Ceglia v. Zuckerberg et al

Filing 238

DECLARATION signed by Peter V. Tytell re 237 Response in Opposition to Motion,,,, filed by Mark Elliot Zuckerberg, Facebook, Inc. filed by Mark Elliot Zuckerberg, Facebook, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G)(Snyder, Orin)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT A PETER V. TYTELL DOCUMENT EXAMINER 116 FULTON STREET SUITE 2W NEW YORK, NY 10038–2712 TEL: 212/233-5333 FAX: 212/233-5336 E-MAIL: typeter@aol.com I reside in New York County, New York, and am a full time forensic document examiner with fully equipped facilities for the non-destructive examination of documents. I have studied the examination of documents with Pearl and Martin Tytell, both of whom had been licensed by the University of the State of New York to teach Questioned Document Examination and Identification. I have studied the standard texts in the field and have taken courses in document analysis and related subjects at Georgetown University’s Institute of Advanced Analytical Chemistry and Georgetown University’s Institute for Criminal Law and Procedure; Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute; the Institute of Paper Chemistry (then at Lawrence University, Appleton, Wisconsin); Rochester Institute of Technology; and John Jay College of Criminal Justice. I have also taken specialized courses and continuing professional education courses, seminars, workshops, etc. I regularly attend meetings of professional organizations in the field and keep abreast of the current periodicals and relevant literature. As part of my initial training and continuing professional education, as well as for specific projects and cases, over more than forty years I have conducted research in various phases of document examination. These have included the history, differentiation, dating, and identification of handwriting (including cursive writing, handprinting, signatures, numerals, etc.); typewriter and other type styles; typewriters and other business imaging equipment; paper; ink and ink differentiation techniques; the development and production of specialized overlay plates for examining typewritten and other machine generated documents (in use internationally by private and government document examiners); as well as in basic areas of the theory and practice of document examination. This research has included on-site observations at producers of paper and papermaking equipment, typewriters, typewriter type and elements, ribbons, carbon paper, ink, pens, digital typestyles, etc., in the United States and other countries. I have also visited government and private document laboratories in this country and abroad to observe techniques and procedures. The results of some of this research have been included in technical presentations. I am a diplomate of the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners (US) and hold the Forensic Science Society (UK) Diploma in Document Examination as a qualified specialist in forensic document examination; and belong to the American Academy of Forensic Sciences (Questioned Document section member and recipient of the section’s Ordway Hilton Award), the American Society for Testing and Materials (Committee on Forensic Sciences, Membership Secretary; Past-Chairman and currently Vice-Chairman of the Sub-Committee on Questioned Documents; recipient of the ASTM Forensic Sciences Award and the ASTM Award of Merit; and ASTM Fellow), the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, the Evidence Photographers International Council, the Inter-Society Color Council, and have participated in meetings of these and other learned organizations in North America and Europe. I am also an active participant in the work of the Scientific Working Group for Forensic Document Examination (SWGDOC) and was a founding member of the editorial board of the International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners. I have taught and lectured on various aspects of the subject to document examiners employed in public and private laboratories as well as to investigators, attorneys, etc. I have also been consulted as an expert in typewriter history, and was a consultant in this area for an exhibition at the CooperHewitt Museum, the Smithsonian Institution’s National Museum of Design. I have worked on document cases submitted by courts, prosecutors, public defenders and legal aid societies, law firms, government crime laboratories, other document examiners, private individuals, banks, insurance companies, corporations, etc. Since 1971 I have testified on handwriting and typewriting identification as well as other document problems in State and Federal courts and other venues. PROFESSIONAL FACILITIES Specialized Instrumentation Compound stereoscopic microscopes (Bausch & Lomb, Leitz, Projectina, A. O. Spencer, and Zeiss) Comparison bridge microscopes (Bausch & Lomb and Leitz) Comparison optical projector (EPOI CP-6) Specialized hand magnifiers, reticules, etc. Light sources of various spectral characteristics Long and short wave ultraviolet lamps and cabinets Specialized viewing filters Front surface half-reflecting mirrors Closed circuit television systems sensitive to the near infrared region of the spectrum for viewing reflected infrared and infrared luminescence, including the VSC-1 (Video Spectral Comparator — Foster & Freeman, Ltd.) Computer hardware and software for image processing ESDA (Electrostatic Detection Apparatus — Foster & Freeman, Ltd.) for indented writing Ronchi rulings Complete sets of specially ruled typewriter and handwriting overlay plates on glass and film, including grids for direct measurement of escapements to 5 µ (0.000 197") Rulers for direct measurements to 0.000 5" (12.7 µ) and other precision measuring devices. Photographic Equipment Nikon digital and 35 mm camera systems for macrophotography Nikon Multiphot 4 x 5 laboratory camera system (adapted for digital imaging) Sirchie custom 4 x 5 field cameras Overhead, opaque, and slide projectors Screens for front and rear projection Other presentation and graphic arts equipment Reference Materials Complete professional library with over 4,500 volumes on document examination, handwriting systems, typography, typewriters, photocopiers, as well as other pertinent forensic and technical subjects Extensive library of relevant journals and articles Extensive reference collection on typewriter type design, including archives of the Imperial Typewriter Co. and the Underwood Typewriter Co. Comprehensive reference files on writing instruments, inks, paper, photocopiers, typography, etc. PETER V. TYTELL PAGE 2 CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION Courses, Seminars, Workshops, etc. Identifying and Managing Errors in Case Analysis: Introduction to Human Error Analysis workshop chaired by Ms. Susan M. Ballou of NIST; taught by Dr. Scott Shappel, Clemson University; Ms. Melissa K. Taylor of NIST Office of Law Enforcement Standards; Ms. Melissa Gische of the FBI; Ms. Linda Connell of NASA; and Dr. Douglas A. Wiegmann, University of Wisconsin, Madison; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Chicago, IL, 2011. Images in the Court Room: The Impact of SWGIT Guidelines in Court workshop chaired by Mr. Carl R. Kriigel of the US Army Crime Lab; taught by Dr. William R. Oliver, MD, and Dr. Richard W. Vorder Bruegge of the FBI; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Chicago, IL, 2011. Forensic Multimedia Analysis workshop chaired by Dr. Zeno J. Geradts of the Netherlands Forensic Institute (NFI); Dr. Leonid I. Rudin, Cognitech; Dr. Richard W. Vorder Bruegge of the FBI; and Dr. Ivo Alberink and Dr. Arnout C.C. Ruifrok, of NFI; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Chicago, IL, 2011. Signature Examination: Translating Basic Science to Practice workshop taught by Dr. Michael Caligiuri, University of California, San Diego and Mr. Linton Mohammed of the San Diego County Sheriff Crime Lab;; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Victoria, BC, 2010. Challenging Signatures workshop taught by Mr. A. Frank Hicks and Ms. Kirsten Singer of the Veterans Administration; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Victoria, BC, 2010. Electronic Recording & Analysis of Handwritten Signatures & Writings workshop taught by Mr. Nicholas Mettyear, Dr. Steven Strach, and Ms. Andrea Devlin; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Victoria, BC, 2010. Signature Examination: Translating Basic Science to Practice workshop taught by Dr. Michael Caligiuri, University of California, San Diego and Mr. Linton Mohammed of the San Diego County Sheriff Crime Lab; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2010. Introduction to Perception, Observer Effects, Bias, and Expectation in Forensic Science workshop taught by Mr. Keith E. Inman, Dr. Norah Rudin, Mr. John J. Lentini, and Michael Risinger, Esq.; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2010. PETER V. TYTELL Challenging Signatures workshop taught by Mr. A. Frank Hicks; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Dearborn, MI, 2009. Handwriting of a Homogenous Population workshop taught by Ms. Marie Durina; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Dearborn, MI, 2009. Indentation Sequencing workshop taught by Mr. Brian Lindblom and Mr. Robert W. Radley; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Dearborn, MI, 2009. The Examination of Documents produced with Inkjet Technology workshop taught by Mr. Gerry LaPorte of the National Institute of Justice; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Dearborn, MI, 2009. Security Documents Before and After the Crime: REAL ID, Physical and Electronic Security Features, Developments in Commercial Printing Technology, and an Introduction to Counterfeit Link Analysis workshop taught by Mr. Troy J. Eberhardt of the US Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Mr. Joseph C. Stevens of the US Secret Service, and Mr. Joel A. Zlotnick of the US Department of Homeland Security given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Denver, CO, 2009. Typography—Testing to Testimony workshop taught by Mr. William Flynn and Ms. Kathleen Annunziata Nicolaides; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Asheville, NC, 2008. Case Examinations of Medical and Business Records ABFDE workshop chaired by Mr. Dennis Ryan and Mr. David Oleksow; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Asheville, NC, 2008. The Applications of Color Analysis and Light Theory in the Forensic Examination of Documents workshop taught by Ms. Danna Bicknell, Mr. Gerry LaPorte, and Mr. Joseph C. Stevens of the US Secret Service; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Washington, DC, 2008. The Impact of Confirmational Bias and Context Effect on Report Writing in the Forensic Science Laboratory workshop chaired by Mr. Joseph P. Bono; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Washington, DC, 2008. PAGE 3 Authenticating Questioned Documents Workshop taught by Mr. Gerry LaPorte, US Secret Service; with Electrostatic Indentation Development—In theory and in practice, taught by Mr. Dan Purdy, formerly of the RCMP and Mr. Tobin Tanaka of the Canadian Border Services Agency; and with Examination of Documents by Analyzing the Paper, taught by Mr. Walter Rantanen of Integrated Paper Service; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Boulder, CO, 2007. Workshop on Management Issues in Forensic Document Units taught by Ms. Diane K. Tolliver, Indiana State Police, and Mr. Thomas P. Riley, Michigan State Police; given at the Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, San Antonio, TX, 2007. Mini-Workshop on the Foster & Freeman Video Spectral Comparator and Electrostatic Detection Apparatus taught by Mr. F. L. Lee, Jr. of Foster + Freeman; given at the Northeastern Association of Forensic Scientists meeting, Rye Brook, NY, 2006. Workshop on Disguised and Simulated Handwriting taught by Dr. Bryan Found of the Victoria Police Forensic Services and LaTrobe University (Australia); given at the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Atlanta, GA, 2006. Workshop on How Frye and Daubert Have Changed the Presentation of Criminalistics and Questioned Documents in Court given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2006. Print Quality Measurement Workshop given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Montreal, Que., 2005. Computer Analysis of Handwriting (CEDAR) given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Montreal, Que., 2005. SWGIT Presents: Guidelines for Acquiring, Processing, Analyzing, and Archiving Video and Image Data workshop chaired by Dr. Richard W. Vorder Bruegge, FBI; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, New Orleans, LA, 2005. Forensic Examination of Electrophotographic (Toner Based) Documents and Devices workshop taught by Mr. Tobin Tanaka of the Canada Border Services Agency, Ottawa; given at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Golden, CO, 2004. The Examination of Photocopy Signatures: Distinguishing between line quality and ink line morphology workshop taught by Mr. Greg A. Dawson of the Centre of Forensic Sciences, Toronto, and Mr. Brian S. Lindblom formerly of the RCMP; given at the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Atlanta, GA, 2004. PETER V. TYTELL The Use of the Haas Atlas CD Compilation workshop taught by Mr. Andrew Szymanski of the Lake Co., OH, Crime Laboratory, given at the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Atlanta, GA, 2004. Forensic Image and Video Processing workshop chaired by Dr. Zeno Geradts of the Netherlands Forensic Institute and Dr. Richard W. Vorder Bruegge of the FBI; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Dallas, TX, 2004. Note Taking Considerations and Techniques for Document Examiners workshop chaired by Mr. Larry A. Olson of the IRS National Forensic Lab; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Chicago, IL, 2003. Paper Science Related to Questioned Document Examination workshop taught by Dr. John F. Waterhouse; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Atlanta, GA, 2002. The Forensic Examination of Plastic Identification, Travel, and other Types of Secure Documents workshop taught by Mr. Ronald N. Morris and Steven Jones, both formerly of the US Secret Service, Daryl Hendricks of the US GSA, Richard Outland of the US Secret Service, and Rick Lusignan of Legend Business Systems; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2001. Canon Photocopier and Facsimile Training Workshop taught by Technical Training staff members of Canon Corp. along with forensic document examiners Mr. Brian B. Carney, Mr. Clarke Mercer and Ms. Joyce Lauterbach; sponsored by the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners; given at the Canon Training Center, Norcross, GA, 2000. Technology and Its Use in Questioned Document Examination Workshop taught by Mr. Robert Dartnell, Mr. Leslie Hawke, Mr. David Tobin, and Mr. Norbert Jaufmann of Foster & Freeman; Mr. Jim Hartman, askSam Systems; Mr. Neil Holland forensic document examiner, private practice; given at the joint International Association of Forensic Sciences/American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Los Angeles, CA, 1999. Forensic Document Examiners — Advance Study Course: Examination of Medical Records taught by Ms. Linda J. Hart, Mr. A. Frank Hicks, Ms. Sandra L. Homewood, Mr. A. Lamar Miller, Mr. David L. Oleksow, Mr. Gerald B. Richards, forensic document examiners, private practice; Mr. Albert H. Lyter, III, ink chemist; Mr. Robert Dartnell, Foster & Freeman; Mr. Robert P. Hart, forensic photographer; Edward R. Blumberg, Esq, Arthur Garcia, Esq., and Fredrick E. Hasty, III, Esq.; sponsored by the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners, given in Miami, FL, 1997 PAGE 4 Digital Imaging Techniques Workshop taught by the staff of the Imaging Technology Center, NASA Lewis Research Center, given at the Lewis Research Center in association with the annual meeting of the Midwestern Association of Forensic Scientists, Cleveland, OH, 1994. Forensic Examination of Counterfeit Documents taught by Mr. James F. Larner, of the Immigration and Naturalization Service Laboratory; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Long Beach, CA, 1994. Laser Printer Workshop taught by Mr. Gary T. Swatton of Capricorn Data Supplies, Kanata, Ont.; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Ottawa, Ont., 1993. Laser Printer Service taught by Mr. Randy Armstrong of Armstrong Business Machines, Irving, TX; a short course by Tech Support Associates, given in Queens, NY, 1993. Paper Knowledge Workshop taught by Mr. Walter Strong of the Mead Paper Corp.; given at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Denver, CO., 1992. Fraudulent Documents: Their Recognition — Part I Fraudulent Documents: Their Deterrence — Part II taught by Mr. James F. Larner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service Laboratory, Mr. Richard W. French of the US Postal Inspection Service Crime Laboratory, and guests; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, New Orleans, LA, 1992. Fundamentals of Chemical Detection, Measurement, and Monitoring: Analytical techniques and biosensors taught by Prof. James H. Wiersman and Ms. Elaine M. Bower; a short course given by the University of Wisconsin, Madison, College of Engineering, Dept. of Engineering Professional Development, given in Alexandria, VA, 1992. Canon Fax Workshop taught by Mr. Carmello Martinez, Jr. and Ms. Charla Wykel, Canon Corp.; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Lake Buena Vista, FL, 1991. Expert Witness Workshop taught by Prof. Carol Henderson Garcia, Nova Law School; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Lake Buena Vista, FL, 1991. Deposition Testimony Workshop taught by Prof. Michael Flynn, Nova Law School; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Lake Buena Vista, FL, 1991. PETER V. TYTELL Crime Scene Reconstruction taught by Dr. Henry C. Lee of the Connecticut State Police Forensic Science Laboratory, Dr. Peter R. DeForest of John Jay College, New York City, NY, and Mr. Jerry W. Chisum of the California Department of Justice; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Anaheim, CA, 1991. Type Identification and Copyfitting for the Service Desk taught by Mr. Steve Kennedy; given at The Typographers Association of the Greater New York Area, New York City, NY, 1990. Law Enforcement Photography Seminar taught by Mr. Dick McEvoy, Jr., Law Enforcement Programs Coordinator, Eastman Kodak Co.; presented by Eastman Kodak Co., Professional Photography Division, given in New York City, NY, 1989. Photocopier Workshop taught by Mr. James H. Kelly of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation Division of Forensic Sciences and Ms. Diane K. Tolliver of the Indiana State Crime Laboratory; given at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Crystal City, VA, 1989. Printing Techniques for Questioned Document Examiners a seminar taught by the faculty; given at the Technical and Education Center of the Graphic Arts, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY, 1988. Copier Workshop taught by Mr. James H. Kelly of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation Division of Forensic Sciences; given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Philadelphia, PA. 1988. Questioned Documents Signature Seminar given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Philadelphia, PA, 1988, included: A Review of Selected Signature Problems taught by Mr. Donald Doud, document examiner in private practice; Signatures - Back to Basics taught by Mr. Frankie E. Franck of the US Postal Inspection Service Crime Laboratory; Contrasting Defects of Forged & Genuine Signatures taught by Mr. Ordway Hilton, document examiner in private practice. Lithographic Materials: A Rochester Institute of Technology seminar on the interrelationship of inks, papers, plates, and fountain solutions taught by Dr. Julius Silver of the Rochester Institute of Technology; presented in conjunction with the Printing Industry of Metropolitan New York. 1983. PAGE 5 Identification of Photocopiers taught by Mr. James L. Lile of the FBI; a seminar/workshop given at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Albuquerque, NM, 1983. Problems of Questioned Documents: Their investigation and prosecution a seminar sponsored by the Criminal Justice Center, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, New York City, NY, 1981. Office Copier Workshop: A course for document examiners taught by Mr. James H. Kelly of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation Division of Forensic Sciences; given by the Forensic Science Foundation, given in Alexandria, VA, 1979. Forgery and Fraud Detection taught by Mr. Ron Dick, document examiner in private practice; given at the Institute of Criminal Law and Procedure, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1974. Conventional Typewriter Classification and Identification taught by Dr. David A. Crown of the CIA; given at the Institute of Criminal Law and Procedure, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1974. Problem Cases in Conventional Typewriting Examination taught by Dr. David A. Crown of the CIA; given at the Institute of Criminal Law and Procedure, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1974. PETER V. TYTELL Seminar on Paper and Its Analysis for Document Examiners taught by the staff; Institute of Paper Chemistry, Appleton, WI, 1973. Problems in Modern Document Photography, taught by Mr. Linton Godown, document examiner in private practice; a short course given at the Institute of Advanced Analytical Chemistry, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1973. Contemporary Typewriter Identification taught by Mr. Ordway Hilton, document examiner in private practice; a short course at the Institute of Advanced Analytical Chemistry, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1973. Seminar on Microspectrofluorometry given by Farrand Optical Co., Inc., Valhalla, NY, 1973. Document Microscopy taught by Mr. Joseph English, Institute of Criminal Law and Procedure; a short course given at the Institute of Advanced Analytical Chemistry, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1972. Principles of Color Technology taught by Prof. Fred W. Billmeyer, Jr. and Prof. Max Saltzman; a short course given at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY, 1972 Forensic Optical Microscopy taught by Prof. Mary L. Willard, professor emerita, Pennsylvania State University; a short course given at the Institute of Advanced Analytical Chemistry, Georgetown University, Washington, DC, 1971. PAGE 6 PROFESSIONAL PAPERS Some Contemporary Sources of Ultraviolet Radiation for Forensic Document Examination poster presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Philadelphia, PA, 2011. Another Look at Stereographic Images presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Victoria, BC, 2010. Pollution Solution? Suggested Identification and Possible Amelioration of a Potential Source of Contamination in Forensic Examinations presentation at the Joint Multidisciplinary Session of the Jurisprudence and Questioned Documents sections, American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2010 The Relationship of SWGDOC and ASTM Committee E 30 — How the Courts View ASTM Questioned Document Standards presentation as part of the workshop on “Standards in the Forensic Sciences: Their History, Development, and Impact on Laboratory Practice” chaired by Mr. John Lentini (also workshop co-chair); given at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Denver, CO, 2009. An Introduction to Typography for the Forensic Document Examiner mini-workshop at the 18th triennial meeting of the International Association of Forensic Sciences, New Orleans, LA, 2008. In-House Production of a Device for Producing Consistent Control Indentations for EDDs poster presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Boulder, CO, 2007. Reflections on the Proceedings of the 1931 Conference of Questioned Document Examiners presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Boulder, CO, 2007. The Polar Bears Secret: Use of polarizing filters in forensic document examination presentation at the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Atlanta, GA, 2006; also given at the 7th Annual Microscope Day at John Jay, presented by New York Microscopical Society and John Jay College, New York, NY, 2009. The Forensic Document Examinations in the Case Concerning Maritime Delimitation and Territorial Questions between Qatar and Bahrain at the International Court of Justice co-presented with Making Serendipity Happen by Dr. M. Beth Olsen, Senior Adviser to HE the Prime Minister’s Advisor for Legal Affairs, Court of the Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Bahrain (formerly Senior Adviser on Information Systems to HE the Minister of State (Agent before the ICJ) of the State of Bahrain); presentations at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Seattle, WA, 2006. Another Look Through Dicroic Filters poster presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Montreal, Que., 2005. PETER V. TYTELL AND PRESENTATIONS Keep Your IRL on the Ball: Some imaging and historiographic techniques for the examination of a baseball poster presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Memphis, TN, 2004. The Detection of Forgery and Fraud in International Council for Commercial Arbitration, International Commercial Arbitration: Important Contemporary Questions, Albert Jan van den Berg, general editor, with the assistance of the Permanent Court of Arbitration, The Hague; ICCA Congress series No. 11; The Hague: Kluwer Law International, 2003, pp. 314-324. Virtual Grids: A method to illustrate findings of forensic document examinations using word processing software paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Baltimore, MD, 2003. The Fundamental Things Apply: Some Concise Technical Comments Germane to the Forensic Document Examinations in the Case Concerning Maritime Delimitation and Territorial Questions between Qatar and Bahrain at the International Court of Justice presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, San Diego, CA, 2002. From the ForensX-Files: A partial account of certain aspects of the public debate over the nature of a purported memo from President Truman presentation at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Reno/Sparks, NV, 2000; presentation at the Mid-Atlantic Association of Forensic Scientists, Atlantic City, NJ, 2000. Unsuccessful Challenges to the Identification and Dating of Typewritten and Photocopied Documents. presentation as member of the panel on “The Impact of Daubert” at the Second International Symposium on the Forensic Examination of Questioned Documents, co-hosted by the FBI and NY State Police, Albany, NY, 1999. Forensic Document Examiners and their Critics informational presentation prepared for the Forensic Science Society, Documents Group meeting, London, UK, 1998. Microscopic Wonders: A new tool for the courtroom presentation at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, San Diego, CA, 1998; presentation (with additional material by Mr. Thomas Vastrick) at the “What’s New” session of the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Indianapolis, IN, 1998. Common Departures from Handwriting Copybook Standards: A Pilot Survey of the Pedagogical Literature (Ms. Rose Karpel principal author) paper presented at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, San Francisco, CA, 1998; poster presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Indianapolis, IN, 1998. PAGE 7 “What’s past is prologue” Approaches to the Examination of Documents Prepared on Contemporary Type Writing Machines keynote address at the Third International Congress of the Gesellschaft für Forensische Schriftuntersuchung, Lucerne, Switzerland, 1997; published in the “Commentary” column International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners, Vol. 3, No. 4 (1997) pp. 316–320; paper presented at the 25th annual meeting of the Northeastern Association of Forensic Scientists, Hyannis, MA, 1999. Pen Pressure as an Identifying Characteristic of Signatures: Verification from the computer paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Chicago, IL, 1995; published in the Journal of the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners, Vol. 1, No. 1 (1998) pp. 21-31; Vol. 2, No. 1 (1999) p. 56. QDs & DBs: Questioned documents and databases paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Long Beach, CA, 1994. Alphabet Soup in a Can: An updated introduction to a pilot project for a database of organizations and groups relative to individuals appearing in court as forensic document examiners paper presented at the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Atlanta, GA, 1994. The Relevance of Published Handwriting Instruction Texts to the Contemporary Document Examiner presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Ottawa, Ont., 1993. Imaging, Computers, and Documents: An incremental approach to building a system for the document examiner paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Milwaukee, WI, 1992. Questioned Document Examination in Czechoslovakia and Hungary: Observations on practice and training technical information presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Milwaukee, WI, 1992. The Use of Mechanical Design Characteristics of the Element for Class Differentiation of Single Element Typewriters with Similar Typeface Designs paper presented at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, New Orleans, LA, 1992. Defining the Terms ‘Class Characteristic’ and ‘Individual Characteristic’: A progress report on building a voluntary consensus standard terminology for questioned document examiners paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Lake Buena Vista, FL, 1991. Terminology for Questioned Document Examiners: An ongoing project for building a voluntary consensus standard: Defining ‘class’ and ‘individual’ characteristics paper presented at the American Academy of Forensic Sciences meeting, Anaheim, CA, 1991. What You See Is What You Get, But How Do You See What You’ve Got? a review of infrared viewing equipment published in The Southwestern Examiner, Vol. 9, No. 1 (1990). PETER V. TYTELL The Bad News Filters In a note on discontinuation of certain Kodak Wratten filters, published in The Southwestern Examiner, Vol. 9, No. 1 (1990). Handwriting Terminology for Questioned Document Examiners: A pilot project for building a voluntary consensus standard paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, San Jose, CA, 1990; published in the “Commentary” column International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners, Vol. 5 (1999) pp. 8–13. ‘Class’ and ‘Individual’ Characteristics and Related Concepts in Document Examination presentation as member of the panel on “The Philosophy of Identification Using Class and Individual Characteristics” at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Oakland, CA, 1989. Documents from Outer Space: An anachronistic type style and a transplanted signature in an ‘historical’ foundling document case presentation at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Oakland, CA, 1989. Transparencies and Acetate Overlays: Their use in the investigation and demonstration of questioned document problems paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Crystal City, VA, 1989; published in the International Journal of Forensic Document Examiners, Vol. 3, No. 4 (1997) pp. 370–374. Alphabet Soup, Second Helping or Next Week We’re Going to Get Organized: An updated introduction to a pilot project for a database of organizations and groups relative to individuals appearing in court as forensic document examiners paper presented at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Tucson, AZ, 1989. IR Video workshop presentation at the SWAFDE workshop session at the joint program of the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting and the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Aurora, CO, 1988. Alphabet Soup or Let’s Get Organized: An introduction to a pilot project for a database of organizations and groups relative to individuals appearing in court as forensic document examiners paper presented at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Sparks, NV, 1988. Pitfalls (and some basic principles) in the Examination of Documents Produced on Typewriters and Other Writing Machines technical presentation as invited guest speaker at the Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Milwaukee, WI, 1988. Keyboard Arrangements of Writing Machines: Their significance in document examination presentation at the 11th triennial meeting of the International Association of Forensic Sciences, meeting jointly with the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Vancouver, BC, 1987. PAGE 8 Determination of the Generation and Order of Preparation of a Photocopy case presentation at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Santa Fe, NM, 1987. Measurement Grids and the Contemporary Document Examiner technical presentation as invited guest speaker, MidAtlantic Association of Forensic Scientists, Alexandria, VA, 1987. Measurement Grids and the Contemporary Document Examiner paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Savannah, GA, 1986. Principles and Techniques of Typewriter Identification technical presentation as invited guest speaker at the Independent Association of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Toronto, Ont., 1986. Measuring Devices for the Contemporary Document Examiner technical presentation as invited guest speaker at the Independent Association of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Toronto, Ont., 1986. Lasers, Lamps, and Chemicals for Developing Fingerprints on Paper and Other Materials: Some information from IDENTA-’85 (The International Congress on Techniques for Criminal Identification and Counter-Terrorism), Jerusalem, Israel, February 24 28, 1985 technical information note prepared for distribution at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Montreal, Que., 1985. Production of Exhibits for Demonstrative Evidence technical presentation at the Evidence Photographers International Council seminar, New York City, NY, 1985. Computerization of Fraudulent Cheques Collection (Dr. Shmuel Kraus principal author) paper presented at IDENTA-’85 (The International Congress on Techniques for Criminal Identification and CounterTerrorism) Jerusalem, Israel, 1985. The Universal Torah Registry: A system for the unique identification of sacred torah scrolls (with Mr. David Pollock) paper presented at IDENTA’85, Jerusalem, Israel, 1985. Photographic Techniques for Questioned Documents technical presentation at a seminar of the Evidence Photographers International Council, Rochester, NY, 1984. It’s All Done with Mirrors: A technique for deciphering writing obliterated with opaqueing liquid paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Nashville, TN, 1984. Measurement and Overlay Plates for Typewriter Cases technical presentation as invited guest speaker at the World Association of Document Examiners regional meeting, Providence, RI, 1984. PETER V. TYTELL The Sign of Four: An empirical technique for identifying and dating typestyle design modifications paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Lake Tahoe, NV, 1983. Techniques for finding and illustrating ‘trash marks’ in a photocopy case (with additional comments by Mr. James H. Kelly) case presentation at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, Albuquerque, NM, 1983. Infrared Luminescence and Reflected Infrared: A comparative study of some imaging techniques technical presentation at the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners meeting, San Francisco, CA, 1983. Special Photographic Problems & Techniques for the Document Examiner (with Mr. George Pearl) technical presentation as invited guest speaker at the Independent Association of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Providence, RI, 1982. Basic Concepts in Typewriter Identification technical presentation as guest speaker at the Independent Association of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Springfield, IL, 1981. Photographing Questioned Documents technical presentation at a workshop of the Evidence Photographers International Council, Cherry Hill, NJ, 1981. Remington Single Element Type Styles paper presented at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting, Vancouver, BC, 1980. Graphic Techniques for the Presentation of Questioned Document Problems technical presentation at the Evidence Photographers International Council meeting, Chicago, IL, 1977. Macro & Infrared Viewing with Closed Circuit TV technical presentation at the American Society of Questioned Document Examiners meeting (“What’s New” session), San Francisco, CA, 1977. PAGE 9 PROFESSIONAL MEETINGS ATTENDED American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS), annual meetings: 2011 — Chicago, IL 2010 — Seattle, WA 2009 — Denver, CO 2008 — Washington, DC 2007 — San Antonio, TX 2006 — Seattle, WA 2005 — New Orleans, LA 2004 — Dallas, TX 1996 — Nashville, TN 1995 — Seattle, WA 1993 — Boston, MA 1992 — New Orleans, LA 1991 — Anaheim, CA 1990 — Cincinnati, OH 1988 — Philadelphia, PA 2003 — Chicago, IL 2002 — Atlanta, GA 2001 — Seattle, WA 2000 — Reno/Sparks, NV 1999 — Orlando, FL 1998 — San Francisco, CA 1997 — New York, NY American Society of Questioned Document Examiners (ASQDE), annual meetings: 2011 — Philadelphia, PA 2010 — Victoria, BC 2009 — Dearborn, MI 2008 — Asheville, NC 2007 — Boulder, CO 2005 — Montreal, Que. 2004 — Memphis, TN 2003 — Baltimore, MD 2002 — San Diego, CA 2001 — Des Moines, IA. 2000 — Ottawa, Ont. 1999 — Los Angeles, CA (with IAFS) 1998 — Indianapolis, IN 1997 — Scottsdale, AZ (Program Co-Chairman) 1996 — Washington, DC 1995 — Chicago, IL 1994 — Long Beach, CA 1993 — Ottawa, Ont. 1992 — Milwaukee, WI 1991 — Lake Buena Vista, FL 1990 — San Jose, CA 1989 — Crystal City, VA 1988 — Aurora, CO (with SWAFDE) 1987 — Vancouver, BC (with IAFS) 1986 — Savannah, GA 1985 — Montreal, Que. 1984 — Nashville, TN 1983 — Lake Tahoe, NV 1979 — Rochester, NY 1978 — Wichita, KS (with IAFS) 1977 — San Francisco, CA 1976 — Atlanta, GA 1974 — Milwaukee, WI 1973 — Silver Springs, MD Evidence Photographers International Council (EPIC), workshops and annual meetings: 1985 — New York City, NY 1984 — Rochester, NY 1981 — Cherry Hill, NJ 1977 — Chicago, IL, Mid-Atlantic Association of Forensic Scientists (MAAFS), annual meeting: 2000 — Atlantic City, NJ Northeastern Association of Forensic Scientists (NEAFS), annual meeting: 2006 — Rye Brook, NY 2003 — Pittsfield, MA 1999 — Hyannis, MA International Association for Identification (IAI), annual meeting: 1982 — Rochester, NY International Association of Forensic Sciences (IAFS), triennial meetings: 1984 — Oxford, England 1978 — Wichita, KS (with ASQDE) 1975 — Zurich, Switzerland 1972 — Edinburgh, Scotland 2008 — New Orleans, LA (Co-convener, QD section) 1999 — Los Angeles, CA (with ASQDE) 1993 — Düsseldorf, Germany 1987 — Vancouver, BC (with ASQDE) Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners (SAFDE), annual meeting: 2004 — Atlanta, GA 1995 — Atlanta, GA 1994 — Atlanta, GA Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners (SWAFDE), semiannual meetings: 2004 (Fall) — Golden, CO 1999 (Spring) — Las Vegas, NV 1998 (Spring) — San Diego, CA 1996 (Spring) — Reno, NV 1995 (Spring) — San Diego, CA 1992 (Fall) — Denver, CO 1991 (Fall) — Phoenix, AZ 1989 (Fall) — Oakland, CA 1988 (Fall) — Aurora, CO (with ASQDE) 1988 (Spring) — Sparks, NV 1987 (Spring) — Santa Fe, NM 1986 (Spring) — Denver, CO 1983 (Fall) — Albuquerque, NM 1983 (Spring) — San Francisco, CA The International Congress of the Gesellschaft für Forensische Schriftuntersuchung 1997 — Lucerne, Switzerland 1995 — The Hague, Netherlands Second International Symposium on the Forensic Examination of Questioned Documents, co-hosted by the FBI Laboratory Division and the New York State Police Forensic Investigation Center, Albany, NY, 1999. International Symposium on Fingerprint Detection & Identification — Ne’urim, Israel, 1995. KRIMINALEXPO ’92 — Modern Criminal Investigation and Modern Technology, Budapest, Hungary, 1992. Spectrum 91 — International Symposium on Forensic Techniques, Detroit, MI, 1991. IDENTA–’85 — The International Congress on Techniques for Criminal Identification and Counter-Terrorism, Jerusalem, Israel, 1985. Second International Conference on Forensic Activation Analysis, Glasgow, Scotland, 1972. PETER V. TYTELL PAGE 10 TEACHING AND The Investigator and the Prosecutor and the Document Examiner invited lecturer at the Federal Law Enforcement Forum, Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, White Plains, NY, 2010. Criminalistics for Poets: Learning to listen to the typescript a Small Press in the Archive presentation as invited guest lecturer, University at Buffalo, State University of New York, 2009. The Librarian and the Forensic Document Examiner in the Detection of Forgery and Fraud class lecture as invited guest lecturer for Information Services and Resources course, Pratt Institute, School of Information & Library Science, New York City, 2008. Review of the ASTM Guide for the Examination of Typewritten Items one day professional level workshop for crime laboratory personnel of the New York City Police Department and the New York State Police, given at the NYPD Lab, 2008. Forensic Document Examination, Part III: Mechanically Produced Documents (with John P. Osborn) lecture in a continuing legal education (C.L.E.) lecture series presented by the New York County District Attorney’s Office, Legal Training Unit, 2007. Forensic Document Examination guest lecturer, Graduate Student Seminar, Forensic Science Faculty, University of New Haven, (CT), 2006. An Introduction to Typography for the Forensic Document Examiner half-day workshop at the annual meeting of the Northeastern Association of Forensic Scientists, Newport, RI, 2005. The Forensic Document Examiner invited presenter for the panel on “Authenticity: Investigating documents and forgeries” at the annual meeting of the Investigative Reporters and Editors, Inc., Denver, CO. 2005. The Attorney and the Document Examiner in the Detection of Forgery and Fraud lecture for the attorneys in the Office of the Prosecutor for the Northern District, Nazareth, Israel, 2003. Questioned Documents invited presenter (lecture and labs) for Forensic Science Educational Conference/New York City, a collaborative project hosted by the American Academy of Forensic Science, Pace U., and Court TV, New York City, NY 2002. The Detection of Forgery and Fraud invited speaker for the program on International Commercial Arbitration: Important Contemporary Questions, 16th ICCA Congress, International Council for Commercial Arbitration, London, England, 2002. Typewriting Examinations and Classification Workshop (with Dr. Philip D. Bouffard and Mr. Robert J. Muehlberger) three day professional level workshop, cosponsored by the Southwestern Association of Forensic Document Examiners and the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners, Las Vegas, NV, 1999. VSC (Video Spectral Comparator) Training Course for the Customs Authority the People’s Republic of China (with Mr. Leslie Hawke of Foster & Freeman) professional level training course, presented by Foster & Freeman, Ltd. (UK), New York, NY, 1998. PETER V. TYTELL LECTURING Typewriting Examinations and Classification Workshop (with Dr. David A. Crown, and Mr. Robert J. Muehlberger) two day professional level workshop, co-sponsored by the Southeastern Association of Forensic Document Examiners and the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners, Atlanta, GA, 1995. Typewriting Examinations and Classification Workshop (with Dr. Philip D. Bouffard, Dr. David A. Crown, and Mr. Robert J. Muehlberger) three day professional level workshop, co-sponsored by the Midwestern Association of Forensic Scientists and the American Board of Forensic Document Examiners, Cleveland, OH, 1994. The Document Examiner and the Investigator training program for the staff of the Security Department of the New York Telephone Co., New York City, NY, 1992. Document Examination training program for attorneys and investigators of the New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate, Office of the Public Defender, Trenton, NJ, 1992. The Document Examiner and the Criminal Defense Attorney lecture with one hour of continuing legal education (C.L.E.) credit presented at the monthly meeting of the Criminal Courts Bar Association of Nassau County, Inc., 1992. Document Examination training program for attorneys and investigators of the New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate, Office of the Public Defender, Trenton, NJ, 1990. The Theory and Practice of Contemporary Writing Machine Identification course for crime laboratory personnel of the Department of Criminal Identification, Israel National Police, Jerusalem, Israel, 1989. Document Examination training program for attorneys and investigators of the New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate, Office of the Public Defender, Trenton, NJ, 1989. Document Examination lecture at the Forensic and Investigator Forum, presented by the New York State Defenders Association in cooperation with the Oneida County Public Defender Office and Hudson Valley Community College, Utica, NY, 1987. Document Examination training program for attorneys and investigators of the New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate, Office of the Public Defender, Trenton, NJ, 1987. Signature Verification training for selected personnel of Bankers Trust, New York City, NY, 1984. The Document Expert on the Stand class lecture as invited guest lecturer for Trial Techniques course, Pace University School of Law, Westchester, NY, 1983. Questioned Documents (with Pearl L. Tytell) lecture as part of Investigative Techniques course for Department of Social Services personnel given by the Center for Productive Public Service, John Jay College of Criminal Justice, New York City, NY, 1979. Typewriter Identification short course for crime laboratory personnel, Dade County Department of Public Safety, Miami, FL, 1978. Line Intersections short course for crime laboratory personnel, Dade County Department of Public Safety, Miami, FL, 1978. Typewriters: Mechanical principles and identification short course presented at the Questioned Document Seminar/Workshop meeting of the Southern Association of Forensic Sciences, Atlanta, GA, 1977. PAGE 11 CONSULTATIONS Law Enforcement United States Department of Justice Anti-Trust Division Organized Crime Strike Force Office of Special Investigations United States Attorney’s Office District of New Jersey Eastern District of New York Southern District of New York District of Vermont These cases involved investigators and/or agents from various agencies, including: Dept. of Agriculture Customs Service Dept. of Defense Drug Enforcement Administration Federal Aviation Administration Federal Bureau of Investigation Dept. of Health, Education & Welfare Immigration & Naturalization Service Internal Revenue Service Dept. of Labor, Office of Labor Racketeering Postal Inspection Service Dept. of Transportation United States Department of State Office of International Claims & Investment Disputes State of New York Office of the Attorney General Criminal Prosecutions Bureau Office of the District Attorney Kings County New York County Suffolk County Prosecutor for the Northern District, Israel Florida Department of Law Enforcement, Pensacola Regional Crime Laboratory Wisconsin State Crime Laboratory, Madison Royal Canadian Mounted Police Israel National Police Landeskriminalamt Baden-Wurttemburg, (Baden-Wurttemburg (Germany) State Crime Laboratory) Legal Aid Societies, Public Defenders, etc. Federal Defender Services Eastern District of New York Southern District of New York Legal Aid Societies (New York State) Bronx County (Criminal) Nassau County (Criminal) New York County (Civil & Criminal) Nassau/Suffolk Law Services Committee, Inc. New Jersey Department of the Public Advocate Office of the Public Defender New York State Defenders Association New York State Capital Defender Office Community Law Offices Harlem Assertion of Rights, Inc. Hofstra University School of Law Community Legal Assistance Corp. Housing Rights Clinic Other Clients and Consultations American International Realty, Corp. American International Group, Inc. (AIG) State of Bahrain (Qatar v. Bahrain, ICJ) Barnard College Barnes Foundation Chase Manhattan Bank Chemical Bank Con Edison Cooper-Hewitt Museum (typewriter history) Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc. Extebank Forensic Accountants, Inc. Forensic Control Systems Government Employees Insurance Co. (GEICO) Heidelberg Eastern, Inc. Kroll Associates Lancer Productions (“Kennedy/Monroe” papers) PETER V. TYTELL Yoko Ono Lennon Macy’s and Macy’s Northeast Maher Terminals, Inc. Michigan Consolidated Gas Company The Morgan Library & Museum Thaw Conservation Center (IR imaging) MorganStanley National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) New York City Campaign Finance Board New York Philharmonic Society New York Telephone Company New York Times North Fork Bank Rutgers, the state university of New Jersey Sony Music Entertainment (Germany), GmbH. United Federation of Teachers United Nations PAGE 12 CONSULTATIONS New York State Law Firms Ainsworth Sullivan Tracy Knauf Warner & Ruslander Alston & Bird Baker & McKenzie Beldock Levine & Hoffman Benetar Bernstein Schair & Stein Bingham McCutchen Bryan Cave Bryan Levitin Franzino & Rosenberg Cahn Wishod Wishod & Lamb Cooper Erving Savage Whalen Nolan & Heller Curtis Mallet-Prevost Colt & Mosle Davis Polk & Wardwell Derfner & Mahler Duker Barrett Gravante & Markel Edwards & Angell Ellen Grossman & Schole Engel & Mulholland Emmet Marvin & Martin Epstein Becker & Green Fensterman & Fensterman Fischetti & Russo Fish & Richardson Friedman & Gass Friedman & Shaftan Gair Gair Conason Steigman & Mackauf Gaston & Snow Graubard Moskovitz McGoldrick Dannett & Horowitz Hill Betts & Nash Jones Day Reavis & Pogue Kaye Scholer Fierman Hays & Handler Kelley Drye & Warren Kellner Chehebar & Deveney Kenyon & Kenyon Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel Kronish Lieb Weiner & Hellman Lane & Mittendorf Leahey & Johnson Liotti & Skelos Lord Day & Lord, Barrett Smith Marks Murase & White Meyer Suozzi English & Klein Migdal Pollack Rosenkrantz & Sherman Millbank Tweed Hadley & McCloy Montfort Healy McGuire & Salley Moses & Singer Newman Schwartz & Greenberg Obermaier Morvillo & Abramowitz Paul Weiss Rifkind Wharton & Garrison Patterson Belknap Webb & Tyler Pavia & Harcourt Pollack & Greene Proskauer Rose Goetz & Mendelsohn Rosner & Goodman RubinBaum Schillinger & Finsterwald Schwartzfeld Ganfer Shore & Rosenblum Seyfarth Shaw Fairweather & Geraldson Shea & Gould Siff Rosen Simpson Thacher & Bartlett Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom Solomon Zauderer Ellenhorn Frischer & Sharp Sonnenschein Nath & Rosenthal Spota O’Rourke & Ammerman Stillman Friedman & Shaw Stroock Stroock & Lavan Sullivan & Liapakis Summit Rovins & Feldesman Vladek Waldman Elias & Englehard Walter Conston Alexander & Green Weiss Buell & Bell White & Case Willkie Farr & Gallagher Whitman Breed Abbott & Morgan Out of State Law Firms Berger & Montague, Philadelphia, PA Berwin Leighton, London, England Bilbie Whitford & Dan, Newcastle, NSW, Australia Blank Rome Comisky & McCauley, Philadelphia, PA Bonner Kiernan Trebach & Crociata, Washington, DC Bradshaw Fowler Proctor & Fairgrave, Des Moines, IA Buchanan Ingersoll, Pittsburg, PA Carpenter Bennett & Morrissey, Newark, NJ Clifford Chance, Hong Kong Crowell & Moring, Washington, DC Cohen Shapiro Polisher Shiekman & Cohen, Philadelphia, PA Connell Foley & Geiser, Roseland, NJ Dilworth Paxon, Philadelphia, PA Fishman Franzblau & Falkin, Roseland, NJ Fleming Merrill & Roth, Newark, NJ Freshfields, London, England; Paris, France Fulbright & Jaworski, Houston, TX Garruto Galex & Cantor, East Brunswick, NJ Goldstein & Manello, Boston, MA Greenberg Margolis Ziegler Schwartz Dratch, Roseland, NJ Greene & Markley, Portland, OR Hogan & Hartson, Washington, DC Johnson Stokes & Master, Hong Kong Keck Mahin & Cate, Chicago, IL PETER V. TYTELL Landau and Scanlan, London, England Lowenstein Sandler Kohl Fisher & Boylan, Roseland, NJ Lum Hoens Abeles Conant & Danzis, Newark, NJ; Roseland, NJ MacElree Harvey, West Chester, PA Mayer Brown, Houston, TX McCutchen Doyle Brown & Enersen, San Francisco, CA McKenzie Martin Taylor & McConnaughey, Atlanta, GA Morrison & Foerster, Orange Co., CA; San Francisco, CA Murphy Taylor Siemens & Elliott, St. Joseph, MO Paterson Lorentzen Duffield Timmons Irish Becker & Ordway, Des Moines, IA Pepper Hamilton & Scheetz, Philadelphia, PA Peterson & Bernard, Ft. Lauderdale, FL Pillsbury Madison & Sutro, San Francisco, CA Riker Danzig Scherer Hyland & Perretti, Morristown, NJ Secretan Troyanov, Geneva, Switzerland Seyfarth Shaw, Boston, MA Skadden Arps Slate Meagher & Flom, Wilmington, DE Smith Mullin & Kiernan, West Orange, NJ Steefel Levitt & Weiss, San Francisco, CA Sulloway & Hollis, Concord, NH Townsend & Townsend, San Francisco, CA Venable Baetjer Howard & Civiletti, Washington, DC PAGE 13 APPEARANCES AS AN EXPERT FEDERAL Eastern District of New York 6/19, 20/78 6/26, 27/78 1/18/79 4/20/79 3/6, 10/80 8/29/80 2/13, 17/81 3/2, 3/81 6/18/81 12/1/81 1/20/82 4/27/82 9/17/82 11/25/83 6/27/85 9/20/85 9/30/85 1/3, 6/86 1/14/86 1/27/86 2/5/86 10/27, 28/86 1/15/87 3/2/87 9/14/87 9/22, 23, 28/87 12/17/87 1/11/88 1/28/88 3/8/88 3/24, 25/88 3/28/88 8/1/88 10/5/88 4/27/89 5/17, 18/89 10/11/89 11/20/89 5/23/90 8/23/91 10/9, 11/91 8/10/92 5/19/93 1/31/94 6/21/94 6/16/95 9/13/95 3/4/96 3/13/96 5/22/96 7/24/96 8/6/96 4/29/97 1/21/98 10/2/00 12/4/01 1/22/02 1/28, 29/02 9/30/02 11/12/02 4/21/03 12/31/03 2/7/05 12/5, 13/07 Judge George C. Pratt Judge J. F. Dooling, Jr. Judge Edward R. Neaher Judge Edward R. Neaher Chief Judge Jacob Mishler Senior Judge Jacob Mishler Judge Eugene H. Nickerson Chief Judge Jack B. Weinstein Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Eugene H. Nickerson Judge Mark Costantino Judge Joseph M. McLaughlin Chief Judge Jack B. Weinstein Senior Judge Jacob Mishler Judge Eugene H. Nickerson Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Francis X. Altimari Judge Eugene H. Nickerson Judge I. Leo Glasser Judge Herbert N. Maletz Judge Henry Bramwell Judge Herbert N. Maletz Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Henry Bramwell Judge I. Leo Glasser Judge Joseph M. McLaughlin Senior Judge John R. Bartels Judge Raymond J. Dearie Judge I. Leo Glasser Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Mark Costantino Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Raymond J. Dearie Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Charles P. Sifton Chief Judge Thomas C. Platt Judge Joseph M. McLaughlin Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Charles P. Sifton Judge Gerald E. Rosen Senior Judge Jacob Mishler Judge Robert R. Merhige Judge Raymond J. Dearie Judge Raymond J. Dearie Judge Howard B. Turrentine Judge David G. Trager Senior Judge Jacob Mishler Judge John Gleeson Judge Reena Raggi Judge Sterling Johnson Judge Allyne R. Ross Judge Reena Raggi Judge Arthur D. Spatt Judge Carol Amon Magistrate Judge J. M. Levy Judge David G. Trager Judge Sterling Johnson Judge Reena Raggi Judge Allyne R. Ross Judge I. Leo Glasser Judge Nicholas G. Garaufis Judge Nina Gershon Judge Nicholas G. Garaufis Judge Joanna Seybert US v. Wilson (78 CR 178) HW, HP, SI, SO. US v. Diaz (77 CR 644) SO, SI. Hudson Transit Lines v. Freund et al. (76 CV 1836) SO, SI. Deutsch v. Raffles (75 CV 697) TW. US v. Mesa-Valencia, et al. (79 CR 578 (S)) HW, HP, NM, ES. US v. Vogwill, et al. ((80 CR 320) HW, HP, SI, SO. US v. Shurkman (80 CR 460) SI, HW, HP, DI. US v. Muni (80 CR 683) CR, SI, SO. US v. Qumar (81 CR 113) HW, HP, DI. US v. Cefalu (81 CR 373 (S)) HP. US v. Sosnowski (81 CR 430) HW, HP, RS, PC, LI. US v. Alvarado (81 CR 688 (S)) HW, HP, NM. US v. Maniego (82 CR 237 (S)) HP, SI. US v. Faragasso (83 CR 124 (S)) SI, SO, HP. US v. Metz (85 CR 64) HW, HP, NM, SI, SO, TW, PR, RS. US v. Pignatalli (85 CR 250) SI. US v. McKay (85 CR 364) AL, IR, IK. US v. Williams (85 CR 514 (S)) TW, AL, PC. US v. Levasseur (85 CR 143) DE. US v. Salstein (84 CR 586 (S)) HW, HP, NM, ID, ES. US v. Viana (85 CR 721) HW, HP, NM, FF, PA. US v. Pinto (85 CR 491 S) HW, HP, NM. US v. Sorrentino (85 CR 757 (S2)) HW, HP, NM, SI, SO. US v. Balbin (86 CR 598) HW, HP, NM, DI. US v. Fulton (87 CR 260 (S)) NM, HP. US v. Santa Cruz, et al. (85 CR 598 (S)) HW, HP, NM, IN, SO, DI, CD. US v. Arrango, et al. (87 CR 179 (S)) HW, HP, NM, FF, PK. US v. Hernandez (87 CR 608) HW, HP, NM, DI. Vargas v. Correa (86 CV 3001) AG, DA, TW, PC, SI. US v. Gutierez-Barranco, et al. (87 CR 779) HW, HP, NM, ES. US v. Franco, et al. (87 CR 585) HW, HP, NM, DI. US v. Campino, et al. (87 CR 816) HW, HP, NM. US v. Tonge (88 CR 196 (S)) HW, HP, NM, SI, DI. US v. Marzouca, et al. (88 CR 377) HP, NM. US v. Wood, et al. (88 CR 723) HP, NM. US v. Mickens, et al. (88 CR 309 (S2)) SI, SO HP, NM. US v. Upfalow (89 CR 314 ) SO. US v. Acosta-Herrera (88 CR 658) HP, NM. US v. Jackson aka Simon (90 CR 216) SO, HW, NM. US v. Mapoma (91 CR 109) CS, CW, TW, SI, SO, NM. US v. Deutsch (91 CR 573) SI, SO, HW, HP. US v. Perez (91 CR 680) SI, HW, NM. US v. Miller, et al. (92 CR 91) HW, HP, NM. US v. Freund (93 CR 712) ST, ID, ES, IK, PR. US v. Chica (94 CR 406) SI, HW, HP, NM. US v. Ortiz (94 CR 389) SI, SO, HP, NM, TW. US v. Busiello (95 CR 481) HP, NM, SO, DI. US v. Burnett (95 CR 272) HP, NM. US v. Aviles Laguardia and Diaz (95 CR 579) HW, HP, NM. US v. Tejada (95 CR 961) HP, NM, SI. US v. Friedman, et al. (95 CR 192) HW, HP, NM, SI, SO. US v. Beras (96 CR 89) HW, HP, NM, SI. US v. Sommerstein, et al. (96 CR 657) HW, HP. US v. Hall (97 CR 680) SI, HW, HP. Strauss v. Envelope Mfrs., et al. (98 CV 6320) (hearing) AL. Strauss v. Envelope Mfrs., et al. (98 CV 6320) IK, ID, IR, IS, AL, AG. US v. O’Kane (99 CR 536) HP, NM. US v. Califano, et al. (01 CR 56) HW, HP, NM, IR, AL, TS. US v. Ramos (01 CR 15) HP. US v. Santoro (01 CR 416 (S-6)) AL, LI, LP, PC. US v. Damti, et al. (02 CR 471 (S–1)) HP, NM, IN, SI, SO. US v. Lugo (01 CR 922 (S–7)) HW, DI. US v. Pressley, et al. (03 CR 297) HP, NM. US v. Persico, et al. (04 CR 911) HW, HP, NM. APPEARANCES AS AN EXPERT FEDERAL Southern District of New York 3/29/78 6/6/78 10/10/80 11/5/81, 1/4, 5/82 1/12, 13/82 5/17/82 5/8/89 2/7, 14/90 12/17/91 6/8, 9, 10/98 4/21, 22/99 5/30/06 Judge Gerald L. Goettel Judge Richard Owen Judge Lee P. Gagliardi Judge Robert L. Carter Judge Morris E. Lasker Judge Robert L. Carter Judge Thomas P. Griesa Judge John F. Keenan Judge Charles M. Metzner Judge Lawrence M. McKenna Judge Denise Cote Judge Paul A. Crotty 5/31/07 Judge Richard M. Berman 7/15/08 Judge John G. Koeltl Northern District of New York 10/27/87 Chief Judge Howard G. Munson District of New Jersey 11/22/91 12/6/91 1/20, 21, 28, 29/93 2/10/99 10/26/04 Judge H. Lee Sarokin Judge John C. Lifland Judge H. Lee Sarokin Judge Robert H. Rodriguez Judge Jose L. Linares District of Massachusetts 10/21/03 Judge Rya W. Zobel District of Vermont 4/7/92 Judge Franklin S. Billings, Jr. Bankruptcy Court Southern District of New York 8/7/00 Judge Richard L. Bohanon US v. Munoz (77 CR 644) TS, TW, TP. US v. Munoz (77 CR 644) TS, TW, TP. US v. Cora (80 CR 452) HW, HP. Hibernia National Bank v. Banco Atlantico, SA AL, IS, LI, PC. US v. Masseria (81 CR 730) SI, SO, HW, HP, DI. US v. John Levasseur HP, NM. US v. Davis, et al. (87 CR 853(SSSSS)) HW, HP, NM. US v. Evans, (89 CR 362(SS)) ES, PC, MT, HW. Talibon v. Duffany, (88 CV 856) SI, SO, HP, NM, ES. US v. King, et al. (94 CR 455(S)) TS, TW, DA. US v. Cusack (98 CR 691) DA, TS, TW, CC, DE. Procter & Gamble Pharmaceuticals, et al. v. Hoffmann LaRoche, et al. (06 CV 34) HW, SI, PA, IK, ER, IR. Dear Cinestudi S.p.A. v. International Media Films, Inc., et al. (03 CV 3038) DA, TS, LP, TW, IK. Ragone v. Atlantic Video, et al. 2007 CV 6048 HW, HP, NM. US v. Oswego Asphalt Corp. Banc One Leasing v. L.T.D. Enterprises (88 CV 4660) SI, DI, LI. US v. McCann (91 CR 347) TW, CL, IN. US v. Torres, et al. (91 CR 394) SI, SO, HW, HP, NM, DE, IR. US v. Porro, et al. (96 CR 420) DA, PC, IJ. US v. Nardone, et. al. (03 CR 327) TS, TW. Brienze v. Prudential Securities, Inc. (02 CV 11715), US v. Bloomer (91 CR 81) 9/1/11 4/3/01 4/5/06 3/5/08 3/31/11 SI, ST, PC. In re: Jeno & Helen Mann In re: FAA — JFK Airport frauds In re: Defense Dept. frauds SI, SO, HW, HP. HW, HP, NM, SI, SO, RS, PR, TW. HW, HP, NM, SI, SO, IR, AL, MT, PC. In re: John Doe (Attanasio, et al) In re: SEC investigation HW, HP, NM, SI, SO. SI, SO, ID, ES. Depositions Middle District of Florida 12/8/98 SI, HP, NM. TS, TW, TP, ID. Re: Vytautus Vebeliunas (99-2379) Grand Jury Eastern District of New York 3/16/82 5/3/84 4/29/86 12/11/86, 3/12/87, 4/16/87 10/2/96 HP, NM, IK. Commerce Bank, N.A., et al. v. Ogden, Newell & Welch, et al. (94-51-CV-J-16A) Western District of Michigan Bassali v. Johnson Controls, Inc. (1:08-CV-00029) Southern District of New York TW, TS, AG, DA, CC, PC. TW, IS. Agnes Trouble v. The Wet Seal, Inc. (99 CV 10997) HW. Procter & Gamble Pharmaceuticals, et al. v. Hoffmann LaRoche, et al. (06 CV 34) HW, SI, PA, IK, ER, IR. Covina 2000 Ventures, et al. v. Merrill Lynch, et al. (06 CV 15497) SI. Abraham Leser v. US Bank National Assn. Civil Action No. 1:09 CV 02362 (KAM-ALC) SI, ES. APPEARANCES AS AN EXPERT NEW YORK Supreme Court New York County 4/4, 5/77 8/15, 18, 19/80 8/26/82 8/8/85 4/27, 6/1/92 1/17/95 8/28/95 10/28/97 1/25/08 10/19/82 8/16/89 11/29/77 12/21/77 9/3/87 Judge Gelanoff Tirado v. Sachs (5532/77) SI, SO. heard by Referee Lloyd Paperno Referee Hurowitz Gruskin v. Board of Elections (15342/80) SI, SO, PR, PA. Referee Sheehan Berlin v. Kirby SI, SO. Judge Joan B. Carey People v. Rifkin (7933/84) SI (Hebrew). Judge Elliott Wilk Klein v. Klein (78573/87) SI, PC. Judge Lewis R. Friedman Haymes v. Haymes (10815/90) SI, PC, TW, AL, IS. Judge Lewis R. Friedman Deutsch v. Deutsch (72326/92) PC, TS, TW. Judge Ira Gammerman Segall, et al. v. Nelkin (601386/97) PC, MT. heard by Special Master Lewis Crespo Judge Ira Gammerman Baje Realty v. Cutler et al. v. Bianco et al. (19205/90) AG, DA, SI. Kings County Justice Eugene Berkowitz Justice Samuel Greenstein Nassau County Justice Mario Pittoni Justice James F. Niehoff Justice Alfred S. Robbins Suffolk County 10/22/92 11/16–17/95 8/24/71 5/21/74 4/11/77 6/13, 21/95 6/24/97 3/20/80 5/19/87 Justice Patrick Henry Justice Arthur G. Pitts Queens County Justice Leo Brown Justice Ann B. Dufficy Justice Martin Rodell Justice Edwin Kassoff Justice Sidney Leviss Bronx County Referee John Buckley Justice Antonio I. Brandveen Surrogate’s Court New York County 11/7/79 6/21, 24/91 Surrogate Marie M. Lambert Queens County Surrogate Louis D. Laurino Landlord & Tenant Court New York County 3/21, 25, 26/80 12/5/91 4/14, 15/97 Judge Ira Gammerman Judge Jane S. Solomon Bronx County Judge Debra Rose Samuels Beaty v. Owens (22211/82) Pellegrio v. Giuliani (19100/89) Bodner v. Booksin Koden v. Katz, et al Shickler v. Nassau Trust Judge Carolyn E. Wade Stein v. Zelman SI, SO. Bauso v. Bauso SI. In re: Capalazzi Petition SI, SO. Fidelity New York FSB v. Efraimov, et al. (13557/91) SI. P&F Trucking, Inc. v. Carol Ceparano as executrix (12779/91) SI. Azur v. Ortiz (7269/80) People v. Rodriguez (407/86) 4/24/03 SI, TW, PC, NM. EDSCO v. Mandelbaum Terranova v. Nackab (Index # 88795/91) TW. ES, IR. 3411 Loeser Realty v. Jerome Ave. Party Center. (76348/96) SI, RS. Manna v. Albano, et al. (08K077477) In re: Ada Messina MT, FX, SI. HW, HP, NM, SI, SO, TW, PC, DE. In re: People v. John Doe ICMS #F2002–004426 Suffolk County In re: Suffolk Co. sewer fraud AL, PC, SI. TW. Depositions Supreme Court, New York County 5/23, 25/07 SI, AL, AG, TW, DA, PA, ST, IS. The Estate of Harry L. Kohn (5629/89) New York County 5/17/79, 6/14/79 SI, SO. SI, HP, NM, LI. The Estate of Benjamin Broudy Grand Jury Kings County 10/8/76 TW. AL, PC. AL, IS, CC, CL, TW, LI. Extebank v. Max Cohen & Sam Antar (88-13121) SI. People v. Grieco (95-993223) SI, PC, PR, TP, TW. Civil Court of the City of New York Kings County: Commercial Part 6/15/09 SI, SO. AL, IK, IR Emanuel Hirsch, et al. v. Food Resources, Inc., et al.(602964/04) SI, AL, PC, PA. NEW JERSEY Superior Court, Passaic County — Law Division 5/19/94 Judge Christine L. Miniman Jackobovics v. Polymeric Resources, et al. (L–84225–87)AL, MT, TS, TW. Depositions Superior Court, Morris County — Chancery Division 4/23/04 Beaumont v. Huff-Mendez (C–206–03) SI, AL. APPEARANCES AS AN EXPERT MICHIGAN Superior Court, Detroit 3/13/74 Judge Kaufman Sloan v. Sloan AG, TS, TW, DA. MISSOURI Circuit Court, Buchanan County — Division No. 4 5/13/09 Senior Judge Michael J. Maloney Janovec v. Larkin, et al. (07BU–CV04380) TW, SI, SO, ID. Depositions 11/19/08 Janovec v. Larkin, et al. (07BU–CV04380) TW, SI, SO, ID. PENNSYLVANIA Court of Common Pleas, Delaware County — Orphans’ Court Division 3/11/10 Pres. Judge Joseph P. Cronin, Jr. In re the Estate of Anthony A. Martino, deceased (463/08) SI. Court of Common Pleas, Montgomery County — Orphans’ Court Division 7/28/98 Judge Stanley R. Ott In re The Barnes Foundation (58,788) Disciplinary Board of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania 9/25/00 In re Anonymous (22DB1999; 48DB2000) AG, TS, TW, CC, DA, TP, ID. AG, TS, TW, DA, CP, LP, PR. AUSTRALIA Supreme Court of New South Wales, Sydney Registry — Equity Division 2/23/94 Mr. Justice Hulme Edward Lunn, et al. v Leslie Savage et al. (3047/89) AG, CC, DA, IK, IR, PA, TP, TS, TW. HONG KONG High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Court of First Instance 10/17–19/01 Mr. Justice Yam Wang Din Shin v Nina Kung (alias Nina T. H. Wang) In re the Estate of Wang Teh Huei. (P8 of 1999) AG, IK, DA. ISRAEL District Court, District of Nazareth 12/1, 3/03 Judge Abraham Abraham State of Israel v. Melamed (1157/02 CR) SO, IK, ID, ES, PC, MT. AMERICAN ARBITRATION ASSOCIATION 4/16/79 Arbitrator Stanley Aiges 5/11/94 Arbitrator Rodney Dennis 4/11/00 Arbitrator William Spiro United Telecommunications Workers and New York Telephone Co. (Telco Case # A 78-90) Re: Discharge of Karen Shugrue AL, LI. The Woodlawn Cemetery and The Cemetery Workers and Greens Attendants Union, Local 365, SEIU, AFL-CIO (13-300-01560-90) HP, DE, IR, DI. Fuks v Shomron, et al. (13-180-01162-97) AL, PC, MT, TW. INTERNATIONAL CENTRE FOR THE SETTLEMENT OF INVESTMENT DISPUTES Mr. Michael Hwang, S.C., President of the Tribunal; Mr. Henri C. Alvarez, Q.C. and Sir Franklin Berman, Q.C., Arbitrators Libananco Holdings Co. Ltd v. Republic of Turkey (Case No. ARB/06/8) 11/5/09 (ICSID) ES, ID, RS. NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 2/13/97 5/1/97 1/9/04 5/16/06 12/19/06 OF SECURITIES DEALERS Chairman Simon S. Kogan, Esq. Palmatier v. Barberis and Smith Barney, Inc. (94-05493) SI, IR, ES. Chairman Mr. David E. Robbins Hardoon, et al. v. Marsh Block, et al. (94-05186) Mr. Paul E. Barr and Mr. Harry Weiss, Panelists FX, MT. Chairman Grupp Metro Equip., et al. v. Morgan Stanley Dean Witter (01–05369) Messrs. Gilbert and Hogan, Panelists DA, IK, IR, ID, ES, HW, HP. Chairman Ira Auerbach O’Brien v. PKS and Valente (05-01834) NM. Chairman Alan Shaw, Esq. Chiam Levin v. GFI Securities, Inc., et al. (02-03848) John Astorina, Esq. and Louis Miron, Esq., Panelists PC, IN, MT. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD 3/28/91 New York County Judge Raymond Green Liquid Carriers Corp. and Local 333 United Marine Division, ILA, AFL-CIO (2CA22969, 2CA23896) IK, IR. ————————————————————————————————— AG AL CC CL CD CP CR CS CW DA Age of documents Alterations Carbon copy Carbonless copy Counterfeit document Computer printer Credit card embosser Checksigner Checkwriter Dating a document DE DI ER ES FF FX HW HP ID IJ Decipherment Disguise Erasure ESDA (indentations) Fracture fit Fax Handwriting Handprinting Indentations Inkjet printer IN IK IR IS LI LP MT NM PA PC Initials Ink Infra-red Insertions Line intersections Laser printer Montage Numerals Paper Photocopier PK PR RS SI SO ST TP TS TW Paper knife striæ Printing Rubber stamp Signature (own) Signature (other’s) Staples Typist Type style Typewriter

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?