Arista Records LLC et al v. Lime Wire LLC et al

Filing 188

DECLARATION of Katherine B. Forrest in Opposition re: 168 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike., 165 MOTION to Strike Plaintiffs' Exhibits Filed as Part of Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MSJ and Defendants' Motion to Strike.. Document filed by Capitol Records, Inc., Elektra Entertainment Group, Inc., Interscope Records, Laface Records LLC, Motown Record Company, L.P., Arista Records LLC, Priority Records LLC, Sony BMG Music Entertainment, UMG Recordings, Inc., Virgin Records America, Inc., Warner Bros. Records Inc., Atlantic Recording Corporation, BMG Music. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 492 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 2 Exhibit 493 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 3 Exhibit 494 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 4 Exhibit 495 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 5 Exhibit 496 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration, # 6 Exhibit 497 to Forrest December 5, 2008 Declaration)(Forrest, Katherine)

Exhibit

495

C RAVATH,
ROBERT AI.U[N RONAI.D PAUL DOUGLAS ALAN HAX STUART JOHN VAN HICHAEL RICHARD KRIS B. F. ROBBINB D. A. O, E. R. . R. C. D, JOFFE JAMES ROBIrRT KL·tlN STEPHli;N C. ALLIrN S, J. C.

SWAI
825

NE

MOORE
PLAZA
AVENUE

LLP

WORLDWIDE
VARDELL,
H. BARON GREHAN S, HADSIrN

FINKI[I.a.,OH
S, ROLFIr DAUNOIrRS O. SROADWATIrR

EIGHTH NY

WILL SCOTT PHILIP ROGER

JAM A. J.

J.

WHIrLAN BARSHAY BOIrCKHAN BROOKS FOGG

I

H

DAVID DAVID RACHIrL PAUL JOIrL IrRIC

S.

FINK£1JI;TEIN
G, SKAISTIS

GREENWALD

NL=WYORK,
TELEPHONE: FACSIMILE:

10019-7475
474-1000 474-3700

O. V. J,

H. F. W.

ZUMBRO HEROLD HILFER· F. SCNOEN

PARKIrR ROSENSI'RG WlrBBTlr G, R M·BAO

WlLLIAH

STEPHgNSON SHULHAN Wo GOLD

MARC SU·IkN T(MOTHY DAVID ROWAN PL·rlrR RANDRA PAUL "rHOMAS MICHAEL RICHARD

(21Z) (212)

FAI· RICHARD THOMAS JULIE RONALD

·irlrO J. E, STARK OUNN ·ElrT

GIrORGE ERIK CRAIG TEENA'ANN R. E.

TAVZ£L ARCELLA V. R. R.

SIrERBOWER

M ERCADO Do T0 WILSON CITYP0iNT BARBUR ONE C. OOLDSTIrlN LONDON N ICHAISKI TELEPHONE: O. B. RAFFIrRTY FACSIHIL[: GOLDMAN HALL L. NORTH W. t. NlrlrOHAM BURNS B, R. IrL HUMMIrL SLIFKIN A. L SHITH FORREST GRAYER 44-20-781r0-1 150 44-2074S3-1000 ECZY DHR ROPEHAKER STREET

SPELU4AN CAM| I, GRIrrN J IrDr·ltAN C. R. WOOLERY MARRIOTT A. J. T, L. It, A. P. A. PAgKIN PITTS
r

CHIrSLIrR
L SCHLIrR LEVIN HIrlNZELMAN KIESSLING TURNER GIrL·TON MILLSON P, W° Po D. IIARRON CI.ARY

DANKOORIKAL

MARK BARKIS JAMIrS DAVID MICHAIrL ANDRIrV4

ANDREW DAHIEN LAUREN TATIANA ERIC k.

THOMPSON ZOUBLK

ANGEULU LAPUSHCHIK SCHIELE

ROGER PHILIP RORY FRANCIS RICHARD WILLIAM JAMIrS STIrPHEN DANIIrL GREGORY PLPTIrR

WLIZASL·rH JUL[I· ANORIr'W JR. STEPHEN KATHIrRINIr KEITH DANI JIrFFREY ROBIrRY A,

WRITERtS

DIRECT

DIAL

NUMBER

MICHAIrL ANTONY GIrORGIr GIrORGIr DARIN GARY TIMOTHY KARIN A.

REYNOLDS RYAN ZO811"2: STIrPHANAKIS SPIrCIAL SAMUEL GIrORGIr COUNSEL C. J. BUTLER

ROGIrRS,
COOPIrR L. GORDON

NCATE£ SORNSTIrlN O. O--.AMEROtl Or R. ElSlrN COUNSlrL

GILLESPIIr,

S

I--

MORLEY H. SHAW

OEMASI

S°

WIlJ3ON

TOWNBENI·

gn

UZABETHANN

CHRIBTINE

RlrSNAR

January 31, 2008
Arista Records

LLC,

et

al.

v.

Lime

Wire

LLC,

et

al.

06 CV 5936
Dear

(GEL)

Joe:
For the

addressing the liability issues in this case, listed below 7th plaintiffs, pursuant to the Court's ruling during the December have provided discovery regarding ownership: hearing,
purpose
arc

of

the

tracks

on

which

Copyright
Arista
Arista Atlantic Records Records

Plaintiff
LLC LLC Alan Brooks HoGtie

Artist
Jackson & Dunn & The

Song Someday
Lost And

Title
Don't

Album
Rock Jukebox

Title
the ! 38-302

SR

Found Be

Brand

New

Man

! 40-290

Recording Recording

Only
With

Wanna You

Corporation
Atlantic

Blowfish
Matchbox 20

Cracked Yourself
Like To Me You Leave It's So You the

Rear
or

View Someone

193-960
227-755

Corporation
BMG BMG Music Music

Long Day
He I'm Talks So Into

Lorrie
SWV

Morgan

Light
Time for the

On

105-180 146-905

About Much

Capitol Capitol
Elektra

Records, Records,

Inc. Inc

Evercicar Maze

Fa·er of Mine Joy and Pain

Afterglow Joy and Pain
Didn't See Me

181-328 20-598

Entertainment lnc. Elektra

Group
Keith Sweat

Games Semi-Charmed

Coming

293-086

Entertainment
Inc.

Group
Third
Records

Eye

Blind

Life

Third Blue Me Down Return B reach

Eye
Of

Blind Saturn

188-673 279-727

Interscope Interscope
LaFace LLC LaFace

No Doubt Wallflowers
OutKast

Dark
Hand

Records

214-646
233-296

Records Mainstream Atliens

Records Usher Record Final

LLC
Motown

Goodbye
Man

Usher

200-154

Company,

L.P.

98

Degrees

Invisible

98

Degrees

249-152

2

Copyright
Motown

Plaintiff
Record Brian

Artist

Song
Last Dance

Title
Back

Album
At One

Title
279-471

SR

Company, L.P. Priority Records
LLC

McKnight
Romeo

Lil' Records

Little Slow

Star

Lil' Da

Romeo Game Not Is To To Be

317-620

Priority
LLC
SONY

Snoop Dogg
BMG

Down

Sold,

Be Told

260-056

MUSIC
ENTERTAINMENT SONY BMG

Anytime
Mariah

You

Carey

Need

A Friend

Music

Box

178-631

MUSIC
ENTERTAINMENT UMG Inc. UMG Inc. Nas One Love lilmatic 207-177 The 226-415

Recordings,

Recovering Counting
Crows
A

Long
On

December

Satellites Lead On

Recordings,

George
Records Inc. Records Inc. Bros. Inc. Bros. Inc. Linkin Paula Kelis

Strait

Lead

200-310

Virgin
America,

Game

Show

Kaleidoscope
Forever Your Girl

277-087

Virgin
America,
Warner Records Warner Records

Abdul

Cold

Hearted

93-688

Green

Day
Park

Pulling

Teeth

Dookie

185-457

Papereut

Hybrid Theory

288-402

Atlantic

Copyright Plaintiff Recording

Artist

Song
I Got

Title

SR
Pre-72 Pre-72

Corporation Capitol
Eiektra

Ray
Inc. The

Charles
Beach

A Woman Girl

Records,
Entertainment

Boys

Surfer

Group
Motown

Inc. Record
L.P. MUSIC

The

Doors

Light My
You're
One

Fire

Pre-72

A Wonderful Pre-72

Company,
SONY

Marvin
The

Gaye

BMG

ENTERTAINMENT

Byrds

Wasn't

Born

To

Follow

Pre-72

A reflecting plaintiffs' Schedule the additional tracks that Katherine raised during the December 7th hearing. For the avoidance of any doubt, we expressly reserve the right to make additional changes to
an

Also, attached

is

amended version

of

3

Schedules conclusion

A and

Specifically, we will likely identify additional of the liability portion of this lawsuit.
B.

tracks

prior

to

the

Since·
-Ann V.

Sankoorikal

Joseph D. Cohen, Esq. Porter & Hedges, LLP
1000 Main

Street, 36th Floor
TX

Houston,
Encls.

77002

BY FEDERAL
BY

EXPRESS

w! encls,

and

ELECTRONIC

TRANSMITTAL

w/o encls.