Schoolcraft v. The City Of New York et al

Filing 560

DECLARATION of Joshua P. Fitch (Master Declaration) in Support re: 559 MOTION for Attorney Fees , Costs and Disbursements.. Document filed by Adrian Schoolcraft. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A - Declaration of Jon L. Norinsberg, Esq., # 2 Exhibit B - Declaration of Nathaniel Smith, Esq., # 3 Exhibit C - Declaration of Joshua P. Fitch, Esq., # 4 Exhibit D - Declaration of Gerald M. Cohen, Esq., # 5 Exhibit E - Declaration of John Lenoir, Esq., # 6 Exhibit F - Declaration of Howard A. Suckle, Esq., # 7 Exhibit G - Declaration of Magdalena Bauza, # 8 Exhibit H - Billing Entries and Costs for Jon L. Norinsberg, Esq., # 9 Exhibit I - Billing Entries and Costs for Nathaniel Smith, Esq., # 10 Exhibit J - Billing Entries for Joshua P. Fitch, Esq., # 11 Exhibit K - Billing Entries and Costs for Gerald M. Cohen, Esq., # 12 Exhibit L - Billing Entries for John Lenoir, Esq., # 13 Exhibit M - Billing Entries for Howard A. Suckle, Esq., # 14 Exhibit N - Billing Entries for Magdalena Bauza, # 15 Exhibit O - Declaration of Jonathan Abady, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Jon L. Norinsberg, Esq., # 16 Exhibit P - Declaration of Christopher Galiardo, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Jon L. Norinsberg, Esq., # 17 Exhibit Q - Declaration of Afsaan Saleem, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Jon L. Norinsberg, Esq., # 18 Exhibit R - Declaration of Michael L. Spiegel, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Nathaniel Smith, Esq., # 19 Exhibit S - Declaration of Zachary Margulis-Ohnuma, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Joshua P. Fitch, Esq. and Gerald M. Cohen, Esq., partners of Cohen & Fitch LLP, # 20 Exhibit T - Declaration of Irving Cohen, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Joshua P. Fitch, Esq. and Gerald M. Cohen, Esq., partners of Cohen & Fitch LLP, # 21 Exhibit U - Declaration of Katherine Smith, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Joshua P. Fitch, Esq. and Gerald M. Cohen, Esq., partners of Cohen & Fitch LLP, # 22 Exhibit V - Declaration of Hugh M. Mo, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of John Lenoir, Esq., # 23 Exhibit W - Declaration of Jeffrey Schlanger, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of John Lenoir, Esq., # 24 Exhibit X - Declaration of David Finkler, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Howard A. Suckle, Esq., # 25 Exhibit Y - Declaration of Mitchell Bloch, Esq. in support of the hourly rate of Howard A. Suckle, Esq., # 26 Exhibit Z - 2013-2014 National Law Journal Billing Survey of Large Firm Billing Rates, # 27 Exhibit AA - 2013-2014 New York City Law Department Year in Review for the Special Federal Litigation Division, # 28 Exhibit BB - New York City Law Department Special Federal Litigation Homepage, # 29 Exhibit CC - Verdict Search's Top Verdicts of 2013, # 30 Exhibit DD - Super Lawyers 2015 Annual List of Top Lawyers in the New York Metro Area, # 31 Exhibit EE - Order in Bernabe v. City of New York, 13 CV 5531 (LGS) relating to Mr. Norinsberg's hourly rate)(Fitch, Joshua)

EXHIBIT
“I”

Law Office of Nathaniel B. Smith
100 Wall Street - 23rd Floor
New York, NY 10005

Invoice submitted to:
Schoolcraft

December 04, 2015
Invoice #10032

Professional Services
Hrs/Rate

Amount

2/3/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Peter Gleason; review of docket
complaint and decision by J. Sweet.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/7/2013 NBS Meeting with Adrian Schoolcraft; Peter Gleason and John Lenoir re
possible representation.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/8/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Peter Gleason re taking on new case.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

2/9/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel in reference to defendant's
examination before trial in class action.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

2/11/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; review of Floyd case.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

2/12/2013 NBS Appear for examination before trial of client in Floyd case and
defend same (3.5) (before MJ Freeman); meeting with co-counsel
and client in re going forward; review of emails re status.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

2/13/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Peter Gleason; telephone to Richard
Guilbert re status.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

2/14/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; review of Floyd decision; meeting
with client and team.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/15/2013 NBS Review of files from counsel; review of pleadings; telephone call to
co-counsel twice; review of penal code.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

2

Amount

2/17/2013 NBS Review of boxes from client and Guilbert.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/18/2013 NBS Review of decisions of file; review of production.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/20/2013 NBS Meeting with co-counsel; preparesubpoenas

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

2/22/2013 NBS Review of emails; telephone call to co-counsel; telephone Graham
Raymond (Village Voice).

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

2/24/2013 NBS Travel with Peter Gleason to meet defendant and his father in
Saugerties, NY.

7.20
575.00/hr

4,140.00

2/27/2013 NBS Review of file; prepare summons fo amended cmplt; file Summons
with SDNY clerk; tc attempt service of same on Law Dept;
telephone call to Peter Gleason re status of serving 5 remaining
defendants.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

2/28/2013 NBS Review of examination before trial; prepare subpoena; prepare
Notice of Appearance.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/1/2013 NBS Telephone conference with potential medical expert (.5); review of
discovery; file Affirmation of Service; review of medical and hospital
records.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

3/2/2013 NBS Review of Section 1983 and 242 issues and jury instructions for
various theories of the case.

5.00
575.00/hr

2,875.00

3/3/2013 NBS Review of discovery; review of discovery plan; review of draft letter
to Justice Department.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

3/5/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re Justice letter and Chris Dunn
three times; review of discovery record.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

3/6/2013 NBS Review of discovery records; telephone call to Chris Dunn
(NYCLU); meeting with City CM Williams; Peter Gleason and
Adrian Schoolcraft (2.1).

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/7/2013 NBS Review of file; meeting with client and Peter Gleason; review of
new matter.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

3/9/2013 NBS Meeting with co-counsel and intern in reference to status.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

3/14/2013 NBS Emails to opposing counsel; letter to Judge Sweet in reference to
motion schedule.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

3/20/2013 NBS Review of Magistrate Judge letter; telephone call to Peter Gleason;
letter to court re two motions; review of discovery file.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

3

Amount

3/22/2013 NBS Appearance in court on Floyd case to see Marino testify (2.5);
telephone call to client (.3); call to Peter Gleason(.4); prepare Rule
34 demand for property.

4.20
575.00/hr

2,415.00

3/23/2013 NBS Review of motion and motion letter; research on taking high-level
government employee's deposition.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/25/2013 NBS Working on opp to motions to quash and compel; telephone call
with client and review of materials with client (1.5); telephone
conference with Jon Norinsberg re Queens DA; suit and sharing
information (0.5).

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

3/26/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client (.5); call to Peter Gleason(.3);
drafting memo of law in opposition to motion.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

3/27/2013 NBS Revising Memo of Law in Opposition(4.5); telephone call to client;
meeting with Peter Gleason; mag and artist re demonstratives.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

3/28/2013 NBS Draft supplemental memo of law.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

3/29/2013 NBS Review of discovery; review of letter re gag order; telephone call to
client; email team; call to Peter Gleason; telephone G. Rayma.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

3/30/2013 NBS Review of gag order cases (1.5); conference with team (1.0).

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

3/31/2013 NBS Review of cases on gag order.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/1/2013 NBS Review of discovery; email reference discovery plea.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/2/2013 NBS Appearance at Floyd trial to hear Mauriello testify.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/3/2013 NBS Appearance at Floyd trial to hear part of Dr. Fagan direct.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/4/2013 NBS Drafting memo of law on prior restraint.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

4/5/2013 NBS Revise memo of law on prior restraint.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

4/7/2013 NBS Meeting at upstate with team.

8.60
575.00/hr

4,945.00

4/8/2013 NBS Meeting with client all day re prep for case and ebt

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

4/9/2013 NBS Continued review of discovery)(4.0); MHL on emergency
hospitalization; meeting with potential expert re: medical mal
practice issues (1.5); meeting with John re: motion; telephone call
to Walker re: same.

4

Amount

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

4/10/2013 NBS Meeting with team after court appearance.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

4/11/2013 NBS Meeting with team and Rae Kosheck re: NYPD re adm trial issues.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/14/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Peter Gleason re: status.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

4/15/2013 NBS Review of production.

2.00
575.00/hr

1,150.00

4/16/2013 NBS Review of production.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/22/2013 NBS Review of testimony in discovery.

3.00
575.00/hr

1,725.00

4/23/2013 NBS Review of PG on Marino, Mauriello and Lauterborn; review of
reports of PG by IAB.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

4/24/2013 NBS Review of AEO files.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/25/2013 NBS Appearance at 1 Police Plaza for conference; telephone call to
client re: status; review of interviews by QAD.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/26/2013 NBS Meeting with client re: background and chronological with John
Lenoir.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

4/27/2013 NBS Meeting with client re: background with John Lenoir.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

4/28/2013 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir re: upcoming trial with
NYPD.

0.20
575.00/hr

115.00

4/29/2013 NBS Telephone conference with with client (1.0) re: trial; research on
collateral estoppel issue.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

4/30/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; research on collateral estoppel
issue.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

5/1/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Peter Gleason re: status; emails with
clients re: same.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

5

Amount

5/2/2013 NBS Draft letter to Publicker re: collateral estoppel issue; email all
counsel re: discovery deadlines; email court re: same.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

5/3/2013 NBS Review of cases; email letter to opposing counsel re: collateral
examination before trial issue.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

5/7/2013 NBS Listening to day-long recording of 10/31/09; taking notes thereof
(7.0); review of discovery requests; prepare same.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

5/8/2013 NBS Review of recordings; prepare discovery responses.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

5/9/2013 NBS Meeting with J. Lenoir re: case and status; review of internal
memos by IAB; review of recordings.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

5/10/2013 NBS Continued review of discovery.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

5/13/2013 NBS Meeting with John and Melissa re: NYPP; telephone call with client.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

5/14/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status; review of discovery
files; outline of production.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

5/15/2013 NBS Continued review of production; email opposing counsel re: status
of IPP trial and Queens DA document.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

5/16/2013 NBS Review of files; telephone call to co-counsel; telephone client; call
to Lisa Bland.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

5/17/2013 NBS Continued review of discovery; telephone call to client (2 times);
call to John Lenoir; email re: same.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

5/18/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client and co-counsel.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

5/20/2013 NBS Review of personal file on defendants; sick report and duty status
at 10/31/09; research on Judge Sweet letter; telephone call to John
Lenoir re: Jimmy McCutkin re: telephone to Lisa Bland.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

5/21/2013 NBS Meeting with Jon Lenoir; telephone conference with co-counsel and
Jim McCutheon; telephone conference office of Lisa Bland; review
of civil commitment articles and decision on dangerousness
predictions; review of discovery record; prepare responses to
objections to City Defendants demands; listening to recording of
IAB interview.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

5/22/2013 NBS Telephone conference re: status; telephone call Lisa Bland re:
possible deal (demand of back pay in consideration of resignation);
review and revised responses to discovery demands.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

6

Amount

5/23/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; call to co-counsel; review of
decisions; email re: status.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

5/24/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status; review of emails from
co-counsel re Eli Silverman.

0.40
575.00/hr

230.00

5/30/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; telephone call to Lisa Bland's
office.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

6/3/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; letter to Judge Sweet on
discovery; telephone call to Lisa Bland re: now want demand from
us and will not agree to stay.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/4/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; telephone call co-counsel; draft
letters to Judge Sweet re: stay and re: alleged discovery
deficiencies.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/5/2013 NBS Appearance in court at conference before Judge Sweet handled by
John Lenoir; conference with John re: same.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

6/6/2013 NBS Review of emails; review of proposed order; review of notes on
defendant's examination before trial; email co-counsel; prepare for
meeting with experts.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

6/7/2013 NBS Review of Queens D.A. files (20); meeting with John Lenoir and
potential experts on NYPD and dangerousness (2.0); telephone
client re: motion for stay of NYPD trial.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/9/2013 NBS Preparing proposed Order to Show Cause on stay of adm
proceedings

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/10/2013 NBS Revised Order to Show Cause; filed same; emails with counsel;
telephone call to co-counsel; telephone call to client re: status; 2nd
appearance at court.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

6/11/2013 NBS Research on Younger abstention issues for stay motion.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

6/12/2013 NBS Review of Younger case law.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

6/13/2013 NBS Review of Younger et al decisions on stay motion.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/14/2013 NBS Email regarding press contracts; telephone call to client; further
research on Younger issue.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/18/2013 NBS Drafting reply on stay; research on issues re: same.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

7

Amount

6/19/2013 NBS Drafting reply; telephone call to client re: reply transcript of
10/31/09; call from Village Voice; telephone G. Rayman re: status
of case.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

6/20/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; review of Floyd
submissions.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

6/25/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; telephone co-counsel re: travel to
upstate; review of issuses regardig : litigation with indigent client;
prepare for same.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

6/26/2013 NBS Travel to Johnstown for meeting with client [8 hours of travel].

13.00
575.00/hr

7,475.00

6/27/2013 NBS Review of tapes for the purpose of responsing to discovery
demands by the CIty for requests for admissions and providing
additional information to the defendants about the recordings.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

6/29/2013 NBS Review of stay decision on NYPD trial.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

6/30/2013 NBS Review of tapes and drafting response to Court Order re:
complication of Plaintiff's deposition testimony and requests to
admit.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

7/10/2013 NBS Travel to Albany and meet with the client at John Garber's office
(194 Washington Avenue); return to NYC { 8 hours travel time} .

12.50
575.00/hr

7,187.50

7/11/2013 NBS Telephone conference with R. Gilbert; telephone conference with
client re decision; telephone call to client; telephone Gilbert

0.90
575.00/hr

517.50

7/18/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re Judge Sweet and re: discovery
status; email opposing counsel re: same and schedule of
examination before trial.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

7/22/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; re: status; review of to do list;
memo to file.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

7/23/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel re: status.

0.40
575.00/hr

230.00

7/24/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Magdelena re: status.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

7/25/2013 NBS Prepare for all counsel conference call; telephone co-counsel;
telephone call client.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/1/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client twice (1.5); review of various
tapes; review of transcripts; prepare Response to the Court Order
re: discovery.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

8

Amount

7/26/2013 NBS Preparing documents for client.

0.90
575.00/hr

517.50

7/27/2013 NBS Meeting with T. Skinner re: case.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

7/30/2013 NBS Revising documents (sub of counsel; memo of understanding;
discovery demands) (1.5); telephone call H. Suckle re: possible
involvement; telephone co-counsel re: status; review of Section
1983 case law (1.5).

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/31/2013 NBS Meeting with H. Suckle re: hospital; draft memo to client; revise sub
of counsel; memo of goals; document demand; emails re: discovery
plan with co-counsel and opposing counsel; telephone call to client
re: status.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

8/1/2013 NBS Meeting with Magdalen re: status and case; review of case law in
jury instructions.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

8/6/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; review of emails and press
coverage; call from G. Rayman re: book out.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

8/13/2013 NBS Read recent book by G. Raymond called NYPD Tapes

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

8/14/2013 NBS Travel to Mayfield, NY (4.5); review of recent decision in Floyd case.

7.00
575.00/hr

4,025.00

8/15/2013 NBS Meeting with client re: examination before trial preparation.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

8/16/2013 NBS Meeting with client to discuss case and deposition (7.5); travel back
to NY (4.5).

12.00
575.00/hr

6,900.00

8/20/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; revised letter to court.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

8/21/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; emails with opposing
counsel re: discovery schedule.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

8/22/2013 NBS Telephone conference with Jon Lenoir re: status; telephone Greg
Radomisle re: hospital inspection; review of emails re: schedule;
conference with all counsel re: schedule; draft objections (2.5);
conference with Adrian Schoolcraft re: same.

4.20
575.00/hr

2,415.00

8/23/2013 NBS Meeting with Magdalena re legal research on state action;
telephone call with Jon Lenoir re: status.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

8/24/2013 NBS Meeting with investigator (1.0); telephone conference with Jon
Lenoir re: Paul Brown (0.3).

1.30
575.00/hr

747.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

9

Amount

8/25/2013 NBS Review of production for AEO issue (5.0); telephone call to J. Smith
(photography of inspection).

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

8/26/2013 NBS Continued review of production.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/27/2013 NBS Travel to Saugerties to meet client (4.5); meeting with client re:
status (3.5).

8.00
575.00/hr

4,600.00

8/28/2013 NBS Review of decision on jury order; telephone Pete Gleason re: suits
and apartment; review of counsel; review of conference orders;
review of production.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/29/2013 NBS Review of productions; telephone call to client (0.5)

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

8/30/2013 NBS Continued review of production.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/3/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

9/4/2013 NBS Email to client re: status; review of status report; review of letter
motion by city.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

9/6/2013 NBS Review of correspondence on discovery; drafting AEO letter
motion; telephone call to client re: status and AEO letter issues (1.0)

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/8/2013 NBS Drafting letter motion on AEO.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

9/9/2013 NBS Revising letter motion; emails on same.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

9/10/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client.

0.20
575.00/hr

115.00

9/16/2013 NBS Email regarding status; telephone call to client.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

9/18/2013 NBS Telephone call and emails reference 81 inspection.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

9/19/2013 NBS Inspection at 81 with defendants, cleint, and Mag.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

9/21/2013 NBS Meeting with client.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/22/2013 NBS Review of motion letter re: AEO and personal property motion.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

10

Amount

9/23/2013 NBS Draft reply letter on AEO and personal property motion (1.8);
telephone conference with client; telephone call with Mag;
telephone call to John Lenoir re: status; review of 81 inspection
photos; review of AEO designations.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

9/25/2013 NBS Appearance in court on motions (2.0); meeting with team re: case
and examination before trial (2.0); prepare for examinations before
trial of plaintiff

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

9/26/2013 NBS Appearance for client; examination before trial and prepare for
same.

9.00
575.00/hr

5,175.00

9/27/2013 NBS Appearance for examination before trial of defendant and prepare
for same.

9.00
575.00/hr

5,175.00

9/29/2013 NBS Meeting with client re: case and next steps.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

9/30/2013 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; review of emails; review of
productions.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

10/1/2013 NBS Meeting with client re: examination before trial and inspection
preparation.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/2/2013 NBS Inspection at Jamaica Hospital; visit Queen's location; meeting with
client; reviewing tapes re: examination before trial.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

10/4/2013 NBS Preparing for Marino and Mauriello examination before trial (5.0);
telephone conference with co-counsel; emails with opposing
counsel re: adjournment for Mauriello; review of PG & Floyd trial
transcripts.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

10/7/2013 NBS Prepared for examination before trial; conference call with
co-counsel; conference with client.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

10/8/2013 NBS Preparing for and taking Marino's examination before trial; calls to
Court on status of various motions.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

10/9/2013 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir re: status.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

NBS Meeting with co-counsel; review and revise status report; review of
motions and filing on case re: discovery; telephone conference with
G. Raymond re: Mauriello counterclaims (will comment in opposing
papers).
10/10/2013 NBS Review of email; conference with co-counsel; review of law on
tortuous interference claim; email opposing counsel re: motion to
amend Mauriello answer.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

11

Amount

10/11/2013 NBS Drafting letter to Court; research on motion to amend.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/13/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status re: NYCLU and Dunn
and going forward; telephone call to John Lenoir re: same.

2.30
575.00/hr

1,322.50

10/14/2013 NBS Telephone conference with L. Dunn; telephone call to John Lenoir
re: case; drafting and research on motion to strike Mauriello
answer; discovery matters (AEO personal property) and opposing
to motion to amend pleadings (7.5).

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

10/15/2013 NBS Revised motion and memo; emails re: same; letter to court;
conference with client re: status.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/16/2013 NBS Prepare for court appearance; appear before Judge Sweet on
various motions (3.2); conference with trial team; telephone call
with Howard Suckle re: status and medical defendant's examination
before trial; email to client.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/17/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; emails re: status; email prior
counsel re: discovery matters.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

10/18/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; review of medical documents
responses; email opposing counsel re: status of production.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

10/22/2013 NBS Meeting with H. Suckle re: medical examination before trial
preparation.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

10/23/2013 NBS Telephone conference with court re: oral argument date; telephone
call with Walter Kretz re: same; conference with co-counsel;
telephone call and email to client; telephone J. Eterno re: status
and Monell issues (alleged conflict of interest issue raised by Law
Dept in the past); review of Jamaica Hospital records; email with
prior counsel re: substitution and document search.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/24/2013 NBS Prepared for examination before trial of Dr. Bernier.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

10/25/2013 NBS Appearance for Bernier examination before trial; wait for response
from Court on video objection; meeting with team.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

10/27/2013 NBS Research on dangerous assessment.

3.00
575.00/hr

1,725.00

10/28/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status; emails re: schedule
and video objections.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

10/29/2013 NBS Preparation for examination before trial of Mauriello; review of
research on video use conference with 10-10.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

12

Amount

10/30/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client (1.0); email opposing counsel re:
adjournment on Mauriello; review of emails; review of Mauriello
testimony in Floyd case; review of AS personnel file records for
examination before trial (2.0)

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

11/1/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client; telephone call to John Lenoir re:
Stop and Frisk; status.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

11/3/2013 NBS Review of Lauterborn recordings and preparation for his
examination before trial.

4.20
575.00/hr

2,415.00

11/4/2013 NBS Prepare for examination before trial.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

11/5/2013 NBS Review of record; prepare for Lauterborn examination before trial

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

11/7/2013 NBS Prepare for and take examination before trial of Lauterborn;
conference with team; telephone call with client re: status.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

11/8/2013 NBS Meeting with investigator (1.0); telephone call same and Mag (0.5);
review of research and emails.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

11/14/2013 NBS Email in reference to Daily News Article; telephone call to Mag
Bauza re: interview with Carol Street.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

11/15/2013 NBS Prepare for Mauriello.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

11/19/2013 NBS Telephone conference with B. Shaffer re: Larry Schoolcraft
examination before trial re: examination before trial of Larry
Schoolcraft; prep for ebts of polce defendants

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

11/20/2013 NBS Prepare for Marino examination before trial.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

11/21/2013 NBS Prepare for Marino examination before trial.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

11/22/2013 NBS Prepare for and appear at Mauriello examination before trial
(busted by defendant).

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

11/26/2013 NBS Drafting notices for depositions ; review of email.

1.00
575.00/hr

575.00

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

12/1/2013 NBS Review of Caughey, Weiss and Hanlon recordings; prepare for
Caughey examination before trial; telephone conference re: status
(left message).

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

13

Amount

12/2/2013 NBS Telephone conference with W. Kretz re: Mauriello; telephone
conference with John Lenoir re: status; call to client re: same;
emails with counsel re: status and discovery deadline.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

12/4/2013 NBS Letter to opposing counsel; email to opposing counsel re numerous
discovery disputes.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

12/6/2013 NBS Emails re: status; prepare opposition to motion for reconsideration.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/7/2013 NBS Telephone conference with client and John Lenoir; prepare for
Caughey examination before trial; prepare for opposition to
Mauriello reconsideration.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

12/8/2013 NBS Prepare for Caughey examination before trial.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

12/9/2013 NBS Take examination before trial of Caughey.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

12/17/2013 NBS Prepare for examination before trial of Mauriello; review of recent
correspondence.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/18/2013 NBS Prepare for Mauriello; conference with co-counsel, telephone call to
client re: status.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

12/19/2013 NBS Prepare for Mauriello.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/20/2013 NBS Take examination before trial of Mauriello.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

12/24/2013 NBS Meeting with client and John Lenoir re: status and possible
settlement demand.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

12/29/2013 NBS Meeting with client to review various tape recording.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

12/30/2013 NBS Meeting with client and review various tape recordings (4.3); obtain
tape recorder from NYPD and send to specialist for enhancement

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

12/31/2013 NBS Review of production; research on compstat.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

1/1/2014 NBS Review of Silverman and Eterno book

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

1/2/2014 NBS Meeting with client re: review of tapes; telephone conference with
co-counsel; emails re: schedule; letter to Court re: schedule

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

14

Amount

1/3/2014 NBS Prepare for Boston and Huffman examination before trial

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

1/5/2014 NBS Prepare for Boston and Huffman examination before trial.

3.70
575.00/hr

2,127.50

1/6/2014 NBS Prepare for and take examination before trial of Boston and
Huffman; meeting with team re: status and going forward

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

1/8/2014 NBS Letter to Court; email re: scheduling

0.20
575.00/hr

115.00

1/12/2014 NBS Prepare for Hanlon examination before trial

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

1/13/2014 NBS Prepare for and take Hanlon examination before trial; conference
with team re: examination before trial and case

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

1/15/2014 NBS Appearance in court; conference with co-counsel; email re: status

2.30
575.00/hr

1,322.50

1/16/2014 NBS Review of production; review of report on crime reporting; emails
re: status of examination before trial

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

1/17/2014 NBS Review of documents produced; review of report of crime reporting;
review of prior discovery demands

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

1/23/2014 NBS Prepare documents for supplemental production; long status
conference with client re: need for AEO production and status of
case (1.3)

1.90
575.00/hr

1,092.50

1/24/2014 NBS Produce documents

0.40
575.00/hr

230.00

1/27/2014 NBS Revising letter to website responders; sending out same; letter to
City Defendants re: examination before trial

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

1/28/2014 NBS Prepare for Dr. Lamstein

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

1/29/2014 NBS Prepare for Dr. Lamstein

2.30
575.00/hr

1,322.50

1/30/2014 NBS Prep for and take Dr. Lamstein examination before trial

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

2/3/2014 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel; email reference
examination before trial.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

2/5/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client; emails reference examination
before trial; and letter to Judge Sweet.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

15

Amount

2/7/2014 NBS Email regarding status with client; meeting with Mag in reference to
redaction issues; letter to Law Department reference redaction;
drafting and revising discovery demands.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/10/2014 NBS Telephone conference with the court clerk reference submission on
February 10, 2014; letter to court; prepare for doctor's examination
before trial (2.8)

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

2/11/2014 NBS Prepare for and attend Dr. Bernier examination before trial.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

2/12/2014 NBS Prepare for and attend Dr. Isakov examination before trial.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

2/16/2014 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir and client reference status;
review of privilege issues.

1.70
575.00/hr

977.50

2/18/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial for discovery letter; emails
reference defendant's examination before trial and Norinsberg
termination letter; request JHMC provide and produce the two
EMT's.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

2/19/2014 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel (HS) reference medical
case; state action; pro and sub due process; review of emails
reference discovery status; telephone call to John Lenoir reference
same.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/20/2014 NBS Email co-counsel; client review of examination before trial for
motion.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

2/21/2014 NBS Review of cited psychiatric journals.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/23/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial; telephone co-counsel;
telephone conference with client reference status.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/24/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial; email reference recording.

0.40
575.00/hr

230.00

2/25/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial; transcripts for discovery issues;
telephone call to Walter Kretz (two times) regarding possible work
out.

5.00
575.00/hr

2,875.00

2/27/2014 NBS Drafting letters to court re outstanding disocvery disputes by
plaintiff and by defendants

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/28/2014 NBS Letter motion regarding discovery issue.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

3/3/2014 NBS Review of emails and letters.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

16

Amount

3/4/2014 NBS Prepare for and attend meeting to confer; emails reference status
same.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

3/8/2014 NBS Review of letters on discovery motions; email to team reference
response.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

3/11/2014 NBS Meeting with team John Lenoir and Mag Bauza; drafting letter to
court.

2.30
575.00/hr

1,322.50

3/24/2014 NBS Meeting with team; telephone call with client.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/26/2014 NBS Review of drafts 30(b)(6); appear in court on discovery status (2.2);
telephone call client; review of document demands; meet and
confer with opposing counsel (1.0).

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

3/27/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client (twice) re subject matters of
numerous 30(b)(6) notices; revising same.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/28/2014 NBS Meeting with Mag reference jury instructions; telephone call with
client reference 30(b)(6); revising same and serving same.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

3/31/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client; review of discovery; emails
reference settlement.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

4/1/2014 NBS Telephone conference with City re: settlement; telephone
conference with client; conference with team re: same.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

4/4/2014 NBS Review of medical expert decisions and affidavit; prepare for
Trainor examination before trial.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/7/2014 NBS Prepare motion to strike paragraph six of Mauriello's counterclaim
(1.3); prepare outline of discovery issues; telephone call to D.
Beekman (Daily News); telephone conference Graham Raymond;
telephone MJ Freeman's chambers; email all counsel.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/8/2014 NBS Prepare for Trainor examination before trial.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

4/9/2014 NBS Preparing for hearing on Raymond motion to compel; appearance
in court on motion (2.2); prepare for Trainor and Gough
examination before trial.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

4/10/2014 NBS Prepare for and take deposition of Trainor; prepare for Gough
examination before trial.

8.90
575.00/hr

5,117.50

4/11/2014 NBS Prepare for and take Gough examination before trial.

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

4/13/2014 NBS Prepare for and meet with potential expert (Roy Lubit).

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

17

Amount

4/14/2014 NBS Telephone conference with co-counsel re: status; conference with
client; emails with opposing counsel re: new dates for settlement
demands/offers/conference; draft letter to MJ Freeman re: same;
email Hearn.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

4/15/2014 NBS Telephone conference with H. Suckle re: status and settlement.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

4/16/2014 NBS Telephone conference with team (1.0); conference with client re:
settlement demands (1.2); research on commitment cases; state
action and Section 1983; review of Plaintiff's demands.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

4/17/2014 NBS Telephone conference with team; review of decisions; telephone
Mag; telephone Howard; telephone John; letter to all defendants
counsel re: Norinsberg termination letter; telephone call to S.
Mettham re: settlement.

2.90
575.00/hr

1,667.50

4/18/2014 NBS Various telephone calls with John Lenoir; telephone client; review
of decisions on involuntary hospital and damages.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/22/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Joe Ferrero.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

4/23/2014 NBS Drafting opposition to Jamaica Hospital motion for protective order;
prepare for and attend examination before trial of Bernier

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

4/24/2014 NBS Prepare for Sawyer examination before trial (3.0); revise opposition
to Jamaica Hospital protective order motion.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

4/25/2014 NBS Prepare for and take deposition of Sawyer.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

4/27/2014 NBS Preparing reply to Mauriello opposition

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

4/28/2014 NBS Prepare for and take Duncan examination before trial and
conference with all counsel and MJ Freeman re: settlement
discussion.

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

4/29/2014 NBS Review of state motion cases; meeting with co-counsel; call to
client.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/30/2014 NBS Appearance in court on JHMC motion for protective order and
Adrian's motion to strile Mauriello counterclaims reference (2.2);
prepare for same; lunch meeting with team and colleague of John's
re: case.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

5/2/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Gregory Radomsile reference
examination before trial; emails to opposing counsel re: same.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

18

Amount

5/5/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Sheri; telephone call to John Lenoir;
prepare letter to Judge Sweet re: Plaintiff's motion to compel;
telephone to John Cohen re: fees; review of Gleason fees.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

5/8/2014 NBS Prepare for conference; attend tc conference with Magistrate
Freeman re: settlement: hospital defendant have no pay status and
City willing to continue discussions; email client re: status; revising
letter to Judge; review of opinion on Mauriello counterclaim/motion
to strike Plaintiff (0.5); research on law enforcement privileged(1.0).

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

5/11/2014 NBS Prepare for James examination before trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

5/12/2014 NBS Prepare for and take James examination before trial.

6.80
575.00/hr

3,910.00

5/13/2014 NBS Travel to Holbrook and meet with Ferrara and his wife.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

5/14/2014 NBS Prepare and take examination before trial of Marquez.

8.40
575.00/hr

4,830.00

5/15/2014 NBS Prepare for and take examination before trial of Sangetti (4.5);
emails with client re: status and settlement (0.5).

5.00
575.00/hr

2,875.00

5/19/2014 NBS Review of production; prepare for meeting with client; telephone
call with co-counsel; research on discovery issues (law
enforcement privilege).

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

5/20/2014 NBS Travel to and from Johnstown, NY meeting with client; conference
with Magistrate Freeman; ex-parte conference with Magistrate
Freeman.

11.50
575.00/hr

6,612.50

5/22/2014 NBS Drafting opposition to City motion for protective order and
cross-motion for documents; research on same.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

5/23/2014 NBS Research on blue wall silence (2.5); telephone call to potential
witness (Stephen Lerner); telephone to Lubit; email team; email
client; review of document production; telephone conference with
Jon Norinsberg re: 81 locker photos.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

5/28/2014 NBS Prepare for conference of motion; appear on motion before Judge
Sweet (2.8); telephone call to Dr. Lubit; telephone call to the office
of Eterno; conference with all counsel re: schedule and need 30-45
days; prepare for Weiss examination before trial; conference with
team re: Weiss; telephone Jon Norinsberg re: locker photos.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

5/29/2014 NBS Prepare for Weiss; take Weiss examination before trial; prepare for
JHMC.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

5/30/2014 NBS Prepare for and take examination before trial of Jamaica Hospital
(Maffia)

19

Amount

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/2/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client; emails with opposing counsel re:
discovery; reviewing production for index.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

6/3/2014 NBS Email regarding plan for discovery; production of Aetna documents
and docket photos; telephone call to J. Ferrara re: examination
before trial for 6/5/14.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

6/4/2014 NBS Prepare for Ferrara examination before trial; telephone conference
with co-counsel re: same.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

6/5/2014 NBS Meeting with team and J. Ferrara; attend deposition of J. Ferrara at
Law Department; drafting discovery demands for Mauriello.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

6/6/2014 NBS Prepare discovery demands re: Mauriello (1.5); conference call with
John Eterno; Eli Silverman and team re: expert issues (compstat,
blue wall, and digital recorder); review of New York City conflict of
interest issue, law, decision (1.2)

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

6/8/2014 NBS Revising discovery demand for Mauriello counterclaim.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

6/9/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client re: status of case.

2.00
575.00/hr

1,150.00

6/10/2014 NBS Drafting demands on Mauriello; drafting letter to court re: amended
discovery schedules.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

6/11/2014 NBS Travel to Rhode Island and meet with Dr. Dan re: ER expert.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

6/12/2014 NBS Continue meeting with Dr. Dan re: ER expert; review parts of PX69
and home invasion recording with expert; revised and drafted
discovery demand; travel back to New York.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

6/13/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Eli Silverman and John Eterno re:
expert discovery schedule (1.0); review of conflict laws; telephone
call to Mag Bauza; telephone to John Lenoir; memo to file on ER
expert (.5)

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/16/2014 NBS Review of city letter re: supplemental discovery; conference with
co-counsel.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

6/17/2014 NBS Prepare for Broschart.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/18/2014 NBS Prepare for and take Broschart re: examination before trial.

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

20

Amount

6/19/2014 NBS Review of scheduling order; email with team re: schedule; email Dr.
Lubit; review of Patrol Guide; prepare for Duncan examination
before trial (3.0)

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/20/2014 NBS Draft opposition to reconsider; review of Duncan examination
before trial; prepare for Duncan.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/23/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client (log) re: status; prepare for and
take examination of Duncan; emails with opposing counsel re:
schedule; telephone call to Dr. Patel.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

6/26/2014 NBS Emails with opposing counsel re: schedule; conference with
co-counsel re: same.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

6/27/2014 NBS Review of Mauriello examination before trial; telephone call to Dr.
Roy Lubit; and prepare for Mauriello examination before trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/28/2014 NBS Review of Mauriello examination before trial; review of Lubit
affirmation in Monaco.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

6/29/2014 NBS Review of Mauriello examination before trial; prepare for continued
examination before trial of Mauriello (4.5); conference with client re:
status; email Dr. Lubit; email John Lenoir.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

7/1/2014 NBS Prepare and take Mauriello examination before trial.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

7/3/2014 NBS Prepare and take Dr. Lwin examination before trial; meeting with
team re: expert report; lunch with team.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

7/6/2014 NBS Prepare for Jamaica Hospital ebt (Dhar) on policy issue.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

7/7/2014 NBS Take and prepare for Jamaica Hospital examination before trial.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

7/9/2014 NBS Telephone conference with police experts.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

7/14/2014 NBS Prepare for examination before trial of City 30(b)(6) witnesses.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

7/15/2014 NBS Prepare for 30(b)(6) of witnesses on appeal; review and quatoa
issues; prepare for City examination before trial on training;
disciplines and crime reporting.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

7/16/2014 NBS Take deposition 30(b)(6) witnesses of City in the morning and
afternoon; prepare for same; conference with co-counsel;
conference with court clerk; prepare for examination before trial
next day.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

21

Amount

7/17/2014 NBS Prepare for and take examination before trial of City 30(b)(6)
witnesses on performance evaluation of supervisors and of police
officers.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

7/18/2014 NBS Review of prior arguments and submissions discussions
outstanding; conference with Dr. Halpern and team.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/21/2014 NBS Drafting letter to Court; review of transcript of prior hearing;
research on legal issues raised by objections and Purpi
examination before trial.

3.40
575.00/hr

1,955.00

7/22/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client and team; prepare letter.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

7/23/2014 NBS Prepare for examination before trial on Thursday; review of recent
City production; emails with opposing counsel re: examination
before trial.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

7/24/2014 NBS Prepare for and attend City 30(b)(6) (cooper); prepare for
examination before trial for Dr. Patel; conference with client.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

7/25/2014 NBS Prepare and take examination of trial of Dr. Patel; draft letter to
Court on application re: Dr. Patel.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/28/2014 NBS Review of Dr. Lwin examination before trial; review letter from
Jamaica Hospital.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

7/29/2014 NBS Emails and telephone conference with client and re: experts; review
of letters to Court.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

7/30/2014 NBS Telephone conference with John and Eli re: expert report.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

7/31/2014 NBS Review of earlier Silverman book on NYPD (2.8); drafting letter to
Judge Sweet; review of letter re: outstanding; telephone conference
with trial team and Dr. Lubit and Dr. Halpern.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

8/1/2014 NBS Review of letters on numerous discovery disputes; review of videos
of Dr. Patel's examination before trial; drafting letter on three motion
letter.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

8/3/2014 NBS Review and revise letter to Court; research on deposition conduct
re: definition of harassment.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

8/4/2014 NBS Drafting letter re: 3 discovery motions; long conference call with
experts Silverman and Eterno (1.5); preparing letter for experts on
police issues and transmitting documents to experts (2.5)

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

8/5/2014 NBS Revise letter to Court on 3 motions; draft second letter re: video
objection.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

22

Amount

8/6/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Mag Bauza to do list; meeting with John
Lenoir re: same; revise letter to Court re: video objection.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

8/7/2014 NBS Review of report; telephone call to John Eterno re: same.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

8/8/2014 NBS Review of reports of experts (police and ER); review of record from
psychiatric experts.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/2/2014 NBS Meeting with co-counsel; review of decisions on discovery; emails
re: scheduling with experts; telephone call with Roy Lubit re: same.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

9/3/2014 NBS Email to all counsel re: schedule; telephone call with Eli Silverman.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

9/5/2014 NBS Review of time limitation issues for examination before trials.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

9/10/2014 NBS Telephone conference with all counsel.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

9/11/2014 NBS Reply to Defendants' letter motion on experts; letter to all counsel
re: expert fees to be paid; review of cases on same.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/12/2014 NBS Travel to Upstate, NY to meet with client; meeting with clientc

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

9/13/2014 NBS Meeting all day with client, John Lenoir and Magdalena Bauza re
summary jugdment motions; motion to amend; wages/damages
issues; trial plans; expert discovery and reports

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

9/14/2014 NBS Meeting with client; return travel to New York

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

9/16/2014 NBS Telephone conference with experts; conference with co-counsel;
emails re: schedule with all counsel.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

9/17/2014 NBS Prepare for and take Purpi examination before trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/18/2014 NBS Prepare for examination before trial; telephone call with Walter
Kretz; telephone conference with Roy Lubit; review of expert
reports served today and with co-counsel.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/19/2014 NBS Prepare for and attaend Carrasco ebt

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

NBS Prepare for meeting with client; outline summary judgment motions;
causes of action.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

23

Amount

9/20/2014 NBS Review of medical expert reports by Jamaica Hospital Medical
Center; Bernier and Isakov.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

9/21/2014 NBS Meeting with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza; meeting with Lubit re:
examination before trial preparation.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/22/2014 NBS Email regarding schedule; telephone call with John Eterno.

0.40
575.00/hr

230.00

9/23/2014 NBS Prep for and attend examination before trial of Roy Lubit; call to
court re: schedule.

8.00
575.00/hr

4,600.00

9/24/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Roy Lubit; telephone call with John
Lenoir; review of emails; letter to court re: motion by city.

1.70
575.00/hr

977.50

9/25/2014 NBS Drafting opposition to discover motion.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/26/2014 NBS Review of production for motion to compel; telephone call with
co-counsel; message from Dr. Lubit.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

9/29/2014 NBS Meeting with Dr. Halpern Ruder and John Lenoir; prepare for
examination before trial; review of CompSTAT notes.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

9/30/2014 NBS Appear for and defendant Ruder examination before trial; prepare
for conference the following day; review of CompSTAT notes.

8.90
575.00/hr

5,117.50

10/2/2014 NBS Email re: scheduling Silverman and Lubit; conference call with John
Lenoir and Mag Bauza re: trial prep review of CompStat notes.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/3/2014 NBS Legal research on Monell issues (1.8) meeting with Mag and John
Lenoir; emails re: trial date; conference with client re: status and
trial date; review of Nelson discover records (1.5); review of Patrol
Guide; review of CompStat notes (2.0); prep motion for discovery.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

10/6/2014 NBS Drafting motion for discovery; drafting letter re: opposition to
adjourn for trial date; emails with opposing counsel; scheduling
Patel examination before trial; telephone call to the clerk for Patel's
attorney.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

10/7/2014 NBS Draft motion on discovery.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/8/2014 NBS Review of Floyd record; research on witness list issues; telephone
call with Dr. Dan Halpern; email correspondences Silverman and
Eterno.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

10/9/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client; review of Eterno production;
email re: same; review of Floyd trial.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

24

Amount

10/10/2014 NBS Review of Floyd transcripts and decision.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/14/2014 NBS Meeting with Eterno (2.5); travel to Hempstead (2.0); review of Rule
68 offer (.5); review of Floyd trial transripts and decision

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

10/15/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Walter Kretz re: Mauriello; wants a
small compensation from Adrian to settle (.3); telephone call to
Suzanna Mettham and Ryan Shaffer re: Rule 68 offer (.4); drafting
reply letter on discovery motion (3.8); briefing schedule and witness
lists.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

10/16/2014 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir; drafting letter to court on
discovery motions/issue (2.8); research on Rule 68 issues (2.5);
email re: discovery schedule.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

10/17/2014 NBS Appear for and defend Eterno examination before trial; revise and
file letter with court re: outstanding discovery issues.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

10/18/2014 NBS Research on Rule 68; draft and send memo to client re: Rule 68
offer; telephone client re: same; telephone call to John Lenoir re:
same.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/19/2014 NBS Review of 2nd Amended Complaint for purpose of motion to
amend; conference call with team re: Rule 68 offer; email exchange
with Howard Suckle re: same.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/20/2014 NBS Telephone conference with with John Eterno (1.5) re: examination
before trial and case; telephone call with chambers re: next
conference; emails re: same; revising pleading for purpose of
motion; review of case law on right to refuse medical treatment
(1.5).

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

10/21/2014 NBS Review of right to refuse medical treatment cases; emails re:
schedule; telephone to Eli Silverman re: his examination before trial.

3.70
575.00/hr

2,127.50

10/22/2014 NBS Meeting with Eli Silverman to prepare for examination before trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/23/2014 NBS Prepare for Silverman; telephone call to Silverman (2 times); review
of report; draft letter rejecting Rule 68 offer.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

10/24/2014 NBS Defend Silverman's examination before trial.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

10/25/2014 NBS Research on criminal standard for exigent circumstances.

3.00
575.00/hr

1,725.00

10/26/2014 NBS Revise letter re: rejection of Rule 68 offer.

1.00
575.00/hr

575.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

25

Amount

10/27/2014 NBS Meeting with John Lenoir re: amended complaint; review of emails;
telephone call to Investigator Skinner; email with Silverman review
of discovery record on complaint; review of tapes re: Amended
Complaint.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

10/28/2014 NBS Prepare revisions to 2nd Amended Complaint for motion to arrest;
research on issues relating to motion to amend.

6.80
575.00/hr

3,910.00

10/29/2014 NBS Prepare for court; appear in court; conference with client and John
Lenoir re: status.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

10/30/2014 NBS Prepare for Patel examination before trial; research warrantless
entry and search.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

10/31/2014 NBS Prepare for and take 2nd examination before trial of Dr. Patel (3.2);
research on causes of action for motions to amend and summary
judgment.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

11/1/2014 NBS Research on exigent circumstances case law.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

11/3/2014 NBS Research an existing cir. case law (3.0); telephone conference with
Roy Lubit; emails with opposing counsel; revised 2nd Amended
Complaint for motion to amend.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

11/4/2014 NBS Drafting motion to amend; letter to court re: page limit; email client
re: status.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

11/5/2014 NBS Drafting motion to amend.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

11/6/2014 NBS Telephone conference with client re: amending complaint.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

11/7/2014 NBS Meeting with S. Korenbaum; emails re: status; telephone call with
Dr. Lubit.

2.20
575.00/hr

1,265.00

11/10/2014 NBS Telephone conference with Dr. Lubit; attend and defend
examination before trial of Dr. Lubit at Martin Clearwater; review of
draft Amended Complaint; research on 4th Amendment warrantless
entry (1.5)

5.20
575.00/hr

2,990.00

11/11/2014 NBS Telephone conference with paralegal (JS) re: case; review of ebt
summaries.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

11/13/2014 NBS Appear and defend Dr. Lubit; conference re: examination before
trial with witness.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

11/14/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial summaries and indexes.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

26

Amount

11/16/2014 NBS Revise complaint; email re: same.

1.00
575.00/hr

575.00

11/19/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial of Lauterborn and Mauriello on
questions about evaluations; email client re: same.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

11/20/2014 NBS Review of file in Azira case on Blue Wall.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

11/21/2014 NBS Emails re: Lubit; review of Azira files.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

12/1/2014 NBS Revising motion to amend

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

12/2/2014 NBS Revise memo re: motion to amend.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/3/2014 NBS Revising 3rd Amended Complaint and Memo Of Law In Support Of
Motion To Amend.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/4/2014 NBS Revising Amended Complaint and Memo on motion to amend;
began review of depositions for summary judgment motion.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

12/5/2014 NBS Review of letters; review of Duncan transcripts, emails with team
re: status.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

12/7/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial record.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

12/8/2014 NBS Drafting letter to Court re: motion to amend; review of examinations
before trial for motion for summary judgment.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/9/2014 NBS Drafting letter to Court re: defendants' motion to adjourn trial and
summary judgment; review of examinations before trial for
summary judgment motion; review of Compstat video.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

12/10/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial for preparation of motions
meeting with John Lenoir re: motions.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

12/11/2014 NBS Review of examination before trial for summary judgment motion;
conference with M. Bauza re: JHMC claims; review of cases.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

12/12/2014 NBS Review of record for summary judgment motion.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/13/2014 NBS Research on exig. cir. exception.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/14/2014 NBS Review of examination for summary judgment facts; review of exig.
cir. cases; review of prima facie tort and tortuous interference case.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

27

Amount

12/15/2014 NBS Research on Mauriello counterclaims.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

12/16/2014 NBS Drafting summary judgment motion.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

12/17/2014 NBS Drafting summary judgment motion.

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

12/18/2014 NBS Drafting summary judgment motion.

12.00
575.00/hr

6,900.00

12/19/2014 NBS Drafting motion for summary judgment.

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

12/20/2014 NBS Drafting summary judgment memo.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

12/21/2014 NBS Drafting summary judgment motion.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

12/22/2014 NBS Draft motions; memo; Rule 56.1 Statement; conference with client
re: sealing and objection to it; letters (2x) Court.

12.50
575.00/hr

7,187.50

12/23/2014 NBS Revising and filing paper; review of paper.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

12/24/2014 NBS Preparing motion papers

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

12/29/2014 NBS Drafting Reply Memo on motion to amend.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

12/30/2014 NBS Researching motion for summary judgment.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/1/2015 NBS Review of motions by defendants.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

1/3/2015 NBS Reading City motion and case law.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

1/4/2015 NBS Reading Mauriello and JHMC motions and case law.

8.20
575.00/hr

4,715.00

NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir; telephone call to client re:
Norinsberg; drafting summary judgment; review of new material.
12/31/2014 NBS Draft opposition to summary judgment.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

28

Amount

1/5/2015 NBS Review of motions; review of recent production by City (videos and
EIU file); conference with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza re: motions.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

1/7/2015 NBS Reviewing motions; meeting with John Lenoir; J. Mck; J.S re:
Compstat videos.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

1/8/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Howard Suckle (.3); meeting with Mag
(.1.5); telephone call to Ryan Shaffer; Paul Callan; Gregory
Radmosili re: summary judgment schedule; review of Lauterborn
examination before trial (4.5)

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

1/9/2015 NBS Emails re: status; conference with team; conference call with client.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

1/10/2015 NBS Review of examinations before trial and Compstat videos.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/11/2015 NBS Review of examination before trial and Compstat videos;
conference with group on Commpstat videos.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/13/2015 NBS Compstat vide review

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

1/14/2015 NBS Conference with client and John Lenoir; review of examination
before trial and motions.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/15/2015 NBS Review of Hanlon examination before trial; review of Marino
examination before trial; review of cases in summary judgment
motion discussion re: Compstat videos.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

1/16/2015 NBS Review of Hanlon examination before trial; review of cases; review
of Compstat video.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/17/2015 NBS Review of examination before trial; prepare summary judgment
oppositions.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/18/2015 NBS Prepare summary judgment opposition; review of Hanlon,
Sangianetti, and Marquez examination before trial; review of
Compstat videos.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

1/19/2015 NBS Review of Compstat videos; review of cases cited in various
motions; research on standard of objective/subjective good faith
and qualified immunity.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/20/2015 NBS Review of decision on motion to amend; review of cases on
conspiracy; review of examination before trial for motion.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

1/21/2015 NBS Drafting summary judgment motion papers (memo of law; rule 56.1
statement); telephone Ryan Shaffer; call Norinsberg re: wants
co-counsel to get access to Adrian Schoolcraft's records (medical)
in IAB file.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

29

Amount

1/22/2015 NBS Drafting memo in opposition; telephone call to Walter Kretz; emails
re: schedule.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/23/2015 NBS Research and draft Response to Mauriello summary judgment
motion.

9.00
575.00/hr

5,175.00

1/24/2015 NBS Review of record; research on cases cited by defendants summary
judgment motion.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

1/25/2015 NBS Review of record for summary judgment motion opposition.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/26/2015 NBS Drafting opposition papers; research on probable cause.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

1/27/2015 NBS Meeting with John and Mag re: summary judgment motion; draft
opposition; research on St amendment issues.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

2/1/2015 NBS Drafting opposition to motions.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

2/2/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Jon Norinsberg (.5); meeting with John
Lenoir re to do list for trial(1.2); conference with client and John
Lenoir re: trial team; drafting opposition to motion (5.0); telephone
call to client re: same; letter to court re: schedule adjustment.

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

2/3/2015 NBS Review of Monell case law for motion; review of supplemental
papers filed by all defendants.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

2/4/2015 NBS Email with client; review of cases on Monell liability; review of
record (ebt's) on Monell issues.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

2/5/2015 NBS Drafting opposition brief.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

2/6/2015 NBS Drafting opposition papers.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

2/7/2015 NBS Drafting opposition to Jamaica Hospital and doctor motion.

7.80
575.00/hr

4,485.00

2/8/2015 NBS Drafting opposition to Dr. Bernier and Dr. Isakov's motions;
conference with John Lenoir; telephone call with Mag Bauza.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

2/9/2015 NBS Drafting opposition motion; conference with John Lenoir (.5)
telephone call with Mag Bauza; drafting 56.1 opposition; telephone
conference with Brian Lee re: Isakov claims (0.2).

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

12.50
575.00/hr

7,187.50

2/10/2015 NBS Opposition motion ; telephone conference with Ryan Shaffer;
telephone call with Jon Norinsberg; email client.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

30

Amount

2/12/2015 NBS Telephone conference with client; call with Jon Norinsberg and
John Lenoir; emails; telephone call with new city lawyer; review of
files under seal; review of opposition motion.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

2/13/2015 NBS Review of 5 oppositions to summary judgment motion & meeting
with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza re: issues to address (3.5),
telephone call to client (2 times); emails re: trial date; telephone to
Jon Norinsberf re: meeting and status.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

2/17/2015 NBS Review of files on summary judgment papers.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/20/2015 NBS Meeting with John Lenoir and Mag Bauza; meeting with Jon
Norinsberg and his group (Gerald Cohen and Joshua Fitch).

4.80
575.00/hr

2,760.00

2/23/2015 NBS Meeting with John Lenoir re: reply to Mauriello.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

2/27/2015 NBS Preparing reply papers.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

3/3/2015 NBS Drafting reply.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

3/4/2015 NBS Drafting reply.

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

3/5/2015 NBS Drafting reply.

10.50
575.00/hr

6,037.50

3/6/2015 NBS Drafting reply.

9.50
575.00/hr

5,462.50

3/9/2015 NBS Research on new evidence issue; telephone conference with team;
revising letter to Court on Matthews.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

3/10/2015 NBS Review of cases on s/i; review of reply submission.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/12/2015 NBS Research on new evidece and new arguments on reply ; meeting
with team.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

3/13/2015 NBS Meeting with team re: trial preparation; drafting letter to Court.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

3/15/2015 NBS Research on motion to strike.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

3/16/2015 NBS Drafting motion to strike.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

31

Amount

3/17/2015 NBS Drafting motion to strike Lamstein Declaration.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

3/18/2015 NBS Review of JPTO reqirement; telephone call to Walter Kretz re:
status; drafting verdict sheet; prepare for trial; review of subpoenas;
meeting witj John Lenoir re: trial lists of witnesses and exhibits.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

3/20/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Walter Kretz re: Kickstarter movie;
email with trial team re; inquiry.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

3/21/2015 NBS Drafting letter re: Lamstein; Q/F issue and adjournment request;
review of exhibit lists for JPTO.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/22/2015 NBS Review of exhibits for JPTO; revise letter to Court.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/23/2015 NBS Prepare witness and exhibit list; rewrite letter to Court.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

3/25/2015 NBS Emails re: status; conference with Scott Korenbaum re:
instructions; telephone conference with John Lenoir and Mag
Bauza re: instructions and to do.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

3/26/2015 NBS Review of production (discs & cd's) for plaintiff's trial exhibit.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

3/27/2015 NBS Review of production for JPTO; emails to opposing counsel; emails
to co-counsel re: status.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

3/29/2015 NBS Review of discovery record for JPTO and witness cross.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

3/30/2015 NBS Review of discovery record for JPTO - exhibits and witness;
telephone call to John Lenoir re: witness responsibilities; telephone
to Mag Bauza re: jury instructions and diagram.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

3/31/2015 NBS Review of discovery for witness list, exhibit list, and JPTO; emails
with opposing counsel re: service of subpoenas.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

4/1/2015 NBS Email team; telephone call Brown (Daily News) re: status; study of
hospital chart; review of Bernier examination of trial and prepare
cross.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

4/2/2015 NBS Meeting with team; review of trial exhibits; conference call with
John Lenoir re: Compstat; call with Mag re: jury instruction; prepare
for cross of Bernier.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

4/3/2015 NBS Prepare for cross of Bernier; review of chart and examination
before trial.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

32

Amount

4/4/2015 NBS Prepare cross of Bernier; review of trial exhibits; review of draft jury
instructions.

6.50
575.00/hr

3,737.50

4/5/2015 NBS Prepare of Isakov cross; review of examination before trial and
chart.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

4/6/2015 NBS Email team; telephone call to Scott Korenbaum re: jury change;
prepare Isakov cross.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

4/7/2015 NBS Review of and revise motion in limine; review of and revise jury
instructions (medical); draft leter to Court re: extension; continued
preparation on Isakov cross.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

4/8/2015 NBS Drafting cross - outlines; letter to court; conference with trial team.

5.80
575.00/hr

3,335.00

4/9/2015 NBS Prepare for trial - jury verdict sheets and cross examination outlines
of witnesses

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

4/10/2015 NBS Prepare for Harlon cross; emails re: status; telephone call to Mag
Bauza re: to do; telephone conference with John Lenoir re:
witnesses; review of witness list.

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

4/12/2015 NBS Prepare for Harlon cross (3.0); review of Lauterborn transcript.

4.00
575.00/hr

2,300.00

4/13/2015 NBS Prepare for oral argument; appear in court for conference with court
(2.0); conference with team thereafter; email opposing counsel re:
Lauterborn CD and Boston illness.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

4/15/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Alan Scheiner re: settlement and trial
date; emails re: discovery and Boston.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

4/17/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Alan Scheiner and team re: settlement
demand email.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

4/29/2015 NBS Review of new recording from City on Lauterborn PG; email trial
team restatus; telephone call G. Radomisli re: status of trial.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

5/5/2015 NBS Review of review of decision on summary judgment motion.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

5/7/2015 NBS Review of decision; telephone call with opposing counsel (Brian
Lee) re: state medical malpractice sliding scale issues and status.

1.30
575.00/hr

747.50

5/8/2015 NBS Telephone conference with trial team re: status.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

NBS Review of decision; email team.

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

33

Amount

5/11/2015 NBS Review of decision on summary judgment; prepare for conference
with court.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

5/12/2015 NBS Prepare for conference meeting with team; conference with court
on case re: schedule for trial and pre-trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

5/13/2015 NBS Telephone conference with Dr. Lubit re: status and trial date;
telephone call to Dr. Eterno re: status and trial date.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

5/15/2015 NBS Emails re: schedule on motions in limine; review of recent EDP
decision.

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

5/21/2015 NBS Telephone conference with A. Schiener; email team re: settlement.

0.80
575.00/hr

460.00

5/22/2015 NBS Review of recent EDP decision.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

5/28/2015 NBS Review of memo re: reconsideration; telephone call with John
Lenoir and email with MG re: same.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

5/29/2015 NBS Prepare reconsideration letter.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

6/1/2015 NBS Drafting letter to court on reconsideration motion.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

6/2/2015 NBS Revising and drafting reconsideration motion.

3.00
575.00/hr

1,725.00

6/15/2015 NBS Review of calendar; telephone call to John Lenoir re: status.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

6/19/2015 NBS Review of motion by City and authorities.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

6/22/2015 NBS Emails re: motions; review of City memo; telephone conference
with City; call to W. Kretz; review of Mauriello memo; emails with
team re: schedule.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

6/23/2015 NBS Email team re: schedule; telephone call to city counsel re: same;
email all counsel re: same.

0.60
575.00/hr

345.00

6/24/2015 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir; telephone S.K. re:
opposition to bifurcation; emails to counsel re: schedule; letter to
Judge Sweet re: schedule; review of motion on bifurcation.

1.30
575.00/hr

747.50

6/25/2015 NBS Emails with counsel re: status; letter to court re: schedule; review of
trial exhibit folder.

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

34

Amount

6/26/2015 NBS Review of draft portion of opposition to bifurcation.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

6/28/2015 NBS Review of draft memo; revise same.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

6/29/2015 NBS Review memo in opposition to bifurcation motion; telephone call to
Scott Korenbaum; call to John Lenoir re: same.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

6/30/2015 NBS Review of motions, memo, and case law on reconsideration
motions by City and Mauriello.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/1/2015 NBS Review of reconsideration motion.

1.80
575.00/hr

1,035.00

7/3/2015 NBS Review of recent production from City Defendants; review of
reconsideration motions.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/4/2015 NBS Drafting opposition to reconsideration motions.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

7/5/2015 NBS Drafting opposition to reconsideration motions.

4.00
575.00/hr

2,300.00

7/6/2015 NBS Revising opposition papers; email co-counsel; emails to opposing
counsel.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

7/7/2015 NBS Review of schedule; review of emails.

0.50
575.00/hr

287.50

7/8/2015 NBS Review of recent and prior productions by the City

7.50
575.00/hr

4,312.50

7/15/2015 NBS Review of emails; telephone call to John Lenoir re: expert
discovery; review of opposition to reconsideratio motions; review of
prior record for reply; review of motion in limine and schedule for
trial preparation.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

7/17/2015 NBS Telephone conference with John Lenoir; review of CompStat clips;
review of emails.

1.20
575.00/hr

690.00

7/21/2015 NBS Preparing memo in reply on reconsideration.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

7/22/2015 NBS Drafting reply on reconsideration; review of documentary on
Schoolcraft; emails with team; review of tape and transcript of the
home invasion; review of witness list and trial exhibits.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

7/23/2015 NBS Drafting reply; review of witness list and exhibit trial list for JPTO.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

35

Amount

8/4/2015 NBS Preparing JPTO draft section.

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

8/5/2015 NBS Preparing JPTO section; telephone call with team re: same.

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

8/7/2015 NBS Review of JPTO sections from defendants; telephone call with
Brian Osterman; conference call with Plaintiff's team re: JPTO
objections; letter to Judge Sweet opposing motion to strike reply.

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

8/9/2015 NBS Review of JPTO submissions and interrogation of sections; email
team; email opposing counsel re: schedule; review of trial
assignments.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/10/2015 NBS Revised JPTO; letter to court re: schedule; emails with co-counsel;
emails with opposing counsel re: JPTO.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/11/2015 NBS Revising JPTO; review defendant's depositions; objections to
exhibits.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/13/2015 NBS Prepare letter motion to court re: JPTO deadlines; review of recent
production and emails re: status with defense counsel.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

8/14/2015 NBS Revising section of JPTO; review and inclusion in sections from
defendants; emails with opposing counsel and co-counsel re:
JPTO; conference with John Lenoir re: rifle issues for trial.

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

8/16/2015 NBS Review of Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits; review of objections.

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

8/17/2015 NBS Review of JPTO; telephone call with Kretz; review of letter to court
from city.

2.50
575.00/hr

1,437.50

8/18/2015 NBS Letter to court in reply on JPTO adjournment.

1.50
575.00/hr

862.50

8/19/2015 NBS Preparing JPTO; review of emails; preparing witness focus sheets;
review of all defendants exhibits for purposes of asserting
objections.

8.50
575.00/hr

4,887.50

8/20/2015 NBS Review of exhibits and serve photos on defendants by email and
fax; letter to court re: filing JPTO; revise and file plaintiff's draft of
pre-trial order.

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

8/21/2015 NBS Preparing witness focus sheets; email opposing counsel re status
and moiton in limine deadline; and to do (Larry Schoolcraft very
sick and in hospital).

4.30
575.00/hr

2,472.50

8/24/2015 NBS Preparing focus sheets; email co-counsel re: mental patient gun
rights.

1.30
575.00/hr

747.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

36

Amount

8/25/2015 NBS Review of various recordings listed on JPTO; letter to court in
opposition to motions.

5.00
575.00/hr

2,875.00

8/31/2015 NBS Telephone conference with clerk and parties; telephone call with
John Norinsberg re status; review of draft motion.

1.30
575.00/hr

747.50

9/2/2015 NBS Telephone conference with W. Kretz re status

0.30
575.00/hr

172.50

9/4/2015 NBS Review of and drafting JPTO; long tc with A Scheinder (3x) with J
Norinsberg re settlement; tc JL re settlement; email team re same

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

9/6/2015 NBS Review of caselaw and statutory provisions for obtaining disability
pension; review of summary plan description for pension benefits

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

9/7/2015 NBS Preparing for trial; preparing cross examinaiton outlines and focus
sheets for witnesses set to testify or likely to testify for various
witness assignements fro trial team

4.50
575.00/hr

2,587.50

9/8/2015 NBS Telephone conference with JN; tc A Schiener (several times) re
settlement; email all counsel re JPTO and new exhibits added; tc B
Osterman re request to discontinue against JHMC (less than 6
figures)

3.50
575.00/hr

2,012.50

9/9/2015 NBS Telephone conference with A Schiener and with co-counsel re
settlement (JN: PG; Harvey Levine; Rick Guilbert) re issues
pertaining to additional pension benefits; review of caselaw cited by
the City on pension issues

3.20
575.00/hr

1,840.00

9/11/2015 NBS Telephone conference with A Schiener and JN re settlement and
willing to increase offer of cash some

0.70
575.00/hr

402.50

9/12/2015 NBS Preparing for trial; drafting cross outlines and witness focus sheets
for trial witnesses and their key points

5.50
575.00/hr

3,162.50

9/15/2015 NBS Telephone conference with A Scheiner re no deal w/o pension
benefit; tc JN re status; drafting detailed settlement memo to cleint
on settlement

3.80
575.00/hr

2,185.00

9/16/2015 NBS Telephone conference with A Scheiner; conf call with JN and GC re
settlement; revised detailed memo to client re settlement; tc JL re
same; email cleint re settlement

2.80
575.00/hr

1,610.00

For professional services rendered

2246.00

$1,291,450.00

Schoolcraft

Page

37

Additional Charges :
Amount
4/25/2013 Amtrak travel from April 25, 2013 to April 27, 2013.

90.00

4/29/2013 Amtrak to Amsterdam, New York.

41.00

6/26/2013 Travel and conference room expense.

211.80

6/28/2013 Sunoco gas station in Sloatburg, NY.

46.54

Holiday Inn Hotel Johnstown, NY.

137.57

7/10/2013 Schoolcraft travel.

164.00

7/11/2013 Amtrak to Albany, NY.

164.00

8/8/2013 LIRR Ticket Jamaica, NY

70.00

8/15/2013 Lodging, gas, and tolls.

380.00

8/27/2013 Travel ($28) and lunch $155.00.

183.00

Travel to Jersey City to meet witness

28.00

9/16/2013 Travel - Amtrack

90.00

9/18/2013 Amtrak Amsterdam to New York.

90.00

9/20/2013 NYC Taxi - Brooklyn, NY.

18.20

NYC Taxi - New York.
9/23/2013 Metro-North New York, NY.
10/30/2013 Photgraphy - SIte Visits to 81st Precient and Jamacia Hospital
11/5/2013 Duplication and Federal Express

15.50
17.00
1,000.00
121.63

11/22/2013 Big Apple Copy Center copies of PDF NYC00010461-NYC00011628.

114.35

11/25/2013 Photocopies of deposition transcripts.

114.35

12/13/2013 Park Slope Inn - overnght

1,193.68

1/3/2014 Amtrak tickets from Amsterdam to New York roundtrip

186.00

1/6/2014 Boston Dep Tr.

843.15

Huffman transcript

1,224.75

Schoolcraft

Page

38

Amount
2/18/2014 Elise Hanlon deposition transcript from Veritext.
3/12/2014 Schoolcraft diskette from the Southern District Reporters.

1,882.40
31.50

Waiting Time for Court Reporter fee.

190.00

Statement on the record documented at Walter Kretz, Esq. office.

165.00

3/13/2014 Michael Marino deposition transcript from Veritext.
Theodore Lauterborn deposition transcript from Veritext.
4/23/2014 Bernier Dep Tr.
5/9/2014 Timothy Caughey deposition transcript from Veritext.

2,856.10
2,436.65
2,238.70
2,164.70

Steven Mauriello deposition transcript from Veritext.

2,740.10

William Gough deposition transcript from Veritext.

1,314.70

5/20/2014 Vintage Cafe for lunch in Johnstown, NY.

26.90

5/23/2014 Stroz Friedberg ckt # 2953 - digital evidence company

602.89

5/30/2014 JHMC - Maffia 30(b)(6) ebt tr

711.00

6/5/2014 Ferrara Dep Tr

651.75

6/6/2014 Shantel James deposition transcript from Veritext.

924.75

6/17/2014 Dr. Catherine Lamstein-Reiss deposition transcript.

2,557.64

Steven Weiss deposition transcript from Veritext.

1,193.25

Dr. Catherine Lamstein-Reiss deposition transcript.

2,557.64

Dr. Isakov deposition transcript.

1,596.60

6/19/2014 Travel for Adrian Schoolcraft from Amsterdam, NY on Amtrak
6/20/2014 Kurt Duncan deposition transcript.
Amtrak for Adrian Schoolcraft New York to Amsterdam, NY.

109.00
1,470.00
39.00

6/24/2014 Dinner with Expert

188.30

7/3/2014 Lwin deposion tr

397.21

7/4/2014 Park Slope Inn - overnight

716.21

Schoolcraft

Page

39

Amount
7/7/2014 Dhar Dep Tr.
7/11/2014 Eli Silverman Ckt # 2973
John Eterno chlt # 2974
7/15/2014 Whittman 30b6 tr
whalen 30b6 tr
Southern District Court Reporter.

1,081.38
3,000.00
3,000.00
422.19
346.20
50.40

7/16/2014 Valenti 30b6 ebt tr

319.95

7/17/2014 Milone 30(b)(6) ebt

498.18

Finnegan 30(b)(6) dep tr

560.17

7/22/2014 Travel on Amtrak from Amsterdam, NY to Manhattan.

173.00

7/25/2014 Car service for witness Dr. Patel.

115.00

7/26/2014 Amtrak New York to Amsterdam, NY.
7/28/2014 Jessica Marquez deposition transcript.

64.00
1,478.25

Steven Mauriello deposition transcript., dated July 1, 2014.

2,188.50

Christopher Broschart deposition transcript.

1,532.75

Frederick Sawyer deposition transcript.

1,421.00

Sal Sangetti deposition transcript.

1,074.50

9/3/2014 Eli Silverman expert fee.
photocopying per page; IOD Inc Putnam Hospital - Mauriello authorizations ckt # 2985
photocopying per page Garfield Pharmacy re Mauriello authorizations ckt # 2984
9/8/2014 Eli Silverman hk # 2986
photocopying per page; Valley Stream - Mauriello authorizations; chk # 2987

1,950.00
168.17
35.00
1,950.00
30.00

9/13/2014 Cabin rental at Bunker Hill to meet with client from September 12, 2014 to September 14,
2014.

200.00

9/15/2014 Hannaford - Gloversville, NY.

110.03

ExxonMobil gas station Mayfield, NY.

51.76

Schoolcraft

Page

40

Amount
9/16/2014 Purpi Dep day one (7-16-14 at 455.66) and day two (9-16-14 433.96)
9/17/2014 Transcript of court appearance with Judge Sweet.
9/19/2014 Carrasco Dep Tr.
9/23/2014 Eternon chk # 2991
John Eterno expert fee
9/30/2014 Eli Silverman expert fee.

889.62
29.70
337.25
1,800.00
1,800.00
2,400.00

Dr. Halpren-Ruder Fees and Expenses for deposition

4,010.35

Eli Siverman; chk # 2994

2,400.00

10/8/2014 Federal Express

32.43

10/21/2014 Dr. Halpren-Ruder Fees

4,400.00

10/28/2014 Transcript of witness Alan Cooper.

1,048.48

Transcript of witness Timothy Trainor.

1,583.01

Transcript of witness William Gough.

509.07

Transcript of witness Dr. Indira Patel.

546.65

10/31/2014 patel day two ebt tr
11/12/2014 Trainor deposition transcript sent by regular mail.
11/19/2014 Amtrak to New York back to Amsterdam, NY.

523.42
7.55
256.00

11/24/2014 Eterno and Silverman deposition transcripts for review by experts sent regular mail.

12.50

11/25/2014 Federal Express documents to Dr. Roy Lubit.

20.00

12/2/2014 Federal Express Dr. Roy Lubit deposition transcript, dated September 2014.

21.94

12/4/2014 Anthony Maffia deposition transcript to Veritext court reporting.

711.00

12/5/2014 Big Apple Copy Center copies and velobind Memo of Law in Support of Motion to Amend,
Notice of Motion, and Exhibits 1-9.

142.41

Kurt Duncan deposition transcript to Veritext court reporting.
12/8/2014 Kurt Duncan day two dated 6/23/14 deposition transcript to Suzanna Mettham.
Anthony Maffia deposition transcript to Gregory Radomisli by regular mail.

521.00
5.45
5.45

Schoolcraft

Page

41

Amount
12/12/2014 Federal Express
Dr. Roy Lubit third deposition transcript by mail.
12/15/2014 Mail to all opposing counsel Plaintiff's Deposition Exhibits #105-174.

20.00
5.45
5.75

12/17/2014 Big Apple Copy Center for copies, exhibits tabs, and velobind Brief.

142.41

12/24/2014 Big Apple Copy Center copies with tabs.

347.55

1/21/2015 Binding and copying.
2/12/2015 Photocopy and velobind Memo of Law In Opposition of Plaintiff's Motion and Rule 56.1
Statement for Judge Sweet.
Photocopy and velobind Declaration of Nathaniel B. Smith with Exhibits ("POX") Number
1-59 for Judge Sweet.
3/9/2015 Photocopies and velobind brief for Judge Sweet.

347.55
83.00
341.97
81.98

10/19/2015 Private Investigator - Skinner

7,254.85

11/10/2015 Park Slope Inn-overniight

1,984.43

11/17/2015 Dr. Lubit Invoice and time records at $500 per hour and $3,500 per half day
Total costs

58,715.00
$151,470.16

Total amount of this bill

$1,442,920.16

Balance due

$1,442,920.16

Law Office of Nathaniel B. Smith
100 Wall Street - 23rd Floor
New York, NY 10005

Invoice submitted to:
Schoolcraft

November 24, 2015
Invoice #10032

Professional Services
Hrs/Rate
12/31/2014 JM

Amount

Office meeting.

1.50
250.00/hr

375.00

1/10/2015 JM

Review of CompStat videos.

4.00
250.00/hr

1,000.00

1/11/2015 JM

Review of CompStat videos.

2.00
250.00/hr

500.00

Discussions of Compstat and Schoolcraft materials.

0.75
250.00/hr

187.50

1/14/2015 JM

Review of CompStat videos.

3.00
250.00/hr

750.00

1/16/2015 JM

Review of CompStat videos.

11.00
250.00/hr

2,750.00

1/19/2015 JM

Telephone conference discussing Schoolcraft and CompStat.

0.59
250.00/hr

147.50

1/31/2015 JM

Email communication of summary judgment City response.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

2/1/2015 JM

Email of summary judgment City response.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

2/3/2015 JM

Email correspondence of City response.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

JM

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

2

Amount

2/5/2015 JM

Email of summary judgment on City reponse.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

2/6/2015 JM

Email regarding summary judgment to City reponse.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

Email exchange for summary judgment for City response.

0.09
250.00/hr

22.50

2/12/2015 JM

For professional services rendered
Balance due

23.38

$5,845.00
$5,845.00

Law Office of Nathaniel B. Smith
111 Broadway - Suite 1305
New York, NY 10006

Invoice submitted to:
Schoolcraft

November 18, 2015
Invoice #10032

Professional Services
Hrs/Rate

Amount

9/7/2014 JL

Read Schoolcraft deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/8/2014 JL

Read Schoolcraft deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/9/2014 JL

Read Schoolcraft deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/10/2014 JL

Read Schoolcraft deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/16/2014 JL

Ferrara summary deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/17/2014 JL

Ferrara summary deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

9/23/2014 JL

Ferrara summary deposition.

8.00
125.00/hr

1,000.00

9/24/2014 JL

Ferrara and Broschart summary deposition.

8.00
125.00/hr

1,000.00

9/25/2014 JL

Broschart summary deposition.

8.00
125.00/hr

1,000.00

9/30/2014 JS

Reading, taking notes and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

5.50
125.00/hr

687.50

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

2

Amount

9/30/2014 JS

Reading, taking notes and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

5.50
125.00/hr

687.50

10/1/2014 JS

Reading and taking notes on "NYPD Tapes."

1.50
125.00/hr

187.50

Reading and taking notes on NYPD tapes

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

Reading and taking notes on Schoolcraft Depositions; listening to and
discussing Schoolcraft tapes from October 31, 2009.

4.43
125.00/hr

553.75

Reading and taking notes on the Schoolcraft depositions; listening to
and discussing the Schoolcraft tapes from October 31, 2009.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

10/3/2014 LS

Trainor summary deposition.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

10/6/2014 JS

Reading, taking notes, and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

10/7/2014 JS

Reading and taking notes and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

2.50
125.00/hr

312.50

10/8/2014 LS

Trainor summary deposition.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with errata sheet.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

10/9/2014 JS

Reading, taking notes and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

JS

Reading, taking notes, and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

1.75
125.00/hr

218.75

LS

Trainor summary deposition.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

JL

Drafting deposition summary - session 2 with errata sheet.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

Reading, taking notes and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

Trainor summary deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

Reading and taking notes.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

JS
10/2/2014 JS
JS

JL

10/10/2014 JS
LS
10/14/2014 JS

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

3

Amount

10/14/2014 JS

Reading and taking notes on the Schoolcraft depositions.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

10/15/2014 JS

Reading and discussing the Schoolcraft depositions.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

10/16/2014 JL

Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with errata sheet.

8.00
125.00/hr

1,000.00

10/17/2014 JL

Mauriello deposition summary - session 2 with errata sheet.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/19/2014 JL

Shantel James deposition summary.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

10/20/2014 JL

Shantel James deposition summary.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

10/21/2014 LS

Gough deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/22/2014 JL

Kurt Duncan deposition summary.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

Gough deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Kurt Duncan deposition summary.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

Listening to radio police calls on disc 10, 22 and Schoolcraft
surveillance videos.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/24/2014 LS

Sawyer deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/27/2014 LS

Sawyer deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/28/2014 LS

Sawyer deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

10/29/2014 JS

Reviewing surveillance videos of Adrian's house and writing
summaries of these videos along with other documents on the CD's
from the Schoolcraft file.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

10/30/2014 LS

Sawyer deposition summary.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

10/31/2014 LS

Gough deposition summary.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

LS
10/23/2014 JL
JS

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

4

Amount

11/3/2014 LS

Summarize Gough deposition transcript.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

11/7/2014 LS

Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.

4.50
125.00/hr

562.50

11/10/2014 LS

Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.

4.50
125.00/hr

562.50

11/12/2014 LS

Summarize Marquez deposition transcript.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

11/13/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Sangetti.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

11/14/2014 JL

Summarized deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS

Summarize deposition of Sangetti.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

11/16/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Sangetti.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

11/17/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Sangetti.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

11/20/2014 JL

Summarized deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

11/23/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

11/24/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

11/25/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

11/26/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Larry Schoolcraft.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

11/28/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Purpi.

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS

JL

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

5

Amount

11/29/2014 JL

Summarize deposition Steven Mauriello.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

11/30/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

Summarize deposition of Purpi.

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

Summarize deposition of Dr. Patel.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS

Summarize deposition of Purpi.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

JL

Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/2/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.

6.00
125.00/hr

750.00

12/4/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Steven Mauriello.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/5/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Dr. Lwin.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/6/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Dhar.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Summarize deposition of Dr. Lwin.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

12/8/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Dhar.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/9/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Dhar.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Summarize deposition of Dominick Valenti.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

Summarize deposition of Carrasco.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Summarize deposition of Dominick Valenti.

8.00
125.00/hr

1,000.00

Summarize deposition of Dhar.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS
12/1/2014 LS

LS

JL
12/10/2014 LS
JL
12/11/2014 LS

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

6

Amount

12/11/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Kevin Finnegan.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/12/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Kevin Finnegan.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/13/2014 JL

Summarize deposition of Bernard Whalen.

2.50
125.00/hr

312.50

12/15/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Cooper.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/16/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Cooper.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/17/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Cooper.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/18/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Cooper.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

12/21/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Maffia.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/22/2014 LS

Summarize deposition of Maffia.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/24/2014 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/26/2014 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

12/27/2014 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/28/2014 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/29/2014 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

12/30/2014 LS

Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

1/1/2015 LS

Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

1/2/2015 LS

Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

1/3/2015 LS

7

Amount

Summarize Lauterborn deposition.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

Summarize Halpren-Ruder deposition.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

1/5/2015 LS

Summarize Lauterborn deposition.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

1/7/2015 LS

Summarize Marino deposition transcript.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

1/8/2015 LS

Summarize Marino deposition transcript.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

1/9/2015 LS

Summarize Marino deposition transcript.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

1/12/2015 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

1/13/2015 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

1/14/2015 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

1/22/2015 LS

Summarized Lubit deposition.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

1/29/2015 LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting videos.

6.00
125.00/hr

750.00

1/30/2015 LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/2/2015 LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/3/2015 JS

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting videos.

6.00
125.00/hr

750.00

LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

5.00
125.00/hr

625.00

2/4/2015 LS

Silverman deposition summary for expert witness.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS

JS

Schoolcraft

Page
Hrs/Rate

8

Amount

2/4/2015 JS

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting videos.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

2/5/2015 JS

Reviewing and taking notes on CompStat meeting videos.

6.00
125.00/hr

750.00

LS

Summarized Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/6/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/9/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/10/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

Summary of Whittman deposition transcript.

1.00
125.00/hr

125.00

Summarize Whittman deposition transcript.

2.00
125.00/hr

250.00

LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/12/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/13/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

4.00
125.00/hr

500.00

2/16/2015 LS

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft deposition transcript.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

JL

Summarize Milone deposition transcript.

1.50
125.00/hr

187.50

2/17/2015 JL

Summarize Milone deposition transcript.

3.50
125.00/hr

437.50

Summarize Adrian Schoolcraft in Floyd deposition transcript.

3.00
125.00/hr

375.00

JL
2/11/2015 JL

LS

For professional services rendered
Balance due

442.18

$55,272.50
$55,272.50

Name
Aldana-­‐Bernier
Boston
Broschart
Carrasco
Caughey
Cooper

Duncan
 (Day
 1)
Duncan
 (Day
 2)
Dhar
Eterno
 (Expert)
Ferrara

Finnegan
 30(b)(6)
Gough
Halpern-­‐Ruder
Hanlon
Huffman
Isakov
James

Lamstein
Lauterborn
Lubit
 (Day
 1)
Lubit
 (Day
 2)
Lubit
 (Day
 3)
Lwin
Maffia-­‐JHMC
Marino
Marquez
Mauriello
 (Day
 1)
Mauriello
 (Day
 2)
Milone
 30(b)(6)
Patel
 (Day
 1)
Patel
 (Day
 2)
Purpi
 (Day
 1)
Purpi
 (Day
 2)
Sangetti
Sawyer
Schoolcraft,
 Adrian
 (Day
 1)
Schoolcraft,
 Adrian
 (Day
 2)
Schoolcraft,
 Adrian
 (Day
 3)
Schoolcraft,
 Larry
Silverman
Trainor
Valenti
 30(b)(6)
Weiss
Whalen
 30(b)(6)
Whittman
 30(b)(6)
Statement

Date
4/23/14
1/6/14
6/18/14
9/19/14
12/9//13
7/24/14
4/28/14
6/23/14
7/7/14
10/17/14
6/5/14
7/17/14
4/11/14
9/30/14
1/13/14
1/6/14
2/12/14
5/12/14
1/30/14
11/7/14
9/23/14
11/10/14
11/13/14
7/3/14
5/30/14
10/8/13
5/14/14
12/20/13
7/1/14
7/17/14
7/25/14
10/31/14
7/16/14
9/19/14
5/15/14
4/25/14
10/11/12
9/26/13
9/27/13
12/11/13
10/24/14
4/10/14
7/16/14
5/29/14
7/15/14
7/15/14
10/25/13

Cost
$

 2,238.70
$

 843.15
$

 1,532.75
$

 337.25
$

 2,164.70
$

 1,048.48
$

 1,470.00
$

 521.00
$

 1,081.38
$

 651.75
$

 560.07
$

 1,823.77
$

 1,882.40
$

 1,224.75
$

 1,757.95
$

 924.75
$

 2,557.64
$

 2,436.65

$

 397.21
$

 711.00
$

 2,856.10
$

 1,478.25
$

 2,740.10
$

 2,188.50
$

 498.18
$

 564.65

$

 523.42
$

 455.66
$

 433.96
$

 1,074.50
$

 1,421.10

$

 1,583.01
$

 319.95
$

 1,193.25
$

 346.20
$

 422.19
$

 190.00

Smith Costs and Expenses 001

Statement

11/22/13 $

 165.00
$

 44,619.37

Smith Costs and Expenses 002