Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 159

RESPONSE/REPLY to 95 Affidavit, Supplemental Claim Construction Brief by Apple, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit Declaration of Christine Haskett, # 2 Exhibit #1- Hearing Transcript, # 3 Exhibit #2- Presentation, # 4 Exhibit #3- Contentions, # 5 Exhibit #4- EP0847654B1, # 6 Exhibit #5- Comparison, # 7 Exhibit #6- Translation, # 8 Exhibit #7- Rule 43)(Pace, Christopher)

EXHIBIT 5

Side-by-Side Comparison of Claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 5,754,119 and
Claim 1 of European Patent No. EP 0847654 B1
‘119 Patent, Claim 1

EP ‘654 Patent, Claim 1

A method of synchronizing message
information among a plurality of transceivers
comprising the steps of:

A method of synchronizing message
information (208) among a plurality of
transceivers (130, 150) comprising the steps
of:

transmitting by a wireless messaging
infrastructure a first message having a first
status;

transmitting (200) by a wireless messaging
infrastructure a first message (205) having a
first status;

in one transceiver of the plurality of
transceivers, changing the first status of the
first message to a second status responsive
to an input to the one transceiver, and
transmitting a second message indicative of
the second status;

in one transceiver (130) of the plurality of
transceivers, changing (220) the first status
of the first message to a second status
responsive to an input to the one
transceiver, and transmitting (235) a second
message (240) indicative of the second
status;

in the wireless messaging infrastructure,
in the wireless messaging infrastructure (110),
receiving the second message, and
receiving (245) the second message; and
responsive to receiving the second message,
characterised in that the method includes
transmitting a third message indicative of
the steps of
the second status; and
in the wireless messaging infrastructure,
responsive to receiving the second message,
transmitting (250) a third message (255)
indicative of the second status; and
in at least one other transceiver of the plurality
of transceivers, receiving the third message,
and responsive to receiving the third
message, changing the first status of the
first message to the second status.

in at least one other transceiver (150) of the
plurality of transceivers, receiving (265) the
third message, and responsive to receiving
the third message, changing (275) the first
status of the first message to the second
status.