AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR TESTING AND MATERIALS et al v. PUBLIC.RESOURCE.ORG, INC.
Filing 198
MOTION for Summary Judgment by AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR TESTING AND MATERIALS, AMERICAN SOCIETY OF HEATING, REFRIGERATING, AND AIR-CONDITIONING ENGINEERS, INC., NATIONAL FIRE PROTECTION ASSOCIATION, INC. (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum in Support, # 2 Appendix A, # 3 Statement of Facts, # 4 Annex A, # 5 Declaration Jane W. Wise, # 6 Exhibit 1-29, # 7 Exhibit 30-44, # 8 Exhibit 45-66, # 9 Exhibit 67-81, # 10 Exhibit 82-109, # 11 Exhibit 110-125, # 12 Exhibit 126-140, # 13 Exhibit 141-148, # 14 Exhibit 149, # 15 Exhibit 150 Part 1, # 16 Exhibit 150 Part 2, # 17 Exhibit 150 Part 3, # 18 Exhibit 150 Part 4, # 19 Exhibit 150 Part 5, # 20 Exhibit 150 Part 6, # 21 Exhibit 150 Part 7, # 22 Exhibit 150 Part 8, # 23 Exhibit 150 Part 9, # 24 Exhibit 150 Part 10, # 25 Exhibit 150 Part 11, # 26 Exhibit 150 Part 12, # 27 Exhibit 150 Part 13, # 28 Exhibit 150 Part 14, # 29 Exhibit 150 Part 15, # 30 Exhibit 151 Part 1, # 31 Exhibit 151 Part 2, # 32 Exhibit 151 Part 3, # 33 Exhibit 152 Part 1, # 34 Exhibit 152 Part 2, # 35 Exhibit 152 Part 3, # 36 Exhibit 152 Part 4, # 37 Exhibit 152 Part 5, # 38 Exhibit 153 Part 1, # 39 Exhibit 153 Part 2, # 40 Exhibit 154-156, # 41 Exhibit 157, # 42 Exhibit 158, # 43 Exhibit 159, # 44 Exhibit 160, # 45 Exhibit 161, # 46 Exhibit 162, # 47 Exhibit 163, # 48 Exhibit 164-173, # 49 Declaration James S. Thomas and Exs. 1-9, # 50 Declaration James Pauley, # 51 Exhibit A-V, # 52 Exhibit W-OO, # 53 Declaration Stephanie Reiniche and Exs. 1-2, # 54 Declaration Christopher Butler, # 55 Text of Proposed Order Proposed Order and Injunction)(Fee, J.). Added MOTION for Permanent Injunction on 10/8/2019 (ztd).
4? -Q=Eÿ4 C@-<9@4ÿ:4-@6 M6- @J T < ÿ 45 9 :-J j 45 6 c @ @6< G 4 ? : = +C < 6 H >= 5 = ? :ÿ : 56964ÿ44=ÿ68IhIi() +J = 9:ÿ 8-; @ÿ@ 8d h I * ÿ 2 3 .X ÿ | 3' % !! z{ "/ # 0 2 ÿ7ÿ9 11 2 6 8ÿ 2 7 ÿ 1ÿ58 ÿ 5 ÿ 2 79 ÿ 76 46 1 8 14 4 ÿ54 6 2 266 7ÿ5 ÿ ÿ 6 ÿ 2 ÿ < >:? ÿ =ÿ < :;;ÿ ÿ @ :A ?B C?Dÿ=ÿ BFE G < < >=C?E ÿG &9@ / 5=ÿ-B <> >6 165 6 -2 5&5&2 6 = ÿ <2?1 >. A 1= 5- ÿ.5 78 4 ÿ 1 4 . - & @ 2/.. C4 ÿ@ /.. ÿ6 9-ÿ9ÿÿ-ÿ 6ÿ ÿ< 8- . 955=ÿ --1 95=3 <&&/-/; ?2 16&8 17- 2 # 62 -52 =529/ÿ0E!F 86 97& D&5 ÿ -. 1/ ÿ EGÿ9=/ C .. 1 H 3ÿ6 9-53< -I /43 <&ÿ 1> & . " 1= 5- ÿ/.. ÿ6 12ÿ 2ÿ5- ÿ- .2/5.A -B <> >2 55=3 78--J5 :> 6> 76 &92 & @ 9 4 6 3-;52A6 38ÿ9&./5.A //&- 2ÿ. ÿ1&/5& 4 31 &ÿ .- 2 -- 22 &ÿ 2ÿ4 -&/ >=6&9 &3 8 6 > E . 5ÿ 2 / 27/5=/ 5= 4 3 G-232ÿ8 .&3-&<ÿ6 12 .6ÿ6 9-/ >8 &5= 95 /-< 6 ÿ<3&B1 78-5 ÿB <&ÿ. ÿ/&. L 3 6 3 &6-6 ÿ -M 5C 3 9ÿ.2 ÿ &/ :.- 95=G- 29# -HS/.. ÿ .-ÿ 6 5-ÿ> / 3> ÿ 8 B/<-ÿ /ÿ26 ÿ-ÿ81/.. ÿ1.A93ÿ/.. ÿ9=-& - 29&2 2-ÿ <&2 ÿ 95=8/ &ÿ/;1 95=86 9& 4 1? < 2 / >3 785.-ÿ. ÿ .98 9& . ÿ6 1 3A >9 ÿ 62C / / <ÿ Tÿ (ÿ ' R # -U2-ÿ-91< G6 9-8 3/ -53< -ÿ16ÿ -B1J5= 4 ÿ 4 9 26- 7ÿ <&ÿ/;= ÿ 1> &/1B4 ÿ 1 . V . ÿ 2 66 G6 / . ? 3 <&&ÿ <&&/-/&ÿ:50-5>:> /1C 6 9-C 9-ÿ9ÿ16//1 1ÿ 55< 1 !:/5.W -ÿ /5I .91 93> 9/.. ÿ . 1 52 ÿ< 1 1?ÿ 26ÿ 6 - <-ÿ955=X< >6 E< 2 G6 V !:/5.W -ÿE< 1?G6 26ÿ93> 9&ÿ ÿ -:52 ÿ< 1ÿ /5ÿ .91 6 - <-I U:95J 6 @ 2 V !. Y- -/ÿ< 1 . 1= . 91 -ÿ >5 W Z/ . V 95-[--2 . /2 12ÿ 235 3 6 \/-ÿ 235. 29 -2 [- 6 W1/5.H <8 . 592 ÿM 57- 2 26 $590/ÿ ./ . 2 .[--2 . 36 51 275/5 ÿ 235 G6 6 6 W/4V 52" 785=/ >#&ÿ8 37- & 1&ÿ6.I / 1 ÿ. ÿ-2 -5 . ÿ . " W/4V 52V- //5.ÿ-532 ./ >$/.- / 3ÿB 1&ÿ6.I 98 92 A 9 /5 ÿ. ÿ 52. .-6 ÿ 6]L 6 !8 //< 8 92& W/4V 52H8/ /5./ >#9 . 1= 1&ÿ6.ID1. 2 ÿ. ÿ-7566 ? ÿ 6 W/4V 52!8 //<ÿ. ÿ D19ÿM 57- 2 1&ÿ6.I 8 92&/ >!<5/?H <8 . ÿ 5 W/4V 52 . 1I.1> &/1ÿ1&ÿ6.ÿ6 9-ÿ&1&ÿ6.ÿ >-ÿ3< -ÿ1_W/4V 52 <&&12> X< ^ ÿ 3 5 / 60: [`a 5. ÿ6. aÿ 1-V 52 !.5 [_ cH-25/ÿ . <25 b ÿ139 1 > 352 3 G6 :? [_ ` \/-ÿ. ÿ- 5 .ÿ .- 2 cÿ 29 >" >7- 2 2. / G6 [` ÿ5-/ 52 _ `W1 901? 2 5 [` ÿ5-/ 52 _W1 901? 2 5 [d `ÿ 29 - //5. a -ÿ 8 92 \/ " 6 ÿ e ÿ fÿ R #ÿ9:- /> 76:95.6ÿÿ6 9-ÿ1;4 9C 68-5Jÿÿ- ÿ-&6 ÿB 3 <&A 5 ÿ-/ 33 ÿ a - 9 .5-&0352 .B9 ÿ5=-g&9 1ÿ5 ÿ /ÿ 1 ÿ< &9 5 ÿ ÿ". 1@ -ÿ ?:/ ? 6. 86 6 / U. <-. 7-8 &J6>ÿ- <9&529-ÿ3-& &9/ F/& 9C M 5 ÿ -. 2 3&C h -. / W 9 95=B9 1@ -ÿ3-&6ÿ 9 9ÿB9 2 .ÿ1/6ÿ 5. ÿ ÿ 2g&9 3&ÿ96ÿ -567/5 A - & 8 3 6 $< 5 / B 76 . 6 8 3ÿ 3 ./2/-ÿ--6ÿ/1@d@ci!" $C 6 23ÿ 1&4 9ÿ9 1a di @ # & ÿ + , 'Q ÿ l , jk ( a - 9 .5-&0352 .B9 ÿ5=-g&9 1ÿ5 ÿ /ÿ 1 ÿ< &9 5 ÿ ÿ". 1@ -ÿ ?:/ ? 6. 86 6 / U. <-. 7-8 &J6>ÿ- <9&529-ÿ3-& &9/ F/& 9C M 5 ÿ -. 2 3&C h -. / W 9 95=B9 1@ -ÿ3-&6ÿ 9 9ÿB9 2 .ÿ1/6ÿ 5. ÿ ÿ 2g&9 3&ÿ96ÿ -567/5 A - & 8 3 6 $< 5 / B 76 . 6 8 3ÿ 3 ./2/-ÿ--6ÿ/1@d@ci!" $C 6 23ÿ 1&4 9ÿ9 1a di @ # & ÿ V5-ÿ 9 I 3 ÿ p nq ÿ 0ÿ p nooÿ ÿ r ns qt uqvÿ0ÿ txw y p p 0uqw ÿypvz ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ !1 ÿ " /3ÿ 83ÿ2 { 1 - 942 5A5- ÿ 6 21 01 ÿ 67 8 ÿ 9ÿ ÿ 19ÿ 1 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ 23 5 1 9 5 5 8 5 9 5 13 5 ÿ1 5 ÿ ÿ 3 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 1 321 ÿ 1 9 5 3 ÿ1 2 ÿ 1 ÿ ÿ" 6 % 9ÿ33ÿ $ &9 ( 1ÿ 3ÿ*ÿ +, ' ÿ 3 '6' 9 ! #ÿ $ ÿ ÿ 3 % ÿ 3 9 '##ÿ ÿ 7 ' (1ÿ ##ÿ 9 1 1 . ÿ ÿ ÿ 6 6 1 ÿ 0 ) -3 1 / 0" 1 ÿ 6 " ! 2 EXHIBIT 9 01 3ÿ6 ÿ8 92ÿ 8 2 5 719 ÿ 8 ÿ 3 ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ 8 8 9ÿ 98 ÿ 9 2 3 39 ÿÿ 8 59 ÿ 9 !#ÿ')++ "$ ( * & ,- /ÿ #3 !4 . 02 ÿ# # 0 56 89ÿ " < !<ÿ= !# !@A" ="< ÿ#!4B D F:FE 7 :;#2 ="> @= # = ÿ#2 !!=3 #ÿC EBÿ ? D GHCHD :Gÿ NOÿ BNPFÿ NQ IJS :NU D JRÿBW BI JJCÿ J K BG J:J:G K R ÿ QGTF SC V F KLM I ÿ F I C B : U KG R JB ÿCJBGDCC *I ÿDCC ÿK NBÿNÿÿBÿ Kÿ QS SK F ÿ JJRÿ BG JJRH Q::DBDP TG FK CN 7 N :M FLB G X:JRJGNDÿEY5Z MK NL: Q MB Cÿ JG ÿ BC FD ÿ Y[ÿNRD * B CC F \ HÿK NBJHQ B] DIH Q:ÿ FS : C 6 FR JB ÿDCC ÿK FGÿ GÿJB ÿB CGDJCV BW QS SG JJRH LMBB^J OS KS LK :NG : U N I K B HBPJGVK HMÿN:CDJCV DD:B GÿC ÿF:DJ: I HF :ÿ CB G BB GG :ÿ GÿI B:D SRK:N :H M K S _ OB ` Jÿ GÿQK GÿNSC BJ^ÿQa^J D GLDJRD JR I H [BGHGÿM C:HB:QÿK FG CKÿDCC ÿ S F NJ DBQ K ÿQH:WF LMBJ ÿWNJJRLK QB b H K G ,3 ;ÿc# == ÿ =# A ?d < !@e# 0 D MK 5F56 8ÿCJBH Q::DBDDFEBE ÿQ :N G CK ÿ 7 :\ F 7 K F ÿK NBÿNÿOJ FÿT:EHJ J ÿC56 89ÿU ÿ C fDCC ÿ CB*I ÿUB NJR[B GN NOS :D OCB B NJR[B GN7 B\fDCC ÿ CBÿ K JBÿS D HS ÿ M I FT Q B G B WDQBÿ DÿGK ÿBÿMFDCC ÿFCVNHÿDCC ÿNRB: B GN:G GBÿ Q:G ÿ NJRMD :ÿDPF NJRMK N: D SH LMJCBÿC ÿ CNM N: C ÿK F HV SN ÿ KG* D D QB ÿ ,- /ÿ #e. 4 . 02 ÿ / # 0 7 JÿK NBÿK B:GBG:ÿ GK :GDÿBHJBC GI SE N I:H Q::H ONÿ ÿ G I Sÿ G :N ÿKHB UD I B LB I S E : J DGBG RKÿ GFHLDBJFÿTGB[I NTgJ FUB Lh LM Hÿ :J ÿW DFÿ GN :E ÿ ÿ DM ÿ LMBE D G C LB J D I G:ÿC ÿ BiK ÿD GBBUB LhBG7 BH Q:ÿK B:GB BG SG ÿ Sg CJONE D ÿ :*I ÿK NBH ONÿ D Ia H F G ÿ I G M G N G N` J LB Gÿ NG:ÿM HLB :ÿ :ÿNHS N:ÿ :ÿ M N:ÿ : B QN C:W ]BG BJ CVBG K B QBVBGB KGVBG B Kÿ : LDIC :ONTC ÿ DM ÿ DG HJBV MJC FBGM HLB HJBÿBJJR[I NTJ Hÿ IC :ÿ G Dÿ :ÿ BJ C W LM LD K K G : H C R NG CV BJC G CKÿ :ÿM HLB ÿN CDJCÿC K b QDJ :ÿ :R DJ ÿWBG BJ CKJ GG V S K S K G : B KD I E S GN CC ÿ BM NB G WI DÿDGNÿCGB:NDBKÿNP C BBLJJRG ÿBHCÿ ÿ B NNHQBK ÿ ÿQWHÿW K B I K: W J DGM HLB : LM Hÿ BJ C* : C iÿS JK VCKLDJCJÿNOS SK ÿ B:R JHCBKÿKHB U CD SG CÿWN G ÿ MK JB ÿCG ÿJCbD HÿW GI S J J K: I E NLM Hÿ :JRÿC ÿ GK :Kÿ DQJRGBHCBÿWGJB Dÿ DGBG V SLBI SÿW :N ÿ ÿB GN ÿN * J G CD LB C I K: P ÿ d <== ÿ 0. 4 # !@j/" k# I G F K lTGBB SKÿ JÿK NBT Q^JÿBD Fÿ ] ÿ ÿC ÿWI:H Q:ÿK ÿ FE ÿEBG mBBLJBGBJ DGGB RIKÿÿ GF GN C ÿ ÿ HÿNC GÿW LBD I LM : D nB JGI ÿP FK SKÿNG ÿDGNÿHQDBT NSHÿ BFBJ K ÿW JFW HQBDHNGF G J I E GB N \MDCGB[I NTD SiK ÿ :ÿM NDI : XFJÿ ÿ DM ÿC ÿ SG G MK HB I a BD 6 LLDJBGBMK B QDÿGMÿ ` J SGÿBBLJBGB Q N ÿ ÿNHS NF B :N QN ÿ S GN C ÿ aI : B BK I J D :NB ÿC NTKÿ GFHLDBJFÿTC GI SE NLM H EKE SB BR ÿW DFÿ GN :E ÿKHB ÿDÿ DG LB J D G:JR BG C ÿ ,/ != # o# " 5CK B^I ÿ Cÿ B\ pG:ÿ GK ÿN KC B :D T C ÿ KN :G ÿ( ÿ G I SKÿ ÿB SÿC Q I B LB ^I G: T Q Q S NGC JRKÿ BG:ÿ GK ÿC ÿK JJÿNM Nÿ C C B:D SC ÿWI ÿ G I SD SI ^ÿÿ MK BFN * G B LB ÿ e. 4ÿ =# 0 / #e. 0= iGK QG C CNS HJ K mB CGDJCqJB : LK :NG ÿ S K K nK B QDÿ GC : NHS NF FB rQ J sF:DT K:N mDD6 B G GÿI B YQa J _ WNCB ÿ GN F BBB HS8DBJ: D [BGHG NJ DB b ÿ t!# 4 o. nB DDJCKÿ M NG:g NG Cÿ]h NM NG ÿW DDQÿ DJ ] ' K 5M mQ K u ' 7:ÿB BDQB[K :S NG Cÿ NG Cÿ] h BG LM NGNÿ CJBDJ :g DJ ] +u 7 K mQ K ) [I NT7:ÿNHS Nÿ NG Cÿ]) DM ÿBG K B QBg DJ ] ( h n mQ K u ÿ e? ÿ= ÿ 0 "0 v4< oe# ! <# w [\ ]' Nÿmy x:ÿÿ ÿn *K ' H K [BGHG] HNJHGÿÿOJEBQ K ÿQH:WFK FG CK NJ DBÿ BG DBJDDF FÿM C:HB:Qÿ LMBJ ÿW b 5ÿ b : D GBH Q:ÿC ÿCz KÿJI NH NÿCGBBD I ÿK NBD SD ÿ+{ÿN R Bÿ KBK ÿ ÿXL* I : I ÿ |### "ÿ 0 !>ÿ "/ # } = #;<# <4~ >o o = 01 3ÿ6 2 57 ÿ 89 9 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ1 ÿ ! #$ÿ ÿ " % ' ÿ % & ( ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿ ! ) 3 ! ÿ ÿÿ,.-01 3% ÿ * ÿ + ,- 2 ÿ /9 1 34 ÿ 8 : 1 0 22 57 9;< = ( ÿÿ* ' ! ÿ ÿ 2 2 ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 01 3ÿ ÿ>* % ÿ ÿ ?2 @A =9ÿ 2 C..6 01 &0B 5 7D 1 ÿ DÿG E6 F ÿ V XTY ÿ Wÿ V TUUÿ Z T[ Y\ ]Y^ÿWÿ \`_ a V V XW]Y_ ÿaV^b ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ 0 ÿ 1 ÿ ÿ c * ) ÿ H ÿ 0 ÿ 1ÿ ÿ 1 ÿ J ÿ D ÿ D D ÿ ! I I 3 I I I I ÿ I ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ J *"! ÿ & & I $ ÿ ! D ÿ J *ÿ - ÿ6 -01 3% ÿ % 2 B M ÿ ÿÿ OJ, ) ÿ * * )0) - L .ÿ 2 ÿ ÿ *& $ÿ 3ÿ )..ÿ ÿ ) Mÿ ..ÿ > ÿ Kÿ ÿ 0& 01 ÿ H N D P J D Q +6 G ÿ 0 - 6 - -1
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.