Google Inc. v. Rockstar Consortium US LP et al

Filing 72

RESPONSE (re 67 MOTION to Transfer Case or, in the Alternative to Stay ) Opposition of Google Inc. to Rockstar's Renewed Motion to Transfer or Stay This Action filed byGoogle Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Kristin J. Madigan, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Exhibit 8, # 10 Exhibit 9, # 11 Exhibit 10, # 12 Exhibit 11, # 13 Exhibit 12, # 14 Exhibit 13, # 15 Exhibit 14, # 16 Exhibit 15, # 17 Exhibit 16, # 18 Exhibit 17, # 19 Exhibit 18)(Warren, Matthew) (Filed on 5/23/2014)

EXHIBIT 16

Table C-5.
U.S. District Courts—Median Time Intervals From Filing to Disposition of Civil Cases
Terminated, by District and Method of Disposition,
During the 12-Month Period Ending June 30, 2013
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

TOTAL
199,639
8.5
43,581 5.0 129,022
8.6 24,261
12.6
2,775
23.7

DC
1,943
9.0 776
7.3
1,111
10.3 12
34.6 44 43.0

1ST
5,385
10.5
1,100 3.7
2,927 11.4
1,257
15.2
101
30.1
ME
357
7.5
141
5.9
196
8.6
18
17.4
2
MA
2,472
8.4
646
3.0
791
7.2
974
15.1
61
31.1
NH
454
8.4
89
3.3
186
5.6
168
13.8
11
18.3
RI
1,121
27.9
80
6.7
998
31.1
32
14.3
11
40.4
PR
981
12.7 144
6.4 756
13.1 65
20.7 16 29.5

2ND
18,348
8.8
3,806 5.2
10,594
8.5
3,615
12.2
333
32.2
CT
1,655
10.6 834
8.3 707
11.3 69
16.5 45 38.4
NY,N
1,160
11.9
239
5.2
585
12.3
304
16.0
32
28.8
NY,E
5,624
8.8
1,210
5.8
3,152
8.3
1,158
12.1
104
30.5
NY,S
8,270
8.3
1,162
4.2
4,924
7.3
2,046
11.5
138
29.2
NY,W
1,370
8.0
326
2.8
1,001
9.8
32
37.4
11
68.0
VT
269
8.8 35
4.0
225
9.2 6
- 3
3RD
24,469
9.4
2,523 3.9
18,088 10.1
3,557
11.7
301
26.9
DE
1,264
8.0 452
4.7 686
9.0 82
11.6 44 33.0
NJ
5,953
6.1
528
3.8
3,368
3.5
1,994
13.0
63
35.6
PA,E
13,614
15.1
583
3.2
11,598
18.0
1,318
9.4
115
17.5
PA,M
1,483
7.1 459
4.4 924
7.8 61
18.6 39 28.7
PA,W
1,918
6.2 360
2.8
1,502
7.1 37
24.3 19 27.0
VI
237
17.8 141
13.1 10
31.0 65
19.2 21 31.9

4TH
12,387
7.5
2,331 5.5
8,367
7.2
1,505
10.2
184
19.2
MD
3,196
7.8
429
6.7
2,131
6.2
582
12.9
54
27.9
NC,E
1,086
8.9
324
7.8
748
9.4 7
- 7 NC,M
573
11.4
364
10.1
172
12.9
26
19.1
11
21.4
NC,W
906
8.1 291
5.0 510
8.8 90
12.8 15 25.2
SC
2,359
8.9
252
3.9
1,949
9.0
128
12.0
30
21.5
VA,E
2,354
5.2
332
3.2
1,387
4.3
588
7.8
47
11.9
VA,W
682
7.1
183
3.0
436
8.5
54
9.6
9
WV,N
394
8.3 99
6.1
285
9.0 7
- 3 WV,S
837
7.5
57
2.9
749
7.6
23
19.0
8
-

Page 1 of 3

Table C-5. (June 30, 2013—Continued)
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

5TH
22,882
10.7
5,168 5.7
15,502 12.0
1,880
13.3
332
21.6
LA,E
6,273
26.0
176
1.1
5,147
31.1
894
14.5
56
19.9
LA,M
596
11.4 169
9.7 381
11.3 32
17.4 14 34.7
LA,W
1,366
12.6 496
8.8 781
14.1 51
20.5 38 26.2
MS,N
606
10.4
208
7.6
229
10.6
158
14.1
11
28.5
MS,S
1,442
10.1 723
7.9 668
11.4 28
20.1 23 18.4
TX,N
3,311
6.7
600
5.6
2,661
6.8
2
-
48
21.3
TX,E
2,523
8.3 622
6.5
1,830
8.6 30
20.5 41 25.5
TX,S
4,474
7.2
1,456
4.1
2,374
8.3
588
9.5
56
21.3
TX,W
2,291
7.3 718
6.2
1,431
6.9 97
17.0 45 19.5

6TH
16,534
8.9
5,017 4.7
7,646
8.9
3,682
12.6
189
25.5
KY,E
1,056
9.0
157
4.4
866
9.0
22
23.6
11
28.0
KY,W
1,124
8.1 310
4.3 761
8.9 43
13.7 10 36.2
MI,E
4,453
7.7
1,044
3.2
1,592
5.3
1,776
13.2
41
21.4
MI,W
1,134
7.3
211
2.0
652
7.3
256
12.3
15
21.8
OH,N
2,939
8.5
881
4.1
1,252
11.7
783
10.1
23
24.7
OH,S
2,228
9.8
858
5.2
687
11.0
653
12.9
30
33.6
TN,E
1,247
10.3
616
5.6
492
12.2
116
14.8
23
22.3
TN,M
1,249
10.7 241
14.6 978
10.0 10
19.3 20 25.9
TN,W
1,104
10.9 699
10.1 366
11.1 23
22.8 16 22.8

7TH
15,706
7.6
4,374 5.5
8,904
7.0
2,224
12.6
204
26.7
IL,N
8,791
6.7
2,450
5.8
5,539
6.3 694
11.2 108 28.6
IL,C
769
9.3
321
6.9
428
10.5
5
-
15
41.2
IL,S
1,106
10.7 482
10.9 590
10.3 12
26.3 22 24.5
IN,N
1,312
10.0
369
3.5
445
8.7
479
16.4
19
29.5
IN,S
2,038
8.8
305
3.4
933
6.6
790
12.4
10
32.1
WI,E
1,030
6.7 224
3.2 767
7.2 23
16.3 16 18.2
WI,W
660
6.1
223
2.6
202
6.4
221
11.0
14
14.5

8TH
13,885
12.2
4,853
7.4
7,943
13.6 915
13.3 174 21.9
AR,E
4,108
46.7
1,017
47.0
3,056
46.6
4
-
31
18.8
AR,W
877
11.7
126
10.3
733
11.8
2
-
16
19.8
IA,N
413
9.9
82
8.5
318
9.8
2
-
11
22.2
IA,S
503
8.2
84
4.3
304
7.1
102
14.6
13
22.1
MN
2,836
5.6
1,357
2.5
721
5.6
736
12.5
22
24.7
MO,E
2,269
10.6
1,076
9.4
1,150
11.1 10
19.8 33 22.4
MO,W
1,970
9.4 945
5.5 957
11.3 45
15.6 23 20.3
NE
507
8.7
40
2.4
438
9.0
11
17.8
18
23.3
ND
173
8.4 10
1.1
160
8.5 1
- 2 SD
229
12.4
116
11.8
106
12.7 2
- 5 -

Page 2 of 3

Table C-5. (June 30, 2013—Continued)
No Court Action
Total Cases

Before Pretrial

Court Action
During or After Pretrial

Trial

Median
Median
Median Median Median

Number
Time Interval
Number Time Interval Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval
Number
Time Interval

Circuit and District
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months
of Cases
in Months

9TH
34,127
6.9
9,122 4.6
21,676
7.0
2,879
13.4
450
23.1
AK
256
9.0 49
5.2
198
9.2 2
- 7 AZ
2,380
7.2
105
2.4
2,090
7.1
156
14.6
29
25.4
CA,N
4,934
6.6
781
3.7
2,662
4.9
1,441
12.2
50
27.5
CA,E
2,906
8.8
1,068
6.0
1,754
10.3 62
17.4 22 31.5
CA,C
11,987
5.6
4,106
4.9
7,576
5.8 143
16.6 162 20.4
CA,S
2,321
6.6
343
3.4
1,223
5.2
724
13.2
31
26.5
HI
685
9.6 340
7.1 281
9.3 45
19.6 19 11.7
ID
493
9.9
42
1.6
366
9.8
74
18.1
11
28.1
MT
458
8.6
163
3.9
172
8.5
112
14.0
11
19.0
NV
2,159
8.8 348
5.3
1,703
9.2 81
8.3 27 39.9
OR
1,798
10.2
631
7.3
1,124
11.2
8
-
35
20.2
WA,E
742
10.0
298
5.2
426
13.0 9
- 9 WA,W
2,955
6.2 821
2.4
2,083
7.7 14
16.2 37 20.1
GUAM
26
16.8 6
- 14
18.4 6
- 0 NMI
27
32.1 21
21.1 4
- 2
- 0
10TH
8,535
8.5
2,314 5.4
5,038
8.5
1,015
13.8
168
23.1
CO
2,611
6.3
817
4.2
1,606
6.3
125
18.0
63
22.7
KS
1,272
7.8
378
5.0
772
8.0
102
18.5
20
25.8
NM
910
8.9
345
6.9
358
9.3
189
11.9
18
25.4
OK,N
739
11.9
56
3.3
656
12.2
18
21.8
9
OK,E
384
11.3
209
11.0
161
11.2
10
14.3
4
OK,W
1,178
8.9
280
3.9
470
8.5
406
12.1
22
18.7
UT
1,232
11.0 161
6.8 963
10.8 84
21.5 24 39.1
WY
209
10.8
68
5.9
52
6.8
81
12.6
8

11TH
25,438
7.3
2,197 3.9
21,226
7.2
1,720
12.7
295
19.3
AL,N
2,576
8.6 78
2.5
2,441
8.5 25
25.9 32 20.9
AL,M
650
9.9 59
2.8 536
9.6 43
16.9 12 20.8
AL,S
568
8.0
110
2.8
439
8.3
12
16.5
7
FL,N
1,378
6.7
43
2.3
1,315
6.8
8
-
12
22.9
FL,M
8,004
10.8
441
4.7
7,351
10.9
129
18.5
83
20.0
FL,S
6,772
5.0
586
3.7
5,997
5.0
82
12.0
107
16.3
GA,N
4,171
6.7
440
2.6
2,298
5.0
1,408
11.6
25
24.9
GA,M
753
9.3
239
6.1
503
10.8
1
-
10
20.8
GA,S
566
8.1
201
6.6
346
9.6
12
26.4
7
NOTE: Median time intervals are not computed when fewer than 10 cases reported. This table excludes land condemnations, prisoner petitions, deportation reviews, recovery of overpayments, and enforcement of judgments.
Includes cases filed in previous years as consolidated cases that thereafter were severed into individual cases. For fiscal years prior to 2001, this table included data on recovery of overpayments and enforcement of judgments.

Page 3 of 3