Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Filing 620

NOTICE by Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC re 578 Proposed Pretrial Order, (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit E, # 2 Exhibit F, # 3 Exhibit M)(Cawley, Douglas)

Download PDF
Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al Doc. 620 Att. 3 EXHIBIT M Dockets.Justia.com IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES LLC, Plaintiff, v. SOFTLAYER TECHNOLOGIES, INC., ET AL. Defendants CASE NO.: 6:09-CV-269-LED BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES LLC'S OBJECTIONS TO GOOGLE'S TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST Presiding Judge: Leonard Davis Trial / Hearing Date(s): April 11, 2011 Court Reporter: Courtroom Deputy: Plaintiff's Attorney(s): Defendant's Attorneys: ** Categories: (A) - Will Use; (B) - May Use; (C) Probably Won't Use Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION BATES NO. 1 eBay Subsidiaries (as of Dec. 31, 2010), Weinstein Exh. 4 eBay and Paypal use Linux servers; Stubhub did until Sept. 2009. 2 Acacia Technologies: Leader in Patent Licensing and Enforcement Admitted Category Marked Offered 402, 403, 801/802, 901 402, 403, 801/802, 901 DATE 12/31/2010 WITNESS 00/00/0000 3 4 Email from J. Anderson to D. Lee and B. DePirro re Nemes Pre-Nuptual Agreement between Richard Nemes and Judy Frenkel. ACACIA000002 BTEX0749153-160 801/802, 901 402, 403, MIL D 402, 403, MIL D 402, 403, MIL D 1/28/2009 3/14/2005 5 6 Stipulation of Settlement/Property Nemes Exh. 38 Adjustment Agreement between R. Nemes and H. Nemes. Fax from R. Steams to D. Garrod containing Garrod Exh. 112 Financial Affidavit in D. Garrod vs. L. Garrod. 5/8/2000 12/16/2010 Page 1 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION BATES NO. 7 Presentation by Michael Schulz entitled, Weinstein Exh. 7 OpenSource at HP, Community Involvement and Internal Use. 8 Email chain between C. Elston and L. Hill re IV-Bedrock 000006 Request for Final Valuation for deal Nemes, Richard M. Authorized to $120k. Intellectual Ventures web screen shots E-mail from C. Elston to D. Garrod RE: Opportunity re: U.S. Patent No. 5,893,120 and $105K offer for the patent. [NET]: Fix hashing exploits in ipv4 routing, IP conntrack, and TCP synq. Settlement and License Agreement entered by Bedrock and Nationwide Mutual Insurance. Email chain between A. Curry and J. Glenn re Settlement discussions Patent License and Settlement Agreement between Bedrock and CME Group. Confidential Settlement and License Agreement between Bedrock and PayPal, Inc. Settlement and License Agreement entered by Bedrock and SunGard. Affiliated Companies, Nationwide.com, About Us section of Website. IV-Bedrock 000318-327 Nemes Exh. 37 IV-Bedrock 000007-9 BTEX00751523-532 Weinstein Exh. 2 BTEX0749125-152 BTEX0752142-2143 Weinstein Exh. 5 BTEX0122319-331 Weinstein Exh. 6 BTEX0748753-768 BTEX0749060-086 Admitted Category Marked Offered 402, 403, 801/802, 901 801/802, 901 801/802, 901 DATE 00/00/2004 WITNESS 3/17/2008 9 10 1/5/2011 4/9/2008 11 12 3/5/2003 12/22/2010 13 14 15 8/4/2010 1/11/2010 4/30/2010 16 17 12/21/2010 403, 801/802, 901 00/00/00 18 Patent License and Settlement Agreement by BTEX0752522-536 and between Bedrock and ConAgra Foods. IPv6+IPSEC+ISAKMP Distribution Page. Schiller Exh. 2 YAHOO00507238 A. Kuznetsov to A. Cox re [Patch 003/103] Kuznetsov Exh. 2 Merge to 1.3.42. DEF00009286-9320 Robert L. Kruse, Chapter 4: Linked Lists, in DEF00005078-5129 Data Structures and Program Design. 801/802 2/19/2011 19 20 21 00/00/00 11/17/1995 106 00/00/1984 Page 2 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 22 Robert L. Kruse, Chapter 6.8: Application: The Life Game Revisited, in Data Structures and Program Design. 23 Daniel F. Stubbs and Neil W. Webre, Data Structures with Abstract Data Types and Pascal, 68-79 (1985). 24 Curriculum Vitae of Mark T. Jones 25 Email from M. Lotvin to R. Nemes re The Bellcore Letter. 26 Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. DEF00005130-5140 106 DATE 00/00/1984 WITNESS DEF00005141-5155 106 00/00/1985 Jones Exh. 1 Lotvin Exh. 19 BTEX0745490 Employment acceptance form of M. Lotvin; HP-000009 - 10 Agreement regarding Confidential Information and Proprietary Developments, executed by M. Lotvin on May 8, 2000. DoS Tracking Tis the season to be SYN flooded. Post-Period Analysis of Web Search Delay Experiments Draft 2. Traffic Impact of the 100 ms Delay Experiment Draft 2. Google webpage entitled: Life of a Packet. GGL-BED00048775 - 779 GGL-BED00049141 - 167 GGL-BED00049253 - 272 GGL-BED00037476-499 MIL B, MIL E, 801/802 MIL C, COM 00/00/0000 1/28/2009 00/00/2000 27 28 29 30 31 10/12/2008 3/28/2008 4/27/2007 5/18/2010 3/28/2007 32 33 34 35 36 37 Frontend traffic overview Life of a request: GGL-BED00037836-845 how our traffic management system works (Astrid Atkinson). Email chain between D. Garrod, M. Lotvin, BTEX0748981-983 R. Parker re Office Lease. Pace University Faculty Evaluation Report Nemes Exh. 27 submitted in 1999 for 1998 re: R. Nemes. BTEX0000578-588 Lease Agreement by and between Crest Properties and Bedrock, January 1, 2009. Handwritten Notes, Intellectual Property IP BTEX0273098-3119 403, PRIV 11/4/2008 3/5/1999 1/1/2009 Nemes Exh. 20 BTEX0124123-133 Curriculum Vitae of Dr. Richard M. Nemes. Nemes Exh. 12 BTEX0745769-772 Letter from S. Merrit to R. Nemes re: Nemes Exh. 24 Peformance Evaluations. PACE 00036 00/00/0000 6/30/1994 Page 3 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 38 Letter from P. Ewers to R. Nemes re: Terms of Appointment for Sept. 1, 1994 to Aug. 31, 1995. 39 Resume for Faculty Appointment re Richard Nemes. Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. Nemes Exh. 23 PACE 00039 Nemes Exh. 21 PACE 00042-45 DATE 6/14/1994 WITNESS 5/4/1989 40 41 42 43 Letter from S. Merrit to R. Nemes re: Pace University's Tenure Policy. Pace University Faculty Evaluation re: R. Nemes. Self-Evaluation of Teaching and Scholarship re: R. Nemes. Email chain between D. Garrod, M. Lotvin, R. Nemes and D. Green re Prof. Richard M. Nemes. U.S. Patent No. 5,893,120 File History for U.S. Patent No. 5,893,120. Email from D. Garrod to D. Lee re Linux claim chart (for U.S. Patent 5,893,120); (Chart attached) U.S. Patent No. 4,996,663 U.S. Patent No. 5,121,495 U.S. Patent No. 5,287,499 Claim 5 of the '120 Patent vs. Claim 1 of the '495 Patent. Google Corporate Information Technology overview. Google Corporate Information Google history. Google Corporate Information Our philosophy. Google Corporate Information User experience Open Source at Google Presentation. Nemes Exh. 22 PACE 00047 Nemes Exh. 25 PACE 00213-215 Nemes Exh. 26 PACE 00234 BTEX0745364-365 6/1/1989 2/18/1998 3/17/1997 402, 403, MIL E, MIL B 5/6/2009 44 45 46 Nemes Exh. 15 BTEX0000159-173 Nemes Exh. 35 BTEX0000174-485 ACACIA000003-54 4/6/1999 8/27/2009 MIL C 2/4/2008 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 DEF00003992-4009 DEF00004032-4049 DEF00004050-4063 Nemes Exh. 13 GGL-BED00049315 - 320 GGL-BED00049337 - 359 GGL-BED00049375 - 378 GGL-BED00049384 - 387 GGL-BED00033440-464 DEM 2/26/1991 6/9/1992 2/15/1994 00/00/0000 12/30/2010 12/30/2010 12/30/2010 12/30/2010 MIL H, 403 00/00/0000 Page 4 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 56 Video Containers.mp4; Video Equipment Yard.mp4; Video Hangar.mp4;Video Plant.mp4. 57 Website article entitled: NRL IPv6 Software Distribution (Release "Alpha-2). 58 Source Code - key.h 59 60 61 62 63 Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. GGL-BED00040209-212 64 65 66 Schiller Exh. 3 YAHOO00507241-242 McDonald Exh. 1 DEF00007971-7974 Source Code - key.h McDonald Exh. 2 YAHOO00507259 Source Code - key.c McDonald Exh. 3 DEF00007942-7970 Minutes for IP Security Working Group. McDonald Exh. 5 YAHOO00507281-7290 Syllabus: COSC 2336 Data Structures and QEDEF00000152-158 Algorithms (UT, Tyler). Department of Computer Science, Bachelor QEDEF00000159 of Science in Computer Science 2008-2010 Curriculum. (UT, Tyler). Message from E. Dumazet to List re KTS0000933 [PATCH net-next] net: avoid RCU for NOCACHE dst. net: avoid RCU for NOCACHE dst. KTS0001018-1020 J. Corbet, G. Hartman, A. McPherson, A White Paper (The Linux Foundation) Linux Kernel Development: How fast is it going, who is doing it, what they are doing, and who is sponsoring it. Source Code - gcache.c BTEX0752238-2257 106, COM, UKN 801/802 DATE 00/00/0000 WITNESS 1/19/1996 9/28/1995 8/17/1995 9/28/1995 12/15/1995 801/802 801/802 00/00/2010 2008-2010 801/802, 901 801/802, 901 801/802, MIL C 10/15/2010 10/20/2010 12/00/2010 67 Ostermann Exh. 3 DEF00008004-REVISED DEF00008015.001REVISED Ostermann Exh. 5 KTS0000426-REVISED - KTS0000438REVISED Ostermann Exh. 4 KTS0000439-REVISED - KTS0000440REVISED 10/21/1991 68 Source Code - gcache.c 00/00/1996 69 Source Code - gcache.h 8/16/1996 Page 5 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 70 Technical Report entitled: GCache: A Generalized Caching Mechanism, by D. Comer and S. Ostermann. 71 Declaration of Alexey Kuznetsov. 72 Daniel F. Stubbs and Neil W. Webre, Data Structures with Abstract Data Types and Pascal, 310-366 (1985). Employment Agreement Regarding Intellectual Property between R. Nemes and Bell Communications. Assignment and Agreement between R. Nemes and Bell Communications. Confirmatory Assignment of Patent Rights by R. Nemes. Letter from D. Green to R. Nemes re Signature for Confirmatory Patent Assignment, with enclosures. E-mail from D. Green to D. Garrod re: Prof. Richard M. Nemes. File History for U.S. Patent No. 5,121,495. Collection of documents from Telcordia re: Patent Application. Application Approval for Filing. Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. Ostermann Exh. 2 DEF00007719-734 Kuznetsov Exh. 1 DEF00009284-9285 DEF00007975-8003 DATE 3/17/1992 WITNESS 801/802 106 12/15/2010 00/00/1985 73 Telcordia Exh. 2 BTEX0285475 Telcordia Exh. 13 BTEX0285476-478 Telcordia Exh. 17 BTEX0285479-480 BTEX0745240-242 MIL B, MIL E MIL B, MIL E 901, MIL B, MIL E MIL B, MIL E MIL B, MIL E 1/13/1986 74 75 1/28/1988 00/00/0000 76 1/23/2009 77 78 79 Telcordia Exh. 16 BTEX0285473-474 Telcordia Exh. 11 GGL-BED00031154-385 Nemes Exh. 14 TELECORDIA00000152-281 Telcordia Exh.4 TELECORDIA00000245-276 GGL-BED00049395-406 5/6/2009 6/9/1992 80 81 82 David S. Miller, Linux Networking Futures 2010. [Issue 1659539] `Detected Tx Unit Hang" and serving hiccups on clovertown. Email from L. Chavey to M. Bligh, M. Waychison, R. Manomohan re fixing route dst cache entry slab allocation. GGL-BED00032100-101 COM, MIL B, MIL E MIL B, MIL E 403, 801/802, 901 801/802 12/31/1987 1/7/1987 00/00/2010 2/24/2009 83 GGL-BED00032664-666 801/802 4/24/2009 Page 6 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 84 Blog post, KS2009: How Google Uses Linux, by Jonathan Corbet. Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. GGL-BED00034737-00034748 Past Page 2, 801/802 DATE 10/21/2009 WITNESS 85 86 87 [Issue 1659539] `Detected Tx Unit Hang" and serving hiccups on clovertown. [Issue 1659161] ip_dst_cache filling up otherwise `free' nodes? Nandita Dukkipati, kiwi: Reducing TCP's Slow Start latency. Tiziana Refice, /24s distribution. GGL-BED00034936-937 GGL-BED00035585 GGL-BED00040274-307 2/24/2009 6/15/2009 11/4/2009 88 GGL-BED00041628-633 00/00/0000 89 Chris DiBona, A 3 Hour History of Free and GGL-BED00033802-861 Open Source Software in 46(ish) Minutes. [Issue 1659161] ip_dst_cache filling up otherwise `free' nodes? [Issue 1659161] ip_dst_cache filling up otherwise `free' nodes? [Issue 1659161] ip_dst_cache filling up otherwise `free' nodes? [Issue 1659539] "Detected Tx Unit Hang" and serving hiccups on clovertown. Google and Open Source, with highlights from the last year.... (Chris DiBona, Google Speaker Series) Zaheda Bhorat, BCS EqualiTEC Career Workshops. Blog Post, What is Linux, by Linus Torvalds. Atanu Saha, Janice Stroud and Roy Weinstein, Risk Analysis: A General Approach to Evaluating Settlement Offers. GGL-BED00032799-2800 GGL-BED00032865-2866 GGL-BED00035987-5988 GGL-BED00040167-169 GGL-BED00033465-507 801/802, 901 00/00/0000 90 91 92 93 94 5/8/2009 5/19/2009 5/19/2009 2/23/2009 801/802, 901 00/00/0000 95 96 GGL-BED00034101-135 Weinstein Exh. 8 801/802, 901, MIL C 5/4/2006 7/2/2007 97 00/00/0000 Page 7 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION BATES NO. 98 John D. Culbertson and Roy Weinstein, Product Substitutes and the Calculation of Patent Damages, Journal of the Patent and Trademark Office Society, Vol. 70, No. 11, 749-761 (1988). 99 Bedrock's Consolidated Responses to Google's 1st Set of Rogs (Nos. 1-6) 100 Bedrock's Consolidated Responses to Google's 2nd Set of Rogs (Nos. 7-8) 101 Bedrock's Objections & Responses to Google's 1st Set of RFA's 102 Bedrock's Objections & Responses to Google's 2nd Set of RFA's 103 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.11 104 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.18 105 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.26 (produced 8/17/10) 106 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.26 (produced 2/4/11) 107 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.34 (produced 1/10/11) 108 Source Code from Linux v. 2.6.34 (produced 2/4/11) Goodwin Procter attorney Bio for David 109 Garrod Exh. 105 Garrod. BTEX0285472 Side-by-side comparison the '120 and '495 Nemes Exh. 30 110 patents. Email from C. Elston to D. Garrod re 111 Nemes Exh. 36 Opportunity re U.S. Pat. 5,893,120. 112 Richard Nemes, A hybrid hashing technique Nemes Exh. 39 for fast access to long term data in a large on- BTEX0748911-920 line data base (1987 Bellcore Database Symposium/ Special Report SR-STS000783). Richard Nemes, New hashing methods based Nemes Exh. 40 113 on Knuth's Algorithm 'R' (Proceedings of the BTEX0748884-910 1990 Conference on Information Science and Systems). 114 Subsidiaries of the Registrant: Nationwide Admitted Category Marked Offered DATE 11/00/1988 WITNESS 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 MIL C DEM MIL C MIL B, MIL E 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 2/14/2008 9/00/1987 00/00/1990 801/802, 901 12/31/2009 Page 8 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION 115 White Paper: Leveraging Cloud Security to Weather Threatening Storms (Akamai). 116 U.S. Patent No. 7,827,254 117 118 U.S. Patent No. 7,865,536 Mirkovic et al., Chapter 2: Understanding Denial of Service, in Internet Denial of Service 11-28, Pearson Education Inc., 2005. Garbee Bdale, From Zero to SPECfp2000...Porting Debian to IA-64 Admitted Category Marked Offered BATES NO. DATE 00/00/0000 11/2/2010 1/4/2011 00/00/2005 WITNESS MIL H, 403 MIL H, 403 119 403, 801/802, 901, MIL C, MIL L 00/00/2003 120 121 122 William Choi and Roy Weinstein, An Analytical Solution to Reasonable Royalty Rate Calculations, IDEA: The Journal of Law and Technology, 2001. Roy Weinstein, Janet Thornton, and Paul White, New Tools for the Calculation of Infringement Damages, 48th Annual Conference on Intellectual Property Law. Paul M. Janicke and LiLan Ren, Who wins patent infringement cases?, AIPLA Quarterly Journal Vol. 34, No. 1, Winter 2006. George J. Stigler, The Throey of Price, 215216 (4th ed., 1987). Confidential Settlement and License Agreement by and between Bedrock and R.L. Polk & Co. Email from E. Zelenock to C. Bunt re bedrock/polk. US. Patent No 6,119,214 Robert L. Kruse, Data Structures & Program Design (2nd ed. 1987). Benvenuti, C., Understanding Linux Network Internals, (Andy Oram ed., 2006). 106 BTEX00761937-947 00/00/2001 11/8/2010 00/00/2006 123 124 00/00/1987 2/00/2011 125 126 127 128 BTEX0761952-953 DEF00000797-810 DEF00006702-7007 DEF00008677-9211 1/10/2011 9/12/2000 00/00/1987 00/00/2006 Page 9 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION BATES NO. 129 Donald E. Knuth, The Art of Computer DEF00006328-6701 Programming, Volume 3/Sorting and Searching. 130 Article entitled: A Queueing Analysis Of Van Wyk Exh. 3 Hashing With Lazy Deletion*, by J. DEF00000001-10 Morrison, L. Shepp and C. Van Wyk. 131 DEF00000149-161 Christopher J. Van Wyk and Jeffrey Scott Vitter, The Complexity of Hashing with Lazy Deletion. Algorithmica (1986) I:17-29. Christopher J. Van Wyk, Data Structures and DEF00009458-9660 132 C Programs. MATCH00009477 133 Match.com's Revenue of Sales Orders Excel spreadsheets 134 Match.com's Purchase Order re:; VendorMATCH00010057 MoreDirect, Inc. Excel spreadsheet 135 Simplified Representation of Match.com Storie Exh. 14 Network As It Relates To The Linux Servers. MATCH00005495-5535 136 137 138 FM Global Policy No. JD184 Storie Exh. 13 MATCH00005831-5907 MATCH00009308 Admitted Category Marked Offered DATE 00/00/1973 WITNESS 12/00/1987 00/00/1986 00/00/1988 1/31/2011 4/14/2010 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 00/00/0000 11/15/2007 Match.com's Operations Network-Logical Circuits Chart re: Public Internet. Jason Cowishaw & Joey Mitchell's, DDoS MATCH00006964-972 Network Defense Project-DDoS Detection (and Mitigation) Booklet (Guide) Version 1. 139 140 141 142 143 Jason Cowishaw & Joey Mitchell's, DDoS MATCH00007512-523 Network Defense Project- DDoS Defense in Depth Booklet (Guide) Version 2. James La Vacca, Alfredo Rodriguez & Dave MATCH00007561-583 Revor's Network Attack Mitigation Planning Booklet (Guide) Version 1.1. Arbor Peakflow Sales Order Form MATCH00008400-401 Match.com Fact Sheet Red Hat Announces Open Source Assurance to Safegaurd Customer Investment. (RedHat) Graph Statistic Chart re: Usage of Disk Network nfs Processes Sensors System MATCH00006193-6200 8/2/2007 7/6/2007 801/802, 901 9/4/2009 00/00/0000 1/20/2004 144 11/30/2010 Page 10 of 11 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION Objection DEF. EX. NO. DESCRIPTION BATES NO. 145 Arbor Peakflow X Protection and Visibility MATCH00007025-028 for the Enterprise Network Booklet (Guide) 146 147 148 149 150 151 152 Match.com's Market Chart-; Excel spreadsheets Bedrock's Consolidated Responses to Match.com's 1st Set of Rogs (Nos. 1-6) Bedrock's Consolidated Responses to Match.com's 2nd Set of Rogs (No. 7) Bedrock's Objections & Responses to Match.com's 1st Set of RFA's Bedrock's Objections & Responses to Match.com's 2nd Set of RFA's TOC for Terms of Policy re: InsuredInterActive Corp. Plaintiff's supplemental and amended responses to Match.com LLC's Interrogatories (Nos. 1-4). Algorithmic Complexity Attacks and the Linux Networking Code", Florian Weimer, 31 July 2003. MATCH00009992 Admitted Category Marked Offered DATE 00/00/0000 WITNESS 00/00/0000 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 1/12/2011 MATCH00005642-718 Lotvin Exh. 2 MIL C, 106 6/30/2009 3/7/2010 153 BTEX0746152-155 7/31/2003 Page 11 of 11 EXHIBIT LIST OBJECTION KEY 106 402 403 408 602 701 801 and 802 901 1002 AFE COM CPO DEM DEP ILG MIL NFL UKN UPA DESCRIPTION This exhibit is objectionable because it is incomplete writing or recorded statement (FRE 106) This exhibit is objectionable because it is not relevant (FRE 402) This exhibit is objectionable because its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, confusion of the issues, or misleading the jury or by considerations of undue delay, waste of time, or needless presentation of cumulative evidence (FRE 403) Compromise and offer to compromise (FRE 408) This exhibit is objectionable because it constitutes testimony on a matter as to which the witness lacks personal knowledge (FRE 602) This exhibit is objectionable because it is opinion testimony by a lay witness that is not reasonably based on perception and helpful to a clear understanding of the witness' testimony or the determination of a fact in dispute (FRE 701) This exhibit is objectionable because it is a statement made by one other than the declarant while testifying at trial, offered into evidence to prove the truth of the matter asserted and not subject to any hearsay exception (See FRE 801 and 802) This exhibit is objectionable because it has not been authenticated (FRE 901) This exhibit is objectionable because it is being used to prove the content of a writing and it is not the original writing (Best Evidence) (FRE 1002) This testimony is objectionable because it assumes a fact not in evidence This exhibit is objectionable because it is a combination of more than one document This exhibit is objectionable because it relates to Microsoft's inequitable conduct claim and can only be used for "Court Purposes Only" (Inequitable Conduct, Laches, Equitable Estoppel) This exhibit is objectionable because it is demonstrative evidence and therefore not properly admitted into evidence This exhibit is objectionable because it is a deposition transcript and hence is not properly admitted into evidence This exhibit is objectionable because it is illegible This exhibit is the subject of a Motion in Limine This exhibit is objectionable because the proper foundation has not been laid This exhibit is objectionable in that it is unknown because it has not been adequately identified by Microsoft and as such, i4i cannot evaluate its substance This exhibit is objectionable because Microsoft appears to offer it as alleged prior art but Microsoft failed to identify it in its invalidity contentions as required by P.R. 3-3 or P.R. 3-6 Late Production - documents produced after the close of discovery LP Dated: March 18, 2011. Respectfully submitted, McKOOL SMITH, P.C. _/s/ Douglas A. Cawley ________ Douglas A. Cawley, Lead Attorney Texas Bar No. 04035500 dcawley@mckoolsmith.com Theodore Stevenson, III Texas Bar No. 19196650 tstevenson@mckoolsmith.com Rosemary T. Snider Texas Bar No. 18796500 rsnider@mckoolsmith.com Scott W. Hejny Texas State Bar No. 24038952 shejny@mckoolsmith.com Jason D. Cassady Texas Bar No. 24045625 jcassady@mckoolsmith.com J. Austin Curry Texas Bar No. 24059636 acurry@mckoolsmith.com Phillip M. Aurentz Texas State Bar No. 24059404 paurentz@mckoolsmith.com Daniel R. Pearson Texas State Bar No. 24070398 dpearson@mckoolsmith.com McKOOL SMITH, P.C. 300 Crescent Court, Suite 1500 Dallas, Texas 75201 Telephone: 214-978-4000 Facsimile: 214-978-4044 Sam F. Baxter Texas Bar No. 01938000 McKOOL SMITH, P.C. sbaxter@mckoolsmith.com 104 E. Houston Street, Suite 300 P.O. Box 0 Marshall, Texas 75670 Telephone: (903) 923-9000 Facsimile: (903) 923-9099 BEDROCK'S COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS Error! Unknown document property name. PAGE 1 Robert M. Parker Texas Bar No. 15498000 Robert Christopher Bunt Texas Bar No. 00787165 PARKER, BUNT & AINSWORTH, P.C. 100 E. Ferguson, Suite 1114 Tyler, Texas 75702 Telephone: 903-531-3535 Facsimile: 903-533-9687 E-mail: rmparker@pbatyler.com E-mail: rcbunt@pbatyler.com ATTORNEYS FOR PLAINTIFF BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES LLC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned certifies that, on March 18, 2010, the foregoing document was filed electronically in compliance with Local Rule CV-5(a). As such, this notice was served on all counsel who have consented to electronic service. Local Rule CV-5(a)(3)(A). /s/ Jason D. Cassady Jason D. Cassady ______ BEDROCK'S COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS Error! Unknown document property name. PAGE 2

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?