Capitol Records, LLC v. Redigi Inc.

Filing 321

DECLARATION of Richard S. Mandel, Esq. in Support re: 319 MOTION for Attorney Fees .. Document filed by Capitol Christian Music Group, Inc., Capitol Records, LLC, Virgin Records IR Holdings, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit Exhibit C)(Mandel, Richard)

~

~.
~

Eb7~ca~c
1
2
3

lJ1V .€.~~~

~71C?.LE~

L.1 .E. r71~i~.~4r1

l..V Uit~

S~U'T`~TERN DIS'~"I.~~C`I' tJF' I~TEW Y~R~f,
CAPITOL R~CQRI~7S, LI..,C, et al , ~

4

~la~.~ti~~~,

5

~.2 GV ~5 ~~~7

"~T.
R~DIG~, INS,, et. aZ,,

7
~~~enda~.t~ ..
1
8

~ _________s _________T___

_ _~
New ~Yark p N.Y ,
Nc~v~m:~aer 7, ~ cJ~.~
~ r5(3 ~.m.

.C7
~
B~ ~c~~e
11.

I~C)I~ . P~C~~A .D J, ~ C1LLICLAN,
l~
Das~ric~ ~t~.dge
1
1
.~
15
~5
.

APPEA.R1~.1~'C~~
~'C?W.~,.N, T~I~BOWT'T'~ ~ LATl~IAN, P,C"
.
~~~o~ne~rs f~~ P~..ain~. f~~
E~~ : RICHARD S : M~1ND~L
JO~TAT~~N 2. i~~N~

17
~.8

HAUS~'FLD LLP
At~,~~n~~~ f~~ ~~~'~ndan~ C~~s~x~m~c~~e
BY: N~TI-iiANSEL C. ~ITJDSNGS

~~
20
2~

ADELM~'~T~T MR.T~; P , C.
Attorrae~~ r~r D~f~ndant, Redigz Tn~.
E : GARY P. ADELI~'EAN
LY
52~~ M. N~A'T'~

2~
23
~;
2
SCaU'~HERN ~I~'~I'R~C'~ R~FUR:'I'~~~, P r ~.

1212) 8(35-CJ~Q~7

E~74capc
1

(Cass c~l~ed}

2

THE CURT:

With ~e~pect to this caste, T guess we T~ave

3

~ ~iapu~e that s~~m~ back t~ what we t~1ke~ abau~ s~m~ t~m~

4

ego, wl~~.~h is w~eth~r or n~~ the ~ndiv~dual d~f~~d~~ts ~~e sari
o~ lock~~ a~~~ the pis ~~~~~ taken ~~ the carpo~~~~ d~~~n~a~~s

6

~z~ throl,ag~. the ~itn~ of the. sutnm ,ry jl~dgmen~ ~ula.ng.

7

Sa fay ~c~ goQd?

~3

~ th~_a~}~ ~.ha~ i.s the l~as~,

~

di~p~~~ cle~~~.y ~;

a.ssu~ o

~o t~,ere ~s a legal.

~a i~het~~r ~r nc~t the Second ~~,x~cu t"~
~ ~a~~u~<~.~y ~. li~~.1.c~ d~.~~~rent

1C~

t~~~a:~~n in T~ltrr~a~.zcs, w~i~h

~.~.

b~c~~~s~ ~h~~'s a caste wh~~~ th~~e w~~ ~. cage,

z~

i:h~n a subsequ~s~t c:~se inval~r ng the ~:ndiviclua~ p~~.ricipals ~.nd

1~

s~~.~rel~,old~:~s r~~ t:.~e c~r~~o~a.te dc~g~nd~.n~ ~h~.t was ~oun~. ~;i~:b1.e

1

i~. t~~ first c~.s~, but I th ail€ ~~~ prin~~:p~~ would ~Pp3:

l5

equally ~o bath

l~

`I~l~rancs zs ~e1,e~raz~.t t~ ~ha,~ si~~.t~tpn.

1'7

t~~re is a f~.c~u~.~. c~s,sp~~e ~s ~.o wh.~:th~r ar xic~t thy. ii~~:iviclual.

18

d~~end~~ts, iz~. fact, Gont~al~ed the ~os:~~rat~ d~f~nd~nt and

~~

directed t.l~a~ ltiga.tioza up th~raugh t~i~ time a~ the sum~nax

~
2:~.
22

jtt~gmen:t rui ng:

~~tT. ~;g, ~.nd

Tk~~~e ~.s ~. 7~egal c~ sgute as ~c~ ~r~~;~~h~~ c~~ nod.
I'm nc~~. sure ,~

t~~:~b~ we shdul~. st~r~ th~~~,

~s th~r~ ~ clis~aut~ a}~c~ut w~!ethex or not -- n.Qt ~rou,
Mme. Mancl~J~.

~3

MFG. M~~NI7EL:

2~

Nl;~. GIT~T7IN~~~

I c`t dri' t think.. ~o.

Y~~, yca~.ta~ ~-Io'~o~.

~o~Y.c~~~ ~xs~~xc°~ ~:~~a~~~~~, ~,c~.

~c ,~ ~ot~ri~~hing that,

~~~,~~ cos-~,~

Ek~7~c~pc
1

we tivnuld ~ikc dseav~ry on.
TIDE GC)UUT:

3

W'ha~. sort of discoverer do ~rau need. ~~a

determine w~a~th~r or i~ar yaux c~.~~z~.~~ weave ruzin~.r~g tk~
1a.~.ic~~.tic~~?

5

L~~ m~ rep~a~~.e, ~caur Ha~aa~,

MR. G~DL~I1~~

Tc is sa~nn~t~! ng ~ha~ w~ thin} pan b~ d~~r~lopec~ ~urt~~~
"
7

~.~acl patentia~..ly ch.~.Ilenged a.n phis T ~ ga~zan.

S

would lz.ke tea develop ~r~ a~'gum~nt b~.sec~ ors
THE Ct~~R~`:

I~ Capitol,

a~~.~ __

Bzs~_ca11y~ the e~.sie~st way to d~ t~iis a.s ~

10

~~~c~w yca~:~r ~:L .~r~.ts ~~ the ~t~nd ~~d w~ ask t1~.~m qu ~~ian~ ~:br~u~

:
1.1

that iri.vc~l~r~m~zat t~Zey ~i~r with re~~~ct tc~ t~~;~ ~. tig~~~.ar~ when.

~~

.~ Baas just ~h~ c~~pa~~.t~ d~~~nd~:nt and whc~ ~~. ~ a.

iz~volv~r~ in

~
.3

~~.,~zznxng t~,~ c~o~~~a~°a~;e d~~ez~..d~nt ~r~d runra:ng ~~~:e ~.a.t~.g~~~c~~,.

l4

don.'t w~:n~ pri~rileged in~t~~:m~~a.r~ri, ~u~ I ~:ha.nk that would lac,

1~

~~evant ~a c~~~ermin~ wh~th~~ car r~.c~t ~h~s~ a~~ p~c~~~~ wh:o a~~

~6
.

~~sponsi,bl.e faz: tY~.e ca~por~~e c1~~enc~as~.~'s l.~.tgat~,~~a s~r~t~gi~~

~~

~nc~, the~e~a~e, arg~aab:i.y ~.i~b~.~ L:~s stcl~ with tY~c~se c1~c~scrns°,

18

thc~sa friar clecis ans.

19

~s th~xe re~l:l~r ~ c~.~sgute about tha.s?

~~

MR;. GZL~I~~NGS ;

~ ~.

Y~~r~: Honor, ~t is ~r~me~:~..irig that we

~idn'~ ~.~c~cus c~~ ~.n. the letL~rs b~fare yo~x.

~~ i:s sarnethng we

wcrule~ Z~.k~ to e~c~l.or~ ~ur~~~r, and w~ wpuld b~ happy '~:a bx~~.e
~~
2~4
~5

i~ to your ~Tc~n.o~ o
Wk~~~, vte th~n~~ the

s, u~ r~al;Ly is ~Qc~~y b~~or~ the

court, ~~ ~c~u cca~~~^t1~ i~~n~x:~ied, ~~~ ~~~~~:~~ x~~ ju~;ic~t~:
SQUT~-TERN ~J~S`~'~~C°~' RE~C?R.T~1~:~, P,C.

(2127 x(15-03(7

Eb74cap~
1

and ~ol~a~t~~a~ e~tQppel a~~iies h~re~ az~d we ~h nl~ we ~~~ each

2

that issue without giver having ~o ~~t to the privity issue,

3

T~1E CaURT:

That may be.

~f T z~.il e can ~.h~ legal. issue

4

~xF ~rQu~ ~avd~', then I Guess you'r~ ~;~gh~.

5

Gc~ rule tl~.~ ~at~Z~r wa.y a? ~1~,~.s <

6

frr~m ~h~ ~r~rt~.es somewhat cursar~.ly lay out: the po~itic~ns.

7

nc~~: c~1t~Ci ing.

8

k~a i.~a~7~~, dour a~:gum~n~ is th~.t ~h:e T~:l~.rc~ra.~.~~ c~.s~ and of h~~

9

C~~es ~:ha~ navy b~~n c~ s~~s~~cl in this ccrn~e~~ ~v~~e ~~ar~ a~ i,n

~.Q
:

I think T'm l ke~:y

Tl~e ~,~~.:ter~ that I received

Yc~u hid a 1 m ~ec~ ~.me~un~ of s~a~~,

I "m

I Ghin~ ~

~ ~racedu~a~.~.y ~~_ff~r~n~ ~a~tt~lr~ and, ~.`h~reore r ~~e wholly

1
.?,

r~a~p1 i~~b~ ~ ~

~ think T wro~.ld co~c~~e { I don't ~h xi-]~

1.,

NIA. M~.nd~l h~:s ~z~.y cha c~ b~:~~. t:o concea~ that these is ~:

~?~

prQ~~d~.tir~~: c~a~fe~en~~ between where those casts were end where

l~

this ca~~ is.

~
.5

~.c~~e~ -~ th~.~: ~ a ~zs~ nc~ can ghat c~c~~s~zt ~ m~:l~;.~ any d:~f~erence
'

1~

for p~.~rpr~s~s o~ the ~.~~~1 ~.na].y~sis.

1?

agree with that.

l8

~rtc~re dully, I g~,e~s I wo~~zld r~i~r~ you a chanr~ ~c~ do ghat

!
9

~3u~ his p~~r~t i~ -- and T ~.hnk I Fm a~~~~:ir~ed tc~

~~ ~r~u giant t:o have ~ ~hanc~ t+~ develcip ~:h~ s

MR. ~~DDII~~~' o

2d

~ t~~,~ n~ I'm 1. S~~7:y ~c~

'T`~TE ~O~TRT ;

Ab,sol.~.t~1.~, ysau~ ~-lora.car,

S wouldn ~ ~. bed tie house an ~k~an~ing my

2~.

view on ~xsa~, j~.zst because ~ ~hinl~ ~.hex~

~~

1.au~, ~:nd I th~.nk there i~ oza.ly sc~ Many wads try slue phis.
MR. GSDDSNG~:

23

Ak~~o1.u'cely, your Honr~r.

Just to

~larz:~y, Te~.tra~a cs wad a ~~s ~ur~ic~.t~, cas~ r nc~i: a cal3_at~z~.1.

2~
~5

~ r~c~t ~. Gon off: c~:s~

E

~~tc~~.,~~1 cage ,
~C?~TTT~ER.N DIS"~'R~~T I~~AE~R'~E~~~ P.~,

~21~} 8Q5-Q3(7t)

~b7~ca~~
Are ~a~ inclined ~a gay that r~s judi~at~ would a~~ly
~

h~re~

3
4

~~~~ GOU T:

Ifm inclined to say ghat the principles

articulated in Tehran cs w~ul~ ~~p~~ h~~~, a~ w ~~ -~
N , G~~?I~~~~
3R

6
7

fPHE C'b~1RT:

CUI~:~.y.
--

~, in fa~~,, i~

,s

rug aid uxadi.~guted.

ghat ~h~ inch v dual. ~.~feridari~s vier. ~ xunn ne,~. ~,~a.is ~.~~er~~~ far
~h~ cr~~~a~~te ~1a.~:n~, ~h~ ~or~aGra~.e c~P~~ndant, a~?~ l~ne~r ~ul~

~

we~.~. s~ha~ tk~~~~ ~re~e do~.~g w~i.ex~. ~h~y ctee~ded ~c~ ~~~ ch~l~.~ng~

~
.0

~~rt~,i~ ~.hin~s, s~.a.pu~,~.~.~ t~ r~~:~taz:n ~~:inc~.

~~.

de~en

12

a.s equ~~ly ~~pl~c~k~l~ he~~.

n~a~ ~~

~t c~rt~. n

I~ wau~.d seem ~~ m~ ~:~at t~l~ze ~~~ian~.~.~ ~.n Tel ~.rc~ni~

s.

~ ~~~~'t ~hin~, o~ a a:~as~~. ~h~.~ s.:~

~ro~..r.~,dr~' t h~ ap~~i~d he~~.
:
L~

MR, ~TL?T~ING~:

1

~our~~~art ~.~st fox ~:~~ ~~~:ic~~:

~
.6

that was.:

~'7

that jucic~m~x~~: m~.~~~. b~ by ~~ cou~°~ c~~ e:omp~~~n~ j~ra:sd ct o~.;

18

th:~rcl, ~.he ,~at~te party ~'or ~rivi~y; end ~our~h~ the same cau~~

I9

e~f ~~~ ic~rz.

~0

'~'~au~' ~Iona~,. T~~trorl~.c~ la.~cl Q~.t ~
~~ laa.d out ~o~.~: ~~cto~~, and.

~'i~t, ~.h~ ~ina1. ~ud~r~en~ an ~~.~ me~~:t~, ~ecr~n.d r

1~Taw, ~ t~i.inl~ we c~.n lit two and three gc~ for right
Rea11.Y, what the qu€~~~. :e~i~ ~.s, ~rour ~Tont~r

2:i.

now.

~~

nc~t ~~.~re hay b~~r~ ~ ~7na1 judgment .n the m~r~.~:~.

~3

.s pretty we?1 a~cep~ed that r~s ~udicata, th:a~. m~~,ns i~ has to

2~

b~ gi n. ~. ~ari~a~ pxQc~edin~, a pr~c~~ ~.~t qn, ~a~gk~.~:?

2~

is whether car
~ tha.n)~ at.

Wh~;t we ~a.a.vv h~:~~ a.~ ~h~ sart~e ~ct~.~n, ~c~ ~ha~
S4T1T~-T,E T ~71:.~`~'~.TGT ~EPQ~2.T~~.~, P,C,

f2~2~ BC~5~CS3Qp

Eb74e~p~
1

~~~s jud~cata would nay apply,

~

~a~k, the Court said

?

raised by a corpalatian i~ a prior ac~~on w~~~ b~rr~d ~y
~~

~~r

ns~~nG~, in Marne Midland

quote, d~~anses ghat coed have been

judieat~..

5

THE. C~U~T:

~h~~'s ~xa~~ it ~ai~.

It didn't ~~y

5

~~~u~t ~~ life ~h~~ awe ~ha~ the ~~~iu dual de~end~~ts ca~e~d

7

~h~n r~~~~ ~v~~yth~ng anew, x~g~t
T s~~ the Zaa~.ge.~~ge you're. sei a.ng ~.i~c~z~,, but T don'

~3

thank that was tl~e hc~lc~ ng cif the ~~.~e; ~ g~.~~
1 R, GI~T~ING~:
~
~
.l

that.

~t is sc~~m~~h~;n~ v~r~ w~r~.~~c~. 3~~ h~ppY to k~~i~f ~r~ greater

`~~~ ~~~.7Fr~'
.

13

T ~r~auld have ~:ea Ica ~~c~ ~n~. l~+~k ~t

~ w ~.1 give you ~. ~~an~~ ~c~ ~~i~~ ~.~.

?`

14

think, c1~:arly, the l~.ng~.ag~ of Telt~~na.~s, at p~g~s ~.~0 and.

1~

I.91, prin~ipa~.ly ~~ao~~ gage, wc~~.~1.~ s~~m ~c~ have ~qu~.1. ~ca~c~

26

1~e~e ~.s tc~ r~hz~ w~~t o~i,

7,''7

~vhe~.l~er ~~ nod t1~.A i~.div~.d~~:~ ~~~endants ~~~13:y uv~rc rur~n~,~?g

~..8

the 1.it get can, w~~.l, tk~ez~

1
.~

de~wn..

~0

MR-. GTI:~DSI~TCS ;

2~.

"I~F-IE COURT:

z

~.h~~~

~ a ~act~.~l c~spi~t~ ~s t~

guess w'e ~a~ld hive to n~i~ ~ .at

Ftic~~~ ,

I ~~.iz1k i:~~.t tvou7,d b~ ~~t~~_~r dt~~?~ b~'

~2

pu~t7.ng ~h~m az~ the ~~~.nd ,in ~~c~nt c~~ m~ and thin I coy.:€l~.

2~

assess and m~:ke a f~.~ad~.n.g,

2~
2~

1~'~T~~ ~~DDII~~~S:

~oua. I-~~,no.r, Tel~xoni~s a.lsr~ said,

q~ate, r~~ ju~.~c~.ta app~~e~ ~.~ r~p~tit~u~ ~i~~.t~~
QLJ'~'~IEF.N I~S'~'R~C'Z' R~C3~:TFR ~ P,C.

raz~rc~~~r~~,~ ~h
(~~2} 8G15-03Qf~

~b7~capc
1

~zght~

~~me cause ~f action.

Agin, w~ don't hive repet.~t~ous

suits here.
So y~u~ view 'is Ghat had `the suit that T

THE ~QURTa
4

~rant~d summary ~u~gment o~, ~f that wend to ~z~~l j~dgm~nt end

5

~~en they ~i1~~ ~

6

~~ur~e t~~y wo~~~ b

7

~~ way an ~m~~d~d ~~m~lain~ Frith the same d~c~~t ~umb~x, th~~

~

ina~~s X11 ~h~ d~~f~rence i~ the ~a~1~?

9
1U

~p~~~te ~~t~~n a~a~n~~ your client, theme ~~
~tu~~ with what they did ~~re, but beca~s

MR. ~~~DT~GS:
:
T~-1E ~UURZ'

Corr~ct~ ~~ur H~n~~o

Q~~y.

I tl~.i,riJ~ that is tl~:~ I~~,~d. o~
~ ~hinIc ~ will ~~r~

11~

~~a~malism ~.,h~~: ~ dran'~ ~nc~ pe~~tt~.sxv~.

1~

ysat~ a ~h~ra.~~ tc~ }~r~.e~ x~ , ~~~~~:a,nly, bud ~~ d+~~sza ~ t ~i:rs~:e me

~,3

as ~~~.a~ per~~~si~r~.

~4

pax~ti~~ summ~~y ~ud~m~n~s are en-~it~.~~. to co~.~1Ll~~ve ~~f~~~..

1~

~:~rt~~.z~~,y, ~.~a.er~ ~.~~ ~as~s

M~'L. ~I~DI~"~~ ;

ri w~~:.c~.

Xc~ur ~iana~:, to ~~ dear ~b~u~ ~~e

16

p~.rt~.a~. summ~:~~r ~ud~m~nt. point., t~.~ uses t:h~~ ~~p tol cite,

1
!

t~~ose ~r~: alI partial su~-nm~~~ j~.~gt~nen:t vrdex~ ~~°~s~rt a prior

18

proce~d~..ng, ~. aiffer~nt ~.ction:, ~igh~ a

19

ord~~ Pram ~ ~.i~~.ric~ c~c~urt judge in ano~he~ di~~r .ct.

~~

THE CC7~7R~~'a

~Iuds~n

~valvee~ an

~ c~.et all th~~, ~au~ your view a.s that ~l~.e

~~

ent ~~ i,s t,i~ burns c~z~ tivheth~~ d~ ~.a~ there was an a~'nend~d

~2

com~laa,nt r~r vaheth~r t:l~.~;r~ ~,,ras a ~-~.ew ~amp~.aint with ~ d~,ff_e~ent

23

ctoGket ntimb~~.

~~
~~

ASR. G~I~L~ZN~S ~

Gc~~~~c~ ,

`~h~.t' s whit t:he ca~~s say,

.
yeaur FT~nc~~
SCILITHER~3 DISTF~ICT REPC)R."I'ER,~, P.~.

~~1.~j BQ5-03Q0

~b7~Capc
1

TIDE CE?CIRT:

~

address this

~t~.t ~he~y dan't gay tka.at »

They dan't

ss~.~ squarely end ~~y .hat ~rou haves i~c~ being ~

new cage; ~ha~ in a si~~~uation aci which ~h~re"~ a~ amended
4
~

compl.aa.n~ , ~ari:ngiiag the same pause cif a~~io~ aga~ris~ two ~.ew
~
.ef~n~.ants ~ ~~Zat the r~ul`~ ~.~ ~atall~r dif;Eexen~.

6

fecund a cage tl~,~t says ghat.

7

~'1R,, ~~DD~NGS:

I l~.a~ten ~ t

Are you aware of cane?

T ~m not, taut Tim nca~ aware of a case

~

~a`her~ r~~ ju.d~c~c~~. anal c:o1..l~.t~~a1. ~~~opp~~. k`~a-~re been a~gl ~d a:n

9

~h~. ~a,me ~rc~~:~edir~.g, to pr~c~.ud~ teat de~~ndant dram rays ~c~

~
.0

those c~~f~~ses,

Right?

11.

let~e~, ~5.~her.

~.gair~, mayk~~ sarneth~.ng 3aetter s~u~~c~ ~o

~.`?

~~:rth~r 1~r~.~~~~~ ~,~. ~~.ti~the

1~

~~c~in.~ed ~cr ~. s r~.g~~ e~~e in which. ~~.i.~ hay b~ezx do~~ ~~~c~r~.

~.~

T~S~ ~~?URT:

C~pi~.ol. ha~~,'t ~c~:izzted ~.o or~~ ~:za ~.~.~i,

~~.an~t~~.oz~, ~~.~ ~ap~.o1: ~a~s ~~c,

This is the l~~guage f~~m `I"el~ron cs;

{'Tn

~
.5

~.~ght o~ the

l

~:~r~-p~.r.t~ par~.~cipa~ c~n ~r~d his a~pa~c~r~t~ day-to-d:a~r ~e~d~~-~h~

17

Tale iza the pr.iox~ litigatiar~, we h4~.c~ that. he trr~s

l~

vrit~x T~lt~anic~ azxd is bavn~. ~~r t~t~ ~~~~.~.~ i~ 'z'eltrQn~~s ~

1~3

liti.c~~.t on ~ri~~.ng ~'rorn this ca.us~ ~f ~c~ion.„

2Q

ndi~xidual c~e~enc~an~' s cr~nti.~~;uc~u~ ~.nd ~~~.ve

ra ~r vi~y

~a you're ha.n~ing yau~ had ran. the fact than prac~~

21

li~.ic~~.t on was at issue in ghat cage,
MR o G~DD~~]'GS:

~

Cc~~r~c~ ~ ~rcau~ Hora~.r.

Actu~~ ~.~,

23

T~ltron~c~, t~~y re~ad~ng o~ the c~~e, i~ there ire ~hr~e oz fatilz

24

di~f~ren~ ~ubsec~u~n~ act a~.s prior to the Second ~~.~'e:uit

~~

~r

cl c s~c~n.

~t cTep~nc~~ can hQ~nr y~~: co~~n~ ~~.~~~no

~aca~r~z~;~.~ t~~s~~~~~ RE~a~.T~~s, P.c.

Thee e~;~ ~a~.i~:

~

t~~z~ sa~To~oo

Eb~4~apc
1

~. f~:~r a~se,~sm~nt at;. the v~~r beginning o~ the opinion,
.

~

'1'H~ ~dCTR~';

~'he c~~her quote ~~. gage 191 ;

"T

3

s~o~khol;der, aft cer, ax' c~~.rect~ar off' a co~paratia~. contrc~l.~ an

~

actcan, b~Qugh~ can its behal:E in ~ux~l~~~~.nce a~ ~aa.s Qwn

5

zr~~e~~~ts, ~.~ ~.~ ~cai~.nd k~~r ~:ne ~e~~x1.~ Qf that a~t_,c~~. _~

6
7
8

~~ue~ are p~e~.~~r ~~.~:a~.

~ tk~zr~~ ~h~

we~u1.~: l~v~ tQ s~~ i~..

.dd~.tan~l ~.ut~M~arity,

Tf t~er~ is
~ l~~ve ' ~aur.d
~

~.rx~r .
How ~.c~ng d~a ~c~u th .n?~ ~~u ne~~: to l~~a_~f it'?

1
.~

~'i~t.e ~IUI~IN~S c

11

'~'x.~ C~~~. ".

1
.3

MR. ~~~T~~NGS:

To suYarrtit ~ brief ~n

~?

,~ ~ul~~r brie khan ~rha~. ~c~u have ~i~ren

~'r.o

au~ raer~p~c~~iv~, ~v~ ~a~ob~bl.~ nee

~~

~r~ti1 the ~~.~~~. nr s~co~d w~~k :~..n Dec~

3
.5

`I'h~~;ksg~.~vi;ng

~,6

cciuzzt~y` ~~~ a di ~~~~nt cn~tt~~ fob ~~.g~~ ~~~s, sa:x ~r~ c~~.gh

18

er; your ~r~nc~~.

~ ~omix~g up, and ~ am gai~g tca k~~ dui a~ the

'I'k~E ~CO'CTR'T':

L~~ Cn~ ~,ea~ what Mr. M~:~~dPI h~S ~:c~ Scl~r on

19

scheduling and anything e~l.s~.

2Q

gttes~s, in resgons~ , right'?

21.
2~
23
~~
~~

MR, MANDEL:

You wand, to submit a b~~ief , T

T ~u~apa~e ~o, if .your F-Tanor wane

brie~a~ng.
T~T~ C4U~.T:

I'm going to give them ~n opportunity to

bzief i~ rnca- e ~'uJ..~~ thin ~ tk~~:~e-pa~~: 1et~e~.
r
S`~IR. NI~T~E.L,:

Th~~'~ ~~:ne,

CJb~ric~~a.~]~y t w~ wru~.cl 1,i~C~

~b74~~~~
1

the app~r~uni~y ~Q r~~~and ~~ ~~~~'re going ~o subn~ ~ a ~r~~~.

2

~~E COURT;

3

MR: ~~D~2NGSr

4

Nr. Giddings, by De~~mb~x 5th.

Thank ~~ur

5

TAE CaU~T:

~

M~. MANTEL:

7

~'~E COURT:

8

S~ De~emb~~ 19th.

9
~o

Z ~hi~~ that is ~ai~r your Honor.

How fang dQ ya~t n~~d, fir. Mendel?
Two w~~~~.
Twa w~ek~.

What ~s what ~ was thinking.

Ail ~'ig~t,

~k. G~DD~NGS:

Youx' Hari~~, ~~ b~ c1~~~, ar.e we doing

~o he pc~x~~it.~~e~ a x~ply~

1
.1.

THE ~flL~R.`~'.

~'~Tt nit sup~ tl'zat I r1.e~=C~ a ~' fly,

l

~arzdidl~r.

.
L?,

.h
letters a~c~ wiL c~~~~ a~gumerx~ b~zcl~ in D~cem~~r, sd T woul~c

~.~;

l,p~r~ t,c~ c~. et i~. wrapped ~p,

1
.5

e~r~: male ~. ~epl~ by tl~.~ u~~r~,

6

l~t~, GZDL~~N~~ ;

18
19
U

Gee ;Fxav~ ~c~rt c~~ ~~~d tla.a.~ ~p twa.~e a~:~eac~~r nc~w i~z

T~~E CC~t3RT ~

~ ~ yc~~.z went Go ma.l~e ~. rep~~, you
Ul~~~.

I dc~n ~ ~ ~~caw ~.~ ~~~ %s ga_~.z~g to b~

S ~:s ~um~ ~.~ w~.11 b~

hc~~~.

~ a~su~ne

.
you'r~ ~e~~. r~ wing to f ir~.d ara~~hin~ ire the r o~pc~si~ior~ that yogi
~7av~n ~ t ~~.r~ady° seems..

~o ~h~ 23xid r ~.~ c;~ v~~ you

.v~ days to

~~~~.
~4

TI3E GC7~'RT:

X11. ~~i,g~.~..

Lei's eta ~h~t.

25

Ixi the me~ntim~, v~r~?a~ else sari w~ o:~ should: w~ be

~au~x~~N z~xsT~.z~~ R~~a~.~~~:~, ~.c~.

t~~.~) ~ca~-a~o~

Eb74c~p~
~
~

~a~~~?
damages dis~~v~~y is ~am~~h~ng ~ certainly
c~n~emp~ated.

~~ coup put ~~~t a~ hold pending ~es~l.ut ~n ~

the mo~io~~ t~ ~ismas~ end motions f~~ ~~con~id~~a~ on o~ she
5
6

ardor d~r~~~i~g the motions to d smissy
50, M~. NCa~de~,

.ram your ~ers~~~tive, what d~ ~~ n~~d

~o a~ ~~~n x~~~~~t ~~ a~~~~~~~
8
9

MR. ~11~NDEL~:

T ~hi~k we've t~~~~~ ~~ Mme. ~ dd~n~s.

~e

don't need and more di~c~v~r~ f~~~~~ ~apit~l~s p~~~pecti~e.

I0

Mr, Ga~ddir~c~s hid taZk~d ~b~ut, ~aerhaps, ur~t.il the end.. cad

~1

~~bru~.ry, :~~x them Ica ~c~mp~.~~e the d.is~aver~ ~~~a~ they ~~~~

~
.2

~h~~ n od,

~
.3
l~
~-~

TAE COU':~T;

Thy ~.~.~cr~v~~y ~h~y f~e:~ they a~e~d mea~;xng

xe~~est~ c~~ ~rau'?
M~. Nt~Nn~L.

'~'~~.

D~.~~r~r~r'~' ~:h~

'~k~e

xa.c~.z.v~lua~

1~

~.~~~~.~~.rz~~ are ~~ek rig ~~ capitol, ~.ca c~~fen,ci ~~e case.

~
.7

a~~:~~ab~:e to that.

~.~

We'a:

T~1e c~n~ th~n~ ~ wau~:c~ p~, n:t out. ~ we thi~.l~~ Lhes~

19

d~~~ne~~.~~.ts ~.~e 1~~r~ec~ ~~y ~:e~ jud~.rat.a a~.d ~013..~~:~ra~. est,a~p~~.,

~ Ca

}gut even :part f a:am that t ~ ~~a.ink. ju~~ a~ri ~h.~ co~.~.e~t of the

~7.

c~i~cave~y disp~.z~~s that we b~i.~~ec~ in ~h~ ~~~t~r~, given ~.~ ya°u

~~

~.~~urzte that somehow ~he~e de~en~~~ ct~~.~,~. stand, ~ think the

~3

d,isc~very requ~~ts ire. ~til~. w~.y cut c~£ bc~u~.d~ end not

2~~

~onne~~ed to ~ny-t~h~ng ~:~~~t' ~ r~~lly :~~~.~an~b~.~,

~" 5

d~f~ns~~, t~ b~ fr~.n}~, ~.h~j~r'r~ ~re~y slim, '~~~v cau:l.d
~C7UTI~EF~N D~~'~'RTC'I` ;REPURTER,~, P.~,

z th. nl~ ~.hes~

(~~.~) 8C}5-Cl~(]~l

Eb7~~apC
~
.

~~

p~a~ably
THE C~7URT:

Yc~~z're alleging ghat they i~.~:~~.n~ec~ csr~.

3

yo~zr cr~~y~ights, wk~at you own`?

4~

MR. MANDE~:

5

THE GflURT;

~
7

7..0
~~

YQ~z've ~~~.achec~ t€~ your ~Qmp~~a.x~t a cc~upl

of I.i~t~ c~~ cc~pyrght~d ma~.era:~~.
MR, NS~Nr~EL:
`~'i~E C~~RT:

9

~~rr~c:t.

Coxzect.
If w~ w~~:~ ~~artin~ fre~m sc~a~~~i ~n~. they

said, T dan'~. ~:hi.r~k you ~~a.11y own. ~.~~.os~ ~p~yrigh~~
M~2. MANDEI~:

Z'm not eon~es~ ~.r~g ~k~iei~ ~nti~.l~mez~.~. too

dis~av~e~~r ~n €awrzer~h~:p,

~
.~

'~'~~ ~'C?UR.T;

:
~3

M~. :1 N~E~;

Wh~~ awe you ~a1.ka;n.~ ~~aut:`?
~ ~ m ~:~~.~.~.ng ~~.~o~t~ ~~~e

~w a.s u~:s shat ~rr~

~
.~

bri~f~d in ~h~ let~~~'~, ~w~ieh are real~.~ p~ mar~.~.y c~ear~d ~.ca

1a

~:hei;~ so-called d~~~n.se~,

16

~rer~ ~a~ ~.f ie.1.d .

17

"T`~~ C~t~~Z:~.

18

NIR. MA1~I~EL:

rah. tl~.e~ re1:a~~ ~:c~ thi.~~gs ghat az~~

Wl~.a~ ~~~ ~rca~: ~alki.n~ a~atr~'?
Ever copyra.c~h.~; c~.s~ ~~.a~ ~a~ai~o1. h~:~

~9

k~~e~ugh~ ~o~ and- a~ ~.hese ~~~o~~.~r~~~ , tv~ have ~o ~~~1 thefin wh~.t.

2Q

~.h~y a~~~ urh~.t tie r~su~.t way, if t~h~r~. ~a~ ~: ~~ttlem~n~, haw

.
~1

m~~h i~: c~~.s ~c~~'.

~2

issue: ~hat~ i.~ deft ~a ~~ c7;e~:ie~~c~..

~3

our ~i.g~.~:~~. e~pla ~ata:on ~`e~r X17.. ~~ th~~e rec+~rd: ngs, Vic?

~~

ba~ic~1]~y ~.1~ of ~~ur ccax7:t~acLs

2~

fit's cry ~~.

~ mean, it hay ~c~ beara.n~ nn and
I"k~e~*' ~~ ~. l~ia~r~ for all 0~'

{
~t tha:s ~o~n~ ~.r~: ~~~ caste, wn~~:e we are. ~ don't ?chow
~O~J`T'~TERN l~~~TRT~'~ ~.EPCII~.TEF~,S, P.C.

~2J:~:~ ~Ci5-~30C1

Eb74capc
~

what that has to d~ with az~y issue that's l~~t.

We pr~~uce~ xn

~i~c~v~ry ana ~h~~ have oui c~n~~~~~ with Apple, which is
ready tie primary relationship ghat is ~igni~~can~

but

4

this po~i~~, ~o~ us to start ~rodu~ n~ x.11 ~~~r l~~ense~, X1.1 ~~

5

auk c~nt~~:~ts ~a~ dig~ta~ ~xpl~~ta~~oz~, everything ielatYng to
cur p~~~c ~s o~ digital exp~aitationf ~t

~~a c~mple~e ~z~~ ~g

7

e~~~~~tion.

If they want to ~ha~Zen~~ awner~h p and ask

8

qu~sti~ns a~ou~ i~ and g~~ us ~o proves ~h~~ w~ awn

~

understand that.

~, ~~n~, z

Eu~ ~h~se o~h~x tap~c~ a e so fay a~i~l~, ~i~d

~~

trey try ~o justify fil~em w ~hou~ ~v~n ex~laznin~ they're

~~,

s~ppo~~d~y ~ela~~~ to t~~~~

12

Dave .never a ~ic~~"la~~d what ~nc~eaz~ .handy d~~e se c~~ld

l~

~a~s~~:I~le ~xi~t ~ae~e, o~ cc~p~rr~a.c~ht m~us~.

l~

~hfls~ d~~ .~.~~s are.

3~5

tzx~m ati a m~.~t~r of ~~~ ~uc~~c~t~. a~ cc~~I.~,t~r~.~ e~~app~I, bud

lt~

ev~~. if ~h~y c~u.7:.d, they! ~:e ~e~t~11~ wthc~~t ~~~.y ~actttal ax

~
.7

leg~~ .~cr~~~.da~.a.o~, a~ ~,his~ pc~~a~~t.

1~
.

TIDE Cot~~.T:

~~l~an l~axzd~ ~e~~ns~, whze~ th~Y

~ can't ~~r~:r~~r v~k~a~

I dQa~.rt ~7~iral~ they're c~~~~:z~.1ed ~c~ ~~~er~:

T'm ir~.c~. ~~c~ t~r~ ~g~e~.

~ ~~.e~ s ~ caauld ~~

~
.9

~uriou~ ~.c~ knc~~,v what ~h~y a~°~, bit it m~.~ b~ ~Yla~. the l~:ga~.

2Ct

ru~.ing d~~p~n es the x~.~ed ~~~~, tc~ do ghat ,

~

Mr. ~ c~~. rigs r d~ yc~u waz~~. to ~a~r ~act~e~h:~n.g°?
~~~, ~au~° Honor.

~.

NCR. G;C~~~NGS.

~~

Pegardin~ M~. i~~andel. s s camm~n~ ~bc~u

24
~~

~~.~ end a~

'~b~uar~, T th~.r~k ~r+~ur ruli~a.c~, ~.ep~nc~ ~g an w~.a~ a.G does ~~ ~.h
ar~..~~iz~.g, has ~.~ im~aac~ c~~. tl~a~,
SC~UTHE~.N D~S'~'~:~~.'T RE~~.?]~~'~RS, P. ro

~'~.~cf: will e~bv au~ly push t~a.~
(~1.2) $~5-03pG

~b74C~p~
l

~ se~~~r~ ~r 1~av~ a'~ery r~~~ impact ~n whit discovery the
end v d~~~ de~enda~~~ are abbe t~ seed in ~h~s a~~~an.

3

~ I

~h~nl~ i~ m~~ b~ ~~emature,
T~~ CQURT:

5
'

ab~u~ all the

5

M~y~~.

~~hy ~o ~Qu t~~n~ ~~u n~~~ to J~now

~eopl~~

nf~ ~g~~e~t ~~s~s t~e~ ha~~ s~t~1e~ with ether

R. ~IbDTNG~;

Your Hanoi, rn~ poa~~~ was that

~ we aye

8

p~~rlu~e~, in y~~~~ view f b~ r~~ judc~ta o~ ca11~~~~a~ est~~~~

~

front as~~~'tin~ an~r c~e~=en~e as ~c~ ~ttr liab~la.ty a~• cer~~. n

1c~

d~~er~s~~ as i.Q the ~:ndiv3r~u~1 ~:~~~ne1~,~t' s liabi].~,ty, then ~

~1

bel~.eve she cl s~ove~~ per ~c~ Lh~~. we cou~,~. negc~c ~~.~ with

1
.2

C~p~:to1. Ft~cc~rds wo~~ld b~ r~ucn

~..s

~T'~IE CC3tJF~.T:

T

hc~~te

greA ~~ ~h t~:a~.

I guess ~:'m ~s1~i.nc t
.J

~4

even if I ~aa.d you can ass~z:t c~L~'~z~s~s that the ~arpo~~.~e

15

c~e~enct~n~ waiv~cl or didn't ~r~~ke, ghat waulc~. be the r.~~ion~.1~

~
.6

:~o~ ge:tt~.~zg discovering o~z ~v~ry in~ringemen~ ~cti~~z they've

!
~I
18
~~

h~.d with ~hi~d ~aartes?
1~1R. ~'~bDING

Your Honor, nu.;~ ~].i~rit b~lle~r~s that i.~

is pertinent tc~ ~h~ t~va~r in which

~0

`I`HE C~U~.'~':

~~

of nc, tnram~ri.t to m~.

~
;~

re~.ev~r~.ce'?

~3

M~. ~TT~D~~1G

~~

TIE C(J~.TR'I'»

~5

NIT~k, G~LI7D~:NG

~f yQu~ c~i~nt believes it

~ p~rtr~.~nt is

What. i.s the ~.r~~.~u1.ab1~ ~a~.sa.s

car ~,t~

Abau~ ~aric~x~ acticans, yeau~ Ilo~.or'?
~e~
I~. r~~~~ ~~ tc~ hc~r ~~~~.~~~. 'h~,~ c~z~.fr~r~:~d

SQU''~'~~RI~1 I7~STR.~~T RE~'C7~.T~R~, F,Ca

{2~.2~ ~3~5-~Q3QQ

E~74cap~
1

its cop~ri~h~~ as ~o ~th~r start-ups, as ~a other risers, which

~

gods, we thin~f ~nta the damage calcination or ~h~ damage __

3

~'~omput~tion" is nat the carrec~ card -- but the equation,
y

~otl ~1a.11.
5

THE CaURT.

~ guess I wau~d went ~c~ ~~~ some . a~,L~hQra~ty

for the ~~ca~aos~.tifln ghat y~u'xe ~n~ t:i~e~ Ica kn~aw ~h~ s~ttl,~zn~nt
7

t~~~m~ Qf ev~~:~~ infr~ng~merat gas

~

assess the d~r~t~.g~ .

~

NlR.: G2I~5~ING~ ;

tk~~y ~av~ ever s:~~~~~~. ~a

`~ca b~ ~~e~~, your Hc~na~, w~ v~~~~z~.'t

1~

a~t~ing for. se~t~~m~~t ~.~:rms.

1~

1~..~t n~ ~1~ the .~~ prig ~~x~~a~~~:m~ni~ ac;~ ans car their ~rpyr gh

~
.~

actac~~~.s as ~.c~ these ~~se~~~d r1.~.ims..

~
.3

~`H~ ~C~L7'R'T':

~ ]~~~. eve the x•equ~st ~,~ks ~c~r a

`Wha.t wau~,d t~zat b~ r~Ievant t.a ~.n th~.s

A list. of o~:he~- ei~farcem~n.t act~.ans ~.h~t they h~v

14

c~~e~

15

brc~uc~h~ ~o pro~~c~, ~.l~eir ~opyrigl~.Cs

1~
~7

M~.. G~~I~TNGS:

:Ct ~r~~ ~~,~c~ ask far 'th.e cautcc~me c~~ the

c~aitn

"~ 8

`I'S~E CdURsT`:

~a~rk~, ~ i:h ~:k ~'m nit 1ike~:~r t~ a~~.cs~i~

19

tt~.~at ,

~0

ha°v~.ng t~c~ do this piececn~al, but ~ dc~ think. at sc~tn~ part ui~

21

mad' gel to the cne~i~.s o£ these, ar~.d trihether ~.hzs is jtzSt

~2

~.e~ign~d to

i3

1~~st a Fishing expedition caz a d~sir~ Ica de~.~~y fur~che~ the

2~

7..i.~a,~atic~ra, ~c~ z g~z~;~~ I'm ~e~~ ga~:ng ~o ~~~alv~ ~.~at new°, bud

.25

~ ~ in s~p~i~Yal ,

I: think the 1.~~g~l c~u.~stic~n may ~~sc~~.-ve

~ va thot~t me

n~~. .c~ paa.n on the c~tl7~~ side car ~rhe~the~ its ~s

E~7~ca~c
M~. GI~~T.~G~:

~

'
~°I-TE CCJURT:
~

Tha~~ you, ~oLir Hdnar

Mr. Ad:e~m~n, this

~ ~Yj.~ quet~~t ~ have.

vex seen ye?u .

~k

~tR. ~DFLNtA~T:

~

TH,~ COtIR'I':

5

~~ny~h~.ng ~1~~ you w~n~ us tc~ cave?

7

NI?~.. .AD~"`I~~:

8

I a~pre~at~ .hat.
I ~~ic1 it with a Sm 1.~.

I have 7.0~~ tca sad, br,~t neat in phis

c~.~~.

9

~I'I~E COURT`:

1
.0

'you hive n.atkxing tc~ say ~~day?
'
No, I C1ar~: ~ th:~,nk w~ ~i,ave az~ythixa.g ~.o

MF. AI:~~~NIAI~]':

~
.l

~~.~` other_ th~~ra. ~;~re a~~ g~i.nc~. tc~ paz~~,cipa.~e, c~~v cau~l.y, in ~:h~

~
.~

d _~~c~~ery ~~a~e~~ ~o ~h~ ex~~n~

1~

~~~1..~ t~a tx~e e~ten.t tk~~~.~ ~-_ ~~aa~r ~ ~t~nd?

. ~t
l

r
i~l'1Zu

~_5

M~..

L.n4AlJ i6..L ~

~. c~.o~s can, b~~:~.u.s~ T think w~

c~tz~

Whi.~~ w~ cc~n~inu~ tc~ Qbj ~t ~o ~he~.r

~T,M~~N:

~~6

pray=~.d~.~.~ r.~r~.a~.n docum~n~s a~~er the cTns~ a~ elamages

l'7

d~.~~ove

~
.S

c~.~t't1,0^u~"., ~,{000 ;~}c~.C~'~S i

~ C?

'Z'~~ ~CJ~71~.T:

2 ~.
,

M~, :AUE~,1
.

~~

THE ~C7UR~',

~:3

SIR e MANDEL <

c~TIC~. W~' G91Ga'1:1.~.:C~ ~3.)CC~ ~~1C-~ c~p~7C7~~~1~~~'` ~~ C~E',~7Q~P

V~ith r~,s~~~~ ~o c~~.mag~s?
T:

'~e~, ~~ra~.~. ~~~~ect ~~ damages.

I~l~, M~nd~:l t yi~u'~e mot ~iJa~ ~C~a~ng to t~.a~.
1V'~.

I t~h~.n~ i:f , key d~m~g~~, t~~y~ r~ea~.

~~vey.er~l~ip ---

~~k
5

~,n th.e c~~~a~~ate c~:s~ prraf~e~:, ~~~- d:id d~;selc~~~

,

MF:. ?~DLM~T:

`~~~~~, ~ mean iz~ ~h~ d~m~g~~ , a~ pa~~ o~

~C)ITTHE~2;L~T DISTRTC",'I' REPC7R'~'E~.S, ~mC.

(~~,2) 805-Q3Q0

Eb74capc

1

the darna~es ph~~a, yes, a~ to ~wners~ip --

~

M~. NI~lNDEL:

3

MR. AI~ELMAN.

W~ ddn s t have a~~ p~abl~m ~it2~ that.
T ~u~t ~~nte~ to ma~~ ~~:r~ than. eras part

o~ whatc~ve~~ ~rau cl~cica.~ here today vii-a_v~s da.scr~very,
~

TAE ~~UR.`~:

T thank w~ w~.~.l resca~~r~ t~.e l~ga1

sue

6

~a wh~~ the d~~~~dan~s ~r~ going bra b~ able ~c~ assert,

7

l~av~ dance th~.t, th~i~. wP wi.l~ decide. w~.at d~.scov~r~r ~~ma~~,~ ai~c~

8

what i~ i

9

t~r~:ib1~ 1onc~ l~ec~us~ T th~.x~,k i~ is gc~in~ to be f~~.r~.y

going ~o ~~ak 7,.i]~~;

Once I

I dc~n"t ~.n~.:~.~~.pate it ~.as~i.xag

1a

discrete,

1~.

to d~.m~.ges way ~c~ne.

12

all a'?~a~g ~,?a:~ ~o h~.ve scamp ~:a~~na~es disc~av~;~y, and. then we ~.~,nd

1~

a~ dot w~:~~.~~.~ by ~h~ incli.vi.c~u~l ~.~fendarz~~ sul~ms.~~ n.g

~
:~

~~?~.~:~.aira~~ an,d the mc~~ic~n~ ~.~

l

~au1.~~.nc~ ~.n~rbc~dy, but ~: t~~n3~ ~ha~ t s ~rh~.t hits gc~~~ on.

~
.~s

~C3:C1~~1~1~3.~.i~,`~:7.C}7'~ 4Vc`~~

1?

d:i.scr~~:~_a~n ~:c~ ~.a~~ this l~.ap~e~, _ _ ~ha~. we'~:~ goira.g ~.o ha~~ ~o~ne
-~

~~

d~,mag~~ discovery, b~,~~. 1.~t'~ ~a.r~t r€~solv~: ~h~.

1~

zs~u~ ~e~,at~.nc~ ~o Tell. ~oni~~ end what a.t mc~aza

~a

I d ~di~.'t ura.~.~r.stand. that.- fact d:i~~ove-ry vaith ~~spect.

S w~.~1,

T mean, m~ uz~rl~r Viand rig a~~d my

c"~.~4+fc"t~j~

nt~~nti~n

.ism~:ss end r ~sazz~a:de~.

~'m nca~
~c~ my

~'L'iC~ ~`~fTtr~3.T1S -- ~1-xlt~. I '~~J11"S.}+. ~ ~r'~.VE' ~~-C~:

s up a sch~du~.~.~c~ a~de~

1.~.~~ ~.ega~.
~c~r th~.s a se.

o~° that b~a.ef ~zg, ~~ac'1

21

t~i~n T ~.~~,ink ~ wild. 1 ke.:C~r ~~sc~Ive; i~ very c~u.icl~~,~r, r~~.~~, or

2~

~rithaut ~n r~pi:r~a.an.

~~

w~ cai~ gel this back an track.

~~
25

'~'he dp~ni.an may ~c~~1c~w ~.ate~°, just ~o ~h~t
Q}~~y

T~ is an i,n~eres~ .ng c~.~e.
~~

Tt hay ~.~,~.r~~~~a a ~.~~ c~~

~~t~a-~~~..r~~, jnli~~a. gc~c~d x~~.sci~~, bt3.~ T ~~ran~ tc~ c~
.~t ~,t mca~vincr.
SC)LTTHERN I~7'~TI~~C"~' ~2:~PQ1~:'I'~R~, P,~.

~~~.~~

S~

8p5-Q3Q0

~~7~ca~c
it may ~e that ~h~ ~`~1t~~nics ~ sup
2

3

~.rzd th~z-z ~~plain late.

okay'?

~ one where I will rude

A.11 right.

Anyth ~r~ e~~~: ~e should cc~ve~ ~oc~~.y.~
IR. MAN~7ELs
S
`
I'H~ CQLTRT:

Ncr~ ~'~c~m plaintiffs
X11

MR. ADELMA~T:

7

MR. GTDDIN~,S

8

TT~E COURT:

dour Honor

?ght

No, your Hana~,
Nn~.

rc~rn tiur pexs~ect~,ve, your ~-TC~no~ .

`~'h~n~s v~~y much.

I wi~.1 issue th~~ chart ardor.
~0
.
~~
~2
1
.3

1.4.

I tharzl~~ the court ~epQr~e~, ~s a~:ways, ~a~ her ~~.~.~~~t
'
~.ra.~ ~~ ~ rn~.
~~ ar~y~ody needs a ~c~~y c~~ ~h~ L
-ran~cript, yQtt C~tn
tale ~h~.~ ~;tp with her nc~w.
(
P,~.~ au~r~.ed)

z
.
1G

I7
1S
1.
20
~~
2Z
23
~~
~5

S4UTIIERN D~S`T'R~CT R~?~QRTER~ , P . C ;.