State of California et al v. Trump et al

Filing 182

MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment and Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed by Department of Defense, David Bernhardt, Mark T. Esper, Steven T. Mnuchin, Kirstjen M. Nielsen, Patrick M. Shanahan, Richard V. Spencer, Donald J. Trump, U.S. Department of Homeland Security, U.S. Department of the Interior, U.S. Department of the Treasury, United States of America, Heather Wilson. Responses due by 6/24/2019. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit, # 3 Exhibit, # 4 Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit, # 6 Exhibit, # 7 Exhibit, # 8 Exhibit, # 9 Exhibit, # 10 Exhibit, # 11 Exhibit, # 12 Exhibit, # 13 Exhibit, # 14 Exhibit, # 15 Proposed Order)(Warden, Andrew) (Filed on 6/19/2019) Modified on 6/20/2019 (cpS, COURT STAFF).

EXHIBIT 1

Washington, DC 20528

Secretary

U.S. Department of Homeland Security

Homeland
Security
March 28, 2019
United States Senate
Washington, DC 20510
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515
Dear Members of Congress:
I am writing to you with an urgent request. For many months now, the Department of
Homeland Security (DHS) has been tracking a surge in migrant arrivals at the U.S. southern
border. It is the responsibility of DHS to secure our borders, enforce our immigration laws, and
provide appropriate humanitarian protections to those who need it. Indeed, Congress has
explicitly directed DHS to take operational control of the southern border. But today I report to
you that we are increasingly unable to uphold that responsibility given the emergency situation.
We are grappling with a humanitarian and security catastrophe that is worsening by the day, and
the Department has run out of capacity, despite extraordinary intra-Departmental and interagency
efforts. I am especially concerned about the level of families and unaccompanied children
arriving at our borders and in federal custody. Accordingly, DHS requests immediate
Congressional assistance to stabilize the situation.
The border numbers paint a picture of a dire situation. Late last year, DHS was
apprehending 50,000 - 60,000 migrants a month. Last month, we apprehended or encountered
more than 75,000, the highest in over a decade. And this month, we are on track to interdict
nearly 100,000 migrants. What we are seeing is nearly unprecedented in the modern era. Unlike
previous flows, these migrants are not arriving in high numbers, one-at-a-time. They are arriving
in large groups. In a normal year, DHS would encounter one or two groups of over 100
migrants. Already in this fiscal year, we have encountered nearly 100 large groups comprised of
100+ migrants, nearly half of which have arrived in remote locations. Our men and women on
the frontlines are simply not resourced to handle these levels, and I report to you today that we
are struggling to transport and process-let alone adequately care for-this many individuals
coming into our custody, especially those in hard-to-reach areas.
The volume of "vulnerable populations" is unsustainable. Our system has been able
to cope with high numbers in the past, but the composition of today's flows makes them virtually
unmanageable. Historically, the vast majority of aliens we encountered were single-adult males
from Mexico who could be quickly removed afaer a short period of detention if they had no legal
right to stay. Today, the majority are families and unaccompanied children, who pose a unique

www.dhs.gov

challenge to the system because most cannot be easily cared for, efficiently processed, or
expeditiously removed, due to resource constraints and outdated laws. The result is a dangerous
and growing backlog of individuals in custody that has forced us to begin releasing large
numbers of aliens, most of whom will never appear for their immigration court hearings, further
exacerbating "pull" factors into the United States. Unfortunately, Alternatives to Detention, such
as ankle-bracelet monitoring, have proven expensive in the long run and ineffective at ensuring
removals ordered by an immigration judge.
Now we face a system-wide meltdown. DHS facilities are overflowing, agents and
officers are stretched too thin, and the magnitude of arriving and detained aliens has increased
the risk of life-threatening incidents. At the present time, Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
has more than 1,200 unaccompanied alien children (UACs) in custody, hundreds of which have
been with CBP for days, an unacceptable length of stay in facilities not designed to hold children
for extended periods. By law, most of these children must be transferred to the Department of
Health and Human Services (HHS) for care in residential shelters. While HHS is taking steps to
rapidly add thousands of shelter beds, the system is hitting peak capacity. In addition to UACs,
CBP has at least 6,600 families in custody, bringing the total number of children sitting in CBP
facilities to approximately 4,700. We are doing everything possible to address these numbers
and reduce backlogs, but they are a symptom of a broken system.
My greatest concern is for the children, who arc put at high risk by this emergency
and who are arriving sicker than ever before after traveling on the treacherous trek. Our
agents and officers are performing more than 60 hospital visits a day-many to ensure young
people get immediate treatment-and we now are regularly seeing individuals arrive with life­
threatening conditions. Moreover, as agents get pulled off the line to escort migrants to receive
medical assistance, we are left with even less capacity to handle new arrivals. The humanitarian
situation cannot be ignored. Reports of violence and sexual assault along the route are now
pervasive, meaning that many arriving migrants require especially focused care. In some cases,
girls as young as 10 years old in DHS custody require pregnancy tests so we can be sure they get
essential medical support. And with increased flows, smugglers and traffickers are forcing more
people into inhumane conditions along the journey and putting lives in danger. They are preying
on innocent people for profit and exploiting this crisis to line their pockets by breaking our laws.
Our most urgent need is to increase throughput to avoid threats to life and
property. At present, DHS border and immigration facilities are at (or over) capacity with
serious over-crowding. We need additional temporary facilities as soon as possible in order to
process arriving aliens, especially those entering illegally between ports of entry. Immigration
and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has been urgently working to acquire additional bed space and
to speed up transfers of individuals into their custody, but DHS has nonetheless been forced to
temporarily release adults and families directly from Border Patrol custody. This prevents us
from detaining them to ensure that they are afforded the most expeditious process under
immigration law and, where appropriate, removed. Without additional assistance, we will be
forced to increase the releases of the single-adult population from ICE-the only population for
which we can currently effectively enforce U.S. immigration laws. As such, we are witnessing
the real-time dissolution of the immigration system.

Moreover, HHS will likely need many more beds as the influx of children grows. In
HHS custody, children receive accommodations appropriate for young people while they await
placement with adult sponsors in the United States. However, because of the surge in arrivals,
CBP has high numbers of children that have not been transferred. As noted earlier, HHS is
taking steps to rapidly add thousands of shelter beds. But in the short term, HHS is still
approaching its maximum capacity and will very likely require thousands of additional beds in
the coming weeks and months. I must emphasize how important it is to quickly transfer children
out of border locations, which are not designed for long-term stay and are especially inadequate
for the care of young people. A potential overflow of children in DHS custody represents our
most acute humanitarian risk.
But bed space is not the only issue. To cope with the overall volume of arriving
migrants, a resource surge is needed throughout the system to ensure efficient throughput and
proper care. This includes medical teams, vehicles and transportation workers, legal services,
and more. We need temporary processing facilities with full humanitarian and staffing support.
And we now project that we will need at least hundreds of additional personnel to support CBP
and ICE in providing humanitarian and operational assistance, including conducting welfare
checks, preparing meals, and accounting for personal property.
In light of the above, DHS requests immediate assistance from Congress, including
emergency resources and specific authorities to cope with the escalating situation.
At this time, DHS is assessing the resources needed to make up for shortfalls and
sustain critical operations. While recent appropriations provided DHS with additional
humanitarian and operational funds, the Department is projecting we will exceed these resources
and be unable to uphold basic mission requirements because of the severity of the flow. I will be
working with the Office of Management and Budget to provide you additional details in the near
future, but the situation is so dire we want to make notification to you now that we will require
additional resources to reduce system backlogs to ensure immediate safety and care of
individuals in our custody.
DHS also seeks authorities to address the underlying causes of this emergency and
to restore order, while ensuring we can provide humanitarian assistance to those who need
it. Most immediately, we need the authority to treat all arriving migrant children equally.
Currently, we can reunite many unaccompanied children from Mexico with their families and
return them home, when appropriate, but we are legally unable to do so for children from non­
contiguous countries. The result is that hundreds of Central American children come into our
custody each day, await transfer to HHS care, and, ultimately, are placed with a sponsor in the
United States. This serves as another dangerous "pull" factor. DHS seeks authority to return
UACs to their families and home countries in a safe and orderly manner if they have no legal
right to stay. In the coming days, I will transmit proposed legislative language to Congress to fix
this, along with measures to allow DHS to keep alien families in custody together through the
immigration process and to allow asylum-seekers to apply for U.S. protection from within
Central America, rather than take the dangerous journey north. These legislative solutions will
help address the root causes of the emergency.

In the meantime, I am doing everything within my authority to prevent the situation
from getting worse. This week I met with senior Mexican officials to discuss what can be done
on their side of the border to help stem the historic flows. I also signed a first-ever regional
compact with the countries of the Northern Triangle-El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras­
to address irregular migration, counter human smuggling and trafficking, and crack down on
transnational criminal organizations that are also fueling the crisis. Operationally, we are
redirecting resources and personnel from across the Department toward border security and
migration management, we are putting out a call for volunteers from non-border missions, and
we continue to receive support from interagency partners. We also plan to redirect field office
personnel staffing ports of entry to help address the humanitarian situation. But once again, this
will not be enough.
We need Congress to act immediately to address the growing emergency. Let me be
clear: the journey of any migrant--especially at the hands of a smuggler or trafficker-is not a
safe one. And the migrant surge has made matters worse, not only for U.S. border security but
for the safety of migrants themselves. We must be able to come together on a bipartisan basis to
take action. We have common cause. We all want to enforce the laws of the United States,
ensure a safe and orderly migrant flow, protect our communities, reduce the flow of drugs,
facilitate legal trade and travel, secure our borders, and support vulnerable populations. This is
one of the most serious crises the Department of Homeland Security has ever faced, and we need
your help.
Copies of this letter have been sent to the Speaker of the House; the Majority and
Minority Leaders in the Senate and House; and the Chairmen and Ranking Members of the
Senate Appropriations Committee, Senate Judiciary Committee, Senate Homeland Security and
Governmental Affairs Committee, House Appropriations Committee, House Judiciary
Committee, and House Homeland Security Committee.
Respectfully,

Kirstjen M. Nielsen
Secretary