The Football Association Premier League Limited et al v. Youtube, Inc. et al

Filing 317

DECLARATION of MICHAEL RUBIN in Support re: 167 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Google, Inc., Youtube, Inc., Youtube, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 162 - 177, # 2 Exhibit 178 - 180, # 3 Exhibit 181 - 184, # 4 Exhibit 185, # 5 Exhibit 186 - 191, # 6 Exhibit 192 - 355)(Schapiro, Andrew)

Rubin Reply Exhibit 192

."." .
-;-;::; ' I)""~"i

HIGHLY
:IDENl1AL VIA-SUPI

- - - - -Original Message- - - -From: Cox, James C. (mail to: JamesCox@j enner. com)

Sent: Tuesday, February 09, 2010 2:33 PM To: Rubin, Michael

Cc: Kohlmann, Susan J.
Subj ect: Viacom Int i 1 v. YouTube: Whi telist Documents

Michael:
In response to our conversation yesterday, please find attached a set of documents bearing the Bates numbers VIA-SUPP000004 - VIA-SUPP000016. The documents are designated Highly Confidential pursuant to the parties i protective order. Together with the document Bates numbered VIA-SUPP000001 - VIA-SUPP000003, which we provided as an attachment to Susan Kohlmann 1 s January 25, 2010 letter, these documents are all of the whitelist documents from after January 1, 2008 in the custody of Jenner & Block or Shearman & Sterling.

Regards, Jay

Housley, Michael
From: Housley, Michael
Sent: Wednesday, April 16,20087:30 PM
To: Pierre-Louis, Stanley; Solow, Warren

Subject: RE: BY on YOU TUBE

Per your request.

ArtisanNewsService
BAAFamily

BadBoyRecords
barelypolitical BdubEtv

bestweekevertv blacktreemedia bpfrecords bravenewfilms BroadwayJoe BroadwayJoe415
bullrunvideo CBS

ChannelFrederator
cimatics Damonjohnson Digitalfilmmaker

fanscapevideos FanscapeVideos4U
FiveChemical freeforlife112

FreshTakes
FutureWorld77
HGiantVid

irenemariemodels
Isitfridayyet

JackassWorldMTV
jerseymouth 1

ladyfragment Lakeshore Records laurenceegibbs LiberalViewer Menudo MyDamnChannel OfficiaiReno911 Paraccount Paramount
Paramount Pictures

ParamountPictures ParentsConnect
ParkMyVibe PinkStrawberry PinkStrawberry1

powermadeak47 dotcom powmadeak47 reaction2006
reno911 miami

rollingoutTELEVISION

RunsHouseVideos shishka

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000004

Snackboard
SpikeTV TDSwriters thatisalsofunny thatsfunny Thatsnotfunny themoviemonkey thesparksfly TNAWrestling tomato808 TVgasmdotcom
TXCANY

universalmusicgroup
vh1 staff Victorweb virtualmtv VLogging

Wiredset

From: Pierre-Louis, Stanley
Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 20085:12 PM To: Housley, Michael; Solow, Warren
Subject: RE: BY on YOU TUBE

can you send me our up-to-date white list? thanks.

From: Housley, Michael Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 5: 10 PM

To: Solow, Warren; Pierre-Louis, Stanley
Subject: RE: BY on YOU TUBE

Addition to white-list has been confirmed.

From: Solow, Warren

Sent: Wednesday, April 16,20084:53 PM To: Housley, Michael; Pierre-Louis, Stanley
Subject: FW: BY on YOU TUBE

Mike, white list this uri

Stan, did you know about this, or did they go rogue

From: Porch, Antonious
Sent: Wednesday, April 16,20084:23 PM To: Solow, Warren
Subject: FW: BY on YOU TUBE

We are marketing our tour!

From: Vargo, Susan
Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 3:56 PM
To: Porch, Antonious

Cc: Rosenstein, Stuart
Subject: FW: BY on YOU TUBE

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000005

Hi Antonious, I wanted to let you know that we have placed the following B-Roll for the Backyardigans Live tour on youtube. Please let us know if you need any further information.

Thanks!

From: Andy Holland (mailto:[e-mail]
Sent: Wednesday, April 16, 2008 3:52 PM
To: Amy Gentry

Cc: Rosenstein, Stuart; Vargo, Susan; Stacey Burns; Nunez, Erica - Nick; [e-mail]
Subject: Re: BY on YOU TUBE

Hello-

The Backyardigans B-Roll is up on You Tube. You can see it here:
Ji tt12:/jYQlitLl1:",.çQm¿watç1i?v=-S_ç¡1'A1JBjJ2t;~_Q

The keywords 1 used for searching are:

Backyardigans Live Tour Tale Mighty Knights USA Nickelodeon Concert
Please let me know if

there are more you'd like me to add.

Thanks!

On 4/15/08, Amy Gentry ~aI1)y.gel1tlY@1:IQad\yayaçTQssam",riça.çQJl1? wrote:

Great. Andy is working on this now and will hopefully have this up today. Will keep you posted and send over the different names we're under.
On Tue, Apr 15, 2008 at 8: 12 AM, Rosenstein, Stuart ~Stllart.RQse11tein@l1içk.çQ111? wrote:

Hey Amy - Spoke to our online group last night and we are free to post on YouTube as long as we own the rights to the footage which we do . i think we should do that right away as we all know that the Canadian show is on the top of the queue and we should knock them off there

Up to you but i would guess it would be a section of b-roll with multiple similar postings under different names to capture the search engine inquiries
Backyardigans Live USA Backyardigans Live Show Backyardigans Live - Nickelodeon

Others?

What ever names you post under should be conveyed to Susan who will send to Antonious Porch in Online Legal for

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000006

their Youtube list

tx
Stuart Rosenstein
Senior Vice President

Resorts & Theatricals

Nickelodeon Recreation
(212) 258 -7764 [phone] (F)

NOTE NEW EMAIL ADDRESS:~l1nJ.gei:iY~1:JdQadw~y_ag9Jis_amelica.com

Amy Gentry Broadway Across America Senior Director of Marketing
206-622-2733, ext 20 1 206-622-8749 fx 2033 6th Ave, Suite 995 I Seattle, WA I 98121
GO TO Iittp:l/lnlp51Qß:~JJincliçl(el,r_9J))l to opt in to receive infonnation about our family shows via text

message!

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000007

Housley, Michael

From: Sean Ray ([e-mail])
Sent: Monday, June 16, 2008 9:24 PM

To: Housley, Michael
Cc: Andrea Cordone; Elliott Kohtz; Evelyn Espinosa; Tim Methenitis

Subject: MTVN white-list

Follow Up Flag: Follow up

Flag Status: Red
Attachments: MTVN white-list.pdf
Attached is a complete list of usernames white-listed for MTVN The following usernames were in CIMS before Andrea started in a rule called VIRAL PLACEMENT:

Wiredset thatisalsofunny thatsfunny

Since then we have added these:
Blunty3000 2008c1assicawards
The following usernames were in CIMS before Andrea in a rule called MTVN Partners:

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000008

BadBoyRecords bestweekevertv blacktreemedia bpfrecords bravenewfilms
bullrunvideo CBS

DamonJohnson
digitalfilmmaker FutureWorld77

irenemariemodels
Isitfridayyet

jerseymouth1 ladyfragment laurenceegibbs LiberalViewer reaction2006
ren0911 miami

shishka Snackboard
SpikeTV thesparksfly
TNAWrestling TXCANY

universalmusicgroup
vh1 staff

Victorweb Vlogging
Wired

set

If you have any questions or need any further assistance please let us know.

Regards,
Sean Ray Client Services BayTSP, Inc. 408-341-2300 (Main) 408-341-2399 (Fax) AIM Handle: seanray13
seflm@PßyJs¡:LÇQLQ

\I\AVl.baVtsp,cQIl

Save the date! Join us for "One World 2008: Managing Piracy in the Global Village" - BayTSP's Sth

Annual Anti-Piracy Conference September 1S_17th, Join us!
The information contained in this email message may be confidential and is intended only for the parties to whom it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient or an agent of same, please notify us of the mistake by telephone or email and delete the message from your system. Please do not copy the message or distribute it to anyone.

From: Elliott Kohtz
Sent: Monday, June 16, 2008 5:28 PM To: paramounCdailies

Cc: ParamounCdailies_cc; Bryan Mejia; Timothy Methenitis
Subject: Spiderwick Chronicles Daily Report 06-16-08

Tracking and Enforcement Update
This report reflects data gathered yesterday.

RJ\PAR~leiís:
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL 1/22/2010

VIA-SUPP000009

Discovered - 0 Pending - 25 Verified - 0 Discarded - 0

As of 2 AM on Monday Jun 16, RADAR has detected no new sources claiming to be Spiderwick Chronicles. We have verified no releases, discarded no releases, and are in the process of finding download sources for all other releases. Please refer to individual RADAR Alerts for potential new detections not covered in this report period.

lnfring~ments:
P2P -1505
Non P2P - 0 Streaming - 0 Cumulative - 205448
Tot! PrQ1Q~_Qls:

eDonkey - 1028 BitTorrent - 477

IQQ.ÇQJJ!11rjes~ Germany - 807 United Kingdom - 106
Israel - 81

USA - 50 France - 47

Regards,
Elliott Kohtz BayTSP, Inc. Client Service Support

i=lliottk@tiylsP,ÇQil
AIM: elliottbaytsp Direct: 408.341.2320

Save the date! Join us for "One World 2008: Managing Piracy in the Global Vilage" - BayTSP's 5th Annual Anti-Piracy Conference September is_17th! Join us! The information contained in this email message
may be confidential and is intended only for the parties to whom it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient or an agent of same, please notify us of the mistake by telephone [phone]) or email and delete the message from your system. Please do not copy the message or distribute it to anyone. This message was prepared at the request of counseL.

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
1/2212010

VIA-SUPP0000010

Attached is a complete list of usernames white-listed for MTVN

The following usernames were in CIMS before Andrea started in a rule called VIRAL PLACEMENT:

Wiredset thatisalsofunny thatsfunny

Since then we have added these:
Blunty3000

2008classicawards
The following usernames were in CIMS before Andrea in a rule called MTVN Partners:

BadBoyRecords bestweekevertv blacktreemedia bpfrecords bravenewfilms
bullrunvideo CBS

DamonJohnson
digitalfilmmaker FutureWorld77

irenemariemodels
Isitfridayyet

jerseymouth1 ladyfragment laurenceegibbs LiberalViewer reaction2006 reno911 miami shishka Snackboard SpikeTV thesparksfly
TNAWrestling TXCANY

universalmusicgroup
vh1 staff

Victorweb Vlogging
Wired

set

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SUPP0000011

Complete MTVN white-list

ArtisanNewsService
BAAFamily

BadBoyRecords
barelypolitical BdubEtv

bestweekevertv blacktreemedia bpfrecords bravenewfilms BroadwayJoe BroadwayJoe415
bullrunvideo CBS

RunsHouse Videos selfmag shishka Snackboard spiketv SpikeTV TDSwriters teodorafilm thatisalsofunny thatsfunny Thatsnotfunny themoviemonkey thesparksfly
TNAWrestling

ChannelFrederator cimatics Damonjohnson
digitalfilmmaker

tomato808 turningthebig40 TVgasmdotcom
TXCANY

duke12085 Edwardtubbs fanscapevideos
F anscape Videos4U

unversalmusicgroup
vh1 staff

FiveChemical
freeforlife 112

Victorweb virtualmtv VLogging

FreshTakes
FutureWorld77 GossipGirl40
HGiantVid

Wiredset IrenaZilberman Blunty3000 2008classicawards

irenemariemodels
Isitfridayyet

JackassWorldMTV jerseymouth1 ladyfragment
Lakeshore Records

lakeshoreent lakeshorerecords laurenceegibbs
LiberalViewer Iivinglegend

menudo MyDamnChannel
OfficiaiRen0911

Paraccount Paramount
Paramount Pictures
Paramount

Pictures

ParentsConnect
ParkMyVlbe PinkStrawberry PinkStrawberry1

powmadeak47 reaction2006
ren0911 miami

rollingoutTELEVISION

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SU PPOOOOO 12

From:
Sß'nt
To:

Sean Ray (seam@baytspcom)

Thursday, r\~ay 14,2009106 PM
Housley, Michael

Cc:

Elliott Kahtz
RE: White-list

Subject:

Attachments' Paramount Video \I\ihite-listxls
Mike..

Here is the Paramount White-list spreadsheet.

F;egards.
Sean Ray

Client Service Manager BayTSP, inc 408-341-2384 (Direct)
(Mobile) 408-341-2399 (Fax) AIM Handle seamay13

from: Hous!ey, ¡v¡ichaei Lmaiito: iViichael.Housiey::¡Jviacorn,comJ

SeFit; Thursday, ¡Viay 2009 8:2.8 i\H
TtD; Sean Ray

Cc Elliott Kohtz
Rf:::. \tVhite-list

Thanks. Seari When you 1'13ve 2 chance,

send rne the current Pararnourrt

frtHtn: Sean Ray Lmaiito:seanr@::baytsp.comJ

St:n¡;~ Tuesday, May 12, 2009 1.2:44 PIIIJ
'r,,: Housley, ~.1ichôel
(:i: Elliott I\ohtz

Rr:: VVhite-lst
r¡j'jkei

YouTube user addecL

has been added to the filters in gV\/l and C'JJ\1S. lIser euhüH' had

been

For your records ¡ have attached

current Cleared U SCI' spreadsheet. know J bJ\'C lìot sent VOl) auci

spreadsheet i;~)f qulte some time.

1/1

1 (HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SUPP0000013

Regards,
Sean Ray

Client Service Managei.
BayTSP. Inc. 408-341-2384 (Dilect)
(Mobile) 408-341-2399 (Fax)
AIM Handle seanray13

IFrom: Housley, rlilichael (mailto: ¡\(¡Iehael. Houslev(glVìacom.comJ
Serit: Tuesdayi 1"1ay 121 20098:52 ,IlM

"'ro~ Sean Ray

Cc: Elliott Kohtz White-list

Sean.
if we have not already done so. please white-list the following username

jimgaffigancomic
Thariks,
Mike

1/ 1

¡ 1\

, HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SUPP0000014

Updated: 5/12/09

~ tk Ne ..... f(:ll ~, "J'IOr::d1~
Not
'-\IU::cl VIL.'C ,
0,. ..r'ell I

." ICI iiuviei I lui me

/
It v

.-J~

iet! il
lame. LiberalViewer
I"~ menu do

I nei" H"

l'ç

It:

rnrn
iUd
liV

Tf\
lUi

-"'))

I turii Il'l,

luvinthen
i iai

blacktreemedia
1:1::
,;-~-

DdCNN
, uvc

1,"llvel",,,,IIJlJsicgroup
¡upinl
'" ililL.e"'''

i :VI I v
"",VVI co ltyiV

IVIUIlI v duniine
lIn r V,-! nn\.,;, lell Il iei

'~n

'~"""5
i buill'

nails
j'\jI--(ClIIX
Vii ''''''" ''GilV'" 11

vh 1 staff

I\jickKC!\ -cilaiiiuu
i ¡.QòOl

'v

.L

CBS iClidllllCli icuc:ldlUI

twtualrntv
iV nmiino

PPUKP¡ctureShow
iupinl
Ill""

j tnt

vcr345
!vv

i tnt Pictures
ii"'co

'Dar
i 1C;I\LC'!

,_v, .v
'dll\IVI
¡-,C" yqi

fiue
'1-'/-'

1 i i

DionrieTv

!dukei¿uöëi ,ihh"
I ICUld

Udl

::n
",;-i1lhn
~ r¡'íeClleol n\.çjl
I

fJlIWCOI

. hldotcorn
._"

¡"''VI!

1\)IIU;: I miami
._,.

V.i"

¡:\I¡c.I()1\1

112
Fïesh i aK8S

...u II" IV,""c: v 'ueo'.,"
I

¡=uture rvuiiu I (

......

Gadzoc01
'IL¡U

I "11l"1 i"a
1')1
ILl

'-J\.lcJl It VIU
ici ;

oiketv pikeTV
tar I ",vi d=¡liYi

'1IULit'I::

IS/\Tl,M
I

¡ SUgdr ::CdfJël
!

iui'll I'V
I

ILL iy

JU n.coni
!W

I'I\.

,a''''LH'' iV
iy

11PI

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SUPP0000015

Paramount Video \i\h¡t~"Hst
II

as oJ 4í30109

Viral :Ist
i 20DD
",,'

UCiii

'FXLover"

, 2010

", ,

DiEL

,Uiil!
iishki',

-,,, ,'"""
,',,'"

"--,

~~t
be
31íp

'¡(Ek;
-7-

,,
¡~~J~!fi;\Uii

~~~
::pwe v
Ill""""'"

"
.,

,"

IM,"1"

,,
" ","

''''

,..",'"

::8S
11'1616

",' "
, ""

,

-"""""""""

,,",,',',""

C,' '"

" ,.
",". ,',,'., , ;:, ",",,' ,J.,

"

"'"

:J

,

-,
"'" ""

"',"

,-

~i

¡¡¡liTiS",

-",'" ',"""";, "'" '"

,

"',',""

'i 'L " .

"""

li'stzfi

",' , '

, , , ~I
¡;i,"~h"rnical

h
" ,i'" :i9

,

_._-""-

,
NDC

-

,,,','"

",'

W" " " '
\lVtox
,':'...., , ;,

"'"

"

ñktornic

""" "
Pè( ;'~
Uh"C ,,,.
,'.X.",' ',_
,, i "" '''''''',' ",,,ll " ,

'-Nviover

,,', i."',' "
r"en
,

"--"

; ',.H,"";
S' ",; , ",.,L" '1')

-

-

-,,-

C",",'!!',

,

",',"',"

12

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL

VIA-SUPP0000016

Rubin Reply Exhibit 193

Rubin Reply Exhibits 194-249

Intentionally Left Blank

Rubin Reply Exhibits 250 - 355

VIDEO EXHIBITS: FILED MANUALLY