MCFADYEN et al v. DUKE UNIVERSITY et al

Filing 279

REPLY, filed by Defendant DUKE UNIVERSITY, to Response to #271 MOTION for Protective Order on Confidentiality and Prospective Sealing Order filed by DUKE UNIVERSITY. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A- Email from Wells to Ekstrand, #2 Exhibit B- Email from Ekstrand to Ellis, #3 Exhibit C- Email from Wells to Ekstrand, #4 Exhibit D- Email from Sun to Ekstrand, #5 Exhibit E- Email from Sun to Ekstrand, #6 Exhibit F- Letter from Smith to Segars dated May 3, 2012)(SUN, PAUL)

Download PDF
([KLELW )   !"   !" 7  #  $        024 2890 1 6 13567 7 6 %& !'   &!   "( ')*! ' !     +,,-.  0&  34 0- / 012& 2.  / 012& 2.  50&  34 0& 61 297 455 121  7 4 7 @A CDCEFGHIA 8BA B6 E6 D6 FJ LNO6 K6M9P CQPS6 UMPD W Q6 TRVO6D 6 R FJ LNOYMQZRVOXJ KXM9P QP UMP K6 R [ \ 896<>= :;6 ?6 = ]2\_`bdf\\ik\ n\ perde\i\ ^\ acegh jj e kqhgh j\ \ eb\ lm of p \ bg s7uwyzx|7 7 9 vx {}~ t €sy \ ‚MO Kƒ 96 6 FJ 6 F„PQVOPR6PJP66JO6‡ O6ˆ6>=6‰OVV„P…RVUV 6MMR R MV66 O …UMV:†PJ6 R=< ?X6R 66R JU66KMV O66 6 MR U M J B… Q = 6 P9V 6 R R „ P U6JO6OMM6OV[RMJŠO †QRNVM…JM†MONORNK9ŒU6J‡MVQ J[†V ŠOŠ…JMV 6OM6 VUU6 6O[ŠO6 9ŠU6 ORN[UR UR6 J ‹ JR „ M Š 9 ŠPUVUX8:†ŠOVURNZ9696†6V†9RU6NORN[URMVQMRUVU6 MR 9R P6 6UMP9ŠU6 PV V O R QV PO 9ŠU6J‡ UR6 P 9R P N J6 „ J P… J M Š 9Š N J ŠO N8OBO„O6MJRJ6 O6QPŽMVJVM…URN…JMVMJŠOJŽ6PM6: †R 6 X [MŠ…PRUZMM9Q†[66 6MŠU6OV[R 6OM66MR†ŠŽ6 U 6 P V 6 V„ ‹ V P VMEJOX6 „6 †V6 66 6 J6PMV„V X [MŠ…PRUZ96‹RŽMJ6 O6;6>=6 Œ6 P6 †9PO696 6 „O6MJRJ6 P99Q Q6UB…R=< ?X‚†MK†V V 8OBO P V 9 Q = 6 „‹6‘MRŠVM…J†VUJ6 X [MV9PO V6 6 6UMP9ŠVM[K…U696 9MM…ŠV 6 6OŠ[R 6‡ 6 „O6 U[RXBPZM†ŠOVU6 6J 9:V V M„ J 8OBO PO …6 „ „ …JRM6M[†VMJVOU6M‹[P‡O X [MŠ…PRUV…[Q6966MJRJ6 O‹ŠŠV 6JO6…OM6 ŠPORM6 6 6 „O6MJRJ6 R9Q„P9Š…PRU „ O 9 J 8OBO P V : : V V9PO V‹RŽM’?69P‡QZRNVMŠ…PRU6O OJ:†6VOZMZMMUVZ9M OU[R6 9Q Q6“>Š:6 Q U6 6MJRJX R 66JOMV< 6 O6J6 O6 …9 9 JJ „ V W J V Q M6 9 V96MŠ…PRUZJQ6M99QŽMMOM696MUO Q“>Š:XT„Q6J6O6JO[6 „V„6MJRJ6 †ŠŽ6‹R Q69QO„UV 6JK96?69P6 R :†9M[OMV V V 9 RV „ ’ 6 M R696†6JRJ696MUV96>Š:6 QZRNVMO[RV‡„69PO VPMJN6KM UV V O PRU„PŽM6 V 69P‡ Q U6 6 M…6 6MVU[R66U†„V 6 „J… V „ ? JJ „ M J V O …R R V6 Œ6J‡MVQMRUVU<„P9PORUZ96J69M6U…:U6UM…ŠVŠ‡M‡O JK9M[UR UR6 P 9R PVR PMV 6 PUV PŠJ69RN96‘MR 6 6 6 Š 9Š N J 6 6 J Ž MMJ VM…J†VUJ6MV9PO V6 UM6 V6†6O…PŠV QMJ6>Š:<J‡MVQ „6OŠ[R 6‡„6 U[RX”M[< „JO JJM6KMR 6‡ 69P[UR UR6 J V O …6 ZR … R U ? 6 Š 9 ŠPUVU6 †ŠV…[Q6MŠM?“>Š:6 QZRN9Š…PRU6 Š:PZMŠ6RŒ MR 9R PZJQ6 R9QŽ6†6’=69P‡ Q U66MJRJXBU6M< 6JVU6 N J : : JJ V 6 6 „ ?“>Š:66O[R96U6‹OV‹OJO O…PŠ;69PZ„[6PMVQ6 †ŠŽ6’ ’=69PR…9V Q Š‡ J66 M6 †6 JJM6>Š:< R„MPURQZJQ6M;“ P [ 9 9 RJ : … 6 9: •69P‡QZRN9Š…PRU6 >Š:6 Q U66MJRJX6 JJ V 6 6 BPA9V†9M6†RN8OBO„O6MJRJ<6VU66O‹Š6J6 V6 96 66OR QVŠŠO 6 X [MŠ…PRU6RMŠV…JRM:†ZR Z„V [ U 6 P V AU J „ …ORU6‡„6MJRJ6 6O6MRUVN96J‡MVQ6R[6OPUQ6M…JMVM JV PJ6MŠ…PRUZM9MŠP 9R 6P[UR URXLUM…MMV V 6OV[R 6 J V V N U Š 96 :„ ‹ JŠOP…URNŽ‡O6MEJO6U6†6MMRU6OV[RMJŠOU…9MR6R[P6 OM66MŠU6MJMV 6 †V ŠV PV O66J…JMV 6OM66Q[6 VP9M R „ 9 „ „ P ‹ R U„ 6 Z„[6 †Š…JRMVMV QM‡OJ‡MVQMRUVU< 6R6J6 Œ6O9NKMV6 R„ZJQ6O‹Š6 6KMR 6 6 UR UR6 P 9R PZMŠŠUV M9OUM UP „ R U J [ Š 9Š N J 6 K9 C–L 6 S6 FGBI‚6 FGBI‚6 C–L DDW6 6 6 _`bdf\\ik\ n\ perde\i acegh jj e kqhgh j eb\ lm of p \ b\ €sy767 9uwyzx|7 —s7vx {} 2 t ˜™773› 42š7 š V6[RMVMV9PO VKKMRVQ6…UR6‹RŽQ:œ“>Š:6 QZRNVMŠ…PRUX JO M‹6 6 U[R6 Š9M:†J6P99Q RV6 ?69P‡ Q U6 6MJRJ6 M „ O …R V 9R’ JJ „ V 6 TM9MR6M…JMPJ6Ž9UU6MV9PO V 6O6 V 6O[P6‡ VRRNV 6 U[RX U„ J „ O …6 6 J696„JMV6R6 9MM6J6 P6X”J ‹OQV 6 Œ6R[MOZM„‹6 †[U[JP6 [VZ„V‹O †ZR V6 ZMM<M6 K9MVPQ9< 69M JM : „J6 6 KM „ 6 6 UVJ[ŠŠ9:…RV:ŽRN†9 O6‡UM…ŠVŠV9PO VU6J69RNVM J6 UMM6U6JU6 6MU6UZ9MJ6 6‘MR 6 U[R6 ŠUV :U6 6 [ Ž 9 M O …9 … „ M…ŠVŠ‡MV6[RMRR6OM66 M6U9ŽV9:Š9QMPV::†6 6 QJ6JOM ‘MR 6 6 O M‹66 JŠOJKMV 6OR O6MŠR 6M6 6JXTMZR6‡ †P6 M M J M VU V 9 O U Ž 6 Q[ ‡QZ6M…JM†M6 OJ‡MVQMRUVU6M6:VMEJO6 M66PM6M JQ V 6O[ŠOP‡ 6 UR UR6 P 9R PPV 6 6 †V URR†PV 6 J„ J [ Š 9Š N J Ž „ Z„ VP „ …JMVMJŠOUVR[PX6 OV[R 6OM66 P9M6 ‹ R „6 6 6 T„VM6J6„JMV6JV†66 R6VO66 R„:†PVMŠRM6 M„O †[JP6 [UR MVZOMQVPRZ„[6J6M6 9Q P : J U J V MM U Š U K9†9VOŠŽ6J6U6J6:9OM U6‡„69VPVMEJO<O„6MM96 QPJ6 U‡[†M6::†9ŠUV 6NMKMV 6M…OR<„6 †VJ6M‰ŠOQ M6‡ Ž J V M6 6V G† ERRWJM†MR†66JX6 ZMM<6MR‹66 †ŠŽ6 [6 O6OŠ[RMV6RŒ†6 ‹QO[ŠO66…V:†6”J ‹OAŽQ MRZJQ6MK†„KJM…J†V 6 …[6… 6 P J 6 6 MV ‹J VM…JM9ŠŠP†PVMMV…PJ6RN6URVM…JMVMJŠOPR†ŠŽ6MEJOX6 „6„U6U6R P6 P6 M6‡„UP†V6 6OV[R 6OM66PM6:V 6 †V6 [ „ : V Q„ ‹ RP „ 6 6 6 6 LUMM:6 R[OQ< LM9R6 6KR6 V‡UMBX V L„ L ž96 BLŽ„ 6 6

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?