Viacom International, Inc. et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 371

DECLARATION of ANDREW H. SCHAPIRO in Support re: 177 MOTION for Summary Judgment Regarding Applicability of the DMCA and on Plaintiffs' Inducement Claims.. Document filed by Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC, Google, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 - 3, # 2 Exhibit 4 - 12, # 3 Exhibit 13 - 17, # 4 Exhibit 18 Part 1, # 5 Exhibit 18 Part 2, # 6 Exhibit 19 - 32, # 7 Exhibit 33 - 41, # 8 Exhibit 42 Part 1)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Schapiro Exhibit 13

1

UN ITE D S TAT ES DIS TRI CT COU RT FO R T HE SOU THE RN DIS TRI CT OF NEW Y ORK

VI ACO M I NTE RNA TIO NAL , I NC. , C OME DY PA RTN ERS , C OUN TRY MU SIC TE LEV ISI ON, IN C., PA RAM OUN T P ICT URE S C ORP ORA TIO N, AN D B LAC K E NTE RTA INM ENT TE LEV ISI ON, LL C,

) ) ) ) ) ) PL AIN TIF FS, ) CA SE NO. ) 07 -CI V-0 210 3 vs . ) ) YO UTU BE, IN C., YO UTU BE, LL C, AND ) GO OGL E, INC ., ) ) DE FEN DAN TS. ) __ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ _) ) TH E F OOT BAL L A SSO CIA TIO N P REM IER ) LE AGU E L IMI TED , B OUR NE CO. , E T A L., ) ON BE HAL F O F T HEM SEL VES AN D A LL ) OT HER S S IMI LAR LY SIT UAT ED, ) ) PL AIN TIF FS, ) CA SE NO. ) 07 -CV -35 82 vs . ) ) YO UTU BE, IN C., YO UTU BE, LL C, AND ) GO OGL E, INC ., ) ) DE FEN DAN TS. ) __ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ _) VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F J OHN ED DOW TA KEN TH URS DAY , N OVE MBE R 1 2, 200 9 LO S A NGE LES , C ALI FOR NIA Jo b N o. 180 93

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

UN ITE D S TAT ES DIS TRI CT COU RT FO R T HE SOU THE RN DIS TRI CT OF NEW Y ORK

VI ACO M I NTE RNA TIO NAL , I NC. , C OME DY PA RTN ERS , C OUN TRY MU SIC TE LEV ISI ON, IN C., PA RAM OUN T P ICT URE S C ORP ORA TIO N, AN D B LAC K E NTE RTA INM ENT TE LEV ISI ON, LL C,

) ) ) ) ) ) PL AIN TIF FS, ) ) vs . ) ) YO UTU BE, IN C., YO UTU BE, LL C, AND ) GO OGL E, INC ., ) ) DE FEN DAN TS. ) __ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ _) ) TH E F OOT BAL L A SSO CIA TIO N P REM IER ) LE AGU E L IMI TED , B OUR NE CO. , E T A L., ) ON BE HAL F O F T HEM SEL VES AN D A LL ) OT HER S S IMI LAR LY SIT UAT ED, ) ) PL AIN TIF FS, ) ) vs . ) ) YO UTU BE, IN C., YO UTU BE, LL C, AND ) GO OGL E, INC ., ) ) DE FEN DAN TS. ) __ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ ___ _)

CA SE NO. 07 -CV -21 03

CA SE NO. 07 -CV -35 82

VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F J OHN ED DOW , TAK EN ON BE HAL F O F T HE DEF END ANT S, AT 9:3 1 A.M ., THU RSD AY, NO VEM BER 12 , 2 009 20 , 2 009 , A T 3 50 SO UTH GR AND AV ENU E, LO S A NGE LES , C ALI FOR NIA , B EFO RE AUD RA E. CR AME R, CS R N O. 990 1, PUR SUA NT TO SUB POE NA.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

AP PEA RAN CES OF CO UNS EL

FO R V IAC OM PLA INT IFF S: JE NNE R B LOC K, LLP BY : SCO TT B. WIL KEN S, ESQ UIR E 10 99 NEW YO RK AVE NUE , N W SU ITE 90 0 WA SHI NGT ON, DC 20 001 (2 02) 63 9-6 072 sw ilk ens @je nne r.c om FO R P REM IER LE AGU E P LAI NTI FFS : PR OSK AUE R R OSE , L LP BY : GIL N. PE LES , E SQU IRE 20 49 CEN TUR Y P ARK EA ST SU ITE 32 00 LO S A NGE LES , C ALI FOR NIA 90 067 -32 06 (3 10) 28 4-5 611 gp ele s@p ros kau er. com FO R F ANS CAP E: TA RKI AN & A SSO CIA TES BY : ALE X T ARK IAN , E SQU IRE 19 01 AVE NUE OF TH E S TAR S SE CON D F LOO R LO S A NGE LES , C ALI FOR NIA 90 067 (3 10) 46 1-1 320 at ark ian @ta rki ana nda sso cia tes .co m

FO R Y OUT UBE DE FEN DAN TS: WI LSO N S ONS INI GO ODR ICH & ROS ATI BY : MAU RA L. REE S, ESQ UIR E 65 0 P AGE MI LL ROA D PA LO ALT O, CAL IFO RNI A 9 430 4-1 050 (6 50) 56 5-3 508 mr ees @ws gr. com (20 2) 639 -60 72 AL SO PRE SEN T: TO M C AVA NAU GH, VI DEO GRA PHE R

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

73 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

M R. T AR KI AN :

I s th e p oo ls id e fi gh t sc en e o n

11 :4 9

E xh ib it 2 9 re fl ec te d o n Ex hi bi t No . 30 , wh i ch i s th e c li p. T HE W IT NE SS : s ee n ei th er c li p. B Y MS . RE ES : Q. Do es i t se em l ik e ly b as ed o n th e da te of t he I d on 't kn ow b ec au se I 'v e ne v er 11 :4 9

e -m ai l on E xh ib it 2 9 a nd t he d at e of t he e - ma il o f th e u pl oa di ng i n Ex hi bi t 3 0? M R. W IL KE NS : M R. T AR KI AN : I s it l ik el y? T HE W IT NE SS : B Y MS . RE ES : Q. No w, G os si p Gi rl 40 w as a u se r na me c r ea te d on 1 1: 5 0 T he t im e f ra me s ee ms l ik el y. O bj ec ti o n ca ll s fo r sp ec ul at i on . A sk ed a n d an sw er ed . G o ah ea d . 11 :5 0

Y ou Tu be b y Fa ns ca pe ; r ig ht ? A. Q. I' m no t su re . W a s th at o n th e li st ?

We ll , fo r ex am pl e , if y ou g o ba ck t o e xh ib it - M R. T AR KI AN : T he g ri d s; r ig ht ? 11 :5 0

B Y MS . RE ES : Q. If y ou l oo k on o n e of t he g ri ds , li ke ma yb e Se e if I ca n se e a pa ge h er e. E xh ib it 2 4 . It 's t in y p ri nt i n Ex hi bi t 24 , b ut i t

E xh ib it 2 3. A. Q.

Ok ay . Ri gh t.

l is ts o n th e fi rs t pa g e, A S ho t of L ov e 2, Ti la T eq ui la

11 :5 1

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

74 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

L ea k, K ri st y' s As s an d t he n Go ss ip G ir l 40 an d th en A S ho t of L ov e 2, T il a T eq ui la L ea k, L es bi an Sa nd wi ch , G os si p Gi rl 4 0. A. Q. Ok ay . Ba se d on r ev ie wi n g Ex hi bi t 24 , is i t y ou r

11 :5 1

1 1: 5 1

u nd er st an di ng t ha t th e - - fi rs t of a ll , th a t th e G os si p Gi rl 4 0 Yo uT ub e u se r na me w as c re at e d by F an sc ap e? A. I th in k th at 's a le ap . W e' re u si ng t h e 11 :5 1

c ha nn el - - us in g th e c ha nn el v er su s cr ea ti n g it i s no t n ec es sa ri ly t he s am e t hi ng s o -- r ig ht ? Q. We ll , is i t yo ur un de rs ta nd in g th at Y o uT ub e

p eo pl e ar e al lo we d to us e ch an ne ls t ha t th e y di dn 't c re at e? A. Q. Ye s. Bu t yo u' re n ot a w ar e of a ny c ir cu ms ta n ce s wh er e 11 :5 2

F an sc ap e di d th at , us e c ha nn el s th at i t di d n' t cr ea te , a re y ou ? A. Q. No . An d in f ac t, i n E xh ib it 2 6, M y- la n Be a uf or d 1 1: 5 2

r ef er en ce s e- ma il in g g os si p bl oc ks w it h th e f ak e e- ma il a dd re ss G os si p Gi rl 4 0 . D oe s th at i nd ic at e t o yo u th at

M y- la n cr ea te d th e Go s si p Gi rl 4 0 Yo uT ub e a cc ou nt ? A. Ex hi bi t 26 ? M R. T AR KI AN : D o yo u k no w wh et he r or n ot M y -l an 11 :5 2

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

75 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

c re at ed G os si p Gi rl 4 0 ? T HE W IT NE SS : B Y MS . RE ES : Q. We re a ll o f th e f ou r vi de os l is te d on B as ed o n t hi s, y es .

11 :5 3

E xh ib it 3 0 on t he G os s ip G ir l 40 u pl oa de d t o Yo uT ub e by F an sc ap e on b eh al f of MT V? A. Q. Al l fo ur ? S ay y o ur q ue st io n ag ai n.

11 :5 3

Th e qu es ti on w as , w er e al l fo ur o f th e v id eo s

l is te d on E xh ib it 3 0 o n th e Go ss ip G ir l Ch a nn el u pl oa de d t o Yo uT ub e on b eh al f o f MT V? A. Th e on ly o ne I w o ul d qu es ti on w ou ld b e t he 11 :5 3

P er ez H il to n fr ea ko ut . Q. A. Wh y wo ul d yo u qu e st io n th at ? I do n' t th in k th a t wa s pr ov id ed b y MT V . I 11 :5 4

d on 't t hi nk P er ez H il t on i s an M TV p ro pe rt y . Q. Ag ai n, i f yo u lo o k ba ck a t Ex hi bi t 26 in

M y- la n' s up da te f or t h e Ce le br it y Wr ap S up e rs ta r Sh ow s he r ef er en ce s -- t he fi rs t bu ll et p oi nt i s " Pe re z H il to n th re w a te mp er ta nt ru m, a nd M TV w an t ed t he w or ld t o kn ow a bo ut i t. a nd Y ou Tu be ." A. Q. Ok ay . So d oe s th at i nd i ca te t o yo u th at P er e z Hi lt on 'L e ak ed ' vi de o cl ip u pl o ad ed t o if il m 11 :5 4

F re ak in g Ou t cl ip i s o ne o f th e cl ip s th at My -l an i s r ef er ri ng t o in E xh ib i t 26 ? 11 :5 4

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

76 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

A. Q.

Ye s. Ba ck t o th e pa ge wi th t he T il a Te qu il a P oo ls id e

11 :5 4

F ig ht S ce ne , in t he v i de o ki nd o f in t he m i dd le o f th e s cr ee n sh ot o f th e vi d eo l oo ks l ik e a ti me co de . l ik e "0 1: 18 :1 8: 03 ." A. Q. Ye s. Do y ou k no w wh y t ho se n um be rs w er e su p er im po se d L oo ks 11 :5 5

o n th e vi de o li ke t ha t ? A. Q. I do n' t kn ow . Wa s in cl ud in g a t im e co de i n th e vi de o 1 1: 5 5

s om et hi ng t ha t MT V ev e r as ke d Fa ns ca pe t o d o? A. I do n' t kn ow . M R. T AR KI AN : f ou r nu mb er s. B Y MS . RE ES : Q. As f ar a s Fa ns ca p e go es , di d MT V ev er pu t ti me 11 :5 6 M ay n ot be a t im e co de . I t' s

c od es i n vi de o fo ot ag e i n or de r to m ak e it lo ok a s t ho ug h th e vi de o wa s u nf in is he d an d it w as be in g le ak ed ? M R. W IL KE NS : T HE W IT NE SS : B Y MS . RE ES : Q. On t he G os si p Gi r l 40 C ha nn el , is t he r e an y O bj ec ti o n to t he f or m. Y ea h, I do n' t kn ow . 11 :5 6

i nd ic at io n fr om l oo ki n g at t he p ri nt ou t th a t Go ss ip G ir l 4 0 is a F an sc ap e ac co u nt ? A. No . 11 :5 6

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

77 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Q.

Th es e tw o fi rs t v id eo s ar e ca ll ed o r h av e

1 1: 5 7

" Ti la T eq ui la L ea k" i n t he t it le , th ey a re no t re al ly l ea ks i n th e se ns e of be in g un au th or iz ed . MT V pr ov id ed

t he se v id eo s to F an sc a pe w it h pe rm is si on t o u pl oa d th em ; c or re ct ? M R. T AR KI AN : T HE W IT NE SS : t he y pr ov id ed . O bj ec ti o n to f or m. F an sc ap e o nl y us es v id eo s th a t 11 :5 7

W e do n 't c re at e vi de os , an d w e do n' t

m an uf ac tu re v id eo s. B Y MS . RE ES : Q. A. An d it c er ta in ly do es n' t st ea l vi de os ? Ye ah . C er ta in ly do es n' t st ea l vi de os . Ex hi bi t 31 . ( Wh er eu po n, E xh ib it 3 1 w as m ar ke d f or i de nt if ic at io n. ) T HE W IT NE SS : B Y MS . RE ES : Q. A. Q. Ca n yo u id en ti fy Ex hi bi t 31 ? Th is i s a co py o f a n e- ma il . It 's a n e- ma il s t ri ng i nv ol vi ng C hr is t y Wi se a t 1 1: 59 O ka y. 1 1: 58 11 :5 7

M S. R EE S:

F an sc ap e, J es si ca N ic o la a t MT V, a nd t he l a st o ne i s f or wa rd ed t o My -l an B e au fo rd a t Fa ns ca pe . A. Q. A. I do n' t se e -At t he v er y to p. Ye s. Th an k yo u. G et ti ng t ir ed a lr ea d y. 1 1: 5 9

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

78 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Q.

So i n th e e- ma il st ri ng a t th e be gi nn i ng ,

1 1: 5 9

J es si ca N ic ol a sa ys t o C hr is ty W is e, " Is t h is H G cl ip o ka y? " T he n th e re sp o ns e fr om C hr is ty W is e i s, " Le t me

k no w wh en y ou a re r ea d y fo r us t o go o ut w i th t hi s. A ls o, i s it o ka y if w e u pl oa d it t o Yo uT ub e w he n it i s r ea dy ?" T he n th e re sp on se i s " Go od t o go . J es si ca N ic ol a. " T he n Ch ri st y Wi se o n t he f ir st p ag e wr it es b ac k, " Yo uT ub e is o ka y t o us e. " A nd J es si c a Ni co la 's 12 :0 0 T ha nk s, fr om 12 :0 0

r es po ns e is " Si r [s ur e ], i f yo u ca n do i t i n th e i nc og ni to w ay ," w it h a s mi le y fa ce . A. Q. Ye s. Do y ou h av e an y u nd er st an di ng a s to w h at 1 2 :0 0 D o yo u s ee t ha t?

F an sc ap e wa s su pp os ed to u nd er st an d by M s. Ni co la 's p hr as e "t he i nc og ni to wa y" ? A. Q. I do n ot . So a t va ri ou s po i nt s th er e we re t im es wh en

F an sc ap e ha d up lo ad ed a vi de o to Y ou Tu be , a nd t he n V ia co m is su ed a t ak e- d ow n no ti ce f or Y ou Tu b e to t ak e it d ow n; i s th at r ig ht ? M R. W IL KE NS : T HE W IT NE SS : t o Yo uT ub e? O bj ec ti o n to f or m. V ia co m i ss ue d a ta ke -d ow n no t ic e 1 2 :0 1

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 14

Schapiro Exhibit 15

Redacted at the request of Plaintiffs pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Schapiro Exhibit 16

1

UN IT ED ST ATE S DIS TR ICT C OUR T FO R THE S OUT HE RN DI STR IC T O F NEW Y ORK

VI AC OM IN TER NA TIO NA L I NC ., CO MED Y PA RT NER S, CO UN TRY M USI C TE LE VIS IO N, IN C., P ARA MO UNT PI CT URE S COR PO RAT IO N, an d B LA CK EN TE RTA IN MEN T TEL EV ISI ON LL C, Pl ai nti ff s, vs . YO UT UBE , INC ., YO UT UBE , LLC , an d GOO GL E, IN C., De fe nda nt s.

) ) ) ) ) Ca se No . ) 1:0 7C V02 10 3 ) ) ) )

__ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ ___ __ _) VI DE OTA PE D D EP OSI TI ON OF MA RK HA LL NE W YOR K, NE W YOR K Tu es day , Feb ru ary 2 3, 20 10 RE PO RTE D BY: ER IC A R UG GIE RI , C SR , R PR JO B NO: 1 881 3

2 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Fe bru ary 23 , 2 010 9: 04 a.m .

VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F M ARK HA LL, he ld at the of fic es of May er Bro wn , 1 675 Br oad way , N ew Yor k, New Yo rk, pu rsu an t t o no tic e, bef ore be for e E ric a L . R ugg ie ri, Re gis ter ed Pro fes sio nal Re por ter an d No tar y P ubl ic of the St ate of Ne w Yor k.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

3 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES FO R T HE LEA D P LAI NTI FFS AN D P ROS PEC TI VE CL ASS : JE NNE R & BL OCK , L LP BY : LUK E C . P LAT ZER , E SQ.

10 99 New Yo rk Ave nue , N W Su ite 90 0 Wa shi ngt on, DC 20 001 -44 12 (2 02) 63 9-6 000 Lp lat zer @je nne r.c om

FO R T HE DEF END ANT S Y OUT UBE , I NC. , YO UTU BE, LL C a nd GOO GLE , I NC. : MA YER BR OWN , L LP BY : BRI AN WIL LEN , E SQ. JA SON I. KI RSC HNE R, ESQ . 16 75 Bro adw ay Ne w Y ork , N ew Yor k 1 001 9 (2 12) 50 6-2 500 Bw ill en@ may erb row n.c om Jk irs chn er@ may erb row n.c om

AL SO PRE SEN T: MA RCE LLO RI VER A, Vid eog rap her

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

55 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:46 11:16:45 11:16:45 11:16:45 11:16:45

HA LL pr ovi ded an y o the r P ara mou nt con ten t to Au dib le Mag ic for fi nge rpr int ing ? A. Q. No , t hey ha ve not . Do yo u k now wh eth er the

fi nge rpr int s t hat we re cre ate d i n M ay of 20 07 are st ill in Au dib le Mag ic' s sys tem ? A. Q. A. Q. Th e 3 09? Ye s. Th ey are . So ot her th an tho se fin ge rpr int s

ar e t her e a ny oth er fin ger pri nts of Pa ram oun t c ont ent in Au dib le Mag ic' s sy ste m t hat yo u a re awa re of? A. Q. No . So ju st aga in to be cl ear , w ith

re spe ct to the fi nge rpr int s t hat ar e in Au dib le Mag ic' s s yst em, do es Par amo unt ha ve any in for mat ion ab out ho w o fte n Au dib le Mag ic has ma de mat che s t o tho se fi nge rpr int s o n a ny web sit e? MR . P LAT ZER : Ou tsi de the sc ope . A. re por ts. I hav e n o k now led ge of an y Obj ect ion .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

56 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:47 11:16:47 11:16:46 11:16:46 11:16:46

HA LL MR . W ILL EN: I pr oba bly sh oul d

ha ve sai d t his be for e b ut the sc op e ob jec tio ns you ar e m aki ng I o bvi ous ly di sag ree wi th and we ha d t his co ll oqu y at th e l ast ve rsi on of thi s d epo si tio n wh ich we ne ed to -MR . P LAT ZER : - - a gai n - MR . W ILL EN: po sit ion . MR . P LAT ZER : MR . W ILL EN: And yo u o urs . I n p art icu lar ou r Y ou und ers tan d o ur

po sit ion is th at thi s f all s w ith in su bto pic fi ve in my Feb rua ry 3rd , 201 0 le tte r. Q. Do es Par amo unt ha ve any

in for mat ion ab out ho w e ffe cti ve Aud ibl e Ma gic 's tec hno log y i s i n i den tif yin g Pa ram oun t c ont ent ? A. Q. e- mai l. No t t o m y k now led ge. Ok ay. L et' s l ook ba ck at th is

I' m l ook ing no w a t t he fi rst He say s,

pa rag rap h o f D r. Bel l's me ssa ge.

Au dib le Mag ic, or "A M h as bee n w id ely us ed by th e m usi c i ndu str y t o d ete ct an d i ssu e

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

57 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:47 11:16:47 11:16:47 11:16:47 11:16:47

HA LL ta ke- dow n n oti ces fo r u nau tho riz ed mus ic co nte nt and ot her br oad cas t m oni tor ing ap pli cat ion s." Do yo u a gre e w ith th at st ate men t? A. I don 't kno w t hat I wo uld

ch ara cte riz e i t a s w ide ly use d b eca us e I do n't kn ow the ex ten t t o w hic h t he c in dus try us es it. Q. As -- ex cus e m e. In M ay of

20 07, wa s A udi ble Ma gic be ing wi del y use d by th e m ovi e i ndu str y? A. Q. Wh at' s t he tim e f ram e? At th e t ime th is e-m ail w as

wr itt en, Ma y o f 2 007 . A. I don 't kno w i f i t w as wi del y

us ed by the mo vie in dus try . Q. Ar e y ou awa re of any m ovi e

st udi os tha t h ad pro vid ed con ten t t o Au dib le Mag ic for fi nge rpr int ing in M ay of 20 07? MR . P LAT ZER : Ou tsi de the sc ope . A. Re pea t t he que sti on, pl eas e. Obj ect ion .

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

62 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:51 11:16:51 11:16:51 11:16:51 11:16:51

HA LL be en rem ove d. So it ma kes se nse t o h ave a

to ol bes ide s j ust au dio to fi nd th e co nte nt. Q. Di d P ara mou nt eve r c ont emp la te

us ing Au dib le Mag ic to hel p m ake P ara mou nt -- le t m e b ack up . ph ras ed. Di d P ara mou nt eve r c ont emp lat e us ing Au dib le Mag ic to hel p P ara mou nt de ter min e w het her ce rta in Par amo unt co nte nt was pr omo tio nal in na tur e? MR . P LAT ZER : Va gue . A. Ye ah. C an you re sta te. I'm no t Obj ect ion to fo rm. Tha t w as po orl y

su re I c lea rly un der sta nd. Q. I thi nk it may be ea si er to do

th is wit h a do cum ent so le t's do t hat . MR . W ILL EN: Ex hib it 6. (H all Ex hib it 6, e-m ail ch ain fr om Jan uar y o f 2 007 pa rti all y re dac ted , B ate s n umb er VIA 117 878 17, ma rke d f or ide nti fic ati on, as of th is dat e.) T his wi ll be

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

63 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:54 11:16:53 11:16:53 11:16:53 11:16:53

HA LL MR . W ILL EN: E xhi bit 6 is a

do cum ent pr odu ced by Vi aco m w ith th e Ba tes nu mbe r V IA1 178 781 7. An e- mai l

ch ain fr om Jan uar y o f 2 007 wh ich h as be en at lea st par tia lly re dac ted . A. Q. A. Q. A. Ok ay. So wh o i s S tev e K auf man ? I don 't kno w. Wh o i s A l P err y? Al Pe rry is a law yer i n t he

co nte nt pro tec tio n a rea . Q. A. Q. At Pa ram oun t? Of Pa ram oun t, yea h. So dr awi ng you r a tte nti on to th e

e- mai l t he pag e e ndi ng in 18, wh ic h i s wr itt en by Ste ve Kau fma n t o A lfr ed Pe rry Ja nua ry 26, 20 07. T he sec ond pa ra gra ph -" In fo llo w-u p

I' ll rea d t he who le thi ng.

to th e G oog le/ You Tub e c onv ers ati on I jus t wa nte d t o m ent ion th at MTV N i s i n the in iti al sta ges of wo rki ng wit h A udi bl e Ma gic wi th con ten t f ilt eri ng. T he We b

Po rta l f ilt eri ng app lic ati on is in be ta te st at our iF ilm si te, an d w e are go ing

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

64 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:55 11:16:55 11:16:55 11:16:54 11:16:54

HA LL to st art ev alu ati ng the pr oce ss of ge ner ati ng the co nte nt fin ger pri nts in t he ne xt wee k o r s o. "N one of th is spe aks to Mo nda y's ch all eng e, but in th e v ery -ne ar- ter m we ca n p oss ibl y u se the fi nge rpr int ing te chn olo gy to hel p B ayT SP ide nti fy 'l ega l' pr omo tio nal co nte nt. I nst ead of se nd ing

DV Ds and ha vin g o per ato rs try to v isu all y id ent ify co nte nt, we ca n f ing erp rin t the pr omo tio nal co nte nt, an d B ay can in st all an Au dib le Mag ic fin ger pri nt lib rar y sy ste m a nd use th e s yst em to aut om ati cal ly de ter min e i f i t i s p rom oti ona l." Do yo u s ee tha t? A. Q. Uh -hu m. Do yo u u nde rst and wh at th e

pr obl em her e t hat Mr . K auf man is de scr ibi ng? A. Ar e y ou ref err ing to "n on e o f

th is spe aks to Mo nda y's ch all eng e"? Q. A. Ye ah. I n t he sec ond p ara gra ph.

I don 't kno w w hat th at' s

re fer rin g t o.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

65 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:55 11:16:55 11:16:55 11:16:55 11:16:55

HA LL Q. Ar e y ou awa re of Bay TSP h avi ng

di ffi cul ty ide nti fyi ng wha t c ont ent wa s, qu ote , p rom oti ona l l ega l c ont ent ? A. Q. I' m n ot awa re of tha t, no . Wh y w oul d i t b e t hat

fi nge rpr int ing pr omo tio nal co nte nt usi ng Au dib le Mag ic wou ld hel p B ayT SP ide nt ify wh at con ten t w as pro mot ion al? A. Q. A. Q. I don 't kno w. Yo u h ave no id ea? No . Ar e y ou awa re of any i nst anc es

in wh ich Pa ram oun t h as fin ger pri nte d pr omo tio nal co nte nt? A. Q. A. Ye s. Wh at are th ose in sta nce s? We ve ry rec ent ly fin ger pri nt ed

th e I ron Ma n I I C omc on tra ile r, wh ich wa s sh own on ly at Com con po st. T her e was a

fi nge rpr int ma de of an Iro n M an II tr ail er th at was si mil ar tha t w as dis tri but ed th rou gh the tr ail er and wa s d ist rib ut ed th rou gh iTu nes . For th at we fin ge rpr int ed

th at spe cif ic con ten t.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

66 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:56 11:16:56 11:16:56 11:16:56 11:16:55

HA LL Q. A. Q. Fo r w hat pu rpo se? To re str ict it s u se. So fi nge rpr int ing wo uld gi ve

Pa ram oun t g rea ter co ntr ol ove r h ow th e co nte nt app ear s o n t he Int ern et? A. Q. A. So -- ye s, yes . Ho w w oul d t hat wo rk? Ho w w oul d p rov idi ng a

fi nge rpr int ? Q. So fo r w hat -- to wh at ve ndo r

wa s t he fin ger pri nt of the tr ail ers y ou ju st spo ke abo ut pro vid ed? A. It wa s p rov ide d t o B ayT SP an d i t

wa s p rov ide d t o Y ouT ube . Q. Wa s t he ide a t hat if t hat

tr ail er was id ent ifi ed on cer tai n w eb sit es it wo uld be ta ken do wn? A. Q. Co rre ct. Be cau se Par amo unt on ly wan te d i t

to ap pea r o n o the r w ebs ite s? A. Q. Co rre ct. So ot her th an the pa rti cu lar

in sta nce th at you ju st des cri bed , d oe s Pa ram oun t h ave a reg ula r p rac tic e o f

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

67 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:57 11:16:57 11:16:57 11:16:57 11:16:57

HA LL fi nge rpr int ing tr ail ers or ot her pr omo tio nal ma ter ial s? A. Th ose ar e t he onl y i nst an ces

th at I'm aw are of . Q. Wh y d oes n't Pa ram oun t g ene ra lly

fi nge rpr int tr ail ers or pr omo tio nal co nte nt? A. Be cau se the pr omo tio nal co nt ent I t's pr omo tio nal . It 's

is wh at it is.

me ant to be vi ewe d.

Th e i dea i s t hat th e

co nte nt is ava ila ble fo r p eop le to ge t th em int ere ste d i n a fi lm. S o we

tr adi tio nal ly wou ldn 't wan t t o l imi t the sc ope of th e a udi enc e t hat se es it . Q. An d a t l eas t i n t he co nte nt of

th is com mun ica tio n f rom Mr . K auf man a nd Mr . P err y t her e w as som e d iff icu lty t hat Ba yTS P s eem ed to hav e i n i den tif yin g whi ch co nte nt was th e l ega l p rom oti ona l c on ten t? MR . P LAT ZER : Fo und ati on. A. Q. Ca n y ou rep hra se. Su re. I n t he con tex t of the Obj ect ion .

e- mai l t hat Mr . K auf man se nt to Mr . P err y,

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

68 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:58 11:16:58 11:16:58 11:16:57 11:16:57

HA LL he se ems to be id ent ify ing an is su e w ith Ba yTS P b ein g a ble to id ent ify wh at co nte nt wa s t he leg al pro mot ion al con ten t. MR . P LAT ZER : Q. A. Is th at rig ht? Th at' s w hat th is e-m ail s eem s t o Sam e o bje cti on.

st ate , y es. Q. Au dit ude . So I wan t t o t alk br ie fly ab out You sa id ear lie r t hat A udi tud e

is no t a te chn olo gy tha t P ara mou nt ha s us ed? A. Q. A. Q. Uh -hu m. Is th at rig ht? I did sa y t hat . Ok ay. Y ou are aw are t hat Vi aco m

si gne d a co ntr act wi th Aud itu de in 20 07? A. Q. I' m n ot awa re of tha t con tra ct. Ar e y ou awa re tha t V iac om is

us ing Au dit ude 's tec hno log y s et asi de Pa ram oun t? A. Ye ah. J ust le t m e r ef res h m y

me mor y f rom no tes . Q. A. Su re. No , I 'm not aw are of a ny use of

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

69 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 11:16:59 11:16:59 11:16:59 11:16:59 11:16:58

HA LL Au dit ude . Q. A. Q. A. Q. By Pa ram oun t? By -By Pa ram oun t. By Vi aco m. Ok ay. W hy is it tha t Par amo unt

ha s d eci ded no t t o u se Aud itu de' s te chn olo gy? A. Be cau se we hav e c hos en to us e a

sp eci fic ve ndo r f or our co nte nt id ent ifi cat ion an d t ake -do wn not ice s on -li ne. T he str ate gy, if yo u w il l, is to

us e t hat ve ndo r a nd to, wh ere we c an, us e bl ock ing te chn olo gy to kee p i t f rom ge tti ng on- lin e i n t he fir st pla ce, s uch as th e Y ouT ube al gor ith m. Q. A. Q. A. No w t he -Go ah ead . No , p lea se. An d t hen th ird ly, we us e Vob ile

as ki nd of a t ert iar y a s p art o f t he Vi aco m a gre eme nt, as a thi rd lay er of pr ote cti on. A nd we fil l w ith th os e w e

ha ve wit h B ayT SP we hav e s uff ici ent

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

Schapiro Exhibit 17

268

UN IT ED S TA TE S DIS TR IC T CO UR T FO R TH E SO UT HE RN DI ST RI CT O F NEW Y OR K

VI AC OM I NT ER NA TIO NA L, I NC ., C OME DY PA RT NE RS , CO UN TRY M US IC . TE LE VI SI ON , IN C., P AR AM OU NT PI CT UR ES C OR PO RAT IO N, a nd B LA CK EN TE RT AI NM EN T TEL EV IS IO N, L LC ,

) ) ) ) ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) ) vs . ) N O. 0 7-C V- 21 03 ) YO UT UB E, I NC ., YO UT UB E, L LC , ) an d GO OG LE , IN C., ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) __ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ _) ) TH E FO OT BA LL A SSO CI AT IO N PR EM IER ) LE AG UE L IM IT ED , B OU RN E CO ., e t a l. ,) on b eh al f of t hem se lv es a nd a ll ) ot he rs s im il ar ly si tu at ed , ) ) Pl ai nt if fs , ) vs . ) N O. 0 7- CV -35 82 ) YO UT UB E, I NC ., YO UT UB E, L LC , and ) GO OG LE , IN C. , ) ) De fe nd an ts . ) __ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ __ __ __ __ __ ___ __ _) VI DE OT AP ED D EP OSI TI ON O F WA RR EN SO LO W NE W YO RK , NE W YOR K JA NU AR Y 14 TH , 201 0 JO B NO . 18 50 9

269 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

VI DEO TAP ED DEP OSI TIO N O F W ARR EN SO LOW , h eld at th e o ffi ces of Wi ls on, So nsi ni, Go odr ich & Ros ati , P C, 130 1 Av enu e o f t he Ame ric as, Ne w Y ork , New Yo rk, pu rsu ant to no tic e, bef ore Ma ure en Rat to, Re gis ter ed Pro fes sio nal Re por ter an d N ota ry Pub lic of th e Sta te of Ne w Y ork on Ja nua ry 14, 20 10, a t 10 :13 a. m.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

270 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

APPEARANCES

FO R T HE PLA INT IFF S: JE NNE R & BL OCK , L LP BY : S USA N J . K OHL MAN N, ESQ . 91 9 T hir d A ven ue, Ne w Y ork , N Y 1 00 22 (2 12) 891 -16 90 sk ohl man n@j enn er. com

FO R T HE DEF END ANT S: WI LSO N, SON SIN I, GOO DRI CH & R OSA TI, L LP BY : MIC HAE L H . R UBI N, ESQ .

65 0 P age Mi ll Roa d, Pal o A lto , C A 943 04 65 0-8 49- 331 1 MR UBI N@w sgr .co m

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

284 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:29:39 10:29:28 10:29:19 10:29:09 10:28:56

A. Q. A.

Ma y 5 th, 20 00. Ve ry pre cis e r eco lle cti on. I bel iev e t he day th e CBS me rge r

cl ose d, so it' s a da y o f n ote . Q. Wh at was yo ur pos iti on on th e

da y y ou beg an wor kin g f or Via com ? A. I was th e d ire cto r o f lit iga tio n

su ppo rt. Q. A. Q. A. Do yo u h old th at pos iti on to day ? No . Wh o h old s t hat po sit ion t oda y? We ll, I sup pos e f unc tio nal ly I

ho ld tha t p osi tio n b ut not wi th th at ti tle . Q. So yo ur tit le has ch ang ed bu t

yo ur job re spo nsi bil ity st ill in clu des th e r esp ons ibi lit y f or whi ch you we re in iti all y h ire d? A. Q. Ye s. Ha s y our jo b r esp ons ibi lit y

ex pan ded ? A. Q. Ye s. Di d y ou hav e o ver sig ht

re spo nsi bil ity fo r o the r V iac om em plo yee s w hen yo u w ere hi red ?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

285 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:31:09 10:30:43 10:30:08 10:29:56 10:29:47

A. Q.

Ye s. Do yo u h ave ov ers igh t

re spo nsi bil ity fo r a gr eat er num ber o f Vi aco m e mpl oye es tod ay tha n t he day y ou we re hir ed? A. Q. Ye s. Wh at is you r c urr ent po si tio n

wi th Via com ? A. I' m t he vic e p res ide nt of

in for mat ion an d k now led ge man age men t. Q. Ca n y ou ple ase de scr ibe y our

du tie s a nd res pon sib ili tie s a s v ice pr esi den t o f i nfo rma tio n a nd kno wle dge ma nag eme nt of Via com ? A. I pla y a ro le in the r eco rds

ma nag eme nt spa ce, th e d ata li fec ycl e of in for mat ion wi thi n t he org ani zat ion . In th at reg ard I hel p t o p rom ulg at e pr oce dur e a s i t r ela tes to th e r ec ord s ma nag eme nt fun cti on. I le ad a

de par tme nt tha t p rov ide s b oth ge ner al, le gal su ppo rt fun cti ons to Vi aco m a nd it s d ivi sio ns, wh ich wo uld al so inc lu de pr ovi din g l iti gat ion su ppo rt for th e en ter pri se.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

286 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:32:43 10:32:15 10:31:58 10:31:51 10:31:32

I als o a ct as the co pyr igh t ad min ist rat or, se rvi ng a v ari ety of fu nct ion s i n t hat re gar d. th ose ar e t he hig hli ght s. Q. Do es you r j ob in any way i nvo lve I wou ld sa y

in ter act ing wi th Bay TSP ? A. Q. Ye s. Do yo u h ave su per vis ory o r

ma nag eme nt res pon sib ili ty wit h r esp ect to Vi aco m's re lat ion shi p w ith Ba yTS P? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. A. Q. Y ou can an swe r. I hav e a t t ime s. Do yo u t oda y? Ye s, to som e e xte nt. Wh en did yo u b egi n t o hav e Ob jec tio n a s t o

su per vis ory or ma nag eme nt re spo nsi bil ity wi th res pec t t o V iac om' s re lat ion shi p w ith Ba yTS P? A. I bel iev e t hat of fic ial ly be gan

in Fe bru ary of 20 07. Q. Ha s t her e b een a per iod o f t ime

be twe en Feb rua ry of 200 7 a nd the pr ese nt dur ing wh ich yo u d id not h ave ma nag eme nt or sup erv iso ry

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

287 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:34:04 10:33:41 10:33:30 10:33:14 10:32:50

re spo nsi bil ity wi th res pec t t o V iac om' s re lat ion shi p w ith Ba yTS P? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Y ou can an swe r. Th e l eve l o f p rac tic al Ob jec tio n a s t o

su per vis ory in vol vem ent ha s v ari ed ove r ti me, bu t I wo uld sa y o ffi cia lly i t h as no t. Q. Th e b uck st ops wi th you ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

Ma ny wou ld say th at, in cl udi ng

th ose wh o I wo uld th ink th e b uck s top s wi th. Q. Yo u i ndi cat ed tha t y ou ha ve

co pyr igh t a dmi nis tra tio n re spo nsi bil iti es. A. Q. A. Ye s. Wh at do you me an by th at? In a pra cti cal se nse , I b eca me

th e, or my dep art men t h ad the -- p lay ed th e p oin t o f c ont act ro le wit h t he ou tsi de wor ld, ou tsi de of Via com , t he pu bli c f aci ng poi nt of con tac t. Q. de tai l? Ca n y ou exp lai n t hat in g rea ter

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

288 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:35:23 10:35:01 10:34:46 10:34:35 10:34:25

A.

My de par tme nt had re spo nsi bi lit y

fo r t he int ake of mo st com mun ica tio ns fr om the pu bli c t hat we re tar get ed to war ds cop yri ght is sue s. Q. Is yo ur dep art men t r esp ons ib le

fo r r egi ste rin g c opy rig hts fo r V iac om wi th the Co pyr igh t O ffi ce? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Y ou can an swe r. No , s ir. I ap olo giz e. Ob jec tio n a s t o

Yo ur dep art men t i s n ot

re spo nsi ble fo r a ll are as of cop yri gh t ad min ist rat ion , i s t hat ri ght ? A. Th at is cor rec t. MS . K OHL MAN N: ca n a nsw er. A. Q. G o a hea d. Ob jec tio n. Yo u

Co rre ct. So wh en you sa y t hat y our of fic e

is th e p ubl ic fac e f or cop yri ght i ssu es fo r V iac om, wh at typ es of cop yri ght is sue s a re you re fer rin g t o, Mr. S olo w? A. Wh ate ver is sue s t he -- th e

ex ten t o f t he iss ues ar e c ont rol led b y th ose wh o c hoo se to int era ct wit h the me cha nis m f or com mun ica tio n. So th at 's

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

289 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:36:35 10:36:22 10:36:18 10:36:04 10:35:41

co ntr oll ed by -- I r ead wh ate ver an ybo dy sen ds to the co mmu nic ati on no de th at I a m r esp ons ibl e f or. Q. Wh at com mun ica tio n n ode ar e you

re spo nsi ble fo r? A. Th ere ar e a nu mbe r o f e-m ail

ad dre sse s t hat ar e p ubl icl y di sse min ate d f or the pu bli c t o u se if th ey hav e a n i ssu e r ela tin g t o I P is sue s w ith ou r w ebs ite s. Q. Yo u'r e t he des ign ate d a gen t for

al leg ati ons of al leg ed inf rin gem ent oc cur rin g o n v ari ous of Vi aco m's we bsi tes . A. Ye s. MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. Q. Is th at wha t y ou are r efe rri ng Ob jec tio n a s t o Is tha t r igh t?

to , M r. Sol ow? A. Q. Ye s. Ar e t her e o the r c omm uni cat io n

no des th at you ar e r efe rri ng to th at fo rm the ca pac ity th at you 've be en re fer rin g t o a s c opy rig ht ad min ist rat ion ?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

290 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 10:37:58 10:37:27 10:37:14 10:37:03 10:36:50

MS . K OHL MAN N: ca n a nsw er. A.

Ob jec tio n.

Yo u

So me com mun ica tio ns hav e c om e i n

th e f orm of tr adi tio nal ma il, sn ail ma il. Q. An d b y c omm uni cat ion s, are y ou

re fer rin g t o t ake dow n n oti ces fo r co nta ini ng all ega tio ns of all ege d in fri nge men t o r o the r t ype s o f co mmu nic ati ons ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Y ou can an swe r. It wo uld in clu de bot h t ak edo wn Ob jec tio n a s t o

no tic es in the mi nor ity an d t he va st ma jor ity of th ose co mmu nic ati ons ar e -ar e - - I do n't be lie ve ref er to wh at yo u a re cal lin g a ta ked own no tic e. Q. Wh at wou ld the ot her ty pe s o f

co mmu nic ati ons in clu de? A. Re que sts to li cen se Via com 's

in tel lec tua l p rop ert y, tip s a bou t in fri nge men ts tha t t ake pl ace in ot he r fo rms ot her th an onl ine , s ign ifi can t am oun t o f N ige ria n b ank ers tr yin g t o ge t i n t ouc h w ith me to he lp my

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

390 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:30:09 13:29:55 13:29:29 13:29:16 13:28:56

th rou gh 63. do cum ent ? A.

D o y ou rec ogn ize th is

No t s pec ifi cal ly.

I do

re cog niz e i t a s a no tic e o f in fri nge men t t o V eoh . Q. A. Q. No tic e o f i nfr ing eme nt to Ve oh? Co rre ct. Ho w d id you le arn th at VH 1

ro ckD ocs , t he con ten t i den tif ied in t he ta ked own no tic e a t E xhi bit 6, wa s pr ese nt on Veo h s erv ice ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I don 't hav e a sp eci fic Ob jec tio n a s t o

re col lec tio n h ow I c ame to kn ow it -kn ow how th is par tic ula r c lip wa s on th e V eoh we bsi te. Q. Ar e y ou fam ili ar wit h t he VH 1

pr ogr am, VH 1 R ock Do cs? A. I hav e h ear d o f i t. I ha ve som e

le vel of fa mil iar ity . Q. A. Do cs. Q. Wo uld yo u h ave be en abl e to Ha ve you ev er wat che d i t? I hav e n ot wat che d V H1 Ro ck

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

391 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:31:27 13:31:09 13:30:53 13:30:43 13:30:23

re cog niz e i t a s y ou enc oun ter ed a cli p fr om tha t s how on th e V eoh we bsi te ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Q. A. Q. I may ha ve. Yo u m igh t n ot hav e? I may no t h ave . Do yo u t hin k s imp ly rec og niz ing Ob jec tio n.

it on th e V eoh we bsi te pro vid es en oug h in for mat ion to kn ow whe the r o r n ot a ta ked own no tic e s hou ld be iss ued ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Co uld yo u r epe at tha t q ue sti on? Su re. D o y ou thi nk si mpl y Ob jec tio n a s t o

re cog niz ing th e c ont ent as Vi aco m o wn ed co nte nt on the Ve oh web sit e, ass umi ng on e w as abl e t o d o t hat , w oul d pro vid e en oug h i nfo rma tio n t o b e a ble to s end a ta ked own no tic e t o t he Veo h s erv ice re que sti ng tha t t he con ten t b e r emo ve d? MS . K OHL MAN N: ob jec tio n. A. I rep eat th e

Yo u c an ans wer . I n m an y c ase s

In so me cas es.

po ssi bly ye s. Q. Bu t i n s ome ca ses me rel y kno win g

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

392 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:32:40 13:32:30 13:32:10 13:31:58 13:31:38

th at Via com ow ned th e c ont ent , i f one wa s c apa ble of ma kin g t hat de ter min ati on, th at alo ne wou ldn 't be en oug h? MS . K OHL MAN N: ah ead . A. cl ip. Q. Yo u'r e n ot per son all y f ami li ar It de pen ds on the na tur e of the Ob jec tio n. Go

wi th all of Vi aco m c ont ent , a re yo u? A. I' m n ot per son all y f ami lia r wit h

al l o f V iac om con ten t. Q. An d y ou hav en' t w atc hed a ll of

th e c ont ent Vi aco m o wns , h as pro duc ed or ha s l ice nse d, hav e y ou? A. Q. No . I h ave no t.

Do yo u t hin k y ou cou ld re cog niz e

ev ery cl ip fro m e ver y p iec e o f a ll of Vi aco m's co nte nt? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. No . Do yo u k now ho w m any m oti on Ob jec tio n a s t o

pi ctu res Pa ram oun t h as rel eas ed? A. Th at que sti on is ver y g en era l

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

393 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:34:15 13:34:06 13:33:53 13:33:34 13:33:13

an d t her e a re mul tip le ans wer s t o tha t qu est ion . I w oul d n eed cl ari fic ati on

of yo ur -- the qu est ion to ad equ at ely re spo nd to the qu est ion . Q. Wh at don 't you un der sta nd ab out

th e q ues tio n, Mr. So low ? A. Pa ram oun t P ict ure s h as rel ea sed

th ous and s o f m oti on pic tur es, po ten tia lly th ous and s o f m oti on pi ctu res in th e l ast on e h und red y ear s or ne arl y h und red ye ars . Man y o f tho se

pi ctu res ar e n ot cur ren tly Pa ram oun t Pi ctu res ' p rop ert y. So yo u g et a

di ffe ren t a nsw er dep end ing on wh at it is yo u'r e r eal ly see kin g. Q. I' m j ust se eki ng an ans we r t o m y

qu est ion , M r. Sol ow. A. Ok ay. P ara mou nt Pic tur es ha s I do no t

ge ner ate d s ome wha t - - n o.

kn ow the ex act nu mbe r o f p ict ure s tha t Pa ram oun t P ict ure s h as rel eas ed. Q. Bu t y ou bel iev e i t t o be in the

or der of th ous and s? A. In th e h ist ory of Pa ram ou nt

Pi ctu res ov er the la st hun dre d y ear s,

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

394 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:35:42 13:35:34 13:35:19 13:34:45 13:34:32

th ey hav e p rob abl y p rod uce d i n t he th ous and s o f a sse ts. Q. An d y ou und ers tan d t hat t hey

do n't pr ese ntl y o wn all of th ose f ilm s. Is n't th at rig ht? A. Q. Th at' s c orr ect . Ca n y ou tel l w het her Pa ra mou nt

ow ns a f ilm to day me rel y b y w atc hi ng th e f ilm ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

In th e a bse nce of al l oth er

in for mat ion , a t t ime s i t m igh t b e di ffi cul t. Q. Ot her ti mes it ma y n ot be .

Ca n y ou rec ogn ize ea ch on e o f

th ose fi lms ba sed on fi ve min ute se gme nts of th e f ilm ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Y ou can an swe r. Ce rta inl y n ot eve ry tim e. Ca n y ou ide nti fy eac h o f tho se Ob jec tio n a s t o

fi lms as a Par amo unt fi lm bas ed on th ose sm all se gme nts ? MS . K OHL MAN N: as to fo rm. A. At ti mes , y es. A t t im es, no . Ag ain , O bje cti on

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

395 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:36:59 13:36:42 13:36:26 13:36:06 13:35:55

De pen ds on the na tur e o f t he cli p. Q. An d w hen yo u c an ide nti fy a

sm all cl ip fro m a Pa ram oun t f ilm a s be ing a Par amo unt fi lm, ca n y ou al way s de ter min e w het her or no t t hat cl ip is fr om a f ilm th at Par amo unt cu rre ntl y ow ns or not ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I sus pec t I co uld be s tum ped an d Ob jec tio n a s t o

sa y n ot 100 pe rce nt of the ti me. Q. Ev en if you co uld re cog ni ze tha t

th e s mal l c lip wa s a Pa ram oun t f il m a nd wa s a cl ip fro m a Pa ram oun t f ilm t hat Pa ram oun t c urr ent ly own ed, co uld yo u al way s t ell wh eth er or not th e c li p w as au tho riz ed by Par amo unt to be on Yo uTu be or una uth ori zed by -un aut hor ize d b y P ara mou nt to be on Yo uTu be? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. It wo uld de pen d o n t he na tur e o f Ob jec tio n a s t o

th e c lip . Q. Ho w m any te lev isi on sho ws, b y

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

396 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:38:08 13:37:55 13:37:43 13:37:32 13:37:21

ep iso de, ha ve all of th e M TVN te lev isi on net wor ks rel eas ed com bin ed? A. Q. I don 't kno w. Is th e n umb er gre ate r o r les ser

th an the nu mbe r o f f ilm s t hat Pa ra mou nt ha s r ele ase d, do you th ink ? A. Q. It 's gre ate r. Si gni fic ant ly gre ate r? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I' m n ot awa re of wha t you Ob jec tio n a s t o

co nsi der si gni fic ant . Q. Do yo u c ons ide r i t s ign if ica ntl y

gr eat er, Mr . S olo w? A. Q. Ye s. Ha ve you wa tch ed all of t hos e

ep iso des , M r. Sol ow? A. Q. No . Ca n y ou rec ogn ize ev ery m inu te

of ev ery on e o f t hos e e pis ode s? A. Q. No . Do es Via com st ill ow n t he ri ght s

to ev ery one of th ose ep iso des to day ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

397 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:39:07 13:38:59 13:38:46 13:38:25 13:38:19

A. Q.

I don 't kno w. Wo uld yo u b e a ble to t ell

wh eth er or not Vi aco m o wne d t he ri ght s to th ose ep iso des me rel y b y v iew ing a sm all cl ip, as sum ing yo u c oul d t ell t he cl ip was fr om one of th ose ep iso de s t o be gin wi th? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. No . As sum ing yo u c oul d r eco gni ze Ob jec tio n a s t o

th at one of th ose cl ips wa s f rom a Vi aco m o wne d M TVN ep iso de, co uld yo u te ll mer ely by lo oki ng at the cl ip wh eth er or not th e c lip wa s a uth or ize d to be on th e Y ouT ube se rvi ce? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n o n.

If it we re an une dit ed cl ip my

as sum pti on wou ld be tha t i t w as un aut hor ize d. Q. Bu t t hat as sum pti on wou ldn 't

al way s b e r igh t, wou ld it? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Ri ght . In the sa me ma nne r t hat Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

398 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 13:40:08 13:39:59 13:39:50 13:39:46 13:39:21

wh en I c ros s t he str eet , a nd the re 's a re d l igh t I ma ke an ass ump tio n t ha t t he ca rs wil l s top an d I am ri ght a dr ama tic am oun t o f t he tim e. As I sa id

ea rli er, th ere ar e f ew abs olu tes in t he wo rld . Q. Ar e y ou fam ili ar wit h a ll th e

co nte nt pro duc ed by bet ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. No . Ha ve you wa tch ed all th e con ten t Ob jec tio n a s t o

pr odu ced by BE T? A. Q. No . Wo uld yo u b e a ble to r eco gni ze

it on si te? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. S orr y. I apo log ize . Unl ike ly. Ob jec tio n a s t o

Wo uld yo u b e a ble to r eco gni ze

sm all se gme nts of an y g ive n p iec e of BE T c ont ent on si te? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. So met ime s. So met ime s n ot. Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

413 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:40:57 14:40:50 14:40:38 14:40:17 14:40:10

ri ght ? MS . K OHL MAN N: Mi sst ate s t he rec ord . A. Ob jec tio n. You ca n a ns wer .

Im por tan ce is a s ubj ect ive w ord

bu t t hat ce rta inl y i s i nfo rma tio n t ha t I' d l ike to ha ve. Q. Wh at val ue doe s t hat in fo rma tio n

pr ovi de to you in th e e xec uti on of yo ur re spo nsi bil iti es at Via com ? A. It ad ds an inc rea sed le ve l o f

pr eci sio n. Q. A. In wh at sen se? It he lps mi tig ate th e r em ova l o f

cl ips th at som e p art s o f t he or gan iza tio n w oul d p ref er to sta y i n pl ace . Q. It pr eve nts Vi aco m f rom

mi sta ken ly rem ovi ng con ten t t hat it it sel f h as aut hor ize d t o b e o n t he se rvi ce. I sn' t t hat ri ght ? Ob jec tio n a s t o

MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A.

Th ose ar e y our wo rds .

I

an swe red th at usi ng my wor ds a m om ent ag o.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

414 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:41:59 14:41:32 14:41:21 14:41:12 14:41:05

Q.

Is th ere an yth ing in acc ura te

ab out wh at I s aid ? A. I pre fer to sp eak wi th my ow n

wo rds an d n ot ano the r p ers on' s w ord s. So I' ll sti ck wit h t he ans wer I us ed or igi nal ly. Q. Is th ere an yth ing in acc ura te

ab out wh at I s aid ? A. I hav e n o i dea . I 'd pr efe r m y

wo rds an d n ot you rs. Q. I' m j ust tr yin g t o g et so me

cl ari ty her e, Mr. So low . A. I thi nk the be st way t o g et

cl ari ty is to acc ept th e w ord s t ha t I us e. Q. Bu t d o y ou see a dif fe ren ce

be twe en the ve rsi on of you r s tat eme nt an d m ine ? A. I don 't kno w h ow you d efi ne the I kno w h ow I S o I 'm

wo rds th at you us e.

de fin e t he wor ds tha t I us e.

mo re com for tab le usi ng the wo rds th at co me out of my mo uth . Q. Vi aco m h ire s t hir d p art ies t o

up loa d c ont ent to Yo uTu be fro m t ime t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

415 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:43:47 14:43:28 14:43:14 14:42:21 14:42:13

ti me. A. Q.

I sn' t t hat ri ght ? I bel iev e t hat to be s o. Is in for mat ion re lat ed to th at

ac tiv ity al so pro vid ed to you r de par tme nt? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. In for mat ion of th at var iet y has Ob jec tio n a s t o

be en pro vid ed to my dep art men t. Q. Do yo u a lso in str uct Mr . Hou sle y

to ma int ain in for mat ion re lat ed to th at ac tiv ity ? A. Q. Ye s. Ha ve you ev er hea rd the t erm ,

Mr . S olo w, whi te lis t? A. Q. Ye s. Wh at do you un der sta nd th e t erm

wh ite li st to mea n? A. Q. In wh at con tex t? In th e c ont ext in wh ich y ou

he ard it in yo ur emp loy men t c apa cit y at Vi aco m. A. I' ve hea rd our ap pro ved o uts ide

co uns el lis t r efe rre d t o i n t hat l ist , pr efe rre d v end or lis ts, I' ve hea rd

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

416 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:45:02 14:44:53 14:44:39 14:44:25 14:44:10

li sts of vi deo co nte nt tha t w e w ou ld li ke, th at has be en aut hor ize d f or pl ace men t i n v ari ous lo cat ion s o n t he in ter net re fer red to in th at reg ard al so. Q. Ha ve you al so hea rd lis ts of

au tho riz ed use r n ame s f rom wh om po sti ngs to we bsi tes su ch as You Tub e sh oul d n ot be rem ove d r efe rre d t o as a wh ite li st? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I' ve hea rd of -- not l ist s o f Ob jec tio n a s t o

us er nam es but th at use r n ame -- u ser na mes ha ve bee n a co mpo nen t o f s uc h wh ite li sts , y es. Q. Is th e i nfo rma tio n t hat

Mr . H ous ley co mpi les , t hat we we re ju st re fer rin g t o a mo men t a go, re fer red t o as a whi te lis t? A. Q. A. Q. By so me peo ple . By yo u, Mr. So low ? Ge ner all y n ot. Ha ve you ev er ref err ed to th at

as a whi te lis t?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

417 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:46:13 14:45:55 14:45:43 14:45:29 14:45:15

A.

I may ha ve bee n o n

co mmu nic ati ons wh ere th e t erm is us ed bu t I ge ner all y t ry to avo id it be cau se I fin d i t o ffe nsi ve. Q. Wh at do you fi nd off ens iv e a bou t

th at ter m? A. I see a rac ial co mpo nen t in the

en tom olo gy of tha t p hra se tha t I f ind of fen siv e. Q. In ter est ing . It is a ter m t hat

is us ed at Via com to de scr ibe , a s you ex pla ine d, con ten t t hat 's bee n au tho riz ed to be on the Yo uTu be se rvi ce an d s hou ld not be re mov ed, th oug h, ri ght ? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I hav e n ote d t he use o f t he ter m Ob jec tio n a s t o

wh ite li st and va rio us usa ges at Vi aco m. I oft en mak e m y o bje cti on s

kn own th en als o. Q. We ll, to be cl ear , g oin g for war d

in th e l ine of qu est ion ing th at I' m go ing to as k y ou abo ut, I may r efe r t o th at phr ase fr om tim e t o t ime ,

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

418 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:47:01 14:46:49 14:46:42 14:46:32 14:46:22

ce rta inl y n ot mea nt to rel ay any r aci al ov ert one wh ats oev er. I 'm sim ply

re fer rin g t o i t b eca use it is th e way Vi aco m h as ref err ed to it in doc um ent s pr odu ced to us an d w e w ant to m ake su re we ar e c ons ist ent wi th the in ter nal te rmi nol ogy , t o t he ext ent th ere ar e ot her wa ys of ref err ing to it in -h ous e, I und ers tan d t hat it ma y b e d one t hat wa y, for ea se of ref ere nce in th e de pos iti on. A. Q. I com ple tel y u nde rst and th at . Yo ur con ten t b ase d o bje cti on is

du ly not ed and I can se e t he ba sis fo r it . A. Q. I und ers tan d. Pl eas e t ake no of fen se of th e

us e o f t he ter m t oda y. A. Q. I won 't. Bu t d o y ou und ers tan d w ha t I

me an whe n I re fer to wh ite li st in th e co nte xt of the up loa din g a cti vit y t ha t Vi aco m a nd its ag ent s h ave do ne an d a re do ing on th e Y ouT ube we bsi te? MS . K OHL MAN N: Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

419 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:48:13 14:47:56 14:47:38 14:47:31 14:47:19

fo rm. A. I -- I a m f ami lia r a nd -- wi th

th e u se of tha t t erm in so me qu art ers ar oun d t he com pan y f or pur pos es, in clu din g o nli ne pos tin g o f c lip s. Q. An d i t w on' t l ead to a ny

am big uit y i f I us e t hat te rm in co nne cti on wit h t he You Tub e w ebs ite i n qu est ion ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. wo n't . Q. A. Q. Ob jec tio n.

Th e u se of the te rm it sel f The co nte xt may -Of co urs e. Of co urs e.

-- ma y b e d iff ere nt. I wan t t o m ake su re we ha ve the

us e o f t he ter m i tse lf gro und ed. A. Q. wa y. Ye s. I g ot you . No w t hat we go t t hat o ut of the Yo u i ndi cat ed a m ome nt ago t hat

Mi cha el Hou sle y, at you r d ire cti on, ma int ain s a se t o f i nfo rma tio n r ela te d to th e u plo adi ng act ivi ty of Via com a nd it s a gen ts on the in ter net in clu din g on th e Y ouT ube we bsi te. A. Th at' s c orr ect . I s t hat ri gh t?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

420 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:49:07 14:49:02 14:48:53 14:48:39 14:48:25

Q.

Do yo u k now if th at in for mat ion

is pr ovi ded to Ba yTS P? A. Q. Ba yTS P? A. Q. Ye s. Ho w i s t hat in for mat ion p rov ide d Ye s. Is th at inf orm ati on pro vid ed to

to Ba yTS P? A. Q. I' m n ot sur e. Ha ve you ev er rec eiv ed th at

in for mat ion vi a e -ma il? A. Ca n y ou rep hra se the qu es tio n?

I' m n ot sur e w hat in for mat ion yo u'r e re fer rin g t o. Q. Ho w d oes Mi cha el Hou sle y sto re

th at inf orm ati on? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I bel iev e h e s tor es it Ob jec tio n a s t o

el ect ron ica lly . Q. In wh at for m d oes Mi cha el

Ho usl ey sto re tha t i nfo rma tio n el ect ron ica lly ? A. Q. I' m n ot sur e. Is it ma int ain ed in a dat aba se?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

421 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:50:18 14:50:01 14:49:47 14:49:31 14:49:19

A. Q.

I' m n ot sur e. Is it ma int ain ed in an Ex cel

sp rea d s hee t? A. Q. It co uld be bu t I 'm no t s ure . Ha ve you ev er req ues ted t hat

Mr . H ous ley pr ovi de you wi th tha t in for mat ion ? A. fo r i t. Q. An d y ou hav e n o i dea , as you si t I hav e n o r eco lle cti on of as kin g

he re tod ay, wh eth er he eve r s ent i t t o yo u? A. I hav e n o r eco lle cti on of He s its so

Mi cha el sen din g i t t o m e.

cl ose to me th at if I w ant ed to se e so met hin g, I h ave a hab it of goi ng an d in vad ing hi s p ers ona l s pac e a nd loo ki ng ov er his sh oul der an d t hin gs. Q. Ot her th an Bay TSP do yo u kno w i f

th ere is an y o the r t hir d p art ies o r Vi aco m a gen ts to who m t hat in for mat io n ha s b een pr ovi ded ? A. I don 't hav e s pec ifi c k no wle dge

of th at but I wou ldn 't be sur pri se d. Q. Ca n y ou ide nti fy any th ir d

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

422 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:51:30 14:51:21 14:51:09 14:50:49 14:50:31

pa rti es or Via com ag ent s t o w hom t hat in for mat ion ha s b een pr ovi ded as yo u si t h ere to day ? A. I bel iev e i t w oul d b e pro vid ed

to Gl oba l. Q. Ot her th an Via com 's age nts w ho

ar e i nvo lve d w ith id ent ify ing Vi aco m co nte nt on the in ter net , d o y ou kn ow if it 's eve r b een pr ovi ded to an y o th er Vi aco m a gen ts or any ot her th ird pa rti es? A. As a lis t? Wh at -- I don 't

un der sta nd the ob jec t o f t he sen ten ce , wh at hav e I pr ovi ded ? we 're pr ovi din g? Q. Th e i nfo rma tio n c ont ain ed in Wha t i s it tha t

wh at Mic hae l H ous ley ag gre gat es at yo ur di rec tio n r ega rdi ng the up loa din g ac tiv ity of Vi aco m a nd its ag ent s on th e Y ouT ube we bsi te and on th e i nt ern et ge ner all y. MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Fo r c lar ity , a re we tal ki ng Ob jec tio n a s t o

di sse min ati on of a l ist th at Mic hae l

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

423 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:52:48 14:52:24 14:52:11 14:51:52 14:51:42

Ho usl ey has cr eat ed or are we ta lk ing ab out th e u pst rea m f rom th at? st rea m o f t hat ? I'm st ill no t D ow n

un der sta ndi ng wha t i t i s t hat yo u'r e as kin g i s b ein g d iss emi nat ed. Q. Le t's fo cus fi rst on th e

in for mat ion be ing di sse min ate d a s ag gre gat ed by Mr. Ho usl ey. MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

Ca n y ou -- now , c an yo u r epo se

th e q ues tio n? Q. Su re. I n t he for m a s agg reg ate d

by Mr . H ous ley at yo ur dir ect ion , do yo u k now if th e d ata re gar din g V ia com an d i ts age nts up loa din g a cti vit y o f Vi aco m c ont ent on th e i nte rne t in clu din g Y ouT ube ha s b een pr ovi ded t o an y V iac om age nt or oth er thi rd pa rty , ot her th an tho se tha t a re inv olv ed in mo nit ori ng the in ter net fo r V iac om co nte nt? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. Ye s. Pl eas e i den tif y t hem ? Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

424 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:55:02 14:54:44 14:53:46 14:53:28 14:53:04

A.

I bel iev e t hat it ha s bee n

pr ovi ded to Je nne r & Bl ock an d S he rma n & Ste rli ng. Q. Do yo u k now wh en tha t

in for mat ion wa s p rov ide d t o y our co uns el in thi s a cti on? A. No t s pec ifi cal ly, no . MR . R UBI N: Su san , I 'll as k

ri ght no w t hat in for mat ion be pr odu ce d in th e c ase . If you wa nt to me et and

co nfe r a bou t i t I 'm hap py to do so . It 's pla inl y r esp ons ive . Q. Ot her th an the pa rtn ers y ou' ve

id ent ifi ed thu s f ar, an d s ett ing as id e th ose th at are in vol ved in mo nit ori ng th e i nte rne t f or Via com co nte nt, ca n yo u i den tif y a ny oth ers to wh om th at da ta has be en pro vid ed? A. Q. No . Do yo u b eli eve th at set o f d ata

is co mpr ehe nsi ve, Mr . S olo w? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. Q. I don 't kno w. Wh at lea ds you to be u nab le to Ob jec tio n a s t o

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

425 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 14:56:35 14:56:10 14:55:46 14:55:30 14:55:16

co ncl ude th at the da ta pro vid ed to yo u fr om Via com su bsi dia rie s a nd Via com ag ent s r ega rdi ng the ir upl oad ac tiv ity wi th res pec t t o V iac om con ten t o n the in ter net an d o n Y ouT ube mi ght no t be co mpr ehe nsi ve? MS . K OHL MAN N: Mi sst ate s t he rec ord . A. Ob jec tio n. You ca n a ns wer .

Wh en one do esn 't kno w t he ex ten t

of th e u niv ers e o f a da ta set i t's ha rd to ma ke a d ete rmi nat ion th at som eth in g is mi ssi ng. Q. Ha ve you ha d a ny exp eri en ce tha t

le ads yo u t o c onc lud e t hat da ta ha s be en, fr om tim e t o t ime , b een mi ss ing fr om tha t d ata se t? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A. I can 't rec all an in sta nc e w her e Ob jec tio n a s t o

an in sta nce or ev ent th at pla yed o ut wh ich le d m e t o b eli eve th at. Q. Is th is dat a s et che cke d pri or

to th e s end ing of a tak edo wn not ic e f or a giv en pie ce of con ten t t o i nsu re th at th at con ten t i s n ot aut hor ize d t o be on

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

505 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:15:15 17:15:04 17:14:41 17:14:19 17:14:04

ac tio n b ear ing Ba tes nu mbe r B ayT SP 00 433 298 . do cum ent ? A. Q. No . Fo r t he rec ord , i t i s an e-m ail Do you re cog niz e t his

se nt by Cou rtn ey Nie man to yo u a nd Mi che len a H all ie amo ng oth ers on Fe bru ary 17 , 2 007 wi th the su bje ct li ne re vie w. A. Q. Do yo u s ee tha t? Ye s. Ms . N iem an wri tes to yo u,

"P lea se dis reg ard pr evi ous re que st. .. th is vid eo bel ong s t o W ire dse t, a pr evi ous ac cou nt. " A. Q. Ye s. Ba sed on te sti mon y e arl ier t oda y Do you se e t ha t?

it 's my und ers tan din g t hat yo u'r e a wa re th at Wir eds et was hi red to up loa d au tho riz ed con ten t o n b eha lf of Via co m to Yo uTu be. I sn' t t hat ri ght ? Ob jec tio n a s t o

MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A.

I' m a war e t hat Wi red set h as bee n

au tho riz ed to upl oad vi deo s f rom ti me to ti me, ye s.

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

506 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:16:53 17:16:36 17:16:22 17:16:03 17:15:34

Q.

So ho w i s i t y ou wer e una ble to

id ent ify th at the vi deo in Ex hib it 21 , pa ge end ing 96 6 w as an aut hor ize d vid eo up loa ded by Wi red set ? MS . K OHL MAN N: Mi sst ate s t he rec ord . A. I don 't see an y r efe ren ce to Ob jec tio n.

Wi red set in th e p iec e o f i nfo rma tio n th at you as ked me to lo ok at. Q. So th e s et of met ada ta pr ovi ded

an d s et for th in Exh ibi t 2 1, pag e 966 wh ich yo u'r e l ook ing at no w f or th e vi deo at is sue , v ide o t itl e v ide o le ngt h, tim e s tam p, las t s een da te, U RL an d u ser na me, is in suf fic ien t f or yo u to ma ke the de ter min ati on whe the r o r no t t he vid eo is aut hor ize d? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Ob jec tio n.

I' ve nev er bee n a ske d t o mak e a n

id ent ifi cat ion ba sed on it ems on a re por t b efo re, so I don 't kno w. T his

is no t - - t his be ars no re lev anc e to an y d uty I' ve eve r b een as ked to pe rfo rm. Q. I' m a ski ng you ri ght no w, he re

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

507 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:17:56 17:17:47 17:17:25 17:17:11 17:17:04

no w t oda y w het her ba sed on th e in for mat ion se t f ort h i n t his do cum en t fo r t his vi deo it 's suf fic ien t f or yo u to ma ke a d ete rmi nat ion wh eth er or no t th e v ide o i s a uth ori zed ? MS . K OHL MAN N: an d a nsw ere d. A. Fr om thi s I ca n't ev en de ter min e I t s ays v ide o Ob jec tio n. As ked

if th ere is a vid eo.

ti tle bu t I do n't ha ve a c lip i n f ron t of me . I d on' t e ven un der sta nd yo ur I h ave al mos t non e

qu est ion , f ran kly .

of th e - - I do n't ha ve the mo st im por tan t i nfo rma tio n t hat wo uld be av ail abl e t o u s t o e ven be gin ma ki ng a de ter min ati on, th e c lip . So no , I 've ne ver at tem pte d t o ma ke a d ete rmi nat ion of -- on a cl ip ba sed on me tad ata al one on a cli p. do n't ha ve the to ols to do th at, n o. Q. Do yo u b eli eve th at tex t I

me tad ata al one is in suf fic ien t t o m ak e a det erm ina tio n w het her or no t a v ide o is au tho riz ed to be on the Yo uTu be se rvi ce?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

508 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:18:51 17:18:44 17:18:34 17:18:28 17:18:14

MS . K OHL MAN N: fo rm. A.

Ob jec tio n a s t o

It wo uld be su b o pti mal t o m ake

a dec isi on on a c lip wi tho ut any - wi tho ut acc ess to so meb ody wh o h as se en a cli p o r h avi ng the cl ip ava ila bl e t o so meb ody wh o h as had so me inv olv eme nt . I don 't kno w. do n't kn ow. Q. A. Q. Wh at add iti ona l - Se ems di ffi cul t. Wh at add iti ona l i nfo rma tio n I' ve not tr ied . So I

wo uld yo u n eed , M r. Sol ow? A. Q. A. Q. I' d l ike to se e t he cl ip. A thu mbn ail of th e c lip ? I' d l ike to se e t he cl ip. Wh en you sa y s ee the c lip , I 'm

tr yin g t o u nde rst and wh at you me an, y ou me an wat ch the en tir e c lip ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. he re. Q. Wh at mor e t han yo u h ave h ere at Ob jec tio n.

I wou ld lik e m ore th an I hav e

th e p age en din g i n 9 66 on Exh ibi t 21 wo uld yo u l ike to ha ve?

DAVID FELDMAN WORLDWIDE, INC. 450 Seventh Avenue - Ste 2803, New York, NY 10123 [phone]

509 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 17:19:41 17:19:30 17:19:24 17:19:14 17:19:03

A. cl ip.

We ll, I wou ld lik e t o hav e t he I wo uld li ke to hav e t he cr eat or

of th e a sse t I th ink it be lon gs to an d pe rso n w ho upl oad ed it sit tin g n ext t o me to o b ut the cl ip is a g ood p lac e t o st art . Thi s i s n ot eno ugh in for ma tio n,

ge ner all y s pea kin g, to mak e a de ter min ati on. Q. Wo uld yo u w ant to wa tch t he cli p

if yo u h ad it? MS . K OHL MAN N: fo r s pec ula tio n. A. We ll, if I had th e c li p I th ink I wou ldn 't I m ean I' d Ob jec tio n. Ca lls

th at I w oul d w atc h i t, yes . ma ke a s and wic h o ut of it. wa tch it . Q.

Yo u'd wa tch it al l t he wa y

th rou gh, ri ght ? MS . K OHL MAN N: A. Sa me obj ect ion . I

I don 't kno w w hat I' d do.

th ink I wou ld mak e t hos e - - I 'd ma ke th ose de cis ion s a s I wa s v iew ing t he cl ip. I do n't th ink th at I'd n eed to

ma ke th