Vargas et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al

Filing 115

DECLARATION of Dr. Richard Boulanger in Support re: 85 SECOND MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Brian Transeau. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A# 2 Exhibit B (part 1)# 3 Exhibit B (part 2)# 4 Exhibit B (part 3)# 5 Exhibit B (part 4))(Ahrens, Julie)

Vargas et al v. Pfizer Inc. et al

Doc. 115 Att. 5

BOULANGER SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION EXHIBIT B FIGURES B9A ­ B9L To illustrate a comparatively large set of obvious differences between the recreated Aparthenonia and the original Bust Dat Groove (w/o ride), figures B9A ­ B9E show differences in audio waveforms and overall rhythmic pattern (B9A); difference in pitch contour and content (B9B); difference in spectral content via the FFT sonogram view (B9C); difference in spectral content via overlays using the FFT spectral view (B9D).

B9A: B9a_WS_WaveformComp

26

Dockets.Justia.com

B9B: B9b_WS_PitchComp

B9C: B9c_WS_SonogramComp

27

B9D: B9d_WS_SpectrumOverlay Further, figures B9E ­ B9L, compare the FFT sonograms and the FFT spectrums of the recreated Aparthenonia and the original Bust Dat Groove (w/o ride) on a beat by beat basis and show them to be unique as well.

28

B9E: B9e_AU_Beat1_WavSono

B9F: B9f_AU_Beat1_WavSpec

29

B9G: B9g_AU_Beat2_WavSono

B9H: B9h_AU_beat2_WavSpec 30

B9I: B9i_AU_beat3_WavSono

B9J: B9j_AU_beat3_WavSpec

31

B9K: B9k_AU_beat4_WavSono

B9L: B9l_AU_beat4_WavSpec

32

BOULANGER SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION EXHIBIT B FIGURES B10A ­ B10F To illustrate that there are no spectral matches between any of the percussion sounds in Recreated Aparthenonia and the original Bust Dat Groove (w/o ride), regardless of where these percussion sounds appear in the pattern, figures B10A ­ B10F show differences in audio waveforms and spectrum of "similar" sounds from different locations in the pattern. (Note: all sounds were normalized prior to the spectral analysis.) B10A compares the waveform and spectrum of the Bust snare to the Recreated snare from Beat 2; B10B compare the waveform and spectrum of the Bust "closed hat" at beat 1.5 with the Recreated "closed hat" at beat 1.5; B10C compares the simultaneous Bust "kick&hat" at beat 1.5 with the simultaneous Recreated "kick&hat" at beat 1; B10D compares the Bust "clean kick" at beat 4.5 with the Recreated "clean kick" at beat 1.5; B10E compares the Bust "open hat" at beat 3.5 with the Recreated "open hat" (not really an open hat in this case) at beat 3.5; and finally B10F compares the Bust "snare roll" at beat 2.5 with the Recreated "snare roll" at beat 4.5. Regardless of where the "similar" percussion events are taken from the pattern, none of them is an extremely close waveform or spectral match.

B10A: B10A_AU_Beat2_BustSnareVsRecreatedSnare_WaveSpec

33

B10B: B10B_AU_Beat2_BustClosedHatVsRecreatedClosedHat_WaveSpec

B10C: B10C_AU_Beat1.5_BustKickHatVsRecreatedBeat1KickHat_WaveSpec

34

B10D: B10D_AU_Beat4.5_BustKickVsBeat1.5RecreatedKicK_WaveSpec

B10E:B10E_AU_Beat3.5_BustOpenHatVsBeat4.5_RecreatedOpenHat_WaveSpec

35

B10F: B10F_AU_Beat2.5_BustRollVsBeat4.5_RecreatedRoll_WaveSpec

36