Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1091

Declaration of Adam S. Cashman in Support of #1090 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed bySamsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC(a Delaware limited liability company). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit 1, #2 Exhibit 2, #3 Exhibit 3, #4 Exhibit 5, #5 Exhibit 6, #6 Exhibit 7, #7 Exhibit 8, #8 Exhibit 9, #9 Exhibit 10, #10 Exhibit 11, #11 Exhibit 12, #12 Exhibit 13, #13 Exhibit 16, #14 Exhibit 21, #15 Exhibit 22, #16 Exhibit 23, #17 Exhibit 24, #18 Exhibit 26, #19 Exhibit 27, #20 Exhibit 28, #21 Exhibit 29, #22 Exhibit 30, #23 Exhibit 31, #24 Exhibit 32, #25 Exhibit 33, #26 Exhibit 34, #27 Exhibit 35, #28 Exhibit 36, #29 Exhibit 37, #30 Exhibit 38, #31 Exhibit 39, #32 Exhibit 40, #33 Exhibit 41, #34 Exhibit 42, #35 Exhibit 43, #36 Exhibit 44, #37 Exhibit 45, #38 Exhibit 46, #39 Exhibit 47, #40 Exhibit 48, #41 Exhibit 49, #42 Exhibit 50, #43 Exhibit 51, #44 Exhibit 52, #45 Exhibit 53, #46 Exhibit 54, #47 Exhibit 55, #48 Exhibit 56, #49 Exhibit 57, #50 Exhibit 58, #51 Exhibit 59, #52 Exhibit 60, #53 Exhibit 61, #54 Exhibit 52, #55 Exhibit 63)(Related document(s) #1090 ) (Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 6/13/2012)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT 53 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 United States Design Patent (10) Andre et al. (12) (45) (54) ELECTRONIC DEVICE (75) Inventors: Bartley K. Andre , Menlo Park, CA (US); Daniel J. Coster , San Francisco , CA (US); Daniele De Iuliis , San Fr떠lcisco , CA (U S); Richard P. Howarth , San Francisco , CA (US); Jonathan P. Ive , San Francisco , CA (US); Steve Jobs , Palo Alto , CA (US); Duncan Robert Kerr , San Francisco , CA (US); Shin Nishibori, Portola Valley, CA (US); Matthew Dean Rohrbach , San Prancisco , CA (US); Peter Russell-Clarke , San Francisco , CA (US); Douglas B. Satzger, Menlo Park, CA (US); Calvin Q. Seid, Palo Alto , CA (US); Vincent Keane Seid , legal representative , Palo Alto , CA (US); Christopher J. Stringer , Woodside, CA (US); Eugene Antony Whang , San Fr떠lcisco , CA (U S); Rico Zorkendorfer, San Francisco , CA (US) (73) Assignee: Apple Inc. , Cupertino , CA (US) (**) Term: (21) App l. No.: 29/284 ,269 (22) Filed: (51) (52) (58) LOC (9) CI. .................................................. 14-02 U.S. CI. ..................................................... D14/341 Field of Classification Search ................ D 14/341 , D1 4/342 , 343 , 344 , 345 , 346 , 347 , 420 , 426 , D1 4/427 , 432 , 439 , 440, 441 , 448 , 496 , 125 , D1 4/137 , 129 , 130, 138, 250, 389 , 147 , 218 , D1 4/247 , 248 , 156; D1 0/65 , 78 , 104 , 46; D1 3/168; D1 8/6 , 7; D2 1/329 , 686; D6/596 , D6/601 , 605; 455/90.3 , 556.1 , 556.2 , 575.1 , 455/575.3 , 575 .4; 379/433.01 , 433.04 , 433.06 , 379/433.07; 361/814; 341/22; 345/169 , 345/173 14 Years Sep.4 , 2007 See application file for complete search history Patent No.: Date of Patent: (56) US D622 ,718 S ** Aug. 31 , 2010 References Cited U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS D289 ,873 D337 ,569 D340 ,917 D346 ,793 D424 ,535 D456 ,023 D478 ,310 D478 ,546 D489 ,731 D498 ,754 D499 ,4 23 D502 ,173 D504 ,889 D505 ,950 D507 ,003 D514 ,121 D514 ,590 D515 ,082 D519 ,116 D519 ,523 D519 ,922 D520 ,020 D527 ,379 D528.542 D528 ,561 D529 ,045 D532 ,791 D534 ,143 D535 ,281 D536 ,329 D536 ,691 D536 ,962 D538 ,822 D541 ,298 D541 ,299 D542 ,771 D546 ,313 D548 ,732 D548 ,747 D556 ,211 D557 ,238 D557 ,259 D558 ,756 D558 ,757 D558 ,758 S 5/1987 Gemmell et al S 7/1993 Kando S * 1111993 Sakagu야ü et al. ......... D14/345 S ’". 5/1994 Iino et al. .................. D14/341 S 5/2000 Peltola S 4/2002 An dre et al S * 8/2003 An dre et al ................ D13/110 S * 8/2003 An dre et al ................ D13/110 S 5/2004 Huang S 1112004 Bl뼈 S 12/2004 Bahroocha et al S 2/2005 Jung et al S 5/2005 An dre et al S 6/2005 Summit et al S 7/2005 Pai et al S 112006 Johnson S * 2/2006 Naruki ................... DI4/203 .3 S * 2/2006 Moskaluketal ........... D14/341 S 4/2006 Tanakaetal S 4/2006 Chiu et al S * 5/2006 An dre et al ................ D13/110 S 5/2006 Senda et al S * 8/2006 Oe et al. .................... D14/248 9/2006 Luminosu et al S S 9/2006 Ka-Wei et al S 9/2006 Shin S 1112006 Kim S 12/2006 Lheem S * 112007 Yang ...................... DI4/203 .3 S * 2/2007 Lee ........................ DI4/203 ,6 S 2/2007 Park S * 2/2007 Tanner ........................ D9/424 S 3/2007 An dre et al S 4/2007 An dre et al S 4/2007 An dre et al S * 5/2007 Cho et al. ............ D14/138 AB S 7/2007 Lheem S 8/2007 Cεbε εt al S 8/2007 An dre et al S 1112007 Howard S 12/2007 Kim S * 12/2007 Hirsch ....................... DI4/217 S 112008 An dre et al S 112008 An dre et al S 112008 An dre et al SAMNDCA00373589 US D622 ,718 S Page 2 D558 ,792 D560 ,686 D561 ,1 53 D561 ,204 D563 ,432 D565 ,599 D569 ,830 D570 ,839 D580 ,387 D584 ,303 2003/0125079 2005/0130715 2006/0281501 2007/0082718 2008/0004085 S 112008 Chigira S 112008 Kim S 2/2008 Hong et al S * 2/2008 Toh ........................... D14/496 S * 3/2008 Kim .......................... D14/496 S * 4/2008 Jang et al ................... D14/496 S * 5/2008 Kwak .................. DI4/138 AD S * 6/2008 Hofer et al. ................ D14/341 S * 1112008 An dre εt al. ........... DI4/138 G S * 112009 An dre et al. ............... D14/341 Al * 7/2003 Park et al. ................... 455/556 Al 6/2005 Fujisawa Al * 12/2006 Zuo et al. ................ 455/575.1 Al 4/2007 Yoon et a1 Al 112008 Jung et al FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS EM KR 000569157 -0005 30-0452432 5/2006 7/2007 OTHER PUBLICATIONS Samsung F700 , announεed Feb. 2007 , [online] , [retrieved on Feb. 8, 2007]. Retrieved from Internet, http://www.gsmarena.com Philips S900 , announced Jun. 2006 , [on1ine] , [retrieved on Feb. 20 , 2007]. Retrieved from Internet, http://VI얘/W.gsmarena.com LG KE850 Prada, announced Jan. 2007 , [on1ine] , [retrieved on Feb 20 , 2007]. Retrieved from Internet , http://www.gsmarena.com App1e iPhone , announced Jan. 2007 , [on1ine] , [retrieved on Mar. 12 , 2007]. Retrieved from Internet , http://VI애이.V. gsmarena.com Tinnos PDA, posted May 19 , 2006 , lonlineJ , lretrieved on Aug. 22 , 2007]. Retrieved from Internet, http://www.mobi1ewhac k. com Meizu M8 , posted Jan. 29 , 2007 , [on1ine] , [retrieved on Sep. 13 , 2007]. Retrieved from Internet, http://VI얘/W.engadget. com iPod U2 Specia1 Edition , down1oaded from hrtp://ipod.wikia.co m/ wiki/IPod_U2_Special_Edition , Oc t. 2004 “ App1e Introduces the U2 iPod ," App1e Corporation press Re1ease , http νwww.app1e.com/pr/1ibrary/2004/octl26u2ipod.htrn1 , 0ιt.26 , 2004 U.S. App l. No. 29/270 ,887 , An dre et al. , E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Jan 8, 2007 U.S. Appl. No. 29/282 ,831 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Ju1 30 , 2007 U.S. Appl. No. 29/282 ,832 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Ju1 30 , 2007 U.S. Appl. No. 29/282 ,833 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Ju1 30 , 2007 U.S. Appl. No. 29/282 ,834 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Ju1 30 , 2007 U.S.App l. No. 29/284 , 187 , Andre etal., E1ectronic Device , fi1edAug 31 , 2007 U.S.App l. No. 29/284 , 188 , Andre etal., E1ectronic Device , fi1edAug 31 , 2007 U.S.Appl. No. 29/284 ,271 ,Andre etal., E1ectronic Device, fi1edSεp 4 , 2007 U.S.Appl. No. 29/284 ,272 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device, fi1ed Sεp 5, 2007 U.S.Appl. No. 29/284 ,276 ,Andre etal., E1eιtromι Deviιe, fi1edSep 5, 2007 U.S.Appl. No. 29/284 ,288 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device, fi1ed Sep 5, 2007 U.S.Appl. No. 29/284 ,308 , An dre et al., E1ectronic Device, fi1ed Sεp 5, 2007 U.S.App l. No. 29/284 ,310 ,Andreeta l., E1ectronic Device , fi1edSep 5, 2007 U.S.App l. No. 29/284 ,312 , Andre et al., E1ectronic Device , fi1ed Sep 5, 2007 * cited by examiner Primmγ Examiner-Cathron C Brooks Assistant Examiner-Barbara Fox (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Sterne, Kessler, Goldstein & FoxPLLC (57) CLAIM The ornamental design for an electronic device , as shown and described. DESCRIPTION FIG. 1 is a front perspective view of an electronic device showing our new design; FIG. 2 is a rear perspective thereof; FIG. 3 is a front view thereof; FIG. 4 is a rear view thereof; FIG. 5 is a left side view thereof; FIG. 6 is right side view thereof; FIG. 7 is a top plan view thereof; FIG. 8 is a bottom p1an view thereof; FIG. 9 is an enlarged elevational view of a representative corner ofthe electronic device; FIG. 10 is a front perspective view of an electronic device showing our new design; FIG. 11 is a rεarpεrspεCt1Vε thεrεof; FIG. 12 is a front view thereof; FIG. 13 is a rear view thereof; FIG. 14 is a left side view thereof; FIG. 15 is right side view thereof; FIG. 16 is a top plan view thereof; FIG. 17 is a bottom plan view thereof; and, FIG. 18 is an enlarged elevational view of a representative corner ofthe electronic device. The broken lines showing portions ofthe electronic device are forthε purposε of illustrating portions ofthε εlεctronicdεV1ιε which form no part ofthe claimed design. The surfaces of the electronic device shown in FIGS. 1-18 show different stippling to indicate contrasting surface treatment. Another embodiment, not shown because the figures would be the same as FIGS. 1-18 , is the same as FIGS. 1-18 except the 1i방1t stippling represents a shiny or glossy surface treatment and the dark stippling represents a matte or flat surface treatment. 1 Claim, 10 Drawing Sheets SAMNDCA00373590 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 1 of 10 US D622 ,718 S FIG.1 FIG.2 SAMNDCA00373591 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 2 of 10 US D622 ,718 S 띤 IJ μ짝찬윗L쓴한피 FIG.3 FIG.4 SAMNDCA00373592 E6SELEOO'달:>CINJiil달S s .딘|콰 9 .딘|콰 11111111111111--11111 1i-------1I11It---j .. 이 ι η ; : … 」 ‘ ---~-J ‘ -.’ “ ‘,;‘ at- , ,, ‘ ·‘ ‘4 ‘; 」펴 」 ‘ ;‘ - - - - - - - - - - 니 · , I ‘/ νμ -〕 -→ 1 J ~ 지 1 --‘ 11ji--]111if11111111 / ‘ ? ” ‘·” ·’ ‘ ---’ ’ ’ q ’ c ” ’‘ ‘ τ 」 -’ ‘ 1 1 1 j ‘ “ S 8IL ‘ ZZ9G Sil 01JO ε }<l<l QS OIOZ ‘ Iε .~n¥ lual~d .Sl u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 4 of 10 US D622 ,718 S f쌀~---;:.~-"-"-'.홉편]it???t:;??댄깐깐깐""":'.":".-:~.r.:.':"":,"~:':.'".: :_:" : ,: ‘?폐l FIG.7 관했횟: -~.:.:펜펙,,"않갚꼬딛짚날:딘꾀??꽉;잔했 、녕i;、,- 끼 j싸~-'.' -~'-~셔μ;‘ 싸사;.;.,;..,;.μ싸L-; /…ι↓~‘ι- ‘;:‘셔펴 .. 아~시 ;r;?? -JL ‘」ι;;/ FIG.8 SAMNDCA00373594 u.s. Patent Aug , 31 , 2010 US D622 ,718 S Sheet 5 of 10 .. . _ •• I ". "_. r' .. ‘ • , ‘ . .., • .•. “ .. ’ • , ~. ‘ .. • • "• " '‘,,__.애 . ,.‘ . ‘ . ', ... ‘ ........ ‘ T... ii • • . ,ι..----. + • • "_’ ....... ... ' "_"' , .‘ ...... .-+ . - .. • . - ‘ ι ..- ~.,.s ‘ ‘ - ’,.-:' •• ’ .• •.. - •. •. r -r_ ‘_‘ •• ........ . , , ‘ /.. ’ ‘ ’ • • ~ ‘ , ’ ’.1 _ _ •• ., ’ • / .‘ “ ‘ . . . . . • . ..,.-’ .. +1,-‘,_+ • ~{ . ., . . . ‘ . . . . r _•. ‘ .<얀 · ‘ . “ . ‘ , l ‘:-’딩" ...t -.-.~: ... FJ"" - - '.. - . ’ • ' '. ‘ ,_1'‘ + • . _; . • •• t .... .. . . ‘. . ‘.'.' P. ‘ I.r. _ ‘ .. .. .. ... . ... ... • .. ‘ ....... • • ,ι , • ~ y _' . - I ‘ ;‘. :: -,. r ..',: "~-.. , - “ ’ , .'•..- . ’,~ .1 - .... : .. :.i • .. .. _...... ‘ ... ’ . ~ £’ ‘ , ’ , “ , .. ’ •• ,' '.1 ‘ .... -_ . '’ ‘ •• ..' ~’ ’ ‘ ’ ‘ 녁l•‘• ‘ ’ 1 • ‘ l ' ‘ ..... 1 ‘ ’ (J • ’ •’ ‘ ‘ • i rr- I • • _‘ ·‘ •. T I r • • . 1 ι c ~.. ,,: • • ,~ ’ ;‘ , , ’ . . . . .. ~." ‘ .. t. _ 냉 • I L ... " -:. ."_ 1 I ,' . + ‘ .. ’ r ‘ I ‘ ~- . + . .. .• ‘ , _... .- L ••• L. -.- - . ’.... - . .• . _ -:_" • • • • . . . . . . “ . . . : .. . • : • • • • ’ ’ • r ‘ ~‘ •. . ‘ ~ , ’ ’ . L ~ · 1...‘ . · ’ [ -t "'r- + .. ι ’ •.. · ‘ ’ ., ‘ ....... . 1+. ‘ ι ':._- . ‘... .o!:: , “ - ‘ , "r-. .;..‘ . “ .... . "‘’ ,, .. . .. . .. . " •.“ • “ ‘ .. ‘ . - .. ‘ . " . . ~ . + • _ . ’ .••“ .... . + . . . . . . -.-‘’, 1. , ~’ ‘ . ‘ .... ’ ‘. , ‘ • , , ‘ . . . . . . .• ‘ ..... ... _-.... rr ‘‘’ • ~ .... _ ."._r J ... ::. , ' ’ ‘ “ . ... ‘ . .. .. l+.. . ‘ ‘..‘.’_'. ... ‘ _ . _ .... .. .. .";:_.- +• ' I[" _: ‘ . ' ‘ -‘ • , • ...: __ " • ‘ II_. • μ . ‘ ‘ .. • __ -•• . .. .. ... • ’... ‘ ..... ‘ ...‘ ’ • .1 - _:;_ ' .. ’ ....... i .. _" 1.'; :' ‘ + . ‘ · ‘ • . ..-:_ . ..-._- ... ‘ ... .. , ’ ‘ “ + .... ’‘’.‘ . ‘ I , • ’ ’ • " ‘ •‘. - • '1' '.... .. • ~“ • • . •. , ‘ •.... ’ “ " . ‘·“에·.. ι ‘ /‘ I " " ' ‘ • • ’ ' •.... t ‘ ',: "' ‘ ‘ .1. ' .... ’ ‘ " , . , - , -L" ’ ‘ . ' •. ' .:‘".. .. .~. .1' +'. .. “ ’ ‘ ‘ ‘ ~ . .. ... . _. ι • .• 1~ • . • ' , ’ • • :. .......... •.’.< .,.‘" 1 .• .- . ... ‘_.1. -_ + • . . ...- …--.. . . •• .‘ - _ “. _ 」 ‘ ‘ ~ - ,• , .... · ‘ ’ ’ W" ‘ _ .. ‘’ .,. - ..‘ . . • • .,‘- ,•.•. ‘- - '1' ‘ , ,, . ι ‘ l ,..:': .. ‘ , ‘ ., , . ... ‘ ..... 'ι‘ +~_ _"'1_“ ... ‘ • ‘ .. .. .,..; ‘ :.. '. +' •• ’ ·‘ ‘ , • ’, J-- : ’ ‘ r: 서 : ’ “ ‘ .' , _".1 ,. , r. " ‘ ‘ _. _ . . .1. +,:.. ‘ " ‘ _.’,.‘ ‘ • ,;, : . ’ · + ‘ , , ’ ‘ . “ ‘ ’ ‘ ...... + .... r • • ; . _ .. ' 1 · ‘ ~ ’ . . " ’ ’ : ... . . . “ ‘ l•‘’, . , ‘ , .. ,‘ ’ ‘ ‘ ’ “ • _ • ‘ ’ ‘ .•. ‘ • • • ., • • '_. ; . ·’ .. 1" 1 ‘ .. ., ’ • '1'... ‘ , “ · . · · ‘ , • ' ........" '1' ’ .:...‘ .. . ‘ _... ‘ • ,‘ "“ "" ’ ‘ • . ‘. , ‘ : ’ . . , , . . ' ‘•.....•. ~ ‘ l•. • ,‘ 、,’ ..' ‘ .’ " .... ‘, ’ .. _.‘ ’‘ · ‘ I" ~ _ ~ ‘ ‘ ’ - ' “ . ‘- • ‘ ’ I • < - ’ - ,‘ ’ ’ “ ’ • ‘ ‘ ’ ‘ ... .•• “ 'ι'1 ‘ ’‘, • . ‘ , '1 , , ι • ’ - “ ‘ . ~. 1-~ , • ‘ .. . . • . . ..... ’ +. ._’ . ‘ - '. • - -‘ ’ , " ' .(‘ . _ ........ .t; . ". ~.r ~t + i ':. • • .....,.: ι.’, ,’· ' ,, ', ' “ ’ ••+ . '‘. . . . . + “ • ’ ‘ • ... ._ 1. . . • ' ... - " 1.' ‘ . • ‘ ‘ ...' - ’~ . ‘ ~ •..- •, ••_.- , ,.. ’ ' -_-. ‘, ‘ ‘ ι … ’ + •• • i· “ , ' ‘ ’ .-+ +.‘.'1' ._.•..-:_ .. " ": “ " ~ .. · ’ ‘ -‘ . .‘ ‘ ’ ..• .... 1 ’ · “ ...... - '1' _1 ~’· ‘ · ‘ •... +• • ‘'1' .-, ; ,‘ ’ 1• μ • •• • ..... ‘ ’ ‘ ‘ • ' • ‘. ‘ . I • - ~ • • " • •• • + ‘ ’ ‘ l “· ‘ - ‘ , 1 ‘ . ~ • -- ..., ~ ‘_ " : 1. • • : +••• I ~ : ’ ‘ -‘ . .:. ‘ . ‘ . . •: _ .. - ' .-_ -. ". . . ’ . ‘. .. . . ... . . “ _.. . ’ l ‘ .. . --; , ~ . . . • . . ‘ . “ I ‘-:- •• ‘ , . .. . . ‘• ‘ , r ‘ . ‘’ . • . " ‘ - .‘. - . :' ‘‘ “ “ ._. . I • i -_ • • _. _ _.. ‘ . .. .. . . . . . . . . ’ - ‘ ’-. ‘ . ... ". r i . ‘ . ‘ , • • ‘r".:'.’" “ . . . . “ ’ ‘ ..... ,. • ~ ~ . . . - ‘ .. •. ‘ • . . . 11 ."1 +‘, . ' • . . ” •• ‘ … • ‘ . ~ - • r ., " .‘ - r '11 ~ 1 .... _.. .-" • .". " ~.- ., i ~... ...... ….- ... -.. . _ - .. . .‘ .. . ... - .. ‘. _. _ _._ _ _. . __ '11 .... '_ • • • ~ r . . . . ’ , • . , ‘ f •• ‘ -- - ‘’ ‘ FIG • 9 SAMNDCA00373595 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 6 of 10 US D622 ,718 S FIG.10 FIG.11 SAMNDCA00373596 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 7 of 10 US D622 ,718 S - - 「 4 」 」 1J 」 l| } -1j tJ L、---l=:[-----zi FIG.12 FIG.13 SAMNDCA00373597 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 Sheet 8 of 10 US D622 ,718 S llll·----· 」 i ‘ . - 」 j • •/ IIIlIlli---fIl ! ‘ . , ‘ , 111--J ‘ .. 1 •, . --? ‘ lI·I ‘ -- FIG. 14 FIG. 15 SAMNDCA00373598 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 //??? jj;‘;• Sheet 9 of 10 ir--‘ : f : ::fL::-; :쉰‘'." .. US D622 ,718 S 쉰l FIG. 16 활핏??;?5펙;??點뚫잖?줬??i꽉?펙藏-쩔 FIG. • 7 SAMNDCA00373599 u.s. Patent Aug. 31 , 2010 US D622 ,718 S Sheet 10 of 10 i ’ -,·, ---‘ ·+ ·‘ ·---‘ ‘ · ‘ , r r + - - ’ ------‘ ··1 --. · - ‘ . - - - , + υ‘ - , , ‘ ‘ ----‘ • L ’ ·. ••‘ 1 · I ·+ .ι ·• ·” .·,--‘·+ ,+ · ·• , · , 1 」 ’ , •, ‘ ·, • ”. ---·, . ·+ ” -- ••. ---‘ -+ ,- •• . • ·n - -- . . • ”, ------+ ··” --’ -. ‘ --,- - - - , ---, - -‘ . , . .. * . - ,- --- ---- “..‘ --“ •• - - - /‘- -- , - ·•. - - , ·. * .--------, + ‘ ‘ - ν ,, --------‘ ‘ -. ’ ,’ . · • • -* ·, , “• - ‘• iJL . • . •• --‘ ----n ‘ · --’, ,. ‘ • -----‘ μ 사 . ‘ · ‘ ”’ μ . -----‘. , , · , · -4 ‘ ‘ ••. - ‘ ‘ ··’ . “ l , - , , .· . . ‘ , , , ‘‘ 、 . ‘ ·” μ 시 ‘ ‘ •., ‘ · . · ·. . ---‘--------------‘ ·. - ‘- • ‘ -. • .- , ---‘ ’ --‘ ’ ‘ ·‘ ·• ------. . , . + ·. ·, ·“ s --‘‘‘ ·r ·” - - ‘ - - -. ‘ · ‘ - - --- - - ‘ ‘ 4 ‘ -, • . ... , ·” . . ‘ ·.. ·” 나 ·’ ·‘ -‘ , ‘ - ‘ ‘ - .’’ . ‘- . ’ ‘ ‘ ‘ - , , ·? , - -- . -- - - ‘ ‘ - ν ‘-----.•. . . ·‘ , , , .•·” ---U ·「 ’ .‘ .- -• . ’ • • .. - ‘ · 서 • ‘ - ‘ - • • ·‘• ‘ - ‘. + · -----, ‘ - -• - -• ‘ • ·, 니 ’ • ·•, ...• ‘ ‘ ‘ ’n + ‘ , ‘ ·r , , ·‘ • ‘ • “• • ’ , J , · • , .. ‘ ---------‘ • ‘ ‘ - a r」 - - - ’ . ‘ - - ... ’ ,- . , ·‘ ‘ • - ” , μ. · - ‘ . , ,- - - 「J ·., , - •• , -• •L ‘ - μ - , ··’ ‘ . • . - ‘ -- . , ‘ , “ ·. • , ·f .----- γ ‘ ’ . ·’ ----·. ---. . , ·‘ ‘ . . “..,.. ,‘ , ‘ .• 」 ‘ . ‘ -.• - • ‘ ‘ , - , ‘ . ·. , ‘ . *“ .. ” ‘ . ‘ - ·. i . ‘ ·. --’1 • - , - -. -·,, - ” . - ,- ‘ ’ ·, ‘ -, - -‘ - -----* 상·“ • ---·. • ‘ ’ ·n , . ‘ ‘ . . ‘ ‘이 , . . --., , -‘ , -----’ ‘ .. • , . ‘ ·--’ ‘ * .’ ‘ · ‘ , , •. ·‘ , ---‘ ‘ v ----‘ , ‘ , • •• ν r ·, . ·n ·‘ ‘ ••. ‘ ‘ μ ‘ 」 · ‘- , - • · ‘- - ‘ , ·, ‘ ·” . ” • ‘ , , •·, ‘ , ·J , ·• • • - ‘ •-----‘·• , ·, •-• • • ‘‘ • ‘ ·a ‘. .-----‘ ··, • ·. ,- •·. 」 ·. ‘ ‘ • ‘ “ ‘ -υr + · - ‘ • ·····!‘ ‘ 「 + . •.----” ‘ . r ‘ ‘ · • ---+ •···.·, . , ., . ” . ‘. , ---‘ ,‘ , jr; ----‘ , , . •• --,• . ‘ •• , ‘ · ·. ·. ‘ ,, - - - - + • - • + ·r --------, . ‘ - ‘ • •.‘ ·‘ . “.... J υ , * ‘• ‘ •• ··, , . • ‘ , , -----‘ ‘ ‘ ‘ - ·. ·. - ‘ • -, • • ι ‘ . . • •• - - ·.‘ -• ” • . ··‘ η ν i | ‘ • ‘ ‘ ·. ·n ----‘ --” ‘ ·” ‘ ----, • . ·. ‘ , ·, ‘ ‘ . . . . ·” . ... ‘‘ · - , - ••- - ·, -‘ - .. . -- •·. ,. - - ·- - .- , ·‘‘ , ’*, ----,. ‘ “ ν -----+ , · ‘ ‘ ‘ ••• , ‘ - ·”. . ..‘ ‘ L ‘ . ‘ -, ... ‘ - + . • .. ‘ -- ‘ .. ·‘ -----, ‘ ---’ ·“ 「 “ --* . - ••• •• ---. ‘ , ·. - - 4 .‘ ‘ - 냐 , ·‘ ‘ ·”• ---, , , ··‘ ι ‘ , • , - ·, , - ’•. -Jr - •- ---·’ ’ ” ‘ ‘• ‘ , -, ‘ , •, ·’--------, υ • ·”·’ ---’, ‘사 ‘, • • •·. •• -----’ , • ” ·-------‘ ·* ..” ‘ ‘ , .• . • ·‘ . “ · j , , ‘ ‘ · ---‘ ·‘ .,·’,‘ ., •. · i • .• ‘ * ‘·• ‘ ‘ ‘ ’ • ·”‘ ” , * i • ‘ .. , ‘ • --• ·· ‘ - - ‘ ·•. ’ - - -’ - ’ .. ”·•‘ -------. - - - •. ---·‘ ----, -------, -- · ‘ ‘, , ‘ ••• ---’ ’ ‘ ·j “ .... ·L ” , . • . ‘ - ‘ + - ---. 、 . . ‘-. ‘ ‘ . , • , • ·, “ , ----] ·. ‘ ··. , . , ‘ ··’. ,. · ·’ ‘ , , , ” , ·iμ ··’ jr --·,· ’ --- •• ‘, ‘ ·‘ . --.. --’ ---- ·‘ . ‘ , , , ι ‘ ‘ . ’ ‘ --i i -- . , , ·+ • ‘ . - •i • 』 -- , • -- }- .-·‘ ’ • r ‘ ι •‘ . . ,- - - ·• - - r- - . ‘ i ι · r i • ι r t . ···r i ι · · Jr ι a 1 . -. • U ? · . 1 . · · · ι ? “ i - · I 「 1 a · · 、 1 1 . 1 i 1i / I . ·. i a • 1 · i a ι jr r 」 .. i 4 r u i 1 . ·. . i 1 i ·, · · ] · 「 . ·. i ·’ 1 ! i ~ L • • .---·k Jr --, ? 1 li i 1 •• 1 ι ι ... j J • • • ‘ ’ ‘ ‘ j . • i n n ‘ i FIG 8 l SAMNDCA00373600

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?