Be In, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 69

REPLY (re 64 MOTION to Dismiss First, Third, and Fourth Causes of Action of The Second Amended Complaint ) filed byGOOGLE UK LTD., Google Inc., YouTube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Colleen Bal, # 2 Exhibit A, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E)(Bal, Colleen) (Filed on 8/15/2013)

EXHIBIT A

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page1 of 34

!
"
#
$%&'( )*'+* +,
(*
&' -%&'.,
/.0 1&2 3
, 0%',
&
*2
*450'*
6
-&./, , *
7 2
6
((0%'*8/ 3 #2 '(, 3
0% &, 3

#%09
*.(/ '.

!"# "# % "
$ %&

#%09
*.(/ '.
(

#2 '(, 3
&, 3
#!
*

)
1
,
.%0/8/(*7 / '. :; & :*'(,
<;
)*
$%0+4 &': &7 &2 &'( $+4(&
*3
*':&'(/

'

()

+
, -# * * * # & 0
.
/$$
1!
*
+2
,
,
,*
)
/$0
31
&
*
2
45 , +
*
2
,
3)
*
6
7
* 8
,
2
%(
*
+
,
* *
/& 1
47
0
+
, 9 2
.
*
,
:
*
+
, 9 2
)
,
,
,
;
#*
$
#*
#
#* + 5
1
) ,, *
5 * ) +
<
*
/# 1 $
%$
0
6

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page2 of 34

#%09
*.(/ '. =

#%09
*.(/> <8 &': (5%0+?5 , &((0%'*8/
(/

# 3, */ (5, 107 42 '( &?&,
2
/
&,
'/( 1

5, 2 "
2 0'

7,
(5

,
.%0/8/(*7 / '. :; & :*'(, $%0+4
<;
)*

= 1 > &': &7 &2 &'( $+4(& =$+4(&> .02 *.(, 8 = *3
2 )*2
*':&'(/> &': +40'
, 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 &2 *?*/ &/ 3 2
'3
0'
,
2
02 0@/
5, , &' &.(, 3 ), &(,
/ /
0' 0% 02 0'/ 03 (5* 107 4+(*% -%&+: &':
!
A

1 A

B ), &(,
02 0'/ 03 (5* 107 4+(*%

&(&

..*// &': -%&+:

<+/*

.(

.( 1&2 #*'&210:*

B (%*/4&// (0 .5&((*2 +':*% 1&2 3
/
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B <%*&.5 03 .0'(%&.( +':*%

1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B 4%07 ,
//0%8 */(044*2+':*% 1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B +'9
+/(
*'%,
.57 *'( +':*% 1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B 7 ,
/&44%04%, 0' 03 (%&:* /*.%*(/ +':*%
&(,
1&2 3
, 0%', 1, 210:* A
& ),

B (0%(,
0+/ ,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @, .0'(%&.( +':*% 1&2 3
(5
, 0%',
&

.07 7 0' 2
&@B (0%(,
0+/ ,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @, 4%0/4*.(, *.0'07 , &:)&'(&?* +':*%
(5
)*
.
1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B 3
%&+: +':*% 1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B (%&:* 2 <*2+':*%
,
1&2 3
, 0%', .07 7 0' 2
&
&@B &': +'3 % <+/,
&,
'*// 4%&.(, +':*% 1&2 3
.*/
, 0%', +/,
&
'*// &':
#%03 0'/ 10:* A
*//,
)
#2 '(, 3
&, 3

#%09
*.(/ '. =

#%09
*.(/> , & .0%40%&(, :+2
/
0'
8

0%?&',
C*: &': *D, '? +':*% (5* 2
/(,
&@/ 03 (5* (&(* 03 1&2 3
, 0%', @, !
&
(5
,
'

5*&:E+&%(*%/

0+'(&, F ,
' *@ 1&2 3
, 0%',
&
*3
*':&'( 1

,
.%0/8/(*7 / '. :; & :*'(, $%0+4 = 1 > , &
<;
)*
/

.0%40%&(, :+2 0%?&',
0'
8
C*: &': *D, '? +':*% (5* 2
/(,
&@/ 03 (5* (&(* 03 *2
&@&%* @,
(5
, 4%, 4&242 03 <+/,
(/
'.,
&.*
'*// , /7 &', $*%7 &'8
'
'?
*3
*':&'( &7 &2 &'( $+4(& =$+4(&> , & 30%7 *% *7 42
/
08** 03
#%09
*.(/ ,
'

0+'(&, F ,
' *@ & ., C*' 03 ':, &': & !
(,
&

4*%7 &'*'( %*/,
:*'( $+4(&

.+%%*'(2 %*/,
8
:*/ , $*%7 &'8
'
!
5, 10+%( 5&/ /+<9 7 &((*% 9 /:, 0' 0)*% (5* 3
/
*.(
+%, .(,
*:*%&2107 4+(*%
-%&+: &':

<+/*

.( 4+%/+&'( (0

!

1 A

&':

!

1 A

/+442 *'(&29 /:, 0' 0)*% (5* /(&(* 2 .2 7 / 4+%/+&'( (0
*7
+%, .(,
&@ &,

5, 10+%( 5&/
/
!

1 A

&/ (5*8

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page3 of 34

3
0%7 4&%( 03 (5* /&7 * .&/* 0% .0'(%0)*%/8 &/ (5* 3
*:*%&2.2 7 &2 *?*: 5*%*, &':
&,
2
'
+':*% 4%, 42 03 4*':&'( 9 /:, 0'
'., */
+%, .(,

5, 10+%( &2 5&/ :,
/
/0
)*%/, 9 /:, 0'
(8 +%, .(,

0)*% (5* /(&(* 2 .2 7 / &2 *?*: 5*%*, 4+%/+&'( (0
&@ &,
2
'

!

1 A

&

&/ (5*%* ,
/

.07 42 :,
*(* )*%/, &7 0'? 42 '(, 3 &': :*3
(8
&, 3
*':&'(/ &': (5* &7 0+'( , .0'(%0)*%/8
'
*D.**:/ G
5, 10+%( 5&/ 4*%/0'&29 /:, 0' 0)*% 1
/
+%, .(,

<*.&+/* , (%&'/&.(/ &
(

/+</(&'(, &7 0+'( 03 <+/,
&2
'*// , (5, :, .( , +:, .*%(&, &.(/ .07 42 '*: 03
' / /(%, '.2 '?
'
&,
5*%*,
'
5, 10+%( 5&/ 4*%/0'&29 /:, 0' 0)*% $+4(& <*.&+/* 5* 5&/ .0':+.(*:
/
+%, .(,
<+/,
'*// , (5, :, .( , +:, *'(*%, , & .0'(%&.( 3 *7 42
' / /(%, '.2 '?
'? '(0
0%
087 *'( , (5,
' /
:, .( &': <*.&+/* 5* 5&/ .07 7 ,
/(%,
((*: (0%(/ &': /(&(+(0%8 ), &(,
02 0'/ , (5, :, .(
' / /(%,
F *'+* , 4%04*% , (5, :, .( 4+%/+&'( (0
/
' / /(%,

!

1 A

< &': .

<*.&+/* & /+</(&'(, 4&%( 03 (5* *)*'(/ ?, '? %, (0 (5, 2
&2
),
/*
/ &@/+, (00H 42 , (5,
(
&.* ' /
:, .(
/(%,
A

0%*0)*% )*'+* , 4%04*% 3 <0(5 :*3
/
0%
*':&'(/ <*.&+/* 4+%/+&'( (0

!

1

: &' &2 *' 7 &8 <* /+*: , &'8 9 ., :, .(
,
'
+:, &2 /(%,
= (
#+%/+&'( (0 1, 2 0.&2 +2 6 * (5, .&/* /50+2 <* &//,
),
*
/
:
?'*: (0 (5* &'

I :, /, 03 (5, 10+%( <*.&+/* /*)*%&203 (5* .2 7 / &2 *?*: &%0/* , &'(& 12
0/* ), 0'
/
&,
2
'
&%&
10+'(8
=
) 8,

(

2 (

;

#%09
*.(/ 4%0),
:*/ /*%), , %, .0'/+2 '? 3,
.*/ ' /H
(,
'&'., &':
&2
, 0%7 &(, (*.5'02
'3
0'
0?8 4%09
*.(/
3,
3 .*% =1

> 03

&'&) ,
'?5 = ,
'?5> @&/ (5* 15, D*.+(,
*3
)*

#%09
*.(/ +'(, .(0<*%
2

&': & /*', *D*.+(, 03
0%
)*

#%09
*.(/ &( &2 %*2
2 *)&'( (, */
7
1

'0@ :0, <+/,
'?
'*// &/ = :*'(, $%0+4 > , & 4%0), 03 /02 0'/
)*
/
:*%
+(,

3 /*.+%* &..*// /*.+%* ,
0%
:*'(, &': /*.+%* *D.5&'?* @, 03 .*/ , $*%7 &'8 ':,
(8
(5 3,
'
&
I
&4&' &': (5* !

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page4 of 34

'

+?+/(

?%**7 *'( = &/(*%

#%09
*.(/ &': 1

?%**7 *'(> @5*%*<8

&..0+'(, .07 42 &'.* 4%09
'?
,
*.(/ =#%09
*.(/> (0 1
+?+/(

*'(*%*: , & @%,
'(0
((*'

&/(*%

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 4%0), 3,
:
:* '&'., &':
&2
5, .0'(%&.( @&/ /,
/
?'*: 0'

<8 ,
'?5 &':

2 )*%
,

*2 *%/ = *2 *%/> (5*'6F , #%*/,
2
2
.*
:*'( 03 -,
'&'.*

#+%/+&'( (0 (5*

&/(*%

?%**7 *'(

&( 1
::*':+7 / 3
0% *%),
.*/

= ::*':+7 /> @0+2 <* .%*&(*: 3 *&.5 %*/4*.(, #%09
:
0%
)*
*.(

5*

::*':+7 / @0+2
:

/4*., 8 , @%, '? (5* %&(* &': :&(* 3 *&.5 %*/4*.(, #%09 &': @0+2 <* /,
3 '
(,
0%
)*
*.(
:
?'*: <8
%*4%*/*'(&(, 03
)*/
5*

#%09
*.(/ &': 1
&/(*%

?%**7 *'( 4%0),
:*: (5&( , @0+2 <* ?0)*%'*: <8 (5* 2
(
:
&@/ 03

(5* (&(* 03 1&2 3
, 0%',
&
5*

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( 4%0),
:*: (5&( = 1

&?%**/ (5&( 3 /0 2
0%
0'? &/ (5,
/

?%**7 *'( &': (5* 0%, '&2*'?&?*7 *'( 2
?,
*((*% , , *3 *.( &': 3 & 4*%, 03 0'*
/ ' 3
0%
0:
8*&% &3 , (*%7 , 0' 1
(*% (/
'&(,

@, 2'0( 3 &'8 4+%40/* / /02 ., J&'8
2
0%
, (

.0'/+2
(&'(/ ,
:*'(, *: :+%, (5*, .0'/+2 '? /*%), <8
3,
'?
%
(,
.*/
5*

&/(*%

#%09
*.(/ >

?%**7 *'( 4%0),
:*: (5&( =-0% *&.5

#%09
*.(/ %*3
*%%*:

, ),
':, :+&2 5, &':; %*(&,
/ %*:
0%
'*: <8 107 4&'8 107 4&'8 @, 24&8
2
(5* &7 0+'( 03 @*'(8 -, 4*%.*'(&?*
)*

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ & 3 ,
** '

K 03 (5* &''+&2<&/* .07 4*'/&(, &?%**: (0
0'

<*(@**' 107 4&'8 &': /+.5 , ),
':, :+&2 @5, &7 0+'( @, 2<* *D.2 )* 03 &'8 <0'+/
.5
2
+/,
&':; 0(5*% .0'(,
0%
'?*'( 0% 4*%3
0%7 &'.*6<&/*: 4&87 *'(/ 0% <*'*3 ( >
,
#+%/+&'( (0 &'
&':

*2 *%/ 0' (5&( :&(*
2

::*':+7 :&(*: *4(*7 <*%

&': /,
?'*: <8 ,
'?5

#%09
*.(/ &?%**: (0 4%0), .0'/+2 '? /*%), (0 1
:*
(,
.*/

.0''*.(, @, /(0.H &:7 , /(%&(, @0%H .07 7 *'., , *4(*7 <*%
0' (5
',
0'
'? '
) 8,

=

2
+

' *4(*7 <*%
*'(*%*: , &' 7 42
'(0
087 *'(

6

;

6 ;
#%09
*.(/ &': &7 &2 &'( $+4(& =$+4(&>

?%**7 *'( (5* = 7 42
087 *'(

?%**7 *'(>

,
'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page5 of 34

5* 7 42
087 *'(
*',
0%

&'&?*% 03

?%**7 *'( 4%0),
:*: (5&( $+4(& @0+2 <* 5, &/ &
:
%*:

#%09
*.(/ &/ 03 *4(*7 <*%

.0':, 0'/ 03 $+4(&L/ *7 42
(,
087 *'( @,
(5
#+%/+&'( (0 (5* 7 42
087 *'(
$+4(& &':

&': 2 /(*: (5* (*%7 / &':
,

#%09
*.(/
?%**7 *'( &': &/ = D5, (
<,

#%09
*.(/ &2 *'(*%*: , & 10'3 :*'(, ,
/0
'(0
,
&2 (8

=10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

> (5*%*(0

?%**7 *'( (5*

?%**7 *'(> $+4(& /,
?'*: (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'( 0'

*4(*7 <*%
5* 10'3,
:*'(, ,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'( 4%0),
:*: (5&( $+4(& =&?%**/ &( &2 (, */
2 7

:+%, (5* (*%7 03 *7 42
'?
087 *'( &': (5*%*&3 (0 502 , /(%, .0'3 :*'.* &': '0( (0
(*%
: '
.(
,
+/* *D.*4( 3 (5* <*'*3 ( 03 M
0%
,

#%09
*.(/N 0% (0 :, 0/* (0 &'8 4*%/0' 3, 0%
/.2
%7

.0%40%&(, @,
0' (50+( 4%, @%,
0%
((*' &+(50%, 0' 03 M
C&(,
'3
0%7 &(, 03 M
0'

#%09
*.(/N >

5* 10'3,
:*'(, ,
&2 (8
=&'8 M

#%09
*.(/N (5* 10'3 :*'(,
,
&2

?%**7 *'( :*3 '*: =10'3,
,
:*'(, '3
&2 0%7 &(,
0'> &/

#%09
*.(/N 4%04%,
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, (*.5', :&(& (%&:* /*.%*(/ 0% H'0@'6
'3
0'
.&2

50@ , +:, <+( '0( 2 7 , (0 %*/*&%.5 4%0:+.( 42
'.2 '?
, (*:
&'/ 4%0:+.(/ /*%),
.*/ .+/(07 *%
2 /(/ &': .+/(07 *%/J/03
,
(@&%* :*)*2
047 *'(/ ,
')*'(,
0'/ 4%0.*//*/ 3
0%7 +2
&/
(*.5'02
0?8 :*/,
?'/ :%&@,
'?/ *'?,
'**%, 5&%:@&%* .0'3 ?+%&(, , 0%7 &(,
'?
,
0' '3
0'
7 &%H*(, 3 '&'., 0% 0(5*% <+/,
'? ,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(, :, 0/*: (0 M
'3
0' /.2
$+4(&N <8
M

#%09
*.(/N *,
(5*% :,
%*.(2 0% , %*.(2 , @%, '? 0%&2 8 0% <8 :%&@,
8
':,
8 '
(,
2
'?/ 0%

0</*%)&(, > &': '0( , +:, , 0%7 &(, (5&( 5&/ =<*.07 * 4+<2 .2 H'0@' &':
0'
'.2 '? '3
0'
, 8
7 &:* ?*'*%&2 8 &)&, &<2 (5%0+?5 '0 @%0'?3 &.( 03 M
2
2 *
+2
$+4(&N >
8 /, '? (5* 10'3,
?',
:*'(, ,
&2 (8
'0':, 0/+%* 03
/.2

?%**7 *'( $+4(& &.H'0@2
*:?*: (5&(

#%09
*.(/L 4%04%,
*(&%8 0% .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, (*.5', :&(&
,
&2 '3
0'
.&2

(%&:* /*.%*(/ 0% H'0@650@ @&/ & 7 &(*%, (*%7 03 5, *7 42
&2
/
087 *'( @,
(5
&': %*7 &,
'*: , *3 *.( &3 /+.5 *7 42
' 3
(*%
087 *'( (*%7 ,
'&(*:

#%09
*.(/

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page6 of 34

) 8, >

+

)
=

6
>

,
,

+
2

,

#%09
*.(/ 7 &, '/ & .07 4+(*% /*%)*%6<&/*: F ,
'(&,
%(+&2#%,
)&(*

?

*(@0%H

(5* =F # > &..*// (0 @5, , 4&//@0%:64%0(*.(*: &': , /(%, 8 2 7 , (0
.5 /
/
.(2 , (*:
#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/ 7 +/( <* 2
0??*: , (0 (5* F #
'

(0 /*': 0% %*.*, @0%H *7 &, / +/,
)*
2
'?

+(2
00HB &..*// (5*

*7 42
08** 4*%/0'&23 2 0% &..*// .0'3,
, */B
:*'(,
&2

#%09
*.(/ /*%)*% , +:,
'.2 '?

#%09
*.(/ .2 *'( ,
,
'30%7 &(,
0'

, +:, @0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ %*2 '? (0 /4*., . .2 *'(/
'.2 '?
&(,
3, ,
(5* F #

&%* 7 &'8 03

5,
?562
*)*2

, 0%:*%
'

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/

2 /(0%*: 0'
/0

'2 & 2 7 , '+7 <*% 03 4%, 2
8 , (*:
), *?*:

#%09
*.(/ 4%03 0'&2&..0+'(, *7 42
*//,
'?
08**/O2 (5&' 5&2 03 &2
*//
3
2

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/O &%* &+(50%,
C*: (0 +/* (5* F #

(0 &..*//

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/
#%09
*.(/ /+</.%, (0 4&8/ 3 &': +/*/ /*)*%&22 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5
<*/
0%
,
(002 0'* 03 @5, , (5* #@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/* 2 .*'/*: 3
/
.5 /
0
,
%07 (5* &..0+'(, 3,
'? %7
#%,
.*@&(*%50+/* 1004*%/ , , <+/,
' (/
'*//
, 0%7 &(, (0 (5* 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002
'3
0'
,
/

#%09
*.(/ 40//*//*/ 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 '
0?,
5*/* 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 ' , 0%7 &(, &%*
0?, '3
0'

4%04%,
*(&%8 .0'3 :*'(, &': .&%*3 2 ?+&%:*: <8
,
&2
+2 8
@, & 2 7 , '+7 <*% 03 5,
(5 , (*:
?562
*)*2

#%09
*.(/ &': &%* 0'2 /5&%*:
8

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/

#%09
*.(/ .%*&(*/ &': +4:&(*/ :0.+7 *'(/ ,
'(*%'&2 8 %*3
2
*%%*: (0 &/ ,
(/
=P 5, #&4*%/ > @5, .0'/, 03 &'&2
(*
.5
/(
8/*/ /+7 7 &%, &': 7 *(50:02 */ 03 :&(&
*/
0?,
%*/*&%.5 &': , 0%7 &(, (5&( 5&)* <**' ?&(5*%*: &': /8'(5*/,
'3
0'
C*: <8

#%09
*.(/

4%03 0'&2&..0+'(, *7 42
*//,
'?
08**/ *,
(5*% 3
%07 (5*, .02 *.(, H'0@2
%
2 )*
*:?* &':
*D4*%,
*'.* 0% 3
%07

#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002
,
/

5* P 5, #&4*%/ &%*
(*

)&2
+&<2 5, 8 4%04%,
* ?52
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, &': .0'/(,
,
&2
(+(* 4%0(*.(&<2 (%&:* /*.%*(/
*
<*2
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/
#%09
*.(/ 40//*//*/ <+/,
'*// &': 7 &%H*(, /(%&(*?, 4%, '?
'?
*/
.,

, 0%7 &(, .+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/ .+/(07 *% , 0%7 &(, , +:,
'3
0'
)*
,
'3
0' '.2 '?

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page7 of 34

@0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ %*2 '? (0 /4*., . .2 *'(/ 4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
&(,
3, ,
?'/
@5, &%* 4%04%,
.5
*(&%8 .0'3,
:*'(, &': .0'/(,
&2
(+(* 4%0(*.(&<2 (%&:* /*.%*(/
*
#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ , +:* <+( &%* '0( 2 7 , (0 (5* 3 2 '?
'.2
, (*:
02 0@,
P 5, #&4*%/ /(%&(*?, 4%, '? , 0%7 &(, .+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/
(*
*/
., '3
0'
)*
,
.+/(07 *% , 0%7 &(, , +:, @0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ %*2 '? (0 /4*., .
'3
0' '.2 '?
&(,
3,
.2 *'(/ 4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
,
?'/ .02 *.(, 8 (5* = %&:* *.%*(/>
2 )*2

' &::, 0'
(,

#%09
*.(/ 40//*//*/ 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(, , +:, ,
&2 '3
0' '.2 '? (/
4&//@0%:/ &': 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0 , 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 &': (0 (5* F #
0?, '3
0'
(/ ,
/
#%09
*.(/ .&%*3 2 ?+&%:/ &': 4%0(*.(/ , %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*%
+2 8
(/
4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, (0 *'/+%* (5&( (5, , 0%7 &(, , '0(
,
&2 '3
0'
/ '3
0' /
&..*//, * (0 (5* 4+<2 . &': , 0'2 &..*//, * (0 & 2 7 , '+7 <*% 03 5,
<2
,
/
8
<2
, (*:
?562
*)*2
#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/ 7 0/( 03 @507 &%* , (5* .07 4&'8L/ (*.5', &..0+'(,
'
.&2
'?
?%0+4
' , *33
(/ 0%(/ (0 ?+&%:
4%04%,
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0%
,
&2

#%09
*.(/ %*E+, &2 *7 42
%*/ 2
08**/ (0 /, &?%**7 *'(/
?'

.0'(&, '? %*&/0'&<2 %*/(%, )* .0)*'&'(/ @5, (84, 2 4%05, ( (5* *7 42
',
*
.(,
.5
.&2 8
<,
08** 3
%07
(&H, 0% :, 0/, 4%04%,
'?
/.2 '?
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, 0% %&:* *.%*(/
'3
0'
5%0+?50+( 5, *7 42
/
087 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& @&/ & /*',
0%

*7 42
08** , (5* (*.5', &..0+'(, ?%0+4 &': 5&: 4%, 2
'
.&2
'?
), *?*: &..*// (0

#%09
*.(/L

.2 86?+&%:*: %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
0/*2
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(,
,
&2 '3
0'
, +:, (5* 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0 (5* F #
'.2 '?
0?, '3
0'

&':

#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*:
,

%*/*&%.5 (002 , +:, (5* #@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/*
/ '.2 '?
0
=

)

,

(

+%, 5, (, * &/ & *',
'? / 7
0%

&'&?*% 03

6

+

) 8,

#%09
*.(/ & /+</(&'(, 40%(,
&2
0'

03 $+4(&L/ @0%H ,
')02
)*: 4%0), '? 3,
:,
'&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.* /*%), (0
&2
(,
,
.*/
#%09
*.(L/ .2 *'(
,

1

P 5, * @0%H, 3
2
'? 0%

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& 7 &'&?*: 1 L/ 3 2 '?/ @, (5*
,,
(5

*.+%, */ &': D.5&'?* 107 7 , 0'B 7 &'&?*: 1 L/ @0%2 :* .0%40%&(*
(,
//,
:@,

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page8 of 34

&..0+'(, &': .0'/02 :&(, 7 &'&?*: &2 03 1 L/ 7 *%?*% &': &.E+, (, &.(, (8B
'?
, 0'B
2
/, 0'
),
7 &'&?*: 1 L/ 4*%,
0:6*': .2 '?/B &': 7 &'&?*: &2 03 1 L/ (*.5', &..0+'(,
0/,
2
.&2
'?
#+%/+&'( (0 &'

::*':+7 :&(*:

+?+/(

::*':+7 > &': /,
?'*: <8 ,
'?5 &': (5*'61(*45*' 05&2
8

1

.0'(%&.(*: @,
(5

&*
3

+?+/(

+%, 5, (, * &(
'? / 7

=#%040/&2 @5*%*<8
>

&'&?,
'?

,
%*.(0% 03 1

#%09
*.(/ (0 4%0), 3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &':
:* ,
&2
(,

.07 42 &'.* /*%), &( 0'* 03 1 L/ /+</, &%,
,
.*/
:, */
'& 1&2 3
, 0%', =.07 7 *'., ,
&
'? '

&':

(5* = +?+/(

,
%/.5 2
*.(%0', = ,
./
%/.5> , &'(&
'

J3 (5* 3 /.&28*&%
0%
,

>

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& @0%H*: 0' & 4%040/&2 (5*

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 &//, @, 1 L/ 3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &':
:
/( (5
,
&2
(,

.07 42 &'.* @0%H $+4(& &': 1
,

@0%H*: (0?*(5*% (0 ,
:*'(, 8 (5* /.04* 03 (5*
3

#%040/&2 <&/*: 0' 1 L/ '**:/ &': 3,
'&'., %*/(%, 0'/
&2
.(,
(
,
) 8,

=
@

' 0% <*3
0%*
@, 1
(5

!
6

+ 2 (
2
6

.(0<*%

, :,
' %*.( ), &(, 03 (5*
02 0'
' &' *67 &, :&(*:
2

1
&/(*%

(5* 1-

,
'

*.*7 <*%

(
;

?%**7 *'(L/ '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/*
$+4(& , 0%7 *: ,
'3
'?5 (5&( :+%, &
'?
(02 $+4(& =, .0'3,
:
'
:*'.*> (5&( 1

@0+2 2 H* (0 5, $+4(& &/ F , #%*/,
: ,
%*
.*
:*'( 03 -,
'&'.* (0 %*42
&.*
2
*&),
'? 1

?

<*?&' /02 ., '? $+4(& 3 *7 42
, (,
0%
087 *'(

.(0<*%

.&2 <*(@**' $+4(& &': 1 L/ 12

;

*2 *%/ @50 @&/
2

' (5* *67 &, $+4(& /(&(*: (5&( 5* 5&:'L( 8*(
2

=.07 7 ,
((*: 0% (02 M 1- N &'8(5, 0' (5, > *.0?', '? (5*, 40(*'(, *D40/+%*
: (5*
'?
/
C,
%
&2
(0 .2 7 / 3
&,
%07

#%09
*.(/ 3 <%*&.5 03 .0'(%&.( &': 0(5*% 40(*'(, .2 7 /
0%
&2 &,

$+4(& , (,
', &(*: '*?0(, 0'/ @,
&(,
(5

#%09
*.(/ (0 &2 0@ $+4(& (0 9 ' 1
2
0,

1

&':

@,
(50+(

,
'.+%%, 2 &<, , 0% 2 (, 0' &': (0 3 2 (&(* & /7 00(5 (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1
'? , 2 (8
, ?&(,
&., ,
(,
-02 0@, /*)*%&2@**H/ 03 '*?0(, 0'/
2 '?
&(,
, & '*@ .0'(%&.( (5* = 7 42
'(0
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

#%09
*.(/ &': 1

?%**7 *'(> @5*%*<8

&?%**: '0( (0 /**H *'3
0%.*7 *'( 03 (5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*

&/(*%

*'(*%*:
#%09
*.(/
?%**7 *'(

0% &//*%( 0(5*% 40(*'(, .2 7 / &': (0 3 2 (&(* & /7 00(5 *7 42
&2 &,
&., ,
087 *'( (%&'/, 0' 03
(,
$+4(& (0 1 L/ *7 42
087 *'( , *D.5&'?* 3
'
0% 1 L/ &?%**7 *'( (0 4&8

#%09
*.(/ &

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page9 of 34

3 03
**

K 03 $+4(&L/ &''+&2<&/* .07 4*'/&(, &( 1
0'

&/ %*E+, <8 (5*
%*:

?%**7 *'( &/ @*2 &/ 1 L/ 4%07 , (0 .0'(,
2
/*
'+* (0 *'?&?*

#%09
*.(/ 3 &2
0% 2

(*.5', &..0+'(, 4%09
.&2
'?
*.(/ &/ %*E+, 3 &( 2
%*: 0%
*&/( (5* 3 /.&28*&%/
,
(0 .0'/,
:*%

#%09
*.(/ 3 3
0% +(+%* 4%09
*.(/

1

#%09
*.(/ &': (5&(

&':

&':

3
+%(5*% &?%**: (5&( $+4(& @0+2 '0(
:

<* 5, (0 4*%3
%*:
0%7 =,
'650+/*> (5* ,
:*'(, /*%), 3 @5,
.&2
.*/ 0%
.5 1
@,
(5

&/(*%

5&: .0'(%&.(*:

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 .0'(,
:
'+* (0 4*%3
0%7 (5* <+2 03 (5&(
H

@0%H
'

0)*7 <*%

$+4(& *7 &, *: ,
2
'?5 &': .0'3, *: , @%, '?
%7
'
(,

(5&( +40' $+4(&L/ (%&'/, 0' (0 1
(,
+43
%0'( @5, @, 2<* G
.5 2

=

#%09
*.(/ @, 27 &H*
2

@5, , *E+, *'( 03
.5 /
)&2

50+%/

K 03 7 8 /&2
&%8
0 , (5*%* , &
3
/

6 K

%*:+.(, 03 @0%H :+* (0 (5* 3 (5&( &7 (5*%* '0@ (5&( @, 2<* .0)*%*: (5%0+?5 (5,
0'
&.(
2
/
+43
%0'( 4&87 *'( > ' (5, *67 &, $+4(& &2 %*4%*/*'(*: (5&( = ' &::, 0'
/
2
/0
(,
/+%*

@, 27 &H*
2

#%09
*.(/ .0'(,
'+* M .N (0 :0 (5* M ,
/,
3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.* /*%),
&2
(,
,
.*/N

@0%H , 0+(5*%' 1&2 30%',
'
,
&

2
/0

@, 2(%8 (0 5&)*
2

.0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.* /*%),
(,
,
.*/N @0%H 3
0% 1
' 5,
/
= 8 9 &( 1
0<

0)*7 <*%

#%09
*.(/ :0 (5* M ,
3 '&'.,
&2

, $*%7 &'8J>
'

*7 &, (0 ,
2
'?5 $+4(& 3
+%(5*% .0'3 %7 *: (5&(
,

@, 2<* 7 &, 8 ,
2
'2 ')02
)*: @, 04*%&(,
(5
0'/ %*/40'/, 2 (8 &': '0(
<, ,

'*.*//&%, 8 @%, '? (5* &.(+&2(*.5', 7 *7 0/ *(. @, 2<* 7 &, 8 ,
2
(,
.&2
2
'2 ')02
)*: ,
'
7 &'&?, &': %*), '? (5* @0%H &': (5*%*3
'?
*@,
0%* 1

@, 2/(, 2'**: &//,
2 2
/(&'.* 3
%07

#%09
*.(/ 3 E+, & 2 M .N (*.5', &..0+'(, @0%H >
0%
(* 0( /,
.&2
'?
' 0% &<0+(

0)*7 <*%

P , 7 *% $+4(& &': ,
7
'?5 4&%(, 4&(*:
.,

, & .0'3
'
*%*'.* .&2 , @5, P , 7 *% %*4%*/*'(*: (5&( , .0'/,
2'
.5
7
'
:*%&(, 03
0'
#%09
*.(/L &?%**7 *'( '0( (0 /**H *'3
0%.*7 *'( 03 (5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*
&/(*%

?%**7 *'( 0% 0(5*% 40(*'(, .&+/*/ 03 &.(, &': , &?%**7 *'( (0 3 2 (&(* &
&2
0'
(/
&., ,

/7 00(5 (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1 L/ *7 42
(,
087 *'(
, (5* &7 0+'( 03
'

@0+2 4&8
:

K 03 $+4(&L/ /&2
&%8B @0+2 .0'(,
:
'+* (0 +/*

(*.5', &..0+'(, 4%09
.&2
'?
*.(/ &/ %*E+,
%*: &': &2 !
2
&'(&

1

'& &': $*%7 &'8 3 &( 2
0%
*&/( (5* 3 /.&28*&%
,

#%09
*.(/ & 3
**
#%09
*.(/ 3 &2
0% 2

/*.+%, */ .07 42 &'.* 4%09
(,
,
*.(/ ,
'
&':

B &': @0+2 .0'(,
:
'+*

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page10 of 34

(0 *'?&?*

#%09
*.(/L /*%), 3 3
.*/ 0% +(+%* 4%09
*.(/ P , 7 *% &2 .0'3, *: (5&( $+4(&
7
/0
%7

@0+2 '0( <* 5, (0 4*%3
:
%*:
0%7 =,
'650+/*> (5* /&7 * /*%), 3 @5,
.*/ 0%
.5 1
.0'(%&.(*: @,
(5

#%09
*.(/ &': (5&( 1

5&:

@0+2 /(, 2'**: /+</(&'(, &//,
: 2
&2
/(&'.* 3
%07

#%09
*.(/ 3 (*.5', &..0+'(, @0%H
0%
.&2
'?
' &' *7 &, :&(*:
2
=+':*%/(&':, 03 5, '?
'?
%,

P , 7 *% (5&'H*: ,
7
'?5 3 5,
0% /

&7 &2> &': &((&.5*: & 2
*((*% :0.+7 *'(,
'? 1 L/ ,
'(*'( (0

.0'(,
'+* , *'?&?*7 *'( @,
(/
(5
' (5*

*.*7 <*%

#%09
*.(/ (5* = *.*7 <*%

*.*7 <*%

*((*%>

*((*% P , 7 *% /(&(*: = @0+2 2 H* (0 5*%*<8
7
: ,

.0'3, 0+% &?%**7 *'( (5&( 1
%7

,
'(*':/ (0 .0'(,
'+* (0 +/*

#%09
*.(/ 3 &2
0% 2

(*.5', &..0+'(, 4%09
.&2
'?
*.(/ &/ &': @5*' %*E+, &': &2 M '&'., .0'/+2 '? &':
%*:
2 3,
&2
(,
.07 42 &'.* /*%),
,
.*/N 4%09
*.(/ , &'(&
'

'& &': $*%7 &'8 (0 (5* *D(*'( 40//, * &( 2
<2
*&/(

3 3 /.&28*&%
0% ,

&':

/ :,
/.+//*: (5* 5, '? 03 %
%,

'0( 7 *&' (5&( 1

,
'(*': M .N '0( (0 +/*
/,

&7 &2 &'( M
$+4(&N :0*/

#%09
*.(/ /*%), , (5* 3
.*/ '
+(+%*B 0' (5*

.0'(%&%8 @* ,
'(*': (0 .0'(,
'+* (0 *'?&?* 80+% (*&7 3 4%09
0%
*.(/ &/ &44%04%,
&(* P *
&44%*., 80+ 7 &H, (5, *D.*4(, 3 +/ &': 80+% /+440%( , (5* 5, '? 03 %
&(*
'? /
0' 0%
'
%,
&7 &2 &'( (0 1

>

' &' *7 &, :&(*:
2

*.*7 <*%

P , 7 *% @%0(* (0 ,
7
'?5 /(&(, =
'?

@0+2 2 H* (0 (5&'H 80+ 4*%/0'&2 8 3 (5* /+440%( ?,
: ,
2 0%
)*' (0 7 * &': 1 Q ( 5&/ <**'
?%*&( 5&), 80+ &/ & <+/,
'?
'*// 4&%('*% &': )*%8 7 +.5 *'9
08*: @0%H, @, 80+
'? (5
*)*' 7 0%* ?0, 0+( 3 2
'?
0% +'.5*/ 0% :,
''*%/Q 504* (5* %*.*'( :,
/.+//,
0'/ &<0+(
&7 &2/ 3
R +(+%* 42
&'/ 5&)* '0( :,
/(+%<*: (5, (0 M .N 7 +.5 <+( @, 2*)*' <* (5* <&/, 3
/
/,
2
/ 0%
/(%0'?*% %*2 0'/5, ?0, 3
&(,
4/
'? 0%@&%:Q
>
#%09
*.(/ %*&/0'&<2 %*2 *: 0' 1 L/ 0%&2&': @%,
8 ,
((*' %*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/
(5&(

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 <* &:*E+&(*2 .07 4*'/&(*: 3 :*.2 ', , %, (0 *'3
:
8
0%
, '? (/ ?5(
0%.*

(5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( &': 3 3 2 (&(, & /7 00(5
0% &., , '?

(%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1
(,
' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ 4%07 ,
* ,
/*/

#%09
*.(/ .0'(,
'+*: (0

&2 0@ $+4(& &..*// (0 , %&:* *.%*(/ .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
2
(/
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*//

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page11 of 34

, 0%7 &(, F #
'3
0'

&': 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 , +:, (5* #@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/*
,
/ '.2 '?
0

:+%, (5* (, * <*3 5* 03 , &2 8 *'(*%*: 1 L/ *7 42
'?
7
0%*
3 ., 2
087 *'(
' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ 4%07 ,
* ,
/*/

#%09
*.(/ :, '0( (&H*
:

&::, 0'&2/*.+%, 4%*.&+(,
(,
(8
0'/ @, %*/4*.( (0 $+4(&L/ &..*// (0 &': +/* 03 .0'3,
(5
:*'(,
&2
#%09
*.(/L , 0%7 &(, :, '0( .5&'?* (5* 4&//@0%:/ (0 (5* F #
'3
0' :
.5&'?* (5* 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0
0?, '3
0'
107 4*%, :&(&<&/*
0

&': :, '0(
:

#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 , +:, (5* #@1
,
/ '.2 '?

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 5&)* (&H*' (5*/* &::, 0'&2/*.+%,
:
(,
(8

4%*.&+(,
0'/ (0 4%*)*'( (5*3 &': 7 ,
(
/&44%04%, 0' 5&: , '0( %*2 *: , ?00: 3 (5 0' (5*
&(,
(
, '
&,
%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ 7 &:* <8 1

%*?&%:, $+4(&L/ *7 42
'?
087 *'( (%&'/, 0' &': 1 L/
(,

,
'(*'(, (0 .0'(,
0'
'+* (0 +/*

#%09
*.(/ 3 (5* <+2 03 (5* @0%H , 5&: 4%*),
0%
H
(
0+/2
8

4*%3
0%7 *:
' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ 4%07 ,
* ,
/*/

#%09
*.(/ :, '0( %*&2 0.&(*
:
2

*7 42
08**/ &': %*/0+%.*/ :*/,
?'&(*: (0 /*%), 1 L/ .2 *'( &..0+'( (0 0(5*% .2 *'(
.*
,
,
&..0+'(/ @5,
.5

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 5&)* :0'* &</*'( , %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.*
:
(/
* ,

=

) 8, ?

?
(

' &' *67 &, (0 ,
2
'?5 :&(*:
%*/,
?'&(, 3
0' %07

*.*7 <*%

$+4(& (*':*%*: 5,
/

#%09
*.(/ &': , .&(*: 5, ,
':,
/ '(*'( (0 %*'( 5, 507 * /*2 5, .&%/
/
2 /

&': =7 0)* (0 $*%7 &'8 , (5* 3, @**H 03 I
'
%/(
&'+&%8
+%, 5, *7 42
'? /
087 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& @&/ &//,
?'*: &'

*7 42
08** .07 4+(*% (5* =107 4+(*%> (0 +/* 3
0%
<*2
0'?*: (0

>

#%09
*.(/ <+/,
'*//

5, 107 4+(*%
/

#%09
*.(/ &': @&/ +/*: 3 ,
0% '(*%/(&(* .07 7 *%.* &': .07 7 +', 0'
.&(,
*(@**'

0)*7 <*%

(5* =-, */> 0' 5, 107 4+(*%
2
/

&':

*.*7 <*%

$+4(& .%*&(*: 3 2
, */

5* -, */ .0'(&,
2
'*: .04, 03 &2 (5* .0'3,
*/
2
:*'(,
&2

, 0%7 &(, 3
'3
0' %07 &( 2
*&/( 3
0+% .2 *'(/ $+4(& 5&: @0%H*: @, :+%, 5, *7 42
,
(5
'? /
087 *'( &(
#%09
*.(/ &/ @*2 &/ .04, 03
2
*/
.04, 03
*/

#%09
*.(/L 4%04%,
*(&%8 (*.5', :0.+7 *'(/ &':
.&2

#%09
*.(/L P 5, #&4*%/ -%07
(*

0)*7 <*%

(5%0+?5

*.*7 <*%

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page12 of 34

(5*%* @&/ '0 <+/,
'*// 9 3, 0' 3 $+4(& (0 42 .04, 03
+/(, .&(, 0%
&.*
*/
P 5, #&4*%/ 0% .2 *'( 3 2 0' 5, 107 4+(*%
(*
,
, */
/

#%09
*.(/L

* :, /0 @,
:
(50+( &+(50%, 0' 3
C&(, %07

#%09
*.(/
$+4(&L/ 2 @0%H, :&8 &(
&/(
'?
:&(* $+4(& %*(+%'*: 5, 107 4+(*% (0
/
&7 ,
(5& &9
**) = &9
**)> &( 5*% 03 , ,
3 .* '

#%09
*.(/ @&/
#%09
*.(/L

*.*7 <*%

' (5&(

+7 &' */0+%.*/

#%09
*.(/L

,
%*.(0%

0+'(&, F , 03 .*/
' *@ 3,

P 5*' $+4(& %*(+%'*: (5* 107 4+(*% (0 &9 0'
**)

*.*7 <*%

&9 2
**) 0.H*: (5* 107 4+(*% , & :%&@*% , 5*% 03 , @5*%* , %*7 &,
'
'
3 .*
(
'*: @,
(50+( <*,
'?
&..*//*: +'(, I
2 &'+&%8

@5*' $+4(& %*(+%'*: (0 %*E+*/( &..*// (0 (5* 107 4+(*%

' $+4(&L/ 2 :&8 03 *7 42
&/(
087 *'(

#%09
*.(/ (*%7 ,
'&(*: $+4(&L/

&..*// (0 (5* F #
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 &': &/ %*3 *.(*: 0' $+4(&L/ 4%03 2 0' (5*
'3
0'
,
2
,*
0'2 '* 4%03 0'&2'*(@0%H = ,
,
*//,
'H*: ' > $+4(& , .+%%*'(2 *7 42
/
8
08*: &( 1

&/ (5*

F , #%*/,
.*
:*'( 03 -,
'&'.* &': 10%40%&(* 10'(%02 *% &( 1
2
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 &': &/ %*3 *.(*: 0' $+4(&L/ 4%03 2 0' (5*
'3
0'
,
2
,*
0'2 '* 4%03 0'&2'*(@0%H = ,
,
*//,
'H*: ' > (5* 3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.*
,
&2
(,
,
/*%), $+4(& .+%%*'(2 4%0),
.*/
8
:*/ (0 1

&/ &' 1

*7 42
08** &%* ,
:*'(, (0 (5*
.&2

3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.* /*%), $+4(& 4%*),
,
&2
(,
,
.*/
0+/2 4%0),
8
:*: (0 1

&/ &'

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08** &': , +:* 7 &'&?,
'.2
'? 1 L/ 3 2 '?/ @, (5* *.+%, */ &':
,,
(5
(,
D.5&'?* 107 7 , 0'B 7 &'&?,
//,
'? 1 L/ @0%2 :* .0%40%&(* &..0+'(, &':
:@,
'?
.0'/02 :&(, 7 &'&?, &2 03 1 L/ 7 *%?*% &': &.E+, (, &.(, (8B 7 &'&?,
, 0'B
'? 2
/, 0'
),
'? 1 L/
4*%,
0:6*': .2 '?/B &': 7 &'&?, &2 03 1 L/ (*.5', &..0+'(,
0/,
'? 2
.&2
'?
=
2

)

' 0% &<0+( I
&'+&%8

) 8, >
6
+

,
+

7 0%* (5&' (@0 @**H/ &3 %*/, '? 3%07
(*%
?',

#%09
*.(/ &': (+%', , 5, *7 42
'? ' /
08** 107 4+(*% $+4(& %*(+%'*: (0
0+'(&, F , 03 .* &': (02
' *@ 3,
:

#%09
*.(/L 3
%0'( :*/H %*.*4(, /(
0',

, **'&
2

#%09
*.(/L
*'0'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page13 of 34

= *'0'> (5&( 5* '**:*: (0 &..*// (5* 107 4+(*% $+4(& (02
:

*'0' (5&( ,
'?5 5&:

?,
)*' $+4(& 4*%7 , 0' (0 (&H* (5* 107 4+(*% 507 * @, 5, 0)*%',
//,
(5 7
?5(
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5*' $+4(& (02
'3
0'
,
:

*'0' (5&( ,
'?5 5&:

?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 (&H* (5* 107 4+(*% 507 * @, 5, $+4(& H'*@ (5&( ,
7
//,
(5 7
'?5
5&: '0( ?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 &..*// (5* 107 4+(*% 0% (&H* , 507 * @, 5, 3 &'8
7
//,
(
(5 7 0%
4+%40/*
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5*' $+4(& (02
'3
0'
,
:

*'0' (5&( ,
'?5 5&:

?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 (&H* (5* 107 4+(*% 507 * @, 5, 5* H'*@ (5&( ,
7
//,
(5 7
'?5 @&/
'0( , (5* 03 .* <+( %&(5*% @&/ , ':, (5,
'
3,
'
&
%(**' (, * C0'*/ &@&8
7
(5&( , @0+2 <* , 40//, * 3
(
:
7
<2 0%

5+/ $+4(& H'*@

*'0' (0 )*%, 8 $+4(&L/ .2 7 (5&( ,
3
&,
'?5 5&:

&+(50%,
C*: 5, &..*// (0 (5* 107 4+(*%
/
*'0' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 *: 0' (5* %*4%*/*'(&(,
8 ,
0'/ 03 $+4(& @507 /5*
H'*@ (0 <* & 3
0%7 *% 4%03 0'&2*7 42
*//,
08** 03

#%09
*.(/

..0%:, 8
'?2

*'0'

%*7 0)*: (5* 107 4+(*% 3
%07 (5* 2
0.H*: :%&@*% 03 &9
**)L/ 03 , @5*%* , 5&: <**'
3 .*
(
H*4( /,
'.*

*.*7 <*%

&': &2 0@*: $+4(& (0 (&H* (5* 107 4+(*% 507 * @, 5,
2
(5 7

' (5* *)*', 03 I
'?
&'+&%8

@5, * (5* 107 4+(*% @&/ , $+4(&L/
2
'

40//*//, $+4(& (*2
0'
*450'*: &9 &': &/H*: 5*% 3 (5* 4&//@0%: (0 2 0' (0
**)
0%
0?
#%09
*.(/L F #

(*2 , 5*% (5&( (5* F #
2'?

@&/ '0( @0%H,
'?

+%, (5, .&2 $+4(&
'? / 2

(02 &9 (5&( ,
:
**)
'?5 5&: ?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 &..*// (5* 107 4+(*%
7
//,

&9
**)

%*&/0'&<2 %*2 *: 0' (5* %*4%*/*'(&(,
8 ,
0'/ 03 $+4(& @507 /5* H'*@ (0 <* & 3
0%7 *%
4%03 0'&2*7 42
*//,
08** 03

#%09
*.(/ &': ?&)* 5, & 4&//@0%: (0 2 0'(0 (5* F #
7
0?

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5, * +/, (5* 107 4+(*% $+4(& 2
'3
0'
,
2
'?
0??*: 0'
(0 (5* F #

&': 5&: &..*// (0 '0( 0'2 5, .0'(&.( 2 /(/O@5, &2 @*%* &..*//, * 0'
8 /
,
.5 /0
<2

(5* 107 4+(*% 5&%: :%,
)*O<+( &2
/0

#%09
*.(/L P 5, #&4*%/ /(%&(*?, 4%, '?
(*
*/
.,

, 0%7 &(, .+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/ .+/(07 *% , 0%7 &(, , +:,
'3
0'
)*
,
'3
0' '.2 '?
@0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ <*2
0'?, (0 (5* .2 *'( 4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
'?
,
?'/ &':
0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// ,
'30%7 &(, <*2
0'
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/

5*/*

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page14 of 34

7 &(*%, / @*%* '0( 4+<2 .2 H'0@' @*%* &( &2 (, */ .&%*3 2 ?+&%:*: <8
&2
, 8
2 7
+2 8
&': @*%* %*/(%,
.(*: (0 5,
?562
*)*2

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5, * +/, (5* 107 4+(*% 0' I
'3
0'
,
2
'?
&'+&%8
I
&'+&%8
.0'(&,
'*:

$+4(& &..*//*: 5, -, */ &': 5, *7 42
/ 2
/
08** 3 :*% 0' (5* F #
02

&':

@5,
.5

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(,
,
&2 '3
0'
'I
&'+&%8

7 &, (5* =I
2
&'+&%8

&(

47

$+4(& +/*: (5* 107 4+(*% (0 /*': &' *6

*7 &, > *'(, *: = +(2
2
(2
00H .0'(&.(/> 3
%07 5,
/

#%09
*.(/L

+(2
00H *7 &, &::%*// (0 5, 4*%/0'&2*7 &, &::%*// &( =8&500 .07 > $+4(& @0+2
2
/
2
:
5&)* <**' +'&<2 (0 /*': (5, *7 &, 3
*
/
2 %07 5,
/
5* '0( <**' 2
0??*: 0' (0 (5* F #

#%09
*.(/

+(2
00H *7 &, &::%*// 5&:
2

+/, (5* 4&//@0%: 5* 0<(&,
'?
'*: 3
%07

&9 <8 3 /*
**)
&2

4%*(*'/*/ 0' I
&'+&%8
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 (5* I
'3
0'
,
&'+&%8
5, /*2 .0'(&,
7
3
'*:

*7 &, 3
2 %07 $+4(& (0

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8

<+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5*' $+4(& *67 &, *:
'3
0'
,
2

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, (0 5, /*2 5* @&/
'3
0'
7
3
&@&%* (5&( (5*8 @*%* 5, 8 .0'3,
?52
:*'(, 4%04%,
&2
*(&%8 &': )&2
+&<2
*
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 @5*' $+4(& *67 &, *:
'3
0'
,
2

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, (0 5, /*2 5* @&/
'3
0'
7
3
&@&%* (5&( (5*/* 7 &(*%, / @*%* 7 &:* &)&, &<2 0'2 (0 .+%%*'(
&2
2 *
8
(5&( 5* @&/ '0( &'

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08** &': (5&( 5* 2
&.H*: &+(50%, 0' (0 &..*//
C&(,

(5* 7 &(*%, /
&2
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 $+4(& *67 &, *:
'3
0'
,
2

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/

&': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, (0 5, /*2 @, (5* ,
'3
0'
7
3 (5
'(*'( 03
+/, (50/* 7 &(*%, / , 5, '*@ *7 42
'?
&2 ' /
087 *'( @, 1
(5
#%09
*.(/ &': , ), &(, 03 (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
' 02 0'
,
&2 (8

(0 (5* :*(%, *'( 03
7

?%**7 *'(

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 &3 *67 &, ,
'3
0'
,
(*%
2 '?

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/

&': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, (0 5, /*2 $+4(& :*2
'3
0'
7
3
*(*: &2
2

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page15 of 34

*7 &, / *)*% /*'( 0% %*.*,
2
)*: <8 5, <0(5 :+%, &': 3 2 '? 5, *7 42
7
'?
02 0@,
/
087 *'( @,
(5
#%09
*.(/ *D.*4( 3 (5* I
0%
&'+&%8

*7 &, (5*%*<8 :*/(%08, )&2
2
'?
+&<2 &':
*

.0'3,
:*'(, .2 *'( :&(&
&2 ,
' (5* *)*', 03 I
'?
&'+&%8

&3 &..*//, 5, -, */ &': (5* F #
(*%
'? / 2

$+4(& %*(+%'*: (5* *7 42
08** 107 4+(*% (0

*'0' &( 5*% 507 *

*'0' %*(+%'*: (5* 107 4+(*% (0 &9
**)L/ 03 , @5*%* , @&/ 2
3 .*
(
0.H*: , &
'
:%&@*% +'(, &%0+': I
2
&'+&%8
<8

@5*' (5* 107 4+(*% 5&%: :%, @&/ @,
)*
4*: .2
*&'

#%09
*.(/ '3
0%7 &(,
0' *.5'02
0?8 = > /(&3 &': %*6,
3
//+*: (0 &'0(5*% *7 42
08**
*3 .2
0%* *&', (5* 5&%: :%,
'?
)*

/+</(&'(, 3, */ <8 /&), (5*7 (0 (5* F #
)* 2
'?

=

( ( A
(

2

#%09
*.(/L

/(&3 7 &:* & <&.H6+4 03 ,
3
(/

, & 3 :*% .%*&(*: 0' I
' 02
&'+&%8

B
5

+
) 8, >
C 2
) 8,

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 $+4(& , '0@ +/,
'3
0'
,
/
'?

,

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?
#%09
*.(/ @,
(50+( &+(50%, 0' (0 4*%3
C&(,
0%7 /*%), 3
.*/ 0% 1

5, '*@ *7 42
/
08*%

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 &': &/ %*3 *.(*: 0' $+4(&L/ 4%03 2 0' (5*
'3
0'
,
2
,*
0'2 '* 4%03 0'&2'*(@0%H = ,
,
*//,
'H*: ' > 1

, .+%%*'(2 +/, $+4(& (0 4*%3
/
8
'?
0%7 =,
'6

50+/*> &2 3,
2 '&'., .07 42 &'.* &': .0'/+2 '? /*%), @5, @*%* 0'.* 4%0),
&2
,
(,
.*/
.5
:*: <8
#%09
*.(/ , +:, 7 &'&?,
'.2 '?
'? 1 L/ 3 2 '?/ @, (5* *.+%, */ &': D.5&'?*
,,
(5
(,
107 7 , 0'B 7 &'&?,
//,
'? 1 L/ @0%2 :* .0%40%&(* &..0+'(, &': .0'/02 :&(,
:@,
'?
, 0'B
7 &'&?, &2 03 1 L/ 7 *%?*% &': &.E+, (, &.(, (8B 7 &'&?,
'? 2
/, 0'
),
'? 1 L/ 4*%,
0:6*':
.2 '?/B &': 7 &'&?, &2 03 1 L/ (*.5', &..0+'(,
0/,
'? 2
.&2
'?
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 1
'3
0'
,
/*%), (0 1
.*/

, 3+2 8 &@&%* (5&( , 4%0), '?
/ 2
'
:,

$+4(& , 7 &H, +'&+(50%,
/
'?
C*: +/* 03

#%09
*.(/L P 5, #&4*%/
(*

/(%&(*?, 4%, '? , 0%7 &(, .+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/ .+/(07 *%
*/
., '3
0'
)*
,
, 0%7 &(, , +:, @0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ <*2
'3
0' '.2 '?
0'?, (0 .2 *'(/
'?
,

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page16 of 34

4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
?'/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
<*2
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/
, 5, '? $+4(&
'.* %,

1

@, &'8 '*@ #%09
(5
*.(/ &': '0 '*@

5&/ '0( +/*:

#%09
*.(/L /*%), , .0''*.(,
.*/ '
0'

::*':+7 / 5&)* <**' *D*.+(*: /,
'.*

+?+/(

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 $+4(& 5&/ 7 &:* 3 /* %*4%*/*'(&(,
'3
0'
,
&2
0'/ (0
1

.0'.*%',
'?

#%09
*.(/L ,
'&<, , (0 4%0), 3,
2 (8
:* '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.*
&2
(,
,

/*%), (0 1
.*/
' &' *7 &, :&(*: I
2
&'+&%8
#%040/&2(5&( 5&: <**' :%&3 <8
(*:
/4*., .&(,
3, 0'/ ,
:*'(, *: <8 1
3,
8*/(*%:&8 (5* 1

$+4(& @%0(* (0 ,
'?5 %*?&%:, &
'?

#%09
*.(/ , &..0%:&'.* @, 3,
'
(5 '&'.,
&2

&': $+4(& &': /(&(*: (5&( = / @* :,
/.+//*:

M 1 N 5&/ 3
03
0%7 &2 8 &44%0)*: (0 5,
2
%*

#%09
*.(/ 3 (5*
0%

M '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.*N 4%09
3,
&2
(,
,
*.(J @, 25&)* (5* 4%040/&2&44%0)*:J>
2
*/4, $+4(&L/ I
(*
&'+&%8
1

*D*.+(, &': 0' <*5&2 03 1
)*
3

%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ @5, @*%* 7 &:* &/ &'
.5
&': :*/4, (5* #%040/&2 .&%*3 (&, 0%, (0 (5*
(*
L/
+2 2 '?

3 '&'., /4*., .&(,
,
&2
3, 0'/ ,
:*'(, *: <8 1
3,

&': $+4(&

507 4/0' , 0%7 *: ,
'3
'?5 , &' *67 &, :&(*:
'
2

4%,
2

1

1-

*2 '
),

*'(0'6

(5&( =M '3
+N 0%(+'&(*2 (5*
8

4%040/&2(5&( 80+ 5&)* /+<7 ,
((*: , .0'/,
/
:*%&<2 0+(/, 03 0+% <+:?*(> &': (5&(
8
:*
:*'(, $%0+4 , =(5*%*3 +'&<2 (0 &..*4( 80+% 4%040/&2>
)*
/
0%*
*
'I
&'+&%8

@5, * @0%H, 3
2
'? 0% 1

$+4(& 7 &:* & 450'* .&2 (0 &'
2

#%09
*.(/L *7 42
08** (5* = 7 42
08**> @, @507 $+4(& 5&: @0%H*: .2 8 :+%,
(5
0/*2
'?
5, *7 42
/
087 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/

+%, (5, .&2 $+4(& &/H*: (5* 7 42
'? / 2
08** (0 5*2
4

$+4(& &'/@*% & (*.5', &..0+'(, E+*/(,
.&2
'?
0'

5* 7 42
08** %*/40':*: <8 (*2 ,
2 '?

$+4(& (5&( , 0%:*% (0 3 ': (5* &'/@*% (0 $+4(&L/ E+*/(, (5* 7 42
'
,
0'
08** @0+2
:
.0'/+2 &..0+'(, ?+, , +/,
(
'?
:*2 '*/
'?
#@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/* &':;
0
0%
/&8, = 5&(L/ 0H
'?
450'*

#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 , +:, (5*
,
/ '.2 '?
#%09
*.(/L P 5, #&4*%/ $+4(& %*/40':*: <8
(*

.&' :0 (5&( 7 8/*2 > 0% @0%:/ (0 /, , &% *3 *.( &': 5+'? +4 (5*
3
7 2
3

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page17 of 34

( (5* (, * 03 $+4(&L/ I
7
&'+&%8

.0')*%/&(, @, (5* 7 42
0' (5
08**

$+4(& @&/ &@&%* (5&( <0(5 (5* 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 &': (5* P 5, #&4*%/ @*%*
,
/
(*
4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, %*/0+%.*/ <*2
,
&2
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/ (5&(

.&%*3 2 %*/(%,
+2 8
.(*: &..*//*/ (0 (5*/* /0+%.*/ (0 5,
?562
*)*2

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ *7 42
08**/ &':

(5&( $+4(& @&/ '0 2
0'?*% &+(50%,
C*: (0 &..*// (5*/* /0+%.*/
+</*E+*'(2 $+4(& &?&, .&2 *: (5* 7 42
8
' 2
08** &': , 0%7 *: 5, (5&(
'3
7
$+4(& 5&: <**' &<2 (0 %*/*&%.5 (5* &'/@*% (0 5, E+*/(,
*
/
0'
7 42
08** , 0%7 *:
'3

' (5* :&8 3 2 '? (5*
02 0@,

#%09
*.(/ &<0+( 5, .0%%*/40':*'.* @, $+4(& &':
/
(5

#%09
*.(/ &..0%:, 8 .5&'?*: (5* 2 ' 4&//@0%: 3 (5* #@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/*
'?2
0?,
0%
0
!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 /,
'3
0'
,
'.* 2
*&),
'?
450'* .&2 / (0 &( 2
2
*&/( (@0 03

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& 5&/ 7 &:*

#%09
*.(/L .+%%*'( .2 *'(/ .2 7 , (5&(
,
&, '?

+'&<2 &:*E+&(*2 (0 4*%3
*
8
0%7 (5* /*%), 3 @5, (50/* .2 *'(/ 5,
.*/ 0%
.5
,
%*:
7 &H, (5*/* .&2 / $+4(& ,
'?
2
'(*':*: (0 4*%/+&:*
@0%H, @,
'? (5

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/L 40(*'(, .2 *'(/ .2 7 , (5&(
&2 ,
&, '?

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& 5&/ .&2 *:
2

#%09
*.(/ , +'&<2 (0 &:*E+&(*2
/
*
8

4*%3
0%7 (5* /*%), 3 @5, (50/* .2 *'(/ @*%* 0' (5* )*%?* 03 5, '?
.*/ 0%
.5
,
%,
7 &H, (5*/* .&2 / $+4(& ,
'?
2
'(*':*: (0 :,
//+&:*

.0'(%&.( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/ '

#%09
*.(/L 40(*'(, .2 *'(/ 3
&2 ,
%07

(2
*&/( 0'* 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'( 0' (5* )*%?* 03 /, '? &
)* ,
?',

#%09
*.(/ :*.2 '*: (0 /, (5* .0'(%&.( &/ & %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/
,
?'
(

:,
/4&%&?, /(&(*7 *'(/
'?
!

+

, -# * * * # & 0
.
/$$
- ;

=

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

'

5* 7 0/( %*.*'( 03 (5*/* .&2 / 0..+%%*: , 0% &%0+': I 8
2
'
+2

!40' , 0%7 &(, &': <*2 *3 /,
'3
0'
,
'.* 2
*&),
'?

#%09
*.(/L /*%),
.*/

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/L .+%%*'( .2 *'(/ (0 .*&/*
,

&': %*/+2 , (5* .2 *'(L/ (*%7 , '? , %*2 0'/5, @,
(*: '
,
'&(, (/ &(,
4 (5

+/,
'?

#%09
*.(/ ,
/

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page18 of 34

2 03
2

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%/ , +:, $+4(&L/ 107 4+(*% &%*
'.2 '?

4%0(*.(*: .07 4+(*%/ ,
')02
)*: , ,
' '(*%/(&(* .07 7 *%.* &': .07 7 +', 0' @, ' (5*
.&(,
(5,
7 *&', 03 (5* 107 4+(*% -%&+: &':
'?

<+/*

.(

!

1 A

$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: (5* 107 4+(*% -%&+: &':
02
A

&

<+/*

.(

!

1

1 <8 ,
'(*'(,
0'&2 8 &': @,
2
(50+( &+(50%, 0' &..*//, 0'* 0% 7 0%*
C&(,
'?

4%0(*.(*: .07 4+(*%/ <*2
0'?, (0
'?

#%09
*.(/ &': <8 0<(&, '? ,
', '30%7 &(, 3
0' %07 /+.5

4%0(*.(*: .07 4+(*%/
$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: (5* 107 4+(*% -%&+: &':
02
A

&

<8 H'0@, 8 &': @, ,
'?2
(5 '(*'( (0 :*3
%&+:

7 0%* 4%0(*.(*: .07 4+(*%/ <*2
0'?, (0
'?

<+/*

.(

!

1

#%09
*.(/ &..*//, 0'* 0%
'?

#%09
*.(/ @,
(50+( &+(50%, 0' &': <8
C&(,

7 *&'/ 03 /+.5 .0':+.( 3
+%(5*%, (5* ,
'?
'(*':*: 3
%&+: &': 0<(&, '? 0'* 0% 7 0%* (5,
',
'?/
03 )&2 , +:, <+( '0( 2 7 , (0
+* '.2 '?
, (*:

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(,
,
&2

0% 4%04%,
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?
8 %*&/0' 03 (5*/* ), &(,
02 0'/
G

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ /+33
*%*: 2
0//*/ *D.**:,
'?

@, ' (5* 8*&% 4%*.*:, (5* 3, , 03 (5, .07 42 '( , +:, @,
(5,
'?
2 '?
/
&, '.2 '?
(50+(

2 7 , 0' (5* .0/( 03 %*/40':, (0 (5* +'&+(50%,
, (&(,
'?
C*: &..*// .0':+.(, & :&7 &?*
'?
&//*//7 *'( &': /&3
*?+&%:, &?&, 3
'?
'/( +%(5*% ), &(,
02 0'/ &': +'&+(50%,
C*: &..*// <8
$+4(&
!

+
-

*
)
- ;

=

,
,
/$0
31
0

,

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: 1&2 3
02
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

.

<8 H'0@, 8
'?2

3
%&+:+2 8 &': @,
*'(2
(50+( 4*%7 , 0' &..*//, &': +/,
//,
'?
'?

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%/

.07 4+(*% '*(@0%H &': :&(& , 0%:*% (0 @%0'?3 2 0<(&,
'
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/L 4%04*%(8 &':

:&(&

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page19 of 34

$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: 1&2 3
02
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

.

<8 H'0@, 8 &':
'?2

3
%&+:+2 8 &': @,
*'(2
(50+( 4*%7 , 0' &..*//, (&H, .048, &': 7 &H, +/* 03
//,
'?
'?
'?
'?
4%0?%&7 / :&(& &': 3 2 3
, */ %07

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%/ &': .07 4+(*% '*(@0%H

$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: 1&2 3
02
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

.

3
%&+:+2 8 &': @,
*'(2
(50+( 4*%7 , 0' &..*//, &': +/,
//,
'?
'?

<8 H'0@, 8
'?2
#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%

/*%),
.*/
$+4(& 5&/ ), &(*: 1&2 3
02
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&
3
%&+:+2 8 &': @,
*'(2
(50+( 4*%7 , 0' &..*//,
//,
'?

.

<8 H'0@, 8
'?2

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%/ &': .07 4+(*%

'*(@0%H
#%09
*.(/ , , 0%7 *: &': <*2 *)*/ (5&( (5* &3
/ '3
,
0%*7 *'(,
0'*: &.(/ 03
$+4(& @*%* @, 2 +2 7 &2 .,
23
, 0+/ &': 3
%&+:+2 , (5&( $+4(&L/ &.(/ :*/.%,
*'( '
<*: &<0)* @*%*
4*%4*(%&(*: +':*% 3 /* 4%*(*'/*/ @, (5* :*2 <*%&(* ,
&2
(5
,
'(*'( (0 , +%*
'9
<+/,
'*//

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/ , (5*%*3 *'(, *: (0 *D*7 42 :&7 &?*/ 4+%/+&'( (0
/
0%*
(2
&%8

1&2 3
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

*

/ & :,
%*.( &': 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ +'2 +2.0':+.( @, ' (5*
7
(
&@3
(5,
7 *&', 03 1&2 3
'?
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

$+4(& 5&/ .&+/*: :&7 &?* (0

#%09
*.(/ , &'
'

&7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7
#%09
*.(/ , &2 *'(, *: (0 %*.0)*% , %*&/0'&<2 &((0%'*8/L 3 4+%/+&'( (0
/ /0
(2
(/
*
**/
1&2 3
, 0%', #*'&210:* A
&

*
2
- ;

=

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 0@'/ &': 04*%&(*/ )&2
+&<2 .5&((*2 , +:,
*
/ '.2 '?
.07 4+(*%/ &': (5*

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*% '*(@0%H (5* F #

$+4(& .07 7 ,
((*: (%*/4&// (0
&..*//, &'
'?

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/L .5&((*2 <8 ,
/
'(*'(,
0'&2 8
2

#%09
*.(/ 107 4+(*% &': (5* F #

&': ), '? &': :0@'2
*@,
0&:,
'?

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page20 of 34

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, 3 5,
,
&2 '3
0' 0% /
0@' +/* &':;
0% 1 L/ +/* &': @,
(50+(

#%09
*.(/L &+(50%, 0'
C&(,

8 $+4(&L/ @, 2 &': +'&+(50%,
2 3+2
C*: .0':+.( :*/.%,
<*: &<0)* $+4(&
,
'(*':*: (0 ,
'(*%3 @,
*%* (5

#%09
*.(/L +/* 03 , .07 4+(*%/ &': , F #
(/
(/

@*%* (5* :,
%*.( &': 4%0D, &(* .&+/* 03 /+.5 ,
7
'(*%3
*%*'.* @,
(5

&': (5*/* &.(/

#%09
*.(/L .07 4+(*%/

&': (5* F #
/ & :,
%*.( %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ @, 2 (%*/4&//
(
2 3+2

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**'

:&7 &?*: , &' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'
'*: &( (%,
&2
5

, +
2
- ;

,
(0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ & )&2 : &': *D, '? 7 42
,
/(,
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

?%**7 *'(

@, 1
(5
!':*% (5* (*%7 / 03 (5* 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,
3
0%

?%**7 *'( , *D.5&'?*
'

#%09
*.(/L &?%**7 *'( '0( (0 *'3
0%.* (5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( &': (0 3 2 (&(* & /7 00(5 *7 42
&., ,
087 *'( (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1 L/
(,
*7 42
087 *'(

1

&?%**: (0 4&8

&''+&2<&/* .07 4*'/&(, &(
0'
@0+2 .0'(,
:
'+* (0 *'?&?*
3 &( 2
0%
*&/( (5* 3 /.&28*&%
,

#%09
*.(/ & 3 , (5* &7 0+'( 03
** '
#%09
*.(/ &/ %*E+, <8 (5*
%*:

&/(*%

K 03 $+4(&L/
?%**7 *'( &':

#%09
*.(/ 3 &2 (*.5', &..0+'(, 4%09
0% 2
.&2
'?
*.(/ &/ %*E+,
%*:
&':

&/ @*2 &/ 3 3
2
0% +(+%* 4%09
*.(/ ' &::, 0'
(,

1

&?%**: (5&( $+4(& @0+2 '0( <* 5, (0 4*%3
:
%*:
0%7 =,
'650+/*> (5* *D&.( /&7 * /*%), 3
.*/ 0%
@5,
.5 1

5&: .0'(%&.(*: @,
(5

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ %*3 '*: 3
%&,
%07 &//*%(, .02
'?
0%&<2 2
* *?&2.2 7 / &?&,
&,
'/( 1
3 2 (&(*: & /7 00(5 (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& 3
&., ,
(,
%07

#%09
*.(/ (0 1

4*%3
0%7 *: &2 03 , 0<2 ?&(,
2 (/
, 0'/ +':*% (5* 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

&': 0(5*%@,
/*
?%**7 *'( 0(5*%

(5&' (50/* 0<2 ?&(,
, 0'/ @50/* 4*%3
0%7 &'.* , *D.+/*: <8 ),
/
%(+* 03 1 L/ <%*&.5 (5*%*03

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page21 of 34

' :,
%*.( ), &(, 03 , .0'(%&.(+&20<2 ?&(,
02 0'
(/
, 0'/
4&87 *'( (0

3 2 (0 7 &H* &'8
&, *:

#%09
*.(/ , *D.5&'?* 3 (5* 5, '? 03 $+4(& &': (*%7 ,
'
0%
%,
'&(*: ,
(/

<+/,
'*// %*2 0'/5, @,
&(,
4/ (5

#%09
*.(/ ' &::, 0'
(,

/&7 * /*%), &/ &' *7 42
.*/
08** 03 1
03

1

1

5, $+4(& (0 4*%3
%*:
0%7 (5*

(5&( $+4(& 5&: <**' 4*%3
0%7 , &/ &' *7 42
'?
08**

#%09
*.(/ , <%*&.5 03 (5* (*%7 / 03 (5* 7 42
'
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,
/ & :,
%*.( %*/+2 03 1 L/ <%*&.5
(

?%**7 *'(

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' , +%*: , &'
'9
'

&7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7
)

6
- ;

(0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5
1

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

%*4%*/*'(*: (0

#%09
*.(/ (5&( , *D.5&'?* 3
'
0%

&?%**7 *'( '0( (0 *'3
0%.* (5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*

&/(*%

#%09
*.(/L
?%**7 *'( &': (0

3 2 (&(* & /7 00(5 *7 42
&., ,
087 *'( (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1 L/ *7 42
(,
087 *'(

1

4&8

#%09
*.(/ & 3 03
**

&/ %*E+,
%*:

<8 (5*

&/(*%

K 03 $+4(&L/ &''+&2<&/* .07 4*'/&(, &( 1
0'

?%**7 *'( &': @0+2 .0'(,
:
'+* (0 *'?&?*

#%09
*.(/ 3 &2 (*.5',
0% 2
.&2

&..0+'(, 4%09
'?
*.(/ &/ %*E+, 3 &( 2
%*: 0%
*&/( (5* 3 /.&28*&%
,
3
+(+%* 4%09
*.(/ ' &::, 0'
(,

1

&':

&/ @*2 &/ 3
2
0%

%*4%*/*'(*: (5&( $+4(& @0+2 '0( <* 5, (0 4*%3
:
%*:
0%7

=,
'650+/*> (5* /&7 * /*%), 3 @5,
.*/ 0%
.5 1
1

@0+2
:

5&: .0'(%&.(*: @,
(5

@0+2 /(, 2'**: /+</(&'(, &//,
: 2
&2
/(&'.* 3%07

#%09
*.(/ &': (5&(

#%09
*.(/ 3 (*.5', &..0+'(,
0%
.&2
'?

@0%H
8 7 &H, (5* &<0)* %*4%*/*'(&(,
'?
0'/

1

,
'(*':*: (5&(

@0+2 %*2 (5*%*0' &': &2 0@ $+4(& .0'(,
: 8
2
'+*: &..*// (0

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/

&': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(,
&2 '3
0'
' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ %*4%*/*'(&(,
* ,
0'/

#%09
*.(/ .0'(,
'+*:

(0 &2 0@ $+4(& &..*// (0 , %&:* *.%*(/ .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
2
(/
,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*//
, 0%7 &(, F #
'3
0'

&': 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 , +:, (5* #@1 107 4*%, :&(&<&/*
,
/ '.2 '?
0

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page22 of 34

' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ %*4%*/*'(&(,
* ,
0'/

#%09
*.(/ :, '0( (&H*
:

&::, 0'&2/*.+%, 4%*.&+(,
(,
(8
0'/ @, %*/4*.( (0 $+4(&L/ &..*// (0 &': +/* 03 .0'3,
(5
:*'(,
&2
#%09
*.(/L , 0%7 &(, :, '0( (*%7 ,
'3
0' :
'&(* $+4(&L/ F #
.5&'?* (5* 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0
0?, '3
0'

&..*// &': :, '0( .5&'?*
:

#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002
,
/

#%09
*.(/

@0+2 5&)* (&H*' (5*/* &::, 0'&2/*.+%, 4%*.&+(,
:
(,
(8
0'/ 5&: , '0( %*2 *: 0' (5*
(
,
%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ 7 &:* <8 1

%*?&%:, $+4(&L/ *7 42
'?
087 *'( (%&'/, 0'
(,

' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ %*4%*/*'(&(,
* ,
0'/

#%09
*.(/ :, '0(
:

%*&2 0.&(* *7 42
2
08**/ &': %*/0+%.*/ :*/,
?'&(*: (0 /*%), 1 L/ .2 *'( &..0+'( @5,
.*
,
.5
#%09
*.(/ @0+2 5&)* :0'* &</*'( , %*&/0'&<2 %*2 &'.*
:
(/
* ,
#%09
*.(/L %*2 &'.* 0' 1 L/ %*4%*/*'(&(,
,
0'/ @&/ (0
:*(%, *'( ?,
7
)*' (5&(

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/L 3 2 (0 (&H* &::, 0'&2/*.+%, 4%*.&+(,
&, +%*
(,
(8
0'/ @,
(5

%*/4*.( (0 $+4(& 0% (0 @&%' , *7 42
(/
08**/ (0 2 7 , $+4(&L/ &..*// (0
, (

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, *'&<2 $+4(& (0 &..*// (5&(
,
&2 '3
0'
*:
, 0%7 &(, @,
'3
0'
(50+( &+(50%, 0' &': +/* , (0 (5* :*(%, *'( 03
C&(,
(
7
/ & :,
%*.( %*/+2 03 1 L/ %*4%*/*'(&(,
(
0'/

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' , +%*:
'9

, &' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7
D
8
- ;

,
2
(0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5
1

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

%*4%*/*'(*: (0

#%09
*.(/ (5&( , *D.5&'?* 3
'
0%

&?%**7 *'( '0( (0 *'3
0%.* (5* '0'6/02 ., 0' .2
, (&(,
&+/* 03 (5*

&/(*%

3 2 (&(* & /7 00(5 *7 42
&., ,
087 *'( (%&'/, 0' 03 $+4(& (0 1
(,

1

#%09
*.(/ & 3 03
**
%*E+, <8 (5*
%*:

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( &': (0
@0+2 4&8
:

K 03 $+4(&L/ &''+&2<&/* .07 4*'/&(, &(
0'
?%**7 *'( &': @0+2 .0'(,
:
'+* (0 *'?&?*

(*.5', &..0+'(, 4%09
.&2
'?
*.(/ &/ %*E+, 3 &( 2
%*: 0%
*&/( (5* 3 /.&28*&%
,
@*2 &/ 3 3
2
0% +(+%* 4%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/ &/
#%09
*.(/ 3 &2
0% 2
&':

&/

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page23 of 34

' &..0%:&'.* @, (5* &<0)* +':*%/(&':, $+4(& 2 ( 5, *7 42
(5
'?
*3 /
087 *'(
@,
(5

#%09
*.(/ &': <*.&7 * &' *7 42
08** 03 1

&': 1

<*'*3 ((*: <8 (5,
,
/

(%&'/, 0'
(,
*/4, $+4(&L/ *7 42
(*
087 *'( (%&'/, 0'
(,
4&87 *'( (0
@,
(5

#%09
*.(/ &/ 4%07 ,
/*: '0% :, 1
:

'*)*% 7 &:* (5*

K

.0'(,
'+* , <+/,
(/
'*// %*2 0'/5,
&(,
4

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& .0'(,
'+*/ (0 @0%H 3
0% 1

*D4*'/* 03

1

(0 1 L/ <*'*3 ( &': &( (5*
,

#%09
*.(/
1

5&/ 7 ,
/&44%04%,
&(*:

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*%

4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(, &': , .+%%*'(2 +/, (50/*
'3
0'
/
8
'?
7 &(*%, / (0 , <*'*3, @,
&2
(/
(
(50+( 4%0), '?
:,

#%09
*.(/ @, &'8 .07 4*'/&(,
(5
0'

/ & :,
%*.( %*/+2 03 1 L/ 3 2 (0 .07 4*'/&(*
(
&, +%*

#%09
*.(/ 3 *,
0% (5*%

#%09
*.(/L 2 03 $+4(& &/ &' *7 42
0//
08** 0% 3
0% 1 L/ +/* 03
*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
+'9 8 *'%,
+/(2
.5*: &':

#%09
*.(/L %&:*
1

5&/ <**'

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' , +%*: , &' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'9
'
'*: &(

(%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7
!
5 , +
2
- ;
=

,
0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 5&: )&2 : &': *D, '? .0'(%&.(/ @, $+4(& , +:, (5*
,
/(,
(5
'.2 '?
7 42
087 *'(

?%**7 *'( &': (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8
5* 10'3,
:*'(, ,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'(

?%**7 *'( 0<2 ?&(*: $+4(& =&( &2 (, */ :+%, (5*
,
2 7
'?

(*%7 03 *7 42
087 *'( &': (5*%*&3 (0 502 , /(%, .0'3,
(*%
: '
.(
:*'.* &': '0( (0 +/* *D.*4(
3 (5* <*'*3 ( 03 M
0%
,

#%09
*.(/N 0% (0 :, 0/* (0 &'8 4*%/0' 3 %7 0% .0%40%&(,
/.2
,
0'

@,
(50+( 4%, @%,
0%
((*' &+(50%, 0' 03 M
C&(,
M

#%09
*.(/N >

#%09
*.(/N (5* 10'3 :*'(, '3
,
&2 0%7 &(, 03
0'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page24 of 34

5* 10'3,
:*'(, ,
&2 (8
=&'8 M

?%**7 *'( :*3 '*: =10'3,
,
:*'(, '3
&2 0%7 &(,
0'> &/

#%09
*.(/N 4%04%,
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, (*.5', :&(& (%&:* /*.%*(/ 0% H'0@6
'3
0'
.&2

50@J:, 0/*: (0 M
/.2
$+4(&N <8 M

#%09
*.(/N *,
(5*% :,
%*.(2 0% , %*.(2 , @%, '?
8
':,
8 '
(,

0%&2 8 0% <8 :%&@,
2
'?/ 0% 0</*%)&(, >
0'
#%09
*.(/ 5&/ 4*%3
0%7 *: &2 03 , 0<2 ?&(,
2 (/
, 0'/ +':*% (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8
?%**7 *'( 0(5*% (5&' (50/* 0<2 ?&(,
, 0'/ @50/* 4*%3
0%7 &'.* , *D.+/*: <8 $+4(&L/
/
<%*&.5 03 (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'(

' :,
%*.( ), &(, 03 (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
02 0'
,
&2 (8
+'&+(50%,
C*: :, 0/+%*/ 03
/.2

?%**7 *'( $+4(& 7 &:*

#%09
*.(/L P 5, #&4*%/ /(%&(*?, 4%, '? , 0%7 &(,
(*
*/
., '3
0'

.+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/ .+/(07 *% , 0%7 &(, , +:, @0%H 4&4*%/
)*
,
'3
0' '.2 '?
&': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ <*2
0'?, (0 (5* .2 *'( 4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
'?
,
?'/ &': 0(5*%
.0'3,
:*'(, 0% 4%04%,
&2
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?
:, 0/+%*/ @*%* 7 &:* (0 1
/.2

#%09
*.(/

5*/*

, (5* .0+%/* 03 $+4(&L/ *7 42
'
087 *'( @, 1
(5

&': 3
0%

(5* <*'*3 ( 03 5, /*2 &': 1
,
7
3
' &::, 0' $+4(& &/ &' *7 42
(,
08** 03 1

7 &:* +'&+(50%,
C*: +/* 03

#%09
*.(/L .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0 &..*//
0?, '3
0'
#%09
*.(/L 2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002 , 0% &%0+': I
,
/ '
&'+&%8
$+4(& 5&/ +/*: &': .0'(,
'+*/ (0 +/*

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?
:*(%, *'( 03
7

#%09
*.(/ (0 (5*

#%09
*.(/
#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' ,
%%*4&%&<2 5&%7 *: <8 $+4(&L/ +'&+(50%,
8
C*:

:, 0/+%* &': +/* 03
/.2

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, 0% 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8

, 0%7 &(, <*2
'3
0'
0'?, (0
'?
10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

#%09
*.(/ , 4&%(*: (0 $+4(& /(%, 8 4+%/+&'( (0 (5*
7
.(2

?%**7 *'(
#%09
*.(/ , *'(, *: (0 %*.0)*% (5* :&7 &?*/ , 5&/ /+/(&,
/
(2
(
'*: &': @, 2
2

.0'(,
'+* (0 /+/(&, &/ & %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ <%*&.5 03 (5* 10'3 :*'(, ,
'
(
,
&2 (8
&7 0+'( 03

?%**7 *'(

#%09
*.(/L 7 0'*(&%8 :&7 &?*/ &%* (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, <+( &%*
&2

<*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
,
/ 7

5*

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page25 of 34

=
(
-

+
+
- ;

,
/& 1
47
(0

=

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 0@'/ )&2
+&<2 %&:* *.%*(/ , +:, P 5, #&4*%/
*
'.2 '?
(*
/(%&(*?, 4%, '? , 0%7 &(, .+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .+/(07 *% 2 /(/ .+/(07 *%
*/
., '3
0'
)*
,
, 0%7 &(, , +:, @0%H 4&4*%/ &': 0(5*% :0.+7 *'(/ %*2 '? (0 /4*., . .2 *'(/
'3
0' '.2 '?
&(,
3, ,
4%0:+.(/ &': :*/,
?'/

#%09
*.(/ &2 40//*//*/ 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
/0
,
&2
*(&%8

<+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, , +:, 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 ' , 0%7 &(, (0 (5* F #
'3
0' '.2 '?
0?, '3
0'

&':

2 .*'/*: %*/*&%.5 (002
,
/
#%09
*.(/ :, 0/*: , %&:* *.%*(/ 4&//@0%:/ 2 ' , 0%7 &(,
/.2
(/
0?, '3
0'
&': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(, (0 $+4(& :+%, 5, *7 42
&2 '3
0'
'? /
087 *'( &(
#%09
*.(/ &': 4+%/+&'( (0 (5* 7 42
087 *'(

?%**7 *'( &': 10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'( @, (5* *D4%*// +':*%/(&':, (5&( &2 /+.5 , 0%7 &(, (0 <* 7 &, '*:
(5
'?
2
'3
0'
'(&,
, (5* /(%,
'
.(*/( .0'3,
:*'.* <8 $+4(& :+%, 5, *7 42
'? /
087 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/ &':

(5*%*&3
(*%
$+4(& +':*%/(00: (5&(

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ 4&//@0%:/ 2 '
0?,

, 0%7 &(, &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
'3
0'
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, @*%* (0 <* +/*: 0'2
,
&2 '3
0'
8
3
0%

#%09
*.(/L <*'*3 ( &': 0'2 :+%, 5, *7 42
,
8
'? /
087 *'( @,
(5

(*%7 ,
'&(*: ,
'

#%09
*.(/ @5,
.5

*.*7 <*%
3 <*?, '? '*?0(, 0'/ @, 1
(*%
'',
&(,
(5

&':

#%09
*.(/ &': @,
(50+( &'8 <+/,
'*// 9 3, 0' ,
+/(, .&(,
'

#%09
*.(/ &<0+( 2
*&),
'?

0)*7 <*% &':

*.*7 <*%

$+4(& .04,
*: %&:* *.%*( :0.+7 *'(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(,
&2
, 0%7 &(, S , +:, P 5, #&4*%/ S (0 5, 107 4+(*% $+4(&L/ /02 7 0(, 0' (0
'3
0' '.2 '?
(*
/
*
)&(,
7 &H* (5*/* .04, @&/ (0 3 2 (&(* 5, (5*3 03
*/
&., ,
/
(
.0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(,
&2 '3
0'

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*%

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page26 of 34

-02 0@, 5, (*%7 , 0' @,
2 '? /
'&(,
(5

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& *'(*%*:

#%09
*.(/L

0+'(&, F , 03 .* ?&,
' *@ 3,
'*: &..*// (0 (5* 107 4+(*% &': 4&//@0%:/ &': 2 '
0?,
, 0%7 &(, (0 (5* F #
'3
0'

+':*% 3 /* 4%*(*'/*/ &': +/*: (5, , 0%7 &(, (0 /*':
&2
/ '3
0'

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, 3
,
&2 '3
0' %07 5,
/
#%09
*.(/

+(2
00H &::%*// (0 5, 4*%/0'&2*7 &, &::%*//
/
2
1

5, $+4(& (0 4*%3
%*:
0%7 =,
'650+/*> (5* /&7 * /*%), 3 @5,
.*/ 0%
.5 1

5&: .0'(%&.(*: @,
(5
+/* 03

#%09
*.(/ H'0@, (5&( $+4(& @0+2 <* 7 &H, +'&+(50%,
'?
:
'?
C*:

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*//

, 0%7 &(, , 4%0), '? /*%), (0 1
'3
0' '
:,
.*/
$+4(& , '0@ 7 &H, +'&+(50%,
/
'?
C*: +/* 03

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, <+/,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(, 3 (5* <*'*3 ( 03 5, /*2 &':
'3
0' 0%
,
7
3
5, *7 42
/
08*%

1

(0 (5* :*(%, *'( 03
7

#%09
*.(/

$+4(& 5&/ :*2 <*%&(*2 &': @%0'?3 2 7 ,
,
8
+2 8 /&44%04%,
&(*:

#%09
*.(/L

%&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
7,
/.0':+.( <8 $+4(& 5&/ .&+/*: 5&%7 (0
1

#%09
*.(/

<8 &.(, , .0'.*%( @, $+4(& &':; H'0@, 8 *'9 '? (5*
'? '
(5
0%
'?2
08,

3 (/ 03 5, (5*3 5&/ :*2 <*%&(*2 &': @%0'?3 2 7 ,
%+,
/
(
,
8
+2 8 /&44%04%,
&(*:
*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
7,
/.0':+.( <8 1

5, @, 2 +2
/ 23

5&/ .&+/*: 5&%7 (0

#%09
*.(/L %&:*
5, @, 2 +2
/ 23

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ , *'(, *: (0 %*.0)*% (5* :&7 &?*/ , 5&/ /+/(&,
/
(2
(
'*: &': @, 2
2
.0'(,
'+* (0 /+/(&, &/ & %*/+2 03 *3
'
(
*':&'(/L 7 ,
/&44%04%, 0' 03
&(,
*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
3
+%(5*% *'(, *: (0 %*.0)*% 3
(2
%07

#%09
*.(/L %&:*
#%09
*.(/ ,
/

*3
*':&'(/ (5* ?&, 4%03 (/ &': &:)&'(&?*/
'/
,

*3
*':&'(/ 5&)* 0<(&,
'*: &/ & %*/+2 03 /&, (%&:* /*.%*( 7 ,
(
:
/&44%04%, 0'
&(,

5* &7 0+'(

03 /+.5 :&7 &?*/ /5&2 <* :*(*%7 ,
2
'*: &( (%, <+( &%* <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**:
&2
,
/ 7
G

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page27 of 34

*3
*':&'(/L .0':+.( .0'/(,
(+(*/ @, 2 +2&': 7 &2 .,
23
, 0+/ 7 ,
/&44%04%, 0'
&(,
4+%/+&'( (0 1&2 3
, 0%', 1, 210:* AA
& ),

. &':

@&%%&'(, (5* &@&%: 03
'?

*D*7 42 :&7 &?*/ &': &((0%'*8/L 3 &': .0/(/
&%8
**/
#%09
*.(/ @, 2.0'(,
2
'+* (0 /+3 *% ,
3 %%*4&%&<2 5&%7 , *3
*
3
*':&'(/L
+'2
&@3+27 ,
/&44%04%, 0' 03
&(,

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &':

.0'3,
:*'(, <+/,
&2
'*// , 0%7 &(, , 4*%7 ,
'3
0' /
((*: (0 .0'(,
'+*
*'(, *: (0 , +'.(, %*2 *3 %*/(%&, '?
(2
'9
)* ,
',

5*%*3
0%*

#%09
*.(/ ,
/

*3
*':&'(/ &': &2 4*%/0'/ &.(, , .0'.*%(
2
'? '

(5*%*@, 3
(5 %07 (5* +'&+(50%,
C*: +/* &': :, 0/+%* 03
/.2

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(,
&2 '3
0'
#%09
*.(/ , *'(, *: (0 & 7 &':&(0%8 , +'.(, %*E+, '?
/
(2
'9
0'
%,

*3
*':&'(/ (0

%*(+%' (5* /(02
*' %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, <+/,
,
&2
'*//
, 0%7 &(,
'3
0'
+
- ;

, 9 2
=
0

,

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ & )&2 : &': *D, '?
,
/(,

&/(*%

@*2 &/ & )&2 : &': *D, '? 7 42
2
,
/(,
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,
$+4(& <*.&7 * &@&%* 03 (5*
%&'/, 0'
(,

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( @, 1
(5

?%**7 *'( @, 1
(5

?%**7 *'( &': 7 42
087 *'(

?%**7 *'( :+%, (5* .0+%/* 03 5, *7 42
'?
/
087 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ %*&/0'&<2 *D4*.(*: (0 <*'*3 ( 3,
8
, '&'., 2 3
&2 8 %07 (5*
?%**7 *'( &': 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

&/(*%

?%**7 *'(

$+4(& @%0'?3 2 &': @, 2 +2 8 ,
+2 8
2 3 2 '(*%3
*%*: @, (5*
(5
&': 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

&/

?%**7 *'( <8

(&H,
'?

&/(*%

?%**7 *'(

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/

&': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(, &': +/, (5*/* 7 &(*%, / (0
&2 '3
0'
'?
&2
4*%3
0%7 /*%), =,
.*/ '650+/*> 3
0% 1
4*%3
0%7 (5* ,
:*'(, /*%), 3
.&2
.*/ 0% 1

H'0@, (5&(
'?

#%09
*.(/ 5&: .0'(%&.(*: (0

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page28 of 34

$+4(&L/ @%0'?3 ,
+2 '(*%3
*%*'.* @, (5*
(5
7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,
5, '? $+4(&
%,
(5*

&/(*%

1

?%**7 *'( 5&/ .&+/*: 1

5&/ '0( .0'(,
'+*: (0 +/*

?%**7 *'( &':

(0 <%*&.5 (50/* .0'(%&.(/

,
'.*

#%09
*.(/ /*%),
.*/ &/ 4%0),
:*: 3 ,
0% '

?%**7 *'( &': 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

4%07 ,
/*: (0

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( &': &/ 1

%*4*&(*:2
8

#%09
*.(/
#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' :&7 &?*: <8 ),
%(+* 03 $+4(&L/ @%0'?3
+2

,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @, (5*
(5

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( &': 7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

?%**7 *'(

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ )&2 : &': *D, '? /*%), &?%**7 *'(/ = *%),
,
/(,
.*
.*
?%**7 *'(/> @, 0(5*%
(5

#%09
*.(/ .2 *'(/
,

$+4(& <*.&7 * &@&%* 03 (5* *%),
.*
*7 42
087 *'( @,
(5

?%**7 *'(/ :+%, (5* .0+%/* 03 5,
'?
/

#%09
*.(/
#%09
*.(/ %*&/0'&<2 *D4*.(*: (0 <*'*3 ( 3,
8
, '&'., 2 3
&2 8 %07 (5* *%),
.*

?%**7 *'(/
$+4(& @%0'?3 2 &': @, 2 +2 8 ,
+2 8
2 3 2 '(*%3
*%*: @, (5* *%),
(5
.*
.&2 ,
2 '?
(5&(

#%09
*.(/L .2 *'(/ @50 &%* 4&%(, (0 (50/* *%),
,
*/
.*

?%**7 *'(/ &': .2 7 ,
&, '?

#%09
*.(/ , +'&<2 (0 &:*E+&(*2 4*%3
/
*
8
0%7 (5* /*%), 3 @5, (50/* .2 *'(/
.*/ 0%
.5
,

5,
%*:

#%09
*.(/

5* 7 0/( %*.*'( 03 (5*/* .&2 / 0..+%%*: 0' 0% &%0+': I 8
2
+2

$+4(&L/ (*2
*450'* .&2 / (0
2
(0 :,
/%+4(
(0@&%:/

?%**7 *'(/ <8

#%09
*.(/L *%),
.*

#%09
*.(/L .2 *'(/ @*%* 7 &:* @, (5* ,
,
(5
'(*'(

?%**7 *'(/ @,
(5

#%09
*.(/L .2 *'(/ @, 7 &2 .*
,
(5
,

#%09
*.(/ &': @,
(50+( &'8 <+/,
'*// 9 3, 0'
+/(, .&(,
$+4(&L/ @%0'?3 ,
+2 '(*%3
*%*'.* @, (5* *%),
(5
.*

2
*&/( 0'* .+%%*'(

?%**7 *'(/ 5&/ .&+/*: &(

#%09
*.(/ .2 *'( (0 (*%7 ,
,
'&(* , %*2 0'/5, @,
(/ &(,
4 (5

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' :&7 &?*: <8 ),
%(+* 03 $+4(&L/ @%0'?3
+2
,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @, (5* *%),
(5
.*

?%**7 *'(/

#%09
*.(/ , *'(, *: (0 %*.0)*% (5* :&7 &?*/ , 5&/ /+/(&,
/
(2
(
'*: &': @, 2
2
.0'(,
'+* (0 /+/(&, &/ & %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ ,
'
(
'(*%3
*%*'.* @, (5*
(5
7 42
087 *'( %&'/, 0'
(,

?%**7 *'( &': *%),
.*

?%**7 *'(/

&/(*%

?%**7 *'(

5* &7 0+'( 03 /+.5

:&7 &?*/ /5&2 <* :*(*%7 ,
2
'*: &( (%, <+( &%* <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page29 of 34

+

, 9 2)
- ;

,
=

,

,

;

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ & )&2 : &': *D, '?
,
/(,
4+%/+&'( (0 @5,
.5

&/(*%

?%**7 *'( @, 1
(5

::*':+7 / @0+2 3 2 3 *&.5 %*/4*.(, #%09 (5&(
: 02 0@ 0%
)*
*.(

#%09
*.(/ @&/ (0 4*%3
0%7 3
0% 1

#%09
*.(/ &2 .%&3 & #%040/&2(0 1
/0
(*:

,
'

&..0%:&'.* @, 3,
(5 '&'., /4*., .&(,
&2
3, 0'/ ,
:*'(, , <8 $+4(& &': 1
3 *:
#%09
*.(/ %*&/0'&<2 *D4*.(*: (0 <*'*3 ( 3,
8
, '&'., 2 3
&2 8 %07 (5*
4%0/4*.(,
)*

::*':+7 / (5&(

#%09
*.(/ &': 1

(5* .0%%*/40':, #%09
'?
*.(/ (5&(
#%040/&2(5&(

@*%* 0' (5* )*%?* 03 /, '? 3
?',
%07

#%09
*.(/ @0+2 4*%3
:
0%7 3
0% 1

#%09
*.(/ 5&: :%&3 3
(*: 0% 1

&': @5,
.5 1

&': 3
%07 (5*

@&/ 0' (5* )*%?* 03

/, '?
?',
$+4(& @&/ &@&%* 03 (5* <+/,
'*// %*2 0'/5, <*(@**'
&(,
4
1

&': 03 (5* 4%0/4*.(,
)*

::*':+7 / &': (5* #%040/&2(5&(

#%09
*.(/ &':
#%09
*.(/ &': 1

@*%* 0' (5* )*%?* 03 /, '?
?',
$+4(& @%0'?3 2 &': @, 2 +2 8 ,
+2 8
2 3 2 '(*%3
*%*: @,
(5
::*':+7 / &': #%040/&2@, 1
(5

<8 (&H,
'?

#%09
*.(/L 4%0/4*.(,
)*

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*%

4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, &': +/, (5*/* 7 &(*%, / (0 4*%3
,
&2 '3
0'
'?
&2
0%7 /*%),
.*/
=,
'650+/*> 3
0% 1
/*%), 3
.*/ 0% 1

H'0@, (5&(
'?

#%09
*.(/ 5&: .0'(%&.(*: (0 4*%3
0%7 (5* ,
:*'(,
.&2

$+4(& &2 7 &:* 3 /* %*4%*/*'(&(,
/0
&2
0'/ (0 1

.0'.*%',
'?

#%09
*.(/L ,
'&<, , (0 4%0), 3 '&'., .0'/+2 '? &': .07 42 &'.* /*%), (0 1
2 (8
:* ,
&2
(,
,
.*/
$+4(&L/ @%0'?3 &': @, 2 +2:, 0/+%* &': +/* 03
+2
23
/.2

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, @&/ :0'* @, (5* ,
,
&2 '3
0'
(5
'(*'( (0
:,
/%+4(

#%09
*.(/L 4%0/4*.(, <+/,
)*
'*// @, 1
(5
$+4(&L/ @%0'?3 @, 2 +2&': +'&+(50%,
+2 2 3
C*: :, 0/+%* 03
/.2

#%09
*.(/L

%&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, &': $+4(&L/ 3 /*
'3
0'
&2

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page30 of 34

%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ (0 1
<*(@**'

4%0D, &(*2 .&+/*: :,
7
8
/%+4(, 03 (5* <+/,
0'
'*// %*2 0'/5,
&(,
4

#%09
*.(/ &': 1

, 5, '? $+4(&
'.* %,

1

/*%), , .0''*.(, @, &'8 '*@ #%09
.*/ '
0' (5
*.(/ &': '0 '*@
*D*.+(*: /,
'.*

+?+/(

5&/ '0( +/*:

#%09
*.(/L

::*':+7 / 5&)* <**'

-+%(5*% (5* #%040/&2@&/ %*9
*.(*: <8 1

0'

4%,
2

#%09
*.(/ %*&/0'&<2 *D4*.(*: (0 <*'*3 ( 3,
8
, '&'., 2 3
&2 8 %07 (5*
4%0/4*.(,
)* *%),
.*

?%**7 *'(/ (5&( 0(5*%

#%09
*.(/ 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'(/ @*%* 0' (5*
)* ,

)*%?* 03 /, '? &': 3%07 (5* .0%%*/40':, 4%03 0'&2/*%),
?',
'?
*//,
.*/

#%09
*.(/ @0+2
:

4*%3
0%7
$+4(& @&/ &@&%* 03 (5* <+/,
'*// %*2 0'/5, <*(@**'
&(,
4/

#%09
*.(/ &':

#%09
*.(/L 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'(/ &': 03 (5* <+/,
)* ,
'*// (5&( @&/ *D4*.(*: (0 %*/+2 3
( %07
(50/* <+/,
'*// %*2 0'/5,
&(,
4/
$+4(& @%0'?3 2 &': @, 2 +2 8 ,
+2 8
2 3 2 '(*%3
*%*: @,
(5

#%09
*.(/L 4%0/4*.(,
)*

<+/,
'*// %*2 0'/5, <8 .&2 , 40(*'(, .2 *'(/ &': .2 7 , (5&(
&(,
4/
2 '?
&2 ,
&, '?

#%09
*.(/ @&/

+'&<2 &:*E+&(*2 (0 4*%3
*
8
0%7 (5* /*%), 3 @5, (50/* .2 *'(/ @*%* 0' (5* )*%?* 03
.*/ 0%
.5
,
5, '?
%,

#%09
*.(/
$+4(&L/ (*2
*450'* .&2 / (0
2

#%09
*.(/L 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'(/ @*%* 7 &:*
)* ,

@, (5* ,
(5
'(*'( (0 :,
/%+4( 4%0/4*.(, <+/,
)*
'*// 3
0%
7 &2 .* (0@&%:/
,

#%09
*.(/ &': @*%* 7 0(,
)&(*: <8

#%09
*.(/

$+4(&L/ @%0'?3 &': @, 2 +27 ,
+2
23
/%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ (0
40(*'(, .2 *'(/ .0'.*%',
&2 ,
'?

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/L &<, , &:*E+&(*2 (0 4*%3
2 (8
8
0%7 /*%),
.*/

4%0D, &(*2 .&+/*: (5* :,
7
8
/%+4(, 03 (5* <+/,
0'
'*// %*2 0'/5, <*(@**'
&(,
4/
&': , 40(*'(, .2 *'(/
(/
&2 ,

#%09
*.(/

,
'.* $+4(& 7 &:* (50/* 7 ,
/%*4%*/*'(&(,
0'/ (5*/* 40(*'(,
&2

.2 *'(/ 5&)* :*.2 '*: (0 5,
,
,
%*

#%09
*.(/

/ & 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ (0%(,
7
(
0+/ ,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @,
(5
*D4&'/, 03 , <+/,
0'
(/
'*// %*2 0'/5, @, 1
&(,
4 (5

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' :&7 &?*: , &'
'

&7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page31 of 34

!
- ;

=

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

3 $+4(& @&/ '0 2
(*%
0'?*% &' *7 42
08** 03
,
'(*'( (0 ,
':+.*

*'0' (0 &2 0@ 5, (0 ?&, &..*// (0
2
7
'

#%09
*.(/ &': @, (5*
(5
#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, $+4(& 3 /*2 (02
'3
0'
&2 8 :

*'0' (5&( ,
'?5

5&: ?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 &..*// (5* 107 4+(*%
7
//,
*'0' %*&/0'&<2 %*2 *: 0' (5* %*4%*/*'(&(,
8 ,
0'/ 03 $+4(& &': &2 0@*:
2
$+4(& (0 (&H* (5* 107 4+(*% 507 * @, 5,
(5 7
3 $+4(& @&/ '0 2
(*%
0'?*% &' *7 42
08** 03
,
'(*'( (0 ,
':+.* &9 (0 &2 0@ 5, (0 ?&, &..*// (0
**)
2
7
'

#%09
*.(/ &': @, (5*
(5
#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% .0'3 :*'(, &': 4%04%,
,
&2
*(&%8 , 0%7 &(, 0' (5* 107 4+(*% &': (5* F #
'3
0'
.&2 *: &9
2
**) %*E+*/(*: (5* F #

$+4(&

2 ' , 0%7 &(, &': 3 /*2 (02 &9 (5&( ,
0?, '3
0'
&2 8 :
**)
'?5

5&: ?,
)*' 5, 4*%7 , 0' (0 &..*// (5* F #
7
//,
&9 %*&/0'&<2 %*2 *: 0' $+4(&L/ 3 /* %*4%*/*'(&(,
**)
8 ,
&2
0'/ &': ?&)* $+4(&
(5* F #

2 ' , 0%7 &(,
0?, '3
0'
P 5, * +/, (5*
2
'?

$+4(& *'(*%*: &': (5* F #

#%09
*.(/ .07 4+(*% &': (5* F #

&..*//*:

2 ' , 0%7 &(,
0?, '3
0'

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% .0'3 :*'(,
,
&2

0% 4%04%,
*(&%8 <+/,
'*// , 0%7 &(, &': *7 &, *: %&:* *.%*(/ (0 5, 4*%/0'&2*7 &,
'3
0'
2
/
2
&..0+'(
/ & 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ 3
7
(
%&+:

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ <**' :&7 &?*: ,
'

&' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page32 of 34

C
- ;

=

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

, 2
'.* *&),
'?

#%09
*.(/ $+4(& 5&/ 42
&.*: 450'* .&2 / (0
2

.+%%*'( &': 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'(/ /(&(, &/ 3 (5&(
)* ,
'?
&.(

#%09
*.(/L

#%09
*.(/ , +'&<2 &:*E+&(*2 (0
/
*
8

4*%3
0%7 (5* /*%), 3 @5, (50/* .2 *'(/ 5,
.*/ 0%
.5
,
%*: 0% @*%* 0' (5* )*%?* 03 5, '?
%,
#%09
*.(/ &': 0(5*%@, :,
/* /4&%&?,
'?

#%09
*.(/ &': (5* E+&2(8 03 , 4%03 0'&2
,
(/
*//,

/*%),
.*/
' 7 &H, 5, :,
'? / /4&%&?, /(&(*7 *'(/ $+4(& ,
'?
'(*':*: (0 4*%/+&:*
#%09
*.(/L .+%%*'( .2 *'(/ (0 .*&/* @0%H, @,
,
'? (5
#%09
*.(/L 40(*'(, .2 *'(/ 3
&2 ,
%07 +/,
'?

#%09
*.(/ &': (0 :,
//+&:*

#%09
*.(/L /*%),
.*/ $+4(& H'*@ (5&( <8

7 &H, (5*/* /(&(*7 *'(/ 5* @&/ 2 H*2 (0 .&+/* 5&%7 (0
'?
, 8

#%09
*.(/L <+/,
'*//

/ & :,
%*.( %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ :,
(
/4&%&?, /(&(*7 *'(/ 03 3 (0 .+%%*'( &':
'?
&.(
4%0/4*.(,
)*

#%09
*.(/ .2 *'(/ &( 2
,
*&/( 0'*

#%09
*.(/ .2 *'( 5&/ (*%7 ,
,
'&(*: ,
(/

0'?0, %*2 0'/5, @,
'? &(,
4 (5

#%09
*.(/ &': &( 2
*&/( 0'* 4%0/4*.(, .2 *'( 0' (5* )*%?*
)* ,

03 /, '? & .0'(%&.( @,
?',
(5

#%09
*.(/ :*.2 '*: (0 /, (5* .0'(%&.(
,
?'

/ & 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ :,
7
(
/4&%&?, /(&(*7 *'(/
'?

#%09
*.(/ 5&/

<**' /4*., .&2 8 :&7 &?*: , &' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
3, 2
'
'*: &( (%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5,
&2
,
/
(, * (0 *D.**: G
7
+
-

+

5

5
) ,,
<) +
- ;
=
0

/%$
#1$

0

#%09
*.(/ %*4*&(/ &': ,
'.0%40%&(*/ <8 %*3
*%*'.* *&.5 &2 *?&(, ,
2
0' '
4&%&?%&45/ (5%0+?5

&/ , /*( 3
3
0%(5 3 2 5*%*,
+2 8
'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page33 of 34

$+4(&L/ &.(,
0'/ .07 42 '*: 03 &<0)* , +:, $+4(&L/ <%*&.5 03 (5*
&,
'.2 '?
10'3 :*'(, ,
,
&2 (8

?%**7 *'( @,
(5

#%09
*.(/B $+4(&L/ 3
%&+:+2 /(&(*7 *'(/ (0
*'(

*'0'

&': &9 (0 ,
**)
':+.* (5*7 (0 &2 0@ 5, &..*// (0 (5* 107 4+(*% &': (5* F # B $+4(&L/
2
7
(5*3 03
(

#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(,
,
&2 '3
0'B

$+4(&L/ (0%(,
0+/ ,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @,
(5

#%09
*.(/L *D, '? &': 4%0/4*.(, .0'(%&.(/ @,
/(,
)*
(5

1 B $+4(&L/ (0%(,
0+/ ,
'(*%3
*%*'.* @,
(5
.0'(%&.(/ @, 0(5*%
(5

#%09
*.(/L *D, '? &': 4%0/4*.(,
/(,
)*

#%09 .2 *'(/B &': $+4(&L/ 40/(6*7 42
*.( ,
087 *'( (%&:* 2 <*2
,

.0'/(,
(+(* +'2 +2 +'3 % &': 3
&@3
&,
%&+:+2 <+/,
*'(
'*// 4%&.(, &?&,
.*/
'/(

#%09
*.(/ ,
'

), &(, 03 1&2 3
02 0'
, 0%', +/,
&
'*// " #%03 0'/ 10:* AA
*//,
$+4(&L/ &.(,
0'/ .07 42 '*: 03 &<0)* @*%* ,
&,
':*4*':*'(2 @%0'?3 ,
8
+2 '
(5&( (5*8 .0'/(,
(+(* 7 ,
/&44%04%, 0' 03 (%&:* /*.%*(/ 3
&(,
%&+: ), &(,
02 0'/ 03 (5* 3
*:*%&2
107 4+(*% -%&+: &':

<+/*

.( &': (5* 1&2 3
, 0%', 107 4+(*%
&

&(&

..*// &': -%&+:

.( &': (%&:* 2 <*2
,
/ & :,
%*.( &': 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ +'3 % &': +'2 +24%&.(,
7
(
&,
&@3
.*/
:*/.%,
<*: &<0)*

#%09
*.(/ 5&/ /+3 *%*: &': @, 2.0'(,
3
2
'+* (0 /+33 5&%7 (0 ,
*%
(/

<+/,
'*// !'2 %*/(%&,
*//
'*: &': *'9 '*: 3
0,
%07 :0, /0 $+4(& @, 2.0'(,
'?
2
'+* (0 +/*
#%09
*.(/L %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, 3 (5*
,
&2 '3
0' 0%
<*'*3, 03 5, /*2 &': 1
(
7
3

&': (0 (5* :*(%, *'( 03
7

#%09
*.(/

#%09
*.(/L %*7 *:, &( 2 &%* ,
*/
&@
'&:*E+&(* (0 .07 4*'/&(* , 3 (5*
( 0%
, +%, /+/(&,
'9 */
'*: &': (5%*&(*'*: <8 $+4(&L/ +'2
&@3+24%&.(,
.*/ &':

#%09
*.(/ /**H/

, +'.(, %*2 *3 (0 4%*)*'( 3
'9
)* ,
+%(5*% 5&%7
/ & :,
%*.( &': 4%0D, &(* %*/+2 03 $+4(&L/ +'3 % &': +'2 +2&.(, (,
7
(
&,
&@3
), */
$+4(& 5&/ <**' +'9 8 *'%,
+/(2
.5*: &':

#%09
*.(/ , *'(, *: (0 &' , +'.(,
/
(2
'9
0'

%*E+, '? $+4(& (0 %*(+%' (5* %&:* *.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(,
&2
, 0%7 &(, /(02 3
'3
0'
*' %07

#%09
*.(/ &': 4%*)*'(,
'? 1

3
%07 +/, (5&( , 0%7 &(,
'?
'3
0'

Case5:10-cv-01773-LHK Document22 Filed08/06/10 Page34 of 34

)
P

-

E

#%09
*.(/ 4%&8/ 3 9
0% +:?7 *'( &?&,
'/(

*3
*':&'(/ &/ 3 2
02 0@/

-0% &.(+&2&': .0'/*E+*'(, :&7 &?*/ , &' &7 0+'( (0 <* :*(*%7 ,
&2
'
'*: &(
(%, <+( <*2 *)*: &( (5, (, * (0 *D.**: G
&2
,
/ 7
-0% &' , +'.(, %*E+, '?
'9
0'
%,

B
*3
*':&'(/ (0 %*(+%' (5* %&:* *.%*(/ &':

0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3,
:*'(, , 0%7 &(, /(02 3
&2 '3
0'
*' %07
-0% &' , +'.(, 4%*)*'(,
'9
0'
'?

#%09
*.(/B

*3
*':&'(/ 3
%07 +/,
'?

#%09
*.(/L %&:*

*.%*(/ &': 0(5*% 4%04%,
*(&%8 &': .0'3 :*'(, , 0%7 &(, (0 .07 4*(* +'3 %2 &?&,
,
&2 '3
0'
&, 8
'/(
#%09
*.(/B
-0% *D*7 42 :&7 &?*/ 3
&%8
0%

*3
*':&'(/L 7 ,
/.0':+.( , &' &7 0+'( (0 <*
'

:*(*%7 ,
'*: &( (%, B
&2
-0% %*&/0'&<2 &((0%'*8/L 3 %*2 '? (0
*
**/ &(,

*3
*':&'(/L <&: 3 (5 (%&:*
&,

/*.%*( 7 ,
/&44%04%, 0' &': $+4(&L/ ), &(,
&(,
02 0'/ 03 (5* 1&2 3
, 0%', 107 4+(*%
&
&': -%&+:

&(&

..*//

.(B
-0% .0/(/ 03 /+, &':
(B
+.5 0(5*% &': 3
+%(5*% %*2 *3 &/ (5, 10+%( :**7 / 9
,
/
+/(

(
!':*% -*:

1, #
)

E

< #2 '(, :*7 &':/ 9
&, 33
+%8 (%, 03 &2 ,
&2
2 //+*/ %&,
/*: <8 (5*

107 42 '(
&,
&(*

+?+/(
"

#

8

&%7 **(
5, 2
2 0'
((0%'*8/ 3
0%
#%09
*.(/ '.