DiTirro v. Facebook, Inc.

Filing 20

MOTION to Dismiss First Amended Complaint; Memorandum of Points and Authorities filed by Facebook, Inc.. Motion Hearing set for 6/11/2014 09:00 AM in Courtroom 3, 3rd Floor, Oakland before Hon. Phyllis J. Hamilton. Responses due by 4/29/2014. Replies due by 5/6/2014. (Attachments: # 1 Declaration of Sandeep N. Solanki, # 2 Exhibit A to Declaration of Sandeep N. Solanki, # 3 Exhibit B to Declaration of Sandeep N. Solanki, # 4 Exhibit C to Declaration of Sandeep N. Solanki, # 5 Exhibit D to Declaration of Sandeep N. Solanki, # 6 Proposed Order Granting Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint)(Gutkin, Jeffrey) (Filed on 4/15/2014)

EXHIBIT D

!

"#$#%&%'#!()!*+,-#.!$'/!*%.0('.+1+2+#+%.!
!
"#$%!&'(')*)+'!,-!.$/#'%!(+0!.)%1,+%$2$3$'$)%!45&'(')*)+'67!0)8$9)%!-8,*!'#)!:(;)2,,<!=8$+;$13)%>!(+0!/,9)8+%!,?8!
8)3('$,+%#$1!@$'#!?%)8%!(+0!,'#)8%!@#,!$+')8(;'!@$'#!:(;)2,,<A!!BC!?%$+/!,8!(;;)%%$+/!:(;)2,,<>!C,?!(/8))!',!'#$%!
&'(')*)+'A!
!
34!!56+7$89!
!
D,?8!18$9(;C!$%!9)8C!$*1,8'(+'!',!?%A!!E)!0)%$/+)0!,?8!=8$9(;C!=,3$;C!',!*(<)!$*1,8'(+'!0$%;3,%?8)%!',!C,?!(2,?'!#,@!
@)!;,33);'!(+0!?%)!'#)!$+-,8*('$,+!C,?!1,%'!,+!:(;)2,,<A!!E)!)+;,?8(/)!C,?!',!8)(0!'#)!=8$9(;C!=,3$;C>!(+0!',!?%)!
'#)!$+-,8*('$,+!$'!;,+'($+%!',!#)31!*(<)!$+-,8*)0!0);$%$,+%A!
!
:4!!"-$6+',!;(<6!=('#%'#!$'/!>')(6&$#+('!
!
D,?!,@+!(33!,-!'#)!;,+')+'!(+0!$+-,8*('$,+!C,?!1,%'!,+!:(;)2,,<>!(+0!C,?!;(+!;,+'8,3!#,@!@)!%#(8)!C,?8!;,+')+'!
'#8,?/#!C,?8!18$9(;C!(+0!(113$;('$,+!%)''$+/%A!!F+!,80)8!-,8!?%!',!?%)!;)8'($+!'C1)%!,-!;,+')+'!(+0!18,9$0)!C,?!@$'#!
:(;)2,,<>!C,?!(/8))!',!'#)!-,33,@$+/G!
!
HAI :,8!;,+')+'!'#('!$%!;,9)8)0!2C!$+')33);'?(3!18,1)8'C!8$/#'%>!3$<)!1#,',%!(+0!9$0),%!45F=!;,+')+'67>!C,?!%1);$-$;(33C!
/$9)!?%!'#)!-,33,@$+/!1)8*$%%$,+>!%?2J);'!',!C,?8!18$9(;C!(+0!(113$;('$,+!%)''$+/%G!C,?!/8(+'!?%!(!+,+K)L;3?%$9)>!
'8(+%-)8(23)>!%?2K3$;)+%(23)>!8,C(3'CK-8))>!@,830@$0)!3$;)+%)!',!?%)!(+C!F=!;,+')+'!'#('!C,?!1,%'!,+!,8!$+!
;,++);'$,+!@$'#!:(;)2,,<!45F=!M$;)+%)67A!!"#$%!F=!M$;)+%)!)+0%!@#)+!C,?!0)3)')!C,?8!F=!;,+')+'!,8!C,?8!(;;,?+'!
4)L;)1'!',!'#)!)L')+'!C,?8!;,+')+'!#(%!2))+!%#(8)0!@$'#!,'#)8%>!(+0!'#)C!#(9)!+,'!0)3)')0!$'7A!!
HAH E#)+!C,?!0)3)')!F=!;,+')+'>!$'!$%!0)3)')0!$+!(!*(++)8!%$*$3(8!',!)*1'C$+/!'#)!8);C;3)!2$+!,+!(!;,*1?')8A!!
N,@)9)8>!C,?!?+0)8%'(+0!'#('!8)*,9)0!;,+')+'!*(C!1)8%$%'!$+!2(;<?1!;,1$)%!-,8!(!8)(%,+(23)!1)8$,0!,-!'$*)!
42?'!@$33!+,'!2)!(9($3(23)!',!,'#)8%7A!
HAO E)!(3@(C%!(118);$(')!C,?8!-))02(;<!,8!,'#)8!%?//)%'$,+%!(2,?'!:(;)2,,<>!2?'!C,?!?+0)8%'(+0!'#('!@)!*(C!?%)!
'#)*!@$'#,?'!(+C!,23$/('$,+!',!;,*1)+%(')!C,?!-,8!'#)*!4J?%'!(%!C,?!#(9)!+,!,23$/('$,+!',!,--)8!'#)*7A!
!
?4!!"$)%#9!
!
E)!0,!,?8!2)%'!',!<))1!:(;)2,,<!%(-)>!2?'!@)!;(++,'!/?(8(+'))!$'A!!E)!+))0!C,?8!#)31!$+!,80)8!',!0,!'#('>!@#$;#!
$+;3?0)%!'#)!-,33,@$+/!;,**$'*)+'%G!
!
OAI D,?!@$33!+,'!%)+0!,8!,'#)8@$%)!1,%'!?+(?'#,8$P)0!;,**)8;$(3!;,**?+$;('$,+%!',!?%)8%!4%?;#!(%!%1(*7A!
OAH D,?!@$33!+,'!;,33);'!?%)8%Q!$+-,8*('$,+>!,8!,'#)8@$%)!(;;)%%!:(;)2,,<>!?%$+/!(?',*(')0!*)(+%!4%?;#!(%!
#(89)%'$+/!2,'%>!8,2,'%>!%1$0)8%>!,8!%;8(1)8%7!@$'#,?'!,?8!1)8*$%%$,+A!
OAO D,?!@$33!+,'!?13,(0!9$8?%)%!,8!,'#)8!*(3$;$,?%!;,0)A!
OAR D,?!@$33!+,'!%,3$;$'!3,/$+!$+-,8*('$,+!,8!(;;)%%!(+!(;;,?+'!2)3,+/$+/!',!%,*),+)!)3%)A!
OAS D,?!@$33!+,'!2?33C>!$+'$*$0(')>!,8!#(8(%%!(+C!?%)8A!
OAT D,?!@$33!+,'!1,%'!;,+')+'!'#('!$%!#(')-?3>!'#8)(')+$+/>!1,8+,/8(1#$;>!,8!'#('!;,+'($+%!+?0$'C!,8!/8(1#$;!,8!
/8('?$',?%!9$,3)+;)A!
OAU D,?!@$33!+,'!0)9)3,1!,8!,1)8(')!(!'#$80!1(8'C!(113$;('$,+!;,+'($+$+/>!,8!(09)8'$%)!,8!,'#)8@$%)!*(8<)'!(3;,#,3K
8)3(')0!,8!,'#)8!*('?8)!;,+')+'!@$'#,?'!(118,18$(')!(/)K2(%)0!8)%'8$;'$,+%A!
OAV D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)!:(;)2,,<!',!0,!(+C'#$+/!?+3(@-?3>!*$%3)(0$+/>!*(3$;$,?%>!,8!0$%;8$*$+(',8CA!
OAW D,?!@$33!+,'!-(;$3$'(')!,8!)+;,?8(/)!(+C!9$,3('$,+%!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'A!
!
@4!!*%,+.#6$#+('!$'/!A88(<'#!"%8<6+#9!
!
:(;)2,,<!?%)8%!18,9$0)!'#)$8!8)(3!+(*)%!(+0!$+-,8*('$,+>!(+0!@)!+))0!C,?8!#)31!',!<))1!$'!'#('!@(CA!!N)8)!(8)!%,*)!
;,**$'*)+'%!C,?!*(<)!',!?%!8)3('$+/!',!8)/$%')8$+/!(+0!*($+'($+$+/!'#)!%);?8$'C!,-!C,?8!(;;,?+'G!
!
RAI D,?!@$33!+,'!18,9$0)!(+C!-(3%)!1)8%,+(3!$+-,8*('$,+!,+!:(;)2,,<>!,8!;8)(')!(+!(;;,?+'!-,8!(+C,+)!,'#)8!'#(+!
C,?8%)3-!@$'#,?'!1)8*$%%$,+A!
RAH D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)!:(;)2,,<!$-!C,?!(8)!?+0)8!IOA!
RAO D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)!:(;)2,,<!$-!C,?!(8)!3,;(')0!$+!(!;,?+'8C!)*2(8/,)0!2C!'#)!XA&A>!,8!(8)!,+!'#)!XA&A!"8)(%?8C!
Y)1(8'*)+'Q%!3$%'!,-!&1);$(33C!Y)%$/+(')0!Z('$,+(3%A!
RAR D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)!:(;)2,,<!$-!C,?!(8)!(!;,+9$;')0!%)L!,--)+0)8A!

!

RAS D,?!@$33!<))1!C,?8!;,+'(;'!$+-,8*('$,+!(;;?8(')!(+0!?1K',K0(')A!
RAT D,?!@$33!+,'!%#(8)!C,?8!1(%%@,80>!3)'!(+C,+)!)3%)!(;;)%%!C,?8!(;;,?+'>!,8!0,!(+C'#$+/!)3%)!'#('!*$/#'!J),1(80$P)!
'#)!%);?8$'C!,-!C,?8!(;;,?+'A!!
RAU D,?!@$33!+,'!'8(+%-)8!C,?8!(;;,?+'!',!(+C,+)!@$'#,?'!-$8%'!/)''$+/!,?8!@8$'')+!1)8*$%%$,+A!
!
B4!!56(#%8#+',!C#-%6!5%(02%D.!*+,-#.!
!
E)!8)%1);'!,'#)8!1),13)Q%!8$/#'%>!(+0!)L1);'!C,?!',!0,!'#)!%(*)A!!
!
SAI D,?!@$33!+,'!1,%'!;,+')+'!,8!'(<)!(+C!(;'$,+!,+!:(;)2,,<!'#('!$+-8$+/)%!%,*),+)!)3%)Q%!8$/#'%!,8!,'#)8@$%)!
9$,3(')%!'#)!3(@A!
SAH E)!;(+!8)*,9)!(+C!;,+')+'!C,?!1,%'!,+!:(;)2,,<!$-!@)!2)3$)9)!'#('!$'!9$,3(')%!'#$%!&'(')*)+'A!
SAO E)!@$33!18,9$0)!C,?!@$'#!',,3%!',!#)31!C,?!18,');'!C,?8!$+')33);'?(3!18,1)8'C!8$/#'%A!!",!3)(8+!*,8)>!9$%$'!,?8!N,@!
',!.)1,8'![3($*%!,-!F+')33);'?(3!=8,1)8'C!F+-8$+/)*)+'!1(/)A!
SAR F-!@)!8)*,9)0!C,?8!;,+')+'!-,8!$+-8$+/$+/!%,*),+)!)3%)Q%!;,1C8$/#'>!(+0!C,?!2)3$)9)!@)!8)*,9)0!$'!2C!*$%'(<)>!
@)!@$33!18,9$0)!C,?!@$'#!(+!,11,8'?+$'C!',!(11)(3A!
SAS F-!C,?!8)1)(')03C!$+-8$+/)!,'#)8!1),13)Q%!$+')33);'?(3!18,1)8'C!8$/#'%>!@)!@$33!0$%(23)!C,?8!(;;,?+'!@#)+!
(118,18$(')A!
SAT D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)!,?8!;,1C8$/#'%!,8!'8(0)*(8<%!4$+;3?0$+/!:(;)2,,<>!'#)!:(;)2,,<!(+0!:!M,/,%>!:B>!:(;)>!=,<)>!
E(33!(+0!OHTTS7!@$'#,?'!,?8!@8$'')+!1)8*$%%$,+A!
SAU F-!C,?!;,33);'!$+-,8*('$,+!-8,*!?%)8%>!C,?!@$33G!,2'($+!'#)$8!;,+%)+'>!*(<)!$'!;3)(8!C,?!4(+0!+,'!:(;)2,,<7!(8)!'#)!
,+)!;,33);'$+/!'#)$8!$+-,8*('$,+>!(+0!1,%'!(!18$9(;C!1,3$;C!)L13($+$+/!@#('!$+-,8*('$,+!C,?!;,33);'!(+0!#,@!C,?!
@$33!?%)!$'A!
SAV D,?!@$33!+,'!1,%'!(+C,+)Q%!$0)+'$-$;('$,+!0,;?*)+'%!,8!%)+%$'$9)!-$+(+;$(3!$+-,8*('$,+!,+!:(;)2,,<A!
!
E4!!F(1+2%!
!
TAI E)!;?88)+'3C!18,9$0)!,?8!*,2$3)!%)89$;)%!-,8!-8))>!2?'!13)(%)!2)!(@(8)!'#('!C,?8!;(88$)8Q%!+,8*(3!8(')%!(+0!-))%>!
%?;#!(%!')L'!*)%%(/$+/!-))%>!@$33!%'$33!(113CA!
TAH F+!'#)!)9)+'!C,?!;#(+/)!,8!0)(;'$9(')!C,?8!*,2$3)!')3)1#,+)!+?*2)8>!C,?!@$33!?10(')!C,?8!(;;,?+'!$+-,8*('$,+!
,+!:(;)2,,<!@$'#$+!RV!#,?8%!',!)+%?8)!'#('!C,?8!*)%%(/)%!(8)!+,'!%)+'!',!'#)!1)8%,+!@#,!(;\?$8)%!C,?8!,30!
+?*2)8A!
!
G4!!5$9&%'#.!
!
F-!C,?!1?8;#(%)!,8!?%)!:(;)2,,<![8)0$'%>!,8!*(<)!0$8);'!1(C*)+'%>!C,?!(/8))!',!,?8!=(C*)+'%!")8*%A!
!
H4!!"0%8+$2!56(7+.+('.!A002+8$12%!#(!"-$6%!I+'J.!
!
F-!C,?!$+;3?0)!,?8!&#(8)!M$+<!2?'',+!,+!C,?8!@)2%$')>!'#)!-,33,@$+/!(00$'$,+(3!')8*%!(113C!',!C,?G!
!
VAI E)!/$9)!C,?!1)8*$%%$,+!',!?%)!:(;)2,,<]%!&#(8)!M$+<!2?'',+!%,!'#('!?%)8%!;(+!1,%'!3$+<%!,8!;,+')+'!-8,*!C,?8!
@)2%$')!,+!:(;)2,,<A!
VAH D,?!/$9)!?%!1)8*$%%$,+!',!?%)!%?;#!3$+<%!(+0!;,+')+'!,+!:(;)2,,<A!
VAO D,?!@$33!+,'!13(;)!(!&#(8)!M$+<!2?'',+!,+!(+C!1(/)!;,+'($+$+/!;,+')+'!'#('!@,?30!9$,3(')!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!$-!1,%')0!
,+!:(;)2,,<A!
!
K4!!"0%8+$2!56(7+.+('.!A002+8$12%!#(!L%7%2(0%6.MC0%6$#(6.!()!A002+8$#+('.!$'/!N%1.+#%.!
!
F-!C,?!(8)!(!0)9)3,1)8!,8!,1)8(',8!,-!(!=3('-,8*!(113$;('$,+!,8!(!@)2%$')!?%$+/![,++);'!45(113$;('$,+67!,8!,'#)8@$%)!
?%)!=3('-,8*>!'#)!-,33,@$+/!(00$'$,+(3!')8*%!(113C!',!C,?G!
!
WAI D,?!(8)!8)%1,+%$23)!-,8!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!(+0!$'%!;,+')+'!(+0!(33!?%)%!C,?!*(<)!,-!=3('-,8*A!!"#$%!$+;3?0)%!
)+%?8$+/!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!,8!?%)!,-!=3('-,8*!*))'%!,?8!=3('-,8*!^?$0)3$+)%A!
WAH E#)+!?%)8%!(00!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!,8!;,++);'!$'!',!'#)$8!:(;)2,,<!(;;,?+'>!'#)C!/$9)!1)8*$%%$,+!-,8!C,?!',!8);)$9)!
;)8'($+!0('(!8)3('$+/!',!'#)*A!!D,?8!(;;)%%!',!(+0!?%)!,-!'#('!0('(!@$33!2)!3$*$')0!(%!-,33,@%G!
WAHAI D,?!@$33!,+3C!?%)!'#)!0('(!C,?!8);)$9)!-,8!C,?8!(113$;('$,+>!(+0!@$33!,+3C!?%)!$'!$+!;,++);'$,+!@$'#!
:(;)2,,<A!

!

WAHAH D,?!@$33!*(<)!$'!;3)(8!',!?%)8%!@#('!?%)8!0('(!C,?!(8)!/,$+/!',!?%)!(+0!#,@!C,?!@$33!?%)>!0$%13(C>!,8!%#(8)!
'#('!0('(A!
WAHAO D,?!@$33!+,'!?%)>!0$%13(C>!,8!%#(8)!(!?%)8Q%!0('(!$+!(!*(++)8!$+;,+%$%')+'!@$'#!'#)!?%)8Q%!18$9(;C!%)''$+/%!
@$'#,?'!'#)!?%)8Q%!;,+%)+'A!
WAHAR D,?!@$33!0)3)')!(33!0('(!C,?!8);)$9)0!-8,*!?%!8)3('$+/!',!(+C!?%)8!@#,!8)*,9)%!,8!0$%;,++);'%!-8,*!C,?8!
(113$;('$,+!?+3)%%!,'#)8@$%)!1)8*$'')0!$+!,?8!=3('-,8*!^?$0)3$+)%A!
WAHAS D,?!@$33!0)3)')!(33!0('(!C,?!8);)$9)0!-8,*!:(;)2,,<!$-!@)!0$%(23)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!,8!(%<!C,?!',!0,!%,A!
WAHAT E)!;(+!8)\?$8)!C,?!',!?10(')!(+C!0('(!C,?!#(9)!8);)$9)0!-8,*!?%A!
WAHAU E)!;(+!3$*$'!C,?8!(;;)%%!',!0('(A!
WAHAV D,?!@$33!+,'!'8(+%-)8!'#)!0('(!C,?!8);)$9)!-8,*!?%!@$'#,?'!,?8!18$,8!;,+%)+'A!
WAO D,?!@$33!+,'!/$9)!?%!0('(!'#('!C,?!$+0)1)+0)+'3C!;,33);'!-8,*!(!?%)8!,8!(!?%)8Q%!;,+')+'!@$'#,?'!'#('!?%)8Q%!
;,+%)+'A!
WAR D,?!@$33!*(<)!$'!)(%C!-,8!?%)8%!',!8)*,9)!,8!0$%;,++);'!-8,*!C,?8!(113$;('$,+A!!
WAS D,?!@$33!*(<)!$'!)(%C!-,8!?%)8%!',!;,+'(;'!C,?A!E)!;(+!(3%,!%#(8)!C,?8!)*($3!(008)%%!@$'#!?%)8%A!
WAT D,?!@$33!18,9$0)!;?%',*)8!%?11,8'!-,8!C,?8!(113$;('$,+A!
WAU D,?!@$33!+,'!%#,@!(0%!,8!@)2!%)(8;#!2,L)%!,+!:(;)2,,<!18,-$3)%A!
WAV E)!/$9)!C,?!(33!8$/#'%!+);)%%(8C!',!?%)!'#)!;,0)>!_=F%!4(3,+/!@$'#!(33!;,+')+'!(+0!0('(!8);)$9)07>!,8!',,3%!@)!
18,9$0)!',!C,?>!2?'!,+3C!$+!;,++);'$,+!@$'#!C,?8!(113$;('$,+A!
WAW D,?!@$33!+,'!%)33>!'8(+%-)8>!,8!%?23$;)+%)!,?8!;,0)>!_=F%>!,8!',,3%!',!(+C,+)A!!
WAI` D,?!@$33!+,'!*$%8)18)%)+'!C,?8!8)3('$,+%#$1!@$'#!:(;)2,,<!',!,'#)8%A!
WAII D,?!*(C!?%)!'#)!3,/,%!@)!*(<)!(9($3(23)!',!0)9)3,1)8%!,8!!$%%?)!(!18)%%!8)3)(%)!,8!,'#)8!1?23$;!%'(')*)+'!%,!
3,+/!(%!C,?!-,33,@!,?8!=3('-,8*!^?$0)3$+)%A!
WAIH E)!;(+!$%%?)!(!18)%%!8)3)(%)!0)%;8$2$+/!,?8!8)3('$,+%#$1!@$'#!C,?A!
WAIO D,?!@$33!;,*13C!@$'#!(33!(113$;(23)!3(@%A!!F+!1(8'$;?3(8!C,?!@$33!4$-!(113$;(23)7G!
WAIOAI!!#(9)!(!1,3$;C!-,8!8)*,9$+/!$+-8$+/$+/!;,+')+'!(+0!')8*$+('$+/!8)1)('!$+-8$+/)8%!'#('!;,*13$)%!@$'#!'#)!
Y$/$'(3!a$33)++$?*![,1C8$/#'!_;'A!
WAIOAH!!;,*13C!@$'#!'#)!b$0),!=8$9(;C!=8,');'$,+!_;'!45b==_67>!(+0!@$33!,2'($+!)L13$;$'>!,1'K$+!;,+%)+'!-8,*!?%)8%!
18$,8!',!%#(8$+/!@$'#!:(;)2,,<!?%)8!0('(!%?2J);'!',!'#)!b==_A!!D,?!(;<+,@3)0/)!:(;)2,,<!#(%!+,!
,23$/('$,+%!?+0)8!'#)!b==_A!
WAIR E)!0,!+,'!/?(8(+'))!'#('!=3('-,8*!@$33!(3@(C%!2)!-8))A!
WAIS D,?!/$9)!?%!(33!8$/#'%!+);)%%(8C!',!)+(23)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!',!@,8<!@$'#!:(;)2,,<>!$+;3?0$+/!'#)!8$/#'!',G!
WAISAI $+;,81,8(')!C,?8!;,+')+'!$+',!%'8)(*%>!18,-$3)%>!(+0!?%)8!(;'$,+!%',8$)%c!
WAISAH 3$+<!',!,8!-8(*)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+c!(+0!
WAISAO 13(;)!;,+')+'>!$+;3?0$+/!(0%>!(8,?+0!C,?8!(113$;('$,+A!
WAIT E)!;(+!(+(3CP)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+>!;,+')+'>!(+0!0('(!-,8!(+C!1?81,%)>!$+;3?0$+/!;,**)8;$(3!4%?;#!(%!-,8!'(8/)'$+/!
'#)!0)3$9)8C!,-!(09)8'$%)*)+'%!(+0!$+0)L$+/!;,+')+'!-,8!%)(8;#7A!
WAIU ",!)+%?8)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!$%!%(-)!-,8!?%)8%>!@)!;(+!(?0$'!$'A!
WAIV E)!;(+!;8)(')!(113$;('$,+%!'#('!,--)8!%$*$3(8!-)('?8)%!(+0!%)89$;)%!',>!,8!,'#)8@$%)!;,*1)')!@$'#>!C,?8!
(113$;('$,+A!
!
3O4!!A1(<#!A/7%6#+.%&%'#.!('!P$8%1((J!
!
d?8!/,(3!$%!',!0)3$9)8!(0%!'#('!(8)!+,'!,+3C!9(3?(23)!',!(09)8'$%)8%>!2?'!(3%,!9(3?(23)!',!C,?A!!F+!,80)8!',!0,!'#('>!C,?!
(/8))!',!'#)!-,33,@$+/G!
!
I`AI D,?!;(+!?%)!C,?8!18$9(;C!%)''$+/%!',!3$*$'!#,@!C,?8!+(*)!(+0!18,-$3)!1$;'?8)!*(C!2)!(%%,;$(')0!@$'#!;,**)8;$(3!
,8!%1,+%,8)0!;,+')+'A!!D,?!/$9)!?%!1)8*$%%$,+!',!?%)!C,?8!+(*)!(+0!18,-$3)!1$;'?8)!$+!;,++);'$,+!@$'#!'#('!
;,+')+'>!%?2J);'!',!'#)!3$*$'%!C,?!13(;)A!
I`AH E)!0,!+,'!/$9)!C,?8!;,+')+'!',!(09)8'$%)8%A!
I`AO D,?!?+0)8%'(+0!'#('!@)!*(C!+,'!(3@(C%!$0)+'$-C!1($0!%)89$;)%!(+0!;,**?+$;('$,+%!(%!%?;#A!!
!
334!!"0%8+$2!56(7+.+('.!A002+8$12%!#(!A/7%6#+.%6.!
!
D,?!;(+!'(8/)'!C,?8!%1);$-$;!(?0$)+;)!2C!2?C$+/!(0%!,+!:(;)2,,<!,8!,?8!1?23$%#)8!+)'@,8<A!!"#)!-,33,@$+/!(00$'$,+(3!
')8*%!(113C!',!C,?!$-!C,?!13(;)!(+!,80)8!'#8,?/#!,?8!,+3$+)!(09)8'$%$+/!1,8'(3!45d80)867G!
!
IIAI E#)+!C,?!13(;)!(+!d80)8>!C,?!@$33!')33!?%!'#)!'C1)!,-!(09)8'$%$+/!C,?!@(+'!',!2?C>!'#)!(*,?+'!C,?!@(+'!',!
%1)+0>!(+0!C,?8!2$0A!!F-!@)!(;;)1'!C,?8!d80)8>!@)!@$33!0)3$9)8!C,?8!(0%!(%!$+9)+',8C!2);,*)%!(9($3(23)A!

!

IIAH

D,?!@$33!1(C!-,8!C,?8!d80)8%!$+!(;;,80(+;)!@$'#!,?8!=(C*)+'%!")8*%A!!"#)!(*,?+'!C,?!,@)!@$33!2)!;(3;?3(')0!
2(%)0!,+!,?8!'8(;<$+/!*);#(+$%*%A!
IIAO D,?8!(0%!@$33!;,*13C!@$'#!,?8!_0!^?$0)3$+)%A!
IIAR E)!@$33!0)')8*$+)!'#)!%$P)>!13(;)*)+'>!(+0!1,%$'$,+$+/!,-!C,?8!(0%A!
IIAS E)!0,!+,'!/?(8(+'))!'#)!(;'$9$'C!'#('!C,?8!(0%!@$33!8);)$9)>!%?;#!(%!'#)!+?*2)8!,-!;3$;<%!C,?!@$33!/)'A!
IIAT E)!;(++,'!;,+'8,3!#,@!1),13)!$+')8(;'!@$'#!C,?8!(0%>!(+0!(8)!+,'!8)%1,+%$23)!-,8!;3$;<!-8(?0!,8!,'#)8!
$*18,1)8!(;'$,+%!'#('!(--);'!'#)!;,%'!,-!8?++$+/!(0%A!
IIAU D,?!@$33!+,'!,--)8!(+C!;,+')%'!,8!%@))1%'(<)%!4518,*,'$,+67!@$'#,?'!,?8!18$,8!@8$'')+!;,+%)+'A!!F-!@)!;,+%)+'>!
C,?!'(<)!-?33!8)%1,+%$2$3$'C!-,8!'#)!18,*,'$,+>!(+0!@$33!-,33,@!,?8!=8,*,'$,+%!^?$0)3$+)%!(+0!(33!(113$;(23)!
3(@%A!
IIAV D,?!;(+!;(+;)3!C,?8!d80)8!('!(+C!'$*)!'#8,?/#!,?8!,+3$+)!1,8'(3>!2?'!$'!*(C!'(<)!?%!%)9)+!0(C%!2)-,8)!'#)!(0!
%',1%!8?++$+/A!
IIAW d?8!3$;)+%)!',!8?+!C,?8!(0!@$33!)+0!@#)+!@)!#(9)!;,*13)')0!C,?8!d80)8A!!D,?!?+0)8%'(+0>!#,@)9)8>!'#('!$-!
?%)8%!#(9)!$+')8(;')0!@$'#!C,?8!(0%>!C,?8!(0%!*(C!8)*($+!?+'$3!'#)!?%)8%!0)3)')!$'A!
IIAI` E)!;(+!?%)!C,?8!(0%!(+0!8)3(')0!$+-,8*('$,+!-,8!*(8<)'$+/!,8!18,*,'$,+(3!1?81,%)%A!
IIAII D,?!@$33!+,'!$%%?)!(+C!18)%%!8)3)(%)!,8!*(<)!1?23$;!%'(')*)+'%!(2,?'!C,?8!8)3('$,+%#$1!@$'#!:(;)2,,<!@$'#,?'!
@8$'')+!1)8*$%%$,+A!
IIAIH E)!*(C!8)J);'!,8!8)*,9)!(+C!(0!-,8!(+C!8)(%,+A!
!
F-!C,?!(8)!13(;$+/!(0%!,+!%,*),+)!)3%)Q%!2)#(3->!@)!+))0!',!*(<)!%?8)!C,?!#(9)!1)8*$%%$,+!',!13(;)!'#,%)!(0%>!
$+;3?0$+/!'#)!-,33,@$+/G!
!
IIAIO D,?!@(88(+'!'#('!C,?!#(9)!'#)!3)/(3!(?'#,8$'C!',!2$+0!'#)!(09)8'$%)8!',!'#$%!&'(')*)+'A!
IIAIR D,?!(/8))!'#('!$-!'#)!(09)8'$%)8!C,?!8)18)%)+'!9$,3(')%!'#$%!&'(')*)+'>!@)!*(C!#,30!C,?!8)%1,+%$23)!-,8!'#('!
9$,3('$,+A!
!
3:4!!A&%'/&%'#.!
!
IHAI E)!;(+!;#(+/)!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!%,!3,+/!(%!@)!18,9$0)!C,?!+,'$;)!'#8,?/#!:(;)2,,<!4?+3)%%!C,?!,1'K,?'!,-!%?;#!
+,'$;)7!(+0!(+!,11,8'?+$'C!',!;,**)+'A!
IHAH :,8!;#(+/)%!',!%);'$,+%!U>!V>!W>!(+0!II!4%);'$,+%!8)3('$+/!',!1(C*)+'%>!(113$;('$,+!0)9)3,1)8%>!@)2%$')!,1)8(',8%>!
(+0!(09)8'$%)8%7>!@)!@$33!/$9)!C,?!(!*$+$*?*!,-!'#8))!0(C%!+,'$;)A!!:,8!(33!,'#)8!;#(+/)%!@)!@$33!/$9)!C,?!(!
*$+$*?*!,-!%)9)+!0(C%!+,'$;)A!
IHAO F-!*,8)!'#(+!U>```!?%)8%!;,**)+'!,+!'#)!18,1,%)0!;#(+/)>!@)!@$33!(3%,!/$9)!C,?!'#)!,11,8'?+$'C!',!1(8'$;$1(')!
$+!(!9,')!$+!@#$;#!C,?!@$33!2)!18,9$0)0!(3')8+('$9)%A!!"#)!9,')!%#(33!2)!2$+0$+/!,+!?%!$-!*,8)!'#(+!O`e!,-!(33!(;'$9)!
8)/$%')8)0!?%)8%!(%!,-!'#)!0(')!,-!'#)!+,'$;)!9,')A!
IHAR E)!;(+!*(<)!;#(+/)%!-,8!3)/(3!,8!(0*$+$%'8('$9)!8)(%,+%!?1,+!+,'$;)!@$'#,?'!,11,8'?+$'C!',!;,**)+'A!
!
3?4!!Q%6&+'$#+('!
!
F-!C,?!9$,3(')!'#)!3)'')8!,8!%1$8$'!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'>!,8!,'#)8@$%)!;8)(')!1,%%$23)!3)/(3!%R1,%?8)!-,8!?%>!@)!;(+!%',1!
18,9+0$+/!(23!,8!1(8'!,-!:(;%2,,<!',!C,?A!!E)!@$33!/)+)8(33C!'8C!',!+,'$-C!C,?>!2?'!#(9)!+,!,23$/('$,+!',!0,!%,A!!D,?!*(C!
(3%,!0)3)')!C,?8!(;;,?+'!,8!0$%(23)!C,?8!(113$;('$,+!('!(+C!'$*)A!!F+!(33!%?;#!;(%)%>!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!%#(33!')8*$+(')>!2?'!
'#)!-,33,@$+/!18,9$%$,+%!@$33!%'$33!(113CG!HAH>!HAO>!OKS>!VAH>!WAIKWAO>!WAW>!WAI`>!WAIO>!WAISAI>!WAIV>!I`AO>!IIAH>!IIAS>!IIAT>!
IIAW>!IIAI`>!IIAIO>!IIAIR>!(+0!IOKITA!
!
3@4!!L+.0<#%.!
!
IRAI D,?!@$33!8)%,39)!(+C!;3($*>!;(?%)!,-!(;'$,+!,8!0$%1?')!45;3($*67!C,?!#(9)!@$'#!?%!(8$%$+/!,?'!,-!,8!8)3('$+/!',!'#$%!
&'(')*)+'!,8!:(;)2,,<!$+!(!%'(')!,8!-)0)8(3!;,?8'!3,;(')0!$+!&(+'(![3(8(![,?+'CA!!"#)!3(@%!,-!'#)!&'(')!,-!
[(3$-,8+$(!@$33!/,9)8+!'#$%!&'(')*)+'>!(%!@)33!(%!(+C!;3($*!'#('!*$/#'!(8$%)!2)'@))+!C,?!(+0!?%>!@$'#,?'!8)/(80!',!
;,+-3$;'!,-!3(@!18,9$%$,+%A!!D,?!(/8))!',!%?2*$'!',!'#)!1)8%,+(3!J?8$%0$;'$,+!,-!'#)!;,?8'%!3,;(')0!$+!&(+'(![3(8(!
[,?+'C>![(3$-,8+$(!-,8!'#)!1?81,%)!,-!3$'$/('$+/!(33!%?;#!;3($*%A!
IRAH F-!(+C,+)!28$+/%!(!;3($*!(/($+%'!?%!8)3(')0!',!C,?8!(;'$,+%!,8!C,?8!;,+')+'!,+!:(;)2,,<>!C,?!@$33!$+0)*+$-C!(+0!
#,30!?%!#(8*3)%%!-8,*!(+0!(/($+%'!(33!0(*(/)%>!3,%%)%>!(+0!)L1)+%)%!,-!(+C!<$+0!4$+;3?0$+/!8)(%,+(23)!3)/(3!-))%!
(+0!;,%'%7!8)3(')0!',!%?;#!;3($*A!
IRAO Ef!".D!"d!gff=!:_[fBddg!X=>!BX^K:.ff>!_ZY!&_:f>!BX"!DdX!X&f!F"!_"!DdX.!dEZ!.F&gA!Ef!_.f!=.dbFYFZ^!
:_[fBddg!h_&!F&h!EF"NdX"!_ZD!fi=.f&&!d.!Fa=MFfY!E_.._Z"Ff&!FZ[MXYFZ^>!BX"!Zd"!MFaF"fY!"d>!Fa=MFfY!

!

E_.._Z"Ff&!d:!af.[N_Z"_BFMF"D>!:F"Zf&&!:d.!_!=_."F[XM_.!=X.=d&f>!_ZY!ZdZKFZ:.FZ^fafZ"A!!Ef!Yd!
Zd"!^X_._Z"ff!"N_"!:_[fBddg!EFMM!Bf!&_:f!d.!&f[X.fA!!:_[fBddg!F&!Zd"!.f&=dZ&FBMf!:d.!"Nf!
_["FdZ&!d.![dZ"fZ"!d:!"NF.Y!=_."Ff&>!_ZY!DdX!.fMf_&f!X&>!dX.!YF.f["d.&>!d::F[f.&>!fa=MdDff&>!_ZY!
_^fZ"&!:.da!_ZD![M_Fa&!_ZY!Y_a_^f&>!gZdEZ!_ZY!XZgZdEZ>!_.F&FZ^!dX"!d:!d.!FZ!_ZD!E_D!
[dZZf["fY!EF"N!_ZD![M_Fa!DdX!N_bf!_^_FZ&"!_ZD!&X[N!"NF.Y!=_."Ff&A!!F:!DdX!_.f!_![_MF:d.ZF_!
.f&FYfZ">!DdX!E_Fbf![_MF:d.ZF_![FbFM![dYf!jISRH>!ENF[N!&_D&G!h_!^fZf._M!.fMf_&f!Ydf&!Zd"!fi"fZY!
"d![M_Fa&!ENF[N!"Nf![.fYF"d.!Ydf&!Zd"!gZdE!d.!&X&=f["!"d!fiF&"!FZ!NF&!:_bd.!_"!"Nf!"Faf!d:!
fif[X"FZ^!"Nf!.fMf_&f>!ENF[N!F:!gZdEZ!BD!NFa!aX&"!N_bf!a_"f.F_MMD!_::f["fY!NF&!&f""MfafZ"!EF"N!
"Nf!YfB"d.Ah!!Ef!EFMM!Zd"!Bf!MF_BMf!"d!DdX!:d.!_ZD!Md&"!=.d:F"&!d.!d"Nf.![dZ&fkXfZ"F_M>!&=f[F_M>!
FZYF.f[">!d.!FZ[FYfZ"_M!Y_a_^f&!_.F&FZ^!dX"!d:!d.!FZ![dZZf["FdZ!EF"N!"NF&!&"_"fafZ"!d.!
:_[fBddg>!fbfZ!F:!Ef!N_bf!BffZ!_YbF&fY!d:!"Nf!=d&&FBFMF"D!d:!&X[N!Y_a_^f&A!dX.!_^^.f^_"f!
MF_BFMF"D!_.F&FZ^!dX"!d:!"NF&!&"_"fafZ"!d.!:_[fBddg!EFMM!Zd"!fi[ffY!"Nf!^.f_"f.!d:!dZf!NXZY.fY!
YdMM_.&!4lI``7!d.!"Nf!_adXZ"!DdX!N_bf!=_FY!X&!FZ!"Nf!=_&"!"EfMbf!adZ"N&A!!_==MF[_BMf!M_E!a_D!
Zd"!_MMdE!"Nf!MFaF"_"FdZ!d.!fi[MX&FdZ!d:!MF_BFMF"D!d.!FZ[FYfZ"_M!d.![dZ&fkXfZ"F_M!Y_a_^f&>!&d!
"Nf!_Bdbf!MFaF"_"FdZ!d.!fi[MX&FdZ!a_D!Zd"!_==MD!"d!DdXA!!FZ!&X[N![_&f&>!:_[fBddg]&!MF_BFMF"D!EFMM!
Bf!MFaF"fY!"d!"Nf!:XMMf&"!fi"fZ"!=f.aF""fY!BD!_==MF[_BMf!M_EA!

!
3B4!!L%)+'+#+('.!
!
ISAI BC!5:(;)2,,<6!@)!*)(+!'#)!-)('?8)%!(+0!%)89$;)%!@)!*(<)!(9($3(23)>!$+;3?0$+/!'#8,?/#!4(7!,?8!@)2%$')!('!
@@@A-(;)2,,<A;,*!(+0!(+C!,'#)8!:(;)2,,<!28(+0)0!,8!;,K28(+0)0!@)2%$')%!4$+;3?0$+/!%?2K0,*($+%>!
$+')8+('$,+(3!9)8%$,+%>!(+0!*,2$3)!9)8%$,+%7c!427!,?8!=3('-,8*c!(+0!4;7!,'#)8!*)0$(>!0)9$;)%!,8!+)'@,8<%!+,@!
)L$%'$+/!,8!3(')8!0)9)3,1)0A!
ISAH BC!5?%>6!5@)6!(+0!5,?86!@)!*)(+!:(;)2,,<>!F+;A!(+0m,8!$'%!(--$3$(')%A!
ISAO BC!5=3('-,8*6!@)!*)(+!(!%)'!,-!_=F%!(+0!%)89$;)%!'#('!)+(23)!(113$;('$,+%>!0)9)3,1)8%>!,1)8(',8%!,8!%)89$;)%!',!
8)'8$)9)!0('(!-8,*!:(;)2,,<!(+0!18,9$0)!0('(!',!?%!8)3('$+/!',!:(;)2,,<!?%)8%A!
ISAR BC!5;,+')+'6!@)!*)(+!'#)!;,+')+'!(+0!$+-,8*('$,+!C,?!1,%'!,+!:(;)2,,<>!$+;3?0$+/!$+-,8*('$,+!(2,?'!C,?!(+0!
'#)!(;'$,+%!C,?!'(<)A!
ISAS BC!51,%'6!@)!*)(+!1,%'!,+!:(;)2,,<!,8!,'#)8@$%)!*(<)!(9($3(23)!',!?%A!
ISAT BC!5?%)6!@)!*)(+!?%)>!;,1C>!1?23$;3C!1)8-,8*!,8!0$%13(C>!0$%'8$2?')>!*,0$-C>!'8(+%3(')>!(+0!;8)(')!0)8$9('$9)!
@,8<%!,-A!
!
3E4!!C#-%6!
!
ITAI "#$%!&'(')*)+'!*(<)%!?1!'#)!)+'$8)!(/8))*)+'!2)'@))+!'#)!1(8'$)%!8)/(80$+/!:(;)2,,<>!(+0!%?1)8%)0)%!(+C!
18$,8!(/8))*)+'%A!
ITAH F-!(+C!1,8'$,+!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!$%!-,?+0!',!2)!?+)+-,8;)(23)>!'#)!8)*($+$+/!1,8'$,+!@$33!8)*($+!$+!-?33!-,8;)!(+0!
)--);'A!
ITAO F-!@)!-($3!',!)+-,8;)!(+C!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'>!$'!@$33!+,'!2)!;,+%$0)8)0!(!@($9)8A!
ITAR _+C!(*)+0*)+'!',!,8!@($9)8!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!*?%'!2)!*(0)!$+!@8$'$+/!(+0!%$/+)0!2C!?%A!
ITAS D,?!@$33!+,'!'8(+%-)8!(+C!,-!C,?8!8$/#'%!,8!,23$/('$,+%!?+0)8!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!',!(+C,+)!)3%)!@$'#,?'!,?8!;,+%)+'A!
ITAT _33!,-!,?8!8$/#'%!(+0!,23$/('$,+%!?+0)8!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!(8)!-8))3C!(%%$/+(23)!2C!?%!$+!;,++);'$,+!@$'#!(!*)8/)8>!
(;\?$%$'$,+>!,8!%(3)!,-!(%%)'%>!,8!2C!,1)8('$,+!,-!3(@!,8!,'#)8@$%)A!
ITAU Z,'#$+/!$+!'#$%!_/8))*)+'!%#(33!18)9)+'!?%!-8,*!;,*13C$+/!@$'#!'#)!3(@A!
ITAV E)!*(C!)+')8!$+',!%)1(8(')!(/8))*)+'%!'#('!9(8C!-8,*!(+0!%?1)8%)0)!;)8'($+!18,9$%$,+%!,-!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!%,!
3,+/!(%!%?;#!(/8))*)+'%!(8)!;,+%$%')+'!@$'#!C,?8!$+')33);'?(3!18,1)8'C!8$/#'%!?+0)8!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!(+0!+,!3)%%!
18,');'$9)!,-!C,?8!18$9(;C!'#(+!'#$%!&'(')*)+'!(+0!'#)!=8$9(;C!=,3$;CA!
ITAW "#$%!&'(')*)+'!0,)%!+,'!;,+-)8!(+C!'#$80!1(8'C!2)+)-$;$(8C!8$/#'%A!