Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Filing 638

NOTICE by Google Inc., Match.Com LLC re #578 Proposed Pretrial Order, of Filing Exhibits to Proposed Pretrial Order (Attachments: #1 Exhibit J - Objections to Amended Counter Depo Designations, #2 Exhibit N - Objections to 2nd Amended Trial Witness List)(Jones, Michael)

Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Doc. 638 Att. 1

Exhibit J

Dockets.Justia.com

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES LLC, PLAINTIFF v. SOFTLAYER TECHNOLOGIES, INC., CITIWARE TECHNOLOGY SOLUTIONS, LLC, GOOGLE, INC., YAHOO!, INC., MYSPACE INC., AMAZON.COM INC., PAYPAL INC., MATCH.COM, INC., AOL LLC, and CME GROUP INC., DEFENDANTS § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § § Case No. 6:09-cv-269 LED

JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

OBJECTIONS TO BEDROCK'S AMENDED COUNTER DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

1

OBJECTIONS KEY

CODE A AA B CC CD DI IH MIL MT NR O V 30(b)(6) 103 104 402 403 602 611c 701 702 802 901 Argumentative Asked and answered

OBJECTION

Beyond scope of counter-designation Calls for conclusion Compound Designation incomplete; incomprehensible Incomplete hypothetical Subject to the Court's ruling on or a pending in limine motion Misstates prior testimony (mischaracterization) Non-responsive Overbroad Vague and ambiguous Outside of the scope of the FRCP 30(b)(6) deposition topics for which witness was designated Assumes facts not in evidence Lacks foundation Not relevant Unduly prejudicial Calls for speculation; speculative Leading Improper opinion by lay witness Improper opinion by expert Hearsay Not properly authenticated

2

Deposition of Joseph D'Avanzo - December 7, 2010 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 8:1 8:5 45:8 45:13 48:20 48:25 51:25 52:4 56:13 56:15 56:21 57:7 80:7 80:9 80:11 80:12 91:5 91:20 92:7 92:10 92:20 93:3 93:19 93:24 101:8 101:15 106:9 106:14 106:18 107:3 108:11 109:11 123:21 124:2 125:17 125:20 127:5 127:18 138:2 138:23 139:17 141:13 141:15 142:4 142:19 143:15 143:17 143:20 143:22 143:24 144:1 144:5 144:16 144:23 145:4 146:2 146:4 146:6 146:9 146:19 146:21 147:9 147:11 147:11 149:12 149:22 149:24 151:5 151:11 152:14 152:16 154:6 154:9 154:25 155:2 155:10 156:10 156:13 156:15 156:16

Google's Objections

104a, 402 602 402 DI DI 402 80:13 ­ 80:16 80:18 ­ 80:21

402

402, AA AA 402 AA AA, 104a, 402 104a, 402, 611c 104a, 602 103, 104a 402, 403 402, 403 MT, 611c 402, 104a, 602 402, V 104a 104a, CC 104a, CC MT 104a CC 402, 403, 602 701 402, 403 104a, 402, 403, 602, 701 104a, 402, 403, 602, 701

109:12-14

3

Bedrock's Counter Designations 156:18 156:22 156:24 156:24 157:14 157:17 157:19 157:20 157:22 157:25

Google's Objections 104a, 402, 403, 602, 701 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403

Google's Counter Designations

Deposition of David Garrod - December 15, 2010 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 8:4 8:9 8:15 8:19 22:8 22:15 25:14 26:9 32:11 32:18 54:23 55:12 77:1 77:4 77:6 77:7 77:9 77:15 77:17 77:20 117:23 118:11 113:2 113:11 136:18 at "My 136:19 next question..." 137:16 137:18 148:5 148:18 197:25 198:5 198:24 199:19 204:6 204:22 207:9 207:14 207:24 208:7 209:3 209:21 236:9 236:14 238:14 238:25 288:13 288:24 300:19 301:4 309:16 310:7 310:9 310:9 310:11 310:12 310:14 310:18 310:20 311:4

Google's Objections NR AA, NR DI, 402 402 402 104a, 602 NR NR DI, 402, 403, 104a

402 104a, 402 402 NR 104a, 602, NR, MIL 402 NR, 104a, MIL 402

402, NR 402, NR

4

Bedrock's Counter Designations 317:13 317:24 325:12 325:22

Google's Objections NR

Google's Counter Designations

Deposition of David Garrod - December 16, 2010 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 371:20 372:4 373:24 373:25 374:2 375:22 377:25 378:15 486:8 486:13 486:15 486:22 486:24 487:12 487:14 487:14 487:16 487:20 487:22 488:17 490:3 490:20 501:4 501:18 501:20 501:23 503:24 504:2 504:4 504:6 519:13 519:25 536:3 537:18 538:18 540:2 540:6 540:21 541:3 541:7 541:9 541:15 541:17 543:25 545:17 546:7 546:9 548:24 549:9 550:17 552:1 552:5 553:7 554:6 554:8 554:8 555:17 556:17 556:24 557:4 557:6 557:11 562:23 563:7 564:1 564:4 571:3 571:15 572:13 572:23

Google's Objections

NR NR

NR NR NR

488:18 ­ 490:2

701 701 402, 403

NR NR

MIL, NR MIL, NR NR, MIL

5

Bedrock's Counter Designations 573:12 574:3 575:3 575:10 592:16 594:1 594:10 597:3 608:8 608:8

Google's Objections 602 402, AA AA, 402

Google's Counter Designations

Deposition of Alexey Kuznetsov - January 27, 2011 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 9:11 9:13 28:1 28:3 29:14 30:1 39:12 39:18 43:5 43:9 50:24 51:4 52:7 52:14 54:8 54:12 54:14 54:20 55:10 55:19 60:21 60:23 94:1 94:2 94:4 94:4

Google's Objections 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403, 105 DI, 402, 403 DI, 402, 403

43:10 ­ 44:3 51:5 ­ 51:19

402, 403 DI, 402, 403 DI, 402, 403

94:5 ­ 94:13 104:11 104:12-105:5 107:5-6 114:13 ­ 114:17 115:11 ­ 115:18 115:23 ­ 115:25

Deposition of Daniel McDonald - January 10, 2011 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 21:6 21:17 21:19 21:19 22:19 22:24 33:3 33:11 33:13 33:17 33:19 33:19 40:5 40:7

Google's Objections

6

Bedrock's Counter Designations 46:8 46:19 49:13 49:16 96:2 96:6 102:7 102:10 104:8 104:24 105:20 106:5 107:6 110:18 111:18 114:21 115:4 115:23 117:6 117:24 118:112 118:20 119:6 119:11 119:22 120:9 120:22 122:7 122:20 124:9 125:14 127:9 128:18 128:24 131:4 131:14 133:4 133:16 135:12 137:11 105:23 106:11 108:1 111:4 114:18 114:24 115:20 117:4 117:20 118:8 118:16 118:24 119:8 119:18 120:3 120:18 121:8 122:16 123:14 125:4 127:6 127:13 128:20 129:2 131:9 131:21 133:13 133:17 135:22 139:8

Google's Objections

Google's Counter Designations

402, 403, DI 402, 403, MIL, 802, 701, DI

96:15 ­ 97:17 105:1 ­ 105:19 105:24 ­ 106:4 106:12 ­ 106:20 108:2 ­ 108:19 110:6 ­ 110:17

402, 403, MIL, 802, 701, DI, A, V 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V 402, 403, A, V 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V 402, 403, A, V, AA 402, 403, A, V 402, 403, V, DI 402, 403, DI 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403, A, 602

122:17 ­ 122:19

402, 403, V 402, 403, V 402, 403, 802, 701, DI 139:15 ­ 139:21 139:23 ­ 140:5 140:23 ­ 141:13 141:15 ­ 143:3

7

Deposition of Ed Miller - December 6, 20101 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 70:3 70:16 71:14 71:17 72:18 74:5 75:5 76:12 77:11 77:13

Google's Objections B B, 402 B, 104a B B, 104a

Deposition of Shawn D. Ostermann, Ph.D. - January 6, 2011 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 20:17 21:6 22:7 22:21 25:11 25:16 35:1 35:5 37:21 38:6 41:2 41:3 41:6 41:13 44:5 44:11 46:21 47:8 61:6 61:17 70:15 72:12 74:9 75:4 76:9 76:24 77:1 77:4 77:6 77:11 77:13 77:25 78:5 78:13 80:1 81:13 84:5 84:12 84:22 85:7 86:7 86:11 87:3
1

Google's Objections 402, 403 602, 402, 403

402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403, MIL 701 402, 403, MIL 701, 802 402, 403, MIL 701, 802, V

81:14 ­ 81:15 81:17 ­ 82:4

84:8 84:14 84:24 85:14 86:9 86:11 87:11

84:25 ­ 85:6

V

Google objects to the designation of any of Edwin Miller's deposition testimony as beyond the scope of counter-designation because Google did not designate any of Edwin Miller's testimony.

8

Bedrock's Counter Designations 88:18 89:14 90:19 90:20 90:22 90:22 91:10 91:14 91:21 92:1 92:3 92:13 92:15 92:19 93:9 93:12 93:20 93:23 95:15 95:25 99:3 99:7 100:19 100:20 100:22 100:25 101:15 101:17 101:19 101:19 102:2 103:17 104:5 104:16 105:9 105:17 107:3 108:5 112:19 113:14

Google's Objections 403, V V V CD CD

Google's Counter Designations

99:8 ­ 99:12 99:14 ­ 99:19 V 402, 403 402 ,403 402, 403 103:18 ­ 103:25 110:4 ­ 110:5 110:7 ­ 110:25 111:2 ­ 111:10 111:16 ­ 111:18

Deposition of Jeffrey Schiller ­ January 7, 2011 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 26:9 26:12 27:6 27:8 32:6 32:7 32:9 32:11 32:13 32:13 33:14 33:15 33:17 33:17 34:4 34:5 34:7 34:7 39:20 40:5 44:8 44:15 45:6 45:10

Google's Objections 402, 403, DI 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402 402 DI DI 402, 403, DI 402, 403

40:6 ­ 40:13

9

Deposition of Mikhail Lotvin ­ June 4, 2010 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 8:3 8:6 8:23 9:14 9:17 10:5 10:8 10:20 10:22 11:13 11:16 11:24 12:4 12:16 12:18 13:1 13:4 14:3 14:5 15:5 15:7 15:14 16:6 21:24 22:1 24:20 24:24 25:11 25:13 25:16 26:2 27:4 27:6 27:13 27:16 27:18 27:21 28:2 28:4 28:12 28:22 29:7 29:17 30:1 30:11 31:4 31:20 32:7 32:22 28:10 28:19 29:3 29:13 29:23 30:9 31:2 31:18 32:5 32:19 33:12

Google's Objections 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 611c, MIL, NR 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403, 802 104a, 602 104a, 602 104a, 602, 402, 403, 103, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL, 802 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL, 802 402, 403, 104a, 103, 602, MIL, 802 402, 403, 602, MIL 402, 403, 602, MIL, 103, 701, 611c,

10

Bedrock's Counter Designations 33:16 33:17 33:19 34:7 71:12 75:9 128:15 152:7 152:17 153:10 172:15 172:19 173:1 191:9 191:12 191:19 192:3 192:21 210:16 211:10 215:5 216:1 216:7 229:20 230:2 34:5 34:19 71:16 75:13 128:23 152:13 153:6 153:14 172:17 172:19 174:6 191:10 191:16 191:22 192:6 193:2 210:16 211:13 215:16 216:5 216:12 229:23 230:11

Google's Objections 402, 403, 103, 701, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 103, 701, 611c, MIL 402, 403, 103, 701, 611c, MIL 402, 403

Google's Counter Designations

NR NR

402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 402, 403 DI

DI DI

Deposition of Mikhail Lotvin - December 28, 2010 Google's Counter Designations

Bedrock's Counter Designations 54:1 54:4 54:25 55:1 55:3 55:11 57:11 57:16 81:11 81:23 82:4 82:9 99:18 100:11 100:20 101:7 238:5 239:1

Google's Objections 602 103, 104, 602, 103, 104, 602, 402, 403 NR, 103, 104, 701 802 NR, 103 NR 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL

11

Bedrock's Counter Designations 239:4 240:5 240:8 240:18 240:24 241:9 241:13 241:20 242:18 242:25 243:9 240:14 240:21 241:5 241:11 241:17 242:16 242:22 243:5 244:11

Google's Objections 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL 104a, 402, 403, 602, 611c, 701, MIL

Google's Counter Designations

12