aU'lob. the!c "II • aior)' ID th: 1'"1'<' ~OOIio', ... plo,... ... N,,"IIliI>o Kun<: ifni I bod "' ..... " •• th .. be _ hudiioS :h< club f<i"rly. tb! _ of Ihc """"",00.1 1>lI>C,"= '1IJIlUI J<"<" . , """, ......... ,., ooy, n..~_.1ot 01 5"'''''"'8 . b""" Ihc Jqlltlllp DIll ","",. .i&t.t hom •. ",'. """. ,t.re<_ ...., will afle, "'" P"'" ..... and ""'_ .. 1>o .... _ lIIf,i..·...f ...111' II ClIk., 1/ .... hod 0 .h..... ~i£h' .... oouId hove in to Saonk ......... ~ve.. ~ln) in..."" M fc,,""'hirly no. b.!ld.h . . ..... ~ <w<. """, ''''' ......:to m<YWV ......... nM' ""teo .............," ......... , .. _ ,ho, .,,. ,'n •• boO,lub I con'! _1 T i".t WI'! $tt ... tIalItl. They lui do.1"! oecm to Ita"" the ""pili. y"" ... OW ""th« dub I ..... '\ """ 0. .... body I;".... ..!>en 1>0 ,010: · 'roo kn<J'O" A-1054 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 13 of 32 From in5ide the book I bej lp a rk Searoh P'g,82 -- -- - -- -- -- r -,--- --.- . . ... onJ II.. ;. on. ~f ,n. ....!;.E p''''',;,;,.... MW~.n I &<' ~<>ftI I'm piftg to bnd' ,"y .-.It! 1.<1)1"< ")~"'''''' ~ A: .... "'y, CIt boll If>." b R>y O)ler.>C1 .. y. "Roy, ..h.n)Oll com. 10 lhe \>Illp.. k lomorrow w,II}'w brin ~ ROY _"'1 1 Ion ,k .. unokr }.,.., 10<4," Some,,*- I'a u'l P" \hi< 1<iI1<1 of "o."<1'tO~~n: ---~ P'g' 100 -, ~' .... . , ',.,.,..,." And I 've kllO\"l1 IWlplllyon ..:.0 II'IOu~1 ~ w .. gut f ... 10 nn 00 • I' PC'J'«Or<lc, cl>o kJ ... .... _rc .,.lil>~ ~ "";,h 10.. " ~~ .nd pl. y • b..tk "" ,bo boo '" the b. ll p,d ,he ..,,,' d. y. ok, ",do, ' ..... R . . . ... _ " . .. _ . _ .~ " ,~~ _ _ : . . .... , _ ""'ir '-, » ,_v •• 01 M 100 don', )'tI1I hue 10 suy i:I ClIc !>arracu and lhI:y )'IdI",,' il ,"" """'. at ,. ;'1.01£1'''" I.. ..;..c, "f Y"" ~"".( ."k ;, in. )"" hlY!: I" povnd ....... d""" • • d "",,'. ell< .... y ....r catch ),>"." A-1055 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 14 of 32 From inside the book [ J'~roh II PlcO notchrg ball play<r i" th;o book Poge ,ii to "" • • 'g-\e>t;"O """P")"" ..,,, .... "llin. 1 tni<>),.lIe fa ... DI ~i: ~ J <hi, .. .." ,. S" • .,.,~ ~. "'p a bil"ic.p: b.JlplOju. I !lO1 a trcmeo_ cIw. U:1 OIl' cI ~Ik "'"nlL" my ntognpll. I. I, ,,, • • 1<Cl h"n If I 50 OD"'pl_ ....... 1 ,~ .. ~ 1 .h>old be: «<og.u:d •• d 00 one: • •b rae: fn1";, 1 ""inY <iv'ng t . . . . .otl jIM:IIg fn. ~"''' ..... oo.j ".~""~"8 r-e- ---_. - . - -~-. --~ ,- . ~- ----,- &ad I.... beud..,... 0/ !ho people CIU)' lnd UIl~ -- ~ - Oft -- -- .,- ---- .._- !ho y..,t •• uy,.,."" H.d 01 .r.d I ..... 1<Ik!. 'Y"" r;ot .uc( with one Ihtre: 11"1 I ,dl thorm,·AI fll! .. I·", =",mru. If hi: " .......... b"n([mI pcr=! o. n .. field, I·m """S t~ .... him. •.., p.I£io! .lm , trictly ... a ba:1_ pIIycr: y". beat 0'1 kind< 01 "''''e> Ibrnug). tho UIfi" ..... 1lO"J1Do .. . _ . Poge 2tQ p'.,...-. . ...... 'oo,JS" oJ><" .......... w . .. rowa '>lev< ,.."" .""'., INri tan 1 _'11M•• it wo.l ...... S<> be .. <><>I 00J' tbct< ri,llo! "'<> ,_.... 01 .. h.bi!iLotlDo. r... """ .... ms baiJpme, .. b>::~ w. eventual), 100. . . y_ way_ -M1 WI! ~.! A-1056 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 15 of 32 From inside th e book :05 pageo mct eh nJ ..... ' b, tlill~ .~ • •- n this beO( & ~~ - ~ Quo • bi~ "~y <c"" .. "",. Ten .,in·,1C> 01 b."in6 practkoo. I think 111 ,.. oho Jo~"ny h",.. (10.,.," ..... \:eo pitel.,.) II>eorJ 01 b, uir., p""'tIc:o. U.do, th:s 111." 'Y)tlll i"'I&-," )I<Iij·re ill . " me ... :I )'Ou """'" Jocr pide>. .. ~""~ ~" H", d ... hiru od". ,hro ... >li<lcJ: .. ,he "",k.. Tho ~ t.•", it. Ou, i , hokood lobaov ' . .... ",ole tho 10,",. hi''''', ,........J ..... ~ .. , 01n~ ... 111 ~1' ~,- ""'I>"" ~ ~ .~ ~ 6'"' _ ... _ U_. K '0 ..,,,,,,body .1... 1\ lOt of pl&ycn d<)n·l b,,- 1M probklU we cLo bOClUS< lIIt~ l:a .... c tho .. famlli<o at ~c= mol Uvc;" hotel>. noO'" 10, ..,~ 01" , .... r<aJO:u. Th<y.~ j"'" .. ,l1i'8 «II. .od "",,,', ",.to ._3h """"V Or Ici<k "'" CIId ...... ' 11 t:> bO ill scboc:l Old tboy ~' g c doll·, ,"'it 'lilli' ~ lake !bem wL 153 f,."'".... ~:......... """ 01" Ik C""" i> ko '"!; .. iH. lIoo: '1';-''''''. Wi([, "'" ...... k... ill ,_'" ,~b l\ao .r...odJ ""'" _ 12. On tho ot~« haf!d, I 1> . ... h:ld ....,. .. ur&<li<llU. ODe of lhe: ,_." ,,1 II I plittbli L'" pitdtill, I\alI b-.,~ "•., "'ams durill~ ':II'li.&r; pr'''iooc, Mol> Ilic: 1(J[Ol.!:r; I«UII b'Wll ,~ d:vp 5OJ;"'" 1ho '~'y. 1"", ...... iblo kin« ill b.nlr_ ~ poo<ibly t: A-1057 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 16 of 32 From inside thE book [ S""'L!i ". ",~ J 10 p,g oo m,tding owing in th .. book 10 Cd abc,.! hI ='"~_ wi:h Koue. H. oai<1 chey'd CO like this: .. /I .... 40 )0"' kp fa:1 'oo:!oy, Mi,l7" "No< "'" gocd" "'{< .. tut ~owd J thor 10:<11" "It bo"" .. boo I run, ~~'7'"'~ ~,~ m. ";.h' Me .. pocioUy, ! _ , I"c!","", ~ ,.~~_ ~ ClID~ ~ v~ " ........... il ~ ." '~.'" D . . . . . . . ."",dillg 10 the zalddl, 01 d>< dllbbc"", ralb! • hlltlng 01 ..... ";'b r... b. t .., hill hudI, "'iciralir.11I>e pitc~ , .!rid"'1 into ~, .bed,,,,, Ilis 1Wi lI"d !k3 back """ doIDC it U 0,,"' " D':II, II ... mi<>,Ud "'. of a ~y po, """ hlo _ i'" btfon • fiaol ....... , tno;vD. all lilt Ii... ~ ....... \ 1<Ilo" to.so ,""v r.IOd. If """ don't b.\C P. • "" "P" "; ~h! , 00CIl ID UJ< _ I. doan', h..... ... lDlIlp.. , """'" " ' . . , ........... " .. . . ' ~.pdop , ..... e ...... «1 • run ;. the ";"11, "tt;o:h D>e.on< "" t.d i_t <nou/1> "'.. 10 hoe " '1, I lhi.. 1"" " .' in . r _ _ And .,.'", in 'flh rll.,., Nnlvw"l. ,.1 ....... " h . ....... , .... "'h"h A-1058 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 17 of 32 From in5ide the book [ S.~rch t l. fa r; 12 P'[O'> rrotrn n J bl~f", y in thi. bock ..... TheR:"'. play ~ it L~ yearnlly"S gan: IIlaI """,1<I1Ia........ n r"nny "'1'0.0", .., bM. 10'< _n: 1<0<1"', 2-1 ., "'" ""'" ."d J;"'..y 10')".\ on oocond. Wi,b """ ""t IIld.')' hill . cleoft dOAI. t~ ri~. cr.uln M ..... WplQ-Geep! 11Ilt wynft roondl IIIn. 1"'" h.llIny I>ome. ,." ,oal ..... ~ .... be ho>n't tooo:bc<! :tOr;l. So bKk ho: ~ '-> it.,d Cun Bldor)' •• bi&. ""'R-~. physical II1II'. H. lita to sli P people en tile Net.oo hl f\1. JIb )'OIl In die rb. }oo. IMl blac k u.d oqo;e,,,,, ~I"" . He abe lika It> <bats: R~bc .. , 00< ,..:.oy-fiv<..y<.....:d chI>- A-1059 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 18 of 32 From inside the book [ 3 .arcr -- ----'-r-·---r- -- _. ---, ----- -0-- nf tho .... nto= .. ~. . . ""'. H ~ ..... j .. t U<llh<r i,dn, h-.d .... ,"u :on ..., boca"", ,"Q . . .....yo 01.1 wkll Mic:kC)' MlJIlI( ...., !he: ~ys. n.: driaki<& ponyiD!. FI. yiac CMIb. En" OK!' io ....!>iIe. j .... to co""oa< his im'F, be'd tm .. k"""", 1-'1")..0 • ~""",I ,.,d tht .... @" .. , JoI1nJ1T IUudw!l. ..... one 0/ !be O<l\':l, 1'., lIy",,'" Iwd l<l "" one 0/ !he: b(lys 1'.. . ~~ lill<lt_ inS '" WII""J ,n.>O. NJd enjoy"', iL Tb< bo<k of Ibc bw ;. tbe ",.1 him ~ '"8 _ Of 000Il ... . nd he I"" the., OUt 00 the "ble b<lot. <X>Otl:'.- L'IC prnc. -Let', ret 10 11tt:se lac Sclull2 'aid, -n.cy ca,'" ll! L,O ....Y /""" ",,"lhem llliI>oio," Silt;', . 1 "' •. lob:e . , , .. tHo ...... _ ~f .... Y"<"8 dtb~ou", t:oys. lDd "" ..... nad.rlt • hirtHolKd ~ boolL Joe pot .... O'o'e. L '. ~ .. " _0 .• __ ~• . __ • ~._ . _" . .... n . .... _ _. .. , . •. _ . . L ~. A-1060 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 19 of 32 From inside thE book [ S e ctrd 70 FOl" notchrg ",,11,d in th, boo. roge 12J -- - --, --- .- -~ -- --- - --, _._.._-_ .- PI wha 0""","" aod <Ioooc<! 0 _1dIl! *""""" . .. "".. d>.yo. M 7"... We ru.e ... "" the ""'""1 no. d n-" s.,.~10 ....... ,J .,d will deposit ;1 in VaJlWUTC" CIpllnIIod<:. W~· .. "a¥ln~ • fl;w doI.Ian .., .t.~ S.oule OO>OU:It in~ ... I set called .p Ia><r thil , ......... ,. I ""'old ..y MN" I ~ a!J<d up "<I "",'.. Pa~e 204 ~Q'''' . ~ u •• ~ .d'.... 1uu U, "' ... , ..... . ,..,....... ~ u"' "' ..... ' ''' r l ,~", ~ . ~ H. ",,,,,1 roi"g 10 let ~ 01\ ""tl\Qul 1O..c k l .~ 01 1c:C1 .... , howev«. Aboo;, a wte, or ....ra j'd be"" up fOf .. kat .«""d n o *" ""', ond ~ .. lIl 1"" "'1 ioob,' .,.., on<! • • , .w..... "'eri.ute.. ""_.'"'& "m', .~ "'-" .. " ,...... . -<ot .... ~ I ;. ..... , ""' ..... -It .................. ,, ~ "C.ffcw:· lit< saki. "TWc lvo:-o·okl<lu;url,w.- W"",, t '1I 1 ,d." sot "P 10 . . JOOOI No .... Millo-. PkI. "n..y a.ll.d. ,Ime'"' - WIU.' "W.U, they ","10<1 .t clewn." they A-1061 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 20 of 32 From inside the book o~.,u.. ~ "'" ."",k IIbJe. and ~.'J'" "" ...... n 1931. "'.", "" ""s.n 'G play [or 11M: Ylllkce •• .wI 19b11. wtlcn lie loll .. I cc""h. he h>Cl pulkd ok..," 10m< 21 WorlJ Soria .hor<.;" KId;,,,,,, 00 hI> <au;dcnblc ..... ".. Ad no .... to... oolic<.l him 'p<ndills "<y .. uch d i~ b a~di~ SWli:I . 111 ... lflV. I\< .Itc""---"",' ib:v t30ub looJisIw:ss. o>ore lik<lv Poge .7 "'~" • ".m 1.. 1 "" ... , ,hen you ""' ...... <1"0·..."'1\ apJn.- R:al Kltr.lk. 1ng I bd1<,c D,_ Goo.~_"' ..... '.looll} oI!•• ded "he. ~ ..... mo 10 lIim . .i,' "n inj.<y. Yn" ...'" ;"'''''''"8 .,.. hi< oi..... I'... ...'" "','" ""'" • 101 <If g.l}"$ wbo <I""" ""'" ' ~ •• 'A ,.k , h .. '0 till ~ •• , ~ ,. b'n wiL\ Ill]"... b<c ..... Iht}' '''''w , ~'" ...... ey M o" ' " AM ""0.;,,,. PagE JJ ~ mad. \he """" Ie 5y:1IClISO • CIIlIpJ. 01 times ud <bon to SoOUlc ..., _ 10 V aD<W>C< ......... "'" & "",..>b<, ~f. "'" • •• , uclUJi .. d.b. tJo bd... d ba....da of b_belI ..., tIi.e bigos. C'I!O!'otaen of tblll.$. 1'011 OItia:. ItIn'rlIllir.lI"""""* di:pwlmel\, J'", aft Iollen ohuin& "oJ" for .. oo ..... year> CV<D. 500ctiln<> you ..1ll iIuo • <lit.. ~ - -_. .. .. -_..._.- ---- -_. _- A-1062 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 21 of 32 From ilside the book [ Searct1 :O ~C 1 rog e 18 0.:1 L '>rn It. lho ""kId. ""i", it in tho",. haby_~ "Cb.d II in 1hI:n:." ADd the WtJrd for d.... 10 r.... 01-..01"" Yo~ don', ""' it .. m""" durir.!j "'" ...... bee> .... ooI:>cHly's Del'o'OCll ""d DObody .'" to imJ'I"M • OOlaOb ",II<> thioIr, you'", Lau of ~dl., "1:""" ''C""", ,,,,,y." oh«kl~!i ,1\0 "tid: .. ~ ...."d i>te>u,", .......... l'B~. \I'h<ft ho bog,n ,,, Yant"", • • oo l~t\II, "'~tn hi: kf' IS a coKh. he bid ~u : kd pll) lor tk "" ..'n i\, d IDGO .1>0"" in ..wit"", '" hi> a>Dido:..b1c 001,,),. OOliml ,Un 'I"'"din!j ..,ry """,h 01 it, !~ ~di!''' ' tillV, he eIt:< .. d DMtibJ. UtnMIPtl !ooIi1h:11:sL ~ lilzlv ~ ~ World Sera flO .... ~ •• .WIiII. "'..., P'g o 106 Plu.a U1 • coac!t ~r SchU, iol Alllau .. bctt it _ lIill • yvu &'" Lu be. ""ltd io mj;"''''k''!l'''' oJ'l, wJ 1haI... """ uI the .....1' A-1063 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 From in s id~ Filed 08/26/13 Page 22 of 32 thE beok [ 3earcr GO p' g" In.tohing leol in th;, boo, Pog.4C oWoo' hi> oot, .. "..,.;,,;,c,. "ill. K.....,. tio ..i<l u..,y'!J S" 1•• .. H .... do )",u,!ell' ~I ,odoy. Mi:lr '" ",A ~,i>: " NOlI"" £00II." .,'{<o. but I", .. ~ o tb<yl<d?n .. It 10"", "'..., I rua, u.. right <10< ...,..c..tl!, I CIllI~ wido .., it ~ . 1.. 1b.~ _ _ kKi.;t- r., IDre lbty bclie'o.. !blt i~ you lool: W<: )'<HJ Iod bad , t:<> .. lo•.b& ,I" , I'''''''' L'K t)1J< 10'1...... ,,1> (U ,",", Su )O~ FP 1Oloo! willt .... limlo !lme . ""d ,hey pl.)'ed ,•.is , .... nol ~u<I ... i'~ tho Y~d< .. ... h<n I td 'ho~ 1001 "0'1 Gnot . . . ",h:!. Ph ~ Unr.. Joe PerilOOC " ICII WOUI~ ~ , .tout so:n:thln~ •mer. I""ID~ ~IDC.,,:I we __ __ _ _ _ _ _u ___ Pogo Its ~ w..:_ ........, . " """. """ .....It' ....... , ............ - - - - .. ODd OurJl I . .., <:05<, ,bi> nt"'iG"b. WlI> ",mal by do: d£hl ,,' M,D.n..1 or Iloe y"",-,. Altbw&b j',., • . - - "'_, ' im, I ~I I tt ..... biOI fUlly """I l-6::. u"" or thir ..,..01"11,, lor: ","<1& out In",r S.)l<r<rn, TJ:>K •• allcd " r ~ chlng lor the 1.1 .",,," Our: or thr: r.,. I ..... Lind, m- h;..-->nd 011 rloo nI .... "'...,,;.. ""-"'_ """ • """'d .... Io.r_ A-1064 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 23 of 32 From inside the book Se ~tch P'9' 1~ you t.it .... 01\ lIIe ~..,. ""'P>'. II """'" 111"" been my bud.. lb:~ ! , ..,., do my job." ! >pM "';1> Ioi.>. 10 I wen' 0..., ... Eddlo O'B ..... HId ,.id. "Edt:!ie. 014 p.lI. IIol> abou' yeu putlin, "" • cwk aDd <Whine roe"/" "It', "'" "'1 pi> .......... "F pitchc ... • E&(;. uOd.. Peg' J:e ".,.. n8'" ,n "" .. ,n, . ...."" ")~ ",... : J ...... I tlH:ugh' he .... p~ &, .... n,."!,,. '''' F' "'" ~ .."". lO.uk ... lor my uwvoph:· "II"" During Iht !, m~ • 1J"f do." _ tho .Wldt ,~ tile ~u&OUl .. d ..1d ' 0 Mike M<nhall, "Hey, 10 Mile ".,.bollio :be ..."",[1 1".- ................ "',... p'Y' 232 ''''.Y '.... <>InC. 1 ",,"""ft, ... t>o><n..u 0""'. ,,-,...pte. Joe got .,'" • 'ellltlC plot< .bouI • c.... tecI • ...;" 000 "t.eD i ' ,"u ~V(' he.cn>«l ~.." '0 lilt: CuCO"-, SliJI . ",1 bela.: 14cppinS inl~ "'" d.!",,~ , ...... g. . Joe ' pie;l a blonde .i"i., in '"" ~n' milo' ,"",~i.rl ••• ~ ""H iy •. bl_ie. Hoot', Y"'".iol en ~ . n um?;"" ., heme u.., ",",to,;", ,.....,.tnr· A-1065 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 24 of 32 From inside the book [ 3 .arch 29 pages ma,ch "i j,,"ny in Ih s bJek Pa~e 34 _ " ' « ,,I Y"'" .... .,Jon" ........ '0 " ... ~ in I>io ""'y. wou'd)VOT Fri, ~ .. ", he """,1d.1· ~ '" lhey plL I"im in w~h Dooley Wo .. a,k. yovn~ pitel., •. It, w .. 'hm: mo"')' ' ..... " II';r U.. " I, """1 thou~L I ...... b . d .. ft" • ..,. "" fri". "Tho Y....... ~ad 50me funn y i<!cas . bo.1I ~ ;.tll>c:nct. WIIaL I did !>ad ..... {.fk: to Page 117 ef._ . . . So I ~ pormWlorl .,..kw.rd ill .... ....,u "'" owkII tho PUou. I f£k .. nibLJ I . .... th.>, ~"" 1")'1 .1", fd, fIInny .!>out I1C bcillJ !be",. They hool " - f.n.y 1001:1 00 {he,.IlCU, 1tI(I I folt 1 •• ~ ..... ao.J """,,""rue.tlc dioo .... «I Dri';"!! OV<'I" (o u.. T"' t~ r . . o. _ _ O. _ . L _ ._.o~ . ''''''¥' ......, ",10, J """,)d D)' k> them , L __ , __ L _ ' __ • _ _ _ _ • • _~M f t .• • P'go 2:/ . - . _. -~. -, - '- . _' .. "'" 10 <10 ,b.>I, I ... ink ~ ..... . pta>lk, llhiol; ;I ..... '.....,. ........ J tried 10 pick ap Ibc oboe, Wi ...... nllcd dawu. I think it ...as uppowi to t.: r"".,. [dtW. . BeO:I«. I <1Il otjJ _at tb: ,1001-*0 b>g .. ~ donn~ nis. A-1066 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 25 of 32 From inside thE book [ 3ectrcl Pog e 5~ - --"..- - -- --- ..., .- .-. ---........ -.._-- ---- - -_ .- to." "" )'Ou b..·• .., .0 ... ......, • . WdJ. ~1inc~ ........ IaIkuIt . tIolll ~ia! ID <u: . JO.'WlY CMll ' how. 1 1m_pc "I.." be l..Ilu .boul I<>!maJ e ..h II'" lit.; Lbe tkgro p.' my'" tall;'! . bo." 1..-. ENWIl. Locs of lim .. in .... C:ub ~ou", Y<lull h'''' • mdin 0" ud ''''TV ~nc:t in . ... ' ile it fI:U ,";IObed bock an~ Poge ICG "",., pUl 10 oooce lnI tllinllh.. r., .... IJIl'I tile ttallld , hl:1rn:1 "';th tho "" ..... "" ;,. AM .".,; .... 01-. ......... . '" "" .... tho 1<1<.....,..... P,"<,2,,4 Goln!I to D""cyland.. I rem,mbeml JDin!! '0 lbe Wurkl·. f . i, ill No ... Yorl. fe w )'Con b«k. P,;,;ng 0." of 010 .... li'llo to"' _ , Ih;... ..... D.... , Rh"""'. 'h ~ "', .. h ~ I. 19~ hVp<d win. pt..... 1 and a Work! Soltes p1l ch·hI"I_, loY. ,/Ie Oluu. Our;'Y IlIKxk>. u", 0.>1 "'>' 1><,.,.... _ in~ tI1nl 01 ...... i/o,,,, .. d.hirog. !nos_ 1 _.-.I ...". ,d A-1067 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 26 of 32 From inside the book L3e~rGh 57 pageo mctc r; "3 9'" 0'" in th", book P'go 20 ia :C~11io1d Who" 1h< gtJX ... os cw" I "a1lc:rl bK k "ID ,..., d.bh"""" an4 Ille", ...os a p,uh of whl ... ,.wet. from the door 10 "'f 1OC:~.r, m ~ "I ,1M: I"Y' """< .... ~;"S 'fIer::. ond j ..... 1 op:n<d"" <IGor MI : k<y ..." r..",lot ,I>., 1",( It>w<I _ And I I" fiI"'" 1'1 "f'." for"" ~im 10, ,haL woo', !<XJC,tIle llme-1962, I 1\0<" ;1 'II'H-irI llamas MARCH P ' g. 20 7 "QU" 1'1 1<It.. ._, ""'"' I uOd.· £ ~". 1...oJ.. "0"1)0 I .. "", "1'1 uillk .b,,,t it.. ""tli&IUlj ..... J"" 1i"1' tu !hilll "My "bole life "''''"... A-1068 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 27 of 32 From incide the book To paqos mmh n1 h .lPpe ll. d i1 ttl s boo, Pag' C7 .-. ~~. r-: .. ""'t'. be. II O'Jl ~ ~ ~ .. ..... . ... ..... "",..." .~ •• .., ...... "'Y ..... ~" I bUnilIKI Th.at'. <U<lly ...... ltappoocd. Ph~ SO' 11K: ~il r~ r \ .. .300 .. <ra~ O !P' ,he "'''''Ff '" ,~ ~. "im ",,! d M ,,",onS boo... f"",vcr tha, f hil LIn>. M, .300. !IIe ....... N_ it'. i" ! .. TIw... ~ "'... h . .......... ..;.h T~v n...... ... _. ~"" " . ,'1'1 CD IX S»<1iIIa «:1<>« "'" pm:>. un ><> "''''__ ~~ I>< • •will] juu¥ "l~ hoppy tII;.!!" ...... n """ of our &")11 8I'b • h~. In I..". ....,,,,,d ltd tile ~m II"" lie )Jm;m up ud u ...... <"",,rID, I Iootal atOIIad 10 II:K1 "," .. ~ .. I»d ~,.pl"'0.d, " II Il-.a, ""PP'''"'' .... .... EO' .-.." 01\0 ol tiIboIJl IWmty bib. I.,.,n lie ""","1 be tJIImb1 il, abru, hi """ !o ». __ .....__ u_, _____ ... u_. __ n•... . _ ,_ .,-. "'-.0 _ h • • < '0 ",9 'he Ao"", ,,.,, l"m . 1ill k .... io! II>< piL<; ~ .m! tlKy1l hioYC to bo p,tico, ... d MI upeet ... y mi.-cl••. lAnI. """,Id.·, il be • .,1uI ~ I f;OtiIdn', J<1 n.: r.d of It1If i! happcr><d io S<211l!. nokldy MMJId ""lb:. But 110,,< ..... whok oounll'J' io "'a",nio, . penn .." nc< • ....J 1m ;, it. ",d 'U!ICI<lSO I can', ,,;!do? I I0OI< a Ti_ ""d ..."t . ,,,,,ed '" A-1069 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 28 of 32 From inside the book . . be 414r: ' UlSot 00, til .. oil w r pilchen hue ount>m ill thO xr. IWld 40' •. Ik .. 0;1 I'd h,,,,, ' G tIlk '" a;.:,-,,- <J< .,....p Il. "" W,lker il l ..... 1<11 '" <lu •.t' It.. ",1<. l ..id 1 wu""", u..y wwld:I'l """I 10 be t>ool>ertd wit), """"1lb>A so , .. oll, ItId lie Slid, ' "011. j"Oti'd be .~d.n P,9C 3X ··Ob . of c:ounc. Harry Walk •. 1'0 doubl ti>ool il. HIrTY Wal'.r illhc rca>OA f ..... K ""001> 0/ ,I... .. ." .- H."" .......... mo • • h,;'. " Uk "" • •" I ..i<I. "J"" b,,,ao"" .-..-booll· ;>Oil ......nIIe, "" • ft I k.,~ '" 1"'V i •."' :III. wo.nd up caQ;'" 'he: man.go' lft<I be "1.1, 10l. J _14 ~O\.• IG 1"'J ""'1 "'.• <loll., po. obi",.., I .. '""~, ~...:k 10<1 . ""H. Now if r""'" " f l"'I""""" <1_.', .... ""'I)'u.I ~ did ,h . t. •.., ...i,V """-lId add " p 10 .. i ll .,"" M ~I ""'. I tell A-1070 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 29 of 32 From inside the book [ Search 2J poee, rnatc~inc heq" " n t~is boo, P'geH A "", .. lion obouI Joe: SC.'I~ I I>:. Mil«. hilln~ IKU 0"' or ,110 boJI •• d " "' .. poi"' " 10 1110: 50. "1< P.OlI .. h: Ml<k'l Ma"\Jo ..... 10 tb( YlAl<c!.. To;Iay bo ... u ~ iI "" Ill< ltm 11)" !lIlblll . 00 ",bo n Sa: II"" '" hi.... ond KKl. "Whc ",'d )"l" ~, it, <:fl the d~ . .. - HO!IIIII, .. Mike H.op.o !III bcea hittinllik< P' go . .. . ... rwy. H< ...",. Iblllmm 1~ 1..-,_. Man,k poin:oJ i, ~ul 10 oil do< Link hi"""""'" UJd eoike' ph)'tfl "m ""'" "a1ch.. £. tan ,o:n,,",,,,, I doubl II. So I'll do lit..,,,, I, .. arwd " , .. nfl' Iftnlnl "bon J<lO ~P>"" " .. Ike<l To ....! tl ••1"", k","~ oft" • .,., fG"f-tIn''''' " ,....... H<r" _ the ..... t>a..., •• Doll ..<. 0, ball 1'<1<>. .... y ~"'r He,...,', he.d. Harper trie, 10 Ileal teCOII~ BIld A-1071 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 30 of 32 From inside the book hell [ So a d MARCH 91 Poge 87 -_.._.. '-"-' _ ..- --- ......... .....-.. - ..... _. --- 10m ,..b. w .. «>:ni"S by 011...." Mm ~.a:f the _ ). RoiJiM: "I d~\ ..... ' .., d~ it It lim. I .ai:I I didn', lIU"~ ~ ,.... r~t , b.1t t/Iq' IIk1Ix:D. j( wu corm.oo px:ice, otd lhe~ I "" J I .. 0"\ d ",bo<>I..,d dJd.,' ~ ~ donon ohiaS' So I I<>ll K_ ..,. I no<<k4 .MII"" .....". n)n .M Ix:'~ "" $1 ~O if Ix: tnloi "'" w~ ., wu """ i... ,Iu, PagE 337 -- -- - - - - -- - --- - - - - - -- --- - -- - --- ,----- - "'ltD v---- - N"" 1", dOla', .... . , ,~hu<k ,he bILl anI""'" Ix: t.-l '~. I"" for 1M"1I d it, I , ... hlm Iho Up or'" • fow riICh.. I...., I ",. nted ,~ ICC if ... ·d sin ko "'" <rIf .pion. H. dirt A-1072 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 31 of 32 From inside the book [ 3e~rch h ouk Pag,7 ",.do nJn per SO"'., _ ill on. I -..t .be inDinp ... i,oo.t biL AI llie mil or .pmt lrainin~ _ """"I'"!"" t"Y .okj to Hw', -Wow. dill,,', 1kNI"" h, y, • r;rtU Ipfi'g!- ud Hwl ..id. " Y"" ~', I;<> by 1~" _ ...do. H ........!" h •• pd spri." ," (The .pring before I .... 1_3 IOd hilt! • !.I 0 ElI.A.l III .... <mO gi~ up a • "'''' I... iog lila< A • _ . , _ V"', t. .. "" , ~ 011 """ "'" uobbc<l <ach ~11><, aM _ ~ mof'l. 0110: ..... H~ , , , .... 111:_ tri.:<! I<> 1hfOW me oil b.aloo1.o....t I lrial 10 wn:sdc ~ Im _0 ""II 111 L'Ic tim< we ...... to:ldln~ ncb """' •. " 11ow·. y<KJ ' ,,1107" I M id. "Gi ... "'" • rlOk. I"'",h to .... ribo." "~'~ tn..~ I>< said. "You",,", """"" me in tbo wmuch. Not A-1073 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-3 Filed 08/26/13 Page 32 of 32 From inside the book [ Se a ch GJ "SI'" ".toiling khl ~ i,- th;, boof< rog.23 - - .. oc= of fll 00 lim, l.tkir" calis:b:l ia n"'i"~ 11 be.. ; iumyi'!'j..:l;. ""01",,<,, " xl o'o')l.,iII& Ano'hc:r ,hill, "" doe. " gI h. w;)s with ~'lr: Ylnk .... btady li1ll< e)M !hiDillt. _ with • • ... 111.1> . rd r."cr 0Jt0;C iJl ...bk l",'d 'W\;"", 00.'" of .. """W>s l>a<~ [I"'" • ,,"", ~o From inside the book [ 8 =.rch 4(' pages "'tchi1g hiller in t~is took Paoe 62 . _-----_._.- ._., - . . _. tloe .. me oIo"'g_ Thy'rt .. l*<S you to <JOey good f""'.-;"S p,inciple., keep lhr: \NIl ,,"wn (""'" Iri'ten Ole hiy..b..U hi"'"), _~ IlIe .,01:;. pitch 1m r;ooc! (don'l pilCh ~ over lho heart of It.: pbl<) , "..,.... me toll """'ntI ""ide ,he ' Ir'.' :>OR ~nd <h,nre . "..... {hop' lb< h,mo, ~fI balmccj, a:u' 1:'" a~>d d lbe hl".r (" -hm Y<'II to.., IWO ><rlles 00 • A-1074 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 1 of 31 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------------- x The Authors Guild, Inc., Associational Plaintiff, Betty Miles, Joseph Goulden, and Jim Bouton, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, : : : : : Plaintiffs, : : v. : : Google Inc., : : Defendant. : : : ------------------------------------- x Case No. 05 CV 8136-DC EXHIBIT 2 [PART 1 OF 3] TO THE DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. BONI IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT A-1075 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 2 of 31 The Super-lawyers: The Small and Poweriul World of the Great Washington Law Firms ~ 0 JJseph C CoukJen Ti l E SU I'I~ H o Re,;E¥V5 LAW Y ~:I{S V;pyhrioht ~m TfJIFY, 1~!) - I FW firrrs - 4m lFOPS Comm on terms and phrases Abe Fortas ,\ere30r Adninistr~tior ,irlinE !..rnErOc ,r attomey Aus1ern ""lu "er K 6,H,"I,,1 iJil Commiltee Concress Covington and Burling Commissicm r antitrust c" led el,"irr,,,., Cor cressiona erg"" Arnold and Porter Clark Clifford client Corcoran corporate 8;kac Cu ","i"iu" ccmsel DaanAcheson oocision Defense CenJcratic Dct),Mr crug Feoo',. g]ve.-nme rt fees fled foreign former Fortas,.,:f Porter hearr.:ls hi'Ed indLEtrv ilgt]n Jemson Justic; Depertmenl r:",-,,,k hennea,- law firm Layir legi,l,bJ l Lloyd Cutler 10'" luLU.;,[, rn,tt,r Tle nt Mudge Rose Nader Nixon Paraba partner Fitman Penn Central p"rc"nt pJltl:al prach: e President ralrmd Ralph Nader f;,.,dolpr GuthriE reoulatorya;wces Repr"Sen:itrvE RelJjblc:m nilion says Soc'Etar; Senator Srnatler3 30mEme "t3ff Sluart Syminglon subcc.-rrritoo ou," Tern{o th r.:l Thurman Arnold tion lold -cmrnv Tommy Corcoran sl.I',o-n, Court talk Ttumn Unim;d 'Alaltoo W~5hillgtQIl LdW Washington Lawyer While House ..- ule Yu,,- A-1076 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 3 of 31 v . ___•__ _ P'go 6 . From inside th e book _ .. _ " - r ' •• , • • _ • _ _ ' - r .... · Wa..hill/(tvu l.4wJ~r "' Lb. Ina.. Am...-icau b~ dep<,d; •.. and .b~pc" tb~ f..de,.) g~n::m..eDI. The Wub iogton L.a."JtT in ret<llt "cades hu . Icppcl beyor.d u,e 3tt~ rn.y" traditio",,) ro~e as legal rep~ntative , The ~p<l n U> ". abdu~ - - traiDed -r-"'- ._. -_ ... _ .. - ..... ... - - ' ---. - - I S I sliIJ !~1 gatherer and -"J"' - i~lerprell'T 01 facu. Ar.d facts. properly presmt«l uKI ur~ flllly an&lyud, p rovide the rationale fo, most logl, I,lIoo. 1he cynics II\Itwlttutandl",." The ~ut. lawy ...·!ubUyi>t ;0'"111\'0 hill"",U iu .. bill Irurn t.h~ P,ge 31 ~ -r ' - Mo" 01 Ih. W3$hingwn Lawye r'. In wo.k ;s don. i~ bee-IO· fae. ronf ...·ncu .. it~ I RS offici. I" '~ing f..,... agOD\ ~I up to {~1l>t'\ rmely) t he l:mlmi'l,ion ... ,,' lnt • • ~ , l Revenue. Esc" oflicia l ~"" "~ 'yi ~g ~"tllnfity 1n .....t tl •• di'l'"": t l>t l .... yo-. mu" A-1077 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 4 of 31 From inside the book I S ,ard 8, "ges mtchin, law,.,. n this JOe>< hundred lIIark by 1.h~ rime Ihls book rncks prlm. C<»· lnglo~ and hrling. t il. <:il,., la~ flflll, grew rrum .1,hty·flW law)"..-) i~ 19110 lu 1.1", I"=ul uu~ h~.t.lrd lhirly. ArnQlt.1 and f'urlo:r weill from Ib ;rty·tt...., 10 .....·.nl:r; W;!m«, Culle, and I'i<k.oi n.l: hom . . n . . '-. " ._ . _ ._ , , , _ • . __ , __ . . • . . _ . rog.I ClJ "" Q\ me mmlS 01 I.M ilUlCk on "'~ller, lilt Stur:IeD.15 lu dr;ullillzlng a quuoo. thu Was.ltJngulII Lawy~B - and lhose ebewber~t.ad ~revlcuo;ly discllSMd only In !.he rmll tbeorctlcal ImTOl5 : "''bat Is the lawyer"5 re:!porulblllt)· tD .......i.n·, &li ODIID~ 10 bi, =lIDIISibilit", to Ill! iodivillwl d im!? Kq:arO-ltsS J ~ccmled A-1078 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 5 of 31 From inside the book [ 3 earch .1 r'"<os mtcrirq 1.'<1 in this book p" ~ , 193 ~er~ , 000 ou r p,e. id.nl ..spi'<ully h .... t...-n k...png an ¥ en ynu,' and 'H3Vf yau N ot" s iv<n a ny tt.nughr .~ In h.nw Inng y<I1J i "l~ 11 10 ", ... ,in wil:~ 1h~ Co.vl1i<Sion 1· Th~", migh, hliv. be<n " e'1 innoc.r.t- rny t,i' D r ~nlJg hr r""y d ''''plici! Dff~ .. 01 3 w.,. klb_ AklID ...h he "'0...... ·1 ""Hi II, ••11<. DC a>.ICpy In <In _~d in fan 1M I ,m in 01 II, \- - . no: m£. p:c:n", o. tn .. , <Ie: told a werftary.) The. he talked ~bo>~t it. The Fed"...1 R t!)enie Ilc",d , h ..gutd, "wu nev~. "'tendo<! to cove< kwu made by Eu.opean k ...ks--.--.-thu·s a I"t " I . '''P. As a matte. 04 bet, ...~ consulted with th. Fedoral Re .. rve Boan:! IIdo.-. ..... mad. Ite Po ! , 373 """" 10' tb~ 011 ".d~$l'>' ".<1 tht po.... '<,m!",IlIOS 10 caU U"e.t, all".....,.. 'public·interf5/. I:!.wyers.' b..c::>.u ... thoy un malo" a <lrong . ~ment lha l Ihey in f~cl .n: public ·inlo,,..l iQ )'et". , th e " definiti"n b~ing '" vllgUe ns it"" "Soon aile. I ",. m i~to nn.cuce for "I\'self . ! was """roached A-1079 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 6 of 31 From inside the book l,.-;s It pages natc'lrO to<1S 11 th , boo, the ."Pres&io.-3~d mo~ , did I 1..1 good. It "'... 61<. being 1hr0Wl1 inlo th.t ",..." by your dad to learn 10 ".im; ,..,.. conJume an alli fullDt of ... aur, b~t yc .. l.u~ ho .. to .... im. "An int'rM h .. to work on p«>plo: t" beeo",. '" d<>et,,<, and "" ......-I, <'If'''' rn rh • .,."",= •.-1 W ... I I _. , m;r... til ,II. .... , Poge Xli' - , -- - -,- - --- - - - - r - --- ' - . - - use 01 ~ h.u...rdous d"'l: ... hen the available luts ""d the r.,"tie",,1 d,"l: I.... dictate slKh .~tion. We bd ieve ,ht the f.cts $ho.. d ....1y lhal p_"" p.... enl~ ...no... ha",rd$ to p"tienu "10,, tak.. it "Iok. are !lOt b;,Jancod by ..y ber.ent t" be "f*ted - . . _ __ • ..,.._.. __ . . ._ . .. __ n .... .. . _.•• __ y_, _, _'.p. _ trained as a .killful &ul>o,e, and i~I"""'I'" 01 facu. And bcu, p,,,!,,,, l), prKet1I"! 3~d .,.,dHlly alLlly'..!, p,,,,,idl' tho: ntit:>naJe rM I'II<)!.I IT""'io.. , 11>0 cynic. noI..-iIlr.,t .ndio.g." Tho artu l ~ h"Y .... k>bbyi<t invcly", hi m.. !! i ~ a hm from th~ A-1080 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 From in~ide Filed 08/26/13 Page 7 of 31 the book [ SCOfch ~ oncy P"3 c11 ....... , " .um" 3nu ""':<:in""" . .,.."'. ,YOY Ule arm la_ eluded two oth ... 1lO."'~$-tho$e ~f P""itkcl Ni m~ and his Atlornoy Gfnoo-_I, Jolm Mitch.U. T Iw l'hGoni1 fir", <>1 Mi lcMl1'. Otputl' Atlo. M)· ~n~r"l , R.,hm l KJ . ;n_ ~"'I , . ucdenly deci~d it ~ 3n offi< .. in W~'hing _ Pog .1 % - -- .- --_. _. ---r--- _ . ~~llIO)' allOrney - ~ ---- r .-.___. --- . $O>y. Ib~ v~ne,.. O>CIltiAJ (0 thi. ""II ~f bar· glining-ia·the-da,k C.~ Mck~,.: " I had • friend ...110 WIU .... ' igncd to " cu. involving _ . Tht :, anomer pq>potr<:d b.lm with TCI1".ark... lik~ 'We " '''~ think yo~ .re do;~g a fin. job OV.T unIque,"' ""),5 lAIl"OOn I\U CU0t:ga ,]. lilt pnVl\e .Il"t~.}· . "a n.sponatJO~ " A~y Ir,l d~ ~tLon D ttorney worth his .. eight ... Il:~ rs tilt u~tionl l ! it.ual ion u d h~s people e~n l act him im· m..ri. ,,,ly .. hI'~ a c.l.'.r is b r eak i~ .-' Hut pri_atr prlClluo~erll ...r. ~ a< MlcUoUJ7 11 art at I di""d,-antastt: "Lawyers as a j!roup ... A-1081 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 8 of 31 From inside the book }J P'S/'" n» toOin, .no, ..),> in t1i, boof< Pogo J W WUlUr.Jo:l"" aOOut "nl< ~ othe, Auofney' (U,e ~'lIy dfeam. I't ,"" me tll1t< i. tb. r"tu r~ Oifford migllt ..., ~rnu\aL«I, ""O .urD pu.....,d, ho: c.wI oPL r... r ""pli<8tX:m . .,,<><1, fiD.IIy, th~ my. Lique .,.om pU~cd 1>)" a ~ n. CUller<! h both .. d c~, .. for at- bl~i~g rorl><'y ........ J>rllClic. in 1 ~ ' ..... town "';(h ~;m. Poge 7 " ..... '" '-'~". 'Y , ,n ~~u.nuuu > •• ""u .. ," .... 'uU< , ~ .. ....." "'., tillY fig"ros ~,e 1 ..-g.I), ",_ wnck , ~ n d lot ."", ·,~", 1 reA!OIM . .. Untll April I, ]972 , IltOrJle)" pracrking in Wruhillllon [Ourts ...~ ,",I rert~;.HI 10 join .. bar n<;O(i..llkln. "fl""liv~ lru.t dat., I.b . D.C. Court of '"'weal:< T"'IlliTe<! attorneys to join • 1.a1l')ers' P",], 1~1 n ..· lamoVff ~I " __ 'al :o.gen<11!0 ,~ ~n ' ~ . y"" , "'""nil JI ' m~ ol><@f§timaIM IMI I"" FTC hirr/d 750 alto r~.}". during hi< 1i"1 live ye.rs ..~ ~TC t~811"fM1\, just to nul~lIIl. 8 4()O.IMft •• ~el. TbI!> SEC lost!! about 75 r>1 iU 380 &ttllnl¥ arh year 10 private pradi",,; the H'C. 10 01 10; 11l.. FCC. 35 of 200; th .. C... B, 2[J ~ A-1082 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 9 of 31 From inside the book [ Swcl1 C","fee 4 pa~,s de~lee m'tc htl1 I in Ih s boo, i~flK<nce of eny kind in W.. hingto~ . If yo~ ... ""t 10 ,"",ploy oo:neo.... "" hIu ; " fl~e!ICe, yo~ "ill haw 10 go rom_h.,e .1.... Fi<tt. becau ... I am ~OII. !lUre ",h.~ 1 til_ 'in~aer.ce' me:\1I.I, b~1 tha.t u ino::> ....,quHJt.ial; """"d, b«a ... e .. hal<"'tr it i" .,. I."" ~~ n', h ... :. 11'" "'Y uq;""< '" I7U •• • "~ n. }'I''''''' ~ l"'uJI<-m. <Te:I. "". "n~. a very "'''po::t:ilil. place on LaSo lle St,~t-IkVQC:, Shad"", M ikva ,· mnd Plot kin, il'. "lied. U ~l tht "un'l tt.e mns..-er , eilher. SiD/:I. 1'1:"1 ",t;on. dO~'1 '~II1!r (han~~ Ih',.,;! ; )'o~ 10 get 10 t.'>< Matt of tM corpora tion-Ih" .. ar t}.ing' are ru.u ""Y<' '- .... r'9,401 .. ,., ..."'.,......,.""" .., _ .., 'w ........... VIo;t .......... ,." "'" "",I".. ~....... !J " ... /\:.,. .01 .. " If, ( lot91. 10) " ioU" .... 1110 ).1Ib It",,,,,,,, it. 'Of<>, .. .".01_ ..... '" L~"" JoIo_ ,G!. '64·'" ... ""'. ~.-. .~ '''' .... ,1«, ro"nIlt<d I>l' f.U f"/lU.net" ,,, 10: .... Da/, lSI R·j~I"" ... IoIIi1~ m .l )) n.»",,"" J.~. '" ..t""""" 11,.,\ ....,".-," ........ ~ ",. so" '" ........... c"",· A-1083 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 10 of 31 From inside the book [ 3earct C~SE P"\l , 31 p:1tlners , quietly btc<ID'le Ille rountry'l experl on the National Recovery Mmln!5lnl1o~. and be draft~ mnrroU5 Rlue Ellgle lmdWllry o;od= (J~Sl ... quickly, u~rlll'tunal~\y, hit !lj>t<ll lty ,""",ourJI.t:d. ~ W1,." lhe SUprt"lllO Cvurl d«lar..J S'RA unoo,.,ll· t~linlJ.lll io tho .x:k chick<ll c..»c." !lor. kv ,",v •. "half of wh~t Ur.der Secre<.ary cf Stat(, th~ departmo~I'S nwnber-t ....o position . Laylin, iD ~I'\$ IluI Ac:htron " b~d al",c\ntely "'".e.-." ",,,Hm, la <1<>" ... itb Covir.gt~n and R~ .\iDS ..p....... ling I ..... and Greuo, two nat;",.. wilh ...n...e .1I.i ... Ac:h .... ~ dealt in. l im.I.1v i~ hi. ~lIiri., r"",rih: ''Tru. J .. ~ r .... no ..... ~hn llr rhi ~ Pog o J ~ QI guilt in the de<_ btooalll" "th~ <J.r""dlnts ill thi< 0.... beli ..... tnt)' did not vielate tbe antit.uA b .....'· If , uc.~ an admi u ion ~d bo:eu <e<Juired lIS th~ price of u agrt'l'., enl, h~ u.id. l~"". would bav. ~ M dec",,,, .nd "11. ca ... wo~1d h..·" to go III t.;.I." A-1084 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 11 of 31 From inside the book : ollt [ Seuch ,9 ,ales m'tc htlj COUIf " this ~(O{ .ighl 10 113m .. ... hat Ihr: ollense 01 ..hich t.e had been ron· was." Arno:d, Ff)rus and I'omr thasfrl thl!! eloud vict~ Iblo~~ l~e courts fOI !iCl'fIl I;lu!hcd and gave lhe m.~ . h~ ~.~_:.- ~ rt.;~ ~T' years before tile gcvemmml .'\~d O,,'en Lilli.lI"",c, lhrlr back pay . h.;I..-I ;n ' ~ " .... cO " " ...... m~.' Page :53 Co~e ... ;" the p('lic. court of WashinJ1l.on Law. Despile tl-.e ..cd 1M lLoe U5~.I I .I.•.j, ,,,,"." To) Web" .... <tctiit , hoe mldt no ~ ret 01 n;" d~1lI .UlIu .. kp:!l.to. and b.nk bwye., I)w,,, .. he I"'blidy ( .~d .~tttM · fully) 'epre;onttd !.he bank in fDrt )'-one ca, ... argued befor-e the '·n:..... <:... _ <:, _ __ .... ~" .. '" ... _~n r.. n ..;_..... ' w • .. ,~ ..... A-1085 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 12 of 31 From insidE the book 25 pgcs mo:chj'9 tor <"''' j, tri o bo ok Q pa.n}·, YUu """"'''''''y .."'v." our 1lIl. • ll<: I'."'.... IIOLe," i:. it ? WI., ""n d.Ii~. it?" ... h John &lpi ...... II~ doli" •• ~pub\k policy· ... an •• t 01 C«og ..... (hat b... i>eeft uf>b.ld by the <ou,h. " I do~', ef(:"I!ni~ the VDn1;I""'nc<'- of ~ FM..,.~1 tifocial , ond I Iu.,.~ DC qulms ..llllSOever about chal. U~. QI _wL~t Pa~ e 12 eight tn Inm . .. wbat tJu: cffen~ 01 ... llich he had been oonVicted was." Arnold, FCrtall Ir.d Porter c:hued this doud tbrough tbr coun. 10' ~"" yrafll bc.fu,e tho 1i:~~traJJlwt bl",h.d and gave the ",cn IMir back pay. And Owen Lon.lmor< , .~ • .,.~.~:.- . ~., n~ r~;". ~ ~ ;I.,j ; n ' n "'"rl " '" ,~ . ",no! r oge 100 o .va;bbl ~ in adv~ nc •. " " Aad .ppeal< I" Ih, ( " un.. al tv...,. 1'.8e , you .'l:! a hm ,in8 d>lt. they . sIr a p"" p""""",nt, you d(ny it. tlley go to c~urt " T hey 5eldom .. im. bUI eYef)'lhin.g stqlS wllDf It I! argued. l11 ey try 10 put In suptrftuouo; le!!I!mo~y, the A-1086 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 13 of 31 From inside thE book "ag e '"'' ~"" > u""'. I""'-"~ '" ...., .. "'u • . .,,,, u"l\ . ,""' J ~"';o J . Ha, ry Co,-;ngton, ..,". m. n of tol~l1y di ' p_ ate pol'SOIllIlily. H Th. ouot.re, laciturn lIur!i ng .."" a mAn O~I of an ok! S~I~ ..hJ F.u''''nc P~j l ' U(n'l< ., ~rr. H. gr_ "[' in ,"e.1 f.I,1<1ra , In"-A, wh~", hr wort td in a ,roctry SlOtt It age. clevffi. and "'~t au th e 1930" Cbarlcs HOfSk)· frcqu<nlly ,od. II>< PenBsyiv3nia Railroad'. CO"8 r.",<>~1 train to g . .. York ,,-hI. JU~K' Coviag- IGn. "Th~ trAi n 1IfO ~ 1d I ~v. Union Stu"," nl I~Mr.lhir ly in II.. aftemoon, and on any given chair car JU dJ!t CG¥ington wOijld P'go 2~1 UO U''''01 ""'" U""C"U'" " un"" ..,,"",. Ull"'~ 'U ... ,." ~ ~~ ~ ~ ... UUSt n it ~Itd In 1940. Tburman Arnvld, the~ tile As<\.\IJ Dt AUQlnty G<.LClal r<l l u .ti,,,.., .""u<r$, kll"'" Br oJlll~'s >kill at ",.edlinr: • c.1>e ond so"llh, 10 opecialth .......j~~e <o~ rt.. .~I"'dite II.. ~u it by co.,-.."inr: II He told Bromley. " 111 m you, kite, my A-1087 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 From in~ide Filed 08/26/13 Page 14 of 31 the book [ 3 0arcr lelUl SIX ptqlIe. n wi!.I a true ffiw:.1.Ufln ICI ",a,.; !he train \Olth him. Th~ .<;IlIIt thing t oming bact -con· Slam Iw>d!hlting: ' KnJwl1\K rowrnm~rI. b~r~au dilers. and j~~ .., and m.,n"",", "r rrgulat,,'Y !i""'ci.., b ""r level uf ad· '&lJlII~e, ",,,,e i""""I~III (m ll,~ (''''' , LUWt:·,~[ , W"d, C.,.,.j[li:lO" '~ . o .. at n t~r o~gh ,~ - -~,,~. ~~, .- -~ ,~,... ... ~" .~ ~. -, -.~ ~~ irIoolM from t he " llOn-Celkr'· ~rm. and thai he considers his practice 10 be "ICtlW 1l1li rtgUJar"· .. hhln Ibt IIlHnlng: of !he ABA «Ilk. '' In an~ evolll," he says. '" my wrutJtuonl.$ mll$t ill: Ih. ulti.mo.l., judI;"" I" lh~ ~q~\ily and d,,,, ..clt:r "r Illy I'",r"nllFa),374 volv.....nt ¢f Congr_ in "",tI , .. :Ul""tin~ Ihe military , Goo5eII "',.,U, K tbe I"'tMltial con Aiot bet.. ~n ~n offk, i. tho miliury I.IId 1ft off",. in Co"fl,ea i. r.<Il il>COn""'l".. tial." G..sel1 Itopped !torI 01 orderiol pr.~nl "$I'~ to ret.'S" . '''T judg~J h~I""; . "n.. k ., _ "~ . , ~'" r~ _. ,_ 'A _"" " . h"d ~ _~ft l " ~ .. _ A-1088 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 15 of 31 From inside the book [ So",rn bond 6 P"Il" m.t:hino .,,~ ben c ~ " this boo, "',,,, u."'< l""UK'3, """ftOOU , . ""'''"~ •..,u J""/:< J - lI aH)' C~vingtQn . ... <re men Qr totally Gi'p."~le pc.-"""~~ty. 'the ...... ce« , ladcura lIurl;.); .... , • man o~t DR "ld &I.do, £""nmg P~.j , .cCo.!S ",ory, H~ S"'''' up in ,urnl Elw<&, Iowa, ... h~," h. "",bd in • groc",y W .." ~( "l!" dO\"e11, and W.D( on "r auorney duting Joh<ucn·. reign .." Scoale maj~rjty 1""o.Io:r, Yk~ Freid.lII. , anoJ 1'",.id.lII.. John"",,, mrt Fortas .. hro b~ "'&!I a fi~!-!e'm C()p);,usm~D hot afle' p.r.bli( po"'" for hOo 1'.:<.15 diwict, ,,~d forlaJ, &!I di· ....... 'm "I ,)". n..............n ' "f ,~. Tn'"",,,', ~. ;vhb~ ~f .1od,k fronl row as &:dw~td lJennott Willi .... argued ~ c.ue. "1'"", .....ola. ""If :lnd be<koned 10 a pag< 10 come get it and I~ke it ,,~ 10 JUltice _ , who .... 5 ~j"j~1I o~ !h~ btnch ." th la"1''' .... 'd. " Ju'!k~ __ ii , ,.~<I 100.." do .... ~t Tnm . 1Id ,mil.d ~"., n""~"" I ""n" ".~~ ,"~ .I;cM .... ;~"" ... h~. ;, ...~< .n ~M '" "0" A-1089 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 16 of 31 From incide the book Page :3 .>Ouru:.; ou .. ua '" UK 'Wl> - filIn"'CQ_mn<~ nnc . 1 0< u. ",c" S'--leo 5<1Ve.nment s~btnilted • <In!t treaty_ l.wyer Loyl;n'$ n. ndi"",rk , ~a1 ly_t~ • Vni td NJ!i~1I$ committee in A1I_ guSl 1070. On aool~tr lrool , OS chairma n o f ~ sl-i . l A_ritan 8a, Awrio.lion ."bcommin~, Layin i. mobilizin" bar SlpJXlrt '" _ _, . ..... """/i .. v w ""on with . 1,,"S. r5---oo , etle";,,l1y with 'I .. ~_rt lactic. l m .n~rlsm' "'11$ of tnt So.lh h3V~ USO<l lor cIecade:! 10 lHgulle iIlld dts3..m un..-ilHng ."-ortlltmeTS: II bini !If tI'.e coun.ry }"ot ~1. 00 single word o. inn""lKm )'l.lu can ~ ~., Mill ~ , ~.~ ,~~~~" ' ~ll ~ .-~,,~ ~nd ..,.,~.ni; I;ly .." .".. . w practice I......, and intem:uioully. Pep<i-Coia wu it! tile 1''''''"' of ch AII..,,~;n, Coca"...,I. lor .. h~1 .... ",,,,I d cIIl , ... Stw\1I Pop ~ ' '''~ ~ ' r'""V" V M .,,~ ___ ~~ " ~'~K'K ,~ ~ u-\d.,.! hi" 0/ h. World, nrul I I""" .. Vir.., Pr~d~r" or Ih' l -!litrd States is I good d.tat l man fer loOftening Up pcltentales A-1090 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 17 of 31 From inside the book [ SeCicli r~jJ r~" " 6w'mc cJo ,. ID (D., T.,",,) d~rj~, ,lot: ,.." Rqr<"~I~liv. ]1'nIAI Pal_~ baQ~I~ OPA l~r;.lflI"''' h. d I~ dUlr P81.,... ..'s , .......it/c• . P~'I<' rJ;,bo'l /01"1" lit. Jn~J,Iri,. l.ongr .... afiU ,al Ille Cll""l '"lUll ... n 0' '"l:"llllon .. net'Oea, ould go .boul <.LlaimiJl ~ i~ . 11,." Ihoy 4,.,j ~A.Clly h..... la: ,l> ohake hi. hand at tbo d""r [lDd >< nd Mm • bill. Cliffo,d ~ (...ftl~l Il<"e, to appl'04Cb II CDng=lI~ lac< to lote oa behalf 01 D SJIf'Oilio dienL And ""~n <UC~ 3~ 'K~ri.nced l'l!:~l warborse "" P'g . 17~ ... _._ .. -.-..... -_., .......,.-. _. .-- --. ._..._.. - HowArd R Kornegay, a North Caroli ... Dcrnoc,~t who ..... a ""'",~r 01 lhe H ....... I .t~'slat. and Fo,.W' Com"",= Com· milt" du";~ hi' fO\l. tl ,m, in eo_gr_. KQr~"Ss)' .e~l Q_ lhf toh1cco lobby I"'y",n u. he:p ell"\aocub.1.e legid.tion '''''lui,;''!! A-1091 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 18 of 31 From in5ide the book [ S"",cI1 38 "[10' ""Ie,;,! 13,,"' ;' Ih, boo, Pog,70 office. Cliffor<l did not I"'n,e,f"'!" ;a !.~ 1?68 aunpaign - al · though his b", pa'tn ••. form.t C IA off'ci.l Thornu O. Fin~"Y' helpod di'~1 S.MtO' £~~ MeCart.~r"' P,,,,,idtn'ial b id. And a£ of rrJd·I07! C6ff~<d w~, the u,jrf {or.igB policy advo... t~ ~ .... '" Edmund ll""k;". ,,·hn b.... ,Iv docidod .. "" tll~ ""'" Page 161 l"'in"Jl!u~gly th~ .rg~m tJw.i. CI.S/! ago.iDSi adrmnbtratiw: Iii". 'The admiDi5lrallve law procfSJ Wall damnm as un·American." tiec:aUIoe Qf tbe "Ill", tbt AdmlftISlrl(l.t Proctdurt Act , thtir pal. did ROt gt! Ibrou~~ Colll:rtSll ij~lil 1046. BU I \~ end 'e.!ijl! ....... I'VIntl whu Ih •. mmn.,. r!nn~ ...:mOO ri. N~ YD,k Pog,368 ~ ..... W'"M ..... ''' ""., .".""U """."', during situations lhal lfSUl! in mass arrtlU. And Cijllu hIS ~II a ,.id;ng I~rcf in th~ Lawyer!' CommluH for Ci~iI RIgbl5 lJadt f ~w. virtually I~e ~nly nr· VlY[Dg wh[IMomlnatt'd group prrssiDl for d~reg:31I~n. ~"" a t"''''''' c"."',, coun. and jail ~ ~rooedule.! A-1092 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 19 of 31 From inside the book [ 3 .arcr 17 P"'J'o m,t,hing I""" ., tri, hm l didn 't think it would be terrible to tij:htu thr lfltitl1l5t laws. This rlpptd Ibro"lh CQrdine<'s l!el~nsr$ sa hrutally h~ II",.. 00"'" .. 00 "'I(reo:<l th. 11f""""t lawi "crr """'ply ¥ ••• _ ' . ¥ •• ",!:"n(y. And he . rg. ~' lha, a C<lmblrution la"~r'Iotj,y;"1 i • ..... tI)' nmf~ ,.,du"loI. on II,e Hill tlun a ,•• m,lawye,·lubbyi"'. " II. i> l,ai,,~..J Iu j.,te,prd IdW> ...,d pID, ide lOJ:a1 ",,.ly'" fur ~b C\i.~t," Abl~r<l ha:! ... ,itten. "0"" w~<> <an interpret Md an .lyze 1I~lf t" .' 1M DI"! , . KaUler ' flan plO,esU<If ag~nl>1 all r.guIation. the t~du'lry !houkl d".... up 3 mudd bm I~at wuuld ","bll"~ • 'r~lp"th~lic <Umu~ 000 ",1 f~.th ~ P'~ /WI ljminary .... pfwcli. ~ _.w ..... . . ~ . _ . _. ,.' .... __ .,. _. __ . ~ . __ , "",.,c," A-1093 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 20 of 31 From inside the book [ Sc orch gavcmmont 93 P'[ O'> rr"ch " g ~." ~I"III.'" in h. bock P' go 6 _ _ .... . . _ OR _ _ • • ___ .'_~ _ .. ___ _ .. , _ , _• • • • Wwu~on h'")'Cl is the man A",erlc.a~ b ... ~ dope ..... U;>on U> '<.~bd~.., .. , ~nd ''-pc'' the Fedual '".....,m.. t nt. Th. W... hir.gton La"'Y.r i~ ret"" .....ade. hc.o be· yolK! U~ attorney'. tr.oditional ",Ie"" l"EaI T"I'reoentative. The "_wed _ • . --_ .. _ " . - 'h~ - --' - , - r ' " - r ' - - .. _ . - -_., . .. --- ... pn<'."'" ~ 1"'_ ~vi.t' .....~ ""'gained nul of anything." Dran .... thtM. had l~t CovingtlJll nd Hurling in 19·41 lO reenl~r gonrnlr1MII; from A1lgU5\ L9<l S to J~De L9~7. whu the IIrm ...~ r ~b ~lldlng Its [ntemallol\llL practice. ke served &II P' go 1>6 --I'''' t < um, ~"' •.",.., DIU "". }or ""~t- I .,."" UJ ,"",U ou f/I;UiD>l d~/!arl. in ~m; ~ilr. ttl/'J , /1. T.ul /,,,, c(mli~l b~d !q lire '~W!T1"".' I~' lAc , £)1 01 "'Ylile." h l'lfl.ku IlIan d yeor alur u llvinZ l h Wlt.ilt Horm, Car· tOT.~ t:tU;()IInltrtd rh~ !riffItJ claln. '"Sa y, Sa .. :· /I.e ,~Id, ,oru A-1094 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 21 of 31 From inside the book ",de ral [ SE "'Th ~ . ~~y~~~,. v_ ~.~. ~_ " ~t'I''''6' ~~, v. """"'" of on •_ _ 'O~"'1 cogulatioD , on~ whio:h stines ~tion in tiI~ "o •.v.r1y· macht. LH l.M\oi~~c, IDrmtrly ~ m.m~ of Ill .. Fm.:.aI Comm~ni_ cations Convr.i5sim, oow an attorney in WasIlingtOl, D~ Uurlir.g to """ttI~ u., progrllm. .Edward Hurlir,g ... nt inta !'ed_ era! murt in Ok lahollU and obtained an 'njullCtio~ hall'as .. I'WA proj«1 tI'hitll conceivlbly could tJlve oon Ih~ ookll ng oompany .. hudful of (\:Stomer!, AtbtsOD clluetled In 111.5 t'edual agtndn, He IDUI(! C(lr«)fUl'$ jauntiness uhilaratillg, aftd lie shred Corooran 's lest for causes, Th.t W .1'11051 fOfly I5 year> ago , 1\0" Ru ll 5.lI quleliy In !he Federlll CUy Club Ind ) wlshed around a gli.M of oouroon and kto >r.d reml~iiJU'!l ab,ul h;, ... " ,..ha. em",,!., l ri.",1 A-1095 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 22 of 31 From inside the book i~t., the b" sirleS' today a~d P~! th.i, "'0"""1 in,,, it, thlreby making ~D iD'''''''''~nt, "-"leu i~ some p~ p,otoed". a,a; n. t Oy. by. nlght c"mpu,;es ... bereby 10m. i""05(»"';bl. corn· I"BI... can ...l ""m. alml: ... ith 9 lot 01 _o ...dhud (lTanH • ...r & ••• .. . " .. ,h.,. M;_ _ ... ~ . . . ~ . . . . ._ _ h ....... , -.;,,_ • • ~_ ~ _ ,~ , & ~ Cg ,ml"l.'" . leppnlI1'l,l" Iht Whh" House: iow 5D thriving a aa ... ...... iu= Ib.t lUI" ''' ~lIy "",atll> h" <Jidn', .v"" but.bn to qo:n ... , _"' __ __ ,,_ _L. ______ • ___ . , ~ _. ___ '-_ . _U __ _ _ ' - ""lit,. __ _ u '-- upon .. hat is h:of'P"ni.s M\II , bec:l u... 0' Mudge R.... is MI thal IIOrt of 6<1n. " W, RT tt<;hniei ..... ," Rondolph CUllI ... , laid . "W. arl not in Ih. b~,inu. of . /'feeling 8'O" "ffllm.r,l. We ... otk dirKlly with Ih. Imll !~lr, nol at ,M. ~.i~h 1 "",,1-,...',. A-1096 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 23 of 31 From inside th e book ""arch 52 P'lI'" ",tchin, t,n in h. book lio~ ""'lk' . rou ~d " i llt. him. and the "''''''' f"'&pl~ BIC "'"'y of him M d noaybo ~v.n 'e5fT'It him a lillie ~il. l'w W. told he'$ " d ,mnod ""..I lawy ..... a~d ",.ybe ho is, in hi. opo<:;"l field • • Rat I nov. ..... I~y ..'idu",~ !h! t,~ bew .11 that much In .bou, 1,,. O~ ~~ ...... ,In "" "" , .... hi. h_I...... l ,<v.I....~ ....... , w,.y~1' COIU "",,,"" 1r~'" a ",.,1 •• Ilcty the inf~rm.1 oIflCt conf.~co o• • ~~ 10 C<>ns.(>.O. Civ.~ 01 ' ,,'U<lU. ~n<I '~rt\ I rt\ .... 110 . 110m t~ • fulI-bkM~ .o~rt proa:edin~. Ih. pro?", •• ""u rces-i.• ., " rich enough diml-~ ~n!il he has uha~st"" all avenues. ..,..,d 13K la-.yer _n't .top ~'"~ .... JIl Ua!HI In lI. asJungton i. ~nd.niably lb. sir_ moot gle impo,tant inf1,,"~ "PO" th e nat"<t 01 th~ Wuh ington t;I.~ Jaw_ Y"''!t I'","'ief!, Phywi l I'rt..im;ty (0 tht •• ,ion.1 ol\t:e ~ itJ ' ''I'ict ! ... ~'mj,,-,io~ nf i"lnrn'IA"n~ • .,..",o~.l d ;""ll.. ion" ~u!ily sdItd"lNl conf~ ... anti an nf I h~ nth.r ntr.in,,~ . n""nr"...,. A-1097 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 24 of 31 From inside the book 87 p',e, "",le';'9 fill" ;, th, boo. P,9C 234 ..... "'" ...... I""auvu "" ''''' ""''' ......... ""~u'u '"' .>< ..." .". . ~ w p,at Eiet law. a~d ifttef113tiOilal ly. ~L·CoIa WI.I 1ft !.lot !}IOCHS of cballeugi"i Coc;a-Cola lor .. hat ..e CI.luld call Ihe Soda Pop Ltaderslllp 01 t~t \Vorld, IItld I tann er Vice I'reldttt c f the U,ul<tl SUIt.,. is .. gOU<l detail ,"a" I", ,"",teaull( up pull:"lates Ko.,,,,,ik (ried t~ explain ~way (he Iolt.. by saying h. wrole it ... bile in tm DominiCAn Republio. "I th.ink th~t whet> 1 w.. t do .. n tlt,,_, I p",bably hd a t"""mnwnulion, bUI I am ..,1_1 Ihin~ it .. os .ot • firm vhich I kD .... ""f$tOnally. I b.li ..... " I __ . ,~ L ____L ____ ._'-_-' ,. bell.' I.hat " " , ___ ., •• " iRdivid ~al l L.~ L __ . ~ _, "_ Ja.wye •• "';Ih Ih. lirm .hou ld be I..... , <o~. ilt<ln' with thl Code of ProhS$ io~.l Rtf.p<>ou.ibai\y. to pun"" th";r ovn 1_!£Inal and pr-of"donal 8"'"t,. Rathe. 1h,. ,lIlemf'ling to ~.h;,,·~ • u~ifi~ d " ro,ition u on Rny p;or. limb. "",tleT. 1110-. "'~mt>n.: nf ,lti' ~rm """"IT''''' ..,.rh A-1098 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 25 of 31 From inside the book [ Scare, firms :JO p' go' m,tchin, firllls in th .. book Pog.26 I'ractia tl", <it) h.d ill tho,.;: .u)~ h.ri !(CU"" in r"'I'<'~>e to i",l~!~d and h~ltly $~i~llted ,it~atiQne. RijI;ht d!., the a.il W". , wlw:~ \ ~e i~dr.tSl riIIl rr:'·olr.ot io~ lxgon '0 boorn 8<f1)\.O Arned"" pator.! aUQmn La" ." \01 ,ho- I~~T ~"" .• 1;" 0 FIll), · by Ih~ SUpfl'_ Comt, ~nd a ~y 1""'Y~' trita p.actic.. i~ Jubjfd. to} them. H ~llCe t~e ~ tW rule caused litually dozens of Con- gteslmfn· lawym, to withdraw from th~ir h,m! during the \"Q years after ilS ~nawn~nl. Pogo no and M...... ~. (Wih"",", W~,bin~lI:In ~ma. ~ve" w,e \IlI: • C~ll., ~nd i'it:hri'\t "". ""'~c:; as the ~I Crav~'h, Swaine ~ nd Mou.e; Ih~ two ftTTJl!l add!""" mnd phon nun,ber In lhe W""hill(:- '''"'lI: IOn t<kl'..... "., rJj",o;lOry.) A-1099 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 26 of 31 From inside the book cff c, 58 p,~es [ 3, arch mat cri"1 offi ce in Ih s tm f: P''l'' Ei6 """'" '" ",l a U"'L~"'" puonc . J U ""!>I>, ~~ L U I""'I'L., \/iUYJU "" UL ~ n~ ""Ll<e. Anyone ",'I", " 'II Ry LTUlLI~Jtd rou!d cv~nl .wl}' find bl ,a ; whQ (UUI"!~'I wOtSD '1 th~ .... rt imidu..;lienl be wa~ltd, 4Ilywi}'. A r...,alf~ i riv~1 vic-Ned l b. lick gf 4<W~ lJllO datiO I1~ froRl a sli~bt.l1 .Ji1T~re"L pt'1Spn:live. H<: lord joumd..<t ""yolle "r 1.a... yer CiD en"""" l rulD a • ..,;L Vd".ly 01 l" fUlI", , a"l;:l ~ lrurn th~ Info'mal oflke oon fe,ern:. 10 II 1~Il·bIoW1l courl p,oaedin~, ur ev." lu Coo'I!:rQS. Gin'" lk. proper re!Quru::o-i.." • ficll .,,,,,,!!h d i.:ul-iL J(Wd laA la\/i\'~r .... on' l .>10" ""I illl~ h&> e.ha .... lcd at! a "~!lue., r .ge 315 appo,n l"", '"" ""'Y ""~IU D."'''' '¥"uu ,arlr ".,, ~ .. an m . S'''"". Th e fact tllat 1hc pft'>On ~u<Sting the intef"i.w ....., a former go~rn""'n1 ofIici~l Bigh & pn",tk entry inl" ~ ... Cm(~, ut Capli~ !Illy>. " It 's a <ombi . nt ;~n " I c3ma,~d~,ic Ind courte,y. \,,,,, fiDd t im. f", .. fermer <ilida1. If ~ m~n Ilsed 1o be w '" wm A-1100 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 27 of 31 From inside the book AJ pagES m<ic h tXl otlic • • " trlS boo, I~ rll.. CO';~llo~ 0.,;/ JI.,ji~t pu~j~t Of/let', 1M "'.,~ 'c~ ... , />..1..,." ''';'')J ~!fir." ~. Ik, ",mill arui "'tlol.' ,,"",. .j R.91 16lh Stud A'W, ., I"~ 'G'I1CJ~rl ./XUiDw, c~''''' Gft lilt; 4ttnu ~,tm. .....u oaiotd""" M v ~'" kon - .11_ i~ t~ , , "",,_...uJ ~'[C otfi£" t9, R.pr.,.".lauve Rith~rd L, OIting<:r , "bile in Collj(r... , "ompl.iued Illal Ih. " <I""" rdllUQ,.,hif-l bttw"",,, II,. ICC ud the railroads u far mon: tlr.o" a matter of phikosophic.l off•• ;t)" It .. a 1<O''';''l economic and peroonal relatioruhip, "hich fffljUen lly 1~~nl~ .. . ~. ""' ~t ;",;A"'". ""."hI. ;nft ........... Io.v ~n ;...~,,,',... cials witll .. born he ~~d lalted about 1M SUj milbon b.ail-out "no.. undelSUlnd ' tile d«p-.ODled nature Ilf the nUlO.Id'. probItm. and"fie rudy to set a~~t correctl~g them . A-1101 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 28 of 31 From inside the book portner 39 P'q8S [ C::eorc1 rnatc~inc , al1ne r n t~is ~(O{ P,"<,59 )lOll Upo<:l 10 p,~c li<e 1 wilh him th.- r .. t ~ f Y"ur ~I~," a _ s.ni o, maR .aid. " Ih hard II) t~n him yn,,'~t. (h., ~~d yn",. rIIl nd ",he~ he 15 alrflldy 8 i'lrtMr." Tht .. Io!clion proem il ritualiUli, One Monday ailt'rnooo in mld·June or nch },(ar Ih~ fiflll'S """'n~ ,,; .atM, l ~ wh.n Cha,~ H" "h; u U " 1""" Valenti·, .' Pogo 119 rabbit ....,.ren of ~""' "'.,~ 1O,.,,:,0~. No .., -.nth .....,.Dty1'~~s la",),c", II J>a, \rO\lblc &old ;,,! c~o~gb .... _ ager boy' \0 <:.1.''1' poptr. nro~nd, ODd _iales gripe obou\ ha'l.~ \0 walk in I~ snow when . .. nio, paM ..." mlb them 0,,",' fo, .. chaL 'The .... o""h ..u . tudv: three men a vO<Ir. O:>e Quantum ;11"'" in !Ii.., P,,",,234 .o~ncem..,t ;n <witing fram bi! ."il" ~I th o W. ldo,f-A.ton.. T~"'n : On Jun~ 1, 1 ~6l , ! . h.n IMU my r"';d"",,~ to New A-1102 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 29 of 31 From inside the book o;ea rc~ ~ S30D ~te 12 p.qes mtc~inc '''''0<1'', in t~is ooeJ< P'g' I. ind ... ,ry h. r'l'r"",ntM. W. 1d told TIt~ lVoU Stout JON' ''')'' J~"lb.n K .. ;,~)' : " I h~v""'t 1m, .1Ight""l tlMb1 thm (ig'''''U r_ U!Ie lung canc~,. J had 10 c~me home evt'Y n4:ht an~ lICe my kids S.Jying. 'Daddy ...hy "" ."''' """k t ...... ~;"""" ~nm...,nv>· " P'g,15 th.r~ art: guidcli ..." Th< \VashiD gtO ~ Lawyer .. och 1,2 00 to 1,.00 baur ~. y<: ... Ihsl .,e '·bilWJl." to ! pI" cl~c cli<'nlS. The .t,a!~~.I·billi~, .. te 'ling"" from f,.JS pe1' bol. f~r a "''Y jun:... """",,iBl~ in 3 l>rgo ~rm to S2~O 10. , .... """'" "".."",""" " I ,~~ n~"'~ Ii ...... _ R .. . ;~. P'g' 5, ' - .,,--,-\aried eMDgh experin« :so that yo~'n ha~e l bacqro~J\d in allllo!t uytb1na • la ... yet tan lIo In W3.lt,lntt(lR. nul rl)lllle from ~do;l ~o fil:ld too much, and yo~'D ~me a dBeuan~e." OD~ oJisj:ruIHI..J ru r11J~r .......ua\~ wit" =iJ:Ded .ft~r I"u y....-. .. . -- .~ . . - ~ -- -" - D _. _ --. A-1103 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 30 of 31 From in5ide the book -:'7 P'~es ma1c~inc ~'!l" que"i"" in tois JOO{ 61 UjlDinirtg \bat curpuratiJ ... !u"e ~ ril!bt tu lq,:w "l'<="ia' tiOll," ....lIio< patine. "'Y'. "I'm a l...,.. geuin~ qucs.iolll like, ' WHI 1 .r. •..., I~ .. pre..eml ~'P"r"\i.Ill' Or ""Y~"" .he who co,n. . .10"1: 1' One year the qu .. tion ...... ' What, lor ex"",,,,_, v,,,,M (".ovi_"" IUId R~ r1irur On if "".....,e B.~kr<l to ,,,,r=nt "90 57 fi r ~:-qu .. tion ud I KIt II, and th~ lert swing, and Ihe It'C'pCW hand, $lowly r~ ... , ,,,•• his ,he" , 4nd II,e 'y~. ar~ wilh me , unblinking , .~d is it ....... i'" or tho pcrm . ""~t uprcs.i." of K quiuical Iist.aer, th. l"""ed-o~ I ",,~ thl i. unr"".,.li"!: 01 .mo_ ~'go 32E ><~~rOl ~ JOO:~ of 1M m_n" Of 11K' a n""t on l.UI"", lIIe slUlYn ' 5 in drarr.at.izlng" a qUfstion tbu Wasltiagton Lawyers - and ~hDse elselfbert--had flreviowly dlKussed only in the Int»t tbeoretltal mOlls; What 15 (be )awYfr', resplmslbiUly to >o<iel ~. as oppooed I.. till. r.,.llOIUib~il¥ to IlD individu] d iem ? A-1104 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-4 Filed 08/26/13 Page 31 of 31 From inside the book "-,, stiJ", P"\l,I05 "'1:"'" 'I'I,n "uggong, C1DUO'S" aDOUl ,"" validity C11 th( jud~",.nu tMt ~.ad pot I"" U,S. iOllI> Ind""hiftL. C6/foro ~u lo pay d_r .tl.ntio~ al Ihe While H_ brio!"",-,o-~upp~ in,"; his '1ucsliollSlook OIl" "".'pc' cdg", In N"l>vemb.. 196; 1<>bD..,., docidod 10 ,eplace ROHTt S_ Pog,l58 --- - --- -,.--" r-- - - . -- -_... _...., -..., -- -r"- - SI"ling I'rodu<t:o C"",J>UlY, .. a, Qnt P"'$OlI ...1>0 sought bdp. --- -~ Th< R_ firm had sub, idiary ~~d .. 141«1 compa~ i es in Louin Amo,ita, Englnnd, and C~rm""y, ..d Ihe Ju.lke Dq>ar\mt~t '" antitrust clivi, ion h.td grave q""'ti~ns "bl ul ..,"'~ 01 its over... P,,<,2,6 R.ep.e<ftII .. ti,'e Wrig~1 Patman ( D., T ... ) , e\oaimun 01 (be HQ"", B.:o.nl<ina: ~~d Cucrenty Co ... m itt~, l'alr.lIn " conl,lIi_ t~lly by h"'lIit. to h~nk .,.", arid \ ' ingli'1l h .... ~ lilt le nn "" gninr<t up ..dl ......",_< 1m hi'" In !1>tm.nt w;tll nl'fd ling '1,,",,_ ~ir.g ,;~.. < I'~''''''n Invo< ,.., nr. I ,, ~ ",.,,,_in.. ,·· wi'" ,..mhl;"~ <1~_ A-1105 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 1 of 33 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------------- x The Authors Guild, Inc., Associational Plaintiff, Betty Miles, Joseph Goulden, and Jim Bouton, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, : : : : : Plaintiffs, : : v. : : Google Inc., : : Defendant. : : : ------------------------------------- x Case No. 05 CV 8136-DC EXHIBIT 2 [PART 2 OF 3] TO THE DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. BONI IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT A-1106 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 2 of 33 From inside the book 9 pog ... m;tch ng "jUl .... in th .. book uo .., ,m I\Ul ...... n .ur~ , rout" """', .. WI: o:nmL1U1 ",." .. ""'t In th e Dinrlcl." One Covington and Burling ,..nrw:. ",id (hi: r.nn av<>lcb crim· i,...1 "",,r1 fur Iwu ,.,....u. Tb. form's l;uill-i~ e."""..,. aro ~"d. th,u fo .. crim;n~1 der~nduu can alfotd lhc pcr·bou.r f.., of $50 .. .... ---_. _. -- _ ., --_._ . . " , - -- - . __ ... ,J",,, Lawyer-1Q!.t>y;", is fu.o:of fyr ..... ~ hQt<\...,1 t"';ning -.~- L~ gi.·eo; Ford Wi(DC:5$e$ tbe nighl b<.fore they IUlif,.. Mad,ley puu th~ wiln .... in a chlir in For1l', Shordwn Hotel .uil~ and ..,b hin. tho o.as<.iest '1UestioM oonceiw.ble for houn. Get rid of tt" .. . --. ---... _...- -- - c ' -'--- r - .. . -- ._._ .-.." - . obi lE'!" mcu (Wl the ""ib or ,Iw! fio"nd:>1 <:nrnmfln ily ; "".... if ~ b.>n k~, Ylitlll'U ha. I~ ritht . n..", ••. nrut pmvl!I (hat tt.e premi.5e of Patman 's 'leery i.! wror.g. lhf dlltUlle is done-immedl.arely , 10 tho bank •• ', fgII u d {~ mpeT; lh~ n", { day, i. ""nci~lory A-1107 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 3 of 33 From inside the book [ S, Qd ~ P', " m,le' '' 9 <no d j, i ri , book Pog,K m., "", 'IT lHI"yrrs- ~ 'r ."', '-''''''u ="fl K "P' hr. <lIRCI"" of! tbe public ,,!tn~ ' l:l~d , hm"~r. ""~ M did nor intewd to I ~I tb~ ~nsumefS win a !);ckdoor victory. Rqardless o! Ihf pybllc-p>lcy W~tJ. b~ mailXa!nfd, (b~ tt5tlmD~y 51'1oyld no! bt fe~e.sm . u.s. Dlstnu ]Udgf .I. Cull"" Gan")' agrmi ovrr J~s· . -- " r-' - . _ - ...-r··.. ··..". -_... Ribicotf in J96g, ~thlt M r. ~ader. a 11..-ytr hi!1\'ltlf "'i th 00 lack of ~bIM(y in a 5 tud· ~p figi'll, ...-ould stOOp to conque f.~ 1'\001' Itn Ij~t Nader crl'dlt for d(lID~ good thlfig!, bocaust tlIlngs /lie ., ro~ In tht COYDtf)'. And a sman publklst. lOll. Ht look Lloyd -- _ .. " .• - _ .. , • . , _.- --'J .- r· ---- - '"b- •.•• ..• - £,..,.. r.. ntium j,••lifying ... hat hi. e :i.nt wulS done. f><rsor.s favorably ;n<li~~ to ...... rd )'O~r clJ.nl are nwre comforlab~" if Y"~ Give them w m.thin; re.l hravy ~nd l~al· look;"8: to .t.ond on" Tw,. t91 1 c::ose~ ilhull"3t. the point : A-1108 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 4 of 33 From inside the book I Se orch 11 P"9 " m'tohing JLIlY in Ih 0 boo, F'l,l13 st{lrie:s loout Arnold a~d P"rt •• ...,d Johmaru..., trany. ism. aDd tlit d hard iD its early m(mlm 10 lmfar nlud on A&P's brighl bras.s doorplatf. Tte Justice Dq:lII,lrr.enl wmeud a grand Jury iD ClNtiaDd 10 investlgatr ---,-- , ... ----_ . - , - -_ -,-.~.- ~ . --~--- <Ji • .".\",J ' rQrn llL~ ~- , .- .... .. 0."""," "lI:<nc; \" SJ"~4d Go:rn.an i>r""'~dlooL ." A""",di,,!: ', 0 Uutll , ll>c ami:ru,\ divi."o" I'J, IoO<l lor crh"inal pn><:trdin" l>tlor•• grand ju<y , Corwron, h~nr, JX,,'u dtd Altomey G..,e,~l Biddle to ,""ul" tIM: CI."" vi, a civil C<) lI!'Ienl Tn., L,,, "n~ele. g.an<l jury did not agre.>, ud Ih. f"r.;mM _<MoW &mud Flalow,!h . jWlire Drpartrn.~1 b"')'u dirtaing ;t. ~olll, th81 (It~ majorily ..... ~I td lo ,etum indictlMcu anyw.y, and IVa, hington be h.~ged. Th. gfOnd jury c~uld h~v. don. $0 A-1109 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 5 of 33 From inside the book 9 pageo malchin, O I~III.(III" the [o)f: Au'lt~r~ think< it ruk ""1ISf~" 10 cre<iil-or bla~m for lact thac 'l~"'ity l.brli"l; h .. DI'V~ ' I"'-"-.M C~ng''"'-< _ H .. ""-)'1' h~ is , I"'ply a I~,.yer who frolll lim. to tirr.~ has pR!l!~led I cUtnl', a'gument ~n an i ss~, If "COn$Um.T ~dv(\CaI~~" had \b ~ 00[<1 <&S<, alld II ........... '1 uf Ih~ A"'oriaD "","vI • . C~""",,, I~ ~ P'q.376 lor Ine 011 lllOuStry all<! \lit POW ~ I compaDle; 10 cau tlle.t, !awy...... ; h<'I;au"" tb~y <~Il mal., a ""'n~ .rgun-.c~1 lhal they In fact ~r~ p~blk·illt~, ... t 1~'"Y~'5, th~ dclinilion bcin~.., vo.gu< Il:! it is. "Soon after I ...~m int~ oraaice r~r mvself. I was ~DDroach~ W\W ~tturn.Y" 'p~blic·i~l ..... rsl A-1110 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 6 of 33 From inside the book cl erk ~ [ S BOrC~ pagoc rro:c,i" cI.,k in this boo. -.- -..- .- .-.--........-- r- .,,· .. -..... -...., . --- .. legl~lat ion nm,1 'rgistPf with th~ CI ... k of Ih~ Hog,", of R.,... ..... senlalive! and thf S«~t~ry of lhe ~~at ~ , Hf mu.;1 f,lr q~ar~rly repores Iktall ill!( ,he 1n\(Tfllt '"'1""'''''n\~d "n~ _ h~ amount of mo~.y .pen!. CliffQ .r.d othtr lawyer'! ..void ....~\. ,ing iu " .d - . peal, He .. 10 W,.. hingtQn "'Iy tho n .. t memil1(l. a s..tutday . • nd ..as Iudy ~noug~ 10 ftnd R d~rk on duly at Ih. Coun 01 Appe11s to acctplltis ~I~ . J \lSt as he utldpated, l~e IObao:o companles ~led tbnl ap- P'go 378 .. _- - - . . - - -. . ....-.---- •. -_._--.--..... --- -. . -·-r· ·· ~ tLer",. Elm.~n unMntanris = 5 in them ,\ wb.n h. c~me _h ~ I\- ~' W~5 hingtnn f~incama lion [-""'Y'" lwau~ h~ " f thr Nfl" Oml spirit co Washington in th ~ h~ found 19305 as a cle'k lU bi< old A-1111 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 7 of 33 From inside the book 48 "90' 'Mle,i'9 ,n,i,,,, .. in o too, r;, rog.l58 ----~ --- - ---''--» ~- .. _ . .. - ._. .. - .... - .... -"-r"--' l'loduetS Company, w a~ onr pe1$(1D who sougtu. belp. Tbt Roa:r ftrm h~ d su~ldbry ,~d ",,1lIi('!.1 companlO!'l in La tin Aglerka, F.nglmd, and ~rnlllny . ..d lh. I~'tke Oqmrlm<~I's anlil nllil Ilivi,iuD had !(fa"" q=livTIS ai»ul ..,"'" uf iu uver ....,. SI~rllng P>g.3.1 r..lrkted OJ(reo<m.~u W~I'~ a'l:uably aucll"" r lO tho: juint u"de.(akil'K' ! ...;n not ",.t.ad lhat a """'D"bI~ ",an , fJ~'1;';" 1,,,/, l"j I<t: Iud ~ ..~,e 'w~,dir;al ~",o~d. !o .nlltru.t Ihn llu,"~, ~Q~ld lIOt ha,'e decided dill", ." tly ... -- ~ -_ ._.- .. _. --_.-- - - -.- llum."·....."<IlI!Ik>n ~n oo".o",.,.i..." b r,,,,,, " Th. F"",,"..tiOll ot M ...clatory Food Sland.o.r<b,· Fm C4",..lk LA,. Qw.,IN"r" Dc· ..-mbor 1 ~47 ; on Fed ... l afttilrut ><Ii.,.;ti.., rron p~ of Ib, Anlilnat La.. S,lttl103iUWI ot the A.tit""t La .. Sect; .... N".. ' "crt Dr., A-1112 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 8 of 33 From inside the book al sten [ 3earcl- 26 P'Q3S m't:hinQ " liSle", i1 ttl s to)f: P,,<, 175 K. ___ . . .. . " •• ~_, , _, K __ / ;. . . _ _ " ."."/;'. ' _K ~ _ _ '" en that (lid (ht.t~ut, " If you dQa 't li k. the taw, ehong. it" (Aus~e'n don); .nd (d l t he mOl! potent si rl!l~ voic. in C",·ingtoD and Burli"8, th. chi.1 jll'llli.. " I W..h.ins~ on 'J Io'l!'''' thr o~gh .~ Pog e t76 r<l iTCInCDL A.stt ... doesn't tlIink mu(h more 01 the ' egulalery ogeDcies than doo:s hi. a.cl!-adv . .... 'Y N3dcr, b~ ~ for '«y di ff.,...n! . 01· sons. LiOi m Ie him Ie. o... erll ~.OU'"' ,.~d rud his opt«h •• ard b.. and trod" iournal article. . ~nd tb~ lru' lrat ion ~nd outra~ .... iI, d.termi .... Ih !>.i<e. II the '1""lily wu d .. rly """,ked, tho housewife could igno.e t~e b.and Mm.ef a. d buy 00 the blsi. of '1", lily. A.u'Urn ",IIi"" oPfJO'il;"" ",len Tugw,;l'~ 1"",.'.... 1 "'e~1 h!:. 1M.. r~.~ At ~ ~ .. m_in~ fif.ho I\:"'inn..l r , ............""';.. A-1113 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 9 of 33 From inside the book ' ci a r<_ 01 ffotd' [ S ,ard P'"J.3 Cod, I i~ g tho~gbt, I .m doing ClAr k O ilfo.d • f.,'Or by mt<~ him. I IOU l},i. I. ucU ., "';1., 0 "(:Jil/," " .....~ <~ _Il V~M" Inti <1,.." /41.,. '" "''', ~ Joe , okl, cou~t 01 Clack C5f!Qrc1':1 fin! <l>J In cou,t In St. I..<lui. , Mi>.M "" , In 1929, u d the faa I~.I h~ ""<I e"&ded me by e.3<:11), forty ye.t •• doe. not dil tu,b m. at all. ! am too bus,. listening to tb. Go<.p"l ,.. apo k"" by Cla, l Cliff()ro . and ,",,,bbling furi~lUll' .. l"~,"" . . . . . I e... ,~< ......, .., . I~"', """ ......... 00" ... ~ • ,." ~I u bilcll ""d 1M ..,h.k {n"inw . DNl ~'14 ~J il. AII<I ~u;1 J.~', TIIhat M', riu ...... i" !1i4",j &",h ~yinr lj~ ",... MY u';l}, iii. [,.,uk., M'lf loU. ah~MI Ai. 'Irk~cl CI,,,II: eli,.,.,/, aM his 'ton.,., Cl.ull: CliD~,rJ: and ""'" "'~< .. 1M ,d·.nd·,d darl,d hi_ A-1114 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 10 of 33 From inside the book commne e 1£ P'"1" [ Sea ch mtc~i1~ co mnllnee in th s boo, a "'CIllO"'" OJ we oomll1"'.., <0'" "' •. -- I ~. rc .. r~ """It: ~lIn. ~", .....d (lit: Ul""lry-l """ t.l,;nk or ..,e ill CIe,..lucl, .00 in !>all.. ~ Rd un the C""-'It, ~nl rigbl hen: in W... ,lou..;lOll, fo. ll,a! maller-thaL are di<tlltorilJ, ... jth 0'"' man in <;\>u ..,J<\< 0;001",1. NOL "'tt1 \&"ye, like. 10 ~ iu,-ol>"CftOLMI .... a corucrvati'-e local b.:<r tculd destroy the publk.i " te,esll.o,,·ye .. thr""Sh a w~, 0\ aUr; tloa. Any uU·po~(;n, . hould 5!art at the tcp, wMch is to $IJ', ... iLhin the A"'e.i.... n B:>r Au<H;iati~11 itull. Th. ABA;' .. Colri- u.. Suv-r l..I~N1 is Ir"'" Mariogs bot ..... lbe H~ CDfmlIUte, blNtsi<m .J 1M; S.,II1" tiel , F. bru&'y-M~ f 19 'it~ • ...., r-<p<>r l 01 .... ...,. c:ommi U«:, 7"- Lr....d S.de, Seol* o.a.nbe, Jt , 1970;."d f~ opnL rtgislno:.;... nat_If fi:ed,.,111 the In ternal Setunt, Divi$i"" of lbe Departmmt ~I I"'tn. 1"br dab nn Awk~I~urt 1'>.,.... , A-1115 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 11 of 33 From inside the book corccron [ Seorch 36 pog' " m:;tc r;ng C'>K>lall ir th .. bock P'go 15~ name, """ (ln~ COrco.an tool, A~atller. pe!ha~ ~,""D mo;>'( irn· IJIJrlnl , ...., ~ "".<lul ..,.<.Iir.,l! (II !he 1-'.<1"...1 ~w~"'''' .. ,! .. ill, me" bra1 booth 10 FDR .rtd !~C I"',hiu".. Toonmy Corco,.n ad'O<;.;ot..:! within \h~ Adru; n;s(wion, U.s . . \'nJ' ( ~"'" U.s. "'_. k IV..'" 11~. ~ .. \ l~ • _ _ w~. . . - - i .~ • • l_ l ~I (""~_ Coreo.an b~t OIl'" hi .. anY"'~Y. Whal Ccr«>",n did n::>\ kno .. ...a, Lh:u. lor" time lUiH had i ... Ituc:LM hi. teC • .ury not t~ mak~ any app<:>intmen!s for Cor<:<oru or put IhfOUgh hi, I'M'" coU•. " l lOld hrr that I "';d~'l "',",,11.0 _ him . ~_ 11~1t M _ .................... ;M " " ...VIo ~f ,I." ..........! ;~ .... m. ,,{ ,"-00 ~._ A-1116 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 12 of 33 From inside the book OJtp J ra1e 71 P'9" mtd-; n) ~.,~.,ote int1i, )(0< Pogc70 offic •• Oiil'ord did IlO'l Jl".uaJl"l~ in th~ 1968 """'I"'ign------tl. tho<:gh his law pa'lno., (0""." C!.\ ofI':ci31 Tho",.. 0 , Fir,noy, h.,l~d dirtd ~~nA!OI Eu~~ Md' .Artny'. Pr"" i~n ! lo l bid_ And as (If mid,19)1 Oiford ... a,\ tn~ thkf rorfig~ policy advistr to 50,"""111 Edam",i lIIlbk;". wl~1 I", "",Iv .Jt,;iJaJ ..."" lhe :"",,1 Pag,347 hard o re of hi~ $iD(eri ty. CUII~T hJS more faith Ihan most or liS In Ihe public . pirit of (l}rpur~tr muxub. H ~ lhiob ll~ can uju~" lhe.., P""'plc, .cd 1"'1 lnmo on th~ blck, aoo latd thcm to good citi .. n;:hip ti .•., building ""r" (a,~ th.l don'l .",it dt<ldly gynk). " and who fora:d Am . fica's lorgest indu.s~riGI ~ •• licn to spe~d ",Ofe than $-IOO,COO in lO pro,,), fight with its -.. ilia . ... bolders-which Is to say, itl o... ~,,_ Phil .\{OOf~, co'f"l,ate guerrilla, pallen tly man eu~rint General )101(1u to,,"ud a con- A-1117 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 13 of 33 From inside the book Se Qrch - _.- _ .----- -------Ribicoff in l~60, "Ih~t ~!r. ~ader, a I• ...,..r him .. U with no lad:: o! ahilil y in ~ . 1~nd _~1' fight , "nuld Sl onp 10 conqu...." No_ Itt's give NOMe c,..dil t.... <kilns good Ihlng., 0..::. " ... thl~,. au wro~.g in the country_ And a smart publicht. too. li e took Lloyd --- - -r- ' -- -- - -,-r -----'--,, ' -_._. P,9" 333 "'''''lUI"'''''' :.o:m" ,.".na, suns w'llen g~ " " m e u _ ~. a miln.,aDtO clear title to the "omp,my nd tbtn complue Ih~ p~bti~ !3Ie. Lloyd C~tlo:t on thf Suplfme Cou rt, replacing Imtk~ TmD CI~,k ; LI<>ytl Cull. , in the Corn "me., Drpanrnmt a, deputy to hi. ok! lri~~d Sc<:,~:..ry John Conn~t earlv in l ~ ~ Ioh~ Ad· i. h~/.rc it i. imrod~<etl, and tlldl ;$ ..1... \ h. t.lid. T I,,, uim;".l ... nc:lions ... <ren't in the Adn,in;'jralion's bill br:caux Cut l. , got thtm out .1 lhe: dra fti",; ~tage. ,\ , I ..... ... ying, )"<lU luI~t 10 li,teb b.t......... t1t~ ~"es "'~D Lloyd Cudor is t.l~ing , b<-co.U!.e he A-1118 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 14 of 33 From inside the book [ ~ c arcr nad cr 1'1'. 11 , .. "'Old Ralph Xadtr , Thi. Mall Na..le" ~1~1j(..d in a Nad .. 's R4idt .. otll<ly ollhe r"m. Tbi. Man Nad... """led IQ in\coYiow .~t'y po.r1.er and ""cry l\MOciate in (he ~nn, lind on the record. , , ~ssi<t3nt to Dr. MillO" Ei::o:nho...... th e cll~irrn~~. ~y5, "CUlIe< ... u Kruf>"Io~, ~bou t h , 100; t.. kept away (rom TV .1.... g~hto"") Sighhhhh. Th~n K~d.r. Wht c,,~ be dm~ abo". him 1 A law_ A-1119 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 15 of 33 From inside the book n«or 4~ [ Searcl1 P"'-l" ""lei ir y '. ' ,UII i" Iii> wuk {then Vic:e Fre.id..,t] through havi"fi Eddie Ricl<e~\wIcke, [pr~idt'llt of £,uttm Airlines] coDtact [AIIGtney Gen· eral] Bill Roger. In lb. !Justk_] Departnlt"t. r agrH'd tho.( N'uon wo$ :he tigbt man, but tho.gbt ... _,_~. ~ .~ __ • _____________ '-, ____,, ___ __ _ ~ ~ U _'- aling ddeal i. tile 1962 Catilomia gubernatorial rlection. NilOn wanted. place to T~ui1d hi~ lite ADd to m.o.ke money .. hUe doing $0. Hc fQU~d '(line p«ullarly ~ppealirc qualit ies in N~ w York; 10 Roben J. OollOvan of tile £01 AlI(tltJ TitrrtJ be " Iormer Vice t'r~dftlt enablfd NI:wn 10 obta:n briefings lro", old Stale DepnllneDI frif nd! bdore hi! lorti, n t ravels, He wa! "'PfCially Inttr ~ l~d 10 Tai wan, W~O!It lo~g liD1~ rull!", Chlan: K11-Shek, ,a~e Mudle ROJSe tEen! Pl:p:!ICob an U c1U5"-e fran- A-1120 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 16 of 33 From inside thE book '"","" L~"IIt1" [ S""'Lh .. rug CUI from und.... , hh ~ ~ banks1 ...as PJUlng I~ Ih~ company," doai"""D Sluurl s.w. ..~ "" 1I1~y 19 1,,1tI s..;,r( acy uf .ooJ the T, .."ury David M. Kc:nnedy of the tigbtc:nl~1I bind O~ bb cornp"ny ~ that the ';~"'nt.~ i .. u~ h~d failt<!; th.tt If P~n C~~_ Bo~nl r'l e 24E b.nk Io.an. Bo,ud mtetin( Wile:; $hQw Patman', antago~IHlI and the cli.~w,"' rcdpr<>UI1 billcrn""" , Dim;\ur Stab,,,,, .., fe . ii" 'tarlC:" , '1oot<3 PBtmon all , ayin5 hc: "'.... ""'cry thot Ad1ninislfG t;o~ bilt<! 1<1 go thro~gh [with lb. g~ ..;tnl~J b«::>u~ no_.~. -' , ~ .~ _ . . ." ~ ... ~, ,. , . D ... ' ,, _ _ . ~ • • • D.o • • r .... _. I-'.,ehl !lanking and (;urren~y C~mmittee is sha.t)'. H e hQld. Ibe emirmn ... lolp by ,·inuc of the lIe,,;onty .y.tom , but D~mo<:r&1> b •• e mlai with R"!,ubiico ns 10 ov.. ri~. hi... In Ik paSI. In tht in_ sUlno. ~f p...,~ Cent,al, th~ GOP m...,,\>e,s told Patman , "One semi of oartisao oolitia. ami we'lll'U! vou." A-1121 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 17 of 33 From inside the book s er",n [ SE 1YCh 50 P"'-l " mlc! i ,'-l ~e rr d ' " ' i, II,;'; "u lk ",,-e h". rna'" COntact .. i,h ~ ?"",.rI~II . .. form in 1M s.""tor" h,me 1I~te" K.o.raoi k, .. ~ dld Ml naone the S~ulOr in the ",.mo, conl in"",, , Jtrry S. Cohm, longtime ~h,d rounsel and Sl31f di~to, of tbe Sc'nalt Anlilnm and Mcoo~ly !ubcclmmitlee and lOW in prl\'ll e pc'BCtlcr, agrers ; I~drcl, be loki me, "The ~rel te Clark hi> abili(y 1" c,,,,vir~. Senal.. r that 'll', to Cliffu"J'~ ' U«ei> i~ ""or :ul~an""'~ '0 do ;, th;~ .. ov'_ .. hkh i. '0 '""V_ Clif!ord', PagE 317 I«ter and .en.. oue a s.. ..... or .. b~ .. ill have i. twd on oflkiiL .ta liQ nery and mailed under .b. Se a. to,'. sign.tu,~. So""t"r RUl$ell I~~t ly obligo< hi", ; so did Se nl'or E.'ere\( M. 1J;,1l",~ ~ fll'~ hi< d.alh. Say. rh ~ IRS m.~~. " 11 rh~ SInal'" i, "- Lma ' trs,.h'.'''''"'. .... No ... iII <'Iv'n Jo.b ~ . '\'".... ,..;.~ • ,., . ~ . ,,, "'" A-1122 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 18 of 33 From inside the book [ Search n" manage<' (0 " ", u:c ml.< (0 ~-" cu, TOmUf<CQ ,0 nclO ."er "It'll Dever <<)me <>ut .. I ', ~., otalut<." C~mmo nto f iold, "lie', ri~III~;I'1 eng"wed on . ton •. '· 110.. did you do it? I ..1<0<1 D~ncaD. How <tid you manage to p<T'uood. Mill. 10 T«:orr.mit "'e bill .nd i ... ~T\ y~.r 'mo~~nt l def~l . From inside the book ln a [ Se a rch 2. pales ",tch ng ni,1 in tri s boo, permitted lilt AMA and Iht Big FQur IQ avoid publi( [rinl. Nad.rconsidored Ini, b3d I.... two r~:uon,. Alter years 01 jQulting with ((>rpor~liora, Nad~r realitN t~eir dr .... d of odo;tnc pubHeit)'~tMal Ihe mosl dr""liv< wny 01 h.lt - A-1123 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 19 of 33 From inside the book tr .. 8 2 poe", [ rmlC1i1~ 1I1~l s - ~3 ar:h in this book - --._.-.- · T ··· .. ... -., ~ ~ biu"f ,""let"",,1 "'nee the SJ.]"", witdi trials : ---- - --perj..y. tor Senll~ mmmittee that he "lPiI.5 a "f~lIo"tt of tht line" ar.d a "prttnOl.fr of C~I~munln lm ~rali!l." Luther Yeung-dabl , iL former R.qlUbllcan (;00,·.,00' of dtnying to l Com~wnl!t J~dge From inside the book 5 p.~es matc htl1 !lefen!l~1l1 in th ' boo { ac' ...... \he result of mcnt.o.l d;s.ase, lilt defEndant c<>ut~ I>e acquitted on t~~ J;roand of ;nlll.n;ty. For tho eq..aU obKun y C].. enl;~ Cid,""n, th. Florida u'er·d.,..."",n , ForbU tDQk a Suo pr~me C<l""( ~gnm~nt and .. OD th. Q X e>toblis,ir.,:: tJ-./It de· f.nwmt.>. """" ;n..li~mt t.JtJe>. wu>l !.av~ <:our.... ] &1 .11 01 A '\a.I!" A-1124 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 20 of 33 From inside the book [ 3,adl 6C P"'1" m'tchinq wash inqton in this book Pag,5 ........ "c .~ ... ~"""' "'" .. ,,.U>",, m.... uo< " ........ vo ''''''~R wagor.•. Big , tu.'f," Thit fn)m a .pe::ialist i~ trar"ro.tati~p law, • mon .. flo " .... involved in Iwo laftdmuit u il merg •• cues . but whn .. <ampl"~1y uft k"""", nutd"" Ih " light ti ,d. nl f~lln .. pl"llditiCIMn in t... ~kl. From n side the book drst lct 27 ,aJos m'tc htlj dlslllCl " this boo, altorney during J olmSCln's ,eign 1.5 SeDate majorit~ leader. Vice Pre3 ldellI. and Presl dellI. ]ohllllOD mot FDrtu .. non h. ,0&:1 a (,o Hern. C"'PK< W rLl." t ,ot "liter publi( po_' f~r his Ttxa. di!!rid•• nd for ..... ... di· ...... t,,' "J ,I... n......... ""'n ' " J .h. Tn'",. ... " .• rl;vi.<j~R " I oiorl,k A-1125 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 21 of 33 From inside the book l S m ch J ric hE7 p"gOG mct ch nl,i ~ht in Ih 0 bo ol, ~ , [ . 12' righl tu 10:-...-• ••• wh~t the ~IJ~II>C of ..1Ucll he had hem WJl· vktnl ...... " ""!>Old, Fortu and r'orteT dULled tJt;, cloud th rough the courU xvm JUrs before the ~ovcmmml blu~ed ~nd g-.'·e the m.n !heir bad p"y. And (ho,'m L.atl.imo,~, ,j,. ~,"~_r • • ~., ~ n.;~ h . ;I...t rn' n ...."rl no< t h. mn.' ro, From riqhts insid~ the book [ 3earcr Iloh lake tht Firth Amendment more than one ~undn:d Ii.,.. Ixf~ re tho t ( ",dru oommillee. The Bill GI Righu , tbi. s.... run says. b Q vory ~n~i~ V"""aftl", a~d it prollOCU corporation. and iBdirid""l. alih , ;1nd on<:~ you n~tt waiving it •__ __ __ . __ _ _____ •_ ,. ___ _,. , ___ " ".... _ _.• L>'_ ,-,_ _ __ ~ A-1126 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 22 of 33 From inside the book [ "",arch ql ''''J'' rmtch"J rJi~llt in thi_ henk o for ny ca$e in whidlliminl: is an important baar." l',ot e"...eT)' c<lS< '~ulls ;~ • mult.ib~lio~-dolbu savin, fc~ " die~t, ~uc~ as '\like Dm1(M gabtd for the shale oil indll.'ltry . BUI Caplin says the sallie prindplc:s "1'1'1 in H"Y I"", ...-oc...,..j,,.;, Knuw It,~ f>W)' From inside the book 82 pageo mct ch n g c ~ < n'" in Ih 0 book P.g.6 ,= .....1 ~, rtgulation, on" ",hiclI stiR.., competition in the ""'1M of atl ..... "_~'. . . A ..... ' . "ot~ 'ly" v.", " ' ''' """ UAfV"'I;" ~~. "". "'" mnrket . fo..... ly • merr,ber of tbe Federal Comm~D;' •• lien. Commi",ion. now a n ~!10""'Y ill Wu .tingIon, 0 ..,.. ' LH looevi~g ••• A-1127 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 23 of 33 From inside the book 12 P'O" mtchin, 0"'0' in th S 000, "The """..., k1wy . .. "",uld ncv. , con';Ocr taking the """'c Ipproach ' 0 ,flo COUrt> o ~d o.~ .....1 th o di ... , ... 10 ~~w '0 enter 8 pl . ..... d (h ... ",nd hi m 011 (0 the <ollrlhD ~.., (0 ;0110,. in$lru< lion. ," Abb,d wro:e in ,. 1970 bw .evWow •• tido. '·\ ' 01 the From inside the book [ S.ad 0 0<",. 1 t lar.l:rove w,att ,. anotlIer nc""", In I\ "~ ..,.t '''''-', ··tM , ...... , {US PS ) " ould J"""''''Uy I..." a good d""l (u .... ~ aboul ,b. <~u, ....l Ih. uod~ "rWri( .." scl:<,o<I, ahm~~h lhr ",d.,,,';I,,... lhem..,I,,,,, engul.'l,d S<Kh ruum"...1 a~d pay (!ric 1=." Ni~'" rno~ths IiIleJ. in lollY In ). US PS p<rmiu~ Ih~ Itadia~ A-1128 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 24 of 33 From inside the book • (Wl1mtl'. Cutler and I'kkerln~ IKI1f 5erves as the Wasl1II~loD o!tlte of Cravath, Smilie and Moore; the 1"'0 1Inn.s even share I h ~ same add[5S n d pllone numbu In the W&!'hiogan~ ~ lOl>r~. Ion telephone dirI)tIOI)".) From inside the book ",, "a :e 59 paJes m.tch ng . eo",e ir t~is took Pale 27E SOn ( Il ., VI.) , then chairman 1)1 tllt Senatt Hanking aDd Co"'.miU.." which had j.....udict;o n 0"". the bU1. F~. !:lItty's 5IIkc. Carey decided to make one lut rou lld of CommltlOX membe,s, p',tiulu iy I),.. &nat<>r who 01'1"'...:<1 the ,,,",,,,an"" C~ ,uncy ___ ., __ _, .L_L'" A-1129 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 25 of 33 From inside the book [ 50 P"'-l" mlc! i r'-l j."ic. S e~rc!1 " iI,i, ow, IIItnt In 19.10 lnd Il>rmm a law pannersh:p. An farly <Jlem ..... R tVI't.tj~. I" 19S~ lbe r,,". ,j,n...t I" u '''I';lIat~ ooe pro,-ld..! • ~at r... u( $9;,000. wh k b "'... reo ported to tbe J""dco Department ~nde, the I'orcig" Af;<nu R~· i'I'~I ;"" '\<t; tb. atho•. u~TCpo.tcd . croll..! for B bcDUJ of ~I Pt. the o..,.'"iwa "I: ''''~lenl.5 ; From inside the book Soarc, 5, "9'" ""toOi'9 ., o •• Y in or;, to)~: Pog,62 ror ID1 nm r.g .... ,.,. aaorr..,y •. ur at 1..0"11"''''' mr "'" I'rO\~""'g er.ough money t\l hi." tMm. Or at yourself for DIlt beir,g wilting \0 pay tllt W e! to provid ~ lh~ mo~ey 10 hi." tb~ better aI · lor.')"5. And.lO forth. Wh.n pul>lic·lmu~ law broune la'llllon3b1~ i~ Wa>ilir.gton A-1130 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 26 of 33 From nside the book 'CO''; 'gtor a nd bJrling' 8~ [ Soc.ch F'l'O m,tc ri ng "covington , ,,,1 bnrling'" thi, boo, P'go C1 i-'age tb ''6''' ' .'~ g", .. .. ,_ , ~w~.u ~~ _ ~"" a ,_,,_, . _ " "'~,,~ . tht FTC ; HeU, ,h~w me unybody i~ W3,bi~Jl'>n wh~ know. mo •• abrxIt tho FTC lhan To"''''y )" m ,.,.. and I'll civ. )'<'U t .... keys to th~ offico. 0. lhe CAll. R...... "'ber. Howard W.stWO<>d c. ,,1ttd th~ CAl!" Covi~gton ~ftd Burling d """ oot fro ..... at A-1131 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 27 of 33 From inside the book J5 P'~es rra,ch " ~ "nllldq" rose""" this boo , P'ge221 '" P'ge 239 ---" ~ - rolyin, up"~ • Madge R.. se legal .. pillbn ' to fight a ror""" Mu dge R.,... p"rtr"~. [N i. nnj" MUdtf RoJ.e and IU predtceJ$O ' ~,nu hne mllnlalnrd ctI'lcrs In W:l.'lbiIrgl~n sin« t.b~ earl)" 19 ~Q5, according 1(1 Randfjlp1l A-1132 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 28 of 33 From inside th e book "I pa~es ma,ch " ~ 1 '' in Ih s bJek 0'' p"Y" 112 .va, a~ ~"t"" ' ''' l~ ' ~ ~,~ .. ~ ,~ .~ .... " ... ~~" ,~~, Ul th ~ ptrfOrTnaMf!.promiw glp nl tb mti~, ~·Grtu ·S l CUpl.antt of a !20.ooo I(e f rom tile loulKlali!ll of ~nnder Lollis W~lbou " a\ no panicul.ar sarp:ise ; IDd<'rll, ~~ somt it q,!tomiud I'"OrtaS.. WillW. P'go 127 u.. lou~J:O<.U ul 1.1J" l~,. , ~ul &t 1,10. ~uu., ~ ul ~r""ri- - Poge 128 ,. . . _ " r _.- 10m,," Liag nd by- 1962 had ' !arltd Li~g·T."'.eo VO~~~.I on a diu)'i~G lhTO~gh the Annci.1 ,",o.1d. Both P,,"~ IInrl l.i.C .re iri"nd. 01 Lyndon johnJOl1, Ibr"~gh .. hnrn Ihoy carne to klllJw and Irld Abe fortas. h 1\l~1 ~·01U.! belped Post tg"" ~."..td "I'll A-1133 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 29 of 33 From inside the book [ S c,,",ch a dmini,tr ~l oo 1.l>I<mg a I"'-"'KIl '" <at "'.",DCIlY "''''"m'''''~UOIi \ ~~"''''g, "" Clilord did tIIrly. Ihal Kennedy did w) bul who iBtend"ll to do a put d...1 "I bllSio_ Ihe J:~nnt<!y Adonlnlot ration. C lillord \t1luld h,~d1~ the lrtmition from EiJ.mho"er 10 KtnlIedy. Itt ..~t \0 .. or!< in m rly fal l drafti~ a docu"""" dfU.il- wi'. • • • .... ~u"n'5 1iaisoD with tbe lame--duc:k ] ohn5<lB Admi~im3tion , ",kll. John Sea" ..., t~ J~i.1 ~ .. ;uaT)' to Spif'O T, A8n~ .. : both took middl'oftO""lon J>D'I itio • • ill til!. Admin~ ... t;o~. And C<lr,x<mte WiUbington-lb~ lobbyists and trade associations and ~' go 337 CUI"'", in rebulla!, dmi", lhal criminal pen.hits .. ne ell •• a priority it...., 10, th~ ind_ry, .lth~USh it "did ucl does" opp<lSl! them, f'urlhtf, he nQ\e! . criminal !O\nclions "Crt n~\' er in the auto Sillety bilL ndthtr ., the original ,JohnlQn Administlal.ioD - , ,,1.,,k"',., "' .. ITI ,J.., vp",.m, ,.,..,,,ood f""m .ho- R"" ... ~nrl A-1134 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 30 of 33 From inside the book [ S ,ad Pag, 33 placed upon ,b. Ir~o", or U"'~"idi.ed <'I.ne.. ,0 ~y ""or uy reul~ o. into any l ~ .. itory. F~ rt h •• , eo"'ri", tho wh. busir.... ''''I''i •...:I nomiul <:.pIal ,m~n" TI... ~irwll" ""ro I,.". an,1 ..... vig3lion~1 .nd nl~.,.. 0r"... tin ..... 1 fnd liU .. .. '''~ n ain· tai ntd or I~bsidized ~y 11-... I'llvermMnL :\ fttd~l inv . irlb. di d i"'·.... ccor.omK co:ucq<Kr.ceo 01 tne .",atJOn plan la"",),<-, WeslWOOCl .. rele lor the IITA . 1'.......... , 0. c.. .... ral J omts .\ . Fa.loy noled lh.t the goveTlUnenl hod "f"'nt '·hundreds or millioru 01 doIl. ~ io the bllilw..g 01 airports, ; ... tsll~l; o o or bt3cun ligblS, etc., and d;recl . uhoidi os paid I. ' he co.tract.rs. N.w that the nnnci.l mg •.\> , rom " ... lOr ~. ".em I"" amnr la~td 100.5 Dllt! 13n~lng rlglID 11 Ken • • dy ' nI.<rn,lt'on.~' Airport in N~ York . Cwi..:tun ~. d nur ~n~ defended it, flf.' bdlrT .. mac", d,e ~ge," N~ 00 Y",k Si al. Cummis>i"" u" Hun"" Rij;lll., lbe" ~l V.iled Slal<~ DL;t,i<:1 Court . The 'q>TC>Ol\ll.tioo d~ttd tbe A-1135 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 31 of 33 From inside the book DC P'''''' mtchin, '1ll.,i<M il1 t1i, boc« MuICU sea ....,.a 0' In" , .... R n,,= m.,.r LIn.. • ne " HI"" ', St~\e~ rvemm .. t submitted a rlnlt traty-lI",y,," 1..:o,lin'. ""~di"""k , ~lIy--to a Unit.d N.Ii~ns C<III\miltM l~ ,>.u· !l"' l 19'0, On ano:he, f"",t . U chaiT:n:ln of :. 'I~d .l .""""iean Bar .......cl.t;on .ubcommiu... l;oylin i~ m""iI;,;n~ h,u ~"ppnrt pt'IIUI:R( looon ... "" ne gu bill WI(t ..as enough to shatler a~y s.bcomcious CUfiord mIght h,,~e ~nl. ru lnro 3bout hulkllng • la .. Trl''''''', ""m •. 50 did a nuil,~r .".,Iy ~""". Ihi> .... '" urr bd.all 01 Ho",.,d H"I:Ir",,', 11\..... A,clr-rinl Pan ."Lrle:ican. t""u~ht~ p,,,,,lkr o~ , . _ - - -r - '-"-h _. - '-" - - _ •••• •• _ ......... __ • • - Ammcan Werld ." lrway' !JoIid hi'" 3 ' ftlbrr O $.10.(00 a year • f • ltl>o~gh be D~vef ~~a'ed ~ n 115 behalf In a Jg nnal [>roc~~g a l lhe Ci.i l Mr~DuUlb IIo; ,.1 ,: SI<pIOl' K l~h"""n. a conVl:n" nd limal 'Ill. thal does cuu ... ,ti~,.aL aviat io" "'0, 10;. Je<;~i~ed [ees A-1136 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 Filed 08/26/13 Page 32 of 33 From inside the book I Search 2, p'g" mlching ",g •• d in -ri s to,f: P'"-l,1[6 By milHl a:l:h Cliff(li'd t.ad conclude:! the Ullited 5131<5 should ni,t windin~ down the \Oa r and let aUI of "i etn,lm, He l'i~tc:, as ~e wrOte Iller, "L.'llt 1M Unl!td StS!" ll.ad entered Vietnam ..1th ~ IImiled aim-to ple vt~1 iu 5\1bjQglItkm by (he nurlb 3 ~d 'D """bl. ,ru, ["",,,Ie nl' Sou[h Vi""",,[. II> c~t.nlliD~ [itbl \Q Io~m . ,,.hal tho: "S"e"",, o£ ..hich he had been eonmttd was." .... nold . F(>,taJ Ind Portc:r r.hQOd u.;. dood through (be eo~'I. £or ~ yean bclon: tJ-.e go~.mDle~t blo. hed "nd gave the ""'ft thei, back p.o.y. And O .. en utlimore, ,,,," .~~_l.- ~. . ~.t ftn S'''''I' ...... .. ,,'l; ("I,;n . " ..." ~";I...t ->Vv · ;n'n , ....... , .... ~~ .... ,.,., ,~_ ~'''6 ........ " "' ~ " . ' ..... - Ii . .. , ug-ued lIlal C~rnpben should h ave 10 inform onlomen lhoy had bee~ ~i.od. The FTC reioc it d SO UP'J ....wl "r~ . m~M by ... 4_1 vOle bllt said .~ch OM miRht t... opproprial~ in """" ,;tu3Iion ._ SOUP triM .gain .. VMr 1"1 .... orith I'ir~slo"" A-1137 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-5 From in~ide Filed 08/26/13 Page 33 of 33 the book ""arch 83 "[10' ""tchin, . ..... 4 ., thi, boo, L"' ... a<kKl "'" II U w",~ ' 1 , .... Iltll I lo>l<'<l my momny ..lon asked l~ e witness if It. ezplaining tilt corporations hne l rq:ht to legv rl'pfl'Sl'Dtation," a .'leIIlo, ~nD~T saY'. ' TRI alwlYS geltl~ quedons like , ' Will 1 "" ~t 10 '~p'_nl oorpnra\la1l51 Or ~nyaM rbe .. bu w ;n.. KloJ"I: " OIl. yt>lr the q~ ... ti~~ ......., ' Wl:IIl , (0' e.... n'P~e, "",uld CoVinol"'" and B.,li.,. if wu " -ere a.1r.ed to ."",=t w Pog .167 "Whl1 lt.adn ·ll>e ... , d / U a <kM lIe n ... lt . "1 den'l know," COl"Co' 3n s.o.id " W~ll ," rontinuro ~~~ ""t, "ho v~ 1"'u (oIlnw.-<l Ibi. Plli<y 01 g<ling III IIIfo C.n..,,-m.~'i<ln''', .L' Y"" did in lit .. r~, in . 11 0/ lb. caM:s that 'iOU have tritd be!o,." the ~·ede nl Po ...er Ccmmission? A-1138 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 1 of 34 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------------- x The Authors Guild, Inc., Associational Plaintiff, Betty Miles, Joseph Goulden, and Jim Bouton, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, : : : : : Plaintiffs, : : v. : : Google Inc., : : Defendant. : : : ------------------------------------- x Case No. 05 CV 8136-DC EXHIBIT 2 [PART 3 OF 3] TO THE DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. BONI IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT A-1139 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 2 of 34 From incide the book [ S. ,,,-ch a lto ..,.y Y'" .. ~" didn't ~I hi!; in u.. . ~ to ca<n, and i.n't m.n ... oagh 10 tA k~ ~ lick ing ... ithout .. ~in;n~, the .... y ~ gll()t1 l a"'Y~r I. <uJlllCYd m . J\' n und ..",,,,d ing wh.1! ~r ot l h~ ad,Oft"· sary system, ", hieh ts my God after all "hat La ... i~ ~bout, Arntri:. '/I ~n .' I"Jro It ;, n;"""",;ntln ... ~ut' dnDI.~ds, ""coyntorod ~fdy, ~im:l & rAl t1~, ,..-mlp s"ruunr AhN.hrun Ir.le\'wllftJ. Th. au tg iadlllllry, mntnwi,n., I",d mOl" !IOriUY5 pf~loIrn>-~b~ publ ic lurar <lY~r .tirr":! by Nade,'. c>;pO .... Ck~(T.1 M/lt"".•tupidly. a priyate Mt«:tiv. to in'o'CStigat< N"ader'~ p,;vote lik Three of t.~ log, altoney • ..,o,king on tk case r«o"" n>ended (hal tho Ja" lce D"p"rtment bring bo>tb civil ond ~ri ml· nal a~til"'~l ac l;OIU, and thal the auto m.n~laetu~n 8M ttot AM A be indiclro for • Sherman A~t "''''"piracy in ,,,,(ruint o f A-1140 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 3 of 34 From inside the book _ . _ ; __ _ _ , w_w. _ _ _ . ______ ... ww_; y_ ... , _ •• __ _ p"'p"<Mul",y .tudlf(! O auto "umper•. n The a.croll}·m5 are no aa:idenl. for tluw l rum lM only law C<I~r;e In lbe: 1l.llpQ w ht!<~ wliling press rderucs is part of the syllabus_ Banzl:u l coll5ider:l the general publk; lhe stud. Ill!' ~" ... u u <ry wUY'" IIV .v "' .... '"6 ..... '~ ...... ,," .....) , ..... ~" •. ,~ ~ d!r:fl, In m.k~ il hUM for nl~ . <)<" Innk Inr a ' hr.sl-<ip3.I' cntJrt . ",~erf they co~ ld nly upon I frit OOly ju~gt : · BIDW! Ntld . Tht court .. hert lhe IiI"1!I appral Is 5r.d ....... :J1ClI J~ riWklioll 0'·", aU lUlU,,, pooceedings i<l r.b~ <a5t. hClKC: tinling to. inlp"rl.a!lt. ul P'g' %6 ag •...,.. And he discarded convftllioD31 law ""'ching mew ...., ..he'f stud .... ts 'P"nd drury hours in lh li".. ry mfmoriling d.r:l.io",. B ~nMa f dt<:idl!<! on lh. so:>-oo..i1 ~[>p"",(h . "The danger in public-inltrrst In ' is thaI you call becotn<." , .I'~lal" non OuilIl". """~" .. vnu ",p un .,,,,In<l """'" n~'''' Na .,;m.. A-1141 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 4 of 34 Fram inside the book 1~ p,g ... m,le,in, ban k n thi, boo k Kioai.... 1',,:.k1.nt uf Ct:nlr~1 Jlank IIr Tr~sl C.,mpony , a ~I~ Lexington bank which tomJ>(lcd with tho ....~'8M bo.n .... , sa.jd the 001 U.S. Dist,itl Court h~d betn .nab!. 10 oht.ain In. SlipuluM di,"fl1.il~te agr ••. 1-'. ,"Pb .¥....•. _ ¥> _.¥. - ............ ..- ...,. , ~ ~ o.,i.,II • good job pr~k i ~8 h< fort Cor.!!",,, ean "" 'U ~,'Did_ ;"1 C~ngr~. John II . \ 'ingling. 1M banl l aw)"n".I~bbyi!!1 we mel earllt r. knows .. hfn 1 n,ht and wben 10 5i(\f.5tep. WIlr.. 0 p"""iblo:, be Ir;", tu k..." ~;. di",.\s <lUI ul Ia~~ ul Ille ir....iuk _1lSUy. ,<>< It 0<0:1"......, ... n,. .Ute. Uut Pe,. a"'" a >1.10"1 a .. ' ...... tate ~ f , triet UlilnlSl ... rO'~R"ler.t, ... k rdu:scd Cutler', cli.nl '. re<jU .. L Seo,· ......1 ..·f tU lat ••• tho biD . ppo ••ed und •• .,.,..... !Olr<hip of Sr""tcr Ruwl1 L<lw ( n . b . l . In lhe!t'l"'" ,·.,in. 8 s"nalOf Sam Jo;rvin (LJ .• N.C. ) b noted amOOl!. colleal!Ue'l for A-1142 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 5 of 34 From inside the book [ Se ",-ch "" ~'[C 84 • Lot'~ ..Q r'r. 0 I~is thins out teg"th"_ Flnil;.ilily 1ft 19S2 Clifford worked ha.d to o~min Iq;;"lllti<l" 3ulhorlolnc pi ~iM:!l to Intll'ase th~ " rite of utulal gas, a bill of I:I~III beodit 10 clitnl Phillip' l'eu<lleuOl. Wilh Ih~ hdp ul tl,~ uil i.cw;lty'. groat ~.(e 19:: y. "', • ·... ' u '"', ..... u '''''''' ua, uu< w.~, .... "1"""" 1'" y,.", al1o .... flC\' from the gov.rnrneDI. (The .......... long <my at the TI}'.n Club ,.ith tho ICC bwyerl c",11 a._kline ~nd t.iJ ",If. 800thel $496.Sl. ) IIc..·e-vtr. Congreuional inY~ ligJlors fOWld MeLA tDrrlspondence In whieh CbeseldiDt ;., qUOted as I\S~ Jng ~'le 337 C~tl~" ill ,tLu(l..:J, d""io::> that <.rin,iuall"',,"1tl.,. ... en: ""er a priority Hem lor Ib~ ind_ry, although il ~did ud d~," "'PP<l:5e I h~m. Further, he nole. , criminal ",nCI""" .. cr. nev"" in the auto .. I~ty hiU_ ueilh •• in the original Joh<$On AdJuinislratiou .11,,",i ..' ... "". 1ft Ih~ ........ rm. r............ "" r,nm flu- H",_ ~,,~ A-1143 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 6 of 34 From inside the book c," led [ SE 1Ych I 0lJ pages match ,, ) co il ed in th S oo ok P"e I~ , , cmll'ltat!on , eliro ~ data lilt FDA called "phony," Chf!5fbro~b-rQ~d's, !r.c., R IQl1gllme COI",.tk:il olanue"",lure" f1II)vod inlQ Ih. drlll: r",ld in the: IQ6:b ".i1h I ,uJI~ined · « 1<,,->< ....,.,jn call.,j ~~a;uri" . S""L dlU.~> ~r~ .atu.aL1e 10 .,tb- l ~ tk ~ 'P'IIl I CJIIUf CD r""raoI"J .fU~ a~d MUI 4 '""""J ""~I / ...,Jf d";"f, " . n u llvlj .. ", "/pnfftl""'d. N J l d barll t~ y~M . .~A" diil" '/. I ",It~d ~t~im . I'll frt bod U YO". S~t "il~',. I ulll'd ega;". &1>. CD"ON~ SfJS lie if I DC tlM a~d t'od Ill,•. 'Y By /II~' PN J C.,uro~ {II. cC~IfI~td a Jlack of j~f<";"'" ".k, Assi5l3nl McrtUry ollho Navy u ll od you, lor ;nst~r.ce, y<lu felt h. "'•.dd not bclhor you .nl_ he 11'&11 • .,iou.," B~t ~l\enl imll1, Capli" .. 1<1 , the 12"')'., wo~l d '" lh<ou£h a d"~llory .-ecilu;on of his ~""" and leaye a memo ror lh. IRS .uK 10 .t~dy. " ,\11 he A-1144 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 7 of 34 From inside the book ccmmlSsw n [ SeuGh r'le 8 ~ ........ , ,1<le \..GIT\m .... on, ~DO elOel'l'n01e . • ne ",'So. " ...... York 1;... firm.......c.1'·~'h, S..·,une 1•.d Moo,.; P~ul. Wei .. , Rir· "ind. Wlu.non .It(! Gacri$Otl. 10 lIlImf 1"'0 of ~ do'~mll~. llim Wamir.gt<ln oBic~ " .UtI)' lor logisHUl I and admi~l.\lr~lin ' Clmv~llieJw;c; ~ut as one promim"," WaD SIr«! rwne told ",... P"e 133 t..nesela:ne says. " 11 yo~ Will 100,1; at tnt spreaQ, n IS au f,\~cr UI~ <owury and Ih",e i> 11 0 o.~ law r",n. I don't"",, how onybody <lin In, ... p"rIl8Iity, bca_ til. r«;g,d do .... at 'he Commi..ion, d~~'t ha~ any compl"in~ .110", ! thbl<, .peak' leT il.>el f. W. it." -thea lWistULt general COUIlSeI of the Federal Cornmumcatioru Comml~cn. lID" I. ~n1cr panner In Aremt, Fox. Kimner. Plot· kin .nd Kahn. Ko:II eox, \be former FCC Comml.5"ion~, s:.at •• , "furry ..., • h~nl rq;ulator. The Cu.1lC,"'iu~.u ..... ultJ Wille , _ •. ~_ ._.~ .. ., . . . • • • -' . _ .... _.L _ . . ~,,_ L _ - ' ___ _ , • • • ~-'- A-1145 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 8 of 34 From inside the book 5c P"9" m.tchin, , hairm"" in thi, boo, Tile tumt>Vn at ~«ICf. ' "4(:1)ClC> 13 ~rut. n~' K.UKl JJ .. on aD«: esli""lIed tMt tk. FTC hi.ed 750 allo.ney. duri~ bilr finl 6v. y~" as FTC d .llI........ iuot 10 !IUi..... I" a 400·""", Iev.l. Th. SEC IoIeI about 1 SoliII- .380 auorrIl)'S seh yur to pri~al' ..,..a;co; the FPC, 1001 70; tloe FCC, 3S of 'CO; the CAR. 20 _ ,~ ,...._~ .... R", _ ~ M "~ " '~ .M ~'" ._ .... I"" .~~. ~~ pa",,",~ of c h~ l<'gblation." Cooler ..... " L ,o~lident ~I a per.., oonal .udit~ce "jt.~ Congr.,.rnaD I'oag<, hiJ u (CC$5l>r .... man . Cooley .... ote ruL " WhiLe I ,cal;'. lht lbe chh"",n OInnol JlO$"i1>ly co~ f..- wilh all petil1oM'" perronally, I am cu- ,hair. 1970 "Ii'lli,." ... ,,, (lr (h~ mr:.""rbers 0/ II", COOlll",i<: La... : D,~ . nd ABA'~ Di>i,it.>. ul fwd. A-1146 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 9 of 34 From inside the book com'r. oom cr 3' "9'" m,tdin, ,o ,olll m i.n . , in toi, book ----- - - -- ----- ,- Cwnm isoio .... Willtam R . ConDole w:wI't h~ppy hfins preo.surffl b~ Tommy the Co,)•. Connole said Corcoran arri~ late in the day J..IId " ..k-.l my ~'~!Ary far pttml ....:nn In _ m~. He had no appoinuneDt 200 IIad asked fer OOO!!. He hAd nat told me rog.11>6 th. head 01 • pin."' Any co~ve,""don .. ith • Ccm missioM ' ,elueo buk 10 a ~t3t.m.~t ~ f fact_ " V..... llnM! "'y, ' Mr_ Co"'mi ~~Tr.r , r MI'" yo" ... ill ~xpe< l lt" t~.t XVI. !itualinn .. ht<h r c~nnot idmtHy to you by name.' " So Ion~ as a~QCy stall IIIl'm· --- ----,-.. -_ - -- - -- - - ---- , ~- - - ~ -- .. -- ~ - -- - -- - Pag.l95 lain ro~~ly !he """'" Iangulf:~' TM~ .re V.riCtiClU_ fCC member. may not accept payme~t lor "Titlng, "'hlcb the prolific Comm4f;ia.... Niohal.. J oh ..... n .. ti .... tes eo.t. him $15,000 • yur . D_ . . . ~" ' _ _ • 1' _ __ • • ~_ ,_. _ _ _ .~.,_. __ , . . .. "'.,.--. __ _. _ . A-1147 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 10 of 34 From inside the book demoa ~tlc [ Se a ch "" 'IlLto - , u< ,.."""~ ... , ''''' r,~"",., , ..... ~. 'DC ........" !',cal- i,., of this mom<>-th.ot the D~:noe •..uo Pariy b .,., u"hsppy . Ih"cc ~f Southern COO,,",""'AtiTo, W~.rn progreo>;TOS, lind big-<:ity laber-is vet)' lrile. b~1 it is .l>e very l... e.~ CUfr~td ... rot •. ".And il i. equally t .... o tb:>.! tilt . """... ~T fail.re ~I the ~ ~u • v • • ,.. • •• ..~ ~ u •• ~ • ••• ~ ••• _., _~, ~ ••• • A'DQld IUld Port. , fro", Dcmoo""lc poIilic>. For ,,0., y.... "rt~r tho JQhn",,~ Admin;~t,ntiQn ..,dtd, (he finn <!<outed leg.1 se,...tces ts tlw Domoc.atic N.tion.1 C"",· min .... ~ha.gi"8 ~nly {or out.(lf.pooc ket ~. Th .... ~,gc 151 Democratic P<f3ldtr.(ial campaign slna: t~4D. Along t.be ... y: Stt,elalY to J~s(lce lto!mn; RO:CQn!un.>etjon Fil!rul~ Cu'l"'n' tlo.; Lawr Drpartmmt ; r~blk W<JL"b Admini:;Lr~twn; th( SEC; iidmi.u..t!. li >c a$iliWl! [0 R.oo><:v.ll 19Js--t I ; >p<cial 113· .:••••.•• '''A __ i"'_R_.1 ""•• .. ~ ~, . lI;A ~'. ~.-'_ .~~ _, . A-1148 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 11 of 34 From inside the book d eci sion [ S e~rcl1 $3-billio" .1m." Cliff,,..1 "".. ~ot invvlv«i in \h" on<itnl'l lrial, in .. hick Cm· in~to~ and B~rting ''1'''C3entcd du !'oM. "Aft •• the , uit w"".11 0.,..,', ud thc de<;"'on ~nlcr~d, C,...lord G,.enew&lt, the d. of ~I;~hl ly mol'< thon $200 million- but wu rapidly ell"'nding in Iho hKr4liv< So"th w'~I~m !nukc... , The FTC d.dlio~ .. ~ m,..ttrp~. of ..,m.thlng Cr oth .. ; I~"}'ers .. bo h"'e <Iudied lhe cue h~ ....... 'l do.:id..J "". r'9,233 <acb :lir!w i~vo!""d ~rti~g 10 ),".y'" and lobbyif;t$ ... it~ p>' titi<~1 dOU1, h diuying ""coession, lhe Civil "'.. onu lia Gcard o\'ertuled iu own na.,ine,'. dKiJio,,-on. ru che<! aft. , IbfM y-.a" GI uha~"ive ~,~dy-only to be .."",sed in tum by John. , h·' , ' " . .. ·, " • A-1149 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 12 of 34 From inside the book I Se ~tC' J w..... '" w"*~8 .. ilh C~.g .ess ;. 3kin 10 bb""ng a .inlle .... oke' f~, . ir I"'lIul>On. Hut son... W1O~ingto n Lawy"," • •<;> ~it31 in t •• p,oe:aJI l~roul~ "'hi,b CO'P"'au, A",~,iu ,ull'S tho Unit..! Stu .. ; !h")' co~lribule to In. ""'rico"';"!!' QI t. h 'y'l ~m, :md ~.~C" ... ~ .u ••• " U', ........ "'b·Wl' ..... wy~, ....." , ........u ..... ou, P". ::93 United Stu.. !hall l>o 0 onembe, 01 cither bouse duri"fj his ClOD · I;n ..... nee in d lk"," \\lof:n a K:ln3M SM:1ICr ...."'«1 James H~t\ry Lau 1UXq>l<d " b'ipdin'. ~nat~ cOll1rn~~ r. I~ It.. Civil War. the prmnplly ejt<:led him from CO"l: reM. No . would the Ju· ri,... Ikno.rt'""'" ......rn\i. 1.",,&n I nh...... " n> W~N"HI MU'~u'lnn A-1150 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 13 of 34 From inside the book co ng r <>< ,ion ~ ~L [ S oarch pagES m,tc h t>;l cO I g, essio'h" l1l h s boo, r«r\J,t \Ie",,1 Congrrssme. 10 perlorm bloody ~.atd"'t """k o~ rtc:l.lcitro nll. A p" m.example: ;1\ \\I.Q • skil· li,h "ed"",] """"', C~mmi~~in1t ~h .• i ........ n MI~~I""ti 10 a UJog,eMionaI 'UbrnmmitlN the [act that Washing· ItCtOr!tty SUPPOl't5 th~ ckarge by , special «llllm;tlee on Con· KrC!&gulIl .thics uf L~" A""""'a\iun of !he Bar u{ the City uf l'iew Yu,k Ihat "law p' ''''li... has delllon. l, alN 3 ~l~II'.)\","J") r~, act""] ."d all'1led Cung~onal ;'np'op<ic:tie., and tht law _ _ . . : . __ ~ •. _ -'_ ., r'......-s . .... "." . ~ _ .. , _ __ " 'P"" "'7 __ .: _ __ • __ _ . _ , _ "r"""" , ~ . L .. , _. _ _ . _. n''''' M "" •""- ' ......, '1 "'''''•• tions .'" from the GI'iLR islut ':wl .tx>w and an fntcrvieJf. My w..u..oon of elhiu >'H' vis law pt'OoCtiou ",]ito t.....ily _I"'" C""trm rnu! I"" PoIDI", T... r. hy J.......,. C. J(i,by , Jf •. Amll~ Itoxncraru . ""'. Elle. W. Oller. a 'WOn ~y the Spodal Com_ ___ r ••.__ ", o.;,...s .... ..... .... eo......;."ai ~,, :~. , ~ ---:.. .:" . ~, _.~, r:,~ A-1151 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 14 of 34 From inside the book 1] P'[ .' m, le' ''g D.hivir ir th .. bock P' go3:A --- --r--·----· r -'--- - r -- " r - - - -- - ---- ---,,-- - - 10 strve o.im~luneo""ly b Congrf55 and the Navy during lhe Se.:~ nd World IV • •. In ~'ly lQ 71 [)ob, iv;' .. u app ......hd b)' lhe R.... rvisl.l Comm;U ... to StCf' I'" W.', . group cf !ICUT", 2,00"0 p ........ r ru-.rt P,9C 3:0 yorce Congress from lbe military. I think we atallllpli5.itd a desirtble tIld.· FDr his filS! thirty·he JR'S Bill DDbr ivir Hpp"Ued 10 be un Ih~ lu,,:llb6lluUs Iu Il w mrurtaltl.liv;,'K as II c"tlrlK'11I(e W"""'<_ , •• ~ _ _ T • __ • r •• _ . ....... . ,_ _ , __ • u._ • . __ .' T . _. _ ~_. ___ , '-- forum.pl (o r non·enfon;~m~nl) of (he W.bb-lluly Aot , whid> .equir., ~e'bm'~1 (O/\(l1IelO'~ 1<1 comply wilh Fede r<>l ",Ie ty Bftd health . lIIndord •. om.Nit won. A-1152 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 15 of 34 From inside the book ~ p.qes mtc~in~ ~"'~ in t~is 00'" P'q' 133 " .. ~,. 01 tho Iell """,... kif> of .l!.n! eO'P'''tion •. The ruult. in""';lably. ;' the !"'lonl;"1 for g,""~ embo' .... umenL In 1M 19ioO<. UnimNl . I"".. an amalgam .llcn . "",11 drug hrm. In"'" in Mn,ri.<;tn..n. N . .. J~'.">'. ",t FDA f"'rJn;"'ion to 0' P'g' 1~ who f>'ac!icc B! Ihe FDA rln l him Ilmor.g the lop ha lf401lon in WIlShiogto •. H o is p"Ttkubrly ... doFt:it the p,;vnle b..~. !ni"S ";Ih }l DA officbk that cc"'p.i .... an eslimared ~inoty.fi,.·. ~cor" of a ~ pr.ttioe. In on. iNl.Ulce , Land .u,,,~Nl in k""";r.<r a nr"';""t on th. morht "'M tho~.~, in .,-!.~5U p'Y' 207 - . -r r - ' ----- - , ---- , Woe or 1 t.aurdous drug .. tlrn t.e available 13C1S ~nd tJ-,e na- tional clru, 1 ... dlctale .IL" aCilpn. We ~I i~v. Ihlt the 1ar;1S .b.... ~,.,aliy lhal f>A .... I".,..~I> 'Il\I b...a.,d> III I"'l iellts who take il .. hid! are poI balanced by any berr.~t to be eq«tc<i 5<"'w", A-1153 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 16 of 34 From nside the book l 3e ~rch " :7 pa9cO mete ri ng f«s ir th;o book ~'g . 170 .... b 00 " ,<cu< "o~ '" ",,, ..... gtlOrllty ,,,au,,,,,, Ihe work I"""'nrm~ "'" . "hi""tKl In nbJN:II~.. ~r"· oar -~ ~LI·"' r"' ~n !~:dnm r-"~ liny. In some IIIUI. lKMeoer. 1M p~blic h>5 a dir«'1 finanCial interest. if a utilit y. lor ir,stallCe . r.ays ~~tI«:e:;Slry lepl letS. tM consurntr Jl'I\.~ Ihe (OSI. In franlons of (en iS adde!l 10 ull~IY ~.g e 220 ttargrove ,.roIe In anotne. ",emo Ln "ug~st. I~'''', ··tM L " ~"" llJSPS1 ..""Id. ~o....,..",. have • ~ denl 10 soy d .., ut the c~~lI$Ol th ~ ~r.dc""ri'e ....locted, alt.nougn (be ... nd.rw,;, ...., t h. mJ<!l~ ... eagaged .uch N~n •• l and pay th.i. leeo." Ni ... moMh< Iller . i ~ ~hT 1911 . USPS p<rrnille<i 'k' leadina ~.ge 375 - c - - ,,- - - - -- , -- - - - -- -- --, - - - - -- - --- - , - a ~. ~ .lIh b:uud_ T he FnA in mid.J Q71 fo'd th @ r A ~ . 'druh to install chml"", 1 rni lP.l ' n~ 1If.. t ..ln. a lt .... 1911. Dobrhir Irels lees will b~ tbt salvation 01 publi:·inlerest la"ll', A-1154 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 17 of 34 From in~ide the book fi .. d [ S oarc!- ~f(~., ClIll cr, ),I""", and other AMA "':p".~.tatiY'5 begn ba rgaining ier B oo~.t decree ",~. befo...: the ~lIil Wn$ fcrm~lIy Filed ( ultimat.ly, on Janllary to, 1'169, ~I",'m days before Ih, J""IllIO~ Administ ,alio~ lelt office). Cut1~r ~Y' the mc~t .. ,""" '''~) '"'''''' ~ .. '" .'"'''' '''''',A< ........ "'. ""Y '" ""''' ......... olSO), 10 make II harder for nl~. o. look lor a 'best-deal' coun:. II'h~ r e t.ty could r~l., upon J friendly judge ," Bloztuf said , Tl>l' (ourt ..!one tll. r,~t lIl'P"al il r,la! ""'ylll':' i ... i:sdil: liun 0'-'" an future ptOCeedi Tlg5 in 1be cast. hence timing is important. " t Tbe data On tbe S~r Lawy~1S Ai!,kult.'. Conm.itte-t, t:.J,,,,,,,. II from /MsriliS belli« Ule H(IU.~ of 110< s..{ U .hl , F.b""ry- M"r 1971: • otaIf ..,.,.. 01 tho ..... comrnitleo, T*~ U";lm Sute, 5"1* l'Tof'O"'. CIt,uobt, .lI. 1910: .... ~ lom.n ~ut rt1isuallOllIU I~1S ~koJ .. ill>'~ hot<<<l&l s.....-it)' Di.""", .. I "'" Dep..-tmmt cl Ju.ni:<. A-1155 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 18 of 34 From in5ide the book [ S<>arc, for.;gn Pag,4, ... " .n~UA'" £ ...... ~ . ,."u~" 1""'1'''' '" ..." ", ... < ..,~ .... "n"'.' " ... oolllelhillf: I am adv<>cating is a g<>Od tt.iog f~r "'Y cli«.1 """ the Unil ed Sta l .~_ I""." Th. diSiinctio n CII rri .. wit~ it lin ;ndepcndel1Ct wt Lnyu. ""Y' h~ wuuld nO\ h~ .... if h. acted ... lhe 3genl of a fo•• ii:!' rog,48 - - luI attempt 10 .xlr:ldilt Iht ousled do:'l3tO. ~b.r<as P•• u lime. "". 10, trial for rae,] to ••uptlo~_ BU I IS 3 p,;vatt ciHztn, Ach~ "f'O~t "';tll III. AO lbo'ity of • fo .....~. Se<:",I~'J of SI" I. on iM~1':'I invol"int rm. ig" gov .. n""'nl~ which c",ingtnn ~nd ~-- -~- --- - -- ----_ . _, .. - -----~.- P,,<,49 dor in hf""ic .. City. 1 l.~rn«l much the« abo~t ~ow b. n ll= i. dcme ...ilh lor.ibn n"ti~ ..... It i.v.oJU3bI •. " (Cr>vinston ~~d Du r]ing_ whi<h ovo:,. hiring h..,y"'" 11"0'" the ~."·~mm.nl, makr. an e1Ce;>tion i~ !.he int.rnati ~ nal field: il acti,-eiy KOUtS "".I, . ~. ,, ~ ...:- ~ . - "- ,- ~ ..:.~ . . ---'- ,......- .._ \ -'-~ A-1156 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 19 of 34 From inside the book 78 P'go' nole';'9 lQ,mo,;" o bo" r;, Peg' 238 ----. - - -- .. -- - - - - , - -- -, ----.--- his lirm lollo..d tbe routine. AI«" it bappcn<d [the Ni.on adl of co.rsc., ew=ryone ..... ""ylng ho..· 'eng. " l'ie "...., II> (ell tho ...."Id lhe PrKidenl ...:as OUr f",",er partn .... No rutler ...·hal yo. do, you are crilid:ted." p 'Y' 274 F.B,1~ c _ nome"'., former n.mncntic S"UI"" fM", "-efl' I~cky, iI • rt:gi'lI~rtd klbbyi<1 k r the T~ba.Wl l_i!ut~, aft in· dus1ry lobby gro~p. &nd four tobitrO cocpclrlllcns: Blown &I WlllWrucn, Liggett'" Myel5. in( ., R. J. R.eynolds, aDd Philip Mnni. Wn.l.lftO " _ tv 9r.~ h'm .. 'M T,,~,.....n '"." ,,"~ l ~ appom",ts. "" Ul"Y cuu'u '''''''.,.- 'I"'DU [n",r ume wI[n ''''' .."" . The Im:t tht the ~rwn IfqUfStln~ tht I~terv/e"o' "<15 a f~r",fr covemmt~1 ,.s. o/fx:lai was nigh automat ic ~~try Into hill oifoc;e, " It'... <ombinatlon 01 c.~"fad •• ie and ~ourte.l'. Caplin .. You fird time /oc a forme.- offid~1. If a m.:rn .. no .-d 10 be A-1157 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 20 of 34 From in:.ide the book ho~ri 'g o [ S oarch t"'V!"'""" ,V" , .. U'""' , ... ' 14y it to _ r ~r ..p<... many p,ival< ?rl>(:titi~.cr i .. il] ;n ,;'t \h~1 \.he,e are I<:w rulemaki"llj hearin;;. i~ .. hich the b~, den doe. ~ol r311 h",do. ~pon th~ obje<lor.'· But oce .... toh'" tho rogulatory ..,cnmu.;ons ""d as"" , Th:I", il "'~'"M6~ ~ '."~~ ' .,;. ,.~~, ~< P'go :051 •• Bruo:e MO~(l"mtry , dlrecl(1f (II Ille ",~ IJoN~ program ,,( Amok! And ""'tef, ,.~. p<<par;n~ lo r I"(~riur De· pIIf1nltfl\ he.. in~~ on (he pipeline <.li] c<.lmpa oi0"5' pI~ n 10 build aCf= '" . ... ~ >J~ ... ~ the Alas\;;ap lund ra t<.l <:l.-- _ TV.. .~hlA .~ eIp1 o it~ti~n . ~ ..I "" ... ~. _~_. Slna1.O ta01;OI> to tIaoe 4"I'olII·Ooriitiau Iee;'.]. ;""." P\u i. burin&> bel"", tk Smale ~· ilWK<' Cemmiltt. DII M . rc~ ( 7 ..-.d 14, (961 ; UIIi in toot det...te ~.<: "ul t ..... """,lhs. " ... n... I.. t M(II"e cor....,I.. I. ri.1 a.ceounl is giwn I~ cr...~ C/;Ho<d: Au ....' "I Will". by lJ.,;d \\.~("" aJld L1n.d lioroIrill, "a"'lIlI"/f, Aslril 19M Ad,~, .. ~ A-1158 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 21 of 34 From inside the book h ro d 1~ P'(leS mtchln( ~ir e d In ~" th S oo ok ~ ~ ~c~u ~ I"'" ~ ~".c u.u ~u".~~. 6 ...." .. ".~" •• an,,, who Wi.ted ~ plDe. 10 ,~\. U •• gurl; •." wal abo ~ .t,~ord;· ""'il)' lucky : Vtry early .Io~g [IQ 21]. k. hired Dean A<heS<ln. who ~~d tho ~h.ri<ma 10 attract <I;"" 'J al<o. 1M! who Muld h:.ndl •. hirn<flf in R ,:n"rtn." rn ; "lid Ill! hi, ... l 1>:0 .1 Sho,h. ~h. P>g' III -r·.......·- ----. -..._. --- -- --r--'-----'-' -_. thin~" ; .rod fru:!lnlion over ",hUh.. . . .btlc change 01 diTeeli~ 1I1s g<I;nt I~ cor'OO;I • v• ..,. un .... y .i l~.t1~n. Until 1065 Anrold ...d Porlcr ~.i,ed il-< nelll" po<ople .lmosI eruirt'lJ from gn".... n"'.r.t ~·i'". Th~ f"'licy gR'" th~ Ii,,,, inForta, roge 375 '"5"' • •. a" l ~'· fl"" 5'4"~ ' K'" ••"" • • ,~ . u. " ' .rtW ' ~ _ "'.".". spt~t a year in l:hil .... a Fulbright ScholAr. and thm anolh.r )feu in Co~mbia as member of • Harvard advhory cl'llnmiU'" on \aX rdorm. Covi ~gton and Durlilll! bired Dabrivir ~n Ihe balis hoth 01 bis Harvard ICCOni aud his fluency i ~ Spanish. ar.d A-1159 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 22 of 34 From inside the book ~1 P'Q" mtchlnQ in c ••"y In tm bock l na, uy l.Ll~ I"'"U"'~.' In,,,, lu u fll~" ••"" 'Ul,e II)' l.Ll~ YU) fOre ... Bdo.e lhi, cont.ry ccd$, b~ .. it >t~nd$ t o> $/I"" th~ sbaI. ~il i<l<l •• t,)' ~ billion dollar! or more in IMd. And the .h,.)( oil <ornpui.~ W<lrked filtc<n y..... to got tho loophole they <>'.". W3Dted. n.~ Ue, ...."'l>, ellCO~ate[ ed a jnt~""Ilcl. Th" autu ;lIdustrr. n'''''n ... b~e, h.. d mU'e !oCIio~. prob1e~l- the p~bti( lurQ r Qv~r ... Iety . ..tirred by N~d.r'5 e~""" G<:..eral Mot" ... , mrpidly, bim:l a p.-iva tc <Iet"".i ... I" ;"""'Ugue Nader'. pri"!11~ life. ,~< =-- ""''''~,.~ .......'''' up "'"' "".... ""'K;~ ..... 'U""""Y "" . t:\ched 10 &mage . uits \oomi~@ o~.r them. Md CUlltr al.., ,...,II't<l It Xad.,s complninl lhal S<l!ij~G ,1..,.;0, without 3 tri31 wo~ld h:r,rm ploinliff<. lie ... id the pto'l'eoti ..e lili~3nu ind~~ "5e'"u31 <>1 lb. latdi"lt ~nd ncb""l 51<11.. in >hi< WUiry, ""'). A-1160 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 23 of 34 From inside thE! book iJ~rsJn null)' linlt...t--!",litiQlly- and p""~iM.ny-IO tb ... U"'I..d SIHIO!!I Seru.1", ~ in n ni'lue I"'sitioln I ~ ~n.lil di~B I~ nF ~ W,,-, h_ i'l:l-on r...."}'~r: LyMIon H. John"'n. I h~ s.oMt~ III.]jnrilyIMd ... : Kobert " ... r, wt.ose love affair ",uh tbe oU induslry " lIS 0"" gf ··-"r--·-' ....- - , . ~- -- r- w ' . _ " • • • - -• • • • " - - _ . hi. la ... pnoctic<, ...hieh <lid not .... fF~r rrom Ihe h"" .. Clifford :spellt ot the Whit. !towe. During a , ..... bling <onVU$ltion ... Itlo repo'I'" iB lQ67 lohl\$<l~ .~mukod th.t "my Fri.nd a.,k" eaned $1.1 millio~ the P'~ y ~ar. P',e2JJ ... u Nu;~.'. liaOOD .. ill. Ih. lame-dtKk 101m... " ,-\dmi"l.nratiQn, .. hIle Jolin 5""5 .... Ihe .~d.l t"'''''''"'Y tn Spi ro T. Agnew ; both lO<Ik middle_hel"" po,;tion. i~ Ih. Adminal r~ doD . And corponlt. W-..hingtoo - th<: lohb)';,u and trade lISO<ICiatio". ~ftd A-1161 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 24 of 34 From inside the book kara,;'. [ 3e arch o p'g" In , te '; ng k.,~ . ik ' , tl-; , to" Pogo :£~ -.,,-, -------- - -- ------ -- -. .--, -- -- ._-- li"5'f>C)' fcc be Dgr(:ed, ,,11,.. o~tI;.,.d al»v~_ ,,<_ K.>ra, il< m<'mo .. me 10 lighl in r{lllnd.boot f ...hio~ . J.aS!iru! killed the LIominirJU1 dir.lal or Ralarl T rujillo in 1961_ T~ P'g . :£5 Ka rasi k tried to e :r;pl~1n aWly lbe leuer by "'ring he wrole it "bIll: In Ih~ Oornini<an Rq>IIbli<; . "I Ihi~k lh.t .. ~" I ,,~'" ~own llu:re, I prol>ably had a r<C<lmmc~dalio~, but 1 _ ""'1- 1 think it '""" ~ot " fnm ..-hid> I kn .... p"'$Oo.:1l ly. I beli .... e 1 __ ._ ,~ L . __ - -,,- - _ ~ • • __ • • -'_"" ,. " " ' __ __ . , __ :r T -- -- - --- - - T r--- - - ~.~ ~ _ _ ,>. • • 0 ._ - - -- - ""L' Byrd bfofor~ t h~ ~n.'Il ' Fi nM r-'! (" -"",min ..., ( nf which h~ chn!rullm J CO Dsiderro I ltt 5u~~r '1~OI.U. Fagtoon ag.ttii 10 "th ink about " tilt mat l~ r . ""he reupon el roD ~n t a lkrlcton!..,d acr<lunt o! conla<1 to ru.r ", j~ , "b" was III ... , j" Ciudad T,u- l".: A-1162 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 25 of 34 From inside the book [ ""ad Pag.91 Tht ~I wouldn't take JohnSoCn. Kenledy 'l"alI lOCI young, and CatiJolic ~~. Adlai SI""etU(ln---did aDr<'n~ ",.11), wan] to d ,j", QKni., Hubrn H ~mphroy, de-tp So~lh •• n ]rgub1c . ",t••• Who ~IS<!~ ClIfford pul l~be. ~n tt~.t informal btu. I~. SvrninM.on. and raised lllOfIev lor rum. and I"role me«!les , and Pogo 92 <a.<;'lI£ ~ po;<l'lO~ III ~ ... m",,), Aamllll .. ",UOft \ ...... ~m L"t , "" Clitr(l,.,j did tarly, lilal Kennedy did Mn) ~ut 1"00 inlelldoo 10 do a g,,~al deal 01 ~wi""", "'"" tI,r X~"nody Adrnlnl!lr.... iom. Clifford .."uld handle tIK Ir ..,dlion ''''''' Eb,o:nho ..... 10 Ken· Do<Iy. H ~ ..~nt \0 war. in ."rly £all d",'u"J< a dtw:u",,,,,1 dotlLij.. .u.ioi .... \, H"",.., ..... H, ...... H , GL . 111), lSI 110 n,." ""... I,k ... H.. old L•• le, C .. I. C . , ..............olo, . $1 " .... hio.o., '''"', 10' ......._,... ~ 0;.,";.;" J: ..... y , 0.«.<1. J I1 J: ....... y. I(.,...,I~, - J_u... •• . '. Joio. " . II . . . . .', ,g.... '''. "g, ' .. c. "ordrn I 'lld . . woIQLo Cli~_ ~M~_ A-1163 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 26 of 34 From inside the book Search 1" P'ge' mtching l~y~1l i1 11-; , lo" P'9,2J Mu=.o SOII.IIrG 01 Inc ".,' n~n,,= m ... .,. Il~' . • ne u mte" SUle. go-/emm..l submitted a <lnlt truly-I • .,y" t.:.y lin'. ""~diwor~, ~Ily--to a UniLed N.Ii~ ... ccmmilLN i~ ,>.". gu, t 1970. On .r,o:her freDt, as Ba, A...'Wcialion I""lrul", cha i.""'~ ~ ( ,~lx:o"'miu~. LIIyli~ ~t1""';o~ 1<1 is R."nhlic1. a 'f'"<'ial A_, ican mobilizln~ Se~.'n' bar support Ar1hur \'"me~~g . Dipl ~'n:l1ic3Ily , Lnylin .M O' Hrio~ wrM~ ~t.o.. lor 1~ ureeks to IlL"fsent botb in the Mcurily Coun rll , lid in t~.e Gtnelill AMtrnllly. The issue tbero .. as support 01 guerrilla! III Gr..., ~ hv YU?05b.\"b. Alban!a. ud Ilulrarla . •" r",,·., soou P'g' ~9 "'" " V"'~" Mon~"'. ..... ,'"" '''' "''t>'o. I"""l'o<., .-.. ,,~, ,~~ ,.....,~ ~'''' Laylln ,eturned 10 Sulllva~ and Cror.l,,·tI!; llLh<lugh he yeor~ec: [or an In\ ... ao:ll",,~1 pmttkc , ""me hOCl • ...,r"l '\II"iL'I In ",,).:r. "Talk II1I}UII wal,t tg alouut l><i,'I( ~u 'j llt ....ati"""l la,, · fer,' " Laylin !laY', "f"'1 y<>u '~~ ~ot 10 I...... 1<> he ~ g-' law)""," A-1164 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 27 of 34 From inside the book lobbl,1sts II poe", [ rnalC1i1~ l ob~~ I "'; ~rC1 i1 Iri, boo, P''l'' 20ll was NlI:o~'s UJlson ""m the lamf-duclr. J~hnl<ln .\dm lnlstlatlo~ , ~f>"(I.1 tmiM;lry to ~plro T .... ~~c .. ; ",hli . J"~n Sta rs ,n5 l~ both 1<J<.Ji< n,iddk.....t,.km corpu"'t~ lM'itJ:.o~> ia t ho AUl1li";"tr.tJ~,,. An<.l W.,,;hi'l(!un-th. luliliybu uti t1ad . ........... tiu",. anu P' go 260 "'ar ... "•• I.a..,,,. O~. Con~r(S3iona! .11111 me,ubcr suggel!t~d tb.a\ the con,millff - and .. podolly f'<>a&<--"bcnl OYer Mfk.,.",.u to ~.dd .~ .... i ..g u y f~V<l riti$nl fo, Coo ley." When e1mi ' ''''''', CooI"y p",. /,rnd 10 drill with ,"" , .-..., Icbbvi,,-~ in 'he n,h'~ Df his oE£.c:.,. A-1165 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 28 of 34 From in5ide the book [ S.",ch 41 p'oes rratch l1 g pOl e • • ,,, thIS bJOk p,,,,,, 5 ~uld be t,ansf"rmed i.to i~.t"'menlS for the ~""",.ing or ""',,"'A" ,... ...... _ AII~rn.y ~ ..al Jnhn Mhrll.n, ""'"~l""'li<lit ..hos. crffie~ti.l' al a <.lllpitali,\ dr~ beyond ,{",oxll , sai d !~ a 1'109 !pte<:h, " In 1948, the nati~ft'l \\11'0 ~UlldTed Ia'il'$\ int1ls- ,rl,,' ~nrrm"lnn< Nlnrrn"'" fnrtv . ..tahr ....... ~n1 nf ' h~ m.n"f,,_ P'O" R yo~ng Ie/low. to do the daily '~nni~g ; I ,il up her ...~d hstle '.h~ di~."." Tt.., _""I;',Ic.t v28~ '""" I\J\d '1oolifie,'inrl. ""1"ilh!l,,"din~, Washington is " heavily laW)'l rffi city _ Wruhingt"" has ~llgHjy l~"-' than one· half ~f ~ ... ~I nf Ihp Uni""<l SU~ ""nub_ A-1166 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 29 of 34 From inside the book ooltical [ S' Ofch P,! , 2A it i:I the [<>".'''Q'I low off... ;r. • politiu.1 w ..·~. ."d Bu, ' illg is not a Iol.ll,,,lly ",,'i li<al r,,,~; on. partacr, Jo~n DQu~I ... sen of (o, mu StuIQ, raul l)Qu/:I.., ma",~ed '0 r~D A "~y ,,,",cr.;.t ... for Sta,tor Co.-orJ:" M((;ov. UAt •. AltIlw~h Cov~,glO1' .. n'. P ..... i.!.on'i. 1 .... m"'; . . . . ;,)""" ~ ..... " i ..... h .. nft ..... ;n' ~ P.y; 23~ P'9,233 Iar:h ai,6nl involvod ~ ling to la'")'trl and lotbyiotl with po-li tical do~l. 1ft di.oyi"8 ,,,,,col'io~, the Civil Aoronnlics Burd ovtrruled h.l own narni.tr'. d..,loio>n--ou rt.lcM<l .afle, Ih, ... y.... u 01 e1h.~.li"e ~'cdy_nly to be reversed in tum hy Job.,.. ~ ., . , • .. A-1167 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 30 of 34 From in~id e the book [ Soarch upbinm,; tha, corporations have a righl 10 1ef:a1 'ep<es'nhlion," ~ JWi~< p"rtn~ Ja)'1 " I 'm Y' S' tlin3 q.-licm lil<l:, ' Will I ku" 10 ' "PM"""I ffl'I"'.~\i""'" Or "nyno~ ~L"" ... 0 com"" llongl ' On~ yt Bl" lb. qu""'tion ...... ' WhBl, lor o:u.mple. wo~Jd CO\'inn01! and Burtiu do it 'IOU w~ ,~ aske'd to rl'llre5e~ 1 a"" . . apf"',nl_, " <lie)' ",""'u "."'''' ' 1".'1'" m ~ ' "m~ wan m e 5\"' •. Th . !act tllat th.. pel'$;)~ r«(",,"li,,!! lhe ;ntt,vi~ ... ,,'as. a for"'.' gU'nmrne,,' ofI'>ci~1 ... as ";8~ aUlom"'i<: e,,' '1' ;nlo hi< alike. {"spl;n ~ II '" I C"mhi""l;" " e l c"",,,rad •• ie Ind mane<y \'on lind I ;~ fnc • In""", ollio"!' If • m,n ",ho n<r<1 In M "'y" From inside the book I Search I told t;j "11" mtchln( told In Ih S oook P,,",,337 Cutle" in Ttbuttal, d<lliO$ that criminal penalties _ r<! ever a priority it"", rer th. inMlry, ~lthou~h it -d id ~nd~" oppose ,hom, F~ rtht" lw IIQIft, c,;,n;"al u"ctions ..er. ne,'or in th auto .. roty bill_ nol:ht, iD the original Job""," Ad,l'-iD;,lration , ,,hm ; ,';nn N>' in th.o ' ..... 'iBM , ...... ,., .... f'Bm th~ H"M~ .nit A-1168 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 31 of 34 From inside the book [ Sea ch mater 53 pa~es I match n1"""'.' i1 lei, boo, --e- -- --- -.- r---- - - By.d ~ror~ Ibe 5tnau FjDa~ Commlilet ( of which he W loS dJ4/.inn4/.lI) o;<;J lL. :u. rnl Ih~ ,;u~. r '1"01 .... F~gtoo" "!troW 10 "Il, il:k a"""I " th. n"'U~I , wh~l,ulA'a £frQn ~pl a sk d<lo~i ..d account ~llhe conUct to K.o ..... ik , .. be ",-u th.n in Ciud.>d Tru· From insid:: the book If,Ii Ur ' 4J pal" mlch,-g milii Q" in 11-; , 1>0" p'''''''''''' uthrr to GM. I.:hr;,.ti~u o.. nnl SIlm. 6.1 raill,oo >ham; 01 ,Ia: 181 'nilliul 0)1 .b....... u~l>ta"di,,~. n", 'QI"pl.~ cax dl1l¥J(nI IllfUUJ:l1 Ih. O><Im lor a doudo, ,..10. Koln~ lu Ih. U.S. Supr..,... Cow-I bela,. Ille ~o.~rum."t WUIl .."d Ch'\>li..na wo>; or<krod .a di"".( it><1f "f .11 OM , IoU: within I.., v... n---IO A-1169 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 32 of 34 From inside the book [ 3e ~rch p,.o.ot c, 90 PlcO mctc r; "3 prodie. " this bco, P'go 1 P'go 70 ~m ~~ lice, ""._" I:\"n " ""''''', uu, '"" h~ !ilI~d, r'1"~ ILI.,.J " I\ou 1101 In l~relit I.. d ~ ..-I..,:,· ..r ic. Pow •• Comn> i.. I~R, I ,""u ld ..., • 'd'" ,~,.. "'" 'UU'DO< I" n Ill( ~r In Ib e Icnll. If a C<l mll"ny PI.II.." bt·ru , ~ II", ~·..!~r~1 mv. 1"';0 oul . r.d hir. ~ op«iolist. I\'h<-n I SUI,tcd "'I p,a<tiC<', I .... ~I"" 10 be Ih< high~,- IcY.1 From inside th e book 'taft 63 P ' ~es m at ch " ~ stall in l1i3 bock P'qe3 15 "PI""Dlt:<'. "" wcy wy,y "" "~ r ' I"'IJU "K" U'IL" .. IlJl UK ,,,,,, . The la~t that the person ' ""lucstir.g the i~U:f~itw .. a) a forme. .l:ovcnrneot offICial was niRh auton,,,t;': talry in;o Iili oIf'(e, c..pli D ""Y" " It'. .. oombin.lioll 01 camilrad~rie ."d ~ou n~.y . You fi~d tin-.c fer. 10'nK' oIIie;'L II z man wh" uxd to I>t A-1170 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 33 of 34 From inside the book [ ,;"atC1 aci " .... lb. [QUIt <J; mont.>! dj",."" tile delendul cout<1 I>e acquit~d on !he ~ruu~d ...1 iusaltily. For Lbe "'III.:IlIy obKure Cluencr Gfd..,n. !he PIorKto n~'."...Ju.. .. dt, FurW Iw L a Suprtm~ CQurt M.li,nmDt U<I ... cn t~t case es.r.ablis~lr.: !hal dofendant1;. leVU imdi~~nt ~IIQ. m ~!1 ba\'e counsel at all SIiI.!!" 01 a From inside the book [ Sc~rch Iri ng 5C pog'< m tchrg 'hill~ ~I n thi, ",0< '"'' '"'''' ""'" IV ......... ~'" ..... !IX>..... ~." 'I:' U " ... '" U~I""1!.""'" ... ith d goo-d <kll Qf d.tac:hed U1U,"""CnI.. "W~ lutd betn doin~ (hi • .'lOr! or thing in our own ur.organi",d , unolrutturrd, unf'ublk ..·ay," a $Odor po.rl nu $tales, "lo~g befQre it bee,me ·th. t1:ing to do' in \V~$h ingt<>n Lr...." T"", CUL· 1l000lri1lf: , but "a!~hC\l A-1171 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-6 Filed 08/26/13 Page 34 of 34 From inside the book 15 P',o, matchin, 10." in trio (0)1, t>a~. II It Wall not a ftrs\-t:1a.\s 10&Jl, "-': didn't "ant 10 ma~e It . s... I cill Yp Ithe Fed)..oo ~nd ~ut -I td Ikem aU tbe lact •. 'Why . .. you caUin~ me en this~ · I"" rnaft ... kcd. Based on tbAl «In· .erOOQD ~nd .. hat""' kne .. of the 1.0.., ... g~ve tho "I'lnloll tM , ' - . _ _ • _ II -'_t.. " SiyS he "'iLl ·' unarUJn~ as 10 \10M! slattle:s to proceeJ under. GUlhrie h.1pc<l ~lee, Ken"ed~-ud tbe go .... ~"'~m-tow . rd Dolen.., PlGdu<llon Act , InlMdtd '" Plott<:: comp."; ... eonsid • .-ed " ..mli~] II> the ., • • o. • • , " ." u'~ 'g"nc:y mn g~.r.~tee provl.-Ion. 1>1 Ib~ ~ .... uRnlOOl It ... e m.lI ~ct1"n tne 10<10. OU! I was IlOl Upot"l Inoy ,e:- didn 'I." II. abo no,.., Mudge R.,$<: n.i!i>er "'p«lcd B r c e"vcd DRy fi""nd.1 knd,t from I. ~ r.M Ctr.lral work . "As a nuU.r of flOCt,· he said. "",. probably lou $50.000. Th.)· ' till n...~ \l< 1,"1 mu~h . nnd I'm nr>1 mnfi",",, 1 nll!l'"ninl: mn .. lhan a A-1172 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 1 of 32 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK ------------------------------------- x The Authors Guild, Inc., Associational Plaintiff, Betty Miles, Joseph Goulden, and Jim Bouton, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated, : : : : : Plaintiffs, : : v. : : Google Inc., : : Defendant. : : : ------------------------------------- x Case No. 05 CV 8136-DC EXHIBIT 3 TO THE DECLARATION OF MICHAEL J. BONI IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT GOOGLE’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT A-1173 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 2 of 32 The Trouble with Thirteen ~ 0 Betty Miles **** 11 Reviews Avon, Sep 1, 1980 - Jwenile Fiction - 116 pages Twef/e-year-o kJ Annie is unl'iilling to face some major changes in her life - c- Common terms and phrases An, eI~ Anni e Ary"" l' )'I.unt Sylv ia C owboy bean s doughnut oirls olad I',nen r;r" ere, ,,, , going C uba om","! B"c~1 "'"'Iiful Dairy Quee n ea rs pierced " " ' i",j d3nce lettu ce lilacs Hl~ look ed M, r'i o,nn Kate M"v'I:l "Y" 1381 felt -<a:E'S mini.!" m;;s Ke nn y kids W1 m s mrl\le Nora 's ~ d 00 ) poj ;) m;) ~ p, rty Peter Ja mes ~ucll ~r"lly ~rulJ" ijy Rach ~a:h" "k,d Rachel looked Rtl chel put couell docr fourposter nightgown Nora p 11"" Coke Deb bie doll hou se [rica "I<,)lili"y OtabteJ :lUeS5 hJOOed Janie .l.fT1l "d Eruc e c, m", cl" ~ rrurl fllln)' kl chen kr ew lal!Jl3,j lP~t ri rp photo booth R<oo.; II"llL LtI roc, picture "...-ned th m s -m ucj11 1,1nq lUrn"d """ k ed wec rn q ''''~ioo WlJl5 \o\~ellnq '/01sr ¥!CIlJ ereJ '!lJrlY Yeah yeled York City A-1174 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 3 of 32 From inside the book ~nce " I Search I '2 Fog" mot ch "9 ' '' ge lo in Ihi, bock P,g o B and Angela and Janie crowding over after lIer. ''What?'' Rachel sat up strale:hrer. [ could see she didn't want them to notice anything. "Mf)m'~ lettln g me get my e;!.l"!\ piel"Cfti. fur my Page 4J "1 don't know, I wasn't that sure I wanted to." Did. anyone, besides Kate? " "Not yet. Angela sttU m ight." I was relieved. It was good not to be the only one P'g o 9J But Just when I gOt relaxed, Debbie had to jump up and stare looking through Kille's records. "I've goua hear lhb !" we~. hokl1ng one up. A-1175 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 4 of 32 From inside the book [ ,,-rc, 11K:: , 1Il1l"-'W !1I ,uw a YUUIIII JiiUy. nUl. UUlIl W ..... W tum Into anything, yet. Anyway, not so f3Sl. Some kids In ()ur claM 00. Kidti Iik.e DebbIe Goldstein and Iris McGee. They act as though they j ust P,,", , 20 gardenin g, jogging, woodworking. dimbng !Tl(luntalns in Vennonl. He makes us special birthday canis wJth lit tle cartoon pic1ures. My twcive-YeM-cid h~rl ~ ~~N'fYln ~nrl ~ d:nn\{ with h~Uoon~ mmin E!: Dill cw "Boy, I h'lle to think. how much noise five twelveyear-old ltirls are going to make. I'm ~ad I don't h.ve 10 be lhere." ~So = t I." 1 uXi q uickly. "So is everyone. The very A-1176 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 5 of 32 From inside the book trirOO1 ~ p'ges I [ Seorc1 mtc~in[ "'Ineen in l1is bock Pag. 8 are funny, but we do. We like the 6ame booke, too. Ll efle Women Is our Cavortte. Radlel'5 n:ad It thlnttll Umcs and I've n:&.llt founeen. We'\·e J"elld ::IU the Little House books over Pog ,U sophl~ttc.aled. "What are you getting Kate for her birthday?" I asked. Kate was iOing (0 be thlrteen Oil S .. tunlay. She . . . . . ... . . ~ __ • • •• • _ • • • _ _ _ _ ._•. T •. • . _ •• T . _~ ___ ~ _ • • • .• _ Pag.51 "Really~" r took a bl~gel" Slt::p and tried to muvt:: m y arms like Kale and h.nk!. ." can'l e\'f"n Imagine being Ib irtun!" ul know it Sue 5topped jumping iUllIJnd. "Still , , W A-1177 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 6 of 32 From inside tho:: book scho a [ Se a ch PO\l,27 ,..,,,"' • • u ........... " ........ " .....] . ... ~u ... " ..............., apartment \'11th 110 y;ml Of ;mythiJ1i. Yoo'd have to ill to II new «hool Kids would lsno~ you, 01: <eke heAl you up. You could gel mugged on the .....,,,ay <:>CllUUl f . . ., SUI'f'Y""U w 8lreet~" ut: " " """"u"'~" .• wondered If RiJl;hel would surt actlll" snuity If bile wenllhere, Maybe s.he wouldn't want l1l4! to meet heY new friends. Probably she'd start wearing IUlppy 6aI'CIa.y t "I didn't mol'" you were gang todo that!" "I dldn '( either. Mom j u~t c.alled (hem up and they &Ilid 10 come over. School wa.s ou t, but the director" A-1178 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 7 of 32 From inside the book E P'l'o m>lch " 9 ,I... in toio bool III!; 1 III ""-lW1)(, !l1f.U "YUW1)(, JiWy. DU < I UUU l W",I< LV tum IntO anythlnc. yet. Anyway. not so fast. Some kkhl In our class do. KxIR like Debble Goldstein and Ids McGee. They act u though they juJl ed. lie ~ading Sevrnleen ." his has a s ubscription to SBWI'I lem. She brings it 10 school and pUIIBS II around in class. She never PlEses thinking of iL Compared with Rachel moving it was such a little thinK:. but It bothered me, I wondered make alllhe _LL. whelher Kate tumlnglhineen woukl _ _ _ L_ •• ___ L kid!! ______ __ ____ • C" ___ _ _ __ • _ _ ~ ~.-- A-1179 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 8 of 32 From inside the book fr ood [ Seorc1 year. Aunt SyiV1a has a fhend whose kJds go to l'b,....I~ " ., .h .. c,"" •• h"" I...... i. P ..... <min .. 01• • h ...... tv .hle -_._-_.- ,-- -- - _ .. - ...._- --, ,-_.- _ .- __ • ,,, ...... ____ d . ___ _ ___ , __ • • L __ __ _ _ - ' _ ~ L __ ' . ~ dragglns me around like seme bIg Ne¥i York expert, making me fee15lullkl. It hurt5 my feellnpl" "I'm SOTTY If I hurt your [eflingC Rachel le:med A-1180 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 9 of 32 From inside the book t ione o [ Soarer 11 pagES m,tc ri t>;l f,ifn,ls in this boe>< Dan:L1.J .:x;mlUlr II a supplr.i!:Q w LIt: liU C}l.UUSIVl:, , wondered if R2chel would start acting snotty if she went there, Mayboc she wouldn't wanl me to meet he~ flew friends, Probably she'd start wearing ~ppy you'll all be happy," 1 never thought before about all the people who could £eel iad when two people get divorced, Not only their children. but their friends and their family, I A-1181 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 10 of 32 From inside the book [ Search :Jj "'l"S matc~inc I 0",1i . i1 ttl , boo, Pag.97 Annie. Denny and ClaY'8 marriage wasn't a waste! 'T'h-. .. .....1 m I ... nf ".vvl v .. o ... a....l ~ In< nfhu. "....l ........ The book. wu upside down. ! can't eYer ...Tap a book. so the title comes out till top. R.&chel turned It over. Then she tilasped. "011. A1tlli~! 011, _ , that's so neat! Th(lllks /" She opened A-1182 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 11 of 32 From inside the book Page 13 ooukl happen, lite Peter James' father." Peter Is Kenny's beat friend . He Uve. on our block. His hther had a heart atuck on the golf CQl1f8C Qne dav lalit fa]] and iust suddenlY died. Poge 17 I-'age :J:j --_ _--- ._. ---,. _ --_ ... _.- -- -- ----- -_. - --_._-.. ._ fast, so we know what part of the city to mClVe to. Sylvia lioiI.y~ [ }lC1ve tu ;I ...... ly ... rdClIciilly thlti minute If I w;m t [() get into Barclay nellt fall . See. they don't _ _ _ _ .\.._. _ _ __ • In..l_ '-- --,_ I. . \.. _..l_ ., ~ . ""..l_ ,, _, A-1183 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 12 of 32 From inside th e book - -_._-_., - '-..--'.' OUt ben article Idea so far was "You Can Teach an Old Dug New Trtck:;,M I thou gh t It up. Nora was perfect for the :uttcle boecaU5e ~he', ten yean old and . l. _ _ •• _ _ • _ _ _ . -' .... . .. _ . .. L . _ . L . . . . . _ . _. _ _ .... Pog e" lapS, panWlg. I saatch~ her behind the ear. "You're a dumb old dog. Ihat'll what you ~re_ " Nora wriggled appredatively. 10 the sun, her fur I tried \0 ioquash Ule feeling down. I Maned to look for Nora I., her fll\'crite sleeping plaCl!s: Ihe chair shpwasn't supposed to lie in, the holl rug, the foot of my . '" . . " A-1184 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 13 of 32 From nside th e book [ Se a m E P"'-l" ""lei ir y ~dj"'"d~ ir Iili> lJJuk Kate's mother, "Mom! It's a. $~ver party. We'\) wcar paj;m"ln.s tllt: wholt: tlillt: r' belter. I knew Kate would like it. B.unbergcr's pajama department Is called Night ute. They had ncks amI racks of nylon pajamas with blkinl pants and smock top~. I would never wear A-1185 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 14 of 32 From inside the book summer [ Se a ch r'9· 101 r'9· 102 u ..,. "'''''' .. U . . "'.ICI ,."" 4.<"-' """" ;u ..... I LV" ' " ",.,., UUI '1) Blue Lake,~ he srud, ~I(yo\l wanted to. " I was S\lrpri8ed. He must have nod~ I wu getting oldet. "Sure. neat." ) 5akl tooplea.sed to tty W act cool. A-1186 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 15 of 32 From inside th e book t .~c ' . r beautiful Sbe loob like a fushion model. which is Whill she Wi\.5 before she got to be a nursery school teacher. Rachel says s.he hated It. except that'!; how ihe met Mr. Weiss. From insidE! the book be st [ Search I[ pogo> mtc h '-g be " in thi, boo>: was the exact color of honey. Rache! stroked Nora'£ back. Rachel doesn't have a dog, 90 she shares Nora with me. Nora loves her next ~t \l) an}"un~ in our family. Maybe she thinks A-1187 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 16 of 32 From inside the book roc h ~ l Smch J 57 1"' ge, mot ch nl' il<h e l in or;, [o)f: Rachel back to the steps and u:r.unb1ed up across our From i1side the book P" . 8 lIrryway, the same things strike us funny. Like words that bother you whim you read them Raehel"s worst CXIImple!s the way the o's don't match in good A-1188 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 17 of 32 From ins ide the book -------.., ---.,.-'-' Our besI: artlcle Idea so far was "You Can Tea.eh an Old Dog New Tricks." I thought It up, Nora was perfect for lhe article l.oec:ause she's teu )'ears (lkl iliid From inside the book ~5 p' go ' m,le';'9 nlQm;n or;, t o,~: "I'm not kicking her, I'd ju~llike to moye aroulld in hll!l'e without bumping Into her, for once." Mom and Dad came In. NOh,ldds," said Mom, "cut It OUt, will you? Let's have a pleasant meaL" A-1189 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 18 of 32 From inside the book rr nv. ~ p.,e, malc1 n Qmove n lhlS ~(o< - Really?" r lOOk 11; bigger step .md tried to move my anns like Kate and Janie. "I CilIl't even imagine being thirt~mf' -I kno ..... it" Sue stopped jump!nll; around. "Still. 1 From inside the book [ Seucf1 after I heard Iris and some klds talking about it 1n the girIs'room. It sounded stupid. "I don't know ..... h)· she wanb to read tlWlglS like A-1190 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 19 of 32 From inside the book cue [ Sea rch 13 P'O" mtch n QslIe in this book P'g.51 "'Well. AnnIe, want to ~s." ... try? ~ I ..."".,,, " T clnnti 11n Sue Jumped up. "~I'• •f,,"v "l"nI\I'\thln<l'mv From inside the book "daOy cucer " wony aoout training Nora. Hut slJe'fi vel'}' Intelligent. She's probably the only dog In r.he world who knows whitt "Dally Quccn" mean" If you even whll'lpec those words, she runs to me car and lrtes to Jump In. A dog A-1191 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 20 of 32 From inside the book [ J e ~roh " ~u,-t ,)'Ivi~" 9 page , ",to,;,-g "~Lln, .,..lv i . " Ihem. I ~ in th, 000' much rather have stayed with Aunt .c;:vlvl" "Vn01 on m.:.1 " I , ,,In A"" h ..1 I 1.."nM "",,~ From inside the book de bbie _ 3e ~rch 1a P'go, m,tchin, 4ebbie in J o [0'': r;, Pogc {1 acros.s me nnu intO me ()1nll)g room. ueOOIC t;Ola~t(;m WiIS stilliding there! I couldn't belle\:e il. Kate never sa1d uylhlng about Debbie coming. Hcrmothcrmust have made Kate ask A-1192 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 21 of 32 From inside the book pe rmo L [ Searoh p'go' "",:ch nJ pi.r.,. d " thi , bock Irs not aU thai dlfferenl Look at Kate." It was true. E)((:ept for the pierced ears, and the dancing, Kate seemed about the AAI1le_ "Ye.w. g\le5S Vn" .Inn" h""",_ tn ... h~n.,.. """"",i,,h. n~ ~ n".hin"'· From inside the book J3 p'ge, motch " 9 k.llny in h, bock P.go22 a- rea.! (Jf'<l~ "Om~It:ll, - 1I.eJlllY !Ioa.It.l, pushing her out of the way. "Sne is not! And you don't have to hick her!" I saki quickly. - II ..... (Jog'~ I A-1193 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 22 of 32 From inside the book [ Sc Ofch )4 "g., m,t,h " g kAt. in th < hnnk Paqe41 MHappy Birthday!" we yelled. Angela began giving v ~ .~ ."... _ ~ ,,; ... ~ ....I "'A ~_ . ~..IM ~~ , ~..l ~ ~ ..l ~" ~ J..""" From inside the book 31 1"'9"' molch"9 look. d " lh, boo. penon whO pUla you do...u . tlut I wallted get Iler somet hin g really good Ftnally In the Indian store I saw a blue enamel brv.celet thgt look.ed qul~ elegant and only cost fuurdollan. After I bought I! I felt much \0 A-1194 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 23 of 32 From inside the book [ Secor,,1i l' peg" m,tcr;rg gir ls in th ", bock Pog ,37 Iv\'! ""'.. ''''-''. IIUII. ..'UIII ""-'''' ",I\;uu'''5'''&,1 ' "YOU're going to have a wonderful time, I know. How many girls dJd Kate lr)Vltc?" "Five, I think. Except now Rac hel won't be there." Pog ' ~E people wouldn't lillY It. espec!alIy girls. II's like caIl!ng vnllr nwn "n,hr onmlll Pog ' 8~ bun ch of black girts II.irh Afros and high wedge 5hCle!'i burst on and grabbed 8Q'aps above us. They were shouting and kidding around about one girl's boy A-1195 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 24 of 32 From inside the book 28 p' go ' m,tcr;ng kid. n thi, boo k ' ' ' '" . . . . u . . . . . . . ., .. .. '" ... " ""'J ' ... Gum " . . . - .. .. _ _ apartmenl with DO yanl or lUlything. You 'd have to go w a new 5Chwl. Kids would iljJlore ~uu, U<' else beal you up. You could gel mueged on the stree t_ OO Pego 2t year. Aunt Sylvia hu a friend whose kids go \0 R~lY'hv . .1 """ v~ ,l,~~ 1,,,,~ I, I'm ,,,,i,,<> .n .t- rI '" , h i ~ .... P'qe 1[4 "1 wlU, thooghl" Even u I saki it I wun'l positive. It's hazd to pn:dlCI how )'00'11 ft:el More. I u5W Iu think you amId. "You !mow how. In hm\c~ ItIP kirk nllt r,h/o.ir 0011 A-1196 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 25 of 32 From inside the book Se~ tC1 ''''''', . .,,,,, .uno<:u "..- y .. 'I.UI<;OUY <IIIU ............ ,,,,,,.. Ing at books. I pretended 10 look through the posters bUll couldn' t eoncenU'ate. After a few minutes I went over and lapped her shoulder. tnOie aresscs COSt! "Yeah '" opent:li me uoor for heJ- and Wilva! hel in. The saleswoman was standing nght inside. I wondered if she'd heurl us Ilghllng, but she dldn't say "Yeah, but we C(luld nan on it N"~ d n ......... ,,"d nl1t It tn ...._.... r ' rlDW, and then each ft. .. n .. ,,1 ~_ ~ A-1197 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 26 of 32 From inside the book I laC'> [ S. '''Th L ral'S match l1 Q lila cs In thIS bock P'ge 56 "''''' ~Ul"U Ul ....," w'"'" .... '" LIn, I,O' UU u, 1..1," ~"u u.., ... , ... the s1g1n of Nora'~ siomach s\\o"elIIng out with every wheeze. I ..... anted to hokl her tight so she cowdn't wheele:any more. I wanled I(! ~arry her to SOIlll!' wann I toot. her into my anns very t:arefulIy and cra....·led slowly out of the Wacs. Bran~het scraped ~it my face. I camed her to the house and set her down in the old slJ.n1;: chair olllho: lJack pon:h. TIn:m I rd!l. uplitalrs A-1198 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 27 of 32 From inside the book [ S"C<Lh I : pogo> mtc r; ,-g l.n" ~. ;11 t1;' b,of< " l O 13 goes." "Iuu::hel minds. H I pulled (he lettuce ou( of the refrigerator drawer. "You know what, Ken ?H I couldn't stop myself. "Rachel thinks her parenls mlghl get :I the print shop and Kenny woukl be home late. She uke<! me to ,t2rt dinner. I took (he lamb chop!! out of the fridge and peeled some C anoI.S and cu t them up and started washinllleuuce fOJ a salad. I wal; paUlPK A-1199 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 28 of 32 From inside the book [ SE 1YcI1 I 17 paqos natc h"1 anYWilV in Ih S oo ok J .. ' ...... , .............. - ............... . Anyway, the wonia that Yme thlngll strike us funny_ Wke ooth~r YllU I'ohen yuu read them_ RaChel'5 worsl eumple Is the way rhe o'!> don't malcr. in good Pay, 34 --- ---- ~ -- --. ---- -- ----- --- - lerrifIe?" I asked. ~It's ~Don't you juGt love it?" nice and brlRht, anyway. M Mom sounded aa thoua}l she was tr)'1na hard to be taCtful.. ·'Have you ··WelI, I <100'1. but Sue and. I started to because eller)·one else was, and It was pretty easy, really, once we got the hang of It. Anyway, we're going to practice LOl!.dht::r this w~k. MI w~ll ~ ~x~rts Dreltv IiOUll- I M A-1200 Case 1:05-cv-08136-DC Document 1073-7 Filed 08/26/13 Page 29 of 32 From inside the book I S<>arch I b oaltit ll -----, - -- - - -- - - - - •. --- . - - - ------ ~ - rr --- ro1lln1l around on the ~wdu51 in the window. They .... ere small and pudgy with little bare pink stomachs. They were 110 cute:: I wanted to ery. ........ _ , '-' __ L _ - ' _ _ <_ >'-." ,,_ . ___ ... ·.u _ h __ _ ,. ~ .. ","""UUlW ....,... ......" c. ~ .. c ........ ~ "J'Y . ''''''''CJ. u, us had any pI'2ctlce with good-bye gift!; before. "Open itlRachd untied the rlhbon and jJulltd the paper oft'.

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?