Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 93

Defendant's MOTION Defendant and Counterclaim-Plaintiff Apple Inc.'s Claim Construction Brief by Apple, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Christine Saunders Haskett, # 2 Exhibit 1, # 3 Exhibit 2, # 4 Exhibit 3, # 5 Exhibit 4, # 6 Exhibit 5, # 7 Exhibit 6, # 8 Exhibit 7, # 9 Exhibit 8, # 10 Exhibit 9, # 11 Exhibit 10, # 12 Exhibit 11, # 13 Exhibit 12, # 14 Exhibit 13, # 15 Exhibit 14, # 16 Exhibit 15, # 17 Exhibit 16, # 18 Exhibit 17, # 19 Exhibit 18, # 20 Exhibit 19, # 21 Exhibit 20)(Pace, Christopher)

EXHIBIT 8

--08/459376

/rJ/~e

! r---5 --92

APPLICANTS:

Paulick, Tho mas E.

EXAMINER:

Pha m, C.

SERIAL NO.:

08/02S,234

GROUP:

2611

FILED:

February 25, 1993

ENTITLED:

Receiver Hav ing Concealed External
Ant enn a

CASE NO.:CE00802RW01

Motorola, Inc.
Cor pora te Offices
1303 E. Alg onq uin Road
Sch aum burg , IL 60196
June 2,1995
AM END ME NT and RESPONSE

Hon orab le Com mis sion er of
Pate nts and Tra dem arks
Was hing ton, D.C. 20231
Dea r Sir:
In resp ons e to the Office Action date
d December 2, 1994, the app lica nt
here by
sub mits the following ame ndm ent
and response.
Jn Th e~ :

c(

(Am end ed 8/26/94, 6/2/95) A com
bina tion radi otel eph one /pag er uni
t inc:;ol~._._.o
a use r inte rfac e, comprising:
a hou sing enclosing radi otel eph one
and pag er
y;
a radi otel eph one ante nna coupled
radi otel eph one circ uitr y; and
a pag er ante nna coupled
e pag er circuitrYi
whe rein the an ten na form
s a 100 surr oun diD at leas t a ortio
D of the
use r iDterfa
is disp osed betw een [the] an outs
ide surf ace of the hou sing and at
lea
orti on of the use r interfac~.

-1-

•• - . - - - -

• • • ---

._--.

- - . - - . _ _T "

_

.~,.;

\
\

987FH085

2.
(Amended 8/26/94) A combination radiotelephone/pager . according to
claim 1 further comprising a shield for shielding at least one the radiotelephone
.and pager circuitry.
3.
(Amended 8/26/94) A combination radio ephone/pager unit according to
claim 1 wherein the user interface further
prises at least one of the following: an
acoustic, a visual and a tactile interfac .
4.
A combination radiotele one/pager unit according to claim 3 wherein the
acoustic, visual and tactile' erface further comprises an electroacoustic
a switch, respectively.

5.
6.

A c bination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 1 wherein the
tenna is integrally formed with at least a portion of the user interface.

omprising:
a housing enclosing radiotelephone and pager circuit
a radiotelephone antenna coupled to the
.0 elephone circuitry;
a pager antenna coupled to t
ger circuitry and attached to an outside
surface of the housing;
a subst
lanar cover, attached to the outside surface of the housing, for
cone . g the pager antenna between the cover and the outside surface of the
ousing such that the antenna is unnoticeable to a user of the unit.
8.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 7 w
cover further comprises at least one of the following: a hand ., a keypad, a lens,
an escutcheon, a keypad and a cap.
9.
(Amended 8/26/94) A combin
radiotelephone/pager unit according to
claim 7 further comprising a .e d for shielding at least one of the radiotelephone
and pager circuitry.

-2-

987FH086

10.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 7 wherein the
pager antenna is disposed between the outside surface of the housing and the
11.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit according to claim
pager antenna is integrally formed with the cover.
12.
A combination radiotelephone/pager unit acc
pager antenna further comprises a loop anten
13.

A combination radiotelephone ger unit according to claim 12 further
lally surrounded by the loop antenna.

14.
A combinatio adiotelephone/pager unit according to claim 13 wherein the
user interface
her comprises at least one of the following: an acoustic, a visual
interface.
(Amended 8/26/94, 6/2/95)

16.
A receiver according to claim 15 wherein the user interface furth~
at least one of the following: an acoustic, a visual and a tactile in ertaCe.
17.
(Amended 6/2/95) A receiver according to clai
5] 16 wherein the acoustic,
visual and tactile interface further comprises a~ctroacoustic transducer, a
display and a switch, respectively.
18.

Canceled 8/26/94, with

prejudice.

19.
A receiver
ording to claim 15 wherein the antenna is integrally formed with
at least a
Ion of the user interface.

-3-

987FH087

(Amended 8/26/94, 6/2/95) A receiver comprising:
a housing;
receiver circuitry disposed in the ho,,~'i~-an antenna coupled to
ceiver circuitry a:od attached to an outside surface
of the housing; an
as
antiall lanar cover; attached to the outside surface of the housing, for
ealing the antenna between the cover and the outside surface of the housing such

~

t:h=a=t~t:h:e~a:n:t:e:n:n:a~l::'
s~u:n::n:o:t:ic::.:e:a::b:l~e.::to::..:a~u::s:e:r-.:o:f-.:th=e~[='t]~r=e=c=e=iv~e~r:,'
urn:·

---

[22] 21.
(Amended 6/2/95) A receiver according to claim 20 wherein the co~
further comprises at least one of the following: a hand grip, a keypad, a lens
escutcheon, a keypad and a cap.
[23] 22.
(Amended 6/2/95) A receiver according to claim 20 herein the
antenna is disposed between the outside surface of the hous' g and the cover.
[24] n.

(Amended 6/2/95) A receiver according

claim 20 wherein the

antenna is integrally formed with the cover.
[25]24.
(Amended 6/2/95) A receive
further comprises a loop antenna.

ccoi-ding to claim 20 wherein the antenna

[26] 25.
(Amended 8/26/ ,6/2/95) A receiver according to claim 24 further
comprises a user interfac substantially surrounded by the loop antenna.
[27] 26.
ded 8/26/94, 6/2/95) A receiver according to claim [26] 25 wherein
the user inte ce further comprises at least one of the following: an acoustic, a
a tactile interface.

REMARKS

All claims originally filed have been reproduced for the examiner's
convenience during examination.

-4-

987FH088

Responsive to the examiner's point 2, the claims have been renumbered
using the examiner's numbering system.
Responsive to the examiner's point 3, claims I, 17, 20, 25, and 26 has been
amended to overcome the examiner's rejection. Regarding claim 6, the pager
antenna is disposed between the housing and at least a portion of the user interface.
Therefore, in claim 6 it is also integrally formed with at least a portion of the user
interface as taught on page 8, lines 30-34.
Responsive to the examiner's points 5-10, claims I, 7, 15 and 20 have been
amended to overcome the examiner's rejection.
Accordingly, the pplicant respectfully request reconsideration of the claims
and passage to allowance at the earliest possible date.
Respectfully submitted,
PAULICK, THOMAS'E.

by:

~tP~
Kevin D. Kaschke
Agent for Applicants
Registration No. 35,767
Phone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]

I hereby certify that this correspondence is being
deposited with the United States Posli'li Service as
first class mail In an envelope addressed to:
Commissioner of Patents and Trademar1<s
Washington,D,C. 20231

by
Kevin D. Kaschke
on
Date

-5-

987FH089