Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 723

Opposition re #720 Emergency MOTION to Strike Portions of Eight Exhibits Containing Roche Manufacturing Trade Secrets that are Not Necessary for Amgen's Infringement Motions or in the Alternative to Seal These Select Exhibits filed by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#2 Exhibit 1 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#3 Exhibit 2 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#4 Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#5 Exhibit 4 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#6 Declaration of Teresa A. Garcia)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 723 Att. 2

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 1 of 9

EXHIBIT 1

Dockets.Justia.com

7002/61/7
.uoy knahT .stnemhcatta yna dna liam-e eht eteled dna rednes eht yfiton esaelp ,daetsnI .stnemhcatta yna ro liam-e eht etubirtsid ro ypoc ,daer ton od ,tneipicer dednetni eht ton era uoy fI .degelivirp ro laitnedifnoc si taht noitamrofni niatnoc yam dna ,mrif wal a ,PLL nietsnuS & grebmorB morf si liam-e sihT

moc.nietsnusgrebmorb.www moc.nusmorb@notsuhj
4000-344 )716( :xaF 462 x 2929-344 )716( :leT 8161-01120 AM ,notsoB teertS remmuS 521 waL ta syenrottA PLL nietsnuS & grebmorB

rentraP notsuH ailuJ
ailuJ

,sdrageR
.rettam siht ot noitnetta ruoy rof uoy knahT

cilbup eht

ni delif eb ton stnemucod laitnedifnoc s'ehcoR taht

tseuqer ym

no

.emit siht ta drocer drocer fo lesnuoc lla gniypoc ma
.siht ssucsid ot

yletarapes uoy tcatnoc lliw .drocer cilbup eht ni laitnedifnoc eb ot demialc srepap eht fo yna gnilif erofeb rettam siht tuoba refnoc ew taht tseggus .deined neeb osla evah suineserF dna negmA yb laes ot snoitom tnecer eht taht dnatsrednu .woleb ,laes ot noitom s'ehcoR no gnilur s'gnuoY egduJ gniweiver fo ssecorp eht ni era eW
,harobeD dna leahciM raeD
fcv.notsuH ailuJ :stnemhcattA )105/9903( )laeS ot noitoM no redrO la te DTL ehcoRaL-nnamffoH :tcejbuS .F .v .cnI negmA YGW-73221-vc-50:1 esaC ni ytivitcA :WF( laeS ot noitoM s'ehcoR no redrO mailliW ,edeaG ;lliW ,zaiD ffodzorD rimidalV ;yhpruM miT ;samohT ,ssoR gnimelF .F samohT ;nasuS ,hcstilpmurK letaP .H pidnaS gnidlapS .M treboR ;boR ,nivlaG ;nnaK treboR ;rehsA treboR htimS .W drahciR oveS eD .A drahciR ;eeneR ,nworB droBuD ;.J accebeR ,siaW ;yaR ,nesbocaJ .rJ ,notcA .M reteP olegnatarF reteP inolamarT -ahcoR aicirtaP ;.R aicirtaP ,hciR nosraC .A aicirtaP ;ozziR .A elociN notgnoL-ybloC .A elociN alleLiD ycnaN sarertnoC acinoM ;elehciM ,dnaleroM ;ekiM ,lladneK ;leahciM ,nuroB enalraFcM wehttaM nesleiN .C wehttaM elyoB yraM yksfopoP .S kraM ;kraM ,zciwelearsI ;oiraM ,erooM lleyaM .S nivnaM ;ytsuR ,yaD ;adniL ,yelxaB imA-neB aroeL ;grebmorB lraC eeL tforcyR .M atsirK ;atsirK ,retraC ;aguleS .J ylrebmiK ;niveK ,srewolF ;smoT .E htieK ;eitaK ,ttocS ttomreDcM neelhtaK werB nailuJ ;notsuH ailuJ ;auhsoJ ,nnuM ;nahtanoJ ,beoL ;noJ ,worBuD satorP .D ymereJ ;refinneJ ,yrolF rekcaW annaeJ resarF .M semaJ huS drawoH lekceH )derflA( knaH notsnhoJ .W egroeG ;.M ffoeG ,yerfdoG asoRaL .J repsaG ilA tasariF ;reffahcS .J ylimE ;divaD ,dirdaM uaenisuoC .L divaD otruC .A leinaD ;anaD ,yrrehScM ;sinneD ,ittergellA noteldneP .N nelluC ;giarC ,reebesaC eogaJ .T rehpotsirhC ;noorK .S rehpotsirhC ;.E sirhC ,nemmaM dleifhcruB .R ybboB ;eirreB ,namdloG ressibrA notA ;ydnA ,nahC ;werdnA ,otomamuK ;ruhtrA madA ,reiB lefitS noraA ;noraA ,dnaH harobeD ,namhsiF ;leahciM ,deirfttoG
MA 84:9 7002 ,50 yluJ ,yadsruhT ]moc.nusmorb@notsuHJ[ notsuH ailuJ

:cC :oT :tneS

:morF

harobeD

,namhsiF

8 fo 1

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 2 of 9

7002/61/7

,moc.relohcseyak@yrotisopeRliamEehcoR ,moc.relohcseyaK@olegnatarfp olegnatarF reteP moc.relohcseyak@amdoam ,moc.relohcseyak@gnimelft gnimelF .F samohT moc.twbp@noitagitilocm ,moc.twbp@niselazas niselaZ .A nevetS moc.rettun@yrrebj ,moc.rettun@arerrefd arerreF .L divaD moc.nusmorb@sniggihc ,moc.nusmorb@notsuhj notsuH ailuJ moc.reebesacyad@rlyad rJ ,yaD .R dyolL moc.relohcseyak@imanebl imA-neB aroeL moc.nusmorb@yhprumt yhpruM .M yhtomiT moc.nusmorb@llahsramj ,moc.nusmorb@nnakr nnaK .L treboR moc.pillahsram@ssort ssoR .I samohT moc.nusmorb@nodeercj ,moc.nusmorb@grebmorbl grebmorB .C eeL moc.sirromenaud@skeewlv ,moc.sirromenaud@dlaregztifmk ,moc.sirromenaud@deirfttogrm deirfttoG .R leahciM moc.ewm@lladneknr lladneK leahciM moc.rf@drofwarc ,moc.rf@trebeh trebeH .J kraM moc.nusmorb@sodrel ,moc.nusmorb@nameelj nameeL .R leoJ moc.nusmorb@rehsar rehsA .M treboR
:ot deliam

moc.relohcseyak@amdoam

yllacinortcele

eb lliw ecitoN 73221-vc-50:1

)wehttaM ,eniaP( 4 mialC 896' dna ,3 mialC 339' ,1 mialC 224'fo tnemgnirfnI fo tnemgduJ yrammuS rof noitoM s'negmA htiw noitcennoC ni dettimbuS dna sterceS edarT 'stnadnefeD gniniatnoC stnemucoD laeS ot NOITOM ]955[ er 7002 ,3 yluJ detaD noitoM s'negmA no redrO eeS .DEINED :deretne REDRO cinortcelE gnuoY .G mailliW egduJ :txeT tekcoD
dehcatta tnemucod oN :rebmuN tnemucoD :reliF

7002/5/7

no

:rebmuN esaC 73221-vc-50:1 :emaN esaC la te DTL ehcoRaL-nnamffoH .F .v .cnI negmA delif dna TDE MP 81:21 ta 7002/5/7 no deretne saw noitcasnart gniwollof ehT

gniliF
sttesuhcassaM fo tcirtsiD
truoC tcirtsiD setatS detinU

cinortcelE fo ecitoN

.gniweiv tsrif siht gnirud tnemucod hcae fo ypoc a daolnwod ,segrahc retal diova oT .egrahc tuohtiw ecno stnemucod delif eht weiv yam uoY ***SRESU SSECCA CILBUP OT ETON*** .dednettanu si xob liam eht esuaceb liam-e siht ot DNOPSER eht yb detareneg egassem liam-e citamotua na si sihT
TON OD esaelP

.metsys FCE/MC

laeS
ot noitoM
no

redrO la te DTL ehcoRaL-nnamffoH .F

.v

.cnI

negmA

MP 91:21 7002 ,50 yluJ ,yadsruhT ]vog.struocsu.dam@ecitonFCE:otliam[ vog.struocsu.dam@ecitonFCE

YGW-73221-vc-50:1 esaC ni ytivitcA :tcejbuS vog.struocsu.dam@ypoCtruoC :oT :tneS :morF

8 fo 2

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 3 of 9

7002/61/7

41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302
PLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD
reiB ruhtrA madA
0062-01120 AM ,notsoB 005 etiuS eunevA citnaltA 074 PLL sirroM enauD sinneD .D

ittergellA

:ot deliam

yllacinortcele

eb ton lliw ecitoN 73221-vc-50:1

moc.relohcseyak@lefeitsa lefeitS noraA moc.niehcsnennos@ttomredcmk ttomreDcM neelhtaK moc.nusmorb@sodrel ,moc.nusmorb@agulesk aguleS .J ylrebmiK moc.relohcseyak@knarfk ,moc.relohcseyak@yddaeg ,moc.relohcseyak@uaenisuocd uaenisuoC .L divaD moc.relohcseyak@sarertnocm sarertnoC acinoM moc.relohcseyak@enalrafcmm enalraFcM wehttaM moc.ewm@yrrehscmd yrrehScM .M anaD moc.relohcseyak@lleyamm lleyaM nivnaM moc.ewm@resarfj resarF .M semaJ moc.relohcseyak@yksfopopm yksfopoP .S kraM moc.nusmorb@smubl ,moc.nusmorb@ozzirn ozziR .A elociN moc.ewm@nnumj nnuM .A auhsoJ moc.ewm@ilaf ilA tasariF moc.ewm@neenedp ,moc.ewm@salocinnasn ,moc.ewm@oirazordg ,moc.ewm@dnaleromm dnaleroM .E ellehciM moc.pillahsram@zciwelearzim zciwelearzI kraM moc.rettun@ykciperh ykcipeR .B rehtaeH moc.nusmorb@ejlemmobs ,moc.nusmorb@smotk smoT .E htieK moc.relohcseyak@amdoam ,moc.relohcseyak@hush huS drawoH moc.ewm@dleifhcrubb dleifhcruB .R ybboB moc.ewm@edeagw III ,edeaG .G mailliW moc.pillahsram@nuroBM nuroB .F leahciM moc.reebesacyad@yelxabl yelxaB-ikasaS adniL moc.sirromenaud@trebelh ,moc.sirromenaud@noorksc noorK .S rehpotsirhC moc.ewm@nesuahnepapl nesuahnepaP .M neruaL moc.ewm@yblocn ybloC .A elociN moc.pillahsram@yelpikm ,moc.pillahsram@nesleiNM nesleiN .C wehttaM moc.ewm@notcap notcA .M reteP moc.relohcseyak@amdoam ,moc.relohcseyak@ressibraa ressibrA notA moc.relohcseyak@ffodzordv ffodzorD rimidalV moc.relohcseyak@nosracp nosraC .A aicirtaP moc.relohcseyak@tforcyrk tforcyR .M atsirK moc.sirromenaud@skeewlv ,moc.sirromenaud@dlaregztifmk ,moc.sirromenaud@hcirp hciR .R aicirtaP moc.pillahsram@letaPS letaP .H pidnaS moc.ewm@ekoold ,moc.ewm@otrucd otruC .A leinaD moc.pillahsram@namtrot ,moc.pillahsram@eneergm ,moc.pillahsram@srewolFK srewolF M niveK
8 fo 3

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 4 of 9

7002/61/7

22001 YN ,kroY weN eunevA kraP 524 PLL relohcS eyaK oveS eD .A drahciR

9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO .cnI negmA .L euqinoM

yadroC

41059 AC

,onitrepuC

004 etiuS .dvlB keerC nevetS 00302 PLL ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD nahC .H ydnA 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD reebesaC .H giarC 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 CLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD
retraC .M atsirK
41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302

PLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD
nworB droBuD eeneR

8406-76009 AC ,selegnA soL 0071 etiuS sratS eht fo eunevA 9991 PLL relohcS eyaK werB nailuJ
40349 AC ,otlA olaP evirD retroP 0513 & lliW ttomreDcM

yremE

elyoB yraM
2046-60606 LI ,ogacihC evirD rekcaW .S 332 rewoT sraeS 0036
nuroB &

yarruM ,nietsreG ,elooT'O ,llahsraM
nuroB .F leahciM

8 fo 4

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 5 of 9

7002/61/7

41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD .M yerffoeG

yerfdoG

relyT

63001 YN ,kroY weN saciremA eht fo eunevA 3311 & bbeW ,pankleB ,nosrettaP retmeleG .M eneguE

41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD nivlaG .M treboR

60606 LI ,ogacihC rewoT sraeS 0036 evirD rekcaW htuoS 332 PLL nuroB & nietsreG llahsraM yrolF .E refinneJ 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD namhsiF .E harobeD

PLL

yremE

50002 CD ,notgnihsaW .W.N ,teertS ht31 006 & lliW ttomreDcM worbuD .B noJ

9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO cnI negmA nostoD .G llerraD 21629 AC ,enivrI 005 etiuS eunevA namraK noV 19181 PLL yremE & lliW ttomreDcM zaiD mailliW
01170 JN ,yeltuN teertS dnalsgniK 043 tnemtrapeD waL .cnI ehcoR aL-nnamffoH alleLiD ycnaN

8 fo 5

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 6 of 9

7002/61/7

otomamuK werdnA 41059 AC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302
PLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD

hcstilpmurK

.M nasuS

01170 JN ,yeltuN teertS dnalsgniK 043 tnemtrapeD waL .cnI ehcoR aL-nnamffoH notsnhoJ .W egroeG

8953-22001 YN ,kroY weN evA kraP 524 PLL relohcS eyaK .T rehpotsirhC

eogaJ

PLL

yremE & lliW

50002 CD ,notgnihsaW .W.N teertS ht31 006 ttomreDcM

nesbocaJ .A

dnomyaR

PLL

,relyT

63001 YN ,kroY weN saciremA eht fo eunevA 331 & bbeW ,pankleB ,nosnrettaP

noskcaJ .O drahciR
22001 YN ,kroY weN eunevA kraP 524 PLL relohcS eyaK lekceH .H derflA 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD dnaH .R noraA

PLL

relyT

0176-63001 YN ,kroY weN saciremA eht fo eunevA 3311 & bbeW ,pankleB ,nosrettaP saaH kirE

41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD namdloG .R eirreB

8 fo 6

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 7 of 9

7002/61/7

satorP .D

ymereJ

60606 LI ,ogacihC rewoT sraeS 0036 evirD rekcaW htuoS 332 PLL nuroB & nietsreG llahsraM noteldneP .N nelluC 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302
PLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD luaP .A ycraD
9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO .cnI negmA noslO .S acirE 9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evriD retneC negmA enO

yleroM

.cnI negmA .L nilrebmiK

41059 AC ,onitrepuC dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 004 etiuS redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD erooM oiraM 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD nemmaM .E naitsirhC
41059 AC

,onitrepuC

004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD dirdaM .M divaD 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD beoL .D nahtanoJ 40349 AC ,otlA olaP evirD retroP 0513 & lliW ttomreDcM

yremE
8 fo 7

egaP

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-3

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 8 of 9

7002/61/7

9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO cnI negmA drofetihW .A ydneW

9871-02319 AC ,skaO dnasuohT evirD retneC negmA enO .cnI negmA ttaW .L trautS
41059 AC PLL

,onitrepuC

004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD
siaW .J accebeR
22001 YN ,kroY weN eunevA kraP 524 PLL relohcS eyaK rekcaW annaeJ 50002 CD

,notgnihsaW

.W.N ,teertS htneetrihT 006 PLL yremE & lliW ,ttomreDcM htimS .W drahciR 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS .dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL

,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD
ttocS .L.J eitaK 01170 JN ,yeltuN teertS dnalsgniK 043 tnemtrapeD waL
.cnI ehcoR aL-nnamffoH inolamarT-ahcoR aicirtaP

60606 LI ,ogacihC rewoT sraeS 0036 evirD rekcaW htuoS 332 PLL nuroB & nietsreG llahsraM
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 723-3 Filed 07/16/2007 Page 9 of 9

8 fo 8

egaP