Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al

Filing 77

RESPONSE to Motion re 75 MOTION for an Order Directing Cisco to Provide Identified Documents to the Court for In Camera Review filed by Cisco Systems, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, Tabs 1-4, # 2 Exhibit A, Tabs 5-6, # 3 Exhibit A, Tabs 7-8, # 4 Exhibit A, Tab 9, # 5 Exhibit B, # 6 Exhibit C, # 7 Exhibit D, # 8 Order)(Babcock, Charles)

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 1 of 31

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 2 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000029 Ib Bates End CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000029 Date 31-Oct-2007 5:51 PM 31-Oct-2007 3:22 PM From I Sam Baxter' (McKool Smith) ! Marta Beckwith Marta Beckwith CC Title RE: ESN Description Privilege Type

Sam Baxter (McKool Smith)

RE: ESN

31-Oct-2007 1:04 PM ld 31-Oct-2007 1:22 PM (CST) CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000030 ')b CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000030 24-Oct-2007 1:39 PM 24-Oct-2007 4:17 AM

Sam Baxter (McKool Smith) Marta Beckwith

Marta Beckwith Sam Baxter (McKool Smith)

! RE: ESN

Garret Chambers i (McKool Smith)

ESN

Marta Beckwith

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

RE: ESN

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

Marta Beckwith

ESN

Attorney/Client Email with attorney regarding discussions with Work Product (ordinary) ESN Email with attorney Attorney/Client regarding engaging him and Work Product finding counsel for urgent (ordinary) issues in case Attorney/Client Email from attorney regarding phone call to Work Product discuss case I (ordinary) Email from attorney Email from attorney regarding phone call to regarding phone call discuss case to discuss case Email with attorney Attorney/Client regarding representation in Work Product _4_ (ordinary) ESN litigation. Attorney/Client Email with attorney regarding representation in Work Product ESN litigation. (ordinary)

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000031

25-Oct-2007 CISCO PRIVILEGED. ! 12:25 PM 000031

Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts)

Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

3b

25-Oct-2007 2:19 PM

Michael A. Bucci (Day Pitney)

Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)

Bartt Showalter ! (Baker Botts) Bryant Boren I (Baker Botts) Doug Kubehl (Baker Botts) 1 Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

FW: Cisco/ESN

Cisco/ESN

Email forwarding email with attorney regarding legal strategy with respect to motion to stay filed in ESN litigation in Connecticut. Email with attorney regarding legal strategy with respect to motion to stay filed in ESN litigation in Connecticut.

I Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

i Attorney/Client Work Product ! (ordinary and ! opinion)

4a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000032

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000032

31-Oct-2007

(logged at 1 b)

Every person listed in the "From" and "To" categories was a Cisco employee unless otherwise indicated.

Page 1 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 3 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 4b 4c CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000033 5b Sc 5d 5e 6a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000034 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000034
17-Oct-2007 I

Bates Begin

Bates End

Date

From (logged at lc) (logged at 1d)

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

CISCO 31-Oct-2007 PRIVILEGED. 9:16 PM 000033

Marta Beckwith

Sam Baxter (McKool Smith)

RE: ESN

Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

(logged at la) (logged at Ib) (logged at lc) (logged at 1d) Marta Beckwith 1:50 PM Bucci, Michael A. (Day Pitney) Sicilian, James (Day Pitney) Michael Ritter FW: Amended Email regarding service of Attorney/Client ESN Complaint amended complaint in ESN Work Product litigation. (ordinary)

6b

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000035 7b

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000036

19-Oct-2007 12:49 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000001) Marta Beckwith

15-Oct-2007 3:25 PM

Rick Frenkel

Charles K Verhoeven , (Quinn Emamuel) Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Mark Michels

FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC RE: We were just sued by ESN, LLC

Attorney/Client Work Product 1 (ordinary) 1 Email regarding research of Attorney/Client ESN for purposes of ESN Work Product 1 litigation. (ordinary) Email forwarding research of ESN for purposes of ESN litigation.

Page 2 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 4 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 7c Bates Begin Bates End Date From

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027)

8a

CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 000042

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000042

19-Oct-2007 1:50 PM

Marta Beckwith

Edward Reines (Weil Gotshal) : Matthew Powers (Weil Gotshal)

FW: Amended Email forwarding email ESN Complaint with attorneys discussing filing of amended petition in ESN litigation.

Attorney/Client I Work Product : (ordinary)

8b

9

I CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 000049

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000049

30-Nov-2007 1:12 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000001) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

Rick Frenkel

Marta Beckwith

FW: ESN

Email attaching invalidity analysis of ESN patent claims. Invalidity analysis of ESN I patent claims (attachment to No. 9) Invalidity analysis of ESN patent claims (attachment to No. 9) Invalidity analysis of ESN patent claims (attachment to No. 9)

10

1

I

CISCO CISCO PRIVILEGED. ' PRIVILEGED. 000063 : 000050 ....._ ... CISCO CISCO PRIVILEGED. . PRIVILEGED. 000072 · 000064 CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 000073 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000086

t 30-Nov-2007

1

30-Nov-2007

--r-

1

12

30-Nov-2007

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

Page 3 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 5 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000088 Bates End
Date From

Description Charles K Verhoeven (Qu inn Emanuel) Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC Email forwarding among attorneys discussing ESN filing, declaratory judgment action in Connecticut and strategy relating to same.

Privilege Type

CISCO 19-Oct-2007 PRIVILEGED. ; 12:48 PM 000088

Marta Beckwith

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

(logged at 7) 1a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000090 CISCO 31-Oct-2007 PRIVILEGED. j 1:48 PM 000090 Sam Baxter (McKool Smith) (logged at lb) (logged at Ic) (logged at 1 d) CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000091 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000092 I 19-Oct-2007 12:50 PM 1 Marta Beckwith Charles K Verhoeven 1 (Quinn Emanuel) Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) FW: Urgent ­ please read; ESN Email forwarding email j Attorney/Client regarding subject-matter j Work Product jurisdiction in ESN (ordinary) litigation and legal opinions regarding same. Marta Beckwith RE: ESN Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

14b 14c 14d

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000093 16b

19-Oct-2007 CISCO PRIVILEGED. I 12:50 PM 000093

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and j has already been : logged--Cisco Privileged.000019) Marta Beckwith

Charles K Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel) Victoria Maroulis j (Quinn Emanuel)

FW: Amended ESN Complaint

Email forwarding email ; Attorney/Client regarding amended ; Work Product complaint in ESN litigation. ( ° rdinary) ,

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000001)

Page 4 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 6 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date From

CC ! Mark Michels 1 Marta Beckwith

Title

Description

Privilege Type

17a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000095

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000097

1 16-Oct-2007 1:49 PM

i Paul Devinsky 1 (McDermott Will & ! Emery)

17b

16-Oct-2007 3:58 PM

Paul Devinsky ! (McDermott Will & I Emery)

Mark Michels

Marta Beckwith

Re: Cisco ­ McDermott Will & Emery IP : Teleconference Re: Cisco ­ McDermott Will & Emery IP Teleconference

Email discussing legal Attorney/Client analysis of claims made by ! Work Product ESN (ordinary and I opinion) Email forwarding basic Attorney/Client information about the ESN , Work Product lawsuit (ordinary)

18a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000098

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000098

17-Oct-2007 4:45 PM

(this email was produced . ! in the Albritton case and ! has already been logged--Cisco I Privileged.000002)

18b

19a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000099

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000100

17-Oct-2007 2:41 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000002) Rick Frenkel Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter John Corcoran Rick Frenkel

John Corcoran

FW: Amended ESN Complaint

Email analyzing issue with ESN's claims in ESN litigation. Email analyzing issue with ESN's claims in ESN litigation.

Attorney/Client I Work Product ! (ordinary and I opinion) Attorney/Client I Work Product ! (ordinary and opinion)

19b

I 17-Oct-2007 ' 1:59 PM

John Corcoran

RE: Amended ESN Complaint

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and

Page 5 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 7 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End
Da e

From 1 has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000001) ; Marta Beckwith

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

20a

CISCO PRI VILEGED. 000101

CISCO ; 15-Oct-2007 PRIVILEGED. j 4:01 PM 000101

John Noh

FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC

Email regarding potentially Attorney/Client filing declaratory judgment Work Product action in Connecticut. i (ordinary)

20b

, CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000102 ; 22a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000106

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000102 CISCO : PRIVILEGED. 000107

26-Oct-2007 5:38 PM

; (this email was produced 1 in the Albritton case and ; has already been ; logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) I Mallun Yen ; Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Mark Michels Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Mark Michels Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Mark Michels Mallun Yen

ESN

18-Oct-2007 7:26 AM

RE: Amended ; ESN Complaint

Email regarding case strategy and determination of representation for ESN lawsuit. Email regarding hiring of local counsel.

A ttorney/C I lent Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client ; Work Product ; (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) ; Attorney/Client Work Product ' (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

22b

17-Oct-2007 10:03 PM

RE: Amended ESN Complaint

Email regarding hiring of local counsel.

; 22c

17-Oct-2007 9:32 PM

Mallun Yen

FW: Amended ESN Complaint

Email regarding strategy with respect to hiring local counsel Email regarding strategy with respect to hiring local · counsel

; 22d

17-Oct-2007 2:41 PM

;

Mark Chandler

RE: Amended ESN Complaint

; 22e

17-Oct-2007 2:32 PM

Mallun Yen

Mark Chandler

FW: Amended Email forwarding email ; ESN Complaint regarding ESN filing an amended complaint

Page 6 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 8 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Ba es Begin Bates End Date From CC Title Description

Privilege Type

22f

23a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000108

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000108

17-Oct-2007

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged---Cisco 1 Privileged.000027) r(logged at 22d)

23b 23c

(logged at 22e)
1 (this email was produced

24a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000119

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000121

19-Oct-2007 12:30 PM

in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) Mark Chandler

Matthew Tanielian

RE: Fair Comparison of Patent Litigation Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007

Email regarding patent statistics.

Attorney/Client

24b

I-24c

18-Oct-2007 9:47 PM EST

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco , Privileged .000154) Rick Frenkel

Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian

Mallun Yen Dan Lang

Fair Comparison of Patent Litigation Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007

Page 7 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 9 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 25a Bates Begin CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000127 Bates End Date From Rick Frenkel Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith CC Title Description Privilege Type Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and · opinion)

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000130
iI

27-Oct-2007 11:27 AM

25b

I

Victoria Maroulis 27-Oct-2007 10:21 AM PST (Quinn Emanuel)

Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith

25c

27-Oct-2007 10:00 AM

j Rick Frenkel

Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith

25d

27-Oct-2007 6:54 AM

Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel)

Marta Beckwith

26a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000131

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000133

12-Nov-2007 4:35 PM

Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels Rick Frenkel

Katherine Bennett Re: ESN v. (Quinn Emanuel) Cisco update Kevin Smith and important (Quinn Emanuel) new date in CT Sayuri Sharper case (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Michael Ritter Re: ESN v. Mark Michels Cisco update Sayuri Sharper and important new date in CT Kevin Smith Katherine Bennett case Re: ESN v. Michael Ritter Mark Michels Cisco update Sayuri Sharper : and important Kevin Smith new date in CT Katherine Bennett case Michael Ritter Re: ESN V. Rick Frenkel Cisco update Mark Michels and important Sayuri Sharper new date in CT Kevin Smith case Katherine Bennett RE: IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16

Email concerning strategy with respect to venue.

Email concerning strategy with respect to venue.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product 1 (ordinary and opinion)

Email concerning strategy with respect to venue and communications with counsel. Email concerning case strategy and legal opinions

26b

12-Nov-2007 11:44

Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels

Rick Frenkel

26c

12-Nov-2007 i Mark Michels 11:30 AM

i Rick Frenkel

RE: IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16 RE: IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16

IP team monthly report Attorney/Client with case summaries and Work Product legal opinions regarding ; (ordinary and various litigation (redacting opinion) all parts not related to ESN lawsuit) Email correspondence Attorney/Client : regarding writing a " Work Product summary of the ESN (ordinary) lawsuit Email correspondence Attorney/Client regarding writing a Work Product summary of the ESN : (ordinary) lawsuit and regarding

Page 8 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 10 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date From CC Title Description making sure the summary is privileged Email correspondence regarding writing a I summary of the ESN I lawsuit and regarding making sure the summary is _privileged Email correspondence regarding writing a summary of the ESN lawsuit Email attaching exhibit to email regarding similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket. Privilege Type

1 26d

12-Nov-2007 11:28 AM

Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels

RE: IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

' 26e

11-Nov-2007 7:11 PM

Mark Michels

I ip-team(mailer list of Cisco's intellectual property and legal
team)

27a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000145

, CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000145

18-Oct-2007 12:31 PM

Kurt Pankratz I (Baker Botts)

Rick Frenkel

IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16 RE: Re: Hertz/TSD Motion to Correct Docket

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

27b

28a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000150

CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 000151

15-Oct-2007 I 3:04 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000212) Rick Frenkel

Marnie Willhoft

FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC

Email regarding informing ' Attorney/Client ' Cisco employee of ESN Work Product lawsuit. : (ordinary)

28b

29a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000152

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000153

2-Nov-2007 3:22 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) John Corcoran

RE: ESN

Response to legal evaluation of potential agreement to dismiss declaratory judgment action ' and potential stay agreement.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

Page 9 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 11 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date From

Title John Corcoran I FW: ESN

Description

Privilege Type

29b

02-Nov-2007 3:22 PM

Rick Frenkel

29c

F2-Nov-2007 8:34 AM

Marta Beckwith

John Noh

Mark Michels

1 ESN

Legal evaluation of potential agreement to I dismiss declaratory I judgment action and I potential stay agreement. Legal evaluation of potential agreement to dismiss declaratory judgment action and ,_·potential stay agreement.

Attorney/Client I Work Product i (ordinary and opinion) 1 Attorney/Client I Work Product I (ordinary and 1 opinion)

30a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000157

CISCO 19-Oct-2007 PRIVILEGED. I 9:57 AM 000158

(This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000227)

30c

(This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged, Cisco I Privileged.000227) (This email was ; produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000227) (This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco

Page 10 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 12 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number
Bates Begin Ba es End From

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

Privileged.000027)

30e

3a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. · 000159

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000160

19-Oct-2007 1:16 PM

(This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000027) i Victoria Maroulis

Charles K Verhoeven (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith

Mark Michels Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

RE: ESN

Email regarding beginning Attorney/Client work on ESN matter Work Product (ordinary)

31b

19-Oct-2007 12:48 PM

Marta Beckwith

Victoria Maroulis Charles K Verhoeven

Michael Ritter Mark Michels Rick Frenkel

ESN

1 32a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000161

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000163

12-Nov-2007 4:36 PM

Mark Michels

Rick Frenkel

RE: IP Team Monthly Report Please Respond by 11/16

Email regarding legal strategy with respect to declaratory judgment action. Email responding to status of various Cisco lawsuits.

Attorney/Client Work Product ; (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

32b 32c 32d 32e 32f 33a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000164 . CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000166 28-Oct-2007 7:55 PM

(logged at 26a) (logged at 26b) (logged at 26c) (logged at 26d) (logged at 26e) Mark Michels Rick Frenkel Re: ESN v. Cisco update and important new date in CT case Email responding to scheduling call regarding case strategy. ; Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

Page 11 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 13 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date From

(logged at 25a) (logged at 25b) 33d 33e 34 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000170 CISCO . PRIVILEGED. 000170 I 18-Oct-2007 I 11:30 PM (logged at 25c) (logged at 25d) ' (This email was ' produced in the : Albritton case and has I already been loggedI Cisco I Privileged.000228) I Marta Beckwith

35

CISCO PRIVILEGED. I 000171

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000171

2-Nov-2007 8:34 AM

John Noh

Mark Michels Michael Ritter I Rick Frenkel

ESN

Email regarding potential agreed motion to dismiss and cooling off period.

Attorney/C I ient Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

36a

i CISCO PRIVILEGED. ' 000172

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000174

27-Oct-2007 12:14 PM

1 I Victoria Maroulis ' (Quinn Emanuel)

Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel

Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) I Kevin Smith ' (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel)

Re: ESN v. Cisco update and important new date in CT case

Email regarding new venue Attorney/Client ; Work Product case and how it relates to ' case strategy. (ordinary and opinion)

! 36b 36c I 36d

(logged at 25a) ; (logged at 25b) (logged at 25c)

Page 12 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 14 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 36e
Bates End Date From

Description

(logged at 25d)

1

37a

: CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000175

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000175

' 19-Oct-2007 i Mallun Yen 8:10 AM

Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels

37b

19-Oct-2007 7:19 AM

Marta Beckwith

Rick Frenkel Mallun Yen Michael Ritter

Mark Michels

37c

18-Oct-2007 11:51 PM

' Rick Frenkel

Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter Marta Beckwith

Mark Michels

Email responding to email regarding selection of local counsel and strategy for filing declaratory judgment action. Email regarding selection of local counsel and strategy for filing declaratory judgment action. Email regarding strategy for filing declaratory judgment action. RE: Otis Email regarding selection of local counsel Email regarding selection of local counsel and case strategy Email regarding strategy with respect to discussing revenue numbers with ESN.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client , Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

38a

. CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000176

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000176

29-Oct-2007 8:16 PM 29-Oct-2007 7:53 PM

r-Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels Michael Ritter Michael Ritter Mark Michels

38b

Marta Beckwith

Rick Frenkel

. Otis

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000177 40a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000178

· CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000177 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000180

; 28-Nov-2007 , 1:30 PM

Rick Frenkel

Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter

ESN

17-Oct-2007 9:50 PM

i Rick Frenkel

Email regarding selection RE: Amended ESN Complaint of counsel for ESN litigation.

Page 13 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 15 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 40b Bates Begin Date ! 17-Oct-2007 9:31 PM (PST) From logged at 22c) CC Title Description Privilege Type

40c

17-Oct-2007 2:41 PM

(logged at 22d)

Mallun Yen

RE: Amended ESN Complaint

40d

(logged at 22e)

40e

41a

: CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000181

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000182

25-Oct-2007 12:28 PM

(this email was produced ; in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) Rick Frenkel

Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel)

Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter

FW: Cisco/ESN

Email regarding requirements to file motion ; in Connecticut.

Attorney/Client Work Product 1 (ordinary)

41b

25-Oct-2007 12:25 PM

Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)

Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel Michael Ritter Mark Michels

I 41c

25-Oct-2007

Michael A. Bucci I (Day Pitney)

! Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Doug Kubehl (Baker ; Botts) Bryant. Boren (Baker I Botts) Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

FW: Cisco/ESN Emailin forwarding email ! Attorney/Clien regarding analysis of I Work Product pleadings filed in I (ordinary) Connecticut action

Cisco/ESN

Email regarding analysis of pleadings filed in Connecticut action

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

42a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. . 000183

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000185

18-Oct-2007 8:09 AM

Rick Frenkel

Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter

Email regarding selection RE: Amended ESN Complaint of counsel.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

Page 14 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 16 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 42b Bates Begin Bates End Date From (logged at 22a)

cc

Title

Description

Privilege Type

42c

(logged at 22b)

42d

(logged at 22c)

42e

(logged at 22d)

42f

(logged at 22e)

42g

43a

1 CISCO 1 PRIVILEGED. 000186

CISCO 1 PRIVILEGED. 1 000187

I 7-Oct-2007 10:03 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) (logged at 22b)

Mallun Yen ; Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

RE: Amended Email regarding selection ESN Complaint of counsel.

Attorney/Client , Work Product (ordinary)

43b 43c 43d

(logged at 22c) (logged at 22d) (logged at 22e)

Page 15 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 17 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 43e Bates Begin Bates End From (this email was produced I in the Albritton case and has already been I logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) Marta Beckwith Title Description Privilege Type

44

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000188 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000189

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000188 CISCO PRIV I LEGED. 000189

15-Oct-2007 8:31 PM

Mallun Yen

John Noh

ESN Complaint

45a

15-Oct-2007 ' 4:02 PM

! John Noh

Marta Beckwith

RE: We were just sued by ESN, LLC FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC

45b

15-Oct-2007 4:01 PM

Marta Beckwith

John Noh

Email regarding mechanics and strategy fro filing declaratory judgment action. Email responding to email regarding strategy for filing declaratory judgment action. Email responding to email regarding strategy for filing declaratory judgment action.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

45c

46a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000190

CISCO " PRIVILEGED. 000191

18-Oct-2007 9:57 AM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000027) Neal Rubin

John Noh Mallun Yen Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian

RE: ESN

Email regarding local counsel in another case

! Attorney/Client ! Work Product , (ordinary)

46b

46c

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and : has already been logged --Cisco Privileged.000011) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000011)

FW: ESN

Page 16 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 18 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number
46d

Ba es Begin

Bates End

Date

From (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000011) Kurt. Pankratz (Baker Botts)

Description

Privilege Type

r

47a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000195

CISCO PRIVILEGED 000197

16-Oct-2007 9:14 PM

Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Rick Frenkel Michael Ritter Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen

Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment

Email regarding status of filings in the ESN case

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

47b

16-Oct-2007 10:43 PM

Mallun Yen

Marta Beckwith

Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment

Email regarding status of filings in the ESN case

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

47c

16-Oct-2007 1:39 PM

Marta Beckwith

Michael A Bucci (Day Pitney) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts) James Sicilian , (Day Pitney) Marta Beckwith Kurt Pankratz r (Baker Botts) r Michael A Bucci (Day Pitney) Kurt. Pankratz (Baker Botts) James Sicilian (Day Pitney)

Response to update regarding service of papers in Connecticut lawsuit

r

47d

r 16-Oct-2007 12:39 PM

M chael A Bucci (Day Pitney)

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment r Re: Complaint : for Declaratory Judgment

Update regarding service of papers in Connecticut lawsuit r Email asking about filing and service of papers in 1 Connecticut lawsuit

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client r Work Product (ordinary)

47e

16-Oct-2007 12:29 PM

1 Marta Beckwith

Bart Showalter (Barker Botts)

Page 17 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 19 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 47f Bates Begin Bates End Date 16-Oct-2007 i 7:35 AM From Michael A Bucci (Day Pitney) Marta Beckwith Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) James Sicilian (Day Pitney) Michael A Bucci (Day Pitney) Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) James Sicilian (DayPitney) Kurt Pancratz (Baker Botts) James Sicilian (Day Pitney) CC Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Title Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment Description Privilege Type

Email discussing complaint Attorney/Client ; Work Product and summons for declaratory judgment in (ordinary and ' opinion) Connecticut Email discussing change to complaint and summons for declaratory judgment in Connecticut Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

16-Oct-2007 10:26 AM

Marta Beckwith

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts)

Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment

47h

16-Oct-2007 6:53 AM

j Michael A Bucci

Marta Beckwith Bart Showalter : (Baker Botts)

Re: Complaint for Declaratory Judgment

I

Email discussing complaint and summons for declaratory judgment in Connecticut

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

47i

16-Oct-2007 8:59 AM

i 'kurt.pankratsz@bakerb . James Sicilian (Day Marta Beckwith otts.com' ; Bart Showalter Pitney) Michael A Bucci . (Baker Botts) (Day Pitney)

Complaint for 1 Declaratory Judgment

1 Email discussing complaint Attorney/Client and summons for " Work Product (ordinary and declaratory judgment in Connecticut opinion)

48a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000198

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000199

19-Oct-2007 8:59 AM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000227)

Page 18 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 20 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 48b Bates Begin Ba es End Date 1 19-Oct-2007 10:56 AM From (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000227) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000227) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privilsed.000227) Kurt Pankratz (Baker Botts)

48c

48d

1 49a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000200

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000201

16-Oct-2007 4:43 AM

Bart Showalter (Baker Botts) Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

Dan Lang

Re: Urgent ­ please read ­ ESN

Email regarding timing of filing of complaint in the 1 Connecticut lawsuit

Attorney/Client Work Product 1 (ordinary)

49b

; 16-Oct-2007 1:34 AM

(this email was produced j in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000008) Rick Frenkel Bright, William O'Shaughnessy, William (McCarter) (MCarter) Giarratana, Mark (MCarter) Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter RE: Conflict : Check Email regarding possible representation in Connecticut. Attorney/Client 1 Work Product (ordinary)

50a

. CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000202

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000203

15-Oct-2007 8:08 PM

Page 19 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 21 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 50b
Bates Begin Bates End Date From CC Title

Description Email regarding possible representation in Connecticut. Email regarding possible representation in Connecticut. Email regarding legal strategy in dealing with venue issues. Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary·) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

15-Oct-2007 6:47 PM

William O'Shaughnessy Rick Frenkel (McCarter)

William Bright (MCarter) ; Mark Giarratana (McCarter)

RE: Conflict Check

50c

15-Oct-2 007 7:40 PM CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000205 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000207 27-Oct-2007 10:21 AM

Rick Frenkel

William 0' Shaughnessy (McCarter) Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel)

Conflict Check

I

5a

(logged at 25b)

Re: ESN v. Cisco: update and important new date in CT case

51 b

27-Oct-2007 10:00 AM

I (logged at 25c)

51c

27-Oct-2007 6:54 AM PST

(logged at 25d)

52a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000208

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000211

27-Oct-2007 6:49 PM

Marta Beckwith

Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Rick Frenkel

Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels · Michael Ritter

Re: ESN v. Cisco: update and important new date in CT case

Email regarding legal I advice from regarding case strategy

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

Page 20 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 22 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Date 27-Oct-2007 12:54 PM 1 Rick Frenkel Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) CC Michael Ritter Mark Michels Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Michael Ritter Mark Michels Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Michael Ritter Mark Michels Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Title Re: ESN v. Cisco: update and important ! new date in CT case Description Email regarding ESN's lack of contacts with the Eastern District of Texas Privilege Type Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

52c

27-Oct-2007 Victoria Maroulis 12:14 PM PST (Quinn Emanuel)

I Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith

Re: ESN v. ! Cisco: update and important new date in CT case

Email regarding new case law regarding venue

' Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

52d

27-Oct-2007 11:26 AM

Rick Frenkel

Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith

Re: ESN v. !, Cisco: update and important new date in CT I case

1 Email regarding call and new case law regarding venue.

Attorney/Client I Work Product I (ordinary and opinion)

52e 52f 52g 53a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000213 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000214 18-Oct-2007 9:08 PM

(logged at 25b) (logged at 25c) (logged at 25d) Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Michael Ritter RE: Nuance . Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion) I Email regarding research I Attorney/Client and analysis regarding ESN Work Product litigation (ordinary and Email regarding the proper way to handle a problem with a filing

53b

I 8-Oct-2007 6:01 PM

Rick Frenkel

RE: Nuance

Page 21 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 23 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Bates Begin Description Privilege Type opinion) 53c 18-Oct-2007 5:53 PM CISCO PRIVIL EG ED. 000215 Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen Rick Frenkel Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel ! Michael Ritter Nuance Attorney/Client Email analysis regarding ESN litigation and possible ' Work Product (ordinary and 1 local counsel opinion) Email regarding selection Attorney/Client of counsel and filing of Work Product declaratory judgment (ordinary and opinion) action. Attorney/Client Email regarding suspicions regarding filing of Work Product complaint and legal strategy (ordinary and ; and opinion regarding opinion) same. Email regarding selection Attorney/Client of counsel and filing of , Work Product declaratory judgment (ordinary) action.

1 54a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000217

15-Oct-2007 8:48 PM

arta Beckwith

RE: Conflict Check

54b

15-Oct-2 007 8:45 PM

; Rick Frenkel

Marta Beckwith

Michael Ritter

RE: Conflict Check

54c

15-Oct-2007 8:13 PM

1 Marta Beckwith

1 Rick Frenkel

Michael Ritter

, RE: Conflict ! Check

54d

logged at 50a)

54e 54f 55a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000218 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000220 27-Oct-2007 10:10 AM

(logged at 50b) (logged at 50c) ' (logged at 25c) Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel) Marta Beckwith Katherine Bennett' (Quinn Emanuel) ! Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Re: ESN v. ! Cisco: update ! and important new date in CT case Email regarding status of declaratory judgment action : and local counsel. Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

55b

(logged at 25d)

Page 22 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 24 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date

From (logged at 52b)

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

56a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000221

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000224

27-Oct-2007 12:54 PM

56b

I (logged at 52c)

56c 56d 56e 56f 57a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000225 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000226 16-Oct-2007 8:33 PM

(logged at 52d) I (logged at 25b) (logged at 25c) (logged at 25d) Mark Michels Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel i Dan Lang RE: We were just sued by ESN, LLC Email regarding opinions Attorney/Client regarding Girard in another i Work Product case (ordinary and opinion)

C

57b 57c
58a

! (logged at 7b) (logged at 7c) CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000229 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000230 18-Oct-2007 11:33 AM F . (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.0000105) 1

Page 23 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 25 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 58b Bates Begin Bates End Date 18-Oct-2007 11:27 AM From (this email was produced ' in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privil eged .0000105) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.0000105) CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000238 CISCO ; PRIVILEGED. 000238 19-Oct-2007 8:56 AM (This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.000227) CC Title Description Privilege Type

58c

59a

59b

1 1

59c ·

60a ·

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000239

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000241

31-Oct-2007 6:47 PM

(This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged-Cisco Privileged.000227) (This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000227) (This email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--

Page 24 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 26 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Bates End Date From CC Title Description Privilege Type

60b

60c

I 60d

I 60e

61a

CISCO PRIVILEGED 000242

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000243

Cisco Privileged.000231) 3 1 -Oct-2007 (This email was 5:04 PM produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged-Cisco Privileged.000231) 30-Oct-2007 (This email was 3:24 PM produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000231) 30-Oct-2007 (This email was 2:38 PM produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000231) 30-Oct-2007 (This email was 11:06 AM produced in the Albritton case and has already been loggedCisco Privileged.000227) I 7-0c1-2007 I (logged at 22c)

61 b 61c 61d

(logged at 22d) 1 (logged at 22e) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and

Page 25 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 27 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin
Bates End

Date

From has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) (this email was produced j in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privilsed.000254) Victoria Maroulis (Quinn Emanuel)

CC

Description

Privilege Type

2

CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 000244

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000244

18-Oct-2007 11:51 PM

63a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000245

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000249

27-Oct-20 07 10:19 PM

Marta Beckwith Rick Frenkel

Katherine Bennett (Quinn Emanuel) Kevin Smith (Quinn Emanuel) Mark Michels Michael Ritter Sayuri Sharper (Quinn Emanuel)

Re: ESN v. Cisco: update I and important I new date in CT case

Email regarding conference call and evaluation of ESN's connections with Texas.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

63b 63c 63d 63e 63f 63g 63h 64a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000252 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000252 15-Oct-2007 8:52 PM

(logged at 52a) (logged at 52b) (logged at 52c) (logged at 52d) (logged at 25b) (logged at 25c) (logged at 25d) Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith John Noh Mark Chandler RE: ESN complaint Email thanking Marta for the update Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

Page 26 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 28 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 64b 65a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000253 CISCO I PRIVILEGED. 00253 1-18-Oct-2007 5:08 PM 18-Oct-2007 9:26 AM
Bates Begin Bates End

Date

From (logged at 44) Mark Chandler Mallun Yen

CC

Title

Description

Privilege Type

RE: ESN

I 65b

Mallum Yen

Mark Chandler John Noh

FW: ESN

Email asking about ; Attorney/Client response from potential Work Product counsel. (ordinary) Email about calling counsel Attorney/Client Work Product about legal issues. (ordinary)

65c

! 66a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000262

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000263

18-Oct-2007 9:06 PM

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged---Cisco Privileged.000004) Mallun Yen

John Noh Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian

FW: Nuance

I Email regarding legal I analysis and opinion regarding ESN lawsuit

Attorney/Client Work Product I (ordinary and opinion)

66b 66c 67a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000266 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000268 18-Oct-2007 11:43 AM

(logged at 53b) (logged at 53c) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.0000103)

67b

18-Oct-2007 11:44 AM

67c

(this email was produced I in the Albritton case and has already been loped--Cisco Privileged.000103) 18-Oct-2007 (this email was produced 11:40 Am in the Albritton case and has already been

Page 27 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 29 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number Bates Begin Date From logged Cisco Privileged.0000103) 67d if 18-Oct-2007 11:38 AM (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged .0000103) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.0000103) (this email was produced 1 in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.0000103) (this email was produced i in the Albritton case and has already been logged Cisco Privileged.0000103) Mallun Yen Mark Chandler Dan Lang RE: ESN To CC

67e

18-Oct-2007 11:33 AM

- 67f

18-Oct-2007 11:27 AM

67g

18-Oct-2007 11:23 AM

68a

CISCO CISCO PRIVILEGED. . PRIVILEGED. 000273 000274

18-Oct-2007 9:08 PM

RE: ESN

Email regarding selection 1 of counsel. 4

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

68b 68c 68d

(logged at 65a) I (logged at 65b) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and I has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000004)

Page 28 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 30 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number 69a
Bates Begin Bates End Date From CC Title Description Privilege Type

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000275

CISCO PRIVILEG ED. 000275

17-Oct-2007 6:26 PM
1 7 -Oct-2007 6:11 PM

Mallun Yen

John Noh Marta Beckwith Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen

Michael Ritter

RE: ESN complaint

Update about status of filings in ESN litigation.

69b

John Noh

RE: ESN . Request for update about complaint status of filings in ESN litigation

Attomey/Client Work Product (ordinary) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

69c 70a CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000282 CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000283 15-Oct-2007 4:13 PM

(logged at 44) Mallun Yen Mark Chandler FW: We were just sued by ESN, LLC Email regarding summary of claims and strategy in ESN litigation. Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary and opinion)

70b

71a

CISCO PRIVILEGED.
000284

i

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000284

17-Oct-2007 2:32 PM
-r-

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) (logged at 22e)

71b

72a

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000285

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 1 000286

15-Oct-2007

(this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) Mark Chandler

Mallun Yen

Email regard ng topics for meeting.

Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

72b 72c
I

(logged at 70a) (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been logged--Cisco Privileged.000027) Chart of patent lawsuits (redacting parts unrelated to ESN litigation) Attorney/Client Work Product (ordinary)

73

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000288

CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000323

Page 29 of 30

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 77-4

Filed 06/30/09 Page 31 of 31

Cisco's Log of Documents Not Produced in Albritton v. Cisco
Number a Bates Begin CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000325 Bates End CISCO PRIVILEGED. 000326 15-Oct-2007 3:25 PM From (logged at 7b) To CC Title

74b

1 15-Oct-2007 1 3:00 PM

: (this email was produced in the Albritton case and has already been 1 logged--Cisco Privileged.000027)

Page 30 of 30