CNG Financial Corporation v. Google Inc

Filing 74

RESPONSE in Opposition re 69 MOTION to Exclude Testimony of Plaintiff's Expert Michael Mazis filed by Plaintiff CNG Financial Corporation, Counter Defendant CNG Financial Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit /Declaration of Hunter in support of CNG Opposition to Motion# 2 Exhibit Exhibit A to Attachment# 3 Exhibit Exhibit B to Attachment to Opposition# 4 Exhibit Exhibit C to Attachment to Opposition# 5 Exhibit Exhibit D to Attachment to Opposition# 6 Exhibit Exhibit D - Part B to Attachment to Opposition# 7 Exhibit Exhibit E to Attachment to Opposition to Motion to Exclude) (Hunter, Barry)

CNG Financial Corporation v. Google Inc

Doc. 74 Att. 6

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 1 of 32

f
t

;'R,:E..:...,~..".;i: U;' :itl;"iriIU~S:. ' , ' :.P" :~D;r'ryF ,r;ii!~.",~.,'.,

f'
Twö hundrøø;:sevøîl'(øoe'~b~ 'feSf)p$Ø.were,availabfeJoranalySis,

f'

App.endix F¡pittivid~~tb'aiiSçpt:øftlø;'vetbafitn.af)s,VVef'igiVeJTbytfes.e27'1
r~pønReøfsJÇ):aJthe-que.sbbJis:the.ywetèaskedlÁflJ1dix¡G:prO.\røêS: how

f'

the,

)àns~lS:prøV:idedby"each rei$pøiàtfe.ôtwßie'Ca$Sife,l':(Ind:, før'fuoseelas$if~tion$?

r.

iio.dføns'tfe fØ$ponde~t'¡wa$misred\of"cøftèd~lheAJUé.tiòit.:andeotnant:øll:Whitf

r

.~l4'~m~¡wa$ba$èd~

.'

r
1

PRIQR:kNØWLEllØi: '.(:FT~RGa:COM.PANlE$
fQrre$pQndai;läililàUføutgrøtJps'.Wilhetlame,cardin ftont;oftbern~OtéSÜøfl
1aasked:i¡ftleyil1adl"øv.er heài:doflhi$êQPai:yuêfére'løday? lfosetfal:¡JYing:PYØ$~ .

r-

:c .'

r'

wêre;a$kefiqiiesfqll ll:r.lI~-..w.hatprQ(#órs'eMeas,dø:tteY'Sèjhor pToy¡(je?" Te:s.t

r;ndc:antff\,rotp'2 'l:~pønd~mts/we:tØ~$ke(lbe$erquest(ons:,e)nlya~øut.GEicä

f,
", .' L',.

'Conløt;gf'OUp, 1.reSpoJlents~Vkrêäskødth~'samø;quøsonsat)ut.~"stale"'.tbit~;
fesPQriØ~rt$'ln ,ø:ønfíQtgrøupawetØ:å$kedUieseq,uestjöns'aD:øut;Nikë~ låbfe, 1"

llelQw.:sJJmma~~:t$,irtcnUn,aaqh~~up;wbö':'ep.lred'~es~to/Etues:t9ri1a.àrid

L

ttëi:'sav~;an ,al's\Yr :tt),(¡ltJ1in'1b:cønSfd.et ~tØ~.
'.......?Ai...b...:. 'j; '. E. '. '1.:.." .bDU'~'l'tAua ~~ë .A'~''''.:D~ëT'i!nM'' P'!"'~llE" 'S:"'(' .1,..,..11.\.

L

:l)"DL~;- ;r';nLyn~~,~;.~~~~;.~ur :I:.~\;~. ~~ . :-"l... ,'. . ;'~. ,~~'ICl.Q-t

"14
.f
t"...,

. .... . ."..~ ,. h. ... . . .", \ "'~l!~:d. :.d~:intQ4fÌ~ttt~~cl.'. '" ..

i'~~'~'.

.. -- - . - ..-

t
i
f'
:2S'

r'

CONFIDENTIAL

ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY GGL-CNG058520

Dockets.Justia.com

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
r
¡

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 2 of 32

f,
r'
1

Ås candbe/s~nftomthei pércntaSesirtTi;p/ø tth'óverwbefirn.¡majøfÌof
te~p,Øndelll$had'pñQI :áwärene5s:öf:äì''køøWledge tegatdi~9'/(iEJCO"at(l'.wheré.

feIØvEtnl., tlieønrerCQ~J::ariyabøutwhiClitbey.yle(é,~skØ(Aløtal¡(jf18resp.ndentS!

I'

Gf~iÌfØdtQbeonawareDf'GËlCOordjdnot knoyiitGotdinsQJaee ,(or,; tøttho~m
:enfrotØßlfi 1.,:CiaimedløbøunawarGofAtLSIAIl$ iO;dîd'tl)knowiít'$ØldÌf$tltå~.
:Qr.. lor;lbøsEljflCihtrøitølr30,.l~faïiedtpl)e:unaWarë,'øfNßørdÍdl1t'knøw:itsørd

r

r
L

shøßs::ørat(eti.weàtl. Becauseit;doe:not:$eem.senSlefo-;aSk.lhes ~nden,
"'I

nu.: es.rs "a&:'~~..:..r'-$'~~'d;'~J;n.,:L,n~w' .. ::i'ie' ."s-,¡i'o";~~"'-i""',we','_ ,. ... :t'GUJÇt~Jli~~l.~'lI'tÇ -:-l." ".' .~i.~ .~l:nl.J'r.J. ..:U;I~,:~.. .Kk..Ui,'I\""~l~.:..,,:U~.. i.l :lU-..~.,-.."l~'ii~ :'re' "e'. ;v....",.."":f:¡,~/g:""

r r
r.....'.

føiJarnderQf~tb;:alläly~. \Wbic~)thus¡basøø"øn.tJ(emaìJ).253tesøoo~f'
Fi¡øm,thi$:pøjnliøn~td,thefidingS:'feporteqbetöw:íifej!h-a$~ør;!¥'éll.1P.~
te.spøndèlltsWb():¡ndìCáted:;'naViriø.'~priørawaténe$s..øf,:an~knöwleøgø;reøarding;QfUie

'cømp:an¥'(or,bQmpanes)abøutwb.îøhthey'wer~(asked:
i.
t.'" -1

,p,QUNtl'DfEØATA.iiRí:UMmE'1E$TGf(QtlPA('NPCOlltR()L:GRÓJJP'
As;f!Qtedeail~r~W:itthèëXceptløri:of¡tbefâCfthatrespøllqenls iit:CøòtrQl;ø,roqp;

.' .

,''ft .

2"Wereaskè:(faQ.ø,~ba;iløl¥spønsøre $ité:\wbie;'res,pO:ndentsinlne¥es.t;Qfø4Pwete'Î~.
Conff:øfxgtoup2;esntiliy r:apl~te$:1ht'Ø:9tøup, lttallQfbør;~p~.,Ilø

,L
'l:"
.~' ..~ ,

t~Pøn4øil:ùi~'tw. grØ(ip$\tecivet$fidnfl~'expi:CØiJ1itèrJ'Øf:al1~r\8S'P~t)ftfs~.(l~t'PØløol~ndquestfJ,$.:a$Keq)~ tli~.nòt$lri1Y.

l,
1
l.,.,

tXl'patlÏ~Jilbe;ifr1di9s;'før tbE!ølWaij.róups'feveä:'lbem iø;ba!li~~iCQns.i$t$1Wili

eacò~lhør~ :ACtrdif9.ly~formøstana:Jy,,~dab:ií'~ 1:0,1 :respønde$'j;1i(le.
têS:Sn.aAd~47' tëo.Rdrits1Iieønl:Qroi~p.;;2;m'âiílpo.tVi;i;wei~btß

av.~gø1ha$e,ønR:cffbj~ 'flf;I!PQndØrtl$).tQ:aChva.'9reàe:r~~Is,.Qflir~Si
L
If

3Ø

r

CONFIDENTIAL A nORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058521

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 3 of 32

r'
¡

'atid$lcbilitJo lheøbtaiAød,percentages. llòachiøv:ø~rmQ(e~~tabte:ideao'fitté'QVerali

l
.1.....-

-

rateòleøofusiØn' due'tørfàPtOl$nøtbeinø;al~et'førJ)mpOS~ pfcømøaiiøo~$QJe,'oi
:tbe;táQr~;belø.wcornpåfeJbe' TÊ$t+CØllÎfølgrø.,p.a:~r!gøs; tt1tlè.we.igblW
'àVetaØ',øfiQQillgttlJ), 1 +!'OøOfJ,9fotipZl~'1lisialtøtaveiaqøbe~ basëd!ønl$Q. '"

I

r:

i):5~~' 1:$5fØ5pøooelitS

.t..,.

r r r
r

E. .' g'b"' ~~-t..ÐA.~:a' ::I.V" -.".U: ": ii'~Rd.S' 'l""'~l'I-e1L -. . ", ," . "," ," '. ~ ".',. ",... ~mAUhU""'A"GE': . 'IC" ';n,

:lma"~$lt.$elec~?Ï,E_$. l1~n:é.ndeiltsW'ête~a n:amëtø:~:

jirl,tben~k~(tfo.hit;~~f;t~r'ikê\flö:~tateaiisøått~t¡a:g~fØtlbtn~,.
Ålle(',rev.¡ewia9',thatd'.seàrCh,Tesûlt$'.p.a:9ø~Øie 're:onÈf,eøls'Wêre:1l$.'ked:~ø: '~$tLF!QSe;

.'i.:YØtl'WåØt~tI'1ø':gøiJ¡~fJt(j. ..we.h$ite.: :W-IfØØl:Ø1çkitig:;~niQ¡hgi ,wbiC/l¡rik,/ifør;y, ;Qfil

.iL

r'

'lh~Njg!Fw.oÜkJ yøq.fttirstl" l~bJE2iSUIlrtii~ilhese ites:ult$..~ti:examínin9' :rabfe:2:~
lhe"reaer' h:èe:$lq,tlitr$Ian.:f¡e:",'firØWiÌ1;
1"~':tbwøfø.ir$t~ irn¡lietønror-Qnt;Qllnæachalseard
TêStilts,pages'se.en"b¥'Jhé::rt$pòndêñmi.:tei,iiam~,of.âff"lJ,.nk$'~ant1lJ t)D

r"

L
L

..thfHiøärCh'(eØlt$J)age-bQtò':th~fflJffng'Jt_'(e,øf!ClÍê'serc, ønd..ib.
lhtøø$ponsøreLiitks;--t1rø'irsled;Ül;Tabé2¡¡;i:á1phal)~etiça(;øidet. lRør'$J$ø:ØI

-i".oF) ,~\I.:t~:U:l. .;'.iJ.~'.q.r~l~..~.:n 1~tlt:t'W:i:~,.'~.l~.~..Ql~-= :i.l;~... I .d' en;ti';-"'~..n. 'U;e' . l' l-...,iCir:l-''~;i:l1.t... .-rñ.''''".o''t''&.'''~;i.,.._- !k..u.. .~,...e".

L
L

..1 ,

ligb'árø: '~JhSQia.aØt)~ø;n~ww¡nSlhG;If1l~r.cø~'anõ

~~tfafJt/øm-aL~;.
Z. :B~t$Ø:'tyÎí1gi~ii)'GSimyifds'ailifereril'ør:aser.iR$.
:pa9,ø"iia:A;q~.WPìri9Tn(øliæ~_öaf;før,CønlOlsi.t)tJ,i~ a-':pl'ed ibeJow

L
L
L:

. ~lh:datá/fotlt\ø~rffr$~mn'$. :$~aii:grø~pS:'$haret)~4on!lMøvØd.

,a~1

rm

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058522

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
l
i
r

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 4 of 32

I t

~none:of,tn~røspoJì$øiøptiølis,.tlre.:data før¡.bes 'qptiOllsarreproViøec iit

r
.f...."!,

'Qe~ntle!data fØf'thø'ffrsl' tlre:~l(øups'aJldêøntrolgtQQP'3.
:t1fo'slriørit:tllR'Yi$uat:pre.nttiøn,cØirSWiútanønhy.srgn~~zefQli

't

pe~cet
T:AEltE2:: 'CtlQJ(~mROUGllER~ØR$:Slt.E:fll2$PONø.ENT'WQ.tJtP' TRY F"~$l

..r'.'~d

l
is.

,r
: · 'T:ESt j . ConkO,I"
;: -,'1
,.'~~: '.;,: ,din.:i:oim1t~'¡Se~rplt.'

.to

r
t\~..

',CQ.:tiØl;. ~~Ji' ".

..
dlA
tlA

r
.. :l."
r.......,.,

.;$ase:'~'
:~~: :iiu" nD;"¡',,"~ou';ooa::.rr. "e.;'tK:g,i¡d"l"i:';."''~'''t'~, '.

. \wabSite~ .ùWhIClìliffç,dif'aT1¥. ,Qnithe:page:

:n~i::;_
;wøtírg, ,øu:,;firs? '.. . .'. . .
.'ëa:

*"d ~"I"'r-~;i~ :':.~ ". u: . '" "",, . ~""~lJ' . "":'"

.f :GlSfG(j'AtLL;$fATf .:~kfG.(); ..' GOOø

'ijdO' '. . 1'4~'Ö '.' 2~ 1"'NÂ
:'i8~.z

t

;.fØ'

. '7tlC7' .. .NA
'2~1

f
.: 2J);
1. ~:.,

'2~()
;'.

4'.3

't
i:

3J),
L

2.1

..:~Â"'"

i~

ØJ
, iUJ
~, "

'.
l;~

~.t .

'~~j'
1MA'

l
r
L
., , ','

t.'O' .

.. ..
.. i

"

'¡'M

. '; ,2.1 .. ¡RA
: :.' '~j~' : :NA,

; t...:ø'

4.3', ., -llA

."2~lU .
a~

"'dlA

r
..f...'....

l

CONFIDENTIAL A nORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058523

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 5 of 32

f"
:1

. -'., '.. .

1ä=~~~~n:Jòø~=~Y,:Ptôfite
l

~.IåhÀ(,ÇPlttQ/1.0ô1;fthlm9-

f'

i4,:fjNi¡ imøw . .15: '~E QF'tJjË$E . ....... . .,'..... - . .
1 :$OYtØ1tNI~flQmøR'agø

..

NA

6,;$ 3~:,(t

$'.1 .

,2:rt
t;~
:2Ø~0:

f
r.-

2~-ã$u.~èl;i;iuD¡&'

~s.iaOi:cø~ni~et,

(\llliureali:cmn) .

r..

¡"'4'.ßa$~-ir t~~) ¡~Q~tide .
6;nt=.nîka~ .'.
7 :Nike-Co" .

j l__itl;.'f:md.fl~~:&tv~ .

~U~

r r
r."'.'
~l._ ,"

ií~..nk~,~Ske~ltçoiW SNi::édff _i-.:mkeg,ò'I:çøil

1Jl
y "1.;&

f5~5
8 .r:. ......r.Ww;u.... e.'..., :)..Cø.II..._..... d.~::........ikl....~.ø,~m4

lb'n.'R'''''1\1 :~riai~;Jitmn
.g. nike:"1i . :

mAlt

r
if L

. - ~~~mKøfO;iQ~'fIc.tW' : 1~Ø:;flik~IleJn$j.$.tQiy

l~;1.e~~eømm 't1NikêtlÙ~n
1'i~~fQr,CQnimtVAid~). ',' L, vpam I~njl~;~CI Abroad:..
MkéW'atCh

L

ij;_~trap:d~r~al(:~i~~~~' . .
'. . .. ~At.n:,Qn1~~calnl

. ..lW\.iØKfaJqT;9J~ulçaqipaigti$lnikøll'
J

14jj;

L

L
t"

,4énumærQflin:diag$~~r,ftQi1,~x~minälQìJDtlÇÎblei... '1b~ar.gilñ

følft)Wi~.

1.,Mèl'te$pøndent.~!înij~'naflØ::GEiCöaiiô!¡b:~lörtä
'~røll.tes.ulfs:pag:é;èØI)làjnÌØlb,øf9.aotç~s~âr.tëQtt$IGrGEicO'as-'we.&Si

r
r'
r;'

33\

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058524

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
(.
i I,

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 6 of 32

1

r

r'
". ."

.:r'"

r.

r
..
fi,.:'.'

r
..
..r. L..,. .',

f
.,
.. .'-.. t ..

Njk&i.alSødfspl~ý.e\tñlfir~:$pøi;sÐ~:HDk$.af'.iSUß'.Wh$('asked'a2t.
"St¡ppøf1¥OuWtmled:to:gø,d1tøcJilø ,G'EIC()~$Wêfjsile" :Wdnøúlidlickinft

ian:Ytli!Jl~ wbidlilíi1k~ifalj¥i 'ôtiithet1ag.kwotJld¥or¡trytif$t2~.~(tll~.of'thês

r
l,

Jrøønnts'$eieG(edJnawwiil$"reeil~ë:ørtlJllnl~t..i1.a%Sêl~:the

~-l:in$:uraøeJiei~Iiri.$d;..il::5~,$ëf~;',ni~WWAUlmiH~~Q1
_,ink A$atn.'âsMnø,:øOh~;SpøRS()re4 UOkineiitin:åOy.;tiema:rkot

....

l
f
li~i

copaqY'.nâi:1:..th$.gej)ericAe:rm"'';(ätda):inslJtance''Jappareötl~ls.($tiCienfto

led;PØfatø';tlk¡tfatsif($;~eata~,$llclnRn1~,líkøry'provlde.;inførhátiOtl

¡áb;s~:t(inpaniØ$\;A'~rßf~. 'ìl:e:dal~ftfl ,Qøntø.l9f(lUp3;:Cleay
;~t.~atllatUte'.actoit)jlig~aeOlø':aenøj¡afä:$ØrÇf.resøJ$;jpage':$iiQt

t
t.'....,

l
.'34'
.f..... "

t'

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058525

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 7 of 32

1

:ré~pons¡bfê for ..t~PQj)deiitsi'$~Yij)g'tb':Y'WØQid,.'çlìC,'øn,ønë:øt':tl,'spon~Øie

i
ri,'"

tik~ to:'go"djr~clytØ;.(SaC().

'F,.bøtöm nne,Wîbiespe:tUttdiØk~tlougef(Qi;js~asfØJtow~M~l:
;respOndents. '~'Întbé;nåfø'Sae(lår; ;bñn9førta,$Øatch"res.tJf$)I'~øe¡mntáiriitK

i

thøoi'ganLc sea~r~ultsfQt'SlËtCQ'as'wølf.a$itfe'Uir~,Slln$ørød;L.inks.~ :fløanyaU

r

ia(D,'alifel&,~ønfi'øñhr':.tlJ:iist:cøilîrik.røt':Qnø,pfih~.otliør iO~nÎb:,SiØ$

:åss~\WiGElPO~, .t!'¡f1diCfed:ayCQlrbl(gr()1lP';(nQmø~;liewho;søød(!'
,

r

øf tb;Uifès,fÌønsøi:ê,lit'k$dø'sø;'nøt~usøtb'eyhaVøl.Jæ:¡in, lhtiame;Seleø.
bØ,beøasecoflfegenenttens lJ$edby

r
L,

tñø, '$,'f;øA$ræ,tinks,

,'$'eønd;lll'$ftl~çt1Qn;EtTt$~ ' ,AllQt~nQu:esti2c::deféfmrned¡wlrøf .lflikthe:
rgsf)nd'ént 'Would... .tkfi~tland~jlireSpønS;tewidenû.ed,Jhø;:$f'Ønsøteditjnks;, it

is

r, L

1fW~ID~:tnat$ornef~pøndøm$:mi9hlbe cøi1fu~Q~mdlbjrikjbat:dieklngøn lñe
$pøns:Qt~tin'k$;wødld'lcíkëi1lto,GEæ,ø!s;:$it;àS',w~Ir.t=ørtOi$irøa$Qn.

t t
..
(.,"" ,d

'l'e$pöndeir,jillbe.tØ$i;grq~p;asWèir:aO:Onfot~tJPst:iil1da:wet:e:;aSkedadfteGt
øø~e4 'qlJ~S:ijn::rega£dfn9!eaøn'olthøthree~pøf'søre,dlifjk$:. SP~êäll¥;
Q~esRøn :5(1t~a$k~ "nø'¡YQuitbink: ciicking(øf)illîÌ1kldoetakg¥øutQni~ ,~8ieø

web$it~..~.?" i~d ;Qt';~l(jn.9;åbQûtbeÎ1.$rtcikenfø'$i:e~i;tC(ìwErs'itØ.C'.ølrQi9rpPf'
.;¡~

1fØPøf¡qelW_1ik-e:;'¡0ø'I~.ilk£.kiti'()nflnKld:0eirlatcø;yo:t:tO)tl

L
:..~ .

..

AtlL$;tAlE,.~:~~,..;T'ta,st,'Contl;,;gQP;~ :reslJcre.af$ø'Wéf$.ask~i~,$a:
..

L
f" .t~

;qtIè$ti.;~gardida 'fbtlfi;(iQrH$pQn$(~ fiÄ~,~.i&YAJQ:i ~;GEIGØØømp.anY,;Pïølilêe'"

,,,'iQé¡Of'hJînkslIeneawJÊU¡iyil;øig,ä$¡$ea(oo., 'l;åble,at;.$wnmaméstßetè$tJ,

f(r Qt.esoii'5'~l

r
. 1"":.. : ~~

35
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

"

'f'"

GGL-CNG058526

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 8 of 32

r
I

aetQ~~ râvi~WiÏ'9;:ral)fe3al;jsb()(:ildbe r~niZedlbal\thei:e'rhfghtbø,maay'
f
t

fea$..ønsfor-respô/lent$:th¡nking:ttatclrokns:()n,a~$pøn-srß( Unk.migbt'tkè tbenito

~lCØ'S\Vieb$JtØ:~laod.ao.âlt;()fini~tea$'øf$wøukfinê.fl"lh.ave':anytjng':tødø

f'
r'

.'$EICØ~$,:älta:üøns~fnrllÌ$r:eas.l\~poøn($Whø:aøaw_ "Yesl".l(ïr
;q~eSlåfl5t1l,~~tbihâskød'()uØ$ØIJ'5~2): "at j¥rparlCtfar,m;i~:Y()i1JlrìiikJhiJt

C1iCìifgi,Qn:-.,$J1l lihk;d(øsia.1(e,øu,!odba__ :~f!1i$itp.iI 'll~ vematm

r'
r.

'~Wè.i';prQVk~,byitØ$.p~nf$;løIlisqOOliø~w.ør~ex~míf1ed:~i:on1y~lh~sø"wh'Q'
~avø ~($iífØ;lli~,;th~i'JNm,iooOfUseio,.th~s,lærl'allø~.;,tiàmØl"

r r
r.

cbetlJ~;lh~tffad~Peã:inG'E'leO\ ,b.use ihey;thtlgld:'1f~y:wereoii,aGfae'ow~b$it~G/l:p:agè',ør ~~l4sg'lhe¥-tb()ùght~Ule'$itwâ~'afliatedorcønnectedwi:'

ßBtCø ~.we£ê;fameQtantl:tabulÇitèct Tabie,~",$('mlicu;i~~,thø;tØSt,1lsfØTQu~fføn

5(~
AtteJl:OÏ)is1ìf$;QintQ'lbpliG1Ãmu;gb?e.Ji~pøndeatsmâdèWìhøli
,tøflsfdeigthe¡irtnj$QR$'tña~'9avø.WtmakjÏlglh.ien:ø$:trabtø:$Ø):' ¡NeXt, iåttentiøn'ls'
~¡\lnJaUié;øJiêl4liirø~hiênpr en;øt.$'m:adøaftercon$KJ~:nín9"tti9'reà$Qn$',re$l'Of1eiits
i"':'

t
r

f,,-',..

L
r r
L,-

;~~vefØf;makglhe ej;tQ~i(labfe abi.

.'(:

,i

L

L
¡ . i,-....,

r'

,

L:.
~~'.-:: . ¡ ~ , " .".

$
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058527

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 9 of 32

I,'
i

lO~LlnU"T"~ "TJ"Aiill1l~~'fIl"'Ol" C:O'Y' S' 'IriE:Ð,A-Tlh'N: ':DE': 's':nAN' j:'r:N" ;;~"""'CRi=.S" ,Ai(,S' ."\ltÆlJ)'
\.....::1;:"\4 , ':, Rni,~'~ ~1:lY¿:l';V.'. .:. ",." ,'"'. ,:". ~I;:~:J,:,I~; " : .:~ '. '. r-'~, : '~çi \ ,;.;.~ :" .,~ :~.~. .Q~'~:_'_ ....I..'flf:i :',

tÄBLE3à: .eUCK..1fl:tlOUGlJ9IUQll&:'$Jie$RESP,GNDERJSMIGll'tR)(

f'

f\ ", ," '.
; ~. ",Nameri,:: "".';~'~.',:¡G','tQ':;,Î~l~~r.tö~ "."

'1:l;sr

, , \Ø-ørilrøl, AVE~$Ë~r: ,

, ' T+et,t1,i'Ç$:,

r ,"l$è,,;;" ',,', ",',,' ,

.f

r
r
,r

i~:.~
: lnso:m-riæ:Finaer:"Save

: . id~Rted béQWldQs1åltey~ to tf,...

. ".' . - .... : :~5;:.~~lb~~~:~~~()~n~, , " , ,'~~lt:Q ,.Att$;TAlE': ßSCQ ': 'tGsta: "

,'.'liJl

:2&)(7

, ?2fl:5"

. ''215

.' ,1iij9

2'521

¡' f.nSú~rlæ:l:n~ :':~v~U', ' , , , , : ,\ '~,lnoo~fìtrf!r;çØJ; ,," ,

; 1aR
"12J~;'

, "~4.'Q ,

· · :23A ' , .: '1,itl

: t$;~
"'1;~J.g

17~1

, "',r: :'('Äf(OOt- ,',p-átYfite '
, ' , ,'", (:bl¡,,~' _~~~feltÐl11Y16-Jil

2ïj:f ' '! 19~J

" . :20:Ø'

':.21/0

:;N'

NA

.. ~42~6'

NA

, 't\i\
',' ..,11~q

,'Avßta ~::øt~:øv~rii; Ø$; ,

~l~a '

t.
f'

'Wbif~4h~ ~.,dø;riQttaøjOtOá'Çêøtm;lbø';rea$'nåvib¥'r~I1ènl$.;hø.,ught
\that~ljtllg:'Olà$f?RS()retUJÌk,wøtJkf :takelb~mtQ.'$EtCbrs,:(orAì~&)wøbs.i;
:andthQS m~y ,nQtbe:)ptØó:âfiØl,:äØum_~tøfinteréStingfid¡~.s'øme~ø')ftØß

L
,
;r"','

fi,'

,eXamihaliQnøfTâbre3a,IbeSatR~~;fQlrnW£l:.
1,. 'Ie.;9lorltàndC()nfrØi;QfOl;'~rasiidønlS;~;íÎilheJia01

l
. '.'¿

()1CØ, bñl-n.Qtødb'~ipa~~t:jnilSi;fle;,ø(ø.ajjîC"~äi,~røSlfør;G1C(),a$
waJfØ$.,itæJb~,'~tlrØi'UJ1k$. WhlI$l-ea'l-QteaC;in~t".l,l~

/

L

qtlesQn":~uØ$li~)f5~ 1lø :øv.e~IJW~lght~':aVêr~~førtla:tw.gøJ~p.s

(
I~' "0, ,

iØp~. ' ,
a'1

1_ifÍI"AV~P"(;~ll~~,WØ~~'fQflfT~+.Qtn~,i-,aòØ'~1ljJ'l+~, 'tS;)t~~QØ'q~;jsPn~:i~,;,,~'~A~~;\tO;tt~UV¡ll.live:'ar~)'~,~

f', '
('

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058528

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 10 of 32

L
I'"

(t$~9tÅ,+18~9$. '* l4:9%13=)tê"~1$17~;6~sa1l'l!atcliøkiøg:'Qnon"êQfthe
,r " i ,,'

$pøn$Or~l;rd(s, WøulQ¡'tâke thernføtbe&aC,Q.'we&page;

r
,,
',f"~"

,a~ CQoool,srØlP 1i:øsp.òJideit$lYPØ( 'În:!tbEt :nalii'e.ISEIê'Ø, ,brinØitg

fPtlr;,'seardi lÉ$uTt$'~page;(cønfafnjJ)~'t"Ørg~n~'~btéStilf'ror:ßt;lctl 'and
wørø llø,n ,a$ked.wh~'lei'.cidg:QIl(a$pD.ns:øiØlnrikt~ö,f,ldtak~,UiefÌt0c1b~,

,
,r,',".,

'~bpa!l'fQr-Ai.tS:l"A;f!E-~;øai)tiiatWâ$J:lQt~tiØßØtallh~rè iQiJthe;

,

'r'

paEt .R(~':lq.,a:rJOn;leì~.,bàfantØdiltJ~n;. ;_røXûêl;'21~ rep.n(hiff~illatêlY'tQ e'ch:SpøJirødlJnk.th$pe~$fa~e:r1tåri'
:ff',,17'!l)$6btafuød'_lie 'Tè.t'9rQ.liP.(Cart"~dlrdl'ørøll'2'rel~liøÎl)"a:s;

r.
'r"
l__..

,suliuJiaft-Let:jn'ltn~lmn'edìate~'precedjl'-9:pâfiagtapb.\WlatlbíS¡sagg:~t~j$ota~t

haýìhS.¡typ:~;jß\~EfCØ,an.dcal~ :tJp:;a/GElCO~i:cl resutt$page~,.rø$pØjt~en~;
ar~'less ilikelytQ' fbirk:tbaNiliiQø;Ø.ii;$Pønsør~'Ul)k$ 'wótJfdlâk~tØitsEJqO~$'

r
L,
," ( ":_',

t.",

web,Sie;lflaii~yørelø1ñfi'tttelfçki1.ønU';Ji~$WOldla,ke¡;fbl$tø
:tompetiQ:g áutQinStlmJi'We.éS.Rrat:is..1lQ$t¡i~døÐtsAlJ')Pøe'ftø,
!ldei:'$tandtòat'tt~$pønS(rø.dUOk~-'all:QfwliêR'"çtn1aintle:ger$iø tønn;

;taautø)Jnsuracø""~,leadfo~pøfiß.quQt$'ir~m()ihet$" "

r
,t.
¡,
": -.. . ..:""

3i.HtQóf~velìtr!1a,r~lbê' fings'.Qblain'Wln~fÌ'~QlgroUp.2
T~poA(h¡!nt$':are.aSkø.t¡ùéQl;$;ifQtl:Øid.~$PøAS$'e.~Ï1k$i Øt,átQl;

,~n;ØIan,rilik~, lMriitlifø.ki;ät.a~~';fr(Wni,tb'~"reølt:ft
lìav¡ll,ty;lìl'øaIC~il$Ø,tË$pønaent$iwe~~s'kedwbØtbtdil)"on-ø;
wganíClJbk!Çnta¡qltafte'GElCO;WØlld iai-.î.'lø'GJtcø's'wøb,ag&.,

t"

,,

("'--

MotØ~,4Ø~~'P,ønød~rotNely lihjs;¡ll~lb.,f:ènftlSin

,t r
L.

(l$$~Wü:;t'~$Øf~'Unksrike~:i$~.~fund"øf.$l~fn

,ag

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058529

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 11 of 32

(

m'~ørenllyèC9~$in9"al!QutthøSPØl1SØfød"kinksândrnOTe like.lyaftnctiorrofthe

!

fåd lbatmanyusefSappai;enllyai~confú$ed.r~ardinR':the,ltecmil1.oflbe
,$e'J'jte~njij$'¡itgeneral
.4;,EspeaUyteIUnQCJté.:ll:e"ltnling;sfrConltOI ;ørQ-l~t, mi:n~$e

rt
l

f';

rê~Pó~:n$'~iJn'lhetJamø',fii',J1tGaleø.. ,anØ'prøagbl:fòñtva,.$éaiÄ

r r
,

tØidllipalf"GØntaiiii. Uiemgamc ,seaF:rßsØJts;løri'N.I~,E 'á$,weu:a$:1t~lhr-e
'S,:..~~i~~~.:i; "7:I¡'e" '.J'~l:l!.e,.r-S:l00,; '3' ,MA~"",'A '0:,' ,~i:e'''e' ,,''-''', ~i.e',,"""";.l:,;"es' '''u'lt' ,~ ' ~~;l¡"l'n' ,liS' . ~ . "Da' "m', ' ".: .:. .D, ,~ . ~r.~i:cu'_:-iii..:tl .J.'. ~1i1'll;I.. ,~,~l.i::...
""

,age..Yeivmriasked,anØJe:adiQg,,'báf~,q:uesti()R', ;on'a~tae,l2$.;:5;+
;ïl¿& +~ØJ3:;I; i2AY/ó.s-aìdìbî;cirrQng:'on;lh;$pølisøte.:,:lJmkswptlJdtakølbem.,
lølG'aQ()~i:rwébpa,ge,;, ThisioòiE:fëS4lìat,otle:-døes' :nølhavø.;totyein;1te'Jiamei,

., "r':"

r. i, r
'""e,

'GlSlCO:orba~viøWiOgia:s~rçb ir~slill~pagø'9.enerafedl~YÎnputting:.tba. naiø;
0aç()lG,'lbmK.'itl'ê1iëk~.g' 'Qns-ponsøre:d'.,Uriks4hat(fo'::i;øtiuenijt)n U:fe'¡name,

!GE.IC:Ø~ ihutøQ'~ntaill'tlgØfØnc.iett~,'au)jiJ$UrailcetWo.Ulfa,køøne:tø)the

r,"'"

i-

G.()'wø~ø~
Even;'witøuticøn'Sidann9;;tn~!rêå$:Øns'lNhyte.~pøndent&,:tlîirik:'$Oi1ne'fiiidiigG;

f
L
r,'"

fê;YØ:a't:llat'1NtikiÄf'ìht,'cliØkl~(øittb'e;~pøilSQre-Mnks. wUI;:te~YOtrl()':$tlc;tXs'

'web$itlia&l1'Il9i(O,4Ø'~'~wijb;l'aVing'~e4iii~niln;'GElCØQr t~¡ti;ajp'a9ø

t
L~

;MntanÛJfl~'fQic;S'eaï:tes.ul før :(:SlQtt, 1flesi¡dets.MddØDØ~;it;tØ:

naø:~øec.!:a;d,()ll~Iñflamø$ai'COanY.erø;Øl,lit$eiêble.\1bpafiè'
:ar~a$!Ij~lJ'tøJhk'tb~tçlKiI~:ør¡ ~,$pøn$QTød:Unb'Ýlwlt'fåø1hern1o $Sårs
webp.è., /A$;tfØ:fihdi'.l9$frØîUiØ'flr.'e'C(mti'f:~as'tøveäf. 'l.aO¥-IaClorsaf&

r"
l.~.

t~iblffQrliø"cøOM!rØl1~tvØ'd.'tfé:Té&t~p';re.pøÐdènt. litpøìAtøf
bitt 'wløn'the:1indi~lør'Uiø'çQtrf.igrotps ai:oompared -fQtlefindinQ;uønttlå',l&$

t
r
f,','".,' .1 '

,afli
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058530

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
:' .

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 12 of 32

ì

t,"'

I'
t ,',

'Qtôup,tne,:confnsìØfl,Øbtained wìttHhe:Iattér'cl~f'i$\dtJeilQfa~ors'it,tbøT,tbaTi:tbø$ë;

r,

béing, n,"ge-,iSElCO~ :a ê .by
l\tttin j&Aø.dil'e,cteØ'tQ.tbe.fhditt,s"ob~íJwh-en:Gu.mei.'a~,.a$k~lø,'
JØ(îca~tf.e',re$'ns:'~¥theY:lløUghN:lwkín~r'Qii;a:link~wø,uld:taØ;lhei;":ka

r
,"
"."

'p,artj¡lat

,,:r,'f

',\VÉjSlte; ÌabJèahs.mfi~riåStltest.ltwb.en~;iÍ1,(ê$pQ$a:tQiQlIn512)'f'1
¡Et;f!EJØi18~ 'm;k8$,¡yu'UJÎfklh'8tC/iØkíiJttC1ff~Sp(JJ/isøreiJnkdfJtakøyoulølhff

:' ..
r,,'"

,..., _bsilø?',one-failre:ØlUlhO$& Mro.!JavQ :ailS;WéfS¡odiç'lle'1'~rE~''Ç~
¡~..

r (
r,',.,
1~~.

:~O'" r'#;...'\f""""SO' "8' ..""...I"',Å,..tlMed" '..rö;ol... ,ki__o:...'..:'""':V':'a,;:t.'~;.J¡,iriCl~A .i,~US',.. ':""Y;" ,

11. ,~lG,...~... ..~:;l;l;l.~i.tH~",~.. .:l....~~.~7.t..~'.lF~i..~ll ~:ll,~. f:..:.~=1\;U:ii:t.Q~.., .~..~~/

lbøltghtthe¥,~aotl.a;'~Sfe.QwebSitøløm~e¡pagè~, 'Orhecuse;th~1tEKbl.:tl!:Jink

was,àffli~eQør ~nn~\Witb'Gsiø.Q. Tllese:datåfe-sO'irriaiiz~:irt'TaQrê:'3b,

f'
l_~~

t
r;'i

t," Ù',

L'

(';

I i"l.

L
f'"
t~~.

t
L
40
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

r

GGL-CNG058531

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 13 of 32

r'
:1 ~

TAElL.3:b:: êuØl(,.'TIlQU,$HERflO,R$:$ill;$:al5$fNai;fl1'$:M($li1ìl1¥
(T#\1Ø8ß ,INJO"C'OtfSIPERlTIOM'RlSPGNi)EflSr: "F.EÂSflNS

J' i
1

VVH\')'

: 'tlË$f:

CM"'øl
1

iCønhl
:2

C'(lìÏrø)
'3

ri
"" .; ; ":r' ",

flamè;-tyed;¡n ,tQ triltatè':$!h

;,iGEfO
..; :(l~i)

GEltØ
((0;;) '%

G:l;I,ÇO
'1411
;:%

NølS
15$1\

:aase=- ' '

. '$

r r
r~

':h~'l.$lri,'Qadtes~ 5~Q'n" '2:1 "" in:
, (wwAtíClrnòm.;ooml
SliQpfør:AutQ¡1nSlJJlftCØ;
t' ""A

~~'5. ~:~ou~În~~r~ìn-:øn,(Jiøk : ,',' ;:$srCO J\il&tA:TE$ein$ElCO .rden~ l$føldbes)fe yø,l. to the ..~. ~'.$í(~../l "

\¡WW;',n.s:ure~:øn,,ëøl1i'

\

.,..5JI

'0

Ø;l
2'.1

ø,

t:t

J/1sUl'tl'Cfinder-$ave. (wwJnsutancender;:Cml

'SJ)

ø
'NA

Q;

f
I~'

t'AI:OOl;..ØIQ'ØUØnlp:Clr:~Pröfjle . "fiA ,~¥:ahp,'cø,Cl1ØllO$1,S"htnlI '

2'9.;8

'NIt'

J¥:Ønba:seenIfomlatile3b~WheD:cøn$:ttIe$whQ/iÚrnk.cJjøkjn9a;P.amPuJar
SpøO"$ø:rediu:nKar~;a$kedtQ;¡nòrcaeithereasoÐs'whytbytbQ1løhtç.ltfri~ön:tñe\J.inlt
\loiird'tak~lføm'tø'GElCØrs,w~b$itØ.,ä,'dfimii1ilJus:le,Vêri(~t~k wl~rt,avêragød'àcrØ$

r

l
Li

:the:ie:t~ro~,'and;cøl1ltØr9rø~p'2lào~øt ttiøYWør~:~rt~ø¡thørbecuslb,y
I:

badly.ig;'~lC.o~,~U$G:,thta,1hught,ihø¥'Wøæ'()ß,:a$SïCOw~h$il.Rllfa9.Ø-"

o.t~$ØtlythØught~ IÎnk\Wasiaffíate.:(roonnetedwilflcG~Je(),
l'bø;bOttøitflinJs tfat; '~rdl~;,øf\whëth'ét'øn'Ø:d~;ørd~'jfioti:iak~Jnt~

l:
r'.
i...~l

,.conøldeØlliønlbø'tøan$;,rèpømtØiìfsi9iV~'førl,jnkll1~rth:di~; öJ)'tJ $p'øred
.,t.Jriks Wøi:fd'ta~1hè$~'lø,.$Ei;C~$;w~ø~,'lbø'l.~vøi,øf:adi,JiabJei;E:ntù$iø'fális,løili.s~,
:tø,a-%..

t
r,
r~

41
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058532

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 14 of 32

(,
¡.

i

r
,,'f,'

. :/.

THINKJNG'SPONSØREÐ,UNK$HAV1~$.OMEKIN0'OFÄfFlUAt:lØN\WlJ'HGEI,C()
A$ed ofalftø$po~Jmts\QUesijQQ3'wa$::"A$ be'St YOU'fe~lll,vmen'YQll fli't

'i,""',,

l"

lQokett,aUhi~:pa9øl'dKYØ1'Payáøy::a(ferdiØill(lånY';øftbeAi$fiA!i$:Itt.';se:(j()rtWhetø

(

¡fiSây$"$pfìore'tinksr1'" :R~are$/øUtæJranswøFs,an'repønrlent$Weie'thøll
a$kø(I;Quø.fiOO4:'1¥Oti:thii~'ØlJ(i: \wñalat& ($pOllsoreø'Link$'t"

.f~

r'

i'

t'..

r

&alnaløm:øt1bvømatiin f~flnSß$;sWøi lf!rê~Qnsø4ø,tfja,Qp.;nded

qtlø.t(al)'(Q~"')¡fe_tthatf$~Ø~'øf~m~beT'Øs.9tøuP',and1Øi6%øf,llds~i¡ÏJ
:ÖOnköJ¡9roP'llbøiigltffØ::$POØ$UnksViète,:sømèbaw;afflfatæwithi,tSt5lQ0L
"FftlNKtN$SPØNS,ØAÈE)iLNJ(SQFFER$ElOQINSORANcra
'Resp't~l1dent$,ril'l'dffØr,gro.op$\wøre~lfenc:skeQlhe'(lUe$tiøli$'seijescrøg,arding

,,
I; ..¡ ,i''''

r 1
1

);,.:...

.i,","""

e-atfQtthøthtee '$ph$()l'üik$:~ '",I)tr'you,fhfn'k(jis.íín'kø1fts _,ih'sQtâtlcøa(Oh

r
"

Wilnstnncmfim-øfl~rljmpan¡esoffør1tJJI¥ ..,¡Í1SJltancø~ tk;J.'$n.oNilltenal'Y ~
-útl1r:~:" Qt.aw: you; 11øts.tf~'â'b-t)'Udthls;¿r- ,Fi:~rifeS~Øridenlsji;ttlie te.tg.roup'arid

'Cbn1mI'w:oøp:s;:i :amf3:. fle'flarn~u$:edfortñ~Qlaríks,;in;th~ql'øsI:¡Qrlwas,StIC();tØt

"r.--;,

;tØ$lione.;¡fJ;eø,"aE~ø.Qp:'1. tb~nam~was:AH~$iÀTE, ,CQntrcøf;,gr()4~2
,'

1:,.. . ."

,,'re$p.nd$.Yíre,ase(~~;questiøJ1r~arq¡Ì1;aJbur;nøtM~PQriSòred.1ink', 'i,AHf'-GEieo(~pati,';P:røfiØ;)t -'tmetif,lheJirks.gØØe.fâted :~Y'fteorg-ani(;
'såar. , Tåblë-4a'SUiiltt,)aô~'lbe'$èle$U)k.

t;i
oJ;

t:l

aefrø:'fe,~ng.táblit4a~it$bøu1d:ba,.~ø(.thaf.tñørø:!iihtbø' ~allY

r~
'i."

iteasn$før;l'~ml~*fnn¡ lh.a'a!$pQtød'Unk,ø~$\GsieQ:ífÌSl,raë&~'ärld

l.t~I,()1lø.:ére$.òns;'wøQld,i:~saàlñall::ail~itagtpdQ;.i$Èle'O~s,:
" ,l'"

",

(~~Uø~~!for'ths, f~$(n~ r~põJ~nl$whø:änsweted. ')e$~;tØ; q.uØ$tiíl:6were\tkert

:: ; ,"f.:'.,.

42'

,r
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058533

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 15 of 32

(,
1.

ask~;QtJQn6b:: ¡_at 1nparwrar¡ ,tnakcsyøu$ay ;that?~lleveiñaûm:âi)$Wßr$
f.",
;I .:, ,"

'p-'Qvjd~ ~y!r~pøJ'øf;tstØ) U1i$,'qQ~tiIJWèi;e,e.xamili'ß(,.aJ:d;'ønittbO$e"Wføgavø

iaO$W~ ÎÍIdiøg,lhY'Wßre,QØfiWsføt~b~rêa$()$beìøgaU~-'lanaely~.
.,",.,,'"

..

f". "' ,

ibeøau$6 1b¥h:adl¥pediltcGEieò.~,ca$,e?;tløymøughUh$Ywe(ø:,ø-lia,~ic'Ø
"wêb$jfeih~;'.laQ~ '.(j"be~U$Øthf:YitlJ'Ø,~lltflØ:;sit'_saftdiøøb¡rCØii$fY4h:

:1,''''

i,. ~

',

~GElC:O'~'wøte;lalbedian(ialìutØdTahlØ4lJ!$lm~eslh;refQi:Quøstiø.n ,$h.

. r,'.'

î\tfø.Js1ifSf:giYnilt)lhø:PøteøDtaê:.~msntel; wh;lhg'J1l_
/1

i

:t

'SPøI1sØtetinks;ö.ffëi~lÇØ~iUs:tcø~WiutCOASid~ffrth,l:e;asøßs'lhø,y'~
(b£baýing'lh~,tllXfit~,(fabla,4a~" Nøxt'¡~*~iW~)('rlsg.jtøn.f~''tet():~peteeRta~of

r:
f"",-'d

føsp.øiJ(Jents WI()'tñtihtthat;tfø:~PQn$øredUnks'¡ø1féIiØdSElPG:iø$ûrånee~ ,tallyih(l'
,Qnly'tlìo.st~whø~whêriirF1diCatin~i'the;fêa:sønwhY'tñ~,y!thØaght'SØ..,:answered'ltwas"eitnet

1...."... .

be,lÆse'ln:è,Yhadtyèd,jttøSfeo-.ibecaU$:~th:e.ylhotlg,hUlr~ywere,;øn;å,GEl~Ø
j~

(',""

wèbit~PâQë~,'arlæcaU$Erlfey tbOU9IiUb:~linlt,Yi$;afftrated ,ør'!tnneø$twiU
,--.aC:O;(måbe: 4~l;.

Ci

'f
j .~ . ...'" .('~.

(

l~
t~
,
L"."'S 1 ",:

(I
, '-

r
r','

i
;r,',., "",l,~

,t

,43

:i T

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058534

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
,I"

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 16 of 32

L
,. .; 'ì 'I "

i~lE4a; 1lrlltøN$$~Ø)l$:QREÐUNKS,ØfFE'RGEJC:Ø'I"$m.CE

r.

\_llÖO'tTì\rnNGlNlG:eQN$lllERÄllQNRe$:pøN()ENf$~~~$()M'SWHJ")
J1SI '

f
" f,,: .

:"~fnØ;d;':':intoWï.:$Ø~ ,'" , ' i$as~~,,:
IQS"i),: ,~'tllink' 1Întf:..~

~ "'" - .

;, " , ,', .~qd:ALt.$tA:n;ßEiQOd :GËlt,ö

F,"'~

, f~iDSraJæ:(;ll~f~,'"

f:. ~

f r (
i
'~,:,'..

f' L

..~~~Wj_..
:~~==~~
"',;'(f"Auló:m$.l'ãnÄi -:' ,

~Q
41:&,

;,.é.:è)
..' '~6&(J

~l.1

,(¡fO
, ifiB;l
.;

'~7~4,

4~'O

I'Ml'

'øter':.lSelC;()AFi,slJraäte¡~føriWilh ..... : 46Jfi

,4~3

44;Jil

'44~7

1j1l .,5~Li

.ln$Qr=~=~~ei;GQnl

:¡ =~;;t;$äG~'=:l~f'\~,~. '4~:' ; ~Hö;ai.. , "\:Ø~~arPidñæ " ,,~ya~~.~~~i~~hlli ;. :ll"
," ;øi~:ßâ;(tQ~,~~".n~ :',_.,~. ,";

., .QJJ, ø,2~O:, ,

, "2/11.:$,:
;'5,9':6 ! ,6:1.l,
:

Dff~o~'GEfCa1ßsu~

HI\
ij.4

"fiA

: 1. " '.:,r'.""'. ;

&1;1, :;

f c'
i.,
:'''"

A,'mim~t øt'findîÎlg$'al1e~'9ø'ftØøxaiJnatønQf'1EaQlø,4~t :'tllê~ ar~\tøi

fØ"oWff1~

If.,,~.t.'A;rip:"a~'.."t.~n:Ii,.lQ' Lr:'"~"~"T..'d'rt"ln '-d,P-..n:lrol;t(iO' .~~.:' ~~~. J "'. ,-J:"~~lJ~~i".ii\l.~:l. .-.\lU:;i.ui':Il:K; :l:~I£':'~~~.r:.at;I!','~.l=- .'._ Uh ''):

-r.'

t.,

~ndøif$¡thô~Ubaflbe,~$øøns~liJk$'Qtfêt'$SçO"i/J$~"fitØlI
:witlÛij'sfJfa1fè.frli:Øtbsf(i$lfpanie." 1i'èØ~'SJl$$ß14~OftlØ$

,lt

,Ij

te$pøeli,:f~abtthaHlie~n$)røUnk$,',øffø.:"ønty;ØEI.Cafi'Q~nqe¡'n¡

L
'.;" . ':6~'

'2;

..~.L ':f" . t'.~,.;..~I.:~;", . ~lil~i:~ ~~ U~~'II.~.~. ~tl~n..Cl~gL: _ ..y.l"~ 'r:lI:\;:

;I;u',.~m"ii\i:ari~'ii' 'w':i""..;a"..t...'.. "'~'".."....""\f1UiI.;""""~n,..i¡"""oi'.:a'.. n,,~ti'a' ~f,;

-t~
t'

'$iØ' ißtiîJøntf~;,G6lCor~. ,btlhi.(hIolPtØvte.quøt$~.øtøiret~aAY'

t.
r',

,44

CONFIDENTIAL ATIORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058535

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 17 of 32

f'
¡l', '.

"in$uralitØ.lhepertilt2øe$.'FSfrledin,p,ailgi'ph1. imniê(iatØlyanøve,wêre;
vfftualty irev.erSed 'Whíle'apprøxiinateJy6$Cøntølgro.ui)'2~rE$pøndeilts'fbø~
thattbeqPøiisørèd:;Liflk$"øfferø;GE:IOQ "iIJsulIceaIb'lfJwìl'ili$Oraßc8iÚØ

".\

t

'J ' i

r
r

øfhfmcøtnpanie~nitø~flanbaff'(5i:.:1o/~)1hquhttli''SØØòs.()~':t'K.soJe~,
''f()tl'ly,t3êl(X()ihsuænce..i
3'~ Eve'f~,Wib(lUlea~t,laltlre$f+C'Ønlrøl;griup:2'vØfs':CEmtiot
,grill. 1 +iCrñrø!9rt)~p3;ay~gØ$.l'it,iS,dearftønvf$uaQy '$xømiQí!l9lbe:

r

t
r,
I:'"....

:fiicge~ 'tñtørrø\êØJJlbf¡d$~(fe1'~lne$ntmJ$.rø~P,'1 + 'QQilir1Jtotp'
,,;l'1llawÌJitle Test+. :tt.lof:9lnQpi'.

4.Møsfleiiii19årelhe';fil)ding$ftQm'Gontrø:f'ørøup'~;,l1ese
rre$PQndent$~11o:,ft'nam~'NIK:l~ nøt;ø.ElQr)~an~ lff:Óiighffø'i:S''areJi
:te$ùltS!;pa9èCbiltaniøgaheøt9.anft~s.i;røhtesûlt$,tQr'liKlË .~'$;~ii($Ii,threø

f'
"

,(.,"'"'- '"

,$POô£eØ;üiJ((sc. :ÂlQUS tbe:jíamø"øaØ()'appe,a(~nowhæ;iø'n ~$é,ard'
!lUlfS;P~Ø., 'wñørt:,a$'k~Wle.ther;tfiei$pl1h$øre:àtíOk$;ø.rtl(H'3ElØ;

('
;1" .. 'l,' ,

'iÍn$uran~~se t(¡(i0f4e,ls,weremøre¡tikø!yftaillhØ Tesl'QrQta,(an4:CQntrt)f
rgroup. '2) 'resPøfløents~.t();tbjik:tle;'$pøns,øte(Unks;iôffère."SEiCQ"rnsu.ranCè.,
$peciPaí,¥~appt-QximátlY~ft¡rds:otifbe¡C'onkr!9,øtlP"3, íeapórr~,'ff.flbt

i
t.,
l~

J.aftheS'pns"r~u6l&'ofeiGØ~ø''fIl$f!tanøe.atcm;.¡n$iil1ÐØ:fiL1
iQtNCfpanles,~" Le,tb,Z$Jhøimhtlñat1lø.;spønSQ~'9f.~:~qnlt'

f

,l;Jc(j¡tJf)~n:cø::~
:EvèfHM*()ut;paY¡h:~t:ØlJ:eflti1lfø'll oo$.$,WñYtbaY-'Qivl"fø'lhb.1i$~, ~

rl~
íi

iÍrlng$'ír:th~cOntrøt'Qro~p$,.any'løwøaltlat;thír:kilbe.\lPØteUriks.4fer'
ril""rs':.l'~"'l-L'.."l;a'" ß'Q'-lni'n, wila'll......1l""'..B,e,.llh,ef' .....';;¡""h' 3;' ril\m&l"l~R' "..'''''08' ':t ~~I~V~ ~.q..l.~.¡ll .~,. :" .,' .lf".: 'G.;", 'ff ..:q¡;~~... ;i~~~~ ", _lL~I." ;

"':OlQ'I. : "'"~~.a;:~.I;~_. : :~iiD:. : , ~'.¡..""_

..
:f"'"

4!i
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

r...:!' ..

GGL-CNG058536

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 18 of 32

I

f'
GEICOørseøing:apage~~ntaJnÎigthoianiciSeai'dt.resûR$fötØS1Q().
'R~$pøndents'Whø'dQ¡tl()ttyein,tbe;.nain,e;~EicC)""anddo;,tJt.,'~. 'the.',riarne,'aE'I,CQ
ail;ywèteQn, tl~lÇ'rø$tiK$;p~'~'ts :bKefy:'()lhink'Ø1t'll~ Spøn$Øre4~ia$;

("

,(';.'

,)

. :1: .'r,.'.,

'WQUfcoftet'$ÈtCQlAl:lanØ", .lßevncebYthøfidiis 1tom:fheitbreäØJti(l1
f~
g:øuP$, 'maiiytacløi-i.rø;t~p,n~ibfe'tøtla(;nfSrQn'ßbsetVef'Willltbß;T.~st~tótJf1

tJ
C.

t-'

'rep~Ðd:enl$'.1ftb',ñn~9&'førh'£Øû;ølgi:øups;arø'Øöarø ~ø':tle.',~íhg$
dth.a'ii,.i;'''se"~':~nn",;Iö''..,l;\z,,n.i¡l0,
frôm.lté.IØ$t9røl1P~ ,Jl ;c.il$.iøØbtilØWiUt~lJø' ;lØf'~~iSidUe.',tQ,¡raêføl',;oie.r .'

. '. U~"_ ~~J.ir..~.~~I~ai..Il,~ ~~l,"~..

t~filø4b. bew" -Rnïaønr,'lh.,who.'whènJin1ipaffng,tñ~teêlllwIthe.y

r:

ltol!ght;a'$,pon.re.;lJ':ofer~r~ElØOiiluranceiar$.were(itwas~ilrbell$~
~tØe¥;hac.:l¥peqj'H~lEfÇ,():;:be~use fnaythøQghtfh~y war~øni~:GElC();WêbsitøJ()mfl

r
f'
l~,.

.f"...

,pafJe,E,r'tfet~'lbe.y/lbøa9titlheJink.was~afliafec;Øi"',cnlIneceøwih:'GE:C()..Nø~

,tlf.in.cøtaUo Iåbfe,4ai(WhlCñihatl tw:JirctaSe&'~fÏler~$l;each~~J), ~Q$Ø
the: ~ercøntgefør'~ø~T$; qn~'GËlCø'¡f)Uran~iaod:i~off($;$EroØ íO$Ur:i1~,~løflS;
wit~ .....arésò$ina1t.,~tbßy.weT(;ltórii~~ tbtJs. l;~bt~4b'qøRfåiÀs'ØnfY¡;tsínSfØ

f'
..':'!

L' .... ",'

percøntagltØfÍle~ (n,~GhtØlt

t
.l~
,",..'' ,. L

.i~

o l~~

l'

t.~
if,"

l,
" :r','.,'F',

,46
CONFIDENTIAL A TTORNEYS' EYES

ONly

GGL-CNG058537

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 19 of 32

L
1"

J.
.t~
i ;.

'f.U:~: 4b:Il:IN.klllß,SP()NSOREDiUNKSOF:fEI''ßEf(:ê:iltl$\:"!tMIQE' (l'AKlN$~Il():tQfl$lf)ERAî1ØNRESfJ()l4DÊØl'S'KR$\S:ØN$;'WF")

;t-'
"',1, .,

Its't
~aAl',; '" .'" :' ,ln:tø(iitatø;s~rçl
,flaSè',~: ,. "

,f

,, : ..:

'l' ,'"

,',

"ttø;nø'pU'tllnk;,îtlÇ; _..

1,.~r ;l
l~
.;t"..,

, 'Ff~:~ll-ç:QuØ$

:t3tticø . 'iAttSvAJT' ,iGEltí':fG$iQnj:
If.:tl

,,
~ø~o:

f

:r,_, Gìi,GSC,_ lnsnmneø): ; ,5;0 .~~~~~e¡~~l , . ,Øjeis
.' iP.lrø,S, "Il_:~t-:; "'. ~,.' 1:
" ~fuf ': '. tnsum'c .:\;,.~.."' -, .,. _. ,

2~1

f
t"'
',"

;JR$~~eétlnile:r'~'~ve' '
1
" ',r',

'=='ljliIL..$,g
, ;I~~.ømiçittiiflfS,"'tm!l :" ..Nî

I);Q

6jÖ

.0:;0

'";£iOO:,?Wa4.....U ~F e.ø:Q.Øipary;firöle YN
':::~~===:~ 'wìtb'.~. .

OJ)

tt,(J

OJ)

NA

.;.

3~t;Ø

';N)

i-',.
l~~"

t (
, ø'
"

1\caJl:l~'$.nÛ'm'tål1~4b,Whé.n tpnsumerswhø.1Mnk'a;,pailcutar

~.pøO$reØ'Unk(øfføis'~lEret)'iJl$ûtàiJ'Ge,àTe, '~ske:qtq;índic.tø:tbØ"føa$Ons;vJh~y!:tb:ø¥"

t

lbfnksQ. 'à:'d9jmínfmø$'.eVß.l~vera9Ødaêjøs'tê$t'~ndt.øooø.:W'OQ(;2~lindØi'5%),; ,
r"

iindi:fUrafltlê(rÇQnf~Qi'i$"dÌJ\fG:tlø:taetÙ1at,én~r'lfi~f'hat~'.fn;GaQr iUl,ey

L'" ': .
("

tJo:t1bUbèywer~øiHl'Gelt()Web.sì1lQlteiPåge;,or:fhø¥~1te;lírkW~
,alliedorCOtled WiaEICÇt thÌ$:~nipa(es;tó~%wnø'm:iS~iPØUGñl

tfala;nqn"$PQ'n$ø$l)$al)c:Jfokff~ntioniQQ:$Ëie()s:namø.øtfreßSlt()Jfi~~n:CØ

r'

t
f
:t: -. _~

(efltrf;Qro~p,R).

~~

iff
CONF'D~~t;- oNL '(
'" íTORNE'(s

~)" ;õ'. ~~':

Jl'

:.;¡.

fir"

.,~f,

GGL-CNG058538

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
!'

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 20 of 32

to.

!

f:
lh)bo.ttØiline,j$,that,lEaltl(~o.fWJ;êthetónedoes:'()~'døøs;n'oUåkø'JI'fo-

(,
f'
f'
'1 '

;cøíl$idør-atiónlbe'reasons,

te$p.derìts

gjVe førfhinking 1hafaSpops:Q'Ød:Umk:offør$

G'ElCQ'sifìuÍ'aitcer theføv.e:øhwfftJ~jOl1 failslotiseto;a'lè\ÌeJgenera~:,ß$i~øl;

a~bf~.
lliNlW$'ni$P()NS()_'lJlN~$:ll~È

r'. l-

. . ì~

A1,U$,lNeSS ReLÁTlØNSlllPWlHiGElCO'

T()~èS/CQtiiOßÆ!$l(Jl)lJ$¡n:øss;aSø,ciati.on'()i'J,~fatQ1h!P~ 'ï~~nfit
,âJlfOlit'f1tQui1s;'were,':then:askedthe'~ëkØ$ti,ood7"series"'re9ardiÌt9/eacl Øf\be,illree

i

,f

. ".,,'..

'Sponsored tinks':"OQiyQU'tfTjttlttbislinkdlfS: hàve: abUSÍiiø:SSiialaliØ¡j$h¡fi'wil~.
,ltIfì$iJG)l hav~ia,bus¡l!,l1S$' relaÐQJ1$'h!ftwih..orat;e yøUtlotsUlt:aDalitn/$?" Vi:hi~
lÌ~llàme used\inth:equestion wasêEI'COfor:ré$P'nJ:føntsnlr,tJe I;estjgr.()~p'atld:
~ÖØlÌtiØI;gr~ups 4and3" 'thatname:WaS!ALl$~ATE fQrte$odnfin'CøtlQl'øro~p't.

f f
r !J
f',
l_~i.

jt:a$l."Oønnql'groi.pZ~poh,deptswère,askedtb$sarre;¡qußsllon :r~~i:f1l~',afo1Jãh :Iifl.

~ "'~irØl--~lCO~om~any!Profile" ~öneof::theaínks;gei1erated by'thø~r.aK
Sëft taG(e 5aisetìm:anzes;thø$e; rØ5olls'-

aa(Qi¡ø'($wøjn~Tabfø?5a,.;it'shØlfdbereccgnfzedthaUhere;miQ.~ma1)

r;
', (.~.' .

teasøJ!$forrë~pøndø.r,lbinkí1bat,:a )Sp;òl1redl;iok'bas,:abusjr1Ø$~rati$lip.\wllh

'~Q;,18ndnøtalf'Qf'~~s:;wø,ufd.ri~i:lYi-âVRaiytjll~'tø:ÔO'\wi
'~aGO~$alfaØlløns~, ;FQttlJisreøsøn, 'f~pøndEmts'wfi,,';ail$wørett;')e$-r'tØ-qu~ijn'1a

-,

L,
f-,'

Wt~'tbøn:Çi$ked':te$()n'tb:: ~aeft;P8cdiØ~tnfif¥,øri'it¡fildll-fJ.;:~pøsore

t.~

.Iibft: dos tra,VQ;àil!tl¡ne'$"re4i1i$híp'Wi--:'I1S' niøv$iatiin'l;ii~f$¡pi,ø.edif)Y'

~~otAØtgiS;q,ues(iøwørøøX~~anà;Qø~lbø.'.Jlay~;an$WØ$
f..
u

iJKlëtlfglhøYWëretØlitU føt-tl:ø 'røaSt~,ib:eín'ål~-;iim~iy~'~$eAlie¥

r'..

48
r..''.., ~.

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058539

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
.,

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 21 of 32

¡,

r;
1

hadtydJnSlStC:O~ ~S~lhø.Y1hØuglit:t"'a.YWere,øii;ac,(3El(;Ow.ifellømø''Page~

r
f'
if,,""

()£betusetbe,lb~lJbtlfe;sit,waS':affliat~;ørøøtiileGØQ:wib 'GEICQ ..wørøtaiiìe
andtalmâ~: Tt;b:ls!:5lir'$uinrnanZØ$i:thø;:i~$.lt.:tQr(;uøtiol'7:b,

AtfeJiti~n;¡$ø'$tQÎYøil(w.tie:t$t.ænfa9Ø:Qf;t~PØtløni$~Who'thØtlgbttbata
:1'.-.

,SporiSOtet ¡l1kdi flave:a.I)U$lnesitêlaØîWp;Wi:h :GaQwnhøutcon$f(leritlth~
:rø.asonstbøygä\l~,førltVi,ng 'thø.ltQUSlits'tr"~:S).;tiexattentiøJlj$~hiell;tq'Ø1
.1,\; :. f".K: ~y~.tW .. .~~. :":Y' '.e~t',V'-l'l~. _a:IG).~ . i'i!. U.:I~~;:.¡;.lt.~. ~: .." ~t:.;'~,: .:.:~~~: ~:: '..'.W;: -": :'~ :'~~~ :J.~
'tAo't"&;-":nAr"'~n'w.'i:e ""'f'rì:_..;.'e' ft;';, W'~O' 's:.,riñWl'''';~r.n' s' O(i'_'-"'1'::n"k'" 'A:;$'b'a"~e' "a" ..k~a.'-lh'r"""

r
-f~,

!rdlåts1û'pWÌ'$2lC(J~ fa,øt1'~Who;wlrenjndicän.9.thareaSO"'Y'lll~Y'

r t
f'

-,

;iiø~tsø~allWøfedifwa$;;øif1l'er~U$ê;tbY lia4ty~d'i,iJiGElG~~ ,beeasetb8:Y
tllöusñttheywete.,øn ;ciGEle.(ìweh$itølotne;iP:ase:,,:ør;bø~QsellJGy,.thoQglittbelmk

~sâlflät~'ør;Cni;ad~iWi'(GEl(tQ'frá~lØ!$b)"

r
· ',J.:-

. i \,.

.. '

:;" -f
í"'~

l
l"
.'
. ',.': !""

t

L
,",:"

r.
.if " "

';49:

f~
A TT CONFIDENTIAL ORNEYS' EYES ONL Y

GGL-CNG058540

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
r;
L

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 22 of 32

11

I

tlBlE$a:~:~~it::=~==~c~=il:~ir~=l::::~~e$S
.',PQIlS' , 'Ini=DiA'IÏI;N' ',;teS' :nõ'N" '~e*Q:s"""'D;è'A"S' 'O"':.S" 'U.IL~')'"

r,

~.~.l".:. Ii~~.i~..~ '. ':~ '..F'.~. ~ :.':.~:l;.;" ~~_..l ..". (;;.:,~n.:..~ .:.

r
'rd~
,,

" ,

IE$f
&f;£cQ
".'.t10:t).
.- .. ..

,;', l :t'':QcØ ;
1

OøntroI
~2"
,

',.'. ~ ", _. i . : \~.: ;

Öonof
,~',
iN.lKE .:. . ).:.....

'.:tlm~¡~jh;:tø:~Îf!ítålØrs_Çn

(.

i6~$e':., "

GElCQ'
íSO)'

;~Eit;ô
;(411
'%

.1\~G:E$lb; 'I+£1':C1+C
:tt4lJl
.~;'

"~

,:~

¡(G~L

'î~mi'

f ., .d". .

'd;l',-',J);y '" 'iorn. ,Q ': ..,.'oeveøQ D 'wlhl ' , ~r dí" .. 'hi" ,"

.. ....... .....- ..... '.-'

%
'.

:~

r
,L
,L'~ " .;

t:rè,:~~~: '
.,

,',' :b.Q~.fa$~lt.$a:o~

.GE:rco.'
,

,ÄllstAlE :$EteØ 'øao'
¡

.f~~ome:"~)
"" .: ".'" . - :.:.:-":. ..~.., .: ~'.,

:$littl

,
;.

2ttO
'14)0.

.'

'1$;2
..

2T~3

;3.ttS

23'iW

Shop¡

fÖJ,A\lø~iiçØ ," twwmsuream!Cml

3'1:.7
..

3:1:.2

'l$;~2

,

:$1.:$i

t5~ß¡

"

lil,tiaitètfntlø.r --~àvØ'
,~ji;lsmal;J~efndér~,eômi
.. .. . ~. . '. ... . '.
,

27:..7

'ftto

34;0
,

d21.8
..

; ..

..

..

:2.9:7

1Uti

r
i-~
..
(.'.,.... 1,

'YÀHØör~~O;Oøi:pçinyPf.ofÎte:
(fJl;y,abQO.çomlc11'011Ø,6'(6~h'll
;t

,

~

llA

#A

-',.-....;..'.:

'59'6

j

N1\
';

"

M
Ø~lØØ:

,~'I\v~røQe,~f~,øv~:øS
iA nùtlQef.of,f,iu¡liag~~ineçe fìøm'

r
:

1:$Jl

examinatiofi'òfTapJø.

Sa" The:SEï'afø the

~ !I~- n , ~løJiiwi. !J
'1., tleariØns4l1JidQf'tñø- t~_sp:Qnr/~nts;¡rï'tñe: l!estgfQiral)i:fQQntfof

d

.~ i''" ,.

."

f9JøUP~';ate,~øn1tiø;beiev.i1:'lheaêbQI~~thi:~ø~~pønsø.ed,ltnkltha$..a.

L
L..
1:

:w$in.e.;røatWJ1Sbpwi,éÊleO",
, ,Z'.Wtnllê'4i\!eiS~për~tali~ifE1t'iC_Ølør,~sf.f .~i~rE!

t
r r
c..

;sl,lira:cl :trm'Ilø;t¡_()dihgtesØIf$.fØh~ih:~(,,wiÛkltae :avøJatle,øftfø'Iesl
~::t~~.;Çi : .'. :~\.. :'.~1, .~I~~, \~'''~'U"~J;;~.:~~:. ':~ ~.=~:..' ~!". ..r~~~;-:;. .:i!i. . ~ '. :,~'~'~l.i~iq.. tK ~if~~.~.Ia~e

'n"-,in.''''Ð'd' ',i;'S' '''e' '..t.I'..' 'c-."'~Ä¡; tiriU"Ä 2': ",s"-ba' "'e' '-nø.'ui-e' 't ""~"'s' .-A)(nÄl'n'l'"

16-'lbe ..n~rê.Ptòvl~~~~'lfI'T~r+'~:Qin2;,.ai,:~$ 1+'3'
$('

CONFIDENTIAL A nORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058541

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
1,
'1'

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 23 of 32

I'

.

1!

l'

i3%,J)eJòUr~ 1i5%re\íelth?ït~;:¡nilyøxeñenc; 'C,. :usualty'usØ~âS;a.
threshoIEtbefØrø:fiøld¡ng ,a;æmus'¡QQ,fjndiilø':bø$ufentt;_açge"clSiQ,bE
aQfinabi~,

',.,"" f,

,f'
i ~.

3.Wnt:teJhreefSpøJlFec(Ufi5J-'fl't paø~nøali iQ&$ 'øl:CØft,

r'
:, ':. ; '.S

9l(C),qp;2 resPøQdeJ;l$aretoøfu~'miølilieVln9fttømlorganics.itecøa'tanj(¡g;

t en:ame~ ,~ :.n~$:a,tlusIOØ$;re:Ii;U"nsii"nI,~j~q~,~. '; h' ,,',.. '''8' l"Or'i'" 'b' ,'.', '" "f.... lo" 'n~l..~i:~n

f'-'"

eVël)i~o.(JtP~agatt~ntiOÏlIøIQê:f~n~~øn..ts9fø.:t:orllØjrbeit~, '
~;J

'fi',

,thiiikiAQa:Spol\etn,;htkd_;travø'..a1):U$ine$~,rw.Îifd3ac() .ba$;tløDñ~ to

f
rdd

dO'(ëilerwlt:llävin9'~Rl;UØ:f1amø~te(\(jr$e~~;øg~;JXmta'jJlli;'~!Øgan,/Ç
søarcti re$U(fs::førGt;(C(l,~espøn'den~swbq,(lø 1iøi;~pe:În:lheÐàll~GE~Q;aAddø-

n:øts~ the,Il~IT,é'$ElC('any;ereøttthøJseÇlfcñ ;r~.patie ;ate;a$:likøiy'lo-:titlhaf

a'$'pønSQtè(lljôks'q~s ha"Øai'Qu$i~ teratilsnj)~~aco,;~,teSl;dèrisWhØ

t,
," . ': '" . .':,.;. 'I"'"

'(lo;'.~iii'~'nàJê'GEieQáld,'tk'se. 1ln~~$a'CO~ØlinC;:SØâ(4ì'''rØ$;pagø'~
,A$,~;fin.dill~S:iftOOfll:1h~Ø~'CoñtfØt ~ou;i(øv~rtmaBYfaètQ:i;$arø,r~l)$íbT.è.fôr

Jhøeqrjs;oû.øbseWé.Wifhthe t'eSlQtøoprøsØferii$. 'ltønlhø' fin:ding$:fòrfu:~
..
(,..,""

~tØnttøi9,ronp$,tlre,cømpêl(edltothèiRiigs.ftQ~Jb~:reSt'9r.(llJli ,fb'~nf$ìØii()btaJfid

(
. .:.'

,w.lt'lfteJatlercfit'j$;QlJe'to,factøf$øllrtlan;;fliøs;be1n9;ataQed,,~,'GÊiCØ:.,
täbfe"~,belØWttali~t!JltvillØStB'n.O~;.n.'¡n.íe.lìng'lb 're.'~y",lñ"

L..,

'thllbta!SpoJìsø~Unk;ØOØliavø-a'b.u$nesl'elb;P.:GE~~an$_edñ '
''wa$.,eilti~\lØ:'lbØ¥'~hà(J~,iin, GEfe£~,;~U$$ØiY:~'hUñeY'''ø'øn;a:
'SEtQO"webs~e; pa:gØ; l;rb:eca$Ø,:fhø.yfhQu,gb.itJiOk.wa&;âfi.atedër'

-,t
f'

:$Øaøø'withGEfOO.,

t
r r
si
CONFIDENTIAL

ATTORNEYS' EYS ONLY

GGL-CNG058542

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
)r,

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 24 of 32

r'

~,.

r,

1'

tAatlË$b:ml,N~",G.lt'.$PQØ$OREI);L'.~$';Ì¥E',AaY$,NES$

r'
1

'CQN$lbe.tløN,~ES~llneNJ$;",q_$.ØN$'~)
, ; "

~tlØN$lllP"-i ~$El.eO,lt"ll$.lN;rO:

r'

TEST

:ContØI
"

,a",' ',',

.'N,' 'mø'lwied in

r:
..

.8aSe:i::"" '

'tø'Ìlitsø~irciti . ." ....... . .

1

GEtG:Ç)

..' .. : "'. . ~ ". , . " ". :

$16'ÇO
~(5Ql
,%:

CØOltol: (CònfrøJ :2 .. :3 tSi;-iCQ !~Jl(E
; ;

:Â~Ë$
(14&)' ;%
. ..

r,
',.r,'".~

',~~~~
,

,01~~:=l:=~r;=l~::G;,
,,',' ,'.., ;':,:".,..'_ ',Øîè.:eø) .. "', ~" .

,r

.....-;..

.$lQJtofAUt~nsu~néå "" Ww:i n ;i. .......i,"s.u.", :Comcø) re .....,." ....";

~'"

,,

'tiill)

$
..
'.. .

t41)
'%:

(5.)
'%;

." . .¡ tm
%,

ØBi.O ,Ai:l.~tA11 ,ØSlQ() GØcø
;

-

't$~'8:

ßkf
.. ;

1~;;il

5JJ
..7~3
: .. ;

, ; :" 1,4,.'~'

$)1

.' , ~

'!5Ji

'2J)
"

\f:P:6'

14Jl
; .

4.?l

r
l
f-"
'f",'
;l~".

'in$tlta_nc,:¡f~f~:\$avØ: '

"

IAf:ønJ~,,Gi;le~lçØipØilyPÌToñt~, 'l"bJZ1I ,', " om.il-Ðttoa'l&llbn ',:, '",ya OQ,c,', .. .., .-,' ,'_' .' , ,
. .". ~". "... .... .

- . . '.. . '.
(WVJt'smneefindeUinm)'

17:8
.. '-

Z¡Ø

:tt5
44;7
.

;$;5:

1:4\;9'

3~.7

J!iA:

ll.

'NA

i

fg,
~4.~
4;~r

'jtVgr;n~ø.f;~~v,~~j
.. .. ..

r
..li:~:'

,¡tS'CiA'l1s,een',fíØfTahle;5lr* ',wfe.n ;êØ$tJ~f$WbotñfØk;~partCtrar

,Sp.Ol1s.red JJidkinas;a'ibusines$reJatlOlhîpd GElÖ:are'askegilø'tnQWtetbe
,:iea$On$Wliy~.:nØ,¥tØir:sø" feW';(14:t- 4~7=1(i%)ìnwaafeithtUi~ir'eo.rsiØn-íSictUØitQ:

f
, t'

,ll1~lact1ñaleitë.rtle;Yltd~ji!'GaEQ~lhY'tblh(~:YWe'$f;n;a,~ÊjCQ
wøh$løíØre:ri~~;()I;~1th~UftØ'1Iil((:~,æfiiat£~(hir.'èØJ1,~'~Wi,;:ttC-(~

i.
l...

lbi$',CØPärt$tò45:%,Y4ø~nilhø.Uliai,a'n0';~P~Ø~~nicjir;
i.fÏflQiîinl~Q!soaln11aqabus.nësi'qnshill.GEtcOl)0li9,tØ.uP/2). ,
'TaA.lwll_'I"I'ri~'ì¡" 'Ii.'4' 'n:a'..---',."..',¡..a:e' '.."_ ,':Ìt",: or' .;-'es' , "n' 'ìS'l,-f,~'J,.'n'l'o."

l;ll~-.~.lJa.,l::, ria.~..:.llQ,l;;~r.~ J.~~.f.:ft~l '.r:..oi~',!~1 ~ :.", ,':!.: Mll:~. ~ .~.":

cøn$fdetátîonlbe';rë$ol1$respøeAJí.wø:fòJfiiiltõn-glñalà,$Pøß$:ø~UtílJa&a '

L

b;ll$iØØ;:fêfsbi~;wJ,;éEtOO. lh'ìØ\it Qf:actbf~bte/oolUíØ.n,falSlØ$:)iêad$:~~.

r
í'

52

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058543

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
i I:

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 25 of 32

Jr
(,

. ~.,

',f" 1'.. ,

fe",

l1lll-KIN$'$PQ:NSØtmI)UNK$llA~ÊQeE"'ÀutH()~lZef)8YGJ$IC,Q
loa$S$,cøO~$iØl1;~$:lQ,;SlØh$Qt$l:PQrêIutorii;añoÀ.rePØdenlS iliälll0u('

""I;.,

rr;'~

gfO,UP$wølE''ll1G'a$ke41be'QuØ$trøii1l;søJiies:rëafd~:eatiQtth:ttae:;$pøSØfØ(

l'
.'
íf-, "

tf';

Liltks~;i1t;;Yôa fhi1/flI'sl¡nttnø$b.øtl/alimêf~b'Y:f('tpanfl~ fQø'fer

-f~m~tiysl~.in.$()tai1t;~fJnØtl1Î1t!f!lt"o~Ødl!feomp8FJl~ tø(iftør
;...:yi:"~IJ...fr.~jf ,,~ ~'nva..'Çl.I:;,~~~ø :::.'V.~:~...~';i,~.. '". . :~~,(a',~ . ~Qi- ULIh7..' .....~l:~lI,~,':RRr~~:.~; _.. ',,:~:

'!hhmnl''nr¿;,l- f",,,,,__ A'-;OOiiVf";'O' t"""#:'~'a' "i.,.....'iJ.i':?'" '.ni:fa,'.i.'''lJlna'n'ü

J(
it:

~'.~itllle:,aUØ$II'WGEC()fòtrø.~l$Jnil~'TØ$;ttt()a~ián(t:Ct)Rfrøt
~ps;~ao~,'tnát,Qäme..wa$-lS;tATE:før,(espønlënts¡íi',eøo.trøl!9røu t..~$l ",
;ÖønlrQl,srøaP' ,~re:;pqntlønf$ werø;'a$ked1nesaire;auøst¡ØD.:~~ärditllJa'fonrthl¡nk'~

Jf
\'/i':"

Ü:~H()Gl;, G'EfQ;()'cØompany'Ptofilø" --/òi1e of'tb:elinl(s :QerieraløcIi:by'theøtgånIC
$èattf, ta'b~6a$umm,añes~'tlet;esllft$~

h

",r

!aerrêréwefigTabi:';S.a~if'$tlfdl1eieeøniZea"tfttiørêmigJïtb~many
;l'a$oiis':fr¡r~ooenl$th¡llk1-l'llt¡a,Spø-l$øtef;UÍl'k;tisf~'iv.edautltortiÐÐ'OT'
,.$Pon$(r$lí:f£~',Gsco;, 'ai¡:I1Qt'aliøftbeæ,'reaons,.wØørd;ctlØC$S:ântyiiavean~ijíi1~1

l",-'d "I ."; :.

ff
ff
",~'

tødØ:Wi~El:G(J;r$:al~flørt$. ;fø"'lh$tea$(ri~tË'pøJjdentëwbøiäl1red);e$"'lö¡
, ,~tiil~a:aiwetelhli 'aské(\t'Q~ØQ13b:'Wlat;, iÒipadîlaG Tirake:tyou411;nkili6;--

:$pønsø"nljnk:l1asbeøn"àlJtiø: b.Y~Jø.J)ffTlMJii1$li'l'" 1'vènJatrn

can$We.ftO:WtØd:b¥røs~dE$tø;thquØ. were,exahl~.anth)nly:lt-~

:.a~,aÂsWì$;iriiøa1f09'ibøi'wøreçørm$'èd, foritøreasøn,s;bøiQgca'Ø~$øø,-r!àlefy~
t~":" : ' :i \:',. .
h.. .se" :'lt..ll:'~'-oi,h-l..l.rl¿riiti":h, 'be'''ca', ... ,~.. .:l.i1.t~f:K¡~''I~~,-,~''V~L~" ",.:..,: ..........'U: 's"e,.h:~:'a:À","¡h't"'':i:v"we'' """'-",a'"ier:tc: U~~~/Ula~.:~~;T... ::l-.~'-"I:l.,. ~~i:..:..~.'
J.,."." ..,. .

,0,

'i';'

,,.,.~;ll:\.~.RV'~'f'=''"t~':if¡'a'rto''lI..,-.n-''''lb'::J;~ ......,~:l..... ,,'.;'.',R.,',..,''" . ø:~~.,.'., ~~.,~,~l~.'.....',,:~, :..', ; q . .JI ' ' ' : , ~~,....,.-..:::Qt~~ evlh .ht,lle:s~ wa ' ~'affit..i~or'OOftfieêted'Wi
'(.EJOO-were.'lUíedJ;iQd:tJat. lllbfø~5h$tfA~ltfft.esll1tfør~u:ti' l¡b,¡

lrt ~
: ~,: .~

I,,," , "Ë" ~¿. ,..j'

p,q;

,',

I;"' "t;

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058544

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
I'

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 26 of 32

L

r
:_. .

TltS'LE,Gå: "i=::~;'~:'l::=~~J:~~Ji~:~~l:Ri=t:~:::Y'GEtCØ

r

'.~RESøN$Wi;r)

i'
~:

t"'",..,',.,

¡ tESif

;QQnf¡,øl
'1

CøiiIrøt

, :CøJ!trøïAVEGlaS

. .. "..- . ,..-

.ai.~~?;:" ..
i()acø40$tfnfcef'í-

NåÆl~,\.'ìiilQ'inilø'~a;fGl,

Gaè:o
" (1&1\

, fd '"

"$

"itSti : "'.~

,::~lC(f

2', , , ,3 ,T+C2;Cl+Ç$'

ØEtr:êl
%

im ..

~

:;t~. 'll . r 1."~Q:1:.

t:i5~ 'f ~.'..~

:$" ~,'

"i105J' '%

--". "~t'

r:
. ...,

',aa, !foyouthiØkliíikl "bas,hèìi :(3El((),

, ", " '~ul~.ñßd~YGÊiëø,tøøffër'
;F~bi.stJfåæ';Ë'Ui~ ·

Alt.STÄ1Ë ,(il5lCt) :GSleØ

r"

,(~.Ali~13ølle;~m~
Stloprt)rA'Øø'Jrlsurånèe

':$1:1

tltll

,:;27:.:'l'

ø2:7atA

2.~7

f"
,", .' r'

,29~7

rwwJnsareOorn~:oml
. .....

tQjO:'23~4'

Z1.i8:, /ll1:7 16c2
1lt230':4 1fa~2;

lnstJ(âl1cØ,lÌlttër-'$age; tYijinstJrancefihd.etèørn~i

2ft?

14';(l':l1;9
N'A
,

r:
('d
~-.
(,"'"

¥AH=;~e:~:~:;s:=~ W\
:Av~!i~:pffl~a~~nes

.. ' ,"".., ..', '"

'4;2;6

NA

RA
:2'$:5) .. 19)(

ÅnUiheroffidînQ.sertergetrOff;exallîhfiøn:øfTcd;Jlë:GCl:., 1Jf1ese JIr~tli

f
t~..
"

fø1føWirlQ'-

~ :r"

, 1,~ øJl'avertø';,;apPfÓxí~telY:$% øh:øs~~t\fs:fF\'lìe. t'~st;9!up:
L',':t ,

ândeotról1Jrø~p'Zál'e.:~$~JfiQbéne,\lifÌ~'Ibat;e~n~h:Qflh.~.th(~ ;~p,on$øl$

t,

'Unk$!ba$,~lla,ut()rier;;nY'ß;ÊiCÕlôøfet'GíJQÒ:ln$UlahtØ.,

t
1" f, "

2L ihØ¡t-vøralepetGènf~øfsfØ~fØr~t'ltøfO.up$1i'an.d!:3¡tveâ
.Uithø:~siøriøvì(lenceib~ th T$tiQf(o.~p;afld(Cønftølgro.up'aJ$:Piimaiy

4ue,~tactOi$'iQ1hrthti;~:b:E(ng .ø:ø'b$aC'Q~, '_OO1ñ~'~VØf~fl~

J:

'55
CONFIDENTIAL A nORNEYS' EYES ONLY

r,,"
.:t

GGL_CNG058545

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
r

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 27 of 32

l1 . '

i
1 "perCètêØnfu$jøJifdr~troiørø..aJ)s 1 and

3issublraøt::ffØl,Ihe

r
r' r'

'eøfre$p:önông"ëV~IQf;cønfiGiö,tl'følJndwittbé"TéstgrQull~nd,Cømtrøt,9tQup:2.

"tierOOPfu$lfiOAAtl'Øutio.ful;(29;5:-l9::4 =)apprtl!XiP1tltaly1iØ%:.l'is,

tØ~Pll(ê$"kï4$~Wh() Jnistkëf1tftiØu~pttl\ata,øøn-$p.n$ø~,~Qmantc;linR

l

m.en(onI(~~EleO~snare.fl(l~eAaOfhøriØd byøaÖQloØfr aElt'Q
1iJ\t(ance."tCQI1to(;øioUP(~).

r,
r.'",.' .

eVêrtWilhø1l,..paYin9!àtten1lOÎø~thé'reasønS'~pøden$:igiveili)r.thirbelrè(~~
fhiö~ÌI~óUiat~.$pcs~r.~,Uurdrad'beën ;atî~~ibY'$ac'ØtQøfédt$:"ilsua~:~$i
nQiljß9t(tdii:elér'Wi.baviø9:typed~intbé;ñafte :ß!SI~Oor$ø,einga;¡~S9e.~ntaining'

'.

r
Fi
" ,¡'",,_;, , N ,..

lbé:ørgal1l(:;setøcf~SUIts:,;t()r';(3f3eO.,Resp:otictent$~'WliQdøl1øf~e:Ùl(óenalIé

ß:EleÖÇlf1ddQ ,/1lsee¡tlenalie,:G'ËICÇ),i;oyvhéréòn,tte.GearCltesU)l:SJiagaa-reas;

like.¡tQ; thirklltfbe:$flflSQred''trik,liad,:been 'a4tQried;~YGaCQtO(Øffèt'it$

iin5niac.:'AsttIihdio9$frømtñø4llfØØ.Q'OfÙOl'grotl$,rø,VØcKman¥factQts,äl'a;
t~l)~jbJ~fàf'fß&;eöJl$IØl~Q'bs:iVeó witlhTestgrQUp,;resptdeJûs. ,m'p:oinhiif
taa;';~høn,tne..'fiÌ1dir-9f; forthe;cør'trøf'9ro,~psärecøinpareq,to:tne finding,s'frprolhø'¡Test

;','''' (.

r
' '.,;.

$tQ,~lt, ~~'C'nfùfon,obiaiheq Wibfte:Jaftertlanyis;duølo:fattQr;:;,øtàer ilb~Jhse;
¡aefrag;alf~édb.Y~EJC:Ø;

".". ( .' §,

N.0w;~i(fet tfe:øa"'When ;COlísrderatînl$imvel1~lhe feaøn$Wlylle,
l'~

.'es", '~..-l.."~9lveklr,~nQcor!J~,li;:lli'll$f'eg\l.. r " ,Ql;iu.. ,'. ',".l:. 'i:,.~.. ,", "&.,...~'. u, " , ,:.

L
("
t

L
L,

58
r"

L

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGl-CNG058546

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
Id

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 28 of 32

,I

C

i.

f
,i

l:Al1lE':6b: iHINKfNG$PONSdREDLiltK$ØAVESeSN MltligRlæll'BY'Gl:lCO'
.'(tÅKíß"INæQtoNS(D~MIlP.,Rla$P~NflE'Nis' '~RfsåN$'_IJ.

fEst

r
:: '."

0;Qot.

CØiltøl

~*'

,Ham~,~;m.;;Íø,ilim~ê;~eaich;

ØF;C('

"'~~'
'1

e0nøl Á~:R~
,,3 ~T+e2:C1i

't,~~
'%

~E"t" ~~GQ'

'z.

,F~
'%

. .:,"~"r.1.

%

"t$~) iI~1 "f1:('

r".."

...... "...... "..

l-E :o/ct% ' '$

.. .

,,
'1' _.,

1l~ød " ,', .., ,
. .. ". . ,
. . . ... - - ,.'...

.n'...',:t.. . uo:U:l"".lnk',.,P¡riLiJ".. ,if'as'd'ir;'ee:'- ',;, ~ s . 'io §,i . , ~UJ t.~ ..; n:1.~'.''' - ." .!l,:P _ ('r,

GËlC~d Atl$:TA11,f3açø 'SEltt).
..

&,J; ~i:",v#'" ,iNE' ," 'C',:, : ",', '"lnsflOOr v, :~l~"":i' "" .iOQueJ~ '0,': '....'.... , .. ", ': '~

t
.".;.õ;., -,.r'

f:teQ';Jli$lrånçe:QWitè, ,,', '1i.ø iiWw~~ome.ttm)

8.Q" :14;;9

f2:t1$~5); 't-tl.
t4;~ 1tt9 ø:

r .$køp3tíno,triAótm(;.!ø(m~n~'2JJl :~ s 1 :et; : c )'
lnstrarice~f:imdøt~'$~v~ '

\41Ø "'t2.tl
.0."0'"

tWJl~dnS1tanæfìi\d~r.c,on)

2£t8:

'Çt:.:.,

'17,&

Ø;d,t:!l:6
'IS

" ¡ß

i'
I.'
;' .....
~'...," ("

'¥ÅtI':'OOèo è~pclriYPt()file'

".-''. 'a...,'".o~Ö6.&~..1.', , "(. t. -cøidt it \

NI\

Ø'A ; '29Jl ",itíA

.'~..J:_I'~.. ,"...' _ "'.I::l ..-,..,.-'.IL-ll..,.

:J~ve~dø.:çt.Ø,'á'l;raQØS:, ·

¥.

"'1.ø.:$i ,9;

.4'øanQe,~enftomTlîJø6Q.,Whencøsullei's;whø,th,ih'k, c:':partCUfat

i$P'Øllre,Unk:b~$:,~Il;aùthoñz iby'BfËl(;Ølq,,~offerIt',jn$n.ce:arøasked,tø
il1fc~fe4be.reasns;~why:~y:lbnk'~()~ (~W'fle$$ ibaii 'l,Ø%îihd~e¡thafJlieir'cønfQÍ(n
(it
, Í$qlIø/t(fthláct~tbahdlnør tlè¥'had-t¥l:)êtUnOOrco; $e:ythø.trgbUliéY weéiQIl

r.
:;i-'~.

. ~c

, if.

at

ß:sicQ.~it.mép'a~;,Qr-¡lhØlytn()QglU~tñ ll ~a~,âfliafedøfCOfted WîUi

L
,l,
if"

" 'IßËJCO.lb cøpal1:lQapprøxtéJy3&.0/ wlio;;rnÌ$takønl, llÒql'ht\tfata;fiQIl

;spJ;sør~!QlQan¡G;JinkmetìØØfIS~C)$:nåme:bRd!b:è.n,autlreQli,¥GE1C,Øio

,QffèræiC'Ò:ifi~u~ca (kQß.l:9.mup~l.

r l r
'(-.

57
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS. EYES ONLY

GGl-CNG058547

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
r.
!

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 29 of 32

r
if '.

1'e,ibøttø. '1i~'Ìs;mat"r.egafdfE,øfWbetØK;ø\dØè;ørdØØtiol,fåkøinto
'CQn$ÎdØfa.tiøilthe:if~asøRS:rø~,øndei;Qivø'fè:tlnkii19th,ata,$.risør~,tiØk'iñas,ibeen

(i
L~'

f'

;aøllÎedbV,(3'elCntQ.øterifirisu~çe~~~~~g¡fOr.:ti:jØ(ñkør?l'j¡øi$:Ei1ia. '
lh~t;êYøfø.f~ct,øJ1ab.le,conhtslollÌ$JØ$: lhønf(4

r
,'
._o"'J

r"

C'

L

r

i-

f r
(i
L. l.:
~" . l~~

~ L"-."

,'

r
r:
58

r

CONFIDENTIAL ATIORNEYS' EYES ONLY

GGL-CNG058548

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 30 of 32

L

r.

f'
(

:l ,

O:ØNØIJ,U$I~$.DiQPltliO$$:
.aa$~:uø:øn tlèJør~Qir:dai"aflana'iye$,.fnyæn.clusipß$.'ate',asfølløW$.

l-'

1.peoJe;~ø.,;tia~~GBQ,().øl:iaGGÒ1e.$lå!p~fte.and\~
søøerateaS:èäid' P:Uk$;pa.$e'tháL.î)l;addîtRtø1beT;øsldl$,øffte~i¡9,alÍiç,
searcb'assøçjate~lfflame.GE~, ;ptoi~ldéS!Spøn$Qte14ìiksfø.Qlher

r:

r r
r
f"
1."

.' :~Ultøjn$ur~,sits'WdQmtuSØfhøln!.lUØ'eaC(li~llhiriha~;Ø(text~ät~

:AØ'tønn.se'ØhñotQ,.flØ,;s~t(tø,Gae~$:~Ø~'ØTbøm;P:~gø. ~mrry
lØ:!(SEJt:en~$: :~lt~a1i$'~ ~Yà,~ßØt:1ii$.l~d\øl".l:ija4~bytles':$,pons'òtei
tmks fØfcollft,$e ibt()~øin ;fQQtbø:rinsoineéisifèSwÏ1en !t-ey jnt~iltt lÖ\9Ò' tø'
ØEtC~Q.

2.

,,:iNp' '''n's'' 'ø,¡.",'A);,u"'''s'll,a'''t''d,' '0':: ';:""0" "'..J,is'e::~h. e','n""~,0E",i:ry:,tie"""'e' 'fa'.' e,
a ~.' _..,..~LlII\..,..l;1 ,:., .~-'li ;.t...U'... ,::~.-.,.~l:Qu:'ll"Q:L:l~.~~.. ;.u. _'.. ,

f'

fl~glrgi,~te J~"~ls;iofcønfsioi;'ias: ~to affliä;Rvi~âut()JiaUØFft;¥~ "ør(,ffeiinQ' ,
!PìQd,u:ctstftØin'jG:StCQ~

..~..~.

r r
\.

,aasei,Qp'l~the':d~ta;,tlaløred.jil1b$.jAVésij~tili;.ín -iq'p.íriiøi1.'äliéSj¡~D(e'

:per~r(tøfcon~:re.$tls¡l-G'oøgl&oih fñm~etplaC&ateJike.iy'tQi~,trii$.~ør
confQse:djn'áJn~nø.d)ø-ih9äJ~ed"b,y!pJafftrf,OOeQ~

... ì,.'...",.'

:1'"

"i,l'

,,

'CSll.flCAllN
,.p', ,u""u~",;l/l-nc2.(); t;L!èl' ,Jó:"-d",,;l7"'~ .... _. .l:~~ :y.~~~~~i:" ~l:.:~._J:JU"!":lioil1o..:, :. u':~l:ll:.lsr p. ~~~~~y~ :~).~ -'1f.:f~... .. .' .. ... l:d' ed'tJ;;.,¡'"'~r;f1~'''~,rirA.rt;lh'' :="~. Y'..Q:P; _.

t"
f"
l.~....

b.t'Øf'rtyl~nö~è';and;bee.I;, tieiør~i$'t~uEtan,~

f"

... - . ~.'. .

:ìj) .'ta' a,"

r
~.~,.~ ,'f,.','"

:j . ..', . ""'~~.: . ::ft.. -_. _ ..'äCóh. :L.~';i.'¡,:p'k,:o' ,

..'......... _. .. , . . - ..

59
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

t

GGL-CNG058549

c,

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 31 of 32

Google Seach: Dike
.'

GroupsNews Frooçile Iiorê))
, S,,;'eaæfi J'Adva~cßd,Searth ,,,-d Preferences

.Gole-;:b ~g~s
Web
Results 1 - 1:0 of about 8,960,POO for nike rdefinWo.rl, (O.25seçonds) ,
N~W$, rßsull$f:ornike -Viewtoday'slopstories
,J.uSlbrewit:StarbucksC~bjofri's Nike bOflfd-

SpohsoredLlriks
Shop förAuto IUStlrance

BìZJourlials,com - Sep 21, '2004
Oelticsoofes ¡(Sip tie"Qp with Nikè

- The

Great Rates., free Quotø
Shop, Compare,

Scolsman- :sep~l, 2004

Save TOday

NewshpsanoOlvriics heip :tiikesales to
;soar -'Seattle Times - Sep21, ,2.0'04 ' ,
Nìk. ,., ö.. . e .c m
Apparel, shø:es:;ndaccessories, , ww ¿i1jkê,cøml~ 5k~ Ql1otes: NKE CaChed-Similar paqes - ,stock

wwAutoandH.oiíre,pöm
Fi:eelnsuraoöeQuøtes ' 'Get ii\sufanceQuotes.lt:sPast, "
Easy, ,& A1~yst=tee!a.ff.

ww,ltisur'eCom:corn

tnsuranoe Hndei -Save
MoneyV'ith Free Insütance Quotes, Quick And Ea$Y Applitation!'flff,

:Nike.:eom

,'
'Nlkehiz: TOe lns(de Slory
,Recognizes the Contributions

www:riike,comtmain,html-Sk :Cached- Similar paqes

ww"insurancefin:òer,eom
See YÖl:rmessagehere,.,

:(More Tasults 'frOffWW.nikRcom)

nlke r NIKEFOOTBALL ,
and Win prizes

\chåt withfhe'coøièstJÛotball.:players,thaUengea friend

in lheg'Cîme Or

i~h:eck 'Out èthe'great toôtba/l,wear.
'www;nikeföötball;comt-6k -Cached-Similar pa-Qes

...staTb\:cksCEOOrinC.Smith ApPointed to Nike''sBoardof Directors; Philp

Knight

of Three Retiring Directors .:21 September ...

¥':nikébizcoml- .25k-Sep 22, 2004 ~Cached-S:ilTilar :pages
uXfmCtmi:unjtyAid,AbrQad ','; Nik~W~tch :=:;:~C:r:::~~n~~~;l::;Ô:~::t~:~:~~~f:;~~~~:=;~,:~r=~:~::eo~~"cøndroøns in 'd
ww:òxfarn,örg.,aul,oampaign$/nike/-t3k - Sep22, '2004 ~ Gached-SimIla( paQe:s

iB'Øycott :N:;keHOrne,pàga
;NfkeplanJ ;ifl Vietnam.

'. .' . . ..

,.... dìsappear. Thea'Dove :stâtements .w,e(e maije by ThuYilnå L:ap, womati wOrkers

at

and teportedbY CBS,!) 'Dctøbe:rt996,...

wW;s:aigöI1Jcornl-'nike/ - '8k- Caçhe:d- 'SilTlar :pa~es ,

lllk~ ;BasketbçiH '"
wWW.nlkëoaSketbálLcom1 -4k- 'S~PL'2, 2004-'Cache.d- ,S¡rrälar Paiies

"D¥&~~W:N'" ,

'. "~' I,:,:' '"" "'. J,'.~.),.:..,.,".1.". : "

.. .. .... ..
H~l'i~'~ "
912412-'04 J: 52 PM

.NikeGölf

'lof2
CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONL Y

GGL-CNG058594

Case 1:06-cv-00040-SSB-TSB
Google Search:nie

Document 74-7

Filed 07/20/2007

Page 32 of 32

NikeGolf, s~s, foöNiear, ;NllæGdlfapparel, hags, courses,iWlktfGoJf equipment,
prodi:ct$,gloves~ players, :pros, scr.e:ell Søvefs,

cøhtests, tips, advi~ ...

',' m:nike.cal-6,k-Sep ~2,2004-Gached-Similar paaes

,ìk''etø.Wn.com ' . .' ' .. .. 'N
nike ;ca ,
Trà'iningJ:otdanTiger AU foQtenrAIl E:quìpment HtlnningOutdoör (ACG)

WW,nikegolf,Gom/.~ 4k - Cached -Similar pages

...~PP,' :Nike llome.\lalking Spe:edAll Äppateiaåsketball LahPe:ClEARANCË Golf

WkàÖ~Ikkicng1:3kActive ...:' ' , l 'jji e; om/- -Üached - SimilafP:cl1es nl eJ
Result Pâge:' ,'i.¿l ,~ § Z ~ i! 10 'Next

'a,eåfchWithin Jesultslt~ti~uaÇJe TO,ols I Search Tips

.. 'i . G' . . ,''
',..',:''OOOOOOÖOO.o~f 'e,;~
~ik~

S..'.á.'r,' ,l .. ... .

I niss¡:tisfied1, Help

us

,improve

Gooqle Gøo!lle, Horne- Advertisin!ô Proqrams-Business Solutions - About

(§2004 'Goug'le

/

20f2

CONFIDENTIAL ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY

9124/2004 3:52PM

GGL-CNG058595