Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 662

EXHIBITS re #660 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Apple Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment Exhibits to Mueller Declaration ISO Apple's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment [660-9] filed byApple Inc.(a California corporation). (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 26, #2 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 27, #3 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 28, #4 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 29, #5 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 30, #6 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 31, #7 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 32, #8 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 33, #9 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 34, #10 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 35, #11 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 36, #12 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 37, #13 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 38, #14 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 39, #15 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 40, #16 Exhibit Mueller Decl Exhibit 41)(Related document(s) #660 ) (Selwyn, Mark) (Filed on 1/25/2012)

Mueller Exhibit 34

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan, 15 - 19 November, 2004
Agenda item

R1-041469

3

Title:

Approved Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #38
(Prague, Czech Republic, 16- 20 August, 2004)

Document for:
Source:

Comments and approval
TSG RAN WG1 Secretary

Notes:
All timestamps in this document are in UTC/GMT+lHunless otherwise noted.

Fact Summary
Meeting:
Dates:
Venue:
Host:
Attendees:
Documents:

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #38
16th through 20th August, 2004
HILTON PRAGUE, Prague, Czech Republic
The European Friends of 3GPP1
96 delegates
246 (including some withdrawn and post-meeting artefacts)

Yoshikazu Ishii
ETSI Mobile Competence Center
[e-mail]

*1 Alcatel, Ericsson, Lucent Technologies, Nokia, Nortel Networks, 02, Orange, Siemens, SIMAlliance, Sonera,
Telefonica, TIM, T-Mobile, VodaJbne, Panasonic.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010870

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Table of contents
Executive summary ......................................................................................................................................

1

1 Opening of the meeting ..............................................................................................................................
1.1
Call for IPR ..................................................................................................................................................

2
2

2

Approval of the agenda and the minutes of the previous RAN WG1 meetings .....................................
2

3.

Summary from RAN#24 and RAN1/2 Ad Hoc ....................................................................................
3

4.

Liaison statement handling .................................................................................................................
3

5.
5.1
5.2
5.3
5.4
5.5
5.6

Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6 ................................................................................................
5
R99 CRs + shadow CRs ...............................................................................................................................
5
Rel4 CRs + shadow CRs ..............................................................................................................................
5
5
Rel5 CRs + shadow CRs ..............................................................................................................................
Rel6 CRs + shadow CRs ..............................................................................................................................
6
Inputs for TS 34.108 + TR 25.993 ................................................................................................................
6
Other ...........................................................................................................................................................
8

6.
6.1
6.2
6.3

MIMO ...............................................................................................................................................
TR 25.876 structure, MIMO requirements ....................................................................................................
System evaluation methodology .................................................................................................................
MIMO Ad Hoc Meeting .............................................................................................................................

7.
7.1
7.2
7.3
7.4

MBMS .............................................................................................................................................
12
13
MBMS indicator channel (MICH) .............................................................................................................
Other MBMS L1 specification aspects ........................................................................................................
14
UE capability definition (incl. macro-diversity) ..........................................................................................
14
MBMS UE performance requirements (joint with RAN4) ...........................................................................
16

8
8.1
8.2

FDD Enhanced Uplink ......................................................................................................................
17
Basic E-DCH physical layer structure (Code mapping, E-DPCCH) .............................................................
17
E-DCH TrCH processing (E-DCH channel coding aspects, self-decodable/non-self-decodable
transmissions) ............................................................................................................................................
19
19
E-DCH transmit power issues (Power offsets, PAR) ...................................................................................
Signalling support for HARQ .....................................................................................................................
20

8.3
8.4
9
9.1
9.2
9.3
9.4

9
9
10
10

Joint session on FDD Enhanced uplink with RAN2 ...........................................................................
22
HARQ principles: Synchronous vs asynchronous retransmissions, SHO operation (continuation of
discussion from joint RAN 1/RAN2 session in Cannes) ...............................................................................
23
Scheduling principles (continuation of discussion from joint RAN 1/RAN2 session in Cannes) ....................
24
Outer loop power control aspects ................................................................................................................
26
Physical layer model and physical layer error requirements .........................................................................
26

10 Other issues for joint discussion with RAN2 .....................................................................................
27
10.1
Review of UL-TDOA Study Item description .............................................................................................
27
10.2
Use of secondaxy scrambling code for IMS .................................................................................................
28

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010871

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

11

Uplink Enhancements for UTRA TDD ..............................................................................................

29

12

Analysis of higher chip rates for UTRAN evolution (TDD) ...............................................................

30

13

Improvement of inter-frequency and inter-system handover measurements ....................................... 31

14

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation (FDD) ....................................................... 32

15

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation (TDD) ..................................................... 32

16

HSDPA ACK/NACK enhancements .................................................................................................

33

(Discussion is limited to coverage improvement and decoder complexity aspects) ....................................... 33
17

Other issues ......................................................................................................................................

34

18 Joint session RAN1 & RAN4 ............................................................................................................
34
18.1
Rel5/Rel CRs .............................................................................................................................................
34
18.2
MBMS Requirements .................................................................................................................................
34
18.3
Rel-6 PAR .................................................................................................................................................
35

19

Closing of the meeting ¯ Friday 5.00 PM ...........................................................................................

35

Annex A: Report from Joint Ad Hoc RAN WG1 - WG4 .........................................................................
36
A. 1
Minimum power limit ................................................................................................................................
36
A.2
MBMS .......................................................................................................................................................
36
UE output power back off ...........................................................................................................................
A. 3
37

Annex B:

List of participants ..................................................................................................................

38

Annex C:

TSG RAN WG1 meetings through 2004 to 2005 .....................................................................

43

Annex D:

List of CRs agreed at RANl#38 ..............................................................................................

44

Annex E:

List oftdocs at RAN1 #38 .......................................................................................................

45

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010872

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Executive summary
WG RAN1 # 38 took place in Hilton Prague, Prague, Czech Republic. The meeting started at 9:00 on Monday 16st August
2004 and finished at 17:00 on Friday 20th.
In the duration of the meeting, the several sessions by only RAN1 delegates were held, and also the joint session with
RAN2 delegates regarding "Enhanced Uplink", and the joint session with RAN4 delegates regarding "MBMS" were held.
On MIMO discussion, the ad hoc meeting was held to resolve the differences among delegates regarding the system
evaluation methodology. On MBMS discussion, the approach of describing MICH was generally agreed, and also the
baseline for the further work to finalise soft combining was decided
On FDD Enhanced Uplink, the working assumption fro "E-DPCCH structure" and "E-DCH Timing" was agreed, and at
the Joint session with RAN2, the agreement was obtained in "HARQ Principles" and "Scheduling Principles"
The number of contribution documents for this meeting was 246, and those documents were categorized as followed.

5. Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6
6. MIMO
7. MBMS
8. FDD Enhanced Uplink
9. Joint session on FDD Enhanced uplink with RAN2
10. Other issues for joint discussion with RAN2
11. Uplink Enhancements for UTRA TDD
12. Analysis of higher chip rates for UTRAN evolution (TDD)
13. Improvement of inter-frequency and inter-system
measuremetns
14. Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation
(FDD)
15. Optimisation of downlink channelisation code utilisation
(TDD)
16. HSDPA ACK/NACK enhancements
17. Other

16
35
29
76
40
1
9
10

16
14
26
15
6
1
8
10

2

2

2

0

1
5
1

0
5
0

Note ¯ In above table, the revised and withdrawn contributions are included in the input documents. The
contributions of RAN1 were only counted for Joint Session.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010873

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

1 Opening of the meeting
1610812004 09:05
The RAN1 Chairman, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger started the meeting.
Mr. Enrico Buracchini from Telecom Italia Lab welcomed the delegates on behalf of the host companies of The European
Friends of 3GPP (Alcatel, Ericsson, Lucent Technologies, Nokia, Nortel Networks, 02, Orange, Siemens, SIMAlliance,
Sonera, Telefonica, TIM, T-Mobile, VodaJbne, Panasonic).
Short wlwcome introduction, enjoy Prague.

1.1

Call for IPR

16/08/2004 09:10

The Chairman drew attention to Members’ obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations’
IPR policies. Every Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner
Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the Individual
Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become essential to the work of 3GPP.
The attention of the members of this Technical Specification Group is drawn to the fact that 3GPP
Individual Members have the obligation under the IPR Policies of their respective Organizational Partners
to inform their respective Organizational Partners of Essential IPRs they become aware of.
The members take note that they are hereby invited:
¯
¯

2

to investigate in their company whether their company does own IPRs which are, or are likely to become
Essential in respect of the work of the Technical Specification Group.
to notif~v the Director-General, or the Chairman of their respective Organizational Partners, of all
potential IPRs that their company may own, by means of the IPR Statement and the Licensing declaration
forms (e.g. see the ETSI IPR forms http://webapp.etsi.org/Ipr/).

Approval of the agenda and the minutes of the
previous RAN WG1 meetings

R1-040810 Draft Agenda for RAN WG1 #38

(RAN1 Chairman)

16/08/2004 09:10 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Mr. Chairman explained the overview of meeting items.
CR input in the first morning and afternoon, and then treat MIMO, Later MBMS in tomorrow morning. We will
have a Joint session with RAN4 on Tuesday evening. Regarding E-DCH on Tuesday afternoon, Joint session with
RAN2 on Wed. E-DCH, and UL-TDOA.
On Thursday or Friday, treat TDD. We will close meeting at 5:00 pm on Firday.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was approved.

R1-040811 Draft Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG1 #37

(RAN1 Secretary)

Decision: This document was not available.

R1-040812 Draft Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Rel.6 Ad Hoc Meeting in Cannes
(RAN1 Secretary)
16/08/2004 09:15
Discussion (Question / Comment): No
Decision: This document was approved with correction the name of the company.

R1-041020 Approved Report of3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Rel.6 Ad Hoc Meeting in Cannes
(RAN1 Secretary)

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010874

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Summary from RAN#24 and RAN1/2 Ad Hoc

3.

R1-040835

Summary from RAN#24

(RAN1 Chairman)

16/08/2004 09:20 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger.
Mr. Chairman, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger presented about the overview of he discussion and decision on the RAN#24,
and also announced the meeting plan in flae next year. In order to cope with several WIs speedy, RAN1 would have
five or six regular WG meetings in next year.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040836

Summary from RAN1/2 Ad hoc meeting in Cannes

(RAN1 Chairman)
(Withdrawn)

Liaison statement handling
R1-040813 (To) Reply LS on Code Sharing during Compressed Mode (To:R1 Cc:R3)
(Reply to R1-040386) TSG RAN WG2
(Nokia)
16/08/2004 09:29 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Discussion (Question / Comment): No
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040814

(Cc) Reply LS on Multiple MBMS Issues (To: $4, R4 Cc: $2, S1, R1, R3, G1, G2,
N1) (Reply to $4-040132) TSG RAN WG2
(Samsung)

Discussion (Question / Comment): This document was already treated in Cannes Meeting
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040815 (Cc) Reply to "LS on RRC release aspects of CS video and voice service
improvements" (To:S2 Cc: R1, R3) (Reply to $2-041641) TSG RAN WG2
(Vodafone)
16/08/2004 09:33 Presented by Mr. Yannick Le Pezennec.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some discussions for this LS. It commented that it was necessary to
look at RAN3 aspects.
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040816
(Cc) LS on RRC release aspects of CS video and voice service improvements
(To:S2, Cc: R1,R2,GP) (Reply to $2-041641) TSG RAN WG3 (Alcatel)
16/08/2004 09:40 Presented by Mr. Stefan Russ.
Discussion (Question / Comment): Wait for the any proposal regarding the LS in this week.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040817 (To) Response LS on Multiple MBMS Issues (To: R1, R2, R3, GP, G2)
(Reply
to R1-040385, R1-040651, etc) TSG SA WG4
(Siemens)
Discussion (Question / Comment): This document was already treated in Cannes Meeting.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040818 (Cc) LS on Proposed Modification to HSDPA Radio Bearer Settings
(To: R2 Cc: R1)
TSG T WG1
(QUALCOMM)
16/08/2004 09510 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): I was commented about PDU size 656.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-041014 (To) LS on the material to be submitted to ITU-R WP8F#14 for Revision 5 of
Recommendation ITU-R M.1457
ITU-R Ad Hoc
(To:R1, R2, R3, R4)
(Telecomm Italia)
16/08/2004 09:56 Presented by Mr. Enrico Buracchini.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010875

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Discussion (Question / Comment): Mr. Chairman commented that anyone who have some comments about the
LS should provided them until Friday morning.
Decision: This documents was noted.
R1-041045

Response to LS on the material to be submitted to ITU-R WPSF#14 for Revision
5 of Recommendation ITU-R M.1457(To:ITU-R Ad Hoc)
ITU-R Ad Hoc
(Telecomm Italia)

20/08/2004 11:31 Presented by Mr. Enrico Buracchini.
Discussion (Question / Comment): No
Decision: This draft was approved in Tdoc R1-041046.

R1-041039

(Cc) Reply LS on Proposed Modification to HSDPA Radio Bearer Settings
(To:T1 Cc: R1)
TSG RAN WG2 (NTT DoCoMo)

20/08/2004 13:52 Presented by Mr. Chairman on behalf ofNTT DoCoMo.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-041040

(Cc) LS on enhancing L1 multiplexing test coverage in 3GPP test
specifications (To:T1, Cc: R1)
TSG RAN WG2 (Nokia)

20/08/2004 13:55 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: It was decided to provide quick feedback to TSG WG-T1 that RAN1 would review the L1 aspects and
provide more feedback from RAN#38bis in Tdoc R1-041049.

R1-041049

DRAFT LS on L1 multiplexing test coverage in 3GPP test specifications
TSG RAN WG1 (Nokia)

20/08/2004 14:45 Presented by Mr. Markku Tarkiainen.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This draft was approved as Tdoc R1-041053 and it was decided to continue the discussion also whether
R99 or Rel.5 until RAN#38bis.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010876

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

5.

Maintenance of R99, Rel4, Rel5, Rel6

5.1

R99 CRs + shadow CRs

There were no contributions to this Agenda Item.

5.2

Rel4 CRs + shadow CRs

R1-040826

25222CR122(Rel-4, F)&CR123(Rel-5, A)&CR124(Rel-6, A): "Correction of
symbol Xi defined in sub-frame segmentation step"
(Siemens)

16/08/2004 09:57 Presented by Mr. Huang Xue Gang.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that there was no isolated impact analysis and how impacts
was this CR.
Decision: This document was not approved and would be provided the revision with isolated impact analysis in R1041017.

R1-041017

25222CR122rl(Rel-4, F)&CR123rl(Rel-5, A)&CR124rl(Rel-6, A): "Correction of
symbol Xi defined in sub-frame segmentation step"
(Siemens)

20/08/2004 14:50 Presented by Mr. Huang Xue Gang.
Decision: This CR was approved.

R1-040883

25.224CR132(Rel-4, F)&CR133(Rel-5, A)&CR134(Rel-6, A) "Transmit diversity
usage for beacon channels in LCR TDD" (IPWireless, Interdigital, Siemens)

16/08/2004 10;01 Presented by Mr. Ma Sha.
Decision: This document was approved.

R1-040913

25224CR135(Rel-4, F)&CR136(Rel-5, A)&CR137(Rel-6, A): "Corrections of radio
access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD"
(Siemens AG, CATT)

16/08/2004 09:15 Presented by Mr. Huang Xue Gang.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that RAN2 would discussed also same CR in Prague.
Decision: This document was approved with modification in the cover sheet (list RAN2 affected specification) in
R1-041018.

R1-041018

5.3

25224CR135rl(Rel-4, F)&CR136rl(Rel-5, A)&CR137rl(Rel-6, A): "Corrections
of radio access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD"
(Siemens AG, CATT)

Rel5 CRs + shadow CRs

R1-040839

25.214CR343rl(Rel-5, F)&CR344rl(Rel-6, A) "Clarification of minimum
power limit"
(Panasonic) (Revised R1-040198)

16/08/2004110:20 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document would be looked at again in Joint session with RAN4 on Tuesday. (See Annex A)
R1-041037

25.214CR343r2(Rel-5, F) CR344r2(Rel-6, A) "Clarification of minimum power
limit"
(Panasonic) (Revised R1-040839)
20/08/2004 14:55 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: It was not clear if CR is need or not. It was decided to conclude discussion in RANl#38bis

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010877

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040874

R1-041469

25.211CR191(Rel-5, F)&CR192(Rel-6, A) "Correction for the slot range of DL
DPCCH power control preamble for CPCH"
(LG Electronics)

16/08/2004 10:14 Presented by Mr. Hak-Seong Kim.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented whether this CR should be for R99 or Rel.4, but it was
decided that it was not necessoxy.
Decision: This document was approved.

5.4

Rel6 CRs + shadow CRs

R1-040823

Introduction of a new Node B measurement ’DL Transmission Branch Load’
(Siemens)

16/08/2004 11 : 15 Presented by Dr. Joern Krause.

R1-040824

CR147 to 25.215 v6.0.0 Introduction of ’DL Transmission Branch Load’
measurement
(Siemens)

16/08/2004 11:23 Presented by Dr. Joern Krause.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some questions about the situation in this Tdoc. It was commented
that this Tdoc and CR should be discussed with RAN4 or RAN3 regarding diversity, power definition, Maximum
power, in especially, power was the most impact to Node B.
Decision: It was decided that Tdoc R1-040823and R1-040824 would be discussed again with RAN4 on Tuesday.
See Annex A.

R1-040875

25.214CR349(Rel-6, F) "Clarification of SSDT uplink only signaling"
(LG Electronics)

16/08/2004 10:23 Presented by Mr. Hak-Seong, Kim.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented whether this CR is necessary for Rel.5.
Decision: This document was technically endorsed. The CR was needed to provide the CR for Rel.5 also revised in
Tdoc R1-041019.

R1-041019

25.214CR349rl(Rel-6, F)&CR350(Rel-5, A) "Clarification of SSDT uplink only
signaling"
(LG Electronics)

19/08/2004 15:10 Presented by Mr. Hak-Seong, Kim.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This CR was approved. MCC will correct cover sheets (RE6 Cat F and appropriate WI code).

R1-041059

25.214CR352rl(Rel-6, F)&CR353(Rel-5, A) "Clarification of SSDT uplink only
signaling"
(LG Electronics)

Decision: The CR numbers of Tdoc R1-041019 was overlapped with other document. In order to cope with this
problem, the new CR numbers (352 and 353) and Tdoc numner (R1-041059) were allocated by MCC after the
meeting closed. R1-041059 was approved as the final version.
[Editor Note] Coffee Break in the morning.

5.5

Inputs for TS 34.108 + TR 25.993

R1-040882

HS RAB combinations for testing

(Ericsson)

16/08/2004 11:47 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010878

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040834

R1-041469

Inclusion of combinations of multiple radio bearers with HSDPA into TS
34.108
(Vodafone Group)

16/08/2004 11:52 Presented by Mr. Yannick Le P~zermec.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that t~is topic should be treated in RAN2, but the chairman
commented that there were some discussion points regarding this issue in RAN1. It was another commented there
were overlaps and differences between this proposal and Ericsson’s proposal, so they should be checked.
Decision: Regarding above two paper (R1-040882 and R1-04083ZD, it was decided that the offline discussion
would be continued during this week and given the feedback to Vodafone and Ericsson again. This topic was
treated again on Joint session with RAN2 on Thursday.

Joint Session RAN1/RAN2 regarding "HSDPA RABs" was held on Thursday morning.
R2-041856

HSDPA RAB methodology

(Qualcomm)

19/08/2004 11:30 Presented by Mr. Hector Vaymaos.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that the link between 34.108/25.993 and the responsibility
from T1, RAN2 or other groups should be carefully considered. However, it was also commented that for the very
short future some very basic RAB combinations were needed to increase the HSDPA test coverage in 34.108, and
are also needed in TR 25.993.
Decision: This document was noted, and there were the sentence revisions on this document as followed.
On DL, all PS RABs will be mapped on the HS-DSCH.
o When with voice/video, all PS-RABs mapped on HS-DSCH
o When no voice/video, test 2 PS RABs on HS-DSCH or sprit DCH/HS-DSCH.
Use MAC-d flow multiplexing to when of RABs on GHS-DSCH > la!!ew the expansien efthe numSer ef P~,Es
On UL, a single transport channel is sufficient for supporting all PS RABs.
Define RABs with support for MAC-d multiplexing on UL to allow the expansion of the number of RABs
supported.
For the PS RAB, support TTI durations of 10 and 20ms, and RLC PDU sizes of 336bits and 656bits.
For the DCCH, use 20ms TTI instead of 40ms (no need to add a new DPCH RAB).
Provide support for NB-AMR and 64kbps CS video on the associated DPCH.

R2-041605

Inclusion of combinations of multiple radio bearers with HSDPA into TS
34.108
(Vodafone Group, Qualcomm)

This document was already seen by the working groups separately @1-04083@
Discussion: It was commented that there was an earlier discussion in RAN WG1 for the uplink rate (lower rates to
be included or not), and also for e.g. video (restricting the TFC or not).
Decision: The conclusion was agreed, expect WB-AMR combination, which is FFS, 128kbps UL is FFS. Agreed to
add 64kpbs support at the next meeting. RABs proposed to 25.993 may be given to T-Mobile. The updated CR on
34.108 is in tdoc R2-041810
Additional HSDPA RABs for inclusion into 25.993 have been proposed and presented in RAN2 (R2-041811).
RAN1 chairman asked for review and input to RAN1 separately. The corresponding input for 25.993 is in R1041038 from T-Mobile and was presented during the RAN1 #38 meeting (also containing the "pointers" to the
agreed RABs included from R2-041810). Due to time contains it was agreed that RAN1 will check the layerl
parameters in flae September ’04 RAN 1 # 38bis meeting.

[Editor Note]

R1-041038

Lunch Break.

Proposed addition for TR25.993

(T-Mobile, Siemens, Nokia)

20/08/2004 13:58 Presented by Mr. Dirk Kistowski from T-Mobile.
Discussion:
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to be reviewed by RAN1 until RANl#38bis.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010879

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

5.6

R1-041469

Other

R1-040904

Issues with Radio Link Synchronization

(Ericsson)

16/08/2004 14:13 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some questions about A a~d B synchronization. It was commented
that the document had two issue, one is Timing maintain handover and link synchronization.
Decision: This document was noted and more discussion was continued till next meeting.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010880

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

6.

R1-041469

MIMO

The overview of MIMO discussion was as followed.

6.1

TR 25.876 structure, MIMO requirements

R1-040931

TR25.876 v.l.5.l "Multiple-Input Multiple Output in UTRA"
(Editor : Lucent Technologies)

16/08/2004 14:50 Presented by Mr. Teck Hu.
Decision : This document was approved as version 1.6.0 in Tdoc R1-041021.

R1-040870

MIMO generic scheme and text proposal for the MIMO TR 25.876
(Nortel Networks)

16/08/2004 14:59 Presented by Mr. Hassan E1 Nahas.

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented about ~he difference form the Nokia proposal in Montreal
meeting.
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to have the offline discussion until Wednesday evening.

R1-040915

Tx Diversity and MIMO

(Alcatel)

16/08/2004 15:19 Presented by Mr. Stefan Russ.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that we need the definition of MIMO and TX Diversity.
Decision: This document was not approved and the text proposal was not included.
[Editor Note]Take break for coffee.

R1-040905

MIMO Evolution Path requirements

(Siemens)

16/08/2004 16:20 Presented by Dr. Seyed H Mortazavi
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that for time consuming we should have offline discussion
before the conclusion.
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to have the offline discussion until Wednesday evening.

R1-040981

MIMO Reference Cases

(Nokia)

16/08/2004 16:45 Presented by Mr. Jean-Philippe Kermoal.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that flais reference cases were very useful.
Decision: It was agreed to use 6 sectors and 2Rx LMMSE as reference case for MIMO for MIMO studies.
It was decided to provide a TP after the offline discussion in Tdoc R1-041022.

R1-041022

MIMO Reference Cases

(Nokia)

19/08/2004 14:45 Presented by Jean-Philippe Kermoal.
Discussion (Question / Comment): no
Decision: This document was approved.

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010881

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-041050

R1-041469

TR25.876 v.l.6.1 "Multiple-Input Multiple Output in UTRA"
(Lucent Technologies)

Decision: This document was not available. It was decided to approval via email until August 31

6.2

System evaluation methodology

R1-040982

Comments and TP on MIMO Compatibility Assessment
(QUALCOMM Europe)

16/08/2004 16:55 Presented by Mr. Hans Schotten..
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: It was decided to provide the revision after offline discussion in Tdoc R1-041023 by Wednesday
evening.

R1-041023

Comments and TP on MIMO Compatibility Assessment
(QUALCOMM Europe)

19/08/2004 14:55 Presented by Mr. Hans Schotten.
Discussion (Question / Comment): no
Decision: This document was approved.

R1-040934

Text Proposal on MIMO System Simulation Evaluation Methodology
(Mitsubishi Electric Research Labs : MERL)

16/08/2004 17:14 Presented by Dr. Neelesh B. Mehta.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040980

Text Proposal on System Setup for MIMO (Nokia, TeliaSonera, T-Mobile)

16/08/2004 17:18 Presented by Mr. Jean-Philippe Kermoal.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted. Regarding the above two proposal, it should be resolved the differences :
Scheduler, LIE speed model, traffic model, inclusion of HSDPA traffic models, modelling of overhead channels
fixed/variable power, wrap-around. With regard to MIMO, we have more offline discussion and after Wednesday,
we would check the discussion results.

6.3

MIMO Ad Hoc Meeting

The Ad Hoc meeting for MIMO was held on Tuesday morning (17/08/2004). Participating companies: Alcatel, ETRI, TMobile, Ericsson, Nokia, Siemens, TeliaSonera, Mitsubishi, Nortel, Huawei, Siemens, Lucent, Samsung, Qualcomm. R1040982, R1-040870, and R1-040905 were also discussed in fiae MIMO AdHoc meeting. The outcome of the discussions
was summarized in R 1-041036.

R1-041036

Summary from MIMO ad hoc meeting

(MIMO ad hoc)

19/08/2004 14:50 Presented by Mr. Hans Schotten of Qualcomm on behalf of the ad hoc meeting
Discussion (Question / Comment): No
Decision: This summary was approved.

R1-041034

Text proposal on System setup to MIMO

(MIMO ad hoc)

19/08/2004 14: 58Presented by Dr. Neelesh B. Mehta on behalf of the ad hoc meeting.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented about editorial revision.
Decision: The document was approved with addition of reference of [6] and correction "the reference cases" in
A. 2.1.10.2. And also it was decided to continue discussion of particular proposals (with indication of gains) at
RANl#39.

The following documents were not treated.

lO

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010882

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040820
R1-040821
R1-040829
R1-040830
R1-040871
R1-040920
R1-040921
R1-040868
R1-040869
R1-040916
R1-040917
R1-040930
R1-040986
R1-040987
R1-040988
R1-040989
R1-041007
R1-041011
R1-041012
R1-041013
R1-040990

R1-041469

Modified per stream rate control for 2-antenna MIMO

(TI)
(=R1-040517)
Text proposal for modified per stream rate control for 2-antenna (TI)
(=R1-040518)
Double-ASTTD with Sub-Group Rate Control
(Huawei Technologies)
Text Proposal for Double-ASTTD with Sub-Group Rate Control
(Huawei Technologies)
CQI feedback for RC-MPD
(Nortel Networks)
Spatial channel coding (SCC) for high throughput with a single receive antenna
(Philips)
Text Proposal for Spatial Channel Coding
(Philips)
Further simulations on RC-MPD and comparison with PARC, DSTTD, and
R’99 TxDiv
(Nortel Networks)
First MIMO Traffic simulations for RC-MPD and PARC with real channnel
estimation
(Nortel Networks)
4Tx open-loop closed-loop (OL-CL) MIMO
(Alcatel)
(=R1-040521)
Text Proposal for 4Tx open-loop closed-loop (OL-CL) MIMO (Alcatel)
(=R1-040595)
Performance aspects of advanced spectral processing MIMO receivers for
multi-code reception
(Fujitsu, Dune Srl)
Comparison of D-ASTTD-SGRC and DSTTD-SGRC using full-queue system
simulations
(Huawei Technologies)
Midamble Allocation and Channelistion Code Allocation Signaling to Support
MIMO in UTRA TDD
(IPWireless) (R1-040580)
Text Proposal for MIMO TR 25.876 (Midamble Allocation and Code
Allocation Signaling)
(IPWireless) (R1-040581)
Per Antenna Rate Control for UTRA TDD
(IPWireless) (R1-040582)
Per-Stream Rate Control for LCR TDD_System Proposal and Initial Link
Level Results
(CATT)
Fairness based multiuser MIMO scheduling
(Samsung)
Antenna selection based MIMO
(Samsung & SNU)
PU2RC Simulation
(Samsung & SNU)
Text Proposal for MIMO TR 25.876 (MIMO Proposal for UTRA TDD)
(IPWireless) (R1-040583)

11

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010883

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

7. MBMS
The overview of discussion and conclusion about MBMS was as followed.

, PP gq .........

g .........P ........ .....................

P P, ....

R1-040983
TR 25.803 vl.3.1
16/08/2004 17:41 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.

(QUALCOMM Europe)

Decision : This document was approved as v1.4.0 in R1-041024.

R1-041024
TR 25.803 vl.4.0
R1-041026
TR 25.803 vl.4.1
20/08/2004 16:40 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.

(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)

Decision : It was decided to approve via E-mail until August 30 (only Siemens TPs will be included. Qualcomm
TPs will be proposed in a separate TP for approval)

R1-040827

Simulation results for 1.28Mcps TDD MBMS
(Revised R1-040441)

(Siemens)

16/08/2004 17:44 Presented by Mr. Huang Xue Gang.
Decision: This document was agreed for inclusion in TR.

12

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010884

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040828

R1-041469

Coverage Results for MBMS (1.28Mcps TDD): Updated Text Proposal for TR
25.803
(Siemens) (Revised R1-040620)

16/08/2004 17:46 Presented by Mr. Huang Xue Gang.
Decision: This document was agreed for inclusion in TR.

7.1

MBMS indicator channel (MICH)

R1-040884

Draft CR for introduction of MICH in 25.21x

(QUALCOMM Europe)

16/08/2004 17:52 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that there were some editorial errors.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-040867

MBMS notification procedure on MICH

(Panasonic)

16/08/2004 18:09 Presented by Mr. Frdddric Charpentier.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are many comments and questions about the proposal notification
procedure from especially Qualcomm and NEC.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-041015

Comments on MICH mapping proposal in R1-040867

(NEC)

16/08/2004 18:34 Presented by Mr. Thanh Bui.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040984

On NI mapping

(QUALCOMM)

16/08/2004 18:41 Presented by Mr. Hector Vaya~os.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are many comments and questions from Panasonic. Regarding MICH,
NEC was objective to Panasonic, Panasonic was objective to Qualcomm.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040848

On MICH mapping

(NEC)

16/08/2004 19:05 Presented by Mr. Thanh Bui.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that in this situation, there are no progress, so take this
proposal as working assumption and analyse until next meeting whether it has any problem.
Decision: This document was noted.
From the discussion about above contributions, the following conclusion was completed.

Conclusion about MICH
¯

General agreement with the approach of describing MICH in R1-040884. Proceed with drafting of RAN1 CRs.

¯

NI mapping (q formula): Take proposal in R1-040984 as working assumption, perform further simulations until
RAN1 #38bis regarding f(.) to confirm the performance.

¯

Inform other WGs about RANI’s decisions on MICH ( in R1-041025).

¯

Version 1.4.1 of the TR 25.803 (in R1-04102f!).

[Editor Note] The first day was finished.

R1-041025
[DRAFT] LS on introduction of the MICH in 25.21 (QUALCOMM)
20/08/2004 12:25 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Decision: The draft was approved in Tdoc R1-041048.

13

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010885

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

7.2

R1-041469

Other MBMS L1 specification aspects

R1-040840

MBMS L1 possible limitations

(Panasonic)
(Revised R1-040710)

17/08/2004 09:09 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are many questions and comments for the issues describing in this
contributions. It was commented that it was good idea to reduce unnecessary functions and BLER measurement of
S-CCPCH was necessary. The question was asked what kind of scenoxio was assumed on BLER measuremsnts.
Decision: This document was noted. I was decided to make a draft LS to RAN2/3/4 with the points where RAN1
can agree on R1-041029.

R1-041029

DRAFT Question on the impact of L1 limitations on MBMS (Panasonic)

20/08/2004 11:35 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some comments and suggestion of sentence revision.
Decision: The draft was approved with modifications in Tdoc R1-041047.
R1-040918

Reordering of TTIs in MBMS

(Siemens)
(Revised R1-040775)

17/08/2004 09:51 Presented by Mr. Thomas Hindelang.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that MTCH level measurement was not really RAN1 matter
and also the similox effect might be achievable by time shifting TX from Node B.
Decision: This document was noted. Only applicable for Soft Conbining depending on measurement time in LIE.
But, this topic is the higher layer issue, RAN1 could not agree at the moment. It was necessary to discuss with other
RAN WG.
[Editor Note] Coffee break

UE capability definition (incl. macro-diversity)

7.3

R1-040841
How MBMS UE capability is defined?
17/08/2004 14:39 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.

(Panasonic)

Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented about the capability about reception of MTCH. It was
commented that this contribution was not only for LIE capability, some description fro network side was necessary.
The question was asked if 6.6 rule was applied. The answer to the question was that it was not necesarrt for SCCPCH carrying MTCH.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-040886 UE Capability for MBMS
17/08/2004 14:52 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.

(QUALCOMM Europe)

Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some question and comments and also objections for the LIE
capability on this contribution. It was commented that soft combining buffer shoud be configured depending on the
configured TTI and the other parameters.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-040919
R1-041016

Further considerations on the UE capability for MBMS (FDD) (Siemens)
Further considerations on the UE capability for MBMS (FDD) (Siemens)
(revised R1-040919)

17/08/2004 15:13 Presented by Mr. Thomas Hindelang.
Discussion (Question / Comment):.It was commented that 256kbps service and around 25% overhead should be
claified.
Decision: This document was noted

14

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010886

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

[Chairman’s Note] Discussion to continue on how to define the MBMS capability requirement
[Editor Note] Coffee break,

Soft Combining
R1-040885

Soft combining aspects of MBMS

(QUALCOMM Europe)

17/08/2004 11 : 15 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some comments and questions regarding the conditions and type
for SC. The question was asked if S-CCPCH needed indentical.
Decision: This document was noted
R1-040998
MBMS Transport and Physical Layer Soft Combining
17/08/2004 11:28 Presented by Mr. Mark Harrison.

(Motorola)

Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some comments about time relation and difference. It was
commented that it should be discussed with RAN2 before decision.
Decision: This document was noted.

Discussion Point for Soft Combining
Time multiplexing on TTI basis & (PhCH) soft combining?
)

Allowing for different MTCH or MTCH and MCCH in different RL to be combined.

)

Combining decision could be based e.g. on TFCI and/or scheduling information
TFCI combining cannot be assumed a-priori. (more pessimistic TFCI power setting ? Or use single TF
detection on each TrCH, fixed position and no TFCI bits)
Draft a compromise proposal for LLR combining in (R1-041030)
Draft an LS to RAN2 with specific questions related to the compromise proposal in (R1-041031_) Nortel

R1-041030

Baseline for finalization of MBMS soft combining
(Qualcomm Europe, Motorola)

20/08/2004 12:45 & 14:30 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was agreed as baseline for the further work to finalise soft combining. It was decided to
continue discussion via reflector before RAN1 #38bis.

R1-041031

Draft LS on questions on MBMS

(Nortel Networks)

20/08/2004 12:30 Presented by Ms. Evelyne Le Strat.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This draft was approved with modifications (removal last two bullets + grammar) in Tdoc R1-041052
(cc: RAN3)

R1-041002

Soft Combining for MBMS

(Ericsson)

17/08/2004 12:16 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
The summ~y of discussion points was presented.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted. It was decided to continue the discussion about timing different.
[Editor Note] Lunch break

R1-040887

S-CCPCH performance with 256 kbps

(QUALCOMM Europe)
(=R1-040716)

15

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010887

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

17/08/2004 14:16 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commnetd that the performance difference between 80 ms TTI and 40
ms TTI would become more large if we have taken into account the measurement gap
Decision: This document was noted. The simulation results on this contribution would be included in the TR.

R1-040849

7.4

UE Capability

(NEC)

MBMS UE performance requirements (joint with RAN4)

The report of this AI was described in clause 18 and also the draft report of RAN1/RAN4 Joint Session was distributed
from WG4 secretary as shown in Annex A.

16

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010888

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

8 FDD Enhanced Uplink
The overview of conclusion about this AI was as followed.

R1-040971

TR25.808 v0.0.3

(Nokia)

17/08/2004 16:23 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-~ao.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was approved as version 0.1.0 in Tdoc R1-041033

R1-041033

8.1

TR25.808 v0.1.0

(Nokia)

Basic E-DCH physical layer structure (Code mapping, EDPCCH)

E-DPCCH Structure
¯ TDM
R1-040962

Proposal on RR, SI time multiplexing with HS-DPCCH

(NTT DoCoMo)

17/08/2004 16:32 Presented by Mr. Anil Umesh
Discussion (Question / Comment): The question was asked what was flae impact to HSDPA on this method. The
answer to the question was that the proposal was to link with Rel-6.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040972

HSUPA Requirements for uplink signalling

(Nokia)

17/08/2004 16;52 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-~ao.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

17

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010889

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040872
R1-041004

R1-041469

UL signalling for FDD enhanced UL
(Nortel Networks)
UL signalling for FDD enhanced UL (Nortel Networks) (Revised R1-040872)

17/08/2004 17:03 Presented by Ms. Sarah Boumendil.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There was a question about the simulation assumption. It was commented that
TDM might impact to PAR due to different gain factors. The question was asked that tailing was assumed or not.
The answer to the question was that it’s not a particular isuue.
Decision: This document was noted

R1-040880

Uplink Signalling alternatives for FDD Enhanced Uplink
(Mitsubishi Electronic)

17/08/2004 17:15 Presented by Mr. Michiaki Takanoy.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

¯

CDM

R1-040956

Uplink Control Signaling

(Ericsson)

17/08/2004 17:27 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Decision: This document was noted.
Mr. Chairman asked companies for their preference between TDM and CDM. NTT DoCoMo, Motorola, Nortel,
Mitsubishi supports TDM approach, Other supports CDM approach. And then it was decided that we should have
the offline discussion for this topic, and also come back in this week.
Regarding this topic, the discussion started again on Thursday afternoon, and as result of the discussion, the
following conclusion could be obtained.

Working assumption
For 2ms TTI
CDM
Power requirement accounted for by E-TFC selection
For 10ms TTI
Either CDM (E-DPPCH same as for 2ms, e.g. 5 times repeated) or TDM (e.g. E-DPCCH same as for 2ms, timemux in first 3 slots of E-DCH)
Power requirements accounted for by E-TFC selection
Additional ways of dealing with power limitation might be necessary
-~Work on a 2ms coding structure can start already.
-~Discussion on CDM/TDM for 10ms taken at RANl#38bis
--~No more simultaneously code channels will be added for E-UL

Uplink signalling Information
Transmission format and HARQ related information up to in the order of 10 bits
E-TFRI [5] bites, Boost [1] bit, NDI[2-3]bits, TSN/RSN[0-3]bits, RV[0-2]bits
Scheduling information up to in the order of 12 bits
Rate request [1-5]bits, power info [4-5]bits, Buffer info [3-4]bits, time duration [0-5]bits
assumed TFC for SHO [3-5]bits, QoS requirements [4]bis

E-DCH Timing

(Huawei Technologies)

R1-040833 EDCH timing
19/08/2004 17:40 Presented by Ms. Ma Sha.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040843

Channel priority and uplink transmission timing

(Panasonic)

19/08/2004 17:55 Presented by Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki.
Discussion (Question / Comment):

18

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010890

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040890

TP on E-DCH Timing

(QUALCOMM Europe)

19/08/2004 18:00 Presented by Mr. Serge Willenegger.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was commented that DPDCH aligmnet was better for TFC selection.
Decision: This document was noted.
Regarding E-DCH timing, many discussion were repeated. Nokia, Ericsson, Samsung, Motorola, and Lucent agreed
with Qualcomm. In especially, Panasonic objected that E-DCH timing was DPDCH flame aligned.
Regarding this topic, the discussion started again on Friday afternoon, and Panasonic supported to the contribution,
as result of the discussion, the following working assumption could be obtained.

Working assumption
E-DCH timing is DPCH frame aligned.

The following documents were not treated.
Uplink signaling for E-DCH
R1-040943
(LG Electronics)
R1-040865
EUL scheduling: signalling support
(Samsung)
EUL physical channel code mapping
(Samsung)
R1-040850
R1-040888
OVSF code space for E-DCH
(QUALCOMM Europe)
R1-040889
TP on PhCH mapping of E-DCH
(QUALCOMM Europe)
R1-040941
Physical channel code mapping for E-DCH
(LG Electronics)
R1-040949
Secondary Pilot for E-DCH
(NEC)
R1-040955
System performance with low capability UE (2ms TTI vs 10ms TTI)
(eanasonic)
R1-040957
Downlink Control Signaling
(Ericsson)
R1-041008
Simulations related to R1-040962
(NTT DoCoMo)

8.2

E-DCH TrCH processing (E-DCH channel coding aspects,
self-decodable/non-self-decodable transmissions)

R1-040855

HARQ: physical layer aspects

R1-040891
R1-040892
R1-040893
R1-040894
R1-040958

Choice of RV and code rates
TP on IR versions
Impact of SNR mismatch on turbo decoding
Reference short-term link curves for 10ms TTI
E-DCH Physical Layer Hybrid ARQ Processing

8.3

(Samsung)
(Revised R1-040797)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(Ericsson)

E-DCH transmit power issues (Power offsets, PAR)

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040831
R1-040859
R1-040909
R1-040927
R1-040928
R1-041005

Power adjustment of ACK/NACK signaling based on ACK/NACK error rate
(Huawei Technologies)
Power control at the maximum power limit for EUL
(Samsung)
EUL Power Requirements
(Motorola)
Retransmission Power Optimisation
(Siemens)
E-DCH HARQ with Power Offset
(Siemens)
Traffic to Pilot Ratio Settings and Pilot Powers for EDCH
(Lucent Technologies)
19

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010891

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

8.4

R1-041469

Signalling support for HARQ

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040832
R1-040837
R1-040838
R1-040842
R1-040862
R1-040895
R1-040896
R1-040897
R1-040922

Downlink Signalling Mapping of ACK and NACK
DL ACK structure
DL ACK Selection
Number of simultaneous reception of Acks in SHO
RV Signalling
E-TFICH performance with synchronous HARQ
E-TFICH performance with asynchronous HARQ
HARQ channel mapping in DL

(Huawei Technologies)
(Via Telecom)
(Via Telecom)
(eanasonic)
(Samsung)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(=R1-040723)
Interaction between Enhanced Uplink and Compressed Mode(Philips)
(Revised R1-040770)

R1-040923

HARQ in SHO for Enhanced Uplink

R1-040942
R1-040944
R1-040952
R1-040973

Signaling to support 2 ms and 10 ms TTIs for E-DCH
(LG Electronics)
Principles of downlink ACK/NACK signaling for E-DCH (LG Electronics)
HARQ Downlink Signalling
(NEC) (R1-040742)
Implicit Redundancy Version for IR HARQ Scheme
(Nokia) (=R1-040752)
HSUPA HARQ ACK/NACK signalling performance
(Nokia)

R1-040974

8.5

(Philips)
(Revised R2-041286)

Signalling support for Scheduler

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040844
R1-040854
R1-040856
R1-040857
R1-040879
R1-040912
R1-040924
R1-040932
R1-040933
R1-040945
R1-040953
R1-040968
R1-040969
R1-040975
R1-040999
R1-041001
R1-041009
R1-041010
R1-040976

Uplink power signalling information for the scheduling (Panasonic)
Uplink signalling for Node B controlled scheduling
(Samsung)
(Revised R1-040696)
Downlink control channel structure
(Samsung) (Withdrawn)
System level performance with periodic TPS reporting (Samsung)
Signalling for primary Node-B selection in SHO
(Mitsubishi Electric)
Multi-step rate scheduling and synchronization scheme (Alcatel Shanghai Bell)
Node B controlled scheduling in soft handover
(Philips)
(Revised R2-041286)
Principles of scheduling for enhanced uplink
(Fujitsu)
Node B controlled scheduling in soft handover
(Fujitsu)
Timing of downlink signaling with 10 ms TTI for E-DCH (LG Electronics)
Robust Signalling in Rate Scheduling (NEC) (R1-040740) (Not Available)
UL Signalling overhead for node B scheduling in SHO
(Siemens)
(Revised R1-040788)
DL Signalling overhead for node B scheduling
(Siemens)
(Revised R1-040787)
HSUPA Signalling aspects of the rate scheduling (Nokia) (=R1-040750)
Signalling framework for Enhanced Uplink scheduling (Fujitsu)
E-DCH scheduling method in SHO
(Panasonic) (withdrawn)
RoT information broadcast as auxiliary information
(Panasonic)
Signalling for E-DCH Scheduling - Text proposal
(Fujitsu)
HSUPA Downlink scheduling signalling performance (Nokia)
2O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010892

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040852

Selection of primary scheduling Node B in SHO

R1-040908
R1-040910
R1-040914

Time and Rate scheduler for Enhanced Uplink
Signalling Support for EUL
Target RoT control methods for HSUPA

R1-040907
R1-040911

Rate Contol Scheduler for Enhanced Uplink
Outer loop power control for EUL

R1-041469
(Samsung)
(Revised R1-040691)
(Motorola)
(Motorola)
(eanasonic)
(Revised R1-040780)
(Motorola)
(Motorola)

21

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010893

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

9 Joint session on FDD Enhanced uplink with RAN2
RAN1/2 Joint Session on this topic started at 09:00 on Wednesday (18/08/2004). The overview of conclusion was as
followed. The draft report of this Joint Session ~vas distributed from WG-RAN2 secretary. (The draft report could be
obtained on FTP server of 3GPP home page).

22

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010894

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R2-041408

Agenda of the RAN1-RAN2 joint session

R1-041469
(Chairman)

HARQ principles Synchronous vs asynchronous
retransmissions, SHO operation (continuation of discussion
from joint RAN1/RAN2 session in Cannes)

9.1

R1-040898

Impact of asynchronous HARQ

(QUALCOMM Europe)

18/08/2004 09:15 Presented by Ms. Jelena Damnjanovic.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R2-041620
E-DCH HARQ delay; synchronous versus asynchonous retransmission
(Ericsson)
18/08/2004 09:45 Presented by Mr. Sven Ekemark.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R2-041589
E-DCH - Comparison of process modes for HARQ
(Siemens)
18/08/2004 10:0 Presented by Mr. Thomas Stadler.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040864
HARQ principle
(Samsung)
18/08/2004 1 o: 15 Presented by Dr. Juho Lee.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040940
HARQ Processes for 2ms and 10ms
(Lucent Technologies)
18/08/2004 11:25 Presented by Mr. Teck Hu.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040906
Fully sychronous HARQ and reliable signaling in SHO
(Motorola)
18/08/2004 09:15 Presented by Mr. Robert Love.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
After discussion for the above 6 contributions, WG1/WG2 Chairman summarised about HARQ as followed.
¯
¯
¯
¯
¯
¯
¯

Synchronous repetitions
How many processes: to be discussed with Lucent paper
>
3 or 4 processes in 10 ms TTI
>
5 or 6 processes in 2 ms TTI
Trmasmission up to N times, Network parameter, or more complex..., per MAC-d flow (diff parameters for
diff QoS support)...
Beta factors up to NW.
Fixed or dynamic or diffirent for transmission and re-transmission, etc.
IR agreed in RAN1 Redundancy versions taken in a given order, with first txansmission always selfdecordable. Retransmissions may not be self-decordable. Number of RVs to cycle use is controlled by the Nw
and may be different for different TFRCs.
No need to recoginize the Node-B from upper layers when moving in/out SHO) however, Node-B may have
SHO status via SHO indicator). LIE selects E-TFC. RV for certain E-TFC may be linked to CFN, some
explicitly signalled for other E-TFC(How and where TBD)

The following documents were not treated.

R1-040876
R1-040899
R1-040938
R1-040939

Multiple number of SAW ARQ processes
TP on synchronous/asynchronous HARQ
System Performance with IR/Chase
SHO Operation for EDCH

(Mitsubishi Electric)
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(Lucent Technologies)
(Lucent Technologies)

23

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010895

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040948
R2-041628

9.2

HARQ signalling in Soft Handover
Robust HARQ

R1-041469
(NEC)
(NEC, Telecom Modus)

Scheduling principles (continuation of discussion from joint
RAN1/RAN2 session in Cannes)

R1-040959

E-DCH Scheduling - Way Forward

(Ericsson)

18/08/2004 15:00 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040900
Scheduling for EUL
(QUALCOMM Europe)
(R1-040728)
18/08/2004 16:55 Presented by Ms. Jelena Danmjanovic.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040978
HSUPA Dynamic Step Adjustment for Node B Controlled Scheduling

(Nokia)
18/08/2004 17:25 Presented by Mr Sebir.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
After discussion for the above contributions, WG2/WG1 Chairman summarised about Scheduling as followed based on
Tdoc R1-040959.
It is proposed to agree on the following items as a basis for the scheduling schemes supported by the E-DCH:
¯ The scheduling grant controls the maximum allowed E DPDCH2DPCCH power ratio.
o E-DPDCH/DPDCH power ratio
o e-TFC index
o E-DPDCH+DPDCH/DPCCH power ratio
o other
¯ This is used only in e-TFC selection algo
¯
All groats are deterministic.
v~;~ grants sent on the shared channel ~ .... ....... ~;~’~ on a per ~ basis)are supported. ~ .... to applicable
Tr~
.......
¯
.........
~, ~ .... .......
vv
for groups of UEs can be considered as a oomp!emerX. Grants can be valid for one ~, for a goups of~s, or all
UE
o These are absolute scheduling gants.
o These gants can have an associated duration
* Dedicated grants can have an associated validity
*
Scheduling gonts can be sent once per TTI or less frequently?
*
*

.

A shared chapel is used to transmit the absolute scheduling grants.
~e absolute scheduling grant contains at least the identity of the ~ (or goup of ~s) for which the grant is
intended and the maximum resources the ~(s) may use.
Relative gants (updates) are supported as a complement to absolute grants.
o Dedicated resources are used to transmit relative grants to each ~. ~is is on the same chapel as the
AC~ACK Dedicated rc~curcc~ arc used to transmit rdativc grant~ to each ~.
~ ~ ~: ....... ¯ .... :~ ~ ~ ~:__~ ~/u: ....... ¯ ...... u:~ The relative grant consists of a ~D bits
x
absolute and relative grants I FFS

,

SHO is FFS
o Some information from all cells from E-DCH active set have to be taken into account. But What ?
;- t~e v n~n~/n~ power ratio a~so fo~ retransmissions handling vs
scheduler gants is FFS.

24

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010896

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Regarding the continued discussion about the scheduling, RAN1 would be finish at the September meeting and input to
RAN2 October meeting, and finally RAN1/RAN2 would complete the discussion at November meeting.

R1-040963
R1-040964

Configurable Cell Level Rate Controller for EUL
(NTT DoCoMo)
Autonomous Rate Ramping for Cell Level Rate Control (NTT DoCoMo)

18/08/2004 18:33 Presented by Mr. Masafumi Usuda. He gave the summary of 0963 and 0964 and claimed that is
depicted in figure 4 and 5 of this document.

R2-041617 E-DCH HARQ protocol
18/08/2004 19:35 Presented by Dr. Stefan Parkvall.

(Ericsson)

Decision: This document was noted.

R2-041650

Discussion document on PHY/HARQ requirements

(Qualcomm)

18/08/2004 20:10 Presented by Mr. Hector Vaymaos.
Decision: This document was noted.

R2-041727 Mapping of SRB with HSUPA
18/08/2004 20:20 Presented by Mr. Denis Faucolmier on behalf of Nortel.

(Nortel Networks)

Decision: This document was noted.

The following documents were not treated.
R1-040845 Comparison on the scheduling points on coding chain (Panasonic)
(Revised R1-040711)
R1-040851
Node B controlled scheduling
(Samsung)
R1-040853
System level performance with various scheduling schemes
(Samsung)
R1-040858
System level performance with SHO scheduling
(Samsung)
R1-040860
Overall RoT management strategy
(Samsung)
Primary Node-B Selection by UE in SHO
R1-040877
(Mitsubishi Electric)
R1-040878
Primary Node-B Selection in SHO
(Mitsubishi Electric)
R1-040881
Consideration to Autonomous Transmission on E-DCH(Mitsubishi Electric)
(=R1-040680)
R1-040901
System performance with T&R scheduling and load control
(QUALCOMM Europe)
Adjustment of Scheduling Timing by UE
R1-040929
(Siemens)
Scheduling Schemes for EDCH
(Lucent Technologies)
R1-040936
Scheduling Performance for EDCH
(Lucent Technologies)
R1-040937
R1-040946
Node B scheduling with transmit power restriction for E-DCH
(LG Electronics)
Per Priority Queue basis Rate Scheduling
R1-040950
(NEC) (R1-040739)
R1-040960
On Scheduling Delays
(Ericsson)
R1-040961
E-DCH Autonomous Transmissions
(Ericsson)
R1-040965
Considerations on Enhanced Uplink Scheduling Options (Siemens)
Uplink signalling for E-DCH scheduling based on predicted TFC (Siemens)
R1-040966
(=R1-040785)
Efficient scheduling in SHO by means of UE feedback (Siemens)
R1-040967
(Revised R1-040786)
R1-040977
1-bit Rate Request/Rate Grant Scheduling Signalling
(Nokia)
R1-040985
Position on scheduler design parameters
(QUALCOMM Europe)
R2-041629
Position on scheduler design parameters
(NEC, Telecom Modus)
R2-041641
Node B controlled scheduling in soft handover
(Philips)

25

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010897

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

9.3

R1-041469

Outer loop power control aspects

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040863
R1-040947
R1-040951
R2-041618
R2-041630

9.4

E-DCH outer loop power control
(Samsung)
Outer loop power control aspects of E-DCH
(LG Electronics)
Outer Loop power control in E-DCH
(NEC) (R1-040738)
E-DCH outer loop power control
(Ericsson)
Outer Loop Transmission Power Control in Enhanced Uplink
(NEC, Telecom Modus)

Physical layer model and physical layer error requirements

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040866
R1-040902
R1-040903

Error requirements of scheduling grants
(Samsung)
(QUALCOMM Europe) (=R1-040730)
HARQ states for EUL
EUL Requirements
(QUALCOMM Europe) (=R1-040731)

R1-040861
R1-040954
R2-041461
R2-041519
R2-041621
R2-041622
R2-041729

Autonomous transmission with TDM approach
Filtering on E-DCH TFCS
(NEC)
TR text proposal on Basic physical layer structure
QoS and Scheduling Principles in HSUPA
Principles of scheduling for enhanced uplink
Signalling framework for enhanced uplink scheduling
Node-B scheduler architecture proposal

(Samsung)
(R1-040741)
(Nortel)
(Nokia)
(Fujitsu)
(Fujitsu)
(Nortel)

26

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010898

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

10 Other issues for joint discussion with RAN2
RAN1/2 Joint Session on this topic started at 08:30 on Thursday (19/08/2004). The overview of conclusion was as
followed. The draft report of this Joint session ~vas distributed from WG-RAN2 secretary. (The draft report could be
obtained on FTP server of 3GPP home page).

10.1 Review of UL-TDOA Study Item description
R2-041413

PowerPoint presentation to accompany #2, proposed Inclusion of U-TDOA UE
positioning method in the UTRAN specifications SI
(TruePosition)

19/08/2004 08:40 Presented by Mr. Rob Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R2-041726

Inclusion of U-TDOA UE positioning method in the UTRAN specifications
Study Item Request
(TruePosition)

19/08/2004 09:25 Presented by Mr. Rob Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There was some discussion on how the process can be handled, especially in
about the output from SI (Feasibility Study ). Supposing the SI is going to be approved in September TSG, the
earliest closing date is December 2004, which TluePosition and the supporters see too late.

The consequence was to modif~v the objectives and output statements of the draft SJD to fit into the current practice
of 3GPP working procedures i.e., instead of including the techniques into the specifications. The sentence of
objection was revised as followed "The objective this study item is to study enhanced network based positioning
methods for FDD, without the need for modif~ving UEs and Node B and thus is compatible with existing LIEs and
Node Bs"
Decision: AWI description sheet will be proposed instead (TS 25.331 will be removed in the affected
specifications). In response to questions from the RAN1 chair, it was confirmed by TrnePosition that there would
be no modification to the physical layer in the UE or NodeB (e.g. no modification to power control behaviour),
hence there would be no work to be done in RAN1. This was the reason that no study phase would be required from
RAN1 perspective.
It was proposed by the WG2 chairman that this should be specific to FDD. lPWireless expressed their concerns
with this decision, commenting that there was no technical justification for this restriction. Resolution on this aspect
was not found". Proposed completion date: RAN#32. (the new proposed WI description sheet is in R2-041857).

R2-041412

Proposed Inclusion of U-TDOA UE positioning method in the UTRAN
specifications Study Item
(TruePosition)

Decision: This document was noted without presentation.

27

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010899

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

10.2 Use of secondary scrambling code for IMS
R1-040935 Secondary Scrambling Code for IMS

(Siemens)

19/08/2004 10:10 Presented by Dr. Przemyslaw CZEREP1NSKI.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some discussions whether the secondary scrambling code on this
contribution was proper. The question was asked what channelization code was used. The answer to question was
that one chanelization code was used and differeut acrambling code was used.
Decision: This document was noted.

R2-041523 Considerations on Single CCTrCH multi-code solution for IMS over radio
(Nortel Networks)
19/08/2004 10:40 Presented by Ms. Sar~a Boumendil
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
After the discussion about above contributions, Mr. RAN1 Chairman commented that the discussion point seems to
be more focused on to a RAN1 issue.
R2-041524 Considerations on Multiple-CCTrCH solution for IMS over radio

(Nortel Networks)
[Editor Note]Coffee break

28

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010900

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

11 Uplink Enhancements for UTRA TDD
R1-040819 TR 25.804 "Uplink Enhancements for UTRA TDD" v0.2.1

(InterDigital)

20/08/2004 08:45 Presented by Ms. Liliana Czapla.
Discussion (Question / Comment): No.
Decision: This document was approved as version 0.3.0 in Tdoc R1-041041.

R1-040846 Geometry Distribution for LCRTDD

(Samsung)

20/08/2004 08:50 Presented by Mr. Sun Chengjun.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040847 Impact of Downlink Signalling for EUCH in LCRTDD

(Samsung)

20/08/2004 08:55 Presented by Mr. Sun Chengjun.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are some comments.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040991 Intra-frame Code Hopping for EU-TDD and Text Proposal for 25.804
(IPWireless)
20/08/2004 08:58 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.

Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: It was decided to include TP with a note that applicability of the scheme for 1.28Mcps TDD is FFS.
HARQ Performance for TDD Enhanced Uplink and Text Proposal for 25.804
(IPWireless)
20/08/2004 09:10 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.

R1-040992

Discussion (Question / Comment): No.
Decision: This TP was agreed.

R1-040993
R1-041035

Power Control for TDD Enhanced Uplink and Text Proposal for 25.804
(IPWireless)
Power Control for TDD Enhanced Uplink and Text Proposal for 25.804
(IPWireless) (Revised R1-040993)

20/08/2004 09:15 Presented by Mr. Nicholas Anderson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This TP was agreed.
R1-041006

Modulation for TDD Enhanced Uplink and Text Proposal for 25.804
(IPWireless) (Withdrawn)

29

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010901

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

12

R1-041469

Analysis of higher chip rates for UTRAN evolution
(TDD)

R1-041000

TR25.895 vl.3.4: Analysis of Higher Chip Rates for UTRA TDD Evolution
(IPWireless)

20/08/2004 09:25 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment): No.

Decision: This document was approved as version 1.4.0 in Tdoc R1-041042.

R1-040994

System Simulation Results for Release 99 type channels for TR25.895 (with text
proposal)
(IPWireless)
R1-041027 System Simulation Results for Release 99 type channels for TR25.895 (with text
proposal)
(IPWireless) (Revised R1-040994)
20/08/2004 09:30 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This TP was agreed to include in the TR with modification in the last sentence "two 3.84Mops systems.."

R1-040995

Text Proposal for Application to 3GPP systems and services (IPWireless)

20/08/2004 09:35 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There were some comments.
Decision : This document was revised wording in Tdoc R1-041043.

R1-041043

Text Proposal for Application to 3GPP systems and services
(IPWireless) (Revised R1-040995)

20/08/2004 14:25 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision :This document was approved.
R1-040996
Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895
(IPWireless)
Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895 (IPWireless) (Revised R1-040996)
R1-041028
20/08/2004 09:45 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment): There are many comments and suggestions about the conclusion, most of all,
the conclusion should be more summarized and more simplified. The addition of WI proposal in recommendation
was not supported from some companies.
Decision: This document was revised regaxding conclusions for R1-041044. RAN1 does not agree to recommend
the creation ofa WI decision is up to RAN.

R1-041044 Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895 (IPWireless) (Revised R1-04028)
20/08/2004 14:25 Presented by Dr. Martin Beale.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision : This documents was approved. Additionally, it was decided that Update TRv. 1.4.1 in Tdoc R1-041051
would be provided on the reflector, and E-mail approval deadline would be August 30.

3O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010902

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Improvement of inter-frequency and inter-system
handover measurements

13
R1-040822

Proposal for multiframe compressed mode by puncturing and unequal frame
segmentation
(Mitsubishi Electric: MMCE)

20/08/2004 15:10 Presented by Mr. Mickael Bouyaud.
Discussion (Question / Comment): Some companies took objection to the contribution with comment of more
detail investigation.
Decision: This document was noted. In current contribution, there is no backward compatibility in SHO. It was
decided to continue discussion and proposal.

R1-040979 On channelisation code sharing during compressed mode

(Nokia)

20/08/2004 15:40 Presented by Mr. Karri Ranta-~ao.
Discussion (Question / Comment): Mr. Chairman suggested that it was necessary to discuss more about coding
save gain.
Decision: RAN1 could not conclude on a significmat code saving gain. Raise question to RAN whether further
work on compressed mode enhancements is useful in RAN1.

31

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010903

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

14

R1-041469

Optimisation of downlink channelisation code
utilisation (FDD)

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040825
R1-040873

Concerns on Fractional DPCH Concept
(Revised from R1-031227)
Power control for F-DPCH

(Siemens)
(Nortel Networks)

15 Optimisation of downlink channelisationcode
utilisation (TDD)
In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040997

Downlink Code Resource Optimisation for TDD HSDPA

(IPWireless)

32

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010904

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

16

R1-041469

HSDPA ACK/NACK enhancements (Discussion is
limited to coverage improvement and decoder
complexity aspects)

R1-040925

Implementation complexity of ACK/NACK performance improvement
(including CR to 25.899)
(Philips)

20/08/2004 16:15 Presented by Dr. Tim Moulsley.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This Draft CR was endorsed. It was decided to provide official CR (number #1) on the reflector by
August 27 in Tdoc R1-041054 and approve on E-mail until August 31.

R1-040926
R1-041032

Effect of PRE/POST scheme on HSDPA cell coverage (including CR to 25.899)
(Philips)
Effect of PRE/POST scheme on HSDPA cell coverage (including CR to 25.899)
(Philips) (Revised R1-040926)

20/08/2004 16:35 Presented by Dr. Tim Moulsley.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This Draft CR was endorsed. It was decided to provide official CR (number #2) on the reflector by
August 27 in Tdoc R1-041055 and approve on E-mail approval until August 31.

33

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010905

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

17

R1-041469

Other issues

In RAN1 #38, there was no time to treat this topic.

R1-040970

HSDPA Code Allocation/Measurement per Cell Portion

(Nokia)

18 Joint session RAN 1 & RAN4
RAN1/4 Joint Session started at 18:30 on Tuesday (17/08/2004).
The draft report of this Joint session ~vas distributed from WG-RAN4 secretary as sho~vn in Annex A.

18.1 Rel5/Rel CRs
R4-040536 Requirement on UE minimum output power when transmitting HS-DPCCH
(QUALCOMM Europe)
17/08/2004 18:33 Presented by RAN4 Qualcomm delegate.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked what difference was between option A and B
Decision: This document was noted.

R4-040468 Response LS on minimum power limit (From R4 to R1 CC: T1RF) (Nokia)
(R1-041058)
17/08/2004 18:42 Presented by RAN4 Nokia delegate
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.
R1-040839 25.214CR343Rl(Rel-5, F) "Clarification of minimum power limit"
(Panasonic) (Revised R1-040198)
17/08/2004 18:45 Mr. Suzuki wanted to have oft-line discussion before discussion at WG meeting. R4-040468
author (Mr. Markus Pettersson) agreed with Suzuki’s plan.

R1-040823

Introduction of a new Node B measurement ’DL Transmission Branch Load’
(Siemens)

17/08/2004 17:55 Presented by Dr. Joern Krause.
Discussion (Question / Comment): WG4 Chairman commented that we have to look at carefully from RAN4
perspective based on TS25.133.
Decision: This document was noted.

R1-040824

CR147 to 25.215 v6.0.0 Introduction of ’DL Transmission Branch Load’
measurement
(Siemens)

For the contribution R1-040823 and R1-040824. it was decided that RAN4 would provide feedback to RAN1 at
their next meeting

18.2 MBMS Requirements
R1-041003

UE performance requirements for MBMS reception

17/08/2004 19:04 Presented by Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger on behalf of Ericsson.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted
R4-040528 New UE Test for MBMS
17/08/2004 19:14 Presented by Panasonic RAN4 delegate
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

(Ericsson)

(Panasonic)

34

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010906

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

R4-040403 MBMS Link Level simulations in the presence of measurement gaps
(Mitsubishi)
17/08/2004 19:20 Presented by Mitsubishi RAN4 delegate.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked about the performance degradation on "Norman S-CCPCH and
MBMS S-CCPCH.
Decision: This document was noted.

R4-040413 Measurement requirements and MBMS reception in CelI-FACH state
(Siemens)
17/08/2004 19:36 Presented by Dr. Joem Krause.
Discussion (Question / Comment):
Decision: This document was noted.

R4-040437 Measurement requirements and MBMS reception.

(Ericsson)

17/08/2004 19:50 Presented by Ericsson RAN4 delegate.
Discussion (Question / Comment): It was asked if another setting is necessary for UE. It was commented that
issues was the interaction on measurement, large interaction and small interaction depending on TTI
Decision: This document was noted.

18.3 Rel-6 PAR
Cubic Metric LS from R1 to R4
¯ RAN4 is pleased to adopt cubic metric
Parameters in equation for Cubic Metric discussed via e-mail before next RAN1 meeting.
HSDPA output power reduction (rel-6)
o

Rel6CR was not approved in RAN4 so far (Rel-6 HSDPA-only transmission, i.e., no E-UL considered)

o

RAN1 can use Cubic Metric or PAR as tools helping to define the PhCH structure.

The WG4 Chairman commented that the problem was how to handle this discussion because R4 is responsible for
24.101 but does not have expertise that R1 has. Wish delegates can communicate within companies.

19

Closing of the meeting ¯ Friday 5.00 PM

20/08/2004 17: 00. The chairman, Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger expressed his appreciation to the delegates and the host
companies for their works, and also RAN1 Secretary, Mr. Tsukasa Sasaki finished his work as secretary on this meeting,
so Mr. Dirk Gerstenbergar appreciated for his work.

35

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010907

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Annex A: Report from Joint Ad Hoc RAN WG1 - WG4
A j oint meeting was held on Tuesday 17~1 from 18:00 to 20:30. The main topic for discussion was the MBMS
requirements and measurements.

R1-040823

Introduction of a new Node B measurement ’DL Transmission Branch Load’
(Siemens)

The issue of testing TX diversity has always been controversial in WG4, proposals had been presented and reviewed a
number of times but finally nothing was accepted. On t~is particular paper, WG4 chairman suggested that WG4 would
analyse and review it and provide feedback in t~e future.

Minimum power limit

A.1

R4-040468 Response LS on minimum power limit (Nokia)

(R1-041058)

This draft LS, to be sent to WG1, represents the agreed view of WG4 on the issue and its feedback to WG1. The actual
behaviour doesn’t exactly map to any of the options presented by the first LS from WG1. Rather, it is a combination of
options 1 and 2.

R4-040536

Requirement on UE minimum output power when transmitting HS-DPCCH
(Qualcomm)

Document illustrates the power variation over time, when TPC commands mandate the UE to lower power to its minimum
or further. It is necessary to look at the issue over time, and not only one DPCCH timeslot, in order to get the correct
understanding. One way to express this behaviour would be that the UE does not need to go below the limit for the
minimum Tx power over any DPCH slot, no matter which channel combinations are transmitted during that slot.
With this contribution, WG4 further clarifies the LS above. Here, the possibility of changing the power level of the
DPDCH and DPCCH within the timeslot is introduced. If WG1 believes this is possible, a third alternative behaviour can
be adopted.

R1-040839 Clarification of minimum power limit (CR343 to 25.214) (Panasonic)
This CR was produced before the information from WG4 was received. It needs to be checked that ~e new requirements
introduced in the CR align wi~ WG4 understanding in R4-040468. WG1 also will need to consider if it is possible to
change the power level of Re199 channels within the timeslot, and then take it into account for a revision of the CR.

A.2

MBMS

R1-041003 UE performance requirements for MBMS reception (Ericsson)
S-CCPCH can be transmitted by multiple cells, 3 types of combining are being envisaged for the UE: Selective combining,
RAKE level combining, Symbol level combining. Performance requirements for the UE for the 3 cases will need to be
specified.
Sari Nielsen (Nokia) reminded WG1 that some of the existing performance requirements in WG4 do not have a test
associated, it was impossible to define due to the complexity. She warned that this could be the case for MBMS, which
presents different complexity issues than the Re199 channels.

R4-040528 New UE test for MBMS (Panasonic)
Two different aspects ofMBMS UE testing are raised, measurement performance and S-CCPCH reception performance.
The proposal is to consider both together in the same test suite.

R4-040403 MBMS Link Level simulations in the presence of measurement gaps (Mitsubishi)
It is noted that these simulation only consider one radio link, the advantages of combining are not taken into account.
The case of reception of normal S-CCPCH together with a MBMS S-CCPCH was raised. It may happen that when
measurements occasions are scheduled having to receive both, these occasions may end up colliding wi~ most of the TTI
of a given MBMS transmission.

36

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010908

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

R4-040413 Measurement requirements and MBMS reception in CelI-FACH state (Siemens)
It was noted that SA4 is assuming an error rate, at higher layers and after FEC, of 1% with a possible relaxation to 10%.
WG1 chairman clarified that the measurement occasions to be used with the S-CCPCH could blank out FACH TTIs, of
10ms, and not the whole MBMS TTI of 80ms. The resulting data loss can be tempered by the fact that the same MBMS
TTI can be received from a different cell if macro diversity is available, and with a different timing due to the RL timing
differences. The combining will then decrease the losses.

R4-040437 Interfrequency measurements during MBMS sessions (Ericsson)
It was clarified that the TTIs considered in this paper are those commonly used in R99. It was clarified that a restriction of
a 10 ms FACH TTI when operating MBMS is not the best way forward, as Siemens paper shows there is a trade off
between UE mobility and MBMS reception. This trade off should be left available for network operation. Additionally,
new techniques are being considered: TTI scrambling, or scheduling of measurement occasions, but WG1 chairman
warned against adding new features to the specification that may not be implemented, in particula~ when other, simpler,
solution can be found.
WG4 couldn’t provide a definite view on the need to set a restriction on t~e TTI size to 10 ms.

A.3

UE output power back off

WG4 chairman explained that WG4 agreed that the Cubic Metric is a better indication to determine the power back off
than the Peak to Average Ratio, as the mapping "CM to back-oft~’ seems to be close to one-to-one. This mapping has only
been show so far for a reduced number of PA implementation and seems to be dependant on the ACLR assumption, so
results from more companies have been requested in order to determine the coefficients of the mapping formula in a
manner that is accurate for all types of PAs.
A separate email reflector will be set for the purpose, WG1 member are invited to join their WG4 colleagues in the
discussion.
The CM, or t~e PAR, are only tools that will finally help to decide the amount of power reduction for a given combination
of channels. Agreement on this reduction is very likely going to need long and heated discussions in WG4, and it will
involve system simulations and the participation of operators.
The main result of the issue will affect the output power requirement in 25.101, like it has been the case for the Rel-5
HSDPA power back oft’; but it will also need to be forwarded to WG1 as useful contributions for the EDCH specification.

37

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010909

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Annex B: List of participants
Title / Name

Organization Represented

Status Code (Category Code) Phone

Email

Guest organisation for 3GPP (OTHER)

DUNE S.R.L.

3GPPGUEST (OTHER)

IT

[phone]

Dr. Jinsong Duan

Panasonic Mobile Comm.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

+ 81 46 840 5369 [e-mail]

Mr. Noriyuki Fukui

Mitsubishi Electric Co.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

Miss Youn hyoung Heo

SAMSUNG Eleclxonics Co.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone] hush.heo@samsung, com

Mr. Hitoshi Iochi

Panasonic Mobile Comm.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

iochi.hit oshi@j p.panasonic, com

Mr. Yoshikazu Ishii

Panasonic Mobile Comm.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Jussi Kahtava

Nokia Japan Co, Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

j [e-mail]

Ms. Nahoko Kuroda

NEC Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone] n-kuroda@cj.j p.nec.com

Mr. Jinsock Lee

NEC EUROPE LTD

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

[e-mail]

Dr. Neelesh Mehta

Mitsubishi Electric Co.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Shinsuke Ogawa

NTT DoCoMo Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

[e-mail].j p

Mr. Anil Umesh

NTT DoCoMo

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

JP [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Aris Papasakellaa:iou

TEXAS Instruments

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

FR [phone]

Mr. Prem Sood

SHARP Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

US

Mr. Michiaki Takano

Mitsubishi Electric Co.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone] m_takax~[e-mail], co.jp

Mr. Hideji Wakabayashi

Mitsubishi Eleclxic Co.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

[e-mail], co.jp

Mr. Hidetoshi Suzuki

Panasonic Mobile Comm.

3GPPMEMBER (ARIB)

JP

[phone]

Suzuki.Hidetoshi@j p.panasonic, com

Mr. Enrico de Marinis

demaxinis@dune. 191.it

Member of 3GPP (ARIB)

[e-mail] j p

[e-mail]

[phone] [e-mail]

Member of 3GPP (ATIS)
38

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010910

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
Mr. Teck Hu

R1-041469

Lucent Technologies

3GPPMEMBER (ATIS)

US

[phone] calhu@lucent, com

Dr. Bo G6ra~sson

Nanjing Ericsson Panda Com Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (CCSA)

SE

Mr. Huabin Liu

HuaWei Technologies Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (CCSA)

CN [phone] lhblhb@huawei, com

Ms. Sha Ma

HuaWei Technologies Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (CCSA)

CN [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Bramslav Popovic

HuaWei Technologies Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (CCSA)

SE

Mr. Ke Wang

CATT

3GPPMEMBER (CCSA)

CN [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Saied Abedi

FUJITSU Laboratories of Europe

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Nicholas Anderson

IPWireless Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Uwe Baeder

ROHDE & SCHWARZ

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone]Uwe.B aeder@r sd.rohde-schwaxz, com

Dr. Martin Beale

IPWireless Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Pierre Bertxand

TEXAS Instruments

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

p-bertrand@ti, com
FR [phone]

Mr. Nicolas Billy

ALCATEL S.A.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] nicolas.billy@alcatel, fr

Ms. Saxah Boumendil

NORTEL NETWORKS (EUROPE)

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Mickael Bouyaud

MELCO MOBILE COMMLrNICATIO 3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Enrico Buracchini

TELECOM ITALIA S.p.A.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

IT [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Thomas Chapman

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Amir Chass

MOTOROLA SEMICONDUCTOR IS 3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

IL [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Stash Czaja

VIA Technologies Inc

US [phone]

Ms. Liliana Czapla

1NTERDIGITAL COMMUNICATION 3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

US [phone] liliana.czapla@interdigital, com

Dr. Przemek Czerepinski

Siemens nv/sa

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] przemek, czerepinski@roke, co.uk

Dr. Jelena Damnj a~ovic

QUALCOMM EUROPE S.A.R.L.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] j elenad@qualcomm, corn

Member of 3GPP (CCSA)
[phone]

[phone]

[e-mail]

braxtislav.popovic@at eliertelecom, se

Member of 3GPP (ETS1)

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

sczaj a@via-telecom, com

39

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010911

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Mr. Uwe Doetsch

ALCATEL S.A.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Jea~-Aicard Fabien

MOTOROLA Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

US [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Lindsay Frost

NEC Technologies (UK) LTD

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Dirk Gerstenberger

ERICSSON LM

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

SE

[phone]

dirk.gerstenberger@ERIC SSON.COM

Dr. Stefan Paskvall

Ericsson Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

SE

[phone]

stefma.paskvall@ericsson, com

Mr. Mask Harrison

MOTOROLA GmbH

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

US [phone]

Mr. Michael Haxt

FUJITSU Laboratories of Europe

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] mike.hart@uk, fujitsu, com

Mr. Thomas Hindelmag

SIEMENS Mobile Communications

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Juergen Hofmann

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] j uergen-ho fmaxm@siemens, com

Mr. Xuegang Huang

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone]xuegang.huang@siemens, com

Dr. Jean-philippe Kermoal

NOKIA Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FI

Mr. Dirk Kistowski

T-Mobile International AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Joern Krause

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] j [e-mail]

Mr. Ymmick Le Pezermec

VODAFONE Group Plc

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone]

Ms. Evelyne Le Strat

NORTEL NETWORKS (EUROPE)

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR + 33 1 394453 39 elestsat @nort elnetworks, com

Mr. Rickard Ljung

TeliaSonera AB

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

SE

Dr. Caslo Luschi

Icera Semiconductor

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] carlo@icerasemi, corn

Dr. Esa MaJkmnaki

NOKIA Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FI

Dr. Beale Maxtin

IPWireless Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Jtirgen Michel

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] michel.j uergen@siemens, com

Dr. Seyed Mortazavi

SIEMENS AG

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] seyed.mortazavi@roke, co.uk

Dr. Tim Moulsley

PHILIPS Semiconductors

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] moul sle2 @prl.reseasch. philips, com

Mr. Mask Murphy

TTP Communications plc

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

[phone]

[phone]

mark.harrison@motorola, com

j ean-philippe.kermoal @nokia. com

Yannick.LePezennec@vodafone. com

rickasd.m.ljung@teliasonera, corn

[phone] esa.malkamaki@nokia, com

4O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010912

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Mr. Alessandro Pace

TELECOM ITALIA S.p.A.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

IT

[phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Feng Qian

VIA Technologies Inc

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

US [phone]

Mr. Ka~i Ranta-a~o

NOKIA Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FI

Mr. Stefan Russ

ALCATEL S.A.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Hans Schotten

QUALCOMM EUROPE S.A.R.L.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR [phone] hans.schotten@qualcomm, com

Mr. Ville Steudle

NOKIA Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FI

[phone] ville, steudle@nokia, com

Mr. Ma~kku Ta~kiainen

NOKIA Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FI

[phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Frdddric Charpentier

PANASONIC Deutschland GmbH

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE

[phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Said Tatesh

Lucent Technologies N. S. UK

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mrs. Caxolyn Taylor

MOTOROLA Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

US [phone]

Mr. Sunil Vadgama

FUJITSU Laboratories of Europe

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] s. vadgama@fuj itsu. co. uk

Mr. Hans van der Veen

Telecom Modus Ltd.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Mattias Wennstr0m

HUAWEI TECHNOLOGIES Co. Ltd.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

CN [phone]

Mr. Nick Whinnett

MOTOROLA Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

GB [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Serge Willenegger

QUALCOMM EUROPE S.A.R.L.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

CH [phone]

Ms. Nadege Noisette

ORANGE SA.

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

FR

Mr. Hyung-Nam Choi

1NF1NEON TECHNOLOGIES

3GPPMEMBER (ETSI)

DE [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Joon-Kui Ahn

LG Electronics Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] j kan@lge, corn

Dr. Bing Bu

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

CN [phone] [e-mail]

Dr. Byung-jang Jeong

ETRI

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Hojin kim

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

wireless@sait, samsung, co.kr

Mr. Yongjun Kwak

SAMSUNG Electxonics

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

evatt@samsung, com

fqian@via-telecom, corn

[phone] [e-mail]

carolyn, taylor@motorola, com

mattias.wennstrom@huawei, com

[e-mail]

[phone] nadege.noisette@fra~cetelecom.com.

Member of 3GPP (TTA)

41

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010913

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Mr. Hok-Seong Kim

LG Electronics Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

bryankim@lge, com

Mr. I1 Gyu Kim

ETRI

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Sung jin Kim

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] communication@soxnsung, com

Mr. Bong Hoe Kim

LG Electronics Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Sung Lark Kwon

LG Electronics Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

[e-mail]

Mr. Hyeon Woo Lee

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone]

wooj [e-mail]

Dr. Juho Lee

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] j [e-mail]

Mr. Kyung Park

ETRI

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] [e-mail]

Miss Eunjeong Shin

ETRI

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

KR [phone] ej [e-mail]

Mr. Yujian Zho~g

Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd

3GPPMEMBER (TTA)

CN [phone] [e-mail]

Mr. Th~xkh Bui

NEC Corporation

3GPPMEMBER (TTC)

JP

[phone]

Mr. Masafumi Usuda

NTT DoCoMo Inc.

3GPPMEMBER (TTC)

JP

[phone] [e-mail], co.jp

Member of 3GPP (TTC)
[e-mail]

Organisation partner representative (ETS1)
Mr. Tsukasa Sasoki

Mobile Competence Centxe

FR [phone] tsukasa, [e-mail]

42

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010914

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Annex C TSG RAN WG1 meetings through 2004 to 2005
TITLE
3GPPRAN1#38bis

CTRY
KR

TYPE
WG

DATES
20 - 24 Sept 2004

LOCATION
Seoul

3GPPRAN1#39
3GPPRANI#40

WG
WG

15- 19 Nov 2004
14 - 18 Feb 2005

Shin-Yokohama
Phoenix

JP
USA

3GPPRANI#40bis

WG

TBD

TBD

3GPPRAN1#41

WG

04 - 08 April 2005
09- 13 May 2005

TBD

EU

3GPPRAN1#42

WG

29 Aug -02 Sept 2005

TBD

EU

3GPPRAN1#43

WG

07 - 11 Nov 2005

TBC

Asia

MEETING TYPES
AH = Ad Hoc
CM = Chairmen’s meeting
JM = Joint
OR = Ordinary
PM = Preparatory Meeting RG = Rapporteurs Group
RM = Resolution Meeting SG = Steering Group
ST = Startup Meeting
TG = Task Group
WG = Working Group
XO = Extraordinary

43

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010915

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Annex D List of CRs agreed at RAN1#38
25.211 191
25.211 192
25.224 132
25.224 133
25.224 134
25.222122
25.222 123
25.222 124
25.224 135
25.224 136
25.224 137
25.214 353
25.214 352
25.899
1
25.899 2

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
-

F Rel-5 . R1-040874 Correction for the slot range of DL DPCCH power control preamble for CPCH
A Rel-6 . R1-040874 Correction for the slot range of DL DPCCH power control preamble for CPCH
F Rel-4 . R1-040883 Transmit diversity usage for beacon channels in LCR TDD
A Rel-5 . R1-040883 Transmit diversity usage for beacon channels in LCR TDD
A Rel-6 . R1-040883 Transmit diversity usage for beacon channels in LCR TDD
F Rel-4. R1-041017 Correction ofsymbolXidefined in sub-framesegmentationstep
A Rel-5 . R1-041017 Correction of symbol Xi defined in sub-frame segmentation step
A Rel-6 . R1-041017 Correction of symbol Xi defined in sub-frame segmentation step
F Rel-4 . R1-041018 Corrections of radio access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD
A Rel-5 . R1-041018 Corrections of radio access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD
A Rel-6 . R1-041018 Corrections of radio access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD
F Rel-5. R1-041059 Clarification ofSSDTuplinkonlysignalling
A Rel-6. R1-041059 Clarification ofSSDTuplinkonlysignalling
F Rel-6 : R1-041056 Implementation Complexity of ACK/NACK performance improvement
F Rel-6. R1-041055 Effect of PRE/POST scheme on HSDPA cell coverage

TEl 4
TEl 4
TEl 4
TEl 4
TEl 4
TEl 4
LCRTDD_Phys
LCRTDD_Phys
LCRTDD_Phys
TEl4
TEl4
Rlnlmp-Rlperf
Rlnlmp-Rlperf

44

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010916

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

Annex E: List of tdocs at RAN1 #38
TSG RAN WG1
Chairman

R1-040811 DRAFT Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 RAN1 Secretary
~37
Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 RAN1 Secretary
R1-040812 DRAFT1 Hoc meeting in Cannes
Rel.6 Ad
[To) Reply LS on Code Sharing during
TSG RAN WG2
R1-040813 Sompressed Mode
(To:R1 Cc:R3)
(Nokia)
[Reply to R1-040386)
[Cc) Reply LS on Multiple MBMS Issues
TSG RAN WG2
R1-040814 To: $4, R4 Cc: $2, $1, R1, R3, G1, G2,
(Samsung)
~11) (Reply to $4-040132)
[Cc) Reply to "LS on RRC release aspects
voice service
TSG RAN WG2
R1-040815 9f CS video and (To:S2 Cc: R1, R3)
mprovements"
(Vodafone)
[Reply to $2-041641)
[Cc) LS on RRC release aspects of CS
video and voice service improvements
R1-040816 To:S2, Cc: R1,R2,GP) (Reply to $2- TSG RAN WG3
(Alcatel)
:341641)
[To) Response LS on Multiple MBMS Issues
R1-040817 To: R1, R2, R3, GP, G2) (Reply to R1- TSG SA WG4
(Siemens)
:340385, R1-040651, etc)
[Cc) LS on Proposed Modification to
TSG T WG1
R1-040818 -ISDPA Radio Bearer Settings (To: R2 Cc:(QUALCOMM)

16/08/2004 ~,pproved

2
2

R1-040810 Draft Agenda

~lot Available
16/08/2004

2
4

:R1-040666
:R2-041241

4

=R1-040667
=R2-041244

4

:R1-040668
:R2-041249

=R1-040670
=$4-040356

4

=R1-040671
=T1-040957

~loted

~loted

16/08/2004

~loted (Treated at Cannes Meeting)

16/08/2004

~loted

=R1-040669
=R3-040941

4

~loted (Treated at Cannes Meeting)

16/08/2004

4

16/08/2004

16/08/2004

R1)

TR 25.804 "Uplink Enhancements for UTRA
R1-040819 TDD" v0.2.1
InterDigital
Modified per stream rate control for 2R1-040820 antenna MIMO
TI

~,pproved with correction the name of the
sompany
16/08/2004 ~loted

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

11
6.1

as version 0.3.0 in Tdoc R1-

:341041.
=R1-040517

~lot Treated

45

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010917

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
Text proposal for modified per stream rate TI
R1-040821 :ontrol for 2-antenna
Proposal for multiframe compressed mode
Mitsubishi
R1-040822 oy puncturing and unequal frame
Electric (MMCE)
segmentation
Introduction of a new Node B measurement
R1-040823 DL Transmission Branch Load’
Siemens
SR147 to 25.215 v6.0.0 Introduction of ’DL
R1-040824 Transmission Branch Load’ measurement Siemens
R1-040825 Soncerns on Fractional DPCH Concept
Siemens
_5.222CR122(Rel-4, F)&CR123(Rel-5,
R1-040826 A)&CR124(Rel-6, A): "Correction of symbol Siemens
defined in sub-frame segmentation step"
R1-040827 ~imulation results for 1.28Mcps TDD MBMS Siemens
R1-040828 2overage Results for MBMS (1.28Mcps TDD): Siemens
~Jpdated Text Proposal for TR 25.803
Huawei
R1-040829 :::)ouble-ASTTD with Sub-Group Rate
Technologies
Sontrol
R1-040830 Text Proposal for Double-ASTTD with Sub-Huawei
Sroup Rate Control
Technologies
Dower adjustment of ACK/NACK signaling Huawei
R1-040831
Technologies
oased on ACK/NACK error rate
R1-040832 :)ownlink Signalling Mapping of ACK and Huawei
~IACK
Technologies
Huawei
R1-040833 --DCH timing
Technologies

R1-041469

6.1

20/08/2004 ~loted

13
16&17/08/2004 ~loted.

For the contribution R1-040823 and
R1-040824:, it was decided that RAN4 would
16&17/08/2004 3rovide feedback to RAN1 at their next
~qeeting

5.4
5.4
14
5.2
5.3
5.4
7

R1-031227)
16/08/2004

R1-040441)

7

R1-040620)

6
6

16/08/2004
16/08/2004

R1-040430)
R1-040431)

~lot Treated
~lot approved and would be provided the
"evision with isolated impact analysis in R1:)41017.
Agreed for inclusion in TR
Agreed for inclusion in TR
~lot Treated
~lot Treated

8.3

~lot Treated

8.4

~lot treated

8.1

19/08/2004

~loted

16/08/2004

R1-040834 Inclusion of combinations of multiple radio Vodafone Group
oearers with HSDPA into TS 34.108

5.5

R1-040835 Summary from RAN#24

3

RAN1 Chairman

~lot Treated

=R1-040518

3

The conclusion was agreed in RANI/RAN2
oint sesion, expect WB-AMR combination,
~vhich is FFS, 128kbps UL is FFS.
16/08/2004 ~loted
~Vithdrawn

46

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010918

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

R1-040837 3L ACK structure
R1-040838 3L ACK Selection
R1-040839 _5.214CR343R1(Rel-5, F)&CR344(Rel-6,
~,) "Clarification of minimum power limit"
R1-040840 MBMS L1 possible limitations
R1-040841 -low MBMS UE capability is defined?
R1-040842 ~lumber of simultaneous reception of Acks
n SHO
Shannel priority and uplink transmission
R1-040843 :iming
Jplink power signalling information for the
R1-040844 scheduling
Somparison on the scheduling points on
R1-040845 :oding chain
R1-040846 Seometry Distribution for LCRTDD
R1-040847 Impact of Downlink Signalling for EUCH in
_CRTDD
R1-040848 3n MICH mapping
R1-040849 JE Capability
R1-040850 --UL physical channel code mapping
R1-040851 ~lode B controlled scheduling
R1-040852 Selection of primary scheduling Node B in
SHO
R1-040853 System level performance with various
scheduling schemes
R1-040854 Jplink signalling for Node B controlled
scheduling
R1-040855 -lARQ: physical layer aspects

Via Telecom
Via Telecom

8.4
8.4

~ot treated
~ot treated
16&17/08/2004 ~ot approved. It was decided to conclude
discussion in RAN1#38bis
17/08/2004 ~oted
17/08/2004 ~oted
~ot treated

Panasonic

5.3

R1-040198)

Panasonic
Panasonic

7.2
7.3

R1-040710)

Panasonic

8.4

Panasonic

8.1

Panasonic

8.5

Panasonic

9.2

Samsung

11

20/08/2004 ~oted

Samsung

11

20/08/2004 ~oted

NEC
NEC
Samsung
Samsung

7.1
7.3
8.1
9.2

Samsung

8

Samsung

9.2

Samsung

8.5

R1-040696)

~ot treated

Samsung

8.2

R1-040797)

R1-040857 System level performance with periodic
TPS reporting

Samsung

8.5

~ot treated
~Vithdrawn
~ot treated

19/08/2004

~oted
~ot treated
~ot treated

R1-040711)

16/08/2004

R1-040691)

~oted
~ot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~ot treated

47

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010919

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
System level performance with SHO
R1-040858
Samsung
scheduling
~ower control at the maximum power limit
R1-040859 Ior EUL
Samsung
R1-040860 :Dverall RoT management strategy
Samsung
R1-040861 ~,utonomous transmission with TDM
Samsung
approach
R1-040862 RV Signalling
Samsung
R1-040863 ---DCH outer loop power control
Samsung
Samsung
R1-040864 -IARQ principle
--UL scheduling: signalling support
Samsung
R1-040865
R1-040866 Error requirements of scheduling grants
Samsung
R1-040867 MBMS notification procedure on MICH
Panasonic
=urther simulations on RC-MPD and
R1-040868 somparison with PARC, DSTTD, and R’99 Nortel Net~vorks
TxDiv
R1-040869 =irst MIMO Traffic simulations for RC-MPD Nortel Net~vorks
and PARC with real channnel estimation
MIMO generic scheme and text proposal for
R1-040870 :he MIMO TR 25.876
Nortel Net~vorks
R1-040871 SQI feedback for RC-MPD
Nortel Net~vorks
R1-040872 JL signalling for FDD enhanced UL
Nortel Net~vorks
R1-040873 ~ower control for F-DPCH
Nortel Net~vorks
__.5.211CR191(Rel-5, F)&CR192(Rel-6, A)
R1-040874 ’Correction for the slot range of DL DPCCHLG Electronics
3ower control preamble for CPCH"
R1-040875 _5.214CR349(Rel-6, F)"Clarification of LG Electronics
SSDT uplink only signaling"
Mitsubishi
R1-040876 Multiple number of SAW ARQ processes Electric
Mitsubishi
R1-040877 Primary Node-B Selection by UE in SHO
Electric

R1-041469

9.2

~lot treated

~lot treated

8.3

~lot treated
~lot treated

9.2
8
8.4
9.3
9.1
8.5
9.4
7.1

=R2-041440

~lot treated
~lot treated
18/08/2004 ~loted
~lot treated
~lot treated
17/08/2004 ~loted
~lot treated

6.2
~lot treated

6.2
6.1
6.1
8.4
14

16/08/2004

~loted

~lot treated
Revised to R1-041004
~lot treated
16/08/2004 ~,pproved

5.3
5.4

Revised to R 1-041019

9.1

~lot treated

9.2

~lot treated

48

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010920

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

R1-040878 Primary Node-B Selection in SHO

9.2

~ot treated

R1-040879

8.5

~ot treated

R1-040880
R1-040881
R1-040882
R1-040883
R1-040884
R1-040885
R1-040886
R1-040887
R1-040888
R1-040889
R1-040890
R1-040891
R1-040892
R1-040893

Mitsubishi
Electric
Mitsubishi
gignalling for primary Node-B selection in SHO
Electric
Jplink Signalling alternatives for FDD
Mitsubishi
--nhanced Uplink
Electric
~onsideration to Autonomous Transmission on Mitsubishi
g-DCH
Electric
-IS RAB combinations for testing
Ericsson
IPWireless,
__.5.224CR 132(Rel-4, F)&CR133(Rel-5,
~,)&CR134(Rel-6, A) "Transmit diversity Interdigital,
Jsage for beacon channels in LCR TDD" Siemens
Draft CR for introduction of MICH in 25.21xQUALCOMM
Europe
QUALCOMM
Soft combining aspects of MBMS
Europe
QUALCOMM
JE Capability for MBMS
Europe
QUALCOMM
S-CCPCH performance with 256 kbps
Europe
QUALCOMM
3VSF code space for E-DCH
Europe
QUALCOMM
]-P on PhCH mapping of E-DCH
Europe
QUALCOMM
]-P on E-DCH Timing
Europe
QUALCOMM
3hoice of RV and code rates
Europe
QUALCOMM
]-P on IR versions
Europe
Impact of SNR mismatch on turbo decodingQUALCOMM
Europe

17/08/2004

8.5
9.2

~oted
~ot treated

:R1-040680
16/08/2004

~oted
Cpproved

16/0~2004

~oted

17/0~2004

~oted

17/0~2004

~oted

17/0~2004

8.1

~oted. The simulation results on this
sontributionwould be included in the TR
~ot treated

8.1

~ot treated

16/08/2004

5.5
5.2
7.1
7.3
7.3
7.3

8.1
8.2
8.2
8.2

=R1-040716

19/08/2004

~oted
~ot treated
~ot treated

~ot treated

49

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010921

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
Reference short-term link curves for 10ms
R1-040894 TTI
---TFICH performance with synchronous
R1-040895 -IARQ
---TFICH performance with asynchronous
R1-040896 -IARQ
R1-040897
R1-040898
R1-040899
R1-040900
R1-040901
R1-040902
R1-040903

QUALCOMM
Europe
QUALCOMM
Europe
QUALCOMM
Europe
QUALCOMM
-IARQ channel mapping in DL
Europe
QUALCOMM
Impact of asynchronous HARQ
Europe
TP on synchronous/asynchronous HARQ QUALCOMM
Europe
QUALCOMM
Scheduling for EUL
Europe
System performance with T&R scheduling QUALCOMM
Europe
and load control
QUALCOMM
-IARQ states for EUL
Europe
QUALCOMM
--UL Requirements
Europe

R1-041469

8.4

9.2

R1-040910 Signalling Support for EUL

Motorola

R1-040911 :Duter loop power control for EUL

Motorola

=R1-040728

18/08/2004

~loted
~lot treated

9.4
9.4

~lot treated

=R1-040730
=R1-040731

6.1
8
9
8
9
8
9
8
8
9
8
5O

~loted
~lot treated

9.2

Siemens

Motorola

18/08/2004

9.1

R1-040905 MIMO Evolution Path requirements
=ully sychronous HARQ and reliable
R1-040906 signaling in SHO

Motorola

~lot treated

=R1-040723

9.1

5.6

R1-040908 Time and Rate scheduler for Enhanced
Jplink
R1-040909 --UL Power Requirements

~lot treated

8.4

Ericsson

R1-040907 Rate Contol Scheduler for Enhanced UplinkMotorola

~lot treated

8.4

R1-040904 Issues with Radio Link Synchronization

Motorola

~lot treated

8.2

~lot treated
16/08/2004

~loted and more discussion was continued till
qext meeting
16/08/2004 ~loted
18/08/2004 ~loted
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010922

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
Multi-step rate scheduling and Alcatel Shanghai
R1-040912 synchronization scheme
Bell
_5224CR135(Rel-4, F)&CR136(Rel-5,
R1-040913 ~,)&CR137(Rel-6, A): "Corrections of radio Siemens AG,
CATT
access procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD"
R1-040914 Target RoT control methods for HSUPA Panasonic
R1-040915 Tx Diversity and MIMO
Alcatel
R1-040916 4Tx open-loop closed-loop (OL-CL) MIMO Alcatel
R1-040917 Text Proposal for 4Tx open-loop closed- Alcatel
oop (OL-CL) MIMO
R1-040918 Reordering of TTIs in MBMS
Siemens
=urther considerations on the UE capability
R1-040919 Ior MBMS (FDD)
Siemens
Spatial channel coding (SCC) for high
R1-040920 :hroughput
Philips
~vith a single receive antenna
R1-040921 Text Proposal for Spatial Channel Coding Philips
Interaction bet~veen Enhanced Uplink and
R1-040922 Sompressed
Philips
Mode
Philips
R1-040923 -IARQ in SHO for Enhanced Uplink
~lode B controlled scheduling in soft
R1-040924 qandover
Philips
Implementation complexity of ACK/NACK
R1-040925 3erformanoe
Philips
mprovement (including CR to 25.899)
Effect of PRE/POST scheme on HSDPA cellPhilips
R1-040926 soverage (including CR to 25.899)
R1-040927 :~etransmission Power Optimisation
Siemens
R1-040928 ---DCH HARQ with Power Offset
Siemens
R1-040929 ~,djustment of Scheduling Timing by UE
Siemens

R1-041469

~lot treated

8.5
5.2
5.3
5.4
8.5
6.1
6
6
7.2
7.3

16/o~2oo4pproved with modificationinthe coversheet
n R1-011018
R1-040780)
16/08/2004

=R1-040521
=R1-040595
R1-040775)
R1-041016

17/08/2004

~lot treated
~loted
~lot treated
~lot treated
~loted
Revised by R1-041016

~lot treated
6.1

R1-040770)

~lot treated
~lot treated

R2-041286)
R1-040769)

~lot treated
~lot treated

6.1
8.4
8.4
8.5

20/08/2004 Endorsed.

16

16
8.3
8.3
9.2

R1-041032

It was decided to provide official
SR (number #1) on the reflector by August 27
n Tdoc R1-041054 and approve on E-mail
Jntil August 31.
Revised by R1-041032

~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated

51

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010923

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
=erformance aspects of advanced spectral
R1-040930 3rocessing MIMO receivers for multi-code Fujitsu,
Dune Srl
"eception
R1-040931 TR25.876 v.1.5.1 "Multiple-Input Multiple Editor(Lucent
9utput in UTRA"
Technologies)
R1-040932 =rinciples of scheduling for enhanced uplink
Fujitsu
R1-040933 ~lode B controlled Scheduling for EnhancedFujitsu
Jplink
R1-040934
Mitsubishi
Text Proposal on MIMO System Simulation Electric
--valuation Methodology
Research Labs
(MERL)
R1-040935 Secondary Scrambling Code for IMS
Siemens
Lucent
R1-040936 Scheduling Schemes for EDCH
Technologies
Lucent
R1-040937 Scheduling Performance for EDCH
Technologies
Lucent
R1-040938 System Performance with IR/Chase
Technologies
Lucent
R1-040939 SHO Operation for EDCH
Technologies
Lucent
R1-040940 -IARQ Processes for 2ms and 10ms
Technologies
R1-040941 Physical channel code mapping for E-DCH LG Electronics
R1-040942 Signaling to support 2 ms and 10 ms TTIs
LG Electronics
Ior E-DCH
R1-040943 Jplink signaling for E-DCH
LG Electronics
R1-040944 Principles of downlink ACK/NACK signaling LG Electronics
Ior E-DCH
R1-040945 Timing of downlink signaling with 10 ms TTI
LG Electronics
Ior E-DCH
R1-040946 ~lode B scheduling with transmit power
LG Electronics
"estriction for E-DCH

R1-041469

~lot treated
6
16/08/2004

6
9.2

~,pproved as version 1.6.0 in Tdoc R1-041021
~lot treated
~lot treated

8.5
16/08/2004

~loted

6
10.2

20/08/2004 ~loted

~lot treated

9.2

~lot treated

9.2

~lot treated

9.1

~lot treated

9.1
9.1
8.1
8.4
8.4
8.4
8.5
9.2

18/08/2004

~loted
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated

52

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010924

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040947
R1-040948
R1-040949
R1-040950
R1-040951
R1-040952
R1-040953
R1-040954
R1-040955
R1-040956
R1-040957
R1-040958
R1-040959
R1-040960
R1-040961
R1-040962
R1-040963
R1-040964
R1-040965
R1-040966
R1-040967
R1-040968

:Duter loop power control aspects of E-DCH LG Electronics
9.3
-IARQ signalling in Soft Handover
NEC
9.1
Secondary Pilot for E-DCH
NEC
8.1
Per Priority Queue basis Rate Scheduling NEC
9.2
:Duter Loop power control in E-DCH
NEC
9.3
-IARQ Downlink Signalling
NEC
8.4
Robust Signalling in Rate Scheduling
NEC
8.5
=iltering on E-DCH TFCS
NEC
9
System performance with low capability UE Panasonic
2ms TTI vs 10ms TTI)
Jplink Control Signaling
Ericsson
8.1
3ownlink Control Signaling
Ericsson
8.1
---DCH Physical Layer Hybrid ARQ
Ericsson
8.2
~rocessing
---DCH Schduling - Way Forward
Ericsson
9.2
3n Scheduling Delays
Ericsson
9.2
---DCH Autonomous Transmissions
Ericsson
9.2
Proposal on RR, SI time multiplexing with
NTT DoCoMo
8.1
-IS-DPCCH
Sonfigurable Cell Level Rate Controller for
8
NTT DoCoMo
--UL
9.2
~,utonomous Rate Ramping for Cell Level
8
NTT DoCoMo
Rate Control
9.2
Sonsiderations on Enhanced Uplink
Siemens
9.2
Scheduling Options
Jplink signalling for E-DCH scheduling
Siemens
9.2
oased on predicted TFC
Efficient scheduling in SHO by means of UE
Siemens
9.2
Ieedback
JL Signalling overhead for node B
Siemens
8.5
scheduling in SHO

R1-041469

R1-040739)
R1-040738)
R1-040742)
R1-040740)
R1-040741)
8.1

~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot treated
~lot Available
~lot treated
~lot treated
17/08/2004 XJ oted

~lot treated
~lot treated
18/08/2004 XJ oted

~lot treated
~lot treated
17/08/2004 XJ oted
18/08/2004 XJ oted
18/08/2004 XJ oted

~lot treated
=R1-040785

~lot treated

R1-040786)

~lot treated

R1-040788)

~lot treated

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010925

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
R1-040969 3L Signalling overhead for node B
Siemens
scheduling
-ISDPA Code Allocation/Measurement per
R1-040970 Sell Portion
Nokia
R1-040971 TR25.808 v0.0.3
Nokia
R1-040972 -ISUPA Requirements for uplink signalling Nokia
Implicit Redundancy Version for IR HARQ
R1-040973 Scheme
Nokia
-ISUPA HARQ ACK/NACK signalling
R1-040974 3erformance
Nokia
-ISUPA Signalling aspects of the rate
R1-040975 scheduling
Nokia
-ISUPA Downlink scheduling signalling
R1-040976 3erformance
Nokia
1-bit Rate Request/Rate Grant Scheduling
R1-040977 Signalling
Nokia
-ISUPA Dynamic Step Adjustment for Node
R1-040978 B Controlled Scheduling
Nokia
:Dn channelisation code sharing during
R1-040979
Nokia
sompressed mode
R1-040980
Nokia,
Text Proposal on System Setup for MIMO TeliaSonera,
T-Mobile
R1-040981
MIMO Reference Cases
Nokia
Somments and TP on MIMO Compatibility QUALCOMM
R1-040982 ~,ssessment
Europe
QUALCOMM
R1-040983 TR 25.803 v1.3.1
Europe
QUALCOMM
R1-040984 3n NI mapping
Europe

R1-041469

8.5

~ot treated

R1-040787)

~ot treated

17
8
8.1

=R1-040805

8.4

17/0~2004

=R1-040752

17/0~2004

~ot treated

8.4
8.5

~ot treated

=R1-040750

~ot treated

8.5

~ot treated

9.2
9.2
13

Cpproved as version 0.1.0 in R1-041033
~oted
~ot treated

18/08/2004

~oted

20/08/2004 ~oted.

RAN1 could not conclude on a
significant code saving gain
16/08/2004 ~oted

6
16/08/2004

~loted. Agreed to use 6 sectors and 2Rx
_MMSE as reference case for MIMO for
MIMO studies

16/08/2004

~oted

16/08/2004

~,pproved as vl.4.0 in R1-041024

16/08/2004

~oted

6
6.1
7
7.1

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010926

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
QUALCOMM
R1-040985 Position on scheduler design parameters Europe
Somparison of D-ASTTD-SGRC and
Huawei
R1-040986 DSTTD-SGRC using full-queue system
Technologies
simulations
Midamble Allocation and Channelistion
R1-040987 ?ode Allocation Signaling to Support MIMO IPWireless
n UTRA TDD
Text Proposal for MIMO TR 25.876
R1-040988 Midamble Allocation and Code Allocation IPWireless
Signaling)
R1-040989 Per Antenna Rate Control for UTRA TDD IPWireless
R1-040990 Text Proposal for MIMO TR 25.876 (MIMO IPWireless
Proposal for UTRA TDD)
R1-040991 Intra-frame Code Hopping for EU-TDD andIPWireless
Text Proposal for 25.804
-IARQ Performance for TDD Enhanced
R1-040992 Jplink and Text Proposal for 25.804
Dower Control for TDD Enhanced Uplink
R1-040993 and Text Proposal for 25.804
System Simulation Results for Release 99
R1-040994 :ype channels for TR25.895 (with text
3roposal)
R1-040995 Text Proposal for Application to 3GPP
systems and services
R1-040996 Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895
R1-040997 Downlink Code Resource Optimisation for
TDD HSDPA
R1-040998 MBMS Transport and Physical Layer Soft
?ombining
R1-040999 Signalling framework for Enhanced Uplink
scheduling

R1-041469

~ot treated

9,2

~ot treated
6
=R1-040580

~ot treated

=R1-040581

~ot treated

=R1-040582
=R1-040583

~ot treated
~ot treated

6

6
6
6

20/08/2004 Decided

to include TP with a note that
applicability of the scheme for 1.28Mcps TDD
s FFS.
20/0~2004 ~,greed

11

IPWireless

11

IPWireless

11

12

IPWireless

7.3

Fujitsu

8.5

by R1-041027

20/0~2004 Revised

wording in R1-041043

15

Motorola

20/0~2004 Revised

12

IPWireless

by R1-041035

12

IPWireless

20/0~2004 Revised

R1-041027
IPWireless

R1-041035

R1-041028

20/0~2004 Revised

by R1-041028
~ot treated

17/0~2004

~oted

~ot treated

55

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010927

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004
TR25.895 vl.3.4: Analysis of Higher Chip
R1-041000 Rates for UTRA TDD Evolution
IPWireless
R1-041002 Soft Combining for MBMS
R1-041003 JE performance requirements for MBMS
"eception
R1-041004 JL signalling for FDD enhanced UL
R1-041005 Traffic to Pilot Ratio Settings and Pilot
~owers for EDCH

R1-041469

20/08/2004 Cpproved

12

Ericsson

7.4

Nortel Net~vorks
Lucent
Technologies

8.4

~Vithdrawn
~oted
17/08/2004 ~oted
17/08/2004

7.3

Ericsson

8.3

R1-040872)

17/08/2004

~oted
~ot treated
~Vithdrawn

r~/l~l,,l~÷i~n f~r TOO r-nk~nr,~l I I~lin# ~nN

~ ..........

~er-Stream Rate Control for LCR
R1-041007 TDD_System Proposal and Initial Link Level
CATT
Results
R1-041008 Simulations related to R1-040962
NTT DoCoMo
RoT information broadcast as auxiliary
R1-041009 nformation
Panasonic
Signalling for E-DCH Scheduling -Te~
Fujistu
R1-041010 oroposal
R1-041011 =airness based multiuser MIMO scheduling Samsung
Samsung &
R1-041012 Cntenna selection based MIMO
SNU
Samsung &
R1-041013 ~U2RC Simulation
SNU
[To) LS on the material to be submi~ed to
ITU-R Ad Hoc
R1-041014 ITU-R WP8F#14 for Revision 5 of
Recommendation ITU-R M. 1457
(Telecom Italia)
To:R1, R2, R3, R4)
R1-041015 Somments on MICH mapping proposal in NEC
R1-040867
:u~her considerations on the UE capability
R1-041016
Siemens
For MBMS (FDD)

as version 1.4.0 in R1-041042

~ot treated
6

8.5

~ot treated
~ot treated

8.5

~ot treated

8.1

6

~ot treated
~ot treated

6

~ot treated

6

16/08/2004 ~oted

4

7.1
7.3

16/08/2004 ~oted
17/08/2004 ~oted

56

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010928

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041017

R1-041018
R1-041019
R1-041020
R1-041021
R1-041022
R1-041023
R1-041024
R1-041025
R1-041026
R1-041027
R1-041028
R1-041029
R1-041030
R1-041031

_5.222CR122r1(Rel-4, F)&CR123r1(Rel-5,
~,)&CR124r1(Rel-6, A): "Correction of
Siemens
symbol Xi defined in sub-frame
segmentation step"
_5224CR135r1(Rel-4, F)&CR136r1(Rel-5, Siemens AG,
~,)&CR137r1(Rel-6, A): "Cou:ections of radio CATT
~ccess procedure for 1.28Mcps TDD"
_5.214CR349r1(Rel-6, F)&CR350(Rel-5, A) Electronics
’Clarification of SSDT uplink only signaling" LG
~,pproved Report of 3GPP TSG RAN WG1 RAN1 Secretary
:~el.6 Ad Hoc meeting in Cannes
TR25.876 v.1.6.0 "Multiple-Input Multiple Editor(Lucent
:Dutput in UTRA"
Technologies)
Text Proposal " MIMO Reference Case" Nokia
Somments and TP on MIMO Compatibility QUALCOMM
~,ssessment
Europe
QUALCOMM
TR 25.803 vl.4.0
Europe
Draft LS on introduction of the MICH in
QUALCOMM
Europe
_5.21x
TR 25.803 vl.4.1
QUALCOMM
Europe
System Simulation Results for Release 99
:ype channels for TR25.895 (with text
IPWireless
3roposal)
Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895 IPWireless
DRAFT Question on the impact of L1
Panasonic
imitations on MBMS
Baseline for finalization of MBMS soft
Qualcomm
sombining
Europe,
Motorola
Nortel Net~vorks
Draft LS on questions on MBMS

R1-041469

5.2
5.3
5.4

R 1-040826)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

5.2
5.3
5.4

R1-040913)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

5.4

R1-040875)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

2

R1-040812)

6

~,pproved Version
~,pproved Version

6
6

R1-040981)
R1-040982)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

~lot treated

7.1

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

7.1
7.1

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

R1-041024)

in Tdoc R1-041048

Decided to approve via E-mail until August 30

R1-040994)

20/08/2004 ~,greed

R1-040996)

20/08/2004 Revised

to include in the TR with modification

12
12
7.2

regarding conclusions for R1-041044
with modifications in R1-041047

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

7.3

20/08/2004 ~,greed

7.3

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

with modifications in R1-041052.

57

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010929

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

16

R1-040926)

Nokia
Nokia

8
6

=R1-040971

IPWireless

11

R1-040993)

MIMO ad hoc

6

scheme on HSDPA cellPhilips
R1-041032 ,,ffect of PRE/POST CR to 25.899)
:overage (including
R1-041033 TR25.808 v0.1.0
R1-041034 Text proposal on System setup to MIMO
~ower Control for TDD Enhanced Uplink
R1-041035 and Text Proposal for 25.804
R1-041036 Summary from MIMO adhoc meeting

2o/o8/2oo4--ndorsed. Decided to provide official OR
number #2) on the reflector by August 27 in
R1-041055 and approve on E-mail approval
Jntil August 31.
~,pproved Version
20/08/2004 ~,pproved with addition and correction
2o/o8/2oo4~,greed
20/08/2004 ~,pproved
20/08/2004 [t

was not clear if CR is need or not. It was
decided to conclude discussion in
RAN 1#38bis

R1-041037 __.5.214CR343r2(Rel-5, F)&CR344r2(Rel-6,Panasonic
~,) "Clarification of minimum power limit"

5.3

R1-041038 =roposed addition for TR25.993

5.5

20/08/2004 ~oted

4

20/08/2004 ~oted

4

20/08/2004 Decided

T-Mobile,
Siemens, Nokia
:Cc) Reply LS on Proposed Modification to RAN2
R1-041039 -ISDPA Radio Bearer Settings (To:T1 Cc:
R1) (Reply to)
RAN2
:Cc) LS on enhancing L1 multiplexing test
R1-041040 soverage in 3GPP test specifications
To:T1, Cc:R1)
R1-041041
R1-041042
R1-041043
R1-041044
R1-041045

TR 25.804 "Uplink Enhancements for UTRAInterDigital
TDD" v0.3.0
TR25.895 vl.4.0: Analysis of Higher Chip IPWireless
Rates for UTRA TDD Evolution
Text Proposal for Application to 3GPP
IPWireless
systems and services
Text Proposal for Conclusion to TR25.895 IPWireless
Draft Response to LS on the material to be RAN1
submitted to ITU-R WP8F#14 for Revision 5
3f Recommendation ITU-R M.1457 (To:ITUR Ad Hoc)

R1-040839)

11

to provide quick feedback to TSG
~VG-T1 that RAN1 would review the L1
aspects and provide more feedback from
RAN#38bis in R1-041049.
~,pproved version

12

~,pproved version

12

R1-040995)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

12
4

R1-041028)

20/08/2004 ~,pproved
20/08/2004 ~,pproved

in R1-041046

58

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010930

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041046
R1-041047
R1-041048
R1-041049
R1-041050

Response to LS on the material to be
RANl(Telecom
submitted to ITU-R WP8F#14 for Revision 5
Italia)
3f Recommendation ITU-R M.1457 (To:ITUR Ad Hoc)
_S on Question on the impact of L1
RANl(Panasoni
imitations on MBMS (To: R2, R3, R4)
c)
_S on introduction of the MICH in 25.21x RANl(Qualcom
To:R2, R3 Cc: R4)
m)
DRAFT LS on enhancing L1 multiplexing
:est coverage in 3GPP test specifications RAN1 (Nokia)
To:T1, Cc:RAN2)
TR25.876 v. 1.6.1 "Multiple-Input Multiple Lucent
:Dutput in UTRA"
Technologies

R1-041051 TR 25.895. version 1.4.1

IPWireless

R1-041052 _S on questions on MBMS (To :R2, Cc :R3)RANl(Nortel
Networks)
_S on enhancing L1 multiplexing test
R1-041053 soverage in 3GPP test specifications
RAN1 (Nokia)
To:T1, Cc:R2)
_5.899CR1(Rel-6, F)"lmplementation
R1-041054 somplexity of ACK/NACK performance
mprovement"
R1-041055 _5.899CR2(Rel-6, F)"Effect of PRE/POST
scheme on HSDPA cell coverage"
_5.899CR1r1(Rel-6, F)"lmplementation
R1-041056 somplexity of ACK/NACK performance
mprovement"
rVlIMO TR25.876 vl.7.0
R1-041057

R1-041469

4

=R1-041045

~,pproved version

7

R1-041029)

~,pproved version
~,pproved version

7

20/08/2004 ~,pproved

4
Decided to approve via email until August 31

6
12
7.3

R1-041031)

4

~rovided on the reflector, and E-mail approval
deadline would be August 30
~,pproved version

R1-041049)

~,pproved version

Philips

16

=R1-040925

Philips

16

=R1-041032

Philips

16

R1-041054)

Editor(Lucent
Technologies)
RAN4

6

=R1-041050

:Dn the reflector by August 27 and approve on
E-mail until August 31.
There were some comments from Samsung.
Revised to R1-041056)
:Dn the reflector by August 27 and approve on
E-mail until August 31. Approved on E-mail.
~,pproved on E-mail.

R1-041058 Response LS on minimum power limit
To:RI,CC:T1RF)
_5.214CR352r1(Rel-6, F)&CR353(Rel-5, A) LG Electronics
R1-041059 ’Clarification of SSDT uplink only signaling"

4

~,pproved version
~loted

5.4

R1-041019)

~,pproved.

59

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010931

3GPP TSG RAN WG1 Meeting #39
Shin-Yokohama, Japan 15- 19 November, 2004

R1-041469

6O

APLNDC-WH-A 0000010932