O'Bannon, Jr. v. National Collegiate Athletic Association et al

Filing 197

NOTICE by Edward C. O'Bannon, Jr. Antitrust Plaintiffs' Evidentiary Bench Memorandum (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D)(Bojedla, Swathi) (Filed on 6/8/2014)

Exhibit A

Plaintiffs’ Exhibits with No NCAA Objections

Trial Exhibit
No.
248

250
252
255
269
270

Description
NCAAPROD00190486- NCAAPROD00190488 - 07/16/06 Draft Minutes of the
Student Athlete Likeness Meeting
NCAAPROD00199495- NCAAPROD00199496 - 09/27/06 Email from Rachel
Newman to David Knopp
NCAAPROD00206598- NCAAPROD00206601 - 03/23/07 Email from David
Knopp to Chris Plonsky & Kevin Lennon
NCAAPROD00072570-NCAAPROD00072581 - 09/25/06 Email from David
Knopp to Frank Rhodes
NCAAPROD00185745- NCAAPROD00185746 - 08/29/08 Email from David Berst
to Myles Brand
NCAAPROD00182953 - 09/04/08 Email from Myles Brand to David Berst

275

NCAAPROD00247417- NCAAPROD00247418 - 11/21/07 Email chain among
David Knopp, Kevin Lennon, Greg Shaheen, Wendy Walters, Leeland Zeller, Scott
Bearby, David Berst and Jim Haynes

278

NCAAPROD00246939-41 - 7/28/08 Email chain among Greg Shaheen, David
Berst, Myles Brand, Wally Renfro, Beth Debauche, Bob Williams, Scott Bearby,
David Knopp, Greg Weitekamp, Bernard Franklin, Kevin Lennon

298

NCAAPROD00205096 - 5/24/09 Email from Greg Shaheen to David Knopp

1

400

NCAAPROD00292647- NCAAPROD00292734 - 04/22/10 "Multi-Media
Agreement between Turner Broadcasting System, Inc., CBS Broadcasting Inc., and
the National Collegiate Athletic Association" (cover letter dated June 4, 2010).

420

NCAAPROD00245955-56 - 01/07/05 Supplement No. 1 "Discussion Document Review of Endorsement and Promotional Activities Involving the Likeness of
Student-Athletes"

421

NCAAPROD00120233-NCAAPROD00120237 - 12/03/07 Email from Myles Brand
to Carol Roland
NCAAPROD00148806- NCAAPROD00148810 - 10/17/10 Email from Wally
Renfro to Mark Emmert, forwarded to Diane Young by Mark Emmert

424

425

NCAAPROD00236835- NCAAPROD00236845 - 04/07/11 Email from Nicole
Branken to Jim Isch, Wally Renfro, David Berst, Todd Petr, Lorry Weaver, and
Monica Richardson, attaching 04/05/11 2011 Presidential Survey Retreat Results

429

NCAAPROD00237827- NCAAPROD00237832 - 12/06/08 Report of the NCAA
Division I Task Force on Commercial Activity in Intercollegiate Athletics - Meeting
Report from its October 6, 2008 meeting

835

NCAAPROD00103570- NCAAPROD00103572 - 07/14/06 Email from Myles
Brand to Kevin Lennon, David Berst, Bernard Franklin, and Greg Shaheen

887

NCAAPROD00168121- NCAAPROD00168125 - 08/07/11 Email from Jeffrey
Hathaway to Mark Emmert [initial email from Dutch Baughman and Other retreat
attendees: Bob Bowlsby, Tom Jernstedt, Scott Kretchmar, Jon Lecrone, Craig
Littlepage, Jeff Orleans, Amy Perko, Todd Turner and Wright Waters]

2

2005

NCAAPROD00531044- NCAAPROD00531053 - 01/27/05 Agenda for
Promotions/Endorsements Discussion Group, attaching Supplement No. 1
"Discussion Document - Review of Endorsement and Promotional Activities
Involving the Likeness of Student-Athletes" and Supplement No. 2 "Proposed
Recommendations from the Membership Services/Corporate Broadcast Alliance
Task Force"

2008

NCAAPROD00386754-NCAAPROD00386755 - 5/03/05 Email from Bo Kerin to
Scott Bearby, Dennis Cryder, Ellen Ferris, David Knopp, Kevin Lennon, Wally
Renfro, Bill Saum, Greg Shaheen and Wendy Walters

2009

NCAAPROD00181044-NCAAPROD00181046 - 5/04/05 Email from Bo Kerin to
Scott Bearby, Dennis Cryder, Ellen Ferris, David Knopp, Kevin Lennon, Wally
Renfro, Bill Saum, Greg Shaheen and Wendy Walters

2011

NCAAPROD00207992-NCAAPROD00208033 - 01/04/06 Email from Greg
Shaheen to Scott Bearby, David Knopp, Peter Davis, and Greg Weitekamp,
attaching State of the Association Speech

2016

NCAAPROD00121273- NCAAPROD00121281 - 05/15/06 Abe Frank Letter to
Congress
NCAAPROD00236390-NCAAPROD00236455 - 01/28/08 Email from Marilyn
Segarra to Wally Renfro and Unknown ([e-mail]), attaching 10/2006
October 2006 Report issued by the Presidential Task Force on the Future of Division
I Intercollegiate Athletics entitled The Second-Century Imperatives, Presidential
Leadership - Institutional Accountability

2017

2018

NCAAPROD00225690- NCAAPROD00225694 - 10/05/06 Timeline of Agent and
Amateurism Subcommittee's Promotional Activities Discussions (February 2004June 2006)

3

2019

01/07 Presentation of GOALS and SCORE Studies to 2007 NCAA Convention
http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/StudentAthlete%20Perspectives%20on%20Their%20College%20Experience.pdf

2020

NCAAPROD00019684- NCAAPROD00019687 - 01/11/07 NCAA Study Group on
Use of SA NIL, Summary of Invited Guest Comments
NCAAPROD00303507-NCAAPROD00303548 - 11/06/07 "NCAA's Bundled
Rights and the Marketplace" Presentation to the DI MBB Committee

2024

2027
2030

NCAAPROD00448033-NCAAPROD00448034 - 01/02/08 Email from Kevin
Lennon to Leeland Zeller and David Knopp
NCAAPROD00122212- NCAAPROD00122213 - 01/05/08 Email Chain among
David Berst, Myles Brand, and Greg Shaheen

2032

NCAAPROD00353009- NCAAPROD00353012 - 01/17/08 Email chain among
Leeland Zeller, Jim Haynes, Wendy Walters, Brad Hostetter, Bo Kerin, Scott
Bearby and Steve Mallonee

2033

NCAAPROD00084885-NCAAPROD00084924 - 02/21/08 Email from Vicki
McEachran to David Berst, with CAIA attachments
NCAAPROD00247582- NCAAPROD00247585 - 07/28/08 Email Chain among
Greg Shaheen, Myles Brand, David Berst, Wally Renfro, Beth Debauche, Bob
Williams, Scott Bearby, David Knopp, Greg Weitekamp, Bernard Franklin, Kevin
Lennon

2037

2038
2039

NCAAPROD00225241- NCAAPROD00225243 - 08/26/08 Memo from Myles
Brand to university presidents
NCAAPROD00119784-NCAAPROD00119785 - 09/04/08 Email from David Berst
to Myles Brand, Kevin Lennon, Greg Shaheen, David Knopp, Bernard Franklin and
Wally Renfro, attaching Principles Related to Commercial Activities in
Intercollegiate Athletics

4

2041

NCAAPROD00120185- NCAAPROD00120186 - 09/08/08 Email Chain among
David Berst, David Knopp, Wally Renfro, Myles Brand, Kevin Lennon, Greg
Shaheen, Bernard Franklin

2042

NCAAPROD00234445-NCAAPROD00234446 - 09/30/08 Email from David Berst
to Myles Brand, Kevin Lennon, Wally Renfro and Greg Shaheen

2044

NCAAPROD00121267 - 10/02/08 Email among David Berst, Kevin Lennon and
Myles Brand
NCAAPROD00104068-NCAAPROD00104082 - 01/12/09 Email from David Berst
to Tom Douple, John Swofford, Karl Benson, Jamie Zaninovich, Wright Waters,
Tom Burnett, Carolyn Schlie Fernovich, Tom Hansen, Jon Steinbrecher, John
Iamarino, Craig Thompson, Doug Elgin, Dennis Thomas, Rich Chryst, Richard
Ensor, Jeff Orleans, Jon LeCone, Thomas Yeager, Dennis Farrell, James Delany,
Kyle Kallander, Doug Fullerton, Mike Tranghese, Ted Gumbart, Bernadette
McGlade, Patty Viverito, Britton Banowsky, Mike Slive, Beth Debauche, Greg
Sankey, Greg Shaheen and Unknown ([e-mail], [e-mail]),
attaching Final Report of the NCAA Task Force on Commercial Activity in Division
I Intercollegiate Athletics

2047

2048

NCAAPROD00104886-NCAAPROD00104900 - 01/12/09 Email from Greg
Shaheen to Brenda Butz, attaching Final Report of the NCAA Task Force on
Commercial Activity in Division I Intercollegiate Athletics

2056

NCAAPROD00206075- NCAAPROD00206077 - 05/11/09 Email from Beth
Debauche to David Knopp [earlier emails include: Scott Bearby, David Knopp,
David Berst]
NCAAPROD00303845-NCAAPROD00303867 - 06/04/09 Email from Greg
Shaheen to Jamie Zaninovich attaching The NCAA, Bundled Rights, Basketball &
More presentation slides

2057

2065

NCAAPROD00334266-NCAAPROD00334277 - 05/14/10 Email from Wally
Renfro to Lydia Sanchez and Diane Young, attaching Presidential Briefing
Documents
5

2066

Protecting the Collegiate Model
Originally from:
http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/newmedia/2010/Emmert/Part5/protecting.html

2067

Amateurism
Originally from:
http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/newmedia/2010/Emmert/Part5/amateurism.html

2068

Commercialism
Originally from:
http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/newmedia/2010/Emmert/Part5/commercialism.html

2070
2071

NCAAPROD00216748- NCAAPROD00216749 - 06/26/10 Email from Greg
Weitekamp to David Knopp, Lenny Daniels and Matthew Hong
NCAAPROD00237222-NCAAPROD00237228 - 07/06/10 Email from Lorry
Weaver to Wally Renfro and Diane Young, attaching Report to Administrative
Committee

2073

NCAAPROD00215616-NCAAPROD00215624 - 08/03/10 Email from Lorry
Weaver to Jim Isch and Bob Fiala re FY 2010 Report (attaching memo to
Compensation Committee re Fiscal Year 2010 Report)

2074

NCAAPROD00220893- NCAAPROD00220904 - 10/11/10 Email from Lorry
Weaver (on behalf of Jim Isch) to self, attaching NCAA Strategic Communication
Plan October 1, 2010

2075

NCAAPROD00184677 - 12/13/10 Email from David Berst to FBS Commissioners

6

2077

01/13/11 Summary of findings from 2010 GOALS and SCORE Studies of SA
Experience (to be presented at NCAA Convention 01/13/11)
http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/%E2%80%A2Summary%20of%20F
indings%20from%20the%202010%20GOALS%20and%20SCORE%20Stu
dies%20of%20the%20Student-Athlete%20Experience.pdf

2078

2010 GOALS study presentation, pulled from the NCAA's website at:
http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/DI_GOALS_FARA_final_1.pdf.

2081

NCAAPROD00623735- NCAAPROD00623741 - 08/24/11 Agenda: Collegiate
Model, Rules Subcommittee

2083

NCAAPROD0722868-NCAAPROD0722873 - 09/30/11 Email from Dave Schnase
to Wally Renfro, Judy Baker and Lynn Dickey re Competitive Equity, attaching
Competitive Equity Within Intercollegiate Athletics

2084

NCAAPROD0714894-NCAAPROD0714976 - 10/11/11 Meeting acceptance for
Lynn Dickey, David Berst, Jackie Campbell, Lynn Holzman, Brad Hostetter, LuAnn
Humphrey, Jim Isch, Kevin Lennon, Steve Mallonee, Donald Remy, Wally Renfro,
Dave Schnase and Emily Wollet, attaching agenda

2085

NCAAPROD0737653-NCAAPROD0737657 - 11/29/11 Email from Dave Schnase
to Kevin Lennon, David Berst, Jackie Campbell, Diane Dickman, Jon Duncan, Lynn
Holzman, Brad Hostetter, LuAnn Humphrey, Jim Isch, Steve Mallonee, Bill Regan,
Donald Remy, Wally Renfro, Geoff Silver and Emily Wollet re NCAA Working
Group on Collegiate Model-Rules, attaching Supplement No. 6a - Competitive
Equity Within Intercollegiate Athletics

7

2086

NCAAPROD00624079-NCAAPROD00624210 - 12/13/11 Annotated Agenda for
Meeting of NCAA Working Group on Collegiate Model - Rules (with attachments)

2088

NCAAPROD00140586- NCAAPROD00140625 - 02/26/12 Division I Agenda
(PowerPoint)
NCAAPROD00631223- NCAAPROD00631264 - 09/26/13 Agenda for Division I
Amateurism Cabinet Teleconference - "Use of Likeness - Promotional Activities
related to Student- Athlete Employment, Draft Legislative Concepts" , with
supplemental documents

2093

2097
2100

2104
2288

03/12/14 Enhanced List of Policies Subject to Group of Five Autonomous DecisionMaking
NCAAPROD00246939-42 - 7/28/08 Email chain among Greg Shaheen, David
Berst, Myles Brand, Wally Renfro, Beth Debauche, Bob Williams, Scott Bearby,
David Knopp, Greg Weitekamp, Bernard Franklin, Kevin Lennon]

NCAAPROD00296082- NCAAPROD00296139 - 12/06/94 "National Collegiate
Basketball Championship Agreement"
01/12/03 NCAA State of the Association address by Myles Brand

2289

01/08/05 NCAA State of the Association by Myles Brand: "The Myths of College
Sports: Debunking the Four Great Commonly Held Misperceptions About
Intercollegiate Athletics"

2290
2291

NCAAPROD00019599 - 01/07/06 2006 State of the Association by Myles Brand,
excerpted
01/12/08 2008 State of the Association by Myles Brand

2294

01/15/09 State of the Association by Wally Renfro

8

2295
2296
2340
2401

NCAAPROD00233314 - 12/04/09 Email from Diane Young to Wally Renfro,
forwarding 01/05/09 "Challenges of Commercial Activity" speech
01/15/10 2010 State of the Association by Jim Isch
2013-2014 NCAA 2014 Division I Manual
EA0132819 - 05/16/07 Microsoft Excel spreadsheet

2403

EA0135544 - 05/16/07 Microsoft Excel spreadsheet

2484

NCAAPROD00206598-NCAAPROD00206618 - 03/23/07 Email from David
Knopp to Chris Plonsky and Kevin Lennon
01/13/11 2011 State of the Association Speech

2485

9