Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College et al

Filing 570

PRETRIAL MEMORANDUM by Students for Fair Admissions, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A1, # 2 Exhibit A2, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F)(Mortara, Adam) (Additional attachment(s) added on 10/2/2018: # 8 Exhibit A1 (Filed Under Seal)) (McDonagh, Christina).

Exhibit E

DEPOSITION DESIGNATION OBJECTIONS
Code
ARG

Objection
Lawyer Argument or Colloquy (Harvard objects to this deposition designation
because it is lawyer argument and not testimony of the witness.)

F

Foundation (Harvard objects to this deposition designation on the ground that the
foundation necessary for its admission has not been laid under Fed. R. Evid. 602.)

FORM

Form (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because the question asked is
compound, argumentative, or has some other defect in form.)

H

Hearsay (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it constitutes or
contains hearsay under Fed. R. Evid. 801-802.)

IC

Improper Compilation of Unrelated Documents, all objections reserved (Harvard
objects to this deposition designation because the question asks the witness to offer
testimony on a document that that consists of different or unrelated documents.)

INC

Remainder of or Related Writings or Recorded Statements (Harvard objects to
this deposition designation because it is incomplete, or it asks the witness to offer
testimony on a document where the remainder of the document should fairly be
considered. (Fed. R. Evid. 106).)

IR

Not Relevant (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it is not
relevant to any issue to be decided in this case under Fed. R. Evid. 401-402.)

LC

Calls for Legal Conclusion (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because
it contains conclusions of law.)

LEADING Leading (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because the question asked is
leading the witness.)
LO

Lay Opinion (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it constitutes or
contains improper opinion by a lay witness under Fed. R. Evid. 701-702.)

MIL

Subject to motion in limine issue (Harvard objects to this deposition designation
because it falls within the scope of Harvard’s pending motions in limine.)

NP

Not Produced / Produced Untimely (Harvard objects to this deposition designation
because the question asks the witness to offer testimony on a document that was not
produced during the course of discovery.)

Code
NR

Objection
Non-Responsive Testimony (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because
it includes statements that are not responsive to the question asked.)

PRIV

Negative inference based on redacted privileged information (Harvard objects to
this deposition designation because it seeks communications or information protected
from disclosure by the attorney-client privilege, work product doctrine, common
interest, joint defense, and/or other privilege.)

S

Speculative (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it includes
statements that are speculative as to matters of fact or law.)

SCOPE

Beyond Scope of 30(b)(6) Notice or Topics (Harvard objects to this deposition
designation because it is outside the scope of the topics on which the witness was
designated as a corporate representative.)

VA

Vague and Ambiguous (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it
includes vague and indefinite statements.)

403

Prejudice Exceeds Probative Value (Harvard objects to this deposition designation
because its probative value is outweighed by unfair prejudice and/or confusion of the
issues under Fed. R. Evid. 403.)

901

Authentication (Harvard objects to this deposition designation because it contains
testimony on a document that has not been properly authenticated under Fed. R. Evid.
901.)

13
18
7
12

17
20
1
5
4
8
24

20
1
10
14
20

29
29
30
33

34
34
35
35
36
36
38

39
40
40
40
40

39
40
40
40
40

34
34
35
35
36
36
39

29
30
30
33

23
8
12
18
22

18
23
3
12
6
8
3

16
5
17
16

Objections

FORM, VA
FORM, VA

FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA

F, FORM, VA

F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F
FORM

F, FORM
F, FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
7
18
7
21
16
16
16
17
16
19
16
21
17
4
17
5
17
7
17
18
17
20
17
24
18
1
18
5
IR
26
20
26
23
27
1
27
2
27
5
27
10

1

44

39
39
39

33
34

27
27

18

9
13
19

17
10

11
13

44

39
39
39

34
34

27
27

19

11
17
19

1
16

11
14

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

24

6

9

23

3
8

19

3

40

43

43

44

45
45

45

46

46

46

45
45

45

43

43

41

5

1

6
17

1

12

7

1

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM

FORM, VA
FORM

FORM

S

F, FORM

F, S

Objections

2

44
44
48
48
189
190
48
48
48
48

18
21
13
18
19
1
13
18
13
18

44
44
48
48
189
190
48
48
48
48

19
22
16
22
23
2
16
22
16
22

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

8
13
16
23
2
2
8
23

8
23
5

18

24

17
19
23
4
10
21
7
19
22

52
52
52
52
53
54
54
54

55
55
56

56

56

79
79
79
80
80
80
81
81
81

79
79
80
80
80
81
81
81
82

56

56

55
56
56

52
52
52
52
53
54
54
55

17
21
2
8
19
5
9
20
2

24

22

8
3
6

11
14
18
24
4
6
8
6

Objections

F, FORM
F, FORM, LEADING, S

F, FORM, NR

F, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA

IR, S

IR

FORM, IR

FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR
IR
FORM, IR
IR
FORM, IR

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
49
7
49
11 IR
49
19
50
10 IR

3

56
56
56
57
57
57
57

55
55

54

51
51

10
13
17
14
17
14
17

9
17

13

22
24

56
56
56
57
57
57
57

55
55

54

51
52

11
15
17
15
21
15
21

15
17

19

22
1

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

21
16
19
10
13
11
11

13
22
3
11
15
21

17
4
8

83
84
84
85
85
86
87

88
88
89
89
89
90

98
99
99

99
99
99

88
89
89
89
89
91

83
84
84
85
85
86
87

1
6
15

20
1
9
13
15
2

22
17
24
11
15
22
17

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
82
4
82
7
82
9
82
14
82
16
82
23
83
5
83
6
83
8
83
12
83
14
83
19

F

F

F, FORM, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 901

F, 901

F, FORM, S

FORM, VA

FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

Objections

4

91
91
92
92
92
92
99
99
99

86
86
87
88
86
86

83
84

3
5
2
8
17
24
2
2
2

23
23
23
2
23
23

23
2

91
91
92
92
92
92
99
99
99

86
86
87
88
86
86

83
84

3
8
6
15
22
24
3
3
3

24
24
24
3
24
24

24
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation
Calls for speculation
Calls for speculation
Calls for speculation

Objections to Counter-Designations

23
10

F, FORM, NR

150
151

150
151

23
5

ARG

H

F, H, S
F, S
F, S
F, S

ARG

5

44

44
44
189
190

112
112
112
112

107

103
103

FORM, H, S
S

F, S
S
F, FORM, S
NR, S
FORM, H
FORM, H
FORM, H

101

18

18
21
19
1

10
10
10
10

20

8
8

20

44

44
44
189
190

112
112
112
112

108

103
103

101

19

19
22
23
2

17
17
17
17

1

11
11

22

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

FORM, H, S
F, FORM, S

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
100
8
101
4
101
6
101
11
101
13
101
13
102
12
102
21
102
23
103
2
103
12
103
16
104
5
104
11
107
5
107
15
107
17
107
19
108
2
108
3
108
6
108
19
109
1
109
4
109
6
109
8
109
10
109
12
109
14
109
14
111
23
112
3
112
8
112
9
112
18
113
2
113
4
113
9
113
18
114
1
114
18
114
19
114
21
114
24
115
19
116
6
116
8
116
9
150
17
150
21

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

12

16

22

8
12
16
3
6
2
7
12
20
3
7

151

151

151

161
161
161
162
162
163
163
163
163
164
164

161
161
161
162
162
163
163
163
164
164
164

151

151

151

10
14
17
4
24
2
10
18
1
5
7

22

20

14

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM, S

FORM
S

FORM, H
FORM, H

FORM
FORM

FORM, VA

FORM

Objections

6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
152
4
152
6
152
8
152
8
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2
44
18
44
19
44
21
44
22
152
4
152
6
152
8
152
8
189
19
189
23
190
1
190
2

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

14
19
24
5
23
16
19
8
11
1
13
1
9
19
10
15
19
6
13
22

21
5
21

166
166
166
167
167
168
168
169
169
170
170
171
171
171
172
172
172
173
173
173

176
177
177

177
177
178

166
166
167
167
168
168
169
169
169
170
170
171
171
172
172
172
173
173
173
174
3
11
9

17
22
3
15
14
17
6
10
23
8
23
7
17
8
13
17
2
11
14
6
ARG, FORM
IR
F, 901

H

F, FORM, H
ARG, FORM, LEADING, S
FORM, LEADING, S
F, S
ARG, F, FORM, S
F, S
FORM, S
FORM, S

F, FORM

F, FORM, 403
FORM, H, LEADING

FORM
ARG, FORM
FORM
H

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
164
16
164
18 FORM, LEADING
164
20
164
23 FORM, S
165
1
165
2
S
166
4
166
7

7

178
179

174
174

170

165
166

10
8

7
11

9

22
3

178
179

174
174

170

166
166

11
12

9
14

12

1
3

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

14
17
3
7

9
20
12
15
2
10
18
3
13
17
9
13
23
2
10
2
7
16
20
1
6
10
18
14

180
180
181
181

182
182
183
183
184
184
184
185
185
185
186
186
186
187
187
188
188
188
188
189
189
189
189
190

182
183
183
183
184
184
185
185
185
186
186
186
186
187
187
188
188
188
188
189
189
189
189
190

180
181
181
181
19
4
13
24
8
16
1
11
15
7
9
21
24
8
12
5
14
18
23
4
6
16
18
19

15
1
5
16

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

ARG, FORM, IR

IR
ARG, IR
ARG, FORM, IR

H, IR

IR, 403

F, 901
F, H, 901
INC
IR
H, S, 901
H, 403, 901
F, FORM, H, 403, 901
IR, 403

F, FORM, S, 901
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S, 901
F, H, 901

Objections

8

186

181
181

10

17
20

186

181
181

12

18
20

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
179
14
179
18

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

1
7
12
18
23
12
19
2
16
19

5
9

14
18
12
22

196
196
196
196
196
197
197
198
200
200

201
201

207
209
210
210

208
210
210
211

201
201

196
196
196
196
197
197
197
198
200
200

1
10
20
15

7
24

3
10
16
21
10
17
24
4
17
21

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
190
21
191
11
191
15
191
16
191
18
191
20
191
22
192
5
192
7
192
10
195
21
195
23

IR
FORM, H
FORM
FORM, H

FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA, S
VA, S
FORM, S
FORM

FORM, VA

FORM
FORM
FORM

Objections

9

202
206
206

198
198
199
200
200

193
193
195

1
9
17

5
18
22
3
15

17
22
10

202
206
206

198
198
200
200
200

193
193
195

2
15
21

16
18
1
13
15

20
24
18

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

16
19
1

3
4

6

15
3
9
11
7
14
20
4
9
16
22
1

223
223
224

224
224

224

224
225
228
230
232
232
232
233
233
233
233
234

225
225
228
231
232
232
232
233
233
233
233
234

224

224
224

223
223
224

1
4
18
9
12
18
21
7
14
16
23
8

8

3
4

17
19
1

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
211
17
211
22
211
24
212
3
212
5
212
6
213
23
214
4
220
14
220
16
220
18
221
4
221
6
221
13
222
8
222
15

IR
S

FORM
FORM, LC

ARG, 901
H
FORM, S

F, S, 901

F, S, 901

F, S, 901
F, FORM, 901, S

F, S, 901

901, F, S

F, 901

FORM, S

ARG, FORM
ARG, FORM

Objections

10

224
224
224
224

224
224

223
223

212

11
14
11
14

11
14

7
13

7

224
224
224
224

224
224

223
223

212

12
14
12
14

12
14

11
15

12

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
234
10
234
10
234
19
234
24
235
7
235
8
235
10
235
18
237
5
237
14
237
17
237
18
237
20
238
1
238
3
238
11
238
13
238
16
238
18
238
24
239
2
239
6
239
8
239
12
240
6
240
12
240
15
240
16
240
18
240
18
241
2
241
3
241
5
241
7
241
9
241
9
241
15
242
1
242
3
242
8
242
13
242
18
242
20
243
5
243
7
243
11
244
3
244
11
244
12
244
12
244
14
244
17
244
19
244
20
F
F, FORM
F, FORM

F, H, IR
F, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM

F, FORM
FORM

F, 901

FORM, VA

F, 901
F
F
H

FORM

Objections

11

240

237

13

15

240

237

14

16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Grace Cheng Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

6

24
8
16
24
21
2
15

11
18
20
23
5

13

15
16
16
16
17
18
25

26
26
26
26
27

26
26
26
27
27

16
16
16
17
17
18
26

13

13
18
21
4
12

6
14
22
7
24
7
5

7

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
5
12
5
20
5
21
6
2
9
7
9
25
10
5
10
17
10
19
10
25
11
3
11
15
11
17
12
2
12
4
12
9
12
11
12
14
12
16
12
21
12
23
13
4

IR, PRIV, 403
IR, PRIV, 403
FORM, IR, 403
FORM, IR, 403
FORM, IR, 403

IR, PRIV, 403

FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA, INC
F, FORM, VA

FORM, IR, VA

F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
F, FORM, IR, VA
FORM, IR

Objections

12

10
18
18

13
13
14
14
15
15

6
8
11

9
16
17
24
13
17

10
18
18

13
13
14
14
15
15

10
9
14

14
19
22
24
15
18

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

4

12

54

54

54

54

16

10

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
27
14
28
2
29
12
29
21
29
23
29
23
29
25
30
2
30
4
30
5
31
18
31
22
32
8
32
19
36
20
37
7
37
8
38
3
38
5
38
19
49
4
49
7
49
9
49
12
49
14
49
22
51
13
51
20
51
22
51
22
51
24
51
24
52
2
52
5
52
6
52
11
52
17
52
18
52
20
52
24
53
2
53
16
53
24
54
2

FORM, IR, SCOPE

FORM, IR, SCOPE

F, FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE

IR, 403
FORM

FORM, IR, 403
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM, VA

Objections

13

54
54
54
55
54
54
54
55
54

17
21
23
4
17
21
23
4
17

54
54
55
55
54
54
55
55
54

19
21
2
4
19
21
2
4
19

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

55
55
58
61
61
68
72
73
73
77
78
78
78
79
79
80
80
83
85
86
86
86
87
87
87
88
88

19
25
24
5
9
14
9
7
10
8
7
9
18
12
17
18
25
21
6
5
22
25
11
13
17
6
19

55
56
59
61
61
68
72
73
73
78
78
78
79
79
80
80
80
83
85
86
86
87
87
87
87
88
89

23
9
5
7
9
19
22
8
18
5
7
12
7
15
8
23
25
25
20
20
23
4
11
14
23
17
17

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA
FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA
FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
F, IR, S, SCOPE
F, IR, S, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, PRIV, SCOPE, 403
F, FORM, IR, PRIV, SCOPE, 403
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, IR, SCOPE, VA
IR, SCOPE, S, H, 403
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE

Objections

14

97

10

97

10

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
54
21
54
21
54
23
55
2
55
4
55
4

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

19

3

6

10

19

21

9

9
15
25

10
17
23
3
14
17
21
3
12
5
8

89

90

90

90

90

90

91

96
96
106

107
108
108
110
110
110
110
111
111
112
112

107
108
108
110
110
110
110
111
111
112
113

96
96
107

91

90

90

90

90

90

89

15
21
23
12
15
19
25
10
22
6
3

13
15
8

15

25

19

17

9

4

24

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM
FORM, INC, VA
FORM, INC, VA
FORM, VA, IR, SCOPE
FORM, VA, IR, SCOPE
FORM, VA
F, FORM
F, FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA

FORM, IR, SCOPE, PRIV, 403
FORM, IR, SCOPE, PRIV, 403
FORM, INC

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA, 403

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA, 403

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA

FORM, IR, SCOPE

FORM, IR, SCOPE

ARG, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA, PRIV

Objections

15

111

98
99

24

20
3

112

98
99

2

25
4

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18
97
10
97
10
97
12
97
18

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

114
114
115
115
116
117
117
117
118
118
119
119
119
119
120
121
121
121
122
123
123
124
124
125
125
125

14
25
16
21
18
9
19
25
11
21
5
14
23
25
21
4
18
24
7
6
10
18
24
4
6
8

114
115
115
116
117
117
117
118
118
118
119
119
119
120
121
121
121
122
122
123
123
124
125
125
125
125

23
14
19
16
7
9
23
9
19
21
12
21
23
19
2
16
22
5
9
8
10
22
2
4
6
10

Objections

F, FORM

F, FORM, SCOPE, LC
FORM
F, FORM, SCOPE, LC

F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE

FORM, S
FORM

FORM
FORM
F, FORM

FORM
FORM, S
FORM
FORM
FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
113
5
113
11 FORM, S
113
13
113
13 S
113
25
114
12 FORM, VA

16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
113
15
113
16
113
15
113
16
98
20
98
25
99
3
99
4

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
125
12
125
19
125
21
125
25
126
3
126
3
126
22
127
3
127
5
127
10
127
12
127
24
128
2
128
7
128
9
128
14
128
16
128
23
128
25
128
25
129
3
129
12
129
14
129
23
129
25
130
17
131
3
131
5
131
7
131
12
131
22
132
3
135
5
135
9
135
11
135
15
135
17
136
6
136
8
136
14
136
16
136
22
136
24
137
11
137
13
138
2
138
4
138
8
138
12
138
19
138
21
139
9
139
12
139
19
139
20
140
4
140
6
141
3
141
5
141
12
F, FORM, LO
F, FORM, LO
F, FORM, LO
FORM
FORM
F, FORM
FORM
FORM
F, FORM
FORM
F
FORM
FORM, S
FORM

FORM
FORM

FORM
F, FORM

FORM, VA
FORM
F, FORM, VA, S
F, FORM, VA, S
F, FORM
F, FORM

F, FORM
F, FORM

Objections

17

131
131
132

13
13
4

131
131
132

16
16
7

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

2
13

19

9

13

15

23

25

13
20
7
13

145
145

145

146

146

146

146

146

148
148
149
149

148
149
149
149

147

146

146

146

146

145

145
145

18
5
11
19

12

23

21

13

11

19

11
17

FORM
FORM, S
S
FORM

F

F, FORM

FORM

FORM
FORM

FORM

24

19

143

144

FORM
FORM
FORM
F, FORM
FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
141
14
141
18
141
20
142
4
142
6
142
14
142
16
142
19
142
21
143
17

Objections

18

362
364
362
364
362
364
362
364
147
147
147
147
147
147
147
147
147

362
364
362
364
12
19
12
19
12
19
12
19
13
16
23
13
16
23
13
16
23

12
19
12
19
364
365
364
365
364
365
364
365
147
147
148
147
147
148
147
147
148

364
365
364
365
12
16
12
16
12
16
12
16
14
20
3
14
20
3
14
20
3

12
16
12
16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

9

23
8
13
10
5
17

8

3
10
18
15
23
24
25
6
16

154

154
156
156
157
158
158

159

160
160
160
161
161
162
164
165
165

160
160
161
161
162
163
165
165
165

159

156
156
157
157
158
159

154

8
16
13
21
11
18
4
14
16

8

6
11
3
18
15
6

17

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
149
21
150
3
150
5
150
13
151
5
151
20
151
22
152
10
152
12
152
19
152
21
153
14
153
16
154
7

FORM

FORM, S
FORM
FORM

FORM
FORM, S
FORM
FORM, PRIV, 403
FORM, PRIV, 403
FORM

FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM

Objections

19

159
159
159
159
159
159

362
364
362
364

10
15
18
10
15
18

12
19
12
19

159
159
159
159
159
159

364
365
364
365

13
15
20
13
15
20

12
16
12
16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

23
6
8
13
21
5
23
2
16
22
5
14
18
3
15
21

13

20

171
172
172
172
172
173
173
174
174
174
175
175
175
176
179
179

180

180

180

180

172
172
172
172
173
173
173
174
174
175
175
175
175
176
179
179

23

18

4
6
11
19
3
10
24
14
20
3
5
16
25
3
19
21

Objections

F, FORM, S

FORM

FORM

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
IR, SCOPE, 403
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
F, FORM, S, H, IR, SCOPE, 403
S, H, IR, SCOPE, 403
FORM
FORM, NR
FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
IR, SCOPE, 403
FORM, IR, SCOPE, 403
FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
165
18
166
15 FORM
166
17
167
5
167
20
167
24 FORM
168
2
168
13
168
14
169
10

14

19
24

21

182
20

14

182
182

21

182

169
169

182

182

182

182

169
169

21

19

21

19

22
24

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation, lack of
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of
knowledge

personal

personal

personal

personal

Objections to Counter-Designations

25

3
7
21
2
4
8
11
14
22
5
16
19
3
11
16
21
21
12
18
2
8
25
5

14
23

180

181
181
184
185
185
185
185
185
185
186
186
186
187
187
187
187
188
189
189
191
191
191
192

193
193

193
194

181
181
184
185
185
185
185
185
186
186
186
186
187
187
187
187
189
189
189
191
191
192
192

180

21
4

5
11
24
2
6
9
12
20
3
5
17
25
9
12
19
21
11
16
22
6
11
3
14

25

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

F, FORM, VA, S
F, FORM, VA, S

FORM, VA
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

FORM

F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM

FORM

FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S
S
FORM
FORM
F, FORM

F, FORM

FORM

Objections

21

18
21

21

182

192
192

14

182

192
193

182

182

19
8

21

19

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

196
196
197
197
198
198
198
199
199
200
200
200
200
201
201
201
202
202
202
203

12
21
13
21
12
14
19
18
22
6
10
13
25
13
16
25
8
13
19
7

196
197
197
198
198
198
199
199
200
200
200
200
200
201
201
202
202
202
202
203

19
11
19
10
12
17
5
20
4
8
11
23
25
14
16
6
11
17
20
10

FORM
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
194
6
194
10 F, FORM, VA, S
194
12
194
12
194
21
194
24 F, FORM, VA, S
195
2
195
3
195
5
195
12 F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

13
17

195
195

22

18
21

192
192

195

195

192
193

22

15

19
8

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

IR, 403, SCOPE

3
9
14
22
24
3
13
22
4
7
24
10
13
19
10
15
9

210
210
210
210
210
211
211
211
212
212
212
213
213
213
215
215
216

210
210
210
210
210
211
211
211
212
212
212
213
213
213
215
216
216

7
12
20
22
25
11
20
24
5
22
24
11
17
20
13
7
23

22

22

208

208

FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, H, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC

FORM

FORM

FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM

IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
203
12
203
12
203
14
203
20
203
22
203
22
205
3
205
7
205
9
205
9
206
22
207
3
207
5
207
12
207
14
207
17
207
19
208
2
208
4
208
20

23

208
209
208
209

204

24
6
24
6

8

209
209
209
209

204

4
11
4
11

25

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
216
25
216
25
217
3
217
10
217
12
217
12
219
12
219
16
219
18
219
22
219
23
220
6
222
7
222
13
223
2
223
10
223
12
223
18
223
20
223
25
224
3
224
3
225
2
225
12
225
14
225
24
226
11
227
20
227
22
227
23
228
24
229
10
229
12
229
18
229
20
230
5
230
7
230
16
230
18
231
4
231
6
231
17
231
19
231
19
233
18
233
21
233
23
234
6
235
23
236
14
237
13
237
19
237
21
238
4
238
6
238
16
238
18
240
3
240
5
240
11
FORM
F, FORM, S
FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

FORM

F, FORM, IR, 403, S, H, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, S, H, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, H, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, H, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, H, SCOPE
F, IR, 403, H, SCOPE
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, FORM
F, FORM
FORM

F, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC
F, IR, 403, SCOPE, LC
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM

Objections

24

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
240
13
240
21
240
23
241
17
241
19
242
6
242
8
242
14
242
16
243
7
243
9
243
14
243
16
243
17
243
19
244
14
244
16
245
12
245
14
245
22
245
24
246
5
246
7
246
12
246
14
247
15
247
17
247
19
247
21
248
4
248
6
248
11
248
13
248
17
248
19
248
19
248
21
249
19
249
21
250
2
250
4
250
8
250
10
250
18
250
20
251
2
251
4
251
9
251
11
251
20
251
22
252
9
252
11
252
18
252
20
252
25
253
3
254
7
254
9
254
15
FORM
FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S, LO
F, FORM, S, LO
F, FORM, S, LO
F, FORM
FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM

FORM
FORM
FORM

F, FORM
F, FORM, LO
FORM, LO
FORM
FORM, LO
FORM, LO

S, H
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA
F, FORM, LO
F, FORM, LO

Objections

25

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

25

3

9
16
22
10
16
21
9
3
9
11
23
4
10
18
11
18
24
3
9

254

256

256
256
256
257
257
257
258
265
265
265
265
267
267
267
268
268
268
269
269

256
256
257
257
257
258
258
265
265
265
266
267
267
268
268
268
268
269
269

256

255

14
19
8
14
19
7
9
7
9
21
2
8
16
9
16
22
24
7
9

7

5

Objections

F, FORM, INC
F, INC, S
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, S, LO
FORM, S, LO, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
S, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
S, IR, 403, SCOPE

F, FORM, INC

FORM
FORM, ARG
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
254
17
254
23 FORM

26

255
255
367
367
367
367
367

255
255

11
22
17
17
17
17
17

11
22

255
255
368
368
368
368
368

255
255

20
24
15
15
15
15
15

20
24

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objection to the omission of the
question related to this answer, which
appears at 255:6-10 and has been
included for context.

Objection to the omission of the
question related to this answer, which
appears at 255:6-10 and has been
included for context.

Objections to Counter-Designations

8
9
13
5
17
7
5
9
4
12
16
24
18
23
4
6

274
275
275
276
276
277
279
279
280
280
280
280
281
282
283
283

274
275
275
276
277
277
279
280
280
280
280
280
281
283
283
283

10
11
13
15
5
10
7
2
10
14
22
24
24
2
4
9
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

FORM, ARG
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

FORM, ARG, IR, 403

FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM
FORM

F, FORM

FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

6

24

273

274

FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM
FORM
F, FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
269
11
269
13
269
15
269
19
269
21
269
21
269
23
271
8
271
10
271
14
271
16
272
16
272
18
273
6
273
8
273
16
273
18
273
22

27

274
274
367
274
274
367

12
18
17
12
18
17

274
274
368
274
274
368

16
23
15
16
23
15

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

2

5

10

24
5
16
9
17
10

295

296

296

296
297
320
321
321
322

297
297
321
321
322
323

296

296

295

3
9
7
15
8
6

11

8

3

FORM
FORM
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE

FORM

LO

FORM, LO

FORM

FORM

24

20

294

294

FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, VA
F, FORM
FORM

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
283
11
283
17
283
19
284
2
284
4
284
4
284
6
284
14
284
16
284
19
284
21
285
2
285
4
285
10
285
12
285
14
285
16
285
16
286
6
286
20
286
22
287
11
287
15
287
15
293
11
293
24
294
2
294
13
294
15
294
18

28

295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295

11
15
11
15
11
15
11
15
11
15

295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295
295

13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19
13
19

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
323
8
323
10
323
12
323
22
323
24
324
7
324
9
324
14
324
16
324
19
324
21
324
21
325
3
325
8
325
10
325
14
325
16
325
21
325
23
325
23
326
13
326
23
326
25
327
5
329
3
329
6
329
8
329
13
329
15
329
20
329
22
330
4
330
6
330
13
330
15
330
16
344
23
345
11
345
13
345
16
345
18
345
21
345
23
346
2
346
4
346
7
346
9
346
22
346
24
347
5
347
7
347
13
347
15
347
15
FORM
FORM
F, FORM
FORM
FORM
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, INC, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, ARG, IR, 403, SCOPE
IR, 403, SCOPE

FORM, VA
FORM
FORM, VA

FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
F, FORM, S, IR, 403, SCOPE
FORM, VA

Objections

29

347
348

24
11

328
348

2
16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Erin Driver-Linn Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
6
7
6
13
8
11
8
25
9
19
10
2
19
8
19
25
20
3
20
25
25
7
26
5
26
19
27
8
27
10
27
10
28
4
29
2
29
3
29
6
29
8
29
20
30
2
30
18
30
20
31
3
31
9
31
14
32
2
32
9
32
11
32
22
32
24
33
7
33
23
34
16
34
18
34
21
35
24
35
25
36
3
36
24
37
3
37
11
39
4
39
6
39
8
40
23
42
23
43
2
43
4
46
4
46
5
46
17
46
20
46
25
47
3
47
4
IR
IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, ISCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
F, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
S
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE
FORM, IR, SCOPE
SCOPE

Objections

24
24

21
12

40
40

48
49
30

2

9

49
49

42
42

9

10
18

15
15

15

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
49
19
50
20
50
21
50
22
50
24
51
4
52
13
52
20
52
21
52
22
52
24
53
10
53
12
53
12
53
13
53
14
53
16
53
19
53
21
54
8
54
10
54
14
54
16
54
19
54
23
55
3
55
5
55
12
55
14
55
21
57
18
57
24
58
2
58
4
58
10
58
11
58
13
59
4
59
6
59
9
59
11
60
7
60
9
60
10
60
12
60
18
60
20
61
5
61
7
61
10
61
12
61
19
61
21
61
21
61
22
61
24
62
23
63
4
62
2
62
2
F, FORM, S, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM
F, FORM, LEADING
FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM

SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, SCOPE
SCOPE
F. FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM
F. FORM, LEADING

Objections

31

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
63
20
63
21
63
23
64
4
64
6
64
12
64
14
64
16
64
18
64
20
64
21
64
23
64
25
65
14
65
16
66
11
66
13
66
17
66
19
66
20
66
22
67
11
67
13
67
22
68
4
68
25
69
3
69
5
69
7
69
9
69
11
69
14
69
16
69
18
69
20
70
6
70
8
70
16
70
17
70
17
70
19
70
19
71
4
71
7
71
9
71
9
71
10
71
19
71
21
72
2
72
4
72
20
72
22
73
2
73
4
73
15
73
17
73
18
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
S, SCOPE
FORM, H, SCOPE
FORM, H, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE, VA
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
F, SCOPE, VA
F, FORM, SCOPE, VA
SCOPE
F, FORM, IR, SCOPE, VA
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE

Objections

32

76
77

21
4

77
77

2
7

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

8

12

22

25

8
13
17
22
2
5
12
19

24

18

4

6

77

77

77

77

83
83
83
83
84
84
84
84

84

85

86

86

86

86

86

85

83
83
83
83
84
84
84
84

77

77

77

77

11

5

2

16

11
15
20
25
3
5
17
22

25

23

20

10

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
73
20
73
20
75
14
75
21
75
23
76
7
76
9
76
11
76
13
76
15

SCOPE

SCOPE

SCOPE

FORM, SCOPE

FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

SCOPE

SCOPE

SCOPE

SCOPE

FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, LEADING
SCOPE

Objections

33

110
110
110
110
110
110
110
110

76
77
76
77
76
77
76
77
76
77

11
14
11
14
11
14
11
14

21
4
21
4
21
4
21
4
21
4

110
111
110
111
110
111
110
111

77
77
77
77
77
77
77
77
77
77

12
13
12
13
12
13
12
13

2
7
2
7
2
7
2
7
2
7

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
86
13
86
13
86
14
86
15
86
17
86
24
87
2
87
9
87
11
87
23
87
25
88
12
88
14
89
6
89
8
89
8
101
12
101
20
101
22
101
24
102
2
102
6
102
8
102
11
102
12
102
20
102
22
102
23
103
4
103
10
103
12
103
20
103
22
104
4
104
6
104
13
105
12
105
14
105
16
105
18
105
20
106
21
106
23
106
23
107
5
107
11
107
13
107
17
107
19
108
4
108
6
108
16
108
17
108
19
108
21
109
4
109
5
109
14
109
16
109
20
FORM
F, FORM

F
F

F
F, FORM
F, FORM
F
F
F
FORM

SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM
F
F, FORM
F
F

Objections

34

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
109
22
110
4
110
6
110
8
110
10
110
10
114
8
114
10
114
12
114
21
114
23
114
25
115
3
115
5
115
7
115
11
115
13
115
14
115
16
115
18
116
7
116
11
116
13
116
18
127
3
127
8
134
14
134
22
134
24
135
3
135
5
135
6
137
20
137
24
142
2
142
5
142
7
142
15
142
17
142
23
142
25
143
6
143
8
143
8
143
9
143
19
143
21
143
21
143
22
143
24
144
2
144
4
144
6
144
10
144
12
144
17
144
18
144
22
144
24
145
11
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE

SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
S, SCOPE
S, SCOPE
S, SCOPE
FORM
FORM, SCOPE
INC, FORM, S, SCOPE
SCOPE

F, FORM

Objections

35

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

10
23
7
13
5
9
2
5
12
9
14
10
16
25
8
16
2
5
6

153
153
154
154
156
156
157
157
157
159
159
160
160
160
161
161
162
162
168

153
154
154
154
156
156
157
157
157
159
159
160
160
161
161
161
162
162
168

21
5
11
24
7
10
3
10
22
12
16
14
23
6
15
24
3
7
8

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

SCOPE

16

16

150

150

FORM, SCOPE
F, FORM SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
145
13
145
17
145
19
145
22
145
24
146
4
146
6
146
9
146
11
146
11
148
23
148
25
149
3
149
9
150
12
150
14

36

165

150
150
150
150

20

17
19
17
19

165

150
151
150
151

23

17
2
17
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

10

9
14
12
17

15

21

25

24

5

23

4

168

178
178
179
179

180

188

188

189

190

192

193

193

193

190

190

189

188

180

178
178
179
180

168

9

2

5

3

6

23

18

12
16
15
13

23

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

F, FORM

F

F

FORM

FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE

Objections

37

180
181
180
181
204
204
191
191
191
191
190
190
190
190
190
190
191
191
191
191

21
5
21
5
13
20
2
5
2
5
12
15
18
12
15
18
2
5
2
5

180
181
180
181
204
204
191
192
191
192
190
190
190
190
190
190
191
192
191
192

22
9
22
9
18
21
3
22
3
22
13
16
23
13
16
23
3
22
3
22

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
166
4
167
12
180
21
180
22
181
5
181
9
165
20
165
23
166
4
167
12
180
21
180
22
181
5
181
9

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

19

3

18
5
14
24
7
16
22
3
4
18
3
20
20
25
15
20
6
14
24
11
22
3
10
13

193

194

212
213
213
213
214
214
214
215
215
216
217
217
218
218
219
219
220
220
220
221
221
222
223
223

212
213
213
214
214
214
214
215
216
216
217
218
218
219
219
220
220
220
221
221
221
222
223
223

194

193

24
9
22
3
14
20
25
3
16
23
9
18
23
13
18
3
12
19
9
20
25
4
11
15

4

25

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
193
11
193
17

PRIV
PRIV
F, PRIV
F
F

F, SCOPE

H
LC
LC

FORM

Objections

38

223
223
223
223
223
223
223

16
16
16
16
16
16
16

223
223
223
223
223
223
223

23
23
23
23
23
23
23

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
191
2
191
3
191
5
192
22
191
2
191
3
191
5
192
22
191
2
191
3
191
5
192
22

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

SCOPE

9

14

13
16
21
2

237

237

238
238
238
239

238
238
238
239

237

237

14
19
25
20

23

12

7

2

237

237

SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE, VA
FORM, SCOPE, VA
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

F, SCOPE
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

SCOPE

F, FORM, VA
FORM
INC

F, VA
F, PRIV, VA
VA

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
225
6
225
7
225
9
226
3
226
5
226
7
226
9
226
15
226
23
227
3
228
3
228
5
228
7
228
15
228
17
229
8
229
24
230
25
231
2
231
8
231
16
232
4
232
6
232
11
232
13
232
13
232
23
233
2
233
4
233
18
233
20
234
12
234
15
234
18
234
20
236
2
236
22
236
24

39

237
238
237
238
237
238
237
238

25
4
25
4
25
4
25
4

238
238
238
238
238
238
238
238

2
12
2
12
2
12
2
12

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
223
16
223
23
223
16
223
23

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

245
247
247
248
248
249
249
250
250
251
251
252
252
253
256
257
257
258
258
259

17
2
9
5
9
6
10
5
8
8
14
6
25
20
22
8
16
13
17
21

246
247
248
248
249
249
250
250
251
251
252
252
253
254
257
257
258
258
259
259

24
7
3
7
5
8
4
6
6
12
4
23
17
3
6
14
11
15
19
22

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
239
22
240
2
240
12
240
14
240
16
241
17
241
19
242
11
242
12
242
19
242
21
243
4
244
14
244
15
244
17
245
3
245
14
245
15
F, SCOPE
F, FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE, S
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE, VA
SCOPE, VA
SCOPE, VA
SCOPE, VA
FORM, SCOPE, VA
FORM, SCOPE, VA

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

Objections

40

245
245

10
13

245
245

11
13

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

14
7
2

13
23
3

25
6
12
17

12
17
2
3

265
266
267

267
267
269

269
270
271
271

273
273
274
275

273
273
274
275

270
270
271
271

267
268
269

266
266
267

15
18
25
19

4
9
15
20

13
25
5

2
24
11

901, F, SCOPE, H
901, F, SCOPE, H

FORM
FORM

FORM, ARF

12

8

265

265

FORM, SCOPE, VA
FORM, SCOPE, VA
SCOPE, S
SCOPE, S
FORM, S, F
SCOPE, S

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
259
24
259
25
260
3
260
3
260
16
261
19
261
21
262
17
262
19
263
9
263
11
264
13
264
14
264
19
264
21
265
6

41

275

271
272
273

269
269
269

267
267

267
267
267
267

20

21
23
4

6
10
24

14
19

14
19
14
19

275

272
273
273

269
269
269

267
267

267
267
267
267

24

17
2
11

8
22
24

17
22

17
22
17
22

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

25

7

11
20
15
18
25
7
11

19

19
14
19
5
8
11
14

277

278

283
283
284
284
284
285
285

285

291
292
292
293
294
296
296

292
292
293
294
294
296
296

285

283
284
284
284
285
285
285

278

278

12
17
3
6
8
12
16

19

18
13
16
23
5
10
17

7

5

SCOPE
SCOPE

SCOPE, S

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE, S

SCOPE

SCOPE

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
277
14
277
17 SCOPE
277
19
277
23 SCOPE

Objections

42

279
279
285
287
287
279
279
285
287
287

267
267
267
267
267
267

17
21
20
10
13
17
21
20
10
13

14
19
14
19
14
19

279
281
287
287
287
279
281
287
287
287

267
267
267
267
267
267

19
3
8
11
13
19
3
8
11
13

17
22
17
22
17
22

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

22
9
12
7
18
11
19
4
14
3
6
25
7
17
3

317
318
319
320
320
321
321
322
322
323
323
323
323
323
324

318
318
320
320
321
321
321
322
322
323
323
323
323
323
324

7
22
5
16
9
17
22
12
25
4
6
25
15
19
5

Objections

VA, S

SCOPE
SCOPE
F, 901, SCOPE
F, 901, SCOPE, S, H
FORM, F, 901, SCOPE, ARG
F, FORM

VA, S
SCOPE
SCOPE

3
9
14

22
5
11

312
313
313

313
313
313

SCOPE, VA
SCOPE
SCOPE

VA, S
VA, S

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
298
15
298
18
298
20
299
4
311
12
311
14
311
16
311
20
311
22
311
24
312
2
312
11

23

15
15
15
12
18
15
15
15
16
14
19
7
14

321
321

43

23
23

321

316
316
316
312
312
316
316
316
313
314
314
316
316

322
322

322

316
316
316
312
312
316
316
316
313
314
314
316
316

3
3

3

21
21
21
16
18
21
21
21
16
17
19
12
21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

17
22
2
12
16
20
5
18
23
5
10
14
19
3
8

16
18
23
4
10
20

327
327
328
328
328
328
329
329
329
330
330
330
330
331
331

336
336
339
340
340
340

336
337
340
340
340
340

327
327
328
328
328
329
329
329
330
330
330
330
330
331
331

16
7
2
8
18
23

20
24
10
14
18
3
16
21
3
8
12
17
25
6
14

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

F, 901, SCOPE, H
F, 901, SCOPE, H
F, 901, SCOPE, H
F, 901, SCOPE, H
F, 901, SCOPE, H
F, 901, SCOPE, H
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
SCOPE

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
324
7
324
9
324
11
324
15
324
17
324
17
326
14
327
15 F, 901, SCOPE, H

44

337

331
331
332

325
325
325
325

14

15
24
12

6
9
20
23

338

331
332
332

325
325
325
325

6

22
10
20

7
10
21
23

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

360
360
360
361
362
362
362
362
371
372
372
372
372
373
373
373
374
374
374
374
384
384

3
9
14
24
4
10
16
21
19
6
11
17
23
22
3
8
2
4
6
10
18
21

360
360
360
362
362
362
362
362
372
372
372
372
372
373
373
373
374
374
374
374
384
384

7
12
22
2
7
14
19
21
2
9
15
18
25
24
6
9
3
4
8
10
19
23

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
340
25
340
25
346
21
346
25
347
3
347
12
347
14
347
18
347
20
347
24
348
2
348
2
359
8
359
25

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

F, 901, SCOPE
F, 901, COPE
F, 901, SCOE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE

SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, 901, SCOPE, H

Objections

45

351
351

14
17

351
35

15
17

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

11
14
18
25
5
15
20
12
18
6
9

24
6
17

22
6
9
10
14
21
2
14

401
401
401
401
402
402
402
404
404
405
405

405
406
408

408
408
408
410
410
410
411
411

408
408
408
410
410
410
411
411

406
406
408

401
401
401
402
402
402
402
404
405
405
405

24
7
11
12
19
24
12
20

4
12
20

12
16
23
3
13
18
21
16
4
7
10

SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL

SCOPE, MIL
SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL

FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
384
25
384
25
401
7
401
9
SCOPE, MIL

46

409
410
410

405
405

395
396
396
396

23
4
6

11
15

24
6
11
15

410
410
410

405
405

396
396
396
396

2
4
9

13
23

4
9
13
15

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

8
17
5
16
13
18
22
2
9
19
24
6
16
14
17
20
23
22

14
19
23

415
416
417
417
418
418
418
419
419
419
419
420
420
423
423
423
424
425

427
427
427

427
427
427

415
417
417
418
418
418
418
419
419
419
420
420
420
423
423
424
425
426

16
21
25

15
3
14
11
16
20
24
7
17
22
4
14
16
15
18
11
20
3

Objections

F, SCOPE
F, SCOPE
F, SCOPE

SCOPE
F, SCOPE, H
F, SCOPE, H
SCOPE, H
SCOPE, H, S
SCOPE, H, S
SCOPE, H, S
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
F, SCOPE
F, SCOPE

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
413
20
414
2
414
4
414
4
415
5
415
5
SCOPE

13

5
9
15
22
10
16

426
426

47

4
7

421

414
414
414
415
416
416

426
426

423

414
414
414
416
416
416

4
17

13

7
13
16
8
13
16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

11
21
13
21
24
4
3
10
14
20
25
9
12
16
3
4
12
24
14

20
23
5
12
22
2
6
23

428
428
429
429
429
429
430
430
430
430
430
431
431
431
432
432
432
432
443

443
443
444
444
444
445
445
451

443
444
444
444
444
445
445
452

428
428
429
429
429
429
430
430
430
430
431
431
431
431
432
432
432
432
443

21
3
10
20
24
4
7
5

19
25
19
22
25
6
8
12
18
23
7
10
14
24
3
10
22
25
18

Objections

FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE, MIL
F, SCOPE

FORM, SCOPE, MIL

SCOPE, MIL, Incomplete
SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
FORM, F, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE, MIL
SCOPE, MIL
FORM, SCOPE MIL

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
428
3
428
3
F, SCOPE

48

442
443

25
5

443
443

3
13

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
428
4
428
6
428
8
428
10

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
452
7
452
16
452
18
452
23
452
25
453
4
453
6
453
8
453
10
453
12
F, SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE

Objections

49

453
453

13
17

453
453

15
21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

William Fitzsimmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

35

18

35

24

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
5
14
5
20
8
15
9
9
10
8
10
16
10
19
11
7
11
11
11
14
12
6
12
7
12
9
12
12
12
14
12
22
15
5
15
7
15
9
15
11
15
13
15
18
15
20
15
20
18
22
18
23
19
1
19
14
20
9
20
11
20
13
20
18
22
19
22
20
22
22
23
3
23
13
23
16
23
18
23
21
26
3
26
4
26
6
26
11
26
13
26
14
32
6
32
10
32
12
32
15
32
17
32
18
32
20
32
22
32
24
33
5
33
8
33
13
33
15
33
20
33
22
34
1
34
3
34
4
34
6
34
10
34
12
34
13
35
13
35
16
F, FORM

F, FORM
F
F, FORM, IR
F, IR
F, FORM, IR
IR
FORM, IR
IR
FORM
FORM, VA
VA, S

FORM
FORM
F, S
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, S

IR

Objections

50

36
36
36

8
11
8

36
36
36

9
11
9

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

2

8
15
19
4
12
15
19
6
22
4
8
13
1
12
3
14
19
24
4

1
4

11
18
21
5
12
15
19
3
6
11
16

36

37
37
37
38
38
38
38
39
39
40
40
40
41
41
43
43
43
47
48

49
49

49
49
49
50
50
50
50
51
55
55
55

49
49
50
50
50
50
50
51
55
55
55

49
49

37
37
38
38
38
38
39
39
40
40
40
40
41
41
43
43
43
48
48

36

12
19
3
10
13
17
24
5
10
14
20

2
9

13
17
2
10
13
17
4
20
2
6
11
23
10
13
12
17
21
2
8

6

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line

FORM

F, S
FORM
F, FORM, S
FORM, S

F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S
FORM

F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
FORM

F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S

Objections

51

49

48
48

48
48

14

14
16

14
16

49

48
48

48
48

17

14
16

14
16

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line
36
11
36
11
36
8
36
9
36
11
36
11

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
55
22
55
22
58
10
58
13
58
15
58
17
61
9
61
12
61
14
61
23
62
7
62
8
62
10
62
22
62
24
63
1
63
12
63
14
63
16
63
20
63
22
64
5
64
15
64
16
64
18
65
5
65
12
65
16
65
21
65
21
65
23
66
8
66
16
66
19
67
24
68
4
68
6
68
7
71
13
71
21
72
21
72
24
73
5
73
6
73
11
73
22
73
23
73
24
74
2
74
3
74
12
74
16
75
3
75
4
75
9
75
10
75
12
75
23
76
1
76
11
76
13
76
17
76
19
77
2
77
4
77
17
77
19
77
24
78
2
78
5
78
8
78
14
78
16
78
23
IR, S
IR, S
IR, S
IR, S
F
F, FORM, S
F, S
F, FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403

F, IR
F, FORM, IR
IR

F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S
FORM

FORM, S, VA
S
FORM, S
FORM, S

FORM, S, VA

Objections

52

75
75

1
1

75
75

2
2

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

3
11

23

6
11
16

88
88

88

89
89
89

89
89
89

89

88
88

9
14
22

4

9
16

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
79
1
79
5
79
7
79
15
79
18
80
3
80
5
80
8
80
10
80
16
80
18
81
3
81
5
81
13
81
20
81
21
82
6
82
8
82
12
83
5
83
19
84
3
84
5
84
10
84
12
85
2
85
4
85
10
85
12
85
16
85
23
85
24
86
2
86
11
86
13
86
17
86
19
86
22

IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403

IC, F, FORM, S, 403

IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403

IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
F, FORM, S
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
IC, F, FORM, S, 403
MISTRANSCRIPTION (SEE ERRATA)

Objections

53

86
87
87
87

86
87
87
87
86
87
87
87

86
87
87
87

24
3
6
9

24
3
6
9
24
3
6
9

24
3
6
9

87
87
87
87

87
87
87
87
87
87
87
87

87
87
87
87

1
4
7
10

1
4
7
10
1
4
7
10

1
4
7
10

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

24
22
1
16
20
1
14
19
8
2
16
2

8

16
22
13

104
105
106
106
107
108
108
108
112
115
115
116

117

117
117
118

117
118
118

117

105
105
106
107
107
108
108
108
112
115
115
116

20
11
14

14

2
23
14
18
24
12
17
19
14
14
24
8

Objections

F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403

F, FORM, IC, S, 403

F, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, IR, S, 403
F, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 403
F, FORM, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403

F, FORM, IR, S, 403

22

17

104

104

F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, S
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, S
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, S, VA
F, FORM, S, VA
F, S, VA
F, 901
F, FORM, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IR, S, 403

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
89
24
90
6
90
8
90
14
90
16
90
19
90
21
90
21
91
2
91
2
91
4
91
14
91
16
91
16
91
21
91
23
92
1
92
5
92
12
92
20
92
22
93
2
93
7
93
11
93
13
93
18
101
11
101
13
103
18
104
1
104
3
104
8

54

3
3

15
1
1
1
5
1
5

105
105
105
105

112
114
114
117
117
117
117

13
16
13
16

93
93

112
114
114
117
117
117
117

105
105
105
105

93
93

18
4
4
3
6
3
6

14
20
14
20

6
6

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

6
8
10
18
23
8
2

5
15
18

130
130
130
130
130
131
133

133
133
136

133
133
136

130
130
130
130
131
131
133

13
16
20

6
8
16
21
6
9
3

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
118
16
119
8
119
10
119
14
119
16
119
23
120
5
120
6
120
8
120
14
121
1
121
3
121
5
123
2
123
4
123
10
123
20
123
22
123
24
124
2
124
17
124
17
125
3
125
22
126
19
126
22
127
5
127
9
127
11
127
16
127
18
127
23
128
1
128
7
128
9
128
10
129
1
129
1
129
7
130
4

F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
S, IR, 403
FORM, S

F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, IR, S, 403

F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403

F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, IC, S, 403
FORM, S
S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, IC, S, 403
IC
F, S
F, S
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, IR, S, 403

Objections

55

117
117
137

130
130
130
130
130

117
117

1
5
5

8
10
13
18
23

1
5

117
117
137

130
130
130
130
131

117
117

3
6
9

8
11
16
21
2

3
6

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

145
146
146
147
147
147
148
148
148
149
150
150
150
150
151
151
152
152
152
152
153
153
155
155
156
156

23
15
21
2
13
21
6
15
23
5
7
12
20
24
7
12
13
17
19
24
8
14
9
12
18
21

146
146
146
147
147
148
148
148
149
149
150
150
150
150
151
151
152
152
152
152
153
153
155
155
156
157

13
19
24
3
19
4
13
21
3
6
10
18
22
24
10
12
15
17
22
24
12
16
10
13
19
3

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
136
22
136
22
137
16
137
19
138
6
138
9
138
16
138
24
139
7
139
18
139
20
140
1
140
3
140
5
145
8
145
10
145
12
145
13
145
20
145
21
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, H, S
F, FORM, IR, S
F, IR, S
F, FORM, VA, S
F, VA, S

S
S
F, H, S
F, FORM, H, S
F, FORM, H, IC, S
F, IC, S
F
F, S
F, FORM, S

Objections

56

15
8
12

140
145
145

145
145

140
10
13

18

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line
137
5
137
9

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

10

18

21

4

12

22

2

12
17
6
10
17
9
16
22
11
18

159

164

164

165

165

168

169

174
174
175
175
175
181
181
181
182
182

174
174
175
175
175
181
181
182
182
182

169

168

165

165

165

164

159

15
20
8
15
21
14
20
1
16
22

4

24

15

10

2

19

12

FORM, INC, S
FORM, INC, S

ARG, INC
F, INC, FORM

F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S, VA
F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S

F, S

F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S

F, FORM, S

H, S

FORM, S
FORM, S

24
8

22
2

158
159

158
159

F, FORM, S

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
157
5
157
7

Objections

57

162
162
162
162
162
162
162
162
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167

1
5
10
13
1
5
10
13
20
1
20
1
20
1
20
1
20
1
20
1

162
162
162
162
162
162
162
162
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167
166
167

3
8
11
15
3
8
11
15
23
5
23
5
23
5
23
5
23
5
23
5

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line
157
9
157
11
157
13
157
17
158
3
158
5
158
10
158
13
158
14
158
15
158
17
158
20

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

15

18
11
14

21
10
13
18
6

21
6
19
2
5
9
18
7

192

192
194
194

194
195
195
195
196

197
198
198
199
199
199
199
200

198
198
198
199
199
199
200
200

194
195
195
196
196

192
194
194

192

4
17
24
3
6
16
5
13

23
11
16
1
10

21
12
19

16

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
182
24
183
4
186
21
186
23
187
5
187
6
187
8
187
21
187
22
187
24
188
1
188
2
188
4
188
9
188
11
188
13
188
15
188
21
188
23
189
10
191
3
191
5
191
7
191
14
191
16
191
24
192
2
192
5

INC
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S, 403

FORM, H, INC
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S

FORM, INC
FORM, INC, S
FORM, INC, S

F, FORM, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, INC, S, 403

F, FORM, INC

F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC, S

FORM, INC

F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S

INC
FORM, INC, S
FORM, INC, S

Objections

58

196
196
196
196

195
195

192
192
192
192

12
16
19
22

1
7

6
9
6
9

196
196
196
196

195
195

192
192
192
192

14
17
20
24

2
9

7
13
7
13

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

217
218
218
219
220

1
4
7
21
14

217
218
218
220
220

3
5
9
12
22

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
200
15
200
20
200
22
201
2
201
4
201
22
201
24
202
6
202
8
202
10
204
24
205
11
205
13
205
18
205
21
206
1
206
3
206
10
208
8
208
13
208
20
208
21
208
23
209
5
209
9
209
12
209
14
210
18
210
22
211
6
211
8
211
15
211
17
211
22
211
24
212
12
212
16
213
4
213
6
213
13
213
15
213
22
213
24
214
1
214
10
214
12
214
14
214
17
214
19
214
20
214
22
214
23
215
5
215
8
215
10
215
11
215
13
215
14
215
16
215
20
216
2
216
4
F, FORM, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, H, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, INC, 403, IR, PII/SPI [MISSED
REDACTION]
F, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S

F, S
IC
F, FORM, IC, S
FORM, H, IC, S
F, FORM, H, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, INC, S, 403
F, IC, INC, S, 403

F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, S, 403
F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC, S
F, FORM, INC, 403
F, FORM, INC, 403
F, FORM, 403

Objections

59

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

16
16
20
22
9
24
16
20
21
9
18
23
15
20
22
1
11
13
17
6
13
17
1
9
6

12
13
16

225
226
226
227
228
228
229
229
230
231
231
231
232
232
233
234
234
235
235
236
236
242
243
243
247

247
248
248

247
248
248

225
226
226
228
228
229
229
230
231
231
231
232
232
232
233
234
234
235
236
236
236
242
243
243
247

15
14
19

18
18
23
7
22
2
18
19
7
16
20
1
18
20
23
9
19
15
4
11
23
23
7
11
8

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
220
24
221
6
221
8
221
9
223
12
224
13
224
15
224
17
225
2
225
6
225
13
225
14

F, 403
F, FORM, 403
F, FORM, 403

F, FORM, 403

F, FORM, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, IC, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
F, S
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, S, 403
F, IC, S, 403
F, FORM, IR, S
F, FORM

F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S

F, FORM, IR, S

FORM, IR, S
S, IR
S, IR
FORM, IR, S

F, FORM, IC, INC, S

Objections

60

2
2

7
10

246
247

22
3

22
3

234
234
234

246
247

20
20
20

232
232

225
225

247
247

247
247

234
234
234

232
232

225
225

1
4

1
4

23
23
23

8
8

8
11

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

4
10

18
1

13

23
2
3
13
8
4
9
9
16
1
7
10
16
1
11
18
23
5
3
12

255
255

255
256

256

256
257
257
257
258
259
259
260
260
261
261
261
261
262
262
262
262
263
264
264

256
257
257
258
259
259
259
260
260
261
261
261
261
262
262
262
263
263
264
264

256

255
256

255
255

24
2
9
2
2
7
10
14
23
2
8
14
23
9
16
21
3
8
10
19

14

23
11

8
16

Objections

F, FORM
F, FORM

F, FORM
F, FORM, S
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM
F, FORM

F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
FORM, IR, S, 403

FORM, H, IR, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, S

F, FORM, IR, 403
IR

F, FORM, H, IR, 403

F, FORM
F, FORM, H, IR, 403

FORM, S
F, FORM, H, 403

F, FORM, IR

8
2

5
24

253
254

254
255

F, FORM, H
F, FORM, IR
F, IR

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
248
21
249
1
249
4
250
10
251
11
251
17
251
19
251
22

61

16

9
12

9
12

23
3

20

256

254
254

254
254

251
252

256

256

256

254
254

254
254

252
252

21

18

10
14

10
14

1
4

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

8

1
3
12
23
5
20

265

266
267
267
267
268
268

267
267
267
268
268
268

265

1
10
13
3
18
21

8

Affirmative Designation
Page
Line
Page
Line
264
21
264
24
265
2
265
6

F, FORM, H
F, FORM, S
F
FORM, H
F, FORM, H, S
F, S

F, FORM, IR
F, FORM, IR

Objections

62

265
265
265
265

10
15
10
15

265
265
265
265

13
15
13
15

Counter-Designations
Page
Line
Page
Line

Kaitlin Howrigan Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

18
17
10
14
10
7
16
17
11
7

27
31
32
33
34
37
37
48
49
52

28
32
33
34
34
37
37
48
52
52

27

9
6
9
5
15
14
24
25
3
11

11
SCOPE, IR, INC
FORM, SCOPE, IR, 901, F
IR, SCOPE
IR, SCOPE, FORM
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, H, SCOPE
FORM, LEADING, SCOPE

SCOPE, IR, F, S, FORM

SCOPE, IR
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE
901, SCOPE, IR, F

SCOPE, IR

IR
IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
w ithout w aiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

17

26

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
5
8
5
17
7
20
7
23
8
12
8
20
9
14
9
17
9
25
10
12
10
13
10
21
10
22
11
8
13
9
13
21
13
24
14
20
15
3
15
15
15
18
16
11
16
12
16
14
16
20
16
24
20
19
22
4
22
8
22
9
22
14
22
18
25
5
25
22
10
10

21

9

63

10
10

25
26
25
26
33
33

23
15
23
15

22
22

14

11

33
33

26
26
26
26

22
22

15

12

13
13

13
16
13
16

13
13

2

4

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Christina Lopez Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

19
2
10
14
22
25

77
78
78
78
78
78

77
78
78
78
78
79

72

21
3
12
18
24
8

21
FORM, SCOPE, S
FORM, SCOPE, S
FORM, SCOPE, S, IR
FORM, SCOPE, S, IR
FORM, SCOPE, S
SCOPE, S

SCOPE, S, IR

FORM, H
FORM, H

SCOPE, H, S
SCOPE, H, S

SCOPE, S
SCOPE, S
SCOPE, S, FORM, IR
SCOPE, S, VA, IR
SCOPE, S, VA, IR
SCOPE, VA, IR
SCOPE, VA, IR
SCOPE, F
FORM, SCOPE, F, IR
FORM, SCOPE, F, IR
FORM, SCOPE, F, IR
FORM, SCOPE, F, IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
w ithout w aiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

2

72

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
52
15
54
8
54
12
54
13
54
22
54
24
55
5
55
9
55
14
55
17
56
2
56
6
56
10
56
13
57
19
57
22
58
3
58
13
58
18
58
20
59
8
59
12
59
17
59
18
60
20
61
10
61
25
62
12
62
16
62
25
65
9
65
18
65
19
65
24
66
5
66
20
67
24
68
13
68
20
69
21

64

79
79

72
73
72
73

11
17

22
4
22
4

79
79

72
73
72
73

14
21

25
21
25
21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Christina Lopez Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

SCOPE, S, IR
SCOPE, S, IR
FORM, SCOPE, S, IR
FORM, SCOPE, S, IR
SCOPE, IR
SCOPE, IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
w ithout w aiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
88
24
89
2
89
6
89
15
89
19
89
22
89
25
89
25
91
12
91
15
91
17
91
22

65

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Christina Lopez Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
4
8
4
13
9
10
10
18
15
18
15
22
15
24
16
3
16
5
16
24
19
6
19
8
19
10
20
10
20
11
20
13
20
25
21
5
21
7
21
21
21
23
22
9
22
11
22
14
22
16
22
20
22
22
23
2
23
4
23
6
23
8
23
13
23
15
23
19
23
21
23
25
24
2
24
15
24
17
24
22
24
24
25
16
25
18
25
19
25
21
26
1
26
3
26
7
26
9
26
14
26
16
26
21
26
23
27
4
27
6
27
12
27
14
27
20
27
22
27
25
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR

IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
FORM

Objections

66

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
28
2
28
7
28
9
28
14
28
16
29
4
29
6
29
9
29
11
29
12
30
12
30
14
30
16
30
20
30
22
30
23
32
21
33
10
33
12
33
14
33
16
34
4
34
6
34
13
38
9
38
14
38
16
38
19
38
21
38
24
39
1
39
6
39
8
39
11
39
13
39
16
39
18
39
23
39
25
40
4
40
6
40
9
40
11
40
13
40
15
40
17
40
19
41
2
41
4
41
7
41
9
41
13
41
15
41
20
41
22
41
25
42
2
42
7
42
8
42
17
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR

Objections

67

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
42
19
43
2
43
4
43
19
43
21
43
24
44
1
44
16
44
18
45
1
45
3
45
6
45
8
45
11
45
13
45
15
45
17
45
19
45
21
46
2
52
18
53
2
53
4
53
21
53
23
54
4
54
6
54
9
54
11
54
18
54
20
55
3
55
5
55
15
55
17
56
3
56
5
56
16
56
18
56
23
56
25
57
14
57
16
57
20
57
22
58
5
58
7
58
14
58
16
59
4
59
6
59
10
59
12
59
23
59
25
60
1
60
3
60
17
60
19
60
24
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, S
FORM, S
FORM
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA

Objections

68

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
61
1
61
9
61
11
61
14
61
16
61
19
61
21
61
25
62
2
62
6
62
8
62
14
62
16
62
20
62
22
63
10
63
12
63
15
63
17
63
21
63
23
64
1
64
3
64
8
64
10
64
15
64
17
64
20
64
22
65
5
65
7
65
10
65
12
65
13
65
15
65
21
65
23
66
2
66
4
66
11
66
13
66
16
66
18
66
19
67
3
67
22
67
24
68
2
68
7
68
16
68
18
68
22
68
24
69
4
69
6
69
11
69
13
69
17
69
19
69
24
FORM
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S
FORM
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA

Objections

69

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
70
1
70
24
71
1
71
11
71
13
72
6
72
8
72
13
72
14
72
22
72
24
73
3
73
5
73
15
73
17
73
21
73
23
74
2
74
4
74
6
74
8
74
19
74
21
75
3
75
4
75
22
75
24
76
5
76
7
76
11
76
13
76
14
76
16
77
11
77
13
78
2
78
4
78
10
78
12
79
4
79
6
79
9
79
11
79
23
79
25
80
6
80
8
80
13
80
15
81
4
81
6
81
11
81
13
81
25
82
2
82
6
82
8
82
14
82
16
83
4
FORM
FORM
FORM, H
FORM
FORM, H
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM
FORM
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, H
FORM, S, H
FORM, S, H
FORM, S
FORM, S
FORM, H
FORM
FORM
FORM, S
FORM, S
FORM, H
FORM, S
FORM
FORM, S, H

Objections

70

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

25

6
15
22
9
15
18
2
7
20
3
6
13

89

91
91
91
92
94
94
95
95
95
96
96
96

91
91
92
93
94
94
95
95
96
96
96
96

90

13
20
5
1
16
25
5
18
1
4
11
18

4

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
83
6
83
14
83
16
83
18
83
20
84
7
84
9
84
12
84
14
84
16
84
18
84
23
84
25
85
3
85
6
85
9
85
11
85
14
85
16
85
19
85
21
85
23
85
25
85
25
87
3
87
24
88
1
89
4
89
6
89
23

FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, H
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR, H
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR

IR, INC

FORM, VA, H
FORM, H
FORM, S, H
FORM, S
FORM
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
IR, H
IR, INC
IR, INC, H

Objections

71

88
90
90
90
90

5
5
13
5
13

88
90
90
90
90

8
11
18
11
18

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
96
20
96
23
96
25
97
4
97
6
97
14
97
16
98
2
98
4
98
12
98
14
98
19
98
21
99
6
99
8
99
12
99
14
99
18
99
20
100
1
100
3
100
5
100
7
100
16
100
18
100
23
100
25
101
5
101
7
101
10
101
11
101
12
101
14
101
17
101
19
101
22
101
24
102
4
102
6
102
9
102
11
102
12
102
14
102
17
102
19
102
21
102
23
103
1
103
3
103
11
103
13
103
25
104
2
104
5
104
7
104
11
104
13
104
15
104
17
104
20
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR

Objections

72

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

3

8

17
16
19
23
4
12
18
7
15
22
7

13
19

3

105

105

106
107
107
107
108
108
108
109
109
109
110

111
111

112

112

111
112

107
107
107
108
108
108
109
109
109
110
110

105

105

7

17
1

15
17
21
2
10
16
5
13
20
5
11

8

6

Objections

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR

IR, H
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
104
22
105
1
FORM, IR

73

108
108
110
110
111
113
108

108
108
110
110
111
113
14
18
12
22
2
8
14

14
18
12
22
2
8

108
108
110
110
111
113
108

108
108
110
110
111
113

16
18
17
25
6
15
16

16
18
17
25
6
15

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
105
25
106
3
106
9
106
13
105
25
106
3
106
9
106
13
105
25
106
3
106
9
106
13

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

9

14

5

17

5

112

112

113

113

114

114

114

113

113

112

11

3

7

3

12

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

Objections

74

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

13

22

6

10

14

114

114

115

115

115

115

115

115

115

114

16

12

8

4

20

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

FORM, VA, IR

Objections

75

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

18

1
7
16

1
4
10
17
19
23
2
4
9
22
3

115

116
116
116

117
117
117
117
117
117
118
118
118
118
119

117
117
117
117
117
117
118
118
118
119
119

116
116
116

115

2
8
15
18
21
25
2
7
20
1
6

5
14
24

24

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR

FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR

FORM, VA, IR

Objections

76

108
108
110
110
111
113

14
18
12
22
2
8

108
108
110
110
111
113

16
18
17
25
6
15

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15
108
14
108
16
108
18
108
18
110
12
110
17
110
22
110
25
111
2
111
6
113
8
113
15

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
119
8
119
10
119
12
119
15
119
17
120
3
120
5
120
9
120
11
120
12
120
25
121
1
121
3
121
6
121
8
121
18
121
20
121
23
121
25
122
2
122
4
122
7
122
9
122
11
122
13
122
15
122
17
123
2
123
4
123
7
123
9
123
12
123
14
123
17
123
19
123
23
123
25
124
2
124
4
124
14
124
16
124
18
124
19
124
20
124
22
125
1
125
3
125
6
125
8
125
17
125
19
125
22
125
24
125
24
126
1
126
5
126
7
126
9
126
11
126
14
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR, 403
FORM, VA, S, IR, 403
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR

Objections

77

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
126
16
126
18
130
17
132
7
132
9
132
16
132
18
132
19
143
6
144
1
144
6
144
10
144
12
144
19
144
21
144
23
144
25
145
5
145
7
145
11
145
13
145
19
145
21
146
8
146
10
146
15
150
24
151
23
151
25
152
5
152
7
152
12
152
14
152
17
152
22
153
8
153
10
154
11
154
13
155
8
155
10
155
18
155
20
155
23
155
25
156
6
156
8
156
16
158
1
158
13
158
15
158
18
158
20
158
24
159
1
159
8
159
10
159
10
159
23
160
10
FORM, VA, IR
H, IR, FORM
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
H, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, H, IR, S
FORM, H, IR, S
FORM, H, IR, S
FORM, IR, S
FORM
FORM, H, S
FORM, H, S, VA
FORM, H, S, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, H, S
FORM, H, S
FORM, H, VA, IR
FORM, H, VA, IR
FORM, H, VA, IR
FORM, H, S, VA, IR
FORM, S, VA, IR
FORM, S, H, VA

Objections

78

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
160
12
160
15
160
17
161
2
161
4
161
8
161
10
161
18
161
20
161
24
162
1
162
13
162
15
163
6
163
8
163
10
163
12
163
16
163
18
163
21
163
23
164
9
164
12
164
23
164
25
165
5
165
7
165
13
165
15
165
19
165
20
166
17
166
19
166
21
166
23
167
6
167
8
167
19
167
21
167
23
167
25
168
5
168
7
168
10
168
12
168
15
168
17
169
2
169
3
169
5
169
7
169
10
169
12
169
17
169
19
170
1
170
3
170
7
170
9
171
12
FORM, S, H
FORM, S, H
FORM, S, H
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA
FORM, H, VA
FORM, H, VA
FORM, H, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, H, VA
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, H, IR, S
FORM, VA, H, IR, S
FORM, VA, IR, S
FORM, VA, IR, S
FORM, VA, H, S
FORM, VA, H, S
FORM, VA, H, S
FORM, VA, S

Objections

79

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

19
2
8
13
15
24
4
10
19
25
12
20
10
23
3
8
16
23
8

FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S
FORM, H, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, H, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA
FORM, H, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR

174
175
175
175
175
175
176
176
176
176
177
177
178
178
179
179
197
197
199

174
174
175
175
175
175
176
176
176
176
177
177
177
178
178
179
197
197
199

18
21
4
10
15
16
1
6
12
21
2
14
22
15
25
6
4
18
5

FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, H
FORM, VA
FORM, VA
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA, S
FORM, VA
FORM, VA

Objections

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
171
14
171
19
171
21
171
24
172
1
172
6
172
8
172
12
172
14
172
22
172
24
173
15
173
17
174
2
174
4
174
12
174
14
174
16

80

174
174
175

18
21
4

174
175
175

19
2
5

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
199
10
199
14
199
16
200
1
200
3
200
6
200
8
200
10
200
13
200
17
200
19
200
19
200
20
200
23
200
25
201
3
201
5
201
16
201
18
201
18
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, S, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR, S
FORM, VA, IR, S

Objections

81

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Lucerito Ortiz Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

IR, Scope
IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, Leading, IR, Scope
Form, Leading, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
IR, Form, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
IR, Scope
Form, Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR
Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Scope, IR
Scope, IR, VA
Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR, VA

IR, F
IR, F

IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
4
8
4
23
7
5
7
16
9
3
9
6
9
16
10
4
10
10
11
4
11
9
11
13
12
5
17
18
18
10
21
19
28
17
28
20
28
22
29
15
29
17
30
6
30
8
30
10
30
12
30
16
30
18
30
20
30
22
32
18
32
20
32
25
33
3
33
8
36
22
37
3
37
5
37
10
37
12
37
25
38
4
38
6
38
8
38
13
38
15
38
18
38
20
38
22
38
24
38
25
39
3
39
22
39
24
39
24
40
21
40
23
40
25
41
3
41
5
41
7
82

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Scope, IR, Leading
Scope, IR
Scope, IR
Scope, IR
Scope, IR
IR
Scope, IR, VA
Form, Scope, IR, H
Scope, IR, H
Form, Scope, IR
Form, Scope, IR
Form, IR, Scope
IR, Scope
IR, Scope
IR, Scope
IR, Scope
Form, IR, H, VA, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope, H
Form, IR, S, Scope

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
41
9
41
21
41
23
41
24
41
25
42
15
43
6
43
8
43
10
44
7
44
10
44
13
44
15
44
16
44
18
45
2
45
4
45
24
46
2
47
5
47
7
47
11
47
13
47
19
47
21
47
21
48
10
48
13
48
16
48
23
49
8
49
9
49
11
49
17
49
19
50
4
50
8
50
10
50
12
50
14
50
25
51
22
51
24
52
21
52
23
57
16
57
18
58
13
58
15
59
6
59
8
59
23
59
25
61
21
61
23
62
9
62
11
63
2
63
4
64
2
83

47

22

47

25

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

11

4

11

14

10

25

6

4

75

76

76

76

79

83

84

94

94

84

84

79

76

76

76

75

75

14

16

4

22

23

12

9

18

9

F, 901

Form, Scope, IR, H

Form, Scope, IR

901

Form, IR, S

IR, S

Form, IR, S

Form, IR, S, Scope, Inc.

Form, IR, S, Scope

Form, IR, S, Scope, VA
Form, IR, S, Scope, VA
Form, IR, S, Scope, VA
Form, IR, S, Scope

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

2

75

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
67
24
68
10
68
12
69
12
69
14
74
3
74
5
74
24

84

82
84
85
85
85
82
84
85
85
85
162
162
162

4
17
2
7
11
4
17
2
7
11
10
14
18

82
84
85
85
85
82
84
85
85
85
162
162
162

8
25
5
9
14
8
25
5
9
14
12
16
20

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

13

96

97

96

2

7

Form, F, S, 90, IR, 403

Form, F, 901, 403, IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

19

95

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8

163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163

85

4

163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
162
22
163
2

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

22

17

97

98

98

98

97

24

15

20

Form, F, 901, IR, 403

Form, F, S, 901, IR, 403

Form, F, S, 901, IR, 403

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

4

97

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14

163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
86

12
21
18
10
14
18
22

163
165
166
162
162
162
162

163
166
167
162
162

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

12
4
23
12
16

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

3

100

100

99

10

25

Form, F, IR, S, 901, 403

Form, F, S, ARG, 901, IR, 403

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

2

99

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8

163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
87

4

163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
162
18
162
20
162
22
163
2

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

18

4

100

101

101

101

100

6

2

16

Form, F, IR, S, 901, 403

Form, F, IR, S, 901, 403

F, IR, E, 901, 403

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

12

100

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14

163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
88

12
21
18
10
14
18
22

163
165
166
162
162
162
162

163
166
167
162
162

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

12
4
23
12
16

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

11

101

101

101

17

9

Form, F, IR, S, 901, 403

Form, F, IR, S, 901, 403

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

8

101

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8

163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
89

4

163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
162
18
162
20
162
22
163
2

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

24

101

102

101

6

22

Form, F, Leading, IR, S, 901, 403

Form, F, Leading, IR, S, 901, 403, ARG

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

19

101

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

10
14
18
22

12
21
18

12
21
18

163
163
165
166
10
14
18
22

8

163

8
12
21
18

163
163
163
165
166
90

4

162
162
162
162

4

162
162
162
162

163
165
166

163
166
167

163

163

162
162
162
163

163
166
167

163

163

162
162
162
163

163
166
167

12
4
23

10

6

12
16
20
2

12
4
23

10

6

12
16
20
2

12
4
23

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

24

102

102

102

24

22

Form, F, Leading, IR, 901, 403

Form, F, Leading, IR, S, 901, 403

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

14

102

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
102
8
102
12 Form, F, Leading, IR, S, 901, 403

8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4
8
12
21
18
10
14
18
22
4

163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
163
163
165
166
162
162
162
162
163
91

4

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

163
166
167
162
162
162
163

163

163

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

12
4
23
12
16
20
2

10

6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
162
10
162
12
162
14
162
16
162
18
162
20
162
22
163
2

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

163:5-6, calls for speculation, lack of
personal knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

13
7
24
5
21
7

122
123
124
124
127
127

5
21
3
9
5
7

Form, H, 901, IR, Scope
Form, H, 901, IR, Scope
Form, H, 901, IR, Scope
Form, H, 901, IR, Scope
Form, S
Form, S

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

120
122
123
124
126
127

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

12
21
18

163
165
166

92

8

163
163
166
167

163
12
4
23

10

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Casey Pedrick Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge
Calls for speculation, lack of personal
knowledge

Objections to Counter-Designations

4
17
22
24
5
12
24
24
10
7

54
54
55
60
65
65
65
66
67
72

54
55
56
61
65
65
66
67
68
72

40
41
43
43
45
48
48
52

12
11
24
5
10
22
12
8
3
12

21
21
2
16
22
7
13
19
47

15
15
35
37

Form
Form
Form
Form
Form

IR, H
F, IR, H
IR, H

93

72
76
77
77

35
37
52

IR, H

13
5
7
13

7
14
20

11

3
21
7
14

73
76
77
78

37
38
53

47

15
16
37
38

16
13
11
5

7
10
23

20

9
25
7
10

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

IR
IR, H
IR, H
IR, H
IR, H

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

14
19
23
6
23
21
11
12

40
41
42
43
44
47
48
51

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
7
17
7
20
13
13
14
6
14
7
14
20
14
21
15
2
15
10
15
13
37
8
37
13

Ruth Simmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

13

10
14

21
9
21

14
25

89

99
99

4

85

94

16
19
3
24
19
2
14
25
16
9
9
20
8
20

IR
IR
Form, IR
IR

F, 901
F, 901, Form, ARG, H
901, ARG

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

116
118
119
120
121
122
123
123
125
126
127
127
129
130

2
24
12
4
18
14
6
6
20
23
25
6

78
78

127
129
131

99
100

90

87

78
79

23
16
5

23
13

6

12

12
11

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

127
129
130

6
24
21
7
2
21
13
16
6
18
12
10
6
17

116
116
118
119
121
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129

84
84
85
88
88
90
91
94
95
95
96
97

Objections

F, 901, H, IR, 403
F, 901, H, Form, IR, 403
IR, 403
F, 901, H, IR, 403
F, 901, IR, 403
F, 201, IR, 403
F, 901, H, Form, IR, 403
Form, IR, 403
Form, IR, 403
Form, IR, 403
F, 901, IR, 403
F, 901, IR, 403
F, 901, H, IR, 403
F, 901, H, IR, 403

18
3
2
14
6
8
24
20
14
22
20
3

83
84
85
87
88
90
90
91
95
95
96
97

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
73
17
73
24
79
12
80
13

Ruth Simmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
without waiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
131
6
131
18

95

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Ruth Simmons Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

14
15
15
16
16
16
21
24
25
26
26
26
27
27

25
7
19
10
15
19
11
22
9
1
15
19
1
9

15
15
15
16
16
16
21
25
25
26
26
26
27
27

3
17
19
12
17
19
14
7
11
5
17
25
7
17

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
6
22
7
18
7
20
8
2
8
5
8
6
8
8
8
11
8
13
8
14
8
20
8
21
8
23
9
4
9
6
9
20
9
22
10
13
11
5
11
10
11
20
11
21
11
23
12
7
14
3
14
4
14
6
14
19

IR
IR
IR
FORM, IR

FORM, IR
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR
IR
IR

FORM, IR
IR

FORM
FORM
IR
IR

FORM

Objections

96

126
126
127

4
7
2

126
126
127

5
7
7

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
27
19
27
19
28
2
28
4
28
6
28
6
28
25
29
2
29
4
29
21
29
23
30
8
36
8
36
12
36
14
36
17
36
21
36
23
36
25
37
2
37
3
37
7
38
4
38
17
40
13
41
12
41
14
41
20
41
21
41
23
41
25
42
4
42
14
43
20
43
21
43
23
43
25
44
3
44
5
44
8
44
10
44
16
44
18
44
21
44
23
45
7
45
23
46
7
46
9
46
9
46
10
46
20
47
10
47
12
47
14
47
15
47
17
47
18
53
17
53
19
INC
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM, VA
IR, FORM, VA
IR, FORM, VA
IR, FORM, VA
IR, FORM, VA
IR, FORM , VA

IR
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR, FORM

FORM
FORM
FORM, IR

IR
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR, FORM
IR, FORM

Objections

97

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

56
57
57
60
60
60
61
61
62
62
63
63
66
66
67
68
68
68
68
69

25
14
19
3
9
18
1
12
21
25
4
17
14
17
3
9
16
22
23
5

57
57
57
60
60
60
61
61
62
63
63
64
66
67
67
68
68
68
69
69

8
17
22
7
16
24
6
21
23
2
15
6
15
1
6
14
20
22
3
23

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
53
21
54
1
54
3
54
6
54
8
54
8
54
9
54
11
54
16
54
18

FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, S
FORM, VA
FORM, VA

IR
FORM, S, VA

FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, VA
FORM, VA

Objections

98

55
55
55
56
56
56

5
8
21
2
11
18

55
55
55
56
56
56

6
14
25
5
16
24

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

21
3
9
3
10
22

24
4
8

80
82
82
83
83
83

84
85
85

85
85
85

81
82
82
83
83
83

2
6
20

12
7
10
8
20
23

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
69
25
70
5
70
7
70
7
71
17
71
22
72
2
72
4
72
8
72
9
72
11
72
11
72
14
72
17
73
6
73
25
74
2
74
4
74
10
74
11
74
13
74
16
74
18
74
20
75
1
75
3
75
5
75
5
75
18
75
25
76
1
76
6
76
22
77
5

FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR

IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR

FORM, S, VA
FORM, S, VA
IR
IR
FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR
IR
IR
IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
IR
IR
IR

Objections

99

83
84
84
84

76
76

24
3
11
15

11
18

84
84
84
84

76
76

1
5
13
17

16
21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
85
22
85
23
87
16
87
21
87
23
88
1
88
3
88
6
88
8
88
9
90
7
90
12
90
14
91
2
92
20
92
22
92
24
93
12
94
18
94
20
94
22
94
23
94
25
95
3
95
5
95
8
95
10
95
13
95
15
95
18
102
21
102
24
103
1
103
6
103
8
103
11
103
13
103
19
109
22
109
24
110
1
110
4
110
5
110
12
111
3
111
7
111
9
111
12
112
23
112
24
113
1
113
7
113
21
114
9
114
11
114
11
114
24
115
10
115
12
115
14
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR, S

FORM, S
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, S, IR

FORM

FORM, S, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, VA
FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, VA

Objections

100

111
111
111
111

88

13
13
13
13

10

111
111
111
111

88

21
21
21
21

17

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

6
10
1
5
12
24
2

25
15
21
6
20
2
3
7
23

125
125
129
129
129
129
130

130
131
131
132
132
133
133
133
133

131
131
132
132
132
133
133
133
133

125
125
129
129
129
129
130

14
19
4
18
25
2
5
7
24

7
10
3
11
17
25
9

Objections

FORM, S, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, S, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, VA
FORM, IR, VA
FORM, IR, VA

IR
FORM, IR
FORM, S, IR

FORM, VA, IR
FORM, VA, IR

IR, S

14

14

124

124

FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR, S
IR
IR
IR
IR
INC
IR, S
IR, S

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
115
16
115
18
115
20
116
2
116
4
116
4
117
11
118
9
121
13
121
16
121
18
121
22
121
24
122
7
122
8
122
8
123
17
123
22
124
11
124
12
13

101

15
21

123
124
124
124
124

130
130

23
15
22
15
22

111

130
130

123
124
124
124
124

111

17
24

25
17
22
17
22

21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
134
1
134
3
134
5
134
5
135
17
135
22
135
25
136
13
136
18
136
23
137
13
137
18
138
3
138
10
138
12
138
16
139
13
139
15
139
17
139
18
139
20
139
25
140
1
140
2
140
4
140
12
141
17
141
20
IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR, S
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
FORM, IR
IR
IR

FORM, IR, VA, S
FORM, IR, S

Objections

102

140
142
142

13
9
14

140
142
143

15
12
8

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Brock Walsh Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
10
9
10
18
10
19
11
8
12
2
12
11
12
13
12
19
13
5
13
14
13
21
14
3
14
8
14
22
15
18
17
1
17
10
17
22
18
17
18
19
19
8
19
9
19
11
20
1
21
14
21
17
22
15
24
7
28
20
28
22
28
24
29
22
29
24
30
6
47
5
47
6
47
11
47
19
47
21
48
5
51
4
51
7
51
9
51
11
51
14
51
15
52
15
53
3
69
16
69
17
69
19
70
3
70
5
70
14
71
20
71
24
72
2
72
14
73
14
74
4
S

F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S
S

FORM, H
S, IR, 403
FORM

FORM
IR
S

F, S

IR
IR

F

IR
IR, FORM

Objections

103

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Caroline Weaver Oct. 9, 2015 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

19

23

21

20
4
22
5
2
20
6
12

119

119

120

122
123
123
124
125
127
128
128

122
123
123
124
125
128
128
129

121

119

119

23
18
22
10
12
4
10
14

8

23

21

Objections

F, FORM, IR, S
F, IR
F, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IR
F, FORM, IR, LEADING
F, IR, S

F, IR, S, 403

IR, S, 403

FORM, IR, S, 403

IR, S, 403

8

3

119

119

FORM, H
H
LEADING

F, S
S
FORM
S
FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
78
15
79
14
80
10
80
18
82
7
82
14
82
16
82
19
88
11
88
12
88
14
88
23
117
24
118
5
118
7
118
7
118
15
118
18

104

118
118
118
119
210
211
210
211
119
210
211
120
121
121
122

8
19
23
9
24
6
24
6
9
24
6
16
9
14
1

118
118
119
119
211
211
211
211
119
211
211
120
121
121
122

14
21
2
17
4
6
4
6
18
4
6
20
12
14
6

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Caroline Weaver Oct. 9, 2015 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations

188

21

188

22

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
166
23
166
24
167
1
167
5
167
7
167
7
167
12
167
12
167
14
167
15
172
20
173
2
173
4
173
7
173
9
173
18
173
20
173
23
174
4
174
7
174
9
174
14
174
16
174
17
174
23
175
7
175
9
175
24
176
17
177
20
177
22
177
25
180
16
181
11
181
12
181
19
181
20
181
23
181
25
182
4
182
5
183
5
183
7
183
13
184
8
184
10
184
12
184
15
185
16
185
21
185
23
186
1
188
4
188
5
188
7
188
12
F, FORM
F, S
FORM
S
FORM
S
FORM, S
S
F, FORM

FORM
S

FORM
FORM
IC
FORM, IC

FORM, IR
FORM, IR
IR
FORM, IR
IR
FORM, IR
FORM, VA
FORM,

Objections

105

188
188

13
17

188
188

15
20

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

15
21
16
25
4
11
17
20
4
4
16
23
17
16

25
5
10
8
21

192
192
193
193
194
194
194
194
195
196
196
196
197
198

198
199
199
202
202

199
199
199
202
203

192
192
193
194
194
194
194
195
196
196
196
197
197
198

3
8
10
11
5

19
23
23
2
9
15
18
2
2
14
21
5
21
23

F, S

FORM, S
FORM, S

FORM

F, FORM
FORM

FORM
FORM
FORM

FORM

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
188
24
188
25
189
1
189
2
F, FORM
189
4
191
7
S
191
9
191
20
191
22
192
2

Objections

106

203
203
203

198
198
198

192
192
192

6
10
15

3
7
14

3
6
9

203
203
204

198
198
198

192
192
192

8
13
1

5
12
15

4
7
10

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

5
14

9
13
19
2

9
4
3
12
19
7
3
16
20
1
18
6
5
13
4
12

204
204

206
206
206
207

215
216
217
218
218
219
222
222
222
223
223
224
225
225
226
226

215
216
218
218
219
221
222
222
222
223
224
225
225
226
226
226

206
206
206
207

204
204

11
9
10
17
5
6
12
19
24
16
4
3
6
2
10
14

11
17
25
7

12
15

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC, S
S

F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC
F, FORM, INC

INC
INC
F, INC, S
S
FORM, S
INC
F, FORM, INC

FORM, H
FORM
FORM, H
H

Objections

19

19
24

222

107

15
20

14

206
206
209
210
210
210
215

226
226

15
19
22
2
6
16
12

206

204
204

226
227

222

206
206
209
210
210
210
215

206

204
205

18
3

15

17
21
25
4
14
16
19

21

22
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
204
3
204
4

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

3
9
15
1
6
13
9
13
21

11
7
20
5
10
19

233
233
233
234
234
234
235
235
235

236
237
237
238
238
238

236
237
238
238
238
239

233
233
233
234
234
234
235
235
235

22
19
3
8
18
6

7
13
24
4
11
20
11
19
23

F, S
S
FORM
FORM
S

FORM, H
H, S

FORM
FORM
FORM, S
FORM, S
FORM, S
F, S

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
227
8
227
19
228
4
228
5
F, FORM, INC
228
7
228
24 F, INC, S
229
3
229
18 F, INC
230
6
230
8
230
16
230
17
230
19
230
19

108

239

239
240
240
244
244
246
246

230
230
231

16

16
6
18
5
10
4
9

20
25
2

239

239
240
240
244
244
246
246

230
230
231

19

19
16
21
8
11
7
11

23
25
2

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

8
13

22
20

19
12

16
24

20
4
17
7
5
11
22

3

239
239

240
241

242
246

247
249

251
252
252
253
254
254
254

255

255

252
252
253
254
254
254
255

248
250

243
247

241
242

239
239

7

2
4
5
3
9
20
1

20
4

8
3

4
2

11
15

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

IC

F, S, 901
F, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 901
F, S, 901
F, FORM, S
F, FORM, S, 901

IR, S
IC

INC, S
INC

Objections

5

5
17

4
8
14

14
18
3
10

16
6
18

252
252
296
296
296
255
296
296
109

5
5
13
17
24
8
13
17

252

250
250

247
247
247

241
241
242
242

239
240
240

252
252
296
296
297
255
296
296

252

250
250

247
247
247

241
241
242
242

239
240
240

8
8
15
22
4
15
15
22

8

11
20

6
12
15

16
19
8
15

19
16
21

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
240
6
240
16
240
18
240
21

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

16
8
22
19
21
1
5
9
18
2
23
8
13
2
7
15
25
11
1
13
19
22
20
6

24
7

255
256
256
257
260
261
261
261
261
262
274
275
275
276
277
277
277
280
281
281
281
281
282
284

285
286

286
286

256
256
257
258
260
261
261
261
261
262
274
275
275
276
277
277
278
280
281
281
281
282
283
284

5
13

6
11
17
4
24
4
7
16
25
5
24
10
15
17
13
23
8
22
11
14
20
5
5
11

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line

F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, IC, IR, S, 403

IC
IC
IC
IC, VA
FORM, IC, S
FORM, IC, S
IC, S
IC
FORM, IC
S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, FORM, IC, S
F, IC, IR, S, 403

F, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 901
F, FORM, S, 901
F, S, 901
FORM
FORM

Objections

24

2

284
284
286
286

110

12
21
17
20

276

262

284
284
286
286

277

262

16
25
18
20

2

5

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line
296
24
297
4

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

13
25

11
14
1
7
13
3
19
20
13
6
9
20
2
2
3

7
16

287
288

289
292
293
293
293
294
294
298
299
301
302
303
304
305
313

313
313

313
313

289
292
293
293
294
294
294
298
300
301
302
303
304
305
313

287
289

14
16

12
24
5
11
1
17
20
23
7
13
23
25
25
3
5

14
9

H, LC

H, IR
INC
INC, IR
FORM, H, INC, IR, S
F, H, INC, IR, S
S
H, LC

F, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, H, IR, S, 403
F, H, S

F, IC, IR, S, 403
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403

Affirmative Designation
Objections
Page Line Page Line
287
1
287
4
F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403
287
6
287
11 F, FORM, IC, IR, S, 403

8

14
25
11
23

12
21
17
20

312
312

111

16
20

300

290
290
291
291

284
284
286
286

312
313

300

290
291
291
292

284
284
286
286

18
2

19

23
9
20
4

16
25
18
20

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Objections to Counter-Designations

Caroline Weaver March 6, 2017 Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

16
4
8
12
18
2
13
18
17
24
4

30
35
35
35
35
81
81
82
83
83
84

30
35
35
35
35
81
82
83
83
84
84

27
28
29
29

20
7
9
13
24
6
14
14
21
2
9

17
9
3
10

Form, IR, Scope
Form, S, IR, Scope
Form, S, IR, Scope
Form, S, IR, Scope
IR, Scope
Form, VA, IR, Scope
Form, S, Scope
Form, S, Scope
Form, VA, Scope, 901, F
Form, VA, Scope, 901, F
Form, VA, Scope, 901, F

IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
Form, IR, Scope
IR, Scope

IR
Form, IR
Form, IR
IR

Objections

*Objections and counter-designations made subject to and
w ithout w aiver of Harvard’s Objections to SFFA’s Witness List.

14
6
16
7

27
28
28
29

Affirmative Designation
Page Line Page Line
4
18
4
20
10
3
10
8
15
18
18
3
21
7
21
9
21
11
21
15
25
25
26
17

11
13
24
21

17
17
18
24

9

84
85
85

112

12
2
8

29
29
29
30

21
21
27
27

10

84
85
85

29
29
30
30

22
22
27
28

10

23
5
16

12
17
15
23

5
5
18
4

16

Counter-Designations
Page Line Page Line

Fabio Zuluaga Deposition Designations

SFFA Affirmative Designations

Objections to Counter-Designations