Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1291

Statement (Joint) Regarding Use of Representative Products at Trial by Samsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation). (Attachments: #1 Declaration, #2 Exhibit, #3 Exhibit, #4 Exhibit, #5 Exhibit, #6 Exhibit, #7 Exhibit)(Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 7/23/2012)

EXHIBIT 1

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL – ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
SAN JOSE DIVISION

APPLE INC.,
Case No. 11-CV-01846-LHK
V.

SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.,
SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA,
INC. AND SAMSUNG
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA, LLC

EXPERT REPORT OF JEFFREY JOHNSON, PH.D.
REGARDING NON-INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. PATENT NO. 7,469,381

02198.51855/4689328.4

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL – ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
68.

In devices with blue glow, when the user

Contacts Feature 1: Blue glow.

attempts to translate the list past the edge of the document, the user encounters a hard stop but a
blue glow is overlaid near the edge of the document.

No area beyond the edge of the electronic

document is displayed, and no translation of the document occurs in the second direction.
Because devices with Contacts that include Contacts Feature 1 (blue glow) do not display an area
beyond the edge of the electronic document and do not translate the electronic document in a
second direction, they do not infringe the independent claims of the ’381 Patent.
Browser
At least 3 Non-infringing Features in Browser
Product

Android

Feature

Version

1

1

Exhibit 4G
Galaxy Ace

2.3.4

3

Galaxy S II

2.3.5

4

Galaxy Tab 7.0

2.2

5

Galaxy Tab 10.1

3.1

6

Gravity Smart

3

2.3.3

2

2

69.

X
X

X
X

2.2.2

Browser Feature 1: Hard Stop.

When the user attempts to translate the

webpage past the edge of the document, the user encounters a hard stop. No area beyond the
edge of the electronic document is displayed, and no translation of the document occurs in the
second direction when the finger is lifted off. Because devices with Browser that include
Browser Feature 1 (hard stop) do not display an area beyond the edge of the electronic document
and do not translate the electronic document in a second direction, they do not infringe the
independent claims of the ’381 Patent.

02198.51855/4689328.4

Page 24

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL – ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
70.

Browser Feature 2: “Escapable” Scroll lock. In devices with Browser Feature

2 (“escapable” scroll lock), when the user initially begins movement of her finger in a near
vertical or horizontal direction, Browser locks the translation of the webpage into constrained
vertical or horizontal translation. However, if the user’s finger movement deviates sufficiently
from vertical or horizontal respectively, then the initial scroll lock is broken and the webpage
then tracks the user’s finger, unconstrained in two dimensions.

As described below,

applications running in two-dimensional mode without a constraint on translation of the
document do not meet both “first direction” limitations of the claims of the ’381 Patent, and
consequently do not infringe the ’381 Patent.
71.

Browser Feature 3: Blue Glow. In devices with blue glow, when the user

attempts to translate the webpage past the edge of the document, the user encounters a hard stop
but a blue glow is overlaid near the edge of the document.

No area beyond the edge of the

electronic document is displayed, and no translation of the document occurs in the second
direction. Because devices with Browser that include Browser Feature 3 (blue glow) do not
display an area beyond the edge of the electronic document and do not translate the electronic
document in a second direction, they do not infringe the independent claims of the ’381 Patent.
ThinkFree Office
At least 2 Non-infringing Features in ThinkFree Office Application

Product

TFO

Version

Feature
1

2

1

Continuum

2.0.0810.01

X

2

Droid Charge

2.0.110222

X

3

Epic 4G

2.0.110222

X

4

Exhibit 4G

2.0.110222

X

5

Fascinate

2.0.0604.01

02198.51855/4689328.4

Page 25

X

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL – ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
6

Galaxy Ace

7

Galaxy Prevail

2.0.110919

X

8

Galaxy S (i9000)

2.0.110222

X

9

Galaxy S 4G

2.0.111005

10

Galaxy S Showcase (i500)

2.0.110222

X

11

Galaxy Tab 7.0

2.0.0604.01

X

12

Indulge

2.0.1115.01

X

13

Intercept

2.0.1115.01

X

14

Mesmerize

2.0.0810.01

15

Replenish

2.0.110222

X

16

Sidekick

2.0.110222

X

72.

NO TFO

X

ThinkFree Office Feature 1: Vertical layout of pages. When ThinkFree Office

display pages of a PDF document in a vertical layout, there is no snapping behavior observed on
any of the edges.

Rather, the user encounters a hard stop on all of the external edges.

No area

beyond the edge of the electronic document is displayed, and no translation of the document
occurs in the second direction.

Because devices with ThinkFree Office that include ThinkFree

Office Feature 1 (Vertical layout of pages) do not display an area beyond the edge of the
electronic document and do not translate the electronic document in a second direction, they do
not infringe the independent claims of the ’381 Patent.
73.

ThinkFree Office Feature 2: Horizontal layout of pages.

When ThinkFree

Office displays pages of a PDF document in a horizontal layout, the behavior of ThinkFree
Office is similar to Gallery Feature 1. General snapping behavior is observed on all right and left
edges of pages except the left edge of the first page and right edge of the last page. Because the
Court has interpreted the ’381 Patent claims to require ’381 Style Snap-back on all potentially
scrollable edges, devices with ThinkFree Office that include ThinkFree Office Feature 2
(Horizontal layout of pages) do not infringe the ’381 Patent.

02198.51855/4689328.4

Page 26

HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL – ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER
74.

In the table below, I indicate which non-infringing features I observed in the

accused applications in the accused devices:
Product

Gallery

Contacts

Browser

ThinkFree
Office

1

2

3

4

1

1

2

3

1

2

1

Captivate

X

X

2

Continuum

X

X

X

3

Droid Charge

X

X

X

4

Epic 4G

5

Exhibit 4G

X

X

6

Fascinate

X

X

X

7

Galaxy Ace

X

X

NO TFO

8

Galaxy Prevail

9

Galaxy S (i9000)

10

Galaxy S II

X

X

11

Galaxy S 4G

X

X

12

Galaxy S Showcase (i500)

X

13

Galaxy Tab 7.0

X

14

Galaxy Tab 10.1

X

15

Gravity Smart

X

X

16

Gem

17

Indulge

X

X

18

Infuse 4G

X

X

19

Intercept

20

Mesmerize

X

X

21

Nexus S

X

X

22

Nexus S 4G

X

X

23

Replenish

X

X

X

24

Sidekick

X

X

X

25

Vibrant

X

X

X

X
X

X
X

X

X

X
X
X
X
X

X

X

X

X

X

X

™ 4 non-infringement features in the Gallery Application:
¾ Feature 1: general snapping behavior (See Exhibit 3)
¾ Feature 2: hold still (See Exhibit 4)
¾ Feature 3: hard stop (See Exhibit 5)
02198.51855/4689328.4

X

Page 27