Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 327

DEPOSITION of Ann Cale Kruger, Ph.D. taken on April 22, 2011 by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5)(Rains, John)

E
X
H
I
B
I
T
4

Use Checkliat

Fair

Name Mn

Date

Kri

EPV7OSO

class or Project

EPV7000 Summer 2000

and Temt

Course

ride of

Wade

Copyrighted

Author and Publisher

to

Instructions

Ssdc

Where

use

is

Justified

counts

favoring

fair

use outnumber

the factors

favor

fewer than

any

use

fair

against

facts

total
in

half

Where

given

determinative

of

favor

of

whether

Check
use

fair

fair

use

those

only

facts
should

Instructors

of the Board of Regents

or at the Office

the factors

in

weighing

deciding

situation

Oxford

Prea

University

2001

diS t181-199

timer

pages

permission from the rights holder
consider the

Oxford

It

the factors

Where

ChNefl tSiS

Awakening

e.g

be used

Portions

sunrer2Th

if

fair

fair

are

those

use

evenly

use as opposed
Not

Is justified

that apply

to

your use

have

reliance

on

questions

total

No

single
at

office

Affairs

fair

should

fads weighing
of the facts wifi be present

the Legal

they

it

should seek

instructors

split

to the

all

consult

against

instructors

In

Item

or factor

their

institution

analysis

of the four

use sections

is

of the

regarding

factors

For more information
Policy
of

on

Use

Georgia

and

Complete

retain

such

Nonprofit

ar

Favor

Purpoee and Character

of Fair

copies

Comment News
or

use

utility

or

is

purpose

For publication
distribution

Use exceeds
necessary

educational

in

achieve

that

to

educational

necessaryto

Factor Weighs

activity

from use

For public
work

changes

Personal Study

intended

Fat Use

Non-transformative
Ii

Parody

Transformative

Against

Entertainment

CriticStt

Use

System

the Use

Profiting

or Scholarship

Reporting

of

Commercial
multiple

Research

new

fair

Weighs

Use

Educational

Teaching
including
for classroom use

for

please see the

use arise

Weighs

El

use factors

work in order to
copyrighted
copy of this checklist for each fair use of
and good faith attempt at applying fair use should
any dispute

Factor

El

fair

of

reasonable

establish
regarding

the

regarding

Copyrighted Wadis in Education and Research for lbs University
which can be found on the web at http/www.usg.edulcopyrlght/

the

which

achieve

Is

your intended

purpose

your

purpose

Pa yrof

Fair

Use

Factor Weighs

Against

Fair

Use

4WoeTrx
ESQUIRE

GaStateOO65256

Exhibit 4 - 1

Factor

Fata

in

Weighs

of Fair Use

$3

$3

Factor

work

educational

to

Important

Weighs

Favor

fri

objectives

21

SrvS

El

Portion

used

Amount taken
to

subject

Factor

work

work

$3

as

whole

Amount taken

or

being

Favor

effect

market

stimulates

Use

of Fair

for

Factor

simliarproduct

No

longer

Effect

on Market

or

on market or

bar

market

potential

Restricted

by the

or permission

Repeated
permission unavailable

the

copies

Factor

Revised
Columbia

Weighs

for

Favor

hr

use by the

Universitys

or

or

the

market

for

classroom reading

purchased

Unrestricted

of Fair Use

University
System
Fair Use ChecldisC

or distributed

use that

User does not own lawfully acquired

other public

$3

made

work

RequIred

aapiiredor
copy of original work
lawfully

students

reasonably

or long-term

demonstrably affects

classroom reading

to

copyrighted

available

Numerous

access

for

work or derivative

original

marketed

market or

Impairs

Significantly

work

copyrighted

few copies made or distributed

purchased
El

for

or sub4ect

Against Fair Use

Weighs

in

Supplements
User owns

necessary

for Original

Mder

One

than

Against Fair Use

Weighs

of Fair Use

market

No

or

more

taught

Ucenslng

Ucenslng

is

comment research

critldsm

work

El

used

heart of the work

tailored

such as

Favor

hr

hr

significant

Use

work

Po.llonusedlscsntraltowodcor

taught

Weighs

potential

or entire

Large portion

Factor

No

Against Fair Use

Weighs

or

comment research

Weighs

Against Fair Use

of Portion Used

Substantlalfty

used

purpose

being

Factor Weighs

Amount and

nantwly

art music novels

plays poetry fiction
Consumable
work wcrtcboolcjest

of Fair Use

not central

is

educational

criticism

$3

is

to entire

significant

$3

of

portion

work

films

of Fair Use

Favor

In

creative

Highly

Factor

Weighs

work

UnpublIshed

Factis or nonfiction

Against Fair Use

Weighs

work

PublIshed

Work

Nature of Copyrighted

Factor

of

Georgia

based

upon

copy
access

of

original

on

the

work

web

or

forum

Weighs

Against Fair Use

the Copyright Advisory

Office

at

http/Iwww.copyrlghtcokamtha.edu/fair-use-checldist

GaStateOO65257

Exhibit 4 - 2