Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 269

Declaration of Sean P. DeBruine in Support of 268 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply / Motion to Continue Deadline for Filing of Elan's Reply Brief in Support of Elan's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Related document(s) 268 ) (DeBruine, Sean) (Filed on 6/8/2011)

Download PDF
#'$%"%& ! $76<./7! )188/3 &764# )/59# *6# %-# );,2/-9# 7H5SVLPH% AHDP BKVSTGDZ% >DZ )0% *()) )(1*+ 4> >HKUD% AQPDN 4RRNH 8NDP C;> AHSWLFH2 8NDP 4RRNH BHDO @81 AULRVNDULQP UQ 6QPULPVH 6>6 CVUHS% 5Z ^L HNYLLK LHYSPLY% 5WWSL"Z VWWVZP[PVU PZ UV[ K\L \U[PS ?\UL *' 5Z > HSZV TLU[PVULK% OV^L]LY% 9SHU PZ JVUJLYULK ^P[O [OL JVU[PU\LK KLSH`Z 5WWSL ZLLRZ [V PTWVZL VU [OL YLZVS\[PVU VM [OPZ TV[PVU' 8LZWP[L 5WWSL"Z [OL [LU\V\Z JSHPT [OH[ P[ ULLKZ [V KLWVZL @Y' 8LaTLS`R ILMVYL YLZWVUKPUN [V [OL TV[PVU% 9SHU X\PJRS` ZJOLK\SLK [OH[ KLWVZP[PVU Z\JO [OH[ VUS` H VUL ^LLR KLSH` ^V\SK IL ULJLZZHY`' 5WWSL"Z YLZWVUZL ^HZ [OH[ [OL KH[L ^HZU"[ JVU]LUPLU[' FL OH]L YLZJOLK\SLK [OL KLWVZP[PVU [V Z\P[ 5WWSL"Z ULLKZ Z\JO [OH[ H [^V ^LLR KLSH` ^V\SK YLZ\S[% VUS` [V IL [VSK [OH[ [OL LUZ\PUN OLHYPUN KH[L% HUK [OL UL_[% HYL SPRL^PZL UV[ JVU]LUPLU[ MVY 5WWSL' >U ZOVY[% HIZLU[ [OL HNYLLTLU[ VM [OL 7V\Y[ [V [OL ?\UL *( KH[L% 5WWSL PZ ZLLRPUN [V KLSH` [OL YLZVS\[PVU VM [OPZ TV[PVU I` H M\SS TVU[O' FL HYL UV[ VWWVZLK [V TV]PUN [OL OLHYPUN [V ?\UL *( PM [OL 7V\Y[ PZ H]HPSHISL' > OH]L UV[ OLHYK IHJR MYVT [OL JV\Y[YVVT KLW\[` HZ [V ^OL[OLY [OH[ PZ H WVZZPIPSP[`' =V^L]LY% ILMVYL HNYLLPUN [V H KLSH` \U[PS ?\S` /% OV^L]LY% ^L ^V\SK SPRL ZVTL PKLH HZ [V ^O` 5WWSL JHUUV[ IL H]HPSHISL MVY H OLHYPUN VU LP[OLY ?\UL *+ VY ?\UL +(' 5SZV% WSLHZL HKKYLZZ `V\Y WYVWVZHS MVY ZJOLK\SPUN [OL M\Y[OLY 7HZL @HUHNLTLU[ 7VUMLYLUJL' 6LZ[ YLNHYKZ% CLHU #-,*! 9EFOB! =KJBH @IBGHOK-=KJBH"9EFOB1REGH"CKIA $(+.! ?EDJENDBS! 9BS $+! %#$$ *-(& ;9 %,! 9EFOB! =KJBH "'! 5E3MPGJE! =EBJ. 2LLHE 6HBJ ?89 =EMQGCE. 6HBJ 2LLHE >EBI $/&)('.! <E- =OGLPHBOGKJ OK 4KJOGJPE 494 CLHU% FL OH]L UV[ `L[ OLHYK MYVT `V\ YLNHYKPUN V\Y WYVWVZHS ILSV^' 6LJH\ZL [OL VYPNPUHS KLHKSPUL MVY MPSPUN V\Y YLZWVUZL [V 9SHU"Z TV[PVU MVY WHY[PHS Z\TTHY` Q\KNTLU[ PZ [VTVYYV^% ^L ^PSS ULLK H YLZWVUZL MYVT `V\ MPYZ[ [OPUN [VTVYYV^ TVYUPUN' >U [OL L]LU[ [OH[ ^L KVU"[ OH]L H YLZWVUZL% 5WWSL ^PSS MPSL H TV[PVU ZLLRPUN [V LUSHYNL [OL [PTL MVY YLZWVUKPUN [V 9SHU"Z Z\TTHY` Q\KNTLU[ TV[PVU' >U [OH[ TV[PVU% ^L ^PSS ZLLR [V OH]L [OL OLHYPUN KH[L TV]LK [V ?\S` /' DOHURZ% CVUHS 9L 7@W ).% *())% @R -0() ;7% !7DGR@% =ML@J! 1=ML@J'7DGR@3UDHJ'BMK2 UPMRD0 CLHU% FL JHU HNYLL [V ^VYR ^P[OPU [OL MYHTL^VYR VM [OL [^V ^LLR L_[LUZPVU VM [OL J\YYLU[ ZJOLK\SL [OH[ `V\ WYVWVZL% PUJS\KPUN [OL KLWVZP[PVU VM @Y' 8LaTLS`R UL_[ ^LLR VU @H` *,[O' EUMVY[\UH[LS`% [OL OLHYPUN $ KH[L VM ?\UL *+ [OH[ `V\ WYVWVZL ^PSS UV[ ^VYR MVY \Z' 5Z HU HS[LYUH[P]L% ^L Z\NNLZ[ WYVWVZPUN [V [OL 7V\Y[ H OLHYPUN KH[L VM ?\UL *(% ^OPJO PZ [OL UL_[ JSVZLZ[ KH[L [OH[ ^PSS ^VYR' =V^L]LY% WSLHZL UV[L [OH[ ?\UL *( PZ H @VUKH`% ^OPJO PZ UV[ ?\KNL CLLIVYN"Z UVYTHS TV[PVU KH`' DOLYLMVYL% PU [OL WHY[PLZ" WYVWVZLK Z[PW\SH[PVU% ^L [OPUR P[ ^V\SK IL ^PZL [V HSZV Z\NNLZ[ HU HS[LYUH[P]L KH[L HZ H IHJR\W PU [OL L]LU[ [OH[ ?\KNL CLLIVYN PZ \UHISL [V HJJVTTVKH[L \Z VU ?\UL *(' DOL UL_[ UVYTHS TV[PVU KH[L [OH[ ^V\SK ^VYR MVY \Z PZ ?\S` /' BSLHZL JVUMPYT [OH[ [OPZ WYVWVZHS ^PSS ^VYR MVY `V\' DOHURZ% CVUHS #-,*- 5E3MPGJE! =EBJ @IBGHOK-=EBJ"5E3MPGJE1BHNOKJ"CKIA $(+.- 9KJDBS! 9BS $)! %#$$ #%-&* ;9 %,- 9EFOB! =KJBH. 2LLHE 6HBJ ?89 =EMQGCE "'- 6HBJ 2LLHE >EBI /6HBJ"2LLHE">EBI1BHNOKJ"CKI0 $/&)('.- <6- =OGLPHBOGKJ OK 4KJOGJPE 494 CVUHS% >U SPNO[ VM 5WWSL"Z PUZPZ[LUJL [OH[ @Y' 8LaTLS`R"Z KLWVZP[PVU PZ ULJLZZHY` [V P[Z VWWVZP[PVU [V [OL Z\TTHY` Q\KNTLU[ TV[PVU% HUK V\Y WYVTW[ VMMLY [V THRL @Y' 8LaTLS`R H]HPSHISL H[ H [PTL [OH[ ^V\SK TPUPTPaL [OL KLSH` [OPZ KLWVZP[PVU ^V\SK JH\ZL% ^L HYL KPZHWWVPU[LK [OH[ 5WWSL"Z JV\UZLS ^PSS UV[ NV MVY^HYK VU [OL )0[O' AL]LY[OLSLZZ% ^L OH]L ILLU HISL [V THRL HKQ\Z[TLU[Z PU @Y' 8LaTLS`R"Z ZJOLK\SL% HZ ^LSS HZ V\Y V^U% ZV [OH[ [OL KLWVZP[PVU JHU [HRL WSHJL VU D\LZKH` @H` *,' 5Z `V\ RUV^% \UKLY [OL SVJHS Y\SLZ 5WWSL"Z VWWVZP[PVU PZ K\L *) KH`Z ILMVYL [OL OLHYPUN' EUKLY `V\Y WYVWVZHS [OH[ 5WWSL MPSL P[Z VWWVZP[PVU VU ?\UL * HUK HIZLU[ HU HNYLLTLU[ I` [OL 7V\Y[ [V ZOVY[LU [OL [PTL IL[^LLU JVTWSL[PVU VM IYPLMPUN HUK [OL OLHYPUN% [OL OLHYPUN ^V\SK IL ZJOLK\SLK MVY ?\UL *+' 9SHU PZ ^PSSPUN [V YLZJOLK\SL [OL OLHYPUN MVY [OH[ KH[L% I\[ ^PSS UV[ HNYLL [V HU` M\Y[OLY KLSH`' >[ ^V\SK HSZV THRL ZLUZL [V JVU[PU\L [OL M\Y[OLY 7@7 [V [OH[ KH` HZ ^LSS' BSLHZL JVUMPYT [OH[ [OPZ ZJOLK\SL PZ HJJLW[HISL [V 5WWSL' DOHURZ% CLHU #-,*! 9EFOB! =KJBH @IBGHOK-=KJBH"9EFOB1REGH"CKIA $(+.! 7MGDBS! 9BS $&! %#$$ $-'' ;9 %,! 5E3MPGJE! =EBJ % "'! 2LLHE 6HBJ ?89 =EMQGCE. 6HBJ 2LLHE >EBI $/&)('.! <6- =OGLPHBOGKJ OK 4KJOGJPE 494 CLHU% DOHURZ MVY NL[[PUN IHJR [V \Z' EUMVY[\UH[LS`% [OL )0[O KVLZ UV[ ^VYR MVY \Z MVY H KLWVZP[PVU' FL HYL NLULYHSS` H]HPSHISL [OL MVSSV^PUN ^LLR% [OL ^LLR VM [OL *+YK' BSLHZL SL[ \Z RUV^ ^OL[OLY [OLYL PZ H KH` [OH[ ^LLR [OH[ ^PSS ^VYR MVY @Y' 8LaTLS`R' >M ZV% ^L JV\SK WYVIHIS` THRL ?\UL * ^VYR MVY V\Y VWWVZP[PVU% ^P[O ?\UL 1 MVY `V\Y YLWS`' >U HU` JHZL% ^L HYL SVVRPUN PU[V ^OL[OLY ?\UL ). ^VYRZ HZ H OLHYPUN KH[L VY ^OL[OLY ^L"SS ULLK [V YLZJOLK\SL [V HUV[OLY KH[L HUK ^PSS NL[ IHJR [V `V\' 6LZ[% 3PTHNL(()'QWN4 )65+3 (" '/09+ CHLN% ;QUTKDN ! >DPJHT ==? *() @HGXQQG AKQSHT ?DSMXDZ @HGXQQG AKQSHT% 64 0,(.-&))+, TQPDN'OHKUD3XHLN'FQO $) .-( /(* +))/ 7LSHFU $) .-( /(* +)(( 9DY #-,*! 5E3MPGJE! =EBJ @IBGHOK-=EBJ"5E3MPGJE1BHNOKJ"CKIA $(+.! 7MGDBS! 9BS $&! %#$$ $#-() 29 %,! 9EFOB! =KJBH "'! 2LLHE 6HBJ ?89 =EMQGCE. 6HBJ 2LLHE >EBI $/&)('.! <6- =OGLPHBOGKJ OK 4KJOGJPE 494 CVUHS% > JHU JVUMPYT [OH[ @Y' 8LaTLS`R PZ H]HPSHISL MVY KLWVZP[PVU VU FLKULZKH` @H` )0' > HZZ\TL [OH[ ^L ^PSS ILNPU H[ 12((HT H[ `V\Y VMMPJL% I\[ WSLHZL SL[ TL RUV^ PM `V\ ^V\SK SPRL [V THRL V[OLY HYYHUNLTLU[Z' >U SPNO[ VM [OPZ ZJOLK\SL ^L WYVWVZL [OH[ 5WWSL MPSL P[Z VWWVZP[PVU [V 9SHU"Z TV[PVU VU @H` *.% ^P[O 9SHU"Z YLWS` K\L ?\UL *' DOPZ ZJOLK\SL ZOV\SK WYV]PKL 5WWSL HTWSL [PTL [V HKKYLZZ HU` YLSL]HU[ [LZ[PTVU` I` @Y' 8LaTLS`R% HUK WLYTP[ \Z [V ZJOLK\SL [OL OLHYPUN VU 9SHU"Z TV[PVU MVY ?\UL ). HSVUN ^P[O [OL 7HZL @HUHNLTLU[ 7VUMLYLUJL' BSLHZL JVUMPYT [OH[ [OPZ ZJOLK\SL ^VYRZ MVY 5WWSL HUK ^L ^PSS YL&UV[PJL [OL Z\TTHY` Q\KNTLU[ TV[PVU' & FP[O YLNHYK [V [OL JHZL THUHNLTLU[ JVUMLYLUJL% > HT Z[PSS H^HP[PUN `V\Y HWWYV]HS [V MPSL [OL Z[PW\SH[PVU HZ ^L HNYLLK' BSLHZL SL[ TL RUV^ PM V\Y HNYLLTLU[ Z[PSS OVSKZ' 6LZ[ YLNHYKZ% CLHU #-,*! 9EFOB! =KJBH @IBGHOK-=KJBH"9EFOB1REGH"CKIA $(+.! >PENDBS! 9BS $#! %#$$ $-'% ;9 %,! 5E3MPGJE! =EBJ "'! 2LLHE 6HBJ ?89 =EMQGCE. 6HBJ 2LLHE >EBI $/&)('.! <6- =OGLPHBOGKJ OK 4KJOGJPE 494 CLHU% DV MVSSV^&\W VU T` ]THPS `LZ[LYKH`% ^L ^V\SK SPRL [V KPZJ\ZZ ZJOLK\SPUN YLSH[LK [V 9SHU"Z YLJLU[ TV[PVU MVY Z\TTHY` Q\KNTLU[' <P]LU [OH[ [OL TV[PVU WYLZLU[Z 9SHU"Z PUMYPUNLTLU[ [OLVY` MVY [OL MPYZ[ [PTL HUK JVTLZ ILMVYL [OL JVUJS\ZPVU VM MHJ[ KPZJV]LY`% L_WLY[ KPZJV]LY`% HUK JSHPT JVUZ[Y\J[PVU% 5WWSL ^PSS ULLK HU VWWVY[\UP[` [V [HRL KPZJV]LY` YLSH[PUN [V 9SHU"Z [OLVYPLZ ILMVYL YLZWVUKPUN [V [OL TV[PVU' FL ^PSS HSZV ULLK [V ZL[ \W H TLL[ HUK JVUMLY YLNHYKPUN HKKP[PVUHS JSHPT JVUZ[Y\J[PVU WYVJLLKPUNZ VU [OL "+-* WH[LU[ #HUK TVYL IYVHKS`$ PU HK]HUJL VM [OL 7@7' BSLHZL SL[ \Z RUV^ ^OLU @Y' 8LaTLS`R JHU IL H]HPSHISL MVY KLWVZP[PVU VU OPZ VWPUPVUZ PU Z\WWVY[ VM [OL TV[PVU HUK JVUMPYT [OH[ 9SHU ^PSS JVUZLU[ [V HU L_[LUZPVU VM [PTL MVY 5WWSL"Z VWWVZP[PVU HUK [OL OLHYPUN KH[L [V HJJVTTVKH[L [OH[ KLWVZP[PVU' 8LWLUKPUN VU ^OLU [OH[ KLWVZP[PVU JHU IL ZJOLK\SLK% ^L L_WLJ[ ^L ^PSS ULLK HU L_[LUZPVU VM H[ SLHZ[ [OYLL ^LLRZ' FL ^PSS HKKYLZZ [OL TLL[ HUK JVUMLY VU HKKP[PVUHS JSHPT JVUZ[Y\J[PVU WYVJLLKPUNZ I` ZLWHYH[L LTHPS' FL"SS [HRL H SVVR H[ [OL Z[PW\SH[PVU YLNHYKPUN [OL 7@7 HUK NL[ IHJR [V `V\ ZOVY[S`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`V\Y HWWYV]HS [V MPSL' DOHURZ' 6;7@ 1;/BE=@; .?CDA@ ! /=B9 224 &+) 3=99?;<=;?9 5A79 F 6E=D; %)$ F 3;@?A 47B>" 0. -($&) *)$#,',#&%&% 1=B;8D D^LS]L 7VUZLJ\[P]L GLHYZ VU ;VY[\ULd THNHaPULb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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?