Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 188

DECLARATION of Katherine B. Forrest in Opposition re: 168 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike., 165 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike.. Document filed by Capitol Records, Inc., Elektra Entertainment Group, Inc., Interscope Records, Laface Records LLC, Motown Record Company, L.P., Arista Records LLC, Priority Records LLC, Sony BMG Music Entertainment, UMG Recordings, Inc., Virgin Records America, Inc., Warner Bros. Records Inc., Atlantic Recording Corporation, BMG Music. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 492 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 493 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 3 Exhibit 494 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 4 Exhibit 495 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 5 Exhibit 496 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 6 Exhibit 497 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration)(Forrest, Katherine)

Download PDF

Exhibit 494 UNITED SOUTHERN STATES DISTRICT DISTRICT OF COURT NEW YORK LLC; ATLANTIC BMG CORPORATION; MUSIC; CAPITOL RECORDS, INC.; ELEKTRA ENTERTAINMENT GROUP INC.; INTERSCOPE LAFACE RECORDS RECORDS; LLC; MOTOWN RECORD PRIORITY RECORDS COMPANY, L.P.; BMG MUSIC UMG LLC; SONY ENTERTAINMENT; RECORDS RECORDINGS, INC., VIRGIN BROS. RECORDS AMERICA, INC.; and WARNER INC., Plaintiffs, RECORDING V. ARISTA RECORDS DEFENDANTS' SUPPLEMENTAL DISCLOSURES FEDERAL RULE FIRST PURSUANT TO OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 26(a)(1) CIVIL ACTION NO. 06 CV 5936 (GEL) LIME WIRE LLC; GREG LIME GROUP LLC; M.J.G. MARK LIME WIRE GORTON; FAMILY LIMITED and BILDSON; PARTNERSHIP, Defendants. Defendants Lime Wire Lime Wire Limited LLC, Lime Group LLC, Mark Gorton, Greg Bildson make and these M.J.G. Family disclosures Partnership to (collectively Rule need of Civil each "Defendants") Procedure first supplemental of the with pursuant and Federal 26(a)(1) and the stipulation the parties that Plaintiffs information: Defendants only disclose identity of individuals discoverable Reservations Defendants time. Defendants make have these not disclosures based upon information of this reasonably case available at this completed their investigation and have not completed prejudice preparation for trial. to Accordingly, these supplemental to disclosures at are provided without that is Defendants' right introduce at a hearing right to or trial any evidence subsequently the discovered. Defendants reserve the clarify, amend, modify, or supplement information Civil contained in these supplemental of this Court. with disclosures in accordance with the Federal Rules of Procedure and the rules Individuals Discoverable Information 1. Defendants and identify the numbers following those individuals (and to the extent known Defendants their addresses have telephone to of the individuals) that currently known may use to to or likely have discoverable information Defendants to support its claims and defenses: Unknown Representatives of Altnet, 14011 Ventura Blvd., Suite 501 Sherman Oaks, CA 91423 Representatives Avenue, South Inc. Unknown 200 12 th of Amazon.com, Inc. Seattle, Washington 98144-2734 206-266-1000 Unknown 1 Infinite Representatives Loop CA 95014 of Apple, Inc. Cupertino, 408-996-1010 Ikezoye Schrempp, Vice President Engineering Michael of Business McTeigue, Vice President Audible Magic 985 University Avenue, Suite 35 Vance Jim Development Los Gatos, CA 95032 408-399-6405 Alex All Rofman, Vice President, Business Development Aydar Rusty Rueff SNOCAP, 310-403-3809 Unknown 14011 Sherman Fax Inc. Ventura Representatives of Brillant Blvd., Suite 501 Oaks, CA 91423 Digital Entertainment, Inc. 818-386-2179 1270844vl 2 John Hank Hummer Berry Winblad CA Venture Partners 300 Hummer One San Lombard Street, Suite 94111 Francisco, 415-979-9600 David James Goldberg A. Pitaro, Fisher Business Affairs Roberto Ken Matt Rita Tarmas Compton, Media Gardin Music Avenue Services and Strategic Partnerships Yahoo 701 First Sunnyvale, California Larry Linietsky Senior Alan 94089 Vice Cohen Kehoe President Global Business Development Noel Andrea Giles Aileen Cliona Davenow Yassin Atkins Murphy Melrose Avenue California West Napster 9044 Hollywood, Hasan 90069 Miah R. Keough, Managing Director Cams, Managing Director Dennis B. Levine, ADASAR Group Oris Capital Partners Michael 445 New Clarke Park Avenue New York, York 10022 Avi Nadar, WhenU 1 Penn New CEO Plaza, Suite 4532 York, New York 10119 1270844vi 3 Chris Zahavah Eric 2601 Maxcy Levin Inc. Klein Elliott Avenue 98121 RealNetworks, Seattle, Washington Carey Sherman Mitch Steve Ken Bainwol Marks Doroshow of America 300 Stanley Pierre Louis Recording Industry Association 1330 Connecticut D.C. Avenue, 20036 Suite Washington, 202-857-9600 Nicholas Janus Zennstrom Friis 2 Skype Technologies Stephen Street W 1T 1 AN London, England Michael StreamCast 20969 Ventura Weiss Networks Blvd., CA Suite 91364 215 Woodland 818-998-8610 Unknown 702 Hills, Representatives 8 th of Walmart S.W. Street 72716 Bentonville, Arkansas 479-273-0280 Sam 45 New W. Yagan 21 st Street NY #6D York, 10010 646-216-8762 Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of Arista Records LLC Forest, York Cravath, Swaine 10019-7475 & Moore, L.L.P. Eighth York, 1270844vl 4 Representatives c/o Katherine 825 B. Avenue New of Atlantic Recording Corporation Forest, Cravath, Swaine & Moore York 10019-7475 L.L.P. Eighth York, New Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of BMG Music Forest, York Cravath, 10019-7475 Swaine & Moore L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of Capitol Records, Cravath, 10019-7475 Inc. Forest, York Swaine & Moore L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of Elektra Entertainment Group & Moore Inc. L.L.P. Forest, York of Cravath, 10019-7475 Swaine Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New Interscope Records Cravath, 10019-7475 Forest, York Swaine & Moore, L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. of Laface Records LLC Swaine & Forest, York Cravath, 10019-7475 Record Moore, L.L.P. Eighth Avenue York, New Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. of Motown Company, Swaine & L.P. L.L.P. Forest, York of Cravath, 10019-7475 Moore, Eighth Avenue York, New Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New Priority Records Cravath, 10019-7475 LLC Forest, York of Swaine & Moore, L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Sony BMG Music Entertainment Forest, Cravath, Swaine & Moore, 10019-7475 L.L.P. Eighth Avenue York, New York 1270844vl 5 Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of UMB Recordings, Cravath, 10019-7475 Inc. & Forest, York of Swaine Moore, L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New Forest, York Virgin Records America, Inc. Cravath, Swaine & Moore, 10019-7475 Bros. L.L.P. Eighth York, Representatives c/o Katherine 825 New B. Avenue New of Warner Records Inc. & Forest, York Cravath, Swaine 10019-7475 of Sharman of Moore, L.L.P. Eighth York, Unknown Unknown 455 Representatives Representatives Real Networks pressplay/Roxio E1 Camino Santa Clara, California Rosso D. 95050 Wayne Allen Mike 216 Lenard Bebel 58th Street Mashboxx Apartment B Virginia Beach, Talmon Ofer Robert iMesh Marco VA 23451 Shabti Summers Jeffrey Kimmel Meister Seelig 708 Third New & Fein LLP Avenue, NY 24th Floor York, 10017 Stephen Gracenote DuPont 2000 Powell Street, Suite 1380 Emeryville, California Mitchell Mitch 94608 Reichgut Golden 1270844vl 6 Jun Group, Inc. 203-761-8744 Mimi Scott AOL One New Kim Boyd Music Time Warner New Center York, Martin York 10019-8016 Glenn Intent 4470 MediaWorks Chamblee 310 Dunwoody Road, Suite Atlanta, Georgia 30338 Paul Senior 845 New Greenberg Vice President, Business Avenue, York, New rd Development MusicNet 3 11 th Floor 10022 York 212-704-0280 Mark Senior New Eisenberg Vice President and Business Business Affairs/ Technology Haussler Wiesenthal Development Christa Rob Sir Howard Stringer Music Avenue New Sony New BMG Entertainment York 10022-3211 550 Madison York, 212-833-5392 Ken Parks Vice Munsen Senior President, Strategy and Business and Distribution Development Ralph Digital Development EMI 150 New Music Fifth Avenue New York 10011 York, 212-786-8877 Elliott Vice Howie Peters President, Senior Counsel and Head of George White, SVP Strategy and Product Singer, VP Strategic Technology Digital Legal Affairs Development 1270844vl 7 Stephen M. Bryan, VP Strategic Planning and Business Counsel Amy Lauren, Associate Warner Music Group 75 New Rockefeller Plaza New Development York, York 10019 212-275-2180 Larry Kenswil, President Christopher Bell Edgar Bronfman Universal Universal 2220 Santa eLabs Music Group Avenue 90404 Colorado Monica, California 310-865-4094 Mark Lime Porter 1000 Gorton Wire LLC S. Baker c/o Charles & Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Main Floor Houston, Greg Bildson Lime Porter 1000 Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Main Hedges, L.L.P. Street, 36 Texas 77002 th Floor Houston, Sam Lime Porter Berlin Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles 1000 Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Zlatin Lime Porter Balevsky Wire LLC S. Baker c/o Charles & 1000 Main Hedges, L.L.P. th Street, 36 Floor Texas Houston, 77002 1270844vl 8 Tim Lime c/o Porter 1000 Olsen Wire Charles & Main LLC S. Baker Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Katie Lime Porter 1000 Catillaz Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 th Floor Houston, Andrew Lime Porter 1000 77002 Fischler Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Zenzele Lime Porter Bell Wire & LLC c/o Charles 1000 Main S. Baker Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Krik Lime Porter Kahn Wire LLC S. Baker c/o Charles & Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th 1000 Main Floor Houston, Felix Lime Porter Berger Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles 1000 Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 th Floor Houston, 77002 1270844vl 9 Kevin Lime Porter 1000 Faaborg Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Main Hedges, Texas L.L.P. th Street, 36 Floor Houston, Christine Lime Porter 1000 77002 Cioffari LLC S. Baker Wire & c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Jesse Rubenfeld Wire & LLC S. Baker Lime Porter 1000 c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 th Floor Houston, Nathan Lime Porter 1000 77002 Lovejoy Wire & LLC S. Baker L.L.P. 36 77002 th c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas Kumar LLC Floor Houston, Akshay Lime Porter 1000 Wire & c/o Charles Main S. Baker Hedges, Texas L.L.P. th Street, 36 77002 Floor Houston, David Lime Porter 1000 Yeu Wire & LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Main Hedges, Street, Texas L.L.P. 36 tn Floor Houston, 77002 1270844vl 10 Michael Lime Porter 1000 Nutt Wire & Main LLC S. Baker c/o Charles Hedges, L.L.P. Street, Texas 36 77002 th Floor Houston, Jorge Mancheno Lime Porter 1000 Wire LLC S. Baker c/o Charles & Hedges, L.L.P. th Main Street, 36 Floor Anthony Carlucci 81 Sycamore Street Massapequa, New York Ron 449 11758 Vogl Huron Avenue Cambridge, Massachusetts Jennifer-Kate 300 Mercer New Barrett Street, Apt. New 1D 10003 York, York Roger Kapsi 137 Rivington Apt. #5 New Street York, New York 10002 Matthew 607 Kotzen Lorimer Street, Apt. 1 Brooklyn, New York Mark 300 New 11211 Kornfilt Mercer Street, Apt. 22J New York, York 10003 Benjamin Hunter 252 New Seventh Soule Avenue, Apt. 81 York, New York 10001 4B Robert 44 Columbia Place, Apt. New Brooklyn, York 11201 1270844v 1 11 Tarum 27 New West Kapoor 82 nd Street, Apt. York 3B York, New 10024 7 Stephen Cho Stonebridge New Lane Princeton, Steffan 1855 Jersey 08540 Pingel West 12 th Avenue Vancouver, V6J 2E7 BC Canada Anurag Singla 30 Newport Parkway, Apt. 2409 Jersey City, New Jersey 07310 Christopher Rohrs 215 New East 84 th Street, Apt. York 1A York, Fisk th New 10028 Adam 95 S. 4 Street New York 11211 Brooklyn, Yusuke Naito 11 Lefferts Place, Apt. York 2 11238 Brooklyn, New Adam 138 Harris 11756 Stephen Street Levittown, New York Sumeet 302 New Mott Thadani Street, Apt. New 12 10012 York, York Aubrey Arago 15 Terhune Avenue Jersey City, New Jersey 07305 Susheel 2110 Daswani Haste Street, Apt. 323 94704 Berkeley, California 1270844vl 12 Dave 1105 Nicponski Summit Ave., Apt New 3 07307 Jersey City, Christine 191 Jersey Nicponski Congress Street, Floor 2 Jersey City, New Jersey 07307 Angel Leon 363 Stockholm New Street, Apt. York 11237 2L Brooklyn, Karl 377 New Magdsick Broadway, York, New 11 th Floor 10013 York Meghan Formel 310 New East 9 th Street, Apt. New York 3 10003 York, Zaphaniah Grunschlag 560 Riverside Drive, Apt. 3P New New York 10027 York, Amy Hoy Sean 3400 #312 Los Clifford Ben Lomond CA Place 90027 Angeles, Schmidt Justin New 245 Avenue C, Apt. 5A NY 10009 York, Steme Rachel 321 New East Houston, Apt. York, NY 10002 1 1270844vl 13 Mike Linksuayer Commons Vice-President Creative San 171 Second and/or Street, Suite CA 94105 300 Francisco, Gipsstrasse 12 10119 Berlin, Germany Rick P.O. Prelinger Prelinger Archives Box 590622 CA San Francisco, C. 94159 Martin DCIA Lafferty Neck 2838 Cox Road, Suite 200 21619 Chester, Unknown 201 San Maryland representatives Street, Suite CA 94105 of BitTorrent 900 Mission Francisco, Unknown representatives 22/24 Boulevard Royal, Luxenbourg Friis, Niklas 101 T Xc of Skype Technologies S.A. L-2449 Janus Zennstrom and other unknown representatives of Joost Schipholweg 2316 The Netherlands and 41 East New 11 th Leiden Street, New 11 ta Floor 10003 York, York Valerio Zingarelli and unknown Dublin, Ireland representatives at Raw individuals at Babel Networks Ltd. Unknown Flow Sugih Jamin, Beat Knecht, Thomas Patel, Dug Song and other 1327 Ann Jones unknown Billeter, Francesco Vass, Benoit at Zattoo representatives Henry, Jignesh Drive, Suite 106 Arbor, Michigan 48105 1270844vl 14 Unknown New representatives New York of Raketu Communications Inc. York, Unknown 487 East representatives Middlefield Road CA 94043 of Verisign Mountainview, Unknown 1902 S.E. of Abacast, reffresentatives 6 Avenue t Inc. Camas, Unknown 211 New Washington 98607 representative Avenue, New of 10016 Qtrax Madison #28B York, York Mitgang, Dmitry Shapiro, Joshua Metzger, Bilger, Todd Dagres, Michael Eisner and unknown Inc. San Steve Dr. Dunning, Ted Meisel, Arthur representatives of Veoh Networks, Ted Diego, CA Alfie Contact Steve Zappacosta at info@zappacosta.com Winwood Page Stuart Sleepwalker's Paradise Contact via pagestu@earthlink.net Or realpolitik(�earthlink.net Brooklyn, New York Members of the group Soulcoughing Members Members Contact 5225 Los Krisfin of the group of the group the above Blvd. CA New Riders of the Purple Sage Kufala Records Slip through Brady Lahr The at Wilshire Angeles, Kayuba 90036 Pucka Members Alex Robert Contact of the group Devon The Quick Fix Kills Rice of the group The Animators Wong, Roth Copley, Phil Galitzine, Kevin via rr@robertrothmusic.com 1270844v I 15 Members Sushirobo Members Members Members Members John of the group The Worship Project of the group The Blam of the group of the group of the group American The The Analog Set Appleseed Cast Sick Lipstick Vanderslice Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Unknown Dean Representatives Representatives Representatives Representatives Representatives of MGM of Studios Disney Studios Bros. Studios of Warner of Sony Entertainment Studios of Universal Garfield Picture Association Nine of America Inch Motion Members Artist Artist of the group Nails Jay-Z Ne-Yo LLC Sparkart P. O. Box 8639 CA Emeryville, 510-420-0201 Rich 94662-0639 Egan Manager of the group Dashboard Confessional 1270844vl 16 Unknown 1601 representatives c/o ARTISTdirect, Inc. Cloverfield South CA 90404 of MediaDefender Blvd. Ste. 400 Santa Monica, JeffTweedy The band The Wilco of Furthumet.com operators Morris Kevin General Wincraft 41 Manager Music Rodney Road Cheltenham, U.K. 044-1242-260066 Unknown Members Anders Unknown Unknown Jari Ahola VTT representatives of the group of Capitol Records Ros Sigun Weberg representatives representatives Research 1 of Interscope Records of P2P-Next Technical Centre of Finland Tekniikankatu FIN-33720 358 20 722 Tampere, Finland 3334 Luista Head of the Rodriguez-Rosell6 Europe Union's representatives Avenue Network of Swarmcast Media Unknown 615 First Suite 330 Minneapolis, 651-340-8787 MN 55413 representatives Cambridge Center Cambridge, MA 02143 8 817-325-2624 Unknown of Akamai 1270844vl 17 Unknown Unknown representatives representatives of Kontiki of RayV Operators of the following websites: http://bt.etree.org/ http://nugs.net/ http : / /www. wizards.co http://torrent.ibiblio.org/ Laura m/ default.asp ?x=magic/magi conline/ do wnloadlinks Tunberg Norwich Avenue CA 91411 5420 Sherman Oaks, 1270844vl 18 Respectfully Submitted, Of counsel: Charles Lauren E. Handler /s/ S. Baker D. K. Joseph Susan & PORTER 1000 SDNY (LEH 6908) BROMBERG (CB1365) (JC3017) Hellinger (SH8148) Cohen & PORZIO, HEDGES, th LLP NEWMAN, P.C. 100 Southgate Parkway P.O. Box Main Street, Texas 36 Floor Houston, 77002 1997 Morristown, NJ 07962-1997 (973) 538-5146 (Facsimile) (973) 889-4326 (Telephone) lehandler(5),pbn.com (713) 226-6000 (713) 228-1331 (Telephone) (Facsimile) cbaker(�,porterhedqes.com icohen�,porterhed.qes.com shellinqer�,porterhed.qes.com A ttorneys for Defendants/ Counterplaintiff SERVICE of the on CERTIFICATE OF The the undersigned hereby certifies that a true and via electronic mail and/or following counsel as correct U.S. copy mail, this 22nd foregoing was served upon day of February, 2008, addressed follows: /s/ Charles TO: S. Baker Katherine Teena-Ann Worldwide 825 New B. V. Forrest Sankoorikal & Moore, LLP Cravath, Swaine Plaza Avenue NY Eighth York, 10019-7475 (212) 474-1000 (212) 474-3700 Counsel (fax) Counterclaim for Plaintiffs/ Defendants 1270844vl 19 Of Counsel: Kenneth L. Doroshow Karyn A. Temple Recording Industry Association 1025 F of America Street, NW, 10th Floor Washington, DC 20004 (202) 775-0101 (202) 775-7253 (fax) 1270844vl 20

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?