Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Filing 638

NOTICE by Google Inc., Match.Com LLC re #578 Proposed Pretrial Order, of Filing Exhibits to Proposed Pretrial Order (Attachments: #1 Exhibit J - Objections to Amended Counter Depo Designations, #2 Exhibit N - Objections to 2nd Amended Trial Witness List)(Jones, Michael)

Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC v. Softlayer Technologies, Inc. et al

Doc. 638 Att. 2

Exhibit N

Dockets.Justia.com

Objections to Bedrock's Second Amended Exhibit List Google's objections to Bedrock's exhibits are below. Objections reference the Federal Rules of Evidence by rule number or are otherwise descriptive. In addition, in some instances Google has asserted the following objections, defined as follows: MP NI SD MIL Exhibit is inadmissible because it contains more than one document or is an improper collection of documents. Exhibit is not sufficiently identified as to allow Google to object to the exhibit Exhibit is inadmissible because it pertains to a defendant that has settled Exhibit is potentially subject to exclusion in whole or in part under a pending motion in limine.

Late production Exhibit was produced after the close of discovery

Google objects to the fact that Bedrock has not provided Google with information sufficient to identify certain exhibits. Google reserves the right to use exhibits to which it has objected; in some instances Google's objections will not apply, depending on how the exhibit is used. Google reserves the right to supplement, modify, or withdraw objections to Bedrock's exhibits based on the facts, circumstances, or rulings issued by the Court that arise or develop subsequent to the filing of this document.

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS TYLER DIVISION § § § § § § § § § §

BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES LLC, Plaintiff, v. SOFTLAYER TECHNOLOGIES, INC., ET AL. Defendants.

CASE NO.: 6:09-CV-269-LED

GOOGLE'S OBJECTIONS TO BEDROCK COMPUTER TECHNOLOGIES, LLC SECOND AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST Presiding Judge: LEONARD DAVIS Plaintiff's Attorney(s): Robert Parker; Douglas Cawley; Ted Stevenson; Scott Hejny; Jason Cassidy; Austin Curry; Christopher Bunt Court Reporter: Trial / Hearing Date(s): Rosa Ferguson ** Categories: (A) - Will Use; (B) - May Use; (C) Probably Won't Use Defendant's Attorneys: Quinn Emanuel and Potter Minton law firms

Courtroom Deputy:

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 1 U.S. Patent 5,893,120 to Nemes Certified Copy 2 U.S. Patent 5,893,120 - Certified File History 3 U.S. Patent 4,996,663 to Nemes 4 U.S. Patent 5,121,495 to Nemes

DATE BATES NO. BTEX 0000159BTEX 0000173 BTEX 0000174BTEX 0000485 BTEX 0761963BTEX 0761978 DEF 00004032 DEF 00004044 CAT Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ ADM 04/06/99 04/06/99 02/26/91 06/09/92 WITNESS

1

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 5 U.S. Patent 5,287,499 to Nemes 6 7 8 U.S. Patent 5,893,120 Re-Exam NPLs AOL/Time Warner Inc. - ACE USA Insurance Policy Article (Intenet), "[IPV4] Route Cache: Introduce rt_genid for Smooth Cache Invalidation ," E. Dumazet, www.mailarchive.com Article (Intenet), "[IPV4] Route Cache: Introduce rt_genid for Smooth Cache Invalidation ," D. Miller, www.mailarchive.com Article (Internet), "Algorithmic Complexity Attacks and the Linux Networking Code ," www.enyo.de/fw/security/notes/linuxdst-cache- dos.html Article (Internet), "Amazon May Have Lost $9.2 Million in Sales Due to Outage ," E. Oswald Article (Internet), "Assessing Trends Over Time in Performance, Costs, and Energy Use for Servers ," J. Koomey, et al., Intel Website, p. 19 (http://download.intel.com/pressroom/p df/server trendsrelease.pdf) Article (Internet), "Denial of Service Attacks ," Cert.org website (www.cert.org) Article (Internet), "Prison Urged for MafiaBoy ," Wired News Report Article (Internet), "Statement of Eric Holder, Deputy Attorney General of the US Before the Subcommittee on Crime of the House Committee on the Judiciary and the Subcommittee on the Criminal Oversight of the Senate Committee on the Judiciary on Internet Denial of Service Attacks and the Federal Response " Article (Internet), "The History of Linux ," Linux Website (www.linux.org)

DATE BATES NO. DEF 00004050 DEF 00004063 CAT Will Use Will Use AOL-BED 021309AOL-BED 021343 BTEX 0750859BTEX 0750868 Will Use Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ ADM 02/15/94 402-403, 802, 901, NI, MIL 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 702, 802, 901 WITNESS

12/09/09- 12/09/10 01/30/08

9

BTEX 0750869BTEX 0750870

Will Use

702, 802, 901

01/31/08

10

BTEX 0118867BTEX 0118870

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

08/14/08

11

BTEX 0749403BTEX 0749405 BTEX 0752383BTEX 0752439

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, MIL 402-403, 802, 901, late production

06/30/10

12

Will Use

08/17/09

13

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, MIL 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 402-403, 802, 901, MIL

12/22/10

14 15

BTEX 0749399BTEX 0749400 BTEX 0749240 BTEX 0749245

Will Use Will Use

06/20/01 02/29/00

16

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

2

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 17 Article (Internet), "The Price of Performance, An Economic Case for Chip Multiprocessing ," L. Barroso, Google, www.queue.acm.org 18

DATE BATES NO. BTEX 0752440BTEX 0752443 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402-403, 802, 901, late production ADM 10/18/05 WITNESS

19 20

21

22

23

Article (Internet), "Understanding Denial of Service Attacks ," U.S. Cert.gov Website (www.uscer.gov/cas/tips/ST04-015.html Article (Internet), "What is Linux? " Linux Website (www.linux.org/info) Article (Internet), "Why Attackers Can't BTEX 0749090BTEX 0749093 Take Down Amazon.com ," J. Pepitone, CNN Money.com Article, "A Survey of Licensed Royalties ," R. Degnan, les Nouvelles, p. 93 Article, "An Analytical Solution to Reasonable Royalty Rate Calculations ," W. Choi and R. Weinstein, The Journal of Law and Technology, Vol. 41, No. 1 Article, "Bargaining Under incomplete Information ," K. Chatterjee and W. Samuelson, Operations Research, Vol. 31, No. 5, Sept-Oct 1983, p. 835-836 Article, "Cost-Effective Flow Table BTEX 0005599BTEX 0005609 Designs for High Speed Routers: Architecture and Performance Evaluation ," J. Xu and M. Singhal, IEEE Article, "Cyber Monday Spending Tops $1B, ComScore Says ," C. Albanesius, PC Mag Article, "Distributed Denial of Service Attacks ," Patrikakis, M. Charalampos, M. Masikos, and O. Zouraki, The Internet Protocol Journal, Vol. 7, No. 4 Article, "Endogenous Bargaining Power in Bilateral Monopoly and Bilateral Exchange ," A. Z. Spindler, Canadian Journal of Economics, VII, No. 3, pp. 463-464 Article, "Internet Denial of Service, Attack and Defense Mechanisms ," J. Mirkovic, S. Dietrich, D. Dietrich, and P. Reihere, Prentice Hall, 2005, pp. 11-28

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, MIL

Will Use Will Use

802 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 402-403, 703, 802, 901 802

07/02/09 12/09/10

Will Use

06/00/97

Will Use

2001

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

1983

24

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

09/00/02

25

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901, MIL

12/01/10

26

Will Use

12/00/04

27

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

08/00/74

28

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, MIL

2005

3

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION BATES NO. No. 29 Article, "Joint Profit Maximization, Negotiation, and the Determinancy of Price in Bilateral Monopoly ," D. Truett and L. Truett, Journal of Economic Education, Summer 1993 30 Article, "Noncooperative Models of Bargaining ," K. Binmore, Handbook of Game Theory, Vol. 1, 179-225 31 Article, "Online Ad Market perks Up After Dismal Year ," Wall Street Journal 32 Article, "Online Ad Spending Surpasses Newspapers ," eMarketer, Inc. Article, "The Bargaining Problem ," J. Nash, Econometrica, Vol. 18, No. 2, pp. 155-162 Article, "The Case for EnergyProportional Computing ," L. Barroso and U. Holzle, L_L Computer Society

DATE CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402-403, 802, 901 ADM 1993 WITNESS

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901, late production 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901

00/00/92

Will Use

04/07/10

Will Use

12/21/10

33

Will Use

04/00/50

34

BTEX 0752258BTEX 0752262

Will Use

12/00/07

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

42

Article, "Two-Person Cooperative Games ," J. Nash, Econometrica, Vol. 21, No. 1, pp. 128-140 Article, "Who Wins Patent Infringement Cases? ," P. Janicke and L. Ren, AIPLA Quarterly Journal, Winter 2006, p. 8 Articles - Collection of Articles BTEX 0749012BTEX 0749059; BTEX 0749087BTEX0749124; BTEX0749161Assignment of USP 5,893,120 from R. BTEX 0122363 Nemes to Bedrock Computer Technologies LLC Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC BTEX 0234468Certificate of Formation from Texas BTEX 0234472 Secretary of State Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC BTEX 0761979 Texas Secretary of State Certificate of Fact Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC BTEX 0761980 Texas Franchise Tax Public Information Report Bedrock Profit Distribution Agreement BTEX 0122336BTEX 0122338

Will Use

01/00/53

Will Use

2006

Will Use

1006, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL

Will Use

03/26/09

Will Use

402, late production 402, late production 402, late production 402, 802, 901

11/06/08

Will Use

03/10/11

Will Use

05/20/10

Will Use

01/26/08

4

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 43 Bell Communications Research Memorandum from R. Nemes re: Proposed Patent Application: A Fast Method for Storing and Retrieving Automatically Expiring Data 44 Book, "Data Structures & Program Design ," R. Kruse, St. Mary's University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, 2nd Ed. 45 Book, "Data Structures with Abstract Data Types and Pascal ," D. Stubbs and N. Webre, California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, CA 46 Book, "Patent It Yourself NOLO's Inventors' Essentials," D. Pressman, 13th Ed. Book, "The Art of Computer Programming, Volume 3 / Sorting and Searching ," D. Knuth, Stanford University Book, "Understanding Linux Network Internals ," C. Benvenuti, Brochure, "Linux Kernel Development How Fast It is Going, Who is Doing It, What They are Doing, and Who is Sponsoring It ," The Linux Foundation

DATE BATES NO. QETEL 0000255QETEL 0000266 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 802 ADM 09/09/87 WITNESS

BTEX 0759496BTEX 0760099

Will Use

1987

BTEX 0760100BTEX 0760578

Will Use

1985

BTEX 0760579BTEX 0761142 BTEX 0761143BTEX 0761878

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, late production

04/00/08

47

Will Use

1973

48 49

DEF 00008677-DEF Will Use 00009211 BTEX 0752238Will Use BTEX 0752257

802 105, 802, 901, late production

2006 12/00/10

50

51

BTEX 0122339Company Agreement of Bedrock Computer Technologies, LLC, a Texas BTEX 0122356 Liability Company Email from A. Absher to A. Kuznetsov KTS 0000244 re: Linux Route.c Question Email from A. Kuznetsov to A. Absher re: Linux Route.c Question Email from A. Kuznetsov to A. Absher re: Linux Route.c Question Email from CIT/Paul to List: Linux netdev re: Rout Cache Performance Under Stress Email from CIT/Paul to List: Linux netdev re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress Email from CIT/Paul to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress Email from D. McDonald to H. Lien re: Bedrock v. Google KTS 0000242 KTS 0000247 BTEX 0750879BTEX 0750880 BTEX 0751042

Will Use

402, 802, 901

11/05/08

Will Use

106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL

12/08/10

52 53 54

Will Use Will Use Will Use

12/03/10 12/13/10 06/09/03

55

Will Use

06/10/03

56

BTEX 0748686BTEX 0748688 GGL-BED 0048228

Will Use

06/09/03

57

Will Use

11/02/10

5

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 58 Email from D. Miller to List: Linux netdev re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 59 Email from D. Miller to List: Linux netdev re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 60 Email from D. Miller to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 61 Email from D. Miller to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 62 Email from D. Miller to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 63 Email from D. Miller to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 64 Email from D. Miller to List: Linux-net re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress 65 Email from E. Zelenock to C. Bunt re: Polk - Number of Servers 66 Email from F. Weimer to List: LinuxKernel re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress Email from G. Glenn to A. Curry re: Settlement Discussions Email from H. Lien to A. Kuznetsov re: Patent Suit Inquiry Email from J. Lee to H. Memes re: Bedrock: Rescheduling for your Dec. 22 Deposition o January 7 or 10, 2011 Email from L. Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2554333] Set/proc/sys/net/ipv4/route/refcnt_relea se to 0 in prod Email from L. Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2554333] Set/proc/sys/net/ipv4/route/refcnt_relea se to 0 in prod Email from Linux Kernel Mailing List to List: git-commits-24 re: Fix Hashing Exploits in the IPV4 Routing, IP Conntrack, and TCP Synq

DATE BATES NO. BTEX 0750878 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL, late production 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802, 901 106, 402-403, 802, 901 106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL ADM 06/09/03 WITNESS

BTEX 0750940BTEX 0750941 BTEX 0748690

Will Use

06/09/03

Will Use

06/09/03

BTEX 0748689

Will Use

06/09/03

BTEX 0748691BTEX 0748692 BTEX 0748693BTEX 0748694 BTEX 0751040

Will Use

06/09/03

Will Use

06/09/03

Will Use

06/10/03

BTEX 0761952BTEX 0761953 BTEX 0748695BTEX 0758696 BTEX 0752141 GGL-BED 0048243

Will Use

01/10/11

Will Use

04/05/03

67 68 69

Will Use Will Use

08/04/10 10/21/10 12/20/10

MWEHNEME 00001 Will Use

70

GGL-BED 0048182- Will Use GGL-BED 0048183

106, 802

03/29/10

71

GGL-BED 0047965

Will Use

106, 802

07/28/10

72

BTEX 0751523BTEX 0751532

Will Use

106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL

05/03/03

6

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 73 Email from Maze. to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2554333] Set/proc/s/net/ipv4/route/cnt_release to 0 in prod 74 Email from P. Roeder to J. LaBarre and E. Pennypacker re: Bedrock v. Softlayer 75 Email from P. Roeder to T. Briggs, et al. re: Bedrock v. Softlayer: Service of Google/Match.com Motion to Compel and Related Motions/Papers in NDCa1 on HP and Paul Roeder 76 Email from R. Olsen to List: Linux-net re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress Email from R. Olsen to List: linux-net re: Route Cache Performance Under Stress Email from S. Ostermann to M. Morlock re: Red Hat and Gcache Email from T. Briggs to P. Feig, et al. re: Bedrock Case Email from T. Briggs to P. Feig, et al. re: Bedrock v. Softlayer, et al. Email from V. Agarwal to A. Pal, et al. re: Handling Y! Specific Kernel Changes Email from Y. Chaikovsky to D. Kilough and C. Bright re: Bedrock Email from Y. Chaikovsky to M. Sarboraria and C. Bright re: Happy Thanksgiving Gcache c: Generalized Caching Routes, by Ostermann

DATE BATES NO. GGL-BED 0048178 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 402, 802 ADM 03/29/10 WITNESS

QEDEF 00005

Will Use

106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802, 901, MIL

05/21/10

BTEX 0751544 BTEX 0751550

Will Use

12/28/10

BTEX 0751041

Will Use

77

BTEX 0751091

Will Use

78

KTS 0000280KTS 0000281 QETEL 0000385QETEL 0000386 QETEL 0000505 YAHOO 0292794

Will Use

79 80 81

Will Use Will Use Will Use

106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 702, 802, 901, MIL 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802, 901 106, 402-403, 802, 901 106, 402-403, 802, 901

06/10/03

06/13/03

08/02/10

04/27/10 09/22/10 05/01/08

82 83

MWEMSFT 0000021 Will Use MWEORCL 0000012 Will Use

11/23/10 11/23/10

84

DEF 00008004-REV- Will Use DEF 00008015.001REV MATCH 0005776MATCH 0005798 MATCH 0005799MATCH 0005830 MATCH 0005495MATCH 0005535 MATCH 0005536MATCH 0005568 MATCH 0005642MATCH 0005718 Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use 402, SD 402, SD 402, SD 402, SD 402, SD

10/21/91

85 86 87 88 89

IAC - ACE USA Miscellaneous Errors and Omissions Policy IAC - ACE USA Miscellaneous Errors and Omissions Policy IAC - ACE USA Miscellaneous Errors and Omissions Policy IAC - ACE USA Miscellaneous Professional Liability Policy IAC - FM Global Insurance Policy

10/01/04- 10/01/05 10/01/05- 10/01/06 11/20/07 10/01/06- 10/01/07 2009-2010

7

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 90 IAC - FM Global Insurance Policy 91

DATE CAT Will Use Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402, SD 402-403, 802, 901 ADM 06/30/10-6/30/11 06/21/10 WITNESS

BATES NO. MATCH 0005831 MATCH 0005907 Letter from D .Tulanon (FINPRO) to N. AMZ 0013200Wollebek (Amazon.com) re: Primary AMZ 0013235 Cyber Insurance (Errors & Omissions) Letter from D. Williams to C. Van Wyk re: Consulting Agreement Letter from D. Williams to S. Ostermann re: Consulting Agreement with KST Letter from QE and MWE to McDonald re: Consulting Agreement Linux Source Code KTS 0000307KTS 0000308 KTS 0000491KTS 0000492

92 93

Will Use Will Use

402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 802, 901, late production, NI MIL, 402-403 MIL, 402-403 MIL, 402-403 MIL, 402-403 MIL, 402-403 MIL, 402-403 402-403, 802, 901, late production 802, 901 802, 901, late production, NI

09/02/10 01/03/11

94

GGL-BED 0048238- Will Use GGL-BED 0048239 BTEX 0752555 BTEX 0759489 Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use

12/18/10

95 96 97 98 99 100 101 102

103 104 105

106 107

108

109

M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix H M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix N M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix O M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix P M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix Q M. Jones Expert Report, Appendix R Merriam -Webster Dictionary Definition BTEX 0761981of Obsolete, www.MerriamBTEX 0761982 webster.com Microsoft Computer Dictionary Fourth Edition NRL Source Code BTEX 0752555 BTEX 0759489 Paper, "Gcache: A Generalized DEF 00007719- DEF Caching Mechanism ," D. Corner & S. 00007734 Ostermann Paper, "Abstract ," for New Hash BTEX 0750960 BTEX 0750975 Function BTEX 0118871Paper, "Denial of Service via BTEX 0118886 Algorithmic Complexity Attacks ," S. Crosby and D. Wallach, Dept. of Computer Science, Rice University Paper, "Leveraging Cloud Security to MYSPACE-BED Weather Threatening Storms: How to 000386MYSPACE-BED Defend Your Perimeter from Today's 000397 Outsized Threats ," Akamai Technologies, Inc. BTEX 0752263Paper, "The Datacenter as a BTEX 0752282 Computer, An Introduction to the Design of Warehouse-Scale Machines ," L. Barroso and U. Holzle, Synthesis Lectures on Computer Architecture

02/11/11

Will Use Will Use Will Use

00/00/99

03/00/92

Will Use Will Use

802, 901 402-403, 802, 901

Will Use

402, 802, 901, MIL

2009

Will Use

402, 802, 901, late production

2009

8

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 110 Paper, "The Impact of Network Downtime on Business Today ," M. Haider, Networks First Market Insight Paper, Warwick Business School 111 Paper, "Traffic Impact of the 100 ms Delay Experiment ," J. Brutlag Paper, "Understanding the Threat of Denial-of- Service Attacks in Society Today ," R. Chen, T. Giedgowd, and L. Greaves Patent License and Settlement Agreement between Bedrock and Conagra (fully executed) Patent License and Settlement Agreement between Bedrock CME (fully executed) PowerPoint Presentation, Denial of Service via Algorithmic Complexity Attacks ," S. Crosby and D. Wallach, Dept. of Computer Science, Rice University Press Release, The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences R. Nemes CV

DATE BATES NO. BTEX 0748731BTEX 0748750 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402-403, 802, 901 ADM 05/00/07 WITNESS

GGL-BED 0049253- Will Use GGL-BED 0049272 BTEX 0748700BTEX 0748730 Will Use

802

04/27/07

112

402-403, 802, 901, MIL

12/01/02

113

BTEX 0752522BTEX 0752536 BTEX 0761879BTEX 0761904 BTEX 0119500BTEX 0119538

Will Use

114

Will Use

115

Will Use

MIL, 802, 901, 402-403, 408, late production MIL, 802, 901, 402-403, 408, late production 402, 802, 901

02/19/11

01/15/10

116 117 118

Will Use Will Use Will Use

402-403, 802, 901

10/11/94

119

120

121 122

123

124 125

BTEX 0745769BTEX 0745772 Settlement and License Agreement BTEX 0749125between Bedrock and Nationwide (fully BTEX 0749152 executed) Settlement and License Agreement BTEX 0761905between Bedrock and PayPal (fully BTEX 0761936 executed) BTEX 0761937Settlement and License Agreement between Bedrock and R.L. Polk (fully BTEX 0761947 executed) BTEX 0749060Settlement and License Agreement BTEX 0749086 between Bedrock and Sungard Symposium Brochure, "12th Usenix BTEX 0119616BTEX 0119623 Security Symposium , " Washington, D.C. Symposium Brochure, "14th Annual CSI Computer Crime and Security Survey, Comprehensive Edition ," Computer Security Institute Exhibit Number Intentionally Left Blank Exhibit Number Intentionally Left Blank

MIL, 402-403, 802, 901 MIL, 402-403, 802, 901, late production MIL, 402-403, 802, 901, late production MIL, 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901, MIL

12/22/10

Will Use

04/30/10

Will Use

02/15/11

Will Use Will Use

12/21/10 08/04/03-08/08/03

Will Use

12/00/09

9

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION BATES NO. No. 126 Exhibit Number Intentionally Left Blank 127 128 Exhibit Number Intentionally Left Blank Web Blog, " [PATCH] Net: Implement Emergency Route Cache Rebuilds When gc_Elasticity is Exceeded ," Linux Networking Webpage, "Welcome to Google ," web.archives.org Webpage, "Yahoo! ," web.archive.org Webpage, Microsoft Server Pricing Webpage, Accessed on 01/25/11 (http://www.microsoft.com/windowsser ver2008/ en/us/pricing.aspx) Yahoo! - ACE USA Excess Liability Insurance Policy Amended and Restated Interactive Marketing Agreement between AOL Inc. and Google Inc., with Amendments Article (Internet), "Google Doodle Celebrates Thomas Edison's Birthday ," E. Banks, USA Today.com Article (Internet), "Interview with Google's Sergey Brin ," F. Correa, Linuxgazette.net Article (Internet), "KS 2009: How Google Uses Linux ," J. Corbet Article (Internet), "Look Beyond Google's Plan to Become Carbon Neutral ," S. Mingay, Gartner Research (http://www.gartner.com/resources/149 800/1498 34/look beyond googles plan to 149834.pdf) BTEX 0749012BTEX 0749020

DATE CAT MRKS OFF OBJ ADM WITNESS

Will Use

402-403, 802, 901, MIL

12/09/10

129 130 131

BTEX 0749049 BTEX 0749107

Will Use Will Use Will Use

802, 901 402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901

12/14/10 12/14/10 01/25/11

132 133

134

YAHOO 0510808Will Use YAHOO 0510819 AOL-BED-GOOGLE Will Use 001 AOL-BED-GOOGLE 398 BTEX 0759490Will Use BTEX 0759491

402-403, 802, 901 402-403, 802, 901

11/12/09 10/01/03

402-403, 802, 901, late production 802

02/11/11

135

GGL-BED 0040112- Will Use GGL-BED 0040115 GGL-BED 0034737- Will Use GGL-BED 0034748 Will Use

06/23/10

136

802

10/21/09

137

402-403, 802, 901

06/26/07

138

139

Article, "Web Search for a Planet: The GGL-BED 0030618- Will Use GGL-BED 0030624 Google Cluster Architecture ," L. Barraso, et al. , IEEE Computer Society Email from Argent to GGL-BED 0032817 Will Use [e-mail] re: [Issue 165961] p_dst_Cache Filling Up Otherwise Free' Nodes?

802

04/00/03

802, 104a, 106, 702, MIL

05/12/09

10

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 140 Email from Chavey to [e-mail] re: [Issue 1659359] "Detected TX Unit Hang" and Serving Hiccups on Clovertown 141 Email from Chavey to [e-mail] re: [Issue 165961] p_dst_Cache Filling Up Otherwise Free' Nodes? 142 Email from Norman to [e-mail] [PATCH] net: implement emergency route cache rebulds whengc elasticity is exceeded. 143

DATE BATES NO. CAT GGL-BED 0032119- Will Use GGL-BED 0032121 MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 802 ADM 02/25/09 WITNESS

GGL-BED 0032223- Will Use GGL-BED 0032224

106, 802

06/04/09

GGL-BED 0008781- Will Use GGL-BED 0008782

106, 802

06/04/09

144

145

146

147

148

149

GGL-BED 0048219Email from Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [Issue GGL-BED 0048220 2735235] Bind9 / udp Performance degradation on 300 Series Email from Chavey to GGL-BED 0047935 [e-mail], et al. re: [net/dev] Change LCFbb1064: (kernel/review//2.6.34) netip_dst_cache: Revert Hard c_Elasticity Implementation GGL-BED 0034912Email from [e-mail] to buganizerGGL-BED 0034913 [e-mail], et al. re: [gnetdev] [Issue 1659539] "Detected TX Unit Hang" and Serving Hiccups on Clovertown GGL-BED 0032193Email from [e-mail] to buganizerGGL-BED 0032194 [e-mail], et al. re: [gnetdev] re: [kernel-resourcemanagement] [issue 1659161] ip_dst_cache filling up otherwise 'Free' Nodes? Email from [e-mail] to L. GGL-BED 0047937 Chavey, et al. re: [gnetdev] [net/dev] Change LCFbb1064: (kernel/review//2.6.34) netip_dst_cache: Revert Hard c_Elasticity Implementation GGL-BED 0006642Email from [e-mail] to GGL-BED 0006643 [e-mail] re: [Kernel Reviewers] A Code Review Email from [e-mail] GGL-BED 0047959to [e-mail], et al. re: Kernel- GGL-BED 0047960 Team

Will Use

106, 802

06/02/10

Will Use

106, 402-403, 802

11/08/10

Will Use

106, 802

02/23/09

Will Use

106, 802

03/02/09

Will Use

106, 802

11/09/10

Will Use

106, 802

06/17/09

Will Use

106, 402-403, 802

06/23/09

11

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION BATES NO. No. 150 Email from [e-mail] GGL-BED 0032575 to [e-mail], et al. re: [kernelteam] [issue 1787987] IP Routing Cache (and Other Bugbears?) Over Running 'Sys' Container on Edge Machines 151 Email from L. Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2554333] i Set/proc/sys/net/ipv4/route/refcnt_relea se to 0 in prod Email from L. Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2554333] i Set/proc/sys/net/ipv4/route/refcnt_relea se to 0 in prod Email from L. Chavey to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 1659161] ip_dst Cache Filling Otherwise 'Free' Nodes? Email from L. Chavey to M. Zenczykowski, et al. re: Kernel 320 for Maglev Email from L. Chavey to M. Zenczykowski, et al. re: Kernel 320 for Maglev Email from L. Colliti to [e-mail] re: 4107319-p3 Email from Lucas. to [e-mail], et al. re: [Issue 1659539] "Detected TX Unit Hang" and Serving Hiccups on Clovertown Email from msb to [e-mail], et al. re: [Issue 1659539] "Detected TX Unit Hang" and Serving Hiccups on Clovertown Email from jtr to [e-mail], et al. re: [issue 2237517] rollout 300 Kernels to GFE Pools Email from netdev-owner to J. Poplawski, et al. re: [PATCH] Fill Null Pointer + Success Return in Route Lookup Patch Google Inc. Purported Source Code

DATE CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 802 ADM 04/13/09 WITNESS

GGL-BED 0048184- Will Use GGL-BED 0048185

106, 802

03/29/10

152

GGL-BED 0048186- Will Use GGL-BED 0048187

106, 802

03/29/10

153

GGL-BED 0032886

Will Use

106, 802

05/19/09

154

GGL-BED 0041788

Will Use

106, 802

03/29/10

155

GGL-BED 0041788

Will Use

106, 802

03/29/10

156 157

GGL-BED 0027509 GGL-BED 0031953

Will Use Will Use

106, 403, 802 106, 802

08/24/09 02/19/09

158

GGL-BED 0032036

Will Use

106, 802

02/23/09

159

GGL-BED 0040330

Will Use

106, 802

12/04/09

160

GGL-BED 0006727- Will Use GGL-BED 0006728

106, 402-403, 701, 802, MIL

06/22/09

161

GGL-BED 0040159 - Will Use GGL-BED 0040160 GGL-BED 0040167- Will Use GGL-BED 0040169

106, 802

02/23/09

162

Google Inc. Purported Source Code

106, 802

02/23/09

12

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 163 Google Inc. Purported Source Code

DATE BATES NO. CAT GGL-BED 0040170- Will Use GGL-BED 0040172 GGL-BED 0027509 GGL-BED 0027603 Will Use Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 802 ADM 02/24/09 WITNESS

164 165 166

Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code

106, 403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 403, 802

02/28/09 03/02/09 03/02/09

GGL-BED 0027604- Will Use GGL-BED 0027605 GGL-BED 0027582 GGL-BED 0027583 GGL-BED 0027543 GGL-BED 0027548 GGL-BED 0027550 GGL-BED 0027553 Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use

167 168 169 170 171 172 173

Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code Google Inc. Purported Source Code

GGL-BED 0027575- Will Use GGL-BED 0027576 Will Use GGL-BED 0039005- Will Use GGL-BED 0039095 GGL-BED 0038752- Will Use GGL-BED 0038872 GGL-BED 0038873- Will Use GGL-BED 0039004 GGL-BED 0038624- Will Use GGL-BED 0038751 GGL-BED 0038370- Will Use GGL-BED 0038493 GGL-BED 0038494- Will Use GGL-BED 0038623 Will Use GGL-BED 0040177 - Will Use GGL-BED 0040206

106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 106, 402-403, 802 802 402-403, MIL

05/19/09 05/20/09 06/25/09 06/26/09 06/26/09 06/29/09 08/06/09

174 175

Google Product P&Ls Google, Inc. Form 10-K - 2009

12/31/09

176

Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2004 Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2005 Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2006 Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2007 Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2008 Google, Inc. Form 10-K and Annual Report - 2010 Google, Inc. Source Code

402-403, MIL

12/31/04

177

402-403, MIL

12/31/05

178

402-403, MIL

12/31/06

179

402-403, MIL

12/31/07

180

402-403, MIL

12/31/08

181 182

402-403, MIL 802

12/31/10

13

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 183 Google, Inc. Source Code 184 Google, Inc. Source Code

DATE BATES NO. GGL-BEDSC 0000060 GGL-BEDSC 0000811 - GGLBEDSC 0000881 GGL-BEDSC 0001325- GGLBEDSC 0001391 GGL-BEDSC 0012070 - GGLBEDSC 0012143 GGL-BEDSC 0012093 GGL-BED 0049058GGL-BED 0049065 CAT Will Use Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 802,NI 802,NI ADM WITNESS

185

Google, Inc. Source Code

Will Use

802,NI

186

Google, Inc. Source Code

Will Use

802,NI

187 188

Google, Inc. Source Code Google.com Availability Report - Q1 2010 Meeting Notes, "Notes from eBay Red Team Event: DDoS Roundtable ," D. Menscher Paper, "DOS Filter Manual ," D. Perkovik PowerPoint Presentation, "Open Source at Google ," Google PowerPoint Presentation, "Project Zappa and Quantitative Latency ," K. Bhandankar, et al., Webpage, "Google CommunicationsWelcome - Key Messages ," (www.google.com/green)

Will Use Will Use

802,NI 802 03/31/10

189

GGL-BED 0048765- Will Use GGL-BED 0048774 GGL-BED 0037585- Will Use GGL-BED 0037590 GGL-BED 0033440- Will Use GGL-BED 0033464 GGL-BED 0049202- Will Use GGL-BED 0049236 GGL-BED 0033064- Will Use GGL-BED 0033065

402, 802

190

802

03/31/03

191

802

192

802

03/10/10

193

402, 802

03/08/10

194

195

196

197

GGL-BED 0049337Webpage, "Google Corporate GGL-BED 0049359 Information, Google History ," www.google.com Webpage, "Google Corporate GGL-BED 0049384Information, Google User Experience ," GGL-BED 0049387 Google Website, www.google.com/intl/en/corporate/ux.h tml GGL-BED 0049375Webpage, "Google Corporate GGL-BED 0049378 Information, Our Philosophy - 10 Things We Know to be True ," Google Website, www.google.intl/en/corporate/tenthings. html Webpage, Google Offices Map and List BTEX 0761948BTEX 0761951

Will Use

802

12/30/10

Will Use

802

12/30/10

Will Use

802

12/30/10

Will Use

802, 901, late production

03/07/11

14

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 198 Webpage, Google Page with Edison Information 199 Webpage, Google Search Engine Page with ' .Edison Picture Yahoo! Finance, Historical Prices for Google, Inc. Google - Various Source Code for Genid Google - Various Source Code for Cand Email from J. LaVacca to J. Cowlishaw, et al. re: DDoS Relief Options to Investigate and Discuss Email from LaVacca to J. Cowlishaw and Mitchell re: DDOS and Network/Security Events 11/30/07 IAC - AON Insurance Policy IAC - FM Global Insurance Policy Match.com Excel Spreadsheet re: Email Summary Match.com Excel Spreadsheet re: Email Summary - Revenue and Email Share Match.com Financial Summary Chart Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2004 Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2005 Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2006 Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2007 Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2008 Match.com/IAC/Interactive Corp. Form 10-K - 2009 Paper, " Global Operations DDOS Attack Summary, Document Version 1.0 ," Match.com Paper, "Match.com Network Attack Mitigation Plan ," LaVacca, Rodriguez, and Revor Paper, "Match.com DDoS Network Defense Project ," Cowlishaw and Mitchell

DATE BATES NO. BTEX 0759493 BTEX 0759495 BTEX 0759492 CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402-403, 802, 901, late production 402-403, 802, 901, late production 402-403, 802, 901 802,NI 802,NI 106, 802, 901, SD 106, 802, 901, SD 402, SD 402, SD 402, SD 402, 802, SD 09/04/08 ADM 02/11/11 WITNESS

Will Use

02/11/11

200 201 202 203

Will Use Will Use Will Use MATCH 0005358MATCH 0005360 MATCH 0005325 Will Use

01/29/10

204

Will Use

11/30/07

205 206 207 208

MATCH 0005719MATCH 0005775 MATCH 0005569MATCH 0005641 MATCH 0010031 MATCH 0010000

Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use

2009-2010 2008-2009 05/00/10-10/00/09 11/00/09-11/00/10

209 210 211 212 213 214 215 216

MATCH 0005284 MATCH 0002350MATCH 0002568 MATCH 0002774MATCH 0002985 MATCH 0002569MATCH 0002773 MATCH 0002986MATCH 0003173 MATCH 0003174MATCH 0003420 MATCH 0003421MATCH 0003566 MATCH 0005302MATCH 0005314 MATCH 0007561MATCH 0005783 MATCH 0005285MATCH 0005293

Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use

402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, MIL, SD 402-403, 802, SD 402-403, 802, SD

2003-2009 12/31/04 12/31/06 12/31/05 12/31/07 12/31/08 12/31/09 06/06/07

217

Will Use

07/06/07

218

Will Use

11/15/07

15

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION BATES NO. No. 219 PowerPoint Presentation - Match.com, MATCH 0006929"Global Security: Now & 2008 " MATCH 0006941 220 PRTG Traffic Grapher - Monitoring Results, with Average and Peak Traffic for Match.com Servers Software House International Inc Invoice No. 6AA07 to Match.com, for Server Costs Match.com - Various Source Code for Genid Match.com - Various Source Code for Cand Declaration of Damian Menscher Discovery - Google Inc.'s Supplemental Responses and Objections to Bedrock's Interrogatories (Nos. 1-10) Discovery - Match.com's Supplemental Responses and Objections to Bedrock's Interrogatories (Nos. 1-9) Google Modified 2.6.18 Source Code Google Modified 2.6.26 Source Code Google Modified 2.6.34 Source Code Webpage, "Google Corporate Information, Search, Ads, Apps, Mobile and Android, Google Chrome, and More...," www.google.com PowerPoint Presentation, "BCS EqualiTEC Career Workshops," Z. Bhorat Email from [e-mail] to J. Poplawski, et al. re: Weird Problem MATCH 0010076MATCH 0010082 MATCH 0005251MATCH 0005259

DATE CAT Will Use MRKS OFF OBJ 402-403, SD ADM WITNESS

Will Use

402-403, 802, SD 402-403, 802, SD NI, SD NI, SD 402, 802

01/07/11

221

Will Use

06/17/08

222 223 224 225

Will Use Will Use Will Use Will Use

01/28/11 01/12/11

226

Will Use

402, 802, SD

01/12/11

227 228 229 230

Will Use Will Use Will Use GGL-BED 0049315- Will Use GGL-BED 0049320

NI NI NI 802 12/30/2010

231

GGL-BED 0034101- Will Use GGL-BED 0034135

802

5/4/2006

232

GGL-BED 0006904- Will Use GGL-BED 0006906

402, 403, 106, MIL, 802

7/9/2009

233

GGL-BED 0048135- Will Use Email from N. Rao to GGL-BED 0048137 [e-mail], et al. re: A Jupiterian Code Review; 4115078p3 move 3 Patch (es) to Effort `net-lp_dst_cach

802, 106

1/6/2010

16

PLTF Exh DESCRIPTION No. 234 Email from Chavey to [e-mail] , et al. re: [Issue 1751985] GFE2s Crashing in FX 235 Email from [e-mail] to D. Miller, et al re: cat/proc/net/tcp Takes 0.5 Seconds on x86 64

DATE BATES NO. CAT GGL-BED 0032443- Will Use GGL-BED 0032444 MRKS OFF OBJ 106, 402, 802 ADM 4/1/2009 WITNESS

GGL-BED 0029916

Will Use

106, 402, 403, 802, MIL

8/27/2008

17