PA Advisors, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 477

Proposed Pretrial Order (Joint Final Pre-Trial Order) by PA Advisors, LLC, Google Inc., Yahoo! Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 4, #5 Exhibit 5, #6 Exhibit 6, #7 Exhibit 7, #8 Exhibit 8, #9 Exhibit 9, #10 Exhibit 10)(Doan, Jennifer)

PA Advisors, LLC v. Google Inc. et al

Doc. 477 Att. 8

EXHIBIT 8

Dockets.Justia.com

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Ribbon Copy of United States Patent No. 6,199,067

PX# 0001 0002

Objections N P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

Bodenhamer Ex. 1

Deposition of Bodenhamer, 2009-08-21 Exhibit 1 Plaintiff's Deposition Notice for Albert Bodenhamer, PA Advisors, LLC, versus Google Inc., et al. Three pages. Deposition of Bodenhamer, 2009-08-21 Exhibit 3 NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Google (regarding documents and persons most knowledgeable), NXN Tech, LLC, versus Google Inc., et al. Seven pages. Deposition of Bodenhamer, 2009-08-21 Exhibit 5 Typewritten document entitled "Reviewer's Guide: Google Toolbar 4." Six pages. Deposition of Bodenhamer, 2009-08-21 Exhibit 6 "Toolbar Search Box," Status: Draft May 20, 2005. Seven pages. Deposition of Bodenhamer, 2009-08-21 Exhibit 7 "Toolbar Usage Statistics Glossary." 14 pages. Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; NXN's Fourth Notice of Rule 30(B)(6) Deposition for Google (Regarding Documents and Persons Most Knowledgeable) Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; NXN's Fifth Notice of Rule 30(B)(6) Deposition for Google (Regarding Documents and Persons Most Knowledgeable Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; 8-27-2001 E-mail from Ilya Geller to [e-mail] Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; June 14, 2005 Letter to David C. Drummond, Esq., From Joseph Diamante

0003

P, R

Bodenhamer Ex. 3

0004

P, R

Bodenhamer Ex. 5

GOOG0134621-626

0005 0006

P, R P, R

Bodenhamer Ex. 6 Bodenhamer Ex. 7

GOOG0003652 -658. GOOG0087414 -427.

0007

P, R

Brewer Ex. 1

0008 0009 0010

P, R P, R, MIL P, R, MIL

Brewer Ex. 2 Brewer Ex. 4 Brewer Ex. 5 BRIN 00000001 00000001

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; June 14, 2005 Letter to David C. Drummond, Esq., From Joseph Diamante Deposition of Brewer, 2009-10-23; Google Records Retention Policy Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document titled "NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Google," dated July 13, 2009 Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document headed "More Ads on Long Thread Experiment" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document headed "GMail pre-brainstorm ideas" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document headed "Gmail Ads OKRs Q406" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Printout of a Goowiki web page titled "Gmail Ads: Dynamic Configuration Framework (AdsConfig)" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document headed "Gmail's Radlinks Experiments" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Printout of a Goowiki web page titled "Gmail Ads: UBAQ Design Doc" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Copy of a printout of a GMail page from experiment.testaccount1 Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Copy of a diagram regarding Caribou Server Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Document headed "GMail Ads, Status: Draft (as of May 20, 2005)" Deposition of Chen, 2009-11-06; Copy of a diagram headed "Internet" Fin Client

PX# 0011 0012 0013 0014 0015 0016 0017 0018 0019 0020 0021 0022 0023

Objections P, R, MIL P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Brewer Ex. 6 Brewer Ex. 9 Chen Ex. 1 Chen Ex. 10 Chen Ex. 11 Chen Ex. 12 Chen Ex. 13 Chen Ex. 14 Chen Ex. 15 Chen Ex. 5 Chen Ex. 6 Chen Ex. 7 Chen Ex. 8

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

GOOG1651186 and 1187 GOOG1651195-1196 GOOG1650988-0991 GOOG1650842-0850 GOOG1650995-0997 GOOG1650999-1006

GOOG1651530 GGL-PA00098257-8265 GOOG1651529

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 1 Plaintiff's Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Google Inc. (Regarding Documents and Persons Most Knowledgeable), with attachment. Seven pages. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 10 Weekly Rolling Forecast. 37 pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 11 Weekly Rolling Forecast. 18 pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 2 Google's Objections to nXn's Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition. Eight pages. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 3 Untitled color spreadsheet. Eight pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 4 Untitled color spreadsheet. Five pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 5 Untitled spreadsheet. Eight pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 6 Google Inc. Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, 4 2007. 113 pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 7 Google Revenue Backlog as of: January 7, 2002. 95 pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 8 2003 Weekly Rolling Revenue Forecast. 52 pages. Deposition of Datta, 2009-12-17; Exhibit 9 2002 Weekly Rolling Revenue Forecast. 29 pages. Deposition of Etkin; Exhibit 12 Document headed Why Should I Buy? Deposition of Etkin; Exhibit 14 Press Release titled Inventor Offers American Privacy to Highest Bidder

PX#

Objections

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

0024

P, R

Datta Ex. 1

0025 0026 0027 0028 0029 0030 0031 0032 0033 0034 0035 0036

P, R P, R P, R F F F MIL P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R

Datta Ex. 10 Datta Ex. 11 Datta Ex. 2 Datta Ex. 3 Datta Ex. 4 Datta Ex. 5 Datta Ex. 6 Datta Ex. 7 Datta Ex. 8 Datta Ex. 9 Etkin Ex. 12 Etkin Ex. 14

GGL-PA00149417-GGL-PA00149453. GGL-PA00149549-GGL-PA00149566.

GGL-PA01658003-GGL-PA01658010. GGL-PA01657312-GGL-PA01657316. GGL-PA00640563-GGL-PA00640567. GGL-PA00000669-GGL-PA00000781. GGL-PA00149454-GGL-PA00149548. GGL-PA00149365-GGL-PA00149416. GGL-PA00149336-GGL-PA00149364. GELLER056078-GELLER056080 GELLER031985

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Etkin, 2009-04-23; Exhibit 7 Mightiest Logicon UniSearch Presentation Deposition of Etkin; Exhibit 8 Document entitled Mightiest Logicon UniSearch Investment Meeting Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Copy of a document headed "Test Ad Serving Privacy Policy and Cookie Optout, last updated August 10, 2007 Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Printout from Goowiki Home titled User Data Storage Policy Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Website printout of an article titled "Ads Quality: SmartASS Models Overview" Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Copy of a document headed "Adgroup RephilGenerator" Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Printout from Goowiki Home titled Capacity planning questions to be answered by clients Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Document titled "NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Google," dated July 13, 2009 Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Printout of a Google web page article titled "Ads retrieval with user's previous query," dated "Revision rl.6 01 June 2007" Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Copy of a document titled "Ad System Overview" Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Printout of a Google web page article titled "Ideas for Using the User's Previous Query/Queries in Ads Serving," dated "Revision rl.2 - 28 Jan 2008"

PX# 0037 0038 0039 0040 0041 0042 0043

Objections P, R P, R N N N N P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Etkin Ex. 7 Etkin Ex. 8 Furrow Ex. 10 Furrow Ex. 11 Furrow Ex. 12 Furrow Ex. 13 Furrow Ex. 14

BATES BEGIN PA000952-PA000976

BATES END

GELLER032633-GELLER032639 161 GGL-PA00135569-5577 GGL-PA00067035-7038 GGL-PA01653382-3395 GOOG1650493-498 GGL-PA00067067-7083

0044

P, R

Furrow Ex. 3

0045

N

Furrow Ex. 5

GGL-PA 00029490-9497

0046

N

Furrow Ex. 6

GGL-PA0098173-8304

0047

P, R

Furrow Ex. 7

GGL-PA00029767

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Copy of an article titled "Smart Ad Selection System (SmartASS)," dated as of October 30, 2003 Deposition of Furrow, 2009-11-05; Copy of an article titled "Ad Auction Estimated Clickthrough Rate," lastupdated 12 November 2003" Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 10 String of emails beginning with an e-mail from Dmitri Krakovsky, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 11 String of emails beginning with an e-mail from David Pann, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 12 Document entitled, "Search and Advertising Technology All Hands, Burbank, November 29th, 2006," Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 2 Resume, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 3 E-mail from Matthew Hall dated December 1, 2006, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 4 String of emails beginning with an e-mail from Glen Hastings, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 5 Document entitled, "Request for 2007 Incremental Investment Funding, SLM/Comscore Data Enhancement, Draft, February 27, 2007," Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 6 Organization chart Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 7 E-mail from Tina Krueger dated October 12, 2007, Deposition of Hall, 2009-11-24; Exhibit 8 String of emails beginning with an e-mail from Robert Dillon,

PX# 0048

Objections N

DEPO. EXHIBIT Furrow Ex. 8

BATES BEGIN GGL-PA00016973-16980

BATES END

0049 0050 0051 0052 0053 0054 0055

P, R P, R P, R A, P, R N N P, R

Furrow Ex. 9 Hall Ex. 10 Hall Ex. 11 Hall Ex. 12 Hall Ex. 2 Hall Ex. 3 Hall Ex. 4

GGL-PA00008471-8474 YH-PSET2441361-YH-PSET2441364 YH-PSET2442800-YH-PSET2442801 YH-PSET1715650-YH-PSET1715696 YH-PSET2201243-YH-PSET2201244 YH-PSET1735117 YH-PSET1269829-YH-PSET1269834

0056

A, P, R

Hall Ex. 5

YH-PSET1321369

0057 0058 0059

MIL P, R P, R

Hall Ex. 6 Hall Ex. 7 Hall Ex. 8

YH-PSET1939817 YH-PSET2040413 YH-PSET889083-YH-PSET889084

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 2 NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition For Google (regarding documents and persons most knowledgeable), with attachment. Seven pages. Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 3 Six pages, the first page containing the text "The Personalization content on Goowiki is deprecated." Six pages. Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 4 Single page headed "Playlist: Google Search Privacy." One page. Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 5 Document headed "Google Accounts Help, Personalized Search Results: Basics." One page. Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 6 Two-page document headed "Google Privacy Center, Privacy Glossary." Two pages. Deposition of Horling, 2009-09-09; Exhibit 7 Printout of a document headed "Web Search Overview, or, The Life of a Query." 25 pages. Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Google (Regarding Documents and Persons Most Knowledgeable) Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "NGram-based Scoring for ContentAds," Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; Plaintiff's Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition Notice for Michael Jahr Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "Phil and Rephil" Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "Rephil" Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "Rephil User's Guide: Training Rephil,"

PX# 0060

Objections P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Horling Ex. 2

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

0061

P, R

Horling Ex. 3

GOOG0079471-476.

0062

N

Horling Ex. 4

GOOG0135075

0063

N

Horling Ex. 5

GGL-PA00005125.

0064

N

Horling Ex. 6

GOOG0010303-304.

0065

N

Horling Ex. 7

GOOG1617858-882.

0066 0067 0068 0069 0070 0071

P, R N P, R N P N

Jahr Ex. 1 Jahr Ex. 10 Jahr Ex. 3 Jahr Ex. 5 Jahr Ex. 6 Jahr Ex. 7 GGL-PA01619173-GGL-PA01619175 GGL-PA00022624-GGL-PA00022659 GGL-PA01625135-GGL-PA01625165 GGL-PA00022346-GGL-PA00022350

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "RePhil Document Parser," Deposition of Jahr, 2009-10-23; "Contents Ads Targeting," Deposition of Kannan, 2009-12-18; nXn's 30(B)(6) Third Notice of Deposition of Yahoo - 3 pages Deposition of Kronquist, 2009-10-28; Copy Of NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Yahoo dated July 13, 2009 Deposition of Kronquist, 2009-10-28; "Targeting Plans for SmartAds" Copy of a printout of a PowerPoint slide deck Deposition of Kronquist, 2009-10-28; "Product Search Algorithm for Offers - Weighting for Product Pages" Copy of a one-page spreadsheet headed Deposition of Kronquist, 2009-10-28; "Yahoo! Marketplace 'Shopping Search'" Copy of a printout of a PowerPoint slide deck Deposition of Kulick, 2009-08-07; "Playlist: Google Search Privacy" Exhibit 3 Document Deposition of Kulick, 2009-08-07; "Google Account Help About Web History Signing In" Exhibit 4 Document Bates Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Defendant Yahoo! Inc.'s Disclosures Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(A)(1) Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Assumptions spreadsheet Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Financial report Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Yahoo! Smart Ads web page

PX# 0072 0073 0074 0075

Objections N N N N

DEPO. EXHIBIT Jahr Ex. 8 Jahr Ex. 9 Kannan Ex. 1 Kronquist Ex. 1

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

GGL-PA00022607-GGL-PA00022615 GGL-PA00026918-GGL-PA00026925

0076

A, P, R

Kronquist Ex. 3

YH-PSET1755985-5993

0077

P, R

Kronquist Ex. 4

YAH0021268

0078 0079 0080

P, R N N

Kronquist Ex. 5 Kulick Ex. 3 Kulick Ex. 4

YAH0021237-1267 GGL-PA00136060 GGL-PA00004869

0081 0082 0083 0084

N P, R P, R A, F, P, R

Markman Ex. 1 Markman Ex. 10 Markman Ex. 11 Markman Ex. 12 YH-PSET0049652-0049671 YH-PSET0562704-0562741

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Targeting web page Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Advertising FAQ web page Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Policy web page Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Data Solutions Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Data Solutions Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Goldmine Next Steps Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; - as promised

PX# 0085 0086 0087 0088 0089 0090 0091 0092 0093 0094 0095

Objections A, F, P, R A, F, P, R A, F, P, R P, R A, F, P, R P, R P, R MIL P, R P, R N

DEPO. EXHIBIT Markman Ex. 13 Markman Ex. 14 Markman Ex. 15 Markman Ex. 2 Markman Ex. 3 Markman Ex. 4 Markman Ex. 5 Markman Ex. 6 Markman Ex. 7 Markman Ex. 9 Mayer Ex. 1

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

Yahoo! Behavorial Yahoo! Customized Yahoo! Privacy E-mail re Strategic E-mail re Strategic E-mail re Projoect E-mail re Goldmine

YH-PSET0500281-0500286 YH-PSET2217927-2217930 YH-PSET1106985-1106986 YH-PSET1238875-1238876

Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Yahoo Form 10-K YH-PSET1072085-1072092 YH-PSET0099889-0099892 Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Assumptions spreadsheet Deposition of Markman, 2009-12-03; Match spreadsheets Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Yahoo dated July 13, 2009 Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of an e-mail dated February 8, 2006, from Mr. Mayer to Farzin Maghoul and others, "RE: Project Frankie Update" Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of an e-mail chain, the top message dated September 20, 2006, from Tim Mayer to Ivan Markman

0096

P, R

Mayer Ex. 3

YH-PSET1841728-1730

0097

P, R

Mayer Ex. 4

YH-PSET0533122-3125

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of an e-mail string, the top message dated November 7, 2006, from Tim Mayer to John Slade and Jeff Weiner Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of a six-page web printout from StoneTemple Consulting dated October 1, 9 2007, titled "Eric Enge Interviews Yahoo's Tim Mayer" Deposition of Mayer, 2009-11-20; Copy of a nine-page printout from the Yahoo! Search Blog titled "From 'To Do' to 'Done' in One Search" Deposition of Patel, 2009-10-27; Printout of a PowerPoint deck titled Behavioral Targeting Review dated 18 March 2005 Deposition of Patel, 2009-10-27; Printout of a PowerPoint deck titled "Behavioral Targeting Overview George John," dated 18 March 2005 Deposition of Patel, 2009-10-27; Printout of three web pages titled Yahoo! Privacy Policy Deposition of Patel, 2009-10-27; Printout of a PowerPoint deck titled BT2 Revival, dated June 3, 2009 Deposition of Patel, 2009-10-27; Printout of a PowerPoint deck titled BT2 Boot Camp Modeling Methodology dated September 29, 2009 Deposition of Robinson: Plaintiff's Notice of Rule 9 30(b)(6) Deposition for Yahoo! Inc. (Regarding Documents and Persons Most knowledgeable), with attachment. Seven pages. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Robinson: 2006 YSM Operations Finance Structure and Priorities, March 2006. Five pages.

PX# 0098

Objections P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Mayer Ex. 5

BATES BEGIN YH-PSET0531172-1175

BATES END

0099

A, F, P, R

Mayer Ex. 6

0100

A, F, P, R

Mayer Ex. 7

0101

P, R

Patel Ex. 2

YH-PSET2138032-8086

0102 0103 0104

P, R P, R P, R

Patel Ex. 3 Patel Ex. 4 Patel Ex. 5

YH-PSET2232366-2398

YAH0021153-1203

0105

P, R

Patel Ex. 6

YAH0021204-1236

0106

N

Robinson Ex. 1

0107

P, R

Robinson Ex. 3

YH-PSET2310723-YH-PSET2310727.

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Robinson: Yahoo's Objections to nXn's Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition. Eight pages. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Robinson: Photocopy of a 179-page Yahoo Inc. Form 10-K filed 02/27/08 for the Period Ending 12/31/07. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Robinson: Photocopy of a one-page yahoo.com printout headed "Be a Better Message Magician," purportedly printed 8/11/2008. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Robinson: 66-page collection of spreadsheets, the first headed Domestic/International Summary. Deposition of Robinson: Photocopy of a three-page typewritten e-mail message to a list, the first recipient being Greg Arnold, from Rachel Glaser, dated Thursday, May 04, 2006. Deposition of Schilace, 2009-08-06; Exhibit 2 Screenshot "We're Giving Away ONE MILLION MILES. Find Out Why..." Deposition of Schilace, 2009-08-06; Exhibit 3 Screenshot "Great Savings, even Mom would Love" Deposition of Schilace, 2009-08-06; Exhibit 4 Screenshot "Your Amazon.com order 002-7273482 has shipped!" Deposition of Schilace, 2009-08-06; Exhibit 5-A SETI Online for Content Onebox Deposition of Schilace, 2009-08-06; Exhibit 7-B Ads Tech Talk Series: Gmail Ads Bates

PX# 0108

Objections P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT Robinson Ex. 4

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

0109

MIL

Robinson Ex. 5

0110

A, F, P, R

Robinson Ex. 6

0111

MIL

Robinson Ex. 7

YH-PSET0155542-YH-PSET0155607.

0112

P, R

Robinson Ex. 8

YH-PSET1346688 through YH-PSET1346690

0113 0114 0115 0116 0117

A, F, P, R A, F, P, R A, F, P, R P, R P, R

Schilace Ex. 2 Schilace Ex. 3 Schilace Ex. 4 Schilace Ex. 5-A Schilace Ex. 7-B GGL-PA00021898-GGL-PA00021908 GGL-PA00015644-GGL-PA00015656

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Schulman: Exhibit 12 Google Press Center, "Google Acquires Kaltix Corp." Press release dated September 30, 2003. One page. No Bates number. Deposition of Schulman: Exhibit 13 Google Press Center, "Google Acquires Applied Semantics." Press release dated April 23, 2000 One page. No Bates numbers. Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Copy of NXN's Third Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition for Yahoo (Regarding Documents and Persons Most Knowledgeable)," dated July 13, 2009 Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a patent application from the U.S. PTO titled "System and Method for Query Substitution for Sponsored Search," dated October 1, 2009

PX# 0118

Objections P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Schulman Ex. 12

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

0119

P, R

Schulman Ex. 13

0120

N

Shahshahani Ex. 1

0121

A, F, P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 10

0122

P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 3

YH-PSET 2509475-9506

Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a PowerPoint slide deck titled "Products Sponsored Search" Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Copy of a document headed "Rough Draft" "Draft of Lifecycle Diagrams (as of 3/27/07)" Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a PowerPoint slide deck titled "Data Needs and Interface for Model Based on Sponsored Search" Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a PowerPoint slide deck titled "Executive Summary" from Yahoo! Strategic Data Solutions

0123

P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 4

YH-PSET2174888-4893

0124

P, R, ROC

Shahshahani Ex. 5

YH-PSET 2523950-3969

0125

P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 6

YH-PSET0189799-9804

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a PowerPoint slide deck titled "Overview of YST Search From Crawl to Query," dated November 29, 2005 Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Copy of a onepage diagram titled MODS High Level Diagram Phase 2 Deposition of Shahshahani, 2009-10-29; Printout of a PowerPoint slide deck titled "Yahoo! Using Toolbar Clickstream Data to Enhance YST, Panama and Search Bucket Testing, David Gerster," dated May 27, 2008 Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Google Inc. Form 10K for the Period Ended December 31, 2007 Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Shelton, 2009-12-03; Lobbying Report Deposition of Singhal, 2009-04-01; Document entitled Google Corporate Information, Technology Overview

PX# 0126

Objections P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT Shahshahani Ex. 7

BATES BEGIN YH-PSET 2505045-5111

BATES END

0127

P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 8

YH-PSET2505909

0128

P, R

Shahshahani Ex. 9

YH-PSET0897875-7887

0129 0130 0131 0132 0133 0134 0135 0136 0137 0138 0139 0140

P, R MIL P, P, P, P, P, P, P, N P, R P, R R R R R R R R

Shelton Ex. 10 Shelton Ex. 11 Shelton Shelton Shelton Shelton Shelton Shelton Shelton Ex. Ex. Ex. Ex. Ex. Ex. Ex. 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

PA 0008557-81 GGL-PA 00000669-81 PA PA PA PA PA PA PA 0008545-56 0008481-92 0008493-502 0008503-16 0008517-30 0008531-44 0008570-82

Singhal Ex. 1 Singhal Ex. 2 Singhal Ex. 3 GGL-PA00012137 - 00012147 GGL-PA00080456 - 00080533

Deposition of Singhal, 2009-04-01; PMetrics Team's Goals, with their taxonomy, etc. Bates Deposition of Singhal, 2009-04-01; Document re personalization content

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Deposition of Suchter, 2009-12-22; Exhibit 2 Document headed Indexer/Superdex Overview on the second page. Eight pages. Bates the last page bearing no Bates number. Deposition of Suchter, 2009-12-22; Exhibit 3 A series of e-mail messages, the top one to Tina Krueger, Darshan Kantak, Marc Canabou, Cheryl Dartt, and Liwen Kao, from David Pann, dated December 12, 2006. Two pages. Deposition of Suchter, 2009-12-22; Exhibit 4 Overview of YST Search From Crawl to Query, November 29, 2005, David "Ciemo" Ciemiewicz. 67 pages. Deposition of Yeh, 2009-12-16; Plaintiff's Notice of Rule 30(b)(6) Deposition Deposition of Yeh, 2009-12-16; Form 10-K Various Support Documents Provided by Stephen L. Becker, Ph.D. Video, Spangenberg-Geller January 9, 2008 Expert Report: Expert Report of Alan H. Gordon dated January 1, 2010 Expert Report: Expert Report of Dr. Stephen L. Becker (Google) dated January 4, 2010 Expert Report: Expert Report of Dr. Stephen L. Becker (Yahoo) dated January 4, 2010 Expert Report: Expert Report of Dr. V. Thomas Rhyne dated January 4, 2010 Expert Report: Expert Report of Dr. V. Thomas Rhyne Rebuttal dated January 1, 2010 Expert Report: Supplemental Expert Report of Dr. V. Thomas Rhyne (Google) dated January 22, 2010

PX# 0141

Objections P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT Suchter Ex. 2

BATES BEGIN YAH0000363-YAH0000369

BATES END

0142

P, R, ROC

Suchter Ex. 3

YH-PSET1371014-YH-PSET1371015.

0143

ROC

Suchter Ex. 4

YH-PSET2505045-YH-PSET2505111.

0144 0145 0146 0147 0148 0149 0150 0151 0152 0153

N MIL A, F, H, P, R H, P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R

Yeh Ex. 1 Yeh Ex. 5 YAH0027592-0027709 BECK 000001 002094 PA0001297

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Expert Report: Supplemental Expert Report of Dr. V. Thomas Rhyne (Yahoo) dated January 22, 2010 BECK 000001 602 BECK 000603 1138 BECK 001138 1637 BECK 001638 2094 American Advertising Federation Survey of Industry Leaders on Advertising Trends 2004 Prepared by Atlantic Media Company November 2004 Research Report Online Search Advertising US Internet Team dated September 2004 BECK 2095 2111 BECK 2112 2125 BECK 2126 2201 BECK 2202 2204 BECK 2205 2207 Google Inc. Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2008 Unisearch Company Operations Unisearch "A Unique Patented Search Enhancement, Automatically Personalized to Each User, with Multiple Applications Across Market Boundaries" Unisearch Executive Summary: An Advance in Personalized Internet Search LexiClone Lexical Cloning System "The Role and Meaning of Predicative and Non-predicative Definitions in the Search for Information" by Ilya S. Geller

PX# 0154 0155 0156 0157 0158 0159 0160 0161 0162 0163 0164 0165 0166 0167 0168 0169

Objections P, R MIL, MIL, MIL, MIL, A, A, A, A, F, F, F, F, P, R PR P, R P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

BECK BECK BECK BECK

000001-602 000603-1138 001138-1637 001638-2094

MIL, A, F, P, R MIL, A, F, P, R MIL, MIL, MIL, MIL, MIL P, R P, R P, R A, A, A, A, F, F, F, F, P, P, P, P, R R R R

BECK 002095 002111 BECK 002126 002201 BECK BECK BECK BECK BECK 2095-2111 2112-2125 2126-2201 2202-2204 2205-2207

BR 009890 009997 GELLER 014878 014883 GELLER 029395 029399 GELLER 029406 029413

0170

P, R

GELLER 033091 033096

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION E-Mail Saved by Windows Internet Explorer 7 Regarding LexiClone.com Article "The Role and Meaning of Consciousness, the Subconscious and Intuition in the Search for Information" sent November 20, 2008 E-Mail Saved by Windows Internet Explorer 7 Regarding LexiClone.com Article "The Patent Technology Overview What the Patent# 6,199,067 Covers" sent November 20, 2008 Unisearch Business Plan Summary "The New Search Technology," White Paper Microsoft Developer Studio Project File The Life of a Dollar: A Talk for Nooglers about Google's Ad System GOOG 63236365 The Role and Meaning of Predicative and Non-Predicative Definitions in the Search for Information (Geller) Ilya Geller-18 (Cited in Becker Report) Ilya Geller-19 (Cited in Becker Report) Ilya Geller-20 (Cited in Becker Report) Ilya Geller-21 (Cited in Becker Report) Ilya Geller-22 (Cited in Becker Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2007 GGL-PA 00000545 00000614 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2007 GGL-PA 00000615 00000668 Google Inc. Form 10-K for the Period Ended December 31, 2004 GGL-PA 00000928 00001039

PX#

Objections

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

0171

P, R

GELLER 033287 033294

0172 0173 0174 0175 0176 0177 0178 0179 0180 0181 0182 0183 0184 0185 0186

P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, P, P, P, P, P, R R R R R R, ROC

GELLER 033540 033543 GELLER 049567 049610 GELLER 054521 054528 GELLER 055288 055999 GELLER 3309033096 GELLER 3309033096 GELLER031979 GELLER031981 GELLER033081 GELLER033081 GELLER033083 GELLER033083 GELLER034109 GELLER034110 GELLER054521 GELLER054528 GGLP 016520181652189 GGL-PA 00000545 00000614 GGL-PA 00000615 00000668 GGL-PA 00000928 00001039

MIL MIL MIL

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Google Inc. Form 10-K for the Period Ended December 31, 2005 GGL-PA 00001684 00001805 Google Inc. Form 10-K for the Period Ended December 31, 2006 GGL-PA 00001820 00001933 Google Inc. Form 10-Q/A for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2004 GGL-PA 00002058 00002118 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2004 GGL-PA 00002120 00002200 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended March 31, 2005 GGL-PA 00002201 00002256 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2005 GGL-PA 00002257 00002313 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2005 GGL-PA 00002314 00002371 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended March 31, 2006 GGL-PA 00002372 00002544 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2006 GGL-PA 00002545 00002613 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2006 GGL-PA 00002614 00002674 Google Inc. Form 10-Q/A Amendment No. 1 for the Quarterly Period Ended March 31, 2007 GGL-PA 00002675 00002863 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2007 GGL-PA 00002864 00002933 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2007

PX# 0187 0188 0189 0190 0191 0192 0193 0194 0195 0196

Objections MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

GGL-PA 00001684 00001805 GGL-PA 00001820 00001933 GGL-PA 00002058 00002118 GGL-PA 00002120 00002200 GGL-PA 00002201 00002256 GGL-PA 00002257 00002313 GGL-PA 00002314 00002371 GGL-PA 00002372 00002544 GGL-PA 00002545 00002613 GGL-PA 00002614 00002674

0197 0198 0199

MIL MIL MIL

GGL-PA 00002675 00002863 GGL-PA 00002864 00002933 GGL-PA 00002934 00002987

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended March 31, 2008 GGL-PA 00002988 00003040 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2008 GGL-PA 00003041 00003113 2006 Weekly Rolling Revenue Forecast 2007 Weekly Rolling Revenue Forecast Google Revenue Data 2002 Google Revenue Data 2003 Google Revenue Data 1Q01 - 4Q02 Google Revenue Data 1Q01 - 4Q02 Google Revenue Data 1Q01 - 4Q02 Google Sales and Revenue Data January 2005 December 2008 Optimizing Ads Promotion (Tang, et al.) Weekly Revenue Forecast dated August 2009 Google Sales and Revenue Information January 2005November 2009 (Set One) Google Inc. Form 8-K dated October 18, 2007 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated November 13, 2007 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated November 30, 2007 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated Ending January 31, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated March 11, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated April 17, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated June 25, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated July 17, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated October 16, 2008 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated January 22, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated February 26, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated April 16, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated May 7, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated July 16, 2009

PX# 0200 0201 0202 0203 0204 0205 0206 0207 0208 0209 0210 0211 0212 0213 0214 0215 0216 0217 0218 0219 0220 0221 0222 0223 0224 0225 0226

Objections MIL MIL P, P, P, P, P, P, P, R R R R R R R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

GGL-PA 00002988 00003040 GGL-PA 00003041 00003113 GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA 00144574 00144574 00149336 00149365 00149417 00149454 00149549 00144585 00144585 00149364 00149416 00149453 00149548 00149566

P, R N P, R P, R MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL

GGL-PA 00640563 00640567 GGL-PA 013269-013276 GGL-PA 01654713 01654753 GGL-PA 01657312 01657316 GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA GGL-PA 01657510 01657531 01657535 01657543 01657565 01657570 01657589 01657599 01657620 01657641 01657667 01657671 01657694 01657716 01657530 01657534 01657542 01657564 01657569 01657588 01657598 01657619 01657640 01657666 01657670 01657693 01657715 01657736

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Google Inc. Form 8-K dated August 5, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated October 7, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated October 15, 2009 Google Inc. Form 8-K dated November 9, 2009 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2008 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended March 31, 2009 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended June 30, 2009 Google Inc. Form 10-Q for the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, 2009 Google Sales and Revenue Information January 2005November 2009 (Set Two) AdSense and Search/Content Networks (Miller) The Effects of Web Personalization on Influencing Users Switching Decisions to a New Website 2006 Prosecution History of the U.S. Patent No. 6,199,067 "Google Accounts Help, Personalized Search Results: Basics." One page. "Ads Broadening" (Bem) "Phil and Rephil" (Thompson) "How UBAQ and SmartASS Work Together (preFLOGs)" (Friedman) "Introduction to UBAQ for Nooglers" (Sussman) "Initial SmartASS UBAQ Features" (Bauer) "Ad System Overview" (Gilbert) Photocopy of a one-page typewritten letter to Michelle Lee, from Donald L. Wenskay of The Walt Disney Company, dated August 2, 2004, with an attachment. 44 pages.

PX# 0227 0228 0229 0230 0231 0232 0233 0234 0235 0236 0237 0238 0239 0240 0241 0242 0243 0244 0245 0246

Objections MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL MIL F N P, R (Incorrect Doc) N P, R P, R N N N N N P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGL-PA 01657737 GGL-PA 01657741 GGL-PA 01657746 GGL-PA 01657767

BATES END 01657740 01657745 01657766 01657771

GGL-PA 01657772 01657804 GGL-PA 01657825 01657882 GGL-PA 01657883 01657945 GGL-PA 01657946 01658002 GGL-PA 01658003 01658010 GGL-PA 122319-122326 GGLPA 16582271658231 GGL-PA00003491-GGL-PA00003639 GGL-PA00005120 GGLPA0001241712427 GGLPA0002181821819 GGLPA0002970529713 GGLPA0002971729720 GGLPA0002976629766 GGLPA0009817398204 GGL-PA00098478-GGL-PA00098522

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION "Smart Ad Selection System (SmartASSTM)" (Bauer, et al.) GOOG002159421600 Relaxing Match Length Rules (Ads-BE tweak) launched (a) 070% QBB/disabling optimization for high quality ads, 5/17 5/23 000% Related websearch targeting method for AFD, 5/24 5/30 000% UI Tweak Blue Bar Spacing, 5/24 - 5/30 000% New AFS SmartASS model, 6/1 - 6/6 090%: GGLPA01654296 11 Reverse spell-corrections in Expanded Match 6/22 - 6/27 020% Search UI "Visual Cleanup," 6/29 - 7/3 000% XBT No Duplicates, 6/29 - 7/3 050% Query-broadening to spell-corrected queries, 7/13 7/17 020% MaxWidth UI Tweak, 8/3 - 8/7 050% Updated Conversion Optimizer Smartass Model, 8/10 8/14 025% Relaxing intra-adgroup tiebreaking rules 8/10 - 8/14 070% Query broadening using co-click data, 8/17 - 8/21 060% CAQ launches: RON Site Chunker, 8/24 - 8/28 050%: New default font faces, 8/24 - 8/28 000% SmartASS Infrastructure Launch Merge Table 8/24 8/28 025% Integrating Information Retrieval and Domain Specific Approaches for Browsing and Retrieval in Object Oriented Class Libraries (Helm)

PX# 0247 0248 0249 0250 0251 0252 0253 0254 0255 0256 0257 0258 0259 0260 0261 0262 0263 0264

Objections N P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R A, P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGLPA01653825 GGL-PA01654015 GGL-PA01654249 GGL-PA01654276 GGL-PA01654276 12 GGL-PA01654296 11 GGL-PA01654369 GGL-PA01654399 13 GGL-PA01654399 6 GGL-PA01654485 GGL-PA01654614 GGL-PA01654655 GGL-PA01654655 GGL-PA01654696 GGL-PA01654737 GGL-PA01654737 GGL-PA01654737 GGL-PA0518105195

BATES END

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION LocationAware Mobile Applications Based on Dictionary Services (Maass) 12_18_09 Production2 Cvr Email_Password "Web Search System Overview: Life Of a Query" (Gilbert) Ads Broadening A Gentle Introduction to Superroot Phil and RePhil Query Rewrite "RePhil Document Parser" (Kasera, et al.) "Query Rewrite" (Baker, et al.) GOOG16168601616867, GGLPA016192611619268 QuickTime MPEG Movie File entitled: Ads Tech Talk: RePhil by Michael Jahr dated 2/26/2008 The good, bad and ugly of contextual ads from Google, Yahoo 7/6/2005 Panel Summary #1 re personalized search software for textual information retrieval based on lexical cloning technology Google Developer Handbook re Kansas Google Developer Handbook re Phil and RePhil NGramBased Scoring for ContentAds RePhil: A Complete Rewrite of RePhil RePhil Document Parser RePhil PowerPoint Presentation How UBAQ and SmartASS Work Together (pre FLOGs) Introduction to UBAQ for Nooglers Initial SmartASS UBAQ Features

PX# 0265 0266 0267 0268 0269 0270 0271 0272 0273 0274 0275 0276 0277 0278 0279 0280 0281 0282 0283 0284 0285

Objections A, P, R P, R (Incorrect Doc) P, R (Incorrect Doc) P, R P, R N N N N N A, P, R P, R (Incorrect Doc) N N N N N P - first page N N N

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGL-PA0519605212 GGL-PA0523005245 GGL-PA0530005308

BATES END

GGL-PA1241712427 GGL-PA148380148391 GGL-PA16191731619175 GGL-PA16192611619268 GGLPA16520281652038 GGLPA16521802188 GGL-PA1653825 GGL-PA16582271658231 GGL-PA16588041658805 GGL-PA2181221814 GGL-PA2181821819 GGL-PA2234622350 GGL-PA2258722596 GGL-PA2260722615 GGL-PA2262422659 GGL-PA2970529713 GGL-PA2971729720 GGL-PA29766

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION 1999; and Lev, Baruch, Intangibles Management, Measurement and Reporting, Brookings Institution Press, Washington, D.C. 2001 Ad System Overview Google Sales and Revenue Information January 2005December 2008 (Set Three) Kansas What is it? Phil and RePhil What is it? Query Rewrite Web Search System Overview: Life of a Query Current RePhil Models PHIL: A Large Hierarchical Latent Variable Model for Text Generation (Harik) "Rephil" (Daverin) "The Life of a Dollar" (Stout, et al.) Gmail Ads "Kansas" (Klenk) "Rephil A complete rewrite of Phil" (Lerner) GOOG00035353544, GGLPA0002258722596 "Rephil" (Video Presentation) (Jahr) GGLPA01653825 Smart Ad Selection System (SmartASS) RePhil: A Complete Rewrite of RePhil Google Inc. Form 8-K dated June 12, 2009 Google Inc. Form 10-K for the Fiscal Year Ended December 31, 2008 Ilya Geller-7 Mightiest Logicon Unisearch Presentation (Cited in Becker Report) Behavioral Targeting Version 00 (Koran) 2008 Weekly Rolling Revenue Forecast CV of Gerald Mossinghoff

PX# 0286 0287 0288 0289 0290 0291 0292 0293 0294 0295 0296 0297 0298 0299 0300 0301 0302 0303 0304 0305 0306 0307 0308

Objections A, P, R ROC F N N N N N N ROC P, R P, R N N N N N MIL MIL P, R ROC MIL N

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGL-PA7616276169 GGL-PA9817398204 GOOG 0638162 0638166 GOOG GOOG GOOG GOOG GOOG 16167571616760 16167721616774 16168601616867 16178581617882 16183251618326

BATES END

GOOG 32673293 GOOG00035353544, GGLPA0002258722596 GOOG002159421600 GOOG0097323-GOOG00097331 GOOG16167571616760 GOOG16168601616867, GGLPA016192611619268 GOOG16183251618326 GOOG2159421600 GOOG35353544 PA 0001304 0001306 PA 0001307 0001414 PA0000952 PA0000976 YH-PSET 81773-81792 YH-PSET2310723-YH-PSET2310720

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION CV of James Allan CV of Keith Ugone CV of Mary Woodford CV of Stanley Peters Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Ad Auction ­ Estimated Clickthrough Rate, Victoria Gilbert, November 12 2003 Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Source Source Source Source Source Source Source Source Source Source Code Code Code Code Code Code Code Code Code Code Code (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited (Cited in in in in in in in in in in in Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Rhyne Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report) Report)

PX# 0309 0310 0311 0312 0313 0314 0315 0316 0317 0318 0319 0320 0321 0322 0323 0324 0325 0326 0327 0328 0329 0330 0331 0332 0333 0334

Objections N N N N P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, P, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, R, ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN

BATES END

GGLP GGLP GGLP GGLP

016533601653366 016533751653376 016533771653378 016533791653380

GGLPA00008471 GGLPA0165018 GGLPA0165102 GGLPA0165103 GGL-PA01652018-189, GGL-PA01653375-80, GGL- PA01653603-47, GGL- PA01653675-799, GGL-PA01657152-208, GGL-PA01659595-618 GGLPA01653325 GGL-PA01658884-9340; GGL-PA01659595618; GGL-PA01659643-1660016 GGL-PA01659341-593; GGL-PA01660017-385 GGL-PA01660386-592 GGL-PA1648522 GGL-PA1648528 GGL-PA16485641648571 GGL-PA1648587 GGL-PA1648793 GGL-PA16487961648821 GGL-PA16488221648871 GGL-PA16488721648935 GGL-PA165018

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report)

PX# 0335 0336 0337 0338 0339 0340 0341 0342 0343 0344 0345 0346 0347 0348 0349 0350 0351 0352 0353 0354 0355 0356 0357 0358 0359 0360 0361 0362 0363 0364 0365

Objections P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN BATES END GGL-PA165102 GGL-PA165103 GGL-PA16519171651923 GGL-PA16519661651971 GGLPA16519661651971 GGLPA1651973 GGL-PA16519731651974 GGLPA16519741651979 GGL-PA16520161652017 GGLPA16520161652027 GGLPA16520281652038 GGLPA1652179 GGLPA16521802188 GGL-PA16521901652199 GGL-PA1653325 GGL-PA16534001653402 GGL-PA16534261653429 GGL-PA1653603 GGL-PA16536041653606 GGL-PA16536071653610 GGL-PA16536111653617 GGL-PA1653618 GGL-PA1653619 GGL-PA1653620 GGL-PA16536211653622 GGL-PA1653623 GGL-PA1653624 GGL-PA1653625 GGL-PA1653626 GGL-PA16536271653630 GGL-PA16536311653647

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report)

PX# 0366 0367 0368 0369 0370 0371 0372 0373 0374 0375 0376 0377 0378 0379 0380 0381 0382 0383 0384 0385 0386 0387 0388 0389 0390 0391 0392 0393 0394 0395 0396

Objections P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN BATES END GGL-PA16536751653677 GGL-PA1653678 GGL-PA1653679 GGL-PA1653680 GGL-PA16536811653704 GGL-PA16537051653706 GGL-PA16537071653717 GGL-PA16537181653734 GGL-PA16537351653743 GGL-PA16537441653787 GGL-PA16537881653798 GGL-PA16571521657160 GGL-PA16571611657162 GGL-PA1657163 GGL-PA16571641657167 GGL-PA1657168 GGL-PA1657169 GGL-PA16571701657181 GGL-PA16571821657185 GGL-PA1657186 GGL-PA16571871657202 GGL-PA16572031657207 GGL-PA1657208 GGL-PA16592221659228 GGL-PA16592681659313 GGL-PA16593141659330 GGL-PA16593411659381 GGL-PA16593821659389 GGL-PA16593901659403 GGL-PA16594041659411 GGL-PA16594121659452

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report)

PX# 0397 0398 0399 0400 0401 0402 0403 0404 0405 0406 0407 0408 0409 0410 0411 0412 0413 0414 0415 0416 0417 0418 0419 0420 0421 0422 0423 0424 0425 0426 0427

Objections P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN BATES END GGL-PA16594531659466 GGL-PA16594671659546 GGL-PA16595471659551 GGL-PA16595521659563 GGL-PA16595641659568 GGL-PA16595691659575 GGL-PA16595761659578 GGL-PA16595791659593 GGL-PA16595951659599 GGL-PA16596001659601 GGL-PA16596021659603 GGL-PA16596041659607 GGL-PA16596081659612 GGL-PA1659613 GGL-PA16596141659617 GGL-PA1659618 GGL-PA16596191659632 GGL-PA16600171660030 GGL-PA16600311660114 GGL-PA16601151660119 GGL-PA16601201660132 GGL-PA16601331660138 GGL-PA16601391660149 GGL-PA16601501660158 GGL-PA16601591660202 GGL-PA16602031660208 GGL-PA16602091660222 GGL-PA1660223 GGL-PA16602241660232 GGL-PA16602331660234 GGL-PA16602351660250

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report)

PX# 0428 0429 0430 0431 0432 0433 0434 0435 0436 0437 0438 0439 0440 0441 0442 0443 0444 0445 0446 0447 0448 0449 0450 0451 0452 0453 0454 0455 0456 0457 0458

Objections P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN BATES END GGL-PA16602511660268 GGL-PA16602691660326 GGL-PA16603271660338 GGL-PA16603391660340 GGL-PA16603411660342 GGL-PA16603431660348 GGL-PA16603491660350 GGL-PA16603511660358 GGL-PA16603591660365 GGL-PA16603661660370 GGL-PA16603711660374 GGL-PA16603751660384 GGL-PA1660385 GGL-PA16603861660419 GGL-PA16604201660424 GGL-PA16604251660429 GGL-PA16604301660438 GGL-PA1660439 GGL-PA16604401660442 GGL-PA16604431660456 GGL-PA16604571660458 GGL-PA16604591660462 GGL-PA16604631660468 GGL-PA16604691660492 GGL-PA16604931660495 GGL-PA16604961660503 GGL-PA16605041660505 GGL-PA16605061660509 GGL-PA16605101660511 GGL-PA16605121660513 GGL-PA16605141660518

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Source Code (Cited in Rhyne Report) Public Filing Demographics Targeting Ads Backend, Mayur Datar Megan Nance, June 5 2006 Landing Page Quality, Debbie Leight Nicholas Fox Clay Bavor Abhishek Bapna Ben Crowell Frederick Vallaeys Aniek van Dijk Kai Hansen Anya Oleinikova Masayuki Suzuki, March 6 2008 How to use the Phil Attribute Generator, Rama Ranganath, April 1 2003 Smart Ad Selection System SmartASS, Eric Bauer Ralph Gasser Arnar Hrafnkelsson Chad Lester Eric Veach, October 30 2003 Rephil Compounds, Josh Levenberg, July 2007

PX# 0459 0460 0461 0462 0463 0464 0465 0466 0467 0468 0469 0470 0471 0472 0473 0474 0475 0476 0477 0478

Objections P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC P, R, ROC MIL P, R, ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN BATES END GGL-PA16605191660520 GGL-PA16605211660524 GGL-PA16605251660536 GGL-PA16605371660538 GGL-PA16605391660543 GGL-PA1660544 GGL-PA16605451660546 GGL-PA1660547 GGL-PA16605481660549 GGL-PA16605501660551 GGL-PA16605521660554 GGL-PA16605551660558 GGL-PA16605591660564 GGL-PA16605651660572 GGL-PA16605731660584 GGL-PA16605851660586 GGL-PA16605871660589 GGL-PA16605901660592 GGL-PA00000928-1037 GGLPA00012409

0479

P, R

GGLPA00013188

0480 0481 0482

N ROC N

GGLPA00016077 GGLPA00016973 GGLPA00021666 GOOG0021845

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION GMail Ads Architectural Overview, Jared Jacobs Matthew Lloyd, January 28 2006 Rephil A complete rewrite of Phil, Uri Lerner, November 3 2004 Toolbar Sync Server, Na Tang, December 28 2006 Categorization of Phil Clusters Documents and Websites into Verticals, David Gehrking, June 5 2006 Access Personalized GAIA Enabled Services From Toolbar, Jenny Zhang, May 18 2005 Ads retrieval with user's previous query, Mayur Datar, February 16 2006 Ideas for Using the User's Previous Query/Queries in Ads Serving, Gregory Friedman, January 28 2008 Beginning Permanent Login, David Kuettel, September 20 2005 User Data Storage Policy, Mark Klenk, October 3 2008 Kansas Developers Guide, Henry Ou, August 25 2008 Beginning Plan for Syntax Revision Improvements Patrick Riley, April 16 2008 Ad System Overview, Victoria Gilbert, July 28 2004 Product Search Engineering Overview, Christos Goodrow, April 15 2008 Google Desktop, Google, No Date Beginning Search Overview, Victoria Gilbert, May 27 2008 Toolbar Search Box, George Diabarov, June 7 2005 Kansas, Vladislav Adzic, June 10 2008 Beginning Query Rewrite, Steve Baker Yossi Gil, October 7 2008 Web Search Overview: Life of a Query, Victoria Gilbert, July 28 2004

PX# 0483 0484 0485 0486 0487 0488 0489 0490 0491 0492 0493 0494 0495 0496 0497 0498 0499 0500 0501

Objections P, R, ROC ROC P, R, ROC ROC P, R, ROC ROC P, R P, R, ROC ROC ROC P, R, ROC ROC P, R, ROC P, R, P, R, P, R, ROC P, R, ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGLPA00021836 GGLPA00022587 GGLPA00022818 GGLPA00022947 GGLPA00027079 GGLPA00029490 GGLPA00029767 GGLPA00049045 GGLPA00067035 GGLPA00067041 GGLPA00086384 GGLPA00098173 GGLPA00098465 GGLPA00135735 GGLPA00147530 GGLPA00148270 GGLPA01619158 GGLPA01619261 GGLPA01620259

BATES END

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION How Mustang Caching Works, Wilmer Van Der Gaast, No Date An Overview of Personalized Search, Daria Antonova, August 29 2007 Gmail Components, Tom Noinski, June 25 2008 Overview of YST Search From Crawl to Query, David Ciemiewicz, November 29 2005 QED Cookbook, Kimoon Yahoo, May 14 2008 Low Cost Content Match Optimization Overview, Anthony Molinaro (Source), December 10 2004 DTC XML Interface Specification 1.0 DRAFT 8, Anthony Molinaro, June 29 2002 Behavioral Targeting Product Version 2.0, Joshua Koran, January 5 2004 Content Match Program Plan 2005, John Deck, April 20 2005 Yahoo! SDS Newsletter, Strategic Data Solutions, January 11 2007 Beginning Goto Stored Data, Meg Crocker (source), November 6 2007 BreadCrumbPreprocessor, Meg Crocker (source), November 6 2007 CGI::Cookie, Meg Crocker (source), August 2 2007 Panama Targeting PRD New Geo Targeting Levels & Demographic Targeting, David Caswell Payam Tehrani, March 3 2008 Sponsored Search Lifecycle Overview, Yahoo Search Marketing, March 2007 Qbert 1.0 Version 1.5, Tina Krueger Sandeep Garg, January 10 2007

PX# 0502 0503 0504 0505 0506 0507 0508 0509 0510 0511 0512 0513 0514 0515 0516 0517

Objections P, R, ROC ROC P, R, ROC ROC ROC ROC P, R, ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC ROC

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN GGLPA01622093 GGLPA01632993 GGLPA01635351 YAH0000403 YAH0000532 YHPSET0024957 YHPSET0025033 YHPSET0081773 YHPSET1372107 YHPSET1989085 YHPSET2460658 YHPSET2461408 YHPSET2478469 YHPSET2503548 YH-PSET2504037 YHPSET2504405

BATES END

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Geo Targeting Design, Meg Crocker (source), January 11 2006 Keystone PRD Version 1.0, Melissa Stein Derek Kwan, June 25 2007 Sponsored Search Personalization, Ben Shahshahani, August 18 2006 Public Filing Exhibit F nXn's Second Response to Yahoo's Motion for Summary Judgment, Notice of Allowability, Geller patent prosecution history October, 21 2000 Amended Yahoo Exhibit 12/21/2009 Exhibit H nXn's Second Response to Yahoo's Motion for Summary Judgment; excerpts of a document entitled IAC-Yahoo! Strategic Partnership, dated May 2, 2007 Agreed Amended Docket Control Order 11/4/2009 Claim Construction Order dated September 30, 2009, and associated briefing. Discovery Order Exhibit B Excerpts from nXn's Amended Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions Against Google, and the Amended Google Exhibit thereto, served on October 30, 2009 Exhibit B nXn's Second Response to Yahoo's Motion for Summary Judgment, nXn's Amended Disclosures as to Yahoo and Amended YahooExhibit as to Yahoo August 22, 2000 Exhibit D Excerpts from nXn's Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions as to Google, served on August 22, 2008

PX# 0518 0519 0520 0521 0522 0523

Objections ROC ROC ROC MIL P, R P, R (Incorrect Doc) P, R P, R P, R P, R P, R

DEPO. EXHIBIT

BATES BEGIN YHPSET2505462 YHPSET2524015 YHPSET2524613 GGL-PA00001684-1798 GGL-PA00003629-30

BATES END

GGL-PA 00144442 00144453

0524 0525 0526 0527 0528

YH-PSET0742907

0529

P, R

0530

P, R

PA Advisors v. Google - Defendants' Objections to Plaintiff's Trial Exhibits

Objections Key A= Authentication A/C = Attorney-Client Privilege F = Foundation H = Hearsay LA = Limited Admissibility

MIL = Motion in Limine N = No Objection P = Prejudicial R = Relevancy ROC = Rule of Completeness S = Settlement DOCUMENT DESCRIPTION Exhibit D nXn's Second Response to Yahoo's Motion for Summary Judgment, nXn's Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement Contentions as to Google August 22, 2000 Google Responses to PA Advisors, LLC's Second Set of Requests for Production of Documents and Things, served December 8, 2000 Google's Responses to PA Advisors, LLC's First Set of Requests for Production of Documents and Things, served October 20, 200 Google's Second Amended Answer, Affirmative Defenses and Counterclaims to PA Advisors, LLC's Second Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement Google's Amended Responses to PA's Second Interrogatories to Defendants 12/21/2009 Google's Answer, Affirmative Defenses and Counterclaims to PA Advisors, LLC's First Amended Complaint for Patent Infringement Google's