Apple Computer, Inc. v. Podfitness, Inc.

Filing 105

Declaration of Greg Wayment in Support of 103 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Podfitness, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19)(Related document(s) 103 ) (Magleby, James) (Filed on 2/22/2008) Modified on 2/25/2008 (jlm, COURT STAFF).

Download PDF
pple Computer, Inc. v. Podfitness, Inc. Doc. 105 Att. 12 ( A [KLELW Dockets.Justia.com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z 08%6&5,%( 0\ $2/ * \ <D K R R % R RJOH ORJOLQHV X WR V $ 7HFKQRORJ\ / L IH V W\ O H *DPLQJ (Q W H UW D L Q P H Q W )L Q D Q F H $OVR RQ $2/ $SSOH DFFXVHG RI KDUDVVLQJ GQ DLU SXULILHU FRPSDQ\ D D\V DJR &RPPHQWV 3 R ROO $UH \RX VSHQGLQJ Q QHZ L3RG WRXFK DSSV" G & D\V DJR z z R P P H Q WV U 7K H L3RG WRXFK XSJUDGH Q DOO\ IRU OHJDO UHDVRQV RU H &R" GD\V DJR z R P P H Q WV E L3RG WRXFK XVHUV LI \RX DRXJKW DIWHU -DQ WKH QHZ GSSV DUH IUHH PD\EH z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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?