Shirokov v. Dunlap, Grubb & Weaver PLLC et al

Filing 55

Opposition re 42 MOTION to Dismiss The Second Amended Class Action Complaint filed by Dmitriy Shirokov. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H, # 9 Exhibit I, # 10 Exhibit J, # 11 Exhibit K, # 12 Exhibit L)(Sweet, Jason)

Download PDF
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS __________________________________________ DMITRIY SHIROKOV, on behalf of himself ) and all others similarly situated, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) ) DUNLAP, GRUBB & WEAVER, PLLC; ) US COPYRIGHT GROUP; THOMAS DUNLAP; ) NICHOLAS KURTZ; GUARDALEY, LIMITED; ) and ACHTE/NEUNTE BOLL KINO ) BETEILIGUNGS GMBH & CO KG, ) ) Defendants. ) __________________________________________) Civ. A. No. 1:10-cv-12043-GAO DECLARATION OF ERIN FITZGERALD I, Erin Fitzgerald, declare as follows: 1. I am a law student at New England Law Boston and a summer associate at Booth Sweet LLP, counsel for Plaintiff in the above-captioned matter, and I make this declaration on my own personal knowledge. 2. This declaration sets forth facts that establish that many of the IP addresses compiled by Guardaley, Limited (“Guardaley”) on behalf of Achte/Neunte Boll Kino Beteiligungs Gmbh & Co. KG (“Achte”) use Internet connections likely located physically inside of the State of Massachusetts. 3. In its copyright infringement lawsuit filed in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia on March 18, 2010 (the “Achte action”), Achte submitted a list of alleged infringers as Exhibit A to its complaint. According to a declaration by Guardaley’s Benjamin Perino, filed on the same date as the complaint, Guardaley’s searches of peer-to-peer networks produced the list of alleged infringers, identifying each one “by the unique Internet Protocol (“IP”) address assigned to that Defendant by his/her ISP on the date and at the time of the Defendant’s infringing activity.” Declaration of Benjamin Perino in Support of Plaintiff’s Motion for Leave to Take Discovery Prior to Rule 26(f) Conference, ¶ 8, No. 10-453 (D.D.C. Mar. 18, 2010). 4. On request by Booth Sweet LLP, I compiled a list of IP addresses for the alleged infringers in the Achte Action. The list includes the 2,094 IP addresses identified in an exhibit to Achte’s original complaint filed March 18, 2010, and the 4,577 alleged infringers identified in an exhibit to Achte’s First Amended Complaint. Excluding duplicates between the lists, there are a total of 4,692 unique IP addresses. 5. There are many web-based tools freely available to the public that help reveal where a person using a particular IP address is likely to be physically located. These facts are readily available to the Defendants in this case from free, public Internet sources and have been readily available since well before the Defendants filed the Achte Action. 6. Using the free, publicly available DNS lookup service at http://lookupserver.com/, I conducted a search of the 4,692 IP addresses. My search revealed that at least 93 out the 4,692 IP addresses identified by Guardaley and Achte as alleged infringers likely have a physical location within Massachusetts. 30 of the 93 likely Massachusetts IP addresses I identified were among those identified by Achte at the time of its original complaint. Achte’s First Amended Complaint included 28 of those 30 alleged infringers, along with 63 other likely Massachusetts IP addresses. 2 7. I cross-checked those 93 IP addresses using another free and publicly available web- based tool. I accessed MaxMind GeoIP geolocation database at http://maxmind.com/. MaxMind claims that this free version can determine the location of “79% [of U.S. IP addresses] within a 25 mile radius.” MaxMind website, http://www.maxmind.com/app/ geolitecity (accessed May 31, 2011). Each of the 93 IP addressed that I located within Massachusetts using http://lookupserver.com/, I again found to be located within Massachusetts using MaxMind. 8. Based on the tracking dates provided by GuardaLey, of those 93 likely Massachusetts IP addresses, there were 6 Massachusetts addresses tracked in September 2009, 4 in October 2009, 5 in November 2009, 33 in December 2009, 16 in January 2010, 14 in February 2010, 8 in March 2010, 6 in April 2010 and 1 in May 2010. 9. 12 of the Massachusetts IP addresses identified by Guardaley and Achte were alleged to have infringed before the Achte’s claimed Far Cry publication date of November 24, 2009. 55 of them, including the Plaintiff in the above-captioned matter, are alleged to have infringed before Far Cry’s January 19, 2010 effective date of copyright registration. 10. I have attached as Exhibit A to this Declaration a list of the Massachusetts IP addresses supplied in the Achte Action as well as the estimated physical location of each such IP address according to www.lookupserver.com and www.maxmind.com. 11. Exhibit A includes the Massachusetts IP addresses tracked by GuardaLey (Column B), the date and time GuardaLey allegedly tracked the alleged infringement (Columns C and D), the state, city, latitude and longitude that lookupserver.com assigns to the IP address 3 (Columns F, G, H, and I), and the state, city, latitude and longitude that MaxMind assigns to the IP address (Columns J, K, L, and M). 12. Using the same method, I have conducted and double-checked a search of IP addresses identified by Guardaley as belonging to alleged infringers in cases filed by Dunlap, Grubb & Weaver PLLC other than the Achte action. Attached as Exhibit B to this declaration is a list of 102 Massachusetts IP addresses I found, using the same search plan as described above, in their lawsuits regarding the following movies: The Gray Man, Uncross the Stars, The Steam Experiment/The Chaos Experiment, Call of the Wild, 13 Hours in a Warehouse, Border Town, Numbers Game, Deceitful Storm and Hellbinders. 13. The earliest date of alleged infringement I have come across in any of Guardaley’s data related to cases filed by Dunlap, Grubb & Weaver PLLC is an IP address in the Gray Man case associated with an alleged date of infringement of March 8, 2009. 14. The earliest likely Massachusetts IP address tracked by Guardaley that I have identified was an alleged Gray Man infringer tracked on April 6, 2009. Based on GuardaLey’s tracking for the movies included in Exhibit B, in addition to the Far Cry class action members, Guardaley tracked at least 2 likely Massachusetts IP addresses in April 2009, 4 in May 2009, 6 in June 2009, 2 in July 2009, 1 in August 2009, 6 in November 2009, 2 in December 2009, 7 in January 2010, 11 in February 2010, 23 in March 2010, 21 in April 2010, 15 in May 2010 and 2 in June 2010. 15. Exhibit B includes the Massachusetts IP addresses tracked by GuardaLey for the movies listed in paragraph 11 of this declaration (Column B), the date and time GuardaLey allegedly tracked the alleged infringement (Columns C and D), the movie that was 4 EXHIBIT A # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Host IP Address 74.104.123.57 76.19.37.84 71.233.25.160 75.67.179.55 24.60.82.171 71.233.145.183 72.74.109.162 76.19.116.60 65.96.127.95 24.60.245.178 69.205.48.178 71.233.145.86 71.192.182.5 66.31.113.14 24.91.120.94 76.118.229.14 66.30.253.164 76.119.10.99 68.163.148.133 68.163.232.156 173.76.165.6 24.61.56.33 71.232.128.163 71.233.129.148 74.76.12.138 24.61.170.39 68.163.190.90 76.119.137.93 Date 9/17/2009 9/22/2009 9/24/2009 9/25/2009 9/26/2009 9/29/2009 10/13/2009 10/18/2009 10/24/2009 10/29/2009 11/19/2009 11/20/2009 11/22/2009 11/23/2009 11/27/2009 12/1/2009 12/1/2009 12/1/2009 12/2/2009 12/3/2009 12/3/2009 12/4/2009 12/4/2009 12/4/2009 12/4/2009 12/5/2009 12/5/2009 12/6/2009 Lookupserver.com Time (Local) State City Lat. 3:01:47 PM MA Framingham 42.3011 2:21:33 AM MA Swampscott 42.4755 5:43:19 AM MA Berkley 41.828 12:00:01 AM MA Monument Beach 41.7177 5:45:07 PM MA Boston 42.3366 4:47:48 AM MA New Bedford 41.6628 5:52:35 AM MA Worcester 42.2647 1:18:34 AM MA Boston 42.3425 1:44:08 AM MA Boston 42.2848 12:22:22 AM MA Agawam 42.0655 4:59:12 AM MA North Adams 42.6881 4:40:13 AM MA New Bedford 41.6628 1:58:44 AM MA Longmeadow 42.0535 3:32:48 PM MA South Easton 42.0262 8:37:16 PM MA Peabody 42.5324 7:17:01 AM MA Boston 42.3059 6:18:15 AM MA Chelsea 42.3997 2:39:50 AM MA Gloucester 42.6179 4:43:08 AM MA Boston 42.3425 3:56:22 AM MA Somerville 42.3919 8:04:29 PM MA Tewksbury 42.6105 11:28:57 PM MA Chelsea 42.3997 12:22:42 PM MA Haverhill 42.7959 1:51:43 AM MA North Andover 42.6723 10:25:04 PM MA North Adams 42.6881 5:39:37 PM MA Salem 42.5153 1:42:25 AM MA Boston 42.3425 6:07:08 PM MA Salem 42.5153 Maxmind.com Long. State City Lat. -71.4393 MA Framingham 42.2788 -70.9069 MA Lynn 42.473 -71.0633 MA Fall River 41.7305 -70.6143 MA Buzzards Bay 41.7683 -70.0726 MA Boston 42.3059 -70.9447 MA New Bedford 41.6529 -71.8089 MA Worcester 42.2647 -71.0677 MA Boston 42.3425 -71.0741 MA Boston 42.3425 -72.6271 MA West Springfield 42.1235 -73.063 MA North Adams 42.6881 -70.9447 MA New Bedford 41.6628 -72.5685 MA Longmeadow 42.0535 -71.0845 MA Brockton 42.0796 -70.9736 MA Peabody 42.5324 -71.0859 MA Boston 42.3059 -71.0316 MA Melrose 42.4574 -70.7154 MA Gloucester 42.6179 -71.0677 MA Scituate 42.2081 -71.1025 MA Boston 42.3425 -71.2306 MA Tewksbury 42.6105 -71.0316 MA Melrose 42.4574 -71.057 MA Haverhill 42.7959 -71.0837 MA North Andover 42.6723 -73.063 MA Adams 42.6271 -70.9075 MA Salem 42.5153 -71.0677 MA Watertown 42.3723 -70.9075 MA Salem 42.5153 Long. -71.4435 -70.9419 -71.1145 -70.6007 -71.0859 -70.9377 -71.8089 -71.0677 -71.0677 -72.6399 -73.063 -70.9447 -72.5685 -71.0382 -70.9736 -71.0859 -71.054 -70.7154 -70.775 -71.0677 -71.2306 -71.054 -71.057 -71.0837 -73.1187 -70.9075 -71.1787 -70.9075 # 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 Host IP Address 68.163.199.37 76.119.146.209 98.217.120.210 98.217.8.249 66.189.105.124 72.93.84.75 24.218.200.12 75.67.200.184 96.233.49.83 24.61.85.246 96.237.250.33 24.91.43.7 76.127.231.51 24.34.232.139 68.163.180.203 98.217.101.205 24.218.249.27 76.127.217.136 72.93.84.241 24.63.149.215 72.93.173.66 65.96.172.202 24.91.231.211 71.232.155.203 24.218.28.18 76.118.113.152 76.127.141.224 65.96.232.190 72.79.198.116 24.147.148.11 Date 12/7/2009 12/8/2009 12/8/2009 12/10/2009 12/11/2009 12/11/2009 12/13/2009 12/15/2009 12/15/2009 12/17/2009 12/18/2009 12/19/2009 12/20/2009 12/22/2009 12/22/2009 12/23/2009 12/23/2009 12/23/2009 12/26/2009 12/31/2009 1/1/2010 1/4/2010 1/6/2010 1/6/2010 1/7/2010 1/10/2010 1/10/2010 1/13/2010 1/16/2010 1/21/2010 Lookupserver.com Time (Local) State City Lat. 12:58:06 AM MA Brookline 42.3221 5:22:54 AM MA Nantucket 41.3152 3:31:14 AM MA Winthrop 42.3678 12:52:48 AM MA Medford 42.4247 2:39:51 AM MA Chicopee 42.1861 3:26:18 AM MA Acton 42.4853 3:52:14 AM MA Framingham 42.2788 9:30:35 PM MA Buzzards Bay 41.7361 8:30:06 AM MA Framingham 42.3233 4:15:26 AM MA Arlington 42.4155 8:49:43 PM MA Fitchburg 42.5908 5:43:37 AM MA Boston 42.2848 1:24:25 AM MA West Springfield 42.1235 2:17:58 AM MA Attleboro 41.9395 10:55:19 AM MA Brookline 42.3326 11:50:52 PM MA Springfield 42.1064 1:32:28 PM MA Revere 42.4163 1:50:42 AM MA Haverhill 42.7914 3:04:25 AM MA Acton 42.4853 1:52:57 AM MA Methuen 42.7324 4:25:38 PM MA Chelsea 42.3997 1:48:19 AM MA Somerville 42.3919 3:15:51 PM MA Bridgewater 41.9703 12:53:49 AM MA Stoughton 42.1186 7:35:50 AM MA Hull 42.2846 4:57:59 AM MA North Dartmouth 41.6623 4:33:41 AM MA Revere 42.4163 2:31:00 AM MA Winthrop 42.3678 5:19:54 PM MA Northampton 42.3306 2:47:55 AM MA New Bedford 41.6354 Maxmind.com Long. State City Lat. -71.1334 MA Boston 42.3425 -70.009 MA Nantucket 41.3152 -70.969 MA Malden 42.4281 -71.1112 MA Everett 42.4063 -72.5255 MA Worcester 42.2647 -71.4419 MA Acton 42.4853 -71.4435 MA Framingham 42.2788 -70.5719 MA Sandwich 41.7194 -71.4352 MA Framingham 42.2788 -71.1756 MA Reading 42.5335 -71.8055 MA Fitchburg 42.5908 -71.0741 MA Boston 42.3425 -72.6399 MA West Springfield 42.1235 -71.2943 MA Attleboro 41.9395 -71.1282 MA Brighton 42.3484 -72.5901 MA Springfield 42.1091 -70.9969 MA Revere 42.4163 -71.1322 MA Haverhill 42.7959 -71.4419 MA Acton 42.4853 -71.1862 MA Lawrence 42.6912 -71.0316 MA Charlestown 42.3801 -71.1025 MA Cambridge 42.3741 -70.9768 MA Stoughton 42.1186 -71.1033 MA Stoughton 42.1186 -70.8741 MA South Weymouth 42.1658 -71.0107 MA North Dartmouth 41.6623 -70.9969 MA Revere 42.4163 -70.969 MA Malden 42.4281 -72.6306 MA Springfield 42.1091 -70.9435 MA New Bedford 41.6529 Long. -71.0677 -70.009 -71.0546 -71.0512 -71.8089 -71.4418 -71.4435 -70.4803 -71.4435 -71.1036 -71.8055 -71.0677 -72.6399 -71.2943 -71.1551 -72.5464 -70.9969 -71.057 -71.4418 -71.161 -71.0642 -71.1072 -71.1033 -71.1033 -70.9506 -71.0107 -70.9969 -70.0546 -72.5464 -70.9377 # 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 Host IP Address 76.19.71.26 209.6.155.67 24.128.169.235 24.218.182.126 65.96.117.135 24.218.150.165 71.232.216.144 76.119.240.160 24.63.43.178 24.128.26.12 71.233.64.166 75.69.146.25 151.203.77.147 98.229.34.186 76.119.187.247 71.235.161.130 24.63.246.88 24.63.67.215 24.63.31.105 24.34.190.76 66.30.210.42 72.74.93.78 24.34.9.5 72.93.72.53 70.19.187.128 173.48.100.13 72.93.84.113 72.93.84.104 Date 1/22/2010 1/26/2010 1/27/2010 1/29/2010 1/30/2010 1/31/2010 2/2/2010 2/2/2010 2/9/2010 2/9/2010 2/9/2010 2/12/2010 2/12/2010 2/14/2010 2/16/2010 2/17/2010 2/18/2010 2/18/2010 2/22/2010 2/28/2010 3/1/2010 3/10/2010 3/11/2010 3/12/2010 3/16/2010 3/17/2010 3/18/2010 3/22/2010 Time (Local) 4:03:33 AM 7:38:00 AM 3:43:17 AM 10:43:43 PM 1:27:21 AM 9:14:14 PM 5:02:38 PM 7:18:38 AM 10:23:48 PM 12:04:08 AM 7:55:24 PM 2:30:37 AM 3:40:32 AM 8:02:59 AM 12:21:19 AM 5:21:09 AM 10:41:09 PM 3:27:58 AM 6:27:46 AM 7:01:44 PM 12:11:32 AM 7:43:11 PM 1:32:19 AM 12:00:53 AM 6:29:22 PM 12:28:02 AM 4:10:02 PM 6:48:46 PM State MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA Lookupserver.com City Lat. Peabody 42.5324 Watertown 42.3722 Malden 42.4281 Concord 42.4586 Quincy 42.2429 Lynn 42.461 South Hadley 42.2586 Westfield 42.1733 North Andover 42.6723 Boston 42.3425 Medway 42.1556 Boston 42.3425 Shirley 42.5801 Methuen 42.7324 South Weymouth 42.1658 Turners Falls 42.6063 Marstons Mills 41.6686 Westfield 42.1733 East Weymouth 42.2093 New Bedford 41.6529 Wilmington 42.5653 Acton 42.4853 West Bridgewater 42.0178 Middleboro 41.8803 Lowell 42.6416 Worcester 42.2893 Acton 42.4853 Acton 42.4853 Long. -70.9736 -71.1789 -71.0546 -71.3597 -71.0098 -70.9463 -72.5752 -72.7715 -71.0837 -71.0677 -71.4268 -71.0677 -71.6367 -71.1862 -70.9506 -72.4804 -70.414 -72.7715 -70.9326 -70.9377 -71.1745 -71.4419 -71.0242 -70.8815 -71.3225 -71.7944 -71.4419 -71.4419 State MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA MA Maxmind.com City Lat. Peabody 42.5324 Watertown 42.3722 Malden 42.4281 Concord 42.4586 Quincy 42.2429 Salem 42.5153 South Hadley 42.2586 Westfield 42.1733 Lawrence 42.7084 Boston 42.3059 Bellingham 42.0766 Boston 42.3425 Marlborough 42.3458 Methuen 42.7324 Hingham 42.2159 Greenfield 42.6342 Marstons Mills 41.6686 Westfield 42.1733 East Weymouth 42.2093 New Bedford 41.7057 Wakefield 42.5013 Acton 42.4853 West Bridgewater 42.0178 Middleboro 41.8803 Worcester 42.2647 North Grafton 42.2244 Acton 42.4853 Acton 42.4853 Long. -70.9736 -71.1789 -71.0546 -71.3597 -71.0098 -70.9075 -72.5752 -72.7715 -71.1435 -71.0859 -71.4719 -71.0677 -71.5506 -71.1862 -70.8793 -72.6026 -70.414 -72.7715 -70.9326 -70.9469 -71.0689 -71.4418 -71.0242 -70.8815 -71.8089 -71.6894 -71.4418 -71.4418 # 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 Host IP Address 72.93.18.38 96.237.133.75 71.192.125.224 98.110.240.101 71.174.135.79 76.119.98.202 74.104.21.154 Date 4/5/2010 4/9/2010 4/13/2010 4/14/2010 4/16/2010 4/21/2010 5/3/2010 Lookupserver.com Time (Local) State City Lat. 12:10:22 AM MA Amesbury 42.8541 4:40:07 PM MA Quincy 42.2429 7:25:30 AM MA Springfield 42.1091 2:26:00 PM MA Methuen 42.7324 2:51:48 PM MA Boston 42.3425 10:11:35 PM MA Randolph 42.1696 7:32:57 AM MA Lowell 42.6416 Maxmind.com Long. State City Lat. -70.9521 MA Haverhill 42.7801 -71.0098 MA Cambridge 42.3741 -72.5464 MA Springfield 42.1091 -71.1862 MA Methuen 42.7324 -71.0677 MA Boston 42.3425 -71.0606 MA Randolph 42.1696 -71.3225 MA Lowell 42.6416 Long. -71.0917 -71.1072 -72.5464 -71.1862 -71.0677 -71.0606 -71.3225 EXHIBIT B # 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Host IP Address 24.218.126.89 71.174.22.160 24.147.210.84 71.248.175.124 71.174.225.159 24.61.204.182 71.232.86.10 72.79.196.216 72.70.242.36 72.70.238.61 76.118.28.37 71.233.192.146 72.74.13.173 72.70.124.247 24.218.41.191 76.119.72.114 24.218.4.96 71.192.216.29 98.217.242.81 24.147.210.84 71.174.4.187 76.19.228.77 96.252.121.73 173.76.63.99 70.22.199.110 71.192.210.116 24.91.107.250 24.91.245.57 75.67.88.229 98.217.98.253 Date 4/6/2009 4/8/2009 5/8/2009 5/19/2009 5/20/2009 5/21/2009 6/15/2009 6/20/2009 6/20/2009 6/20/2009 6/28/2009 6/29/2009 7/26/2009 7/28/2009 8/15/2009 11/11/2009 11/12/2009 11/16/2009 11/18/2009 11/19/2009 11/22/2009 12/8/2009 12/23/2009 1/9/2010 1/13/2010 1/14/2010 1/17/2010 1/18/2010 1/23/2010 1/23/2010 Time (Local) 6:10:42 AM 1:41:17 PM 6:54:33 AM 7:17:37 AM 10:42:46 AM 1:33:16 PM 7:55:16 PM 2:27:24 AM 3:17:48 AM 3:54:53 AM 4:32:46 AM 63:38:03 AM 8:12:12 PM 3:56:20 AM 6:34:49 AM 1:01:34 AM 7:25:58 PM 8:10:23 PM 6:21:48 PM 4:42:59 AM 1:16:45 AM 12:29:26 AM 1:20:36 AM 6:18:23 PM 6:49:57 PM 8:17:10 PM 10:14:21 AM 7:59:26 AM 2:11:10 AM 12:43:36 AM Related Title The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man The Gray Man Uncross the Stars Uncross the Stars Uncross the Stars Uncross the Stars Uncross the Stars The Steam Experiment The Gray Man The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Lookupserver.com State City Lat. MA Cambridge 42.3741 MA Salem 42.5153 MA North Andover 42.6723 MA Hopkinton 42.225 MA Newton 42.3533 MA Lowell 42.6339 MA Fitchburg 42.5908 MA East Longmeadow 42.062 MA Hinsdale 42.4318 MA Chicopee 42.1852 MA Waban 42.3276 MA Salem 42.5153 MA Salem 42.5153 MA Gloucester 42.6179 MA Norwell 42.1508 MA Springfield 42.0981 MA Boston 42.3425 MA Westfield 42.1733 MA Lawrence 42.7084 MA North Andover 42.6723 MA Worcester 42.2647 MA Provincetown 42.0511 MA Millbury 42.1912 MA New Bedford 41.6529 MA Boston 42.2941 MA South Hadley 42.2586 MA West Yarmouth 41.6494 MA New Bedford 41.6529 MA Marshfield 42.1112 MA Haverhill 42.7959 Long. -71.1072 -70.9075 -71.0837 -71.5315 -71.1883 -71.2957 -71.8055 -72.4989 -73.074 -72.5636 -71.2328 -70.9075 -70.9075 -70.7154 -70.8228 -72.5774 -71.0677 -72.7715 -71.1435 -71.0837 -71.8089 -70.196 -71.7789 -70.9377 -71.0543 -72.5752 -70.2415 -70.9377 -70.7127 -71.057 # 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 Host IP Address 66.30.109.189 76.24.72.49 24.62.65.142 173.76.60.113 72.79.216.252 98.217.32.255 71.184.148.41 71.192.46.37 98.216.47.4 71.232.174.20 98.217.33.247 65.96.152.69 76.119.203.37 76.119.136.137 72.74.12.180 173.76.113.175 151.199.27.149 72.74.222.92 75.68.239.69 71.233.233.125 76.24.59.145 98.216.24.167 71.233.88.70 96.236.112.253 98.216.243.91 72.74.225.147 173.76.105.117 72.93.8.110 96.233.100.227 66.30.129.28 Date 2/1/2010 2/6/2010 2/7/2010 2/7/2010 2/17/2010 2/21/2010 2/21/2010 2/25/2010 2/25/2010 2/28/2010 2/28/2010 3/1/2010 3/1/2010 3/4/2010 3/5/2010 3/5/2010 3/7/2010 3/11/2010 3/15/2010 3/16/2010 3/17/2010 3/19/2010 3/22/2010 3/23/2010 3/23/2010 3/23/2010 3/25/2010 3/25/2010 3/26/2010 3/26/2010 Time (Local) 12:47:53 AM 10:27:28 PM 2:34:04 PM 1:15:43 AM 9:57:51 AM 3:28:15 AM 10:53:56 PM 4:53:15 AM 12:06:20 AM 4:17:26 PM 11:40:36 PM 4:15:40 AM 7:46:27 PM 8:42:03 AM 12:24:45 AM 9:15:30 PM 4:28:50 PM 12:28:07 AM 1:38:40 AM 7:47:57 AM 12:01:52 AM 3:44:20 AM 1:36:24 PM 8:02:14 PM 3:59:08 AM 1:03:55 AM 1:58:34 AM 2:57:55 AM 3:00:48 AM 6:15:57 PM Related Title The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment Call of the Wild The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment He Who Finds a Wife The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment Call of the Wild The Steam Experiment 13 Hours in a Warehouse The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment The Steam Experiment Border Town The Steam Experiment Call of the Wild Border Town The Steam Experiment Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Border Town Border Town Fast Track No Limits Fast Track No Limits Call of the Wild The Chaos Experiment Lookupserver.com State City Lat. MA Lowell 42.6339 MA Fall River 41.6926 MA Blackstone 42.0396 MA Brockton 42.0796 MA Agawam 42.0655 MA Billerica 42.5493 MA Norwood 42.1818 MA Florence 42.3294 MA Whitman 42.0804 MA Mendon 42.103 MA Lowell 42.6336 MA Malden 42.4281 MA Sandwich 41.7194 MA Salem 42.5153 MA Gloucester 42.6179 MA Leominster 42.5244 MA Boston 42.3425 MA New Bedford 41.6529 MA Peabody 42.5324 MA Greenfield 42.6342 MA Nantucket 41.3152 MA South Easton 42.0262 MA Westfield 42.1733 MA Springfield 42.1091 MA Everett 42.4064 MA New Bedford 41.6529 MA Lynn 42.4733 MA South Yarmouth 41.6713 MA Framingham 42.3233 MA Attleboro 41.9395 Long. -71.2957 -71.1341 -71.5305 -71.0382 -72.6271 -71.2558 -71.1962 -72.6936 -70.9393 -71.5439 -71.2957 -71.0546 -70.4802 -70.9075 -70.7154 -71.7657 -71.0677 -70.9377 -70.9736 -72.6026 -70.009 -71.0845 -72.7715 -72.5461 -71.0512 -70.9377 -70.9419 -70.1916 -71.4352 -71.2943 # 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 Host IP Address 98.216.191.167 98.216.41.192 98.217.193.251 71.233.20.69 24.63.46.142 76.19.185.197 71.233.23.36 76.118.243.123 76.19.229.8 24.62.55.8 98.229.108.166 66.30.168.41 24.60.239.157 76.24.25.99 24.147.127.198 76.19.205.55 71.233.32.154 75.67.128.31 24.61.32.176 76.127.224.153 71.232.81.217 98.217.38.62 66.30.216.4 24.61.201.58 76.24.146.47 76.119.149.159 173.76.65.50 66.30.157.181 71.192.151.66 71.235.234.214 Date 3/26/2010 3/30/2010 3/31/2010 3/31/2010 4/2/2010 4/3/2010 4/9/2010 4/9/2010 4/9/2010 4/9/2010 4/10/2010 4/10/2010 4/11/2010 4/11/2010 4/11/2010 4/11/2010 4/11/2010 4/12/2010 4/13/2010 4/15/2010 4/16/2010 4/16/2010 4/21/2010 4/26/2010 4/30/2010 5/1/2010 5/1/2010 5/2/2010 5/2/2010 5/2/2010 Time (Local) 12:02:04 AM 5:17:18 PM 11:02:31 PM 12:55:00 AM 12:49:47 AM 2:23:24 PM 2:39:23 PM 2:45:22 PM 8:26:45 PM 10:38:16 PM 12:00:26 AM 12:16:08 AM 2:23:10 AM 12:08:00 AM 12:08:57 AM 1:24:08 AM 6:29:18 PM 6:44:23 PM 9:10:32 AM 4:07:48 AM 12:18:58 PM 4:08:42 PM 9:30:35 PM 9:36:29 AM 11:49:42 PM 4:50:59 PM 12:18:34 PM 12:06:09 AM 3:41:35 AM 4:01:07 PM Related Title Locator 2 Call of the Wild Call of the Wild Border Town The Chaos Experiment Call of the Wild Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game The Chaos Experiment Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game Numbers Game The Chaos Experiment The Chaos Experiment Deceitful Storm Deceitful Storm Deceitful Storm The Chaos Experiment Deceitful Storm Hellbinders Lookupserver.com State City Lat. MA Wayland 42.3613 MA Brockton 42.0796 MA Boston 42.3059 MA Lawrence 42.7084 MA Westminster 42.5566 MA Taunton 41.9113 MA North Andover 42.6723 MA Longmeadow 42.0535 MA Provincetown 42.0511 MA South Weymouth 42.1658 MA Acton 42.4853 MA North Easton 42.0564 MA New Bedford 41.6354 MA Cambridge 42.3741 MA North Andover 42.6723 MA Acushnet 41.7138 MA Lowell 42.6339 MA Lynn 42.4721 MA Salem 42.5153 MA Agawam 42.0655 MA Fitchburg 42.5908 MA Billerica 42.5493 MA Woburn 42.4897 MA Lowell 42.6241 MA Springfield 42.0981 MA Attleboro 41.9395 MA Attleboro 41.9395 MA Randolph 42.1696 MA Springfield 42.0954 MA New Bedford 41.6529 Long. -71.3629 -71.0382 -71.0859 -71.1435 -71.9086 -71.13 -71.0837 -72.5685 -70.196 -70.9506 -71.4419 -71.1199 -70.9435 -71.1072 -71.0837 -70.8997 -71.2957 -70.9584 -70.9075 -72.6271 -71.8055 -71.2558 -71.1595 -71.3389 -72.5774 -71.2943 -71.2943 -71.0606 -72.5243 -70.9377 # 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 Host IP Address 65.96.240.140 71.126.244.157 24.61.49.59 71.192.130.208 71.233.3.232 76.24.136.72 98.217.93.253 71.232.18.70 72.72.24.250 24.63.151.146 71.192.130.3 24.147.178.253 Date 5/3/2010 5/4/2010 5/7/2010 5/11/2010 5/13/2010 5/14/2010 5/14/2010 5/15/2010 5/17/2010 5/18/2010 6/1/2010 6/19/2010 Time (Local) 6:43:57 PM 10:16:24 PM 7:49:12 AM 11:39:34 AM 4:01:11 AM 1:40:46 AM 7:41:23 PM 2:27:43 PM 4:39:53 AM 1:21:25 AM 4:46:31 AM 5:40:21 PM Related Title Hellbinders Deceitful Storm Hellbinders The Chaos Experiment Hellbinders The Chaos Experiment The Chaos Experiment Hellbinders Hellbinders Hellbinders The Chaos Experiment The Chaos Experiment Lookupserver.com State City Lat. MA Boston 42.3425 MA Methuen 42.7324 MA Danvers 42.5767 MA Springfield 42.0807 MA Lowell 42.6241 MA Springfield 42.1186 MA Lowell 42.656 MA Cambridge 42.3741 MA Quincy 42.2654 MA Methuen 42.7324 MA Springfield 42.1298 MA Boston 42.3605 Long. -71.0677 -71.1862 -70.9549 -72.5582 -71.3389 -72.5499 -71.3049 -71.1072 -71.0185 -71.1862 -72.5687 -71.0548 Maxmind.com # State City Lat. 1 MA Cambridge 42.3741 2 MA Tewksbury 42.6105 3 MA North Andover 42.6723 4 MA Hopkinton 42.225 5 MA Methuen 42.7324 6 MA Lowell 42.6241 7 MA Fitchburg 42.5908 8 MA Holyoke 42.2238 9 MA Chicopee 42.1852 10 MA Chicopee 42.1852 11 MA Watertown 42.3722 12 MA Salem 42.5153 13 MA Gloucester 42.6179 14 MA Peabody 42.5324 15 MA Scituate 42.2081 16 MA Springfield 42.1091 17 MA Boston 42.3496 18 MA Westfield 42.1733 19 MA Lawrence 42.7023 20 MA North Andover 42.6723 21 MA Worcester 42.2647 22 MA Wellfleet 41.9215 23 MA Millbury 42.1912 24 MA Brockton 42.0827 25 MA Framingham 42.3011 26 MA Holyoke 42.2238 27 MA South Yarmouth 41.6713 28 MA New Bedford 41.6354 29 MA Duxbury 42.0502 30 MA Haverhill 42.7959 Long. -71.1072 -71.2306 -71.0837 -71.5315 -71.1862 -71.3389 -71.8055 -72.6409 -72.5636 -72.5636 -71.1787 -70.9075 -70.7154 -70.9737 -70.775 -72.5464 -71.0746 -72.7715 -71.1551 -71.0837 -71.8089 -70.0169 -71.7789 -71.0191 -71.4393 -72.6409 -70.1916 -70.9435 -70.695 -71.057 Maxmind.com # State City Lat. 31 MA Lowell 42.6339 32 VT Colchester 44.55 33 MA Milford 42.1544 34 MA Fall River 41.695 35 MA Springfield 42.1091 36 MA Lowell 42.6416 37 MA Norwood 42.1818 38 MA Northampton 42.3306 39 MA Brockton 42.0796 40 MA Milford 42.1544 41 MA Lowell 42.6416 42 MA Malden 42.4281 43 MA Sandwich 41.7194 44 MA Salem 42.5153 45 MA Gloucester 42.6179 46 MA Leominster 42.5244 47 MA Chelsea 42.3997 48 MA New Bedford 41.6529 49 MA Peabody 42.5324 50 MA Greenfield 42.6342 51 MA Nantucket 41.3152 52 MA Whitman 42.0804 53 MA Westfield 42.1733 54 MA Springfield 42.1091 55 MA Everett 42.4063 56 MA Brockton 42.0827 57 MA Lynn 42.4733 58 MA Centerville 41.6562 59 MA Framingham 42.3233 60 MA Seekonk 41.8387 Long. -71.2957 -73.1552 -71.521 -71.1443 -72.5464 -71.3225 -71.1962 -72.6306 -71.0382 -71.521 -71.3225 -71.0546 -70.4803 -70.9075 -70.7154 -71.7657 -71.0316 -70.9377 -70.9736 -72.6026 -70.009 -70.9393 -72.7715 -72.5464 -71.0512 -71.0191 -70.9419 -70.3493 -71.4352 -71.3187 Maxmind.com # State City Lat. 61 MA Weston 42.3578 62 MA Brockton 42.0796 63 MA Boston 42.3425 64 MA Andover 42.6489 65 MA Gardner 42.5899 66 MA Attleboro 41.9395 67 MA Lawrence 42.7023 68 MA Longmeadow 42.0535 69 MA Eastham 41.8375 70 MA Weymouth 42.2068 71 MA Acton 42.4853 72 MA South Easton 42.0262 73 MA New Bedford 41.6529 74 MA Cambridge 42.3646 75 MA Andover 42.6489 76 MA New Bedford 41.7057 77 MA Lowell 42.6523 78 MA Lynn 42.4721 79 MA Lynn 42.4733 80 MA Feeding Hills 42.0704 81 MA Fitchburg 42.5908 82 MA Lowell 42.6416 83 MA Wakefield 42.5013 84 MA Lowell 42.6416 85 MA Springfield 42.1186 86 MA Attleboro 41.9395 87 MA Brockton 42.0827 88 MA Randolph 42.1696 89 MA Springfield 42.1091 90 MA New Bedford 41.7057 Long. -71.2956 -71.0382 -71.0677 -71.1655 -71.9887 -71.2943 -71.1551 -72.5685 -69.9748 -70.9552 -71.4418 -71.0845 -70.9377 -71.1028 -71.1655 -70.9469 -71.3506 -70.9584 -70.9419 -72.6764 -71.8055 -71.3225 -71.0689 -71.3225 -72.5499 -71.2943 -71.0191 -71.0606 -72.5464 41.7057 Maxmind.com # State City Lat. 91 MA Boston 42.2848 92 MA Stoughton 42.1186 93 MA Danvers 42.5767 94 MA Springfield 42.0807 95 MA Lowell 42.6416 96 MA Springfield 42.1186 97 MA Billerica 42.5493 98 MA Cambridge 42.37 99 MA Boston 42.3425 100 MA Lawrence 42.7084 101 MA Springfield 42.0807 102 MA Boston 42.3425 Long. -71.0741 -71.1033 -70.9549 -72.5582 -71.3225 -72.5499 -71.2558 -71.0812 -71.0677 -71.1435 -72.5582 -71.0677

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?