EMG Technology, LLC v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 209

MOTION to Change Venue by Apple, Inc., American Airlines, Inc., Dell Inc., Hyatt Corporation, Marriott International, Inc., Barnes & Noble, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration, # 2 Exhibit A, # 3 Exhibit B, # 4 Exhibit C, # 5 Exhibit D, # 6 Exhibit E, # 7 Exhibit F, # 8 Exhibit G, # 9 Exhibit H, # 10 Exhibit I, # 11 Exhibit J, # 12 Exhibit K - Part 1, # 13 Exhibit K - Part 2, # 14 Exhibit L, # 15 Exhibit M, # 16 Exhibit N, # 17 Exhibit O, # 18 Exhibit P, # 19 Exhibit Q, # 20 Exhibit R, # 21 Exhibit S, # 22 Exhibit T, # 23 Exhibit U, # 24 Exhibit V, # 25 Exhibit W, # 26 Text of Proposed Order)(Rambin, Daymon)

EMG Technology, LLC v. Apple, Inc.

Doc. 209 Att. 2

EXHIBIT A

Dockets.Justia.com

EXHIBIT A CONVENIENCE CONSIDERATIONS Identified Non-Party Witnesses Witness Relevance Location of Witness Santa Monica, CA (CDCA) Travel Time/ Distance to LAX 0; 15 miles Travel Time/ Distance to TYR 4 hr, 45 min; 1345 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1347 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1311 miles 4 hr, 35 min; 1072 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1317 miles 4 hr, 30 min; 1310 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1304 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1315 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1560 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 5 hr, 22 min; 1130 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1361 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1326 miles Page 1

Elliott Gottfurcht Grant E. Gottfurcht AlbertMichael C. Long J. Teague McKnight Manuel V. Beltran Stephen K. Woesner John Marinuzzi Donald Dukeshire Marlo L. Longstreet Thomas Ciotti Thomas M. Coester Scott Doyle John E. Gunther Jun-Youg E. Jeon

Applicant Applicant Applicant

Pacific Palisades, 0; CA (CDCA) 16 miles Irvine, CA (CDCA) Park City, UT Santa Ana, CA (CDCA) Santa Ana, CA (CDCA) Mission Viejo, CA (CDCA) Huntington Beach, CA (CDCA) 0; 35 miles 1 hr, 54 min; 597 miles 0; 24 miles 0; 30 miles 0; 45 miles 0; 30 miles

Applicant (Ancestor Patent) Applicant (Ancestor Patent) Applicant (Ancestor Patent) Applicant (Ancestor Patent) Applicant (Ancestor Patent)

Ownership Interest Pacific Palisades, 0; CA (CDCA) 0 Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Palo Alto, CA Los Angeles, CA (CDCA) Washington, D.C. Westlake Village, CA (CDCA) Pasadena, CA (CDCA) 1 hr, 20 min; 324 miles 0; 0 5 hr, 45 min; 2306 miles 0; 33 miles 0; 9 miles

EXHIBIT A Witness Relevance Location of Witness Los Angeles, CA (CDCA) Westlake Village, CA (CDCA) Los Angeles, CA (CDCA) Redwood City, CA Bay Area, CA Menlo Park, CA Bay Area, CA Bay Area, CA Bay Area, CA San Francisco, CA Bay Area, CA Mountain View, CA Bay Area, CA Los Angeles, CA (CDCA) Los Altos, CA Mountain View, CA Travel Time/ Distance to LAX 0; 0 0; 33 miles 0; 0 1 hr, 20 min; 329 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 326 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 317 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 349 miles 0; 0 1 hr, 20 min; 319 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 317 miles Travel Time/ Distance to TYR 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1361 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1573 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1577 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1578 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1562 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1562 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1562 miles Page 2

Jonathan Miller Steven C. Sereboff Brennan C. Swain Openwave Systems, Inc. employees Tim Hyland Alain Rossmann Peter King Bruce Schwartz Russell Greer Mark Fox Andrew Laursen Mark Lentczner Brad Sandman Chris De Herrera Bruce Leak Stephen G. Perlman

Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Prosecuting Attorney Prior Art

Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art Prior Art

EXHIBIT A Witness Relevance Location of Witness Sunnyvale, CA Travel Time/ Distance to LAX 1 hr, 20 min; 315 miles 0; 9 miles 0; 9 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 335 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 335 miles 0; 0 0; 0 47 min; 231 miles Travel Time/ Distance to TYR 5 hr, 5 min; 1562 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1326 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1326 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1570 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1570 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 4 hr, 45 min; 1330 miles 4 hr, 54 min; 1423 miles

Palm, Inc. employees Art & Logic employees Bob Bajoras Protovu employees Rick Soss Angel Gulermovich Online Labs former employees AVERAGE

Prior Art

Attempted Pasadena, CA Commercialization Attempted Pasadena, CA Commercialization Attempted Foster City, CA Commercialization Attempted Foster City, CA Commercialization Attempted Los Angeles, CA Commercialization Attempted Los Angeles, CA Commercialization

Page 3

EXHIBIT A

Parties and Their Witnesses Party Location of Party Witness Travel Time/ Distance to LAX 2 hr, 30 min; 972 miles 4 hr, 5 min; 1587 miles 3 hr, 15 min; 1240 miles 6 hr, 15 min; 2477 miles 6 hr, 20 min; 2454 miles 6 hr, 4 min; 2387 miles 1 hr, 20 min; 314 miles 3 hr, 15 min; 1211 miles 3 hr, 15 min; 1221 miles 4 hr, 25 min; 1756 miles 5 hr, 45 min; 2287 miles 6 hr, 20 min; 2454 miles 4 hr, 24 min; 1697 miles Travel Time/ Distance to TYR 5 hr, 45 min; 1766 miles 4 hr, 7 min; 523 miles 45 min; 92 miles 5 hr, 52 min; 1364 miles 5 hr, 52 min; 1322 miles 5 hr, 30 min; 1227 miles 5 hr, 5 min; 1557 miles 45 min; 120 miles 2 hr, 45 min; 187 miles 4 hr, 15 min; 788 miles 5 hr, 22 min; 1118 miles 5 hr, 52 min; 1322 miles 4 hr, 20 min; 949 miles

Microsoft Corporation Scottrade, Inc. Southwest Airlines Co. Priceline.com, Inc. Zagat Survey, LLC Comcast Corporation Apple Inc. American Airlines, Inc. Dell, Inc. Hyatt Corporation Marriott International, Inc. Barnes & Noble, Inc. AVERAGE

Redmond, WA St. Louis, MO Dallas, TX (NDTX) Norwalk, CT New York City, NY Philadelphia, PA Cupertino, CA Fort Worth, TX (NDTX) Round Rock, TX (WDTX) Chicago, IL Bethesda, MD New York City, NY

Page 4