Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 723

Opposition re #720 Emergency MOTION to Strike Portions of Eight Exhibits Containing Roche Manufacturing Trade Secrets that are Not Necessary for Amgen's Infringement Motions or in the Alternative to Seal These Select Exhibits filed by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#2 Exhibit 1 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#3 Exhibit 2 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#4 Exhibit 3 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#5 Exhibit 4 to the Declaration of Deborah E. Fishman#6 Declaration of Teresa A. Garcia)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 723 Att. 3

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-4

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 1 of 5

EXHIBIT 2

Dockets.Justia.com

7002/61/7

>>fcv.smoT .E htieK<<
.uoy knahT .stnemhcatta yna dna liam-e eht eteled dna rednes .stnemhcatta yna ro liam-e eht etubirtsid ro ypoc ,daer ton od ,tneipicer dednetni eht ton era uoy si taht noitamrofni niatnoc yam dna ,mrif wal a ,PLL nietsnuS & grebmorB morf si liam-e sihT

fI

eht yfiton esaelp ,daetsnI .degelivirp ro laitnedifnoc

moc.nusmorb.www 4000ˇ344 )716( :xaF 2929-344 )716( :leT 8161-01120 AM ,notsoB teertS remmuS 521 waL ta syenrottA PLL nietsnuS & grebmorB

yenrottA
smoT .E htieK

>>fdp.70-01-7

namhsiF .D ot smoT .K morf .rtL<< htieK tseB

,sdrager
.dehcatta
ees

esaelP

,harobeD raeD

fcv.smoT .E htieK ;fdp.70-01-7 namhsiF .D ot smoT .K morf .rtL :stnemhcattA :tcejbuS stnemucoD laitnedifnoC :er namhsiF .D oT .rtL notsuH

lasoporP

ailuJ

;moc.relohcseyak@erooMJ ;moc.relohcseyak@lleyamm ;moc.relohcseyak@nosraCP
MP 71:6 7002

harobeD ,namhsiF ,01 yluJ ,yadseuT smoT .E htieK

]moc.nusmorb@smotK[

:cC :oT :tneS :morF

harobeD ,namhsiF

1 fo 1

egaP

lasoporP

stnemucoD laitnedifnoC

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY
:er

Document 723-4

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 2 of 5

namhsiF .D oT .rtL

WAL TA SYENROTTA

.oN yam

tekcoD( ttocS negmA ,36

.yteritne rieht ni )415 L.J eitaK fo noitaralceD eht ot stibihxe eht lla elif ylcilbup dna ,55 ,54 ,34 ,9 ,8 ,5 stibihxE fo noitpecxe eht htiW .)315
.oN

)4(

tekcoD( tnemegnirfni
)3( )2(

fo tnemgduj yrammus rof noitom sti fo troppus ni hsidoL .F yevraH fo noitaralceD eht fo ypoc detcadernu na drocer cilbup eht ni elif yam negmA

.)215 .oN tekcoD( 1.65 eluR lacoL ot tnausrup tcat detupsidnu fo tnemetats sti fo ypoc detcadernu na drocer cilbup eht ni elif yam negmA .)015
.oN

tekcoD(

tnemegnirfni

fo tnemgduj yrammus rof noitom sti fo troppus ni wal fo mudnaromem sti fo ypoc detcadernu na drocer cilbup eht ni elif yam negmA

)1(

mialC 339' ,1 mialC 224' fo

tnemegnirfnI

fo

tnemgduJ yrammuS

6 mialC 896' dna ,3 rof noitoM s'negmA

deussi

ytilaitnedifnoc

:laes ot snoitom eht ot noitulos

'seitrap eht fo slained tnecer s'gnuoY egduJ yb desiar desoporp s'ehcoR si gniwollof eht ,dessucsid ew sA
:harobeD raeD

105/9903
.la te

,dtL ehcoR aL,nnamffoH

.F

.v

eliF ruO .cnI negntA

eR

41059 AC

,onitrepuC

PLL

004 etiuS ,,dvlB keerC snevetS 00302 ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD ,qsE ,naˇsiF .E harobeD LIAME AIV

7002

,O l yluJ

MOCˇNUSMORBˇSMOTK
123
x

2929 3ˇ 7]6 T SMOT .E HTIEK

MOC.NUSMORB.WWW

4O00 344

7ˇ6

F

-p

929 344
NOTSOB

7i6

T
REMMUS

8161-0112OAM

TEERTS

521

ˇ

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-4

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 3 of 5

.eussi na eb lliw lavomer rieht taht etapicitna t'nod ew os ,serugif eseht no yler ton seod negmA ,egdelwonk ruo oT .detcader era 31 erugiF dna ,21 dam 11 selbaT taht dedivorp ,delif ylcilbup eb ˇe 36 tibihxE

)ll(

.55 tibihxE fo noitrop yna elif ot negmA rof yrassecennu si ti ,suhT .esaeler cilbup rof devorppa neeb evah taht 54 tibihxE fo segap eht nihtiw dnuof si rof detic si ti etouq eht dna ,tnemetats 1.65 s'negmA fo 22 hpargaraP ni detic ylno si 55 tibihxE ,egdeMonk ruo oT

)01(

.setic negmA hcihw ot segap ylno eht eˇ eseht ,egdelwonk ruo oT ,drocer cilbup eht ni delif eb nac 54 tibihxE fo 72605000-52605000-R,CTI segap ylnO
.setic negmA hcihw ot tibihxe siht fo segap ylno eht era eseht ,egdelwonk ruo oT .drocer cilbup eht ni delif eb nac 34 tibihxE fo 852180000R dna ,352180000R ,42180000R segap ylnO

)9(
)8(

.tibihxe

evitanretla na ot ro tnemetats s 1.65 s'negmA ot snoitatic htiw tnemucod sˇ ot secnerefer rehto tnemelppus ot negmA wolla llM ehcoR suht dna ,desaeler ylcilbup eb lliw taht stnemucod rehto htiw evitadmuc era tnemucod evitisnes ylhgih siht ot secnerefer rehto s'negˇ ,evoba sA .drocer cilbup eht ni delif ot ,tnemetats 1.65 s'negmA fo 8 hpargaraP ni detic si hcihw ,78940000 -ALB-R-CTI delebal egap eht wolla ylno lliw ehcoR ,9 tibihxE; roF

eb

)7(

.negˇ yb

dereffo stibihxe rehto htiw evitalumuc ylerem era 8 hpargaraP ot secnercfer rehto eht taht seveileb ehcoR tub ,stibihxe evitanretla ot ro 1.65 s'negmA ot snoitatic htiw tibihxe siht ot snoitatic yna tnemelppus ot negmA wolla osla lliw ehcoR .delif ylcilbup eb ot ,76640000-ALB-R-CTI ,tnemetats 1.65 s'negmA fo 31 hpargaraP ni ot detic egap eht wolla 11ˇ ehcoR tub ,negˇ yb dereffo stibihxe rehto htiw evitalumuc ylralimis si 8 tibihxE .htiw noitcennoc

)6(

1

ni dereffo si tibihxe siht taht noitisoporp hcae rof stnemucod lanoitidda ot setic ydaerla negmA ,tnemetats 1.65 eht fo 1 hpargaraP rof tpecxe ,taht dna ,noitom s'negmA ot yrassecennu si tnemucod egap 002 evitisnes ylhgih siht fo klub eht taht seton ehcoR ,stibihxe evitanretla ot ro tnemetats 1.65 s'negmA ot snoitatic htiw tibihxe siht ot snoitatic yna tnemelppus ?tnemetats 1.65 s'negmA fo ot negmA wolla ot gnillˇ reˇ era eW hpargaraP ni ot detic egap eht si hcihw ,delif ylcilbup eb ot 87140000-ALB -R-CTI delebal egap eht ylno wolla lliw ehcoR ,5 tibihxE ot tcepser htiW

)5(

PLL
Filed 07/16/2007 Page 4 of 5

2 egaP 7002 ,01 yluJ ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesae yaD .qsE ,nanaˇlsiF .E harobeD
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-4

A653107 105/9903

.qsE ,notsuH ailuJ .qsE ,lleyaM nivnaM .qsE ,nosraC aicirtaP

CC

/TEK

.degnahcnu niamer yam tnemgduj yrammus rof noitom s'ehcoR ot noitisoppO s'negmA ni stibihxE eseht ot secnerefer ro snoitatouq yna tub ,ylcilbup desolcsid ro delif eb ton lliw 84 dna 63 tibihxE
.drocer cilbup eht ni delif eb nac )436 .oN tekcoD( noteldneP .N nelluC fo noitaralceD eht ot stNihxe eht ,84 dna 63 tibihxE rof tpecxE
eht fo 7 mialC taht

)2(

)1(

degnirfnI toN si dna 211 § CSU 53 rednU dilavnI si tnetaP 943' tnemgduJ yrammuS rof noitoM s'ehcoR ot noitisoppO s'negmA
ot 1

,noitaralceD nivlaG eht

.1 elbaF" stcader dna ,712-512 segap sevomer negmA taht dedivorp tibihxE elif ylcilbup yam negmA ,eromrehtruF

)3(

nivlaG .M treboR fo noitaralceD eht ot 5-2 stibihxE elif feirb

.)566 ylcilbup

.oN yam

tekcoD( negmA

)2(
)1(

.)466 .oN tekcoD( tnemegnirfni fo tnemgduj ylpeR sti fo noisrev detcadernu na drocer cilbup
fo

yrammus fo troppus ni eht ni elif yam negmA

fo

tnemegnirfnI

tnemgduJ yrammuS

6 mialC 896' dna ,3 mialC 339' ,1 mialC 224' mialC rof noitoM stI fo troppuS ni ylpeR s'negmA

PLL

3 egaP 7002 ,01 yluJ ,redlehctaB & dirdaM reebesaC yaD .qsE ,namhsiF .E harobeD
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 723-4

Filed 07/16/2007

Page 5 of 5