Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1068

Declaration of Bill Trac in Support of #1063 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Samsung's Reply in Support of Samsung's Motion for Summary Judgment filed bySamsung Electronics Co. Ltd.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10, #11 Exhibit 11, #12 Exhibit 12, #13 Exhibit 13, #14 Exhibit 14, #15 Exhibit 15, #16 Exhibit 16, #17 Exhibit 17, #18 Exhibit 18, #19 Exhibit 19, #20 Exhibit 20, #21 Exhibit 21, #22 Exhibit 22, #23 Exhibit 23, #24 Exhibit 24, #25 Exhibit 25, #26 Exhibit 26, #27 Exhibit 27, #28 Exhibit 28)(Related document(s) #1063 ) (Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 6/8/2012)

EXHIBIT 5

iRiver U10 (1GB) - NYTimes.com

HOME PAGE TODAY’S PAPER VIDEO

Log In Register Now

MOST POPULAR TIMES TOPICS
Search All NYTimes.com

$11~ NeW ~ork ~im~

I

Personal Tech

Sunday, February .......
WORLD

Page 1 of 2

Go

U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION ARTS STYLE TRAVEL JOBS

[ [NGh DIRECT

I

REAL ESTATE AUTOS

Delight yourself in the LORD and he will give
you the desires at your head. - Psalms 37:4

Christian & Single?
Advertise on NYTirnes.com

PERSONAL TECH > MUSIC PLAYERS > IRIMER UlO

RELATED ARTICLES
BITS; Apple Introduces Tools to (Someday) Supplant
Print Textbooks
Amid an Avalanche ofiPad Apps, the Best of 2Oll App Smart

iRiver UlO (1GB)

HOUSES OF THE HOPEFULS:
TAKE A LOOK AT THE G.O.P.
CANDIDATES’ HOMES2’

I
NYTIMES.COM STYLE
Get DealBook by E-Mail
REVIEWS WHERE TO BUY

n
PRICE RANGE

CNET Rating

$100.00

See All Stores on CNET ,,

Average CNET User’s Rating

--

Sign up for the latest financial news delivered before the
opening bell and after the market close.
Sign Up
I
See Sample I Privacy Policy

Read All User Reviews on CNET *
Subscribe

THEGOOD

Wonderfully sleek and stylish design; unique and intuitive interface;
supports OGG files and subscription content; includes FM radio, voice
recorder, alarm clock, and SRS Wow sound effects; photo, video, and
text viewing; great battery life.

Personal Tech
Pogue’e Post

Gadgetwiee

FOLLOW US ON
Twitter

MOSTPOPULAR-TECHNOLOGY
E-MAILED BLOGGED

THEBAD

Expensive; maximum capacity is 1GB; no autoplay; no album art; useful
cradle is sold separately.

THE BOTFOM
LINE

The pricey iRiver Ulo is a superbly designed MP3 player that is both
easy to use and packed with pretty much every feature in the book. But
Apple won’t be quaking in its boots until iRiver ups its capacity to 2GB
and 4GB.
© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Used by permission.
Read Full Product Review on CNET ,,

User Reviews
Average Users Rating: ~ @e;

1_. jasonbeckett
Oct 20, 2005
09:02 am
Rating:

1. Traveling Light in a Time of Digital Thievery
2. Start-Ups Seek to Help Users Put a Price on Their
Personal Data
3. Bits: Scientific Agency to Drop BlackBerw for iPhone
4. App Smart : Flirting Tips for the Tongue-Tied, or the
Simply Shy
5. Is This Living Room Big Enough for My TV?
6. An ’Entertainment Device’ Is Expected From Google
7. Gadgetwise: How Sonos Outshines Apple in Home
Audio
8. The Piracy Problem: How Broad?
9. Pogue’s Posts: Things That Were Once Amazing
lO. Gadgetwise: A Compact Camera Whose Lens Isn’t
Go to Complete List ,,

pThe best in function and feature...out performes the iPod/pp
Pros: Good size display, easy to use interface, packed with features./pp
Cons: EXPENSIVE! expensive, expensive./p
Read More on CNET ,,

http://www.nytimes.com/technology/personaltech/music-players/iRiver-U 10-1GB-/314321... 2/12/2012
SAMNDCA00326325

iRiver U10 (1GB) - NYTimes.com

2_.Inyoury
Oct 25, 2005
06:36 am
Rating:
OOOO{

Page 2 of 2

pAwesome once you can get movies on it/pp
Pros: Small, Sleek, Sexy and what a sereen/pp
Cons: Storage is a bit small/p
Read More on CNET ,,

Enian
Oct 24, 2005
07:02 am
Rating:
OOOe~

pU guys should know about THIS!!/pp
Pros: compact, multiful, good inteffaee/pp
Cons: none except small eapaeity/p

What you get for ... $900,000
ALSO IN REAL ESTATE ,,

Read More on CNET ,,

Off the grid in the city
An Olympic plethora of London homes
Read all user reviews on CNET ,,

nytJmes.ont

REAL ESTATE

Similar Products
See all ,,

GET A FREE NOOK m,,~a,,~,k~_
S+MPLE TOUCH .... I

m
iRiver Clix

iRiver Clix

Sanlsung
Galaxy Player
5.0

SanDisk Sansa
Clip Zip

Ads by Google

n,~.1

V’,~en you sign up fera one-year ~l
NOOK subscription to The Times. ~ ]

iRiver LPlayer

what’s this?

Online Jobs Earn $1000+
Enter simple contests & Earn Money. Take home $1000+ cash prizes!
www.prizes.org
i-i-r Tech - Official Site
Associate, Bachelor Degree Programs Browse Programs Now & Learn More.
www.ITT-Tech.edu
Free Online Advertisinq
See What $75 of Google Ads Can Do For Your Business. Try It Now!
www.Google.com/AdWords

Home

World

U.S. ~ Business Technolo.gJL Science Health Sports .O,oinion Arts Stve Travel Jobs Real Estate AutosSite MaD

© 2012 The New York Times Company Pr vacv Your Ad Choices Terms of Service Terms of Sale Corrections RSS He~ Contact Us Work for Us Advertise

http://www.nytimes.com/technology/personaltech/music-players/iRiver-U 10-1GB-/314321... 2/12/2012
SAMNDCA0032 632 6

iRiver U10 (1GB) - NYTimes.com

Page 1 of 2

Log In Register Now
"OMEPAGE I TODAY SPAPER I V’DEO i MOST POPULAR I T’MESTOP’CSI
Search All NYTimes.com

[llt.~’CW [~erk $im~

Personal Tech

Sunday, February .......
WORLD

[ I]N.G IL DIEE(T],

~0

U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEALTH SPORTS OPINION

ARTS

STYLE

TRAVEL

I

JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS

Delight yourself in the LORD and he will give
you the desires of your heart. - Psalms 37:4

Christian & Single?
Advertise on NYTimes.com
PERSONAL TECH > MUSIC PLAYERS > IRIVER U10

RELATED ARTICLES
BITS; Apple Introduces Tools to (Someday) Supplant
Print Textbooks
Amid an Avalanche ofiPad Apps, the Best of 2Oll App Smart

iRiver UlO (1GB)

HOUSES OF THE HOPEFULS:
TAKE A LOOK AT THE G.O.P.
CANDIDATES’ HOMES)

l
NYTIMES.COM STYLE
Get DealBook by E-Mail
REVIEWS WHERE TO BUY

n
PRICE RANGE

CNET Rating
¯ 444,:’;,

$100.00

See All Stores on CNET ,,

Average CNET User’s Rating
44O i
Read All User Reviews on CNET ,,

--

Sign up for the latest financial news delivered before the
opening bell and after the market close¯
Sign Up
]
See Sample I Privacy Policy

Subscribe
THEGOOD

Wonderfully sleek and stylish design; unique and intuitive interface;
supports OGG files and subscription content; includes FM radio, voice
recorder, alarm clock, and SRS Wow sound effects; photo, video, and
text viewing; great battery life.

Personal Tech
Pogue’s Post

Gadgetwise

FOLLOW US ON
Twitter

MOST POPULAR-TECHNOLOGY
E-MAILED BLOGGED

THEBAD

Expensive; maximum capacity is 1GB; no autoplay; no album art; useful
cradle is sold separately.

1. Traveling Light in a Time of Digital Thievery
2. Start-Ups Seek to Help Users Put a Price on Their
Personal Data

THE BOTP0M
LINE

The pricey iRiver Ulo is a superbly designed MP3 player that is both

3. Bits: Scientific Agency to Drop BlackBerw for iPhone
4. App Smart : Flirting Tips for the Tongue-Tied, or the
Simply Shy

easy to use and packed with pretty much every feature in the book. But
Apple won’t be quaking in its boots until iRiver ups its capacity to 2GB
and 4GB.
© 2012 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. Used by permission.
Read Full Product Review on CNET ,,

User Reviews
Average Users Rating: .I OO" i" i’

1_. jasonbeckett
Oct 20. 2005
09:02 am
Rating:
ooe4(

5. Is This Living Room Big Enough for My TV?
6. An ’Entertainment Device’ Is Expected From Goggle
7. Gadgetwise: How Songs Outshines Apple in Home
Audio
8. The Piracy Problem: How Broad?
9. Pogue’s Posts: Things That Were Once Amazing
lo. Gadgetwise: A Compact Camera Whose Lens Isn’t
Go to Complete List ,,

pThe best in function and feature...out performes the iPod/pp
Pros: Good size display, easy to use interface, packed with features./pp
Cons: EXPENSIVE! expensive, expensive./p
Read More on CNET ,,

http://www.nytimes.com/technology/personaltech/music-players/iRiver-U 10-1GB-/314321... 2/12/2012
SAMNDCA00326327

iRiver U10 (1GB) - NYTimes.com

2_.Inyoury
Oct 25, 2005
06:36 am
Rating:
OOOO{

Page 2 of 2

pAwesome once you can get movies on it/pp
Pros: Small, Sleek, Sexy and what a sereen/pp
Cons: Storage is a bit small/p
Read More on CNET ,,

Enian
Oct 24, 2005
07:02 am
Rating:
OOOe~

pU guys should know about THIS!!/pp
Pros: compact, multiful, good inteffaee/pp
Cons: none except small eapaeity/p

What you get for ... $900,000
ALSO IN REAL ESTATE ,,

Read More on CNET ,,

Off the grid in the city
An Olympic plethora of London homes
Read all user reviews on CNET ,,

nytJmes.ont

REAL ESTATE

Similar Products
See all ,,

GET A FREE NOOK m,,~a,,~,k~_
S+MPLE TOUCH .... I

m
iRiver Clix

iRiver Clix

Sanlsung
Galaxy Player
5.0

SanDisk Sansa
Clip Zip

Ads by Google

n,~.1

V’,~en you sign up fera one-year ~l
NOOK subscription to The Times. ~ ]

iRiver LPlayer

what’s this?

Online Jobs Earn $1000+
Enter simple contests & Earn Money. Take home $1000+ cash prizes!
www.prizes.org
i-i-r Tech - Official Site
Associate, Bachelor Degree Programs Browse Programs Now & Learn More.
www.ITT-Tech.edu
Free Online Advertisinq
See What $75 of Google Ads Can Do For Your Business. Try It Now!
www.Google.com/AdWords

Home

World

U.S. ~ Business Technolo.gJL Science Health Sports .O,oinion Arts Stve Travel Jobs Real Estate AutosSite MaD

© 2012 The New York Times Company Pr vacv Your Ad Choices Terms of Service Terms of Sale Corrections RSS He~ Contact Us Work for Us Advertise

http://www.nytimes.com/technology/personaltech/music-players/iRiver-U 10-1GB-/314321... 2/12/2012
SAMNDCA00326328