Siddharth Hariharan, et al v. Adobe Systems, Inc., et al

Filing 1

FILED ON 11/07/2013 PETITION FOR PERMISSION TO APPEAL PURSUANT TO RULE 23(f). SERVED ON 11/07/2013. [8856405] (HC)

Case No. __________
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT

IN RE HIGH-TECH EMPLOYEE ANTITRUST LITIGATION

Petition for permission to appeal from the United States District Court
Northern District of California
The Honorable Lucy H. Koh, Presiding
Case No. 5:11-2509-LHK
DEFENDANT-PETITIONERS’ EXCERPTS OF RECORD
VOLUME IV OF VIII
ROBERT A. VAN NEST, #84065
DANIEL PURCELL, #191424
EUGENE M. PAIGE, #202849
JUSTINA SESSIONS, #270914
KEKER & VAN NEST LLP
633 Battery Street
San Francisco, CA 94111-1809
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 415 397 7188
Attorneys for Defendant and Petitioner
Google Inc.

789556

EXCERPTS OF RECORD
N.D.CAL.
DOCKET #

DOCUMENT

PAGE

Volume I of VIII
(District Court Orders—Public Versions)
1.

531

Oct. 24, 2013 Order Granting Plaintiffs’
Supplemental Motion for Class Certification
(public redacted version)

0001

2.

382

April 15, 2013 Order Granting in Part and Denying in
Part Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
(public redacted version)

0087

Volume II of VIII
(Expert Reports – Public Versions)
3.

518-2 518-4

Expert Report of Professor Kevin M. Murphy
(public redacted version)

0140

4.

424-2

Supplemental Expert Report of Edward E. Leamer,
Ph.D.
(public redacted version)

0340

Volume III of VIII
(Expert Reports – Public Versions)
5.

440

Supplemental Expert Report of Professor Kevin M.
Murphy
(public redacted version)

0402

6.

442

Expert Report of Kathryn M. Shaw, Ph.D.
(public redacted version)

0570

Volume IV of VIII
(Depositions and Declarations – Public Versions)
7.

308-1,
445-2

Deposition of Edward Leamer

0676

8.

538-8 538-11

Declaration of Danny McKell in Support of
Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification
(public redacted version)

0691

1
789556

N.D.CAL.
DOCKET #
9.

516-6

10.

DOCUMENT

PAGE

Declaration of Frank Wagner in Support of
Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification
(public redacted version)

0713

District Court Docket Report

0725

Volume V of VIII
(District Court Orders FILED UNDER SEAL)
11.

Oct. 24, 2013 Order Granting Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification
(under seal version)

0804

12. 383

April 15, 2013 Order Granting in Part and Denying in
Part Plaintiffs’ Motion for Class Certification
(under seal version)

0890

Volume VI of VIII
(Expert Reports FILED UNDER SEAL)
13.

Expert Report of Professor Kevin M. Murphy
(under seal version)

0944

14.

Supplemental Expert Report of Edward E. Leamer,
Ph.D.
(under seal version)

1144

Volume VII of VIII
(Expert Reports FILED UNDER SEAL)
15.

Supplemental Expert Report of Professor Kevin M.
Murphy
(under seal version)

1180

16.

Expert Report of Kathryn M. Shaw, Ph.D.
(under seal version)

1348

17.

Expert Witness Report of Kevin F. Hallock, Figure 7

1454

2

N.D.CAL.
DOCKET #

DOCUMENT

PAGE

Volume VIII of VIII
(Depositions and Declarations
FILED UNDER SEAL)
18.

Deposition of Michael Devine

1455

19.

Declaration of Danny McKell in Support of
Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification
(under seal version)

1458

20.

Declaration of Frank Wagner in Support of
Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Motion for
Class Certification
(under seal version)

1480

21.

Exhibit 24 to Declaration of Lin W. Kahn in Support 1492
of Defendants’ Opposition to Plaintiffs’ Supplemental
Motion for Class Certification

3

7

Case511-cv-02509-LHK

FiledOl/23/13

Document308-1

Page2

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

UNITED

1

2

NORTHERN

STATES

of

62

DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

SAN

JOSE

DIVISION

3

4

---------------------------5
IN RE HIGH-TECH EMPLOYEE
6

ANTITRUST

LITIGATION

No.

11-CV-2509-LHK

7

---------------------------8
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

9

10

VIDEOTAPED

11

San

12

DEPOSITION OF EDWARD
Francisco

California

Friday October 26

13

Volume

14

LEAMER

2012

I

15
16
17
18
19

by

20

Reported

21

ASHLEY

22

CSR

No.

12019

23

Job

No.

1545691

SOEVYN

24
25

PAGES

1

-

476

Page
Veritext

National

Deposition
866 299-5127

Litigation

Services

1

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Q
A

1
2
3

Filed0123 13

1

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

Page22

0942 52

agree

I will

You look to your talent competitors

5

what they’re paying

6

compensation relative

7

9

and you want to

to see

correct

to

make sure your

force

11

offers high

12

competitive

force from

13

Q

0943 07

salary if you are not feeling

the

15

alleged

16

the class

19
20
21
22
23
24
25

Some firm that has

but for

world

0943 14
on

would

the

bilateral agreements did not exist during

period
I

You understand

All

I

So

0943 16
0943 19
0943 23
0943 26
0943 29

right

In

the

but for

I

go

world

over

don’t have any evidence

would

or

data that

0943 43
0943 46

so

0943 51

the cold calling

redistributed in a

0943 32
0943 34

all

ahead

Well I’ll leave it
So

the concept

do

support that conclusion

Q
A
Q

what we’ll call

and that’s a world in which

there have been more cold calling

A

0943 09

a

them

Let me ask you to focus

14

0943 04

You don’t want to

match some high salary

18

0943 02

Yeah actually only to the extent that

there’s a competitive

A
Q

0942 56
0942 58

them is competitive

10

17

0942 54

0943 00

A

8

62

0942 50

if that’s what you mean by

Q

of

0942 50

Well

competitive

4

Document308

but for

at

said

0943 54

have been

0943 57

what I

would

0943 59

world

Page
Veritext

National Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

86

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document308

MR GLACKIN

1
2

BY

Page23

MR

5

7

0944 04
change

The total amount wouldn’t

A

I didn’t say

Q
A
Q

9
10

that

was embedded

was what

8

0944 05

in your

I recognize

that that

0944 11

So

But there’s no evidence
So

to

support

12

the same and redistributed whether it would

13

gone

whether it would

but for

A

15

question and

18

to

we

So

don’t

you don’t

I answered

0944 23

in the

You would

0944 28

to answer

exercise

need to
that

0944 30

have the data that allows

us

22

determine

23

much cold calling

Q

0944 33

In

0944 38

know

that allows

to estimate in the

the

would

already

that question

don’t have the data

we

been

down

0944 19

have

0944 37

21

25

0944 17

have been

it

Q
A

24

have gone

Well yeah absolutely

17

20

would

0944 26

carry out an econometric

19

0944 15

world

16

do

0944 12

that

you don’t know one way or another

whether the level of cold calling

up

0944 07
0944 09

question

11

14

0944 04

but it

might go to different people

6

62

0944 03

PICKETT

Q

4

of

0944 03

Objection

mischaracterizes

3

Filed0123 13

1

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

would

us

I

said

0944 45

to

but for

world how

world

0944 47
0944 50

occur

but for

0944 41

would

there have

there have been an increase

in

0944 52
0944 55
Page

Veritext

National Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

87

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document445

2

Filed0622 13

Page1

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

1
2

UNITED

STATES

DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION

NORTHERN

3
4
IN
5

RE HIGH TECH

ANTITRUST

EMPLOYEE

No 11 CV2509 LHK

LITIGATION

6
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

7
8

VIDEOTAPED

9

DEPOSITION

San Francisco

10

Tuesday

11
12

June

OF EDWARD

LEAMER

California

11

2013

Volume II

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Reported

by

ASHLEY SOEVYN
22

CSR

23

Job

No
No

12019
1682449

24
25

Pages

477

856

Page
Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

477

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

Filed06 22 13

2

Page48

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

Q

2

1052 50

that means something

that you think

On a weighted

1052 54

basis using all the

in your regression if the contemporary

3

observations

4

variable

5

statistically significant

6

the lag variable 25 percent of the

7

percent of the titles are not positive or

8

statistically significant does that cause

9

concern

variable

for Adobe

MR GLACKIN

11

THE

13
14

BY

MR

1053 00

is positive

12 percent of the time and

time so that

63

1053 06
1053 10

you any

WITNESS

Object

to

1053 13

1053 18

form

I explained

this

before

Yes or

no

I

told you the conclusion that I drew

I

1053 18
1053 19

MITTELSTAEDT

Q
A

1053 02

1053 17

10

12

1052 57

does it cause you any concern

15

from that evidence

16

this set of regression analyses are supportive

17

the implications of this stack

18

referred to before that Adobe

19

setting structure

and that it’s not simply

20

not simply seeing

socalled

21

It’s not

which

is that Adobe

has this
of

of information that I

1053 19
1053 21
1053 23
1053 27
1053 33

salary

1053 35

you’re

has an internal

1053 39

market driven wages

1053 41
1053 46

that

22

Q

23

else you’ve

24

that Adobe’s compensation structure

25

that raises for one or a few

But do those

results along

seen enable you

to

with everything

draw a conclusion
was so

people would

rigid
propagate

1053 46
1053 48
1053 52
1053 57
Page 574

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

2

Filed06 22 13

Page49

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

into raises for all or nearly all of the technical

1054 01

2

employees

1054 04

3

MR GLACKIN

4

THE

WITNESS

over

Object

Well we’ve been through this

5

ground

6

studied

7

we’re making

8

facilitates what allows the

9

in

any individual

bit

throughout the

11

BY

MR

I’ve

And the structure

a reference to

10

is what

not

supports what

the impact
to

of

the

1054 08

1054 15
1054 20
1054 25

propagate

1054 29

firm

1054 30

But I’m asking

Adobe

with respect to

13

these

results for Adobe

14

conclusion that Adobe’s compensation structure

15

so

16

would

17

nearly all of the technical

18

Do

1054 30
1054 38

enable you to draw a

agreements

was

rigid that raises for one or a few employees

1054 40
1054 43

into raises for all or

1054 48

employees absent the

necessarily propagate

1054 51
1054 57

19

MR GLACKIN

20

THE

WITNESS

Object

Well

21

that but perhaps I didn’t

22

done

23

hypothesizes

24

hypothesis

25

to

I’ve

1054 08

1054 12

that

MITTELSTAEDT

Q

12

this ground quite a

anti cold calling conspiracy

the

1054 05

form

to the

not carried
that

to the

form

I thought
My

I answered

point is I’ve

out an analysis which
that explores your

So I do not have an opinion

with regard

1054 58
1055 00
1055 01
1055 04
1055 10
1055 11
1055 13

that specific hypothesis

Page 575
Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

Filed06 22 13

2

Page93

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

coefficients support your

2

theory

1330 10

that

1330 12

A
Q

3
4

I understand

1330 12

you

Thank

What I’m asking

1330 12

is a different question

5

What I’m asking

is if these

6

just barely above

7

consistent with your theory

8

1330 14

coefficients were all

semirigid pay structure

zero would you still say that’s

1330 28

10

threshold is for you to conclude

11

supportive

12

A

1330 35

that it’s

1330 37

Well I’m trying to let you know that these

1330 39

numbers are so far above whatever

14

would

15

a

1330 41

threshold one

want to impose that it is clear that there is

So

you’re asking

response if these

17

my

18

different

19

in

front of

Q

me to guess what

numbers turned out to

It’s very hard to do

you

that

it’s very hard to

1330 44
1330 46

semirigid salary structure here

16

1330 33

sir

of your opinion

13

20

1330 26

that there’s a

I’m trying to get you to tell me what the

9

1330 21

would

be

be

Sitting here

1330 50
1330 52
1330 55
1330 58

guess

Are you saying that as long as the job

1331 01

21

titles have positive coefficients for those

two

1331 04

22

variables as long as they are above zero that

1331 08

23

supports an opinion

1331 13

24

would

25

all or nearly all employees

that a raise to

some individuals

necessarily be transmitted into a raise for

1331 18
1331 24
Page 658

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

Filed06 22 13

2

Page94

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

MR GLACKIN

2

THE

WITNESS

Object

to

1331 27

form

There’s nothing

stated

in my

3

opinion

that I’ve

4

changes

in wages

5

The opinion

6

calling

7

individual but affects a whole collection

8

individuals across

being

9

So

across

is about the existence

the

doesn’t

firm

1331 31

anti cold

1331 34

the

the

of

1331 38

affect any

1331 40

of

1331 43

firm

this structure

1331 28
1331 29

that refers to wages

translated

agreement which

any

that you see here

the structure

1331 44
1331 48

10

estimate

11

that is consistent with the idea that the structure

1331 52

12

facilitates the transfer of the impact

1331 56

13

across

14

BY

MR

the

1331 59

firms

1332 01

What I’m asking

though is if these

were lower and closer to

17

they are consistent with an opinion

18

structure

19

some title would

20

the whole

22
23
24
25

cause

MR

Q
A

a raise in compensation

Object

to

for

1332 05

1332 15
1332 19
1332 21

class

class or nearly all of the

1332 01

1332 10

that the

was rigid enough that a raise for one or

MR GLACKIN
BY

numbers

zero would you still say

16

21

broadly

MITTELSTAEDT

Q

15

coefficients that describe

the

1332 25

form

1332 29

MITTELSTAEDT
Or are you are not

offering that opinion

I’m not offering an opinion about

transmission of specific individual’s

the

salary

1332 29
1332 31
1332 32
Page 659

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

2

Filed06 22 13

Page159

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

substantial

2

Q

3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Do

increases

you know what percentage

A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
Q
A
involved

Q

It

know but

1725 12

relevant to the

1725 13

is

1725 17

What business is Intel

in

1725 18

Intel is a chip maker and manufacturer

1725 20

Right

1725 21

in chip

Right
So

1725 22

design
make software does

It doesn’t

it

Does

it

1725 27

they have software engineers who are
in the

All

design

right

That’s
Do

of

those

They have a whole

bunch of

engineers don’t they

of the total

semiconductors

25

A
Q

1725 31
1725 32
1725 36

you know what percentage

23

1725 27
1725 28

chips

true

class is involved

1725 23
1725 26

I’m sure

22

24

1725 09
1725 11

your San Jose variable

of

hardware and semiconductor

A
Q

1725 05

amount

Is that question

appropriateness

1725 04

of the

Off the top of my head I don’t

it’s a substantial

Q

1725 00

Silicon Valley

technical class is outside

A

5

after 2004 and

in designing and building

1725 36
1725 37
1725 40

I do not know

1725 44

that

Is that relevant

to your choice

of

1725 45
Page 817

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

Filed06 22 13

2

Page160

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

A

2
3

Q
A

yes

first

Q

questions

11

with

I get to ask those

of

Well

I don’t

14

not on target with what I’ve

MR GLACKIN
BY

Q

All

hypothetically

19

variable
of

Object

to

So

let me ask

is it possible that

out there to account

better in your
That’s
So

1726 08

1726 15
1726 15
1726 21

1726 23

you

1726 26

there’s a

for the demands

22

is

that are

form

engineers that might be appropriate

25

with

done but go ahead

21

24

1726 05

1726 12

into

for

or perhaps

even

1726 41

possible

assume hypothetically that there

such a variable

1726 36
1726 40

model

let’s

1726 27
1726 33

the nationwide demand for semiconductor

A
Q

1726 03

1726 23

right

18

23

You’re okay

MR HINMAN

17

20

hypothetical

want to be dragged

hypotheticals that are inconsistent

16

expert

1726 12

13

15

1725 58
1726 00

as an

you

of

1725 53
1725 56

that

A

12

is

hours

now

Hypothetically

you’re familiar with the concept

10

no

possibilities are relevant

All of these

Okay

or

variable

of

but possibilities don’t mean actual

8
9

I’d like to know

1725 48
1725 51

is that

that relevant to your choice

6
7

Well these are all speaking to the same

point which I admit which

4
5

1725 46

variable

And let’s assume that the

1726 43
1726 45
Page 818

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

Filed06 22 13

2

Page164

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

A

1

I didn’t say single most

2

Important enough so that these

3

all the way up to the CEO

4

so

5

And I take

6

conduits

7

having

8

going

9

that the CEOs would

decisions

office

would

go

Important enough

risk antitrust litigation

that to be symptomatic

effect that these

information that they were blocking

of

a big impact
to tolerate

Q

1734 17

important

were

on the firms and they were not

it

into Adobe

11

13
14
15
16

A
Q
A
Q
A

was not a significant

cold calling

senior management

12

event

to Adobe’s

no

Okay

What about

19

Q

Google

of that conduit

And

not to cold

call

and it’s also true isn’t

could

22

it

1734 56

right

25

cold call into Adobe

of

the other defendants

other than

1734 50

1734 54

of information

21

24

1734 42

1734 51

and Apple is a symptom of the

specifically that every one

A
Q

1734 38

1734 49

20

23

1734 33

1734 48

I’m saying

that the agreement

importance

1734 30

1734 47

testimony

I’m

18

1734 27

1734 46

Is that your

between

1734 23

1734 46

No

17

1734 21

1734 36

Are you saying that Google

10

1734 20

1734 59
1735 04

Apple

1735 08
That’s

And every

cold call into

1735 08

correct
one of the other defendants

Intel other than

could

Google right

1735 09
1735 10
Page 827

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

2

Filed06 22 13

Page165

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

A
Q
A
Q
A
Q

1
2
3
4
5
6

Pixar or

In

no

No

1735 17

Okay

1735 19

And so
I

yes

you agree with

1735 19

that

1735 21

agree

And every

single other employer in the

7

world including all

8

than

the other defendants other

of

Pixar could cold call into Lucasfilm right

MR GLACKIN

9

THE

10

WITNESS

11

other channels

12

BY

are

Object

Okay

I stipulated that all these

You testified before

again

15

calling

if you

16

discovery and internal

17

every

day by virtue of every

18

these

other companies

19

in

20

and I’ll

That’s

23

nothing

24

obstructions to these

25

The fact

1735 39
1735 39

of price

1735 42

equity was going

on

each and

call from each one of

1735 45
1735 49

And all of that plays a role

1735 52

of price discovery does

1735 54
1735 58

familiar and I stand

22

in that

want

and the process

process

That sounds

correct

1735 35

that cold

that sound familiar

was occurring

A

1735 29

1735 39

read it to you

21

1735 26

1735 36

open

14

the process

1735 25

1735 34

form

to the

MR HINMAN

Q

13

1735 16

But that does not say

by

that

there’s

statement that says these
conduits were unimportant

that the obstruction occurred

is evidence

1735 59
1736 01
1736 01
1736 06
1736 08
Page 828

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

2

Filed06 22 13

Page166

of

179

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1

that these

MR

2

1736 11

were extremely important

MITTELSTAEDT

In

each respect

3

move to strike that as nonresponsive

4

three questions

5

stay here and insist that the witness answer

6

because

7

take

1736 13

got
to

1736 15

them

1736 18

that I have left and I’m going

time

I’m not going

up any more time with

that

So I

he’s taking

MR GLACKIN
everything

down

and

voices

If

you

know proceed

some lowered

11

that everyone will be happier

12

of

in a more measured

MR HINMAN

Okay

Well

1736 18

with a

1736 18

way

1736 18

I think
a lot

I don’t

mean to

So

16

MR GLACKIN

I lost my place

he

agreed what

18

BY

Give me a

1736 58

second

You just read the part that

19

Q

1737 01

Yeah yeah

the agreements themselves you also understand

21

those

companies

22

every

other way except

24
25

A
Q
There

could

I understand
So

1737 01

that

1737 04

all recruit from each other in
for cold calling

is that

1737 08
1737 13
1737 15

that

let me go back to my question

was a lot of

to

And then also with respect

20

23

1736 58
1736 59

said before in this deposition

MR HINMAN

he

1736 54
1736 58

15

17

1736 40
1736 43

table

that then

convey

1736 18
1736 18

I’m detecting

emotion on the other side of the

13

to

we can just calm

10

14

I’ve

up our

8
9

1736 13

I

then

rain to use your analogy that

1737 19
1737 21
Page 829

Veritext

National

Deposition

866 299 5127

Litigation Services

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document445

2

Filed06 22 13

Page179

of

179

8

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page25

of

63

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page26

of

63

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page27

of

63

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page28

of

63

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page29

of

63

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document538

8

Filed1030 13

Page30

of

63

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538

11

Filed10 30 13

Page24

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page25

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page26

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page27

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page28

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page29

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page30

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page31

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page32

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page33

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page34

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page35

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page36

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page37

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page38

of

41

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document538 11

Filed10

30 13

Page39

of

41

9

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

I

3
4
5

6

Filed1007 13

Page2

of

49

MAYER BROWN LLP
LEE

2

Document516

H

RUBIN SBN 141331
Irubinmayerbrown com

D

EDWARD
JOHNSON SBN 189475
wjohnson mayerbrown com
DONALD
FALK SBN 150256
dfalk mayerbrown com
ERIC
EVANS SBN 232476
eevans mayerbrown com

M

B

Two
6

7

Palo Alto Square Suite 300
3000 El Camino Real
Palo Alto CA 94306 2112
Telephone
650 331 2000
Facsimile
650 331 2061

8
At

9

for

Defendant

Google

10

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

11

NORTHERN

12

OF CALIFORNIA

SAN JOSE DIVISION

13

14

DISTRICT

IN

RE HIGH TECH EMPLOYEE

Master

Docket

No 11 CV2509 LHK

ANTITRUST LITIGATION

DECLARATION OF FRANK WAGNER
IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS

15
THIS

DOCUMENT RELATES TO

OPPOSITION

16

TO PLAINTIFFS

MOTION FOR CLASS

ALL ACTIONS

CERTIFICATION

17
18
19

20
21

I

22

1

Wagner

Frank

I

am Director

23

familiar with Google’s

24

general

25

and

26

I

27
28

if

declare
of Compensation at Google Inc

Google In

that capacity

I

am

compensation including salary bonus and equity as well as Google’s

recruiting practices I

called to testify could

have personal knowledge
and would

testify

of the facts set forth in this Declaration

competently

thereto

EDUCATION AND PROFESSIONAL BACKGROUND

2

I

received

a Bachelor of Science degree in business

administration from the

University of California Berkeley and a Masters in Business Administration in Finance

from

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document516

6

1

was

a Principal

3

was

the

4

H

at

Manager

of

POSITION

3

5

a compensation

Hewitt Associates

Compensation and

Page3

Benefits

consulting firm from 1986 to

at Herbalife

from 1984 to

I

joined Google as the Director

Google

I

2007 and

1985

approximately 25 direct reports As Director of Compensation

7

compensation

8

recognition

9

III

worldwide

Google personnel

Compensation

of

6

manage

I

including base salary

I

have
of

aspects

all

bonus equity and

awards

GOOGLE’S COMPENSATION

4

10
11

In general

ways

that support three

main business objectives

Google

1 attracting

12

in

13

talent

14

interests

15

presentation

16

Google’s compensation

17

presentation

18

practices that Google continues to apply today Attached

19

presentation

20

philosophy and practices

21

benchmarking process

22

2009

23

Google

24

Prior to

AND JOB DUTIES AT GOOGLE

In April 2007

for

49

of

A Haas School of Business

the University of California Berkeley Walter

2

Filed1007 13

2 supporting

to set

delivered

interests

on October

30

I delivered

and

described

compensation

continues

Google’s success

2007

and

Attached

to engineering managers

at

compensation

the world’s

3 aligning
as

in April

that

2009

that also reflects

best

employee

EXHIBIT

Google

philosophy and principles

as

employees

its

A

is

a

that summarizes

philosophy and practices during the period 2005 to

also reflects the broader

which

in

pay

and retaining

Google’s culture of innovation and performance

with shareholder
I

strives to

2009

This

as well as certain

EXHIBIT B

is

another

Google’s compensation

provides additional detail about the overall market

further

below

as well as the general

that

Google used during the period 2005

benchmarking

to apply today

5

25

26
27
28

1

process

and

to

certain practices that

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document516

6

Filed1007 13

Page4

of

49

1

2
3
4
5
6

A

7

6

Base Salary

Benehmarking

8

9
10
11

12

7

13
14
15
16

17

18

19

20
21

22

8

23
24

25

26

27
28

2
DEC

OF FRANK WAGNFR ISO

DIN’S

OPPOSITION

10

moT FOR CLASS CRT
NO 11 CV 2509 LLIK

MASTER DOCKET

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document516

6

Filed1007 13

Page5

of

49

1

2

3
4
5
6
7

9

8

9
10
11

12
13

10

14

There

15

eg

16

Google

17

software

18

example

19

Vice President

20

Software

engineers

Engineer level

sales product

3 that

managers

are spread across

of job codes

at

hundreds of job families such as

engineers

site reliability

the job family of software engineer

are thousands

consists of seven

and

sublevels

financial analysts For

levels

3

to

9 and

the

level

11

21

22

12

23
24

25
26
27
28

When Google

uses the term

internal

equity in

the context of

3
DECL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO DEL’S

OPPOSITION TO

MOT FOR

MASTER DOCKET

NO

I

CLASS CERT
I CV2509 LHK

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

compensation

it

2

based on

3

employee

4

relative to other

5

their

means

Document516

that

performance

that corresponds

Filed1007 13

6

Google employees should

receive

Page6

equitable

and that therefore there should be variation
to each

employee’s

and

performance

of

49

compensation

treatment

in compensation

contribution

to the

for each

company

employees

13

6

7

8
9
10
11

12

14

13

14

15

16
17

15

Merit based

salary adjustments and promotion

18

and are based on an employee’s

19

approximately 2005 and

20

retroactive

21

and any changes

22

promotions

23

to January

to

in

performance

2007 Google

switched

decisions

the compensation

compensation were made prospectively

eligible employees

cycles During

during the previous four quarterly

2006 Google made compensation

rt In

salary adjustments occur annually

in February

that

would be

setting process to the fall

to January

1 Google

also

awards

in the fall and spring

16

24

25

An

26
27

algorithm is depicted

on

the chart

on page 11 of EXHIBIT

example

of this

B

28

4
DECL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DITTS OPPOSITION TO

MOT FOR

MASTER DOCKET

NO

I

CLASS CERT
I CV25094.14K

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document516

Filed1007 13

6

Page7

of

49

1

2

3

4
5

B

1

6

7
8

Bonuses

17

On

Annual Company Bonus
top of base salary an employee’s compensation

also includes

various

potential

cash bonuses

9
10
11

12
13

18

All employees hired on or before December

New

14

annual company bonus

15

January 1 will receive

16

program covers the calendar

17

a

employees

pro rated

incentive

at

that year are eligible for the

ak a Nooglerswho

Google

payment

31 of

to reflect time

year and from 2005 onwards was

are hired after

worked The

annual bonus

paid early in the following

year

19

18
19
20
21

22
23

24

25
26
27
28

5
DECL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DEES OPPOSITION TO MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCKET NO ICV 2509.111K
I

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

1

Document516

6

Filed1007 13

Page8

of

49

20

2

3
4

5
6
7
8

2

9

10

Other Special Bonuses

21

11

12
13

14
15

22

16
17
18
19

20

23

21
22

23
24
25

24

26
27
28

6
DELL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DEFS OPPOSITION TO MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCKET NO ICV 2509 111K
I

Case5 11cv 02509LHK

Document516

1

C
25

A Google employee’s

Filed1007 13

Page9

of

49

Equity

2

6

3

as

Google Stock Units

or

compensation

package

also includes

restricted stock

known

GSUs

4
5

6

i

7
8
9
10
11

12

13

14
15
16

26

17
18

19

27

20
21
22
23

24
25

28

26
27

29

28

7
DECL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCK F NO 1 CV 2509 LHK

I EFS OPPOSITION 10

I

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document516

Filed10 07 13

6

Page10

of

49

1

2

30

3
4
5
6
7

D

Compensation Change

8

31

Google consistently tries

9

in

2011
to

improve and innovate

its

compensation and

total

rewards package

10

1

I

32

12
13

14
15

16

33

17

18

19
20

Google decided
January

1 2011

to raise all

employee

salaries

by

10

effective

I

21
22

23

34

24

25

26
27
28
87
DECI OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DEES OPPOSITION 1 0 MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCKET NO 1 I CV 2509 111K

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document516

6

Filed10 07 13

a

1,000 bonus

Page11

of

49

1

2
3

Google

4

EXHIBIT

C is a

document

also provided

5

as

6

which summarizes Google’s changes

7

to

all

employees

in

2010

Proposal dated November

Attached

8 2010

1 2011
35

8
9
10

related

to the

During the
change

Revised Compensation

titled

to its compensation

latter part of

in Google’s

2010

I

was an

program

that

became

effective

January

active participant in the discussions

compensation practices

During

my participation

in these

discussions

11
12

13

E

14

36

New

Hires

15

16
17
18

19

20
21
22

37

23

24

25

38

26
27
28

9
DECL OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCKET NO I I CV25091 1M

OFFS OPPOSITION TO

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

Document516

1

F
39

When

Page12

of

49

Counteroffers

2

Filed10 07 13

6

3

another

a Google employee

indicates

that

he

or she has

received

an

offer

from

employer

4
5
6

7

8
9
10
11

12
13

14

IV

GOOGLE’S RECRUITING PRACTICES
41

15

16

17
18

19
20

42

21

Since

22

example from 2005

23

in size

The

24

2001

2011

of

to late

is

included

Public Offering

2009

chart that reflects

43

25
26

to

its Initial

the

number

in

2004 Google

of software

has grown significantly

engineers

at

Google more

For

than tripled

Google’s average number of employees per year during the years

as Exhibit

XN 04 to the

Between 2004 and 2011 Google

Expert Report of

aggressively

Dr Kevin Murphy

recruited

and

hired

from hundreds

employers

27
28

10
DECI OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DEES OPPOSITION TO MOT FOR CLASS CERT
MASTER DOCKET NO I I CV2509111K

Case5 11 cv 02509 LHK

1 declare under penalty

1

2

Document516

that the

of

foregoing is true and correct

6

Filed10 07 13

Page13

of

49

perjury under the laws of the United States of America

Executed

on November

9 2012

in

Mountain

View

3 California
4

5

6

7

8
9
10
11

12
13

14

15

16

17
18
19

20
21

22
23
24
25
26

27
28

DM

OF FRANK WAGNER

ISO

DEFT OPPOSITION TO

M

Tri

WW1

MOT

FOR CLASS CERT
CV7 in

PT NI

10

CAND ECF

Page

1

of

79

ADRMOP CONSOLEFilingPRVADR RELATE

US

District

Court

San Jose
511cv 02509 LHK

California Northern District

DOCKET FOR CASE

CIVIL

In

re High Tech Employee

Assigned to

Hon

Lucy

Referred to Magistrate
Relate Case

Case

in

Case

Jury

Judge Paul Singh Grewal

Nature of Suit 442 Civil Rights Jobs

5 12 cv 01262 LHK
Alameda County

other court

05 23 2011
Demand Both

Date Filed

Antitrust Litigation

H Koh

Jurisdiction

Superior

Court

Federal

Question

RG

11574066

Cause 28 1441

Petition

for

Removal

In Re
Attorney

Palm Inc

represented

NonParties

by Benjamin Patrick Smith
Morgan Lewis
Bockius

One Market

LLP

Spear Street Tower

San Francisco

CA

94105

415442 1000
Fax [phone]
Email bpsmith morganlewis
com

LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

Siddharth
individually

Hariharan
and on

behalf

represented
of

all

others

similarly situated

by Anne Brackett Shaver
Lieff Cabraser

Heimann

Bernstein

LLP
275

Battery

Street

29th Floor

San Francisco

CA

94111

415956 1000
Fax [phone]
Email ashaver lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brendan Patrick Glackin
Lieff Cabraser Heimann

Bernstein

LLP
275

Battery

Street

29th Floor

San Francisco
415956 1000

CA 94111 3339

Fax [phone]
Email bglackin lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

2

of

79

Dean Michael Harvey
Heimann

Lieff Cabraser

Bernstein

LLP
275

Battery

Street

29th Floor

CA 94111 3339

San Francisco

415956 1000
Email dharvey lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

L Cramer
PC

Montague

Berger

1622 Locust

Street

PA 19103

Philadelphia

215875 3000
Fax [phone]
Email ecramer bmnet

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

B Fastiff
Heimann

Lieff Cabraser
Bernstein

275

LLP

Battery

Street

29th Floor

CA 94111 3339

San Francisco

415956 1000
Fax [phone]
Email efastiff lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
James Gerard Beebe Dallal
Joseph Saveri

255

Law

Firm

California Street Suite

San Francisco

CA

450

94111

415 500 6800
Email jdallal
saverilawfirmcom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John
Grant

D Radice
Eisenhofer

485 Lexington

PA

Avenue

29th Floor

New York NY 10017
646722 8500
Fax [phone]
TERMINATED 0614 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph Peter Forderer

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Leiff Cabraser

275

Battery

Heimann

3

Bernstein

of

79

LLP

Street

29th Floor

CA 94111 3339

San Francisco

415956 1000
Email jforderer
lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph

R Saveri

Saveri Law Firm
505 Montgomery
Suite

Street

625

CA

San Francisco

94111

415 500 6800
Fax [phone]
Email jsaveri saverilawfirmcom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joshua

P Davis

University

San Francisco School

of

of

Law
2130 Fulton Street
San Francisco CA 94117

415422 6223
Email davisjusfca edu

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

M Lehe

Katherine

Law Foundation of Silicon
Fair Housing Law Project
152

N Third

Valley

St

3rd Floor

San Jose

CA

95112

408280 2458
Fax [phone]
Email

lehe lawfoundation
TERMINATED 0323 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
katherine

Kelly

org

M Dermody

Leiff Cabraser

Heimann

Bernstein

LLP
275

Battery

Street 29th Floor

San Francisco
415956 1000

CA 94111 3339

Fax [phone]
Email kdermody lchb com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

4

of

79

Kevin Edward Rayhill
255

California Street

450
San Francisco
Suite

CA

94111

415 500 6800
Email krayhillsaverilawfirmcom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Linda
Grant

Nussbaum

Phyllis

Eisenhofer

485 Lexington

PA

Avenue

29th Floor

New York NY 10017
646722 8500
Fax [phone]
Email lnussbaum gelaw com

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Janine

Cisneros

Heimann and

Lieff Cabraser
Bernstein

275

LLP

Battery

Street 29th Floor

San Francisco
415956 1000

CA 94111 3339

Email lcisneroslchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Peter
Grant

A Barile

III

Eisenhofer

485 Lexington

PC

Avenue

New York NY 10017
646 722 8500
Fax [phone]
Email pbarile gelaw com

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Richard Martin Heimann
Lieff Cabraser

Heimann

Bernstein

275 Battery Street 30th Floor
San Francisco CA 94111 3339

415956 1000
Email rheimann lchb com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Sarah Rebecca Schalman Bergen
Berger and Montague

1622 Locust
Philadelphia

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

PC

Street

PA 19103

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

5

of

79

215875 3053
Fax [phone]
Email sschalman bergen bmnet

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shanon Jude Carson
Montague
1622 Locust Street
Berger

Philadelphia

PC

PA 19103

215875 4656
Fax [phone]
Email scarson

bmnet

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

Brandon

Marshall

represented

by Anne Brackett Shaver
See above for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brendan Patrick Glackin
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Dean Michael Harvey
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

L Cramer

See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

B Fastiff

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
James Gerard Beebe Dallal
See above for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John

D Radice

See above

for address

TERMINATED 0614 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph Peter Forderer
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Joseph

6

of

79

R Saveri

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joshua

P Davis

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Katherine

See above

M Lehe
for address

TERMINATED 0323 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kelly

M Dermody

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kevin Edward Rayhill
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Linda

Phyllis

See above

Nussbaum

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Janine

Cisneros

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Peter

A Barile

See above

III

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Richard Martin Heimann
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Sarah Rebecca Schalman Bergen
See above for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shanon Jude Carson
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Michael Devine

represented

7

of

79

by Anne Brackett Shaver
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brendan Patrick Glackin
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Dean Michael Harvey
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

L Cramer

See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

B Fastiff

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
James Gerard Beebe Dallal
See above for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John

D Radice

See above

for address

TERMINATED 0614 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph Peter Forderer
See above for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph

R Saveri

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joshua

P Davis

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Katherine

See above

M Lehe
for address

TERMINATED 0323 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kelly

M Dermody

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

8

of

79

Kevin Edward Rayhill
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Linda

Phyllis

See above

Nussbaum

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Janine

Cisneros

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Jennifer Leebove
Joseph Saveri

255

Law

Firm

California Street

Suite

450

San Francisco

CA

94111

415 500 6800

Fax 415

500 6803

Email lleebove saverilawfirmcom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Peter

A Barile

See above

III

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Richard Martin Heimann
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Sarah Rebecca Schalman Bergen
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shanon Jude Carson
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

Mark

Fichtner

represented

by Anne Brackett Shaver
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brendan Patrick Glackin
See above for address

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

9

of

79

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Dean Michael Harvey
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

L Cramer

See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

B Fastiff

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
James Gerard Beebe Dallal
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John

D Radice

See above

for address

TERMINATED 0614 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph Peter Forderer
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph

R Saveri

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joshua

P Davis

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Katherine

See above

M Lehe
for address

TERMINATED 0323 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kelly

M Dermody

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kevin Edward Rayhill
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Linda

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

Phyllis

L1 01

Nussbaum

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

See above

10

of

79

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Janine

Cisneros

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Peter

A Barile

See above

III

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Richard Martin Heimann
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Sarah Rebecca Schalman Bergen
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shanon Jude Carson
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

Daniel Stover

represented

by Anne Brackett Shaver
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brendan Patrick Glackin
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Dean Michael Harvey
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

L Cramer

See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric

B Fastiff

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
James Gerard Beebe Dallal

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

See above

11

of

79

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John

D Radice

See above

for address

TERMINATED 0614 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph Peter Forderer
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Joseph

R Saveri

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

P

Joshua
Davis
See above for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Katherine

See above

M Lehe
for address

TERMINATED 0323 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kelly

M Dermody

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Kevin Edward Rayhill
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Linda

Phyllis

See above

Nussbaum

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Lisa Janine

Cisneros

See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Peter

A Barile

See above

III

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Richard Martin Heimann
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

12

of

79

Sarah Rebecca Schalman Bergen
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shanon Jude Carson
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Plaintiff

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

represented

by Anna Tryon Pletcher
Department

of Justice

Antitrust Division

450 Golden Gate Avenue
Box 36046

Room 10 0101

CA

San Francisco

94102

415436 6727
Fax [phone]
Email annapletcher usdoj gov

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

V
Defendant

Adobe Systems Inc

represented

by Robert Addy

Van

Nest

Keker
Van Nest LLP
633 Battery Street
San Francisco

CA 94111 1809

415391 5400
Fax [phone]
Email rvannest kvn com

LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Craig Andrew
Jones

555

Waldman

Day

California Street

26th Floor

San Francisco

CA

94104

415626 3939
Fax [phone]
Email cwaldman jonesday com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
David Craig Kiernan
Jones

555

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

Day

California Street 26th Floor

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

San Francisco

CA

13

of

79

94104

415 626 3939
Fax [phone]
Email dkiernanjonesday com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Robert Allan Mittelstaedt
Jones

555

Day

California Street 26th Floor

San Francisco CA 94104
415 626 3939

Fax [phone]
Email ramittelstaedt jonesday com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

W Kahn

Lin

Jones

555

Day

California Street 26th Floor

San Francisco

CA

94104

415 875 5844
Fax [phone]
Email linkahn jonesday com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant
Apple Inc

represented

by George

A Riley
Myers LLP

O’Melveny
2 Embarcadero

Center

28th Floor

San Francisco
415984 8741

CA

94111

Fax [phone]
Email griley
ommcom

LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Robert Addy
See above

Van

Nest

for address

LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Amanda

R Conley

O’Melveny and Myers

Two

Embarcadero

Center

28th Floor

San Francisco
415984 8829

CA

Email aconley

94111

ommcom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Two

79

Myers
Center 28th Floor

Embarcadero

San Francisco

of

Brown

Christina Joanne

O’Melveny

14

CA 94111 3823

415984 8979
Fax [phone]
Email cjbrownomm
com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

F Vigo
O’Melveny
Myers LLP
Flora

Two

Embarcadero

Center

28th Floor

San Francisco

CA

94111

415.984.8700

Fax [phone]
Email fvigo omm
com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
George Riley
O’Melveny Myers

LLP

Two

Center

Embarcadero

28th Floor

San Francisco
415984 8741

CA 94111 3823

Fax [phone]
Email griley
ommcom

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Michael Frederick Tubach
O’Melveny
Myers LLP

Two

Embarcadero

Center

28th Floor

San Francisco

CA 94111 3305

415984 8700
Fax [phone]
Email mtubach omm
com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant
Google Inc

represented

by Anne

M Selin

Mayer Brown

Two
Suite

LLP

Palo Alto Square

300

3000 El Camino Real
Palo Alto CA 94306

650331 2000
Fax [phone]
Email aselin
mayerbrown com

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

15

of

79

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Daniel

Keker
633

Edward Purcell
Van Nest LLP

Battery

Street

San Francisco

CA 94111 1809

415391 5400
Fax [phone]
Email dpurcell kvn com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Donald

M

Falk

Mayer Brown

Two

LLP

Palo Alto Square

Suite

300

Palo Alto

CA 94306 2112

650331 2030
Fax [phone]
Email dfalkmayerbrown com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

D

Edward
Johnson
Mayer Brown LLP

Two

Palo Alto Square

Suite

300

Palo Alto

CA 94306 2112

650331 2000
Fax [phone]
Email wjohnsonmayerbrown com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eric Evans

Mayer Brown

Two

LLP

Palo Alto Square Suite 300

3000 El Camino Real
Palo Alto

CA 94306 2112

650331 2000
Fax [phone]
Email eevans mayerbrown com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eugene Morris Paige
Keker
633

Van

Battery

Nest

LLP

Street

San Francisco
415391 5400

CA 94111 1809

Fax [phone]
Email

EMP kvn com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Justina

Keker

16

of

79

Kahn Sessions
Van Nest LLP

633 Battery Street
San Francisco CA 94111

415391 5400
Fax [phone]
Email jsessions kvn com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

H

Lee
Rubin
Mayer Brown

Two
Suite

LLP

Palo Alto Square

300

Palo Alto

CA 94306 2112

650331 2000
Fax [phone]
Email lrubinmayerbrown com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Van

Robert Addy
See above

Nest

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant
Intel

Corp

represented

P

by Gregory
Stone
Munger Tolles
Olson

LLP

355 South Grand Avenue
35th Floor

Los Angeles

CA 90071 1560

213683 9100
Fax [phone]
Email gregory stonemtocom
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Robert Addy
See above

Van

Nest

for address

LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Angela Marie

Munoz

Bingham McCutchen
3 Embarcadero

Center

SF CA 94111
415393 2370
Fax [phone]
Email angelamunoz bingham com

TERMINATED 0426 2012
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

355

of

79

S Phillips

Bradley
Munger

17

Olson

Tolles

LLP

S Grand Avenue

35th Floor

Los Angeles

CA 90071 1569

213683 9100
Fax [phone]
mtocom
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Email phillipsbs

Donn

P Pickett

Bingham McCutchen
Three Embarcadero

LLP
Center

CA 94111 4067

San Francisco

415393 2000
Fax [phone]
Email donn pickett bingham com
TERMINATED 1020 2013

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

H Busch

Frank

Bingham McCutchen
Three Embarcadero

San Francisco
United

Center

Ca 94111

Sta

415393 2074
Fax [phone]
Email frank busch bingham com
TERMINATED 1020 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Frank Hinman
Bingham McCutchen

CA

San Francisco

LLP
Center 18th Floor

Three Embarcadero

94111

415393 2462
Fax [phone]
Email frank hinman bingham com
TERMINATED 1020 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Gregory
Munger

M Sergi

Tolles

Olson

LLP

355 South Grand Avenue
3500
Los Angeles
Suite

CA 90071

213683 9100
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Holly

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

A House

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

of

79

LLP

Paul Hastings

55 Second

18

Street

Twenty Fourth

Floor

San Francisco

CA

94105

415856 7217
Fax [phone]
Email hollyhouse paulhastings com

TERMINATED 0927 2011
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John P

Mittelbach

Munger
355

Tolles

Olson

LLP

S Grand Ave

35th Floor

Los Angeles

CA 90071

213683 9166
Email john mittelbach mtocom

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Shah

Sujal

LLP

Bingham McCutchen
Three Embarcadero

San Francisco

Center

CA 94111 4067

415 393 2955
Fax [phone]
Email sujalshah bingham com

TERMINATED 1020 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Zachary

J Alinder

Bingham McCutchen
Three Embarcadero

San Francisco

CA

LLP

Center

94111

415 393 2226
Fax [phone]
Email zacharyalinder bingham com
TERMINATED 0426 2012

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Krystal

N Bowen

Bingham McCutchen
Three Embarcadero

San Francisco

CA

Center

94611

415393 2760
Fax [phone]
Email

krystal

bowen

bingham com

TERMINATED 1020 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Intuit

Page

Inc

represented

19

of

79

by Catherine Tara Zeng
Jones

Day

1755 Embarcadero
Rd
Palo Alto CA 94303

650739 3939
Fax [phone]
Email czeng jonesday com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Craig Ellsworth Stewart
Jones

555

Day

California Street 26th Floor

San Francisco

CA

94104

415 626 3939
Fax [phone]
Email cestewart jonesday com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
David Craig Kiernan
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Robert Allan Mittelstaedt
See above

for address

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant
Lucasfilm

Ltd

represented

by Chinue Turner Richardson
1201 Pennsylvania Ave
Washington
United

DC

NW

20004

Sta

202662 5766
Fax [phone]
Email crichardson cov com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Cody Shawn Harris
Keker and Van Nest LLP
633 Battery Street
San Francisco CA 94111 1809

415391 5400
Fax [phone]
Email charris kvn com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Daniel

Edward

See above

Purcell

for address

TERMINATED 0724 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

20

of

79

A Garza

Deborah
Covington

and Burling

LLP

1201 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington DC 20004

NW

202662 5146
Fax [phone]
Email dgarza cov com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Emily Johnson Henn
Covington

Burling

333 Twin Dolphin
Suite

LLP

Drive

700

Redwood Shores

CA

94065

650632 4700
Email

ehenn cov com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Eugene Morris Paige
See above

for address

TERMINATED 0724 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John Watkins Keker
Keker
Van Nest LLP
633

Battery

Street

San Francisco
415391 5400

CA 94111 1809

Fax [phone]
Email

jwk kvn com

TERMINATED 0724 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
John

W

Nields

Covington

Jr

and Burling

LLC

1201 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington DC 20004

NW

202662 5058
Email jnields cov com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Justina

Kahn

See above

Sessions

for address

TERMINATED 0724 2013
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Paula Lenore Blizzard
Keker
633

Van

Battery

San Francisco

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

Nest

LLP

Street

L1 01

CA

94111

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

21

of

79

415 391 5400
Fax [phone]
Email

plbkvn com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Thomas

A Isaacson

Covington

Burling

LLP

3600
1201 Pennsylvania Avenue

NW

Washington DC 20004
202783 0800

Fax [phone]
Email tisaacson cov com

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Defendant
Pixar

represented

by Robert

T Haslam

Covington

Burling

333 Twin Dolphin
Suite

III

LLP

Drive

700

Redwood Shores

CA

94065

650 632 4702
Fax [phone]
Email rhaslamcov com

TERMINATED 0514 2013
LEAD ATTORNEY
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Chinue Turner Richardson
See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Deborah
Covington

A Garza
and Burling

LLP

1201 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington

DC

NW

20004

202662 5146
Fax [phone]
Email dgarza cov com

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Emily Johnson Henn
Covington

Burling

333 Twin Dolphin
Suite 700

Redwood Shores

LLP

Drive

CA

94065

650632 4700
Email

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

ehenn cov com

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

22

of

79

ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

W

John

Jr

Nields

See above

for address

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

A D Herczeg

Jonathan
Convington

LLP

Burling

NW

1201 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington DC 20004

202662 5052
Fax
Email jherczeg cov com

TERMINATED 1121 2012

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Thomas

A Isaacson

Howrey LLP
3600

NW

1299 Pennsylvania Avenue
Washington DC 20004

202783 0800
Fax [phone]
Email tisaacson cov com

PRO HAC VICE
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED

Date Filed

0523 2011

Docket Text
1

JOINT NOTICE

OF REMOVAL

from Alameda County
Filing fee

Apple Inc

of Action from State

Court Their

Superior

350.00 receipt number
Intuit

Inc Adobe

0523 2011

2

Declaration

of

Cody

Harris

in

Inc

Sheet

Pixar Google

gba

s1

is

RG11574066

gba

Corp

Intel

Inc

Lucasfilm

COURT STAFF

Support of 1 Notice of Removal

County Superior Court Complaint attach
Related document

number

case

34611060153 Filed by

Systems

Ltd Attachments
1 Civil Cover
5 23 2011 Entered 0524 2011

Court No Process

by Lucasfilm

filed

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

Filed

on

Alameda

Ltd

5 23 2011

Entered 0524 2011

0523 2011

3

Declaration

Lucasfilm

5 23 2011
0523 2011

4

of David

Ltd

Rhonda

of

Lucasfilm

https ecf cand

in

Support of 1 Notice of

s1

gba

Removal filed by

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

Entered 0524 2011

Declaration

Ltd

5 23 2011

Anderman

Related document

Hjort

in Support of

Related document

s1

1 Notice

gba

of

Removal filed by

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

Entered 0524 2011

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0523 2011

5

on
6

5 23 2011

Declaration

of Joel Pdolyny
Related

in Support of

document s 1
Entered 0524 2011

Declaration

of

Google Inc

Tadhg Bourke

8

s1

Related document

Declaration

of

M

James
Kennedy
document s 1

Related

5 23 2011
9

Declaration

of Debbie

on
10

by

11

Intel

12

13

on

14

15

16

on

NOTICE of

Filed

on

on

on

on

of

Removal

COURT STAFF

Filed

COURT STAFF
gba

COURT
gba

Entered 05 24 2011

gba

COURT

05 24 2011

COURT

gba

Inc

Intuit

05 24 2011

Statement by Pixar

gba

COURT STAFF

Entered 05 24 2011
Case Management Statement due by
set

9 22011

for

gba

Floor San Francisco

Declaration

Ltd

524 2011

NOTICE of

of

Cody

01 30

PM in

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

on

524 2011

Other 15

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

gba

COURT STAFF

in Support of

Harris

s1

1 Notice

gba

of

Filed

on

Removal

COURT STAFF

Entered 05 26 2011

Corporate Disclosure

Filed

Filing

Related document

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
14 Notice

gba

05 24 2011

Management Conference

by Lucasfilm

STAFF

https ecf cand

Removal filed
Filed

Entered 0524 2011

AMENDED
Filed

20

of

1 Notice

in Support of

s1

Statement by

Entered

ADR SCHEDULING ORDER

filed

0524 2011

1 Notice

COURT STAFF

Statement by Google Inc

Entered

CASE DESIGNATED for Electronic
5 23 2011 Entered 0524 2011

19

on

Filed

Statement by Adobe Systems Inc

Corporate Disclosure

523 2011

5 23 2011

18

COURT STAFF

Statement by Apple Inc

523 2011

523 2011

A 15th

0524 2011

on

523 2011

Courtroom

0524 2011

gba

Entered

Corporate Disclosure

Filed

NOTICE of
on

523 2011

Corporate Disclosure

Filed

8 26 2011 Case

0523 2011

Removal filed by

of

by Lucasfilm Ltd gba

Corporate Disclosure

NOTICE of

Filed

0523 2011

on

Filed

Entered 05 24 2011

Corporate Disclosure

Filed

NOTICE of

STAFF
0523 2011

1 Notice

in Support of

R OldhamAuker

523 2011

NOTICE of

STAFF
0523 2011

Removal filed by

Entered 0524 2011

COURT STAFF
0523 2011

of

COURT STAFF

gba

Related document

Certificate of Interested Entities

STAFF
0523 2011

Corp

5 23 2011

Filed

0523 2011

Filed

Entered 0524 2011

filed

0523 2011

COURT STAFF

Entered 0524 2011

by Pixar

0523 2011

gba

1 Notice

in Support of

5 23 2011
0523 2011

79

Removal filed by

of

gba

of

Entered 0524 2011

5 23 2011
7

s1

Related document

Apple Inc

0523 2011

1 Notice

of Jack Gilmore in Support of

Declaration

Adobe Systems Inc

0523 2011

23

Page

Notice

Statement by

Entered

Intel

Corp gba

COURT

05 26 2011

by Lucasfilm Ltd

Other 11

pl452253614062028

Notice

re

7

Declaration

Other 6

L1 01

in

Declaration

Support
in

11 62013

CAND ECF

Support 1 Notice

of

Removal 10

Declaration

in
in

Support 9

Notice

Other 2

Filed

on

in

17

524 2011

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

STIPULATION

Inc

Systems

22

by Lucasfilm Ltd

23

to Proceed

Harvey

24

6 111
25

on

on

531 2011

assigned

as COURT

MOTION for leave
fee

275

receipt

5 27 2011

STAFF

case
on

Filed

to appear in Pro

to

526 2011

by

Entered

Siddharth

US

klhS

District Judge

to Judge

Hon

Hac Vice

number 44611007160

for

Committee on

06 01 2011

Entered

A Garza

Deborah

Filing

by Pixar Attachments

filed

Filed

Saundra

Judge Magistrate Judge Joseph

Signed by Executive

6 12011

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

Proposed

Corp Intuit

Entered 0527 2011

Case reassigned

to the

by Adobe
Intel

Entered 05 31 2011

for all further proceedings

no longer

on

Filed

in

524 2011

on

Hariharan

Reassignment

ORDER REASSIGNING CASE

C Spero

Declaration

Filed

US Magistrate Judge

Filed

Impending

Filed

Brown Armstrong

0616 2011

Before a

Dean

CLERK’S NOTICE of

COURT STAFF
0601 2011

18

re

COURT STAFF

Inc Google Inc Siddharth
Ltd Pixar Tubach Michael

Declination

3

Support 5

Extending Time To Respond To Complaint

Hariharan

0531 2011

in

Entered 05 26 2011

Apple

Inc Lucasfilm
05 26 2011
0527 2011

Declaration

79

in Support 8 Declaration
in Support 13
Support 16 ADR Scheduling Order gba

Support 19 Notice Other gba
Entered 0526 2011

0526 2011

Other 4

of

Declaration

Declaration

COURT STAFF
21

Certificate of Interested Entities

Support 12 Notice

Declaration

0524 2011

24

Page

on

616 2011

1

Entered

06 17 2011
0616 2011

26

MOTION for leave
fee

275

Proposed

receipt

to appear in Pro

Hac Vice

number 44611007160

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

for Jonathan Herczeg

by Pixar Attachments

filed

Filed

Filing

on

616 2011

1

Entered

06 17 2011
0620 2011

27

CASE MANAGEMENT SCHEDULING ORDER Case Management
Conference set for 915 2011 03 00 PM via Telephone Signed by Judge
Saundra Brown Armstrong on 6 2011 lrc COURT STAFF Filed on
6 20 2011 Modified on 6 21 2011 jlm COURT STAFF Entered
06 20 2011

0621 2011

28

ORDER
Hac Vice

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong
for

Deborah

A Garza

jlm COURT

GRANTING

STAFF

25 Motion

Filed

on

for Pro

621 2011

Entered 0623 2011

0621 2011

29

ORDER
Hac

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong

Vice for Jonathan Herczeg

jlm COURT

GRANTING

STAFF

26 Motion

Filed

on

for Pro

621 2011

Entered 0623 2011

0628 2011

30

NOTICE of
Removal

filed

Modified on

https ecf cand

Filing of Declaration

by Lucasfilm

630 2011

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Ltd

of

Kumud Kokal

Purcell Daniel

jlm COURT

STAFF

pl452253614062028

in

Support re 1 Notice of

Filed

on

628 2011

Entered 0628 2011

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0628 2011

25

Page

31

of Daniel Purcell

Declaration

Ltd

Lucasfilm

6 28 2011

in Support re

Modified on

1 Notice

Removal

of

1 Exhibit Purcell Daniel

Attachments

6 30 2011

jlm COURT

filed

79

by

on

Filed

STAFF

of

Entered

06 28 2011
0629 2011

32

NOTICE of

Pendency of other Actions or Proceedings filed by Siddharth
Harvey Dean Filed on
29 2011 Modified on 630 2011 jlm

6

Hariharan

COURT STAFF
0629 2011

33

Declaration

of

Entered 0629 2011

M Harvey

Dean

Actions

or Proceedings

Exhibit

A

2

6 29 2011

Exhibit

by

filed

B

in Support of

Modified on

s 32

document

Related

6 30 2011

32 Notice

Hariharan

Siddharth

jlm COURT

Pendency

of

of Other

1

Attachments

Harvey

STAFF

Dean

Filed

on

Entered

06 29 2011
0630 2011

34

35

630 2011

on

Filed

0630 2011

Second NOTICE

of

7 12011
36

Pendency
Harvey

jlm COURT

Declaration

of

1

Exhibit

0706 2011

37

receipt

Attachments

on 630 2011
06 30 2011

Filed

Entered

in Support of

s

jlm COURT

Modified on

35 Second Notice

of

Pendency

by Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments
35
Harvey Dean Filed on 630 2011

to appear in Pro

STAFF

Entered 0630 2011

Hac Vice

number 34611061838

for John

D Radice

Filing fee

by Siddharth Hariharan

filed

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

1 Proposed

by

filed

filed

Related document

71 2011

MOTION for leave
275

Dean

STAFF

or Proceedings

A

Modified on

Dean

Harvey

of Other Actions or Proceedings

M Harvey

Dean

of Other Actions

Hariharan

Siddharth

Entered 06 30 2011

Siddharth Hariharan

0630 2011

by

Certificate of Interested Entities

Filed

on

7 62011

Entered 0708 2011

0706 2011

38

MOTION for leave
fee

275

receipt

Attachments

to appear in Pro

Hac Vice

number 34611061839

for Linda

filed

P Nussbaum

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

1 Proposed

Filing

by Siddharth Hariharan
Filed

on

7 62011

Entered 0708 2011

0713 2011

39

ORDER

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong

D

Hac Vice for John
Radice
Entered 0714 2011

0713 2011

40

ORDER
Hac Vice

jlm COURT

GRANTING

STAFF

Filed

37 Motion
on

for Pro

713 2011

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong GRANTING 38 Motion for Pro
for Linda
Nussbaum jlm COURT STAFF Filed on 713 2011

P

Entered 0714 2011

0719 2011

41

0719 2011

42

MOTION to Relate Cases C11 3539 HRL C11 3538 HRL C11 3540
PSG C11 3541PSG filed by Intuit Inc Broderick Catherine Filed on
7 19 2011 Modified on 7 20 2011 jlm COURT STAFF Entered
07 19 2011
of Catherine

Declaration

Cases
Filed

filed

on

by

Inc

Intuit

719 2011

T

Broderick

in

Support of 41 Motion to Relate

Related document

Modified on

7 20 2011

s 41

Broderick

jlm COURT

Catherine

STAFF

Entered 0719 2011

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0719 2011

43

EXHIBITS
Intuit

42 Declaration

to

Inc

Exhibit

C

4

Exhibit

Catherine

Filed

Exhibit

COURT STAFF

0720 2011

44

45

1

Attachments

Broderick

0720 2011

26

Page

in Support of Catherine
Exhibit

D

Exhibit

of

Relate Cases

B

Exhibit

Broderick

filed

B

Exhibit

s 42
720 2011

by
3

jlm

Entered 0719 2011

M Harvey

Dean

by

filed

3

7 20 2011

T

Exhibit

Modified on

RESPONSE re 41 Motion to Relate Cases filed
Harvey Dean Filed on 7 20 2011 Modified
STAFF Entered 0720 2011
Declaration

2

79

Related document

7 19 2011

on

A

Exhibit

of

Exhibit

C

Hariharan

7 21 2011

s 44

jlm COURT

jlm COURT

to

Motion to

1

Attachments

Related document

Modified on

Hariharan

Siddharth

721 2011

44 Response

in Support of

Siddharth

by
on

Dean

Harvey

STAFF

A

2

Filed

on

Exhibit

Entered

07 20 2011
0720 2011

46

Proposed

Order

Modified on

0720 2011

47

48

35 Notice

721 2011

of Pendency

Catherine

Filed

by
on

Dean

STAFF
Inc

Intuit

41 MOTION to Relate Case
Entered 0720 2011

Extending Time to Respond to Complaint filed by Apple
Adobe Systems Inc Siddharth Hariharan Lucasfilm Ltd Google Inc

MOTION for leave
275

Filing fee

Hariharan

on
50

275

Filed

number 44611007340
1 Proposed

filed

ORDER

to appear in Pro

Bergen

Siddharth

Hac Vice
filed

for

Filed

Shanon J Carson

Filing

by Siddharth Hariharan

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

Filed

L

on

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

Filed

Filing fee

on

Entered 0726 2011

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong

GRANTING

41 Motion

to

C113539 HRL C113538 HRL C113540 PSG C11

3541 PSG Signed by

Judge Saundra

Brown Armstrong on

COURT STAFF Filed on 7 27 2011
STAFF Entered 0727 2011
Hac

by

to appear in Pro Hac Vice for Eric
Cramer
number 44611007340 filed by Siddharth Hariharan

1 Proposed

Relate Cases

ORDER

R Schalman

Order
jlm COURT STAFF

number 44611007340

1 Proposed

receipt

7 26 2011

53

for Sarah

Entered 0726 2011

Attachments

0728 2011

Entered 0722 2011

MOTION for leave
275

52

Hac Vice

722 2011

on

Entered 0726 2011

receipt

7 26 2011

0727 2011

receipt

MOTION for leave
Attachments

51

to appear in Pro

Attachments

7 26 2011

fee

0726 2011

720 2011

re

7 20 2011

Corp Intuit Inc Pixar Tubach Michael
Modified on 725 2011 jlm COURT STAFF

0726 2011

on

Entered 0720 2011

Intel

49

Filed

STIPULATION

Inc

0726 2011

or

of other Actions

Harvey

jlm COURT

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Broderick

0722 2011

32

re

by Siddharth Hariharan

Proceedings

Modified on

07 25 11 lrc
jlm COURT

728 2011

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong GRANTING 51 Motion for Pro
Cramer jlm COURT STAFF Filed on 728 2011

Vice for Eric

L

Entered 0728 2011

0728 2011

https ecf cand

54

ORDER

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

GRANTING

L1 01

50 Motion

for Pro

11 62013

CAND ECF

27

Page

Hac Vice

J Carson

Shanon

for

jlm COURT

STAFF

Filed

on

of

79

728 2011

Entered 0728 2011

0728 2011

55

ORDER
Hac

7 28 2011
0802 2011

56

Fastiff Eric

of Eric

San Jose

STAFF
58

49 Motion

STAFF

88 2011

82 2011

1 Proposed

Attachments

Modified on

8 32011

on

Order

jlm COURT

B

Division

on

Filed

in Support of 56 Motion to Transfer
Actions
to
by Siddharth Hariharan
Related document s 56

Fastiff
filed

82 2011

Modified on

8 32011

jlm COURT

Entered 0802 2011

ORDER That case numbers C11 2509 SBA C11 3538 SBA
SBA C11 3540SBA and C11 3541 SBA be TRANSFERRED
Jose Division

35 Notice and 56 Motion to

re

7 2811

C113539
San

to the

Case Signed by Judge

Transfer

COURT STAFF Filed
jlm COURT STAFF Entered

Brown Armstrong on
42011 Modified on 852011

Saundra

8

for Pro

Filed

by Siddharth

the San Jose Division filed

to

due by

on

Filed

Fastiff Eric

0804 2011

jlm COURT

Bergen

Entered 0802 2011

Declaration
the

Case

Transfer

Responses

STAFF
57

R Schalman

Entered 0728 2011

MOTION to
Hariharan

0802 2011

GRANTING

by Judge Saundra Brown Armstrong

Vice for Sarah

lrc

on

08 04 2011
0805 2011

59

NOTICE of

0805 2011

60

Change

by Daniel Edward

08 05 2011

to the

Purcell

Purcell Daniel

to Judge

Hon

08 05 2011

for all further proceedings

longer assigned

61

Entered

ORDER REASSIGNING CASE
Koh

0808 2011

of Address

85 2011

on

Filed

Case reassigned

Judge

H

Lucy

Hon Saundra Brown Armstrong

no

case Signed by The Executive Committee on

jlm COURT

STAFF

Filed

on

8 52011

Entered 0805 2011

CLERKS NOTICE SETTING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
AFTER REASSIGNMENT Case Management Statement due by 10 19 2011
Case Management Conference set for 1026 2011 02 00 PM in Courtroom8

mpb COURT STAFF

4th Floor San Jose

Filed

on

882011

Entered

08 08 2011
0808 2011

62

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Case Management

Regarding

California San Jose Division

by Siddharth Hariharan of Standing Order
For The Northern District Of

In Civil Cases

Harvey

Dean

Filed

on

8 82011

Entered

08 08 2011
0811 2011

Case Assigned
matters

0906 2011

63

tsh

Proposed

to

Magistrate Judge Howard

COURT STAFF

Pretrial

Order

Siddharth Hariharan

Inc

0912 2011

64

Pretrial

re

21

Order

on

R Lloyd

811 2011

for all discovery

Entered 08 11 2011

Systems Inc Intel Corp
Ltd Google Inc Apple Inc Intuit
962011 Entered 09 06 2011

Number 1 by Adobe

Pixar Lucasfilm

Harvey Dean

ORDER

Filed

Filed

on

511 cv 03541 LHK Adopting as modified Proposed
No 1 Signed by Judge Koh on 912 2011 Case Numbers 11
in

CV3538 11CV3539 11CV3540
CONSOLIDATED

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

under

and 11 CV3541 are hereby
MASTER FILE No 11 CV2509 LHK

pl452253614062028

L1 01

All

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

docket entries regarding
Master File Number

cases

of the consolidated
notation

in

the Consolidated Action shall

11 CV 2509
it

a document

If

on

will be docketed

the Master

number s to

the docket text as to the case

be docketed

COURT STAFF Filed on 912 2011 Modified
dhm COURT STAFF Entered 09 12 2011
lhklc3

0913 2011

65

AMENDED COMPLAINT

Corp Intuit Inc

bySiddharth Hariharan

Saveri Joseph

or

some

with the

pertains

it

text

79

913 2011

on

Adobe Systems Inc Apple

Consolidated against

Intel

Inc Google Inc

Docket

which

of

under

one

pertains to only

28

Ltd Pixar Filed
913 2011 Entered

Lucasfilm
Filed

on

09 13 2011
0922 2011

66

MOTION for Leave to File DEFENDANT LUCASFILM LTD S MOTION
FOR ADMINISTRATIVE RELIEF REQUESTING LEAVE TO FILE A
SEPARATE MOTION TO DISMISS DECLARATION OF DANIEL
PURCELL IN SUPPORT filed
Order
Purcell Daniel Filed

0926 2011

67

OPPOSITION

to File a Separate

Opposition

66

to

by Lucasfilm
on

922 2011

MOTION for

Motion to Dismiss

68

NOTICE of

Intel

Order by
for Leave

Hon Lucy

H Koh

Filelhklc1

to

Requesting Leave

Relief

Declaration

of Eric

Dean

B

Fastiff in

in

substituting

Hinman Frank

Corporation

granting

on 926 2011
Entered 09 26 2011

Filed

STAFF

by Frank Hinman

of Counsel

Substitution

A House as counsel for
9 27 2011 Entered 0927 2011
69

Entered 09 22 2011

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

filed

Holly

0928 2011

1 Proposed

Attachments

Administrative

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Harvey
Modified text on 927 2011 dhm COURT

0927 2011

Ltd

part and denying

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

part

in

928 2011

in for
Filed

on

66 Motion
Entered

09 28 2011
1004 2011

70

ADR

1004 2011

71

ADR

Filed

72

ADR
Dean

1005 2011

73

ADR

74

ADR

Filed

1012 2011

75

ADR

on

ADR

options

Kiernan

ADR L R 3 5 b of discussion of ADR options
Filed on 10 42011 Entered 1004 2011

ADR L R 3 5 b of discussion
10 52011 Entered 1005 2011

Certification
Filed

on

Certification

Michael

of

Catherine

Certification

Zachary

1006 2011

on

Certification

Broderick

1005 2011

ADR L R 3 5 b of discussion
10 42011 Entered 10 04 2011

Certification

David

Filed

on

ADR

ADR L R 3 5 b of discussion of ADR
105 2011 Entered 10 05 2011
ADR L R 3 5 b of discussion of ADR
10 62011 Entered 10 06 2011

Certification

and Kennedy

of

ADR L R 3 5 b

for Pixar

of discussion

Henn Emily

Filed

on

of

ADR

options

Harvey

options

Alinder

options

Tubach

options

by Henn

1012 2011

Entered

10 12 2011
1013 2011

https ecf cand

76

DISCOVERY DISPUTE JOINT REPORT 1 by Adobe Systems
Inc Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan Intel Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Statement

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Daniel Stover Saveri Joseph

1013 2011

77

MOTION to

1 19 2012

Dismiss

09 00

Daniel
78

on

Filed

Proposed

Order

Ltd

by Lucasfilm

filed

10 13 2011

on

Filed

AM in Courtroom8 4th

H Koh Responses
1013 2011

due by

1027 2011

10 13 2011

Motion Hearing

79

MOTION to

set

due by

Hon Lucy
11 32011 Purcell
Ltd

Modified on

for

1 19 2012

for

set

10 13 2011

Entered

Dismiss Consolidated Amended

Motion Hearing

79

Floor San Jose before

Replies

77 Motion to Dismiss by Lucasfilm

re

10 13 2011

of

Entered 1013 2011

10 14 2011 linking
dhm COURT STAFF Entered 10 13 2011
on

Filed

1013 2011

29

Page

Complaint

PM in

01 30

H Koh Responses

Purcell Daniel

entry to

document

77

by Apple Inc

filed

Courtroom8

4th Floor

San
by

11 4 2011 Replies due
12 22011 Attachments
1 Declaration
2 Proposed Order
Tubach
Michael Filed on 10 13 2011 Entered 10 13 2011

Hon Lucy

Jose before

1013 2011

80

Joint
for

MOTION

to Stay Discovery

12 82011 01 30 PM in

Lucy

H Koh Responses
1

Attachments

by Google Inc Motion Hearing

filed

Courtroom8 4th Floor San

10 27 2011

due by

Declaration

on

Filed

2

before

Jose

due by

Replies

H Rubin

Lee

of

Order
Rubin Lee

4 Proposed

due by

11 3 2011

A

3
Entered

Exhibit

1013 2011

set

Hon

B

Exhibit

10 13 2011
1014 2011

81

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Consolidated Amended

by Apple Inc

re

79

MOTION to

Tubach Michael

Complaint

on

Filed

Dismiss

10 14 2011

Entered 1014 2011

1014 2011

82

CLERKS NOTICE Continuing

MOTION to

Motion Hearing Set Reset Deadlines

Dismiss Consolidated Amended

Dismiss Motion Hearing

set

for

H Koh

Hon Lucy
Entered 1014 2011

Floor San Jose before

10 14 2011
1017 2011

83

Amended
for

MOTION to

1 26 2012

Lucy

01 30

84

Dismiss

PM in

H Koh Responses

Purcell Daniel

1019 2011

126 2012

JOINT CASE

Filed

Ltd

Courtroom8 4th Floor San

due by

on

in Courtroom

mpb COURT STAFF

by Lucasfilm

filed

10 27 2011

10 17 2011

MANAGEMENT

Replies

79

MOTION to

Complaint 77

01 30 PM

as to

8 4th
Filed

Motion Hearing
before

Jose

due by

on

set

Hon

11 3 2011

Entered 10 17 2011

STATEMENT filed

by Adobe Systems Inc

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Intel

Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Anne Filed on 10 19 2011 Entered 1019 2011

Daniel Stover Shaver

1020 2011

85

JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT Amended

Management Conference Statement

Joint

Inc

by Adobe Systems

filed

Case
Apple

Inc

Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth Hariharan Intel
Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover

Michael

Corp

Shaver

1025 2011

86

ADR
Inc

1025 2011

https ecf cand

87

ADR

Anne

Filed

Certification

Rubin

Lee

on

10 20 2011

Entered

ADR L R 3 5 b of
on 10 25 2011

discussion

Filed

Certification

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

ADR L R 3 5 b

10 20 2011

of discussion

pl452253614062028

of

ADR

options

of

Google

Entered 1025 2011

L1 01

of

ADR

options

Harris

11 62013

CAND ECF

88

Filed

1025 2011

Minute

Entry and Case Management

on

10 26 2011

Conference held on

10 262011

PM in Courtroom8 4th

before

for

set

Hon

H Koh

Lucy

Courtroom8

Lee Anne

6 10 2013

4th Floor

Shortridge

79

Case Management

Initial

H Koh

Judge Lucy

before

set for

Floor San Jose Jury Selection

09 00 AM in Courtroom8 4th
Jury Trial

Order

Case Management Conference

Further

of

Entered 10 25 2011

Cody
1026 2011

30

Page

AM

09 00

in

Courtroom8

Pretrial Conference

for

set

for

set

Hon

Floor San Jose before

Date Filed

126 2012 01 30

6 10 2013

H Koh

Lucy

4th Floor

5 15 2013

San Jose

02 00

PM in

San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh Court Reporter
mpb COURT STAFF Date Filed 10 26 2011

Entered 1028 2011

1103 2011

89

NOTICE by

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Michael

Brandon

WITHDRAWAL

Amended Complaint NOTICE OF
OF PRAYER FOR INJUNCTIVE RELIEF Glackin

Brendan

on

Daniel Stover re 65

Marshall

1104 2011

90

Filed

11 32011

STATUS REPORT
Pursuant

To The

Regarding Voluntary Dismissal

88 by

Dkt

11 42011

92

OPPOSITION
Complaint

79 JOINT

to

MOTION to

DECLARATION

Dean

of

on

Filed

1

Attachments
Exhibit

E

6

11 42011

A

Exhibit

Exhibit

F

transcript

filed

may

PACER Any
Restriction

MOTION to
Devine Mark

s 79

document

D

5

Filed

on

C

B

held on

be viewed

1027 11

Lee Anne

Per General Order

Release of Transcript

than

79

byMichael

Harvey Dean

No

5

Shortridge Telephone

59 and

Conference

Judicial

set

for

H Koh

Restriction

After that date

days from date of

2 62012

las

it

may

Redaction

this

Filed

until

if

408

number
policy

only at the Clerks Office public terminal

Notice of Intent to Request

business

Judge Lucy

before

purchased through the Court Reporter Transcriber

later

11 42011

on

Entered 11 04 2011

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2 Exhibit
3 Exhibit
4 Exhibit

Related

Court Reporter Transcriber

287 4580

Filed

in Opposition to

Complaint

Hariharan

Siddharth

Entered 1104 2011
of Proceedings

Transcript

Dismiss Consolidated Amended

Saveri Joseph

M Harvey

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

94

Katherine

11 72011 dhm COURT STAFF

Dismiss Consolidated Amended

1107 2011

Lehe

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner

filed

Modified text on

93

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Entered 11 04 2011

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

1104 2011

Case

OPPOSITION to 83 AMENDED MOTION to Dismiss filed by Michael
Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall Daniel
Stover
Saveri Joseph Filed on 11 42011 Modified text on 11 72011

dhm COURT STAFF
1104 2011

Related

of

2011 Minute Order and Case

Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Entered 1104 2011

Hariharan

91

26

Courts October

Management Order

1104 2011

Entered 1103 2011

the deadline

this

or

may be

for the

be obtained through
required

is

due no

filing Release of Transcript

on

11 72011

Entered

11 07 2011
1130 2011

https ecf cand

95

STIPULATION

Stipulated

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Proposed

Protective

pl452253614062028

Order by Adobe Systems

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Inc Apple Inc
Hariharan

Intel

Daniel Stover

parties are advised

Standing Order Regarding Motions

US

of

79

Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Harvey Dean Filed on 1130 2011 Entered 11 30 2011

CLERKS NOTICE The

1201 2011

31

to take notice

Under

to File

of the

new

Seal in Civil Actions before

H Koh THIS IS A TEXT

ONLY DOCKET
ENTRY THERE IS NO DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED WITH THIS
NOTICE mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 12 12011 Entered 12 01 2011
Lucy

District Judge

CLERKS NOTICE The

1201 2011

parties are advised

Standing Order Regarding Motions

to take notice

Under

to File

US

of the

new

Seal in Civil Actions before

District Judge Lucy H Koh THIS IS A TEXT ONLY DOCKET
ENTRY THERE IS NO DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED WITH THIS
NOTICE mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 12 1 2011 Entered
12 01 2011

1202 2011

96

REPLY

83 Amended MOTION

to Dismiss
DEFENDANT LUCASFILM
SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFFS
CONSOLIDATED AMENDED COMPLAINT filed byLucasfilm Ltd
Purcell Daniel Filed on 12 2 2011 Entered 12 02 2011
re

LTD S REPLY

1202 2011

97

IN

REPLY

MOTION

79

re

byApple Inc

1205 2011

98

Tubach

to Dismiss Consolidated

Michael

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

Michael

Amended

12 22011

on

by Apple Inc

Tubach

Opposition Response

Filed

re

97 Reply
on

Filed

Complaint

filed

Entered 12 02 2011
to

12 52011

Entered

12 05 2011
1205 2011

99

STIPULATION and Proposed Order
Discovery by Intuit Inc Attachments

Concerning

1

US

by
Mail Broderick Catherine
Entered 1205 2011

of Service

0105 2012

100

NOTICE by
Catherine

0118 2012

0119 2012

101

102

Filed

NOTICE of
1 18 2012

Hariharan

by Joshua

P Davis

Motion

to

File

Under

File

104

Seal Joint

Filed

ORDER

on

Broderick

Filed

on

Case Management

on

Proposed

1 19 2012

by Michael

Concerning

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Exhibit

Joint

Entered 0119 2012

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
re

102

Administrative

Motion to

Harvey

Entered 0119 2012

Testifying

lhklc1

Siddharth

Public Redacted

Case Management Conference Statement

1 19 2012

Koh on 123 2012
01 23 2012

https ecf cand

Davis Joshua

Seal Joint

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Under

Dean
0123 2012

Filed

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Hariharan

12 52011

Statement filed by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Attachments
1

Version Harvey Dean
103

Proof

Entered 0118 2012

Case Management Conference Statement

0119 2012

on

of Attorney

Appearance

Administrative

Conference

on

Filed

Name and Email Change
1 52012 Entered 0105 2012

Inc

Intuit

Expert

Testifying

Certificate Proof of Service

Expert Discovery

COURT STAFF

pl452253614062028

Signed by Judge Lucy

Filed

L1 01

on

123 2012

H

Entered

11 62013

CAND ECF

0124 2012

105

REQUEST

by Apple Inc

ORDER

Order
Brown

Equipment

Christina

125 2012 dhm COURT STAFF

Modified text on

106

Bring Electronic

to

1 Proposed

Attachments

0124 2012

Granting 105 Request

dhm COURT STAFF
107

STIPULATION

on

79

124 2012

Entered 01 24 2012

Equipment

to Bring Electronic

of

into the Courtroom

Filed

Courtroom filed by Apple Inc Signed by Judge Lucy
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 124 2012 Modified

0124 2012

32

Page

into the

H Koh on 12412
text

125 2012

on

Entered 01 24 2012

AND ORDER MODIFIED BY THE COURT re 95
Judge Howard R Lloyd on 124 12 hrllc1 COURT
on 124 2012 Entered 01 24 2012

Signed by Magistrate

STAFF
0126 2012

108

Filed

Entry and Case Management

Minute

on

Conference

held

1 262012

Further

1 26 2012

Order

Floor San Jose

mpb COURT STAFF

Case Management

H Koh

Case Management Conference

PM in Courtroom8 4th
Shortridge

Further

before Judge Lucy

418 2012 02 00
Lee Anne

set for

Court Reporter

Date Filed

Date Filed

126 2012

Entered

01 27 2012
0126 2012

110

H Koh

1

Entry Motion Hearing held on
26 2012 before Judge Lucy
126 2012 re 83 Amended MOTION to Dismiss filed by

Minute

Date Filed

Ltd

Lucasfilm
filed

STAFF
0127 2012

109

MOTION

79

by Apple Inc

MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT filed

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Dean

Harvey

0130 2012

111

Entered 0127 2012

through

only

No

59 and

Restriction

las

MOTION to

to

Filed

Withdraw

by Michael

Marshall

After

Katherine

Transcriber
that date

Conference

on

this

terminal

until
it

may

Redaction

policy

transcript

may be

or

this

as Attorney

Attachments

Responses

for the Release of

the deadline

required

through
is

due no

PACER
than 5

later

Restriction

set

for

Entered 01 31 2012

Motion for Leave
due by

1 Proposed

may

purchased

filing Release of Transcript

131 2012

408287 4580

number

be obtained
if

H Koh Court

Judge Lucy

to

Withdraw as Counsel

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Daniel Stover

4 13 2012
3 23 2012

Judicial

Request

days from date of

4 30 2012

1 26 12 before

Shortridge Telephone

the Clerks Office public

Notice of Intent

business

filed

held on

the Court Reporter

Transcript

Any

at

Lehe

Entered 01 30 2012

Lee Anne

Transcriber

be viewed

https ecf cand

1 27 2012

of Proceedings

Transcript

Per General Order

113

by Michael Devine

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

130 2012

on

Reporter

0323 2012

Complaint

mpb COURT

STATUS REPORT PLAINTIFFS STATUS REPORT REGARDING
DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF PRAYER FOR DECLARATORY
RELIEF AND CAL BUS
PROF CODE 16600 CLAIM PURSUANT TO
THE COURTS JANUARY 26 2012 MINUTE ORDER AND CASE
MANAGEMENT ORDER Dkt 108 by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Filed

112

on

Filed

Siddharth Hariharan

0131 2012

Amended

Lee Anne Shortridge
126 2012 Entered 01 27 2012

Date Filed

JOINT CASE

to Dismiss Consolidated

Court Reporter

46 2012 Replies

Order
Lehe

Brandon
due by

Katherine

Filed

on

Entered 0323 2012

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0330 2012

Page

114

STIPULATION re
filed

Format of

Production

Inc Brown

by Apple

Christina

3 30 2012

on

of

79

Stored Information

Electronically

Filed

33

Entered

03 30 2012
0411 2012

115

MANAGEMENT

JOINT CASE

STATEMENT filed

by Michael Devine

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Harvey Dean Filed on
11 2012 Entered 0411 2012

4

0417 2012

116

MOTION to

Case

Relate

Order
Rubin Lee
0417 2012

117

Declaration

byGoogle

Inc

Rubin Lee

0417 2012

118

Declaration

on

1

H Rubin

Lee

A

Exhibit

s 116

Related document

A

filed

s 116

MOTION to

Relate

1

Exhibit

Attachments

Lee

Rubin

Case

Relate

document

Related

Support of 116

in

MOTION to

04 17 2012

Entered

byGoogle Inc

filed

04 17 2012

Entered

Exhibit

417 2012

1 Proposed

Attachments

Support of 116

in

Attachments

Filed

of

Corrected

H Rubin

Lee

of

417 2012

on

Filed

Inc

by Google

filed

417 2012

on

Filed

Case With

A

Entered

04 17 2012
0418 2012

119

ORDER
Motion

LHK
0418 2012

120

on

held

4 182012

Further

4 18 2012

Order by

122

Filed

Order

Further

425 2012

NOTICE of

part

116

Case Management

H Koh

set for

Date Filed

531 2012 01 30
Bedard

04 23 2012

Entered

Motion to Relate Case

426 2012

Modified on

79

04 18 2012

Entered

Case 512 cv 1262 LHK

Filed

by Frank

of Counsel

Substitution

on

426 2012

H Busch

in case

COURT
dhm COURT
lhklc1

Extending

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

filed

Fichtner Google

Inc

Time

Siddharth

to

and

Sujal

J Shah

04 26 2012

Entered

STIPULATION

Ltd

in

511 cv 02509

Court Reporter Christine

418 2012

Complaint

123

case

Entered 0425 2012

Busch Frank

0501 2012

on

granting

Related

in

418 2012

before Judge Lucy

Date Filed

H Koh

Hon Lucy

5 11 cv 02509 LHK
STAFF
STAFF

on

Floor San Jose

mpb COURT STAFF

0426 2012

Filed

Case Management Conference

PM in Courtroom8 4th
121

part and denying

in

Motion to Dismiss

Entry and Case Management

Conference

0425 2012

granting

83
COURT STAFF

Dismiss denying

lhklc1

Minute

H Koh

by Judge Lucy

to

Answer Consolidated Amended

Hariharan

Inc Michael Devine Mark
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm

Intel

Busch Frank

Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover
Entered 0501 2012

Filed

on

5 12012
0516 2012

124

NOTICE of
Filed

0516 2012

0521 2012

125

126

on

516 2012

NOTICE of
5 16 2012

ANSWER

5 21 2012
0521 2012

https ecf cand

127

Appearance

by Richard Martin Heimann

Heimann Richard

Entered 05 16 2012

Appearance

by Kelly

M Dermody

Dermody Kelly

Filed

on

Entered 0516 2012

to

Amended

Complaint

byIntel

Corp

Pickett

Donn

Filed

on

Entered 0521 2012

Defendant Adobe Systems

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Inc s

ANSWER

pl452253614062028

to

Amended

L1 01

Complaint

byAdobe

11 62013

CAND ECF

Inc

Systems

128

Defendant

0521 2012

129

ANSWER

0521 2012

130

ANSWER
on

0521 2012

131

132

ANSWER

133

134

Demand
Craig

Complaint

Henn Emily

byPixar

on

Filed

Complaint

Ltd

byLucasfilm

Purcell Daniel

Filed

byGoogle Inc

Complaint

Lee

Rubin

Filed

on

Entered 0521 2012

Amended

to

byApple Inc

Complaint

Tubach

Michael

on

Filed

Entered 0521 2012

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Tubach Michael

Complaint

0523 2012

Jury

Service Stewart

Entered 0521 2012

Amended

to

5 21 2012
0522 2012

Amended

to

5 21 2012
0521 2012

Amended Complaint

to

Certificate Proof of

Entered 0521 2012

5 21 2012

ANSWER

1

Entered 05 21 2012

Amended

to

5 21 2012

79

Service Kiernan David

Certificate Proof of

ANSWER

Attachments

521 2012

on

Filed

of

Entered 05 21 2012

Inc’s

Intuit

Inc

byIntuit

1

Attachments

521 2012

on

Filed

0521 2012

34

Page

by Apple Inc
Filed

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED
Conference

filed

by Michael

on

132 Answer

re

522 2012

ORDER

to

Amended

Entered 05 22 2012
Case Management

Extending

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Dean

Harvey

Filed

on

523 2012

Entered 0523 2012

0524 2012

135

0524 2012

Hon Lucy H Koh denying 134 Stipulation in case 511cv 02509
LHK Associated Cases 511 cv 02509 LHK 511cv 03538 LHK 5 11 cv
03539 LHK 511 cv 03540 LHK 511cv 03541 LHK 5 12 cv 01262 LHK
lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed on 524 2012 Entered 0524 2012
Order by

Set Reset Hearing

re

135 Order on

Stipulation

Further

Case Management

725 2012 02 00 PM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 524 2012 Entered 05 24 2012

Conference set for

0525 2012

136

ASSOCIATION of
Shaver

Stover

0525 2012

137

Siddharth

Anne

Filed

MOTION for Extension

Time

of

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

0525 2012

138

Time
Rule

on

Filed

Declaration

525 2012

3

Exhibit

Exhibit

H

M

18
23

https ecf cand

Exhibit
Exhibit

C
9

4

14

R

in

10

N

Exhibit

2 Related

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

D

I

Exhibit

19

Motion for Class

to File Plaintiffs

63

Devine Mark

by Michael

filed

Shaver

MOTION for Extension

Support of 137

of

Civil Local

to

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Exhibit

Exhibit

Michael

Entered 0525 2012

Motion for Class Certification Pursuant

byMichael

filed

Law Firm by

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Exhibit

5 25 2012

Saveri

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Entered 05 25 2012

B Shaver

Ann

of

to File Plaintiffs

63

on

Hariharan

Pursuant to Civil Local Rule

Certification

Anne

R Saveri

Counsel Joseph

Devine Mark Fichtner

S

5

Attachments

E

Exhibit

Exhibit

J

11

O

15 Exhibit
20 Exhibit

document

s 137

pl452253614062028

T

6

1

Exhibit

Exhibit

K

F

7
12

16 Exhibit P
21 Exhibit

Shaver

Anne

L1 01

A

Exhibit

U

2

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

G
L

B
8

13

Q

17 Exhibit
22 Exhibit

Filed

on

1
525 2012

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

35

of

79

Entered 0525 2012

0525 2012

139

Proposed
Motion

Order

re

MOTION for Extension

137

for Class Certification Pursuant

Devine Mark Fichtner
Shaver

Stover

0529 2012

140

Anne

on

Filed

Time

to Civil Local

to File Plaintiffs

Rule

6 3 by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Hariharan

Siddharth

of

5 25 2012

Entered 0525 2012

Hon Lucy H Koh denying 137 Motion for Extension of Time to
511 cv 02509 LHK Associated Cases 511cv 02509 LHK
5 11 cv 03538 LHK 5 11 cv 03539 LHK 511 cv 03540 LHK 511cv
03541 LHK 512 cv 01262 LHK lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed on
Order by

File in case

5 29 2012
0529 2012

Entered 0529 2012

Set Reset Hearing
Further

Courtroom8

5 29 2012
0529 2012

141

140 Order on Motion

re

Case Management Conference

Discovery

4th Floor

San Jose

Dispute

Modified text

1 Exhibit
on 530 2012

143

NOTICE of

6 12012
0603 2012

144

Time

to File

mpb COURT STAFF

on

Filed

Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Tubach

Michael

Filed

dhm COURT STAFF

on 529 2012
Entered 05 29 2012

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed by Adobe Systems Inc
Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan Intel Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Daniel Stover

0601 2012

of

64 2012 02 30 PM in

2 by Apple Inc Michael

Joint Report

A

Attachments

142

for Extension

for

Entered 0529 2012

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

0601 2012

set

Appearance

filed

Filed

by Joseph

on

612012

R Saveri

Entered 06 01 2012

Saveri Joseph

Filed

on

Entered 0601 2012

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION

UNOPPOSED
1

Harvey Dean

by Michael

to

Amend

Pretrial

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Order

No

Brandon

618 2012 Replies due by
6 25 2012 Attachments
1 Exhibit Exhibit A to Motion
Proposed
OrderShaver Anne Filed on 6 32012 Modified text on 6 42012 dhm
Marshall

Daniel Stover

COURT STAFF
0603 2012

145

Declaration

of

Pretrial

Filed

on

Amend Correct

0604 2012

147

Order by

Motion to Amend

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
Attachments

filed

in Support of

Unopposed
byMichael

Filed

Hon Lucy
Cases

on

63 2012

H Koh

granting

Exhibit

A to

Shaver

MOTION to

Motion to Amend
Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
Related document

Entered

144

5 11 cv 02509 LHK

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

144

1

s 144

Administrative

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Anne

Associated

https ecf cand

R Saveri

Plaintiffs

Order No 1

Hariharan

MOTION to

Firm

of Joseph

Declaration

144

Administrative

Resume Related document
632012 Entered 06 03 2012

Anne

Shaver

byMichael

filed

Declaration

Pretrial

in Support of

Unopposed

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Shaver

146

B Shaver

Plaintiffs

Order No 1

Hariharan

0603 2012

due by

Entered 0603 2012

Anne

Amend Correct

Responses

pl452253614062028

s 144

06 03 2012

Amend Correct
5 11 cv 03538 LHK 511 cv 03539
Motion to

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

36

of

79

LHK 511 cv 03540 LHK 511cv 03541 LHK 5 12 cv 01262 LHK
lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed on 642012 Entered 0604 2012
0604 2012

149

Minute

Entry

64 2012

Management Conference held on

Further Case

H Koh

Judge Lucy

Date Filed

642012

before

Case Management

Further

912 2012 02 00 PM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose
Lee Anne Shortridge mpb COURT STAFF Date Filed
6 42012 Entered 0605 2012
Conference set for
Court Reporter

0605 2012

148

Case Management Order
Order

Counsel

is

of Discovery

Referral

Case Management

Further

advised that this Order contains

4 2012

addition to the dates discussed at the June

new

dates in

Case Management

Conference
Signed by Judge Lucy

on

0612 2012

6 52012

H Koh on 652012
148

Pursuant to Signed Order
Singh Grewal for
Lloyd no longer

all

150

Case Reassigned

assigned to the case

NOTICE by

Michael

Linda
151

Filed

to

Howard

Judge

COURT STAFF

tsh

Judge Paul

Magistrate

Filed

R

on

Entered 0612 2012

Marshall

0614 2012

COURT STAFF

further discovery disputes Magistrate

6 12 2012
0614 2012

lhklc1

Entered 0605 2012

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Daniel Stover of withdrawal

Filed

614 2012

on

Affirmative

Defenses

Attorney John Radice

Brandon

Nussbaum

Entered 06 14 2012

ORDER

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED
and

of

filed

by Pixar

Regarding Amending Answers

Henn Emily

on

Filed

614 2012

Entered 0614 2012

0615 2012

152

and Order Regarding Amending

Stipulation

Answers and Affirmative

H

by Hon Lucy
Koh granting 151 Stipulation in case 5 11 cv
02509 LHK Associated Cases 511 cv 02509 LHK 511cv 03538 LHK
5 11 cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540 LHK 511 cv 03541 LHK 512cv
Defenses

COURT STAFF Filed on 6 15 2012
dhm COURT STAFF Entered 0615 2012

01262 LHK

6 18 2012
0618 2012

153

NOTICE of

lhklc1

Compliance

Order by Michael
Marshall

Dean

Filed

STAFF
0618 2012

154

Declaration

2

6 18 2012

Declaration

with the Courts June

Declaration

with the Courts June

on

1

Attachments

Compliance

Plaintiffs

Management Order
Compliance

Case Management

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Daniel Stover

Regarding

5 2012

with the Courts June

Modified text on

of Joseph

5 2012

of

5

R Saveri Regarding

Case Management

Modified text on

Brandon

M

Dean
Harvey
2012 Case

Order
Harvey

6 19 2012 dhm COURT

Entered 0618 2012
of Eric

B Evans

regarding

5 2012
618 2012

with 148 June

Compliance

Case Management Order by Google Inc Evans Eric Filed on
Modified text on 619 2012 dhm COURT STAFF Entered 06 18 2012

0618 2012

155

Declaration

Inc s
Filed

https ecf cand

of Catherine

Production

on

of Data

T

Zeng

148 Order Regarding Defendant

and Documents

618 2012 Modified

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

re

text

on

by

Intuit

Inc

Zeng

Intuit

Catherine

619 2012 dhm COURT STAFF

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

37

of

79

Entered 0618 2012

0618 2012

156

C Kiernan

of David

Declaration

Systems Incorporateds

Production

Inc

Filed

Kiernan David

COURT STAFF
0618 2012

157

of

0618 2012

158

M Hinman

Data and Documents
Modified text on

0618 2012

159

148 Order Regarding

re

Henn Emily

by

Intel

Corp Hinman Frank

619 2012 dhm COURT STAFF

618 2012

Entered 06 18 2012

148 Order Regarding

re

Pixar’s Production

on

Filed

619 2012 dhm COURT STAFF

of Frank

Declaration

6 19 2012 dhm

Modified text on

Entered 0618 2012

Documents and Data by Pixar

Modified text on

and Documents by Adobe Systems

of Data

618 2012

on

of Jonathan Herczeg

Declaration

148 Order Regarding Defendant Adobe

re

Production

Intel’s

of

Filed on 618 2012
Entered 06 18 2012

of Christina Brown re 148 Order Regarding Apple Inc s
Document and Data Productions by Apple Inc Brown Christina Filed on
Declaration

6 18 2012

619 2012 dhm COURT STAFF

Modified text on

Entered

06 18 2012
0618 2012

160

Declaration

of Justina

and Data Production

6 18 2012
STAFF
0621 2012

161

Modified on

148 Regarding

re

by Lucasfilm

6 19 2012

Ltd

Document

Lucasfilm’s

Sessions Justina

linking entry to entry

Filed

on

dhm COURT

148

Entered 0618 2012

MOTION for leave
fee

K Sessions

filed

305

receipt

to appear in Pro

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Peter

of

filed

A Barile

III

Filing

by Michael Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Order
Barile

1 Proposed

Attachments

Hac Vice

number 0971 6911874

Peter

Filed

6 21 2012

on

Entered 0621 2012

0702 2012

162

STATUS REPORT REGARDING REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS AND DATA
by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Daniel Stover

7 22012
0702 2012

163

0702 2012

164

0702 2012

165

166

167

168

ORDER

Case Schedule

re

COURT STAFF

NOTICE of

Filed

on

161 Motion for Pro Hac

Vice lhklc1

Entered 07 02 2012

Appearance

Signed by Judge Lucy

on

Filed

722012

H Koh on 722012

Entered 0702 2012

Rayhill

Rayhill

Kevin

Leebove

Leebove

Lisa

by Kevin Edward

lhklc1

Filed

on

Entered 0703 2012

NOTICE of

Appearance

by Lisa

Jennifer

Filed

on

Entered 0705 2012

AMENDED ANSWER
Ltd

Purcell Daniel

COURT STAFF

https ecf cand

Brandon Marshall
Kelly

ORDER re Discovery Signed by Judge Lucy H Koh on 628 2012
COURT STAFF Filed on 722012 Entered 07 02 2012

7 52012
0705 2012

ADermody

Entered 0702 2012

Hon Lucy H Koh granting
COURT STAFF Filed on 722012

7 32012
0705 2012

Exhibit

Order by

lhklc1

0703 2012

1

Attachments

to

65 Consolidated Amended Complaint

Filed

on

7 52012

Modified on

byLucasfilm

762012 gm

Entered 0705 2012

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0705 2012

Page

169

ANSWER

Amended
on

Filed

75 2012

65 Amended Complaint

to

Modified on

byIntel

Corp

Pickett

7 62012 gm COURT STAFF

38

of

79

Donn

Entered

07 05 2012
0705 2012

170

AMENDED ANSWER
Inc

to

65

AMENDED COMPLAINT

5

Kiernan David Filed on 7 2012 Modified on
Entered 0705 2012

byAdobe Systems

7 62012 gm

COURT STAFF
0705 2012

171

AMENDED ANSWER
byIntuit

Inc Zeng

Catherine

gm COURT STAFF
0705 2012

172

AMENDED ANSWER
on

Filed

75 2012

to Plaintiffs

65 Consolidated Amended
on

Filed

7 52012

Complaint

Modified on

762012

Entered 07 05 2012
to

65 Amended Complaint byPixar Henn Emily
62012 gm COURT STAFF Entered

Modified on

7

07 05 2012
0705 2012

173

AMENDED ANSWER
Lee

Filed

on

to

65 Amended Complaint

75 2012 Modified

on

byGoogle Inc

Rubin

76 2012 gm COURT STAFF

Entered 0705 2012

0705 2012

174

AMENDED ANSWER
byApple Inc

Tubach

gm COURT STAFF
0709 2012

175

filed

Ltd

Order by

Complaint

Modified on

76 2012

Entered 07 05 2012

ORDER AMENDING CASE

Siddharth

Hariharan

Inc Michael Devine Mark
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm
Harvey Dean Filed on

Intel

Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover

7 92012
176

752012

on

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

Inc

Fichtner Google

65 Consolidated Amended

Filed

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED

SCHEDULE

0710 2012

to Plaintiffs

Michael

Entered 0709 2012

H Koh

Hon Lucy

02509 LHK

175

granting

Stipulation

in case

5 11 cv

511 cv 02509 LHK 511cv 03538 LHK
5 11 cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540 LHK 511 cv 03541 LHK 512cv
Associated Cases

01262 LHK lhklc1
07 10 2012

COURT STAFF

Filed

on

7 10 2012

Entered

Fact Discovery Cutoff 129 13 Expert Discovery
326 2013 Final Pretrial Conference set for 731 2013 02 00 PM in
Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose Jury Selection set for 8 27 2013 09 00 AM
in Courtroom 8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh Jury Trial set
for 8 27 2013 09 00 AM in Courtroom
8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon
Lucy H Koh mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 710 2012 Entered

0710 2012

Set Deadlines Hearings
Cutoff

07 18 2012
0710 2012

Set Reset Hearing
Motion
before

set

for

re

176 Order on

Stipulation

1213 2012 01 30 PM

Hon Lucy

H Koh

in

Hearing

re

Class Certification

Courtroom8 4th Floor San

mpb COURT STAFF

Filed

on

Jose

710 2012

Entered 0828 2012

0719 2012

177

CLERKS NOTICE AMENDING TRIAL SCHEDULE CHANGING DATE
FOR COMMENCEMENT OF TRIAL Jury Selection set for 8 26 2013
09 00 AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh
Jury Trial

https ecf cand

set

for

8 26 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

09 00

AM

in

pl452253614062028

Courtroom8

L1 01

4th Floor

San Jose

11 62013

CAND ECF

39

Page

before

Hon Lucy

H Koh

mpb COURT STAFF

on

Filed

of

79

719 2012

Entered 0719 2012

0723 2012

178

ORDER

Show

to

Cause

Why

Case

No 5 12 CV 01262 LHK

Dismissed for Failure to Prosecute Signed by Judge Lucy

7 23 2012
7 23 2012
0906 2012

179

0906 2012

180

on

0911 2012

181

Lisa

NOTICE of

on

Filed

STATEMENT filed by Michael
962012 Entered 09 06 2012

by Joseph

Appearance

9 62012

on 723 2012 Modified on
Entered 0723 2012
Filed

MANAGEMENT

JOINT CASE
Leebove

COURT STAFF
COURT STAFF

lhklc1S
lhklc1S

Should Not Be

H Koh on

Peter

Devine

Forderer Joseph

Forderer

Filed

Entered 0906 2012

CASE MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT SUPPLEMENTAL

filed

by

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall
Dermody Kelly Filed on 911 2012 Entered 09 11 2012

Michael

Daniel Stover

0912 2012

182

RESPONSE

to

181

Rubin Lee
dhmS COURT STAFF

Google Inc

0912 2012

183

Minute

Filed

on

912 2012

Statement by

Modified text on

913 2012

Entered 0912 2012

Entry and Case Management

on

Case Management

Plaintiffs Supplemental

9 12 2012

Order

Further

held

9 122012

Final Pretrial Conference

Case Management

H Koh

before Judge Lucy

Conference

Date Filed

10 31 2013 01 30 PM in
Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose Jury Selection set for 1112 2013 09 00
AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh Jury Trial
set for 1112 2013 09 00 AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon
Lucy H Koh Motion Hearing set for 1 17 2013 01 30 PM in Courtroom8
4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh Court Reporter Lee Anne
Shortridge
mpb COURT STAFF Date Filed 912 2012 Entered
09 13 2012
0912 2012

Set Reset Hearing

re

Inadvertently

docketed

Further

184

not calendared

Case Management

PM in Courtroom8 4th
0918 2012

287 4580

held on

set for 12 12 2012 02 00
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on

be viewed

0912 12

Lee Anne

Per General Order

may

Release of Transcript

PACER Any
than

Restriction

Order was

Conference

No

5

59 and

Judicial

set

for

H Koh

Conference

Restriction

After that date

days from date of

12 17 2012

las

until
it

may

Redaction

if

408

number
policy

only at the Clerks Office public terminal

Notice of Intent to Request

business

Judge Lucy

before

Shortridge Telephone

purchased through the Court Reporter Transcriber

later

Further Set

Case Management

Entered 1016 2012

Court Reporter Transcriber

transcript

when

Floor San Jose

of Proceedings

Transcript

for

183 Case Management Conference

Hearings

9 12 2012

set

this

or

the deadline

may be

for the

be obtained through
required

is

due no

filing Release of Transcript

this

Filed

on

918 2012

Entered

09 18 2012
0919 2012

https ecf cand

185

NOTICE of Appearance by James Gerard
on 9 19 2012 Entered 0919 2012

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

Beebe

Dallal

L1 01

Dallal

James

Filed

11 62013

CAND ECF

1001 2012

186

Motion

Administrative

to

File

Under Seal

1

Attachments
Exhibit

Shaver

5

Redacted

Declaration

MOTION to

7

Exhibit

on

Filed

4

6

Exhibits

10 12012

Memorandum

Certify Class and

2 Proposed

Exhibit

Redacted

Expert Report

Exhibit

Redacted Shaver Anne
187

Redacted

Class Certification Brief

Redacted

Anne
1001 2012

188

12 10 2012

due by

Replies

Exhibit

to Colligan

Declaration

and Memorandum of
1

10

Exhibit

and

Points

57 9
Anne
1001 2012

189

Exhibit

and

6

69
on 10 12012

of

Edward

and Memorandum of
1

Attachments

1001 2012

190

on

of

H Koh Responses

Colligan

Authorities

3

A

Authorities

E Leamer PhD

4

9

Exhibit

and

1

Exhibit

Shaver

Anne

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

5

in

Declaration

in

Certify Class

Devine Mark

s 187

2

Exhibit

Filed

on

by Michael

Support 186
Support 187

Authorities

Shaver

Anne

MOTION to
byMichael

filed

Brandon Marshall Daniel

2

3

Exhibit

10 1 2012

3

Related

Entered

10 01 2012

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Declaration

MOTION to
byMichael

Support of 187

in

Points

1

s 187

and

8

Exhibit

B

Memorandum of

Attachments

of Points

Devine Mark

filed

Hariharan

189
190

byMichael

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Siddharth

Hariharan

Certify Class

Support of 187

in

and

Stover

191

MOTION to

filed

7

Exhibit

Devine Mark Fichtner

1001 2012

11 12 2012

Order
Shaver

1 Proposed

Related document
Entered 10 01 2012

Exhibit

Edward

Certify Class and

document

Courtroom8

due by

Entered 10 01 2012

Points

10 1 2012

Declaration

Brandon Marshall

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Filed

filed

Exhibit

Exhibit

Declaration

Authorities

1 5 11 55 58 68 and 70 7 Exhibit 56 8 Exhibit
10 Exhibit 71 Related document s 187
Shaver

6

Filed

Declaration

Entered 10 01 2012

of Points

Support of 187

in

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

to

Entered 10 01 2012

B Shaver

Ann

of

Lucy

3

Declaration

Exhibits

117 2013 01 30 PM in

Attachments

10 12012

on

Filed

Hon

Order

Colligan

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Daniel Stover Motion Hearing set for
4th Floor San Jose before

79

by Michael Devine Mark

filed

P Forderer

of Joseph

Declaration

of

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

1001 2012

40

Page

re

Administrative

188

Declaration

Motion

to

File

in

Support

Under

Seal

MOTION to Certify Class and Memorandum
Shaver Anne Filed on 10 12012 Entered

Authorities

10 01 2012
1008 2012

192

Declaration
to File

of Robert Booth In Support of Plaintiffs Administrative

Under

Seal filed

byPalm Inc

Smith Benjamin

Filed

on

Motion

10 8 2012

Entered 1008 2012

1008 2012

193

Proposed

Order

Administrative
Filed

1008 2012

194

on

Proposed

https ecf cand

192

Declaration

Motion to

10 8 2012

MOTION to
Responses

re

File

in Support of Granting Plaintiffs

Under Seal by Palm Inc

Withdraw

as Attorney Jonathan

due by 10 22 2012 Replies
Order
Henn Emily Filed

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Smith Benjamin

Entered 10 08 2012
Herczeg

pl452253614062028

by Pixar

10 29 2012 Attachments
10 82012 Entered 10 08 2012

due by

on

filed

L1 01

1

11 62013

CAND ECF

1009 2012

195

Defendants

Joint Response

186

to

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Lucasfilm

Inc

Intel

on

Corp Pixar

10 92012

10 10 2012

Ltd Intuit Inc

COURT STAFF
Declaration

of

Administrative

Kiernan David
186

of Lisa Borgeson

Declaration

dhmS

Donna Morris in Support of 195 Joint Response to Plaintiffs
Motion to Seal filed byAdobe Systems Inc Related

s 195 Kiernan David Filed on 10 92012 Modified
10 10 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 10 09 2012
197

Filed

Entered 1009 2012

document

1009 2012

Google

A

Exhibit

79

counsel posted document

as a motion and failed to link entry to document

incorrectly

196

1

Attachments

Modified on

of

Motion to Seal

Plaintiffs Administrative

filed

1009 2012

41

Page

on

text

Support of 186 Plaintiffs Administrative

in

Motion to File Under Seal filed byIntuit Inc Related document s 195
Kiernan David Filed on 10 92012 Modified text on 10 10 2012 to
conform with

caption

of

dhmS COURT STAFF

document

Entered

10 09 2012
1009 2012

198

Order Granting 186 Plaintiffs Administrative

Proposed

Inc

Seal by Adobe Systems

1

Attachments

Motion and Motion for Class CertProposed
Expert Report of Edward

C

Exhibit

Exhibit

199

Declaration

of

Exhibit

Motion

to

with caption

195

in Support of

Seal

filed

Joint Response

Ltd

by Lucasfilm

of Alan Eustace in Support of

Declaration

Under Seal
Filed

on

document

1009 2012

201

on

1009 2012

202

Seal

filed

filed

203

of

James

M Kennedy

in Support of

195

Pursuant

to Civil Local

Motion

Evangelista
to

File

for Class Certification

Corp

Related document

Modified text on

1010 2012

COURT STAFF

https ecf cand

M

of Tina

Administrative

Intel

File

Evans Eric
with caption

of

s 195

s 195

to conform

Filed
of

on
document

Plaintiffs

Seal Plaintiffs Notice

and Memorandum of

79 5d

with caption

195

of

to File Under

Henn Emily

in Support of

Under

with caption

Rule

Motion

Plaintiffs Administrative

by Pixar Related document

Declaration

Motion

s 195

Wagner in Support of 195 Administrative
Motion to File
by Google Inc Related document s 195
Evans Eric

10 92012 Modified text on 10 10 2012 to conform
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 1009 2012
1009 2012

on

Motion to

Administrative

10 9 2012 Modified text on 10 10 2012 to conform
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 10 09 2012

Declaration

Submitted

195

Related document

text

of Frank

Under Seal
Filed

by Google Inc

10 9 2012 Modified text on 10 10 2012 to conform
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 10 09 2012

Declaration

document

filed

to

Related

s 195 Purcell Daniel Filed on 10 92012 Modified
10 10 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 10 09 2012
200

document

of

document

1009 2012

B

Proposed Redactions
3
Kiernan David Filed on

Redactions

DAVID J ANDERMAN

Plaintiffs Administrative

2

Under

Notice of

Plaintiffs

Redactions

10 92012 Modified text on 10 10 2012 to conform
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 1009 2012
1009 2012

A

File

to

E Leamer PhD With

With Proposed

Exhibits

Motion

Law in

of

Motion and

Support

Filed

with caption

document

of

on

filed

by

10 92012

Busch Frank

dhmS

Entered 1009 2012

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

1009 2012

42

Page

204

Declaration
of

195

Mark Bentley Pursuant

of

Motion

Administrative

to Civil Local

to File Under

Seal

Rule

79 5d

by Apple

filed

of

79

in Support

Inc

Related

document s 195
Brown Christina Filed on 10 92012 Modified text on
10 10 2012 to conform with caption of document dhmS COURT STAFF
Entered 1009 2012

1010 2012

205

MOTION for leave
305

fee

Certificate Proof of Service

Chinue

Certificate of

1010 2012

on

Filed

T

Hac Vice Chinue

to appear in Pro

number 0971 7189136

receipt

Richardson

Filing

by Pixar Attachments
Good Standing Richardson

1

filed

Entered 1010 2012

Hon Lucy H Koh granting 205 Motion for Pro Hac Vice lhklc1
COURT STAFF Filed on 1011 2012 Entered 10 11 2012

1011 2012

206

Order by

1016 2012

207

MOTION for leave
305

fee

receipt

number 0971 7203150

1017 2012

208

A Isaacson

Certificate of

H Koh

Hon Lucy

Order by

granting

5 11 cv 02509 LHK Associated

207

Filing

by Pixar Attachments

filed

Good Standing
on 10 16 2012 Entered 10 16 2012

Certificate Proof of Service
Filed

Hac Vice Thomas

to appear in Pro

1

Thomas

Isaacson

Motion for Pro Hac Vice

in case

5 11 cv 02509 LHK 511 cv 03538
LHK 511 cv 03539 LHK 511cv 03540 LHK 5 11 cv 03541 LHK
COURT STAFF

lhklc3

1112 2012

209

210

on

Filed

1017 2012

Entered 1017 2012

OPPOSITION to 187 MOTION for Class Certification filed by Apple Inc
Tubach Michael Filed on 11 12 2012 Modified text on 11 13 2012

dhmS COURT STAFF
1112 2012

Cases

MOTION to
Systems

Dr Edward E

the Report of

Strike

Inc

Entered 1112 2012

Inc Google Inc

Apple

Pixar Motion Hearing

set

for

Intel

Leamer

Corp Intuit Inc

117 2013 01 30 PM in

by Adobe

filed

Lucasfilm

Courtroom8

Ltd

4th Floor

H

San Jose before Hon Lucy
Koh Responses due by 11 26 2012 Replies
due by 12 32012 Attachments
1 Declaration
of Susan J Welch
2
Exhibit Hinman Frank

1112 2012

211

Motion

Administrative

Kiernan David

1112 2012

FILED

212

DOCKET

Filed

File

to

on

Filed

IN ERROR
230

Systems
Pixar

Inc

to

Entered 11 12 2012

1112 2012

Under Seal

1112 2012

filed

by Adobe Systems Inc

Entered 11 12 2012

DOCUMENT LOCKED PLEASE SEE

Expert Report of Prefessor
Opposition Response

on

Kevin

Motion

M Murphy

in

Support of 209

for Class Certification filed

Related

by Adobe

Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc
document s 209
Hinman Frank Filed on

Apple

Lucasfilm

11 14 2012 wv

1114 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF Modified
COURT STAFF Entered 11 12 2012

MOTION for an

Evidentiary

Modified text on

1112 2012

213

Adobe Systems
Lucasfilm

on

1112 2012

https ecf cand

214

Ltd

11 14 2012

Declaration

Inc

Apple

on

Hearing on Class Certification Issues

Inc Google Inc

Intel

filed

Purcell Daniel

of Catherine

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

T

Zeng

in

Filed

on

Support of 211

pl452253614062028

L1 01

by

Corp Intuit Inc

11 12 2012 Modified
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 11 12 2012
Pixar

Ltd

11 12 2012

joint

text

Administrative

11 62013

CAND ECF

Motion

to File Under

Seal

by

filed

Inc

Intuit

215

Catherine

Declaration

on

Filed

J Brown

of Christina

in Support of

text

on

of

79

s 211

Related document

11 12 2012 Modified
COURT STAFF Entered 1112 2012
Zeng

1112 2012

43

Page

11 14 2012 dhmS

209 Opposition

Motion

to

for

filed by Apple Inc PUBLIC REDACTED VERSION
Ex 1 6 2 Ex 7 3 Ex 8 15 4 Ex 16 5 Ex 17 6
Ex 18 7 Ex 19 22 8 Ex 23 9 Ex 24 10 Ex 25 27 Related
document s 209
Brown Christina Filed on 11 12 2012 Modified text on
11 14 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 11 12 2012

Class Certification

1

Attachments

1112 2012

216

Proposed

Order

re

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION

213

for an Evidentiary

Inc

Hearing on Class Certification Issues by Adobe Systems

Inc

Apple

Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Pixar Purcell Daniel
Filed on 11 12 2012 Modified text on 11 14 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF
Entered 1112 2012

1112 2012

217

of Lin

Declaration

Under Seal

Robert

Mittelstaedt

1112 2012

218

Declaration

W Kahn

of

1112 2012

219

on

to File Under Seal filed

Sessions

1112 2012

220

Justina

Under Seal
Filed

1112 2012

221

on

11 12 2012

Under Seal
Filed

1112 2012

222

on

File

of Christina

Under Seal

Christina

1112 2012

223

EXHIBITS
Systems

C

4

Filed

1113 2012

224

Exhibit

Proposed
Systems

1113 2012

225

re

Inc

on

Proposed

on

211

D

in

re

re

210

211

https ecf cand

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Motion

Administrative

s 211

document

File

to

Busch Frank

s 211

in Support of

1

211

Motion

to File

Evans Eric

Administrative

Related document

Entered

Motion

E

Brown

File Under Seal filed

to

A Opp

Exhibit

s 211

Motion to

11 12 2012

2

Related document

B

Exhibit

s 211

byAdobe
3 Exhibit

Kiernan David

Entered 11 12 2012
Motion to

Administrative
Filed

MOTION to

on

File Under Seal

11 13 2012

Strike

Entered

the Report of

Leamer by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc

Inc Lucasfilm Ltd
11 13 2012

s 211

Related document

Entered 1112 2012

Related document

J Brown

Kiernan David

Order

Motion

Entered 11 12 2012

Exhibit

211

Henn Emily

Support of 211 Administrative

Administrative

5

s 211

Entered 11 12 2012

Attachments

Order

Inc

Related

11 12 2012

11 12 2012

Ltd

in Support of

Corp

byApple Inc

filed

Filed

Motion

Administrative

Support of 211 Administrative

in

11 12 2012

byGoogle Inc

filed

11 12 2012

Declaration

on

Wagner

of Frank

Declaration

Sessions

Busch

byIntel

filed

211

in Support of

byLucasfilm

Filed

of Frank

Declaration

to File

Entered 11 12 2012

Related document

byPixar

Motion

s 211

Entered 11 12 2012

K

of Justina

Related document

1112 2012

M Kennedy

James

11 12 2012

Declaration

on

Filed

to File Under Seal filed
Filed

Support of 211 Administrative

in

byAdobe Systems Inc

filed

Pixar

Busch Frank

pl452253614062028

Filed

on

L1 01

by Adobe

11 13 2012

Dr Edward E
Intel

Corp Intuit

1113 2012

Entered

11 62013

CAND ECF

1113 2012

44

Page

226

Lee Anne

Court Reporter Transcriber

287 4580

Per General Order

may

transcript

0604 12

held on

of Proceedings

Transcript

be viewed

No

59 and

Conference

Judicial

PACER Any
later

5

than

After that date

Restriction

Notice of Intent to Request
days from date of

business

2 11 2013

las

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

by

Restriction

set

for

it

may

Redaction

if

408

policy

this

or

the deadline

until

79

H Koh

number

only at the Clerks Office public terminal

purchased through the Court Reporter Transcriber
Release of Transcript

Judge Lucy

before

Shortridge Telephone

of

may be

for the

be obtained through
required

due no

is

filing Release of Transcript

this

1113 2012

on

Filed

Entered

11 13 2012
1113 2012

227

210
in

1113 2012

228

MOTION to

Declaration

229

Proposed

1114 2012

230

in

Corp re 212

Order

re

on

File

Opposition Response

to

Inc
Ltd Pixar

Kevin

M Murphy

Inc Google Inc

Related document

Modified text on

231

NOTICE of Appearance
Entered 1115 2012

1115 2012

232

MOTION Administrative

Motion

Comply with

Rules

Google Inc

Civil Local

11 29 2012

11 15 2012
of

Administrative
Civil Local

Order re 211

Inc

Kiernan

Support of 209

OF DOCKET

212

Corp Intuit Inc
Hinman Frank Filed on

Lee

Rubin

on

Filed

Order Compelling

for

filed

Intel

s 209

73 a and 34 c 2

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Declaration

on

1119 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF

1115 2012

due by

in

Motion CORRECTION

Apple

11 14 2012
11 14 2012

233

to

11 14 2012

Entered

Lucasfilm

1115 2012

Filed

Order Revised Proposed

byAdobe Systems

on

Declaration

209 Opposition Response

Under Seal by Adobe Systems

11 14 2012

Expert Report of Professor

Filed

Support

Entered 1113 2012

Brown Christina

Support

224 Proposed

Motion to

Filed

Responses

re

in

E Leamer 215

Dr Edward
11 13 2012

by Apple Inc

Declaration

Entered 1113 2012

Administrative

David

on

Filed

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

11 13 2012
1114 2012

the Report of

Strike

Support Busch Frank

Motion 215

Intel

Entered

11 15 2012

Defendants

filed

to

by Michael Devine

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

due by
Entered 11 15 2012
Replies

12 6 2012

Shaver

Anne

Brendan P Glackin in Support of 232 MOTION
Motion for Order Compelling Defendants to Comply with

Rules

73 a and 34 c 2

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

1

Attachments

Exhibit

A

filed

by Michael Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2

Exhibit

B

Related document

s 232

Shaver Anne Filed on 11 15 2012 Modified on 11 16 2012 ewn COURT
STAFF Modified on 11 16 2012 ewn COURT STAFF Modified on
11 28 2012 PURSUANT TO ORDER DOC 242 THE GLACKIN
DECLARATION IS PERMANENTLY LOCKED dhmS COURT
STAFF Entered 1115 2012

1115 2012

234

Proposed

Order

Compelling

232

MOTION Administrative

Defendants to

2 by Michael

https ecf cand

re

Comply with

Motion for Order

Civil Local

Rules

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

73 a and 34 c
Brandon

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Marshall

Anne

Shaver

Daniel Stover

11 15 2012

on

Filed

45

of

79

Entered

11 15 2012
1116 2012

235

MOTION to Remove

Incorrectly

236

Amended

filed

237

Daniel Stover

OPPOSITION

1

Attachments

MOTION for

213

to

Certification Issues

11 16 2012

A

Exhibit

2

233

Brandon

Exhibit

B

Related

on 11 16 2012 Modified
Entered 11 16 2012
Filed

an

Hearing on Class

Evidentiary

1 Proposed

Attachments

MotionGlackin Brendan
1119 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF

Administrative

Modified text on

on

text

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

byMichael

filed

Order Denying Defendants

on

Comply with

Defendants to

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

MOTION

232

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

document s 232
Glackin Brendan
11 19 2012 dhmS COURT STAFF

1116 2012

11 16 2012

on

Filed

73 a and 34 c 2 CORRECTION OF DOCKET

Rules

byMichael

Marshall

Brendan

in Support of

Motion for Order Compelling

Administrative
Civil Local

P Glackin

of Brendan

Declaration

by Michael Devine

filed

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Order
Glackin

1 Proposed
Entered 1116 2012
Attachments

1116 2012

Document

Filed

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Filed

Entered 1116 2012

1119 2012

238

OPPOSITION

MOTION

232

to

AdministrativeMotion

for Order

Comply with Civil Local Rules 73 a and 34 c
2 filed by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit
Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Pixar Attachments
1 Proposed Order
Hinman
Compelling

Defendants to

1119 2012 Modified
STAFF Entered 1119 2012
Frank

1119 2012

239

Filed

M Hinman

of Frank

Declaration
filed

on

Ltd

Pixar

in Support of

Filed

dhmS COURT STAFF
Declaration

Motion

of

to File

JOSEPH
Under

1

Attachments

Hinman Frank

238

240

on

211
241

Order

Under

Seal

re

Inc

Modified text on

Motion

Exhibit

B

Plaintiffs

3

filed

Filed

on

in Support of

s

1120 2012

211

Administrative

Devine Mark Fichtner

byMichael

1119 2012

Declaration

in

s

Related document

Entered 11 19 2012

Support 211

Class Certification

to

the Declaration

Exhibit

Proposed

document

Motion

Administrative

to

TO INFORMATION DESIGNATED CONFIDENTIAL BY

for

Exhibits

Redactions

to

AS TO INFORMATION DESIGNATED

PLAINTIFFS by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Attachments
Plaintiffs

Intel

AERelated

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

240

AS

Motion
Corp Intuit Inc

238 Opposition

Entered 1119 2012

P FORDERER

Seal

Forderer Joseph

Proposed
File

11 20 2012 dhmS COURT

Exhibit

11 19 2012

CONFIDENTIAL BY PLAINTIFFS
Siddharth Hariharan

1119 2012

on

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google

Lucasfilm

1119 2012

text

C

Exhibits

Redactions

Hariharan

Siddharth

Plaintiffs

of Christina

1

Exhibit

Proposed

A

Opposition to

Redactions

Brown Plaintiffs

to the Declaration

Forderer Joseph

of Susan

Filed

on

2

Proposed

J Welch

1119 2012

Entered 1119 2012

1121 2012

https ecf cand

242

ORDER

by Judge Lucy

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

H Koh denying

pl452253614062028

213

Motion

L1 01

for

Hearing

granting

11 62013

CAND ECF

and denying

in part

Incorrectly

Filed

243

Filed

Order by

Hon Lucy

on

Attorney Jonathan

on

1126 2012

244

11 21 2012

H Koh

Motion

Remove

to

COURT

lhklc1

194 Motion to Withdraw

granting

79

11 21 2012

Entered

A D Herczeg

235

granting

5 11 cv 02509 LHK

of

terminated lhklc1

as Attorney

COURT STAFF

Filed

Entered 1121 2012

M Lehe

Katerine

Motion

in case

11 21 2012

Hon Lucy

Order by

232

in part

Document

STAFF
1121 2012

46

Page

H Koh

113 Motion to Withdraw

granting

COURT STAFF

lhklc1

on

Filed

as Attorney

11 26 2012

Entered

11 26 2012
1205 2012

245

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed by Adobe Systems Inc
Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Corp Intuit Inc

Intel

Inc Pixar Daniel
12 05 2012
1210 2012

246

Shaver

Stover

Motion

Administrative

to

File

1

Redacted

Exhibit

Filed

1210 2012

247

Authorities
filed

5

12 5 2012

Entered

by Michael Devine Mark

filed

Anne Shaver
4

Exhibit

2 Proposed
Exhibit

Under

Exhibits

Order

Redacted

3

Reply

SealShaver Anne

Entered 12 10 2012

MOTION to
210 MOTION to

Certify Class and
Strike

Memorandum of

the Report of

Shaver

Daniel Stover

Anne

on

Filed

Points and

Dr Edward E

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

byMichael

Marshall

of

187

re

Under Seal

Brandon Marshall Palm

on

Filed

Reply Class Certification

12 10 2012

on

REPLY

Declaration

Leamer

Report Edward

Anne

Ltd

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

Lucasfilm

Leamer

Brandon

12 10 2012

Entered

12 10 2012
1210 2012

248

Declaration

Dean

of

M Harvey

Opposition Response
Hariharan
Exhibits

filed

247 Reply to
Devine Mark Fichtner

in Support of

byMichael

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Under Seal

Filed

2

Exhibit

7

11

7

Exhibit

31

Exhibit

10

Exhibit

34Related

6

Exhibit

document

s 247

3

Exhibit

8

8

Exhibit

Shaver

Anne

4

32

Siddharth

1

Attachments

Exhibit

Exhibit

9

Filed

9

5

33 10
12 10 2012

Exhibit

on

Entered 1210 2012

1210 2012

249

Declaration

of

Edward

Opposition Response
Hariharan

Shaver

1210 2012

250

E Leamer
filed

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Anne

Filed

on

12 10 2012

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Hariharan

247 Reply to
Devine Mark Fichtner

in Support of

byMichael

Entered

by Michael

Shaver

Anne

s 247

12 10 2012

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Opposition Response

Siddharth

Related document

Filed

re

on

247 Reply

to

1210 2012

Entered

12 10 2012
1211 2012

https ecf cand

251

CLERKS NOTICE CONTINUING FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT
CONFERENCETO DATE OF MOTION HEARING Further Case
Management Conference set for 117 2013 01 30 PM in Courtroom8 4th
Floor San Jose
THIS IS A TEXT ONLY ENTRY THERE IS NO

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

47

Page

of

79

DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED WITH THIS DOCKET ENTRY mpb
COURT STAFF Filed on 1211 2012 Entered 12 11 2012
1212 2012

252

Under Seal LETTER RE CORRECTION TO
SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS
CERTIFICATION AND IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO
STRIKE THE REPORT OF DR EDWARD E LEAMER AND REPLY
EXPERT REPORT OF EDWARD E LEAMER PH filed by Michael
Motion

Administrative

File

to

CONSOLIDATED REPLY

IN

D

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

Stover

1 Proposed

Attachments

Dean

Harvey

1212 2012

253

on

Filed

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Hariharan

Order

12 12 2012

2

Redacted

Exhibit

Letter

Entered 1212 2012

Letter from Brendan P Glackin RE CORRECTION TO CONSOLIDATED
REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND IN
OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE THE REPORT OF
DR EDWARD E LEAMER AND REPLY EXPERT REPORT OF EDWARD
E LEAMER PH
Harvey Dean Filed on 1212 2012 Entered
12 12 2012

D

1217 2012

254

Order
Evans

Proposed

255

to File Under Seal filed

Susan

1217 2012

256

Filed

Zeng

1217 2012

257

File

to File Under

258

Declaration

Motion

259

Declaration

Motion

of

1218 2012

260

Declaration

Motion

Sessions

1218 2012

261

of Justina

Justina

Declaration

K

to File Under Seal filed

Anne
0109 2013

262

NOTICE of
Saveri

https ecf cand

Filed

on

Change

s 254

Welch

s 254

12 17 2012

in

Motion to

s 254

12 17 2012
254

of

Joint Administrative

Related

document

s 254

Entered 1217 2012

in Support of

254

Joint Administrative

Related document

byPixar

12 17 2012
in

document

Related

Inc

Entered

s 254

12 17 2012

Support of 254 Joint Administrative

byLucasfilm

12 18 2012

Ltd

Related document

s 254

Entered 1218 2012

Support of 254 Joint Administrative
Related document

s 254

Motion
Selin

Entered 12 18 2012

of Address

Dallal

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Entered

byGoogle Inc

1218 2012

Law Firm

on

Wagner

Motion

Joint Administrative

Related document

Inc

1217 2012

filed

on

3

Entered 12 17 2012

document

Entered

byApple

Sessions

Seal

Filed

of Frank

filed

Filed

AC

Support of 254 Joint Administrative

Seal filed

Chinue

to File Under

in

M Kennedy

James

Inc

byIntuit

12 17 2012

on

Filed

Exhibits

Support of 254 Joint Administrative

Brown in Support

Seal

to File Under

Richardson

in

12 17 2012

of Christina

to File Under

254

Related

byAdobe Systems

on

Filed

by Google Inc

Exhibit

Entered 1217 2012

filed

on

2

1217 2012

on

Corp

Zeng

W Kahn

filed

Brown Christina
1217 2012

Seal

Filed

of Lin

Under Seal

Wang Lin
1217 2012

T

Seal filed

A

in Support of

12 17 2012

Catherine

Declaration

Under

Filed

byIntel

of Catherine

Declaration

Motion

on

Eric

J Welch

of Susan

Declaration

File

to

1 Appendix Appendix

Attachments

1217 2012

Motion

Joint Administrative

by James Gerard Beebe

James

Filed

on

pl452253614062028

192013

L1 01

Dallal for Joseph

Entered 01 09 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

0109 2013

263

JOINT ADMINISTRATIVE
Certification

Declaration

Order

B Evans

of Eric

to Supplement

B Evans Supplemental

of Eric

Kevin Murphy Proposed
Declaration

MOTION for Leave

2

Inc

by Google

filed

A to

Exhibit

Order
Evans

4 Proposed

110 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Motion

1

A to

Exhibit

to

File

Under

Filed

Seal

to

2

of

1

on

3

Declaration

of

192013

Entered 0109 2013

by Google

Seal filed

Motion

Administrative

Eric

Declaration

Decl

Evans

Modified text on
Administrative

79

Record

Attachments

Kevin Murphy

264

the

of

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class

in Support of Defendants

0109 2013

48

Page

Inc

Exhibit

Attachments

B to

Motion to Seal
3 Exhibit C to Administrative
Motion to
4 Declaration
of Anne Selin
5 Proposed Order
Evans Eric Filed

Administrative

Seal
on

0109 2013

265

1 92013

of Frank

Declaration

Under Seal
Filed

0109 2013

266

on

19 2013

Under Seal

0110 2013

267

268

filed

on

Filed

NOTICE of
1 10 2013

in Support of

Corp

264

Motion

Administrative

s 264

document

Related

Brown in Support

byApple Inc

19 2013

of

264

File

Motion to

Administrative

s 264

Related document

Brown

01 09 2013

Entered

by Lisa Janine Cisneros Cisneros Lisa

Appearance

to

Busch Frank

01 09 2013

Entered

of Christina

Christina

0110 2013

Busch

byIntel

filed

Declaration
File

Entered 0109 2013

Filed

on

Entered 0110 2013

JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT filed

by Adobe Systems Inc

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Intel

Daniel Stover

0111 2013

0114 2013

269

270

Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Harvey Dean Filed on 110 2013 Entered 01 10 2013

ORDER Re Motions to Seal Signed by Judge
lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed on 111 2013
OPPOSITION
Supplement

Motion

263 JOINT

to

the Record

in

E Leamer

Defendants

1

0114 2013

271

Administrative

E Leamer
3

Exhibit

of

Motion

to

Exhibit

File

Motion

https ecf cand

272

Under Seal

NOTICE by

Intuit

Inc

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Dean

Strike the Report of

filed

in Opposition to

on 114 2013
Entered 0114 2013

Filed

by Michael Devine Mark

Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants

Redacted

4

to

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2

Exhibit

in Opposition to Defendants

Highlighted Harvey

0115 2013

Leamer

Exhibit

B

Filed

of Request

Declaration

D

114 2013

of

L1 01

Dr

Motion
Edward

Motion

E

Redactions

Entered 01 14 2013

to Bring Electronic

pl452253614062028

Dr Edward
Redacted

Administrative

Declaration

Administrative

on

of

Motion

Administrative

Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants

Redactions Highlighted

Leamer

A

Leave

by Michael Devine Mark

Dr Edward E

in Opposition to Defendants

C

MOTION to

filed

116 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

1

Administrative

210

Motion Harvey Dean

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

and

for

Opposition to Plaintiffs

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Declaration

Administrative

Modified text on

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION

REDACTED

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

H Koh on 111 2013

Entered 0111 2013

Support of Defendants

for Class Certification

Dr Edward

Lucy

Equipment

into the

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

Courtroom Attachments

1 15 2013

Modified on

Order
Zeng

1 Proposed

273

H Koh

ORDER

by Judge Lucy
Motion to

Administrative

Motion

for

File

Motion

to

granting

Under

Class Certification

Administrative

Under

Motion

Consolidated Reply

to

File

Support of

in

to File Under

its

in

part

in

Related

in part and denying

granting

252

Administrative

Letter granting in part and

Motion to

Joint Administrative

COURT STAFF

lhklc3

ERRATA re 215 Declaration in Support by
Filed on 116 2013 Entered 01 16 2013

0116 2013

275

0116 2013

276

ERRATA re
Anne

0116 2013

277

on

Filed

116 2013

by

filed

MOTION to

Inc

Intuit

COURT STAFF
278

Declaration

Nov 12

on

Filed

Floor San Jose before

M Harvey

Motion

116 2013

for

REDACTED

Hariharan

0116 2013

279

on

due by

Time

116 2013

d Portions

filed

by Michael

226 2013 10 00 AM in Courtroom5 4th

26 2013

AO

Exhibits

to

File

Under

of Plaintiffs Motion

Declaration of Dean

mpb

due

1 Declaration
of
Compel and Plaintiffs

Attachments

Motion to

REDACTED

2 Proposed

Order

Documents Harvey Dean

Entered 01 16 2013

Motion

Administrative

272 Notice

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Granting Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Google
Filed

re

H Koh on 11613

Entered 01 16 2013

in Support of Plaintiffs

to Shorten

Selin

Magistrate Judge Paul Singh Grewal Responses

1 30 2013 Replies

by
Dean

set

on

Filed

2012 by Google Inc

Signed by Judge Lucy

Siddharth

Motion Hearing

Stover

Christina

Entered 01 16 2013

Compel Google Documents

Devine Mark Fichtner

on

in Support of Joint

ORDER TO BRING EQUIPMENT INTO COURTROOM
Other

0116 2013

Support 221

Motion to Seal dated

Administrative

Inc Brown

Apple

File Under

Filed

CLERKS NOTICE re Deficiency dhmS COURT STAFF
1 16 2013 Entered 0116 2013
in

246

in part

Documents Related to Plaintiffs
Motion for Class Certification and

274

Declaration

186

part

to Plaintiffs

Seal

0116 2013

222

Entered

and denying in part 211
Documents Related to Defendants

Seal Portion of Glackin

254 Defendants
Seal in case 511 cv 02509 LHK
1 15 2013 Entered 0115 2013
denying

79

in part

Seal

Motion to Strike

Opposition to Defendants
Motion

Documents

granting

Under

part and denying

in

Seal

granting

File

Opposition to Class Certification
Administrative

on

of

116 2013 COUNSEL POSTED DOCUMENT

INCORRECTLY AS A NOTICE dhmS COURT STAFF
01 15 2013
0115 2013

Filed

Catherine

49

to

M

Seal

Pursuant to Civil Local Rule

Compel Google Documents and

79 5

the

Harvey in Support Thereof filed by Michael Devine
Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
1

Attachments

Documents

Exhibit

Redacted

A
2

Plaintiffs Motion

Exhibit

Support Thereof with Exhibits

AO

B

to

Compel Google

Declaration

Redacted

of

3

Dean

M Harvey

Exhibit

Version of Plaintiffs Motion To Compel Google Documents

Dean

M Harvey

in Support

Declaration

1 16 2013

https ecf cand

of

in

C Highlighted
4

Exhibit

Thereof Harvey Dean

D
on

Entered 0116 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

Filed

11 62013

CAND ECF

0116 2013

280

MOTION to

Shorten Time on Plaintiffs Motion to Compel

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

Stover

1 Proposed

Attachments

1 16 2013
281

Minute

79

by Michael

filed

Order Granting Plaintiffs Motion

Compel Harvey Dean

Filed

to

on

Entered 0116 2013

Entry Motion Hearing held on

117 2013

Date Filed

and

of Points

of

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Hariharan

Shorten Time on Plaintiffs Motion to

0117 2013

50

Page

Authorities

1 17 2013

MOTION to

187

re

by Michael

filed

mpb COURT STAFF

H Koh

Memorandum

Devine Siddharth Hariharan

Fichtner Daniel Stover Brandon Marshall
Shortridge

before Judge Lucy

Certify Class and

Court Reporter

Lee Anne

117 2013

Date Filed

Mark

Entered

01 22 2013
0117 2013

282

Minute

Entry and Case Management

on

Conference

held

1 172013

Further

1 17 2013

Order

Floor San Jose

mpb COURT STAFF

Shortridge

H Koh

Case Management Conference

PM in Courtroom8 4th

Case Management

Further

before Judge Lucy

Date Filed

set for

313 2013 02 00

Lee Anne

Court Reporter

117 2013

Date Filed

Entered

01 22 2013
0122 2013

283

Motion

Administrative

1 Exhibit

Attachments
Exhibit

D

6

0122 2013

284

on

Filed

Declaration

of

Under Seal

285

File

Under Seal

David

0122 2013

286

Letter

Filed

122 2013

byIntuit

1 22 2013

287

of Tina

M

to File Under Seal filed

Frank

0122 2013

288

Filed

Filed

289

on

on

filed

byIntel

Motion to

Administrative

File

s 283

Entered 01 22 2013
283

Motion to

Administrative

document

s 283

Kiernan

01 22 2013
Paul

S Grewal

Evans Eric

Filed

on

in Support of

Corp

Related

283

Motion

Administrative

document

s 283

Busch

Entered 01 22 2013

Wagner

in

byGoogle Inc

122 2013

NOTICE of

Evangelista

122 2013

of Frank

Declaration

Under Seal

0122 2013

283

Entered 0122 2013

Declaration

C

4 Exhibit
5
9 Proposed Order

Related document

Related

Entered

from Eric Evans to Honorable

G

Under Seal Kiernan

to File

in Support of

Inc

B

Exhibit

Exhibit

in Support of

K Borgeson

filed

on

on

by Adobe Systems Inc

01 22 2013

byAdobe Systems Inc
Filed

3
8

Motion

1 22 2013
0122 2013

F

Entered

Donna Morris

filed

filed

A

Exhibit

Exhibit

Administrative

of Lisa

Declaration

Under Seal

2
7

1 22 2013

Kiernan David

0122 2013

E

Exhibit

Granting Renewed

David

File

to

Support of 283 Administrative

s 283

Related document

Motion
Selin

to File

Anne

Entered 01 22 2013

Compliance

with 273 Court’s January

15

2013 Order

re

Motions

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon
Marshall Daniel Stover Harvey Dean Filed on
22 2013 Modified text
to Seal

by Michael

1

on

0122 2013

290

1 23 2013

Entered 01 22 2013

to PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR
CLASS CERTIFICATION AND MEMORANDUM
OF LAW IN SUPPORT in

REDACTION
compliance

https ecf cand

dhmS COURT STAFF

with the Court’s

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

January

15

pl452253614062028

2013 Order 273 by Daniel Stover

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Siddharth Hariharan

Dean

Harvey

0122 2013

51

Page

291

REDACTION

on

Hariharan

Michael

Exhibit

1

Exhibit

5

6

Exhibit

10

11

redacted
19 Exhibit

15

Exhibit

20

20

1

23

27
31

Exhibit

2

Exhibit

2

6

7

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

3

3

7

8

Exhibit

11
16

12

4

12

Exhibit

Exhibit

24

with

Exhibit

14

18 Exhibit
22 Exhibit

19
23

29

Exhibit

26
30

33

33

Exhibit

34

Exhibit

32 redacted

32

35

36

35

14

5
10

29 redacted

31

Exhibit

13
18
22

Exhibit

17 Exhibit
21 Exhibit

25 redacted

Exhibit

28

28

8

13

16 Exhibit 17
21 redacted

Exhibit

34

SUPPORT OF

IN

in compliance

4 redacted
9 Exhibit 9

Exhibit

Exhibit

27

redacted

B SHAVER

FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

24 redacted

Exhibit

Exhibit

Entered 0122 2013

15 2013 Order 273 by Daniel Stover Siddharth
Devine Mark Fichtner Brandon Marshall Attachments

January

the Court’s

1 22 2013

DECLARATION OF ANNE

to

PLAINTIFFS MOTION

79

Devine Mark Fichtner Brandon Marshall

Michael

Filed

of

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

36

25

Exhibit

26
30

37 redacted

Exhibit

37

38
41
52

38

Exhibit

39 redacted

39

Exhibit

40 redacted

40

41

Exhibit

42 redacted

42

Exhibit

50

51

45

Exhibit

53

55

49
53

Exhibit

58

Exhibit

50 Exhibit 60
51 Exhibit 61
52 Exhibit 62 redacted
63 redacted
54 Exhibit 64
55 Exhibit 65
56 Exhibit 66

57

Exhibit

67 redacted

Exhibit
Exhibit
Exhibit

70

Exhibit

61

Exhibit

46

58

Exhibit

Dean

on

Filed

Exhibit

56

Exhibit

68 redacted

Exhibit

71 Harvey

47

43

59

48

57

Exhibit

69

Exhibit

122 2013

44

60

Entered

01 22 2013
0122 2013

292

Joint Administrative

Motion

Support of

Administrative

Inc

Apple

Plaintiffs

Inc Google Inc
1 Proposed

Attachments

3

Exhibit

to

Under

File

to

Seal

filed

Corp Intuit Inc

Intel

Order

2

Joint Response

Lucasfilm

Ltd Pixar

REDACTED

4 Opposition highlighted

highlighted Busch Frank

Filed

on

in

by Adobe Systems

Opposition

Exhibit

REDACTED

Declaration

Declaration

Seal Defendants

Motion

1 22 2013

5

Entered

01 22 2013
0122 2013

293

AFFIDAVIT
compliance

OF EDWARD T COLLIGANAND

with the Court’s

January

15

EXHIBITS

A AND B

in

2013 Order 273 by Michael Devine

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Harvey Dean Filed on
22 2013 Entered 0122 2013

1

0122 2013

294

Declaration
File

Under

of Frank

Administrative

Busch Frank

0122 2013

295

Declaration

Motion

in Support of

Filed

on

to File

Under

T

Zeng

Filed

296

on

Under

Support

Joint Response

byIntuit

SEAL

Seal
FOR

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Joint Administrative
of

Motion to

Plaintiffs

document

s 292

Support of 292 Joint Administrative

122 2013

EFILED UNDER

AND MOTION
LAW IN SUPPORT

https ecf cand

in

filed

DOCUMENT
to File

in

byIntel

Seal Defendants

Motion to Seal

Catherine

filed

Motion

0122 2013

292

Corp Related
122 2013 Entered 01 22 2013

Motion to Seal

of Catherine

Administrative

Zeng

Busch

Seal Defendants Joint Response

Inc

Entered
re

in Support of Plaintiffs

Related

document

s 292

01 22 2013

273 Order on

Administrative

PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF MOTION
CLASS CERTIFICATION AND MEMORANDUM
OF

by Michael

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

52

Page

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Shaver

3
8

in Support of Plaintiffs

14
29

Exhibit
Exhibit

39

13

Exhibit

40

Exhibit

14

45

18

Exhibit

54

23

67

27

Exhibit

Exhibit

15
32

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

22

4
9

Attachments

1

Declaration

Anne

2

79

B

Exhibit

4

of

Motion for Class Certification

of

5 Exhibit 21
6 Exhibit 24
7 Exhibit 25
10 Exhibit 34
11 Exhibit 37
12 Exhibit

42

Exhibit

46

19

Exhibit

15

Exhibit

16

44

Exhibit

Exhibit

20

48

17

59

68

47

43

Exhibit

21

49

Exhibit

24 Exhibit 62
25 Exhibit 63
26
Harvey Dean Filed on 122 2013 Entered

01 22 2013
0122 2013

297

REDACTION to PLAINTIFFS CONSOLIDATED REPLY IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND IN OPPOSITION TO
MOTION TO STRIKE in compliance with the Court’s January 15 2013
Order

273 by Daniel Stover

Siddharth Hariharan

Fichtner Brandon Marshall

Harvey

2

1 redacted

Exhibit

Exhibit

4 redacted

6

10

9

Exhibit

14

Exhibit

Exhibit

11

18
21

Exhibit
Filed

3

15

298

on

1 22 2013

DOCUMENT

EFILED UNDER
Under

to File

12

14

Exhibit

6

Exhibit

10 redacted

Motion

0122 2013

7

Devine Mark

16

8

Exhibit

Exhibit
Exhibit

Dean

of

2 redacted

Exhibit

5

Michael

Declaration

11
21

4

M

3

Exhibit

7
13
17

9

5

Exhibit
Exhibit

12
26

of

Dean

SEAL

Seal

re

273 Order on

Administrative

PLAINTIFFS CONSOLIDATED

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

M Harvey

Exhibit

20

0122 2013

299

1

Attachments

2

IN

Declaration

4

5 Exhibit 10
15 8 Exhibit 16 9 Exhibit 17 10 Exhibit 18
12 Exhibit 20
13 Exhibit 22
14 Exhibit 23
15
Exhibit 25
17 Exhibit 26
18 Exhibit 27
19 Exhibit 29
30 Harvey Dean Filed on 122 2013 Entered 01 22 2013

13
11 Exhibit 19
Exhibit 24
16
6

1

34

Entered 0122 2013

REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND
OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE in compliance with the Court’s
January 15 2013 Order by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
Hariharan

8

Exhibit

27 redacted
19 Exhibit 28
20 Exhibit 29
31 22 Exhibit 32 23 Exhibit 33 24 Exhibit

Exhibit

Dean

Harvey

Exhibit

13 redacted

redacted
redacted

1

Attachments

Exhibit

DOCUMENT

7

2

Exhibit

3

Exhibit

4

Exhibit

Exhibit

EFILED UNDER

SEAL

Seal

re

273 Order on Administrative
from Brendan
Glackin

P
RE
CORRECTION TO CONSOLIDATED REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO
STRIKE AND REPLY EXPERT REPORT OF EDWARD E LEAMER PH D
Motion

to File

Under

Letter

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon Marshall
Harvey Dean Filed on 122 2013 Entered 01 22 2013

Daniel Stover

0122 2013

300

Declaration

Motion

of Christina

to File

Administrative

Under

Motion to Seal

Brown Christina
0122 2013

301

REDACTION
Leamer

Brown in Support

Seal Defendants

to

Filed

210

in compliance

on

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

292

Joint Administrative

byApple Inc

122 2013

MOTION to

Strike

Exhibit

pl452253614062028

s 292

Entered 0122 2013
the Report of

Adobe Systems
1

in Support of Plaintiffs

Related document

to

Dr Edward E

15 2013
Inc Pixar

with the Court’s January

Corp Apple Inc Intuit Inc
Lucasfilm Ltd Attachments

https ecf cand

filed

of

Joint Response

Welch

L1 01

Order 273 by
Google

Declaration

Intel

Inc

in

Support

11 62013

CAND ECF

Busch Frank

122 2013

on

Filed

302

DOCUMENT

EFILED UNDER

Motion

0122 2013

Under

to File

E Leamer

Edward

Corp Intuit Inc
Susan

Seal

Lucasfilm

J Welch

303

SEAL

273 Order on

re

2

Exhibit

Ltd
to

Motion

Pixar

Dr

1

Attachments

Inc

Declaration

Busch Frank

Intel

of

on

Filed

Entered 0122 2013
of Justina

79

Administrative

Strike the Report of

to

Welch Declaration

Declaration

of

01 22 2013

Entered

210 by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google

1 22 2013
0122 2013

53

Page

Filed

on

K Sessions

Motion to Seal

Administrative

122 2013

Renewed

in Support of Defendants

Ltd

byLucasfilm

filed

Sessions Justina

Entered 01 22 2013

0122 2013

304

REDACTION OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR CLASS
CERTIFICATION by Intel Corp Apple Inc Intuit Inc Adobe Systems Inc
Pixar Google Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brown Christina Filed on 122 2013
Entered 0122 2013

0122 2013

305

Declaration

Seal

of

M

Anne

byGoogle

filed

Renewed

Selin in Support of Defendants

Inc

Selin

Anne

on

Filed

122 2013

Motion to

Entered

01 22 2013
0123 2013

306

Declaration

J Brown

of Christina

in Support of

307 Renewed

to Seal filed

STAFF
0123 2013

307

Renewed

Motion to

Administrative

1 Proposed

128 2013

Modified text on

308

on

Filed

Entered 0123 2013

Attachments

0123 2013

Administrative

1 23 2013
dhmS COURT

by Apple Inc Brown Christina
Modified on 128 2013 linking entry to document
307
Motion

File

Under Seal

by Apple Inc

filed

Order
Brown Christina
dhmS COURT STAFF

on

Filed

123 2013

Entered 0123 2013

REDACTION to 304 Redacted Document by Intel Corp Apple Inc Intuit
Inc Adobe Systems Inc Pixar Google Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Attachments
1

1

Exhibit

6

Exhibit

11

Exhibit

14b

2
7

16

12

25

3
8

12
17

15

21

Exhibit

20

26

Exhibit

3

Exhibit

Exhibit

14c

Order

19

Exhibit

7

Exhibit

Exhibit

20 Proposed

2

Exhibit

Exhibit

13

8

4
9

Exhibit

13

14d

Exhibit

16

Exhibit

4

Exhibit

Exhibit

14

18

9

5
10

Exhibit

22

Exhibit

21

27

14a

14e

Exhibit

17

Exhibit

5

Exhibit

15

19
23

6

10

Exhibit

11

Exhibit

Exhibit

14f

18

Exhibit

22a

24

PURSUANT TO ORDER 317 DOCUMENT REMOVED
DOCUMENT TO BE REFILED LATER
28

Exhibit

22b

25

Exhibit

1 23 2013

33

29

Exhibit

Exhibit

Modified on

22c

30

23 31 Exhibit 24
27 Brown Christina Filed

26 34 Exhibit
123 2013 fff COURT STAFF

on 131 2013 sp COURT STAFF
COURT STAFF Entered 0123 2013
replaced

0123 2013

309

EXHIBITS
Pixar

4

307

A1e
D1 9

5

Inc Google Inc
1

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

A1f

E1

PURSUANT TO ORDER

https ecf cand

Motion

Administrative

Apple

Attachments

Exhibit

Exhibit

re

Inc

Systems

317

6

to

Intel

A 1b

32

Exhibit

2

Modified on

on

Attachment

27

1 31 2013

sp

File Under Seal filed

byAdobe

Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd
Exhibit
1c 3 Exhibit
1d

Exhibit

B1

A
7

Exhibit

C1

A
8

1a

Exhibit F
1 11 Exhibit G
DOCUMENT REMOVED

10

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

54

of

79

DOCUMENT TO BE REFILED LATER
12

G1b

Exhibit

J1

Exhibit

17

13

K1Related

Exhibit

123 2013

G1c

Exhibit

14

H1

Exhibit

document

1 23 2013

15

s 307

Exhibit

Brown

I1

Christina

COURT STAFF
Attachment 11 replaced on 131 2013 sp COURT STAFF Modified
1 31 2013 sp COURT STAFF Entered 01 23 2013
on

Filed

0123 2013

310

MOTION to Remove
Sessions

0123 2013

311

Modified on

Justina

Proposed

Order

on

Filed

1 23 2013

fff

Document filed by Lucasfilm
Entered 01 23 2013

MOTION to Remove

310

re

Ltd

Lucasfilm

Incorrectly

Filed

Sessions Justina

on

Filed

16

Incorrectly

Ltd

Document by

Filed

123 2013

on

Entered

01 23 2013
0123 2013

312

Document Exhibit 22a to Declaration
Brown filed byLucasfilm Ltd Related document s 308
Justina Filed on 1 23 2013 Entered 01 23 2013

EXHIBITS
Christina

Sessions

0123 2013

313

re

308 Redacted

Motion

Administrative

File

to

Under

Seal Google’s

Motion to Seal

Plaintiffs Administrative

Portions

Response

2

Exhibit

314

3

Declaration

EXHIBITS

G1a to

Exhibit
of

Anne

Exhibit Selin

0123 2013

2

Exhibit

Declaration

Filed

3

Exhibit

Anne
on

M

4 Proposed

123 2013

Ltd

1 28 2013

linking entry to

Sessions Justina

Filed

document

Exhibit

In

Exhibit

Order

1

5

7 Exhibit

8

Entered 01 23 2013

307 Defendant’s Renewed

Lucasfilm

Motion to

M Harvey

6 Exhibit

Selin

In Support of

of Plaintiffs

Compel Google Documents and the Declaration of Dean
Support Thereof filed by Google Inc Attachments
1

of

on

Administrative

123 2013

Motion filed by

Modified on

dhmS COURT STAFF

307

Entered 0123 2013

0123 2013

315

ORDER DENYING MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME by Judge Paul S
Grewal denying 280 Motion to Shorten Time ofr COURT STAFF Filed
on

0124 2013

316

1 23 2013

STATUS REPORT

1 24 2013
317

Order by

by Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

0125 2013

Entered 0124 2013

Tubach

Michael

Filed

on

Entered 0124 2013

H Koh

Hon Lucy

310

granting

Motion to Remove

Incorrectly

511 cv 02509 LHK Associated Cases 511cv
02509 LHK 511 cv 03538 LHK 511cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540
LHK 511 cv 03541 LHK 512cv 01262 LHK lhklc1 COURT STAFF
Filed on 125 2013 Entered 01 25 2013
Filed

0125 2013

318

Document

OPPOSITION

in case

278

to

REDACTED
Rubin

2

filed

Declaration

Modified text on

0125 2013

319

Administrative

https ecf cand

Compel Google Documents

128 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Motion

Plaintiffs Motion

Attachments

MOTION to

byGoogle Inc Attachments
1 Declaration
of Lee
of Alan Eustace Evans Eric Filed on 125 2013

1

to

to

Under

Seal re Google’s

Entered 0125 2013
Opposition

Compel and Supporting Documents

Exhibit

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

File

1

2

Exhibit

pl452253614062028

2

3

Declaration

L1 01

H

filed

to

by Google Inc

of Laszlo

Bock

11 62013

CAND ECF

4

Declaration

320

B Evans

of Eric

1 25 2013
0201 2013

55

Page

Order
Evans

5 Proposed

Eric

79

on

Entered 0125 2013

JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT by Adobe

Statement

Filed

of

Inc

Systems

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Corp Intuit Inc
Dermody Kelly

Intel

Daniel Stover

0205 2013

321

287 4580
transcript

Per General Order

may

be viewed

No

Ltd

Conference

Judicial

PACER Any
later

5

than

Restriction

After that date

Restriction

days from date of

for

set

5 62013

las

until
it

may

Redaction

this

this

may be

or

the deadline

for the

be obtained through
required

due no

is

filing Release of Transcript

on

Filed

if

408

policy

only at the Clerks Office public terminal

Notice of Intent to Request

business

H Koh

number

Shortridge Telephone

59 and

02 01 2013

Entered

Judge Lucy

before

purchased through the Court Reporter Transcriber
Release of Transcript

Brandon Marshall Pixar

21 2013

0117 13

Lee Anne

Court Reporter Transcriber

on

Filed

held on

of Proceedings

Transcript

Lucasfilm

252013

Entered 02 05 2013

0205 2013

322

ORDER REGARDING JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT TO THE
COURT Signed by Judge Lucy H Koh on 2 05 2013 lhklc3 COURT
STAFF Filed on 25 2013 Entered 02 05 2013

0208 2013

323

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED

ORDER

Regarding

Michael

Devine Mark Fichtner Google

Marshall

Plaintiffs

Inc

Dean

Harvey

Daniel Stover

Permiting Supplemental

Motion to Compel Google Documents

Briefing

Siddharth

Filed

on

2 82013

filed

by

Brandon

Hariharan

Entered

02 08 2013
0211 2013

324

STIPULATION AND ORDER PERMITTING SUPPLEMENTAL
BRIEFING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL GOOGLE

DOCUMENTS
STAFF Filed
0213 2013

325

Supplemental

by Judge Paul
on

211 2013

Brief re

REDACTED

filed

278

S Grewal
Entered

MOTION to

byMichael

Supplementalof Dean
Harvey in Support
Compel Redacted Related document s 278

0213 2013

326

Motion

to

File

Under

Motion to Compel Google

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
1

Attachments

Harvey

0215 2013

327

1

Siddharth

Hariharan

Declaration

of Plaintiffs

Harvey

Motion to

Dean

Filed

on

Entered 0213 2013

Administrative

Regarding

COURT

Compel Google Documents

Attachments

M

ofr

02 12 2013

Devine Mark Fichtner

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

2 13 2013

323

granting

Dean

Exhibit

Filed

STATUS REPORT

on

A

2

Seal Portions

Documents

Joint Discovery

by Michael

Devine

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Exhibit

2 13 2013

of Plaintiffs Supplement

filed

B

3

Exhibit

C

4

Exhibit

D

Entered 0213 2013
Status

Report by Adobe Systems

Inc

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan Intel Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Daniel Stover Shaver

0218 2013

328

RESPONSE

REDACTED

https ecf cand

re

278

Anne

MOTION

Filed

to

on

2 15 2013

Entered 0215 2013

Compel Google Documents

Supplement regarding Plaintiffs Motion

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

to

Compel

filed

11 62013

CAND ECF

byGoogle
on

Filed

0218 2013

329

Inc

Exhibit

2

0220 2013

330

0220 2013

331

2

Exhibit

B

A

2

Inc

by Google

Seal filed

Declaration

218 2013

File

to

Eric

B Evans

of Eric

Attachments

4 Proposed

02 18 2013

Entered

3

C

Order
Evans

Inc

by Google

Seal filed

Exhibit

4

D

Exhibit

Eric

5

2

S Grewal

submission

written

Fisher ofr

order after

to be issued

hearing

COURT STAFF

Date Filed

Court Reporter

226 2013

Grewal granting 313 Administrative
part and denying
granting

319

granting

to File Under

in

part

Seal

326

granting

COURT STAFF

279
Filed

File

in part

granting

File Under

in

Seal

Motion to File Under
329 Administrative
Motion to File

in

331

part

228 2013

Motion

Administrative

Motion to

Administrative

on

S

Judge Paul

Under Seal

Administrative

part and denying

in

to

Motion to

Administrative

in part and denying

granting

Under Seal

psglc2

part

in

in part and denying

Motion

Summer

Entered 0226 2013

ORDER GRANTING IN PART SEALING MOTIONS by

Seal

of

220 2013

on

Filed

Attachments

Declaration

Entry Motion Hearing held on
26 2013 before Magistrate Judge
re 278 MOTION to Compel The court takes matter under

Minute
Paul

Under

B

Exhibit

Evans 6 Proposed
Entered 0220 2013

333

3

on

Filed

Motion

Administrative

Eric

0228 2013

B Evans Evans

of Eric

79

ORDER RE Privilege Logs Signed by Judge Lucy H Koh on 220 2013
lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed on 220 2013 Entered 0220 2013

1

332

Under

File

to

Exhibit

Eric

Declaration

of

Entered 02 18 2013

Motion

1

Order
Evans

1

Attachments

218 2013

Administrative

1

0226 2013

56

Page

File Under Seal

Entered 02 28 2013

0228 2013

334

ORDER RE PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION by
Judge Paul S Grewal denying 278 Motion to Compel
psglc2 COURT
STAFF Filed on 228 2013 Entered 02 28 2013

0302 2013

335

Administrative

2013

Motion

Joint Discovery

Exhibits

Under

Report

1 and 2

Seal Exhibits

filed

2

1 and

Cisneros Lisa

to the

March

1

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Siddharth Hariharan
Exhibit

File

to

Status

Filed

1

Attachments

32 2013

on

Entered

03 02 2013
0302 2013

336

JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT by Adobe

Systems Inc Apple
Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth Hariharan Intel
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover

1

Attachments
Cisneros Lisa

Exhibit

COURT STAFF
0302 2013

337

Declaration
re

335

March

of Lisa

J

Motion

to File

Joint Discovery

Status

Cisneros Lisa

Siddharth
Filed

dhmS COURT STAFF

https ecf cand

Discovery

Status

Modified text on

Report

2

Slip

Sheet

342013 dhmS

Cisneros Regarding Late Filing on

Devine Mark Fichtner
Stover

A to Joint
322013

Entered 0302 2013

Administrative

1 2013

on

Filed

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

on

Under

Seal Exhibits

Report 336

Hariharan

322013

Status

3 22013
1 and 2

Statement
to

the

Report by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel
Modified text on

34 2013

Entered 0302 2013

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0304 2013

Page

338

NOTICE OF REQUEST

for In

text

0304 2013

339

on

1

3 52013

A

Attachments

0306 2013

340

James

JOINT CASE

Devine Mark

Decision filed by Michael
Brandon Marshall Daniel

to File Statement of Recent

Devine Mark Fichtner

Dallal

79

Exhibit
Shaver Anne Filed on 34 2013 Modified
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 03 04 2013

MOTION for Leave
Stover

of

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

Camera Review by Michael

57

Filed

Hariharan

Siddharth

1 Supplement
2 Declaration
3 Proposed
on
42013 Entered 0304 2013

Order

3

MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT filed

by Adobe Systems Inc

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Brown Christina Filed on 362013 Modified text on
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 03 07 2013
Intel

Daniel Stover

3 82013
0308 2013

NOTICE by

Google Inc

Compliance

341

with February

re

334 Order on Motion to Compel Notice

27

Evans Eric

2013 Order

on

Filed

of

3 82013

Entered 0308 2013

0308 2013

342

ORDER RE DEPOSITION
on March

8 2013

OBJECTIONS

Signed by Judge Lucy

COURT STAFF

lhklc1

Filed

on

382013

H Koh

Entered

03 08 2013
0308 2013

343

MOTION for Leave
Ltd

to File Statement of Recent

EXHIBIT

1

Attachments

1

Decision

filed

by Lucasfilm

ERROR REFER TO

FILED IN

DOCUMENT 345
Exhibit 1
2 Proposed Order
Sessions Justina Filed on 3 82013
Modified on 311 2013 fff COURT STAFF Entered 0308 2013
0308 2013

344

CORRECTIONS to 340 Joint Case Management Statement by Lucasfilm
Ltd Sessions Justina Filed on 38 2013 Modified text on 3 11 2013
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0308 2013

0308 2013

345

ERRATA re

0308 2013

346

MOTION for Leave to File Statement of Recent
CORRECTION OF DOCKET 343 343 1 by Lucasfilm Ltd
Justina Filed on 38 2013 Entered 03 08 2013
Administrative

1

Declaration

343

Motion
of Eric

to

File

Under Seal filed by Google
2 Signature Page

B Evans

Declarations Stipulations

Evans Eric

Filed

on

Inc

3 82013

Decision
Sessions

Attachments

Entered

03 09 2013
0312 2013

347

Administrative
Sealing

Motion

to

Proposed

Order

3 Exhibit

8 Exhibit
9 Exhibit
Entered 0312 2013

0313 2013

348

File

Under

Order filed by Google Inc

MOTION for leave

Seal Pursuant

Attachments

4 Exhibit

to February

5 Exhibit

10 Exhibit Selin

Anne

28

1 Declaration
6 Exhibit

Filed

on

2013
2
7 Exhibit

3 12 2013

Hac Vice
Filing fee
305 receipt
by Pixar Nields John Filed on 313 2013

to appear in Pro

number 0971 7545843

filed

Entered 0313 2013

0313 2013

https ecf cand

349

Order by

Hon Lucy

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

H Koh

granting

348

pl452253614062028

Motion for Pro Hac Vice

L1 01

in case

11 62013

CAND ECF

58

Page

of

79

5 11 cv 02509 LHK for NieldsAssociated Cases 511 cv 02509 LHK 511
cv 03538LHK 511cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540 LHK 511 cv 03541
LHK 512 cv 01262 LHK lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed on 3 13 2013
Entered 0313 2013

0313 2013

350

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER Signed
13 2013 lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed
03 13 2013

0313 2013

357

Minute

Entry

H Koh

Management Conference
Floor San Jose

STAFF
0314 2013

351

0314 2013

352

353

355

on

Filed

356

0315 2013

358

359

Robert

Filed

on

on

314 2013

314 2013

Entered

on

Inc

Inc

314 2013

Intuit

Intuit

Inc s

Inc

Entered 03 14 2013

Ltd

Sessions

03 14 2013
Tubach

Michael

Entered 03 14 2013
Intel

Corp Shah

Sujal

Entered 03 14 2013

NOTICE of Change In Counsel
WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL
03 15 2013

by Cody Shawn
Harris

Cody

NOTICE OF
on 315 2013

Harris
Filed

Entered

ORDER RE REDACTIONS FOR LACKOF RELEVANCE AND OR
lhklc1

360

on

Document Redactions by

RESPONSIVENESS

0315 2013

Filed

Document Redactions by Apple Inc

Statement Regarding

on

Filed

03 14 2013

Entered

Redactions by Adobe Systems

314 2013

Statement Regarding

Filed

0315 2013

314 2013

Statement re 350 Order Regarding Redactions by Lucasfilm

Filed

0314 2013

Henn Emily

Statement re 350 Order Defendants Adobe Systems Inc and

Justina

0314 2013

mpb COURT

Shortridge

Entered 03 15 2013

Statement re 350 Order Statement regarding Redactions by Google

Mittelstaedt

354

Lee Anne

313 2013

Entered 0314 2013

Statements Regarding

0314 2013

set

Document Redactions by Pixar

Statement Regarding

Evans Eric

0314 2013

Date Filed

Court Reporter

Date Filed

3 14 2013

313 2013
3132013 Further Case
for 422013 02 00 PM in Courtroom8 4th

Management Conference held on

Further Case

before Judge Lucy

H

by Judge Lucy
Koh on March
on 313 2013 Entered

Signed by Judge Lucy

COURT STAFF

STATUS REPORT

Filed

on

H Koh on March

315 2013

Joint Discovery

Status

15 2013

Entered 0315 2013

Report by Adobe Systems

Inc

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan Intel Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar
Daniel Stover

Harvey Dean

Filed

on

315 2013

Entered 03 15 2013

0318 2013

361

ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT GOOGLE INC S RENEWED
ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL PURSUANT TO
FEBRUARY 28 2013 SEALING ORDER by Judge Paul S Grewal granting
347
ofr COURT STAFF Filed on 318 2013 Entered 03 18 2013

0318 2013

362

ORDER RE MARCH 15

https ecf cand

H Koh on March

2013

18 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

STATUS REPORT

lhklc1

Signed by Judge Lucy

COURT STAFF

pl452253614062028

L1 01

Filed

on

318 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

59

of

79

Entered 0318 2013

0319 2013

363

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by Apple Inc from Court Reporter Lee Anne
Shortridge Brown Christina Filed on 319 2013 Entered 03 19 2013

0321 2013

364

NOTICE of
3 21 2013

0322 2013

365

R Conley

Conley

Amanda

Filed

on

Entered 0321 2013

Joint Discovery

3 22 2013

by Amanda

Appearance

Status

Inc

Report by Google

Modified text on

Selin

Anne

on

Filed

325 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered

03 22 2013
0326 2013

366

Reporter

held on

of Proceedings

Transcript

Lee Anne

Transcriber

3 13 13 before

Judge Lucy

H Koh Court

number

408287 4580

Shortridge Telephone

No

email lee anneshortridge cand uscourts gov Per General Order
Judicial

Conference policy

Office public terminal
Reporter

Transcriber

Restriction

After

from date

until

that date

Intent to Request

this

transcript

may be

or

may

Redaction

be obtained
is

through

due no

of this filing Release of Transcript

Related documents

s 363

las

the Court

for the Release of Transcript

required

if

be viewed only at the Clerks

purchased through

the deadline
it

may

59 and

on

Filed

PACER Any

later

5

than

Restriction

3 26 2013

set

Notice of
days

business

for

6 24 2013

Entered

03 26 2013
0326 2013

367

TRANSCRIPT ORDER

Cisneros Lisa

Shortridge

0327 2013

368

MOTION for Leave
1

Attachments
Catherine

0328 2013

369

Filed

370

MOTION to

371

2

3 27 2013
by

Busch Frank
Withdraw

Haslam Robert

Filed

1

Exhibit

on

4 11 2013 Replies
0328 2013

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

on

Filed

Robert

Filed

and
on

Decision

3 Proposed

by

filed

372

by Pixar Responses

due by

418 2013 Attachments
1 Proposed
328 2013 Entered 03 28 2013

373

Order by

Order

on

Authentication

3 28 2013

filed

ORDER

Regarding Document

by Adobe Systems

Inc

Mittelstaedt

Entered 0328 2013

Order by

0329 2013

Inc

Order
Zeng

Hon Lucy H Koh granting 368 Motion for Leave to
COURT STAFF Filed on 329 2013 Entered 03 29 2013

0329 2013

Intuit

Corp for Court Reporter Lee Anne
on 3 28 2013 Entered 0328 2013

as Attorney filed

due by
Filed

Intel

A

Entered

Entered 0327 2013

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED
Admissibility

3 26 2013

Exhibit

Lee Anne
03 26 2013

for Court Reporter

to File Statement of Recent

TRANSCRIPT ORDER
Shortridge

0328 2013

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

Hon Lucy H Koh granting 343
COURT STAFF Filed

Decision lhklc3

Motion for Leave
on

3 29 2013

Filelhklc3

to File Recent

Entered

03 29 2013
0329 2013

https ecf cand

374

Hon Lucy H Koh granting 339
Decision lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed
03 29 2013
Order by

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

Motion for Leave
on

3 29 2013

L1 01

to File Recent

Entered

11 62013

CAND ECF

0329 2013

Page

375

Supplemental
Seal

0329 2013

376

Declaration

of

Order dkt

to

s 361

document

361 Order on

Brief re

pursuant

filed

Evans Eric

D Harvey
s 361

Motion to

Administrative

361

byGoogle

filed

on

Filed

in Support of

to File Under Seal pursuant

Related document

no

329 2013

361 Order on

dkt
Evans Eric

to Order

no

60

of

79

File Under

Inc

Related

03 29 2013

Entered

Motion

Administrative

361 filed byGoogle Inc
on 329 2013 Entered

Filed

03 29 2013
0329 2013

377

OPPOSITION
pursuant

3 29 2013

to

361 Order on

Order dkt

to

no

Motion

Administrative

361 by Google Inc

Modified text on

to

File

Evans Eric

Under
Filed

412013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Seal

on

Entered

03 29 2013
0329 2013

378

DECLARATION
Administrative

byGoogle Inc

of Eric

Motion

to

B Evans
File

Under

document

Related

in Opposition to
Seal pursuant

s 361

361 Order on
to Order

Evans Eric

dkt

Filed

no

on

361

filed

3 29 2013

Entered 0329 2013

0329 2013

379

Joint Discovery

Status

Report by Adobe Systems

Inc

Apple

Inc

Michael

Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth Hariharan Intel Corp
Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover Harvey
Filed

329 2013

on

Modified text on

Intuit

Dean

41 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0329 2013

0401 2013

0402 2013

380

381

ORDER REGARDING DISCOVERY Signed by Judge Lucy H Koh
4 01 2013 lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed on 41 2013 Entered
04 01 2013

on

CASE MANAGEMENT
CONFERENCEFurther Case Management Conference set for 482013
10 00 AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose
THIS IS A TEXT
ONLY NOTICE THERE IS NO DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED WITH THIS
DOCKET
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 422013
CLERKS NOTICE CONTINUING FURTHER

ENTRY

Entered 0402 2013

0405 2013

382

ORDER

0405 2013

383

0405 2013

384

by Judge Lucy

DOCUMENT EFILED UNDER SEAL by Court Staff lhklc3 COURT
STAFF Filed on 45 2013 Additional attachment s added on 452013
1 Certificate Proof of Service
mpbS COURT STAFF Entered
04 05 2013
ORDER RE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

4 52013
385

H Koh on

April

STATUS REPORT
Lisa

Filed

5 2013

lhklc1

STATEMENT Signed
COURT STAFF Filed

by
on

Entered 0405 2013
Joint Discovery

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

https ecf cand

granting

to Certify Class denying

Judge Lucy

0405 2013

H Koh

in part and denying in part
187
210 Motion to Strike denying 263
Motion for Leave to File in case 511 cv 02509 LHK lhklc3 COURT
STAFF Filed on 45 2013 Entered 04 05 2013

Motion

on

4 52013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Status

Report by Michael

Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Cisneros

Entered 0405 2013

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0408 2013

386

JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT

Kiernan David

387

0408 2013

388

Paige Eugene

Conference

4 82013

held

79

by Adobe Systems Inc

Modified text on

by Lucasfilm Ltd

49 2013 dhmS

4 82013

on

Lee Anne
04 08 2013

for Court Reporter

48 2013

on

Filed

Entry and Case Management

Minute

of

Entered 0408 2013

TRANSCRIPT ORDER
Shortridge

STATEMENT filed

482013

on

Filed

COURT STAFF
0408 2013

61

Page

Order

Entered

Further

Case Management

H Koh

before Judge Lucy

Date Filed

Case Management Conference set for 515 2013 02 00 PM
8 4th Floor San Jose Final Pretrial Conference set for
5 82014 01 30 PM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose Jury Selection set for
5 27 2014 09 00 AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy
H Koh Jury Trial set for 527 2014 0900 AM in Courtroom8 4th Floor
Further

in Courtroom

before Hon Lucy H Koh Court Reporter Lee Anne Shortridge
mpb COURT STAFF Date Filed 48 2013 Entered 04 08 2013

San Jose

0408 2013

Set Reset Hearing
Hearings Final

8 4th

re

388 Case Management Conference

Pretrial

Further Set

58 2014 01 30 PM in Courtroom
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on 48 2013 Entered

Conference

Floor San Jose

set

for

04 08 2013
0408 2013

389

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by Apple Inc for Court Reporter Lee Anne
Shortridge Brown Christina Filed on 48 2013 Entered 04 08 2013

0409 2013

390

NOTICE by
Marshall

AND
0409 2013

391

392

Daniel Stover

246

OF WITHDRAWAL

Dean

Harvey

Notice of Withdrawal

Filed

Reporter

Filed

of Proceedings

Transcript

on

held on

Lee Anne

Transcriber

on

Brandon

REGARDING DKT NOS
Entered 0409 2013

4 92013

Nos

195

211

254

Conference policy

Office public terminal

48 13 before

H Koh Court

Judge Lucy

408287 4580

number

Shortridge Telephone

Reporter

Transcriber

Restriction

After

from date

until

that date

Intent to Request

this

transcript

may be

or

it

may

Redaction

No

be obtained
is

s 387

be viewed only at the Clerks

las

the Court

on

Filed

through

due no

of this filing Release of Transcript

Related documents

59 and

for the Release of Transcript

required

if

may

purchased through

the deadline

264

Entered 0409 2013

email lee anneshortridge cand uscourts gov Per General Order
Judicial

186

4 92013

Motion Regarding Dkt

of

Hinman Frank

and 292

0412 2013

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Michael

PACER Any

later

than

Restriction

4 12 2013

set

5

Notice of
days

business

for

7 11 2013

Entered

04 12 2013
0412 2013

393

Joint Discovery

Status

Devine Mark Fichtner

Report by Michael

Hariharan

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

4 12 2013

Modified text on

Cisneros Lisa

Siddharth

Filed

415 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

on

Entered

04 12 2013
0412 2013

394

Joint

Renewed

Dr Leamer

Apple Inc Google
Attachments

https ecf cand

Motion to

Administrative

Expert Reports of

1

Inc

Exhibit

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Intel

and

File Under Seal Portions

Dr Murphy

Corp Intuit Inc

A1

2

Exhibit

pl452253614062028

B1

filed

Lucasfilm
part

L1 01

of the

by Adobe Systems Inc

1

Ltd
3

Pixar

Exhibit

B1

part

11 62013

CAND ECF

62

Page

2
8

4

B2

B1

Exhibit

F1

Exhibit

12

14

G2

Exhibit

Filed

5
C1 6
G1 10
A2
C2 highlighted
Exhibit

E2

D1

Exhibit

13

15

highlighted

7

11

Exhibit

D2

Exhibit

F2

Exhibit

79

E1

Exhibit

highlighted

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

highlighted

Order
Brown Christina
415 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

17 Proposed

highlighted

412 2013

on

3

Exhibit

highlighted

highlighted

16

part

9

of

Modified text on

Entered 0412 2013

0412 2013

395

File

Busch

of Frank

Declaration

Under

in Support of

394

of the Expert Reports of

Seal Portions

Motion to

Joint Administrative

Dr Leamer

s 394

Murphy filed byIntel Corp Related document
on
12 2013 Entered 0412 2013

and

Dr

Busch Frank

Filed

4

0412 2013

396

Declaration

of

M

Anne

Murphy
on

0412 2013

397

4 12 2013

Motion

to File

Dr Murphy
Filed

0412 2013

398

Declaration

Motion

Christina

399

Murphy
Filed

0412 2013

400

Declaration

Brown in Support

412 2013

402

ORDER

James

in

Entered

of Justina

Filed

Shortridge

404

s 394

and

Brown

04 12 2013
Dr Leamer

Motion
and Dr

s 394

document

in Support of

linking entry to

K

Sessions

on

413 2013

394 Defendants

Chinue

document

Filed

on

to

Kahn Lin

Renewed

412 2013

dhmS COURT

394

Support of 394 Joint Administrative

in

document

Related

04 13 2013

H Koh on 415 2013

Entered

lhklc3

by Michael

Cisneros Lisa
Status

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Status Report Signed

COURT STAFF

Filed on

04 15 2013
Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Joint Discovery

Dr Leamer and
s 394 Sessions

the Expert Reports of

of

Entered

Filed

on

for Court Reporter

4 15 2013

Report by Adobe Systems

Devine Mark Fichtner Google

https ecf cand

and

Catherine

Dr Leamer

Support of 394 Joint Administrative

M Kennedy

TRANSCRIPT ORDER
Hariharan

0419 2013

Dr Leamer
Zeng

Joint Administrative

Regarding April 12 2013 Joint Discovery

4 15 2013
403

394

of the Expert Reports of

by Pixar Richardson

415 2013

by Judge Lucy

0415 2013

of

Related document

Motion to File Under Seal Portions
Dr Murphy filed byLucasfilm Ltd

0415 2013

Filed

Entered 0413 2013

Declaration

Justina

s 394

document

Related

Seal Portions of the Expert Reports of

Kahn

to Seal filed

STAFF
401

Inc

byAdobe Systems

of

Anne

Support of 394 Joint Administrative

Inc Related
412 2013 Entered 04 12 2013

Modified on

0413 2013

on

in

Seal Portions of the Expert Reports of

Seal Portions

filed

on

Motion

Zeng

byApple Inc

filed

of Lin

Under

Dr

Entered 04 12 2013

Under

Filed

Declaration
File

T

byIntuit

of Christina

to File

Dr Murphy
0412 2013

Under

filed

412 2013

on

Selin

and

Entered 0412 2013

of Catherine

Declaration

Dr Leamer

s 394

document

Related

Motion

Joint Administrative

of the Expert Reports of

byGoogle Inc

filed

394

Selin in Support of

to File Under Seal Portions

Inc

Siddharth

pl452253614062028

Entered

Inc

Inc Michael
Intel Corp Intuit

Apple

Hariharan

L1 01

Lee Anne

04 15 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

63

Page

Inc

Ltd

Lucasfilm

Filed

on

419 2013

Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover
Modified text on

of

79

James

Dallal

422 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0419 2013

0425 2013

405

Declaration

Thomas Henry

of

Kiernan David

0425 2013

406

0425 2013

407

Inc

Kiernan David

Google Inc

Anne

Selin

linking entry to

402

on

425 2013
15

April

425 2013

on

Inc

byIntuit

filed

Entered 04 25 2013

Re 402

Filed

document

counsel

Counsel Karen Robinson
Filed

G Berry

of William

Declaration

425 2013

In House

of Adobe’s

Declaration

Systems

on

Filed

In House

Intuit’s

filed

2013 Order

filed

by

4 26 2013

Modified on

dhmS COURT STAFF

byAdobe

04 25 2013

Entered

Entered

04 25 2013
0425 2013

408

of James

Declaration

M Kennedy

April 15 2013 Order

4 25 2013

Modified on

COURT STAFF
0425 2013

409

filed

426 2013

Related Discovery

C Sherrod

Regarding

410

document

dhmS

402

Corp Shah

of

Filed

Sujal

on

April

15

Entered 0425 2013

Declaration

Of Compensation

Production

Intel’s

Materials filed byIntel

4 25 2013
0425 2013

linking entry to

Court’s

Entered 0425 2013

of Joy

Declaration

on behalf of Pixar pursuant tp 402
by Pixar Richardson Chinue Filed on

filed

Ltd

byLucasfilm

document

M Jeon

Thomas

s 402

in Support of

1

Attachments

Purcell Daniel

402 Order dated

Attestation Related

Signature

Filed

on

2013

425 2013

Entered

04 25 2013
0425 2013

411

Declaration

A

of Heather

Tubach

Exhibit

Moser

Michael

Grenier
Filed

filed

on

byApple Inc

425 2013

Attachments

Entered

1

04 25 2013

0426 2013

412

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by UNITED STATES OF AMERICA for Court
Reporter Lee Anne Shortridge Pletcher Anna Filed on 426 2013
Entered 0426 2013

0426 2013

413

JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT by Adobe Systems Inc Apple
Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth Hariharan Intel

Corp Intuit Inc

Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover
Dallal James Filed on 4 26 2013 Modified text on 429 2013 dhmS
COURT STAFF Entered 0426 2013
0503 2013

414

Joint Discovery

Lucasfilm

Status

Report by Adobe Systems

Devine Mark Fichtner Google

Inc

Lucasfilm

Filed

on

Ltd

53 2013

Inc

Siddharth

Inc

Apple

Hariharan

Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover

Modified text on

Inc Michael
Corp Intuit

Intel

James

Dallal

56 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0503 2013

0508 2013

415

JOINT CASE
Michael

MANAGEMENT

Daniel Stover Cisneros Lisa

dhmS COURT STAFF
0510 2013

https ecf cand

416

CONFERENCESTATEMENT filed

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Filed

on

582013

Modified text on

59 2013

Entered 0508 2013

JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT by Adobe

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

by
Brandon Marshall

pl452253614062028

L1 01

Systems

Inc

Apple

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

64

of

79

Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth Hariharan Intel
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover
Dallal James Filed on 5 10 2013 Modified text on 513 2013 dhmS
COURT STAFF Entered 0510 2013
0510 2013

417

Motion

Administrative

File

to

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

1

Attachments

Motion

2

3 Redacted
Filed

0510 2013

418

on

Under Seal filed by Michael Devine Mark
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

1Redacted Supplemental Class Certification
2Redacted Expert Report of Kevin Hallock 3 Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

Leamer

Report of Edward

510 2013

Order
Harvey Dean

4 Proposed

Entered 05 10 2013

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION

to Certify Class and Brief in Support of Class

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover Motion Hearing set
Certification filed

8 4th

in Courtroom

by

Floor San Jose before

6 21 2013 Replies

Harvey

2

due by

Kevin Hallock

4

712 2013

Exhibit

Redacted

Lucy

for

882013 01 30 PM

H Koh Responses
1

Attachments

3

Lisa Cisneros

Declaration

Hon

Expert Report of

Leamer

Expert Report of Edward

Order
Harvey Dean Filed on 510 2013 Modified
5 13 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 05 10 2013
Proposed

0514 2013

419

Attorney Attorney

STAFF
0514 2013

420

0515 2013

422

370 Motion

T Haslam

514 2013

514 2013

Entered

COURT STAFF

H Koh on

CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER Signed by Judge Lucy
5 15 2013 lhklc3 COURT STAFF Filed on 515 2013
05 15 2013
Minute

Entry

Further Case

H Koh

515 2013

Date Filed

Filed

on

Date Filed

5152013

Further

515 2013

Case

Courtroom8

in

4th

mpb COURT STAFF

Entered 05 16 2013
Michael

Devine Mark Fichtner

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

517 2013

Entered

Management Conference held on

JOINT DISCOVERY STATUS REPORT by
Siddharth Hariharan

as

COURT

05 14 2013

Management Conference set for 882013 01 30 PM
Floor San Jose Court Reporter Raynee Mercado

423

Withdraw

371 Stipulation Regarding

Admissibilityand Authentication lhklc3

before Judge Lucy

0517 2013

to

terminated lhklc3

III

5

on

text

Entered 0514 2013

H Koh granting

Order by Hon Lucy
Filed on

421

Robert

Filed on

Document

0515 2013

H Koh granting

Order by Hon Lucy

due

Dean

Declaration

Redacted

Exhibit

Hariharan

Siddharth

Modified text on

Cisneros Lisa

520 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0517 2013

0517 2013

424

Joint Response

Supplemental

Documents

to Administrative

Motion in Support

filed

Motion to

File

Under Seal

of Class Certification

by Adobe Systems Inc

Attachments

and
1

Plaintiffs Supplemental

REDACTED

Motion and

4 Proposed

Order

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Expert

Supplemental

3

Exhibit

Brief in Support of Class Certification

5

Certificate Proof of Service

Documents Lodged Under Seal Kiernan David

https ecf cand

Exhibit

REDACTED
2 Exhibit
E Leamer PhD REDACTED

Witness Report of Kevin Hallock
Expert Report of Edward

Plaintiffs

Related

pl452253614062028

Filed

L1 01

on

POS

of

517 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

520 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Modified text on

0517 2013

65

Page

425

of Catherine

Declaration

Motion

Administrative

T

Zeng

File

to

Under

1

Attachments

5

1107
2140

Exhibit
Exhibit

6

10
14

Exhibit

2739
2740

2
2

Part

Exhibit

Part

3

Motion

Exhibit

912

11
15

Exhibit

1761
2738

Exhibit

2739

Exhibit

8

19

Exhibit

9

Exhibit

2135

Exhibit

12
16

3

Part

4

914

Exhibit

2739
2740

Exhibit

in

Inc

Intuit

GG

Exhibit

7

by

filed

13

1
1

Part

Part

21 Exhibit 2743
22 Exhibit 2744
23
Service Related document s 424
Zeng Catherine

Certificate Proof of

on

18

FF

Exhibit

1760
2142

Exhibit

20

2
JJ

Exhibit

Exhibit

17

Filed

EE

Exhibit

II

Exhibit

to

Seal Plaintiffs Supplemental

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents

HH

79

Entered 0517 2013

Support of 424 Response

in

of

517 2013

520 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Modified text on

Entered 0517 2013

0517 2013

426

Declaration

of Justina

K

Motion

Administrative

Sessions
File

to

Support of 424 Joint Response

in

Under

Ltd

1

Attachments

359

Envelope

711

9

5

715

Exhibit

17

Exhibit

360

Exhibit

10

2

6

8

Exhibit

3

690

Exhibit

716

Exhibit

Motion

Seal Plaintiffs Supplemental

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents

11

7

Exhibit

in

by Lucasfilm

filed

112 4
710 8 Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

727

to

12

Exhibit

728

Exhibit

729 14 Exhibit 730 15 Exhibit 944 16 Exhibit 945 17
959 18 Exhibit 2002 19 Exhibit 2084 20 Exhibit 2088 21
2094 22 Exhibit 2096 23 Exhibit 2100 24 Exhibit KK 25

Exhibit

LL

Exhibit

PPRelated

13

Exhibit

Exhibit

5 17 2013

26

MM

Exhibit

27

s 424

document

NN

Exhibit

28

Sessions

Exhibit

Justina

OO

Filed

29

on

520 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Modified text on

Entered

05 17 2013
0517 2013

427

Declaration

File

B Evans

of Eric

Motion

Administrative

Under Seal

Q

Exhibit

W

Exhibit

Eric

Documents

428

Exhibit

7

Exhibits

to

re

5

Exhibit

1
10

14

of Lin

https ecf cand

text

on

Related

to

in

File

7

15

Exhibit

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

5

AD F

Attachments
Exhibit

document

V

s 424

1

6

Evans

Exhibit

872

to Certify Class Public

byGoogle Inc
3

Exhibit

650
12

8

192

4

Exhibit

651 9
1868 13

Exhibit

Exhibit

1871 16 Exhibit 1872 17
Evans Eric Filed on 517 2013

to

Seal Plaintiffs Administrative

Motion in Support

filed

2

to

of Class

Support of 424 Joint Response

Documents

Motion

Exhibit

s 418

Plaintiffs Supplemental

1

186

Exhibit

Under

to

520 2013 dhmS COURT

U filed

Exhibit

T

Exhibit

EE

648
11

1870

W Kahn

Certification and Related

Attachments

661

document

Motion

Under Seal

4

Exhibit

2

Exhibit

Exhibit

2735 Related
Entered 0517 2013

Administrative

6

Exhibit

Exhibit

Declaration

by Google Inc

S

Exhibit

175

Exhibit

597

1869

Motion in Support

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION

418

Exhibit

653

File

8

Joint Response

Seal Plaintiffs Administrative

filed

Exhibit

Cisneros Declaration

Exhibit

429

X

Exhibit

Attachments

0517 2013

3

on 517 2013 Modified
Entered 0517 2013

EXHIBITS

557

R

Filed

STAFF
0517 2013

2

Under

Plaintiffs Supplemental

Certification and Related

424

in Support of

File

to

by Adobe Systems

Exhibit

pl452253614062028

11

L1 01

3

Motion

to

of Class

Exhibit

Inc
12

4

Exhibit

11 62013

CAND ECF

66

Page

210

5

216

Exhibit

6

300

Exhibit

7

416

Exhibit

8

1158

Errata

of

79

9

1159 10 Exhibit 1160 11 Exhibit 1250 12 Exhibit 2486 1
13 Exhibit 2486 2
14 Exhibit 2486 3
15 Exhibit 2487
16 Exhibit
2501 17 Exhibit 2800 18 Certificate Proof of Service Related document
Exhibit

s 424

Kahn Lin

COURT STAFF
0517 2013

430

REDACTION

Filed

517 2013

Modified text on

Motion

N Bowen

of Krystal

to

File

Under

1

AA

Exhibit

6

9

Exhibit

BB

Exhibit

Exhibit

10

Exhibit

2
7

424

in Support of

dhmS

CC

3 Exhibit
8 Exhibit

Intel

Y

4

DD

Joint

Motion

Seal Plaintiffs Supplemental

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents by
Attachments

5 20 2013

Entered 0517 2013

Declaration

Administrative

on

in

Corp

Z

Exhibit

9

5

391

Exhibit

392 11 Exhibit 393 12 Exhibit 397 13 Exhibit 398 14
399 15 Exhibit 400 16 Exhibit 478 17 Exhibit 781 18
Exhibit 2030
19 Exhibit 2033
20 Exhibit 2035 Bowen Krystal Filed
on 5 17 2013 Modified text on 5 20 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF
Entered 0517 2013
10

Exhibit

Exhibit

0517 2013

431

Declaration

of

Administrative

M Kennedy

James
Motion

to

File

424

in Support of

Under

Joint Response

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents

1 Cisneros Ex 129

Attachments

4 Cisneros Ex 424

420

Cisneros Ex

Ex SS

8 Cisneros Ex

1309

11 Cisneros Ex

TT

QQ

12 Cisneros Ex

3 Cisneros Ex

6 Cisneros Ex 1308

9 Cisneros Ex

UU

in

by Pixar

filed

2 Cisneros Ex 137

5 Cisneros Ex 1306

to

Motion

Seal Plaintiffs Supplemental

RR

7

10 Cisneros

13 Cisneros Ex

VV

s 424 Richardson Chinue Filed on 517 2013
520 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0517 2013

Related document
Modified text on

0517 2013

432

Declaration

Brown in Support

of Christina

Motion

Administrative

to

File

Under

424

of

Joint Response

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents

s 424

Related document
text

0517 2013

433

on

5 20 2013

EXHIBITS

re

432

Under Seal

Certification

Declaration

1

Exhibit

L

Exhibit

268

Exhibit

6

1376

2

Related
Exhibit

Exhibit

11

M

Exhibit

Documents

H
7

2

278

15

Exhibit
Exhibit

12

1854

18

1855

18

Exhibits

N

I
8

16

Exhibit

Exhibit

3

part

1858

21 Exhibit 1859 Related document
on 517 2013 Entered 05 18 2013

filed

Exhibit

279

Exhibit

part

3

19

O

13

1855

s 432

of

in

Motion to

Class

byApple Inc

J

4
9

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

part

Exhibit

in

Modified

Brown

of Christina

Motion in Support

1855

Filed

517 2013
05 17 2013

on

Filed

Entered

to Plaintiffs Administrative

Exhibit

Exhibit

Motion

by Apple Inc

filed

Support Declaration

in

Joint Response

Plaintiffs Supplemental

and

Attachments

Christina

dhmS COURT STAFF

Support of Defendants
File

Brown

to

Seal Plaintiffs Supplemental

1

1856

K

P

5
10

1130

14

17

Exhibit

20

Exhibit

Brown Christina

0520 2013

434

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by Apple Inc for Court Reporter Raynee Mercado
Brown Christina Filed on 520 2013 Entered 0520 2013

0522 2013

435

MEDIATION STATUS REPORT
Siddharth Hariharan
Filed

https ecf cand

on

522 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Cisneros Lisa
523 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Modified text on

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

67

Page

of

79

Entered 0522 2013

0528 2013

436

STATUS REPORT

Joint Discovery

Inc

Report by Adobe Systems

Status

Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan

Daniel Stover
Extension

0530 2013

437

of

51 e

Rule

438

1

Attachments

Time

5

Declaration

of

to File Due to Technical

James

Dallal

Ltd

Lucasfilm

Filed

on

Brandon Marshall Pixar

James

H Koh on May 30 2013

5 28 2013

No

59 and

Court Reporter
Restriction

After

that date

it

530 2013

Filed on

be obtained

required

if

is

s 434

transcript

may

be viewed

purchased through

rhm

on

Filed

PACER Any

through

due no

of this filing Release of Transcript

Related documents

uscourts gov Per General

this

may be

or

number

H

Koh
510451 7530

Judge Lucy

before

the

for the Release of Transcript

may

Redaction

policy

terminal

the deadline

until

Intent to Request

May 15 2013

Conference

Judicial

the Clerks Office public

from date

Civil Local

Signed by Judge Lucy

H Mercado CSR Telephone

com raynee mercado cand

rayneeh hotmail
at

held on

of Proceedings

Court Reporter Raynee

only

to

Entered 0528 2013

COURT STAFF

lhklc1

re

Dallal

05 30 2013

Transcript

Order

G

Pursuant

Failure

ORDER RE DISCOVERY STATUS REPORTS
Entered

0531 2013

Corp Intuit Inc

Intel

than

later

Restriction

5

for

set

5 31 2013

Notice of
days

business

8 29 2013

Entered

05 31 2013
0621 2013

439

OPPOSITION

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION to Certify Class
Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc
418

to

by Adobe Systems

Ltd Pixar Brown Christina Filed on 621 2013
6 25 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 06 21 2013

Lucasfilm

on

0621 2013

440

Supplemental

Expert Report of Professor

Opposition to Motion filed by Adobe Systems
Intel

Corp Intuit Inc

Appendix Related document
Modified text on

0621 2013

441

Declaration

STAFF
0621 2013

443

Declaration

filed

Inc

on

Filed

2

621 2013

Entered 0621 2013

of Class Certification

Brown Christina

linking entry to

document

and

Plaintiffs

Related

621 2013
dhmS COURT

Filed

450

on

Entered 0622 2013
Anne

of

filed

6 25 2013

M

Selin In Support of

450 Defendants

Joint

Motion to Seal Defendants Opposition to Plaintiffs
Motion in Support of Class Certification and Related

Supplemental

on

Google

439

1 Exhibit

of 450 Defendants Joint
Under Seal Defendants Opposition to

by Apple Inc

625 2013

Administrative

Document

File

to

Motion in Support

Supplemental

in Support of

Inc Apple Inc
Attachments

Busch Frank

Modified text

Brown in Support

of Christina

Modified on

s 439

Pixar

625 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Adminstrative Motion

Documents

Ltd

Lucasfilm

M Murphy

Kevin

filed

by Google

Inc

linking entry to

Selin

Anne

document

450

Filed

on

621 2013

Modified

dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0622 2013

0621 2013

444

Declaration

of

Administrative

Supplemental

https ecf cand

James

M Kennedy

Motion to

Seal Defendants

Motion in Support

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

in Support of

450 Defendants

Opposition

of Class Certification

pl452253614062028

L1 01

to

Joint

Plaintiffs

and

Related

11 62013

CAND ECF

Document

625 2013

Expert Report

of

79

6 21 2013
dhmS COURT

on

450

Entered 0622 2013

EXHIBIT

Filed

document

linking entry to

STAFF
442

Chinue

by Pixar Richardson

filed

Modified on

0622 2013

68

Page

on

Inc

by Adobe Systems

filed

6 22 2013

Shaw Ph D

Kathryn

of

439 Opposition

re

Motion

to

s 439 Kahn Lin
625 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Related document

Modified text on

Filed

Entered 0622 2013

0622 2013

445

Declaration

Inc
1

1

Exhibit

6

6 25 2013
446

2

Supplemental

1

Kahn

in

9

0622 2013

447

of Lin

Declaration
File

9

2

28 30

Errata

W Kahn

in

Exhibit

part

Modified on

STAFF
0622 2013

448

1

6

of Catherine

Under

Filed

document
449

450

1 10 part 2
Exhibit

Administrative

450

to Plaintiffs Supplemental

Documents

filed

451

Exhibit

Declaration

of

Administrative

Documents

STAFF

https ecf cand

Filed

450

Motion to
Motion in

on

6 22 2013

dhmS COURT

Support of 450 Administrative

s 450

document

Related

on

625 2013

Motion to

Zeng

linking entry to

Entered 0622 2013

3

4

Filed

File

to

Under

linking entry to

Seal Defendants

Moiton in Support

Exhibit

Ltd

Motion

4

Sessions Justina

K SESSIONS

to

File Under

Motion

by Lucasfilm

on

document

450

622 2013

in

Opposition to

of Class Certification and Related

1

Attachments

Exhibit

Filed

625 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

JUSTINA

filed

625 2013

Entered 0622 2013

Motion

Plaintiffs Supplemental

Justina

in

Inc

by Lucasfilm

Modified text on

0622 2013

Zeng

Modified on

Plaiintiffs Supplemental

3

document

text

by Adobe

filed

Kahn Lin

11

2

Busch in Support of 450 Defendants Joint
Motion to File Under Seal filed by Intel Corp Busch Frank

Joint Administrative

2

Errata

part

on 622 2013 Modified
Entered 06 22 2013

on 6 22 2013 Modified
dhmS COURT STAFF

622 2013

on

T

Intuit

dhmS COURT STAFF
0622 2013

3

28 30

of Frank

Declaration

Filed

by

Seal filed

Catherine

0622 2013

linking entry to

Inc

by Adobe Systems

Filed

s 450

document

625 2013

Modified text on

Entered 0622 2013

Declaration
File

Related

6

10 Related

Support of 450 Joint Administrative

Under Seal Defendants Opposition

Inc

5

Exhibit

Exhibit

6 22 2013

Support of Class Certification and Related Documents
Systems

5

10

Attachments

Support of 439 Opposition to

1 10 part 1

5

4

Exhibit

on

Filed

s 439 Kahn Lin
dhmS COURT STAFF

6 25 2013

4

Exhibit

Pixar

Entered 06 22 2013

Related document

on

Ltd

Lucasfilm

3

Exhibit

to

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

for Class Certification filed

Exhibit

21 27

Exhibit

W

of Lin

Motion

to

Attachments

4

3

STAFF

dhmS COURT

DECLARATION

20

2

Exhibit

439 Opposition

of

filed

Corp Intuit Inc

Intel

7 Exhibit 7
8 Exhibit 8
s 439 Brown Christina

document

0622 2013

Class Certification Motion

Google Inc

Exhibit

Brown in Support

of Christina

Supplemental

in Support of

Seal Defendants

1

2

Exhibit

6

on
22 2013
Entered 0622 2013

450

Joint

Opposition to

Support of Class Certification and Related

Ltd

Related document

Modified on

s 450

Sessions

625 2013 dhmS COURT

Entered 0622 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0627 2013

69

Page

452

NOTICE OF ERRATA to

439 Opposition

to Supplemental

Motion and 440 Supplemental Expert Report

Certification

M Murphy

of

79

Class

Kevin

of Professor

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp
Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Pixar Attachments
1 Corrected Exhibit 7
Brown Christina Filed on 627 2013 Modified text on 628 2013 dhmS
COURT STAFF Entered 0627 2013
Intuit

0712 2013

453

Letter
Filed

0712 2013

454

CoLead
712 2013

from

on

Class Counsel re Notice

Motion

Administrative

to

File

1

Under Seal

Declaration

Anne

of

4 Exhibit
5 Exhibit
12 2013 Entered 0712 2013

0712 2013

455

REPLY

418

in Support of

REDACTED

456

Declaration

of

B Shaver

Anne

Shaver

in Support of

455

1 Exhibit

Declaration

of

Edward

Opposition Response

455

0712 2013

458

Shaver

Declaration

of

Anne

E Leamer

in Support of

REDACTED

filed

on

0712 2013

459

Shaver

text

Filed

on

7 15 2013

Entered

07 12 2013

in Support of

byMichael

s

Related document

455 Reply

to

Devine Mark Fichtner

s

Related document

712 2013

Entered

by Michael

on

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

s

455 Reply to
Devine Mark Fichtner

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Anne

Devine Mark

byMichael

712 2013

Non Party Sheryl Sandberg
REDACTED filed

Siddharth Hariharan

Support

3 Exhibit Related document

Opposition Response

455

in

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2 Exhibit

Filed

Hariharan

7 12 2013

Entered 0712 2013

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Siddharth Hariharan

3

on

Certify Class

Plaintiffs Reply

Shaver Anne Filed on 7 12 2013 Modified
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0712 2013

457

on

Filed

455

0712 2013

to

Order

Filed

Siddharth

Class Certification Motion filed by Michael

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

Anne

715 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Anne

of Supplemental

2 Proposed

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

0712 2013

B Shaver

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner

filed

Modified text on

by Michael Devine Mark

filed

6 Exhibit Shaver

Exhibit

7

Dean

Harvey

Settlement

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

of

Entered 07 12 2013

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

07 12 2013

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover re 457 Declaration
in Support
456 Declaration
in Support 455 Reply to Opposition Response 458
Hariharan

Declaration

in

Support Shaver

Anne

Filed

on

7 12 2013

Entered

07 12 2013
0714 2013

460

ORDER REGARDING JULY 12 2013 NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT
LETTER Signed by Judge Lucy H Koh on 714 2013 lhklc3 COURT
STAFF Filed on 714 2013 Entered 0714 2013

0719 2013

461

RESPONSE to 454 PLAINTIFFS ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE
UNDER SEAL PLAINTIFFS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF SUPPLEMENTAL
MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION filed by Lucasfilm Ltd
Attachments
Exhibit

https ecf cand

E

1

Exhibit

A

Sessions Justina

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

2

Exhibit

Filed

on

B

3

Exhibit

719 2013

pl452253614062028

C

4

Exhibit

Modified text on

L1 01

D

5

7 23 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

dhmS COURT STAFF
0719 2013

70

Page

462

JOINT RESPONSE
Seal

Plaintiffs

Frank

Filed

on

Motion To

Administrative

Inc

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

filed

Inc Busch

79

Entered 0719 2013

454

to

of

719 2013

Google Inc

File

Corp Intuit

Intel

7 23 2013

Modified on

Under

counsel

posted document incorrectly as a motion and failed to link entry to related

dhmS COURT STAFF

document

0719 2013

463

Inc
text

464

To

Rowan

of

Related document
text

0719 2013

465

on

7 23 2013

Declaration

To

0719 2013

466

7 23 2013

Proposed

Order

468

Motion To

s 462

Google Inc

Lucasfilm

Christina

469

Inc

on

470

on

Filed

To

https ecf cand

471

Modified

07 19 2013
Plaintiffs

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

Inc

Hariharan

Siddharth

Intel

Brandon Marshall Pixar Daniel Stover

719 2013

PhD

Inc Michael
Corp Intuit
Brown

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple

re Mediation

Entered

07 19 2013

in Plaintiffs Reply in Support of Supplemental

re

457

Supplemental

Declaration

of

Expert Report of

Edward

E Leamer

455

Inc Apple Inc Google
Corp Intuit Inc Brown Christina Filed on 719 2013
text on 723 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0719 2013

in Support of

on

719 2013

posting

STAFF
0719 2013

7 19 2013

Entered

418 Supplemental Class Certification

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel
Attachments
1 Exhibit Leamer Related document

when

text

Opposition Response by Adobe Systems

to

Intel

REPLY

Filed

File Under Seal

to Evidence

E Leamer

Modified

0719 2013

by Google Inc

Seal filed

on 719 2013 Modified
Entered 07 19 2013
Filed

Joint Response

Class Certification Motion and Rebuttal

Reply

Joint Response

Corp Intuit Inc Busch Frank Filed on 719 2013
723 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0719 2013

Ltd

Filed

OBJECTIONS
Edward

Inc

719 2013 Modified
07 19 2013

462 Defendants
Under

Intuit

Intel

Devine Mark Fichtner Google

0719 2013

on

Filed

File

Anne

by

Seal filed

Entered

Busch Frank

462 Defendants

STATUS REPORT
Inc

Under

dhmS COURT STAFF

re

Modified text on

0719 2013

Modified

07 19 2013

Entered

Busch in Support of 462 Defendants Joint Response To
Motion To File Under Seal filed by Intel Corp

Motion To

Administrative

Inc

File

dhmS COURT STAFF

Related document

467

by Adobe Systems

7 19 2013

Support of 462 Defendants Joint Response

Selin in Support of

Selin

on

Filed

Administrative

Plaintiffs

0719 2013

in

Motion To

s 462

of Frank

Declaration

on

Mason

Administrative

7 23 2013

text

T

M

Anne

of

Plaintiffs

File Under Seal filed

s 462 Mason Rowan
dhmS COURT STAFF

Related document

on

Motion To

Administrative

Plaintiffs

To

Support of 462 Defendants Joint Response

s 462 Kahn Lin
dhmS COURT STAFF

7 23 2013

Declaration

in

document

Related

on

W Kahn

Administrative

Plaintiffs

0719 2013

of Lin

Declaration

Entered 07 19 2013

Declaration

Modified on

document

7 23 2013

incorrect

Entry linked to document

MOTION filed

Corp Intuit Inc

s 462

Busch Frank

event type selected

418

dhmS COURT

Entered 0719 2013
of Christina

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Brown in Support

pl452253614062028

of

469 Objection

L1 01

to Reply

11 62013

CAND ECF

Evidence

469
472

filed

EXHIBITS

re

Motion To

Inc

byAdobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google

Inc Attachments
Brown Christina

Intuit

0719 2013

Intel

File Under

re

Motion To

Inc

Intel

Exhibit

7 19 2013

7 19 2013

Seal

Exhibit
Exhibit

J

To

B

To

C

7

on
19 2013
Entered 0719 2013

Filed

Administrative

Plaintiffs

1

Exhibit

K

6 Exhibit
Related document s 462

O

s

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google

Exhibit

F

L

2

7

G

Exhibit

M

Exhibit

3

8

Busch Frank

723 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Modified text on

Corp

document

Administrative

Plaintiffs

Busch Frank

Attachments

5

79

Entered 0719 2013

Joint Response

filed

Intel

of

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google
1 Exhibit
2 Exhibit
3

s 462

462 Defendants

Inc

Related

Attachments

Corp Intuit Inc
4
9

B

Exhibit

723 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

File Under

H
N

Exhibit

2

Joint Response

filed

Related document

EXHIBITS

on

Filed

Seal

A

Exhibit

462 Defendants

Modified text on

473

1

Corp Intuit Inc

D

Exhibit

0719 2013

71

Page

Filed

on

Entered

07 19 2013
0719 2013

474

EXHIBITS

re

Motion To

Inc

Intel

Part

1

document

File Under

475

3

2739

Exhibit

s 462

of Christina

s 462

Related document
text

0720 2013

476

on

7 23 2013

Proposed

filed

Order

re

2

Part

Administrative

Plaintiffs

by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google
1

Attachments

4

STAFF

on

3

Part

719 2013

of

File

2

Exhibit

2739

Related

Modified text on

462 Defendants

Under

Christina

dhmS COURT STAFF
462 Defendants

2739

2738

Entered 07 19 2013

Motion To

Brown

Exhibit

Exhibit

Filed

Brown in Support

Administrative

Plaintiffs

To

Joint Response

Busch Frank

dhmS COURT

Declaration

To

Seal

Corp Intuit Inc

7 23 2013
0719 2013

462 Defendants

Seal filed

Filed

Entered

Joint Response

To

on

Joint Response

by Apple Inc

719 2013

Modified

07 19 2013
Plaintiffs

File Under Seal CORRECTION OF DOCKET
Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc
Busch Frank Filed on 720 2013 Modified text on 723 2013 dhmS
COURT STAFF Entered 0720 2013
Administrative

467

0722 2013

477

Motion To

by Adobe Systems

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED
Lucasfilm and Pixar filed by Pixar

ORDER

Substituting

Henn Emily

Filed

Counsel by

on

7 22 2013

Entered 0722 2013

0722 2013

478

TRANSCRIPT ORDER
Hariharan

by Michael

Mercado Harvey Dean

0723 2013

479

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Filed

on

for Court Reporter

722 2013

Entered

Raynee

07 22 2013

d

MOTION TO ENFORCE LOCAL RULE 73 1 AND STRIKE
DEFENDANTS IMPROPER SUR REPLY filed by Michael Devine
Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

due by 729 2013 Attachments
1 Proposed
on
23 2013 Entered 0723 2013

Mark

Responses

Order
Harvey Dean

Filed

7

0723 2013

https ecf cand

480

DEAN M HARVEY in Support of 479 MOTION TO
ENFORCE LOCAL RULE 73 1 AND STRIKE DEFENDANTS
IMPROPER SUR REPLY filed byMichael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
Declaration

of

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

d

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

2

481

B

Exhibit

479

0724 2013

C

4

Filed

on

Exhibit

Dean

Harvey

Exhibit

D

7 23 2013

H Koh granting

1

Attachments

5

E

Exhibit

of

79

A

Exhibit

s

Related document

Entered 0723 2013

477 Stipulation

PermitKeker

to

LLP to Withdraw as Counsel for Lucasfilm lhklc3 COURT
724 2013 Entered 0724 2013

Nest

STAFF
482

3

Order by Hon Lucy

Van

0725 2013

72

Page

Filed on

NOTICE of

M Paige

by Robert Addy Van Nest Daniel Purcell Eugene

Appearance

Justina

K

Sessions

Van Nest Robert

Filed

725 2013

on

Entered 0725 2013

0726 2013

483

BRIEF

Regarding the Impact of the Proposed

Motion

Supplemental

Settlement on Plaintiffs

for Class Certification re

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

460 Order by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Hariharan

Harvey Dean Filed on 726 2013 Modified
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 0726 2013

Stover

0726 2013

484

JOINT BRIEF

Regarding the Impact of the Proposed

on

Settlements

the Supplemental

Inc

Adobe Systems
Christina

STAFF
0728 2013

485

Filed

text

on

729 2013

Pixar and Lucasfilm

Class Certification Motion re 460 Order by

Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc Brown
on 726 2013 Modified text on 729 2013 dhmS COURT
Apple

Entered 0726 2013

OPPOSITION
AND STRIKE

d

479 MOTION TO ENFORCE LOCAL RULE 73
1
DEFENDANTS IMPROPER SUR REPLY filed by Adobe

to

Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Intuit Inc Attachments
Order
Brown Christina Filed on 728 2013 Modified text on
7 29 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF Entered 07 28 2013
Systems

1 Proposed

0729 2013

0729 2013

486

487

NOTICE of
7 29 2013

Appearance

NOTICE of
7 29 2013

Appearance

by Daniel Edward

by Eugene Morris Paige

NOTICE of Appearance by Justina Kahn
on 7 29 2013 Entered 0729 2013

0730 2013

489

Letter

0801 2013

490

CoLead
730 2013

from

0808 2013

495

Minute

STATEMENT filed

on

of

Settlement

Harvey

on

Filed

Dean

8 12013

88 2013

re

by Michael Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Cisneros

Entered 0801 2013

Entry Motion Hearing held on

Date Filed

Filed

Entered 07 30 2013

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Filed

Eugene

Sessions Justina

Sessions

Class Counsel re Notice

CASE MANAGEMENT
Lisa

Paige

Entered 0729 2013

488

on

on

Filed

Entered 0729 2013

0729 2013

Filed

Purcell Daniel

Purcell

418

8 82013

before Judge Lucy

SUPPLEMENTAL MOTION

H Koh

to Certify Class

by Michael Devine Siddharth Hariharan Mark Fichtner Daniel Stover
Brandon Marshall Further Case Management Conference held on
82013
filed

8

before Judge Lucy

ADR

H Koh

Further Case

Courtroom8

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

8 82013

Case referred to Private

10 32013 01 30 PM
Lee Anne Shortridge
88 2013 Entered 08 19 2013

Management Conference

4th Floor

mpb COURT STAFF

https ecf cand

Date Filed

set

for

in

San Jose Court Reporter
Date Filed

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

0809 2013

73

Page

491

MOTION for Leave
1

Attachments

to File Statement of Recent

1

Exhibit

Decision

Statement of Recent

Order and Stipulation Riley George

Filed

on

of

79

by Apple Inc

filed

2 Proposed

Decision

89 2013

Entered

08 09 2013
0812 2013

492

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by Apple Inc for Court Reporter Lee Anne
Shortridge Brown Christina Filed on 812 2013 Entered 08 12 2013

0812 2013

493

TRANSCRIPT ORDER

Cisneros Lisa

Shortridge

494

of Proceedings

Transcript

Reporter

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

0819 2013

by Michael

held on

Lee Anne

Transcriber

on

Filed

Lee Anne

for Court Reporter

8 12 2013

88 13 before

08 12 2013

Entered

H Koh Court

Judge Lucy

number

Shortridge Telephone

408287 4580

email lee anneshortridge cand uscourts gov Per General Order
Conference policy

Judicial

Office public terminal
Reporter

Transcriber

Restriction

After

Intent to Request

from date

or

this

transcript

may be

that date

it

Redaction

may
if

s 492

be obtained

required

las

the Court

for the Release of Transcript

is

Filed

through

due no

of this filing Release of Transcript

Related documents

59 and

be viewed only at the Clerks

purchased through

the deadline

until

may

No

on

PACER Any

later

than

Restriction

8 19 2013

set

5

Notice of
days

business

for

11 18 2013

Entered

08 19 2013
0823 2013

496

MOTION for Leave

to File Statement of Recent

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

Hariharan

Stover

1

1

Attachments

Exhibit

filed

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Statement of Recent

Order and Stipulation Harvey

Proposed

Decision

Dean

Filed

Decision

on

2

823 2013

Entered 0823 2013

0827 2013

497

CHART

Related

Administrative

to

424 Defendants

Motion

to

File

Joint Response

to

Plaintiffs

Under Seal and Suporting

Declarations

Filed

May 17 2013 filed by Adobe Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel
Corp Intuit Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Pixar Related document s 424
Selin
Anne Filed on 827 2013 Modified text on 828 2013 dhmS COURT
STAFF Entered 0827 2013
on

0830 2013

498

MOTION for Leave

to File Statement of Recent

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

Hariharan

Stover

1

1

Filed

0919 2013

499

Attachments

on

830 2013

MOTION for Leave

on

0919 2013

500

Letter

Motion
Filed

0921 2013

501

from

to File Statement of Recent

on

919 2013

Hariharan

Decision

filed

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

Order
Dallal James

Filed

of Class Action Settlements

Harvey Dean

Entered 09 19 2013

MOTION for PreliminaryApproval
of Points

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Order
Harvey Dean

Class Counsel and Counsel for Settling Defendants re

for Preliminary Approval

Memorandum

https ecf cand

Siddharth

1 Exhibit
2 Proposed
Entered 0919 2013

CoLead

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

2 Proposed

Attachments

9 19 2013

filed

Entered 08 30 2013

Devine Mark Fichtner
Stover

Exhibit

Decision

and

of Class Action Settlements

Authorities

in Support Thereof

pl452253614062028

L1 01

REDACTED

11 62013

CAND ECF

filed

by Michael

Marshall

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Motion Hearing

Daniel Stover

Granting

502

of Class Action Settlements

M Dermody

5

1
6

9 21 2013

Order

1

Exhibit

6

Exhibit

filed

501

Intuit

on 921 2013
Entered 0921 2013

MOTION for

by Michael Devine Mark

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

in Support of

REDACTED

PreliminaryApproval

Exhibit

1 Proposed

with Defendants

Ltd and PixarCisneros Lisa Filed
on 923 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

of Kelly

Declaration

Brandon

10 32013 01 30 PM in
Hon Lucy H Koh Responses due

Lucasfilm

Modified text

79

Motion for Conditional Class Certification and

Plaintiffs

PreliminaryApproval

Inc

of

for

set

Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose before
by 10 72013 Replies due by 10 15 2013 Attachments

0921 2013

74

Page

2

Exhibit

2

3

Exhibit

3

4

4

Exhibit

5

s 501 Cisneros Lisa Filed
dhmS COURT STAFF Entered

Related document

923 2013

Modified text on

on

09 21 2013
0921 2013

503

R Saveri

of Joseph

Declaration

Approval

of Class Action Settlement

Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
1

Attachments

on

Filed

MOTION for Preminary
REDACTED filed by Michael Devine

1

Exhibit

921 2013

501

in Support of

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

s 501

Related document

Modified text on

Cisneros Lisa

923 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0921 2013

0921 2013

504

Motion

Administrative

Preliminary Approval

File

to

1

Exhibit

5

6

0925 2013

505

Exhibit

6

Exhibit

Order
Cisneros

Lisa

MOTION for Leave

Seal Portions

Class Settlements

of

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan
Attachments

Under

1
7

on

Devine Mark Fichtner

Siddharth

1

1

0925 2013

506

NOTICE by

Filed

on

Exhibit

9 25 2013

1

Decision

4

5

8 Proposed

filed

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel

2 Proposed

Order and Stipulation

Entered 0925 2013

Ltd Pixar of Letter to
Letter Henn Emily Filed

Lucasfilm

Attachments

Devine Mark

Entered 0921 2013

Hariharan

Stover

Cisneros Lisa

M Harvey

Dean

9 21 2013

to File Statement of Recent

Attachments

by Michael

Motion for

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
2 Exhibit 2
3 Exhibit 3
4 Exhibit

Declaration

Filed

filed

of Plaintiffs

Attorneys

on

General

925 2013

Entered

09 25 2013
0925 2013

507

NOTICE by
28

U SC

Section

9 25 2013
0926 2013

508

Intuit

Inc
1715

of Mailing

of Letter

to

Attorneys

General Pursuant to

1 Exhibit Kiernan David

Attachments

Filed

on

Entered 0925 2013

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT filed by Adobe Systems Inc
Apple Inc Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Google Inc Siddharth
Hariharan
Filed

on

Intel

Corp Brandon Marshall

926 2013

Modified text on

Daniel Stover

Sessions

Justina

930 2013 dhmS COURT STAFF

Entered 0926 2013

0930 2013

509

ORDER
307

by Judge Lucy

Administrative Motion to File

denying in part

https ecf cand

H Koh granting

335

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

in part

Under Seal

and

denying

granting

in part

in part

and

Administrative Motion to File Under Seal granting

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

75

Page

and

in part

denying

Seal granting
to File

346

in part

in part

Under Seal

granting

283

and denying in
Under Seal granting

Administrative Motion to File

02509 LHK

COURT STAFF

lhklc4

Administrative Motion

in part

Administrative Motion to File
in part

394

Under

271

part

and

in part

denying

5 11cv

Seal in case

930 2013

Filed on

79

Under

Administrative Motion to File

and denying in part

of

Entered

09 30 2013
510

ORDER

by Judge Lucy

H Koh granting

granting

0930 2013

496 Motion

Leave

for

491 Motion

for

Leave

498 Motion

to File granting

to File

Leave

for

to

File granting 499 Motion for Leave to File granting 505 Motion for
Leave to File
THIS IS A TEXT ONLY ENTRY THERE IS NO

DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED WITH THIS DOCKET ENTRY
lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed on 930 2013 Entered 0930 2013
1001 2013

511

CLERKS NOTICE CONTINUING FURTHER CASE MANAGEMENT
CONFERENCEAND MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL Further
Case Management Conference set for 1021 2013 02 00 PM in Courtroom8
4th Floor San Jose Motion Hearing set for 10 21 2013 02 00 PM in

4th Floor San Jose before Hon Lucy H Koh
THIS IS A
TEXT ONLY NOTICE THERE IS NO DOCUMENT ASSOCIATED
WITH THIS DOCKET
mpb COURT STAFF Filed on
10 12013 Entered 1001 2013

Courtroom8

ENTRY

1001 2013

Set Reset Hearing
Hearing
on

1007 2013

512

re

511 Clerks Notice Clerks Notice Continuing Motion

EFILED UNDER

DOCUMENT

Pixar

Motion

Under

to

Intel

Supplemental
Filed

1007 2013

514

on

Seal

Corp Intuit Inc

Declaration

10 7 2013

REDACTION

Seal

to

Lucasfilm

Kevin

Administrative

2

Exhibit

Motion

for

14

1007 2013

515

Ltd Pixar

Apple

Motion

Inc
1

Attachments

Motion to

of Plaintiffs

File

1

Attachments
of

3

Under

Plaintiffs

Ann

4

Exhibit

Reply

Decl Kahn Lin

Motion

B Shaver
4

in

to

Exhibit

Filed

26

to

on

Entered 1007 2013

Seal

to

509 Order on

by Google

https ecf cand

Inc

M Murphy Brown Christina

Class Certification

of

REDACTION

1 2013

Administrative

Joint Administrative

to Declaration

Dean Harvey in Support
Harvey Decl
5 Exhibit 29 to Harvey

10 72013

Entered

Entered 10 07 2013

509 Order on

Plaintiffs

M

Corp Intuit

Intel

10 72013

on

509 Order on

Defendants

of Professor

for Class Certification

Declaration

re

Filed

by Adobe Systems

by Adobe Systems Inc

Support of

Administrative

Inc Google Inc

SEAL

Supplement the Record

Google Inc

509 Order on

Brown Christina

EFILED UNDER

to File

re

Expert Report of Professor Kevin

Apple

DOCUMENT
for Leave

SEAL

Seal
Inc

Inc Lucasfilm Ltd
10 07 2013
513

Filed

Entered 1001 2013

Motion to File Under
Murphy by Adobe Systems

1007 2013

mpb COURT STAFF

Motion and Deadlines Hearings

Set

10 12013

Joint Discovery

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Inc

Status

Administrative

Attachments

Motion to
1

Report Selin Anne

pl452253614062028

File

Exhibit

L1 01

Filed

Under

Exhibit

on

A to

March

10 7 2013

11 62013

CAND ECF

76

Page

of

79

Entered 1007 2013

1007 2013

516

REDACTION

509 Order on

Seal

to

Inc

by Google

Class Certification

3

1

2

Opposition

14

Exhibit

to

Brown

of Defendants

21

Plaintiffs

Part

4

5

Opposition

Exhibit

Opposition to Plaintiffs

Brown Declaration

to

Motion
8

Certification

of Defendants

4

in Support of Defendants

7

26

Brown

to

25

Exhibit

1007 2013

517

10 7 2013

Motion

10 Motion to

Under

File

Under

Class Certification by Adobe Systems
Lucasfilm

Brown in Support

Christina

2

for Class Certification

4

6
11

part

5

Exhibit

12

Exhibit

2

7

15

12

17

part

Exhibit

18

part

6

1

8

16

13

Exhibit

19

Exhibit

17

22

Exhibit

19

Administrative

to

REDACTION

Seal

to

509 Order on

1

Attachments

3

Exhibit

9

16
23

Declaration

Edward
part

4

14

part

10

20

10

1

14

17

part

Exhibit

Exhibit

3

Exhibit

Exhibit

17

3

2

9

Exhibit

20

18

24

1

Edward

E Leamer Ph

D

3 Expert Report

E Leamer

Ph

2 Expert Report
of Professor

M Murphy

D

Kevin

10 07 2013

Brown

DOCUMENT

EFILED UNDER

Motion

519

Under

to File

LEAMER PH D
version

Exhibit

11

14

Exhibit

1 18
1 21

part

21

Exhibit

File

29

25

Exhibit

27

Under

10 72013

Kevin
part

re

M Murphy

3

Christina

SEAL

of Professor

Kevin

M Murphy

2

part
4 Expert
5 Reply Expert Report of

Filed

on

10 7 2013

509 Order on

Entered

Administrative

Seal EXPERT REPORT OF EDWARD

ISO October

1 2012

Motion

to

Certify Class

No 190

by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover
Cisneros Lisa

at Docket

Hariharan

https ecf cand

Motion to

Administrative

5

Exhibit

Intel

Report of Professor

1007 2013

of

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion

Exhibit

part

Intel

Corp Apple Inc Intuit Inc Adobe Systems Inc
Google Inc Lucasfilm Ltd Attachments
1 Expert Report of
by

Pixar

Motion for

Plaintiffs

22 26 Exhibit 23 27 Exhibit 25 28 Exhibit 26
Brown Christina Filed on 10 72013 Entered 1007 2013

518

Motion to

Administrative

Exhibit

1007 2013

to

Anne

Inc Apple Inc Google Inc

Exhibit

13

Exhibit

509 Order on

Opposition

Pixar

Exhibit

15

2
2

Ltd

re

of Defendants

Exhibit

Exhibit

Exhibit

27

Exhibit

Leamer Report Selin

273 Order on

Defendants

Corp Intuit Inc

9

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion

Strike

SEAL

Seal

Seal

to File

to

Entered 10 07 2013

EFILED UNDER

DOCUMENT

Opposition

Brown Declaration

to

in Support of Defendants

Declaration

in Support of Defendants

for Class Certification

Brown

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class

Exhibit

Brown Declaration

to

Motion for

Plaintiffs

to

Part

Opposition

14

Exhibit

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class Certification

on

in Support

19 to Brown Declaration
in Support
Motion for Class Certification
6

for Class Certification

in Support of Defendants

Filed

Motion for

Declaration

3

Class Certification

Exhibit

Brown

to

Plaintiffs

14 to Brown Declaration
in Support
Motion for Class Certification Part

in Support of Defendants

Declaration

14

Exhibit

Under

to

Exhibit

to Plaintiffs

File

Opposition to Plaintiffs Motion for Class Certification

of Defendants

2

Part

1

Attachments

in Support of Defendants

Declaration

Motion to

Administrative

E

redacted
Siddharth
Filed

on

Entered 1007 2013

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

520

DOCUMENT

EFILED UNDER

Motion

1007 2013

77

Page

Under

to File

SEAL

509 Order on

re

Seal REPLY

of

79

Administrative

EXPERT REPORT

OF

EDWARD E LEAMER PH D ISO December 10 2012 Reply Brief redacted
version
at Docket No 249 by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth
Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

10 72013
1007 2013

521

Cisneros Lisa

on

Filed

Entered 1007 2013

EFILED UNDER

DOCUMENT

SEAL
Seal

509 Order on

re

Administrative

TO
DEFENDANTS JOINT ADMIN MOT FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT
THE RECORD ISO THEIR OPPOSITION TO THE MOT FOR CLASS
CERT AND MOT TO STRIKE DR LEAMER’S EXPERT REPORT Docket
No redacted version at Docket No 270 by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner
Motion

to File

Under

PLAINTIFFS OPPOSITION

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Siddharth Hariharan

1

Attachments

DECLARATION OF EDWARD E LEAMER IN OPPOSITION
TO DEFENDANTS ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION Docket No redacted
at Docket No 270
Cisneros Lisa Filed on 10 72013 Entered
version
10 07 2013
Declaration

1

1017 2013

522

NOTICE of

ORDER
1017 2013

1018 2013

523

524

ORDER

STIPULATION WITH PROPOSED

10 18 2013
525

10 17 2013

on

Entered 1017 2013

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT UPDATED filed by Adobe
Systems Inc Apple Inc Google Inc Intel Corp Van Nest Robert
on 10 17 2013 Entered 1017 2013

Counsel for

1020 2013

Filed

P Stone AND CONSENT

by Gregory

of Counsel

Substitution

Stone Gregory

RESPONSE
Filing of

Intel

Corporation

filed

by

Regarding Substitution

Corp

Intel

to

523

the

Non Settling

Defendants

Unauthorized

1

Exhibit
Filed

A

2

Exhibit

B

3

Exhibit

527

on

H Koh granting

text

C
on

4

Exhibit

D

10 21 2013 dhmS

5 11 cv
02509 LHK Associated Cases 5 11 cv 02509 LHK 5 11 cv 03538 LHK
5 11 cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540 LHK 5 11 cv 03541 LHK 5 12 cv
Order by Hon Lucy

01262 LHKlhklc1
10 20 2013

1021 2013

Supplemental

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

1020 2013 Modified
COURT STAFF Entered 1020 2013
Dermody Kelly

526

on

Devine Mark

Updated Case Management Statement by Michael

Attachments

of
Filed

Entered 1018 2013

Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

1020 2013

Stone Gregory

Filed

COURT STAFF

Case Management Order by

and

denying

in part

504

Hon

524

Stipulation in case

Filed on

Lucy

10 20 2013

H Koh

Entered

Order granting

Administrative Motion to File

Under

in part

Seal in

5 11 cv 02509 LHK Associated Cases 5 11cv 02509 LHK 5 11cv
03538 LHK 5 11 cv 03539 LHK 5 11 cv 03540 LHK 5 11 cv 03541
LHK 5 12 cv 01262 LHK lhklc1 COURT STAFF Filed on
case

10 21 2013
1021 2013

https ecf cand

534

Entered

10 21 2013

10 21 2013 before Judge Lucy H Koh
Date Filed 10 21 2013 re 501 MOTION for Preliminary Approval of Class
Action Settlements
REDACTED filed by Michael Devine Siddharth
Minute

Entry Motion Hearing held on

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

78

Page

Mark Fichtner Daniel Stover

Hariharan

Brandon Marshall

1021 2013

Management Conference held on

79

of

Case

Further

H Koh

before Judge Lucy

Date Filed 10 21 2013 Further Case Management Conference set for
12 18 2013 02 00 PM in Courtroom8 4th Floor San Jose Court Reporter
Lee Anne Shortridge mpb COURT STAFF Date Filed 10 21 2013

Entered 1028 2013

1022 2013

528

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by Apple Inc for Court Reporter Lee Anne
Shortridge Brown Christina Filed on 10 22 2013 Entered 10 22 2013

1022 2013

529

TRANSCRIPT ORDER

Cisneros Lisa

Shortridge

1022 2013

530

TRANSCRIPT ORDER

531

ORDER

1025 2013

532

by

Filed on

EFILED UNDER

Lee Anne
1022 2013 Entered 10 22 2013
418 Motion

1024 2013

SEAL

Service lhklc1

Certificate Proof of

Entered

Court Reporter

H Koh granting

by Judge Lucy

DOCUMENT

on

Filed

Lee Anne
10 22 2013

for Court Reporter

10 22 2013

Corp for

Intel

COURT STAFF

lhklc1

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth

on

Filed

Stone Gregory

Shortridge

1024 2013

by Michael

Brandon Marshall Daniel Stover

Hariharan

to Certify

Entered

by Court Staff

COURT STAFF

Class

10 24 2013
1

Attachments
Filed

10 25 2013

on

Entered 1025 2013

1025 2013

533

NOTICE by
Marshall

Daniel Stover re 501

Supplemental

3

Settlement

C

Exhibit

Dermody Kelly

1028 2013

535

NOTICE by
Marshall

MOTION

REDACTED

Action Settlements

B

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Michael

4

Filed

Michael

on

D

1028 2013

536

Motion
with

E

6

A

Exhibit

Exhibit

F

7

for PreliminaryApproval

Notice

of

Filing Pursuant

1

Attachments

Filed

EFILED UNDER

on

10 28 2013

SEAL

2

Exhibit

Exhibit

G

Entered 10 25 2013

MOTION

REDACTED

3 Cisneros Lisa

DOCUMENT

1

Attachments
Exhibit

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

2013 Case Management Order
Exhibit

5

10 25 2013

Daniel Stover re 501

Action Settlements

of Class

Notice Of Filing Revised And

Documents

Exhibit

for PreliminaryApproval

Brandon

re

1

Exhibit

to

Brandon
of Class

October

2

Exhibit

21

2

3

Entered 10 28 2013

527 Order on

Administrative

Under Seal Attachment D to Plaintiffs Settlement Agreement
by Michael Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan Brandon

to File

Intuit

Marshall

Daniel Stover

Cisneros Lisa

Filed

on

10 28 2013

Entered

10 28 2013
1028 2013

537

NOTICE by
Marshall

Michael

Devine Mark Fichtner Siddharth Hariharan

Daniel Stover re 527 Order on Administrative

Seal Second Notice

of Filing Pursuant

Management Order Attachments
10 28 2013 Entered 1029 2013

1030 2013

538

1

October

21

1 Cisneros Lisa

Brandon

to File

Under

2013 Case
Filed

on

Document OF FILING REVISED
FILED IN RESPONSE TO
PLAINTIFFS ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL

NOTICE by
REDACTED

Intel

Corp re 430

INTEL

Redacted

CORP DOCUMENTS

PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN SUPPORT

https ecf cand

to the Court’s
Exhibit

Motion

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

OF CLASS CERTIFICATION AND

pl452253614062028

L1 01

11 62013

CAND ECF

Page

RELATED DOCUMENTS
PHILLIPS

B

Exhibit

10

7

Part

12

7

Part

2

B

Exhibit

10

of

5

Part

10

10

of

2

B

Exhibit

Exhibit

Part

10

5

of

1

B

Exhibit

10

of

B

10

A

Exhibit

Exhibit

Part

8

Part

8

of

3

Phillips

10

Part

11

Bradley

B

10

of

B

Exhibit

Part

6
6

of

Exhibit

1

of

10
B

10
B

Exhibit

79

9

Part

4

Part

Exhibit

9

of

4

of

B

10

10 30 2013

on

Filed

of

OF BRADLEY S

Declaration

3

Attachments

SUPPORT

IN

79

Entered 1030 2013

1030 2013

539

of Proceedings

Transcript

1021 13

held on

Lee Anne

Court Reporter Transcriber

H Koh

Judge Lucy

before

Shortridge Telephone

408

number

287 4580

No

email lee anneshortridge cand uscourts gov Per General Order
59 and Judicial Conference policy this transcript may be viewed only at

the Clerks Office public

Reporter

Transcriber

Restriction

that date

After

Intent to Request

from date

terminal

until

may be

or

it

Redaction

may
if

purchased through

be obtained

required

s 528

las

on

Filed

PACER Any

through

due no

is

of this filing Release of Transcript

Related documents

the Court

for the Release of Transcript

the deadline

later

than

Restriction

set

10 30 2013

5

Notice of

business

for

days

1 28 2014

Entered

10 30 2013
1030 2013

540

Order by Hon Lucy
Attachments

1 Claim

10 30 2013

Filed on

1031 2013

Set Reset Hearing
Hearing

re

re

Form

Entered

4th Floor

Filed

on

501 Motion for Settlement

Intuit

San Jose

10 31 2013

PACER

COURT STAFF

2 Notice lhklc1

10 30 2013

540 Order on Motion

Pixar Lucasfilms

Courtroom8

STAFF

H Koh granting

set

before

Entered

for Settlement

for

5 12014

Final

01 30

Approval

PM in

Hon Lucy H Koh mpb COURT
11 01 2013

Service Center

Transaction

Receipt

11 06 2013 16 44 22

PACER Login

kv0159

Description

Docket

Billable

https ecf cand

Pages

Client

Report Search

30

uscourts gov cgi bin DktRpt

Code
Criteria

Cost

pl452253614062028

hteal

511 cv

02509

LHK

3.00

L1 01

11 62013