State of California et al v. Trump et al

Filing 220

MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment Re Section 2808 and NEPA filed by Commonwealth of Virginia, State of California, State of Colorado, State of Hawaii, State of Maryland, State of New Mexico, State of New York, State of Oregon, State of Wisconsin. Motion Hearing set for 11/20/2019 10:00 AM in Oakland, Courtroom 2, 4th Floor before Judge Haywood S Gilliam Jr.. Responses due by 10/25/2019. Replies due by 11/1/2019. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix of Declarations re: Environmental Harms, # 2 Declaration of Colonel William Green, # 3 Declaration of Alison Lynn Reaser, # 4 Declaration of Heather Leslie, # 5 Request for Judicial Notice ISO Mot for Partial Summary Judgment Re Section 2808 and NEPA, # 6 Proposed Order Granting Motion for Partial Summary Judgment, # 7 Certificate/Proof of Service)(Leslie, Heather) (Filed on 10/11/2019)

1

2

XAVIER BECERRA
Attorney General of California
ROBERTVV.BYRNE

3

SALLY MAGNANI
MICHAEL L. NEWMAN

Senior Assistant Attorneys General
4

5

MICHAEL P. CAYABAN
CHRISTINE CHUANG
EDWARD H. OCHOA

Supervising Deputy Attorneys General
6
7

8
9
10
11

12
13

BRIAN J. BILFORD
SPARSHS. KHANDESHI
LEE I. SHERMAN
JANELLE M. SMITH
JAMES F. ZAHRADKA II
HEATHER C. LESLIE (SBN 305095)

Deputy Attorney General
State Bar No. 305095
1300 I Street, Suite 125
P.O. Box 944255
Sacramento, CA 94244-2550
Telephone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
E-mail: Heather [e-mail]
Attorneys for Plaintiff State of Cal(fornia

14

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

16
17
18

STATE OF CALIFORNIA et al.;

19
20

Case No. 4:19-cv-00872-HSG
Plaintiffs,

v.

21
22
23
24
25

DONALD J. TRUMP, in his official
capacity as President of the United States of
America et al.;

_______________

Defendants.
__,

DECLARATION OF HEATHER LESLIE
IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
PARTIALSUMMARY JUDGMENT
REGARDING SECTION 2808 AND
NEPA
November 20, 2019
10:00 am
Honorable Haywood S. Gilliam,
Jr.
Trial Date:
None Set
Action Filed: February 18, 2019

Date:
Time:
Judge:

26
27
28
Declaration of Heather Leslie ISO Mot. For Partial Summ. J re Section 2808 and NEPA (4:19-cv-00872)

1
2
3
4

I, Heather Leslie, declare as follows:
1.

I have personal knowledge of the. facts set forth in this declaration. If called as a

witness, I could and would testify competently to the matters set forth below.

2.

I am employed by the California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney

5

General, and currently serve a Deputy Attorney General within the Office's Publie Rights

6

Division, Environment Section. I am a licensed member of good standing with the California

7

State Bar and represent the State of California in the above-captioned matter.

8

9

3.

In my role as one of the attorneys representing the State of California in this

matter, on September 10, 2019, I e-mailed Andrew Warden, an attorney with the United States

10

Department of Justice and counsel for the Defendants, requesting the latitude and longitude

11

coordinates for the border barrier projects identified on page 4 of Exhibit 1 of the Notice of

12

Decision by the Department of Defense to Authorize Border Barrier Projects Pursuant to 10

13

U.S.C. § 2808, ECF No. 206-1.

14

4.

On September 23, 2019, I received an e-mail from Andrew Warden, counsel for

15

Defendants, stating "Attached is a chart listing the coordinates for the 2808 projects." Attached to

16

that e-mail was the list of coordinates I have attached hereto as Exhibit 1. I shared this list of

17

coordinates with other attorneys representing the State of California in this matter and we

18

provided this list of coordinates with our declarants for their use in determining the proposed

19

location of the border barrier projects that Defendants seek to construct under 10 U.S.C. § 2808.

20

This list of coordinates is the only information I received from the Defendants in response to my

21

September 10, 2019 e-mail.

\

22
23

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is
true and correct. Executed on October 11, 2019, at Sacramento, California.

24

ls/Heather Leslie

25

HEATHER LESLIE

26
27
28
1
Declaration of Heather Leslie ISO Mot. For Partial Summ. J re Section 2808 and NEPA (4:19-cv-00872)

EXHIBIT 1

2808 Project Coordinates
\1,';:,,;'iWf'ProjecL /
El Centro 5
El Centro 5
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
El Centro 9
San Diego 4 (1 &2:
San Diego 4 (1&2:
Yuma 6 (1&2)
Yuma 6 (1&2)
Yuma 6 (1&2)
Yuma 6 (1&2)
San Diego 4 (1 &2:
San Diego 4 (1&2:
Yuma 6 (1&2)
Yuma 6 (1&2)
El Paso 8 (1 &2)
El Paso 8 (1 &2)
El Paso 8 (1&2)
San Diego 11
San Diego 11
El Paso 2
El Paso 2
El Paso 2
El Paso 2
El Paso 2
El Paso 2
Yuma 2
Yuma 3
Yuma 3
Yuma 3
Yuma 3
Yuma 3
Yuma 3
Yuma 10/27
Yuma 10/27
Yuma 10/27
Laredo t
Laredo 7
Laredo 7
Laredo 7
Laredo 7
Laredo 7

~' ti. 11.atStart

"" · ·'-' Long Start" .

32.66609683
32.66441744
32.65298241
32.65674745
32.65997305
32.66268114
32.66672509
32.66400527
32.66639969
32.67008528
32.55576079
32.55675216
32.71603068
32.71905241
32. 71643589
32.7167382
32.55637513
32.55535062
32.71869511
32.71815515
31.33337004
31 .3329165
31.33333552
32.57427251
32.57687801
31 .33336836
31.78372235
31.33231251
31 .332323
31.78371916
31.33229403
32.36531415
32.23292391
32.1935563
32.18075874
32.15087662
32.05345764
32.05685869
32.41373234
32.35454649
32.41831713
28.19685431
28.12144242
28.0204 7236
27 .86155739
27.74799699
27.73322231

The coordinates are not survey
accurate and are subject to change

-115.4825268
-115.50539
-115.6621623
-115.6119704
-115.5685476
-115.5317336
-115.4740716
-115.5107808
-115.4783807
-115.4310461
-116.877791
-116.866256
-114.7605058
-114.7191752
-114.7606214
-114.7560448
-116.8658211
-116.8777419
-114. 719492
-114.7282353
-108.6176304
-108.71 58582
-108.7158147
-116.6581131
-116.6260834
-108.582411 9
-108.1824416
-108.9321214
-108.962631
-108.1566405
-108.8986798
-114.3866211
-113.955219
-113.8280496
-113.7868986
-113.6908774
-113.3798902
-113.3906895
-114.5445796
-114.3498202
-114.5597239
-100.2088407
-100.0703333
-1 00.0053196
-99.89226627
-99.8004009
-99.77084466

,.

,,

Lat End

Long End

Fence Program

32.66639969
32.66502661
32.65674745
32.65997305
32.66268114
32.66400527
32.67008528
32.66441744
32.66672509
32.67065177
32.55675216
32.56012814
32.71764807
32.70406484
32.7167382
32.71825951
32.55768939
32.55637513
32.70419718
32.71824028
31 .33337005
31.33337004
31.33375248
32.57670274
32.57866339
31.33340657
31.78371909
31.33229403
31 .33231251
31.78370825
31.33229168
32.3579244
32.19928542
32.18621857
32.17759305
32.05685869
32.0390333
32.05381251
32.35831411
32.26078649
32.41373234
28.12144242
28.02047236
27 .86156482
27.74799699
27.73322231
27.70087

-115.4 783807
-115.5003213
-115.6119704
-115.5685476
-115.5317336
-115.5107808
-115.4310461
-115.50539
-115.4740716
-115.4231003
-116.866256
-116.8414011
-114.7365576
-114.7257261
-114.7560448
-114.7284394
-116.8531846
-1 16.8658211
-114.726013
-114.7269522
-108.6175192
-108.6176304
-108.6176157
-116.6282079
-116.6045492
-108.4792601
-108.1582742
-108.8986798
-108.9321208
-107.9631931
-108.8859448
-114.3623999
-113.8465093
-113.8044093
-113.776713
-113.3906895
-113.3341097
-11 3.3810172
-114.3621746
-114.0440488
-114.5445796
-100.0703333
-100.0053196
-99.89227461
-99.8004009
-99.77084466
-99.74378

Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Primary Pedestrian Replacemen
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Veh icle to Pedestriar
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Primary Pedestrian Replacemen
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Vehicle to Pedestriar
Veh icle to Pedestriar
Secondary
Secondary
Secondary
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar
Primary Pedestriar

'l0 ·

,;:

·;,,

Fund Type il' .
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808
2808

California v. Trump, 19-CV-872 (N.D. Cal.)
Sierra Club v. Trump, 19-CV-892 (N.D. Cal.)
Produced by Defendants on Sept. 23, 2019