Capitol Records, LLC v. Redigi Inc.

Filing 321

DECLARATION of Richard S. Mandel, Esq. in Support re: 319 MOTION for Attorney Fees .. Document filed by Capitol Christian Music Group, Inc., Capitol Records, LLC, Virgin Records IR Holdings, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit C)(Mandel, Richard)

1

~~~~~~

Cow~:n, Lieb~wvik;~ 8~ T.atrn~n, T~.C,
11~;~ Av~nez~ of khe Americas
New York, NY I~C~36
(
212)7~p-9~C1(7 Tel
(
~I2)575-0671 ~~x
~vww.c}l.~~z~t
~tict~a►•c~ ~.1V1~n~c~
(2I"?~ 790~92~ 1
rs~n c~?cl~.a~iat

~3 E-r~~i~ s~l~~i~v~zaix sdcl~~smb~r~ «7~R ~cl.usc~~ert~. ~o~v
1
-l+an. Rich~rc~ J, Sultvaza, ~J.S.T~,J'.
~(~ ~`~lcy ~qu~r~
N~+~v `~s~rk, NY I ~~C17
Re

~itc~l ~tecorcls; ~,,I~C:' v. ~3.~TJ~~i tic., 12 ~v, ()t~~5 ~I~J~)

T~ear.Tr~c1~~; ~ttliv.~n:
'~✓~ rep~~~s~~at ~1~infY€f' Ga~ittai ~. ~~rd~, ~,~,~ (``~~p tai°') in t~ris active at~c~ writs jait~tly
~vit}~ coc~~~.s~l fir ~i~~fcra~~~~ts (~sse~7rt~a~;~Y~r• ~ti~t ~~.t,~~lo~pti ("I.II?s"}, p~u~su~nt Cc~ ~.ttle ~..U, t~f~`~uz~
~Ionc~i•';; In~tiv~~lt~~i Fr~ctic~s, s~~arclir~z~; ~ c~isput~ av~i• Tt7s' dzs~avery regtYests, Thu parties
exGl~~~~~;~r~ ~etfi~rs aba~t t}~cse displttes t~z~ actc~l~~z~ 1~ end 1S ttnd cesr~cluc~ec~ a l~x~gt~y C~lep~►o~~
c;c~~►~~r~~~~ ~r~ t~ct~ber 1'7, ~,i~ t 3 in rah ch Nfcssrs. Mancl~ end ~in~ pa~tic pat~;cl ~e~t~ ~apit~l at~cl
I
~I~ssr~. ~z~irussa~ ~x~~srr►~~~ ar~d Ciddn~s particip~ieci for II7s.
C~~itti~'~ I'~rs~kc~~.
]T~5 ~.c~v sed filie Cr~n~•~ rn tl~e pa~•ties' jcaittt Septe~x~ber ] C~, ~[11~ Ietter €~7at "they ~n~y she
~clditica~~~l ~r1d liniit~:d disc;ov~r~." C~x~ Se~at~r~~bcr l~, '2U~3, ti~~; C;r~l~~•t axdc~~~~ "tae wompt~tio~a af'
i cizsc~v~ry ley I~ov~k~b~:r ~, 2f3 a ~." Bocket Na. 1~4 ~cr~~~aha~is adcied~, Sc~e ~ls~ Ar~~~ncled
ll
~~s~ ~ai~~.gerneni ~~1~i~; T~c~uk~;t N~. l?9'~ 3 ~"~a~ll ~•~t~aai~zix~~; d~st~tav~r~ shad b~ ~c~.n~~~etecl by
~Qv~i~n~~r ~, ~f313") (Emp~~a~is de~dct~). ~l~vertt~cles~, TDs ~nex~~lic~hly ~v~~ite€I kwen~y cl~~s
I
b~;fc~r~ rn~a li~a~ ~~r~ci ~t~r~ilitl,~ ti~eit~ e~isct~v~ry requests, capi~s er1'wki cl~ ~r~ ~tt~~he~i, ai S~:~C~ ~,ny.
~t~ ~ctc~bet' 9', ~t?13, `i"h~ ~'vc~c~ests ire ~ki~tirriely end alscs iit~~~rc~p~rly~s~el~ rn~~siv~ ~m~~ut~~t~ ~C
i~~t~el~vax~t ~f'~ri~c~tit~zi ~,~vel1 t~cyc~t~ci tli~ s~a~e cif anytliit~~ r~:c~t~i~~r~d ~a ~~fciae~ the case.
Clnt~~x~ ~'ecl. ~. Civ. ~. G(c~), t~~»r~ service b~y t7i~i1 car e~~r~~il ~~ncter T~er~. I~, ~i~v. l~.
5(b)t~)(C) tax Seta}(~)tF), three c~~ys ~r~. ~c~~lc~c~ ~'or x~esY~n~7s~,° Ca~itc~l's respa~~s~s are thus no# clue
ut7tit T~]~v~:znbt~r 11, ~0'1~~, ~~ll~r the: vlose c~.t'ctis~ov~t~~. Giveza ~I~~' t~xlu~'e 1a at~~d~-dry tk~~ (~oui~'s
~Ehcc~ul~, n~c~ r~s~c~nse s~Yaufd b~ r~~t~i,red. ~~ ~A ~, G~orrirnoYxweal~ii An~7ti~i~ ~ Li~f~ Ins. Gti. vw
I
)a,lessic~, 2C}U~ 'W1,, ? 1~x~~3GK (I~I.I~. Cal. July 20, 2Uq~) ~r~c~~esks I`car ~c~r~~ssio~i sc:rv~d 3U da~~
befo~~~ cscc~very cut-of~eic~mecf l~niir~~~fy T~ut~ ~(c~)); ,ic~nes v. I-T~~ c~7feld, Zt)(33 W~. 214iS~23,
at n.1~3 {S.I~.~t.Y'. 3txn~: l~, 2Q(}3j ("the. di~c~v~r~r dc~a~i[ine; ciat~ is 4~ic c~at~ c7~~ r~rl~i~t~ ~tds~n~r~r,~
~~l-~uaalr.0 ,~~ c~n~~detcl*') (ef~~ha~is ~c~d~~l); ~r~ventia v. C1r(cdns Cc~txnt~, 1~2 ~.~t.~. 17, ~{~
(W,L~.t~,Y, 14)x"7) (rcc~~a~~ts fir pxodu~tian ;~ervc~ b~fc~re. r:nr~ o~ ~isc~vc:ry cud-c~f~°deern~c~
~.tnlit~~ely wlzer~c rc~pc~nses kvere dui ~;ft~r t11~ c~xt-c~ft~.
~Ca~~it~l ~~~evei- ec~r~s~nt~ci iii vv~•iti~~~; ~o ~m~i~ ~ervic~ ~iy tl~~ Ii~s (as it I7ac~ with IteI~ pi's
aoc~nsel~, t~t~t even itiit 17~~, the x~a~~s would sill adc~~ ~hr~~ days t€~ ~x~~~ital's i•~spc~ns~ tiiz~~,
295Cj3/UtJ3lI43S 1 H2.2

C:o~van, Lieb~wi~~ ~ ~La~mair, P,C.
Ilan. Itichai•i3 J. ~ulliv~n, ~.~,S.D,7,
C
~~,taber 25, 2t~ t 3
~'~z~;~
Ta ~7aicr~ ir,a~t~rs wa~•se, ~l~e k~elated ~~~c~uests dcz~nand eno~~maus am~t~nts t~~ r~elevgi k
infai°in~tign ~r~r l~eyanc# IDs' p~•amise of"l n~it~d' cl scnvery. liven tl~~ aun~~~~ case pasture,
}
wl~~re I~e~i~i has ~tt•~~d~ ~`c~u~~d lia1~1~ for inf~~it~g4zn~nt~ tli~ sixty r~~an~izz~ng subj~uts for
~cta~~icatic~~ are r~rl~~~l~~r the ~T~~ .a~e,j~intIy a~~d ~evexally li~.ble; fc~i p~zrti~i~~~~r~~ in Re~i is
nfx6n~an~ acts ~~e~ C`a~ tal'.~ Men~,aranc~u~~ in Qp~aasitir~n ~~a Mafi~~t tea I~is~n ss, Do~~e~ I'~o,
13~, ~t 1t7-ES} aid t~ac~ statuary darz~a~es fc~r w~aich ~X( ds~en~c~ants ~~~~j~i~itl~ end sev~r~It,y l at~l~.
Y~i; tie ~~.rl~ oi~:TDB' ~.lr~ti~~~ly kyiquests have virtua;ll~ r~e~t$~ n~;to c~~ ~~v tt~ th~s~:tropics.
fi;
xis l~avc ser~~~d eight c~a~c~rn~nt re~ue~ts end tw~i nkez~rag~tt~~ ins (~~.~q;uGsks 7-8, l 1 M]
Inter~c~~;Gzt~ri~~ ~1~?~~ clzr~ctect a~ x~ac~hani~al. ~•Q}~~lt;i~~ }~~ici by C~piCnl ft~r mc~~~ Eh~,n S00
;rec~r~lin~~, ancl~c~it.7~ C<~~x~al'~ ~t•~:c; ent~, pr~l~caus, c;~~lcula~T~a~ts ~Ai~cl c~~sp~.rt~~ r~~~rrdin~ ~u~t~
r~z~~l~~tiicals. I'h~s case c~inc~:~~nin~; ~;r~cin~ reca~din~s fay ~aichia~~ try do r~r~itl~ rneefl~,~u~~tl.
s`nyalties, pay~t~Ie to sr~~x~;r~riCer•s end zriusi~ ~auE7li~h~rs ~rh~ awn a e1if~'erent ~apyri~;l~t its mlisic~l
~c~t~~~a5it.iri~s. ~'our~s~l fc~r ~I3s caritetic~ that the z~Gc~rc~ i~ch«t~•~'~ ~t~~~posec~ly "ut~~'~ir" ~t•~c~ices
c~t~~ci~in~ ~~.~rr~~~nt ofi~~c~i~iz~ical~ tra thi~r~ part~~~ r~~~~ ~anea~tl~ ail "t~nal~an ~~~ds°' defense.
~-Iaw~ve~~ at~y such;all~~~d cc~r~~tuct G~~t~sc~~t ~►~ harm to T.t~~, is ~xY~a~~~aus ~o ~~het~~~r Cad tc~l's
sc~~and ~°ec;c~rdire~,s l~~v~; l~~en iY~fxi~~ec~, ~r~ci ihu~ could ~~ot passf b(y support unclean h~~c3s,
~v~ilaC~le in ext~'~n~z~:ly l mitc~~ ~: rct~rr~st~nc~.~ wv~~t~rt~ the ~anduct rel~.fes directly t~ the su~j~~t
~x7~t~~r cif the suit. ~~ ~,
, ~~~~tic~ v I" k~k~ttl:~, ~~3 ~', ~"7, X52 (~,cl Cir. I~'1 ~~, Prue ~. ~~x
Fist 't G~°c~u~, Tnc., ~[?()7 ~JL 2~~ ~7 ~~.T.7,I'~I.Y. Jai, 2C~ ~~U7); C~r~~r,~~. ~r. ~~PT~. Trot;., 76~ 1~,
Cupp. 2~U, 2~ti (5.~,~f,Y, 19 1}; Warritrr~awit~~ v, 11~~~ric~n ~~~nily Ass'K~, 74S ~`: Supt, 1~(l}
1~~i n~ I2 ~5.1~.i~.Y. l9~)4~},
ds
I f~irthei• sees: evc~~~y ~ir~glc~ r~c~r~x~ntr~~ie~ati~7rx, ~~,re~r~~cr~t a~~ ~~licy relatarr~ t~
i,
`<erple~itatiat~" car "use" t~~'rnure tl~~tt ,SgtJ t~~~t~~cl rz~sy scc, I~e~uests 2, Vi 10, acid da~~}mints
cc~n~erx~in~ C;~pitc~I's c wn pl~~is f~d~ °<~•e~eli tz~" digital r~coi~ttin~;~. ~~ Iiequ~st iris. 17-1~.
+~r~~~ tal'~ authc7~•ized explt~itat~an of its or~vn g~cc~rd.in~s his na `b~aa•i~g a~ wlieEher tl~~ Il`~s
~~z•ticip~teci ire ~ :~Di~i's itifr ngir~~ acts, ~r~ct culiec~in~; such nfarm~tian fc~r ~~~~nclre<~~ o~ 4r~~or~l~l
fan~c~us r~rbtc~iz~~s wc~ctle~ b~ an izasu7~~rab1~ ~~~r~~:~~, ~~u J C~pi~~~atr (Do~k~t No. 10~) at 11 ~"C~~"
course, Ca~~ to1, ns co~yx ~}~~ a~v~lc~r, does not Fc~zicit its right to clazm ~ap~r ~ht itxfxin~cn~te~xt
merely l~a~c~E~se it p~amits c~~~ain ~xse~ rrf its wc~rlGs,"},
I
nterrog~ta~•~ 4 ;:~~l s abut every cca~yri~ht ir~~'rin~;~z~~e~E ~,~lainl Ca~~~i~a~ his asserted ~~vi~l~
a~es~ae:ct tc~ filae l~i~i~~~•e~s cif r~ct~rdin~s at issue. It avcaitlEt ~e ~xtre ~.l}~ bu►'e~ensutYae to cc~rrt~ile
sll~~ ir~f~~m~tc~~x, trdn~ ~fwhach lea.~ls to ~dxnissibl~ evi~~nce. 7nterrr~~atories 2, ~, ~,9, IO, I~l,
<3nc~ ~~ irnpic~~ert~! seek b~~nad di~c;c~v~r~ into tl» ~~n~1~~~tyin~ nfrin~e~rrent alr~~c~y resvlv~d by
this Court, ii~cludir~~ wl1a~ ~tcEs nCr•it~~;ecl ~a~ tit's cc~~7y~~ ghts, t~~e fair use a~~d fiY~sC salt dcfc:n~es,
whether C~.~aitcjl°s a~~~:c~x~din~;s h~v~ been `°cii~trili~~ted" u~~dei• the Copy~i~ht Act, s~canciary
}ir~6i~ ty~ t~t~cl Che ~tsp~:~:ts of R~L7 firs "s~ft~rr~rc ~rct~itec~ure" altered tc~ n~ri~x~e. 8~~.~tts~-they
are in p~~iv ty ~+it~1 I~edi~i, Ids axe barre~~ t~;~ coll~:ter~l ~str~~pel anti the law ~~~h~ ~a~e ctactrin~
f~•~7m relit ~;at~~~ issues already ~utetxY~ined. ~e~a ~,, Ira z~: Telttc~rii~s ~e~vs.~7nc,r 7~i2 ~', d
1'~S, l~(3-91 (~c~ ~:ir•. 1~~5); F;reat~~r'v Girt. Flee. ~~,, 4~7 I~.'~i~ 4G8, 4'72 ~2c~ ~'ir. 197~~;1V~ar~r~
v.~it~ cif ~e~v Ita~ ~~~:tle, 3~~ F. S~.t~~p. ?~ 5~'7, SIS (~.I~.tS.Y'. 200 6). Cn~~tx•aty tc~ T1)a'

13fI'~10111I~~35~}~ 1.2

C€~wan,~,i~bc~~rit~ ~ I~at~.rr~~tY1, P.C.
~-Tc~~~, Ri~harrl J. ~ulii~a~a, U.~,I~,J.
C~ctc~ber ~5, ~~?]
'
Pi e 3
~sser~~a~,s, preel~lsi~e e#f~~t in~.y b~ ~i~ven ~n ~1~~ Cou is ~~~~nt of ~ar~ al sr~nimar~y jtic~~rrtent. ~~ e,
U.~. I)e~~t of Jui~lic~e v. I-lud~+c~rs, 2~1i~7 U,S: I]ist. L~XIS X2749 (S.L?.N.'Y, ~0~7~ ~°`fede~~C
courts Ix~v~ e~.priticieel Application of c~a~later~rl estnp~e~l , , . tc~ cl~cisic~i~s including g~rti~l
s~.t~r~~ry jLid~m~~zt"}; Cried Taylat~, Inc, v. ~`Ii;S. ~i~c,,7X~ ~",Sup~a, 1171, 1127 (S,]?,N.Y. X9$9}
( r~ntiix preclusive ef~'eet to p~t~#i~l s~s~~i~nary j~rcigme~~t~; ~-Tarris Tr~~st & Say.]dank v, John
f ancook Mt~t, L~F~ Ii~.s. C~~ 7~2 ~'. Su p. 998, Ia(}7-~9 (S,D.~`J.~x~ 1~~~)(s~r~~), ~f~ci ire p~~t
~
ar►c~ t~e~er~ed in part on e~the~• ~rou~~ds, 97C~ ~.2c~ ~ 138 (?d Cix•; ~9~2), Capzt~~ ~c~~c~ ~c~t
re,c~~itt~lat~ the c~pic~cis e~ c~~n~~ braef~d ~tncl determined a~~ su~~m~ary ~ud~~~x~n~, wixere the e►niy
is~c~e ~~ be liti~;atcc~ is whett7~a~ Tl~s ~arti~p~t~c~ in ik~e acts airead~ d~cteY•xnin~~l tp b~ ~~~i•ir~~in,~,.
I
~~t~,-~•~~~tc~~~y 1l r~l~at~s t4 "~~~ti~;~~c~~ ~C'c~~~n~3~~s,,' ~ tf~ec~~•y ~rrif}~ ~~a applicatic>~ tr►
statutc~~~y datnag~s i~t ~ c~p~rz~~~#. infrii~~etnent case. I~~t~r~•a~;~tary I2 se~lcs ~ur~ ~e~a.1 ar~E~rnents.
I~~tc,r~•o~atory 13 is i~~cc~mpx-e~3e;~isib~e and b~~s~ef on tl~~ n~istake~x as~~~zn~xti~xi ghat Cap~tvt's right
to objet to rc-s~lc of its ~~c:~Q~'din~s is rooted izx t;e~ntract lar~ t;~tthez' thin Gcrp~t•i~,}it la:~r,
~~~tez~~n~ate~ry lG r~fer~n~~~ ~n unsp~;cifi~d `~'evei•sian ~~'ri~hts" tT7s cannot ~x~~l~in.
~nl~rrc~~atuai~~~ ~I ~ ~u~cl 19 r~1€~t~ ~~ a~~~r• t`uxms o~ d~az~a~e~ ~ ~uc~ as Ills' ~~ra~t~ -- t~iat C;~~i~c~l
I ~l~eted nc~t to pursue. ~1I i~~ the above ~~•e a1sz~ ov~:~•bt•t~~e~, va~u~ ~ndlc~r inelev~nt. Givers
aas
the t~rire~sr~n~~ile n~t3:tru cal II~s' ua~tit~-►e1y ~°~~u~s4:s artci tc~ crf~,~~r ~n~ mean zlg~ ti ~omprortx sc iz2
ti~~ir sc+~~~, t~l~ C;c~urt ~~~c~riicl :i~sut~ ~t pr.~tecCiv~ nrdei rel~evin~ C~pi~al of the E~e~a•deri c~_F r~s~c~ns~.
~~s'
I 1'~sit~~
?l~i~~tif~"~~~i~~s that t~.~~ ~;~s' disc;~very r~E~~~~s~s ~~r~ ~t~ti~n~~v is ~~vithaut n~.eri~ a»d rcfle~ts
1
~t desire tc~ ~voiel the ccansecj~t~a-~u~s of ~ciain~; die IL~s to k~~i~ a~;tit~r~ ne~z the end a~'th~ cage:
,
disct~very t•~E~u~sts se7•~eci ~~ithzn tlai ty ~3~tys c~i'kl~e d.isGavery deacllir~~: rr~~c time:~y. She,
G~''aff~"sns v. C,h~tn~; cY~ :~ax~ ~'i~~r,~ 20C~~ `Wt., 482332 (~,I7:~,~C, C~ct. 21, ~U08~; `~'hom~s v,
1
~~.~it core, 3~4 ~`.3t~ ~ 17{x? l1'79 ~l0~li. fir, ~t~C13}. 'T`h~ ~as~~ Pl~intif~ cites da nn# hold
ot~7crwise. Cornr~ric~ri~ealth Ai~nt~ity_ ~ddressed re~(rt~~ts Cor ~~ issic~~~ (~r~~i~.h a~r~ i1~t ai ~ss~c~
he~ze) ~rz~ t~~~•~~ed can ~tk~~ i~,ter~~r~t~tia~10{' ~ ~"atiFa~•~-~ia lc~c~l r~~[~~ ~~0~ ~VI.. ~1~~~G8, ~t *~. ~n
~G ,vTrnd~, the c~ sc~t~e;•~ r~t~ue~ts wcrt~e s~rv~ci jest twc~ cl~~ys prior to tl~c: cTas~ +~~'cli~car~+~ry,~ac~
"minimal, if any, r~l~v~n~e t~ the instant ~~~ic~~," az]~ neEuded requc~ts ~. mcci ~t "d~I'c:~~c~~nts
wl~c~ h~ct ~e~~7 ctis»r,xss~~i l'z~afn Gk~u ~Gi,v~~." 1~~ ~,~..~. at 2C1. Ifth~ ~c~urt ~~t~z~mines that II7s'
clisca~ver~ rec~~~csis ~~r~ ~ii~tit~ely, har~ver~~:f, Il~~ r~~~a~ctfirlly r~;c~i~~st tl~~.t Yee ~c~~~~~~ exte~~r! t~~
~iscave~~y s~edule to ~~i~ovic~e sut'fi~ient tir~~~ to ~c~mplet~ t1Ye discc~vet•y s~Leessary to ~~s~rE ih~ir
inc~ividr~4~~ c~~f~~~s~;v. ' `his i~ ~te~~~el~~ tae c~titcame i~~ k~i~in~i~~"s awtl case, ~o~~~s. ~~ac~c~ with
a~r u<khCv ur7tin~~.~y d s~t~ve~y requests, the coiu~t ret~petx~d cliscov~ry "tc~ aI}~w bc~tla parties frs
dcy~+et~~y ~h~ r~co~ci f~~rtl~~~.°' ~(~€7~ WL 2~4~S~Z3, at *~.
~.:~ ~bs' ~vlvl pan t~ ~~i~r~i~s ~ penditl aid II3s h~v~ not yet filed ~i~ answer in ti~is ease, it
is nit yet cic~~a • what ~~fenses or c4u~t~r claiirss Macy will ~ss~rto N~~vertCi~less, g~a~ ct~~~~e fir ~n
E;xtensic~~~ e~i~t~ ~a~cti~asE TT~s ~v~;~t~e t~~decl ko t}pis ~~ tior► ~3t tl~~ ~~cl t~f t~r~ case, ltd t}i~ir n~~~
~c~~:tns~1 have: not ~.ven x~ecc vc~l, lct ~~~n~ i•ev ~~veci, C=~~itvl'~ val~~~n naus pr~~u~ti~tY, ~Iareover°,
~k~ s i~ ~~at t17r; #y~~~ cif t;~se wl~~re tfae party se~:kin~ an c~;t~nsicr~i has h~xct a~~n~l~ oppc~rt~inity tc~

2 Y367/O1 t(143~42~,2

~~w~n,Z,ebr~~rf~ ~ Latnxan,P.~.
Hon, I~~ch~rd_ J. S~.~tli~~~n, ~J,~.~.J.
~?et~t~~z~ ~S, ~C~13
F~g~ 4
G~rr~pt~te dascar~~Yy ~~t his c~1~s~n i~~t tc: dili~et~tly pty~rs~~e i~~ c~pti~i~s~ Ay~d,ifPlaintiff(~zs
~lain~ed in t~~ ~c~atemlae~ Idth I~t~~~~),.plans on ding a ~ur~~rnar~ jud~i~nt ~rnatic~n "pram.~tly,"
e.~f~;~di~~ ciisc;c~~~r~ ~~n~~r ~,I~,~.P. S6(~j is also ~p~aropri~t~, ~e~ p~Cr Po~c~r LLG v, ~3c~RasaGrur~c~} ~00'~ ~'L, 1837135, at '~6 ES.T~.1~,`~, ~un~ ~6, 2007);
Pl~ii~ti~f atsn cl~~~~~~ tl~~;k riisaevery as in ceY~t~in ai~irmative cie~ens~~ is ic~zp~~~p~:x beca~~se
~l~s ~~i~e "collaterally ~~~o~p~c~'" ~'t~~ r~liti~~t~i~rg c~rt~ii~Z f r~ctir~~s ~h~ Court ~~~a~~ ag~~n~t ~.~Digii.
in its sur~lmacy jud~~n~rif orct~~~ beca~s~ II~s ai~~ "in privity Fritts ReUi~;~," Mc►st t~~fensus u~an
wlx~cl~, ills 1Yave sr~u~l~t ~iiscove~•y ti~vc ~e teat ~t ssete in the ~ourl's sx~rr~pr~a~~' juci~m+~nk oreler ( >
the #fir t~s~ dcautrinc, estap~u~, wai~e~°, uncl~~r~ }Y~nds, ~tc.)~ a~ic~ t1~e~'e~'vie, collateral estop}~~1
~E~7~~~at ~.~~~~. S~~ ~a~t~ v, Fo~ih~,z~~ Univ. I~~cul~v cYc Admin. IZ~~. ~'t~n, 263 I~,3d '196,. ~C~~ n;.7
~~cl Cir. 20Q1 } tciCat c~t~ omitt~cl). T'u~~th~p•, cc~il~teral estoppe:,l does nat ~aa~~l~ to ~a2~ti~l ~rrrnmary
jud~r~cntwhere kcere has tic~t beei7 a °`v~ticl ~n~l,juc~grn~rrt," Fall ~~. ~1.C~. Srrait}~ ~ort~., ~5l ]~,3ci
~G, 6~1 ~~ci Ci~~, 2QOG)x Avoi~~al~ Shipyarr~s, Inc, v. ~r~sitreil 1~1t~~~dgs, 7~C ~'.~c~ 12~r5 (5~I7 G r,
1986). I~:e~~rtil~ss, "collaEer~a1 esft~ppel cic~~es~ nat s~~~ k tp c~ii~ect attacks in t}~e same aase,. but
~~atf~er [ap~alies nnly~ ire s~.rl~se~~z~x~t aut~ans.'° ~11~af~t~Gz r~ Pt~wcz T~~~;c~mc ~L~nd ~v. ~r~~~isiine Falls of
N,~C.~Ine:, 362 Iced, A~p~, 151, 1ST (2r~ C'iz°. 2U1d~ (internal duo anon omitted}. t~or th s re~sorl,
each of Ply nfii~f'~ ~as~s (~~z~clsar~, C~°~ecl, end ~I~trx~ ~ "'rust ~ w~ cl~ it~vatv~c~ issues ~~ais~d ~ ~ri~t~
~iti~~tznns, a~•e iti~tp~~site.< ~v~.~~ if`cc7la~ter~~ estr~p~a~l eould ~p~p1Y> ho~~v~r, "privf~r ~inc~~r sc~cti
c~ th~~ry depenc~~ do a finding llaat the p~~~c~ta a~,a zest w~ntn e~l~atet~~ ~stc~~~~! ~s ap~alie~ ~~tivel~r
~~rtzci~~ated i~t tf~~ previous l ti~at ors" ~~~d "c~tr~ic~(I~;cl" tlae ~thi~~ d~ti ncian~'s tt•ial st~•at~;~y,
Sti~hCin~ 'T`ea{ ~3~h~~r~tigin~ Van D~ I3~l~i~~;en V~~~ C7~►d~~ndee~lao~~ders ire ~Iet apit~r~l VtYr~
~l~c~l~t ~I~~t't I3.~V. v. P~~illip~~~a;_C. Sclueit~~r,, 327 ~,3~ 173y X37 (~c~ G~it•. 2~a~), ~'laintifftaa~
S
prc~vi~l~d this ~auz•t with nn ; G~e1~ evie~c.nce, i'1~i~~ti~'~"s fir~;un3ez~t ~lsc~ c.antr~v~nes the pr~rpc~ses cif'
t!x€. b~•Qae~ e~is~c~v~~~y r~r1Gs, w~~c;h al3aw ~~arties to prtab~ 1'~cts that ~az7~aatetatraldy Iead fo
~d~riissible evicl~ilc;~. 1'i~i~lfiff sho~ilcl ~~at be pet'tn~tiect tra pi•e~cnpt discovery siT~~~at~ be cause i~
th z k~ it hay ~ l~~a~ a~~uin~nt tc~rat cGi°t~ii7 deFet~~~s ,mom! not ~~~~ly.
~'l~inti~f alsa ~r~3u~s tti~t II~~S' c1is~~vet•~ ree~~e~ts ire ufzc~~ly burclenst~me ~z~d c~v~rbroad.
Bc~t, tl~~; ~a~~y appQsin,~ ~rc~dt~ciic~n ~nt~st ~-~ravicl~ su4~~icient detail ~ixd expl~nat.ioai ~batxk the
n~i#z~~•~ of fl7e burden in terz~is of tir~le, r~~ar~~y, ~~ri proced'u~•e w~ii~l~ ~rat~ld ~~ rec~uirecC, ~5
~
'd~vtt~•ds v: I'c~rc~ T~!(catc>r Via,, ~Q~2 WL 55'33F~3, ~t *`~ (~.T~. Cat, I~~ta. ~~, 2012). Pl~ii~tiffys
faiture t~ l~r~vicle any spect~cit~ ~s i~ its ~lte~;~el ~Sui•cien is i'r~tt~l tee this ~i~gufnc n€. Moreover,
Plr~inti~f scelcs ~ac~~enti~tly t~ai_l.lic~rzs cif iolf~zrs its clar7~a~es fi'o~n the T17s. IDs hive a x~i~ht tv fully
a~v~ic~p t~Ye e~tric~el~c:e to c~Gfe~zcl themselves ~~s to Matti Ii~bilitx an~~ c~amn~;es. `I"~itou~h the meet
end ct~s~fer 1~rc~~;~ss, the TT)s a~;i•~ed to n~~•t~o~v cert~zri ~~~qucsfis ~n f~ci~ l~te~ thy; e~f~icier~k
na~.n~t~~rn~:rit ci fphis ease (~r~~i inctie.~t~ci ~ tivill n~~i~s~ t~ Go~7t~z~ue lh~t }~rc~~~~s), butt S'I~iratiff
r~~'u~ecf to etas ~ve~~• any q~ie:sti~ns on ~lx~ basis ~i~~t th~;y we~~e ~a~it melt',
~l~:s'' c~t~i~:r r~:e~cs~sts s~~~ci~~4x~ly r~C~r~~~~~d try F'1~:intiFf a~•~ all "~ie~son~bly c~t~ut~:t~;e~ tt~
le:ac~ fio ~ari~nis~iblc ~victe~lc~.'a ~~e~~• w~~~~pl~;
Dt~cuzxx~z~t ~~.~c~v~s~ 1~T~s, 3, ~, c~ 9 a~~ci ta~tex:~•o~atory dos. ~„ ~; l~, & ~ ~ ~;a t~ v;~hetlacr

~~3~7~t~~ ~r~~~sa~~,a

~b'Gi~~31p ~.,~k~awi:~ 6~ ~,~trn.anr I.C.
I-~c~~~, It~~ha~e~ ,T. r~lli~a~, CJ,S.~.J,
Caetob~r~ 5~ ~t~ 1.3
~
'a,~e S

~lainti~~I`~~t~~lty has a cc~py~r~ht Infiin~emen~ claim ~~;ai~st fh~ ~'1~s. F'l~intif'f" n'rus1: ~ri~v~ ~z ~~lic~
cc~pyz~r~~a~ i~~ exrch oftie s~n~;s ar~~] ~h~ d~tu, time, end ~r~c~itic~t7 of ~~.~h ~It~ ,~d violation ~r~der
r~rt~ic~ it ~~~k~~~ ~~~c 'c~s ~t~ axcl~t: to ~ucc.c~d ~n ~t~y c~I'its ul~~i~t~s, arx~l ~h~s~ ~.~qu~sts ~~d
int~i~rca~~t.nri~s se~:k i~~~'o~~3iiat~c~n re[?t~~ to P1~int C~~'s ability to pr~~c~ ~h~s~ t~qui~it~ elerr~ents.
Tnt~~~rc~~atarV I`~c~~, 14, 1r>, ~c. ~U ~a to whe;th~r ~'1~i71k ff can prc~v~ tt~~ requisite ele~n~nts
o~ its c~~riv~.five ~c~p~i~;ht claims ~~ainst lac IUs, ~~ar instane~, ~'laintififm~ust demt~nstr~t~ that
ttre IDs- had ~ direct ~n~nci~l interest 7~ the. ~ll~~~dly intx~ngiz~~ ~cti~~s`t~y a~n~ ~x~rcised ~ te~;aily
suifici~~lt level of conc~~c~t c vii• iht~se ~,Ile~e~lly info r~~ ~~ tats ~a succeed oi~ same afthes~;
claims, anc~ thG~e Irtterr~~~tc~ri~s se~l~ pr~ais~ly t~~~t ty~~ ~ifri~for~~atUn,
Ir~ter•t•a~;at~~i~y Nis. 4, 7, ~, lQ 1 .1, 12, 17, l~ ~~a tc~ ~am~gcs, tivhicl~ even the tight
c~~s~ov~i;y sc,~edule, CDs ~z~ay:~~r~~perly seetc a~ t~~i~ r~int i~~ time.
~17oc~Er~71~nC [~~~u~s~ fps. 1, 2, , 6~ ~ L 4~ ~.~id ~~nteri~o~a~c~z~ Noy. T t 3, 6,~ 13 g~ try tt~~
~5tc~p~el/ii~~plicd ~c~nset7~, ~'~ir use, T~lvl~tl, ~v~ivet', a~7d ~r~t ~~1c afzi~~tnative €lef~ns~s, ~ttt~oi~~
~tl~ers. ~~car n~tat~ce, sra ~ ~zf'fik~c~~ I2ec~tzesCs arici I~7tex~o~~t~~• yes seek infoxm~liar~ r~~az~ctirr~
whetl~s~~• Plaint l~` c.axccrt~z•~.~;~~ tic .~~i~i syste~~ az~c~►i~~ctur~, wl~icla r~~a~y ~v~ X•isc~ tc~ ~ d~fcz~5e
poi• im~liec~ c~~~sent, l~'i~t~l~z~.x°, s~~n~ cif the~~ ~equ~sts anc~ ~i~.terc~g~tot•ies solicit i~~f~a~~x~ii~n th~it
re~t~y k~e~u• an tiv~reth~~• there ~r~ as ~~x~~y vc~latic~~:s as i'1~~r~taLfc.t~rim~ ~~as►r~~~l~ as l'1~i~3~f~'ar~a},
ha~re i~~r7 QCs c~nset~t or ~v~;iv~d its ct~pyrrght el~in~s zip ~►nti1 ~ cea•t~ia~a point i~ time (~n~ alle~~~l
it~£~~itig~t~i~r~t~ k~~f~~~c~ That ~at~ ~t7lxlci nat ~~ ~cti~nttble~.
-~
l~ocurr~e.F~t Rec~~s~sts I~Ic~s, 7-8 ~ ~ 1~16~~ 3rd Irttcrrogatary Nas, ~ 1 ~~: ?2 ~o to tl~~; uazcle~n
hax~ct~ a;£fiz~r~~a~ve de~ense~ an~nn~ ~~h~rs, ~tlasn~~icti ~~s l~la skiff n~~y (~~~v~ itsc~lfinfi~in~~d ~on its
re~o~-c~ia~~ art~isis ~~7~i p~~odti~cei~s' ri~lzts tc~ r~~~ive ~~rxechanical ray~ltic~s in tlic c~n~pasi#i~r~s c~~' the
~tlle~ec~Iy r~~ii~~ed.
~o~urr~~nt I`Zeque~ts ~NQs. 1Erb ~r~. 17 ~u to ~a~tc~~~ti~l ct~~,~Y~t~rcl~~it~tis, itic~.luclin~ b~~t not
timitecl to t~~z'tt~oc~s in~r;rf~rencc: with bus i~~ss r~laticsns, v alafioa~s of Neer Yor1c acid ~alifoi~nia's
cl~c~~~tiv~ t~~ac~c ~i~acf ce ~t~tu~+~s, ~~e1/cap vic~l~tians affe~~iai ~ulc~ state antitr~zst laws fc~z°
c~r~spiriri~ witi~ ai.iler rc,c,urr~l Ialzc:ls tc~ c~a~~ne7• the digital clt~~r~la~c~l markeC. II~s m~ty p~•apc;rly ask
fc~i~ this cate~;c~ry t~f infcir~xx~tac~r~ at this pint to Cimc.
7~c~cti~tm~nt ~ec~~i~~t Ness. 1.3 ~ 2~ ~c~ to I'l~i»~it~'s ~re~servatiozy and prc~~lxct.ic~aa duiie~
un~ei~ tl~e ~eeierai Ii.ules sty tl~~~ ihu II~s ~nny E~~st assess wlz~tt~ei• Plaintiff has ~rc~c~uc~cl ~lI
~~~qu~;~tc~r~, r~c~~~w~~~vte~~:~ dc~c~uments<
I~e~~eat`tul[y,
~
.d~ 1[ a ♦~~ L~A.1
~.V Y[ A~IJ {..h^ ~.df 5 ! IY.1R x.~~ A ♦~e

/s/ i~~c~dcc~r~f S ~lt~r~~cl~l
1
~i~l~aa~i S. IV~~raclel

z ~aa7~aa a~~~~s~a~,~

+~~~LJ ~~~'~~1~ ~1~~

fsr~,Iet~r2~s ,I. ~'iz~l~~trs~
~~
J~.~~es .t. 1'i~zirussc~

~

._

I~!'l ~~~ T.INI"I'~:U S'i'A~T~S I~~STRICT CC3~(:il~'~'
SC}CI'~'~-~:~~tN ~~S'TI2iCT ~F NFW 'Y(~12K
I~mGV-Ot?Q5 (1~,1~~
~'l~inti#~;
v,

T
~~1~iCTI [T~CC., JC1~(N C~5SCN1Vit~C.l'1L,f~, alai

i~.c~~ ~~.,,
C~~fe~~tl~rafis..
D:~I+~l~1~Ai'~'T~i ~T(~~~N (.~S`~`E1~iM~~C~'ICI2
l
`~.~i

~) L.,r~.R~~' ~d,Ll].~+CJ►L1'II'S

y
i a7~;ar • ~1.J,I,~ ~~. ~~~~J ~a~7~a7 R'~1'.i„ L~~Z.QiJV~;lLEILY ill' ~'lJl,.lAlY3.L` ~.L k7 f'1~4 ~l iJ l[S~l~F l;a'~7 1, lJ
i

~rtu~~c~~~~:z~r~ ~,~~.~r~r~: :

p~r~~r~~r~frs Jc~t-r~r c~ssEr.~~~~c~-icy ~~va t,~~ ~~
r~~r~c~~~~~-~

1~~5~'C)NC~1NG I'~1~~."1~~':

}~'Ir~f~'rti't~F' C`.:~I~t"l"Q~ (~L~(7(tD, C.•L~t~'

~{~rst.~aiYt to I~itt~.s 2~ azle{ ~E~ ~~#~ the f~`~4lur~tl R~tics c~i" C;ivi! ~7t•ca~,ecic~re, D1":~'~NI7AN"C'
;
1t~1-[~C (:~S~~N~I~1C'IIi.[t_ ~.fi~IL7 LC\IZT~Y RUI7t~~t.>I'[( I~►~r~eby r~c~i~est~ that PL~i(t~IT[~F=
C'/1.1'E']-'~~ l~f1C'Olt[)~, I~L.C. rc~s~ac~i~c~ t~ tine kUl(~~v~s7~ ~~.~cEt►est ~~r ~rod~.acCic~~ a~~~~~~ut~~►e~#ts aa~el
`['hinds ~"(~ec~E~ests'') d~~~ci pr~~#~rc~e the ~~~3~UNI~~,~iU'['~ anal ti~iri,~s ciuscri~ie<t hua•cir~, ~t the L~c~.iti~n
Gt~re~c~ upon lay cot~n~~(~ 4~i~hin twenty (2~}) days of s~:i•vice.
3~I~,
I ~3~]'VI'~'lf)1~f
'~'1xc~ follc~~~i►z~; ~-[c~fi~ailia~t~ ~~~r~y to tli~se Itec~~res~t~:
(.

"I~C~~UIVIL;1`~T°1"~~~" }ids kl~c san-~e Mall r~~~al~in~ as ec~a~sti;zi~:el b~+ ~~;d~eal T~ulc; r~i'

"rvif Pt~oc~c~~~rr~ 34 ~int~i ii~~.li~cic:~ wiCt~oa~t Iit~i t~tie~~~ tl~~ origid~~l dot• iclen~ic;al c1{t~iic~te whcn tl~

o~•i~ina{ i~ ~~c~t ~vailahlc;;} and alt nor►-i4l~ritie~a! cogie:~ (~vh~th~:r t~c~r~-itlertt ~a! t~ccat~se ~aS'n«fies
~n~~de on eo~ies n~` a~ lchec~ cc~mtnunts, ~nt~c~lG~Ci~ns,anart~s, ~ranstnis:;ion r~ntali~ti, car ~xi~;lrli~l~tin
~f: ar~y l~it~.d') ~tt~rl drafts cif' ai! wt- tirr , w~7ett~e~• h~nr3~~vr~rtt~n, ~y~~c~~ , ~i~inficd c~~~ c►~h~~~wis~ praciuc~~.l,
~t~d in~izidr.~, wth~tit lixrtit~rtian, I~tters, cgc•i°~s~c~ncicnce, ire~rnar~rrd~, tc~~,l pteaciin;~~, rrt~t~s,
1
'~JJC71'1S} <l~l'~~1I1~'Y'1~;~, Cc"1~~llC~z~1"S, C~tc~l'i~~, ~;3'1V~~ CSI' ~r~p[;Y15~ 1'GCC7CCtS, SLliT11'Cl~l'1~5, l'~~OCf~S~ PYt~55i~~E5

cat• fc3~,s ot`~~:I~}~hcatt~ ells, c~nvcrs~tian~ ~r it~t~rv~~ws, t~l~gt•~~~~s, ~r~~tilg~•~r~~, f~c:~i~t~ l~
t~~a~ts~x~is~i~n~ (includiri~ cove• s#iv~is ar~ci c~i~fir~nK~fiic~~ls), ~ tcc~t•aiticalCy ~tc~rec3 i~a~`crrar~~ti~~n (see
c~~;f"1T~it~t~ ~~~rn~be~~ tavr~ b~lativ)~ ~i~~a~akes ur ~~car~€s t~fi sn~etn~, c~~~~~il~ttc~ns, ~t~tebc~e~ks,
l~l?r~ratc~~y r~c~t~l~c~oks, work ~s.p~i°s, b~ic~ics, ~i~zin~~hlct:~, l~rc~ctittres, ~it•c~tlars, m~t~itals,
[~~s~r~t~tic~t~s, s~le~, ~~vertisin.~ r~r ~~~c~t~t~tic~rt~l lilei•att~re ot• 1~iaterials, l~ti~e~~s, graphs, chants, bl~1c
pr ~~ts, tlra~~ri:~~~9 stcet~~~es, ~~i~c~t~a~t•a~h~, film d~nc~ se~ctr c! r~~~r~d~ict any; ~~pe r~cc~r~cliri~;s, c~~~ any
cst~ler tatt~;i~ri~ ttl~tcri~tis ca~~ ~vhi~I~ t}~~re is ~~ny re~;c~rcful~ ~tiY rvritin~ of~i~y sort, `~'Ite C~~•t7~ ~~15c~
ir~cil2cics the fii~, ~ofcle~• tal,s, end/o~ cc~nt~inex•s ~rlcl 17hei5 appended t~a~ at• ~ssr~~i~te~i ~~ith, ~~r~Y
phy~ic~at :~tcs~~~~e eie~~ic;~ ~s~~~ciatec! ~~itiY c;acf~ oa•i~i~nt ~g~c1~o~• c:~c~~y o#all dt7~ll~Cl~ITS
rec~uesteci S}~reici.
`~

"CC.,F~,~~°R.t~i~llC~~I,,L1' S~l'~JI2~1? l~I1~C)ItM~TIQN" ("~~l'°~ (aa~ fhe s~~r~e li;i(!

i~~canir~~ a:~ r;ar~st,t~L►eci by ~'ec~e3~a1 k~.uie eaf Civil ~'rr~ueciei~•c. Zti ~n~ 34 and inc(t~~esj ~~ith~~it
litrtitatic~n,. tN~~ ~Callra~vii7~;:
a_

r~ctivil:y listir~~s «t'eEectct~~~ic tri~iil rrcei~~tw ~rtef/~~~• transrnitt~l[s;

i~.

c~~~lp~ri i~e~st~lti~lg ~e~~~~~ il~.c tt~~ cif any st~i~twat•U ~~ra~;~•~in, ir~clt~di~~~; ~~ti~~~~~t~t

1it11ii~tc~i~ wu~~i~ ~~r~c~ssip~~; Dt~C~CIIVICN'1'~;, ;s~aresi~ls4~eets, c~~i~a~.~a~e ftle~, ~l~~Y~•ts,
~r~~~s ~n~t ati~tiinGs~ ~i~ut~•t~nic ~~~t~i(, instant ~ness~~i►~~ prc~~ra►ns t~t~l~~~tir1 board
~c•c~~i~~r~~s, c~~~ratin~ ~ystc»zs, so~rr~~ cods, I'Rt~ filc,s, P~~ fi(~s~~ t~~~tcl~ tile,

7

~S~II files, t~n~l ~t(I iT~isc~;l{aneous i77~di~~ c~rz wCiicE~ ll~c~ reside ai7d re~arc~less of
wh~thet~ ~ttcl~ electi~~nic data e,~ist in~t~ ac€:ive file, d~:.(,et~~1~Fi~e, nr~i1~ i'r•a~rl~~:t~t;
~,

~~ly ar~cf ail terns stc~r~;cl ~~ cc~m~a~~i~i~ ~n~~~ior•i~s, i1~rd disks, f7a~ipY ~lis1~~,

CIS-R.t?M, r~~z~netic tape, t~~icratiche, cir an any ~~?th~t~ v~fa r;lc fay° di~it~f data
:
~t~r~ ~, znc(lczt• tr~r~s~7~'r~~~ , iiYul~Tc~En 4~i#hoot lfirtiitat on a persc~rt~l c~ ~rC~! ass'ts~a~lt,
~.~;,a ~?~fm 3~il~t, t~(~~1c1~e1~~~, Tt~e~ ~r other deviu~,
3.

~`~C)U,°,"~t~t)R" tne~~t~~; l'Ittir~tifF~~YtT4L, I~t~~C7[~:i3~,1~I.~C, its par~~xt

cc~rE7~r•~ti«n~, suE~sit~inr ~s ~.ncf ~~f~li~t~s; ~~~l~rd'i~~~ ~iut ►got tin~itcc t~ C_~f~ivc~•s~( Mit~ic Gresit}~
~ec~ardin~s, l~nc. ar~d ~~pitc~l )~i~~~ic ~rtres~~, ~~~~i eG~ch c~~'tli~ir c~tnplc~yees, ag~r~ts, ~•~}~t`e~c~~~ka~ives,
aCt~t~~~►~ys oi• at~~ persatl aetin~ ~r prir•~~rt~t1 to a~totl hell~it csf fi1~se res~sontlin~ D~fer~t~anf,
~~,

IN~~:C`/1~~~U~`eL C~~s[~Ia~1I~~N`~'S ~1~c~ns F~c,fe►Zclants John C7sset7mact~c;f• ~~~d L.tls•i'y

I
~..t~dc~l~~li aE1Ja Id~~ren~~ ~. ~t~a~et.
5.

CC)MIvIUNIC;'~T~~N~ ~tiear~5 e~Gxy ctiscic~~~.ar~; l~~nsf~r•, ~r e~ch~4~g~ ~~°

ir~~'~r~n~a~io~1 c~~~ ~~ini~>~~,11c~~veve~• ~~~c~e, ir~clficji~7s~ b~:~ ~tt~~ Ii~~ti~ec~ ~ta tllrauS~-~f~~~il~ 1~tte~•~ i~~~stz~n~
tar~ss~gin~ acac{ t~~t r~~~~sa~in~. C~J1V11VtUNCC~t1`I'IC)I`•3~ ~ktetll "t t~clt~c~~, [)t~C ~.iMGN"'I`S r~nel LSD..
G.

RL~YC~I ~r~cti~ns t~►~ z~t~iia~c m~rIccCplace f~o~ p~~~wa~vri~~ ~li~~~ita~ ~t~i~~ic ika~t i~ a

I
7e;,t'enci<in~ in this r~<~lter ~.~~c1 i!s ~i~~1~iay~~.~s, t~ff~~ci's, anel di~•e~~c~►~~ ~~kr~►~ thin the, ~N~~iVI[~IJAI~
I ~~+Ldp1J,~A ~1'I'S,
~
7.

~a~+°T~~,~~ ~R~~-I~I'G~'FLJR~ zrs~~t~s t[1~ stx~u~t~~~•~ ~~r~tr~[~C~«~~~ u~f ~~ c~►r~:~~atc~~

sy~cen~ t}iaC corx~p~•ise ~ot~tGv~tr~c: com~7~►~eri~~, t}~c ~;~t~:~~r~a~~y visit~[c ~~ropel•ti~s c~1'tihrise
G~c~tn~€~nents, ~rtc1 file r~i~~ic~t~sh%ps t~~fi~v~;~r~ t:~xe~7~,
8.

I~tt,;1"C"~1.L LC}N~I`L~]T PRUV[C7F;IZS t~ea~~s any us~tity, other th~ry [~.~Dl~il, t3~at

5ull~ car distributes to c;~kc~~tisurs cli~ital vers'sai~s, wl~~the►~ iri ~v~lule ~r iia p~r•t, rs#`t~lusic r•~corc~it~~~
t~~hat e:t~c~~us~s•s c~czFv~ticf~ci at' Str~~ir~~ over the It~fierl~et tee ~,t~ ors ~t~~ir c~m~~~~ters or ~ih~;~ ~te~:t~•oni~
~I~vic~s (~.g., cell ~l~~r~cs),
9.

17 G~`1'~\I~ IJ~~~L,Cai~'~'~°:IC?N ~Yzeans thy: ~at~at~ss b~ ~vhiet~ DIGIT~IL CC)NT.~N'T
3 .~

i'Ct~`~Ir~11(~ sc;lt c~a~ diste Guts cli~ita! versions, w4~et[~~~• wl~ate- oy~ ire p:~rt, c~rmlzsis rccocdi~3~s tc~
end-~Gse~~s..
l td.

IZC~f~RI711`~(~ r~RT[S"I'S mans airy i»~l vid~aal Ur pe~~f`r~r•n~it~g g~pu~ that recc~rd~~i

t~~ast~~~ 3•~~ardin~~ l'oa~ '~'"(~~i.
I 1.

PI~.~O~[3Lt€:~,~~ ~~~eans arty i~~livici~~t~~.l~ ~r p~~rformin~ ~roti~a ttia~ ~a~c~dc~ced ~n~sEcr

t•e~;c~r~l~ ~~~s ~F'or Y~CJ.
T 2,

CC7N(i~~1~1~~"l~IC3I~ i1~►eax~s a~emu~~~:t•ntic~n; wl~c~tFtci• in ~x~c~a~ey car iii kind,

13,

i2.~C`C)~~7 I~A.L~L,I~ n~r~a~~~ ~Xs7~r br~~nd an~lot~ tra~f~m~rk ~~~aci~t~~! ~vii~i thc.

~~n~rfc~ti~n~~ a~ music r~cor~in~;s c~~~ ri~~~si~ r~icl~c~s ot~a~►~ t4~ar~ ~APITUL T~~:C'~}t~~~~, I.,~a~ end'
i~~cit►d'rn~ I~~~t rsc~t li~i7it~t! tc~ l~i~~t~n~.~~ MExsie C;r~u~y, E~Mt, ~~t~y, I3M~, Univ~r~~l 1V1t~~ic: ~ro~ip9
aE~ci Paly~~•~n~
I~4.

~[,L~Cx~~T~~,.Y E."(~1'~'C~1Cs~-t'I'kaC7 ~~~IC a muat~s the. S 1~ scarps listed in ~;~hibii A

~c~ `~~71~~ Art~e~~lcci Cra~r~ taint iii this fit ~~t c~a7,
l5.

C'R.~~ t~72 Sf~~1~~ i~n~a,r~~ tli~ 55 s~s~~~s listed ~n ~:xhi}ait .~3 f~ Y+~~JIt Ainenc3~c]

~c~~~~plaat~t icy this liti,~atic~n.
I~a~

~'RI S~ fi~~~~xtls ar~~y ne~~~ cfiss~►n iaat~un Dery ~e anc1 t~~c~ir a~~;~~ti:;~ and cr~zplayc~~s,

incl~E~din~; t~t~t nil li~nit~d to e~tabtishecl nears servi~~s {;~.e,, C.~N; Fc~~t, ~Sl'~i3C}, r~+eE~sites~ ~S~S
fe~c3s, pc>cicasts ar~tl bla~;s.
1,7,

"N'I;f~St:}}N" fiacl `~E'~~t~CJN~" shill i~~~:li~d~ bath ~~~ sii~~E~lar ~i~d ~~fG,ral, ~r~d sll~fl

~7~e~y~ ~ncl refer tc~ arty n~~ua~al t~urr~an b~ ~~~4 Fi~~n~, ~r~pt~i~tor~hi~~, ~~i~ne~•sh't~~, eca►~~~c~~•~ti~it~i j~aint~
ver~tut~e, sh3.rcholclei-ti i~~vE~st~~~~~, inemF~~~•s, Ii~~~iCucl lit~~iility t;t~~~1p~n~Y, lit~tit~cl Ciahility ~at•fin~~~s~ii~a,
~encF•al~~a~r~n~r~hip, li►~~it~;r~ ~at~tn~rsi~ip, ta~ti~r, l~;il~ —girl cc~m~~~i~y, ~ov~rnln~~~~ ~~e»i u~~
~over•r~r~~ctl~t bt~dv> c~ss~cia't~i~r~, employers, ~;~nplc~ye4~, ~~~ents, ~~ar~tn~rs~ csEfic~i•s, cSir~ci~ars,
B•cp:•~.~~rl~atives, ~ft~~(iatc~ ar~cl ill ~tf~t~t~ ~f~t~ms fif ~~•~~~~iration -or entity i~r c~~hc~~ ~;r•c~tip c>~~
cc~ ~~bi~r~t on off: tl7t~ C'c~~~;g~a ng acting as c~nc.
l ~,

C'QLit~""~' t~c~ns ~7~~~~ ca~'J:t~ial stiand~t~rl{~), r~ce~trt~e~s}, a~~ ~ai•Qtc~col~s), wl~etkier

GV1'lCf.~i1 C1E` £IC7~,
_~

.0 9.

I~t~Y~L'I~'Y 5'~I'A'- 'E.~VIE•~!'T'~i~i~:~rts st~teme~~tts of rc~~~tlCi~s, rugal~dless ati ty~ae, thclt
[

Y£~I7 ~~t~c~v~cic; tca I~1~?CC~~f~I1IC ~I2TIS"~'S ai~c! 1'I~f)~L1C~TtS,
2~.

ALJI~[rI` t~~~~~~:~ an examn~tiora, ccv~w, ~~~ ins~aecCiot~ c~CRQYAL'f"Y

5"i"~"C°~IVI~N"1"(5) u~lh~th~~• initialed ~t ~~7~ a~~:c~uc~t c~f'RLCC~~T~~1C AR°~'1~TS ~r• P.R~E~~C~C~It~
c~~ ~~s ~~~~~sEa1t o~f an it~[~rr~~~t~~ uc~t~~pli~~»~ ~aa•c~~~ss.
1,

"lnclt~cli~l~;3z i:~ ~~sed tc~ llc~stt'atc ~~ Ct~;c~E~c~st -tar p~rtauet~~tr t~}~~s cif U~C'~:JNt~I~'i'S

c°~Erya►est~c:l, ~tnei s~~c~ll nat ~~ cc~~~stra~ed as li~nitin~ tf~~ [~~c~~re:st 'tn x3s~}~ ~v~y„
?2,.

°`U~•" ~hrau~ci E~~ e~~~tc~u~t~ to i°equi~~~ thy. ~ir•~~~c~c;st ~~~ssik~l~ r~~spanse, rind si~c~~4ld be

r~c~ac~ ~s "a:~d/o~."

~'tiu~su~ra~ to 3~r~le ~~~e~ of tlic Feeleral l~.~il~s c~~' C"ivil. S'rr~~~.c~~~re, these C~t~CUIY[I:i~fT
r~c~uc sty sf~~ll be e~c~2n~ej ~~~ be cc~~-~Cinlrin~~ its n~Cr~r~ scr ~th~t ~f l:~ef~n~a~ts, tC~eii~ ~i~~ectar~, ~~f~c~~•~,
e~it~~~l~ay~;c;s, ~ Lnta, r~p~~s~r~t~tti~e~ ~r any ~r~o►i ~ctir~ ~1~ b~*l~al~' o~t` i~e~P~nd~r~t~, st~bs~gcE~r~t~ly
cli~;~ave~ ter o~t~ii~ ~7~ssessic~~r, c~~stoc~y tit° ~c~nts•~~~ ~~ r~t~y ~C}C'TJI~t.~N`I° ~t~ev rusty r~c~z~~s~~~ ~r
r•cc~~~irec! Ee~ 17c; }~rr~~lttcec3, D~f~r~cEarifs shaft ~►•t~m~~tly ►~~al~c: Mich [~C~~~..t~t~ ~l"~' ~v~l l~t~al~:..
1,

ttz ~r'oc~t.xcin~; ~7C~CCJMt::T'+II'~5 and ~51z yc~tt ~~•e t€~ fi~cttish ill pC7~:'tJMC~I`1'S ol•

E ;~I `rte yoiic R~c~ss~;ssic~i~, ci~atati.y ref• c~ant~~ol, ~~e~~a~~cCle~s r~(' the ~71~ysi~~i lou~kt ~rt~ cif t~ze.
DC)GUiVtENTS ~r wh~t}~er ~t~ch U~}CLl1VIEN~'S c~~~ ~n~tc~ri~~ls are ~t~ssess~~ direC~ly by ya~~ car
ycjur ~ii~~ectors, af`Iiuc~rs, ~~~e:r~fs, c~m~I~y~~S, w•c~~resentativGs, st~S~sicli~trie~, m~itl~gic~~ a~;utjts,
a('fifi~l_c.s, il~vesCig~~tc~~•s, car key y~~ur ~~ttc~rneys ar kk~~ir ~~ertts, ert~;>l~~~ees, i•epre5entativ~s o►•
ir3ve~ti~;atc~cs.
2.

En j7ro~luc~rt~; ~:~C)C~[TMC~N`l'S ~i1d BSI, ycn~ ate rcc~~zesCec~ tc~ pt~c~c~dace tt~~ c~ri~fri~l

t~f each L?(.?C'~JNt~:~N"i~ nt~ ii~rt~ c~fi ~I~51-s~cc~~iesicd, tctgeEhef~ ~~vi~t~a all neon-ir~~~~tical cs~pi~s ~n~l c~rn~~
r~(~s~xch T~~~UMUitiI"1'. It`t~iU ui• ~rn~.i c?~'~~r~y D~7+CUM~le1:~E" ter itean s~f ~;SI c~r~nat be lc~cateci, r~

_ ~_

copy Sl~~i~ b~ p~~e~c~uceci ire Iieri ~1x~rcc~F, a~~c~ ~E~<3!( b~; fe~i~~e ~1~c~, far a DC)Ctl~v1~CI~~', b~~~t~~t or
sia~~l~ci i~ tl7e s~tn~ Ynanii~;t• t~s tl~e c~~~i~;ina1.
~<

DoG~arnez~ts oi• ~5:~ t~c~i ~Cl7er~v~s~ x•~spcansive tt~ thcs~ l~ec~u~st~ sh~11 tae ~E•~cl~~cc~i ~'

suafi l~Q~~1MCNT5 r~i~ ~;Sl ~n~iTtion, di5c~~ss, ccfer ~~, or ex¢~l~ its C~a~: ~t~~~.7N1 iV`~" that ~~•e
,
~
.n(lec~ Ic~r~ by tl~csc ~egLiests, aE• it'siacF~ T~C3C't.fN1k~N'1'S zre atiachecl tt~ C~C~Ct,iMf~N"1 S c~ll~~j ~'~i'
,
E~~y i}~~s~ C3ocEir~~~nt I~ec~ues~s at~d cc~n~t"rt~ite ~~a~l~it~ s~li~s, tt~~t~s~t~i~t~al ~-~~en~~ratid~~~ i~tt~rs, cover
Sh~~ts, ~~o~~r~n~r~t~, ~val~iatia~s ~i• siit~il~r t~a1:~i•i~al~.
~4,

Ali T.~f:~~C.JN1~t~"~'S end ~S~ s11<tIl be r~~cl~ic~~. i~~ tfac s~t~~~~ ~t•cler a~ t1Y~y are kept

~~t~ ~~~~.int~ine~ h~ yr~ct i~~~ tlit~ ord~in~zt~y cc~~~t~~~ t~f ~<Gt~r ~usitYi;~s. ~~I .s~h~~~l b~ pra~I~~~e~i in ~n~t~ve
~
oY~tnaf~ If ~r~y ~C3~~.1~v1~,I~"~~~~ c~~~ it~~~~s c~C ~4[ iaave b~~n r~t~~v~c~ ~'i•c»r~ tk~~ ~I~~ i~~ ~vh~cf~~ tE~~y
wv~r~ Fc~ctnc9 fir ~~Gt~~~~s~:fi ~~' ~~~•o~PG~~in~ ttic,d~t i~~ r~..spc~r~s~ t~ tlies~e r~ec~~zes~~s, i~r~clicatc~ ~'~~~ e~~~l~l
[
~OC;IJMNT tlz~ fil~~~} i~~c~r7~ 4vi~ich tl~e C.~C~C~UMt~N'I`(~} 4vas twcre) ari~inally Ic~c~ted.
4,

~~l I~c:~~(~10/3E~1'S shill b~. ~rr~c{~tc~ci ire thy; file #«I~l~t~, ~n~~io~e cat• ~t}~►c~r

c~sYtrtin~r i~~ wE~ict~ €!~e DQCI.JNI~1~tTS ~r~ k~~~t ~x• m~ir~tainec~ by ya~~, If 1~r ar~y r•~~~~n tl~~
cc~►~t~.~iner ea~~~tc~t bu ~r4~ei~sc;ecl, ~rc~~i~~ce. c,c~~Zies ~E'nl( 4ab~.ls car ~th~e td~nt fyir~~ rrir~t~lc~.
i,
(

l?cic~~n~t~.t~~s and E:SI. sh~l1 k~e ~rac:fuced iri ~uck~ i'ashi~~n as lt~ ~ic~it fy the

cle~arti~ent, I?ranch car t7tlic~ ire t~vhc>se ~c>ssessioia ~h~.y ~v~r~ I~~~t~cl atxl, ~vl7c~e~ applica~rlt;, Chi
n~tt~r~~~ ~~a-s~7~n iz~~ t~ul~c~se ~ossessiori tf~ey wc;re fc~~~r~cl at1tl, il~e b~isine~s a~ldi~css cif ~ac;h
~f~?C'~1M€~~N~1~"s c~ist~c~cfian(s).
'7.

~)c~~cam~t~ts ~t[acli~:.r~ ec~ eac,h c~th~r si~c~r~ld t~~t ~t~~ ~G~azt~~tied, incl~.~dii~,~~ 4~~~1` ~~ot

iir~xitc:c~ t~, e-rz~~lil t~ttac~zo~~ents,
8.

It' a ~~C'C~~'If~N'I" c7r t~i~~ cif L5I once c;~istcd ~~ncl 1~41s S~t~se;giaenlly t~~er~ Ic~:;t,

~1~stroy~d: cat° ~ cather~vi~e ~z~issin~;, ~teasc pae•c~vi~~ s~~f'I~ciei~t kt~f~r~~x~t~r~n tca idex~til'y lf~e

G .,

t~C)GUiv~~~'s~i"I` ~nci st~t~ the €i~Eail~ cc~x~~erniry~ iYs lass:
fill i~~}C'L1Ml~N`i"~ proci~uc~ci its papct~ ~'~~'~n ~hc~xilcl f~c r~~~~~7~~k~er~t~ se~.u~~lti~i.~y,

~~.
.

iv~~h a ira~ie~tre r3~X,~~~a~:~~ on e~ci~ page, a~~c~ with a ~at'~~x ic~c;~tiE'~i►~~ ~:h~ p~~ty proci~i~~in~; tl~~
]~tJC'LN1NT:
~(~?.

[f' y~~.~ cl~ir~ the ~tte~ri~c~y~~~x~tak p~°i~vilu~~ car arty otfi~~~ ~~t~avi(~~e o~r ~vr~~~k prac~trci

p~~~t~ctian :Fc~r any l"?C~~"L1MI<~i'F, ~~rc?vie{e; ~ c~ctaifc;d ~t►v~l~~c 1~~? that cort~~ ~~s at test fie
['~lla~vi'n~ informa~ic~:~ Fc~~• e:~~h ~C)C;U~rI~~;N'1'th~t y~t~ ~aav~ wthll~Ici;
~.

;eta#~ ~fi~ clue at~~e t~~~UIVtC~I"I~ ~r itc~r~ c~~` ~~!',

l
~:

icic~ry~~fy e~i~h anti ~v~r~r ~~.tlhc~r o~ t}i~ i7t3~(JM~.N'T ~r CetY~ ref Call;

c,

ic~~t~►tify ~;~i~t~ 4~t~ci ev~tY ~ct~svn ~~~~ca ~r~e~~~~e~l car ~~t~ti~i~~tc~~~ in the

~r~p~~•~.i: can nf' k~e I7C~G~lI!vf}ANT Ur item cif f~5i;
cl.

dcr~Gi~y e~~c~l~ a~~cl ~~rcry }~c;s°~~i~ r~vho rcecivcc3 tf~c 13C7~l.l~'I~aI~~~` car it~~n pi"

I CI
c.

c~entitiy ci~c{~ anti ev~.ry~ pe;rsc~tt fi~~~~~1 w[te>~rt tli~. ~C~CjUMGl~1~irc r~r ite~~t ~f"

CfS[ ti~a~ f•ccei~ed,
f.

~~~~c.~~rid~ ca ~~nc~~•~! ~~~~ri~lic,~~► t~f'ti~~; sc~biect matter;

~~

slate t'l~e prc,se~1~ 4c~~.afic~n o(' -the 17C~~'111VI~NT ~r• it~.~n ~t CS[ end afl

.c~pics ti~~~~e;ot`;
~
It.

i~i~nCil'~F ~a~:~3 ~r~d e~v~ry p~i•st~r~ laavita~ ~~ist~idv ~t~ ~~►~l~`c►1 cif° the

QCJC~UPv~f=N~Z' car ite~r~ c~#"C:~[ ~t~c~ X11 cc~pi~s tl~ereaf;
i.

icicntily~ t}~e; nui7~be~•~d ~~c~l~~est~s) t~ wf~ich [hE l~~(7CUMisTJ~~> ol. ~t~ix+ ar'

f~Sl is t•~s7~c~nsive; ~►nc~
j.

~~ravic~e sut'f~~ cnt info►~matia~~ cc~xic:ernin~ the I;~QC;~1I~~~E~~l'~' ca~~ itet~ cat'

_ °~

C:Sr and Cl1e, ci►~~.f~n~str~ncc;s tl~e~•eaf to c~cp[aiiT the claim cif privilege or~ ~ix~a~ectic~n
~n~~ t~ permit l~~;.a~,juciic~ti~r3 of the ~~J~C~}~i•iety oC.i}~~ elaiir~.
1 l.

~f yt~c~ ~~~ert privil~~a with res~aect tca ~~t~t o~ a rc~peansiv4 L)~LUI'vIC~!'1 ~7• tet7a

~f`~~SI r~c14~e:t the ~t•ivi!'c;~cc~ ~at'tign ~t~d incii~~te clearly ~n the DUG6J1VILl'*1`1' wl~c ~~c the tr~~tci~ al
w~i:~ ~~e;~ia~l~c~, I'N~odGace the ~•~c~~c~ecl ~?C)~UI~t~N"1' c~~• item of ~;ST even i~' ~~~i believe lf~~t t~~e
Egon-re;cf~~e;~~;c1 pt~t~tion i~ x~a r~s~i~r~sive, fc~~t~tii'y ttie t~~ci~ctcd ~at~tic~ns ran tl~c p~~ vil~~~ Ic~~ ire t is
satx~~o i~~~nncr [~s with~a~lcl ~~CtY'MtaN`~":~.1~lc~n-~•~spc~►~siver~~ss ~f'ct }ac~~iora ~~f a I~~GUMCN'[' €~1`
it~t~~t of taS~ i~; nc~t ~ ~t~f~ci~r~t basis fc~r red~~Ci~E~.

~~r<,~~rs~r rc~~~~ta:c~~~t~cp~t~a~r
ail C(.~Ml~i~1`~~~~"1'~C,1N~ tE~~t r~~~r at~ relate ~c~ CtCL~[Ul ~et~veera YOU ands

1.~7

Y~L1~t E'ar~t7t C'c~m~ranr~~,

~:~

YE~tJC~ ul~~itiir~~•ie~;

cl.

Dt~I"-CF1L CC)N`F`~NI" I?]~t~VTT~~°,R:S;

e.

C~tf~er RG~C7R~ [..,~1t3~i~S;

f:

1~:1~C~IZI~T~ti(Ci t1~.T~~T

~;,

~'1~f7~I~tIC~~1~~; Ktncl

C2~t~}LJ~~ST° F+U~Z 1'~tC3~~ilC'I'~t~l`1 l~i{7►, ~v
All C:(~~~~~v1[.I~fIGI~'TIt)~5 thztt ~•c~('er ur reia~e to ~~~e ea:pl~~itatic~r~ c~t`t.kae 1'~LL,LGI:;C~I.,~'
~'Ut'~'I~IUi-ITI:J~ ~(JNUS car t'~tl -1~7:~ SC~I~C~S bc~twe~,n YC~tJ arid:
~.

~~~CaIGZ,

_g~

b,

YC1-t.1R 1'ar~nl ~~rnpa«ies;

~.

~rou~ .s«~5~d,~7►~;~s;

~a,

~~c~~~r~.~, cc~NP~~~,~~r~ ~>zt~~r~~~;r~s~

e°.

C}thee R~~C~I~ I~~1E3~L~~

~.

~~.C~~t1~CR,5,

~2~(~~J~~'I' F~YI-~ P~~t~I1T.JGTIfJI'V~ I`d~?. 3
~!i C~~IV[NtLTt"~ICATI~I'`~I~ t~x~t re(`~r or ref~l~ i:~ revL~~sic~n rights on the I'`RL~-i ~'~~
SC31~l~CG~ ~t~cl:
~:

Ct~17~C.;r~;.

~?.

~~~~° ~it3'GTI~.~..'C)T17~Jci111~5;

CI,

BICrI"T'AL~ C~~~ITENT PC~U`t~1L7I"Ii,Sx

;
f

[~L;~CJR~3iN~; ~i:~~'T"tS'!'S; <~►~cl

~.
;

~I~t)D~~L;RS,

~T~f~UT~'~" I+'C3~ 1'P~.CJ►1)L7~~'I4N l''rIC~, ~:
ALI.~ Ct~M1VIUNIGII'I'I~N~ tt~~t t•efcc c~a• rekate i;c~ `r`CJUt2. a~l~~ed ~•'tghts its the
/~~~,~;G~I~C.,~'' C`C3I'~''Rt(:~~~1~~'Z ~ ~'C)N~~ rye P~~F~`W l a72 SUIJGS f~etwe~n Y~11 ancf ___
a.

~2~,l~iGi:

~.

~`C)iJR f'aret~t Curn~~u~ties;

G.

~~~~I.[~ ~ll~?SlC~IciflGS,

~!.

D}~lI ~'x~L C.C)~`I~i }:;N l~ k~I~{~V(t~I'~Id~'s,

c
~

C7tfier I~ECC)RL} [a~E~f~.I..,S;
f',

RC~'t7RD~NCr A~'1'1S'C"S, ~R~d

~.

~~~tc~l~~..IC~i~~,.

AI.I,~ n~ ~l(?[T~. t~t~;rn«~I ~~~v~MUS~!(Ct1~"1"i~)i~~ tl~G~l re:~~r ar i•~I~tc tc~

1ZIC~:I.

~I1 c~c~rtCr~~:ts a~' a~r~e;m~t~C~, t~clucli~xg clr~f~s thctec~f, bet~v~~r7 Yt~U G~riel ~~~y t~iir~d ~S~rCy
~~I~~f re~'~t• ~~r r~~ate tr;~ the C?if~~f`~l'A~L E~~"~I.C~~T~1Tl(~~] ~f tie i~i~,~,1 ~7~ SCJI~G~" c~i~ t1~~

~2t ~.1E~T TC~1Z I'~t~1l~U~."T~()N 1~CC), 7.
AlJ t~~nt,t~G~cis ear a~re~tt~:ent.s, ir~c~~~c1i►~~ cis~~t~s t1~~rcQf~ bc~w~~n Y~~.J c~nc~ ~i~y I~XCxiT`AT~
C~'~I~`] ~t~rC' E' .C7VIt71~f~, that r~,fer a~• relate to tl~t° {7a~~~~~.rrt ~faxrcch~tiic~7 ray;tlti~s t
,
E2E~~QR~?[Nf:; ~1It'~'~S7"S e>►• ['T~.C)T}IJC~t:1i~.5 fir the t)~C:~1'I't1[, ~XP1.~C~1I`!~A'i'IC~N rafthe P~~w
1 972 ~f3NCr5 ~r tf~e ~LL~;CIE;L7~~` ~;C)1~YRIGI-~"C'Gt~ S~N~S.

till c;~y~#~rt~a~;tti c~~• ~~t~e~;~~~t~~:~, in~lucl~~~; cl~•~f~s tl~zc;a~c.c~f', be~~v~;~,€~ Yt~U~ ~.t~d any tl~irc~' ~~~.a•ty
tl~~~ ref~7~ u~• ~-~lat~ ter thy; payment c~~i~ r~ech~tnical r~~ya(~i~~~tt~ l~~,~`(7f~:~~l~i~ ~1R`C'1~S"I~S car
i'I~C)~)LIC.~t~S Cyr tl~e l.~IG~"l~A~~., E:;~C~~I~C)X'~I~'f~`T'1~1V ~rf the F~T~I;-197'? S~NC~~ gar tt~~
l
A T,~~Gf~t=)T_,Y C'C~~Y~IGEI'T'EI:? ~~i~GS.
~I~
l

1L~`1' ~+~'C)R PI~:~)T~iJC'T'IC?N 1~IU. 9;
f'111 contracts car ~x~;t~e~~~~ents, inGlG~cjiti~ c!~•t~f'ts th~r~:c>f, betweua~ 1~{31:i' ~tnci fi~C-l~~I~iNG

'
~11~"~'tS'1~S or ~'R(.~DUC~R~' tlt~t ~°e1~~~• c~~• ~~ulat~ i~ the I'CZ~:-"1~17~ ~~C7NGS ter ~tle ~,I~LECrI~~i7[~~`

ICI+:,~UE~°I' ~CIT~ PR(3I)~JG'i~()1"~t P+IC}. 1.0;
~'°tJLJI~ ~'C~I.~.f.C'Y cyt• l'(~~~(Ct1.~S, il~cludin~ cirafi~s tE~G~~ec~rt; that. Teter or relay tt~ the itse of
the i'CtE-1972 ~C?`~IGS car tt~e ALL G~rt~C3L~Y C~f?l~'~ItIC~-I'1'Cp ~C)NGS fc~t~ 1.~1.Gi'~'~1~.
t~t.C)T'~'~1'I`tC~TAI.
~~~!~t~U~~`T' I~'C1T~ I'"I~C}~1~C1~"~"~;CC7►1~ N~), 11:
~~)U~t I?C7Ia~C~,'' c~z~ ~'()L[E"1~5, i~Xc;lc~cling ~ir~ft~ the~~~;o~; tli~t rvf~r at• rclat~ to tEa~
day€~~~r~t oftraec~taraic,~l rc~y~lties ~c~ R~G~C~T~[~~ ~1~"1'tS"i'~ ~~~e1 ~'F~C~~~IC~'i~S fur the
I
JI~ITAI.~ l~~I~t~~{'1'~h~'rC~`{~ c~t'ti~e P'T~:~~~1972 ~f~7NGS ot•tihe ~II~Iy~G~I~I,Y ~Cll'~4'`~t.CGT~T~,i~
S4~7I~Ci.~.~,
1
tiI+~~~~~;T ~+"Clit. I'It~i}~~~"~'It~l'~ ~`~l'f,1~ 12~
~'(~7`U7Z ~t.~~y~~';Y car ~'~LlC1CS, it~cll~c~iri~, pr'rr~e v~rsiarls and cir~fts thc~~e,c~t 'that re~~.r cat°
,
rel~tc~ to tf~c. }~~ly~i7~.n# cif ~z~~;ehanic~l ~~oy~ilti~ s to It~lGO1tI~I~`~fCJ Fly"ISIS"l ~ G~i° T'R~a~:►CCR~a far
the; rlcirt-DI:GI~'~11~ EXPL.C?JT~`1'[Q~I taf the I~RE~;- l ~7? ~F.~NGS a~' the Ali rE~~~~~[7t.,'S'

~t~,At1~~T T~C~I~ Pit{UI~i1~7'I(~1~1 T~!`~. ~~:
~(3l.l.i~ P~?.La1CY Uzi• .I'C)I,fC<C~~~, ir~~,luding prior ~,Fe~siorts ~~e~ t~at`#s thei•uc~E; :Chaff ~cl'w~~ sic
~~el~tu tc~ the ~aym~nt ~# mechanic{~I rc~ya.lties to .RI ~~'URI~INU AI~`~'I4~1"S car C'RU1~UG~~2.
~vh~;~~ the C'.{~~ -1072 S~3N~i~+ or tie ~L:I.~~~~~CaQLY ~'(~~'YRiGT-iTC ] ~+JNt,~ ace: so{c~ ar
c~tht~r~~isc distribe~tcacl Div I~DI~I.
tCUiJ~'.~'i1' F()E~ ~'[2C?i:IU+~TTC`fl'~ Nth. tit:
I
~.(~-~t't~[.°~"~~ 5°C'ft~f'~.?:Mf~~1~~`5 ~;cnet~~t~el Eiy Y~7~~1 ~'or• C~~~~~ItI~1NG A~TfST~ car
~I~(~I7U~~~R.S ~hc~~vin~; Cil~ ~7ay~~r►~nt c7~~'me,char~ic~l ~•~y~lfiius ti•~ax~ Che I7[GI~T~I~
~:~C'4~I~C1!'f'~ri"IfJN oCtl7c~- E'~~~a-1X72 ~4~~i~f~~ c~x~ the ALLL~[~L~3~~' ~C}PY[~XG~-1'T'~~1~ Sf7N~S,.

1~~'t,~~~ST I+l7I2 ~'RQ17CT~;'TIC►N NC). 1~:
Royat~y ~talet~~et~ts~~n~c~ted h3r ~'~OIJ Por ~Z~;CQC2,Ca~I~~i ~12~'~~S'~"~ ~nc3 ~'T~C~1~LT~CRS
shc~wit~ t13~ payt~zent r~E tYae~h~:~tscal ray~.~ti~s 1'oc t(~c s~l~: ~r cii5trib~rtian a C the F'RFe-1~7~
~+QNC-S ~r tf~e ALLEsG~;T~I,Y GGP~RIC~I-Ifi~t~ SCJNCS ~y 1'~~.;t~IG'I,
]ft~ ~..11~4~1' ~'~I~ 1'I~t7~~.IC`~IC}1'~ N+C~. 1C:
tLll 1LLIDI'I'~ YC?iJ lave l~cei~ subj~ut tc~ that ~~~f~:a• o~~ re1~►t~ to the- ~il~~~d Holt-payment t~F
tx~c~cki~~ic«iI rr~yG~lt ~s k<i RF,(~()1~~DI~IC t~R°i"C5'I 5 nr I'RO[~T~~I>RS for Chu ~IGT~'~~
,
1~~f'Lf~[rT'~1~t'IC1N cs1`the I~f~a~t972 ~~NtS c~~• ti~u t~~.:,L~Ci~[~L~t'' CO~'YI~~CrJ-1'I'~~ ~fJ1V~..~'~".
I
~EQ`ET~S'~' I+'C1I~. PI2~1J►iJ~.~`I'I11"V IeT(3..1(i:
X111 c5t Y~}UR an~~ly4es aiz tl~e im{a~~cf R.~t71C"tI co~~1d ~i~ve; on the a~~~~~nt c~ mastey YaC..1
4:>~• c~tlle>i~ I~.I3C'C3Cti~ 1~~4E3F?IJ~ i;oiilci inal~.
l
~:l~ rtJ~"I' 1~C3~~ ~"~(7~LT~C°I'IC9i~I N'(). 17:
A fl 1~C3GC.,~MIa~'~1"l"S re(ai:it~~ tc~ Yf~UI2 ~14tr~s or r~~entiar~s tp cl~velop ~C~F"~'W~F~E
~,RC'I~l"1'~~C"1`U~C~ fc~~~ t'~:~~Il n cif sci~7~s t~ci~ia~tafly ~~t1r ~~as~cE ft'or~i L~ICrI`I'A~, ~C~i~1T~N~•C
Pl2UViI.~EEi:S.
]:~.~ ~J~+,"T `(}~2 J.'~~(~~1:~C:'TI(71V itit~3. l8:
A ~! D~~UV1C~N'1'S relat'in~ tc> ~Z~C:C~It~I7 T~,~~13T~~~' ~~lai7s c>r~ ir~i~nt~i~~t~s t~~ cfcv~lc5~~
St?t~'~'W,~R1~ AL2C'[-1I'I'~C`E~C~R1~:: [~~r resc;llirt~ c~t'songs r~~•iginally purchased t~~ot~~i DEGI'IiAi_.

C~~f~LT~+a~" ` I+C1121'~(~~3CJC~'I~)1V P~iE3. 1~7:
~tl ~oiltr~ict~ sac ag~z-e~r~~~nt~~ ~~twe~t~ `~C)1.J ~z~ct x~iny t}~ircl p~~=t~ tklut ~~~~er c~~• relai~ to the
st~~t•a~e, rnaint~.ttar~ce. c>~• ec>sr►pi}<~t on of ~~,SI.

~12

It~(,~C.rF~'~" FO!1~ ~'[~Cl~:it~Cl`~£3~T'`+~[). 2Ci:
All co~~tr~cCs ~t~ ~gi•~emc~t~fs tt7dt YC)lJ c~f~ter~d pr~~l~~il~its cat• lii~nits Y~Ll ~'r~m }~rt~clt~cin~
~7C)~,UNIFsTd"l~a i-~t~c~estcc~ ley the 7N1)IVtDL7~1L Dt.£~E~~D~N~I'S in this at~r►tC~~ertt tlecC titi~ati~n.

~~R6t .t~. C~r;sstrrcrra
~etl3 R. C;~assn~ar~ ~SG-811.6}
,Tune;; J. I'izzirussc~ ~l~tc~ lzcrc vic:~ pe~~din~~p
?'~~thanie;! G. Cait~tiin~s (~~~c~ 1~cie: vice pertciin~)
I
-IAtJSl~I~,~.:1~ [:~~,P

C"cr~rrr.4clt,f~r,Ic~~trr ~~s,s~r~ri-r~rc~l~~rt~ ~~:I
cf~•r~~ 1~~rcrc~~~~dr

-~ f 3

C~l~'I`I'C)C31~t~~CC?ItUS, ~~I.~C 'V.1t~U1GI CtJC., JOI-IN C)SSL;N~r~~1C[-tL;R, tINU L,r1I~I~Y
~~~OII~'I~t, ~1/I<i~~ Lr1W~~~1~E 5. Itt~G~i.,
C
C~~sr: Rio. 1~-Cf/-QQ0~5 (I~,JS)
#~I4"I'R1~"I" 4i~ CCp~UMBI~1
I ~Yi~~ c~~x~~l~~yt~ci i» Chi DI~'Tttl~~~' ~I' ~'(Jt_3U1~~['13rF1~ 11~y bt~sit~ess add~~ess is 17~~} K
~tr~.c~ti, NW S~iit~ ~SU, W~~~►in~=~~ar~, LAC", '~UUDC, 1 a~r~~ ove~e 1~~~ ale c7~f'~igl~t~~n ~e~s~~ t~z~ii ~~~.~c~t ~~
~~a~°ty t.c~ fife rvitl~i~~f ~ct~r~t~~
Can C~c~tc~b~ a~ ~I, ~~ 13, I ~~~'vc~d the ('~rl i~win~ dc~crrmun~ erzt tied DTF'TI'ri~7~,i'~"~`~ ~~~1I~
f~S~~+,~1 AC'~-~~~,1~ Al`1I) L~T~,~~Y 1tU-1~t~L~'~~'~ ~+'.~125'I' 1Z~+C~'I1~+~ST TC~R ~.~(~DUC"TT+Dl~C
E~~~ ~C3+~~ME1~"~"'T'~ ~~iI7~ "~"~~:~N~~'T`C7R t~L~1.i~`i'Il+Y+ ~A,1'~'~"(~L 17~CC>~2.D~, GAG a~z ~L~L
tNT~R~~TC~+ P/SR'~E~'l~S iri this ~=~ctica« 1~y ~~a~,in~ tr~i gap es th~r~~('G~cl~-r~~d ia~ se~lccl
~nvelc~~~5 aci~ires~ed ~s ~c~llo~~rs,
~~~ A'~'T.A.GH~I~ I..i~`~
~Y MAIL: By ~~lacic~~; ~ t~~~i~ copy tkaereoC itt ~ ~~:~lec~ e~iv~l~pe~'ac~~i~~es~ud a~ ~t~~av~, a~~cl ~(neing
it for rinel in~iiling lc~lla~vir~~; ardit~at~y E~~t~'r«e~s~ pr~cticc~. I atn t~cF~c~~Cy Fai~7ilia~• t~vi~~ t1~c; tir~n'S
~~r•ac~i~c. o~`c:cillectior~ anc~ p~ic~ecs~iii cc~rres~~c~nc~~r7ce~ ~af~adin~s and c~tt~~:r ~r►~tters fc~~- rn~ilit~~;
;
with Chi ~.~i~~~~t~ StGrtCS ~'~stal ~~r~vice. `1`I~c. c~rres~aoncl~ncc, ~~leadie~~;~ ~r~ci c~~fiur ~nattUr~ acs
tlepGsit.eti with the tJ~tlitecl ~t~t~s f'e~st~tE Seevice wifh postage th~;rc;c~n Cully p~~e~~t~ic1 ire
~~l~as~7ir►~t~a3~, LAC, cYt~ t~~~ sai~~ clay itY tl~~~ occCin~ry cc~i~a~se o~6tisir~ess. I am a~v~re that oxi~ t~7~7ti~ta.
gC'the ~~~~lr•~y ~~~~ve:cl~ s~;r~~icc~ is ~~r~se~in~di~vr~lid il'~I7~ p~stal~eEu~~:e~lt~~ti~~~ d~t~e or ~s~st~a~~ me~te~i~
ctat~ is ~n~~r~ than onw tiG~~ a:~:er cicate o!'c~~;pc~sit ~'c>r ~~n~ilir~g iz~ affidavit..
I c#~~lt~l•~ t~~ai: T at~7 ~~~~~71oy~d iii thc, t~~~'~ce ~t'~ inemb~r c~t'tF~e l~~r ~'f'thi;; ~'c~t~rC ~t ~~vi~c~se:
ciir~c~Li~~~~ t1~e ~~i•vic~ was

a~~e,

Exe;c~ifeci ~i7 C~~tf7ber ~3, X01.3 in Wa~(~ii~~;tc~n, ~~~.C..
~~tted: C~etc~bet• t.~~ ?~11 ~:~
,5"cttz l~. G~,~,strac~n

1J~~+t~ Y ll.+&r. Li1~7~

~.~1,I'CrI"C~l, RI~~C7E~:D5, ~~L,C 1~, T~~I~[~l I1~C., JC~I-Ihi ~?SS~NMAC~~(~R., A~It~ i.,~A.T~.R'Y
RLlT~C1~PI ~, A.f[~/~ LA~U~T~1G~ , ~QC~ Ia
Case fila. 12-CV-(JO()~~S {ItJS}
~ ic~l~arci ~e~tc~ti ~Ix~n~iei
1 I33 ~l~~e~~~:~e ~f t~i~ As~~~ric~'s
~~~~~ ~'arlc,'ht~S' 1(7C~~~
~~~1?~ 7~Q-~~)2~1~1
k~r~~ail: rsi~ c~,~:ll.~:c~i~~
,
Ionatl~,ai~ ~~~cliar'y :i~~~
Cc~rvan, ~_~el~~~vii:~ ~S'c L,atEt~at7, t'.CF.
1 1 ~3 ~ven~~~«~'t~te A~~7~:~•i~a's
1~f~4v York, NY 1(?~3G
(
2l2) 79{?-~2aG
Et~~ail: ;jzl~ e~cll.c~rn
~~t~r ~t[~~ip r~c4~~m~n
1
7r►vi~ ~Sf~~~p~irc~ L.t~~vit 8c ~F~~ve,s:~,Lf'
~ I~ Wiest I4ti~ Stt~eet, Stl~ k~'l~7ar
flew ~°o~•lc, ~f~` ~ U~ ! ~

f~fb~f7i"f'!E°J/fJ~~L"G<]l'G~~di"~l~itfl(1~~, (.Et'l~tl()~

1
2e~c~tAt~ti, GZC

l
t flc7r,vre~~~ c?~ Rerc~r~~~,fnr• I'feritrti~f, C.,'~r~itc~l

,
~itc~t-~rc~r~f~Re~nF•cl;for^ Def~rrda~~tf ;Rel~i~ri
I
~xc.

~,r~~~il: ~;ae}~Ft~z7c~~v~ss}st~~ii°~r.~c~t~t
~~~~~t1t 1Vic~~~! fi~~;~r.
~I~ ~~es~ (nth ~t,~~~e~, 5~~ ~a Ica~a,.
Ne~+~ `i~rat•k, DIY 1 ~~ l~
~212:~-X3(7-5a~f)
~
;mai~: s~n~t~~~c~~vissl~~zpaix~c~,cc~t~n

~1tle~~~r~e,}f r~f~~~~~;vriGll`nr~ ~c~f~~~lcxrtl, 1~'~~i~~i
l
rtc:

I)T~TItxC~' C(?LJ~t~'
SUU'1'~=~Eltl~i llISTItG'C' i~T+~ l~fl+~'UV Yt~Itic

1~~1,},~J~
[lY .111!+. Ut`!~ F L`!~~ 47r

~12-GV'~p0~95 (~tJ~~

Gt~I'I'I'C?L I~ECC3~I7~, T~I~,C;
Pl~~ntiff,
~,
I~~;D.Cf~~ II~C~:.y JC~1-1I`~! ~S~k~N~,~CHI~;T~, ~.t~ci
L,r~R~~.~? RCJ'~~t3I.,~'I-~ a/l~fa I,~1.~' ,l'~I~'~; ~.
I~.~~~L,
I~ct'er~ti~r~~s,

'
.'J.44 S1~~~ AJ~A4A.1L A
.
~
.~.'J ~.*:JA 1~.~~L i.+ ~ ~V it ~Ft.i \ ~P4 ~kf~~J~f*#'~~I1

~Y l.{.Af V.L~L~Y
'F~

1
'LA~i 7'I'I~ `~' CA~'~'I'C7L I2.~± +GC~~~F~~ [~C~~
,
~~C34~flt:J1'~Jl~l`~~ ~~I~"CI S:

Q~'FEI'~(Dt~,7'~1"1`~ J(~~IN'~~Sf~~~NMA~,CH~'R ~lN17 LA121"i.~"
ItC1T.~C1~;~~-~

~~.~:>~}~t~~r~rr~~ r~~~rt~~r~~,

r~~,nt~ar~~tr~E~ c:~f~~r~r~c~~~ r;i~:lc:c~~~z~~, ~,r~c~

t'~~rs~~ar~~ to l~ed~r;~il ~~~1~; c~f~;i~~ii €'rc~~t;c~i.ii~e ~i3, D~ CNllAl`~J"~'~ JC7~•Ci~
C
~~SLNMf1~:1-tI::R: ~l~'dD L~1~~tt~:Y CZIJt~C~t,['~-~ hc'c~;t~~~ r~ec~~t~ss th~~t PT,~I.CNT'~~'1^ ~AC~f`['i?1:,
RG~C?ADS, Ir1,~~ an~r~ve~~ the f«llc~wi~~~ i~7tcrrt~~~~tc~ries witllir~ twenty (ZO} clays o~F`~~r•vic~, anc~
a f~u~~~vrxrcls suppl~,ir~~;nt s«ch intes~t~~~;at~ry ~n5~~vc;~~s as n3~y lac; rlGccssary t~ ci~n~}~ly ~~viGh the
rcc~~Fi~~cinents of (~.i~l~; "~6(e) offife ~~'~cl~:~°al Rules ~~'C:ivil }'rc7c~diti•~.
I?~I+I~I.t'1'CC}N~
' fc>{{c~tiv ~i~ del"initio~~s ~p~~ly in 1l~e~sr, ~~tc~~~~c~~~t~ri~;a~
I"t3e
"
`~C?G," "~'`C~UR" ~riean~ E'I~intiff C'~i'1'1'(JI, ~.~ ~'{~T~[7~, 1.~:,C, its ~aa-enx
cc~r~~r~~•~~Cii~~as, ~G~~Si~~i~ti~s ~~~1 ~~f~li~~t~;s, ir~cli2c~i~~~ but not lirnit~d to I.~~ZivcY~sG~I ]Vi~~si~ ~,ro~Tp

I~t.~ct>r•clin~s~ Cn~.. and ~a~aitc~f N1Etsic G~rtaE~p, ~inei etch «l~tl~eir em~(oyees, ~~~at~sx ~~~}~r~set~tG~~ives,
2~t~c~~~neys~ o~• ~n} pe,•~a~x ~ctia~g~o~~ ~~it~•pt~~~ ed try Pict gin. be(i~li"fl~tl~e r~s~~~n~iit~~ I7cte~~cia~~~~.
,
2
.

iNT~IViI~CJt1i: I~I~FIaN~AN`T"S xne~EZS Defendants Jahn C~ss~nrn~che;r a~~ci I.~arey

I~tt~fc~I~~E~ ~1kf~ ~:;a~v~~ncc Vii. Rc~~el.
3.

C'C~1~~tUN~~`A"f Infi~S ~7~ean~ ~t~y ciis~lcls~~~~~, tra~s~~r, o►r ~ cch~~e~g~ ~t

in1'orn~~t ~r~ c~~• ~~ r~ic~i~, t}c~kvev~t r»~d~, it~ct~►clirlg ~ctt rrc~t i[~r~ tee to itirot~gl~ e~~7~ 1; (~~cyx~,: in~ta~~t
t~~~ssagi~l~ ~~~c1 t~~t rn~~tisa~t~;in~. ~'UIVtIvI[1NI~~!`~'I~NS sht~ll rn~1~~cic~ C~~G'~1tVC NT arzd. ELI,
~,

I~t~~':I~IC,I tn~.e~ns the t~~li~le n~~z•k~t~~a~~ [ar pt•~-~~vt~ed €1i~;ititl rnt~si~ that i

I
~e~c~el~r~t ire ~~~i~ ~n~t~~~i• anti ids ~r~~~~a(o~~es, r~t~f a~~•s, end dix•~,c~~rs o~th~~~ tha1~ ~~~ liV[~~VC~~`t~1.~

~.

~C~C~T4V~~~~ r~RC tlf'T~C:TtJI~E means ille sta•ucCr~re rs~~ ~ti•~ictuzrc;~ c~'~ cc~~n~r~~e~~

syst~iz~ that catj~~r se software cc~n~~oiiex7ts, the e;~t~rry~~ly vis 6~e prt~~~rt ~s vftl~c~s~
c~~~~~€~ner~ts, ~nc~ tf~~ rcfati~~n~hi~s'bet~n~~~t~~ tt~e~r~~
C.

DT~xi ["t~ t~, ~~31~Yt"~~~'C` ~'~~C~V1[~ CAS tx~c~at~s ~r~y er7tity, ~~tftc.~~ th~x~ I~L;C31G]? that

s~~is ar• diserit~i~t~s ~.a ~►~~-~~t~~~~s ~ii~i~~l versions, vrhuthc►• rz w4-►ate c~i• in ~~~t~-C, c~~'rt~t~si~ r~ccr~di~~~;~
tE~~t e~rzi-~ssees c[o4vr~lca<~cl ur ~ir~~u~~ c~~ver~ tE~~ [r~t~rr~~t to a~ ~n tl~eis- c~znp~zt~t•s car ether ~I~~trc~ni~
cic~~~iues (~.~., ~~il ~l~c~r~es).
7.

T3l~I"C~I~ C~`.PI,C7IT1lTC(~i~i ~x~e~ias tl~~ ~arc~~e~s by r~~~ich I~IC~~"t't~~ C(~N"t"L~1~"~.

~'i~.t~3`aI~F ~~S sal# c~t~~ listr~ib~~~tc t~i~itai v~~:~ic~n~9 a~rk~eth~r r~vhc~fe car in ~G~rt, c~f`t~~i~si~ i~eco~•din~~ ~~
~:n~1-~~s~.rs,
~.

ItEC(~RC3It~C~ ~,1~"~I'l~'I'S ~~7erin5 ar~y irtclividt~al ~r ~~rfr~r•~~7it~g;~~~u~ tf~~~ t'e~ortjeci

~i7nster~ reua~~d i~~~s fcsr 4' ~~CJ.
~.

I'TZ~~UG~:.R~ t~~u4~~zs any i~~divic~i~~l car per:Cc~ri~~i~g groin that ~r~ciucecl-~n~~sttr

t~~~~c~~in~s `ke~r YC}U.
1 C~.

GUI~~[P:~.I~~~~1~'IE~I~(means ce~~i~~n~i~atioi~, r~~17~ti~Er in ri~+~nG~ oc in ~:in~~~

1 1.

Ri~CfII~~ L,~lk3~ t~ rn~~~~~ ~~ny br~ix~,ct ~ndlc~a• tr~c#~r~~ai^k assr~cint~d ~viCk~ tike

tna~~l~~i~ir~~ cif t~u~ ~ a'~e.~t•~lin~;s or n~~Jsic. v~cl~4~:~ cathet~ thin C;/~['E"['O[, RFC`C~~.D~, ~_,t:C ~n~l
_ ~.M

inch~ctin~ btrt got lir~~iteci tc~ VVa~•n~r M~rSic Gi~utt~~, C~/I~, S~r~y, AMC,1~ni~vers~rt( ~lisic ~rc~~~~,
and t'c~ly~rat~~.
I ~~

~\I.,I..~G~I:)C.,Y ~01'~I~[C;II'['~;5:~ SUT~(G~ tr~c:~lr~s lit; ~1~ songs lisi;eel in [~~ch bit E1

tv k`t~Cl~2 ~f~1~nc~~~i C;ar~~plaint i~a t~ii~ liti~at~vr~.
l 3,

PRC-1972 5~I`~GS rnear~s tl~~ ~S sc~~~~~ li~tecl ire Cxtii~aat E~ tc~ 1~U'U1Z t1n~t~:ncleel

C~?rn~Eain't ici.t~yis }iti~~t~stl.
1.4.

['I~.1~;5~ ~~i~~rts any ~~~~vs ~is~~~nin~t n►~ s~rvic~~ at~cl t;hcir ants ~tnd ~,iYt~toyet;s,

~~c~udi~~~; k~G~t nit l~r~~it~d tea ~st~l~lished ►tc~vs service (i.c,, ~N~, Fc~x, ~~NE3C), wel~sites; TOSS
f~~cls, pr~cle~sts ~xncl l~Ic~~~.
l~

"~E;~R~~~~" and '`~'~1~.~'~I'~IS" 5h~ti~ ir~clt;~l~ bpth t}~~e srt~~~la.r ~~ncl }alural, ~n~i siaall

~~near7 anti ~~e~e~~ tc~ any rxat~ir~i h,~u~7att ~~Qat~a fir~Y~, ~r+~~ri~t~~~~~t~ ~~, p~r~rie~•s~~i~, ~.c~e~csrs~tion, j~ai►1~
ve:~~ti~r~, sk~~~•e:~~ciCrl~t~, inv~sYc?rs, r7~embur~, lii~~ited litelail ty ~at~p4~ny, Citnt~d li~l~iliy p~~1~ti7e.i°~I~ip,
~ cnera! per°tt~~rshi~, lit~itec~ ~~~rtii~rsl7ip, trust, Iraa~ — ~~tl ~rs~~~~nys ~vv~rnme~rrt went car
;
~;r~t~~;rt7tn~.nt t~c~~y; a5sc~~i~ti+~n, e~iiplr~~ers, ein~tc~~f~es, a~eilts, ~a~~trers, ~ti~oe~~s, du~e~i.~rs,
~~cp~~esen~a~ives, r~~1'ti~iz~i~~ a~~c~ alb o~~Ycr ~'t~z•~ns ~c_7Fc~i~~ai~iz~tic~r~ roc er~.t~ky c~~~ crtl~~~• ~roci~s c~~~
cc~t~~~ina~ian dithe fa~~eg~in~ nctir7g its c~n~.
l G,

t'(~LI~.Y tnc;~ns any aftical s~ci~~ci{~t•rl(s), proc~ctur~(s), or pr~tc~col(s~~ tvhetlt~r~

tivr~Ct~r► c~~• nat:
1 7.

C2C~Y;~I.,"I'Y' S'~':~.T'ENI:N"I' i~~~an4 :~t~tements c~C rc~~4tlti~s, t•u~;€~~•d~uss of'ty~ae, ti~~f

YU~J ~r~~nvicie tt~ [~~C.,f~I~D1i~iCr ~It`1IS`CS s~~3d E~ItC)L~UG~IZS.
,
l ~,

AC.fI:~~7' tn,e~zt~s art ~,x~nlin~tic~a~, revietiv, or ir~spcctic~l~ oP ~QY~1L~'Y

~`-!'A'T'C'~!IT~~'~'(S) t~vltc}t1~c;~- isait-sated at Cl~~ t•er{G~~st of ~E::[:(7~.I~iNC lI~.TI~'['S or ~'I~C)I~LJG~;t~
,
~~t' ~s ~ t~~~i.~lfi c~:f ar. ~~~t~~~n~~l cot~~np~iznGe ~~acess~ "lt~eltidtn~~ is ~tsec~ tcr ~illustx~te: ~t R~c~c~~~~ For
p~rticu~nr ty}a~~s of'~~T~C~CE~E~II~~'1"fi ~~c~~rest~cc~, and shell nat 1~~ eo~~s~~~ued as fiu7i~i~~~ tl~e Rec`~tic~t
in atly rv~~~,
~I
r~d~.~ ~~

"~Ot~'' sl~~t.~l~~ b~ cc>n~~t~~~a~cl lc~ re~uir~ t:l~re br~ac~~~t ~assibi~ rr~s~Gar~s~, at~c1 s~~~~lel ~~

`~~11~1/t~~',~,
R~_

II~~~IT'(~'Y e~G~x c~~r.c~s ~t r~r ft~r«~~r ctnplc~ye~; of ~:;Ai~i`I"QI, RFC~C3RI)~ I.,[;C loo 1~ad and
ii~t~, ~cti~~~ w ti7 ~[3T3tG1 ~ndf~a~~ kl~~ iN[atV~T~UA[,, I)t~~~~~1i)AN"1" ,anti It~~.l`~~`t~~' the data,
tilne;a ar~d ]c~~:~tiatl c7F`~r~cf~ C'~MMLtNCC;fI'T'IC7N cia~y such icxdivictusil fact 4vitj~ RI I~I~t ~r~c~/or
i~ae i~ll~iV:TI~L1fll.a I.~~f'~NUA~(TI'S.

I~~r•e~~}~ A~1I,~~,E?[3~.Y C.(~~'1''l~I~sF-~"Ck~T~ 5(~i~~ ~i7ci e~u1~ Pl~~'-1~7~ ~~NCi,
CUT h~"f"II~ Y tl7c rave, tity7e, and to~ntic~t~ cat ~ acii ~tc;t that yc~t,< <titegc~ !•eskilts ~n ff1~ tN1~I Vl~7LfAIa
~~;~~~;~J~~~'~'S'~ Iial~ifi~y iii t}~i~ a~;tic~r~, n1t~n~ ~wilh ~n ex~3l~natic~n f~z~ ~vhy end ~~t~~,v each ~cl
irti'i-i~i~;~d on each :~1~..1,I;~LDLY C~}PYRI~r~I'I ~~ St~I~1~ a.t~ci ~~cl~ I'I~E~197~ ~C)`(`~IC~,
~i~fi`~`~l~i~UG~'1.'C)TiY l~i+a. 3:
1~~~~ e~clx CC~iv~NiLlh(I~~~fIt~~V i~i~:n~~~~c1 in res~c~r~~c: tc~ In~e~•~ac~~;atc~ry N~c1~~t~c:t~ 1,
II~Ii'~']-'I~~Y any ~~tiak~ ~''U~) took as a ~~esuEt at c~~• ~~~l~:teci #~~ each ~01~1IiV1UT~IIC:~STlU1~.

Fcr~~ Cell t4 t_~1~ECE~)I,Y' CC~~Yt~7GN`I'C~~) S(~N~~~ at~c! I'1~C;-I97i. SQRtCr~~ IU.L;NT[~'1'
each prier ~^c~p~~•i~h~t i~~fi`i~~~ern~r~t c~l~iit~~~ as knell ~s the c~uteorne ~t~~i`thafi c~aii-~ (i.~.> r~vhe~}.~er ~'(~~1
rv~t~e ~~c~~ssf~~I~ G~i~ci if's~a, ~tac; ~~~~~ur~C c~CC~C)~M~'~w~]~+AT[~N ~.htxt ~i7u ~~~1•e mile to ob~~in fo
cc_~~t~~~un5ttte f`or t~~c: al~e~;ed infr•ir~~;ein~.t~t), t}zat YC)t) 1~~ivc ptirs~aed against 3I(~~;e~4 ir~f'r•in~~~•s
,
oth~a• thin I~.~ ~I~~C1 ~r the Ifi113~IVI~UAi.,1?[: I~,~f NC~~~I"1 ~,

t ar e~c~ ~LI.~I_,~;Cs~I~ltY ~C7i'Y`Izic,~-i`~'I.aI~ ~aNC~ z►~cl PI~F;-t~~'7~ ~C~~fG, t~1~~,NT'1~"Y the
c;c~~~trac~tc~4~l inn ~~~~~ irl ~:4►c~~ t~.t~a~'~~T~I~Ii~Ci fi~1~'i~I~'(' car E'f~C)t~C~C~Tt ~:at~~tt'~~.t tflGtt YC3C~f cc~nt~nd

_ ~_

E~ruvic{es 1`C?lJ an irt~cr•~;st ~i~ tl~e cc~~~yA~i~;ht try ~aul~ ~~'tf~ise s~~ngs. It'nv s~ieli language ~~ist~,
II:3i~,.N`~IJiY t}~e far~~~,a~e, pr•c~vi~~~n, ~~~~tute ~~~ ~ai;l~~:r ~~G.~l~xs tl~~~ YC~U cc~«tericl }~~~ovidc;s ~UC,~ air
int~rc5t i~~ Ck e ar~~:ryt•i~ttt c~~'~e~ck~ saki;.

for ea~f~ afiif•mative clet~nsc d~ntifi~ci belc~4v, state; all Cads tl3at lrC?~..I ccin~~~ld ~~er~ticr
~~cl~ iyy~ppliG~.k~le, ~s tc~ tktc INi~tVI~3[~AI, ~7~`I~'LN~1.N`['S, in ti~is liti~tir~~1:
a. Thy ~'~it• ~~se c~c~ctrin~;
b. ~l`~~ ~sto~~acl cic~c~rit~r;;
c, "I"h~ waives ~ic~~firit~e;
cl, Ti~t~ ~~tzc_#~:an 11ar~~~ ~foet~ir~e.
e. ''Che ti~s~w~~3c~ d<>c;tM4i~~~ as cpclifiecl ire 17 LS,S.G. ~ E~~;
f`: T(~e stzb.~t~~ti~,l neat~-in'fi~it3;ing use cl~ctri~~
,
~. `7~~a~ ess~ntiai ~t~~s defc~-~s~;
lt. ~a~i3 c~f''tl~~, saFe h~rbc~r px~cavisiorts o~flee DEC°A., (~ 1J.5.~. ~ ~ ~?; and
i. "i'hc; ~c~o~~~~z7on 1~►w d~c~~tt•i~~~ of"~~t~austiafz,
I
I`~T°I'~1ZRl'3G~1:TCl]tY NC3. '~:
State a31 facts tfia~ ~'C?L~ uot~~le►~~1 de~~ac~t~str•~tte thUlt the [`~lL7CV ~C~Ur~I~~ 1]k?~'I;;N[~~~3"C'S slid
nsat~ ac;t tivitl~ i~i~~cicc~~t intc.t~fs ~s t1~~1: ~~a~~~7s l~~~ been. cic~~~~;d ley the cc~u~•t~ i~tt~r7a~c~tin~; 17 ll.S,~.,
SC~~~(c)(Z), Qt tie nl~I..I1C~1~C.~I,Y C,Uf'YL21G1-("C"LsD SC~?~1CFS and 1'ix.Ej-1972 Sf)h~1CxS.

;
~tr~tc all ~1~cts t~k~at ~'C1~J ~gr~~~n~d eritatl~'~~,~~C~ try ~t~~iG~t~:y da~na~;~;~ a~;~~i~~st, ~~r~~il~~r
at~car-~~~ys' fees E-r~it~~ the I]~L~~VIUUr`tL D~~;~'~~I[~Ar1~{~S.

~ ~~

S1:at~: t~11 ~~cts til~~t YOU contend d~rt~anstt~z~Ce ttlat the 1~4'fJIVI'I)U°A[~ 171 ~~;h1[?~4NTS
i17ac~~ "clistrik~utic~«s," as tf~at te~•~i1 is xrseci in 1'1 U.S,C. ~ l~G(3}~ of'th~ ~~I~~G~I~L~Y
~
'C~P'YRTGH~'~~ ~C~I~IG anc~ ~'~:F~"l~?2 Si~Nf,

~t~te ill facts that'~'~tJ ca~~te;nci d~;x~it~tl~lr~tc ~fi<tt ~hc~ ~N1~IVli7~Jt~Ia I?I.~'~aNl~~li~`C'S
nt~tz~ior~ally ind~~~~ti o~~ ~ric~~~ra~~d efirrc~et iiz~'rin~~rr~~t~t of e~~.Px AL,LE~~I~[.°Y
GUP'Y ~IC~~'TEI~ ~C)N~ end P1Z~:-197 `~~~tG,

Stag all t"~c~s that YC)lJ c~~t~i~d demvn~~r~,~e Y{~UR ~17iti~titiari ol`tla~rt~~~es w~~Ir t~espcct
t~ R~l~~[C~i ar~ tl~e lI*II'.?IVIi~L1A~, DEsE~~~1'~ID~1N~l~~' ai(cgeci infii•i~n~cirr~t~t ~~°ftE~e ~[~IaC_f~~;T~i..aY
C(~P'YRIU~-1'T'Fs:Q S(~NC~: at~c! 'I~1'-197 SaNE~~.

Sty tG ~z1E (~ututs that ~r'l~fJ rc~nt~;i~ci cle~na~~stf-~~~: that ~. statzata►~y clarna~~ awa►•c1 i~ ~l~i~ action
yvc~rs~i~ ~3nt lie ~~~olly dis~ar~apsa~•~i~o~G~t~ t« the ~~(~IJI~ actual h~r~~r~ s~iel~ that ~~~ tit~ry d~~~rrt~~~s
~~ott~~ bG ~~i~~itiv~ ~~~d ~mcca~~stitut:ic~nGil.
I
N'~'T+1RRQiC~1:T()R'S~' NUJ. 13:
i'b~N1'II~~` the ~ontracCiial lart~ ~~a~e in each caf'~t~I)~R AGt;.la[~~i1t: ~f"1`S with ~?I+GYT'~li..
C:f)N°I'~~I`~' ~'I~C~VII~C~~~S f~~~t Ya~.l cu.nienci ~x~~ihitaiCs the re-s~1e a~CCI~~~ Al~1 ~;~~~1~at:)~.Y
C'QC'~'I2.IG:I-I`I'~;D SC)N~~S ~ilcf C'I~E-1172 SE)i'~JG~,
~.11 1 A~a A1X~1L,l ~.h'► 1. if.44 R
}

1`I~l, 1~.

II~~N~'T"~1~`r~ Ck~e ck~~tractur~i~tics o~r ~CtriE~i~[c~ c~I'REL~I~I':~ ~C~F7'WAttF
~1It~'I-il-i'}C~'1'l.J~~.I z~nc~ lie [i~rCTIVIT~[S~iL llL~INI~~k~I°i'~' ra#c in develcrp~~ e~ich c~f~those
c~(~4~~•ric~~r~i:~t cs ~x• ~i:tci~ut~~ tk~ it `t`rJU cca~lt~nci dives rise tc~ ti c I1'+(D1VtIJUA[.. I~I~T'~~NI~FIN`I'a'

u {~ u

liability i~1 ~tlis act ~~7,.

"c~~~ ~;acli ~LL,~G~T~L,Y C~;f''~'i~~G[1~"?D St7i~IG ,stzte <~ll ~~~c~t4 t~~~t ~C7U c~nl~~~d
cic~~~s~ns ~•ake t}~at each song was v~iicfly ~ca~yr ~ht~c~,

rya° e4~ch r'I~.~;-~ ~7'? S(aT~~'r, st~~~ ~:~ll facts that Y°C31~ c~t~tc~nd cf~rr~~t~str~le tk~ae l~~
~~:apayt` gh.~ i~atc.~~~~t in ~;r~cf~ sc~n~; hay riot t~c~vet•tecJ to ~h~. Ct~,~C)I~.t~[NG ~1.I~`I'tS'C' ~7r l'R~I~[J~ER.

~~~tte~all ~F~~~t~ tl~~t Y~JCJ cc~i-~~~z~c] r~en~~E>x~~strat~ t1~~t I ~I~ l i~ ~~c~~ st~fi~ici~~~tly ~apit~li~~ci
t~ ~~~y a m~~~~c~t~rY j~ict~rracnt ~~~ir~si it its l'hir~ ~ctsc~~~.

IC7I~1~`1`C~'Y tEj~ ~~~~c~~r~~t of ~~c~t ~cvenc~c tltttt ~t~?U c~r~n~~~~d

~)r~;i rYzal~~s c~fl~ot"each

rc~a~~~ c~~I`n rtl~~s ~a~t ►~~art~iri~~:alun~; wit1~ the dotal ~unai~nt ~~f''ti~t rvv~r~~~~ Y€~(~J ~c~i~t~;nc1 ~ha~~
R.GL~ICiI leas rn~c~e cif the Y•e.s~~l~ at'tl~~: AI..I.,f~G~'1~LY ~'QI'Y~dCr11TED ~C7NC~S attct Pft~-1~7`~
SC~NGS.

State al! [=acts that Y4LJ cortt~~~~~ cle~ric~i~str~te tllal t11e ~'~Il:)IVIl~UF1L TJ~~LN17f~NTS
have nlacie ~~c~i~~v fi~c~►~i ~~~i31~1°s ~•~sal~: raf tl~t Al~1~Ir,C~i~[~t.~`~ ~;(J~'~'It.~C;l.C('LE7 SC)NC~ ~izycl
[ '~Z~1-I'97~ SU~lGS, ae~~i II~1;~!"I'IC'Y tl~~; toia[ arn~a~«~t o'f"~nc~ney VC~U Gor~tenc! tEic> ~1'~l1~IV[1~t.1~1.X~,
(3L[ k:~NI~ANT~s lave ~j~~~cl~; ff~o~~~ ItI t~ICrl "~ t~~s~le ~?f t}xs~ AI,I,F~C~k'I7~,Y C'.C~[yY~IGf-CTED
S(.7N~~ ~~nti PRC~I~?2. ~C)1~iG~Sy ii~uluciin~ tF~r~7Rr~}l 4aiiy C(~~U(~'I~N~A"TI~~I tP~~t YQU ~crntc~~d
ll~e INI~I~VIL?UAL I~~E~'I~NI~A~'~1`F~ h~verec~ii~eci ft~n~n R.~~T~1~~~~,

7 .,

r~~rr.r~~o~~~cc~~y ten.~~:
C~~i[sici~ of'tl~e acts IL~CNTIF'[l:~i in r~s~~c~r-~s~ l~ ~~~t~rai~~~ioi•y Ni~t~~b~r~ ~, I~)l,l~t"£'I~ `~
e~~cf~ pct t~:ker~ by tk~c tNn[~'IL?U~L I~EE'~NI~~N'I'S that YUt1 cot~tenct ~iv~::~ rise tc~ th~.ii~
liat~ility in this a~tic~n,
IN:I'EItI2QGATQRY NC). 2l
~`c~r e~cfx aLl1~:~Cr~t~C>Y C()P`iIRIC~I~T~~ SC~NU a~~d'Y~;~- l ~'7? S(.~NC, it~C~~N'l'1~~Y tau
total ~ri~.i;h~nical ~•c~~~altic~ t1~at t~av~ ~~~i~ to tl~c Rt,~'C7RU1~lG AR'1~[STS r~r P~fQ1~UC:~~ZS witl~t
t~~~ ai-i~,irtc~l cc7~yri~ht inter~e:~t ~n e;zeGk~ sU~~~ tl~~t G►~~se P~•<~in tl~~ CJ1GITn. ~;~~'i,CJC't`~1TIC~N c~i~
~~~~t~ sc>rt~.

I~~NTII=~~ e~tcf~ I~:[~C(~I~I")tNC~ n:~~['1~T c~►' 1'f~;(~~~UG~:R that ll~ts uc~t~t~stetl lltu ~tY~rau~~t
c~~ t~ie:a(~~.tiic~l rc~yaltiC~ tl~~t l~~ve ~~eri paid to t}i~r~~ ~c~r the e:h~lait~t ot~ ~1~C~~~.1lLI~l~GGI:~LY
~:QI"~ ,[G(I~I"~;1~ ~C?fi~]G5 ~ncl f'I~~:a-19~~' ~fJI~1~S, ~vhet}~e~• ttirota~h att .~C.1T~]"T t~f~ riot, r~Ct~~rt
~vit~~ the result c~~t~t~t ~:~7nt~st (1,~,, ~vh~th~~• raaa~~c ist~ch~~7icaC rayatties ~u~re f~un~ t~ ~e c~~v~.d t~
t ic k~L~~ItC~il`~G ~Ct"I'I~"[' c7~• PRC~UIJC[~F~ a~~cl wh~:.tl~cr ~~~uh t;~~chGlnic~Gl ~•c~yr~iti~s yv~rc ~~~i~}.
A.I~LLC►~C?I~~'' CC7:~'"y'P~~1=1"C"I~I~ C7NGS
~AM1'II~

C~ctc~bet• 9~ 2f~[~
S'nt1~ lt. G~~,ssraxcrt~
~ .'~t~l {~. ~i`rlSSi11r~71 ~"`~`~tbt~~ i~~
~

;(~iracs ,~. T'izzir~rssc~ (pr~~ lTcr~ ~~c~ ~e,i~clin~~
NaiF►zli7iuf C', Gicl~iz3~s ~»~~ hcrc t~rc~ ~~~~nclira
~1/1:t~~~`~I,I~ I..I~P
1 7~(~ I4 ~tr`~~t, ~~,1~,a Stri~.~ G~O
Ccr~rr~~.s~~ fr~r•.T~1~~~ f;~~~,s~~~tfracr~da~F~c~ Z,~~~~~l~l~~rc~'€~Ilad~

~~~ovr or ~~;~~v~~~<.
cn€'~~ox~ ~~~c~~~~s, r.rJc v. x~c~~t~t: ~v~.,;~o~r~t r~~~~~.~~Acx~r~, ~~~a ~,~t ~r
Il.L.~~VL~£.['la ~I~1/~ Lr~ YY~t.1::~LVI::~L'. n~. L'1.~4JL:~d.~

GG~SG ~s~. ~~-~GV-I~QQ~~ (~.~~a~

T~i~TT2.IC'.T (~I' C'C7LU~~I`t1~
t arty c~x~~lc~yce! ire Cl~c [~I~'I'RIC"1'(~l~ GC3I~UIvtE3IA. \t iEy L~usirics~ acids°ess i:~ 17!)0 '1
~trc:el, I~JW ~t~ite 65Q, W~is}Zipi~tc~r~, .tt~~' Zt3U0G: E ~~x~ c~ve~~ the ~}~~ c~C~t~~~t~er~ y~a~s ~nc1 a~~~ nt~t
~~~~~ty t~ the within ~cGic~n;
Qn f3~t~I~c,r- ~.?, ~C}13, E sei~vecl the; lnil~wit7~ dr~~l~m~.nt{5) e~~titl~cl ~~T~~'. .~1A1'~TS ~~-~1
{
~~5~+;~IIvTACt~-Xi,1~. x;('31) L~1.I~~t'+~ I~[.tl)C►1G~'~~~~ ~+"[~~t."hT ~~"~" C~~ Ii~'i'~+alt1~+~3C~A'I'C}~l:E
~l'(~ ~";[fA~~»t` `1I~'T' ~.A~~'IT~~~ It {'Cf~~~t3~,1~~;~' can AI.aL CIV''C'~:~lZ~ S'("E=~T7 ~~I~I'IE' ii`t this
~~;tic~x~ 6y ~a1K~~irz~ ~r~t~ ~;~~~i~s the~~e~st r:iaclr~~~ct in sc~[~d ~t~velt~p~~ ~c1Li~•es~~d ~s Follows;
~I~~ ~i'~"I"AGI~~ ~.,IS'Y'
I iV.CAZi.~: .I=3y placia~~ a tt•ti~ cr~~y ther~c~f iti a sc~al~;cl c:nvel~pcs ~cic{r~;s5ed a5 ~h~~ve, ~t~c~ pt~cin
~~'
it ~fo~~ ~~~d trl~iliz~~ ~~~Ilc~~~vii~~ brdi~ri~cy hl~si~~~5s pract~~us. I a~~~~ t~e~cf(y Farnili~ar ~it~~ tl~efir~tl'~
~~t~act€~~ afec~lle~tiic~~z ~r~~ ~7~•o~essi►~~ c:oz•t•~s~~~~3d~.ncc~, ~~rlc~a~lin~s ~i~c1 cri~k~e~~ n~Gitters Tor m~zili~~g
r~~i~3~ ~}~e U~1it~cl 5t~tes I'~~t~I ~e~~vice. 'I'E1~ a~a~~re~F7a~~cletlee, p~e~di►~~s ~t1d ot~~e~~ i~r~tt~►~s ~~~•~
cle~osrtc~t ~v tE~ th.r; Ua~itc~ci, State I'c~~taJ Sea•vic~ ~v~th }a~?stag~ Clrcrec~tl fully ~~~e~~~ie~ t7
W~~l~i~~~tunr DC. ~n the sEz~i~e clay in tk~~e c~s~~ir~~ry cc~~ar~~~~f~~i~ n~:ss. E ~m aw~~~~ that n~ i~-tc~tir~n
of ~h~ ~~a~~ly ~urvc:c~, ~;~E-tric~ is }al•est►rne;c3 i~v~licl if tk~e pcast~tl' ~a~icell~ti~~~~ dt~i~, or ~7~rsia~~ ~c.te~r
cf~tte a:~ ~~~t~re t}late ~.~tac~ c~Ety aftLx' c al:e t~# deposit ~`o~- ~~~~ailin~ in z~ffici~vit.
I declare ~h~tt T ~~~1 ei~~}~loy~ci ire the aC~ce cif a ineti~~E~et~ a~'tl~e taar of this C~adtt'x Ott vvhr~s~
di~•Gcttc~~l tla~ servie~. waG ~nade~
~'x~r~~.~t~;d ors (.~c.tobet- 9; "Z~1.3 ire ~V~~~~~n tc~~i, Q.~ ,

~~'~tyr R, Cictrsr~a~~
S~tti .L~.. G~ssitz~n ~~~i~~ ~ 1fib

s~,~~.v~cr ~~~~r
c~~~~~~~c~~., c~r,~~~r~as, ~,t,c; v, R~al~~ ~rc~.,.~c~~-rr~ e~~~~c~n~~c~~r~;R, ~N~ t_,~R~~~
E~[.JE~C)~,I?~-~, A./[/A LA VV~~;;N~~ S, t2QC.,~L,
Ca~c N~, 12-~V-4~(1C~~S (R.~~:?
I~~c~~~~rrt St~p~~er~ ~!tr~xi~~l
~r~w~n, Lie~c7wilz ~c t.,at~riat~, ~:C.
l l 3.3 t4v~nu~ of tl~e ntn~r~c:~~'s
l~c~~v ~c~rlc, NY l ~(13C~
~'? L2} 7~~-991
l:;~n~~i[: rstt~~cll,uo€i7
~I~~artt~~a.~~ ~~ci~ary Kitt
Ccr~ran, L,~f~c~wit~ L~t,n~.aia, I',G'.
1 1~:~ ~~~en~~~; t~ft(7U ~~.rY~eric~~'s
h~~w Yat~lc,, NY tOt}3~
21
( ~.} 79~-9~~i~
E :t•i~it; j~k~C~ull,cc~~-n
~r,y ~'l~il~~~ ~iciel~~~.~~~
I~avi~ Slt~pira [~er~vit c~ Mayes I.sL,I'
' "W'~st l~~h trc~tx StY~ ~ylor~e
~Y~

~1,~~~r~~cy r~f'I~eera~°c~~`vf~ F'l~rnti~f, C'cz~i~'nl
I~~cra~-ct's; Lf,C'

~~~r,r~t~~A~ ~a~f'IZe~t~r~d,~i~' ~'dc~~r~trff,° ~ct~ai~~~'

~ttlorr~ae~, af.~Cc~;n~°cl;fizt° L7e.,f~r~cl~tnt, 1~17i~i
.
Ir~c~.

(
Z12) 23(}-SSUO
Errt~il; ~a~~ya crci~4~issh~~r€.~.~c~~r~
~.~~•~e~~ tViici~a! Ms~tr
U~r!is Ship t•c~ ~'~ I.,~~n~it 1,,1:,x'

4L~ Nest I~th 51r~:et, Stk~ C~ic~Ur
f ~Y'c~rlc, NY ~gC1J~
lew
~~ 12)-23U~_55(?d
~
;cn~il; sm~itz~'vci~vi4sh~~~irG~.co~~~

~
1f!`~•t~ca~ r.~~'CZ~c~ay~cl~~f~ 17ef~r~tlr~j~r~, I~eUt;~i
fr~c.