Apple Computer, Inc. v. Podfitness, Inc.

Filing 105

Declaration of Greg Wayment in Support of 103 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Podfitness, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19)(Related document(s) 103 ) (Magleby, James) (Filed on 2/22/2008) Modified on 2/25/2008 (jlm, COURT STAFF).

pple Computer, Inc. v. Podfitness, Inc.

Doc. 105 Att. 16

(

A

[KLELW

Dockets.Justia.com

:HE ,PDJHV

0DSV 1HZV H

6KRSSLQJ *PDLO PRUH

0\ 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

3URGXFWV
L KRZ LWHPV RQO\ 6KRZLQJ DOO WHPV 7 KRZ JULG YLHZ 6

5HVXOWV
6RUW E\ UHOHYDQFH

RI DERXW

IRU HD6EXGV ZKLWH U SRQVRUHG /LQNV

VHFRQGV

6 F KHVH :KLWH QRLVH HDQFHOLQJ IRDP FRYHUHG F DUEXGV IHDWXUH QRLVH $DQFHOLQJ PLFURSKRQHV F XGLR GHYLFHV ,QFOXGHV DUU\LQJ FDVH DQG H[WUD $ DP HDUEXG SDGV :KLWH IR GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

F XUWOH %HDFK 1RLVH DQFHOLQJ ZKLWH 7 HDUEXGV

5 0XVLFVDQG &RPSXW
HOOHU UDWLQJV

$RVH LQ HDU KHDGSKRQHV % S GLVWLQFWLYH FRPELQDWLRQ RI DXGLR ZHUIRUPDQFH DQG FRPIRUWDEOH ILW : Z %RVH FRP Z ) KLWH (DUEXGV LQG *UHDW 9DOHQWLQH V *LIWV /LNH 'LJLWDO )UDPHV &DPHUDV 0RUH : ZZZ 5DGLR6KDFN FRP

-

/ KLWH (DU %XGV DW $PD]RQ 4 Z SULFHV RQ ZKLWH HDU EXGV R $ XDOLILHG RUGHUV RYHU VKLS IUHH &PD]RQ FRP XGLR YLGHRVIXUQLWXU
HOOHU UDWLQJV

(RQ\ :KLWH 6WHUHR
6 D U EXGV ) 21< 0'5(; /3 :&8 : 21723,$ 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 :+,7( 683(5 /,*+7 ,1 7+( ($5 '(6,*135(0,80 6281' 683(5,25 %0661(: 683(5 60$// $ ' 0 /21* 7+52: $ 5,9(56($53+21( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW 0RPIRUWDEOH (DUEXGV ( ROGDEOH VLOLFRQ NLW 3HUVRQDO ILW ZDUEXGV VWD\ LQ HDU %ORFNV QRLVH ( ZZ SRGILWNLW FRP %DUEXGV ZKLWH *URZVH 7KURXJK 7RQV RI +HDGSKRQHV 3 UHDW GHDOV RQ $XGLR 6SHDNHUV - ULFH*UDEEHU FRP

D

6 KLWH L3RG (DUEXGV Q WHUHR HDUSKRQHV 3DVVLYH 3 -RLVH FDQFHOLQJ GHVLJQ HDUO ZKLWH KRXVLQJ ZLWK G DFU\OLF ILQLVK PP WLWDQLXP P LYHUV ZLWK QHRG\PLXP U DJQHW FRUH ,Q OLQH $ROXPH Y GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW 6

, DEUD &HOO (DU 3KRQHV WQQRYDWLYH FHOOXODU VWHUHR HDUEXG Z FKQRORJ\ %X\ -DEUD IURP -DEUD H ( ZZ -DEUD FRP X/LPH FRP VHOOHU UDWLQJV 4DUEXGV XLFNO\ VHDUFK PHUFKDQW SULFHV 6 V WRUHV 'HDOV 5HYLHZV (KRSSLQJ \DKRR FRP : UEXGV &KHDS 3ULFHV D ( H +DYH &RPSXWHUV 0RUH ZDUEXGV RQ 6DOH 5HDG 5HYLHZV ZZ 1H[7DJ FRP &RPSXWHUV

Q

K

(9& +$) : *XP\ DUEXGV &RFRQXW :*LWH K
& XP\ (DUEXGV RFRQXW :KLWH'R DZD\ ZLWK H VRUHQHVV FDXVHG E\ EXON\ HDUEXGV WKDW GRQ¶W ILW \RXU DUV ,QWURGXFLQJ WKH -9& *XP\ SKRQH HDUEXG

LJHU'LUHFW FRP V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

7

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH XP

LH 87)

$ KHDGSKRQHV 1GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

RLVH &DQFHOLQJ
6 DUEXGV :KLWH ( .LOLFRQH HDU EXGV IRU VXSHUE ILW DQG FRPIRUW 8S WR K S RXUV EDWWHU\ OLIH ,Q IOLJKW OXJ DGDSWRU VXSSOLHG S HUFHQW RI RXWHU QRLVH $ GXFHG ZKHQ WXUQHG RQ UH GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW & &RQQHFWLRQ VHOOHU UDWLQJV

3

266 .(% :+ 6WHUHR K (DUEXGV :KLWH
] &DUU\LQJ $ DVH & : GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

5 0XVLFVDQG &RPSXW

-

HOOHU UDWLQJV

L3RG (DUEXGV KLWH+
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
HOOHU UDWLQJV

7

R\DO %XVLQHVV (TXLS V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

5

HFK0LFUR FRP VHOOHU UDWLQJV

7

LKLWH L3RG (DUEXGV & 5K\WKPV 3DVVLYH 1RLVH DQFHOLQJ 6WHUHR L (DUSKRQHV :KLWH 7KH 5K\WKPV EUDQG 6WHUHR F DUSKRQHV 3DVVLYH QRLVH H DQFHOLQJ GHVLJQ 3HDUO $ KLWH KRXVLQJ Z GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

P(OHFWURQL[ FRP

S

KWWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH XP

LH 87)

5 HILQH SURGXFW UHVXOWV IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH
3ULFH UDQJH 2 8QGHU YHU W R %UDQGV 5 RQ\ 3 6 .KLOLSV M RVV -F Y 0 QVHQ H RUH ª 6WRUHV ' H%D\ V LVFRXQWFHOO 6HOOFHOOJURXS 6HFWRU FRP 0+23 &20 RUH ª 6HOOHU UDWLQJ VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS 0 +DV D UDWLQJ RUH ª 5HODWHG VHDUFKHV VRQ\ HDUEXGV ZKLWH

*R

HVXOW 3DJH 1H[W *RRJOH GRHV QRW FKDUJH IRU LQFOXVLRQ LQ LWV VHDUFK UHVXOWV RU DFFHSW SD\PHQW I , RU EHWWHU SODFHPHQW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV QIRUPDWLRQ IRU 6HOOHUV +HOS

6HDUFK WKH :HE

H

K

*RRJOH +RPH $GYHUWLVLQJ 6ROXWLRQV %XVLQHVV 6ROXWLRQV $ERXW *RRJOH *RRJOH $FFHSWV *RRJOH &KHFNRXW /HDUQ PRUH

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH XP

LH 87)

:HE ,PDJHV

0DSV 1HZV H

6KRSSLQJ *PDLO PRUH

0\ 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

3URGXFWV
KRZ LWHPV 6KRZ JULG YLHZ RQO\ 6KRZLQJ DOO LWHPV :

5HVXOWV
6RUW E\ UHOHYDQFH

RI DERXW

IRU HDU6 XGV ZKLWH E SRQVRUHG /LQNV

VHFRQGV

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

YHUHVW6WRUH

: (DUEXGV &KHDS 3ULFHV &RPSXWHUV 0RUH ( H +DYH ZDUEXGV RQ 6DOH 5HDG 5HYLHZV : Z 1H[7DJ FRP &RPSXWHUV Z & KLWH (DUEXGV ) RPSXWHU $FFHVVRULHV %LQG :KLWH (DUEXGV (L]5DWH FRP 0LFURSKRQHV 5DUEXGV 5DWLQJV HYLHZV DQDO\VLV UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV 9LHZ DQG EX\ HDUEXGV : ZZZ &RQVXPHU6HDUFK FRP :KLWH (DUEXGV 6 KLWH HDUEXGV 2QOLQH ZKRS 7DUJHW FRP 1ZZ 7DUJHW FRP

$

ULFHVKRSSH FRP V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

3

DOO\KRRJOH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

6

% R QDNHG HDUEXGV V XGFOLFN FKDUPV VQDS RQ HDUEXGV W\OH IRU WZHHQV DQG XUEDQ \RXWK ZZZ EXGFOLFNV FRP

%

6 +,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 21< :+,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 ) 621< 0'5(; /3 :&8 : 2 : 1723,$ 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 1(2'<0,80 +,7( + $*1(7 ,1&/8'(6 ($5%8' 0 2/'(5 :+,7( %R[HG :HLJKW O $ EV GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW 6 +,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 21< :+,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 ) 621< 0'5(; /3 :&8 : 1723,$ 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 2 1(2'<0,80 +,7( + $*1(7 ,1&/8'(6 ($5%8' 0 2/'(5 :+,7( %R[HG :HLJKW O $ EV GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

QOLQV *DGJHW6WRUH H
HOOHU UDWLQJV

2

UXVW\(OHFWURQLFV V
HOOHU UDWLQJ

K

7

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

6 +,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 ) 21< 0'5(; /3 :&8 21723,$w¢ò 67(5(2 2 ($5%8'6 :+,7( 5('8&(6 : 876,'( 12,6( )25 +,*+ $ 7(16,7< ,1 GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW : KLWH L3RG (DUEXGV KLWH (DUEXG KHDGSKRQHV IRU L3V G SHDUO ZKLWH ZLWK DFU\OLF ILQLVK R V HWV RI FXVWRP ILW HDU VOHHYHV HW RI IRDP ILWWHG HDU VOHHYHV TXLFN G $LVFRQQHFW WR GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

PU0DUW FRP V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

$

9LVLRQ 6\VWHPV

L

L3RG (DUEXGV :KLWH
3RG (DUEXGV :KLWH 'HOLYHU XOWLPDWH VWHUHR VRXQG 7UDGLWLRQDO I GHVLJQ ZLWK FXVKLRQHG UXEEHU EXGV RU FXVWRP ILW $YDLODEOH LQ PXOWLSOH $RORUV , 7HF F GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW ,3RG (DUEXGV :KLWH L : 7HF 7 : L3RG (DUEXGV % KLWH %X\ WKLV LWHP DW D : UJDLQV/DQH FRP IRU D /RZ 3ULFH $I R GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW : +,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 $ +,7( 67(5(2 ($5%8'6 GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW RZHVW0DUNXS FRP

/

DUJDLQV/DQH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

%

3

$

YHUHVW6WRUH

5 HILQH SURGXFW UHVXOWV IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH :
ULFH UDQJH 2 8QGHU YHU W R 5 %UDQGV 3 6RQ\ .KLOLSV M RVV -F Y 0 QVHQ H RUH ª 6WRUHV ' H%D\ V LVFRXQWFHOO 6HOOFHOOJURXS 6HFWRU FRP 0+23 &20 RUH ª 6HOOHU UDWLQJ VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS 0 +DV D UDWLQJ RUH ª 5HODWHG VHDUFKHV VRQ\ HDUEXGV ZKLWH

*R

K

HVXOW 3DJH 3UHYLRXV 1H[W *RRJOH GRHV QRW FKDUJH IRU LQFOXVLRQ LQ LWV VHDUFK UHVXOWV RU DFFHSW SD\PHQW I RU EHWWHU SODFHPHQW

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

H

,
QIRUPDWLRQ IRU 6HOOHUV +HOS

K

*RRJOH +RPH $GYHUWLVLQJ 6ROXWLRQV %XVLQHVV 6ROXWLRQV $ERXW *RRJOH

*RRJOH $FFHSWV *RRJOH &KHFNRXW /HDUQ PRUH

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

:HE ,PDJHV

0DSV 1HZV H

6KRSSLQJ *PDLO PRUH

0\ 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

3URGXFWV
L KRZ LWHPV RQO\ 6KRZLQJ DOO WHPV L KRZ JULG YLHZ 6

5HVXOWV
6RUW E\ UHOHYDQFH

RI DERXW

IRU HD6EXGV ZKLWH U SRQVRUHG /LQNV

VHFRQGV

L 3RG (DUEXGV :KLWH ' RG (DUEXGV :KLWH 3 HOLYHU XOWLPDWH VWHUHR VRXQG F 7UDGLWLRQDO GHVLJQ ZLWK XVKLRQHG UXEEHU EXGV IRU FXVWRP ILW $YDLODEOH LQ $ XOWLSOH FRORUV , 7HF P GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

RZHVW0DUNXS FRP

$RVH LQ HDU KHDGSKRQHV % S GLVWLQFWLYH FRPELQDWLRQ RI DXGLR ZHUIRUPDQFH DQG FRPIRUWDEOH ILW : Z %RVH FRP Z ) KLWH (DUEXGV LQG *UHDW 9DOHQWLQH V *LIWV /LNH 'LJLWDO )UDPHV &DPHUDV 0RUH : ZZZ 5DGLR6KDFN FRP

/

K - RLVH FDQFHOLQJ HDUEXG HDGSKRQH ZKLWH PP GULYHUV (; W\SH IRU LPSURYHG V RXQG TXDOLW\ &RPSDFW L EDWWHU\ ER[ $$$ EDWWHU\ $ FOXGHG Q GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

1RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 1 (DUEXGV :KLWH

X\6HOO/HDVV 7UDGH FR H
HOOHU UDWLQJV

/ KLWH (DU %XGV DW $PD]RQ 4 Z SULFHV RQ ZKLWH HDU EXGV R $ XDOLILHG RUGHUV RYHU VKLS IUHH &PD]RQ FRP 0RPIRUWDEOH (DUEXGV ( ROGDEOH VLOLFRQ NLW 3HUVRQDO ILW ZDUEXGV VWD\ LQ HDU %ORFNV QRLVH ( ZZ SRGILWNLW FRP %DUEXGV ZKLWH *URZVH 7KURXJK 7RQV RI +HDGSKRQHV 3 UHDW GHDOV RQ $XGLR 6SHDNHUV &ULFH*UDEEHU FRP , HOO 6WHUHR (DU 3KRQHV G QRYDWLYH FHOOXODU VWHUHR HDUEXG Q ZHVLJQV %X\ -DEUD IURP -DEUD ( ZZ -DEUD FRP HDUSKRQHV

%

6 80< 3+21( &(16,7,9,7< '% 0: 25' /(1*7+ )7 / 3 6+$3( *2/' 3/$7(' &/8* 0$; ,1387 : 3$%,/,7< $ 0: $ (,*+7 2= :+,7( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

(9& +$) : *80< *$5%8'6 :+,7(

LDV&5$=<'HDOV FRP

5

, L3RG (DUEXGV :KLWH 7HF 7 : L3RG L (DUEXGV :KLWH %X\ WKLV 1 DHP DW %DUJDLQV/DQH FRP IRU W $ /RZ 3ULFH RI GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW 6

DUJDLQV /DQH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

4DUEXGV XLFNO\ VHDUFK PHUFKDQW SULFHV 6 V WRUHV 'HDOV 5HYLHZV (KRSSLQJ \DKRR FRP : UEXGV &KHDS 3ULFHV D ( H +DYH &RPSXWHUV 0RUH ZDUEXGV RQ 6DOH 5HDG 5HYLHZV ZZ 1H[7DJ FRP &RPSXWHUV

%

K

RLVH &DQFHOLQJ (DUEXGV , 32' :KLWH )RDP FRYHUHG F DU %XGV 3RUWDEOH DQG ( RPIRUWDEOH GHVLJQ 1RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 0LFURSKRQHV 7KH PLFURSKRQHV PRQLWRU QRLVH

RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 1 (DUEXGV :KLWH

R\DO %XVLQHVV (TXLS V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

5

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

$ Q G : G WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

) 21< 0'5(; /3 :&8 21723,$ÃÆ 67(5(2 $$5%8'6 :+,7( ( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

+,7( 67(5(2 6 ($5%8'6

MXPSVKRS FRP

L

¢òw¢òJXP\ SKRQH P w¢òw¢òVHQVLWLYLW\ GE # Z w¢òw¢òFRUG OHQJWK IW w¢òw¢òO VKDSH JROG SODWHG F SOXJ w¢òw¢òPD[ LQSXW DSDELOLW\ PZ $ òw¢òZHLJKW w¢ GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

( -9& +$) : *XP\ w DU%XGV :KLWH

QEHDWDEOH6DOH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

8

L 80< 3+21( 0 6(16,7,9,7< '% # : &25' /(1*7+ )7 / 6+$3( *2/' 3/$7(' & 3/8* 0$; ,1387 $3$%,/,7< 0: $ (,*+7 : 2= :+,7( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW 3 RG (DUEXGV :KLWH 3 $HUVRQDO 3RUWDEOH L3RG FFHVVRULHV L3RG +HDGSKRQHV'HOLYHU XOWLPDWH VWHUHR VRXQG7UDGLWLRQDO GHVLJQ ZLWK FXVKLRQHG UXEEHU EXGV IRU FXVWRP ILW$YDLODEOH $ LQ GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

( -9& +$) : *80< *$5%8'6 :+,7(

\ 6LPSOH 6WRUH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

0

XUHJL]PR

3

K

80< 3+21( & 6(16,7,9,7< '% 0: 6 25' /(1*7+ )7 / 3+$3( *2/' 3/$7(' &/8* 0$; ,1387 $3$%,/,7< 0: * (,*+7 : 2= :+,7( 80< 3+21( $(16,7,9,7< 6 GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

(9& +$) : *80< *$5%8'6 :+,7(

HFWRU

FRP VHOOHU UDWLQJV

6

5 HILQH SURGXFW UHVXOWV IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH L

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

3ULFH UDQJH 2 8QGHU YHU W R

5

*R

%UDQGV 3 6RQ\ .KLOLSV M RVV -F Y 0 QVHQ H RUH ª

6WRUHV ' H%D\ V LVFRXQWFHOO 6HOOFHOOJURXS 6HFWRU FRP 0+23 &20 RUH ª

6HOOHU UDWLQJ VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS 0 +DV D UDWLQJ RUH ª

5HODWHG VHDUFKHV VRQ\ HDUEXGV ZKLWH

HVXOW 3DJH 3UHYLRXV 1H[W *RRJOH GRHV QRW FKDUJH IRU LQFOXVLRQ LQ LWV VHDUFK UHVXOWV RU DFFHSW SD\PHQW I , RU EHWWHU SODFHPHQW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV QIRUPDWLRQ IRU 6HOOHUV +HOS

6HDUFK WKH :HE

H

K

*RRJOH +RPH $GYHUWLVLQJ 6ROXWLRQV %XVLQHVV 6ROXWLRQV $ERXW *RRJOH *RRJOH $FFHSWV *RRJOH &KHFNRXW /HDUQ PRUH

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

:HE ,PDJHV

0DSV 1HZV H

6KRSSLQJ *PDLO PRUH

0\ 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

3URGXFWV
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

5HVXOWV
6RUW E\ UHOHYDQFH

RI DERXW

IRU HDU6 XGV ZKLWH E SRQVRUHG /LQNV &RPSXWHUV 6RIWZDUH % <DUJDLQ 3ULFHV %RX ZDQW LW ZH JRW LW ZL]5DWH FRP

VHFRQGV

ZZ WQJGLUHFW FRP

Z

$ KLWH KHDGSKRQHV ) OO NLQGV RI +HDGSKRQHV 6DOH ZDFWRU\ 3ULFH ZLWK 7RS 4XDOLW\ ( ZZ $EHLHU FRP 5DUEXGV 5HYLHZV HYLHZV DQDO\VLV UHFRPPHQGDWLRQV 9LHZ DQG EX\ HDUEXGV : ZZZ &RQVXPHU6HDUFK FRP :KLWH (DUEXGV 6 KLWH HDUEXGV 2QOLQH ZKRS 7DUJHW FRP 1ZZ 7DUJHW FRP % R QDNHG HDUEXGV V XGFOLFN FKDUPV VQDS RQ HDUEXGV W\OH IRU WZHHQV DQG XUEDQ \RXWK ZZZ EXGFOLFNV FRP

$5 02%,/( 7+( $XW

&

+( $ 9 &RPSDQLHV VHOOHU UDWLQJ

6

7

K - RLVH FDQFHOLQJ HDUEXG HDGSKRQH ZKLWH PP GULYHUV (; W\SH IRU LPSURYHG V RXQG TXDOLW\ &RPSDFW L EDWWHU\ ER[ $$$ EDWWHU\ $ FOXGHG Q GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 1 (DUEXGV :KLWH

X\6HOO/HDVV 7UDGH FR H
HOOHU UDWLQJV

%

6 80< 3+21( &(16,7,9,7< '% 0: 25' /(1*7+ )7 / 3 6+$3( *2/' 3/$7(' &/8* 0$; ,1387 : 3$%,/,7< $ 0: $ (,*+7 2= :+,7( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

(9& +$) : *80< *$5%8'6 :+,7(

LDV&5$=<'HDOV FRP

5

KWWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

R : LVH &DQFHOLQJ (DUEXGV , 32' :KLWH )RDP FRYHUHG F DU %XGV 3RUWDEOH DQG ( RPIRUWDEOH GHVLJQ 1RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 0LFURSKRQHV 7KH L PLFURSKRQHV PRQLWRU QRLVH $ Q GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

RLVH &DQFHOLQJ 1 (DUEXGV :KLWH

R\DO %XVLQHVV (TXLS V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

5

) 21< 0'5(; /3 :&8 21723,$ÃÆ 67(5(2 $$5%8'6 :+,7( ( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

+,7( 67(5(2 6 ($5%8'6

MXPSVKRS FRP

L

¢ - òw¢òJXP\ SKRQH P w¢òw¢òVHQVLWLYLW\ GE # Z w¢òw¢òFRUG OHQJWK IW w¢òw¢òO VKDSH JROG SODWHG F SOXJ w¢òw¢òPD[ LQSXW DSDELOLW\ PZ $ òw¢òZHLJKW w¢ GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

( -9& +$) : *XP\ w DU%XGV :KLWH

QEHDWDEOH6DOH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

8

, 80< 3+21( 0(16,7,9,7< 6 '% # : &25' /(1*7+ )7 / 6+$3( *2/' 3/$7(' & 3/8* 0$; ,1387 $3$%,/,7< 0: $ (,*+7 : 2= :+,7( GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

(9& +$) : *80< *$5%8'6 :+,7(

\ 6LPSOH 6WRUH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

0

V HOLYHU XOWLPDWH VWHUHR FRXQG7UDGLWLRQDO GHVLJQ ZLWK XVKLRQHG UXEEHU EXGV IRU P FXVWRP ILW$YDLODEOH LQ 3 XOWLSOH FRORUV3ULFH 1RWH $ULFHG SHU GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

: 7HF L3RG (DUEXGV ' KLWH 7 :

EL](QWHUSULVH FRP

(

5 HILQH SURGXFW UHVXOWV IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH 1
3ULFH UDQJH 2 8QGHU K YHU W R %UDQGV 3 6RQ\ .KLOLSV M RVV -F Y HQVHQ 6WRUHV '%D\ V LVFRXQWFHOO 6HOOFHOOJURXS 6HFWRU FRP H +23 &20 6HOOHU UDWLQJ VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS + WDUV DQG XS 0DV D UDWLQJ RUH ª V 5HODWHG VHDUFKHV VRQ\ HDUEXGV ZKLWH

*R

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

0RUH ª

0RUH ª

5HVXOW 3DJH 3UHYLRXV 1H[W *RRJOH GRHV QRW FKDUJH IRU LQFOXVLRQ LQ LWV VHDUFK UHVXOWV RU DFFHSW SD\PHQW I , RU EHWWHU SODFHPHQW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV QIRUPDWLRQ IRU 6HOOHUV +HOS

6HDUFK WKH :HE

H

K

*RRJOH +RPH $GYHUWLVLQJ 6ROXWLRQV %XVLQHVV 6ROXWLRQV $ERXW *RRJOH *RRJOH $FFHSWV *RRJOH &KHFNRXW /HDUQ PRUH

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

:HE ,PDJHV

0DSV 1HZV H

6KRSSLQJ *PDLO PRUH

0\ 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV

6HDUFK WKH :HE

3URGXFWV
L KRZ LWHPV RQO\ 6KRZLQJ DOO WHPV : KRZ JULG YLHZ 6

5HVXOWV
6RUW E\ UHOHYDQFH

RI DERXW

IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH 6 SRQVRUHG /LQNV

VHFRQGV

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

ZZ 3RZHUVHOO6KRSSLQ

$RVH LQ HDU KHDGSKRQHV % S GLVWLQFWLYH FRPELQDWLRQ RI DXGLR ZHUIRUPDQFH DQG FRPIRUWDEOH ILW : Z %RVH FRP Z 6 KLWH (DUEXGV KRS 5DGLR6KDFN IRU +HDGSKRQHV DQG $FFHVVRULHV IRU \RXU KROLGD\ JLIWV Z : Z 5DGLR6KDFN FRP Z

Z
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

ROWV FRP VHOOHU UDWLQJV

Y

DVWWUDGHV FRP

(

( 1RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR 1 DUEXGV :KLWH
( RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR PP DUEXGV :KLWH GULYHUV +] N+] G IUHTXHQF\ UHVSRQVH &ORVHG QHVLJQ UHGXFHV RXWVLGH RLVH DQG LPSURYHV EDVV $ VSRQVH ,Q OLQH UH GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

RZHVW0DUNXS FRP

6

/

K

621< 0'5(; /3 ( :&8 )RQWRSLD 6WHUHR N DUEXGV :KLWH
F K] VW\OLVK QHFN FKDLQ RUG JROG SODWHG O VKDSHG 8

QEHDWDEOH6DOH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

VWHUHR SOXJ LQFOXGHV R FRPSDFW FDVH VSDUH VHW I HDUEXGV UZKLWH HYLHZV $GG 1 WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

( RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR
0DUEXGV :KLWH 1 D[IXQ '0; 0 :+ 1 ( RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR L DUEXGV :KLWH %X\ WKLV WHP DW %DUJDLQV/DQH FRP $ U D /RZ 3ULFH RI IR GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW DUJDLQV /DQH V
HOOHU UDWLQJV

%

( RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR U 1DUEXGV :KLWH
U HVSRQVH &ORVHG GHVLJQ HGXFHV RXWVLGH QRLVH DQG LPSURYHV EDVV UHVSRQVH ,Q OLQH PXWH VZLWFK ,QFOXGHV WKUHH VL]H ILW NLW DQG P $[WHQVLRQ FDEOH :KLWH H GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

ZZ WQJGLUHFW FRP

Z

( RLVH ,VRODWLQJ 6WHUHR
+ DUEXGV :KLWH 6 HDGSKRQHV +HDGSKRQHV + 0LQL )XOO 6L]H HDGSKRQHV PP GULYHUV +] N+] IUHTXHQF\ UHVSRQVH&ORVHG Q GHVLJQ UHGXFHV RXWVLGH RLVH DQG LPSURYHV EDVV UH $ VSRQVH,Q OLQH GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW XUHJL]PR

3

21< )21723,$ 6WHUHR (DUEXGV 6 6 :+,7(
G XSHU OLJKW LQ WKH HDU V HVLJQ 3UHPLXP VRXQG XSHULRU EDVV 1HZ VXSHU VPDOO PP ORQJ WKURZ GULYHUV 8OWUD KLJK SRZHU & 1HRG\PLXP PDJQHW $ ORVHG GHVLJQ GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

UDVV*DWH &RQVXPHU (

%

K

621< )21723,$ 7(5(2 ($5%8'6 6 :+,7(
83(5 /,*+7 ,1 7+( ($5 '(6,*1 35(0,80 6281' 683(5,25 %$66 1(: 683(5 7 60$// 00 /21* +52: '5,9(56

GYLYD //& VHOOHU UDWLQJV

$

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW

3

8 ($53+21( +2/'(5 1/75$ +,*+ 32:(5 $ (2'<0,80 0$*1(7 GG WR 6KRSSLQJ /LVW

5 HILQH SURGXFW UHVXOWV IRU HDUEXGV ZKLWH
ULFH UDQJH 2 8QGHU YHU W R 5 %UDQGV 3 6RQ\ .KLOLSV M RVV -F Y 0 QVHQ H RUH ª 6WRUHV ' H%D\ V LVFRXQWFHOO 6HOOFHOOJURXS 6HFWRU FRP 0+23 &20 RUH ª 6HOOHU UDWLQJ VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS VWDUV DQG XS 0 +DV D UDWLQJ RUH ª 5HODWHG VHDUFKHV VRQ\ HDUEXGV ZKLWH

*R

HVXOW 3DJH 3UHYLRXV 1H[W *RRJOH GRHV QRW FKDUJH IRU LQFOXVLRQ LQ LWV VHDUFK UHVXOWV RU DFFHSW SD\PHQW I , RU EHWWHU SODFHPHQW

DUEXGV ZKLWH

6HDUFK 3URGXFWV QIRUPDWLRQ IRU 6HOOHUV +HOS

6HDUFK WKH :HE

H

K

*RRJOH +RPH $GYHUWLVLQJ 6ROXWLRQV %XVLQHVV 6ROXWLRQV $ERXW *RRJOH *RRJOH $FFHSWV *RRJOH &KHFNRXW /HDUQ PRUH

WWS ZZZ JRRJOH FRP SURGXFWV"KO HQ T HDUEXGV ZKLWH VD 1 VWDUW