Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 662

EXHIBITS re #660 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Apple Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Exhibits to Mueller Declaration ISO Apple's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment [660-9] filed byApple Inc.(a California corporation). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 26, #2 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 27, #3 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 28, #4 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 29, #5 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 30, #6 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 31, #7 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 32, #8 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 33, #9 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 34, #10 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 35, #11 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 36, #12 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 37, #13 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 38, #14 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 39, #15 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 40, #16 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 41)(Related document(s) #660 ) (Selwyn, Mark) (Filed on 1/25/2012)

Mueller Exhibit 40

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 04 - 08 April, 2005

R1-050369

Agenda item

3

Title:

Approved report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #40 in Scottsdale
(Scottsdale, AZ, USA, 14- 18 February, 2005)

Document for:
Source:

TSG RAN WG1 Secretary

Notes:
All timestamps in this document are in GMT-7Hunless otherwise noted.

Fact Summary
Meeting:
Dates:
Venue:
Host:
Attendees:
Documents:

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #40
14th through 18th February, 2005
Embassy Suites Hotel Phoenix - Scottsdale, Scottsdale, AZ, USA
The North American Friends of 3GPP
81 delegates
195 (including some withdrawn and post-meeting artefacts)

Yoshikazu Ishii
ETSI Mobile Competence Center
[e-mail]

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011016

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Table of contents
Executive summary ......................................................................................................................................

1

1 Opening of the meeting ..............................................................................................................................
1.1
Call for IPR ..................................................................................................................................................

2
2

2

Approval of the agenda .......................................................................................................................

2

3.

Approval of the minutes from previous meetings .................................................................................

2

4.

Summary from TSG RAN#26 .............................................................................................................

3

5.

Liaison statement handling ..................................................................................................................

4

6.
6.1
6.2
6.3
6.4
6.5

Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6 ...............................................................................................
R99 CRs + shadow CRs ...............................................................................................................................
Rel4 CRs + shadow CRs ..............................................................................................................................
Rel5 CRs + shadow CRs ..............................................................................................................................
Rel6 CRs (if not covered by other agenda item) ............................................................................................
Other ...........................................................................................................................................................

6
6
6
6
6
7

7.

MBMS UE capability ........................................................................................................................

9

8.

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation (FDD) ....................................................... 10

9.
9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4
9.5
9.6
9.6.1
9.6.2
9.6.3
9.6.4
9.6.5

FDD Enhanced Uplink ....................................................................................................................
Reporting from the conference calls on Enhanced Uplink ............................................................................
Timing, HARQ and Scheduling ..................................................................................................................
Measurements for RRM .............................................................................................................................
LIE categories (TS 25.306) .........................................................................................................................
Interaction with other features ....................................................................................................................
Enhanced Uplink CRs on the specifications ................................................................................................
CRs for TS 25.211 ................................................................................................................................
CRs for TS 25.212 ................................................................................................................................
CRs for TS 25.213 ................................................................................................................................
CRs for TS 25.214 ................................................................................................................................
CRs for TS 25.215 ................................................................................................................................

13
15
16
21
23
24
25
25
27
28
28
29

10.

IMS (RAB support enhancement work item) ...................................................................................

30

11.

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation (3.84 Mcps TDD) ......................................31

12.

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation (1.28 Mcps TDD) ......................................32

13.

Work Item on 7.68 Mcps TDD ..........................................................................................................

33

14.

Study Item on TDD Enhanced Uplink ...............................................................................................

34

15.

Review of RAN WG1 Terms of Reference ........................................................................................

35

16.

Other Business ................................................................................................................................

35

17.

Closing of the meeting : Friday 5.00 PM ...........................................................................................

36

Annex A:

List of participants ..................................................................................................................

37

Annex B:

TSG RAN WG1 meetings in 2005 ..........................................................................................

40

Annex C:

List of CRs agreed at RANI#40 ..............................................................................................

41

Annex D:

List of Outgoing LSs to 3GPP other groups .............................................................................

43

Annex E:

List of Tdocs at RAN1 #40 .....................................................................................................

44

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011017

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Executive summary
WG RAN1 #40 took place in Embassy Suites Hotel Phoenix - Scottsdale, AZ, USA. The meeting started at 9:00 on
Monday 14al February 2005 and finished at 16:00 on Friday 18th.
On Monday, "Maintenance of R99-Rel. 6", "MBMS UE capability", and "Optimisation of downlink channelisation code
(FDD) were discussed. Regarding "Optimization of downlink channelization code", the set of CR for TS25.211-215 was
agreed.
Through Tuesday to Thursday, "FDD Enhanced Uplink" was mainly discussed. Timing/HARQ/Scheduling issues, UE
capabilities, and compressed mode for EDCH were discussed and then more than ten CRs were agreed. Additionally,
RAN1/2/3/4 joint session regarding RRM EDCH was held on Wednesday evening.
The number of contribution documents for this meeting was 190, and those documents were categorized as followed.

16
14
Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6
MBMS UE Capability
8
8
Optimisation of downlink channelisation code (FDD)
25
19
FDD Enhanced Uplink
105
85
IMS(RAB support enhancement work item)
1
1
Optimisation of downlink channelisation code (3.84 Mcps
4
3
T.~[?) .................................................................................................................................................................................
Optimisation of downlink channelisation code (1.28 Mcps
2
2
~:[?.D.) .................................................................................................................................................................................
Work Item on 7,68 Mcps TDD
4
2
Study Item on TDD Enhanced Uplink
5
4
Note: The w-ithdrawn and revised documents were counted in the numbers of document on this table.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011018

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

1 Opening of the meeting
1410212005 09:05
The RAN1 Chairman, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger and welcomed the participants to the 40th RAN WG1 and opened the
meeting at 09.05am.
Mr. Donald E. Zelmer from Singular Wireless LLC welcomed the delegates on behalf of the North American Friends of
3 GPP.

1.1

Call for IPR

14/02/2005 09:05

The Chairman drew attention to Members’ obligations under the 3GPP Parmer Organizations’
IPR policies. Every Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Parmer
Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the Individual
Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become essential to the work of 3GPP.
The attention of the members of this Technical Specification Group is drawn to the fact that 3GPP
Individual Members have the obligation under the IPR Policies of their respective Organizational Partners
to inform their respective Organizational Partners of Essential IPRs they become aware of.
The members take note that they are hereby invited:
¯

to investigate in their company whether their company does own IPRs which are, or are likely to become
Essential in respect of the work of the Technical Specification Group.

¯

to notif~v the Director-General, or the Chairman of their respective Organizational Partners, of all
potential IPRs that their company may own, by means of the IPR Statement and the Licensing declaration
forms (e.g. see the ETSI IPR forms http://webapp.etsi.org/Ipr/).

Approval of the agenda

2

R1-050035 Draft Agenda

(RAN1 Chairman)

14/02/2005 09:10 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
The Mr. Chairman informed about the discussion in this week.
Decision: This document was approved.

Approval of the minutes from previous meetings

3.

R1-050040 DRAFT Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #39

(RAN1 Secretary)

14/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Mr. Yoshikazu Ishii.
Decision: This document was approved in Tdoc R1-050180.

R1-050180
R1-050075

Approved Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #39
DRAFT Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG2 #45

(RAN1 Secretary)
(RAN2 Secretary)

14/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Mr. Yoshikazu Ishii.
Decision: This document was approved just on RAN1/2 Joint session topic in 12.2.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011019

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Summary from TSG RAN#26
R1-050041

Summary from TSG RAN#26

(RAN1 Chairman)

14/02/2005 09:25 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Mr. Chairman informed about the discussion and decision regarding the last plenary meeting. At last plenary
meeting, in addition to the normal discussion, the big topics "UTRAN evolution" was discussed a~d then the
process of this topic and SI were approved. As the topic related to RAN1, MIMO was approved to postpone until
RAN#28.
As the other information, the WG1 election will be held at the WGs co-located meeting in May.
Decision: This document was noted.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011020

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Liaison statement handling
R1-050036

Reply LS on parameter set for PS streaming reference radio bearer combination
with downlink rate up to 128 kbps (To ; T1, Cc ; RAN1)
(WG RAN2)

14/02/2005 09:30 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050037

Reply LS on Synchronisation of FDD MBMS P-t-M Transmissions from
Clusters of Cells (To ; RAN3, Cc ; RAN1, RAN4)
(WG RAN2)

14/02/2005 09:35 Presented by Mr. Mark Harrison.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050038

LS on Layer 1 synchronization procedure (To ; RAN1, Cc ; RAN3, RAN4)
(WG RAN2)

14/02/2005 09:35 Presented by Mrs. Ning He.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050039

LS on Radio link failure criteria on Fractional DPCH
(To ; RAN3, RAN4, Cc ; RAN1)

(WG RAN2)

14/02/2005 09:40 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050123 LS on Details on MCCH (To ; RAN4, Cc ; RAN1)
14/02/2005 09:40 Presented by Mr. Elias Jonsson.

(WG RAN2)

Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions on how to pick up the information from MCCH.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050124

LS on reference cell in SFN-SFN observed time difference measurement
(To : RAN1, Cc : RAN2)
(WG T1)

14/02/2005 09:45 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Discussion (Question / Comment): From Panasonic, it was informed that there is and contribution to this topics.
From Nortel, it was commented that it should be confirmed whether the other WG spec (RAN4) have CRs or not in
addition to TS25.215.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050125

LS on modified parameters for 5.9 speech radio bearer 6.10.2.4.1.9 in 34.108
(WG T1)

(To ; RAN1, RAN2)
14/02/2005 09:55 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that RAN2 discussion should be checked.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050175

LS on the measurements required for EDCH congestion control (To : RAN1,
Cc : RAN2, RAN4)
(WG RAN3)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This LS was noted at RAN1/2/3/4 joint session on RRM EDCH.

R1-050199 LS on alignment of MBMS transport channels (To : RAN1, RAN2) (WG RAN3)
18/02/2005 09:10 Presented by Dr. Joern Krause (Siemens).
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to send the reply LS indicating that no significant impact on
RAN1 specifications is expected with an intxoduction of an SFN-MFN offset (no impact with introduction of ma
SFN-CFN offset) that would lead to alignment of TTI starting times and the proposed solution CFN mod2 = 0 is
not preferred in Tdoc R1-050214.
R1-050214 [DRAFT] Reply LS on alignment of MBMS transport channels (Siemens)
18/02/2005 12:20 Presented by Dr. Joern Krause.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011021

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This draft LS was approved with modification in Tdoc R1-050221

R1-050221 Reply LS on alignment of MBMS transport channels

(WG-RAN1)

R1-050211 LS on Layer 1 synchronization procedure (To ; RAN1, Cc ; RAN3, RAN4)
(WG RAN3)
18/02/2005 09:35 Presented by Ms. Ning He.

Decision: This document was noted.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011022

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

6.

Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6

6.1

R99 CRs + shadow CRs

R1-050110

25.215CR150rl(ReI99, C),CR151rl(Rel-4, A), CR152rl(Rel-5, A), CR153rl(Rel-6,
A) "Removal of TGPL2"
(Ericsson, Samsung)

14/02/2005 10:00 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that t~ere was a concerning for the removal on R99.
Decision: ~ii~ii~iiI~ii~~i~. The decision on release will be taken at next RAN meeting.

6.2

Rel4 CRs + shadow CRs

6.3

Rel5 CRs + shadow CRs

R1-050113

25.214CR365(Rel-5, F), CR366(Rel-6, A) "Correction to computed gain factors
quantization"
(QUALCOMM Europe)

14/02/2005 10:05 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): From Philips and Vodafone, it was commented that this issue is not sure to
rely on from network side and so it should be checked by network manufacture side. Also there are some comments
and question for the motivation and benefit of this issue.
Decision: It was decided to revisit this topic after the offline discussion. In last day, from Qualcomm Europe, the
following "Way forward" was proposal.

Way forward proposal: Agreed Rel5 CR, but not Rel6 CR, principle agreement to increase the gain factor
resolution from Rel6 onward (CR to be brought to RAN#40bis)
Final decision: Relation to RAN4 specification should be checked w.r.t accuracy requirement and also whether the
objective of the CRs is already possible with the current specifications. Companies cma raise concerns on the CR
over the RAN1 refletor before the RAN meeting. ~iiNli~iiN~iiN~ ~.
After the meeting, Lucent raised some concerns for Rel-5 CR on the RAN1 reflector.

Not Treated
R1-050171 UE behavior in DPCH frame offset reconfiguration

6.4

(Intel)

Rel6 CRs (if not covered by other agenda item)

R1-050099 25.214CR354r2(Rel-6, C)"Timing maintained Hard Handover"

(Ericsson)

14/02/2005 11 : 10 Presented by Mrs. Ning He.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some questions and comments on the behaviour on non-timing
maintained handover, how to recognize between timing maintained and non-timing maintained handover. From
Notre1, it was commented that from the influence of the issue should be checked from RAN3 aspects.
Decision: It was decided to discuss more from viewpoint of"Node B indication needed?". This CR was revised in
Tdoc R1-050201.
R1-050201 25.214CR354r3(Rel-6, C)"Timing maintained Hard Handover"
18/02/2005 09:40 Presented by Ms. Ning He.

(Ericsson)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~i~i~l For RAN plenary, MCC adds 25.433 to the cover page.

R1-050100 25.214CR355rl(Rel-6, B)"Faster L1 DCH synchronization"

(Ericsson)

14/02/2005 11:50 Presented by Ms. Ning He.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011023

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented regarding the relation to the RAN4 specification
Decision: It was decided to replace Qpost with Qont, and should be reconfirm with RAN2 about indication of the
post-sync-failure (depends on RAN2 discussion). Revision 2 of the CR in tdoc R1-050173. Draft an LS to RAN4 in
todc R1-050174.

R1-050173 25.214CR355r2(Rel-6, B)"Faster L1 DCH synchronization"
18/02/2005 09:50 Presented by Ms. Ning He.

(Ericsson)

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that L1 specification can not distinguish the content and
information, so this issue may depend on RAN2.
Decision: ~i~i~i~.’:~I~i~i~i~i~i~:. ¯ ............ .:................’:. ~. If RAN2 comes to another conclusion, the CR
text shall be updated accordingly.

R1-050174 Draft LS on Faster L1 DCH synchronization

(Ericsson)

18/02/2005 09:55 Presented by Ms. Ning He.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

R1-050216 LS on Faster L1 DCH synchronization (To : RAN4)
R1-050082

(WG RAN1)

25.215CR154(Rel-6, F)"Clarification of cell on SFN-SFN observed time
difference"
(Panasonic)

14/02/2005 12:00 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment): From Mr. Chairman, it was suggested that the set for the earlier release should
be prepared for the RAN Plenary.
Decision: ~ii~i~ii~i It was decided to consider possibility for CRs to the earlier releases (R99...) at
RAN Plenary as company proposal.

R1-050096

25.224CR140r2(Rel-6, C) "Improvements to uplink closed-loop power control for
1.28Mcps TDD"
(IPWireless)

14/02/2005 12:20 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment): The CR was already agreed at the last meeting (RANl#39). Because the set of
CRs from other group was not available, the approval for the CRs was postpone at the last plenary. And also, the
version of specification was updated. As the results, this CR was checked for the new version of specification and
was changed on only the cover sheet.
Decision: ~ii~ii~ii~li The Category was changed from TEI6 to LCRTDD-Phys after meeting.

R1-050114 25.215CR147r4"Introduction of ’DL Transmission Branch Load’ measurement"
(Siemens)
14/02/2005 12:15 Presented by Dr. Joel Krause.
Discussion (Question / Comment): The CR was already agreed at the last meeting (RANl#39). Because the set of
CRs from other group was not available, the approval for the CRs was postpone at the last plenary. And also, the
version of specification was updated. As the results, this CR was checked for the new version of specification and
was changed on only the cover sheet.
Decision: ~ii~i~:... ~ii~i

6.5

Other

R1-050154 AMR-WB reference RAB configurations
14/02/2005 12:20 Presented by Mr. Mark1~ Tarkiainen.

(Nokia)

Discussion (Question / Comment): From Vodafone It was asked why the SRB5 was not used
Decision: It was suggested to check PL 0.84 and why SRB5 is omitted.

R1-050205 AMR-WB reference RAB configurations
18/02/2005 1 o: 10 Presented by Mr. Mark1~ Tarkiainen.

(Nokia)(Revision of R1-050154)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted. RAN 1 confirms the correctness of the RAN1 parameters.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011024

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005
R1-050153
R1-050172

Feature Clean-Up
Feature Clean-Up

14/02/2005 12:25 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.

R1-050369
(Nokia) (Withdrawn)
(Nokia, Motorola)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted. The decision on removal of features should be taken TSG RAN level. Hence
this part of the discussion is deferred to RAN#27.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011025

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

7.

R1-050369

MBMS UE capability

R1-050083 MBMS UE capability

(Panasonic)

14/02/2005 14:05 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was confirmed that 12kbps UE capability is the minimum but the technical
discussion should be made from 64kbps. It was asked if both of the capability poxt A and B are mandatory. The
answer to the question was Yes.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-050138 MBMS UE Capability for FDD

(Motorola)

14/02/2005 14:20 Presented by Mr. Mark Harrison.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
There are many discussion regarding "Number of TTI", "Maximum TTI", "Simultaneous reception of DL DPCH
and S-CCPCH". It was commented that "Maximum" should be removed from Table 4.X.2 because the relation of
the maximum TTI and number of TrCH is not cleox.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-050152 On MBMS UE Minimum Capability

(Nokia)

Decision: This document was noted with relation to R1-050083 and R1-050138.
It was decided to update Motorola proposal (R 1-050138) according to the discussion by considering as followed:
PhCH limitation (PhCH bits, codes), 1TrCH for soft combining (also for the whole cluster), 64kbps simultaneous
S-CCPCIq/DPCH, Keep or remove "MAX" TTI for the moment, could be limited to only one TTI per combination
provide that RAN2 has no objections (Revision in Tdoc R1-050176). And also it was decided to indicate TTI issue
together with the RAN1 parts of UE capabilities in an LS to RAN2 (Tdoc R1-050177). 1RL cluster and bitrates
higher that 256kbps seem to be supported within this specification.

R1-050176 MBMS UE Capability for FDD

(Motorola, Panasonic)

18/02/2005 10:20 Presented by Mr. Mark Harrison.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
For the finalization for the UE capabilities, how do we treat this working assumption. How do we convert to RAN2
specifications in this 2 weeks for RAN plenaxy. It should be this proposal to RAN2.
Decision: This document was noted. Include updated the proposal from176 (with limit on SCCPCH codes) and
indicate TTI issue together with the RAN1 pa~ts of UE capabilities in draft LS R1-050177.

R1-050177 LS on MBMS UE capability

(Panasonic, Motorola)

18/02/2005 15:50 Presented by Mr. Mark Harrison
Discussion (Question / Comment):

Decision: N~i~.i~i.~i~.iN~ with modification on "Overall description" in Tdoc R1-050222.
R1-050222 LS on MBMS UE capability (To : RAN2, RAN3, RAN4)

(WG RAN1)

R1-050092 TTI reordering with measurement gaps of 10 and 20 ms

(Siemens)

14/02/2005 15:30 Presented by Dr. Juergen Michel.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that how the RAN4 part is specified. There were some
comments regarding how to switch off the power.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050093 Draft LS on TTI reordering
14/02/2005 15:30 Presented by Dr. Juergen Michel.

(Siemens)

Decision: The gain would be usable when the network does not utilise fiae freedom in scheduling provided by
selection combining. Amount of gain would need to be compared to what is achievable using by MSCH properly. It
was postponed to next meeting with waiting for RAN4 feed back.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011026

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code
utilisation (FDD)

R1-050150 F-DPCH simulation results

(Nokia)

14/02/2005 16:40 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked if the simulation for the UE speed 120km was done. The answer
to the question was that not yet. The other question was that the both of option 1 and 2 were mandatory or not. To
the question, there are no differences for both options from implementation viewpoint. There was the other question
regarding the definition of Ec/Ior in fig. 2. The answer to the question was that Ec/Ior is the average of one slot.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050151 F-DPCH operation in SHO

(Nokia)

14/02/2005 17:10 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranto-aho,
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some comments regarding the timing reference.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050128 Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field
14/02/2005 16:55 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.

(Philips)

Discussion (Question / Comment): There was a comment about the problem when the TPC power is weak.
Decision: This document was noted

Conclusion:
1. F-DPCH shall be mandatory for UEs supporting HSDPA
2. Only one slot format : 2TPC bits, without pilots
3. Phase reference other than P-CPICH.

R1-050098 F-DPCH Downlink Power control
14/02/2005 17:25 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

(Ericsson)

Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions regarding the motivation and benefit for this new
requirement. There are commented that the power offset is useful way from RAN3 specifications.
Decision: This document was noted.

10

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011027

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Conclusion:
Or of down shall be applied together with a quality criteria (to be defined by RAN4), network should ensure that
reliable TPC commands reach the UE. Whether to satisf~v all RL with DL QoS target is FFS. Use of PO could
simplif~v RAN3 specifications (assuming that the offsets are the same if pilots are used).

R1-050066 Optimization of Outer Loop Power Control for F-DPCH
(Top Optimized Technologies)
14/02/2005 17:45 Presented by Mr. Alfonso Campo.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked what the gain of this method.
Decision: This document was noted. Outer loop convergence should not be a problem fro F-DPCH

R1-050129 CR25.211-200 (Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips, Nokia)
14/02/2005 18:25 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
This CR was based on Nortel CR (R1-050079).
Decision: This CR was minor-revised in Tdoc R1-050178.

R1-050178 CR25.211-200rl (Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips, Nokia)
15/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
Decision:

(Nortel)

R1-050080 25.212CR193rl(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
14/02/2005 18:30 Presented by Ms. Evelyne Le Strat.
This document is just copy of the last meting for the current version specification.
Decision: ~i~i~NNi

(Nortel)

R1-050081 25.213CR70rl(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
14/02/2005 18:35 Presented by Ms. Evelyne Le Strat.
This document is just copy of the last meting for the current version specification.
Decision:

R1-050132 CR25.214-368 (Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips, Nokia)
14/02/2005 18:35 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
This CR was based on Nortel CR (R1-050076).
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked if the Qout/Qin is same for F-DPCH and DPCH.
Decision: Qin/Qout kept for FDPCH, but separate parameters might be added in case RAN4 considers if necessary.
It was decided to include the text from Tdoc R1-050098 (exclude part on multiple RL QoS ~The UE shall run a
quality target control loop such that t~e quality requirement is met for each radio link set.") Revision in R1-050179.

R1-050179 CR25.214-368rl(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips, Nokia)
15/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
Decision:

R1-050184 [Draft] LS on Introduction of Fractional DPCH (Philips, Nokia, Nortel, Ericsson)
16/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
Discussion (Question / Comment): From Panasonic, Outer loop Power control for F-DPCH, already fixed value?
It is RAN4 task. So discussed with RAN4. Add sentence ~RAN1 also asks RAN4 to consider with what granularity
a signalled TPC error rate target could be followed by the UE"
Decision:
with addition of sentence ~RAN1 also asks RAN4 to consider with what
granularity a signalled TPC error rate target could be followed by the UE" in Tdoc R1-050191.

N .i i.NNiN .iN

R1-050191 LS on Introduction of Fractional DPCH (To : RAN2, RAN3, RAN4) (WG-RAN1)

11

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011028

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005
R1-050133

R1-050369

CR25.215-155 (Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips, Nokia)

14/02/2005 18:50 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
This CR was based on Nortel CR (R1-050077).
Decision:
R1-050076 25.214CR357r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
Decision: This document was noted

(Nortel)

R1-050077 25.215CR148r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
Decision: This document was noted

(Nortel)

R1-050079 25.211CR194r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "

(Nortel)

Decision: This document was noted

R1-050047

Addition of support for BTFD in flexible position multiplexing of transport
channels (include CR)
(Mitsubishi Electric ; MMCE)

15/02/2005 09:30 Presented by Mr. Vincent BELAICHE.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked if it is required to change the RAN2 specification. The answer to
the question was No. Some comments were that this feature in the specification can not arrive to the finalization by
this March, that is the deadline of the Re1.6.
Decision: This document was noted. As the conclusion of the R1-050047 and R1-050048, there was no agreement
from the group to introduce this feature in the specifications.

R1-050048 Gain of BTFD in flexible position multiplexing of transport channels
(Mitsubishi Electric ; MMCE)
15/02/2005 09:30 Presented by Mr. Vincent BELAICHE.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

Conclusion
No agreement from the group to introduce this feature in the specifications.

R1-050042
R1-050043
R1-050044
R1-050045
R1-050046
R1-050130

25.211CR194r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
(Nortel) (Withdrawn)
25.212CR193rl(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
(Nortel) (Withdrawn)
25.213CR70rl(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
(Nortel) (Withdrawn)
25.214CR357r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
(Nortel) (Withdrawn)
25.215CR148r2(Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH "
(Nortel) (Withdrawn)
CR25.212-200 (Rel-6, B)"Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field"
(Philips) (Withdrawn)

12

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011029

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

9.

R1-050369

FDD Enhanced Uplink

The overview of FDD Enhanced Uplink discussion is as followed.

E DCH TT! [ms]

EtH!CH TT! [~s]

. . . . . . . . . . . i..:0, l

2
:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

t~O:l

!280 1
8Z6/

~02m in

max

tl 72 ~

/

DCH TT! [eN~]
DL T~I ~CNpS]
Ped~d [Chips]
UE P~oc time

38400
30720 ]
! 53600 ~
~

[slot]
Minimum

~o
~28°
876
1 ~72

7680
?680
6] 440

8.34] 5.34

Maximum

1!.36~

UE Proc time [ms]

8.36

13

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011030

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

14

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011031

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

TS
25.211
25.211
25.211
25.212
25.212
25.213
25.213
25.214
25.214
25.214

CR
197
198
202
198
199
72
73
362
364
369

R
1
1
2
1
1
2
1
2

C
Tdoc
F R1-050182
F R1-050195
F R1-050223
F R1-050194
C R1-050108
F R1-050064
F R1-050204
F R1-050215
F R1-050198
F R1-050224

R1-050369

Title
E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences
E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequence Hopping
E-HICH/E-RGCH/E-AGCH timing
PLnon-max and PLmax
HARQ bit collection for E-DCH
Correction on E-DPCCH power offset
Defining E-DPDCH power offset
Gain factor setting for E-DCH
Reliable E-RGCH/E-HICH Detection
DL/UL timing association of E-DCH operation

R1-050057 TR25.808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Layer Aspects, vl.0.1 (Editor : Nokia)
15/02/2005 11:05 Presented by ]V[r. Karri Ranta-a~o.
Decision: This document was agreed as version 1.1.0 in Tdoc R1-050188.

R1-050188 TR25.808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Layer Aspects, vl.l.0 (Editor : Nokia)
R1-050231 TR25.808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Layer Aspects, v2.0.0 (Editor : Nokia)
This document was submitted to RAN#27 for approval.

Reporting from the conference calls on Enhanced Uplink

9.1

R1-050049 Minutes from RAN1 Conference Call #1 on Scheduling and HARQ
(RAN1 Chairman)
15/02/2005 11 : 15 Presented by ]V[r. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050050

Minutes from RAN1 Conference Call #2 on NodeB measurements and interaction
with RNC admission/congestion control and RRM with EUL (RAN1 Chairman)

15/02/2005 11 : 15 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Decision: This document was noted on R1/2/3/4 joint session.

R1-050051 Minutes from RAN1 Conference Call #3 on UE categories for EUL
(RAN1 Chairman)
15/02/2005 11 : 15 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Decision: This document was noted.

15

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011032

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

9.2

R1-050369

Timing, HARQ and Scheduling

Timing & number of HARQ processes
R1-050145 E-AGCH Timing

(NTT DoCoMo)

15/02/2005 11 : 15 Presented by Mr. Anil Umesh.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are many discussions on this contribution. From NTT DoCoMo, it was
commented that this contribution is for the efficient HS-PDSCH power allocation not to waste the txansmission
power resource.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050073 Relative timing of downlink signaling channels for E-DCH

(Nortel)

15/02/2005 11:45 Presented by Ms. Evelyne Le Strat.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050078 E-DCH timing

(Lucent Technologies)

15/02/2005 12:15 Presented by Dr. Rainer Bachl.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050105
R1-050186

E-DCH Downlink Timing Relations
E-DCH Downlink Timing Relations

(Ericsson)
(Ericsson)(Revised from R1-050105)

15/02/2005 13:40 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050134
R1-050181

E-HICH timing relationship
E-HICH timing relationship

(Siemens) (=R1-050010)
(Siemens) (Revised from R1-050134)

15/02/2005 13:50 Presented by Dr. Thomas Chapman.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050056 Timing of E-HICH and number of HARQ processes

(ZTE)

15/02/2005 14:00 Presented by Mr. Wang Chen.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050070 Timing and the number of HARQ processes for HSUPA

(LG Electronics)

15/02/2005 14:10 Presented by Mr. Joon-Kui Aim.

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-050087 EUL timing and the number of HARQ processes
15/02/2005 14:20 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.

(Panasonic)

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that the Node B process has several calculation as
compared with HSDPA.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050165 Number of HARQ processes & DL timing

(QUALCOMM Europe)

15/02/2005 14:30 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050063 Number of HARQ processes

(Samsung)

15/02/2005 14:50 Presented by Mr. Yongjun Kwak
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050074 Number of H-ARQ processes for E-DCH

(Nortel)

15/02/2005 15:00 Presented by Ms. Evelyne Le Strat.

16

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011033

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked if the number of HARQ process is configurable, that is, has 2
options. The answer to the question was that flae best way is one (fixed), but the comfigurable number is better from
Network side.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050131 Number of HARQ processes

(Siemens) (Revised from R1-050010)

15/02/2005 15:10 Presented by Dr. Thomas Chapman.
Decision: This document was noted.
On oft-line discussion, the different proposals from different companies were summarized and the summary was informed
from Nortel as follows:

1. E-AGCH
Nortel proposal
¯
RG based, 2ms TTI, per process : 2 ms
¯
RG based, 2ms TTI, per UE (AG applies to all processes): 2 ms
¯
Other cases : 2 or 10ms
o RG based, 10 ms TTI (per UE)
o Non RG based, 2ms TTI (does this case - RAN2??)
o Non RG based 10ms TTI
Ericsson/Panasonic/Qualcomm/LG/Siemens/Samsung proposal (AGCH duration = TTI duration)
¯
RG based, 2ms TTI, per process : 2 ms
¯
RG based, 2ms TTI, per UE : 2ms (10ms AGCH would not be of interest as UL direction would be the
blocking direction,????)
¯
RG based, 10ms TTI (per UE) : 10ms
¯
Non RG based, 2ms : 2ms
¯
Non RG based 10ms : 10 ms
Questions:
¯
Does the 2ms non RG based case apply ??
¯
If 2ms non RG based apply, can we mix 2ms and 10ms UEs in the same group ?

2. E-RGCH for non serving cell
Nortel proposal
¯
Non RG based : 2 or 10ms, probably one value only to be decided (depending on multi-bit overload)
¯
RG based : 2 or 10ms, probably one value only to be decided (depending on hysterisis)
Generally : one value independently from TTI length possibly dependent on the scheduling type
Ericsson
¯
10 ms only ??
Question:
Would 2ms lead to a power problem if the objective is to be received at cell edge.
Should we have the same non serving RG duration for RG based and non RG based ?
Panasonic ?

3. E-RGCH for serving cell
Nortel proposal
2ms independently of TTI length
LG proposal
2ms TTI : 2ms RGCH
10ms TTI : 2ms E-RGCH (TDM)
Ericsson/Panasonic proposal
2ms for 2ms TTI
10ms for 10ms TTI
Question : is power so much of a problem for E-HICH and E-RGCH ?

4. E-HICH
Nortel proposal
2ms TTI : 2ms E-HICH
10 ms TTI (2 cases identical from HARQ process numbers)
¯
2ms E-HICH (TDM) (no reduction of RTT)
¯
10 ms E-HICH

17

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011034

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Siemens : 10ms TTI, 2ms E-HICH, "best" 2ms selected for RTT reduction.
LG proposal
2ms TTI : 2ms E-HICH
10 ms TTI : 2ms E-HICH (TDM) (no reduction of RTT)
Ericsson/Panasonic/Samsung/Qualcomm/Nokia proposal
2ms for 2ms TTI
10ms for 10ms TTI
¯
¯
¯

if power is an issue : for 10 ms TTI : 10ms E-HICH and 10 ms E-RGCH
if power is "no" issue, RTT is not big issues but sequence/code management is : 2ms E-HICH, 2ms ERGCH and TDM (selectable timing within 10ms frame)
if power is "no" issue, RTT is an issue and sequence management no big problem : 2ms E-HICH, 2ms
E-RGCH ("best" 2ms chosen within 10ms frame)

Discussion & Conclusion (Chairman’s note)
1. Relation ofEDCH TTI a~d Control channel duration
¯
AGCH
¯
RGCH(non-serving cell)
¯
RGCH(serving cell)
¯
HICH
Using the excel sheet form Qualcomm
¯
10EDCH TTI ¯ 8ms HICH, 4 processes (conditional to split in 203)
¯
2 EDCH TTI ¯ 2ms HICH, 8 processes (conditional to split in 203)
¯
Control channels are sub-frame aligned
¯
Timing and duration of RGCH (non-serving cell) ¯
~ Duration :~...o~/~ ox ~.-o°~ o o~ 10ms - consequence is that the channel timing is not linked to a particular LIE,
process or TTI length.
) Timing ¯ Offset 2 slots relative to PCCPCH of the non-serving cell
¯ Timing and duration of HICH
)
Duration : 2ms HICH for 2ms EDCH, 8ms HICH for 10ms EDCH
)
Timing ¯ Offset ~ 2 slots relative to PCCPCH (i. e. aligned with HS-PDSCH)
¯
Timing and duration of RGCH (serving cell) ¯
) Duration ¯ 2ms RGCH for 2ms EDCH, 8ms RGCH for 10ms EDCH (10ms EDCH ¯ ~8ms
RGCH~
~ Timing ¯ Off’set ~ 2 slots relative to PCCPCH(i.e. aligned with HS-PDSCH)
¯ Timing and duration ofAGCH ?
Duration
÷
RG based ¯ same as EDCH TTI i.e. 2ms or 10ms, ~-- - ~o-~ ~n---ox
% Non RG based ¯ 10ms AGCH, irrespective of EDCH TTI
Timing Offset 2 slots relative to PCCPCH (i.e. aligned wil~ HS-PDSCH)
The above agreement was captured in specification with the following CRs.

R1-050206 25.211CR202(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH/E-AGCH timing "
(Qualcomm Europe)
18/02/2005 11 : 15 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some editorial errors: The number of specification on the cover
sheet (214=>211), Double sub-clause 7.11.
Decision: This CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050217.

R1-050217 25.211CR202rl(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH/E-AGCH timing "
(Qualcomm Europe)
18/02/2005 14:00 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~ii~ii~ii~li After the meeting, this document was revised in Tdoc R1-050223.

18

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011035

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

R1-050223 25.211CR202r2(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH/E-AGCH timing "
(Qualcomm Europe)
Decision: ~i.~i.~i.~ on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting

R1-050207 25.214CR369(Rel-6, B)" DL/UL timing assoication of E-DCH operation "
(Qualcomm Europe)
18/02/2005 11:40 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that E-AGCH duration for EDCH 10ms TTI could be 8 and
10ms. Remove "Note"
Decision: This CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050218.

R1-050218 25.214CR369rl(Rel-6, B)" DL/UL timing assoication of E-DCH operation "
(Qualcomm Europe)
18/02/2005 14:05 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~i~ii~ii~li After the meeting, this document was revised in Tdoc R1-050224.

R1-050224 25.214CR369r2(Rel-6, B)" DL/UL timing assoication of E-DCH operation "
(Qualcomm Europe)
Decision: ~ii~ii~!~ii~ on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting.
2. Timing relation on Control channels
¯
All aligned (to SFN, HS-DSCH, or other)
¯
Some aligned
3. Timing resolution of Control channels
¯
3 slots, 1 slot, 15 slots
RGCHAtICH timing are aligned, rounded with a resolution of 3 slots and offset with a multiple of 3 slots + x
slots towards SFN.
AGCH is offset with a multiple of 3 slots + x slots towards SFN.
x=either 0 or 2 slots.
(i.e. ~.~r~ ....1;~ ,~;~, ~ v~,~m ^,~,~ ; .... ~r~ a!i~ned "~vith HS v~,~
=> need a little bit more discussion for the x
4. UE/NodeB processing times
¯
NodeB ¯
#HARQ processes for many possible combinations
¯
¯
¯
¯

2ms EDCH ¯ 6-11
10ms EDCH ¯ 3-5
Additional processes for SHO?
Configurable or fixed

For 10 ms E-DCH TTI:
1. 10ms E-HICH and 10 ms E-RGCH (#HARQ processes)
2. 2ms E-HICH, 2ms E-RGCH
¯
"best from RTT" 2ms within 10ms frame
UE processing time
¯

3ms(2ms and 10ms), max 2Mbps for 10ms)

¯

4 slots (2ms), 8slots/5.2ms (10ms)

¯

3 slots(2ms), 9slots/6ms (10ms)

19

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011036

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

¯

3 slots (2ms), 6 slots/4ms (10ms)

¯

Limit bitrate for 10ms to 2Mbps? 8 ms HICH?

From Qualcomm, the results of the offline discussion regarding the "Timing & HARQ" on Tuesday evening was informed
by using Table 9-1, and in Thursday afternoon by using Table 9-2 updated from Table 9-1.
Table 9-1

A10

Configu ration
# HARQ processes
E-DCH TTI [ms]
E-HICH TTI [ms]
tau_ec0 [256 chips]
Tec [ms]
Constants
RTT_max [chips]
To min
To max

A2

B10

B2

10
10
-60
2

UE Proc time [ms]

Minimum iiiiiiiiiiiiiii~I~ii~: ~ 14.912.9
Ma×imum I 6,2 4:2 I 6i9 4,9

10
10
-70
2

2
2
8O
2

1280
876
1172

Minimum :iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii~l~iii} ~ I 734 4.34
~
Ma×imum

2
2
90
2
1280
876
1172

1280
876
1172

1280
876
1172

9i36 6i36 11036 7.36

I

IIII

Table 9-2

Configuration

C10

# HARQ processes
E-DCH TTI [ms]
E-HICH TTI [ms]
tau_ec0 [256 chips]
Tec [ms]

C2

10

2

-50
2

70
2

1280
876
1172

1280
876
1172

38400
30720
153600

7680
7680
61440

Constants
RTT_max [chips]
To min
To max

Temp
DCH TTI [chips]
DL TTI [chips]
Period [chips]

Minimum,
Ma×imum

~
I I

8:34
11i36 8i36

UEProctime[ms]~ I
Maximum,,

I
7i57

2O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011037

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050111 HARQ Operation Point

R1-050369

(Siemens)

18/02/2005 15:00 Presented by Dr. Jurgen Michel.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050112 Retransmission Power Optimisation
18/02/2005 15:00 Presented by Dr. Jurgen Michel.

(Siemens)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050200 EUL performance with de-boosting on E-DPDCH

(QUALCOMM Europe)

18/02/2005 15:10 Presented by Dr. Durga Malladi
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some discussions regarding the scaling mismatch, RoT overshoot
results, and gain factor.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050210 EUL E-DPDCH De-boosting Result
18/02/2005 15:20 Presented by Mr. Robert Love.

(Motorola)

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050122 Draft LS on Control of HARQ Operation

(Siemens, Nokia, Philips)

18/02/2005 15:30 Presented by Dr. Jurgen Michel.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented from some company that we should sent the LS and ask
RAN2 to evaluate the complexity taking this scheme into consideration. Also from some companies, it was
commented that we have not convinced the real gain of this scheme and should be cleax.
Decision: No recommendation from RAN1 to go further with this feature.

Not Treated
R1-050052
R1-050053
R1-050067
R1-050095
R1-050118
R1-050119
R1-050120
R1-050136
R1-050147

9.3

Efficiency of DL ACK
(Via Telecom) (=R1-041410)
Selecting the Primary Node(s) for DL ACK
(Via Telecom) (=R1-041411)
UE behaviour on RG from Non-serving RLS
(Alcatel)
Definition and Signalling way of Time Duration
(Mitsubishi Electric)
Comparative performance of dedicated vs. autonomous mode
(Motorola)
Performance of EUL in Autonomous mode with and without hysteresis
(Motorola)
Performance of EUL with and without happy bit
(Motorola)
Relative Grant Step Size
(Siemens)
Control over serving vs. non-serving E-DCH resource allocation
(NTT DoCoMo)

Measurements for RRM

On the Wednesday (16th) evening, RAN1/2/3/4 joint session on E-DCH RRM was held. The following RAN 1
contributions were treated at the session.
R1-050155 RRM aspects of the Enhanced Uplink feature
(Vodafone Group)
16/02/2005 Presented by Mr. Ymmick Le Pezennec.

21

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011038

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050062 UTRAN measurement for E-DCH RRM

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 Presented by Dr. Juho Lee.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050069 Radio resource control and measurement for HSUPA

(LG Electronics)

16/02/2005 Presented by Dr. Joon-Kui Aim.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050088 Uplink EDCH/DCH resource allocation and measurement

(Panasonic)

16/02/2005 Presented by Dr Jinsong Duan.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050146 Measurement report of AG for common rate control (Autonomous ramping)
(NTT DoCoMo)
16/02/2005 Presented by Mr. Masafumi Usuda.
Decision: This document was noted.
The contributions from other WGs are as followed: R2-050348, R2-050397, R2-050436, R2-050437, R2-050438, R2050449, R2-050511, R3-050097, R3-050254(R1-050175), R3-050218, R4-050201.
As the decision of the joint session, RAN1 Chairman summarized as follows (Tdoc R1-050208).

R1-050208 Notes of Joint Session on RRM EDCH

(RAN1 Chairman)

Decision: This document was noted.

Discussion & Conclusion for Measurements for RRM (Chairman’s note)
Scheduler limits/targets
Set a limits to the NodeB & inaccuracy requirements for the scheduler
1. Total interference in the NodeB: RTWP or relative interference (e.g. RoT)
2. Power controlled part of the total interference or use of overload indicator triggering mechanism
(RAN1/RAN2 to discuss)

Inaccuracy of scheduler operation
=> RAN4 should investigate how accurate the scheduler can follow the targets set by the RNC in x% of the time

New Measurements for admission control
Non GBR E-DCH:
Nothing needed.
Non-scheduled GBR E-DCH:
RNC rules, same as for DCH?
GBR EDPDCH/DPCCH power ratio that is sent on AGCH? (reporting => RAN2)
Interference headroom that can be used for additional GBR users? (RAN1)
DCH:
Nothing needed in principle due to EUL.

Feasibility and accuracy of measurements
Not Treated
R1-050089
R1-050166
R1-050137
R1-050143

Long term solution for ping-pong effect
Measurement in support of RRM
RRM for E-DCH
Common measurement for E-DCH

(Panasonic)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(Siemens) (Withdrwn)
(NEC) (Not Available)

22

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011039

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

9.4

R1-050369

UE categories (TS 25.306)

R1-050094 Proposal of UE categories for the Enhanced Uplink
(Vodafone Group, NTT DoCoMo)
17/02/2005 09:55 Presented by Mr. Yannick Le Pezennec.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions regarding coding rate.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050106 E-DCH UE Categories

(Ericsson)

17/02/2005 10:10 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050121 UE Capability for EUL

(Motorola)

17/02/2005 10:15 Presented by Mr. Robert Love
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions regarding number of category and simultaneous
process, signalling for the LIE category. It was commented that the number of LIE categories could be reduced from
viewpoint of network.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050141 HSUPA UE Capabilities

(Nokia) (Revised from R1-050028)

17/02/2005 11:30 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-aho.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
From Samsung, limitation of DCH categories.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050167 E-DCH related UE categories

(QUALCOMM Europe)

17/02/2005 11:40 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Decision: This document was noted.
Discussion & Conclusion for UE categories (Chairman’s note)
1. Category definition (codes, TTI)
~ lxSF4, 2xSF4, 2xSF2, 2xSF2+2xSF4 =>Table 9-3

3. Joint with HSDPA or separate capabilities ->RAN2
4. SRB on EDCH->RAN2
Mr. RAN1 chairman drafted the category candidates as shown in Table 9-3 using the table on Qualcomm paper (R1050167).
Table 9-3
Cat

Maximum
E-DPDCH set

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

SF4
S F4
2xSF4
2xSF4
2xSF2
2xSF2
2xSF2 + 2xSF4
2xSF2 + 2xSF4

Support for
2 ms TTI EDCH
No
Yes
Yes
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes

Maximum transport
block size for 10 ms TTI
[bits]
7296
7296
14592
14592
20000
20000
20000
20000

Maximum transport
block size for 2 ms TTI
[bits]
1460
2919
5837
8756
11520

From operator side, it was commented that the number of categories should be reduced more, 6 categories is quite enough.

23

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011040

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Conclusion
UE categories will be a subset of the categories/parameter combinations listed in the table.
Agreement on Cat 1, 3, 4, 5 and 8. No agreement whether cat 2, 6 and 7 are in or out, the most controversial issue
being cat 2 and 6. The total number of categories should not exceed 6.
Status :
Cat 2 and 7 could be removed, no agreement on whether or not to have cat 6.

Interaction with other features

9.5

R1-050107 E-DCH and Compressed Mode

(Ericsson)

17/02/2005 17:00 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050127 Interactions between HSUPA and compressed mode

(Philips)

17/02/2005 17:15 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050135 Compressed Mode for EDCH

(Siemens)

17/02/2005 17:30 Presented by Dr. Thomas Chapman.

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050144 Compressed mode handling

(NEC)

17/02/2005 17:35 Presented by Ms. Nahoko Kuroda
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-050107 : Schedule around the gap for 2ms TTI, SF/2 for 10ms TTI
R1-050127 : Schedule around the gap
R1-050135 : Schedule around the gap for 2ms TTI, "HLS" for 10ms TTI
R1-050144 : Schedule around the gap for 2ms TTI, SF/2 for 10ms TTI.

Discussion (Chairman’s note)
E-DPDCH
¯
Relation with compression-technique related power increase with grmated powers?
¯

How to deal with GBR? Temporary throughput decrease would need to be compensated with increased
throughput =higher power

¯

Brute-force DTX

¯

No use of HARQ functionality : puncturing & HARQ retransmissions

¯

Method to choose : FFS

E-DPCCH : FFS
DL control channels : FFS

Not Available
R1-050149 TFC selection for EUDCH

(NEC)

24

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011041

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

9.6

R1-050369

Enhanced Uplink CRs on the specifications

9.6.1 CRs for TS 25.211
R1-050148 Reserving Hadamard sequence to improve interference calculation for EHICH/E-RGCH
(NTT DoCoMo)
16/02/2005 10:00 Presented by Mr. Masafumi Usuda.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are comments and questions regoxding the reason for the couple with the
Code Hopping. From NTT DoCoMo, it was informed that the simulation results will be provided.
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided that this topic can be considered at the next meeting if
simulation results are available.

R1-050116 E-HICH/E-RGCH Peak Power Requirement

(Motorola)

16/02/2005 10:10 Presented by Mr.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050090
R1-050183

E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences
E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences

(Siemens)
(Siemens) (Revision of R1-050090)

16/02/2005 10:25 Presented by Dr. Juergen Michel.
Decision: ~iNN~NIiK~i~I

R1-050091 25.211CR197(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences" (Siemens)
R1-050182 25.211CR197rl(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences"
(Siemens) (Revision of R1-050091)
16/02/2005 10:25 Presented by Dr. Juergen Michel.
Decision:
the cover page on "Proposed Change aspects")

N~iiNi~ii@~Nii~@ii~iiNiNNNi~iNNi~Niii~. .:"®~iNNNi~iN). (It is necessaxy to modif~v

R1-050103 E-RGCH/E-HICH Signature Sequences

(Ericsson)

16/02/2005 11:25 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050104 25.211CR199(Rel-6, F)"E-RGCH/E-HICH Signature Sequences"

(Ericsson)

16/02/2005 11:30 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050169 Structured and improved E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences
(Huawei Technologies)
16/02/2005 11:25 Presented by Dr. Branislav Popovic.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050170 CR25.211-201(Rel-6, F) "E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences"
(Huawei Technologies)
16/02/2005 11:25 Presented by Dr. Branislav Popovic.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050101 E-RGCH/E-HICH Sequence Hopping
16/02/2005 11:40 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

(Ericsson)

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that it is difficult to do a good allocation to UEs and
implementation.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050102 25.211CR198(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequence Hopping"
(Ericsson)
16/02/2005 11:40 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
25

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011042

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Decision: This CR was revised with linked to R1-050182 in R1-050195.

R1-050195 25.211CR198rl(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequence Hopping"
(Ericsson)
18/02/2005 12:05 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~i~ii~!~ii~. For Plenary, MCC modif~v the cover page with CR linked to Tdoc R1-050182.

R1-050187 Comparison of E-HICH/E-RGCH signature sequences

(Ericsson)

16/02/2005 11:55 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

Discussion (Chairman’s note)
Sequence hopping
Sequence hopping pattern with 3 slot periodicity. An exact fixed pattern will be chosen depending
on the sequence selected.
Sequence to replace the current on the specification is either
~ Ericsson proposal (CR R1-050104)
~
Siemens (CR R1-050183)
~ Huawei (CR R1-050170)
~ Different sequences are similar complexity wise
Regarding the above three sequence hopping, there was a long discussion. The comment was that now it was not
possible to decide the best sequence because of the lack of the simulation results.
Then, Mr. RAN1 Chairman proposed the following way forwaxd.

Way Forward:
Sequence hopping with Siemens sequence is taken as basis for CRs to be drafted Combinations of the other two
sequences with hopping may be evaluated until 25 February. And if better performance is shown then the sequence
will be changed. The corresponding CRs will be presented to RAN, sourced by RAN1.
During the meeting, regarding above issues, the CR from Siemens was agreed in Tdoc R1-050182 and the CR from
Ericsson was agreed with captured the CR from Siemens in Tdoc R1-050195.

R1-050140 E-DPCCH performance in SHO: a comparison between CC and RM
(Nokia)
16/02/2005 14:15 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-~ao.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050117 E-DPCCH performance with energy detction vs. CRC

(Motorola)

16/02/2005 14:25 Presented by Dr. Amitava Ghosh.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050142 Number of Absolute Grant bits transmitted on E-AGCH
(Nokia) (=R2-050079)
16/02/2005 14:50 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-aho.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050168 E-AGCH aspects

(QUALCOMM Europe)

16/02/2005 14:55 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050109 E-AGCH Power Consumption

(Ericsson)

16/02/2005 15:00 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.

26

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011043

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

R1-050058 E-AGCH SF and channel coding

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 15:05 Presented by Dr Juho Lee.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050115 Performance of E-AGCH
16/02/2005 15:10 Presented by Dr. Amitava Ghosh.

(Motorola)

Decision: This document was noted.

Discussion (Chairman’s note)
The difference of the four contributions:
Current 25.211/25.212, SF256, CC1/3, x bits.
R1-050168
SF256 CC1/3 <=7bit
R1-050058
SF128, CC1/3, 5.Dbits
R1-050109
SF256 CC1/3, 7-8bits
R1-050115
SF256, CC1/3 Tailbiting <=10bits
In order to inform the results of discussion on E-AGCH, it was decided to make the draft LS to RAN2 in Tdoc R1050193.
For RAN2 LS
With the current coding scheme, a total number of AGCH information bits should not exceed 7-8 information bits.
With modifications of the current coding scheme, the total number of bits might be increased to 9-10 information bits.
¯ The power ratio should be represented with 5 bits.
¯ Single process flag (lbit)
¯ Other bit needed by RAN2 (x bits)

R1-050193 Draft LS on E-AGCH contents

(Ericsson)

18/02/2005 12:10 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

R1-050219 LS on E-AGCH contents (To :RAN2)

(WG RAN1)

Not Treated.
R1-050054 25.211CR196(Rel-6, F)"Modify the alphabetic index of E-HICH and E-RGCH
signature sequence"
(ZTE) (Withdrawn)
R1-050071 25.211CR196(Rel-6, F)"Modify the alphabetic index of E-HICH and E-RGCH
signature sequence"
(ZTE)

9.6.2 CRs for TS 25.212
R1-050059 25.212CR198(Rel-6, F)"PLnon-max and PLmax"

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 16:30 Presented by Dr Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that the value of PLmax could be related to the UE
categories.
Decision: The principle of this CR was agreed, and it was to revise the CR in accordance with the UE categories
(e.g Pimax fro the highest category ). Revision in Tdoc R1-050194

R1-050194 25.212CR198rl(Rel-6, F)"PLnon-max and PLmax" (Samsung,Nokia, Philips)
18/02/2005 12:15 Presented by Dr Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~i~ii~!~ii~li In order to informed this proposal and CR, the draft LS was made in Tdoc R1050213.

R1-050213 [Draft] LS on support for higher layer signalling of Plnon-max value (Samsung)
27

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011044

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

18/02/2005 12:15 Presented by Dr Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

R1-050220

LS on support for higher layer signalling of Plnon-max value (To : RAN2, RAN3)
(WG RAND

R1-050055

25.212CR197(Rel-6, F)"Modify the description of CRC attachment for E-AGCH"
(ZTE) (Withdrawn)
25.212CR197(Rel-6, F)"Modify the description of CRC attachment for E-AGCH"

R1-050072

(ZTE)
16/o2/2oo5 16:55 Presented by Mr. Wang Chert.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that there are no problem on the current sentences in
specification.
Decision: ~

R1-050108 25.212CR199(Rel-6, C)"HARQ bit collection for E-DCH"

(Ericsson)

16/02/2005 17:00 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision:

Not Treated
R1-050164 CR25.212-201 (Rel-6, F)"E-AGCH channel coding specification"

(Motorola)

9.6.3 CRs forTS 25.213
R1-050064 25.213CR72(Rel-6, F)"Correction on E-DPCCH power offset"

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 17:00 Presented by Ms. Youn hyoung Heo.
Decision:

R1-050065 25.213CR73(Rel-6, F)"Defining E-DPDCH power offset"

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 17:00 Presented by Ms. Youn hyoung Heo.
Decision: ~i~i~’...~i~iiii After the discussion of other topic, this CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050204 in
order to catch up the results of the discussion.

R1-050204 25.213CR73rl(Rel-6, F)"Defining E-DPDCH power offset"

(Samsung)

18/02/2005 14:00 Presented by Dr. Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: ~ii~....’~ii~ii~il

9.6.4 CRs for TS 25.214
R1-050060 25.214CR362(Rel-6, F)"Gain factor setting for E-DCH"

(Samsung)

16/02/2005 17:05 Presented by Dr. Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that which reference for E-TFC is not clear in this CR.
There are some discussions regarding the power control.
Decision: This document was noted, and revised in Tdoc R1-050209.

R1-050209 25.214CR362rl(Rel-6, F)"Gain factor setting for E-DCH"

(Samsung)

This document was revised in Tdoc R1-050215.

R1-050215 25.214CR362r2(Rel-6, F)"Gain factor setting for E-DCH"
(Samsung, Nokia, Philips)
18/02/2005 17:05 Presented by Dr. Juho Lee.

28

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011045

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision:

R1-050126 Uplink DPCCH power setting
(Philips)
R1-050185 CR25.214-367 Power ratio setting for UL physical channels in relation to E-DCH
(Philips) (Revised of R1-050126)
17/02/2005 17:30 Presented by Mr. Matthew Baker.
Discussion (Question / Comment): Some companies concerned this power setting scheme. It was commented that
it was difficult to get the power setting information in SHO case.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-050061 25.214CR363(Rel-6, F)"Power control at the maximum power limit"
(Samsung)
17/02/2005 09:15 Presented by Ms. Youn hyoung Heo.
Decision: The revised CR to be prepared for RANl#40bis.

R1-050197

25.214CR363rl(Rel-6, F)"Power control at the maximum power limit"
(Samsung, Nokia, Ericsson) (Withdrawn)

R1-050139 UE behaviour when reaching the maximum tx power

(Nokia)

17/02/2005 09:18 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-~o.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

Conclusion (Chairman’s note)
First, E-DPDCH is scaled on sub-frame basis. Within the sub-frame, equal scaling.

R1-050097 25.214CR364(Rel-6, F)"Reliable E-RGCH/E-HICH Detection"
17/02/2005 09:35 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

(Ericsson)

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that the performance should be checked from WG4 side.
Decision: This CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050198.

R1-050198 25.214CR364rl(Rel-6, F)"Reliable E-RGCH/E-HICH Detection"

(Ericsson)

18/02/2005 14:40 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision:

9.6.5 CRs forTS 25.215
There is no input.

29

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011046

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

10.

R1-050369

IMS (RAB support enhancement work item)

R1-050156 ROHC Packet Handling Using RLC Segmentation and Concatenation
(Ericsson)
17/02/2005 18:20 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted

3O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011047

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code
utilisation (3.84 Mcps TDD)

11.
R1-050163
R1-050196

Out-of-sync detection for TDD HSDPA operation without an associated DL
DPCH
(IPWireless)
Out-of-sync detection for TDD HSDPA operation without an associated DL
DPCH
(IPWireless)

This document will be sent ~d discussed on the reflector after the meeting.
Decision: This document was agreed on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting. As related to this document, the
following CRs were also agreed on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting.

R1-050227

CR25.221-118(Rel-6, B)"Release 6 HS-DSCH operation without a DL DPCH
for 3.84Mcps TDD"
(IPWireless)

Decision: This document was agreed on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting.

R1-050228

CR25.224-141(Rel-6, B)"Release 6 HS-DSCH operation without a DL DPCH
for 3.84Mcps TDD"
(IPWireless)

Decision: This document was agreed on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting.

31

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011048

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

12.

R1-050369

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code
utilisation (1.28 Mcps TDD)

R1-050068 Tx Power requirements for Optimisation of DL Code Utilisation for TDD LCR
(UTStarcom, IPWireless)
R1-050189 Tx Power requirements for Optimisation of DL Code Utilisation for TDD LCR
(UTStarcom, IPWireless) (Revision of R1-050068)
17/02/2005 18:25 Presented by Mr. Ka Leong Lo.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions regarding smart antenna topic.
Decision: This document was noted.

32

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011049

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

13. Work Item on 7.68 Mcps TDD
R1-050157 7.68Mcps TDD option: work organisation

(IPWireless)

17/02/2005 18:40 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment): The comment was that which WG is responsible for the stage 2.
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to clarify responsibility for the stage at RAN#27

R1-050158 Draft TR: 7.68Mcps TDD option: physical layer

(IPWireless)

17/02/2005 18:45 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

Not Treated
R1-050159 Draft TS: 7.68Mcps TDD Option; Overall Description: Stage 2 (IPWireless)
R1-050192 Draft TS: 7.68Mcps TDD Option; Overall Description: Stage 2 (IPWireless)
(Revised of R1-050159)

33

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011050

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

14. Study Item on TDD Enhanced Uplink
R1-050160 8-PSK for TDD Enhanced Uplink and text proposal for TR25.804 (IPWireless)
17/02/2005 18:55 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment): From InterDigital, this proposal has no problem and is a beneficial
Decision: ~i~ii~i~ii~ii~ii~il

R1-050161 Text proposal on Node-B scheduling for TR25.804
(IPWireless)
R1-050190 Text proposal on Node-B scheduling for TR25.804
(IPWireless) (Revised of R1-050161)
17/02/2005 19:05 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

R1-050162 Draft text on conclusions and recommendations for the TDD enhanced uplink SI
(IPWireless)
17/02/2005 19:10 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision:

R1-050212 TR25.804 v.l.0.1
(InterDigital)
Decision: This document was agreed as vl. 1.0 with some editorial modification on the reflector after the meeting.
TR25.804 v.l.l.0
R1-050229
R1-050231
TR25.804 v.2.0.0
This document was submitted in RAN#27 for approval.

(InterDigital)
(InterDigital)

34

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011051

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

15. Review of RAN WG 1 Terms of Reference
R1-050202 Review of WG RANI Terms of Reference

(RANI Chairman)

18/02/2005 14:30 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Decision: This document was endorsed.

16. Other Business
After the meeting, the number of TR 7.68Mcps TDD option: physical layer was assigned as 25.809.

35

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011052

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

17. Closing of the meeting ¯ Friday 5.00 PM
18/02/2005 16: 00. The RAN1 chairman, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger expressed his appreciation to the delegates and the host,
the North American Friends for 3GPP for their works. The meeting was dismissed at this time.

36

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011053

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

AnnexA: List of participants

Mr. Shinsuke Ogawa
Dr. Jinsong Duan
Mr. Hitoshi Iochi
Mr. Prem Sood
Ms. Nahoko Kuroda
Mr. Tsukasa Sasaki
Mr. Noriyuki FUKUI
Mr. Hideji Wakabayashi
Mr. Youngbum Kim
Ms. Youn hyoung Hoe
Mr. Elias Jonsson
Mr. Anil Umesh
Mr. Benoist S6bire
Member 0f 3GPP (A~!S)
Dr. Stefan Parkvall
Mr. Donald E. Zelmer
Mr. Karri Ranta-aho
Member 0f 3GPP (CCSA)
Ms. Sha Ma

NTT DoCoMo Inc.
Panasonic Mobile Comm.
Panasonic Mobile Comm.
SHARP Corporation
NEC Corporation
Fujitsu Limited
Mitsubishi Electric Co.
Mitsubishi Electric Co.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
Nippon Ericsson K.K.
NTT DoCoMo Inc.
Nokia Japan Co, Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)
3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]

[e-mail]. nttdocomo.co.jp
Duan.jinsong@jp. panasonic.com
Iochi. hitoshi@jp, panasonic.com
[e-mail]
n-ku [e-mail], nec. com
[e-mail]
n-fukui@isl, melco.co.jp
h.wakaba@cew, melco.co.jp
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Elias.jonsson@ericsson. com
u [e-mail], ntttdocomo, co.j p
[e-mail]

Ericsson Inc.
Cingular Wireless LLC
NOKIA Telecommunications Inc

3GPPMEMBER (ATIS)
3GPPMEMBER (ATIS)
3GPPMEMBER (ATIS)

[phone]
[phone]
[phone]

[e-mail]
don.zelmer@cingular, com
[e-mail]

HuaWei Technologies Co., Ltd

[phone]

[e-mail]

Mrs. Ning He

Nanjing Ericsson Panda Com Ltd

[phone]

ning. [e-mail]

Dr. Robert Karlsson

ZTE Corporation

[phone]

Robert. ka rlsso n @ztewist ro n. com

Mr. Zhisong Zuo

ZTE Corporation

3GPPMEMBER
(CCSA)
3GPPMEMBER
(CCSA)
3GPPMEMBER
(CCSA)
3GPPMEMBER
(CCSA)

[phone]

[e-mail]

Membei Of 3GPP (E~S!)
Mr. Uwe Baeder
Mr. Vincent Belaiche

ROHDE & SCHWARZ
MELCO MOBILE
COMMUNICATIONS

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI) [phone]
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI) [phone]

Uwe. Baeder@rsd. rohd e-schwarz, com
vincent, belaiche@mmce, mee.com

37

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011054

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005
Mr. Hyung-Nam Choi
Ms. Evelyne Le Strat
Ms. Liliana Czapla
Mr. Uwe Doetsch
Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger
Dr. Amitabha Ghosh
Mr. Mark Harrison
Dr. Joern Krause
Mr. Yannick Le Pezennec
Mr. Yongjun Kwak
Dr. Branislav Popovic
Mr. Philip Booker
Dr. Thomas Chapman
Mr. Heino Geilach
Dr. Baijun Zhao
Mr. Ka Leong Lo
Mr. Robert Love
Dr. Durga Malladi
Dr. JQrgen Michel
Mr. Dirk Kistowski
Mrs. Nadege Noisette
Mr. Alessandro Pace
Mr. Enrico Buracchini
Mr. Ville Steudle
Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki
Mr. Markku Tarkiainen
Mrs. Carolyn Taylor
Mr. Serge Willenegger
Mr. Nicholas Anderson
Miss Eliza Wong
Dr. Rainer Bachl
Mr. Matthew Baker
Mr. Chris Barroso
Mr. Eric Fablet
Dr. Stefan Brueck
Mr. Alfonso Campo

INFINEON TECHNOLOGIES
Nortel
INTERDIGITAL COMMUNICATIONS
ALCATEL S.A.
ERICSSON LM
MOTOROLA Ltd
MOTOROLA GmbH
SIEMENS AG
VODAFONE Group PIc
SAMSUNG Electronics
Huawei
Siemens NV/SA BELGIUM ETSI
Siemens Mobile
Siemens Communications
UTStarcom
UTStarcom
MOTOROLA Ltd
QUALCOMM EUROPE S.A.R.L.
SIEMENS AG
T-Mobile International
ORANGE SA
TELECOM ITALIA S.p.A.
TELECOM ITALIA S.p.A.
NOKIA UK Ltd
PANASONIC R&D Center Germany
NOKIA Corporation
MOTOROLA Ltd
QUALCOMM EUROPE S.A.R.L.
I PWireless
ALCATEL S.A.
Lucent Technologies
Philips Semiconductors Sophia
Freescale Semiconductors
Freescale Semiconductors
Lecent Technologies
Top Optimized Technologies S.L

R1-050369
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ATIS)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

[phone]
+ 33 1 39 44 53 39
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]

Hyung-Nam.Choi@infineon. com
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
mark. [e-mail]
joern, krause@siemens, com
Yannick. [e-mail]
[e-mail]
Branislav. [e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
dirk. [e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
ville.steudle@nokia, com
Suzuki. [e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Bakermp2@prl. research, philips.com
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Alfonso. cam po@opti mizedtech, ney

38

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011055

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005
Mr. Alvaro Lopez medrano
Dr. Luis Mendo
Dr. Stamatis Georgoulis
Mr. Asbjorn Grovlen
Mr. Arik Gubeskys
Ms. Mariana Lyu
Mr. Diptendu Mitra
Dr. Tarik Muharemovic
Mr. Mark Murphy
Dr. Manook Soghomonian
Mr. Alex Margulis
Member 0f 3GPP (TTA)
Dr. Joon-Kui Ahn
Dr. Sung Lark Kwon
Dr. Juho Lee
Mr. Ilgyu Kim
Mr. Bong Hoe Kim
Mr. Dong Wook Roh
Mr. Yujian Zhang
Mr. Dragan Vujcic
Mr. Kyung Park
Member af 3GPP (TTC)
Mr. Mikhail Shnaider
Mr. Masafumi Usuda
Oiga~isatia~ pa~ne~
representative
Mr. Yoshikazu Ishii

R1-050369

Top Optimized Technologies S.L

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

[phone]

Top Optimized Technologies S.L
UbiNetics Ltd
NOKIA Corporation
Freescale Semiconductor Israel
Research in Motion Limited
Telecom Modus Ltd.
TEXAS Instruments
TTP Communication plc
3
Intel Corporation SARL

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)
3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]

[e-mail]
[e-mail]. upm.es
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
tarik@ti, com
mark. m urphy@ttpcom, com
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

LG Electronics Inc.
LG Electronics Inc.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd
ETRI
LG Electronics Inc.
LG Electronics Inc.
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd
LG Electronics Inc.
ETRI

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)
3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]
[phone]

jkan@lge, com
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
dwroh@lge, com
yujian.zhang@samsung, com
dvujcic@lge, com
kyungp@etri, re. kr

NEC Corporation
NTT DoCoMo Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTC)
3GPPMEMBER (TTC)

+(61 3) 92714042
[phone]

mikhail@3g, nec.com.au
usud a@wsp, yrp. ntttdocom o. co.j p

Mobile Competence Centre

ETSI

[phone]

ishii.yoshikazu@etsi, org

39

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011056

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Annex B: TSG RAN WG1 meetings in 2005
TITLE
3GPPRANI#40

TYPE
WG

DATES
14- 18 Feb 2005

LOCATION
Scottsdale

CTRY
USA

3GPPRANI#40bis

WG

04 - 08April 2005

Beijing

3GPPRAN1#41

WG

09- 13 May 2005

Athens

China
GR

3GPPRAN1#42

WG

29 Aug -02 Sept 2005

London

UK

3GPPRAN1#43

WG

07 - 11 Nov 2005

TBD

Asia

MEETING TYPES
AH = Ad Hoc
CM = Chairmen’s meeting
JM = Joint
OR = Ordinary
PM = Preparatory Meeting RG = Rapporteurs Group
RM = Resolution Meeting SG = Steering Group
ST = Startup Meeting
TG = Task Group
WG = Working Group
XO = Extraordinary

4O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011057

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Annex C List of CRs agreed at RAN 1#40
25.211 200 1

B Rel-6

25.212 193

B Rel-6

RANimp-RABSECodeOptFDD
RANimp-RABSECodeOptFDD
RANimp-RABSE-

R1-050178 Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field
R1-050080 Introduction of F-DPCH

1

25.213 70 1 B Rel-6 R1-050081 Introduction of F-DPCH
25.214 368

1

B

Rel-6

R1-050179 Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field

25.215 155

-

B

Rel-6

R1-050133 Introduction of F-DPCH without pilot field

25.215 150
251215 15i
25.215 152
25.215 153
25.214 354
25.214 355
25.214 365
25.215 147
251215 154
25.224 140
25.211 197
25.211 198
25.211 202
25.212 198
251212 199
25.213 72
25.213 73
25.214 362
25.214 364
25.214 369

1
i
1
1
3
2
4
~
2
1
1
2
1
~
1
2
1
2

C
C
C
C
C
B
F
B
F
C
F
F
F
F
C
F
F
F
F
F

Re199
RelL4
Rel-5
Rel-6
Rel-6.
Rel-6.
Rel-5
Rel-6
RelL6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6
RelL6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6
Rel-6

R1-050110 Removal of TGPL2
R1L050110 Rem0~al0fTGPL2
R1-050110 Removal of TGPL2
R1-050110 Removal of TGPL2
R1-050201 Timing maintained Hard Handover
R1-050173 Faster L1 DCH synchronization
R1-050113 Correction to computed gain factors quantization
R1-050114 Introduction of’DL Transmission Branch Load’ measurement
R1L050082 ciarificati0n0fceii0nsFN~sFN0bservedtimediffe~ence
R1-050096 Improvements to uplink closed-loop power control for 1.28Mcps TDD
R1-050182 E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences
R1-050195 E-HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequence Hopping
R1-050223 E-HICH/E-RGCH/E-AGCH timing
R1-050194 PLnon-maxand PLmax
R1L050108 HARQbitc011ecti0nf0rELDCH
R1-050064 Correction on E-DPCCH power offset
R1-050204 Defining E-DPDCH power offset
R1-050215 Gain factor setting for E-DCH
R1-050198 Reliable E-RGCH/E-HICH Detection
R1-050224 DL/ULtiming association of E-DCH operation

25.221

118 -

B

Rel-6

R1-050227 Release6HS-DSCHoperationwithoutaDLDPCHfor3.84McpsTDD

25.224

141

B

Rel-6

R1-050228 Release 6 HS-DSCH operation without a DL DPCH for 3.84Mcps TDD

-

RANimp-RABSECodeOptFDD
RANimp-RABSECodeOptFDD
TEl
TEl
TEl
TEl
TEl6
TEl6
TEl5
TEl6
TEl
LCRTDD-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
EDCH-Phys
RANimp-RABSECodeOptTDD
RANimp-RABSECodeOptTDD

41

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011058

R1-050369

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

Note ¯ The CRs in Tdoc R1-050223, R1-050224, R1-050227 and R1-050228 were agreed on the RAN1 reflector after the meeting. After the meeting, the category of CR
140r2 for TS25.224 in R1-050096 was changed from TEI6 to LCRTDD-phys for RAN#27 proposal.

42

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011059

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Annex D List of Outgoing LSs to 3GPP other groups
R1-050191

LS on Introduction of Fractional DPCH

R1-050216
R1-050219
R1-050220
R1-050221
R1-050222

LS on Faster L1 DCH synchronization
LS on E-AGCH contents
LS on support for higher layer signalling of PLnon-max value
Reply LS on alignment of MBMS transport channels
LS on MBMS UE capability

RAN2, RAN3,
RAN4
RAN4
RAN2
RAN2, RAN3
RAN3
RAN2, RAN3,
RAN4

RAN2

43

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011060

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369

Annex E: List of Tdocs at RAN1 #40
rom ji ua~e ~-~i

R1-050035 Draft Agenda
RAN1 Chairman
R1-050036 Reply LS on parameter set for PS streamingWG RAN2
eference radio bearer combination with
Jownlink rate up to 128 kbps (To ¯ T1, Cc ¯
:~AN1)
R1-050037 Reply LS on Synchronisation of FDD MBMS
WG RAN2
D-t-M Transmissions from Clusters of Cells
’ToRAN& Cc RAN1, RAN4)
R1-050038 _S on Layer 1 synchronization procedure WG RAN2
’To RAN1, Cc RAN3, RAN4)
R1-050039 _S on Radio link failure criteria on Fractional
WG RAN2
DPCH (To RAN3, RAN4, Cc RAN1)
R1-050040 DRAFT Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 RAN1 Secretary
~39
R1-050041 Summary from TSG RAN#26
RAN1 Chairman

2
5

=R2-042698

14/o2/2oos~,pproved
14/o2/2OOSNoted

:R2-042706

14/02/2005 Noted

5

:R2-050249

14/02/2005 Noted

5

:R2-050300

14/02/2005 Noted

3

14/02/2005 &pproved

4
8

14/02/2005 Noted

~Vithdrawn

8
8

~Vithdrawn

8

~Vithdrawn

8
R1-050047 &ddition of suppo~ for BTFD in flexible
Mitsubishi
3osition multiplexing of transpo~ channels Electric(MMCE)
’include CR)

~Vithdrawn

~Vithdrawn

8

R 1-041312)

R1-050048 3ain of BTFD in flexible position
Mitsubishi
8 R1-041478)
~ultiplexing of transpo~ channels
Electric(MMCE)
R1-050049 ~inutes from RAN1 Conference Call #1 on RAN1 Chairman 9.1 R1-050022)
~cheduling and HARQ
44

15/02/2005Noted. As the conclusion of the R1-050047
and R1-050048, there was no agreement
[rom the group to introduce this feature in the
specifications.
15/o2/2oo5Noted
15/o2/2oo5 Noted

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011061

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
Date(CET)i
T EM i

R1-050050 Vlinutes from RAN1 Conference Call #2 on RAN1 Chairman
~lodeB measurements and interaction with
:~NC admission/congestion control and
:~RM with EUL
R1-050051 Vlinutes from RAN1 Conference Call #3 on RAN1 Chairman
JE categories for EUL
R1-050052 Efficiency Analysis of DL ACK Structures Via Telecom
R1-050053 Selecting the Primary Node(s) for DL ACK Via Telecom
LZTE

(From)

i

9.1

R1-050027)

16/02/2005 Noted

9.1

R1-050033)

15/02/2005 Noted

9.2
9.2

= R1-041410
= R1-041411

Not Treated
Not Treated
~Vithdrawn

~l~+i~ i~v ~ C ~1~ ~ C D~

~Vithdrawn
R1-050056 Timing of E-HICH and number of HARQ ZTE
~rooesses
R1-050057 TR25,808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Editor (Nokia)
_ayer Aspects, v1,0,1
R1-050058 E-AGCH SF and channel coding
Samsung
Samsung
25,212CR198(ReI-6, F)"PLnon-max and
R1-050059
~Lmax"
25,214CR362(Rel-6, F)"GaJn factor setting Sa msu ng
or E-DCH"
Samsung
R1-050061 25,214CR363(Rel-6, F)"Power control at the
~axJmum power limit"
R1-050062 JTRAN measurement for E-DCH RRM
Samsung
R1-050063 1umber of HARQ processes
Samsung
25,213CR72(Rel-6, F)"CorrectJon on ER1-050064 DPCCH power offset"
Samsung
25,213CR73(Rel-6, F)"Defining E-DPDCH
R1-050065 ~ower offset"
Samsung
DptJmJzatJon of Outer Loop Power Control Top Optimized
R1-050066 or F-DPCH
Technologies
R1-050067 JE behaviour on RG from Non-serving RLS
Alcatel
R1-050060

9.2

15/02/2005 Noted

15/02/2005 &g reed as versi on 1.1.0 in Tdoc R 1-050188.

9
9.6.2
9.6.2

9.6.4
9.6.4
9.3
9.2
9.6.3
9.6.3
8
9.2

16/02/2005 Noted

16/°2/2°°SThe principle of this CR was agreed, and it
was to revise the CR in accordance with the
LIE categories (e.g Pimax fro the highest
,~ategory )in Tdoc R1-050194
16/o2/2oo5 Revised in Td oc R 1-050209
17/o2/2oosThe revised CR to be prepared for
RAN l#40bis.
16/o2/2oo5 Noted
15/o2/2oo5 Noted
16/o2/2oo5 &g reed
16/o2/2oos&greed. After the discussion of other topic,
lhis CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050204
14/o2/2oo5 Noted
Not Treated

45

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011062

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
T EM i (From)i Date(CET)i

Tx Power requirements for Optimisation of UTSarcom,
12
R1-050068 DL Code Utilisation for TDD LCR
IPWireless
Radio resource control and measurement
9.3
R1-050069
LG Electronics
or HSUPA
Timing and the number of HARQ processes LG Electronics
9.2
R1-050070
or HSUPA
25.211CR196(Rel-6, F)"Modify the
9.6.1
R1-050071 alphabetic index of E-HICH and E-RGCH ZTE
signature sequence"
9.6.2
R1-050072 _5.212CR197(Rel-6, F)"Modify the
ZTE
Jescription of CRC attachment for E-AGCH"
R1-050073 Relative timing of downlink signaling
Nortel
9.2
:hannels for E-DCH
R1-050074 ~lumber of H-ARQ processes for E-DCH Nortel
9.2
R1-050075 DRAFT Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG2 RAN2 Secretary
3
= R2-050233
~45
8
R1-050076 _5.214CR357r2(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Nortel
R1-041523)
DPCH "
8
R1-050077 _5.215CR148r2(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Nortel
R1-041524)
DPCH "
R1-050078 ---DCH timing
Lucent
9.2
R1-050079 __.5.211CR194r2(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Nortel
8
R1-041522)
DPCH "
R1-050080 _5.212CR193r1(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Nortel
8
R1-041307)
DPCH "
R1-050081 _5.213CR70r1(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Nortel
8
R1-041308)
DPCH "
R1-050082 _5.215CR154(Rel-6, F)"Clarification of cellPanasonic
6.4
3n SFN-SFN observed time difference"
R1-050083 VIBMS UE capability
R1-050084 Void
R1-050085 Void
R1-050086 Void
R1-050087 --UL timing and the number of HARQ
3rooesses

Revised in Tdoc R1-050189
16/o2/2oo5 Noted
15/o2/2OO5Noted
Not treated
16/o2/2OO5Not agreed
15/o2/2OO5Noted
15/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2OO5 RAN1/2 Joint session part was approved
14/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2OO5Noted
15/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2oosAgreed
14/o2/2oosAgreed
14/o2/2oosAgreed. Itwas decided to consider possibility
Ior CRs to the earlier releases (R99...) at
RAN Plenary as company proposal.

Panasonic

7

14/o2/2OO5Noted

Panasonic

9.2

15/o2/2OO5Noted

46

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011063

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
Date(CET)i
T EM

R1-050088 Jplink EDCH/DCH resource allocation and Panasonic
"neasurement
R1-050089 _ong term solution for ping-pong effect
Panasonic
R1-050090 ---HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences Siemens
R1-050091 25.211CR197(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Siemens
Signature Sequences"
R1-050092 ]-TI reordering with measurement gaps of Siemens
0 and 20 ms
R1-050093 Draft LS on TTI reordering
Siemens
R1-050094 aroposal of UE categories for the Enhanced Vodafone
Jplink
Group, NTT
DoCoMo
R1-050095 Definition and Signalling way of Time
Mitsubishi
Duration
Electric
R1-050096 25,224CR140r2(Rel-6, C) "Improvements toPWireless
I
Jplink closed-loop power control for
,28Mcps TDD"
R1-050097 25,214CR364(Rel-6, F)"Reliable EEricsson
:~GCH/E-H ICH Detection"
R1-050098 ---DPCH Power control
Ericsson
R1-050099 25,214CR354r2(Rel-6, C)"Timing
Ericsson
qqaintained Hard Handover"
R1-050100 25,214CR355rl(Rel-6, B)"Faster L1 DCH Ericsson
synchronization"

9.3
9.3
9.6.1
9.6.1

i

(From)

i

16/o2/2OOSNoted
Not treated
Revised in Tdoc R1-050183
Revised in Tdoc R1-050182

7

14/o2/2OOSNoted

7
9.4

14/o2/2OOSNoted
17/o2/2OOSNoted

9.2
6.4
9.6.4

Not treated
14/o2/2oo5 &greed
17/o2/2OOSRevised in Tdoc R1-050198

8
6.4

14/o2/2oo5 Noted
14/o2/2oosThis CR was revised in Tdoc R1-050201.

6.4

14/o2/2oo5It was decided to replace Qpost with Qout,
and should be reconfirm with RAN2 about
indication of the post-sync-failure (depends
3n RAN2 discussion). Revision 2 of the CR in
ldoc R1-050173.

R1-050101 ---RGCH/E-HICH Sequence Hopping
Ericsson
R1-050102 25.211CR198(Rel-6, F)"E-RGCH/E-HICH Ericsson
Sequence Hopping"

9.6.1
9.6.1

16/02/2005Noted
16/o2/2oo5 R_e¥ised with ]hLked to R_]-050]S2 iuR_]-050]gi

R1-050103 ---RGCH/E-HICH Signature Sequences Ericsson
R1-050104 25.211CR199(Rel-6, F)"E-RGCH/E-HICH Ericsson
Signature Sequences"
R1-050105 ---DCH DownlinkTiming Relations
Ericsson
R1-050106 ---DCH UE Categories
Ericsson
R1-050107 ---DCH and Compressed Mode
Ericsson

9.6.1
9.6.1

16/o2/2OOSNoted
16/o2/2OOSNoted

9.2
9.4
9.5

Revised in Tdoc R1-050186
17/o2/2OOSNoted
17/o2/2OOSNoted

47

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011064

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
Date(CET)i
T EM

R1-050108 _5.212CR199(Rel-6, C)"HARQ bit collection Ericsson
or E-DCH"
R1-050109 ---AGCH Contents and Power Consumption Ericsson
R1-050110 _5.215CR150r1(Re199, C),CR151r1(Rel-4,Ericsson,
~,), CR152r1(Rel-5, A), CR153r1(Rel-6, A) Samsung
’Removal of TGPL2"
R1-050111 -IARQ Operation Point
Siemens
R1-050112 :~etransmission Power Optimisation
Siemens
R1-050113 _5.214CR365(Rel-5, F), CR366(Rel-6, A) QUALCOMM
’Correction to computed gain factors
Europe
:luantization"
R1-050114 __5.215CR147r4"lntroduction of’DL
Siemens
Transmission Branch Load’ measurement"
R1-050115 Performance of E-AGCH
Motorola
R1-050116 ---HICH/E-RGCH Peak Power Requirement Motorola
R1-050117 ---DPCCH performance with energy
Motorola
Jetection vs. CRC
R1-050118 Comparative performance of dedicated and Motorola
autonomous modes
R1-050119 Performance of EUL in Autonomous mode Motorola
~vith and without hysteresis
R1-050120 Derformance of EUL with and without happy Motorola
3it
R1-050121 JE Capabilities for EUL
Motorola
R1-050122 ::)raft LS on Control of HARQ Operation Siemens, Nokia,
Philips
R1-050123 _S on Details on MCCH (To ; RAN4, Cc; WG-RAN2
:~AN1)
R1-050124 _S on reference cell in SFN-SFN observed WG-T1
:ime difference measurement (To: RAN1,
Cc: RAN2)
R1-050125 _S on modified parameters for 5.9 speech WG-T1
adio bearer 6.10.2.4.1.9 in 34.108 (To;
:~AN 1, RAN2)
R1-050126 Jplink DPCCH power setting
Philips
R1-050127 nteractions between HSUPA and
Philips
:ompressed mode

i

(From)

9.6.2
9.2
6.1

i

16/o2/2oosAgreed
16/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2oosFechnically agreed

9.2
9.2
6.3

R1-050003)
R1-050004)

18/o2/2OO5Noted
18/o2/2OO5Noted
14/o2/2oos:Dnly Rel-5 was agreed, but Rel-6 was not
agreed.

6.4

R1-041494)

14/o2/2oosAgreed
16/o2/2oo5 Noted
16/o2/2OO5Noted
16/o2/2oo5 Noted

9.6.2
9.6.1
9.6.2
9.2

Not treated

9.2

Not treated

9.2

Not treated

9.4
9.2

17/o2/2OO5Noted
18/o2/2OO5Noted. No recommendation from RAN1 to go
[urther with this feature
14/o2/2OO5Noted

5

= R2-050307

5

= T1-050483

14/o2/2OO5Noted

5

= T1-050490

14/o2/2OO5Noted

9.6.4
9.5

Revised in Tdoc R1-050185
17/o2/2OO5Noted

48

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011065

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
T EM i (From)i Date(CET)i

R1-050128 ntroduction of F-DPCH without pilot field Philips
R1-050129 CR25.211-200 (Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Philips, Nokia
3PCH without pilot field"

8

14/02/2005 Noted

8

14/o2/2OOSMinor-revised in Tdoc R1-050178

8
R1-050131 klumber of HARQ processes

Siemens

~Vithdrawn

9.2

R1-050132 CR25.214-368 (Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Philips, Nokia
3PCH without pilot field"

15/o2/2oo5 N oted
14/02/2005 It

8

R1-050133 CR25.215-155 (Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of F- Philips, Nokia
3PCH without pilot field"
R1-050134 ---HICH timing relationship
Siemens
R1-050135 Compressed Mode for EDCH
Siemens
R1-050136 .~tep size for relative grants
Siemens
8iepae~
R! 050137 R4R4~C4e~4:~
R1-050138 VIBMS UE Capability for FDD
Motorola
R1-050139 JE behaviour when reaching the maximum
Nokia
:x power
R1-050140 ---DPCCH performance in SHO: a
Nokia
:omparison between CC and RM
R1-050141 -ISUPA UE Capabilities
Nokia
R1-050142 ~lumber of Absolute Grant bits transmitted Nokia
3n E-AGCH
R1-050143 Common measurement for E-DCH
NEC
R1-050144 Compressed mode handling
NEC
R1-050145 ---AGCH Timing
NTT DoCoMo
R1-050146 Vleasurement report of E-DPDCH/DPCCHNTT DoCoMo
3ower ratio for common rate control
’Autonomous ramping)
R1-050147 Control over serving vs. non-serving E-DCH
NTT DoCoMo
esource allocation
R1-050148
NTT DoCoMo
:~eserving Hadamard sequence to improve
nterference calculation for E-HICH/E-RGCH

R 1-050010)

was decided to include the text from Tdoc
R1-050098 (exclude part on multiple RL QoS
’The UE shall run a quality target control loop
such that the quality requirement is met for
~ach radio link set.") Revision in R1-050179.
14/o2/2oo5&greed

8
9.2
9.5
9.2
8~3
7
9.6.4

=R1-050011

16/o2/2oo5 Noted

9.6.1
9.4
9.2
9.3
9.5
9.2
9.3
9.2
9

Revised in Tdoc R1-050181
17/o2/2oo5 Noted
Not treated
~Vithdrawn
14/o2/2oo5 Noted
17/o2/2oo5 Noted

R1-050028)
= R2-050079

17/o2/2oo5 Noted
16/o2/2oo5 Noted
Not available
17/o2/2oo5 Noted
15/o2/2oo5 Noted
16/o2/2oo5 Noted
Not treated
17/o2/2OOSNoted. It was decided that this topic can be
,~onsidered at the next meeting if simulation
results are available.

4g

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011066

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
T EM i (From)i Date(CET)i

R1-050149 ]-FC selection for EUDCH
R1-050150 ---DPCH simulation results
R1-050151 ---DPCH operation in SHO
R1-050152 Dn MBMS UE Minimum Capability
R! 050153 ~
R1-050154 ~,MR-WB reference RAB configurations

NEC
Nokia
Nokia
Nokia
Nek4a
Nokia

9.5
8
8
7
6:8
6.5

R1-050155 :~RM aspects of the Enhanced Uplink
Vodafone Group
’eature
R1-050156 :~OHC Packet Handling Using RLC
Ericsson
.~egmentation and Concatenation
R1-050157 A68Mcps TDD option: work organisation IPWireless

9.3

Not available
14/o2/2OOSNoted
14/o2/2OOSNoted
14/o2/2OOSNoted
~Vithdrawn
14/o2/2oosFhis document was revised in Tdoc R1::)50205.
16/o2/2OOSNoted

10

17/o2/2OOSNoted

13

17/o2/2OOSNoted. It was decided to clarify responsibility
Ior the stage at RAN#27

R1-050158 ::)raft TR: 7.68Mcps TDD option: physical IPWireless
ayer

13

17/o2/2oos~,greed as v0.1.0 as soon as TR number is
available.

R1-050159 ::)raft TS: 7.68Mcps TDD Option; Overall IPWireless
::)escription: Stage 2
R1-050160 3-PSK for TDD Enhanced Uplink and text IPWireless
3roposal for TR25.804
R1-050161 Text proposal on Node-B scheduling for IPWireless
]-R25.804
R1-050162 ::)raft text on conclusions and
IPWireless
ecommendations for the TDD enhanced
Jplink SI
R1-050163 ::)ut-of-sync detection for TDD HSDPA
IPWireless
3peration without an associated DL DPCH
R1-050164 CR25.212-201 (Rel-6, F)"E-AGCH channel Motorola
:oding specification"
R1-050165 ~lumber of HARQ processes & DL timing QUALCOMM
Europe
R1-050166 Measurement in support of RRM
QUALCOMM
Europe
R1-050167 ---DCH related UE categories
QUALCOMM
Europe
R1-050168 ---AGCH aspects
QUALCOMM
Europe

13
14
14
14
11
9.6.2
9.2
9.3

Revised in Tdoc R1-050192
17/o2/2oos]-his text proposal was agreed into TR.
Revised in Tdoc R1-050190
17/o2/2oos]-his text proposal was agreed into TR.
Revised in Tdoc R1-050196
Not treated
15/o2/2OOSNoted
Not treated

9.4

17/o2/2OOSNoted

9.6.1

16/o2/2OOSNoted

5O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011067

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
Date(CET)i
T EM

R1-050169 Structured and improved E-HICH/E-RGCH Huawei
Signature Sequences
R1-050170 3R25.211-201(Rel-6, F) "E-HICH/E-RGCH Huawei
Signature Sequences"
R1-050171 JE behavior in DPCH frame offset
Intel
econfiguration
R1-050172 --eature Clean-Up
Nokia, Motorola

i

(From)

9.6.1
9.6.1

i

16/o2/2OOSNoted
16/o2/2OOSNoted

6.3

Not Treated

6.5

14/o2/2OOSNoted. The decision on removal of features
~hould be taken TSG RAN level
18/o2/2oosTechnically agreed from RAN1 perspective

R1-050173 __.5.214CR355r2(Rel-6, B)"Faster L1 DCH Ericsson
synchronization"
R1-050174
Ericsson
6.4
graft LS on Faster L1 DCH synchronization

6.4

R1-050175 _S on the measurements required for
WG-RAN3
--DCH Congestion Control (To:RAN1, Cc:
:~AN2, RAN4)
R1-050176 VIBMS UE Capability for FDD
Motorola

5

= R3-050254

14/o2/2OOSNoted

7

R1-050138)

18/o2/2oo5Noted. Include updated the proposal from R1:)50176 (with limit on SCCPCH codes) and
indicate TTI issue together with the RAN1
)arts of UE capabilities in draft LS R1:)50177.

R1-050177 graft LS on MBMS UE capability

7

Panasonic

R1-050178 3R25.211-200 rl(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of Philips, Nokia
---DPCH without pilot field"
R1-050179 3R25.214-368 rl(Rel-6, B)"lntroduction of Philips, Nokia
---DPCH without pilot field"
R1-050180 ~,pproved Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 RAN1 Secretary
~39
R1-050181 ---HICH timing relationship
Siemens
S
R1-050182 __.5.211CR197rl(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCHiemens
Signature Sequences"
R1-050183 ---HICH/E-RGCH Signature Sequences Siemens
R1-050184 EDraft] LS on Introduction of Fractional
Philips, Nokia,
::)PCH
Nortel, Ericsson
R1-050185 3R25.214-367 Power ratio setting for UL Philips
3hysical channels in relation to E-DCH

18/o2/2oosApproved with the modification in Tdoc R1:)50216

8

R1-050129)

18/o2/2oosApproved with modification on "Overall
description" in Tdoc R1-050222
18/o2/2oosAgreed

8

R1-050132)

15/o2/2oosAgreed

3

R1-050140)

9.2
9.6.1

R1-050134)
R1-050091)

9.6.1
8

R1-050090)

9.6.4

R1-050126)

Approved version
15/o2/2OOSNoted
16/o2/2oosAgreed and captured by CR25.211CR198rl
Tdoc R1-050195).
16/o2/2oosAgreed
16/o2/2oosApproved with addition of sentence ""in Tdoc
R1-050191
17/o2/2OOSNoted

51

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011068

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
T EM i (From)i Date(CET)i

R1-050186 ---DCH DownlinkTiming Relations
Ericsson
R1-050187 .Comparison of E-HICH/E-RGCH signatureEricsson
sequences
R1-050188 ]-R25.808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Editor (Nokia)
_ayer Aspects, vl. 1.0
R1-050189 ]-x Power requirements for Optimisation of UTSarcom,
I PWireless
:)L Code Utilisation for TDD LCR
R1-050190 Text proposal on Node-B scheduling for IPWireless
]-R25.804
R1-050191 _S on Introduction of Fractional DPCH (To WG-RAN1
:
:~AN2, RAN3, RAN4)
R1-050192 :)raft TS: 7.68Mcps TDD Option; Overall IPWireless
:)escription: Stage 2
Ericsson
R1-050193 :)raft LS to RAN2 on AGCH
R1-050194 25.212CR198r1(Rel-6, F)"PLnon-max and Samsung,
=hmax"
Nokia, Philips
R1-050195 25.211CR198r1(Rel-6, F)"E-RGCH/E-HICH
Ericsson
Sequence Hopping"
IPWireless
R1-050196 ::)ut-of-sync detection for TDD HSDPA
~peration without an associated DL DPCH

9.2
9.6.1

R1-050105)

9

R1-050057)

12

R1-050068)

17/02/2005 Noted

14

R 1-050161 )

17/02/2005 ]-his

8

15/o2/2oo5 Noted
16/02/2005 N oted
Approved version

text proposal was agreed into TR.

Approved version

13

R1-050159)

Not treated

9.6.1

18/02/2005 Approved

9.6.2

R1-050059)

:)50219.
18/02/2005 Agreed.

9.6.1

R1-050102)

18/02/2005 Agreed

11

R1-050163)

with modification in Tdoc R1-

]-his document will be sent and discussed on
lhe reflector after the meeting.
~Vithdrawn

R1-050198 __5.214CR364r1(Rel-6, F)"Reliable E:~GCH/E-H ICH Detection"
R1-050199

18/02/2005 Agreed

Ericsson
WG-RAN3

18/02/2005 Noted.

It was decided to send the reply LS
indicating that no significant impact on RAN1
~pecifications is expected with an introduction
3f an SFN-MFN offset (no impact with
introduction of an SFN-CFN offset) that would
lead to alignment of TTI starting times and the
proposed solution CFN mod2 = 0 is not
)referred in Tdoc R1-050214.
18/02/2005Noted

5

_S on alignment of MBMS transport
:hannels (To : RAN1, RAN2)

R1-050200 --UL performance with de-boosting on E- QUALCO M M
Europe
:)PDCH
25.214CR354r3(Rel-6, C)"Timing
R1-050201
Ericsson
qqaintained Hard Handover"

9.2
6.4

R1-050099)

18/o2/2oo5Agreed

52

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011069

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005

R1-050369
T EM i (From)i Date(CET)i

R1-050202 Review of WG RAN1 Terms of Reference RAN1 Chairman 15
R1-050203 Timing and process number
QUALCOMM
9.2
Europe
R1-050204 _5.213CR73r1(Rel-6, F)"Defining E-DPDCHsamsung
9.6.3
~ower offset"
R1-050205 ~,MR-WB reference RAB configurations
Nokia
6.5
R1-050206 3R 25.211-202 (Rel6, F) "E-HICH/EQUALCOMM
:~GCH/E-AGCH timing"
Europe
R1-050207 3R 25.214-369 (Rel6, F) "DL/UL timing
QUALCOMM
association of E-DCH operation"
Europe
R1-050208 ~lote of Joint Session on RRM EDCH
RAN1 Chairman
Samsung,
R1-050209 _5.214CR362r1(Rel-6, F)"Gain factor
setting for E-DCH"
Nokia, Philips
R1-050210 --UL E-DPDCH De-boosting Result
Motorola
R1-050211 _S on Layer 1 synchronization procedure WG RAN3
’To ; RAN1, Cc; RAN3, RAN4)
R1-050212 TR25.804 v.1.0.1
InterDigital
R1-050213 Draft] LS on support for higher layer
Samsung
signalling of Plnon-max value
R1-050214 DRAFT] Reply LS on alignment of MBMS Motorola
:ransport channels
Samsung,
R1-050215 _5.214CR362r2(Rel-6, F)"Gain factor
setting for E-DCH"
Nokia, Philips
R1-050216 _S on Faster L1 DCH synchronization
WG RAN1
R1-050217 3R 25.211-202 rl(Rel6, F)"E-HICH/EQUALCOMM
:~GCH/E-AGCH timing"
Europe
R1-050218 3R 25.214-369r1(Re16, F)"DUULtiming QUALCOMM
association of E-DCH operation"
Europe
R1-050219 _S to RAN2 on AGCH (To : RAN2)
WG RAN1
R1-050220 _S on support for higher layer signalling ofWG RAN1
=lnon-max value (To : RAN2, RAN3)
R1-050221 Reply LS on alignment of MBMS transport WG RAN1
shannels (To : RAN3, Cc : RAN2)
R1-050222 _S on MBMS UE capability
WG RAN1
R1-050223 3R 25.211-202 r2(Rel6, F)"E-HICH/E- QUALCOMM
:~GCH/E-AGCH timing"
Europe

18/o2/2OO5Endorsed
Noted
R1-050065)

18/o2/2oosAgreed

R1-050154)

9.6.1

18/o2/2OO5Noted. RAN 1 confirms the correctness of the
RAN 1 parameters.
18/o2/2OO5Revised in Tdoc R1-050217.

9.6.4

18/o2/2OO5Revised in Tdoc R1-050218.

9.3
9.6.4
9.2
5

R1-050060)

16/o2/2OO5Noted
Revised in Tdoc R1-050215.

= R3-050320

18/o2/2OO5Noted
18/o2/2OO5Noted

14
9.6

Agreed as v1.1.0 in Tdoc R1-050229.
18/o2/2oo5 Approved in Tdoc R1-050220.

5
9.6.4

R1-050209)

6.4
9.6.1

R1-050206)

9.6.4

R1-050207)

9.6.1
9.6
5
7
9.6.1

18/o2/2oosApproved with modification in Tdoc R1:)50221
18/o2/2oosAgreed
Approved version
18/o2/2oosAgreed. After the meeting, this document was
revised in Tdoc R1-050223.
18/o2/2oosAgreed. After the meeting, this document was
revised in Tdoc R1-050224.
Approved version
Approved version
Approved version

R1-050217)

Approved version
After the meeting, agreed on the reflector

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011070

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #40bis
Beijing, China, 4 - 8 April, 2005
R1-050224 3R 25.214-369r2(Re16, F)"DL/UL timing QUALCOMM
association of E-DCH operation"
Europe
R1-050225 3omparison of E-HICH/E-RGCH SignatureSiemens
Sequences
R1-050226 _~5.211CR197r2(Rel-6, F)"E-HICH/E-RGCH Siemens
Signature Sequences"
R1-050227 3R25.221-118 (Rel-6, B)"Release 6 HS- IPWireless
3SCH operation without a DL DPCH for
3.84Mcps TDD"
R1-050228 3R25.224-141(Rel-6, B) "Release 6 HS- IPWireless
3SCH operation without a DL DPCH for
3.84Mcps TDD"
R1-050229 ]-R25.804 v. 1.1.0
InterDigital
InterDigital
R1-050230 ]-R25.804 v.2.0.0
R1-050231 ]-R25.808 FDD Enhanced Uplink; Physical Editor (Nokia)
_ayer Aspects, v2.0.0

R1-050369

9.6.4

R1-050218)

9.6.1
9.6.1

~,fter the meeting, agreed on the reflector
Not available

R1-050182)

Not available

11

~,fter the meeting, agreed on the reflector

11

~,fter the meeting, agreed on the reflector

14
14
9

~,greed version.
Submitted in RAN#27 for approval.
Submitted in RAN#27 for approval.

54

APLNDC-WH-A 0000011071