AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC. et al v. PUBLIC.RESOURCE.ORG, INC.
Filing
89
REPLY to opposition to motion re #69 MOTION for Summary Judgment and Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment and Permanent Injunction, #60 MOTION for Summary Judgment Filed MOTION for Permanent Injunction (Plaintiffs' Reply in Further Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment and Permanent Injunction and Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment) filed by AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL RESEARCH ASSOCIATION, INC., AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION, INC., NATIONAL COUNCIL ON MEASUREMENT IN EDUCATION, INC.. (Attachments: #1 Plaintiffs' Statement of Material Facts in Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment, #2 Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendants' Statement of Disputed Facts, #3 Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Objections to Plaintiffs' Evidence, #4 Declaration of Nikia L. Gray, #5 Exhibit VVV, #6 Exhibit WWW, #7 Exhibit XXX, #8 Exhibit YYY, #9 Exhibit ZZZ, #10 Exhibit AAAA, #11 Exhibit BBBB, #12 Exhibit CCCC, #13 Exhibit DDDD, #14 Exhibit EEEE, #15 Exhibit FFFF, #16 Exhibit GGGG, #17 Exhibit HHHH, #18 Exhibit IIII, #19 Exhibit JJJJ, #20 Exhibit KKKK, #21 Exhibit LLLL, #22 Exhibit MMMM, #23 Exhibit NNNN, #24 Exhibit OOOO, #25 Exhibit PPPP, #26 Exhibit QQQQ, #27 Exhibit RRRR, #28 Exhibit SSSS, #29 Exhibit TTTT, #30 Exhibit UUUU, #31 Exhibit VVVV, #32 Exhibit WWWW, #33 Exhibit XXXX, #34 Exhibit YYYY, #35 Exhibit ZZZZ, #36 Exhibit AAAAA, #37 Exhibit BBBBB, #38 Exhibit CCCCC, #39 Exhibit DDDDD, #40 Exhibit EEEEE, #41 Exhibit FFFFF, #42 Exhibit GGGGG, #43 Exhibit HHHHH, #44 Exhibit IIIII, #45 Exhibit JJJJJ, #46 Exhibit KKKKK, #47 Exhibit LLLLL, #48 Exhibit MMMMM, #49 Exhibit NNNNN, #50 Exhibit OOOOO, #51 Exhibit PPPPP, #52 Exhibit QQQQQ, #53 Exhibit RRRRR, #54 Exhibit SSSSS, #55 Exhibit TTTTT, #56 Exhibit UUUUU, #57 Exhibit VVVVV, #58 Exhibit WWWWW, #59 Exhibit XXXXX, #60 Exhibit YYYYY, #61 Exhibit ZZZZZ, #62 Exhibit AAAAAA, #63 Declaration of Wayne Camara, #64 Plaintiffs' Objections to Defendant's Evidence, #65 Certificate of Service)(Hudis, Jonathan)
EXHIBIT ZZZZZ
Case No. 1:14-cv-00857-TSC-DAR
~ ~ 1~ Bookshare
Log in
fitle, author or- ISBN
Browse
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare for Me? •
Get Started •
Get Involved •
An Accessible Online Library
My Bookshare
S1gn up toda y
for people with print disabilities
Announcemems
Be a Part of Uterary History
Help Center •
More Search Categories
Go Set a Watchman is on Bookshare. Learn why
Find the books you want with so browse and
this is so cool and join the discussion!
~·
352,673 Titles
and Counting!
search categories!
Go Set a
Watchman Is Here!
GO 5tT A
Wr\ TCHt\1AN
EXHIBIT
Th1s proJect IS supported by th~ U.S Department of Education, Office of Special
Education Programs (Award Number H.327Dl20002) (}pinions eJqJre".aSed herein are
th"~ofthe
authors 1md do not nt!'c.~ri ly r~present tht! position of the U.S
Department of Educshon.
f
Yo a
illil!l
About
Partners
Legal
Privacy
Accessibility
Blog
Book:share8 and Benetech8 are registered trademarks of Beneficentlechnology,lnc. This website is If! Copyright 2002-2015, Beneficent Technology, Inc..
Donate
1
-~ l t~ Bookshare
Log in
Titte autho r or ISBN
Browse
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare for Me? •
Get Started·
Get Involved -
Help Center •
My Bookshare
About
.. Leadership
• Partners
• Su pporters
• Blog
• New s
• Legal
• Privacy
• Accessibility
Benetech
Programs
Bookshare1 is the wor1d"s largest accessible online library for people with pri nt disabilities.. More t han 320,000 people in nearly SO
countries have access to Bookshare's collection of over 300,000 t itles. More than 500 U.S. and international publishers contri bute t o our
social mission by donating their digital files, making it possible for Bookshare to serve users around the world and ensuring that
content is ava ila ble to people with print d isabilities at the same time as t hei r peers.
• Global literacy
• Human Rights
• Environment
• Benetech Labs
Other Global
Literacy Initiatives
• DIAGRAM C.,.,ter
• Route 66 Lit eracy
Bookshare is a Globa l literacy initiative of Benetech, a leading Silicon Valley-based nonprofit
technology company founded by Jim Fruchterman, a ,.,3cArthurAwafd.winning mci~l
entrepreneur and fo rmer rocket scientist Benetech uses technology to address pressing social
needs.. Its four programs-Global Uteracy, Human Rights, the Environment, and Benetech
Labs-measure success in t he number of lives ch a need for the better.
benetech
fiCHNOLOG'I'
5UVUIG HUMAIIII"
In add ition to Bookshare, Benetech's Globa l Literacy Program in dudes the DIAGRAM Center. a Research a nd Development Center
whose goal is t o dramatically change the way image and graphic content is produced and accessed and Route 66, an on line
instructional literacy program for adolescent and adult beginning reade ~ .
Bookshare o perates in the U.S. under a copyright exemption-the Chafee Amendment- which grants no nprofit organizations the
abil ity to make books available to people with print disabiliti es without publisher permission. Bookshare receives publisher pennission
to provide books to members outside t he U.S. a nd receives significant publisher cooperation in building its collection.
Thanks to fu nding fro m the U.S. Department of Educa tion, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), Bookshare is free fo r all
qualified U.S. students. Qualified individuals who are not students pay a nom ina l annual fee for their membersh ip. Our membershi p
partners may a lso cover part or all of the membersh ip fees.
f
You
lim
About
Partners
Legal
Privacy
Bookshare8 and Benetech• are registered trademarks of Beneficent Technology, Inc. This website is
Accessibility
Blog
e Copyright 2002-2015, Beneficent Technology, Inc.
Donate
2
~ '~ Books hare
Log in
Title. author or ISBN
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare for Me? -
Get Started-
Browse
Get Involved -
Help Center •
My Bookshare
Is Bookshare for Me?
.. Who Qualifies?
o What Does It Cost?
Booksharei opens up the world of reading fo r people with print disabi lities.
If you ca nnot read tra ditional print books because of a visual impairment, physical disability or severe learn ing disability, Bookshare
can help!
Our books a re "accessible," which means you can read our books many differen t ways.
Bookshare offers the world's largest collection of accessible titles. As a result. people of a ll ages. as well as schools and many
orga nizations around the globe can access the books they need for school, work, career adva ncment, skill development and the simple
love of reading in fonnats that work fo r them,
How can you read Bookshare books?
'" Listen to books with high qua litytext-t~speech
voices
• Hear and see highlighted words on screen
• Read with digital braille or enlarged fonts
• Create physical braille or large p rint
• Read directly from your lntemet browser
• A.nd more!
Who Qualifies?
f
e
What It Costs
$
Sign Up#'
Accessibility
Blog
You
iJI!l
About
Partners
Legal
Privacy
Bookshares and Benetech& are registered trademarks of BE!flefi cE!flt Technologyj Inc. This website is e Copyright 2002-2015, Beneficent Technology, Inc.
Donate
3
~ 1~ Books hare
Log in
Title, .author or ISBN
Advanced Search
Browse
Get Involved·
Is Bookshare for Me? •
Help Center •
My Bookshare
Get Started
o Sign Up!
t How to Find
Books
• How to Read Books
Get started with Bookshare8 ! In this section, you will sign
up and team how to read your first book.
Ready to stan.? Make sure you qualify for Bookshare, then
follow these steps.
Reaetent Authortties:
• nourokJsjst
•flmilydoctor
• psychi011trist
• l••mingdisabilityspeci0111ist
• spec.i.. leducation teilclwr
• schoolpsyrholotist
• clinical psycholosist with a background in learning disabilities
Other Disabilities
o
autiSm
• int•llectual disabilities
o
arterrdon deficit hyJ>(!~ctivirydisordftr (ADHD)
•hearing i05S
andpeopl• w hosefirstlanguOII~isnotEnaUshDONOTQUAUFYforBoobhatebu!don~critM'ia ~~tdvl.nn.,.f
&grMmtnts
tt.OIIt determine Boob ha~ llli£ibility.
liowwef, it is quit. possible that a person with one or morfl of these dW!bi&lies coukl st.Jll qua liFy lior Boob haRt bec:;n,se of an
accompanying print d i :H~bility For exampl-. a penon who is both de.ilf and b~11cl, or who has ADHD and signifk.ant dyllexiOII, coukl
qualify.
Frequently Asked Qualifications Questions
For more information on Booksflare's qualifiations. ~ad the frequ end' asked qualifications questions in the t-t.lp Cenler,
f
••
1111'1
Partners
Lepl
Privacy
Bookshare' and BellMech1 al'l! regiSU:aalt tnn\\td to Lha4 tdiFU~ UI'\CWrspeci.ll ~tion law 1n UM: U.S... don (fol~ lrfy v nct.r
tiHI~i,&htl.iwutm_ptil>n. otaU1-Uidwtawhh l ndividwiEd\IOdonPt.tm 1 1E~qu:~lify l01~t w..-lob.. roteum:p&e. •
dc•fst\l~t -M dl .a niEPwt-.o &.t&dinatcx~.at.,adotl4wi~Lcf.nocmc.t~tM<.09Yrisht ~olptiftt di.s.abilrty.wh.iliqu:tli!)ina
torolbttkNfccste~~ tD~fneu. Yttl m~ s.:~awltt\outiE.Psc;r504 plarti
(la tb.ttU,J "'l)'qU.11rf)'for •«H3unda'tha
c..opy.iJhl to.w o;J.)L~mptitm.
lht:~rds'Jitt int.httU.S..~t~\'6wfUchocnnilcoP)i"nslJnddf.wibuliondthbc-~ip utd~"-m.bo~p~QIJ!yto«rUin
spo<• itd_ol_pl.. ~q..UIHsundt-'d
~ b,. a copyrlaf!t ;r.trlr~l. lhus.. Sookahatwdootlt'lot ut tnt t'\llt::s fOt qu.alific.Jt~an. h
a "'W¥ ~poiUnt dut Boo:~Wurt
~th«M't'\11atotf\$.!.1.re~an(OntinU.toMIW~wltnd\41mott~pilllcan.t&sabaidnwbtn~~tal'1t~ft1:prif\!.
~ copyriah: t~w e:amocKln. Not lll ~NCIM.tl witb lndivid~l Eduction Pflru (lfh) QUatify ~ ~re Wf't'ic.,_ fO(cxa:rrrp&t. l
rrJdttewt\Jt'OI.IW,ot mcttt:h.-COP>~ ; dtf"Wrlonofpin,·d"tabif'cy, what qouaJif:,in.f
tor other~ r~b~~ lOde-a~ Yct.nwnylofudenU.""~'I[fi'f;or 304' »tam f1n the u.~ I'Nyq,u..t\fyfor ~ unllttlh.
d:u:f1o~t-Mth 1n JEP 'Nho is I'UdirtJ ~ tla 1n
C'OCII}"'~';Pt Llw ~W~mJWoa ,
Th.l .u and:lll'd.s Mt in. U,. I.LS.. Copyt1i)\t lAM wwl'lich petl'l"it ce.~ mAd- di:J.tr;butioft of' theM cop)"'i.atu.d ft\l.ttfiall .apply only to ccnoin
OIJ«iil
q~»ulico ...Ot<..., '""'"' An,..d..,onl f i711SC t ill!. "'01~
whld> -.kf
lloolo.h•••
wei>""'"-
otbtf'Wi:..e bela eoP'Y'Ii.Mt '"fril"'gtment. Thloli.. ~h:uo OOtS no:~ tht n.des for qu ~rJ!lc;t tion,. h D ~ tty ~t tha-t ~arc
i'f"_;P""CI t~fUf.esto •nwr • wec~tn cofllinu.e 10
n..,..~..,.,lth t.Mmoi.t.kpfont db.abi1idn'lllhcnh o;:rome) tor .-~&Pfl"1.
Thbc-oPJfiltlt l.tw' o~cion G 4 ~~ b~r&m wh:ch ttics to ~t..I"Cc 1M r~ ol peop~ who • t uMblc-t.o rlt.lld narm.:.lpnnt with
~~
Koncmk:ria}lt:
olpubld.~
)ft/'jouthou.. lti:t Mt~baud Of!~ ml~1 btMf.t from .acctit tO K<~ ~~ ... h.
~•.rfc.bo d14 ~mprlon m.::s IJ'O'lP a{ pe6pl4l wt'lo ~I'• :n.sumtd
(0
not be-'~ to :lett~\$ fVlUI~r pru, t tn:Jftti:ll~ boroi.4C of .1 J&Wrt
d~bi l ily. Publi:Wtt~d pinal cord injury, cereb1al palsy, traumatic brain injury, a neurological condition, etc,
Our Booksh:;ne team believesst1ongly in the value o r ac~b l e medi.i ror all students who might benefit from them, beyond those who
currently qualify under these copyright exttmptions. Booksh.are i5 working with domestic and international publi.shers to see if there is a
market model solution fo r t hese other students that provides publisl'w!t'!. and authors with compensation. We would like all mainstream
eboolcs sold to be accessible, and to see that all material that is born digit:aU born accessibly for aiLIt is also important that
yis
Sook.share continues to operate in careful compliance with copyright law to ensure that Bookshare can continue to serve students with
s.e'olere disabilities today. We look forward to the day when everybody who might benelit from acce!3ible materials has .access to them,
Thank you foryOtJr understanding.
Not exactly what you wanted?
• Qualifying Disabilities
Search the Help Centar: ' - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - '
Want to contact us? D ~
f
lou
illl!)
Bookshare• and
®
Benetech 11
About
Partners
legal
or \..Call Us 650.)5 2..0198
Privacy
are registered trademarks o t Ben eficent Technology, Inc.. This website is
Accessibility
Ill
Hours.: M· F 9·5 Pacific Time
Blog
e Copyright 2002-2015, Beneficent Technology,lnc
Donate
11
/
~ 1~ Bookshare
a.
Title, author or ISBN
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare for Me? •
Get Start&d •
Log in
Browse
Get Involved·
Help Center •
My Bookshare
What Does It Cost?
• Who Qualifies?
Learn about Membership Costs
o What Does It Cost?
Bookshare• is FREE for qualified U.S. students of any age and schools through an award from OSEP (Office of Spe<:ial Edue<~tion Programs, U.S. Department of Education). Non-students and other
organizations pay a low fee.
•
~
Jill.
-
Individual
• Other Organizations: S&-10 por book. (Learn more)
• Discounted fees available in some countries
Details
Details
•
•
•
•
Organization
• U.S. Schools: FREE
• U.S. Students: FRE E
• Other Individuals: SSO annually+ S25 setup
• Discounted fees available in some countries
For stud'l!n~ adults, sen iors, veterans and othe r individuals with print disabilities
Find an d read un limited books on your own
Access free reading tools
Membership Partners may provide sign up and payment assistance
• For schools, agencies, hospitals, senior centers, and organizations serving qualifi ed
individuals
• Sign up qualifiod mombo"
• Manage your member's accounts
• Find and get books for your members
• Access free reading tools for your members
Sign Up Individual
Sign Up Organization
f
About
Partners
legal
Privacy
Accessibility
Blog
Donate
Bookshare• and Benetech• are registered tra demarks of Beneficent Technology, Inc. This website is e Copyright2002-2015, Beneficent Technology, Inc.
12
::' ~ '" Books hare
Login
Tide, author or ISBN
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare For Me?
Get Started
Browse
Get Involved
Help Center
My Bookshare
My Bookshare
Welcome to My Bookshare!
You must Log In to use this page or Sign Up for a Bookshare account.
About
Partners
Legal
Privacy
Accessibility
Blog
Donate
Bookshare0 and Bonetoch• are rrwns with disabilities.
• Must bear a notice that any further reproduction or distribution in a fonnat other than a specialized fonnat is a n infringement.
• Must include a copyright notice identifying the copyrightownerand the date of the original publication.
• •specialized formats• means Braille. audio. o rdigiu l t.I:'Xt, which i:s ndusive-ly intended for use by blind or other persons with
disabilities..
Benetech's authorized ent ity status has been confirmed by the U.S. Department of Education, when it has made major grant awards for
Bookshare, which may only be made to an authorized entity.
You can rea d the full text of the Chafee Amendment in the next section.ln addition to books made available unde r the Chafee
Amendment, some publishers and authors have provided permission for books and other pu b~cations to be made available in
accessible digital formats to individ uals with qualifying disabilities in the U.S. and many other countries around t he world.
f
About
Partners
legal
Privacy
Booksharefl and Benetech8 are registered trademarks of Beneficent Technology, Inc. This website is
Accessibility
Blog
Donate
e Cop)'right2002-2015, BeneficentTedmology, Inc.
16
_~' '~~ Bookshare
,
0.
Title, author or ISBN
Advanced Search
Is Bookshare for Me? •
Get Started·
Log in
Browse
Get Involved·
Help Center •
My Bookshare
Digital Millennium Copyright Act ("DMCA")
Benetech respects the intellectual property rights of others
If you believe that any content on the Bookshare website infringes onG or more of your copyright rights, please notify our designated
agent by email, mail, or fax at the following address:
Bookshare, Director of Operc~tions
480 California Avenue, Soite 201
Palo Alto, CA 94301;.1609
Te~
(650) 644-3400
Fax: (650) 475-1066
Email: dmca-agent(at)bookshare.org
Your DMCA notice must include the following:
1. A physical or electronic signature of a person authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exdusive right that is. allegedly
inhingedi
2.. klentification of the copyrighted woric daimed to have been infringed, or, if multiple copyrighted works at a single onlifle site afe
covered by a single notification, a representative list of such works at that sitei
3. Identification of the material that is claimed to be infringing or to be the subject of infringing activity and that is to be removed or
access to which is to be disabled, and information reasonably sufficient to permit Benetech to locate the materia~
4. lnfonnation reasonably sufficient to permit Benetech to contact the complaining party, such as an address, telephone number,
and, if availableJ an electronic mail address at which the complaining party may be contacted;
5. A statement that the complaining party has a good faith belief that use of the material in the manner complained of is not
authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law; and
6. A statement that the information in the notificatK>n is accurate, and under penatty of perjury, that the complaining party is
authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right t11at is allegedly infringed.
Failure to include all of the above information may delay or prevent the
~ng of the
DMCA notice.
Benetech expects a ll users of tl1e Bookshare website to comply with applicable copyright Laws. Benetech will respond to notices of
alleged infringement that comply with the fonnalities of the DMCA, or if it otherwise becomes aware of facts and circumstances from
which infringement is apparent or likely, by remDVing or disabling access to material that is claimed to be infringing. Benetec.h will also
comply with the relevant proviSI'ons of the OMCA in the event that a counter-notification is received by its designated agent.
f
About
Bookshan!0
Partners
Legal
Privacy
and Benetech' are registered trademarlYJ the l)f«C'dul'ltS and "to:J:;u"b r d~ fol access to books tflat were originally developed by learning Ally. A Bookshare user
must register and supply a ~gned certification completed by an appropriate professional in the field of disability services educaOon,
medicine, psyct.alogyora related an!a. The certifier must bE! a recognized expert who can attQSI:to thi! physical basis that limits th-e
app~cant's use of standal"d print Appropriate certifying experts may differ from disabilityto disability. Fot"ex<~mple, in the case of
blindness and visual impairments, an approp riate certifier may be a physician, ophthalmologis~ or optometrist. In the case of a
perceptual disability, a neurologist, learning disability specialist, or a psychotogist with
a background in teaming disabilities may be the
most qualified certifying professional
In additioo, since any U.S. resident who has previously submitted a proof of disability to NLS (NationaiU~ry Service for the Blind and
Physically Handicapped of the Libr.tryof Congress) or learning Ally would qualify under the law, we have cooperative agreemen~
where NlS or l eamingAIIy will certify to us that he or she tlassuch proof on file already,
2. Contractual Agreement
All Bookstla~ usen. haw to agree to tenns of use that forbid violation of the copyright law restrictions on redistribution and use of
copyrighted material th.c:rJoh!Wv\ol:u••~ T
r::lml:li"iiiil tow thnir ~cuu~ Boobh.are .)nd ~W~~ lq;al. consequences as a
Ril41olt or 'hm lc:t!Qtu. o\ 11.11'~ (l ;ftl the publhl-.lqlr:MIIA!Iyh"rj lhtoppc.tunlty tboCIIW'Itrnlfnl Of'\. dM2 .II.If II!~ and Bookstlare
mad~
numerous changes in response to their concerns.
3. Copyright Notice
In order to comply with the copyrigtlt law regulating the provision o f xt*'-UbleboOb (O ptopl. v.i!h C~Pb'lm'~ Boobhare e!'lsures.
that all copyrighted materials bear a noticethatanyfurther~uction or distribution in afurmatother than 1 specialized fonnatis
an in fringement. Such content includes a copyright noti<:e identifying the copyright owner and the date of the origin;al publication.
In addition, other language reminds users or their obligations to U5e this material only •s permitted by their agreements with
Bookshare and the law. It a lso informs people who are not Bookshare U'I.Ci rl ~r lhl-1 ~ oll ~rt- d~sf1..1bo-o!( is a
t
violation cltho<"OI)).,.i.sht llollw 111"1d ~t th.ty$hoo..ld erase such a book without using or copying it. View the text of the Bookshare legal
Agreements.
4. Encryption
Bookshare encrypts a reque-sted book for a given user, and the files are delivered through secure/encrypted channels.
5. Fingerprint
All copyrighted material downloaded is fingerprinted as part of the encryption process so that the identity of the authorized user is
contained within the decrypted material in a difficult-to-find fashion. This way, if a user illegally redistributes material downloaded
from Bookshare, it is possible to confirm both that the materials came from Bookshare and wtlich user was responsible.
6. Security Database
All transactions, encryption codes and fingerprints are stored in a database enabling Bookshare to track any abuse to the source. For
more information on how we use this information, pf('-""" ~ our-8oolohor• ~er
por;ey..
7. Security Watch Program
Asecurity progr.am monitors all mnsactions and automatically limits AJ'ryuiotrwhoit account~• moti' than a fixed number of
titles in a given month (typically 100 titles) , Boolcshare regularly searches the web for illegal copies of content originating from
Bookshare user downloads, and suspends the accounts of users found to have been the source of such content Book:share also issues
take-down notices to the websites hosting such content.
f
®
About
Partners
Legal
Privacy
Bookshare' and Benetech• are registered trademarks of Beneficent Technology, Inc.. This website is
Accessibility
Blog
e Copyright 2002·2015, BenefiCent Tecllnology, Inc.
Donate
18
f'IIV~ Bookshare
Sign Up
~
eclnflnn Outthts .acooutl'l b fOr ~ peftoOn ~ .a Prini.OiubPy, .and -Mil bt . . . -~PmotofOQ;abiltcy ~ a. ~~
.
y.,
~.
Member Information
Please Gli.ur.,fro,mQt.lonabo.A thiiiMnoil W~t~o..ca beusinc Boabt\are•., ~penon isunckr the ace of 1&. only the
............
penon's pam'Jl