PA Advisors, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 477

Proposed Pretrial Order (Joint Final Pre-Trial Order) by PA Advisors, LLC, Google Inc., Yahoo! Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10)(Doan, Jennifer)

EXHIBIT 3

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS MARSHALL DIVISION

PA ADVISORS, LLC,, Plaintiff v. GOOGLE, INC. et al Defendants PLAINTIFF'S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS KEY FOR OBJECTIONS General Objections: Form Objections: R ­ Relevance L ­ Leading P ­ Fed. R. Evid. 403: Prejudicial Arg ­ Argumentative H ­ Hearsay A ­ Assuming Facts Not in Evidence F ­ Lacks Foundation C ­ Compound I ­ Incomplete N ­ Narratives V ­ Vague and ambiguous MIL ­ Subject matter covered by motion in limine S ­ Beyond the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) deposition topics
Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Civil Action No. 2-07cv-480

JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT Sanjay Data BEGIN 15:8 26:9 27:3 27:25 29:5 END 15:23 26:16 27:23 28:19 31:1

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 15:9 END 15:23

I1 R, P R, P R, P R, P

Where defendants state an objection or objections to a designation, but do not provide a counter-designation, defendants have objected to that designation in its entirety. Where defendants state objections but also provide a counter-designation, defendants have objected to the designation for the stated bases, but provided the non-objectionable portions of the citation, or the portions of the transcript necessary to make the testimony complete. 1

1

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 42:14 44:5 44:16 44:23 45:7 45:12 46:16 48:8 48:21 49:9 49:21 50:5 51:6 51:15 52:24 53:18 54:6 54:13 56:5 56:21 59:12 59:15 59:24 60:5 61:25 65:3 65:8 65:12 66:17 66:23 67:8 75:3 77:19 78:4 78:24 79:6 80:3 84:13 84:16 9:16 10:1 END 44:3 44:14 44:21 45:5 45:9 46:3 46:22 48:19 49:7 49:19 50:3 50:22 51:13 51:19 53:16 54:4 54:11 55:16 56:9 57:12 59:13 59:22 60:3 61:23 62:12 65:6 65:10 65:21 66:21 67:6 67:20 75:6 78:2 78:22 79:4 80:1 80:3 84:14 84:24 9:22 10:6 2

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

51:15

51:17

I

R, P, V, F R, P, V, F R, P, V, F V, F V V V, F R, P, V, F

V, S V, F, S

V R, P

Ivan Markman

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 10:9 14:17 15:1 18:25 20:14 22:13 23:16 24:4 25:5 32:3 39:2 39:12 53:15 69:6 71:16 79:8 84:23 87:18 92:16 111:4 116:9 124:17 130:18 9:19 51:4 51:15 52:8 60:2 65:22 115:4 118:10 11:10 18:16 20:24 28:15 29:12 40:12 42:16 45:24 46:3 END 10:9 14:20 15:4 20:5 21:11 23:5 23:24 24:19 25:12 32:6 39:5 39:18 55:6 69:21 72:9 79:19 85:20 90:16 96:11 112:1 116:21 126:10 131:9 9:25 51:13 52:6 52:15 61:24 69:4 115:11 118:25 11:20 18:17 21:4 29:3 29:18 41:17 43:5 45:25 46:15 3

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

P, R

24:20 32:21

24:22 P, R 32:25

MIL, P, R P, R P, R

P, R 127:4 131:16 7:6 51:14 52:7 128:5 131:20 7:7 51:14 52:7

Gabriel Mattera

I R, P, V R, P, V, F

R, P R, P

Carlton Robinson

21:5

22:12

MIL, P, R P, R

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 46:25 51:20 52:9 56:23 61:22 62:5 76:15 77:8 79:14 80:6 80:25 81:19 86:20 91:6 93:15 95:10 100:6 101:16 104:20 106:11 108:8 112:11 114:13 115:3 127:7 128:18 13:1 16:16 17:9 23:24 24:2 26:6 26:9 26:14 26:19 28:10 28:13 28:19 29:3
01980.51319/3345726.1

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 47:9 52:5 END 47:22 52:8

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

END 47:8 52:2 52:13 57:7 62:2 62:11 76:20 78:25 79:23 80:18 81:10 82:4 87:6 91:17 94:4 96:3 100:16 101:25 106:03 107:22 109:17 113:21 114:25 116:7 127:18 129:17 13:13 17:7 17:17 23:25 24:3 26:7 26:12 26:17 26:19 28:11 28:16 28:24 29:14 4

P, R, S P, R, S P, S P, S

62:3 62:12 79:1 79:24 80:19 81:14 86:10 87:7

62:4 62:19 79:13 80:5 80:24 81:17 86:19 87:11

S P, S S S

P, R 100:17 102:1 106:4 101:15 102:9 106:8 P, R 114:5 114:12 P, R P, R

Eric Schulman

R, P

27:1 27:8

27:4 27:22

I

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 29:17 30:24 30:25 31:4 31:25 33:2 33:15 34:7 34:22 36:11 39:25 40:3 40:11 40:15 42:7 42:10 45:14 45:20 46:7 46:21 46:24 47:12 47:22 48:6 48:8 48:13 49:5 54:8 55:21 58:1 58:4 58:9 58:22 59:1 62:8 62:12 62:21 63:3 63:22 64:2 64:8 END 29:18

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 29:19 END 30:14

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

I

31:22 32:16 33:13 34:5 34:20 35:15 36:16 40:1 40:9 40:13 40:19 42:8 42:21 45:18 45:21 46:12 46:22 47:10 47:18 48:4 48:6 48:11 48:17 49:12 5 5 : 17 55:24 58:2 58:4 58:20 58:24 59:21 62:9 62:19 62:25 63:14 63:25 64:6 64:24 5

33:25

34:5

R, P R, P R, P

R, P R, P

58:18 59:1

58:20 59:9

R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 65:3 65:19 66:21 67:2 75:9 75:14 76:10 79:10 81:8 81:14 82:11 82:15 83:5 86:18 88:4 88:16 89:15 90:25 92:12 94:6 95:16 96:20 97:9 99:6 100:19 101:19 120:14 120:21 121:8 11:15 12:15 12:19 13:1 13:12 13:25 14:12 14:18 16:15 17:15 24:2 24:9 END 65:16 65:21 66:23 67:3 75:12 75:24 76:13 79:20 81:12 81:24 82:13 83:3 84:2 88:2 88:14 88:17 90:15 91:17 93:3 94:12 96:16 97:5 97:11 99:10 101:5 101:21 120:17 121:6 121:21 12:9 12:16 12:23 13:9 13:22 14:9 14:15 15:6 17:12 17:23 24:5 25:21 6

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 65:3 END 65:7

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P

88:19

88:20

I R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P R, P

Luke Yeh

R, Arg R, Arg R, C R R

R, P

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 27:10 28:2 28:18 31:8 32:12 33:7 33:21 34:2 35:24 37:5 38:14 41:3 41:14 42:3 43:13 44:13 44:21 45:7 45:20 46:4 46:12 48:17 51:9 52:17 53:5 54:2 54:8 54:19 55:5 60:14 61:3 63:12 63:23 64:24 68:14 7:14 8:18 19:2 33:3 34:20
01980.51319/3345726.1

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Edward Etkin

END 27:18 28:15 31:5 31:12 33:2 33:12 33:24 35:18 37:2 37:14 39:11 41:11 41:25 42:16 44:10 44:18 45:4 45:17 46:1 46:9 46:19 49:19 52:14 53:2 53:7 54:5 54:16 55:2 59:15 60:16 62:24 63:20 64:21 64:25 68:19 7:16 11:2 21:4 33:14 35:3 7

R, P R, P R, P R, P

43:3

43:9

R, P I R, P R, P R, P R, P

R, P R, P R, P R, P, F R, P R R R R R

65:2

65:22

R, P R, P R, P

Defendants' incorporate by reference their designations of this witness' deposition R, P, MIL

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 49:2 61:23 64:15 74:17 78:12 80:7 82:8 85:6 151:11 224:17 231:19 248:4 253:24 Devesh Patel 255:13 10:15 11:7 14:11 25:4 26:12 29:2 29:20 32:10 44:20 45:4 46:12 48:7 51:9 62:5 63:8 66:4 68:21 70:17 73:9 74:18 75:15 75:25 76:12 END 49:20 62:14 65:6 77:18 79:8 81:11 83:8 85:21 154:2 227:18 232:14 252:8 254:15 256:7 11:4 14:8 25:1 26:9 28:24 29:17 32:7 43:25 45:1 46:9 48:4 51:6 62:2 63:5 66:2 68:18 70:14 73:6 74:15 74:25 75:22 76:9 78:2 8

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 61:23 64:7 64:13 65:7 79:9 81:13 83:9 84:14 85:22 END 62:3 64:11 64:14 65:14 80:6 82:7 83:16 85:5 86:11

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

R, P I

I I I I

252:20 253:23 254:16 255:10 256:8 256:15 I Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

R L, F I

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 78:4 80:12 82:8 82:18 85:2 86:20 87:3 91:8 91:16 101:19 102:11 102:16 105:22 107:9 112:14 114:6 116:14 125:19 130:21 131:19 135:18 142:18 144:24 10:20 16:1 17:21 19:9 21:8 22:15 22:23 25:12 26:12 28:19 29:23 32:4 33:6 35:25 END 78:12 81:12 82:11 84:21 86:13 86:25 91:5 91:13 101:16 102:3 102:13 104:21 107:6 112:4 113:2 116:11 125:16 130:19 131:16 135:15 140:25 142:20 145:4 15:23 17:14 19:2 21:6 22:13 22:15 25:5 26:10 28:7 29:20 31:24 33:1 35:23 37:10

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Chauman Brewer

8:21

9:4

18:8 19:9 20:4 21:8 21:21

19:2 19:25 21:6 21:12 22:13

I R, P R, P R, P R, P, F R R, P, MIL R, P, S S S S F, I R, P R, P, S, V

26:6

26:10

33:6 35:21 35:25 9

33:23 35:23 37:3

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 37:12 40:18 40:21 41:9 41:17 42:4 43:1 45:25 46:12 48:20 48:24 50:3 51:4 52:14 54:4 54:19 55:20 57:8 58:2 58:7 59:17 59:21 60:10 62:25 64:22 65:19 67:20 68:20 73:17 75:7 75:23 77:15 79:2 80:12 81:13 END 40:15 40:18 41:5 41:14 42:2 42:8 44:17 46:7 48:16 48:22 49:21 50:15 52:11 54:2 54:17 55:18 57:6 57:17 58:5 59:13 59:19 60:7 62:22 64:19 65:14 65:19 68:17 73:15 74:2 75:20 77:6 78:24 80:3 81:11 81:13 10

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN 39:5 END 40:15

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

43:11

44:17

R, P, MIL, S V S R, P, S R, P, S R, P R, P, I

48:25

49:21

R, P, MIL, V, F R, P, MIL, V, F R, P, S R, P, S R, P, V R, P, S R, P R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL, S R, P, S, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, I, V, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL R, P, MIL

51:4

51:19

56:7

57:6

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT Bartholomew Furrow BEGIN 10:23 END 14:14

Defendants' CounterDesignations

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

BEGIN END Google objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Google is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

14:19 20:2 22:3 26:2 28:22 31:10 34:2 36:14 37:2 37:23 38:23 39:8 45:7 46:25 54:24 58:2 61:10 62:21 63:2 63:8 64:3 67:1 67:9 68:7 70:18 79:5 83:14 88:10 89:2 97:20 101:19 108:2

19:25 22:1 25:23 28:20 30:23 33:19 36:8 36:25 37:21 38:21 39:6 44:21 46:21 54:17 57:21 61:5 62:13 62:22 63:6 64:1 66:24 67:7 68:5 70:16 79:3 83:2 88:3 88:18 96:15 101:11 107:25 109:24 11

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 110:3 117:7 120:13 127:10 128:10 131:19 134:13 135:11 137:16 149:5 152:10 155:1 159:5 159:21 160:15 161:8 177:18 178:12 181:11 8:20 10:10 19:14 22:20 26:4 28:8 28:16 29:25 39:16 39:24 45:5 52:17 61:23 73:23 74:15 77:13 79:8 83:12 99:13 106:9 11:15 END 117:5 120:7 127:6 128:5 131:15 134:2 135:6 137:4 149:1 152:8 154:18 158:16 159:19 160:11 161:6 177:9 178:6 180:24 183:1 10:8 19:4 22:14 25:22 28:6 28:13 29:22 39:13 39:20 45:3 52:9 61:20 73:20 74:12 77:10 78:18 83:9 99:10 105:25 107:23 12:4

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Matthew Hall

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

Brian Horling

Google objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly

01980.51319/3345726.1

12

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN END

Defendants' CounterDesignations

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

BEGIN END designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Google is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

12:13 12:19 14:9 14:13 14:24 15:17 16:19 17:12 19:15 20:22 23:5 25:7 26:3 26:21 27:11 29:25 30:21 32:6 33:15 35:8 36:25 37:10 39:22 40:11 40:22 41:8 43:2 44:9 45:3 45:14 45:24 47:3 47:13 48:13

12:15 13:24 14:11 14:22 15:15 16:17 17:10 19:13 20:20 23:3 24:5 26:1 26:19 27:9 28:20 30:16 32:3 33:13 35:6 36:23 37:8 39:20 40:9 40:20 41:6 42:18 44:7 44:11 4 5 : 10 45:19 47:1 47:10 48:11 49:6 13

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 49:8 52:8 54:1 58:12 59:24 61:17 64:15 65:8 68:17 68:23 72:7 72:18 73:18 74:23 78:23 79:23 84:10 86:9 89:9 94:18 97:9 99:16 110:16 101:17 102:15 103:17 111:22 112:10 112:18 113:4 117:9 122:21 126:5 127:22 130:9 133:1 135:3 137:9 137:24 138:18 11:13 END 52:6 53:24 58:10 59:22 61:12 64:13 65:6 68:15 68:21 72:5 72:16 73:14 74:14 78:9 79:21 84:4 86:7 89:6 94:16 96:22 99:11 100:14 110:15 102:13 103:15 111:20 112:8 112:16 113:2 117:7 122:19 126:3 127:1 130:7 132:24 135:1 137:7 137:22 138:7 140:4 15:19 14

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Michael Jahr
01980.51319/3345726.1

Google objects to this entire deposition

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN END

Defendants' CounterDesignations

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

BEGIN END because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Google is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

Ashvin Kannan

15:22 23:13 39:23 42:4 46:21 56:3 60:19 61:18 77:15 89:18 90:17 94:1 98:14 99:25 103:13 104:24 107:6 115:12 116:11 117:17 126:3 127:19 133:23 135:12 7:19 20:15 24:10 25:1 26:3 27:12 30:23 32:21 34:5

23:10 39:12 41:22 46:17 55:21 59:25 61:16 77:12 89:16 90:15 93:17 98:12 99:21 103:11 104:1 107:4 115:2 116:9 117:15 125:21 126:18 133:7 135:10 136:22 20:4 23:3 24:14 25:25 27:10 30:21 31:8 34:3 34:17 15

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 34:19 35:16 37:5 39:8 41:21 42:7 43:16 45:8 46:21 47:14 48:22 48:17 50:6 51:3 51:20 52:16 54:10 56:18 57:12 57:18 61:9 63:9 64:19 66:20 66:25 68:21 69:4 71:3 75:7 77:12 79:10 83:18 86:17 92:1 93:8 94:10 96:14 98:2 100:23 8:6 17:16 END 35:14 37:3 39:6 41:18 42:5 43:13 45:2 45:14 47:12 48:20 48:15 50:4 51:1 51:18 52:13 54:8 56:16 57:10 57:16 61:7 62:22 64:17 66:18 66:23 68:19 69:2 71:1 75:5 76:15 79:4 83:16 86:15 91:25 92:22 94:8 96:12 96:22 99:17 100:25 16:9 17:20 16

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

David Kolm

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 17:25 18:7 21:10 22:1 29:19 30:10 38:3 39:8 39:11 43:9 43:19 65:5 76:15 77:14 78:24 79:8 85:4 85:8 88:10 9:23 15:6 17:11 32:14 37:2 41:21 END 18:4 20:17 21:12 29:17 30:6 37:25 39:6 39:9 42:24 43:17 65:2 76:1 77:12 78:21 79:6 82:17 85:6 86:1 89:17 15:4 17:5 31:23 36:15 41:11 41:25

Defendants' CounterDesignations

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

BEGIN END designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

Ken Kronquist

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

42:12 46:3 46:23 47:19 49:11 49:24 50:23 51:19 54:21 56:9 60:16 62:13 64:19

45:3 46:12 47:15 48:11 49:21 50:15 51:11 54:13 56:4 60:12 62:5 64:13 65:15 17

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 66:3 68:3 70:11 74:15 76:17 84:19 87:17 88:8 99:17 99:23 101:13 8:4 20:8 24:23 31:1 37:8 38:16 38:20 42:4 43:18 48:9 48:18 50:6 54:5 56:23 9:6 10:6 11:20 12:24 15:3 28:11 31:17 33:9 35:7 36:3 37:5 38:4 42:17 44:14 44:25 END 67:18 69:19 74:13 76:15 83:9 85:18 88:6 99:15 99:21 101:8 105:18 19:22 24:19 33:24 37:6 38:14 38:18 41:22 43:11 47:19 48:12 50:4 54:2 56:21 60:17 9:20 11:18 12:22 15:1 28:9 31:15 32:23 35:4 36:1 37:3 38:2 42:15 44:6 44:23 45:9 18

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Soren Riise

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

Ben Shahshahani

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 45:11 45:22 46:17 63:5 73:17 74:13 78:17 82:14 82:20 83:2 84:1 84:13 87:5 89:15 92:3 97:11 97:15 98:21 104:7 104:22 105:10 113:19 116:14 117:4 117:14 117:21 118:14 123:11 124:16 132:12 133:7 133:17 140:22 141:09 145:15 148:22 149:16 153:7 158:15 163:6 165:13 END 45:20 46:12 62:14 73:10 74:5 77:7 82:12 82:18 82:25 83:24 84:11 87:3 89:13 92:1 97:5 97:13 98:14 103:8 104:13 105:8 113:5 116:12 117:2 117:12 117:19 118:12 123:3 124:14 131:23 132:17 133:15 140:20 1 4 1 : 07 145:13 148:5 149:14 152:2 158:13 162:17 165:11 165:18 19

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 165:20 171:15 172:23 176:18 178:6 182:19 184:25 186:20 186:23 187:7 187:14 188:8 189:1 6:4 12:10 16:17 25:15 26:17 27:3 27:13 30:10 30:17 35:24 37:8 39:1 40:18 42:16 42:21 55:1 65:4 68:8 68:15 81:1 82:4 90:14 91:9 91:18 END 171:8 172:2 176:16 177:21 181:12 183:20 185:17 186:21 187:5 187:11 188:1 188:12 189:4 12:5 16:15 25:13 26:15 27:1 27:11 30:8 30:15 35:18 37:6 38:19 40:10 42:8 42:19 54:19 64:22 68:4 68:13 80:9 81:23 82:11 91:7 91:16 91:23

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Zachary Zhang

Yahoo objects to this entire deposition because nXn, LLC. has not properly designated the testimony that is seeks to play at trial. Instead, nXn, LLC. chose to designate nearly the entire deposition. Yahoo is willing to provide objections only after nXn, LLC. engages in a good faith effort to designate a reasonable amount of testimony.

Ilya Geller

Defendants object to Mr. Geller's testimony being presented by deposition because he is in Plaintiff's control, Plaintiff did not make him fully available 20

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN END

Defendants' CounterDesignations

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

Ilya Geller

198:17 199:17 200:2 201:25 202:2 215:9 216:10 216:19 217:2 225:17 226:6 9:8 13:14 13:24 14:2 101:12 102:2 128:11 129:2 130:2 131:14 132:2 132:12 133:2 133:22 134:3 135:6 135:16 135:21 136:4 136:24 138:2 138:9 139:4 139:20

198:20 199:25 200:19 201:25 202:23 215:15 216:15 216:25 217:3 225:19 226:21 9:11 13:18 13:25 14:2 101:25 102:22 128:25 129:25 130:24 131:25 132:9 132:25 133:20 133:25 134:16 135:10 135:19 136:2 136:22 137:9 138:7 138:22 139:18 139:24 21

BEGIN END for deposition as detailed in Defendants' motion for sanctions, and Plaintiff has not made a showing that he is unavailable to testify at trial. Defendants incorporate by reference their designations of this witness' deposition P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R P, R 202:24 203:12 P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R 9:6 9:7 MIL, P, R I, P, R I, P, R I, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R P, R P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R R, P R, P R, P P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R L L L, A, C L, A

01980.51319/3345726.1

Plaintiff's Designations DEPONENT BEGIN 140:5 140:13 141:6 142:8 143:2 143:22 144:2 144:9 144:15 144:18 145:2 145:15 145:24 146:2 146:7 146:12 146:19 146:23 147:11 147:22 148:2 148:6 148:22 149:2 149:14 150:2 END 140:7 141:4 141:7 142:25 143:14 143:25 144:6 1 4 4 : 12 144:16 144:25 145:13 145:22 145:25 146:5 146:9 146:17 146:20 146:23 147:18 147:25 148:3 148:20 148:25 149:9 149:25 150:16

Defendants' CounterDesignations BEGIN END

Dfdts.' Objections to Pl.'s Designations

146:24

147:8

L, A L, A L, A L, A L, A P, R P, R, L P, R, L P, R, L P, R P, R, F P, R, F P, R MIL, P, R, L MIL, P, R MIL, P, R MIL, P, R, L MIL, P, R P, R P, R, F P, R, F P, R P, R, F, L, A MIL, P, R P, R MIL, P, R

01980.51319/3345726.1

22