Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al
Filing
77
RESPONSE to Motion re 75 MOTION for an Order Directing Cisco to Provide Identified Documents to the Court for In Camera Review filed by Cisco Systems, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, Tabs 1-4, # 2 Exhibit A, Tabs 5-6, # 3 Exhibit A, Tabs 7-8, # 4 Exhibit A, Tab 9, # 5 Exhibit B, # 6 Exhibit C, # 7 Exhibit D, # 8 Order)(Babcock, Charles)
Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al
Doc. 77 Att. 2
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 1 of 19
TAB A-7
Dockets.Justia.com
wara v. Lisco submission log
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 2 of 19
Page 1 of 2
Parker, Crystal
From: Parker, Crystal Sent: To: Cc: Friday, June 19, 2009 3:13 PM 'Patricia L. Peden'; nickpatton@texarkanalaw.com Babcock, Chip; Flynn-DuPart, Mary Lou; Adair, Kathy; 'Marcie Long'
Subject: RE: Ward v. Cisco submission log Patty, We all agreed that Cisco would produce to the Court in camera the privileged documents Cisco produced in the Albritton case. I believe the log contains all of those documents. If you will let me know whether there are any documents produced in the Albritton case that were not identified, we will add them to the list. Otherwise, we will get the documents to the Court. Thanks,
Crystal J. Parker Jackson Walker L.L.P. 713-752-4217
From: Patricia L. Peden [mailto:ppeden@pedenlawfirm.com] Sent: Wednesday, June 17, 2009 12:32 PM
To: Parker, Crystal; nickpatton@texarkanalaw.com Cc: Babcock, Chip; Flynn-DuPart, Mary Lou; Adair, Kathy; 'Marcie Long'
Subject: RE: Ward v. Cisco submission log
Crystal: We will look through the list and confirm that it includes all of the documents produced in the Albritton case. It will take us a day or two to do that and get back to you. Cisco's submission log should also include the documents that Baker Botts gave Cisco for production in the Albritton case. Also, there are documents on Cisco's privilege log separate and apart from the documents produced in the Albritton case that should be submitted. We will identify those documents for inclusion on Cisco's list. Can you confirm for me that Cisco's privilege log has not changed since it was last produced to Ward? If additional documents have been logged on Cisco's privilege log, please provide us with an updated privilege log so that we can identify the documents we would like submitted to Judge Hendren. Finally, you may want to include a column on the far left of the submission log that numbers the documents. If the Court has questions about the documents and wants further argument, it helps to be able to discuss the documents by number. Thanks, Patty
From: Parker, Crystal [mailto:cparker@jw.corn] Sent: Wednesday, June 17, 2009 7:58 AM
To: ppeden@pedenlawfirm.com ; nickpatton@texarkanalaw.com Cc: Babcock, Chip; Flynn-DuPart, Mary Lou; Adair, Kathy
Subject: Ward v. Cisco submission log
«DOCSOPEN-#5536654-v2-Privileged_Documents_Produced_in_Albritton_v Cisco_case.DOC»
6/26/2009
w aro v. Lisco submission log
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 3 of 19
Page 2 of 2
Patty and Nick, Attached is the submission log containing all the privileged documents produced under the Protective Order and non-waiver agreements in the Albritton v. Cisco case (except one as described below). As we agreed in our hearing with Judge Hendren, Cisco will submit these documents for in camera inspection on or before next Friday. Judge Hendren asked us to come to an agreement regarding this list. Please confirm that these are all the privileged documents produced under the Protective Order and non-waiver agreements in the Albritton v. Cisco case. You will notice that one document is missing: CISCO PRIVILEGED.000014, which was inadvertently produced as a privileged document, when it is only responses to privileged documents but not itself privileged. I will have it bates labeled and produced to you as a non-privileged document before we submit these documents to Judge Hendren. Take care,
Crystal J. Parker
Jackson Walker L.L.P. 1400 McKinney, Suite 1900 Houston, TX 77010 713-752-4200 (main) 713-752-4217 (direct) 713-752-4221 (main fax) 713-754-6717 (direct fax) Email: c arkein Internet Email Confidentiality Privileged/Confidential Information may be contained in this message. If you are not the addressee indicated in this message (or responsible for delivery of the message to the addressee), you may not copy or deliver this message to anyone. In such case, you should destroy this message and kindly notify the sender by reply email. The statements contained herein are not intended to and do not constitute an opinion as to any tax or other matter. They are not intended or written to be used, and may not be relied upon, by you or any other person for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be imposed under any Federal tax law or otherwise.
6/26/2009
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 4 of 19
TAB A-8
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 5 of 19
WARD V. CISCO CISCO'S SUBMISSION LOG
No. 1 Begin Bates End Bates To No. No. CISCO CISCO Bart Showalter l PRIVILEGED.° PRIVILEGED. (Baker Botts) 00001 000001 John Corcoran Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter CISCO Bart Showalter CISCO PRIVILEGED.° PRIVILEGED. (Baker Botts) 00002 000003 Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Mark Michels Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) John Corcoran Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Mark Michels Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) John Corcoran (logged at 1) CISCO CISCO Bart Showalter PRIVILEGED.0 PRIVILEGED. (Baker Botts) From Rick Frenkel CC Dan Lang Main Date Title 17-Oct2007 1:47 p.m. Amended ESN Complaint Description Email regarding ESN's filing of an amended complaint. Privilege Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
2a
Marta Beckwith
Dan Lang
17-Oct2007 4:47 p.m.
RE: Amended ESN Complaint
Email regarding attachment to ESN's amended complaint
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
2b
Rick Frenkel
Dan Lang
17-Oct2007 4:45 p.m.
RE: Amended ESN Complaint
Email regarding attachment to ESN's amended complaint and legal strategy with respect to same
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
2c
Kurt Pankratz
Dan Lang
17-Oct2007 4:32 p.m.
RE: Amended ESN Complaint
Email regarding attachment to ESN's amended complaint
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
2d 3
Rick Frenkel
18-Oct2007
ESN
Email regarding the court clerk's changing
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
I Every person listed in the "From" and "To" categories was a Cisco employee unless otherwise indicated.
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 6 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
From
Privilege
00004
000004
4a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00005
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000005
4b 5
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00006
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000006
5b 6a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00007
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000008
Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Mark Michels Mallun Yen Michael Ritter (logged at 3) Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Mark Michels Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Dan Lan. (logged at 31, Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts)
Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)
Dan Lang
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)
Dan Lang
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
Jillian Powell (Baker Botts) Rick Frenkel
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
6b
7a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00009
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000009
Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Micheal Ritter Mallun Yen Steve Shortgen (Baker Botts)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
JiWan Powell (Baker Botts)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 7 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
7b
Jillian Powell (Baker Botts)
Steve Shortgen (Baker Botts) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)
Kurt Pancratz 22-Oct(Baker Botts) 2007 10:58 a.m. 22-Oct2007 11:50 a.m. Rick Frenkel 25-Feb2008 9:32 p.m.
RE: ESN
8a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00010
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000010
Jillian Powell (Baker Botts) Steve Schortgen (Baker Botts) lo· sed at 7a (logged at 7b) Mark Chandler
Re: ESN
Email between Baker Botts attorneys asking Jillian about her call to the court clerk regarding the ESN complaint Email between Baker Botts attorneys regarding calls made by Plaintiff
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
8b 8c 9a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00011
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000013
Mallun Yen
9b
John Noh
Mallun Yen
Rick Frenkel
18-Oct2007 10:06 a.m. 18-Oct2007 10:04 a.m. 18-Oct2007 9:47 a.m.
FW: ESN PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENT IAL RE: ESN
Attorney Client Email regarding Yen's Work Product (ordinary) lack of involvement with the article at issue Produced-not privileged Produced-not privileged
9c
Mallun Yen
John Noh
Rick Frenkel
Re: ESN
Produced- not privileged
Produced-not privileged
9d
Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian Neal Rubin John Noh
Mallun Yen
Re: ESN
Email regarding sources that local counsel persuaded the court clerk to change the date, discussing the lawsuit and asking whether there is a news story
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
9e 9f 10 11
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00019 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00027
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000026 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000027
(logged at 5a) (logged at 5b) (logged at 6b) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel 15-Oct2007 We were just sued by ESN, LLC Email discussing lawsuit filed by ESN against Cisco Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 8 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
12
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00028 CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00037
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000028 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000041
Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel
Mark R. Weinstein (White & Case) Marta Beckwith
3:00 p.m. 25-Oct2007 11:44 a.m. 22-Oct2007 10:47 a.m.
13
14
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00043 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00044
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000043 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000048
Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel)
Marta Beckwith
Charles K Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel)
25-Feb2008 4:01 p.m. 22-Oct2007 11:01 a.m.
ESN Filing Date - From the Blogs A/C Privileged In case you haven't seen this about your DJ case in ESN Troll Tracker
Email with attorney regarding alteration of docket and discussing speculation regarding same Email forwarding article about the ESN filing to legal team
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
15
Marta Beckwith
Bart Showalter (Baker Botts Marta Beckwith Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)
16a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00087
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000087
Samir Bhavsar (Baker Botts)
25-Feb2008 4:07 p.m.
16b
Marta Beckwith
Samir Bhevsar (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith
25-FebBart Showalter 2008 (Baker Botts) 4:01 p.m. Doug Kubeh 25-Feb(Baker Botts) 2008 Bryant Boren (Baker Botts 5:56 p.m. Samir Bhavsar (Baker Botts) Chad Walters
.(Baker BottsL
16c
Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)
In case you haven't seen this about your DJ case in ESN Troll Tracker Response to question from Cisco's counsel regarding Frenkel being revealed as the Patent Troll Tracker Troll Tracker Question from Cisco's counsel regarding Frenkel being revealed as the Patent Troll Tracker Troll Tracker Email to Cisco's Counsel regarding Frenkel being revealed as Patent Troll Tracker
Email informing Cisco's counsel that Frenkel has been revealed as the Patent Troll Tracker Response to article written about ESN lawsuit and expressing opinion about the bias of the same
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
17
CISCO PRIVILEGED.°
Bart Showalter CISCO PRIVILEGED. baker Botts)
Marta Beckwith
Bryant Boren
25-Feb2008
Troll Tracker
Email informing counsel that Frenkel
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 9 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
00089
000089
(Baker Botts)
(Baker 3:56 p.m. Botts) Chad Walters (Baker Botts) Doug Kubeh (Baker Botts) Samir Bhavsar (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Mallun Yen Mallun Yen Dan Lang 25-Nov2007 8:13 a.m. 18-Oct2007 9:23 a.m. 18-Oct2007 11:43 AM 18-Oct2007 11:44 AM 18-Oct2007 11:40 AM 18-Oct2007 11:38 AM New local rules ESN
has been revealed as the Patent Troll Tracker
18
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00094 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00103
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000094 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000105
Greg Chambers (McKook Smith) Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Michael Ritter Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith Mark Michels Michael Ritter Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith
Email asking for analysis of changes to the local rules Email about contacting attorneys who handled a motion to correct the docket Email about contacting local counsel about legal advice Email about contacting local counsel about legal advice Email about contacting attorneys who handled a motion to correct the docket Email about contacting attorneys who handled a motion to correct the docket
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
19a
19b
RE: ESN
19c
RE: ESN
19d
FW: ESN
19e
RE: ESN
19f
Rick Frenkel
Dan Lang
18-Oct2007 11:33 AM
RE:ESN
Email about legal opinions concerning enforcement of filing dates and legal strategy regarding
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 10 of 19
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 11 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
From
CC
Main Date
Description
Privilege
Ho 1113111111111111=11111
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00122
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000125
lo·ed at 5a lo ed at 5b Mark Chandler
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Mallun Yen
25-Feb2008 10:14 PM
ESN PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENT IAL
11111111111111111111111111111111
Email regarding Yen's lack of involvement in article at issue
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
extummimummig lo
lo·ed at 21a ed at 21b 23d lo·ed at 9a amis lo ed at 9b 1121111 lo ed at 9c EMI EEMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII lo ed at 9d 1·1111111111111111111111111111=111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 lo ed at 5a ERN Eimummimmimm lo ed at 5b INMIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIINIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Email forwarding email Attorney Client 24a CISCO 18-OctESN CISCO Matthew Tanielian Mark concerning calling local Work Product (ordinary) 2007 PRIVILEGED.0 PRIVILEGED. Chandler counsel 00126 000126 9:40 a.m. 24b lo ed at 3 IIIIIIINIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIallMIIIIIIMNNMMIIIIIIIIII Email responding to 17-OctRe: 25a CISCO Rick Frenkel John Attorney Client CISCO 2007 Amended proposed legal Work Product (ordinary) PRIVILEGED.0 PRIVILEGED. Corcoran ESN strategy 00134 000135 4:46·.m. Com laint 25b lo·ed at 2b 11111.11111111 lo ed at 2c 25c 1111111111111111111111111111 25d lo ed at 2d MOM 111111111111111 Amended Rick 17-OctJohn Corcoran Email responding to Attorney Client 26a CISCO CISCO proposed legal PRIVILEGED.0 PRIVILEGED. Frenkel 2007 ESN Work Product (ordinary) Complaint strategy 00136 000137 4:47 .m. 26b lo·ed at 25a 26c 1111111111111111111011.1111111111111 lo ed at 2b IIMIIIMIMIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIINIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 26d 11111111.11111111 lo ed at 2c 26e 11111111111111111011111111.11111 lo·ed at 2d IMIIIIIIIIHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIMIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIMIIII Email regarding Attorney Client Matthew Tanielian Rick 19-OctFair CISCO CISCO Frenkel Comparison sending statistics to I PRIVILEGED.0 PRIVILEGED. 2007 of Patent patent reform coalition 00138 000140 Litigation 12:47 p.m. Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007 23b
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 12 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
iTo
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
27b
Rick Frenkel Mark Chandler
Matthew Tanielian
Mallun Yen Dan Lang
19-Oct2007
27c
Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian
Rick Frenkel
Mallun Yen Dan Lang
28a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00141
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000144
Rick Frenkel
Mallun Yen
28b
Mallun Yen
Rick Frenkel
Fair Comparison of Patent 12:29 Litigation Statistics, p.m. 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007 18-OctFair Comparison 2007 of Patent 9:47 p.m. Litigation Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007 25-FebESN PRIVILEGED 2008 AND 9:51 p.m. CONFIDENT IAL 25-FebESN PRIVILEGED 2008 AND 9:51 p.m. CONFIDENT IAL
Email regarding sending statistics to patent reform coalition
Attorney Client
Email regarding busiest jurisdictions for patent cases
Attorney Client
Email discussing Yen's lack of involvement in the article at issue Email discussing Yen's lack of involvement in the article at issue
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
28c 28d 28e 28f 28g 28h 29a 29b 29c 29d 29e 29f 29g
CISCO 00146
CISCO 000149
(logged at 9a) (logged at 91a) (logged at 9c) (logged at 9d) (logged at 5a) (logged at 5b) (logged at 28b) (logged at 9a) (logged at 9b) (logged at 9c) (logged at 9d) (logged at 5a) (logged at 5b)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 13 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
30a 30b 31a 31b 31c 31d 32a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00154 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00167
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000156 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000168
(logged at 27b) (loiged at 27c) (logged at 19e) (logged at 190 (logged at 199) (loiged at 19h) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel (logged at 3) (logged at 19c)
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00169
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000169
Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)
Dan Lang (dlang)
18-Oct2007 9:36 a.m.
ESN
Email regarding the clerk's changing of the date for the ESN complaint and discussing proof of filing on October 15
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
32b 33a 33b 33c 33d 33e 33f 34
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00192
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000194
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00204
(logged at 19d) (logged at 19e) (togged at 19f) (logged at 3) (logged at 4a) CISCO Kurt Pankratz PRIVILEGED. (Baker Botts) 000204 Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter
Zahner, Gail (Day Pitney)
35a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00212
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000212
Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Marta Beckwith
Marta Beckwith
35b
Anthony J. Downs
Bucci, Michael A. (Day Pitney) Sicilian, James (Day Pitney) Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel
17-Oct2007 2:00 p.m.
Complaint for Declaratory Judgment Cisco v ESN LLC Re: Hertz/TSD Motion to Correct Docket Re: Hertz/TSD Motion to Correct
Email regarding service of complaint for declaratory judgment on ESN
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
18-Oct2007 11:57 a.m. 18-Oct2007 11:21
Email forwarding pleadings in another case Email sending pleadings in another case.
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 14 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
36a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00227
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000228
36b
36c
36d
36e
Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts) Bart Showlater (Baker Botts) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Mallun Yen Rich Renfree Bart Showlater (Baker Botts) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Mallun Yen Rich Renfree Bart Showlater (Baker Botts) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Mallun Yen Mark Michels Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts) Kurt Pancratz
Rich Renfree
a.m. 19-Oct2007 10:01 a.m.
Docket RE: ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case
Email attaching ESN's amended complaint and discussing service
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Mark Michels
19-Oct2007 9:57 a.m.
Re: ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case
Email discussing service of ESN complaint and amended complaint
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts)
19-Oct2007 8:59 a.m.
Re: ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case
Email discussing service of ESN complaint
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts)
19-Oct2007 10:56 a.m.
Re: ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case
Email asking for a return call
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Bart Showalter
19-Oct2007
FW: ESN Files Motion to Enjoin
Email regarding getting started with work on the ESN case
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 15 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
CC
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
(Baker Botts) 36f Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Micheal Ritter CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00231 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000233 'Victoria Maroulis' (Quinn Emanuel) Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel
7:55 a.m. Mark Michels 19-OctBart 2007 Showalter Kurt Pancratz 1:30 a.m. 1-Nov2007 9:10 a.m. 31-Oct 2007 6:47 p.m. 31-Oct2007 5:04 p.m.
I 37a
Michael Ritter Victoria Maroulis Michael Ritter
37b
37c
Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith
37d
Rick Frenkei Marta Beckwith
37e
Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith
Mark Michels Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Charles K. Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Michael Ritter Smith Mark Michels Victoria (Quinn Emanuel) Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Charles K. Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel) Rick Michael Ritter Frenkel Mark Michels Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Charles K. Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel)
Cisco's CT Case ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case Re: ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call Re: ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call Re: ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call
Email regarding ESN's motion to enjoin and discussing strategy regarding same Email discussing status of potential settlement regarding venue issues Email discussing status of potential settlement regarding venue issues Email discussing comments to draft opposition to motion to stay
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
30-Oct2007 3:24 p.m.
Re: ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call
Email discussing comments to draft opposition to motion to stay
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
30-Oct2007 2:38 p.m.
Re: ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call
Email discussing comments to draft opposition to motion to stay
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 16 of 19
No.
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To
From
C
Main Date Title
Description
Privilege
37f
Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith
Kevin Smith
38a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00234
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000237
Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter (logged at 19a) (logged at 19b) (logged at 19c) (logged at 19d) (logged at 19e) (logged at 19f) (logged at 4a) (logged at 3) (logged at 19d)
Marta Beckwith
Michael Ritte 30-OctMark Michels 2007 Victoria 11:06 Maroulis Charles K. a.m. Verhoeven 18-Oct2007 12:21 p.m. 18-Oct2007 11:57 a.m. 18-Oct2007 11 :54 a.m.
ESN v. Cisco -Conference Call Re: ESN
Email discussing draft opposition to opposition to motion to stay Email discussing another case in which another firm filed a motion to correct the docket Email discussing another case in which another case filed a motion to correct the docket Email discussing another case in which another case filed a motion to correct the docket
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
38b
Mallun Yen
Re:ESN
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
38c
Rick Frenkel
Re: ESN
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
38d 38e 38f 38g 38h 38i 38j 38k 39a 39b 39c 39d 39e 40a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00250 CISCO PRIVILEGED,0 00254
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000251
(logged at 19e) (logged at 19f) (logged at 4a) (logged at 3) Marta Beckwith CISCO PRIVILEGED. Michael Ritter 000254 Rick Frenkel Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Michael Ritter
Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith
Mark Michels Mark Michels
19-Oct2007 8:11 a.m. 19-Oct2007 7:19 a.m.
Re:
Email about select on of counsel Email about case strategy and selection of counsel
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
40b
Re:
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 17 of 19
No. 40c 41 42a
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
To Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter ip-disputesteam(Cisco IP team mailer list) John Noh ( Mark Chandler
From Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen
CC Mark Michels
Main Date Title 11:51 p.m. 25-Nov2007 18-Oct2007 New EDTx rules ESN
Description Email about case strategy Email about change to local rules Email regarding clerk changing date of ESN docket and calling counsel to discuss same
Privilege Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00255 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00256
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000255 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000256
42b 43a 43b 43c 43d 43e 43f 43g 43h 43i 44a 44b 45a 45b 45c 46a 46b 46c 46d 46e 46f 46g 46h 46i
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00257
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000260
(logqed at 3) (logged at 38c) (logged at 19a) (logged at 19b) (loved at 19c) (logged at 19d) (logged at 19e) (logged at 19f) (logged at 4a) (logged at 3) (logged at 2c) Slogged at 2d) (logged at 9d) (logged at 5a) (logged at 5b) (logged at 38b) (logged at 38c) (logged at 19a) (logged at 19b) (logged at 19c) (logied at 19d) (logged at 19e1 (logged at 19f) Slogged at 4a)
CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00261 CISCO PRIVILEGED.° 00264 CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00269 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000261 CISCO PRIVILEGED, 000265 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000272
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 18 of 19
No. 46j 47a
Begin Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00276
'End Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000277
o (logged at 3) Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel logged at 6b) Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel
From Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)
CC Dan Lang
Main Date Title 16-Oct2007 Urgent please read - ESN
Description Email regarding amended complaint and legal opinions regarding same
Privilege Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)
47b 48a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00278
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000281
Mallun Yen
18-Oct2007 1:09 p.m.
ESN
Email discussing a motion to correct the docket in another case
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
48b 48c 48d 48e 48f 48g 48h 48i 48j 48k 49a
(logged at 38a) (logged at 38b) (logged at 19a) (logged at 19b1 (logged at 19c1 (log_ged at 19d) (logged at 19e) (loRged at 190_ (logged at 4a) (logged at 3) CISCO John Noh Mallun CISCO PRIVILEGED.° PRIVILEGED. Yen 00287 000287 (logged at 32a) (logged at 3) John Noh
18-Oct2007 10:54 a.m.
ESN
Email forwarding earlier email about changing of the docket
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
49b 49c 50a
CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00324 CISCO PRIVILEGED.0 00327
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000324
Mallun Yen
17-Oct2007 6:28 p.m.
Amended ESN Complaint
Email forwarding ESN's amended complaint
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
50b 51a 51b 51c 51d 51e 51f
CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000331
(logged at 1) Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter (logged at 48a) (logged at 38a) (logged at 38b) (logged at 19a) (logged at 19b)
Rick Frenkel
18-Oct2007
ESN
Email discussing how venue reform would affect the case
Attorney Client Work Product (ordinary)
Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-3
Filed 06/30/09 Page 19 of 19
No.
gari lo ed at 19c MIMIIMIINIIIIIIIIIIIMMIIIIIIIII lo ed at 19d lo ed at 19e 111101111111111111111111 mom lo·ed at 19 EMI lo ed at 4a 51k 111111111111111111111
511 lo ed at 3
Begin Bates No.
End Bates No.
o
From
Main Date
Description
Privilege
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
MIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII·1IIIIIIIIII
6111v.4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?