The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 317

DECLARATION of MICHAEL RUBIN in Support re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 162 - 177, # 2 Exhibit 178 - 180, # 3 Exhibit 181 - 184, # 4 Exhibit 185, # 5 Exhibit 186 - 191, # 6 Exhibit 192 - 355)(Schapiro, Andrew)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC., ET AL., ) ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) ) YOUTUBE, INC., ET AL., ) ) Defendants. ) ) THE FOOTBALL ASSOCIATION ) PREMIER LEAGUE LIMITED, ET AL., on ) behalf of themselves and all others similarly ) situated, ) ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) ) YOUTUBE, INC., ET AL., ) ) Defendants. ) )

ECF Case Civil No. 07-CV-2103 (LLS)

ECF Case Civil No. 07-CV-3582 (LLS)

SUPPLEMENT TO REPLY DECLARATION OF MICHAEL RUBIN IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Rubin Reply Exhibit 72

Rubin Reply Exhibit 73

Rubin Reply Exhibit 74

Rubin Reply Exhibit 75

YouTube - Gonna Make Sweat

Browse

Upload

Create Account

Sign In

Gonna Make Sweat
chu2007 1 videos
Slugs and Snails attack of the crow 3d animation 425,968 views
strag1 Featured Video

pump it (performin' by the slugs)
347,985 views laneykhu

Ma-ia-hii Ma-ia-huu Ma-iahaa Ma-ia -ha-ha
9,043,1 13 views superbkid

C & C Music Factory Freedom W illiams- Gonna
843,843 views Castivaz

FLUSHED AWAY animation Movie Trailer
105,886 views moviepreviews4U

Gonna Make You Sweat (Everybody Dance Now)
49,205 views puppiechow6

1, 094 , 618
chu2007 -- October 05, 2006 -- Singing Dancing Slugs - see fixed sync version at http://www .youtube.com /watc... view s

bébé shrek
8,554,7 83 views lohyt

Category:
Film & Animation

chick
27,713,997 views coyotitoyo

Tags:
slugs animation dance music comedy movie trailer clip sing funny

Dancing Slugs - Made by a 6yo
315,734 views gonzosj

Loading... Respond to this video...

Everybody Dance Now! Slugs!
68,237 views daninhampshire

i dont feel like dancing
98,850 views antolarra

Highest Rated Comments
chicihrii
3 years ago 36

Videos Animados
4,591,0 11 views igorbz

OMG sooooooooooooooo funny

hippywawa
3 years ago 21

awsome!

Kiwi!
26,413,947 views Madyeti47

Evolution of Dance All Comments (187)
sweetangelgirl122681
3 years ago 20

see all Very cute!!

10,410,211 views facundisimo

Dancing Slugs
lol. This video was featured on news.
3,341,5 58 views LULAWKA

eunicep79
3 years ago 16

Elbenno2
3 years ago 17

LO L! I love it!

Keith Sweat - Make You Sweat (12" UK Remix)
24,458 views nkzeroG

Ch28Kid
3 years ago 16

om g thats so cute love it This is from the movie fushed away

gonna make you sweat ;)
10,359 views IrvMstr

Froggy5
3 years ago 13

UB40 GIRL I WANT TO MAKE YOU SWEAT
65,562 views limegreendarlene

Froggy5
3 years ago 12

Tis is from the movie Flushed away

Wpuszczony w kanal- Dont worry be happy
19,391 views ErnikeK

Next

View all Comm ents »

monkey farts!
7,296,4 54 views pussydribble

Help

About

Safety

Privacy

Terms

Copyright

Uploaders & Partners

Developers

Advertising

Language: English

Location: Worldwide

Safety mode: Off

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7W3bxHFShw

6/3/2010

Rubin Reply Exhibit 76

Video ID V i d e o Ti tl e Le n g th ( Se c o n d s) D ate V id e o U p lo ad e d Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t U se r n a m e D a te Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t C r e ate d Sig n u p E m ail Sig n u p I P Vid e o I D V i d e o Ti tl e Le n g th ( Se c o n d s) D ate V id e o U p lo ad e d Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t U se r n a m e D a te Yo u Tu b e A c c o u n t C r e ate d Sig n u p E m ail Sig n u p I P

lvA6oabsA_E new clips from MTV2's Wonder Showzen 52 2/21/2006 mosjef73 2/17/2006 [e-mail] 166.77.6.4 x-Igybtxczk New Clip from MTV2's The Andy Milonakis Show 150 2/21/2006 mosjef73 2/17/2006 [e-mail] 166.77.6.4

Rubin Reply Exhibit 77

Rubin Reply Exhibit 78

Rubin Reply Exhibit 79

Expanded Wilkens Declaration Table
Wilkins Decl. VideoID Exhibit 1 2 3 4 Mey5E9B-hHs 2zXpVsZEk0Q CnWrOdaeZfM iZaKWmLYUas Duration Alleged (min: Work in sec) Suit 10:56 3:05 9:58 9:39 South Park, Episode 1102 Grease Daria, Episode 101 The Godfather MTV Video Music Awards, 2007 Dora the Explorer, Episode 119 How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days Beavis & Butthead, Episode 303 Braveheart Chappelle's Show, Episode 102

Video Title cartman sucks part one Grease We Go Together

Uploader Username redshadowizbak catch0621

Uploader Email

Upload Date 3/15/2007 12/7/2006 8/23/2007 7/24/2007

Aniversy Daria 101 Part 2 The Godfather I Sjenova - Part 8 Britney Spears VMA 2007 "Gimme More" Dora the Explorer wishing star How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days (Part 1) Cornholio! BraveHeart Wallace Defeat's The First Garrison Tyrone Biggums in School temamoda

5

6nJNHYOsxXo

3:35

9/18/2007

6 7 8

L5wQ_ehwl4A JZJuAWslb44 7uHO3jdxdkA

10:20 9:43 6:02

patbtr thetalkingdude PimpyD12

8/8/2008 11/16/2006 2/7/2008

9

Bwf8ETBW64U 7:57

kcmmdr

7/5/2006

10

jeL4-kTIAJY

4:37

Jay1126

9/28/2006

Wilkins Decl. VideoID Exhibit 11 39FNJprqvXs

Duration Alleged (min: Work in sec) Suit 1:45 Titanic Clarissa Explains It All, Episode 103 Raiders of the Lost Ark The Hills, Episode 102 Beverly Hills Cop BET Awards, 2006 The Addams Family Spongebob Squarepants, Episode 4A An Inconvenient Truth The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,

Video Title Titanic - floating door scene Clarissa Explains it All (No T.V.) Part 2 of 3 Raiders of the Lost Ark Opening of the Ark the-hills-s01e2pt3 Beverly Hills Cop (Part Three) Beyonce at the BET Awards 2006 The Addams Family Part 9/10 Spongebob and Patrick Fighting An Inconvenient Truth (Full Movie) NY Daily News names Jon as one of their 'Best Dressed'

Uploader Username RivuChan

Uploader Email

Upload Date 1/11/2007

12

aTRZ26db1XY

9:10

picklesnr1989

12/14/2007

13

B5UOfWjv6hs

2:34

YanDaMan263

12/4/2007

14 15 16 17

EdcIXGe4Oco iLkyOWykXGs j8Wxc0uVcs4 9tLPoJ47lG0

4:14 9:53 3:51 9:59

clauditaalvarado Tripler112593 NevilleKlaassens cathhyy

8/9/2006 5/3/2007 11/1/2007 10/12/2008

18

GE7z11qMobE

2:55

opperkerty

6/8/2007

19

CAl8KEOaTgg

96:26

sssukkk

12/11/2006

20

1WLhUJSxIbk

1:59

badgermushroom2

1/11/2007

-2-

Rubin Reply Exhibit 80

Metadata Regarding Clips Dismissed from Suit by Viacom

Rubin Reply Decl. Ex. No. 314A/B

VideoID

Duration (min: sec) 2:02

Work in Suit Chappelle's Show (104) Comedy Central Presents (1016) Comedy Central Presents (902) ZODIAC Drawn Together (105) DRILLBIT TAYLOR iCarly (102) Jackass (102) Jackass (203)

Video Title Dave Chappelle NY Boobs Old Jon Reep Reel best of comedy central (stand-up) part 3 Zodiac en DVD extrait 3 valetines day videos Don Tales Two Lincoln Hires Ninjas! (Drillbit Taylor) opening icarly Jackass 2/3 ver. Latinoamerica [Sub] Jackass Party Boy Full

Uploader Username Fueri86

Uploader Email

Upload Date 8/28/2007

Le52xv31TTM

313A/B

L6a_iKo83RE

6:38

GrinReeper

8/3/2006

330A/B

qFXAl0IQiM4

8:21

ant1film

4/9/2008

312A/B 349A/B

kg2WUirHOhw xiFajP-KVzE

1:12 8:45

waytobluefrance Drawntogetherfan08

11/20/2007 2/13/2008

282A/B

aWt-fduKFmo

1:46

tastefullymine

3/7/2008

342A/B 270A/B 320A/B

vlQhux5mXfY 6WhsXvOe2IU n8wDRoQkN1c

1:02 7:27 3:42

juan940513 BoLiVaGaNDo heyepl

10/6/2008 3/22/2008 4/19/2007

Rubin Reply Decl. Ex. No.

VideoID

Duration (min: sec)

Work in Suit

Video Title

Uploader Username

Uploader Email

Upload Date

317A/B

mJkGJQyDNQ0

1:59

343A/B

WBxZLCDm2uo

7:33

285A/B

BrCI7t5SU-s

8:33

LARRY THE CABLE Larry the Cable GUY: Guy HEALTH INSPECTOR Punk'd MarathonAshley Tisdale Punk'd (802) JoJo - Zac Efron [Part 2] Reno 911! Dangle's Stolen (201) Bike Shorties Watchin' Shorties (112) South Park (101) South Park (1111) Storytellers (44) Strangers With Candy (307) SWEENEY TODD this is the entire collection of Dane Cook's shorties watching shorties videos. South Park Kennys Tode Staffel 1 Imagination Land Alanis Morissette - Q&A 2 Strangers With Candy Sweeney Todd extrait 3

nutbusternut

7/8/2006

ChingDude

10/13/2007

DeathToTNA

4/13/2008

352A/B

YbCNhLX-mi8

09:21

sylar38

8/31/2007

301A/B 318A/B 281A/B 345A/B 344A/B

hhXlVDxYzvg N-4MT9u6LUs aUonqu5RIcM wfWEjb3DtV0

5:48 8:30 4:06 2:15

okkihaase garrettc134 iAMmin3 FCSoles waytobluefrance

5/23/2008 1/9/2008 7/1/2008 1/6/2008 9/22/2008

wcHwE01xHNU 1:10

-2-

Rubin Reply Decl. Ex. No. 280A/B

VideoID

Duration (min: sec)

Work in Suit The Colbert Report (3033) The Hollow Men (102)

Video Title the colbert report 1/5 SuperMoviesDow nload.com Police Interview

Uploader Username

Uploader Email

Upload Date

aITz05jvTlk

4:17

freeforlife112

3/13/2007

295A/B

F-vuYx6d1XM

3:02

davidarmand

11/28/2006

-3-

Rubin Reply Exhibit 81

Comparison of Video Clips Viacom Has Withdrawn from the Case to Those that Remain Clips In Suit

Work in Suit

Dismissed Clip (Video ID)

Dismissed Clip Uploader Username

Locate d at Ex.

Clip in Suit (Video ID)

Clip in Suit Uploader Username

Clip In Suit Ex. No.

Nature of Similarity

Drillbit Taylor Drillbit Taylor Drillbit Taylor Drillbit Taylor Drillbit Taylor The Heartbreak Kid The Heartbreak Kid The Heartbreak Kid Hot Rod Hot Rod Iron Man

5kWtyVo-8k0 5kWtyVo-8k0 sxNuomEUG G0 sxNuomEUG G0 AgGf_xso0HI

tastefullymine tastefullymine tastefullymine tastefullymine tastefullymine

269A/B 269A/B 335A/B 335A/B 279A/B

05-rpbKib-c 28xcyE87EWM 2dZ66NoxefY 2x1i2SCkRh0 a4nSnBS-Yno

vthokiesfan2 XBloodyMelyX drillbit001 Pawfict themightykop13

255A/B 260A/B 261A/B 262A/B 274A/B

Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format

g5ce_rOoGcc

dreamworksfansite

297A/B

jgg9pIPqcuk

BlueViperz

308A/B

g5ce_rOoGcc

dreamworksfansite

297A/B

SHWybzGNlIQ

weliveonlyto

333A/B

g5ce_rOoGcc 6xFe570faSI 6xFe570faSI DUTtBxd2KP

dreamworksfansite HotRodMovie HotRodMovie waytobluetube

297A/B 271A/B 271A/B 291A/B

z0d_wjgerjM _zPnAMSIz0I 4ImcoZoPHdY 7FZx2Ykf0l0

geojospaog13 itrulyamloved crazyosgood martoralho

354A/B 254A/B 267A/B 272A/B

Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format Indistinguishable in kind and format Indistinguishable in kind and format Identical

-1-

Work in Suit

Dismissed Clip (Video ID) Q

Dismissed Clip Uploader Username

Locate d at Ex.

Clip in Suit (Video ID)

Clip in Suit Uploader Username

Clip In Suit Ex. No.

Nature of Similarity

Jamie Kennedy's Blowin Up (101) Jamie Kennedy's Blowin Up (103) Sweeney Todd The Andy Milonakis Show Transformer s Transformer s Transformer s Transformer s Transformer s Transformer s

k6CSyIS5528

BrienTA

311A/B

zdvpptWbSv4

jkss1

355A/B

Identical

88XvlfKnGwI Gy3TrIlnTvA

BrienTA dreamworksfansite

273A/B 299A/B

rjQ3idh6Whk _HdZSFiXfDs LNKunwTCtH A 4j3nWwCY4N Q rSVdjKXmVDo i6nh-vJl3n0 ijN91rPxcMo JF5XI1hJ_30 1JqB_xvmWXw

jkss1 Kaliyagain

331A/B 252A/B

Identical Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format Identical Identical Identical Indistinguishable in kind and format Indistinguishable in kind and format Indistinguishable in kind and format

_sTgT76i3vc gxjpdGjv59o hfPAw9MM6 9A hfPAw9MM6 9A xWCkluxpG W8 j4A-BqFSSL8 1168T5BsmV Y

mosjef73 dreamworksfansite dreamworksfansite dreamworksfansite dreamworksfansite dreamworksfansite dreamworksfansite

253A/B 298A/B 300A/B 300A/B 351A/B 306A/B 258A/B

milonakis4evar way2blue yugiohtcgcollecto r02 headonisthebest coolbuddybk Domovix chipdog

316A/B 268A/B 332A/B 304A/B 305A/B 307A/B 259A/B

-2-

Rubin Reply Exhibit 82

From: Date: To:

"heather gilette" [e-mail]::
Mon, 17 Apr 200612:19:52 -0700

[e-mail]::
YouTube Content Verification Tool

Subject:

login and instructions...

Dear Donna,

Thank you for signing up for our content verification tool! i have created an account for you.

The username is: tle1b
The password is:_
The password and email address for this content verification account can be changed by you at anytime. Simply login to the account and click on the 'my profile' link in the navigation bar. Once on this page, click on the 'edit' link next to the 'hello, I'm tle1b'. On this next page you wil see fields for email address and password that can be

changed.
Also, attached is a short tutorial so you have everyhing you need to get started!
Thank you again!

Heather Gilette
Copyright Agent
YouTube, Inc.

List of attachments: Instructions for the CVT.doc

Confidential

VIA01837343

Rubin Reply Exhibit 83

Redacted at the request of Defendants pending a meet and confer and, if applicable, further action of the Court.

Rubin Reply Exhibit 84

Rubin Reply Exhibit 85

To:

"[e-mail]" -([e-mail];:
"Copyright Service" -([e-mail];:

From: Cc: Bcc:
Sent Date:

Subject:

2006-09-0822:44:58 CST Welcome to the YouTube Content Verification Program

Thank you for signing up for our Content Verification Program! I have created an account for you.

The password is: _
The username is: moca1 i1 v

The username is: v1 t2m

The password is:_
The password and email address for this content verification account can be changed by you at anytime. Simply login to the account and click on the 'my profile' link in the navigation bar. Once on this page, click on the 'edit' link next to the 'hello, I'm v1 t2m, or moca1 i1 v'. On this next page you will see fields for email address and password that can be

changed.
Also, attached is a short tutorial so you have everyhing you need to get started!

Thank you againl
Misty The YouTube Team

Attachments:
Instructions for the CVT.doc

Highly Confidential

800001-02694950

Rubin Reply Exhibit 86

To: From: Cc: Bcc:
Sent Date:

"[e-mail]" -:[e-mail];:
"Copyright Service" -:[e-mail];:

Subject:

2006-09-1401 :37:56 GMT Welcome to the YouTube Content Verification Program

Thank you for signing up for our Content Verification Program! i have created an account for you.
The username is: m01 t1 a

The password is:_
The password and email address for this content verification account can be changed by you at anytime. Simply login to the account and click on the 'my profile' link in the navigation bar. Once on this page, click on the 'edit' link next to the 'hello, I'm m01 t1 a'. On this next page you will see fields for email address and password that can be changed.

Also, attached is a short tutorial so you have everyhing you need to get started!

Thank you again!
Misty The YouTube Team

Attachments:
Instructions for the CVT.doc

Highly Confidential

800001-04897957

Rubin Reply Exhibit 87

Rubin Reply Exhibit 88

To: From: Cc: Bcc:
Sent Date:

"[e-mail]" o([e-mail];: "Copyright Service" o([e-mail];:
"courtneyni @ baytsp.com" o(courtneyni @ baytsp. com;:

Subject:

2006-10-0909:05:13 GMT Welcome to the YouTube Content Verification Program

Thank you for signing up for our Content Verification Program\ I have created an account for you.
The username is: moca1 i1 v

The password is:_
The username is: eki1 pi s

The password is:_
The username is: ydem21 01 c

The password is: _
The username is: t1 m 1 c

The password is:_
The password and email address for this content verification account can be changed by you at anytime. Simply login to the account and click on the 'my profile' link in the navigation bar. Once on this page, click on the 'edit' link next to the 'hello, I'm moca1 i1 v, eki1 pi s, ydem21 01 c, or t1 m1 c'. On this next page you will see fields for email address and

password that can be changed.
Also, attached is a short tutorial so you have everyhing you need to get started\

Thank you again!
Misty

The YouTube Team

Attachments:
Instructions for the CVT.doc

Highly Confidential

G00001-04954200

Rubin Reply Exhibits 89-160

Intentionally Left Blank

Rubin Reply Exhibit 161