O'Bannon, Jr. v. National Collegiate Athletic Association et al

Filing 197

NOTICE by Edward C. O'Bannon, Jr. Antitrust Plaintiffs' Evidentiary Bench Memorandum (Attachments: #1 Exhibit A, #2 Exhibit B, #3 Exhibit C, #4 Exhibit D)(Bojedla, Swathi) (Filed on 6/8/2014)

Exhibit B

Plaintiffs’ Exhibits with 402/403 Objections Only

Trial
Description
Exhibit
No.
283
NCAAPROD00181574- NCAAPROD00181575 - 09/03/10 Email from
David Berst to Jim Isch and Lorry Weaver [responding to email from Isch to
Berst, Greg Shaheen, Scott Bearby, Wally Renfro, Joni Comstock, Bernard
Franklin, Keith Martin, Mike Racy, Dan Dutcher, Bob Williams and Kevin
Lennon]
305

Objection

403

NCAAPROD00221251- NCAAPROD00221252 - 07/14/03 Email from Heidi
Clarke to Peter Davis
EA0031106-EA0031108 - 11/07/07 Email from David Kirkpatrick to Jeremy
Strauser
12/18/12 Joel Linzner Deposition Exhibit - List of Electronic Arts' NCAA
Videogames

402; 403

758

EA0031706-EA0031708 - 01/14/08 Email from Sean O'Brien to Joel Linzner,
Jordan Edelstein, Tyler Vaught, Jeremy Strauser, Kendall Boyd, Tom
Goedde, David Tinson, Brent Nielsen

402; 403

776

EA0021434-EA0021435 - 11/01/10 Email from Joel Linzner to Tom Goedde
and Todd Sitrin
EA0195461-EA0195462 - 11/05/10 Email from Joel Linzner to Todd Sitrin

402; 403

EA0014243-EA0014244 - 05/01/06 Email from Tom Renedo to Joel Linzner
and Paul Cairns
EA0017763-EA0017764 - 08/03/06 Email chain between Pat Battle and Joel
Linzner

402; 403

702
756

777
784
785

1

402; 403
402; 403

402; 403

402; 403

786

EA0194923-EA0194924 - 12/01/06 Email from Joel Linzner to Pat Battle

402; 403

794

EA0194762 - 08/10/07 Email from Joel Linzner to Pat Battle

402; 403

826

NCAAPROD00391554- NCAAPROD00391556 - 08/25/05 Email from
Kevin Lennon to Bo Kerin, Steve Mallonee (NCAA), Ellen Ferris and Wendy
Walters

402; 403

1126

NCAAPROD00300482-NCAAPROD00300517 - 12/22/08 Men's basketball
contract between EA and CLC. Signed by EA, CLC, ASUCLA Executive
Director, Ohio State University Senior Vice President for Business and
Finance and University of Southern California Senior Vice President of
Administration.

402; 403

1127

CLC0181360-CLC0181361 - 08/13/07 Email correspondence among CLC
executives [David Kirkpatrick, Derek Eiler, Cory Moss, Pat Battle; earlier
emails include: Wendy Harmon and Cathy Aldridge]

402; 403; MIL

2000

NCAAPROD00180111-NCAAPROD00180114 - 03/29/04 Email from Bill
Saum to Dennis Cryder, Wally Renfro, David Price, Scott Bearby, Melissa
Caito, Jo Jo Rinebold and David Knopp, with attachments

402; 403; MIL

2001

NCAAPROD00204756 - 04/19/04 Email from David Knopp (NCAA) to
Dennis Cryder and Bill Saum
NCAAPROD00198170 - 04/21/04 Email from Bill Saum to Dennis Cryder,
Melissa Caito, Wally Renfro, Scott Bearby, David Knopp, Jo Jo Rinebold,
Jess Howard, Rachel Newman, Deana Garner, Angie Cretors, Rhonda Place,
Jeff Howard, and David Price

402; 403; MIL

NCAAPROD00245468- NCAAPROD00245469 - Commercialism and
Licensing Issues Survey

402; 403; MIL

2002

2003

2

402; 403; MIL

2004

NCAAPROD00197832- NCAAPROD00197839 - 05/27/04 Email from
Corey Bray to Bill Saum, Dennis Cryder, Melissa Caito, David Knopp, Scott
Bearby, Wally Renfro, Rachel Newman, and Jo Jo Rinebold, attaching
"Commercialism and Licensing Issues Survey." (results)

402; 403; MIL

2006

NCAAPROD00247339 - 03/16/05 Email from Myles Brand to Greg Shaheen

402; 403

2012

NCAAPROD00068455-NCAAPROD00068456 - 01/04/06 Email forwarding
from Bob Williams to Wally Renfro, Dennis Cryder, and Erik Christianson a
12/22/05 email from Gail Dent to Bob Williams

402; 403

2015

NCAAPROD00082991-92 - 02/25/06 Email from Peter Davis to Gail Dent,
David Knopp, and Erika Austin

402; 403

2021

NCAAPROD00246775- NCAAPROD00246777 - 03/02/07 Email from Joel
Linzner to Greg Shaheen and Pat Battle
EA0038158-EA0038173 - 07/13/07 Email from Todd Sitrin to Jordan
Edelstein and Joel Linzner, attaching NCAA Exec Pres v3.1 PowerPoint
NCAAPROD00181533-NCAAPROD00181541 - 08/19/07 Email chain
among Greg Shaheen, Myles Brand and Tom Jernstedt

402; 403

NCAAPROD00250820 - 01/05/08 Email Chain among David Berst, Myles
Brand, and Greg Shaheen
NCAAPROD00100838- NCAAPROD00100840 - 01/14/08 E-mail from Peter
Davis to Sean O'Brien, Moss, Kirkpatrick, Erika Austin, Jim Haynes and Greg
Shaheen

402; 403

NCAAPROD00211834- NCAAPROD00211863 - 07/16/08 Email from Carol
Roland to Jim Isch and Bob Fiala, attaching 2007-2008 Report to
Administrative Committee documents

402; 403

2022
2023

2029
2031

2034

3

402; 403
402; 403

402; 403

2036

NCAAPROD00233331-NCAAPROD00233335 - 07/25/08 Email from David
Knopp to Wally Renfro, attaching EA SPORTS NCAA Football 09
Frequently Asked Questions Re: File Sharing

402; 403

2040

NCAAPROD00412504- NCAAPROD00412505 - 09/04/08 Email chain
among Wendy Walters, Brad Hostetter and Kevin Lennon

402; 403

2049

NCAAPROD00120855 - 02/22/09 Email from Wally Renfro to Myles Brand
and David Berst
NCAAPROD00206315- NCAAPROD00206320 - 03/06/09 Email chain
among NCAA, CLC, EA executives [ultimately forwarded from Peter Davis
to Greg Shaheen and David Knopp; original message from Tyler Vaught to
Dave Kirkpatrick and Erika Austin, later including Jeff Roth, Cory Moss, Joe
Dunn, Scott Kirshenbaum, David Bertram, Caldridge, Pat Battle and Peter
Davis]

402; 403

2054

NCAAPROD00083731- NCAAPROD00083733 - 03/07/09 Email from Joe
Dunn responding to Peter Davis' original message which included: CBS,
CLC, IMG, and Host Communications

402; 403

2061

NCAAPROD00237076-NCAAPROD00237078 - 10/19/09 Email from Wally
Renfro to Diane Young, attaching memo from Jim Isch

2062

NCAAPROD00450883- NCAAPROD00450884 - 12/14/09 Email from Joe
Dunn to Erika Austin and Peter Davis [original email from Moya Nickodem
to Dave Kirkpatrick, David Bertram and Boyd Kendall; Kirkpatrick
forwarded to Erika Austin, Cory Moss, Caldridge and Bertram; Austin
forwarded to Peter Davis and Joe Dunn]

402; 403

2087

NCAAPROD00430717-NCAAPROD00430780 - 01/12/12 Meeting
Reminder for DI Leadership Council meeting, attaching Agenda and meeting
documents

402; 403

2052

4

402; 403

403

2090

NCAAPROD00626528-NCAAPROD00626859 - 09/25/12 Agenda for
NCAA Working Group on Collegiate Models - Rules, with supplemental
documents

402; 403

2092

NCAAPROD00629338- NCAAPROD00629498 - 5/2/13 Agenda for NCAA
Division I BOD meeting

402; 403

2491

NCAAPROD00137943- NCAAPROD00137945 - 03/1/07 Email between
Kevin Lennon and David Berst

402; 403

5