Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College et al

Filing 570

PRETRIAL MEMORANDUM by Students for Fair Admissions, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A1, # 2 Exhibit A2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F)(Mortara, Adam) (Additional attachment(s) added on 10/2/2018: # 8 Exhibit A1 (Filed Under Seal)) (McDonagh, Christina).

Exhibit C

1/8/13

1/21/13

2/20/13
2/00/13
2/20/13
2/20/13
2/21/13
2/26/13
2/28/13
4/15/13
4/16/13

4/22/13

4/29/13

4/29/13

4/30/13

4/30/13

P006

P007
P008
P009
P010
P011
P012
P013
P014
P015
P016
P017
P018
P019
P020

P021

P022

P023

P024

P025

2/14/13
2/18/13

8/14/13
12/3/12
12/20/12
1/7/13

Date

Ex. #
P001
P002
P003
P004
P005

Bever Email to Driver-Linn re: Updated memo and exhibits

Description
Reading Procedures, Class of 2018
Searches 2013 - Class of 2018
Fall 2012 College Admissions Analyses
Fall 2012 College Admissions Analyses
Methods PowerPoint
Yong Email to Waters re: reconfirming meeting, Wednesday
January 9th
Donahue Email to McGrath, et al. re: Fitz' drafts
Sample Models of Harvard's Admissions Data
Admissions Part II - Subtitle
Driver-Linn Email to Jilek re: two possible meetings
Contents, Part I: Access
Admissions and Financial Aid at Harvard College
Admissions and Financial Aid at Harvard College
Donahue Email to Fitzsimmons re: two possible meetings
Bever Email to Hansen re: Admissions power point
Hansen Email to Bever re: Admissions power point
Hansen Email to Yong re: Admissions Data
Hansen Email to Yong re: data files
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Follow-up
Stats of Classes of 2009-2016, Exs. 1-4
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Exhibits on admissions and
financial aid
Heenan Email to Driver-Linn re: two quick things
Bever Letter to Fitzsimmons re: Harvard College
Admissions and Low Income Students
Bever Letter to Fitzsimmons re: Harvard College
Admissions and Low Income Students

Page 1 of 30

HARV00074954

HARV00069732

HARV00069729

HARV00075051

HARV00075053

HARV00065444
HARV00029852
HARV00065741
HARV00075493
HARV00029846
HARV00031687
HARV00076038
HARV00065693
HARV00075073
HARV00075072
HARV00008791
HARV00008788
HARV00075060
HARV00069810

HARV00009110

Beginning Bates
HARV00000798
HARV00023564
HARV00032957
HARV00069535
HARV00069096

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00074962

HARV00069734

HARV00069731

HARV00075052

HARV00075059

HARV00065444
HARV00029857
HARV00065757
HARV00075494
HARV00029847
HARV00031729
HARV00076080
HARV00065695
HARV00075164
HARV00075072
HARV00008792
HARV00008789
HARV00075060
HARV00069813

HARV00009112

Ending Bates
HARV00000815
HARV00023564
HARV00033022
HARV00069616
HARV00069101

May Use

Will Use

Will Use

Will Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
Will Use
May Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
Will Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use

CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

CM, F, H, MIL, 403, 901, 702

CM, F, H, MIL, 403, 901, 702

CM, H, IR, MIL

H, IR, MIL

H
CM, MIL, 403, 702
CM, MIL
H, MIL
CM, F, 901, MIL, 403, 702
MIL
MIL
CM, H, MIL
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702
H, MIL, 403
H, MIL
H, MIL
CM, H, IR, MIL
CM, F, 901, MIL

IR, H

CM, F, 901
CM, MIL, 403, 702
CM, MIL, H, 403, 702
CM, MIL, 403, 702

Harvard Objection

Date
5/1/13

5/1/13

5/30/13

6/3/13

6/9/13

6/11/13

6/12/13

7/9/13

9/9/13

10/7/13

10/8/13

10/8/13

3/19/14
4/9/14
5/13/14
7/10/14

8/15/14

8/28/14
8/29/14
10/15/12

Ex. #
P026

P027

P028

P029

P030

P031

P032

P033

P034

P035

P036

P037

P038
P039
P040
P041

P042

P043
P044
P045

Bever Email to Driver-Linn re: Admissions simulation
power point
Meeting Invite re: Fisher v. University of Texas Discussion
#2
Modeling Admissions to Harvard College: Preliminary
Analysis
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: HFAI Outcomes
McGrath Email to Farzan re: Meeting request
Meeting Invite re: Race-Conscious Admissions
Bever Email to Driver-Linn re: Agenda for Khurana
Ortiz Email to Bever re: Report on differences in SAT
scores
Bever Email to Ortiz re: SAT distribution data
Bever Email to Ortiz re: Updated SAT distribution
Introduction to the Office of Institutional Research

Meeting Invite re: Fisher v. University of Texas Discussion

Donahue Email to Fitzsimmons re: Preliminary slides for
the financial aid discussion
Waters Email to Bever, et al. re: Revised Draft slides for
Friday
Waters Email to Fitzsimmons re: Revised Draft slides for
Friday
Banks Email to McGrath re: No subject

Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Low income demographics

Description
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Admissions memo
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Harvard College
Admissions and Low Income Students
Demographics of Harvard College Applicants

Page 2 of 30

HARV00025055
HARV00025057
HARV00068151

HARV00024974

HARV00010743
HARV00026390
HARV00077826
HARV00074976

HARV00069113

HARV00077839

HARV00074891

HARV00077840

HARV00035514

HARV00031432

HARV00073988

HARV00007803

HARV00004968

HARV00069760

HARV00019628

Beginning Bates
HARV00023547

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00025055
HARV00025057
HARV00068198

HARV00024974

HARV00010786
HARV00026391
HARV00077826
HARV00075041

HARV00069119

HARV00077839

HARV00074897

HARV00077840

HARV00035515

HARV00031486

HARV00074044

HARV00007864

HARV00004968

HARV00069767

HARV00019635

Ending Bates
HARV00023555

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use

Will Use

May Use

Will Use

May Use

IR, 403, Illegible
IR, 403
H, MIL

H

H, IR, MIL, 403
H, MIL, 403, PRIV
F, MIL, PRIV, 901
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

F, MIL, PRIV, 901

CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

F, MIL, PRIV, 901

H

H, MIL, 403

H, MIL

H, MIL

H, MIL, 403, 702

H, MIL, 403, 702

CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
Will Use
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

9/27/13

10/31/13

11/7/13
1/29/14
2/3/14
3/25/14
12/12/49
9/18/52

2/2/11

P052
P053

P054

P055

P056
P057
P058
P059
P060
P061

P062

P066

P065

P064

P063

5/28/13
8/14/13

P051

P050

00/00/13

4/22/13

P048

P049

Date
5/21/13
2/25/13

Ex. #
P046
P047

Description
Letter to Erica re: follow-up to Fitz's question
Notes on Slides
Distribution of Applicant Average SAT - Scores by Income,
Classes of 2009-2016
G2: Understanding Differences in the High School
Experience and Opportunities of College Applicants
Searches 2012 - Class of 2017
Harvard Admissions Office, Summer 2013, Coordinator
Manual
Distribution List for Dean Smith's Incoming Mail
McGrath Email to Yong re: AP Search
Yong Email to Banks re: Harvard Club of Western PA Outreach Event
Lavoie Email to Fitzsimmons, et al. re: Search, Video &
UMRP Email Reports
Yong Email to Ortiz re: Search by Club spreadsheet
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons re: 2019 search
Ortiz Letter re: hometown recruiters
Bowman Email re: HFAI Program outline for COFHE
Harvard College Admission Policy
Admission Policy
Faust Memo to Members of the Corporation re: Proposed
Changes in Admissions Policy
The Common Application - First-Year Application Blank
Form
Universal College Application - First-Year Admissions
Application
Harvard Application Supplement, For Entrance in Fall
2015
Native American Heritage Affidavit

Page 3 of 30

HARV00028576

HARV00030303

HARV00022119
HARV00010998
HARV00018894
HARV00012304

HARV00014746

HARV00007052

HARV00019220
HARV00023563

HARV00005346

HARV00007766

HARV00075057

Beginning Bates
HARV00069739
HARV00069757

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00028576

HARV00030332

HARV00022120
HARV00011000
HARV00018895
HARV00012307

HARV00014759

HARV00007074

HARV00019245
HARV00023564

HARV00005369

HARV00007771

HARV00075059

Ending Bates
HARV00069740
HARV00069759

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

F, IR, 403, 901

H, INC, IR
H
F, 901, IR, H
F, 901, H
F, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

H

H

H
CM, H

F, H, INC, 901

NP, F, H, IR, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, 403, 702, 901

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
May Use
F, H, MIL, 403, 901, 702
May Use
MIL

7/15/13

1/2/13

7/10/13
8/16/13

8/19/13

8/24/13

9/4/13

9/4/13

9/27/13
11/22/13
12/16/13

3/11/14

4/24/14
5/12/14
8/12/14

P077

P078
P079

P080

P081

P082

P083

P084
P085
P086

P087

P088
P089
P090

7/13/15
4/24/14
7/13/15

9/10/13
10/23/12

Date

P076

Ex. #
P067
P068
P069
P070
P071
P072
P073
P074
P075

Description
Admissions Calendar 2012-2013
Admissions Calendar 2013-2014
Reading Procedures, Class of 2016
Reading Procedures, Class of 2017
Reading Procedures, Class of 2019
Interviewer Handbook 2013-2014
Interviewer Handbook 2014-2015
Interview Information Sheets
Harvard College Personal Interview Report
Life Cycle of a Harvard Applicant from Prospect to
Matriculating Freshmen!
Scanlon Email to Moulton, et al. re: undergrad
demographics
Gilfillian Email to Cheng re: Help requested please
Harvard Information Session
Howrigan Email to D'Amelio re: Approve Harvard's I'm
First Profile by 8/19!
Ortiz Email to McGrath re: Diversity Training
Cheng Email to staff re: Revised Friday Orientation
schedule
Cheng Email to Banks re: All Staff Orientation Friday
September 6
Cheng Email to Stone re: cannot tell her yet!!
Walsh Email to Kim re: High priority interviews
Email to Cheng re: FYI on College Confidential
Neal Email to Fitzsimmons re: Admissions/Early v
Regular/Legacy
Cheng Email to Boutte-Thompson re: Updating Intranet
Rice Email to Yong re: Ethnicity and Forms
Brown Email to Fitzsimmons re: New counselor letter

Page 4 of 30

HARV00015814
HARV00009837
HARV00011158

HARV00004125

HARV00015940
HARV00029720
HARV00015881

HARV00014622

HARV00010315

HARV00004943

HARV00017145

HARV00015880
HARV00009838
HARV00011166

HARV00004129

HARV00015944
HARV00029723
HARV00015883

HARV00014623

HARV00010317

HARV00004943

HARV00017147

HARV00015621
WEAV028

HARV00074747

HARV00074744
HARV00015620
WEAV001

HARV00016974

Ending Bates
HARV00029776
HARV00031933
HARV00021334
HARV00009903
HARV00001454
HARV00015862
HARV00001438
HARV00000015
HARV00003519

HARV00016971

Beginning Bates
HARV00029766
HARV00031933
HARV00021316
HARV00009881
HARV00001439
HARV00015816
HARV00001392
HARV00000008
HARV00003516

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

CM, F, 901
F, 901, H, IR
H

H

H, IR
H, IR
F, 901, H, IR

H

H

F, 901, H

F, 901, H
H

H, MIL

F, 901, H

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
May Use
May Use
Will Use
F, H, 901
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
Will Use
May Use

1/00/14

P093
P094
P095
P096
P097
P098

P100
P101
P102
P103
P104
P105
P106
P107
P108
P109
P110
P111
P112
P113
P114
P115
P116
P117
P118

12/7/12
1/17/13
1/17/13
3/14/13
6/11/13
11/5/13
11/15/13
11/18/13
1/25/14
4/21/14
3/20/18
4/3/18
12/24/13
12/28/13
12/31/13
12/31/13
1/1/14
1/15/14

10/7/15

P092

P099

Date
8/26/14

Ex. #
P091

Description
Waters Email re: September 4 and 5 Orientation Agenda
Harvard College Admissions & Financial Aid Alumni
Disclosure Form
2014 Harvard College Admissions and Financial Aid Staff
Admissions Chart
Handwritten Notes
Handwritten Notes
Handwritten Notes - HFAI Meeting
Handwritten Notes
Outline with Handwritten Notes re: Diversity and
Admissions
Class of 2017 - Dean's Lineage and Interest List
Class of 2017 - Dean's Lineage and Interest List
Legacy List
Email to Walsh re: HW Applicant
Ellwood Email to Fitzsimmons re: My Hero
Harvard College Class of 2018, EA Lineage Applicants
Cheever Email to Bouchard re: applicant
Cheng Email re: Priority candidates
Looby Email re: RSVP+
Redacted Email to Banks re: waitlister
Neal Email to Fitzsimmons re: Harvard Admissions
Fish Email to Fitzsimmons re: Hi, Bill
Applicant File from Suncoast Community High School
Applicant File from Stuyvesant High School
Applicant File from Parkview High School
Applicant File from Hume Fogg High School
Applicant File from Johns Creek High School
Applicant File Suncoast Community High School
Application File from Folsom High School
HARV00003500

Ending Bates
HARV00010033

Page 5 of 30

HARV00005694
HARV00011623
HARV00005682
HARV00019403
HARV00010543
HARV00032715
HARV00004890
HARV00016007
HARV00011752
HARV00006884
HARV00006025
HARV00004008
HARV00092081
HARV00094481
HARV00091218
HARV00091894
HARV00095100
HARV00094536
HARV00003879

HARV00005743
HARV00011624
HARV00005693
HARV00019404
HARV00010543
HARV00032774
HARV00004890
HARV00016010
HARV00011754
HARV00006884
HARV00006026
HARV00004009
HARV00092132
HARV00094535
HARV00091228
HARV00091924
HARV00095136
HARV00094623
HARV00003905

HARV00028384

HARV00018127
HARV00018145
HARV00018152
HARV00067488
HARV00028373

HARV00018132
HARV00018151
HARV00018162
HARV00067491

HARV00003496

Beginning Bates
HARV00010028

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

Illegible

F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901, H, IR
H, IR
IR
H, IR
H, IR
H, IR
F, 901 H, IR
H, IR
F, H, IR, 901
Illegible
Illegible

F, 901, IR, 403
H, 403, Illegible
H, 403, Illegible
H, 403, Illegible
F, 901, H, 403, Illegible

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
May Use
F, 901

Date
10/31/13
11/5/13
11/11/13
11/11/13
12/10/13
12/11/13
12/12/13
12/20/13
12/26/13
12/30/13
1/4/14
1/4/14
1/6/14
1/6/14
1/6/14
1/7/14
1/10/14
1/21/14
2/21/17
2/21/17
5/23/17
5/23/17
5/23/17
5/23/17
11/12/12
1/7/13

1/12/13

3/14/13
3/19/13

Ex. #
P119
P120
P121
P122
P123
P124
P125
P126
P127
P128
P129
P130
P131
P132
P133
P134
P135
P136
P137
P138
P139
P140
P141
P142
P143
P144

P145

P146
P147

Description
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Applicant Summary Sheet
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons re: one pager
Yong Email to Banks re: one pager
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons and McGrath re: record
number
Applicants 2016 vs 2017
Howrigan Email to Yong re: one pager

Page 6 of 30

HARV00010469
HARV00021585

HARV00019909

Beginning Bates
HARV00076335
HARV00076469
HARV00076274
HARV00076821
HARV00076503
HARV00076245
HARV00076506
HARV00089351
HARV00077297
HARV00076691
HARV00076934
HARV00077154
HARV00076529
HARV00076841
HARV00077069
HARV00077072
HARV00077345
HARV00076339
HARV00071271
HARV00071702
HARV00072416
HARV00072560
HARV00072713
HARV00072453
HARV00020734
HARV00014627

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00010471
HARV00021585

HARV00019910

Ending Bates
HARV00076336
HARV00076471
HARV00076276
HARV00076824
HARV00076505
HARV00076247
HARV00076508
HARV00089384
HARV00077299
HARV00076694
HARV00076935
HARV00077156
HARV00076530
HARV00076844
HARV00077071
HARV00077073
HARV00077347
HARV00076340
HARV00071303
HARV00071746
HARV00072452
HARV00072625
HARV00072749
HARV00072527
HARV00020735
HARV00014628

May Use
Will Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

CM, F, 901
CM, F, 901, H

F, 901, INC

INC, 403
INC, 403
INC, 403
INC, 403
H

INC, 403

INC, 403, Illegible

Illegible

Illegible
Illegible

Illegible
Illegible

Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible

Harvard Objection

Ex. #
P148
P149
P150
P151
P152
P153
P154
P155
P156
P157
P158
P159
P160
P161
P162
P163
P164
P165
P166
P167
P168
P169
P170
P171
P172
P173
P174
P175
P176
P177

Date
11/5/13
11/26/13
12/2/13
12/2/13
12/2/13
12/5/13
12/6/13
12/10/13
12/13/13
1/2/14
1/5/14
1/7/14
1/7/14
1/13/14
3/2/14
3/2/14
3/14/14
3/17/14
3/17/14
3/18/14
5/5/14
5/7/14
5/21/14
6/27/14
8/27/14
8/23/12
1/16/13
8/13/13
12/5/13
1/14/14

Description
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons, et al. re: one pager
Class of 2018 - EA Applicants
Early Action Admits 2017 vs 2018
Fitzsimmons Email to McGrath re: stats
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons re: stats
Class of 2018 - EA Applicants
Early Action Admits 2017 vs 2018
Early Action Admits 2017 vs. 2018
Early Action Admits 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Yong Email to Banks re: EA Stats
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018
McGrath Email to Yong re: stats for monday
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
McGrath Email to Yong re: 0317 stats
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Yong Email to Banks re: one pager
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
Regular Action Docket Meeting Schedule - Class of 2017
Projected Targets for the Class of 2017
Docket - Area Person and Chair Assignments, 2013-2014
Class of 2018 - EA Applicants
Projected Targets for the Class of 2018

Page 7 of 30

Beginning Bates
HARV00022117
HARV00018646
HARV00004229
HARV00004924
HARV00021281
HARV00007772
HARV00004225
HARV00004202
HARV00004224
HARV00001887
HARV00001884
HARV00014684
HARV00004223
HARV00004221
HARV00002724
HARV00016806
HARV00004313
HARV00016782
HARV00001891
HARV00010499
HARV00014676
HARV00004274
HARV00004268
HARV00003592
HARV00018639
HARV00001460
HARV00010476
HARV00001484
HARV00007772
HARV00004098

SFFA Exhibit List
Ending Bates
HARV00022118
HARV00018646
HARV00004236
HARV00004927
HARV00021284
HARV00007773
HARV00004225
HARV00004202
HARV00004224
HARV00001887
HARV00001885
HARV00014686
HARV00004223
HARV00004221
HARV00002724
HARV00016809
HARV00004316
HARV00016784
HARV00001892
HARV00010500
HARV00014677
HARV00004274
HARV00004269
HARV00003593
HARV00018639
HARV00001460
HARV00010477
HARV00001485
HARV00007773
HARV00004104

Will Use/May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901, INC
F, 901
CM
CM, F, 901
F, 901, 403

Harvard Objection
H
F, 901, IR
F, 901
H
H
CM, F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
H
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
H
F, 901
H
H, CM
F, 901

Ex. #
P178
P179
P180
P181
P182
P183
P184
P185
P186
P187
P188
P189
P190
P191
P192
P193
P194
P195
P196
P197
P198
P199
P200
P201
P202
P203
P204
P205
P206
P207

3/13/13
3/15/13
3/15/13
3/19/13
3/19/13
3/19/13
1/30/14
3/5/14
3/13/14
3/14/14

Date
2/9/14
1/14/14
4/2/17
5/31/17

Description
Docket - Area Person and Chair Assignments 2014-2015
Applicants 2017 vs. 2018 Chart
2017 Applicant List
Area Assignments, Meeting Schedules
Class of 2018 Admits
Chart of Target at 84%
Area Report Class of 2017
E & F Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018
K, L & N Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018
T, U & Z Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018
C & D Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018
C & D Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019
E & F Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019
P, R & S Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019
P, R & S Dockets - Official #1 Class of 2018
A-Z Waitlist Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019
D Docket Cleanup Handwritten Notes
E Docket Handwritten notes
E Docket To Do List
K Docket Handwritten notes
Memorandum from Fitzsimmons re: Final Choices
Class of 2017 - My Docket Lop List Chart
Class of 2017 - Docket Lop List
Lop Me List
Class of 2017 Docket Lop List
Lop Me List
Lop List
Bryan Email to Dikkers, et al. re: S lop list
Class of 2018 Docket Lop List
Smith Email to Howrigan re: F Docket Lops

Ending Bates
HARV00001708
HARV00005250

HARV00001478
HARV00006411
HARV00010483
HARV00012234
HARV00036613
HARV00040757
HARV00042067
HARV00045274
HARV00046797
HARV00048279
HARV00053330
HARV00056250
HARV00062494
HARV00065929
HARV00066121
HARV00066162
HARV00066183
HARV00010469
HARV00001812
HARV00066302
HARV00067540
HARV00018624
HARV00066245
HARV00067563
HARV00066374
HARV00001867
HARV00065296

Page 8 of 30

HARV00001497
HARV00006412
HARV00010485
HARV00012235
HARV00038055
HARV00042066
HARV00043871
HARV00046796
HARV00048278
HARV00049654
HARV00054709
HARV00057840
HARV00064156
HARV00065929
HARV00066121
HARV00066163
HARV00066184
HARV00010475
HARV00001813
HARV00066303
HARV00067542
HARV00018624
HARV00066247
HARV00067564
HARV00066375
HARV00001867
HARV00065297

Beginning Bates
HARV00001707
HARV00005250

SFFA Exhibit List
Will Use/May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

F, 901, IR, Illegible
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901, H
F, 901
F, 901, IR, H

F, 901, H, IR
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
Illegible
F, 901, IR
F, 901
F, 901
F, 901, IR
INC

F, 901
CM, F, 901 403
CM

Harvard Objection

Date
3/14/14
3/14/14
3/15/14
3/16/14
5/2/14
9/22/12
10/2/12
10/15/12
10/26/12
10/31/12
11/28/12
11/30/12

11/30/12

12/1/12
12/6/12
12/12/12

12/12/12

12/20/12

12/27/12

12/27/12
12/28/12
12/28/12
1/8/13
1/8/13
1/9/13

Ex. #
P208
P209
P210
P211
P212
P213
P214
P215
P216
P217
P218
P219

P220

P221
P222
P223

P224

P225

P226

P227
P228
P229
P230
P231
P232

Description
Bryan Email to Howrigan, et al. re: F Lop
Donahue Email to Howrigan re: Lop list
Bryan Email to Howrigan, et al. re: F Lop
Smith Email to Howrigan re: F Lop
Ray Email to Kim re: J wait list prep
Howrigan Email to Cheng re: Interview Friday
Kaufmann Email re: Officer Spreadsheet Survey Results
Ray Email to Ortiz re: Crimson article garnering attention
Cheng Email to Howrigan re: new docket
Granoff Email to Howrigan re: Tim's guffaw
The Myth of American Meritocracy by Ron Unz
Stone Email to Cheng re: Harvard Women's Ice Hockey
McGrath Email to Gilman re: Asian-American Quotas at Ivy
League Universities
Fitzsimmons Email to Hibino re: No subject
Ortiz Email to Banks re: ugh
Birk Email to Yong re: Reminder about Redbook deadline
Cheng Email to Ray, et al. re: R/A Reading - borrowed
from DDM
McGrath Email to Vidra re: From Robert Dujarric re: AsianAmerican applicants
Email to Pacholok re: Ron Unz/David Brooks Ivy League
treatment of Asian American applicants
Pacholok Email re: Ron Unz
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons re: Pres Fausts questions
Fitzsimmons Email to Yong re: Pres Faust questions
Yong Email to Howrigan re: RO data
Driver-Linn Email to Scanlon re: ipeds
Grant Email to Fitzsimmons re: message

Page 9 of 30

HARV00023320
HARV00019930
HARV00004937
HARV00029858
HARV00075506
HARV00005071

HARV00023318

HARV00035209

HARV00067805

HARV00004938
HARV00067690
HARV00009158

HARV00032477

Beginning Bates
HARV00066372
HARV00065546
HARV00066372
HARV00066685
HARV00066752
HARV00017569
HARV00013012
HARV00028915
HARV00017401
HARV00065335
HARV00016675
HARV00022645

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00023320
HARV00019931
HARV00004937
HARV00029858
HARV00075507
HARV00005071

HARV00023319

HARV00035211

HARV00067805

HARV00004938
HARV00067690
HARV00009159

HARV00032480

Ending Bates
HARV00066373
HARV00065547
HARV00066373
HARV00066685
HARV00066754
HARV00017570
HARV00013023
HARV00028916
HARV00017401
HARV00065335
HARV00016712
HARV00022645

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

F, H, 403, 901
H
H
H
H, MIL
H

H

H

H

H, IR

H, IR, 403

H, INC

Harvard Objection
F, 901, H
F, 901, H, IR
F, 901, H
F, 901, H, IR
F, 901, H, IR
CM, F, 901, H, IR
F, 901, H
F, 901, H, IR
F, 901, H
F, 901, H, IR, 403
F, 901, H, 403
F, 901, H, IR

Date

1/10/13

1/19/13

1/19/13

1/21/13

1/21/13

1/23/13
1/28/13

2/6/13

2/13/13
2/22/13
2/26/13
3/5/13
3/9/13

3/11/13

3/21/13
3/22/13
3/25/13
4/11/13
4/11/13

4/24/13

6/10/13

6/11/13

Ex. #

P233

P234

P235

P236

P237

P238
P239

P240

P241
P242
P243
P244
P245

P246

P247
P248
P249
P250
P251

P252

P253

P254

Description
Scanlon Email to Driver-Linn re: seeking info on racial
demographics of Harvard College students
Fitzsimmons Email to McGrath , et al. re: Draft statements
A Note on the Collection and Reporting of Data on Race
and Ethnicity
Email to Pacholok re: Unz/David Brooks Articles
McGrath Email to Pacholok re: Note on collecting and
reporting
Yong Email to Zupan re: The orchid that
Donahue Email to Madsen re: No subject
Neal Email to Fitzsimmons re: Draft Annual Admissions
Applications Gazette Article
Email to Smith re: The Mytho of American Meritocracy
Miller Email re: No subject
McGrath Email to Lewis re: Unz
Dickerson Email to Yong re: Ethnicity change and App
Menand Email to Fitzsimmons re: Unz
Hansen Email to Moulton, et al. re: NPR: Discrimination
Against Asians in College Admissions
Neal Email to Pacholok re: Two Revised Articles
IM conversation between Yong & Pacholok
Faust Email to Madsen re: No subject
Email to Ortiz re: Question
Email to Ray re: Prefrosh match
Email to Donahue re: Connecting Harvard with high
achieving low income students
Donahue Email to Fitzsimmons re: Thank you and follow
up
Email to Pacholok re: New Criterion: Is the college process
fair?
HARV00008302

HARV00008301

Page 10 of 30

HARV00004967

HARV00004984

HARV00023616
HARV00026710
HARV00016629
HARV00028630
HARV00028633

HARV00075623

HARV00023431
HARV00013119
HARV00077882
HARV00021581
HARV00007877

HARV00023599

HARV00004967

HARV00004981

HARV00023613
HARV00026708
HARV00016628
HARV00028629
HARV00028633

HARV00075623

HARV00023430
HARV00013119
HARV00077882
HARV00021581
HARV00007877

HARV00023588

HARV00014511
HARV00023607

HARV00026565

HARV00026562
HARV00014509
HARV00023600

HARV00023433

HARV00065452

HARV00065460

HARV00074739

Ending Bates

HARV00023432

HARV00065450

HARV00065449

HARV00074737

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

F, H, 901

H

H

H
F, H, 901
H, MIL, 403, PRIV
F, H, IR, 901
H, IR

H, IR

H
F, H, 901
H, IR
H, IR
H

H, MIL, 403, PRIV

H
H, IR

H

F, H, 901

F, H, 901

H

H, MIL, 403, PRIV

Harvard Objection

Date

6/18/13

7/24/13

7/24/13
7/26/13
8/1/13

8/5/13

10/15/13

11/12/13

1/3/14

1/8/14

1/26/14

1/27/14

2/7/14

2/11/14

2/19/14

2/20/14
2/25/14

2/25/14

3/5/14

Ex. #

P255

P256

P257
P258
P259

P260

P261

P262

P263

P264

P265

P266

P267

P268

P269

P270
P271

P272

P273

Description
Addendum on the Collection and Reporting of Data on
Race and Ethnicity
Yong Email to Fitzsimmons re: Request, please and thank
you
McGrath Email re: Wait-List Applicant Offered a "Z"
Email to McGrath re: College Admissions and Asians
Yong Email to Ortiz re: Report Request
Moulton Email to Bever, et al. re: articles this weekend on
admissions
McGrath Email to Fitzsimmons re: Request for participation
in a Harvard undergraduate research project
Donahue Email to Neal re: Does this woman have her stats
right?
Email to Fitzsimmons re: Hawaii students admitted Early by
Harvard
Fitzsimmons Email re: Hawaii students admitted early by
Harvard
Lewis Email to McGrath re: Utah Schools Committee Results of Ranking Session
Email to Looby re: Interview Report Problem
Email to Weaver re: Outstanding candidates from Savannah
area
Clagett Email to Cheng re: a minute of your time
Cheever Email to Pacholok re: Question from Joseph
Kusnan
Staff Email string re: tour request
Cheng Email to Fitzsimmons re: Call with alums
Cheng Email to Kusnan re: From Harvard Admissions
Office
Yong Email to Neal re: background data 2014 to 2017

Page 11 of 30

HARV00005105

HARV00029875

HARV00029017
HARV00010891

HARV00029909

HARV00022625

HARV00022223

HARV00011933

HARV00032339

HARV00026671

HARV00011118

HARV00004894

HARV00011035

HARV00075625

HARV00032454
HARV00032306
HARV00022048

HARV00014512

HARV00030509

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00005106

HARV00029875

HARV00029021
HARV00010891

HARV00029909

HARV00022626

HARV00022230

HARV00011935

HARV00032341

HARV00026697

HARV00011141

HARV00004896

HARV00011035

HARV00075625

HARV00032455
HARV00032306
HARV00022050

HARV00014513

HARV00030512

Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

H

F, H, 901

F, IR, H, 901
H

F, H, 901

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, 901

H, IR

H, 403

H

H

H

H

H, IR, MIL

H
F, H, 901
F, H, 901

H

F, H, 901

Harvard Objection

Date
3/9/14

3/24/14

3/31/14
4/3/14

4/7/14

4/7/14
4/8/14
4/28/14

4/22/14

4/23/14
4/26/14

4/26/14

4/27/14

4/29/14

5/30/14

6/25/14

6/30/14
7/6/14
10/20/17

7/2/13

7/2/13

Ex. #
P274

P275

P276
P277

P278

P279
P280
P281

P282

P283
P284

P285

P286

P287

P288

P289

P290
P291
P292
P293
P294

P295

Kane Email to Fitzsimmons re: op-ed on the Fisher decision

Cheng Email to Yong re: Intranet forms
Faust Email to Madsen re: One College
The Diversity Report Email to Faust re: Assignments from
The Diversity Report
Madsen Email to Faust re: Meeting Sunday
Bernhard Email to McGrath re: letter to President Faust
from high school student re: admissions diversity
Memo from Driver-Linn to Khurana re: Harvard College
Projects from the Office of Institutional Research
Bever Email to Driver-Linn re: Recent news articles on
Affirmative Action
Banks Email to Ortiz re: No subject
Rouse Email to Bassett, et al. re: First Generation Meeting
Email to Faust re: The Myth of American Meritocracy
Facts About Asian American Admissions at Harvard
Faust Email to Iuliano re: op-ed on the Fisher decision

Cheng Email to Vidra re: Tonight's wrap up re: alum dinner

Description
Faust Email to Heenan re: No subject
Neal Email to Fitzsimmons re: Draft Gazette Article with
Tuition/Smith
Email to Weaver re: Difficulty with Interviewer
Evans Email to Cheng re: We are all Harvard
Manning Email to Fitzsimmons re: college admissions
policies under attack
Jiang Letter to Faust re: Bessie Jiang
Weaver Email re: Chronicle of Higher Education Article
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: meeting in Mass Hall

Page 12 of 30

HARV00007799

HARV00006868
HARV00023801
HARV00007522
HARV00076081
HARV00007310

HARV00074175

HARV00077521

HARV00024781

HARV00016501

HARV00030047

HARV00014518
HARV00010356

HARV00022126

HARV00029930
HARV00019582
HARV00027658

HARV00005215

HARV00022479
HARV00009990

HARV00027590

Beginning Bates
HARV00010368

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00007802

HARV00006868
HARV00023816
HARV00007523
HARV00076082
HARV00007313

HARV00074501

HARV00077822

HARV00024782

HARV00016507

HARV00030050

HARV00014519
HARV00010358

HARV00022127

HARV00029932
HARV00019582
HARV00027659

HARV00005215

HARV00022480
HARV00009991

HARV00027597

Ending Bates
HARV00010369

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

Harvard Objection

H

CM, H
F, IR, 901
H, IR
F, H, 901
MIL, 403, PRIV

INC

H, MIL

H

H, MIL, 403, PRIV

F, H, 901

F, H, MIL, 403, PRIV, 901
F, H, IR, 901

F, H, 901

F, H, 901
F, H, 901
H, IR, MIL, 403, PRIV

F, H, 901
F, 901

H

Will Use/May Use
May Use
H

5/27/14

6/13/14
12/10/14

11/00/15

P298

P299
P300

P301

6/9/17

7/00/17

8/15/17

10/20/17

1/5/18

2/13/18

3/15/18

3/20/18

3/20/18

P304

P305

P306

P307

P308

P309

P310

P311

P312

P313

P303

6/9/14

5/27/14

P297

P302

Date
5/9/14

Ex. #
P296

Description
Lutz Memo re: Admissions Task Force Discussion
Faust Email to Ely re: Invitation to Serve on Universitywide Committee
Faust Email to Fitzsimmons re: Invitation to Serve on
University-wide Committee
Farzan Email to Ryan, et al. re: Ryan Committee
Lutz Memo re: Diversity Committee
Report of the College Working Group on Diversity and
Inclusion
Report of the Committee to Study the Importance of Student
Body Diversity
Diversity/Admissions Task Force
Email from Faust to Warikoo re: Invitation to Serve on
University-wide Committee
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Memo to Smith re: Race-Neutral Alternatives to Consider
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Draft Report of the Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives
Gershengorn Email to Henson re: Friday's agenda

Page 13 of 30

HARV00097370

HARV00097002

HARV00097511

HARV00097002

HARV00097167

HARV00096591

HARV00096591
HARV00097167

HARV00096538

HARV00096532

HARV00095214

HARV00097309

HARV00072381

HARV00007348

HARV00072342

HARV00008069

HARV00007982

HARV00026387
HARV00072345

HARV00007488

HARV00007398

Ending Bates
HARV00072355

HARV00096538

HARV00096532

HARV00095214

HARV00097308

HARV00072381

HARV00007346

HARV00072342

HARV00008048

HARV00007944

HARV00026381
HARV00072344

HARV00007486

HARV00007396

Beginning Bates
HARV00072346

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

Harvard Objection

H

MIL, 403, PRIV

H, MIL, 403, PRIV
F, H, MIL, 403, PRIV, 901

INC

Will Use/May Use
May Use
INC

4/3/18

4/00/18

1/8/13

2/28/14
4/15/14
5/2/14
5/2/14

P315

P316

P317

P318
P319
P320
P321

11/13/03
3/29/12

12/00/12

12/19/12

P329

P330
P331

P332

P333

P325
P326
P327
P328

P324

P323

1/00/88

3/25/18

P314

P322

Date

Ex. #

Demographic Makeup of Applicants and Matrics - New
Methodology vs. IPEDS
COFHE Admissions Statistics, Class Entering 2013
McGrath Email to Balian re: stats
Chart of Overall vs. Asian American
Overall stats vs. African Americans stats
Applicants, Admits, and Matriculants - Old Methodology
NLNA
SAT Averages - Old Methodology
Demographic Makeup of Applicants, Admits, and Matrics New Methodology vs. IPEDS
Six and Four Year Graduate Rate by Ethnicity
Demographic Breakdown of Applicants and Matriculants
Class of 2017 - EA Applicants
Geography - Classes of 2015 - 2018
Statement on Asian-American Admissions at HarvardRadcliffe
A Classy Affair by Elizabeth W. Green
Harvard Courts Minority Students
Working Paper - The Missing "One-Offs": The Hidden
Supply of High-Achieving, Low Income Students by Hoxby
& Avery
The New York Times, Harvard Shuns Quotas and Narrow
Criteria

Report of the Committee to Study Race-Neutral Alternatives

Description
Redline Draft of the Report of the Committee to Study RaceNeutral Alternatives
Smith Memo re: Committee to Study Race-Neutral
Alternatives

Ending Bates

Page 14 of 30

HARV00010595

HARV00023143

HARV00003906
HARV00006405
HARV00007766

HARV00001859

HARV00001857

HARV00001851

HARV00004683
HARV00032507
HARV00023177
HARV00023173

HARV00074743

HARV00097310

HARV00010642

HARV00023144

HARV00003906
HARV00006407
HARV00007767

HARV00001860

HARV00001858

HARV00001856

HARV00004789
HARV00032524
HARV00023178
HARV00023174

HARV00074743

HARV00097328

HARV00097303

HARV00097202
HARV00097285

HARV00097222

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

F, H, NP, 901

F, H, Illegible, 901
F, H, 901

F, 901
F, 901
F, 901

F, 901

F, 901

F, 901

F, 901

F, H, 901

F, H, 901

Harvard Objection

Date

12/24/12

1/4/13
1/15/13

3/17/13

1/22/14
3/27/14

4/7/14

4/28/14

6/17/14

11/24/14

12/21/14

12/26/14

12/11/15

7/00/17

6/14/18

6/15/18

7/29/18

4/23/74

Ex. #

P334

P335
P336

P337

P338
P339

P340

P341

P342

P343

P344

P345

P346

P347

P348

P349

P350

P351

The New York Times, Is Harvard Unfair to AsianAmericans?
The Brutal Application Process to (Sue) Harvard
The Atlantic, Do Diversity Initiatives Indirectly Discriminate
Against Asian Americans?
The Harvard Crimson, Khurana Fields Criticisms on
College Diversity
FAS Reserves Dwindling, Dean Says
The New York Times, Harvard Rated Asian-American
Applicants Lower on Personality Traits, Lawsuit Says
Harvard Crimson: In Internal Reports, Harvard Concluded
Asian Americans Suffer 'Negative Effects' in Admission
Process
The New York Times, 'Lopping,' 'Tips' and the 'Z-List': Bias
Lawsuit Explores Harvard's Admissions Secrets
DeFunis v. Odegaard, 416 U.S. 312 (1974)

Khurana Email to Fitzsimmons re: New York Times article

Description
The New York Times, The 2012 Sidney Awards I by David
Brooks
Frontline: Challenging Race Sensitive Admission Policies
Banks Email to Fitzsimmons re: HFAI Fights Back!
Email to Pacholok re: NYT: Better Colleges Failing to Lure
Talented Poor
Harvard Gazette, New Harvard College dean
Harvard Gazette, College Admits Class of '18
The Chronicle: Affirmative-Action Foe Plans Campaigns
Against 3 Universities
Ivy Day is Asian Discrimination Day; And Whites Reap the
Benefits

Page 15 of 30

HARV00023487

HARV00026550

HARV00077858
HARV00005053

HARV00023314

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00023491

HARV00026552

HARV00077861
HARV00005055

HARV00023316

Ending Bates

F, H, 901

F, H, IR, NP, 403, 901

May Use
May Use

F, H, IR, NP, 403, Illegible, 901

F, H, IR, 403, MIL, NP, 901

H

H

F, H, 403, 901

F, H, MIL, 403, 901

H, IR, MIL, 403

H

F, H, 403, 901

F, H, 901

H, NP
CM, H

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, 901
H

F, H, 403, 901

Harvard Objection

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

Date

6/28/78

00/00/79

1/23/89

9/16/94

7/14/96
6/24/97

7/24/00

6/19/03
6/23/03

2/24/06

9/12/06

12/10/07

12/12/07

6/3/10

Ex. #

P352

P353

P354

P355

P356
P357

P358

P359
P360

P361

P362

P363

P364

P365

Elizabeth Bangs, "Harvard Adds Another 'Hallmark'
'Distinction and Diversity' Now Central to Your College
Experience"
William Julius Wilson, "Class Consciousness"
Lani Guinier, "The Real Bias in Higher Education"
Johnson v. Board of Regents, 106 F. Supp. 2d 1362 (S.D.
Ga. 2000)
Ronald Roach, "Class-Based Affirmative Action"
Grutter v. Bollinger, 539 U.S. 306 (2003)
Scott Jaschik, "Size Matters: From Amherst to Pomona,
Liberal Arts Colleges Are Increasing Enrollments and Trying
to Keep a Small College Environment"
Alan Finder & Karen W. Arenson, "Harvard Ends Early
Admission"
Harvard Gazette, Harvard Announces Sweeping MiddleIncome Initiative
Arianna Markel, "Harvard Lags in Community College
Recruitment"
Anthony P. Carnevale & Jeff Strohl, "How Increasing
College Access Is Increasing Inequality, and What To Do
About It"

City of Richmond v. J.A. Croson Co., 488 U.S. 469 (1989).

Description
Regents of University of California v. Bakke, 438 U.S. 265
(1978)
Alan M. Dershowitz & Laura Hanft, "Affirmative Action
and the Harvard College Diversity-Discretion Model:
Paradigm or Pretext?"

Page 16 of 30

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List
Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

H, INC, NP

H, NP, Illegible

H, NP

H, NP, Illegible

H, IR, NP

H, NP
F, H, 901

F, H, 901

H, IR, NP
H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

F, H, 901

H, IR, NP, 403

F, H, 901

Harvard Objection

Date

7/00/11

7/00/11

9/29/11

11/21/11

12/4/11

12/14/11

9/19/12

3/9/13

3/16/13

5/16/13

5/23/13

6/24/13

7/10/13

7/12/13

7/29/13

Ex. #

P366

P367

P368

P369

P370

P371

P372

P373

P374

P375

P376

P377

P378

P379

P380

Description
John R. Logan, "Separate and Unequal: The Neighborhood
Gap for Blacks, Hispanics and Asians in Metropolitan
America"
Sean F. Reardon, "The Widening Academic Achievement
Gap Between the Rich and the Poor: New Evidence and
Possible Explanations"
U.S. Census Bureau, "2010 Census Shows Black Population
has Highest Concentration in the South"
Shartia Brantley, "Who Are the Black 1 Percent'?"
Mark S. Barajas, "Academic Achievement of Children in
Single Parent Homes: A Critical Review"
Julia Isaacs & Katherine Magnuson, "Income and Education
as Predictors of Children's School Readiness"
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
David Leonhardt, "The Leading Liberal Against Affirmative
Action"
David Leonhardt, "Better Colleges Failing to Lure Talented
Poor"
McGregor McCance, "Analysis of U.Va.'s Incoming Class
Shows Consistent Quality with Dynamic Change"
"Bridging the Higher Education Divide: Strengthening
Community Colleges and Restoring the American Dream"
Fisher v. UT Austin, 133 S. Ct. 2411 (2013)
Minicucci Email to Fitzsimmons re: Admissions data from
COFHE?
Minicucci Email to Kane re: Admissions data from
COFHE?
Thomas J. Kane and James E. Ryan, "Why 'Fisher' Means
More Work for Colleges"

Page 17 of 30

HARV00022934

HARV00022931

HARV00002730

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00022936

HARV00022933

HARV00002730

Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

H, NP

H

H

F, H

H, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

F, IR, 403

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, NP

H, NP

Harvard Objection

Date

9/00/13

10/13/13

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/11/14

4/28/14

9/25/14

10/1/14

Ex. #

P381

P382

P383

P384

P385

P386

P387

P388

P389

P390

P391

P392

Arthur L. Coleman, Teresa E. Taylor, & Katherine E.
Lipper, "The Playbook: A Guide to Assist Institutions of
Higher Education in Evaluating Race- and EthnicityNeutral Policies in Support of the Mission-Related Diversity
Goals"

Description
Segment Analysis Service Tagging/Historical Analysis
Output File
Richard D. Kahlenberg, "A Fresh Chance to Rein in Racial
Preferences"
Alexandria Radford & Jessica Howell, "Addressing
Undermatch: Creating Opportunity and Social Mobility"
Arthur L. Coleman & Teresa E. Taylor, "Emphasis Added:
Fisher v. University of Texas and Its Practical Implications
for Institutions of Higher Education"
Dalton Conley, "The Why, What, and How of Class-Based
Admissions Policy"
Danielle Allen, "Talent is Everywhere: Using ZIP Codes
and Merit to Enhance Diversity"
Nancy G. McDuff & Halley Potter, "Ensuring Diversity
Under Race-Neutral Admissions at the University of
Georgia"
Richard L. McCormick, "Converging Perils to College
Access for Racial Minorities: Examples of Responses that
Work from Washington State and New Jersey"
Richard Sander, "The Use of Socioeconomic Affirmative
Action at the University of California"
Jonah Newman, 'What Does the Education Dept. Know
About Race?' Chronicle of Higher Education"
Adam Vaccaro, "Harvard's Endowment Is Bigger Than Half
the World's Economies"

Page 18 of 30

HARV00075704

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00075715

Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

H, NP

H, IR, 403, NP

H, IR, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

F

Harvard Objection

Date

12/00/14

00/00/15

7/21/15

11/17/15

3/00/16

7/8/16

9/13/16

10/14/16

11/14/16

11/17/16

1/13/17

3/11/17

Ex. #

P393

P394

P395

P396

P397

P398

P399

P400

P401

P402

P403

P404

Lorelle L. Espinosa, Matthew N. Gaertner, & Gary Orfield,
"Race, Class, and College Access: Achieving Diversity in a
Shifting Legal Landscape"
Robert P. Jones, Daniel Cox, Betsy Cooper, & Rachel
Lienesch, "Anxiety, Nostalgia and Mistrust: Findings from
the 2015 American Values Survey"
Camille L. Ryan & Kurt Bauman, "Educational Attainment
in the United States: 2015"
Scott Jaschik, "Poll: Public Opposes Affirmative Action"
Bernadette D. Proctor, Jessica L. Semega, & Melissa A.
Kollar, "Income and Poverty in the United States: 2015"
Richard D. Kahlenberg, "School Integration in Practice:
Lessons from Nine Districts"
Anna Steinbock, "Danielle Allen Named University
Professor"
Donna Rosato, "A Surprising Way to Limit Student Debt:
Most Students Today Take More Than Four Years to Earn a
Bachelor's Degree"
Emma Garcia, "Poor Black Children Are Much More
Likely to Attend High-Poverty Schools Than Poor White
Children"
Justin Berkman, "SAT Historical Percentiles for 2015, 2014,
2013, 2012, and 2011"

Description
David Murphey, "The Academic Achievement of English
Language Learners: Data for the U.S. and Each of the
States"
Sean F. Reardon, Rachel Baker, Matt Kasman, Daniel
Klasik, & Joseph B. Townsend, "Can Socioeconomic Status
Substitute for Race in Affirmative Action College
Admissions Policies? Evidence From a Simulation Model"

Page 19 of 30

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List
Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

H, NP

H, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, NP

H, IR, NP, Illegible

H, IR, NP, 403

H, NP

H, IR, NP

H, NP

H, NP

May Use

May Use

H, IR, NP

Harvard Objection

May Use

Will Use/May Use

Date

4/00/17

5/2/17

7/00/17

9/1/17
9/14/17

9/27/17

10/16/17

10/24/17

1/29/18

4/26/18

8/10/18

8/13/18

8/13/18

8/13/18

Ex. #

P405

P406

P407

P408
P409

P410

P411

P412

P413

P414

P415

P416

P417

P418

Description
Jennifer Glynn, "Opening Doors: How Selective Colleges
and Universities Are Expanding Access for High-Achieving,
Low-Income Students"
Anthony P. Carnevale & Martin Van Der Werf, "The 20%
Solution: Selective Colleges Can Afford to Admit More Pell
Grant Recipients"
Raj Chetty, John N. Friedman, Emmanuel Saez, & Nicholas
Turner, and Danny Yagan, "Mobility Report Cards: The
Role of Colleges in Intergenerational Mobility"
N.P. 'Narv' Narvekar, "Message from the CEO"
Gloria G. Guzman, "Household Income: 2016"
Lisa J. Dettling, Joanne W. Hsu, Lindsay Jacobs, Kevin B.
Moore, & Jeffrey P. Thompson, "Recent Trends in WealthHolding by Race and Ethnicity: Evidence from the Survey
of Consumer Finances"
Expert Report of Richard D. Kahlenberg
American Association of Community Colleges, "Students at
Community Colleges"
Rebuttal Expert Report of Richard D. Kahlenberg
Supplemental Expert Report Regarding the Final Report of
the Committee to Study Race-Neutral Alternatives of
Richard D. Kahlenberg
Harvard College Website: Admissions Statistics
The New York Times, Economic Diversity and Student
Outcomes at Harvard University
The New York Times, Economic Diversity and Student
Outcomes at the University of California, Berkeley
The New York Times, Economic Diversity and Student
Outcomes at the University of California, Los Angeles

Page 20 of 30

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List
Ending Bates

H, IR, NP
H, IR, NP

May Use

H, NP

H

H

H, NP

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

H

H, NP

May Use
May Use

H, IR, NP, 403
H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

Harvard Objection

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

8/13/18

P420

P428
P429
P430
P431
P432
P433
P434
P435
P436
P437
P438

P427

P426

P425

P424

P423

P422

10/25/16
10/25/16
10/25/16
10/25/16
10/25/16
10/25/16
10/16/17
1/29/18
4/6/18
6/14/18

8/13/18

P419

P421

Date

Ex. #

Description
US News & World Report, Economic Diversity: National
Universities
Annie E. Casey Foundation, "Children in Single-Parent
Families by Race"
"Segment Analysis Service: An Educationally Relevant
Geodemographic Tagging Service," College Board
Amherst College, Common Data Set 2017-2018
Kate Antonovics & Ben Backes, "The Effect of Banning
Affirmative Action on College Admissions Policies and
Student Quality"
Richard D. Kahlenberg & Halley Potter, A Better
Affirmative Action: State Universities that Created
Alternatives to Racial Preferences
Richard D. Kahlenberg, "Introduction" in Affirmative
Action for the Rich
U.S. Census Bureau, "Population by Region"
U.S. Census Bureau, "America's Families and Living
Arrangements"
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Native Spreadsheet - NEVO Data Chart
Expert Report of Peter S. Arcidiacono
Rebuttal Expert Report of Peter S. Arcidiacono
Errata to Rebuttal Expert Report of Peter S. Arcidiacono
Declaration of Peter Arcidiacono
Data Set Produced by Harvard

Page 21 of 30

HARV00006413
HARV00006471
HARV00006541
HARV00006607
HARV00006695
HARV00006759

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00006413
HARV00006471
HARV00006541
HARV00006607
HARV00006695
HARV00006759

Ending Bates

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

F, IR, 403, 901
F, IR, 403, 901
F, IR, 403, 901
F, IR, 403, 901
F, IR, 403, 901
F, IR, 403, 901
H
H
H
H
CM, F, IR, 403, IC, 901

H, INC, IR, NP

IR, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, NP

H, IR, NP

IR, NP

H, IR, NP

Harvard Objection

11/9/88

Date

10/14/12

P447
P448

P449

6/15/15

10/31/94
10/26/97

P446

7/2/15

4/20/17

7/20/17

7/20/17

8/2/17

P451

P452

P453

P454

P455

P456

P450

3/26/93

P445

P444

P440
P441
P442
P443

P439

Ex. #

Harvard Responses to Plaintiff's Second Request for
Production of Documents
Harvard Responses to Plaintiff's Requests for Admission
Harvard Responses to Plaintiff's Second Set of
Interrogatories
Harvard Responses to Plaintiff Interrogatory No. 2

Harvard Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Interrogatories

Beyond Bias and Barriers: Fulfilling the Potential of Women
in Academic Science and Engineering
Harvard Responses to Plaintiff's First Set of Requests for
Production

The New York Times, The Self-Destruction of the 1 Percent

The Changing Face of West College: An Interview with
Fred Hargadon, the New Dean of Admission
Asian American Student Task Force: Prelim Proposals and
Recommendations on Issues Related to the Princeton
University Community
Shapiro Letter to Fu
The Washington Post, Sticking to Their Own Kind

The Effect of Race Follows the Same Pattern Across Deciles
as Other Characteristics in Harvard's Admissions Process

Description
Admissions Rates by ALDC and Academic Rating for
Domestic white and Asian American Applicants
Race, Class, and Affirmative Action - Sigal Alon
Logit Model of Admissions Removing Personal Rating
Updated Card Base Model without Personal Ratings
Applicant Share Calculations

Page 22 of 30

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List
Ending Bates

F, H, IR, 901

H, F, 403, 901, 702

H, INC
H, F, 403, 901, 702
H, F, 403, 901, 702
H, F, 403, 901, 702

H, F, 403, 901, 702

Harvard Objection

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

F, 901

F, 901

H, INC, IR

H, IR, 403

F, H, IR, 403, 901
F, H, 901

May Use
May Use
May Use

F, H, IR, 403, 901

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

6/15/18

8/16/18
8/21/18
8/21/18
8/21/18

8/21/18

8/21/18

P464

P465
P466
P467
P468

P469

P470

2/18/03

8/13/12

11/2/15
3/00/07

P473

P474

P475

P476
P477
P478

P472

6/7/77

6/13/18

P463

P471

4/19/12
6/12/18

Date
5/31/17
8/11/17
4/11/18

Ex. #
P457
P458
P459
P460
P461
P462

Fisher v. UT Austin, Brief of Harvard, et al. as Amici
Curiae
Fisher v. UT Austin, Brief of Harvard as Amicus Curiae
ABAFAOILSS - Institutional Liaison Description
From the Web Site: About ABAFAOILSS

Grutter v. Bollinger, Brief of Harvard, et al. as Amici Curiae

Description
Harvard Privilege Log
Harvard Supplemental Privilege Log
Harvard Second Supplemental Privilege Log
Merged Harvard Privilege Logs
McGrath Letter re: admissions process
Email from Harvard to Alumni re: Defending Diversity
Harvard College Admissions & Financial Aid Website:
What We Look For
Email from Harvard to Admissions Officers re: Current
litigation regarding admissions
Harvard Office of Institutional Research Website
Harvard Admissions Lawsuit Website: Fact Check: SFFA
Harvard Admissions Lawsuit Website: Key Points
Harvard Admissions Lawsuit Website: Statements
Harvard Admissions Lawsuit Website: Supporting
Documents
Harvard Admissions Lawsuit Website: The Lawsuit
Harvard Graduate School of Education Website: James E.
Ryan
Harvard University Website: Office of the President, Future
Plans
Regents of University of California v. Bakke, Brief of
Harvard, et al. as Amici Curiae

Page 23 of 30

HARV00066599
ABAFAOILSS089
ABAFAOILSS051

HARV00018900

HARV00066521

HARV00066632

HARV00029940

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00066631
ABAFAOILSS090
ABAFAOILSS052

HARV00018938

HARV00066558

HARV00066681

HARV00029945

Ending Bates

May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

F, H, IR, 901
F, H, IR, 901

H, NP

F, NP, 901

F, H, IR, NP, 901

F, H, IR, NP, 901

NP
F, H, IR, NP, 901
F, H, IR, NP, 901
F, H, IR, NP, 901

H, NP

NP

Harvard Objection
CM, F, MIL, 403, PRIV, 901
CM, F, MIL, 403, PRIV, 901
CM, F, MIL, 403, PRIV, 901
CM, F, MIL, 403, PRIV, IC, 901
H
H, NP

Date

4/14/11

8/27/12

10/4/12

10/10/12
10/18/12
12/13/12
12/14/12
1/13/13
10/7/13
4/25/14

4/25/14

1/5/16

5/19/22
5/20/22
6/10/22
10/25/25
11/3/25
11/4/25
11/10/25
12/17/25
12/18/25

1/11/26

5/8/26

Ex. #

P479

P480

P481

P482
P483
P484
P485
P486
P487
P488

P489

P490

P491
P492
P493
P494
P495
P496
P497
P498
P499

P500

P501

Willis Email to McArthur re: Fisher v. Texas planning
Email re [ABAFAOILSS] Do you agree?
Herrera Email re: Reminder: ABA IL Update
Herrera Email to Ray re: Some items for ABA folders
ABAFAOILSS Email re SAT/ACT Testing Gap Update
Nance Email re: What is the Definition of URM?
Chan Email re: Barnard College
Cho Email re: ABA Admissions and FA IL Updates for
Spring Meeting
Salazar Email re: ABA Admissions and FA IL Updates for
Winter Meeting
A. Lawrence Lowell Letter to Prof Wm. Hocking
A. Lawrence Lowell Letter to Rufus Tucker, Esq.
Letter to Attorney Martin
Leighton Letter to President Lowell
Lowell Letter to James
James Letter to Lowell
James Letter to Lowell
Brown Letter to Lowell
Lowell Letter to Brown
Report of the Special Committee Appointed to Consider the
Limitation of Numbers
Chicago Daily Tribune, Harvard Scans Racial Traits of
Applicants

Redacted Email to Banks re: Help on a "likely" conversation

Description
ABAFAOILSS Email re ABAFAOILSS Spring Meeting &
40th Anniversary
ABAFAOILSS Email re Fisher v. Texas Planning

Page 24 of 30

ABAFAOILSS036

HARV00067679

HARV00014629
HARV00014555
HARV00014772
HARV00035068
ABAFAOILSS016
ABAFAOILSS040
ABAFAOILSS035

HARV00006870

ABAFAOILSS030

ABAFAOILSS008

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

ABAFAOILSS037

HARV00067680

HARV00014630
HARV00014557
HARV00014777
HARV00035072
ABAFAOILSS021
ABAFAOILSS041
ABAFAOILSS035

HARV00006871

ABAFAOILSS032

ABAFAOILSS015

Ending Bates

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, 901
F, H, IR, 901
H, IR
H, IR
F, H, 901
F, H, IR, 403, 901
F, H, IR, 901

H

F, H, 901

CM, F, H, IR, 901

Harvard Objection

Date

5/11/26

11/3/05

10/6/90
1/11/12
1/12/12

1/12/12

2/2/12

5/15/12

7/4/12

11/30/12

11/30/12

12/19/12

3/22/13

4/10/13

4/30/13

6/3/13

7/1/13

Ex. #

P502

P503

P504
P505
P506
P507

P508

P509

P510

P511

P512

P513

P514

P515

P516

P517

P518

P519

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: July 4

Fitzsimmons Email to Hibino re: Steeplechase

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: Hey!

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: No subject

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re Wow!

Fitzsimmons Email to Hibino re: Thursday

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: No subject

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: No subject

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: Just so's you know!

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: Question

Quay Letter to Merhill re: Complaint

Hibino Email to Fitzsimmons re: No subject

Description
Jewish Daily Bulletin, Race Determining Factor in Regard to
Harvard Applicants, He Admits
The Harvard Crimson, Writing the Wrong: A. Lawrence
Lowell
Blank Harvard College Application for Admission
The Harvard Crimson, Ed. Department Clears Harvard
Kropp Letter to Faust re: Complaint
Hibino Email re: Fitzsimmons meeting at Ruth's Chris
HARV00016646

Ending Bates

SFFAHARVARD0002467
HARV00018452
SFFAHARVARD0002451
SFFAHARVARD0002446
SFFAHARVARD0002460
SFFAHARVARD0002462
SFFAHARVARD0002452
SFFAHARVARD0002450
HARV00004995
SFFAHARVARD0002431
SFFAHARVARD0002469
SFFAHARVARD0002468

Page 25 of 30

SFFAHARVARD0002467
HARV00018462
SFFAHARVARD0002451
SFFAHARVARD0002446
SFFAHARVARD0002460
SFFAHARVARD0002464
SFFAHARVARD0002453
SFFAHARVARD0002450
HARV00004995
SFFAHARVARD0002431
SFFAHARVARD0002469
SFFAHARVARD0002468

HARV00016645

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

H, IR, NP
H, IR, NP

May Use

H, IR, NP

H

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

H, IR, NP

CM, H, IR, NP

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901
F, H, NP, 901
H
F, H, IR, NP, IC, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, 901

Harvard Objection

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

12/22/14

12/22/14

P524

P525

P538
P539
P540
P541

P537

P536

P534
P535

P533

P528
P529
P530
P531
P532

P527

6/19/15

1/00/15
5/9/17
7/26/17

11/25/14

P523

P526

Date
2/5/13
6/18/14
6/20/14

Ex. #
P520
P521
P522

Unanimous Written Consent in Lieu of a Meeting of the
BOD of SFFA
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn

Boston Latin Applications to Harvard College (2014-2019)

Description
The Spectator: It's Time for a New Legacy
Email to Pedrick re: Race Bias pdf
Zhang Email to Wang re: Statistics Paper
Pedrick Email re: NYT article: Is Harvard Unfair to AsianAmericans?
Pedrick Email to Hughes re: The Brutal Application Process
to (Sue) Harvard - NYMag
Zhang Email to Pedrick re: The Brutal Application Process
to (Sue) Harvard
Student Paper Entitled Quantifying the Asian Penalty in
College Admissions
Stuyvesant High School (NY) 2017-2018 High School
Profile
Stuyvesant High School Directory of Guidance Services
Stuyvesant Applications to Harvard College (2014-2019)
The Argo: Harvard Not Fair?
Peter Email re: Emerging stories of interest
Boston Latin Enrollment Data (2013-14)
Boston Latin School Contact Info of Directors & Guidance
Counselors
Boston Latin School Website: College Counseling
Planning for College by Jim Montague

Ending Bates

Page 26 of 30

SFFA-Harvard 0000052

SHS 000005

SHS 000035

SHS 000033

SFFA-Harvard 0000067

SHS 000012

SHS 000035

SHS 000033

SHS 000002

SHS 000036
SHS 0000001
SHS 000002

SHS 000036
SHS 0000020

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

F, 901, IR, 901, 702

F, IR, 901
F, H, IR, 901

F, IR, 901

F, H, IR, 901
F, IR, 901, 702
F, H, IR, 901
F, H, IR, 901, IC
F, H, IR, 901

F, IR, NP, 901

CM, F, H, IR, 403, 901, 702

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, IR, 901

F, H, IR, 901

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
May Use
F, H, IR, 901
May Use
F, H, IR, 901
May Use
F, H, IR, 403, 901, 702

8/30/18

10/4/90

P554

9/7/04

P557

9/25/07
3/29/07
4/1/16
3/27/14
4/1/15

P559

P560
P561
P562
P563
P564

P558

9/8/06

P556

P555

6/16/17
2/15/12

Date

Ex. #
P542
P543
P544
P545
P546
P547
P548
P549
P550
P551
P552
P553

The Chosen: The Hidden History of Admission and
Exclusion at Harvard, Yale, and Princeton by Jerome
Karabel
Peter Arcidiacono's Merged Database of Data Set Produced
by Harvard
The Princeton Review, Cracking College Admissions, 2nd
Edition
The Price of Admission by Daniel Golden
The Harvard Crimson, 2,058 Accepted Into Class of 2011
The Harvard Gazette, College Admits 2,037
The Harvard Gazette, College Admits Class of '18
The Harvard Gazette, Harvard College admits 1,990

Declaration of Peter Arcidiacono

Description
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Subpoena to Stuyvesant High School
Kropp Letter to Faust re: withdrawing the complaint
Hibino Letter to Bok re: review of undergraduate admissions
programs
Statement of Findings

Page 27 of 30

HARV00023650

HARV00023643

HARV00016639

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00023695

HARV00023659

HARV00016639

Ending Bates

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

Will Use/May Use

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, INSUFF, 901
F, H, NP, 901
F, H, NP, 901
CM, F, H, NP, 901
F, H, NP, 901

F, H, IR, NP, 403, INSUFF, 901

CM, F, IR, 403, Illegible, IC, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, NP, 403, INSUFF, 901

H, New analysis - exceeds scope of
expert reports disclosed under FRCP
26(a)(2)

F, IR, 901

Harvard Objection

3/30/17

3/28/18

7/30/18

1/30/15

10/8/14

6/30/15

P565

P566

P567

P568

P569

P570
P571
P572
P573
P574
P575
P576
P577
P578
P579

10/8/13

P585

3/19/13

9/22/12
2/14/12
2/20/13
5/1/13

P581
P582
P583
P584

P586
P587
P588
P589

4/23/14

P580

7/30/18

Date

Ex. #

Howrigan Email to Cheng re Interview Friday
Admissions Part II - Subtitle
Bever Email to Hansen re: Admissions power point
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re Admissions memo
Modeling Admissions to Harvard College: Preliminary
Analysis
Memo to All Staff Attaching Several Documents
Applicants 2016 vs 2017
Howrigan Email to Yong re: one pager
E & F Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019 (excerpts)

Yong Email to Bever re Report on differences in SAT scores

Description
The Harvard Gazette, Harvard College Admits 2,056 to
Class of '21
The Harvard Gazette, 1,962 Admitted to Class of '22
SFFA's Supplemental Objections and Responses to
Harvard's First Set of Interrogatories
IRS Letter to SFFA
Letter to IRS re Form 1023 (Application for Recognition of
Exemption) on Behalf of Students for Fair Admission
Annual Report of Students for Fair Admissions
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Exhibit withdrawn
Declaration of Peter Arcidiacono
Email re R/A Reading
SFFA-Harvard0000001

Ending Bates

Page 28 of 30

HARV00001478
HARV00010469
HARV00021585
HARV00048729

HARV00069113

HARV00017569
HARV00065741
HARV00075073
HARV00023547

HARV00020793

HARV00032540

HARV00001497
HARV00010475
HARV00021585
HARV00048918

HARV00069119

HARV00017570
HARV00065774
HARV00075164
HARV00023555

HARV00020794

HARV00032540

SFFA-Harvard0000122

SFFA-Harvard0000008
SFFA-Harvard0000119

SFFA-Harvard0000051

SFFA-Harvard0000001

Beginning Bates

SFFA Exhibit List

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

Will Use/May Use

CM, F, H, 901
CM, F, 901
CM, F, H, 901
INC, Illegible

CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

CM, F, H, IR, 901
CM, MIL
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

H, MIL, 403, PRIV

H
F, H, 901

F, H, IR, MIL, 901

F, H, INC, MIL, 901

F, H, NP, 901

Harvard Objection

3/17/14
1/17/13
3/19/13
2/14/12
4/15/13
4/29/13
5/1/13

3/20/18

3/31/18

4/3/18

4/8/18

4/8/18

4/8/18

4/9/18

P606

P607

P608

P609

P610

P611

P612

7/22/14

6/30/14

Date

P594
P595
P596
P597
P598
P599
P600
P601
P602
P603
P604
P605

P593

Ex. #
P590
P591
P592

Smith Email to Gershengorn re Confidential and privileged

Description
E & F Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018 (excerpts)
Selected Topics in Casework and Diversity
Banks Email to Ortiz re: No subject
Outline with Handwritten Notes re: Diversity and
Admissions
Memo to All Staff Attaching Several Documents
P & S Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2018 (excerpts)
C & D Dockets - Official #1, Class of 2019 (excerpts)
Docket
Applicant Summary Sheet
Class of 2018 Docket Lop List
Class of 2017 - Dean's Lineage and Interest List
Howrigan Email to Yong re: one pager
Admissions Part II - Subtitle
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Follow-up
Heenan Email to Driver-Linn re: two quick things
Bever Email to Fitzsimmons re: Admissions memo
Smith Email to Fitzsimmons and Khurana re Memo from
Dean Smith
Smith Email to Khurana and Fitzsimmons re Edited draft
report
Murphy Email to Gershengorn re Draft Committee Report
Ellsworth Email to Khurana et al re Final Committee
Report
Khurana Email to Gershengorn et al re Confidential and
privileged
Fitzsimmons Email to Gershengorn re Confidential and
privileged

Page 29 of 30

HARV00097740

HARV00097739

HARV00097716

HARV00097695

HARV00097676

HARV00097654

HARV00097512

HARV00001730
HARV00056250
HARV00046797
HARV00011185
HARV00003880
HARV00001865
HARV00011651
HARV00021585
HARV00065741
HARV00075060
HARV00075051
HARV00023547

HARV00028373

Beginning Bates
HARV00036613
HARV00013367
HARV00006868

SFFA Exhibit List

HARV00097740

HARV00097739

HARV00097738

HARV00097715

HARV00097694

HARV00097675

HARV00097653

HARV00001749
HARV00057311
HARV00046927
HARV00011202
HARV00003881
HARV00001866
HARV00011651
HARV00021585
HARV00065774
HARV00075060
HARV00075052
HARV00023555

HARV00028384

Ending Bates
HARV00037736
HARV00013472
HARV00006868

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

H

H

H

H

F, H, 901

H

CM, F, H, 901
CM, INC, Illegilbe
CM, INC, Illegible
F, 901
CM, F, H, INC, Illegible, 901
F, 901
F, 901
CM, F, H, 901
CM, MIL
CM, H, IR, MIL
CM, H, IR, MIL
CM, H, MIL, 403, 702

Will Use/May Use
Harvard Objection
May Use
CM, INC, Illegible, 403
May Use
May Use
CM, H

4/9/18

5/11/17

P614

P615

P631

P630

P628
P629

P616
P617
P618
P619
P620
P621
P622
P623
P624
P625
P626
P627

Date
4/9/18

Ex. #
P613

ABAFAOILSS 2003-2013 listserv
Academic Decile Intervals
ALDC Admit Rates by Academic Rating
ALDC Interview Stats
Share Admits/Rejects Within Each Rating
Share Admits/Rejects Within Each Rating
Share Admits/Rejects Within Each Rating
Share Admits/Rejects Within Each Rating
Share Applicants by Academic Index
Share Applicants by Academic Index
Share Applicants by Academic Index
Share Applicants by Academic Index
Number and Share of Applicants with Personal Rating 2 or
Higher
Share of Applicants with Personal Rating 2 or Higher
Number and Share of Applicants with Personal Rating 2 or
Higher
Share of Applicants with Personal Rating 2 or Higher

Subpoena to Association of Black Admission and Financial
Aid Officers of the Ivy League and Sister Schools

Description
Smith Email to Ellsworth re Final Committee Report
Gershengorn Email to Khurana et al re Final Committee
Report

Page 30 of 30

ABAFAOILSS008

HARV00097743

Beginning Bates
HARV00097741

SFFA Exhibit List

ABAFAOILSS015

HARV00097763

Ending Bates
HARV00097742

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use

May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use
May Use

May Use

May Use

Harvard Objection

F, IR, 901
CM, F, H, IR, 901

H

Will Use/May Use
May Use
H