Garcia v. Microsoft Corporation

Filing 1

NOTICE OF REMOVAL with COMPLAINT, filed by Microsoft Corporation. Consent form to proceed before U.S. Magistrate and pretrial instructions provided. (Filing fee $ 350.00 receipt number 569668) (Attachments: # 1 Exhbit A# 2 Exhibit B# 3 Civil Cover Sheet)(epm) Please visit our website at http://www.gand.uscourts.gov to obtain Pretrial Instructions.

I

f

Case 1:07-cv-02363-CC

Document 1-4

Filed 09/27/2007 ~f
7

Page 1 of 2
r.

~~

J 4· t I Re ·r 5 05 NOGAJ

: .1 1 he ;A·, Civil Ct)rei I he o t a iel tho i n·' o rmali m c . oMa i n ed here In neither To p l aCe n Cr Su py la i n·srt the h iri p and iien -Ice of plea d inp % or o l ha p apr r·1 ill fect uir lcl I it.^ e p l its pr a y dell by loca l ri te t of court T hl I lo -m la req i l ·ad !cr the u to of the CIe r M e4 C9ur1 far the F u r po % e of i n titling the Civil d c c gel rec n r. i (S E C . 14 3'fF 'LCT IQ NS A TTAf: F1E0)

s

~C I'V I I,. (; Cf1/ ;EF: SA N Ef :

'~'~ ~" ,

1 . (a) FILAINTIFF(S)
F tancisco G ar ci a, ind i vi clu a l ly, a n 3 on be ha l l'nf H- . m in or c hil cl ;ii Z vario {iar+: ia, an d a!I otFc n. :,imi l u 1 !i1 uale d I
(b) C01 JI if1'Y Of itE SI[IENCE OF F IfiST LI STI :CI 1· u llC n-------------P I. .IIINIIF . F_
pJl:Erl Vi V I lvrN ni F G1SE5)

ID E:1= EN DAN T(S)
h1 ic rc s-3 lt Co rpbrat·o n

11Y) .

CO l11V"Y ' OF ItE SILIENCE OF P RST L1STI: L1 DE'PF MCAHT____________________
QM us n1F (AiES OHIO) MO" E tli IAI d C,Dh01 YW TIN C&LE' ti USE 'M E I U1TF) h OPINE 1ww I OF LAM n+va wD

i C ) A YI 0 fi;N EY; i (F MN hA1YlE , ADDR E5S, i T LE PI-+aN E : MAAl 3 1 _R, p ,ND I.- MAII. A1 ] DR1=_:i :i?
C'hriiiopber -C Taylor

Ei TTC1RME_ YS

(IF FNCIYVI+!)

R .-rin an Tayl Or & Lee . 11.11-C

4M » oZc+xrib [3 r idge Road, A os·N el l, ( 'uk 3a)?E(77O) 6504' 00

John 1 . . St·.pFc mcn, Ir., K ristia+ : 'ti"; cA h sl er [3ravrn, CECrin I)icl :a m n Al ; ton & Bird LLP

1201 West Peaclriree Stiecl, Atla;lta. 1 ;4303 04 ( t 04 ) 88 1 ·7 0 H1

11 . E 3,qSII4, DF=AM1,3D1C11ON
{r1JYCl? JUI "P F CN 'E IIC-X ditYI

"II . C:fTIZERSNIIP OF PRINCIPAL . PARTIES~
FUR LI EF IPLF IN f

(PUKE All "7 ' 1'W gl lE i0): lpi P LNH1 1fF FIND ONI l IOl f PCMS D_FE I4C A 1 Y7) IF'Olt I)I'IER 'G1 YG1lE40NL17

A E NI I: ..,, 7F J iVSFG~nIEFM I,I EN' hQ« pM TI ) 4-J ' ~J1N ~FFHI 2 U S GITIEF NiAE NI j 1 DYI R Sf'T OEFE1 iGV~T I ~ J~ 'T+p :fi TE dfli EMriP DF plat fl ! S IM 1 T E li Il i)

17J

,1

LJ

r=, 1 I ;I11I EM O F " H S STAIE 2 Cf112 F I (~f Mp rHEF,3TAT! J

I

PAL _~ ` I CJ , PIJ~ E OFRIIU~ +ESS OF 1Hri t 4T E

` ~J ' L~J '

FdtEGl i(. O.R ~TF '1' Cf · 1

C s I a~ S ~~ ~~ M N MO-HA3 0 A SI S TJIT E U I ] I_ 1 1 _ ] 9 PXfl 3FI NAl 1 0H

I

V . ORIG l N
L~J 1

('LaC E A N ) IN CNE B O X C -Nt'n

RII O Cl f I~~lC L ,J 2 1 TlLilY{ OUF TM

fRAJiS ERFE1) F 1ltXI 1 jILE tE N,'MlIT]C O R L._I I E 1P oE LLA 1 EICC VRT C ~J ' /lE ]F f E (SPEp FT Q S'R:GIj

Ai4 EAl " 0 p S1WC1 ' U I 1C Al10H ~ T L~ .1 t JII D j E aJO E YTJ5 W

7FJ~' ~

1

J.

Crli{.

l %SE ID F

.A C :

IOM far 1 H E ui 1 ·CriN.lir Ikivr 9 uHixRwHiCH vO U A ltEiIJ IMl XE01MR17!
JUR ISd:II [ MiLL SU LTUlEi1 JNU E3 'xIER Sf'IY)

A,11 R:EI I 14IIE iMl .NT IDF CAU !E - DO f10T ME

Rtinov ;d jai:isdiction exis·s under 2 8 IJ .S ( .. § 1441 s od CAFA . Plaurii ff a11eges frawd, aonversiori, dec :eptivc piactices, etc: ( IF [ .O NIP L E:(, C HE :I{ R EASCMN 1 3E L0 1M1) ED 1 U nL si 9dlY lar ge nun b er o f p.rtln E] E Pr 3blum a tou iir q or pn v erv lnQ a ri luncu

'_ , 2 Un«i ail1y la r ge n ~rnti e r giC l e ims or d efe -n s us r_` ~ 7 1' a n· i ii p pa riili el love it gatl o n :~ ~1r a Ctiomi b y forer n men l J 1 J ~ &I I I_ , 3 F +kc tua I ue ~ ~n t ieao!Fii on al qy rompl e · c r_, E IA u n l plsu sit ~~r .:i~ e rt~ J ~ J

r-J 9 Iieei for ~ii iC O- rer}~ cwlside UNted S l ales b~ aL ni arl e -o I~ =I 1 G rea ' er ~~h an n crm ,i t r nlu r u df e ~r lden c u 1 L

---- C-- ---- -- ------------ ...
FI» 2 OF I'IG I c °J :i! _ OIVI_Y
W=C PI ~

1

__ I !- E d o-ri ded d is co -rery per loc U nueE+·d

[_] 11 E : I Sl e 1 ce of Nig hly te c. hnicad I s s u ef e n d ; rnDf

._ O'CiP J TIIV LI E: 0, ON F t IEVf :IRISE
. A !'I;YrdC . FP_~ I rMG J IlXE(fF
i,

-------------------------------- -----------------ii

___.· ANY] 1I+7 3 ... . ... . ..

ACG I ' -------- # ~ W rG JJ[)C F------- --- F+ r. n-Po _ 47 salt ~ --

CAM E 01 AC fl[]nL,_ °-__- ,:

Case 1:07-cv-02363-CC

Document 1-4

Filed 09/27/2007

Page 2 of 2

I-CFN . '

3s 'J ]YH S a il AT1YSlh i Y LSFI' L9 (AINMp I PP43i J,ON 9 L_J £ 1 I -~I £V) '* LL tda: ~' fSlf] 5M 1 4 l 7H :6r I M (DA'OMB .II~ gN3tId3 EM.3 S r SF{ L N 'a R 35 1 (N~V iLL li~Id 3 ^II dO7YM) a" bS t{Hl[ 3 Y J ~

L In

1~s~~o U~ mD Jc~ =_r~ us Izu rvoanr ~cnx r~ u cnz i j,~~ro a rvrnti s,xr ~a~srasrO of ~v ) izenma :~c r+o KV~w ~c~ -nor ~a~dka~+a 3+hS3ilAB - 2gl73C IfpX13 AVFH~ ffA I3J3iHL (F ,ll A~I c Gr. JIMI ( NV ZY~ .Ii 1. ~l3oMB Y PdS ~LLiC) IA 3 ' ~~~NS'K3 c k~/ ' 1K 1 S '+ 3d (r2[3E Wf yiiflRfi3N ~l 14 ·Mp I TO!lX31ri3(7rZLlti C· 1Hl ~ iLAd~ XY .N3 1 Yd WhS 3 LLd) . .N~'CI;] N rLNI LpAII(r V, 1
J. Ri ']P ~ C N3eICC3~lf]M 7~I L91l M3 1~h' M C 1 3 ~11Jta I VCIU0 I S NdlLL il ) Ud 1'i3NN5,3HL .l 0 JI1C1 :33Gfi bO l: Trd K1_ Ilai :f~ M 4 1 x1 5 '~~(r1 3~i(I3 hC~F1W'TI Z /3 fbf.3 M I H iT4-i47'~I V ,t1,21 3 eC kLd

su++rxB 3 > 529icQU is3!r:) WuLL3d3 i

IF R ~~
[] 113

0:013 311V Ik ;d Oil d .i l/ ~ ;) ;IEIO)

( ' s ) :3sr~ 0- '111A ----------------------------------------U-. N I-'-"-I-W-0-h . -0--I-w--? --:I---f-C-i--h--:-:-l--3-1-G-N-[---S-3-1[?]-0-N-AY-C-l-.l-2l-li - r d 3-1 3i - W O I r T T S 3 g l l -- - 9 f -] .
MW 31
1 . +310Yl :la£L cl+-l :)d .4 a3 13 I+U114 O11 ;)1I6IGNr'i 3 A N ;) :I K^ []

ON

6 iI ,IO H~W :~ SV 3 C NICIN 3d 3 Flt d l C~3 11rl:lkl 01-1101330 321 V t3 'i1l : l 1111O

L-21)13013

DOWN,

~ .L I N - d" I dIAI } 01 .N! Cg I ----t) a - 'I --------------------------------------------------------------I '------(---------wrign ---m--m
.l»:W3:)S 33 310N :15 .%r3n d ,
1q i u nj e 1+~bwl Ape pun yew .ua ld ·11ol4)
U .~a]rns~~~cr-~ rrvu~ ~Naal 7 NC LLY1lLl fi~ ~ ~_J ( , 14IML ,. . 3m

3'a~M kiO b 3 KId )1:MIJ . s

.It, I Q3a'ri fZZ A ~i: zZ*z n 11 1 zr9
-A k 4'!IL4r2 [ r3 Fm r SI N '] IhL1dQ]Ilrli [_~ 53+~~I
J-3c URIft r- 3 'aN 13i! "S d 1Y g

j 3l CrJlwi :cMrib lll2L3iCRid ';P . G] M ff x l h

. uns~+n

A , .a3XW -Mv0sxw akwD

~I Yii AM N~~1~

&!1 :3

cNazn ra Hu smi ice C
CI"1V1id2i } LLD-711 [
i Ytl7~ a iA ~i~ ~

=4wM~a I S" iJ X4NY 0C .! i[ L QI fY}"~S DS O 1~1 lgrmuu.Y oar I_ i3 r3
SMX I_Y J~iCJILV IS tl31LD OE B Imo' ^ ~uu v..s . ~kSftl' oi~~axw Tno~a kn ori

_ 1~I<~ OM ~OMI25 i06r1 2 ryd

e 1 xuak Gd ip rew+aa ?vTx( l : ] s frursi srwfdovi1xc[=1

J -:; V .x)u II AMiA' Ktl p [I Z 1 w l 2r-rarexr Os 3a

fi+ir Sri i:'Qa ~ bwl'. Y wZ~u q `~t~57 «:

ot [ ( .]

, . L-Vu+ fn lxxo ticl SoLc a xvecc C:j

Lnaxe-~,arrri i~r~c~~d ~c C' - vxr, w- .,anNi T*r- s 3CU
XMDAb ,h w
! al 1 R1 Mv06 i[3 u LI 3{10 0[ E C] .LLf1 o Tl J.3I OC Zi3 n71{NM?1 DWgC C~
Me

J.171T 'Il

~r~s ~~ .urrn .~o.uua~~ca ~s1=7

Ill TI3 W A13fiS TaN ] LLYdXO 3 ow I- ~ 5`}]!13! ' ZIV 09i ~~ K x' QiL '1 " Yd I*D 9 d4 r1 a7o n JCD ~_] gig a i fl L: IL' ~d]~Id

bawD004=]

C7

r.x.r naroZ, L~o a A .i~o ~ ~trv ac s l=~ ~v r. x Lr~! c»y -4) i~cxaRe s~ c 1=]

X)aoAIcM ~ur~~ aarw~ z~ I .]

er w

L7~ Nd1N O~RI . .°. ~iTC9 YEB I W S kLiLLtMI T~1MirtV 03V10 CEO I~ L'Y KX.YLIENLS :M i0N CX3 Slo l_] S1;N TI6RLl fY~ 1£N MID GL K .91 ,'l '.'kQTI vFq l17YC LL:a C] Sr A !~al 7YC 7 ]] L 37V ~2l mi =W l k3t{SOi O ~~] ~ '

_a~vtira~v~~wl=7

-e ixb .4 wo I .]

Ztl=Jr~~ la~ii~MJY1 ~ Q~'!h'~Y ~lI~J rtl ~ r. iZ

53.i~ T

A Lr KMi stpun L. G tEq *!K l; 4 ' 3 317.

n3Knaicw ae ~a 1lITeL YI y L'fl]CIad3A l IVWSr£ ~~ 3RMM 0, ! ~J
7A QxU acs JY1v SSYQT

C~

A1IlEM 1 Lf1~f ~d~~rl ~ RiI VSIC

~ 1fi 'LMIV dC ' r 7a7~ ~ ~~5SiZ~

ya -3 (q PL0 151m]Ll][NQ a IJC16 RId -i9; 1 _ 3 6 - rKF R 3 1 x+lA SlI- p4l 7N] .79i Ij

.v aun~.r ;rnaaa r .C~l Lx ra3rcrn sr+CO as I:] I S~ I d1~2Nf 1b0 L~~id(C1

JllL3iC Qid h/ :R 12 3-il J0 TNOt1C C_1 Alllc Mff L1f1 d721dLi CLL9ic C_I '

091

ad A q..d 4s) Mxuc)N a ) ia)swa ISO M
(n wd Ipl.j S1~

vc)uv~x~o~ n oX w CSI 'SLY53LVl3 x wx12l3y'i000EiY JNYt.01l~ kddY3~ ~LtlJS O[ w,~] I

JILraF 6 d I-uYiO S'kQIOL)'1r3 NH X91 :3

to -ua v sr v Mannn xsl : 7

cRI -m 769 1 ,, 3

awe 01 Udcuaa C=1 . 3Ev7t LC-maz C=1 .-03r3 Mon 3 a ,~ota~c~~ x [.I

Ncx..MY 'CIDYOC aMf10 1 L CL

rKilNIS 3 1N0VIiCLL51JCU d M X G8 iiO'nLL .~k~1 OGis'~f L ~~l.A4 ~iN~1 1 ~1 h _IN~.1117 ~ 1 l
Jm41Q

am-cUJdlu o!{L C_I I .L73~111:7fi0ol isl lalli,11 jC0 9u o JzYl31NCKI LOiJAOl1 L ~...

ECO1 :91 11ZA, .?l Vd (ftlHl Ed 4A[] ~ur.a rl~Ci

tq ilIJJ IVId'~,f b!3X14d~ []

'!i31i 1~3+510 4A ' ~M7L~WV dr~I R .wtadF~ · 4 :31i 1~3~51p

:3

11f3VyllLLa 1 iITSLd 7pNq t C~ T f

su~oFx~n~~raa~s~K C=1 gar WXYw << 4 [.L .
340hW0'1t Ce WpIV.ArISVO i I C.

ia~a a nwax [_

GA9c rf esa %* C7 rx 3w uXs r s p [] a~~o .~. auO a~ C]
aan ~xm cYia ~w_ a ~:~r~
G~sc vl auk ~a

~+~~~,n w.l = ] ~i0¢ ~ao wn cxo n~~r~oH ~r~~ u vw,c~ w a a.l '
·7 r+u CIA L I*

-s~~~a~3ti xx) sr,ec,2N3cn~~ ¢r~_
I

!ILL-13h[33 '.1~N eLLL3r1 y4Jl~M4tiYd~W] i C~ Ak [3^O }Rl~d [:1

.s L :s~ X

-h NrrtKH U ~n lz'hs :k: y ZZr ~~

WINa

:cc H i Rui wi X Pill aarnal .Lli1S; j C! =1

~+Tifi ~i5itir+`u ~ nZ3~3 ~S~Z> r~-3ral-45:i M

uawEx rr irc ci ti . V rwtird T:O X1WG3 :n D% 094 C=1 w 0 euW j 1

r1 nv_Qa

X- WA

a

a X-M

M

[.I

m fl J! V NI "I A
t.